1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

STRADLING YOCCA 

CARLSON & RAUTH LAWYERS

SANTA MONICA

4848-3083-6912v8/022904-0012

STRADLING YOCCA CARLSON & RAUTH, a Professional Corporation 

Paul Glassman (SBN 76536) 

100 Wilshire Boulevard, 4th Floor 

Santa Monica, CA 90401 

Telephone: (424) 214-7000 

Facsimile: (424) 214-7010 

Email: pglassman@sycr.com 

Attorneys for Creditor and Party-In-Interest, 

South San Joaquin Irrigation District 

UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT 

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 

SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION 

In Re: 

PG&E CORPORATION 

- and - 

PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC 

COMPANY, 

Debtors.

Bankruptcy Case 

No. 19 - 30088 (DM) 

Chapter 11 

Lead Case 

Jointly Administered 

JOINDER OF SOUTH SAN JOAQUIN 

IRRIGATION DISTRICT TO VALLEY 

CLEAN ENERGY ALLIANCE STATUS 

CONFERENCE STATEMENT 

REGARDING PRECONFIRMATION 

LEGAL ISSUES [Dkt No. 5442] 

□ Affects PG&E Corporation 

□ Affects Pacific Gas and Electric 

Company 

 Affects both Debtors 

*All papers shall be filed in the Lead Case, 

No. 19-30088 (DM).

Date: January 23, 2020 

Time: 1:00 p.m. 

Place: United States Bankruptcy Court 

450 Golden Gate Ave., 16th Flr, Crt. 17 

San Francisco, CA 

Judge: Hon. Dennis Montali 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 1 of

14
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

STRADLING YOCCA 

CARLSON & RAUTH LAWYERS

SANTA MONICA

-1- 

4848-3083-6912v8/022904-0012

South San Joaquin Irrigation District (the “District”) joins in Valley Clean Energy 

Alliance’s (“VCE”) Status Conference Statement Regarding Preconfirmation Legal Issues [Dkt. 

5442](the “Statement”) filed in response to this court’s invitation in its Memorandum Regarding 

Confirmation Issues dated November 15, 2019 [Dkt. No. 4760] for parties to identify legal 

objections to the competing plans that could readily be resolved pre-confirmation as a matter of 

law. 

The District is an irrigation district organized and existing under Division 11 of the Water 

Code of the State of California. The District provides water for irrigation and domestic use and 

also generates solar and hydropower electricity for sale to Pacific Gas and Electric Company 

(“PG&E”) pursuant to certain prepetition contracts. Additionally, for several years the District 

has sought to provide retail electric service to approximately 40,000 customers. 

The District and PG&E are party to two proceedings pending in the California Court of 

Appeals, Third Appellate District relating to the District’s planned acquisition of certain assets 

for the retail sale of electricity (the “Property”) from PG&E either through a consensual 

transaction or by exercise of the District’s eminent domain power pursuant to California law. 

Briefing is far along in both appeals, but the proceedings were stayed by the state court upon the 

bankruptcy filing. After the filing, the District renewed its earlier offer to acquire the Property 

from PG&E; this offer was rejected. 

The District joins in VCE’s requests that this Court consider whether section 6.22 (the 

“Anti-Municipalization Provision”) of the Ad Hoc Committee of Senior Unsecured 

Noteholders’s (“AHC”) proposed plan of reorganization [Dkt. No. 4257] (the “Noteholder Plan”) 

is appropriately included in a plan of reorganization under section 1123(b)(6) of title 11 of the 

United States Code, 11 U.S.C. § 101 et seq. (the “Bankruptcy Code”) or otherwise and should be 

excluded from any compromise plan that may be reached by the AHC and the Debtors. 

The Anti-Municipalization Provision provides that the Reorganized Debtors (as defined 

in the Noteholder Plan) shall not sell and shall oppose any attempt to municipalize any portion of 

the operating business or assets for a period of five years after the effective date of the 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 2 of

14
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

STRADLING YOCCA 

CARLSON & RAUTH LAWYERS

SANTA MONICA

-2- 

4848-3083-6912v8/022904-0012

Noteholder Plan. Among other things, the Anti-Municipalization Provision improperly interferes 

with the sovereign authority of governments to take property for public use, discriminates against 

governmental units by not imposing a restriction on sale to any other entity, and constrains the 

business judgment of the future boards of the Reorganized Debtors. 

