N85 W12545 Westbrook Crossing • Menomonee Falls, WI 53051

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

October 5, 2018 

Submitted via regulations.gov

Ambassador Robert E. Lighthizer

U.S. Trade Representative

Office of the U.S. Trade Representative

600 17th Street NW

Washington, DC 20508

RE: Request To Consider Requests for Exclusion of Particular Products from the 

Determination of Action Pursuant to Section 301: China’s Acts, Policies, and Practices 

Related to Technology Transfer, Intellectual Property, and Innovation (USTR-2018-0025)

Dear Ambassador Lighthizer:

ECM Industries LLC (“ECM”) hereby submits this request to exclude items under the 

Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States (“HTS”) subheading 9030.33.3800 from the 

additional ad valorem duty of 25 percent on approximately $34 billion worth of Chinese 

imports.139

ECM is a small business with a long history of manufacturing and supplying electrical 

components and products for the construction, industrial power, and transportation markets. We 

are headquartered in Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin, and have a global presence with six locations 

across the U.S., Mexico, and China. Our legacy dates back to 1959 with the founding of Gardner

Bender, one of our leading brands. Since then, we have built a world-class organization.

ECM employs 350 employees worldwide, of which 320 are based in the U.S. Our company is 

one of the U.S.’s preeminent suppliers of innovative and niche electrical products and systems 

and we are dedicated to providing our customers with solutions for their electrical applications. 

From lighting a commercial building to remodeling a home to providing the electrical 

connections that stand up to the harshest outdoor environments, the brands of ECM Industries 

provide the right solution for the most demanding applications.

 

139 Notice of Action and Request for Public Comment Concerning Proposed Determination of Action Pursuant to\

Section 301: China’s Acts, Policies, and Practices Related to Technology Transfer, Intellectual Property, and 

Innovation, 83 Fed. Reg. 28710 (Jun. 20, 2018). 
2

I. Product Description

We request that USTR exclude the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC

that is imported under HTS subheading 9030.33.3800. 

Item: #VC6300, Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC

HTS subheading: 9030.33.3800

Item Description: Electrical tester, made of plastic and metal components. Instrument that 

measures electrical connections through contacts and probe(s) attached to enclosure.

Material(s): Made of Plastic and metal components

Item Size (inches H x W x D): 5.4x12.2x9.5

Item Weight (ounces): 63.20

II. ECM Cannot Source the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 

VAC/DC From Countries Outside Of China. 

The Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC and comparable products are not 

available in the U.S. or countries outside of China. While we have explored the possibility of 

sourcing these products from other countries, there are no alternative manufacturers of the Volt 

Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC. 

Shifting to a non-Chinese source for the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 

VAC/DC is not a viable option at this time. Global supply chains are extremely complex and it 

can take years to find the right partners who can meet the proper criteria and our produce the 

Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC at the scale and cost that is needed. 

The Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC is designed and packaged to our 

unique specifications and we have been working with our Chinese vendors for over 20 years to 

ensure that the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC meets the high quality 

standards we expect. We have invested millions of dollars in tooling, training, and employ 

nearly 20 people in Shanghai who oversee and manage our supplier base. It is nearly impossible 

for us to develop similar relationships and supply chains in the near term to make this product.

We have explored the possibility of sourcing the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 

VAC/DC from other countries. This is extremely impractical given the prohibitive cost 

disadvantages of other countries such as labor and raw material costs. Several of our Chinese 

suppliers have even looked to move their factories to countries outside of China to remain in 

business and continue to support customers such as us. However, this relocation will not happen 

in the near term to help provide tariff relief. 

Additionally, there are few viable U.S.-based sources that manufacture the Volt Doctor VoltageContinuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC. We believe that developing the necessary manufacturing

capacity within America is technically and economically infeasible in the short term to meet our 

customers’ demand requirements. Based on our understanding, the U.S. suppliers of Volt Doctor 

Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC also import products or components from Chinese 

suppliers and then add some limited value through additional manufacturing here in the U.S. 

Because of this Chinese reliance, these suppliers have already demanded 25 percent price 
3

increase for this product. Because of this we have already run into difficulties on guaranteeing 

supply on the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC. 

III. The Imposition of this Duty on the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-

600 VAC/DC Has a Significant Impact on ECM’s Business, Resulting in a 

Significant Profit Loss and Reduction of ECM’s Workforce. 

As you can tell from the below information, we import a significant amount of the Volt Doctor 

Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC from China and imposition of this duty will 

negatively impact our business. 

Year Value (dollars) Quantity

2015 [ [

2016 [ [

2017 [ [

The Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC is already subject to a heavy duty. 

The proposed duty on the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC would cost 

ECM hundreds of dollars in increased duties. The cumulative impact of the list 1 Section 301 

tariffs would cost ECM millions of dollars in increased duties. These additional unexpected 

costs for our small business are layered on top of the detrimental impacts from the Section 301 

tariffs imposed on our products on lists 1 and 2 and those proposed for list 3 that total over $5.9

million. Overall, these tariffs cripple ECM, forcing ECM to reduce its workforce in the U.S. to 

afford these tariffs. 

