1

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Exhibit D 

FEE SUMMARY DETAIL 

Task: Case Administration (CA)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/17/2019 Calderon, Justin Review cases and bankruptcy 

calendars (0.1). 0.10 $70.00

10/31/2019 Calderon, Justin Communications w/ R. Sussman 

re: calendar (0.5); further 

communications w/ R. Sussman 

re: calendar (0.2).

0.70 $490.00

TOTAL 0.80 $560.00

Task: Corporate Governance and Board Matters (CG)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/1/2019 Kortright, 

Magallie

Prepare court submissions for 

attorney review (2.0); 

electronic data update (1.7).

3.70 $1,480.00

10/1/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T.

T/c’s w/ client and Weil re: 

motion re: compensation 

issues (0.5).

0.50 $767.50

10/1/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ Company re: OII 

submission (0.3); review 

client comments re: OII 

submission (0.2).

0.50 $740.00

10/1/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Legal research re: wildfire 

issues (4.3). 4.30 $2,537.00

10/1/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails w/ Board Chair re: 

various Governance issues 

and Committee Guidelines 

(0.6).

0.60 $984.00

10/1/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails from Directors w/ 

various bankruptcy questions 

(0.6). 0.60 $984.00

10/2/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review client requests 

concerning compensation 

objections (0.3); review court 

order re: matter (0.1).

0.40 $592.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 1

of 40
2

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/3/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review Board minutes (1.0); 

review of 2011 IRP report 

(1.0); draft work product re: 

same (1.0).

3.00 $1,770.00

10/4/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Draft press points (1.0); 

emails re: media (1.0). 2.00 $3,280.00

10/4/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (0.2). 0.20 $91.00

10/4/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review media inquiries (0.9); 

call w/ advisor re: same (0.5); 

communications w/ client re: 

same (0.2); call w/ client re: 

same (0.2); attend Board call 

(1.0).

2.80 $4,144.00

10/4/2019 Campbell, Eamonn 

W.

Review of Tubbs docket 

updates (0.1). 0.10 $91.50

10/4/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review 2011 IRP report (0.8). 0.80 $472.00

10/4/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Organize docketing of Tubbs 

fire case and hearings (0.3); 

review order issuing from 

case management conference 

in Tubbs fire case (0.1).

0.40 $236.00

10/4/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board Meeting 

(1.5), review of Board 

materials (0.5).

2.00 $3,280.00

10/4/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails directors re: various 

issues concerning litigation 

pleadings and governance 

(0.7).

0.70 $1,148.00

10/4/2019 Steinhardt, Brian 

M.

Board call. 1.50 $2,460.00

10/4/2019 Purushotham, Ravi Board meeting. 1.00 $1,325.00

10/5/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (0.3).

0.30 $136.50

10/6/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review correspondence re: 

matter (0.4). 0.40 $592.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 2

of 40
3

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/6/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Review drafts of Tubbs filings 

(0.9); emails w/ A. Frankel, 

N. Goldin, E. Campbell re: 

same (0.2).

1.10 $1,204.50

10/7/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review motion for protective 

order in Tubbs (0.5). 0.50 $820.00

10/7/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie

Case 

management/administration 

(0.3).

0.30 $136.50

10/7/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails w/ Board Chair and 

other directors re: Court 

hearing and various 

Governance matters (0.5) 

teleconfs with Board Chair 

and other directors re: same 

(0.3).

0.80 $1,312.00

10/8/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Draft material re: media 

inquiry (1.0). 1.00 $1,640.00

10/8/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review media response (0.3). 0.30 $444.00

10/8/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ Cravath, 

Board re: protective order 

(0.1); review hearing 

transcript (0.4).

0.50 $740.00

10/8/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Email w/ R. Sparks Bradley 

and K. Kinsel re: question 

from N. Goldin re: Board 

documents (0.2); review and 

revise K. Kinsel research 

summary (0.3).

0.50 $420.00

10/8/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Draft work product re: 2011 

IRP report (0.8); obtain 

additional report (1.1).

1.90 $1,121.00

10/8/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Revisions to memo re: 

Governance and Board 

Committees (0.5); emails re: 

same (0.3).

0.80 $1,312.00

10/9/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Email to Company re: request 

for documents related to 2007 

ERM recommendations (0.2).

0.20 $118.00

10/10/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ team re: 

media (0.2); review Butte 

investigation (0.1).

0.30 $444.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 3

of 40
4

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/10/2019 Isaacman, Jennifer Revise factual analysis work 

product (1.0). 1.00 $590.00

10/10/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs w/ PGE 

legal re: stock trading issues 

(0.3).

0.30 $492.00

10/10/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference call w/ Board 

Chair (0.5) and emails re: 

various Board issues (0.2).

0.70 $1,148.00

10/10/2019 Steinhardt, Brian 

M.

Calls to M. Ponce and 

Company re: case status. 0.50 $820.00

10/11/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Attend Board meeting call 

(1.0); review Board call 

materials (0.2).

1.20 $1,968.00

10/11/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review OII submission (0.4); 

prepare re: media interaction 

(0.7).

1.10 $1,628.00

10/11/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review material re: media 

inquiry (0.7). 0.70 $413.00

10/11/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Board materials (0.5); 

Board telephonic meeting 

(1.5).

2.00 $3,280.00

10/11/2019 Purushotham, Ravi Board meeting (1.5); review 

of board materials (0.4). 1.90 $2,517.50

10/12/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review media developments 

(0.2); communications w/ 

team re: same (0.1).

0.30 $444.00

10/13/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review documents re: media 

inquiry (2.3). 2.30 $1,357.00

10/14/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Company re: pending 

matters (0.5); t/c re: Butte 

settlement w/ clients (0.5).

1.00 $1,640.00

10/14/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review material re: media 

inquiry (0.3); call w/ client re: 

same (0.3); call w/ Company 

re: same (0.2).

0.80 $1,184.00

10/14/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Review recent media (0.5); 

emails w/ N. Goldin and J. 

Isaacman re: same (0.4).

0.90 $985.50

10/14/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Review J. Isaacman summary 

of podcast re: PG&E (0.4); t/c 

w/ K. Kinsel and J. Isaacman 

re: N. Goldin research project 

(0.6); review documents 

3.10 $2,604.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 4

of 40
5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

received from client per same 

(1.8); draft summary for R. 

Sparks Bradley re: same (0.3).

10/14/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Detailed review of documents 

re: media inquiry (9.3). 9.30 $5,487.00

10/14/2019 Isaacman, Jennifer Obtain podcast re: PG&E's 

safety culture (0.2); emails w/ 

R. Sussman and R. Sparks 

Bradley re: same (0.2); 

summarize podcast episode 

(1.2).

1.60 $944.00

10/14/2019 Isaacman, Jennifer Review Board documents for 

factual analysis work product 

(1.5).

1.50 $885.00

10/14/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Continued drafting Tubbs 

litigation overview chart 

(0.8).

0.80 $472.00

10/14/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Weekly call w/ J. Loduca/J. 

Kane re: legal updates (0.5). 0.50 $820.00

10/14/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review 8k (0.2); review 

materials circulated to Board 

re: power shut down, legal 

updates (0.5).

0.70 $1,148.00

10/15/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Correspondence w/ team re: 

Board meetings and call w/ 

team re: CPUC hearing (0.4).

0.40 $592.00

10/15/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Correspondence w/ STB team 

and client re: Board meetings 

(0.3); review court order re: 

PSPS (0.2); review K. Kinsel 

research re: prep analysis 

(0.2).

0.70 $588.00

10/15/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Confirm accuracy of dates on 

internal docket for Tubbs fire 

case (0.2).

0.20 $118.00

10/15/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review alternative financing 

(0.5), emails, issues re: same 

(0.3).