Additionally, the District joins in VCE’s concerns regarding the scope and effect of the 

discharge, release and injunction provisions of the Proposed Plans (defined below) as they apply 

to Governmental Units (as defined in the Proposed Plans). Both the Noteholder Plan and the plan 

proposed by PG&E [Dkt. 5101](as may have been amended from time to time, the “PG&E Plan” 

and together with the Noteholder Plan, the “Proposed Plans”), contain expansive discharge, 

release and injunction provisions (see Article X of the Proposed Plans). Both plans also contain a 

provision entitled Special Provisions for Governmental Units (“Section 10.13”). It appears that 

Section 10.13 is intended to provide relief to Governmental Units from the broad and expansive 

discharge, release and injunction provisions of the Proposed Plans, however it is not clear that 

this provision provides real and sufficient protection. Given the breadth of the discharge, release 

and injunction provisions of the Proposed Plans (see e.g. sections 10.3-10.9 of the Proposed 

Plans), and in light of Article I, Interpretation; Application of Definitions and Rules of 

Construction subsection (j),1 the District joins in VCE’s request for clarification as to the scope 

and effect of the discharge, release and injunction provisions of the Proposed Plans as to 

Governmental Units, and in particular that they do not affect the exercise of the power of 

eminent domain and ancillary related authority of Governmental Units as such exist outside of 

bankruptcy in any respect. 

 

1

 Article I, Interpretation; Application of Definitions and Rules of Construction subsection (j) 

provides “any effectuating provisions [of the plan] may be interpreted by the Reorganized 

Debtors in a manner consistent with the overall purpose and intent of the Plan, all without further 

notice to or action, order, or approval of the court or any other entity, and such interpretation 

shall control in all respects;” 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 3 of

14
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

STRADLING YOCCA 

CARLSON & RAUTH LAWYERS

SANTA MONICA

-3- 

4848-3083-6912v8/022904-0012

CONCLUSION 

Wherefore, the District respectfully requests that this Court include consideration of the 

propriety of the Anti-Municipalization Provision and the scope and effect of the release, 

discharge and injunction provisions of both Proposed Plans on governmental units in any preconfirmation briefing schedule. The District reserves all of its rights to raise substantive 

objections to plan provisions at the appropriate time. 

DATED: January 22, 2020 STRADLING YOCCA CARLSON & 

RAUTH A PROFESSIONAL 

CORPORATION 

By: /s/ Paul R. Glassman 

Attorneys for Creditor and Party-in-Interest 

South San Joaquin Irrigation District 

 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 4 of

14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

PROOF OF SERVICE OF DOCUMENT 

I am over the age of 18 and not a party to this bankruptcy case or adversary proceeding. My business address is: 

100 Wilshire Blvd., 4th Floor, Santa Monica, CA 90401. 

A true and correct copy of the foregoing document JOINDER OF SOUTH SAN JOAQUIN IRRIGATION DISTRICT TO 

VALLEY CLEAN ENERGY ALLIANCE STATUS CONFERENCE STATEMENT REGARDING PRECONFIRMATION 

LEGAL ISSUES will be served or was served (a) on the judge in chambers in the form and manner required by LBR 5005-

2(d); and (b) in the manner stated below: 

1. TO BE SERVED BY THE COURT VIA NOTICE OF ELECTRONIC FILING (NEF): Pursuant to controlling General 

Orders and LBR, the foregoing document will be served by the court via NEF and hyperlink to the document. On January 

22, 2020 I checked the CM/ECF docket for this bankruptcy case or adversary proceeding and determined that the 

following persons are on the Electronic Mail Notice List to receive NEF transmission at the email addresses stated below: 