Additionally, applying this tariff on the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 

VAC/DC will have a significant impact on ECM’s customers. ECM has thousands of customers, 

with more than 95 percent based in the U.S. Our customers are predominantly U.S. distributors, 

retailers, and manufacturers that distribute or use our products in electrical construction, 

maintenance, and repair applications. Because of the competitive nature of our business, and the 

fact we deal with many power buyers such as big box stores, we cannot recover the costs of the 

tariff on Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC by passing it along to our 

customers as they are extremely price sensitive and will look for an alternative supplier. 

Imposing this tariff on our product would cause substantial downstream injury to those industries 

as well, which would eventually trickle down to the U.S. consumer. 

This ad valorem tariff on the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC places 

our company between a rock and a hard place. If we try and pass the full amount of the duty on 

to our customers, we run the risk of losing our contracts with major customers, and with that 

millions of dollars of sales and profits. The alternative is not a good one, and that means 

reducing our workforce in the U.S. in order to absorb the costs of this tariff. We have been a 

healthy and growing business and have not laid anyone off in over five years; in fact we have 

been hiring. As of July 6, 2018, we have implemented a hiring freeze and are only replacing 

critical positions as a result of attrition. Because of the cumulative impact of these tariffs, we 

will be forced to reduce our headcount by 50 to 60 people in order to offset the costs to our 

bottom line. 
4

When the tariff on Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC can be passed on, 

we expect most of the impact will be felt by consumers and contractors who buy and use 

VC6300 in electrical installation and repair and remodel projects, which will ultimately have an 

impact on the cost of construction projects. In fact, a significant portion of the product is 

purchased by consumers directly at most leading retailers and hardware chains across the 

country.

Instead of impacting China’s manufacturing industry, the tariff on the Volt Doctor VoltageContinuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC will significantly harm ECM and our customers here in the 

U.S.

IV. Imposing the Ad Valorem Tariff under Section 301 on the Volt Doctor VoltageContinuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC Will Not Be Effective in Eliminating 

China’s Predatory Acts. 

USTR’s Section 301 report found that various policies and practices of the Chinese government 

are designed to promote Chinese companies as leaders in supplying certain advanced 

technologies around the world and to reduce imports of these technologies that Chinese 

industries rely upon. According to USTR and the White House’s Office of Trade and 

Manufacturing policy, China has participated in physical and cyber-enabled theft of 

technologies, required technology transfer for market access, and investment restrictions, among 

other coercive and intrusive restrictions that harm American intellectual property rights, 

innovation, and technology development.140

According to the various Section 301 reports, the technologies that China targets through its 

policies are advanced technologies in the following industries: (1) advanced information 

technology; (2) robotics and automated machine tools; (3) aircraft and aircraft components; (4) 

maritime vessels and marine engineering equipment; (5) advanced rail equipment; (6) new 

energy vehicles; (7) electrical generation and transmission equipment; (8) agricultural machinery 

and equipment; (9) new materials; and (10) pharmaceuticals and advanced medical devices.141

Notably, the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC and its manufacture are 

not among the list of advanced technologies or industries that are targeted by the Chinese 

government policies.

The Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC has been on the market for many 

years and does not contain sensitive technology or intellectual property that is the target of 

China’s practices. In fact, ECM has been sourcing the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 

120-600 VAC/DC from China since the 1990’s and has not experienced these challenges. To the 

contrary, ECM has enjoyed a constructive relationship with its Chinese suppliers and has not 

 

140 USTR, Findings of the Investigation Into China’s Acts, Policies, And Practices Related to Technology Transfer, 

Intellectual Property, and Innovation Under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 1–2 (Mar. 22, 2018) [hereinafter 

Section 301 Findings]; Office of Trace and Manufacturing Policy, Executive Office of the President, How China’s 

Economic Aggression Threatens the Technologies and Intellectual Property of the United States and World (Jun. 

2018) [hereinafter China’s Economic Aggression].

141 Section 301 Findings, at 14. 
5

encountered any of the intellectual property theft, cyber theft, or other technology-related 

compilations that advanced technology industries have faced. 

In sum, our importation of the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC from 

China is not linked to any purportedly unfair practices. Imposing punitive tariffs on our imports 

would only harm our small business and the U.S. customers we serve without advancing the 

stated objectives of the Section 301 proceeding.

* * *

ECM appreciates the opportunity to request this exemption from the Section 301 tariffs. While 

we understand and support the motivation for fair trade policies and a level playing field, we 

respectfully request that the Volt Doctor Voltage-Continuity Tester 120-600 VAC/DC imported 

from China under HTS subheading 9030.33.3800 be exempt from the additional 25 percent ad 

valorem duty because it will not accomplish the desired purpose and will have a significant 

detrimental impact on ECM, the businesses we supply, and U.S. consumers.

Respectfully submitted, 

David Scheer

Chief Executive Officer

ECM Industries LLC