0.80 $1,312.00

10/15/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails w/ Board Chair re: 

governance issues (0.5). 0.50 $820.00

10/16/2019 Laspisa, 

Rosemarie

Update document repository 

(1.0). 1.00 $400.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 5

of 40
6

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/16/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ client re: CPP (0.2); 

review media issues (1.2). 1.40 $2,072.00

10/16/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ client re: Tubbs status 

(0.3); call w/ team re: same 

(0.1).

0.40 $592.00

10/16/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Emails w/ N. Goldin re: CPP 

(0.2); emails to Company re: 

documents (0.3); review same 

(0.3).

0.80 $876.00

10/16/2019 Campbell, Eamonn 

W.

Emails w/ N. Goldin, K. 

Docherty, N. Denning re: 

Tubbs trial planning (0.2).

0.20 $183.00

10/16/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Correspondence w/ client re: 

document requests (0.3); 

review K. Kinsel research per 

request from N. Goldin (0.3).

0.60 $504.00

10/16/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Email w/ Company re: 

additional document request 

(0.2); review additional 

documents from Company 

(1.4).

1.60 $944.00

10/16/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review of documents re: 

media inquiry (0.6); update 

material re: same (0.5).

1.10 $649.00

10/16/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re: Debt financing 

(0.7).

0.70 $1,148.00

10/16/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review financing motion 

papers (1.0). 1.00 $1,640.00

10/17/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Prepare for (0.3) and call w/ 

media re: upcoming article 

(0.6); t/c w/ Company re: 

same (0.1).

1.00 $1,640.00

10/17/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Attend Board meeting (1.4). 1.40 $2,072.00

10/17/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Prepare for media (1.0); call 

w/ media re: materials (0.5); 

review media follow up (0.2).

1.70 $2,516.00

10/17/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Review WSP report to CPP 

(2.4); t/c and email w/ K. 

Kinsel re: legal research for 

N. Goldin re: client public 

statement (0.3).

2.70 $2,268.00

10/17/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review Board documents 

(0.7); compile summary re: 2.20 $1,298.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 6

of 40
7

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

same (0.4); review media 

inquiry (0.3); draft material 

re: same (0.8).

10/17/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board Meeting 

(1.5); review Board materials 

(0.5).

2.00 $3,280.00

10/17/2019 Purushotham, Ravi Restructuring committee call 

(joined late). 0.60 $795.00

10/18/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Correspondence re: media 

inquiry (0.7). 0.70 $1,148.00

10/18/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T.

Attend Compensation 

Committee meeting (1.0); 

preparations for same (0.3).

1.30 $1,995.50

10/18/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Prepare media material (0.7); 

call w/ Company re: same 

(0.3); review CPUC update 

(0.3).

1.30 $1,924.00

10/18/2019 Campbell, Eamonn 

W.

Review of briefing re: Tubbs 

motion for protective order 

(0.3).

0.30 $274.50

10/18/2019 Phillips, Jacob M. Participation in compensation 

committee meeting (1.0); 

prepare for same (0.5).

1.50 $1,260.00

10/18/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Review materials re: CPUC, 

PG&E, PSPS emergency 

hearing re: PSPS (1.5); 

prepare summary of hearing 

for N. Goldin (0.5); review 

and revise media material 

from N. Goldin (0.5); 

correspondence w/ K. Kinsel 

re: same (0.6).

3.10 $2,604.00

10/18/2019 Calderon, Justin Review Tubbs calendar re: 

protective order motion (0.1); 

communications w/ K. Kinsel 

re: same (0.1).

0.20 $140.00

10/18/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review briefing re: Tubbs 

protective order (0.5); draft 

summary emails re: same 

(0.3); review docket entries 

triggered by filings (0.3).

1.10 $649.00

10/18/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Attend CPUC PSPS 

teleconference (1.2); draft 

summary re: same (1.0).

2.20 $1,298.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 7

of 40
8

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/18/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review findings of 2011 IRP 

report (0.5); revise prep 

analysis re: same (0.3).

0.80 $472.00

10/18/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails w/ Board Chairman 

and PGE legal re: various 

governance issues (0.6).

0.60 $984.00

10/20/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T.

T/c w/ client and advisors to 

prepare for Compensation 

Committee meeting (1.0).

1.00 $1,535.00

10/20/2019 Phillips, Jacob M. Participation in preparatory 

call prior to compensation 

committee meeting (1.0); 

review materials re: same 

(0.3).

1.30 $1,092.00

10/20/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review filings in Safety 

Culture OII and summarize 

same for OII tracking chart 

(0.5).

0.50 $295.00

10/21/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Work on material re: media 

inquiry (0.5). 0.50 $820.00

10/21/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T.

Attend Compensation 

committee meeting (1.0); 

preparations for same (0.7); 

preparatory t/c's and emails 

prior to meeting (0.3).

2.00 $3,070.00

10/21/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie

Assist J. Calderon w/ 

documents for review (0.1). 0.10 $45.50

10/21/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review media issues (0.5); 

call w/ client re: same (0.4); 

call w/ Company re: same 

(0.6).

1.50 $2,220.00

10/21/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Emails w/ J. Calderon re: 

interviews (0.5); t/c w/ R. 

Sussman re: reports to 

company, factual review 

(0.3); emails w/ R. Sussman 

re: same (0.3).

1.10 $1,204.50

10/21/2019 Phillips, Jacob M. Participate in preparatory call 

prior to compensation 

committee meeting (1.5).

1.50 $1,260.00

10/21/2019 Phillips, Jacob M. Draft prep analysis for 

compensation committee 

meeting (0.3).

0.30 $252.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 8

of 40
9

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/21/2019 Calderon, Justin Review interview memos fact 

analysis (1.0); 

communications w/ J. 

Franklin, J. Fell, R. Sussman, 

and R. Sparks Bradley re: 

same (0.4).

1.40 $980.00

10/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference call w/ PGE Legal 

re: Annual Meeting planning 

(0.5).

0.50 $820.00

10/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Weekly call w/ J. Loduca/J. 

Kane (0.4). 0.40 $656.00

10/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review L. Cheng 

email/materials to Board 

(0.4).

0.40 $656.00

10/22/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Prepare materials for media 

(0.8); call w/ Company re: 

same (0.2).

1.00 $1,640.00

10/22/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Attention to media issues 

(1.6); call w/ Company re: 

same (0.4); call w/ team re: 

estimation (0.1); 

correspondence w/ client 

group re: media (0.3).

2.40 $3,552.00

10/22/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Review recent media (0.4); 

emails w/ N. Goldin and J. 

Isaacman re: same (0.6); t/c 

w/ N. Goldin re: same (0.1).

1.10 $1,204.50

10/22/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Review and revise material re: 

media inquiry (0.3); call w/ J. 

Isaacman re: N. Goldin 

factual research request (0.3); 

review work product re: same 

(0.7); emails w/ team re: same 

(0.3).

1.60 $1,344.00

10/22/2019 Calderon, Justin Review interview memos for 

fact analysis (0.7); email to N. 

Goldin re: same (0.1).

0.80 $560.00

10/22/2019 Isaacman, Jennifer Draft material re: media 

inquiry (3.6); calls w/ N. 

Goldin (0.1), R. Sussman 

(0.1), and R. Sparks Bradley 

re: same (0.1).

3.90 $2,301.00

10/22/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails w/ Board members re: 

litigation strategy (0.3). 0.30 $492.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 9

of 40
10

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/23/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review inverse brief (1.1); 

call w/ client re: media (0.4); 

call w/ company re: same 

(0.4); prepare material re: 

same (0.9); correspondence 

w/ client re: same (0.3).

3.10 $4,588.00

10/23/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Review and revise material re: 

media inquiry (1.3); 

calls/emails w/ J. Isaacman 

and N. Goldin re: same (0.3); 

factual research re: same 

(0.4).