 Elliot Adler eadler@theadlerfirm.com, bzummer@theadlerfirm.com 

 Annadel A. Almendras annadel.almendras@doj.ca.gov 

 Monique D. Almy malmy@crowell.com 

 Dana M. Andreoli dandreoli@steyerlaw.com, mterry@steyerlaw.com 

 Anne Andrews aa@andrewsthornton.com, aandrews@andrewsthornton.com 

 Richard L. Antognini rlalawyer@yahoo.com, hallonaegis@gmail.com 

 Tyson Arbuthnot tarbuthnot@rjo.com, jyeung@rjo.com 

 Lauren T. Attard lattard@bakerlaw.com, agrosso@bakerlaw.com 

 Herb Baer hbaer@primeclerk.com, ecf@primeclerk.com 

 Kathryn E. Barrett keb@svlg.com, amt@svlg.com 

 Chris Bator cbator@bakerlaw.com, jmcguigan@bakerlaw.com 

 Ronald S. Beacher rbeacher@pryorcashman.com 

 Hagop T. Bedoyan hbedoyan@kleinlaw.com, ecf@kleinlaw.com 

 Andrew David Behlmann abehlmann@lowenstein.com, elawler@lowenstein.com 

 Tanya Behnam tbehnam@polsinelli.com, tanyabehnam@gmail.com 

 James C. Behrens jbehrens@milbank.com, mkoch@milbank.com 

 Jacob Taylor Beiswenger jbeiswenger@omm.com, llattin@omm.com 

 James T. Bentley james.bentley@srz.com, Kelly.Knight@srz.com 

 Peter J. Benvenutti pbenvenutti@kellerbenvenutti.com 

 Robert Berens rberens@smtdlaw.com, sr@smtdlaw.com 

 Ronald F. Berestka rberestka@stonelawoffice.com, csepulveda@stonelawoffice.com 

 Heinz Binder heinz@bindermalter.com 

 Neil Jon Bloomfield njbloomfield@njblaw.com, gklump@njblaw.com 

 Jason Blumberg jason.blumberg@usdoj.gov, ustpregion17.sf.ecf@usdoj.gov 

 Ameneh Maria Bordi ameneh.bordi@kirkland.com, leo.rosenberg@kirkland.com 

 Jason Borg jborg@jasonborglaw.com 

 Mark Bostick mbostick@wendel.com, bankruptcy@wendel.com 

 James L. Bothwell jbothwell@hugueninkahn.com, jguzman@hugueninkahn.com 

 Peter R. Boutin peter.boutin@kyl.com, lara.joel@kyl.com 

 Erin N. Brady enbrady@jonesday.com 

 Gregory A. Bray gbray@milbank.com 

 Michael D. Breslauer mbreslauer@ecf.courtdrive.com, wyones@swsslaw.com 

 W. Steven Bryant , molly.batiste-debose@lockelord.com 

 Chane Buck cbuck@jonesday.com 

 Elizabeth J. Cabraser ecabraser@lchb.com, awolf@lchb.com 

 Anthony P. Cali anthony.cali@stinson.com, lindsay.petrowski@stinson.com 

 Peter C. Califano pcalifano@cwclaw.com 

 Steven M. Campora scampora@dbbwc.com, nlechuga@dbbwc.com 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 5 of

14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

 Leah E. Capritta leah.capritta@hklaw.com, lori.labash@hklaw.com 

 Nicholas A. Carlin nac@phillaw.com, rac@phillaw.com 

 Katherine Rose Catanese kcatanese@foley.com 

 Jennifer Machlin Cecil JCecil@winston.com, ECF_SF@winston.com 

 Karen J. Chedister kchedister@h-jlaw.com 

 Christina Lin Chen christina.chen@morganlewis.com, christina.lin.chen@gmail.com 

 Richard A. Chesley richard.chesley@dlapiper.com, bill.countryman@dlapiper.com 

 Shawn M. Christianson schristianson@buchalter.com 

 Robert N.H. Christmas rchristmas@nixonpeabody.com, nyc.managing.clerk@nixonpeabody.com 