2.00 $1,680.00

10/23/2019 Isaacman, Jennifer Revise material re: media 

inquiry (1.6). 1.60 $944.00

10/23/2019 Isaacman, Jennifer Revise factual analysis work 

product (2.7). 2.70 $1,593.00

10/23/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review 

Legal/Regulatory/Legislative 

documents to prepare updates 

for Board (0.8).

0.80 $1,312.00

10/23/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails w/ Directors re: 

litigation strategy and 

governance (0.5).

0.50 $820.00

10/24/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Correspondence w/ client re: 

media (0.3); review 

correspondence from client 

re: same (0.3); prepare 

material re: media (1.6); call 

team re: fires (0.2); call 

company re: internal issues 

(0.4).

2.80 $4,144.00

10/24/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Review and revise media 

statement (1.6); calls w/ N. 

Goldin and J. Isaacman re: 

same (0.3).

1.90 $1,596.00

10/24/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft summary of CPUC 

Prehearing Conference (2.0); 

review of documents re: same 

(1.0).

3.00 $2,100.00

10/24/2019 Isaacman, Jennifer Revisions to material re: 

media inquiry (1.4). 1.40 $826.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 10

of 40
11

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/24/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board Meeting 

(1.0), review L. Cheng posted 

materials related to the 

meeting (0.5).

1.50 $2,460.00

10/24/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails directors re: various 

governance issues (0.7). 0.70 $1,148.00

10/25/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Revise draft filing on OII 

(1.0). 1.00 $1,640.00

10/25/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T.

Compensation committee 

meeting (1.0); prepare for 

same (0.5).

1.50 $2,302.50

10/25/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review media outreach (1.0); 

call w/ Company re: same 

(0.2); review safety OII 

submission (0.3); review 

communications re: notice of 

depositions (0.2).

1.70 $2,516.00

10/25/2019 Isaacman, Jennifer Prepare material re: media 

inquiry (0.3). 0.30 $177.00

10/25/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs directors re: 

various governance issues 

(0.7).

0.70 $1,148.00

10/26/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ client re: 

court submissions (1.0). 1.00 $1,480.00

10/27/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Participate in Board Call 

(2.0). 2.00 $3,280.00

10/27/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ client re: 

court submission (0.1); Board 

call (2.0); call team re: 

workstreams (0.1); review 

Board protocol (0.2).

2.40 $3,552.00

10/27/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board Meeting 

(2.5); review Board materials 

(0.8).

3.30 $5,412.00

10/27/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference calls, emails w/ 

Management, certain 

Directors and Advisors to 

prepare for Board Meeting 

(1.2).

1.20 $1,968.00

10/28/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Conference call w/ clients re: 

status (0.5); t/c w/ team re: 

press and governance (0.3); 

1.30 $2,132.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 11

of 40
12

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

t/c w/ Company re: status and 

upcoming filings (0.5).

10/28/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (0.1). 0.10 $45.50

10/28/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Weekly call with J. Loduca/J. 

Kane re: various issues (0.5). 0.50 $820.00

10/29/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review media inquiry issues 

(0.4); review fact summary 

(0.3); communications w/ 

client and company re: court 

submission (0.2).

0.90 $1,332.00

10/29/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Review and revise Board 

work product (0.9); emails/t/c 

w/ K. Kinsel and N. Goldin 

re: same (0.4).

1.30 $1,092.00

10/29/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Cite check Board work 

product (3.1). 3.10 $1,829.00

10/29/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re: settlement 

discussions, 10Q reserve 

disclosure and governance 

matters (1.3).

1.30 $2,132.00

10/30/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ N. Brownell re: matter 

(0.3); review correspondence 

to CalFire (0.3); t/c w/ 

management and Board re: 

matter (0.5); correspondence 

re: media inquiry (0.8).

1.90 $3,116.00

10/30/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ client re: media 

inquiry (0.3); prepare material 

re: media inquiry (0.5); 

review factual summaries of 

Board activity (0.5).

1.30 $1,924.00

10/30/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review email re: Tubbs 

hearing (0.2). 0.20 $296.00

10/30/2019 Phillips, Jacob M. Call w/ bankruptcy counsel 

re: timeline for motion re: 

compensation approval (0.3).

0.30 $252.00

10/30/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Review and revise Board 

work product per comment 

from N. Goldin (1.3); 

emails/calls w/ K. Kinsel and 

N. Goldin re: same (0.5).

1.80 $1,512.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 12

of 40
13

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/30/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Review K. Kinsel summary of 

hearing re: Tubbs fire trial 

(0.1).

0.10 $84.00

10/30/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Attend hearing in Tubbs case 

re: protective order (1.2); 

draft summary re: same (0.3).

1.50 $885.00

10/30/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Fact check Board work 

product (3.5). 3.50 $2,065.00

10/31/2019 Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance coverage 

issues, email w/ N. Goldin 

and team re: Board meeting 

preparation (0.3); review and 

revise D&O insurance 

analysis re: 2017 Policies, 

2018 Policies, EIS Policies 

and claims (1.5); emails w/ N. 

Goldin and team re: same 

(0.3); address follow-up 

questions re: same (0.5).

2.60 $3,172.00

10/31/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Internal t/c in preparation for 

Board call (0.9); t/c w/ K. 

Orsini re: matter (0.2).

1.10 $1,804.00

10/31/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T.

T/c w/ Compensation 

Committee member re: 

upcoming meeting (0.5).

0.50 $767.50

10/31/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review media inquiry issues 

(0.3); call w/ Company re: 

same (0.3); confer w/ team re: 

Board meeting preparation 

(0.3); correspondence w/ team 

re: same (0.2); 

communications w/ team re: 

cyber issue (0.1).

1.20 $1,776.00

10/31/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Draft/revise analysis for 

Board meeting (0.8); emails 

w/ N. Goldin, R. Sussman, K. 

Kinsel re: same (0.7); emails 

w/ E. Alcabes re: same (0.2).

1.70 $1,861.50

10/31/2019 Campbell, Eamonn 

W.

Prepare analysis for Board 

meeting (1.0). 1.00 $915.00

10/31/2019 Phillips, Jacob M. Review of compensation 

committee meeting materials 

(0.3).

0.30 $252.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 13

of 40
14

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/31/2019 Sussman, Rebecca 

A.

Call w/ advisors and 

Company re: media inquiry 

(0.4); prepare for same (0.2); 

draft analysis for meeting w/ 

Board (4.1); calls/emails w/ 

R. Sparks Bradley (0.5), J. 

Calderon (0.3), K. Kinsel 

(0.4), and N. Goldin re: same 

(0.6); review new Complaint 

filed against PG&E officers 

(0.7).

7.20 $6,048.00

10/31/2019 Calderon, Justin Revise of letter to PERA 

(0.7); communications w/ 

team re: same (0.3).

1.00 $700.00

10/31/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

T/c w/ Company et al. re: 

Board work product (0.3); 

prepare analysis for Board 

meeting (2.0).

2.30 $1,357.00

10/31/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs/emails w/ Board 

Chair, CEO and General 

Counsel re: Board and 

Governance issues (1.0), 

review 8-K disclosure 

obligations and Employment 

Agreement re: discussions 

(1.0).

2.00 $3,280.00

10/31/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Board materials (0.7). 0.70 $1,148.00

10/31/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Calls, emails, review 

materials re: D&O Insurance 

and Indemnity (0.7).

0.70 $1,148.00

10/31/2019 Kelley, Karen H. T/c w/M. Ponce re: Form 8-K 

disclosure question. 0.20 $285.00 

TOTAL 204.60 $233,422.00

Task Code: Court Hearings (CH)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/1/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Prepare summary of NB case 

management hearing (0.4); 

communications w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley, N. Goldin re: same 

(0.2).

0.60 $354.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 14

of 40
15

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/1/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Attend case management 

conference for In re: North Bay 

Fire Cases (1.1).

1.10 $649.00

10/7/2019 Qusba, Sandy Participate in exclusivity 

hearing. 4.00 $6,140.00

10/7/2019 Fell, Jamie Prep for (0.5) and attend 

Omnibus Hearing (1.0). 1.50 $1,492.50

10/23/2019 Calderon, Justin Attend CPUC Prehearing 

Conference (3.0). 3.00 $2,100.00

TOTAL 10.20 $10,735.50

Task Code: Claims Administration and Objections (CM)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/2/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft Proofs of Claim for 

directors (1.4). 1.40 $980.00

10/3/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: finalizing draft 

proofs of claim for directors 

(0.2).

0.20 $244.00

10/3/2019 Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance, email w/ J. 

Fell and K. McLendon re: client 

proof of claim (0.2); 

preliminary review of same 

(0.3).

0.50 $610.00

10/3/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie

Assist J. Calderon w/ 

documents for review (1.5). 1.50 $682.50

10/3/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare proof of claim forms 

for directors and riders (1.5); 

gather information for proof of 

claim forms and riders (0.9) and 

correspondence w/ K. 

McLendon, J. Calderon and 

clients re: same (0.3).

2.70 $2,686.50

10/3/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft Proofs of Claim for 

clients (2.3).

2.30 $1,610.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 15

of 40
16

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/4/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

T/c w/ E. Alcabes and J. Fell re: 

insurance points in directors’ 

proofs of claim (0.2); emails w/ 

J. Fell and J. Calderon re: 

circulation of drafts of claims to 

directors (0.1).

0.30 $366.00

10/4/2019 Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance, further 

review draft POC for directors 

(0.5); email/conference call w/ 

J. Fell and K. McLendon re: 

same (0.5).

1.00 $1,220.00

10/4/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie

Assist J. Calderon w/ 

documents for review (0.2). 0.20 $91.00

10/4/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare proofs of claim forms 

and riders for directors (1.0); 

draft summary email to clients 

for circulating drafts (0.4).

1.40 $1,393.00

10/4/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft Proofs of Claim for 

directors (2.4); circulate draft 

proofs of claim for internal 

review (0.3).

2.70 $1,890.00

10/5/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review draft proofs of claim 

(0.2). 0.20 $296.00

10/5/2019 Fell, Jamie Manage proofs of claim 

process, including 

correspondence w/ clients (0.5); 

revise riders to proofs of claim 

(0.5).

1.00 $995.00

10/6/2019 Fell, Jamie Manage proofs of claim process 

and revisions (0.4) and 

correspondence w/ client re: 

same (0.2).

0.60 $597.00

10/7/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Conference call w/ client, P. 

Curnin, J. Fell and J. Calderon 

re: draft POC and various 

litigation matters (0.4); further 

emails w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: finalizing 

directors' POCs (0.2).

0.60 $732.00

10/7/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ client re: director 

indemnification (0.5). 0.50 $820.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 16

of 40
17

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/7/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft Proofs of Claim for 

outside directors (0.6); 

including communications w/ 

team re: same (0.2).

0.80 $560.00

10/8/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: filing of directors' 

proofs of claim (0.1).

0.10 $122.00

10/8/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare proofs of claim for 

directors (0.8). 0.80 $796.00

10/9/2019 Calderon, Justin Communications w/ team re: 

Proofs of Claim (0.3). 0.30 $210.00

10/10/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: finalizing 

directors' POCs (0.2); 

conference call w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: coordination of 

execution and filing of 

directors' POCs (0.2); further 

emails w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: directors' POC 

information and updates for 

directors (0.2).

0.60 $732.00

10/10/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review proofs of claim (0.3). 0.30 $444.00

10/10/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare proofs of claim forms 

and riders (0.7); research re: 

Proof of Claim in response to 

client question (0.4).

1.10 $1,094.50

10/10/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft Proofs of Claim for 

outside directors (5.0); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.5).

5.50 $3,850.00

10/11/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: transmittal of 

proofs of claim to directors and 

follow-up matters (0.2).

0.20 $244.00

10/11/2019 Calderon, Justin Finalize Proof of Claim and 

mail (0.5).

0.50 $350.00

10/14/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails w/ N. Goldin and J. Fell 

re: filing of directors' POCs 0.30 $366.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 17

of 40
18

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

(0.2); further t/c w/ J. Fell re: 

same (0.1).

10/14/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare proofs of claim for 

directors (2.3). 2.30 $2,288.50

10/14/2019 Calderon, Justin Communications w/ J. Fell re: 

proofs of claim (0.5); additional 

communications w/ J. Fell re: 

proofs of claim (0.3).

0.80 $560.00

10/15/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: status on executed 

POCs from directors (0.2).

0.20 $244.00

10/15/2019 Calderon, Justin Communications w/ J. Fell re: 

proofs of claim and review of 

riders (0.3); communications w/ 

directors re: same (0.1).

0.40 $280.00

10/16/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare proofs of claim (2.2). 2.20 $2,189.00

10/16/2019 Calderon, Justin Communications w/ J. Fell re: 

proofs of claim (0.3); 

communications w/ directors re: 

proofs of claim (0.4).

0.70 $490.00

10/17/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails w/ N. Goldin and J. Fell 

re: filing of directors' proofs of 

claim (0.2).

0.20 $244.00

10/17/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review proofs of claims (0.1). 0.10 $148.00

10/17/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare/finalize/send proofs of 

claim (0.7) and answer director 

questions re: same (0.3).

1.00 $995.00

10/18/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare and file proofs of claim 

(1.8). 1.80 $1,791.00

10/18/2019 Welman, 

Timothy

Deliver proofs of claim to 

PrimeClerk for J. Fell (2.0). 2.00 $530.00

10/21/2019 Fell, Jamie Finalize/file proofs of claim 

(1.0). 1.00 $995.00

10/21/2019 Welman, 

Timothy

Deliver proofs of claim to 

PrimeClerk for J. Fell (2.0). 2.00 $530.00

10/23/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

T/c w/ J. Fell re: status on 

directors' proofs of claim and 

Prime Clerk updates (0.2).

0.20 $244.00

TOTAL 42.50 $35,510.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 18

of 40
19

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Task Code: Fee/Employment Applications (FA)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/1/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee application issues 

(0.4); review fee examiner 

protocol opposition brief (0.8); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.1).

1.30 $1,924.00

10/1/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Review draft opposition to fee 

examiner protocol and proposed 

protocol revisions (0.6); email 

M. Torkin re: proposed 

comments on CSM draft 

opposition to fee examiner 

protocol and motion (0.1); 

numerous emails M. Torkin and 

N. Goldin re: opposition to fee 

examiner protocol and 

comments thereon (0.5); emails 

B. Benedict re: comments on 

fee examiner opposition (0.2).

1.40 $1,708.00

10/2/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Prepare monthly fee statement 

materials (2.3). 2.30 $2,518.50

10/3/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails w/ R. Sparks Bradley 

and accounting re: August 

statement (0.1); further emails 

w/ accounting re: finalizing 

August statement (0.1).

0.20 $244.00

10/3/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Prepare monthly fee statement 

materials (2.0); emails w/ 

accounting re: same (0.7).

2.70 $2,956.50

10/3/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Begin review and comment on 

August statement. 1.00 $1,220.00

10/4/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Prepare monthly fee statement 

materials (0.5); emails w/ 

accounting re: same (0.3).

0.80 $876.00

10/4/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Continue review and comment 

on statement for August (1.8); 

prep email update to STB team 

re: billing guidelines (1.0); 

email R. Sparks Bradley and J. 