 Alicia Clough aclough@loeb.com 

 Tiffany Strelow Cobb tscobb@vorys.com 

 John B. Coffman john@johncoffman.net 

 Kevin G. Collins kevin.collins@btlaw.com 

 Brian S. Conlon bsc@phillaw.com, rac@phillaw.com 

 Charles Cording ccording@willkie.com, mao@willkie.com 

 Manuel Corrales mannycorrales@yahoo.com, hcskanchy@hotmail.com 

 Anne Costin anne@costinlawfirm.com 

 Donald H. Cram dhc@severson.com 

 Ashley Vinson Crawford avcrawford@akingump.com, dkrasa-berstell@akingump.com 

 John Cumming jcumming@dir.ca.gov 

 J. Russell Cunningham rcunningham@dnlc.net, emehr@dnlc.net 

 Keith J. Cunningham , rkelley@pierceatwood.com 

 Keith J. Cunningham kcunningham@pierceatwood.com, rkelley@pierceatwood.com 

 James D. Curran jcurran@wolkincurran.com, dstorms@wolkincurran.com 

 Tambra Curtis tambra.curtis@sonoma-county.org, Kristin.whalley@sonoma-county.org 

 Nicolas De Lancie ndelancie@jmbm.com 

 Judith A. Descalso , jad_9193@ecf.courtdrive.com 

 Erin Elizabeth Dexter edexter@milbank.com 

 Shounak S. Dharap ssd@arnslaw.com, mec@arnslaw.com 

 Kathryn S. Diemer kdiemer@diemerwhitman.com, ecfnotice@diemerwhitman.com 

 John P. Dillman houston_bankruptcy@publicans.com 

 Jonathan R. Doolittle jdoolittle@reedsmith.com, bgonshorowski@reedsmith.com 

 Jennifer V. Doran jdoran@hinckleyallen.com 

 Dustin M. Dow ddow@bakerlaw.com, jmcguigan@bakerlaw.com 

 Jamie P. Dreher jdreher@downeybrand.com 

 Geoffrey B. Dryvynsyde gbd@cpuc.ca.gov, geoffrey.dryvynsyde@cpuc.ca.gov 

 Cecily Ann Dumas cdumas@bakerlaw.com, hhammonturano@bakerlaw.com 

 Dennis F. Dunne cprice@milbank.com, jbrewster@milbank.com 

 Dennis F. Dunne ddunne@milbank.com, jbrewster@milbank.com 

 Huonganh Annie Duong annie.duong@mccormickbarstow.com, dawn.houston@mccormickbarstow.com 

 Kevin M. Eckhardt keckhardt@hunton.com, candonian@huntonak.com 

 Michael Eggenberger meggenberger@piercebainbridge.com, gchang@piercebainbridge.com 

 Joseph A. Eisenberg JAE1900@yahoo.com 

 Michele Ellison mellison@gibbsgiden.com, lrochelle@gibbsgiden.com 

 David Emerzian , Melany.Hertel@mccormickbarstow.com 

 G. Larry Engel larry@engeladvice.com 

 Krista M. Enns kenns@beneschlaw.com 

 Scott Esbin sesbin@esbinalter.com 

 Joseph M. Esmont jesmont@bakerlaw.com 

 Michael P. Esser michael.esser@kirkland.com, michael-esser-3293@ecf.pacerpro.com. 

 Richard W. Esterkin richard.esterkin@morganlewis.com, melissa.boey@morganlewis.com 

 Michael S. Etkin metkin@lowenstein.com 

 Jacob M. Faircloth jacob.faircloth@smolsonlaw.com 

 Brett D. Fallon bfallon@morrisjames.com, wweller@morrisjames.com 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 6 of