Fell re: comments on billing 

guidelines email update (0.2).

3.00 $3,660.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 19

of 40
20

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/4/2019 Fell, Jamie Reviewing monthly invoices for 

privilege (2.3) and corr. w/ 

billing coordinators and K. 

McLendon re: same (0.3).

2.60 $2,587.00

10/5/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review monthly fee 

submissions (0.7). 0.70 $1,036.00

10/7/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Internal emails w/ accounting, 

N. Goldin, R. Sparks Bradley 

re: August statement (0.2).

0.20 $244.00

10/7/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review monthly fee statement 

(0.2). 0.20 $296.00

10/7/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Further preparation of fee 

application materials (0.9); 

emails w/ K. McLendon and N. 

Goldin and accounting re: same 

(0.5).

1.40 $1,533.00

10/7/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails accounting and J. Fell 

re: finalizing August statement 

(0.1); review final version of 

August statement (0.1).

0.20 $244.00

10/7/2019 Fell, Jamie Review monthly invoice for 

privilege. 0.80 $796.00

10/10/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review monthly fee statement 

(0.2). 0.20 $296.00

10/10/2019 Fell, Jamie Reviewing invoices and prep 

same re: fee protocol, billing 

guidelines.

0.60 $597.00

10/11/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Prepare monthly fee statement 

materials (1.1). 1.10 $1,204.50

10/14/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee protocol (1.0).

1.00 $1,480.00

10/14/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Prepare monthly fee statement 

materials (1.2); emails w/ N. 

Goldin re: same (0.2).

1.40 $1,533.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 20

of 40
21

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/16/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Prepare monthly fee statement 

materials (0.3); email to N. 

Goldin re: same (0.1).

0.40 $438.00

10/21/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee protocol (0.3). 0.30 $444.00

10/21/2019 Calderon, Justin Communications w/ J. Fell re: 

monthly fee application (0.1). 0.10 $70.00

10/22/2019 Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance, t/c w/ Weil 

(K. Kramer) re: fee application 

objection and next steps (0.3); 

email w/ M. Torkin, J. Fell and 

K. McLendon re: same (0.2).

0.50 $610.00

10/22/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee objection (0.2). 0.20 $296.00

10/23/2019 Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance, conf call w/ 

Weil (K. Kramer), Latham, 

client (R. Reilly) and STB (N. 

Goldin, J. Fell) re: PERA 

objection re: defense costs for 

securities claims (0.5).

0.50 $610.00

10/23/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ Weil re: fee objection 

briefing (0.4). 0.40 $592.00

10/23/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

T/Cs Fell re: CNO on nonobjected-to portion of STB 4th 

monthly statement.

0.20 $244.00

10/24/2019 Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance, email client 

(R. Reilly), Weil (K. Kramer, 

M. Goren), J. Fell and Latham 

re: client spreadsheet showing 

status of exhaustion of retention 

(0.3).

0.30 $366.00

10/24/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Review draft CNO for 4th 

monthly statement.

0.10 $122.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 21

of 40
22

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/24/2019 Fell, Jamie Draft/prepare CNO for 4th 

monthly fee statement.

0.80 $796.00

10/25/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft STB Fifth Monthly Fee 

Statement for Bankruptcy court 

(5.5). 5.50 $3,850.00

10/25/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Emails accounting team and J. 

Fell re: second interim fee 

application. 0.20 $244.00

10/28/2019 Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance coverage 

issues, communications w/ STB 

team (N. Goldin, K. McLendon, 

J. Fell) re: PERA objection to 

fee application and next steps 

re: same (0.5); review draft fee 

application submission (0.1); 

email K. McLendon and J. Fell 

re: same (0.1).

0.70 $854.00

10/28/2019 Calderon, Justin Revise draft Fifth Monthly Fee 

Statement (0.8).

0.80 $560.00

10/28/2019 Fell, Jamie Draft CNO re: July fees (0.4).

0.40 $398.00

10/29/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Circulate revised fee examiner

protocol to STB team, including 

emails accounting department 

regarding protocol (0.2).

0.20 $244.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 22

of 40
23

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/30/2019 Calderon, Justin Serve Fifth Monthly Fee 

Statement w/ PrimeClerk (0.4).

0.40 $280.00

10/30/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Review draft of 5th monthly

statement for August (0.7); 

email J. Fell and accounting 

team re: statement for August 

(0.1).

0.80 $976.00

10/30/2019 Fell, Jamie Finalize, file and serve August 

fee statement (1.0); begin 

review of September invoices 

(0.9).

1.90 $1,890.50

TOTAL 37.80 $40,838.00

Task Code: Fee Objections (FO)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/21/2019 Fell, Jamie Review and summarize PERA 

objection to fee statements 

(0.9).

0.90 $895.50

10/23/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

T/c w/ J. Fell re: PERA-NM 

limited objection to STB 4th 

monthly statement, proposed 

response considerations and 

timetable (0.2); t/c w/ J. Fell re: 

update on call w/ Weil and 

Alcabes re: PERA-NM limited 

objection to STB 4th monthly 

statement (0.3).

0.50 $610.00

10/23/2019 Fell, Jamie Research re: fee objection (0.8); 

call w/ WGM, K. McLendon 

and E. Alcabes re: fee objection 

(0.5) and follow-up calls w/ N. 

Goldin and E. Alcabes re: same 

(0.5); draft summary/analysis 

re: objection and response (0.5).

2.30 $2,288.50

10/24/2019 Fell, Jamie Review D&O insurance and 

limits (0.5); correspondence w/ 0.80 $796.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 23

of 40
24

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

STB re: fee objection response 

(0.3).

10/25/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

T/c w/ J. Fell re: proposed 

approach to D&O insurance and 

response to PERA limited 

objection (0.3).

0.30 $366.00

10/25/2019 Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance coverage 

issues, communications w/ J. 

Fell re: PERA fee application 

objection, D&O coverage for 

securities claims, and next steps 

(0.8); further review PERA 

objection re: same (0.3).

1.10 $1,342.00

10/25/2019 Fell, Jamie Calls w/ E. Alcabes and K. 

McLendon re: D&O insurance, 

fee objection and response 

(0.9); research and outline re: 

response to fee objection re: 

August fee statement (0.8).

1.70 $1,691.50

10/28/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Meeting w/ M. Torkin, N. 

Goldin, E. Alcabes and J. Fell 

re: response to PERA-NM 

limited objection and next steps 

(0.4); review revised CNO on 

STB 4th statement and t/c w/ J. 

Fell and email E. Alcabes re: 

same (0.1).

0.50 $610.00

10/28/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Confer w/ team re: PERA fee 

objection (0.5). 0.50 $740.00

10/28/2019 Fell, Jamie Draft letter to PERA objection 

(0.9); draft email outline re: fee 

request and response to PERA 

(0.5).

1.40 $1,393.00

10/29/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine

Review draft letter to PERANM's counsel re: limited 

objection to STB 4th and emails 

w/ E. Alcabes and J. Fell re: 

comments (0.2).

0.20 $244.00

10/29/2019 Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance coverage 

issues, review/revise draft letter 

to PERA counsel re: Simpson 

Retention Order and PERA 

1.00 $1,220.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 24

of 40
25

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

objection (0.8); email w/ J. Fell 

and K. McLendon re: same 

(0.2).

10/29/2019 Fell, Jamie Draft/revise letter to PERA re: 

objection (0.9); follow-up w/ N. 

Goldin, E. Alcabes and K. 

McLendon re: same (0.4).

1.30 $1,293.50

10/31/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Revise letter re: PERA fee 

objection (0.5); emails w/ J. 

Calderon, J. Fell re: same (0.2); 

emails w/ N. Goldin re: same 

(0.1).

0.80 $876.00

TOTAL 13.30 $14,366.00

Task Code: Litigation: Contested Matters and Adversary Proceedings (LI) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/14/2019 Qusba, Sandy Prepare for (0.3) and t/c w/ J. 

Loduca, K. Orsini, S. Karotkin, 

defense counsel, M. Moore, R. 

Barrera, P. Curnin and M. 

Ponce re: next steps w/ 

litigation (0.5).

0.80 $1,228.00

TOTAL 0.80 $1,228.00

Task Code: Plan/Disclosure Statement (PL)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/1/2019 Frankel, Andrew 

T.

Communications w/ K. Orsini, 

STB re: estimation and POC 

issues (0.5).

0.50 $767.50

10/1/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Emails w/ document vendor, 

Cravath and Weil re: 

subrogation settlement 

discovery (0.6); emails w/ T. 

Kovoor re: same (0.4).

1.00 $1,095.00

10/1/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A.

Call w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

document database (0.2). 0.20 $168.00

10/1/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Backstop Approval 

Motion (0.8). 0.80 $1,312.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 25

of 40
26

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/1/2019 Qusba, Sandy Begin review of objection to 

exclusivity (1.0); review UCC 

and Union pleadings in support 

of termination of exclusivity 

(0.8); correspondence with 

Board members regarding same 

and next steps (0.8).

2.60 $3,991.00

10/2/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails and teleconfs directors 

re: various issues re: Brief 

opposing Elliott motion re 

Exclusivity (0.6).

0.60 $984.00

10/2/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review and comment on 

objection to motion to terminate 

exclusivity (1.6).

1.60 $2,456.00

10/3/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Emails w/ J. Isaacman, 

document vendor, Cravath and 

Weil re: subrogation settlement 

discovery (0.9); review 

documents for same (1.2).

2.10 $2,299.50

10/3/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer

Review documents re: 

subrogation settlement and 

objections (2.9); call w/ R. 

Sparks Bradley re: same (0.2).

3.10 $1,829.00

10/3/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference call w/ 

Cravath/Lazard re: Bank 

Commitment Letters (0.8); 

document review re: same (0.7); 

emails and teleconfs directors 

and Qusba re: same (0.5).

2.00 $3,280.00

10/3/2019 Steinhardt, Brian 

M.

Call w/M. Ponce re: status of 

case. 0.20 $328.00

10/3/2019 Steinhardt, Brian 

M.

Call w/Lazard & Cravath re: 

bank commitment letters. 0.80 $1,312.00

10/3/2019 Steinhardt, Brian 

M.

Review of papers re: 

commitment letters. 0.50 $820.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 26

of 40
27

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/3/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi

Review of debt commitment 

letters.

0.30 $397.50

10/3/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review and comment on 

objection to motion to terminate 

exclusivity (1.5); review debt 

financing letters (1.5); t/c w/ N. 

Brownell re: next steps (0.5); t/c 

w/ R. Barrera re: same (0.5); t/c 

w/ M. Ponce re: status update 

(0.5); t/c w/ S. Karotkin re: 

status (0.3).

4.80 $7,368.00

10/4/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G.

Communications w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley re: production 

specifications re: subrogation 

settlement, timing (0.5).

0.50 $210.00

10/4/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Review subrogation settlement 

documents for production to 

TCC (0.7); emails w/ J. 

Isaacman re: same (0.5); emails 

w/ Cravath and Weil re: same 

(0.6).

1.80 $1,971.00

10/4/2019 Fell, Jamie Review (1.0) and circulate for 

STB group motions re: 

termination of exclusivity (0.3).

1.30 $1,293.50

10/4/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer

Review documents re: 

subrogation settlement (3.0); 

call w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

same (0.2).

3.20 $1,888.00

10/4/2019 Steinhardt, Brian 

M.

Call with M. Ponce and Cravath 

re: commitment papers. 0.50 $820.00

10/4/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi

Review of commitment letters. 0.50 $662.50

10/4/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review J. Montali's Order and 

correspondence w/ restructuring 

committee re: same (0.5); 

2.70 $4,144.50

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 27

of 40
28

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

review revised draft of 

objection to Motion to 

Terminate exclusivity (0.7); t/c 

w/ Board re: 10/7 hearing, debt 

and equity exit financing and 

the issues (1.5).

10/5/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Review subrogation settlement 

documents for production to 

TCC (3.5); emails w/ document 

vendor, Cravath and Weil re: 

subrogation settlement 

discovery (0.6).

4.10 $4,489.50

10/5/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review various pleadings for 

10/7 hearing (1.10); summarize 

approach for restructuring 

committee (1.0).

2.10 $3,223.50

10/5/2019 Fell, Jamie Review pleadings for Monday 

Omnibus Hearing. 1.50 $1,492.50

10/6/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Emails w/ document vendor and 

T. Kovoor re: subrogation 

production issues (0.6).

0.60 $657.00

10/7/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Review subrogation settlement 

documents in preparation for 

production (0.8); emails w/ 

Cravath, Weil, T. Kovoor re: 

same (1.1); review R&Os re: 

subrogation production (0.4); 

email to S. Qusba and N. 

Goldin re: same (0.1).

2.40 $2,628.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 28

of 40
29

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/7/2019 Qusba, Sandy Meeting w/ D. Gottlieb re: case 

update (0.5); correspondence w/ 

R. Barrera re: exclusivity 

hearing (0.3).

0.80 $1,228.00

10/8/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G.

Production review/QC of STB 

production (1.0); coordinate 

transfer w/ Cravath (0.5); 

communications w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley re: production (0.5); 

follow up w/ vendor re: 

production (0.5).

2.50 $1,050.00

10/8/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Finalize subrogation settlement 

production (0.4); emails w/ T. 

Kovoor and Cravath and 

document vendor re: same 

(0.5).

0.90 $985.50

10/8/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs w/ Directors, 

S. Qusba re: Exclusivity hearing 

and issues (0.4); teleconf with 

S. Qusba re: same (0.3).

0.70 $1,148.00

10/8/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c w/ M. Moore re: update 

from Exclusivity hearing (0.5); 

t/c w/ M. Ponce re: update from 

Exclusivity hearing (0.3).

0.80 $1,228.00

10/9/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G.

Build production analytics for 

attorney review (2.0); follow up 

communications w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley re: production (0.5).

2.50 $1,050.00

10/9/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Review subrogation settlement 

documents for deposition 

preparation (1.8); email to 

Cravath re: same (0.4); review 

draft R&Os to Bondholders 

(0.5).

2.70 $2,956.50

10/9/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Montali Exclusivity 

Decision (0.5), emails, 

teleconfs, various issues re: 

same (0.5).

1.00 $1,640.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 29

of 40
30

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/9/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review Judge Montali's 

Exclusivity Order (0.3); 

correspondence w/ 

Restructuring Committee re: 

same (0.8).

1.10 $1,688.50

10/10/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G.

Prepare copies of productions 

for files (0.8); communications 

w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: same 

(0.2).

1.00 $420.00

10/10/2019 Laspisa, 

Rosemarie

Upload document productions 

(0.5); prepare case file copies 

(0.5).

1.00 $400.00

10/10/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Teleconf with Cravath (0.5) and 

S. Karotkin (0.7), and emails, 

various issues, documents (0.3) 

re: Debt Commitment Papers 

and Board Recommendation.

1.50 $2,460.00

10/10/2019 Steinhardt, Brian 

M.

Call re: debt papers. 0.50 $820.00

10/10/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi

Call on debt commitment letters 

w/ Cravath, Lazard and other 

(0.5); review of debt 

commitment letters (0.6).

1.10 $1,457.50

10/10/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c w/ S. Karotkin and K. 

Orsini re: next steps (0.5); 

correspondence w/ M. Ponce 

and R. Purushotham re: same 

(0.3); t/c w/ R. Barrera re: same 

(0.4); t/c w/ S. Karotkin, K. 

Ziman, J. Loduca and J. Simon 

re: 10/11 Board call (0.7); t/c w/ 

M. Ponce re: debt financing 

commitments (0.2); t/c w/ Weil, 

Cravath, Lazard and STB teams 

re: debt financing commitments 

(0.5); review and comment on 

draft Board agenda (0.2); t/c w/ 

K. Ziman and R. Barrera re: 

debt commitments (0.6).

3.40 $5,219.00

10/11/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference call w/ Board Chair 

and R. Barrera re: debt 

commitment letters and NOLs 

(0.5), emails re: same (0.3).

0.80 $1,312.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 30

of 40
31

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/11/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c w/ R. Barrera re: Board call 

(0.3); review Board material 

(0.4); t/c w/ N. Brownell re: 

Board meeting (0.3); participate 

in Board call (1.5); review and 

comment on CPUC OII 

response (1.5); t/c w/ R. 

Barrera, N. Brownell and M. 

Ponce re: next steps (0.3); t/c w/ 

S. Karotkin re: debt 

commitments (0.2).

4.50 $6,907.50

10/13/2019 Qusba, Sandy Prepare for call w/ M. Moore 

(0.8); t/c w/ same re: next steps 

(0.5); correspondence w/ N. 

Brownell re: next steps (0.2).

1.50 $2,302.50

10/14/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference calls w/ Board 

Chair and various Directors 

regarding debt commitments 

and various litigation issues 

(1.0); emails re: same (0.2).

1.20 $1,968.00

10/15/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs directors re: 

litigation and settlement (0.3); 

t/c S. Qusba re: litigation and 

settlement (0.4).

0.70 $1,148.00

10/15/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with M. Ponce regarding 

community structure (0.4); t/c 

with R. Barrera regarding next 

steps (0.3); t/c with S. Karotkin 

regarding same (0.3); review 

draft pleadings regarding 

debt/equity commitments and 

comment on same (2.1).

3.10 $4,758.50

10/16/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs w/ Directors 

re: various issues and litigation 

strategy issues (1.2). 1.20 $1,968.00

10/16/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with R. Barrera, M. Ponce 

and N. Goldin regarding Tubbs 

trials (0.4); correspondence 

with same regarding follow-up 

(0.3).

0.70 $1,074.50

10/17/2019 Qusba, Sandy Correspondence with M. Laffell 

and D. Mielle regarding Tubbs 5.50 $8,442.50

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 31

of 40
32

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

issues (0.2); t/c with B. Bennett 

regarding next steps (0.4); t/c 

with M. Ponce regarding same 

(0.3); review objections to 

Subro RSA (1.7); t/c with R. 

Barrera regarding update 

regarding Board/RX committee 

calls and next steps (0.4); t/c 

with board regarding various 

issues, including potential 

settlement of claims (1.5); 

review restructuring committee 

material and participate in call 

with same (1.0).

10/18/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review B. Johnson letters to 

CPUC and Governor (0.8).

0.80 $1,312.00

10/18/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conf call w/ J. Loduca, S. 

Qusba re: bank commitments 

(0.4). 0.40 $656.00

10/18/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review financing proposal and 

Lazard comparison to existing 

bank commitments (0.8), 

emails, issues, teleconfs re: 

same (0.4).

1.20 $1,968.00

10/18/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with M. Ponce and J. 

Loduca regarding debt 

commitment motion and Tubbs 

trial (0.5); t/c with N. Brownell 

regarding open issues (0.4); t/c 

with B. Bennett regarding 

catchup (0.4).

1.30 $1,995.50

10/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Finance Committee Meeting re: 

debt commitments (1.2), review 

related materials, emails and 

issues related to debt 

commitments (0.5).

1.70 $2,788.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 32

of 40
33

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review RSA Support Motion 

(0.8). 0.80 $1,312.00

10/21/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review K. Ziman declaration 

and motion for debt financing 

(1.2); review and comment on 

reply regarding RSA Subro 

Motion (0.8); t/c with M. Ponce 

regarding financing committee 

topics (0.2); t/c with finance 

committee, Weil, Lazard and 

senior management regarding 

exit financing (1.2).

3.40 $5,219.00

10/22/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review and comment on 

Motion Supporting Financing 

(0.9), emails re: same (0.3).

1.20 $1,968.00

10/22/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review NOL presentation 

regarding potential settlement 

(0.7).

0.70 $1,148.00

10/22/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/cs (numerous) with N. 

Brownell regarding various 

issues, including estimation and 

revisions to the ch. 11 plan 

(0.8); t/cs (numerous) with M. 

Ponce regarding same (0.6).

1.40 $2,149.00

10/23/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, various issues re: RSA 

hearing and Motion re financing 

commitments (0.5).

0.50 $820.00

10/23/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review correspondence 

regarding board updates (0.3); 

attend court hearing regarding 

plan process and Subro RSA 

(4.5); correspondence with 

Board members regarding 

summary of same (0.7).

5.50 $8,442.50

10/24/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with N. Brownell regarding 

wildfire update and board 

meeting on 10/27 and 28 (0.4); 

meeting with M. Ponce 

regarding same (0.3); 

participate on Board call (1.0); 

correspondence with Board 

members regarding next steps 

(0.4).

2.10 $3,223.50

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 33

of 40
34

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/25/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference call w/ M. Moore, 

S. Karotkin, S. Qusba re: 

various POR issues (0.8), precall w/ Advisors (0.2).

1.00 $1,640.00

10/25/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

next steps (0.3); t/c with M. 

Ponce regarding same (0.2); t/c 

with S. Karotkin, M. Ponce and 

M. Moore regarding plan 

options (0.8); review M. 

Moore's correspondence and 

calls with S. Karotkin regarding 

same (0.5); t/c with N. Brownell 

regarding same (0.3); review 

subpoenas regarding bar date 

motion and correspondence 

with Board members regarding 

same (1.3).

3.40 $5,219.00

10/26/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with B. Bennett regarding 

negotiations with TEC and 

claims analysis (0.5); t/c with 

N. Brownell regarding update 

(0.4); t/c with R. Barrera 

regarding same (0.5); 

correspondence with M. Moore 

regarding pleadings (0.3); 

review board material for 10/27 

call (1.0).

2.70 $4,144.50

10/27/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with N. Goldin and M. 

Ponce regarding upcoming 

Board meeting (0.5); t/c with 

M. Ponce and N. Brownell 

regarding same (0.5); t/c with S. 

Karotkin regarding next steps 

and Kincaid fire (0.5); t/c with 

Board and professionals 

regarding upcoming hearings 

and strategy regarding next 

steps (2.0); review and 

comment on Board memo and 

correspondence with M. Ponce 

regarding same (0.7).

4.20 $6,447.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 34

of 40
35

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/28/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review submission re: 

subrogation issues (0.6); call w/ 

Company counsel re: same 

(0.2); communications w/ team 

re: same (0.4).

1.20 $1,776.00

10/28/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Amended RSA, emails 

re: same (0.4).

0.40 $656.00

10/28/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, issues re: mediator 

appointment, communications

strategy (0.4).

0.40 $656.00

10/28/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with M. Ponce regarding 

catch-up (0.2); t/c with B. 

Bennett regarding update (0.3); 

t/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

same (0.5); t/c with M. Ponce, 

P. Curnin and J. Loduca 

regarding update (0.5); review 

and comment on amended and 

restated Subro RSA (1.8); 

correspondence with Weil 

regarding same (0.4).

3.70 $5,679.50

10/29/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review Weil comments to 

Subro RSA (0.7); t/c with S. 

Karotkin regarding consolidated 

mark-up (0.6); t/c with M. 

Ponce (numerous) regarding 

catch-up (0.6); review B. 

Bennett correspondence 

regarding mediation (0.3); t/c 

with B. Bennett regarding same 

(0.3); t/c with N. Brownell 

regarding Sacramento meeting 

4.90 $7,521.50

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 35

of 40
36

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

(0.5); t/c with S. Karotkin 

(numerous) regarding mediation 

and next steps (0.7); t/c with S. 

Karotkin, J. Wells and J. 

Loduca regarding same (0.6); 

correspondence with M. Ponce 

regarding same (0.6).

10/30/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review revised draft from 

Willkie regarding Subro RSA 

(0.8); review correspondence 

regarding potential rebate (0.2); 

t/c with R. Barrera regarding 

catch-up on mediation, Kincade 

and other issues (0.5); t/c with 

J. Loduca, R. Hall, S. Karotkin, 

J. Wells, M. Ponce, P. Curnin 

and N. Brownell regarding 

mediation (0.5); t/c with R. 

Barrera regarding update (0.4); 

t/c with M. Moore regarding 

update (0.4).

2.80 $4,298.00

10/31/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with N. Brownell and M. 

Ponce regarding update and 

next steps (0.3); t/c with M. 

Ponce, P. Curnin and N. Goldin 

regarding board call on 11/1 

(0.2).

0.50 $767.50

10/31/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare overview and talking 

points for board discussion re: 

Proposed Ch. 11 Plan and 

PERA Objection (1.5); 

discussion w/ STB group re: 

same (0.7).

2.20 $2,189.00

TOTAL 131.40 $179,515.50

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 36

of 40
37

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Task Code: Pre-Trial Pleadings and Motion (L200)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/1/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Continue preparation of motion 

to dismiss (6.5). 6.50 $10,660.00

10/1/2019 Blake, Stephen Further revisions to joint 

motion to dismiss (4.5); 

communications w/ P. Curnin 

and N. Goldin re: same (0.5); 

emails w/ DPW re: same (0.5); 

email director defendants re: 

same (0.5).

6.00 $7,950.00

10/1/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Revise MTD brief draft (2.2); 

communications w/ team re: 

brief (0.3).

2.50 $3,700.00

10/1/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Revise MTD brief (0.5); emails 

w/ J. Isaacman, K. Kinsel, R. 

Duran re: same (0.4); emails w/ 

S. Blake and E. Campbell re: 

same (0.4); emails w/ P. Curnin 

and N. Goldin re: client 

communication re: MTD brief 

(0.5).

1.80 $1,971.00

10/1/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W.

Draft proposed order on motion 

to dismiss (1.0); revisions to 

draft motion to dismiss (4.5).

5.50 $5,032.50

10/1/2019 Duran, Raul G. Legal research re: MTD brief 

(2.2). 2.20 $1,298.00

10/1/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer

Review motion to dismiss draft 

brief (1.0). 1.00 $590.00

10/1/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer

Legal research (3.5) and writeup re: MTD (1.4). 4.90 $2,891.00

10/2/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Further preparation of motion to 

dismiss (5.0). 5.00 $8,200.00

10/2/2019 Blake, Stephen Communications w/ team and 

DPW re: motion to dismiss 

arguments (0.5); 

communications w/ MWE re: 

same (0.5); review key cases 

proposed by team (2.0); prepare 

updated draft insert for DPW 

(1.7).

4.70 $6,227.50

10/2/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Revise MTD (1.5); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (1.0).

2.50 $3,700.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 37

of 40
38

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/2/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Research for MTD (0.8); emails 

w/ K. Kinsel, E. Campbell, S. 

Blake re: same (0.5).

1.30 $1,423.50

10/2/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W.

Revise draft motion to dismiss 

(2.5); draft proposed order 

granting motion to dismiss 

(0.7).

3.20 $2,928.00

10/2/2019 Duran, Raul G. Review offering documents 

(2.7). 2.70 $1,593.00

10/2/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J.

Review offering documents ISO 

MTD brief (1.0); prepare work 

product re: same (0.7).

1.70 $1,003.00

10/2/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer

Review SEC filings for MTD 

(1.0); emails w/ team re: same 

(0.1).

1.10 $649.00

10/3/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ DPW re: joint motion to 

dismiss (0.4); revise motion to 

dismiss papers (1.5).

1.90 $3,116.00

10/3/2019 Blake, Stephen T/c w/ DPW re: draft MTD 

(0.8); multiple communications 

w/ DPW re: draft MTD and 

supporting papers (0.5); 

communications w/ MWE re: 

drafts (0.4); review updated 

draft from DPW (2.0); revise 

updated draft for directors (1.5).

5.20 $6,890.00

10/3/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Revise MTD draft (1.0); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.5).

1.50 $2,220.00

10/3/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Review comments from Latham 

re: MTD brief (0.3); emails w/ 

S. Blake and N. Goldin re: same 

(0.2).

0.50 $547.50

10/3/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W.

Revise draft motion to dismiss 

(0.9). 0.90 $823.50

10/3/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W.

Revise of draft motion to 

dismiss (2.4). 2.40 $2,196.00

10/4/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Final review of MTD draft 

(1.3). 1.30 $2,132.00

10/4/2019 Kortright, 

Magallie

Collection of ECF filing for 

team review (0.1); preparation 

of court submissions for 

attorney review & electronic 

data update (0.5).

0.60 $240.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 38

of 40
39

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/4/2019 Blake, Stephen Review two updated drafts of 

joint motion to dismiss (2.8); 

provide directors’ comments 

(1.0); review RJN, declaration 

and notice of motion drafts 

(1.2); multiple communications 

w/ DPW re: finalizing of MTD 

(0.4); additional 

communications w/ DPW re: 

finalizing of MTD (0.2); 

communications w/ P. Curnin

re: preliminary statement (0.3); 

communications w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley and DPW re: Cravath 

comments and incorporate same 

(0.3); authorize filing (0.3).

6.50 $8,612.50

10/4/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review MTD (0.5). 0.50 $740.00

10/4/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel

Work on finalizing MTD brief 

(0.4); emails w/ S. Blake, E. 

Campbell, DPW re: same (0.5); 

review comments from 

Latham/Cravath re: MTD (0.3); 

emails w/ S. Blake re: same 

(0.2).

1.40 $1,533.00

10/4/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W.

Finalize motion to dismiss 

(2.5). 2.50 $2,287.50

10/4/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W.

Review of motion to dismiss 

brief (0.3). 0.30 $274.50

10/5/2019 Kortright, 

Magallie

Preparation of parties MTD 

filings for attorney review (1.0); 

electronic data update, as per R. 

Sparks Bradley (0.9); c/f w/ R. 

Sparks Bradley re: same (0.1).

2.00 $800.00

10/5/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review final MTD (0.5). 0.50 $740.00

10/7/2019 Blake, Stephen Draft update to director 

defendants re: MTDs (0.3). 0.30 $397.50

10/15/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W.

Call w/ S. Blake re: reply brief 

preparations (0.2); draft outline 

of reply brief (0.2).

0.40 $366.00

10/16/2019 Blake, Stephen Prepare for motion to dismiss 

reply (0.4); t/c w/ E. Campbell 

re: preparing outline (0.1).

0.50 $662.50

10/21/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W.

Draft outline of reply brief 

(0.2). 0.20 $183.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 39

of 40
40

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP

425 Lexington Ave

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

TOTAL 82.00 $94,578.00

Task Code: E-Discovery: Processing (L630)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount

10/1/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G.

Follow up communications w/ 

R. Sparks Bradley re: additional 

documents for collection (1.0).

1.00 $420.00

TOTAL 1.00 $420.00

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5221-4 Filed: 12/30/19 Entered: 12/30/19 11:41:14 Page 40

of 40