14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

 Michael C. Fallon mcfallon@fallonlaw.net, manders@fallonlaw.net 

 Joseph Kyle Feist jfeistesq@gmail.com, info@norcallawgroup.net 

 David M. Feldman DFeldman@gibsondunn.com 

 Matthew A. Feldman mfeldman@willkie.com 

 Mark E. Felger mfelger@cozen.com 

 James J. Ficenec James.Ficenec@ndlf.com, caroline.pfahl@ndlf.com 

 John D. Fiero jfiero@pszjlaw.com, ocarpio@pszjlaw.com 

 Kimberly S. Fineman kfineman@nutihart.com, nwhite@nutihart.com 

 Stephen D. Finestone sfinestone@fhlawllp.com 

 Timothy M. Flaherty tflaherty@mpplaw.com 

 Daniel I. Forman dforman@willkie.com 

 Jonathan Forstot jonathan.forstot@troutman.com, john.murphy@troutman.com 

 Jonathan Forstot , john.murphy@troutman.com 

 Matthew Hampton Foushee hampton.foushee@hoganlovells.com, hfoushee@gmail.com 

 Carolyn Frederick cfrederick@prklaw.com 

 Peter Friedman pfriedman@omm.com 

 Roger F. Friedman rfriedman@rutan.com, csolorzano@rutan.com 

 Xiyi Fu jackie.fu@lockelord.com, taylor.warren@lockelord.com 

 Lars H. Fuller lfuller@bakerlaw.com 

 Larry W. Gabriel lgabriel@bg.law, nfields@bg.law 

 Gregg M. Galardi gregg.galardi@ropesgray.com 

 Richard L. Gallagher richard.gallagher@ropesgray.com 

 Craig Solomon Ganz ganzc@ballardspahr.com, hartt@ballardspahr.com 

 Jeffrey K. Garfinkle jgarfinkle@buchalter.com 

 Oscar Garza ogarza@gibsondunn.com 

 Paul R. Gaus paul.gaus@mccormickbarstow.com 

 Duane M. Geck dmg@severson.com 

 Evelina Gentry evelina.gentry@akerman.com, rob.diwa@akerman.com 

 Janet D. Gertz jgertz@btlaw.com, amattingly@btlaw.com 

 Christopher Gessner cgessner@akingump.com, NYMCO@akingump.com 

 Barry S. Glaser bglaser@lkfirm.com 

 Paul R. Glassman glassmanp@gtlaw.com 

 Gabriel I. Glazer gglazer@pszjlaw.com 

 Gabrielle Glemann gabrielle.glemann@stoel.com, rene.alvin@stoel.com 

 Jaime Godin Jtouchstone@fddcm.com 

 Matthew A. Gold courts@argopartners.net 

 Eric D. Goldberg eric.goldberg@dlapiper.com, eric-goldberg-1103@ecf.pacerpro.com 

 Amy L. Goldman goldman@lbbslaw.com 

 Eric S. Goldstein egoldstein@goodwin.com 

 Rhonda Stewart Goldstein Rhonda.Goldstein@ucop.edu, Lissa.Ly@ucop.edu 

 Richard H. Golubow rgolubow@wcghlaw.com, jmartinez@WCGHLaw.com 

 Michael J. Gomez mgomez@frandzel.com, dmoore@frandzel.com 

 Michael W. Goodin mgoodin@clausen.com, mgenova@clausen.com 

 Eric R. Goodman egoodman@bakerlaw.com 

 Mark A. Gorton mgorton@boutinjones.com, cdomingo@boutininc.com 

 Mark A. Gorton mgorton@boutininc.com, cdomingo@boutininc.com 

 Michael I. Gottfried MGottfried@elkinskalt.com, AAburto@elkinskalt.com 

 Louis Gottlieb Lgottlieb@labaton.com, mpenrhyn@labaton.com 

 Eric A. Grasberger eric.grasberger@stoel.com, docketclerk@stoel.com 

 Debra I. Grassgreen dgrassgreen@pszjlaw.com, hphan@pszjlaw.com 

 Eric A. Gravink eric@rhrc.net 

 Elizabeth A. Green egreen@bakerlaw.com, orlbankruptcy@bakerlaw.com 

 Stuart G. Gross sgross@grosskleinlaw.com, iatkinsonyoung@grosskleinlaw.com 

 David Matthew Guess guessd@gtlaw.com 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 7 of

14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

 Elizabeth M. Guffy eguffy@lockelord.com, autodocket@lockelord.com 

 Cameron Gulden cameron.m.gulden@usdoj.gov 

 Mirco J. Haag mhaag@buchalter.com, dcyrankowski@buchalter.com 

 Laurie Hager lhager@sussmanshank.com 

 J. Noah Hagey hagey@braunhagey.com, tong@braunhagey.com 

 Oren Buchanan Haker oren.haker@stoel.com, rene.alvin@stoel.com 

 Kristopher M. Hansen dmohamed@stroock.com, mmagzamen@stroock.com 

 Adam C. Harris adam.harris@srz.com, james.bentley@srz.com 

 Robert G. Harris rob@bindermalter.com 

 Christopher H. Hart chart@nutihart.com, nwhite@nutihart.com 

 Bryan L. Hawkins bryan.hawkins@stoel.com, Sharon.witkin@stoel.com 

 Jan M Hayden jhayden@bakerdonelson.com, gmitchell@bakerdonelson.com 

 Jennifer C. Hayes jhayes@fhlawllp.com 

 Alaina R. Heine alaina.heine@dechert.com, brett.stone@dechert.com 

 Cristina A. Henriquez chenriquez@mayerbrown.com 

 Stephen E. Hessler, P.C. , jozette.chong@kirkland.com 

 Sean T. Higgins aandrews@andrewsthornton.com, shiggins@andrewsthornton.com 

 Morgan R. Hirst mhirst@jonesday.com, mmelvin@jonesday.com 

 Michael R. Hogue hoguem@gtlaw.com, navarrom@gtlaw.com 

 David Holtzman david.holtzman@hklaw.com 

 Alexandra S. Horwitz allie.horwitz@dinsmore.com 

 Marsha Houston mhouston@reedsmith.com, hvalencia@reedsmith.com 

 Shane Huang shane.huang@usdoj.gov 

 Brian D. Huben hubenb@ballardspahr.com 

 Jonathan Hughes , jane.rustice@aporter.com 

 Edward R. Huguenin ehuguenin@hugueninkahn.com, jguzman@hugueninkahn.com 

 Michael A. Isaacs Michael.Isaacs@dentons.com, Alissa.Worthing@dentons.com 

 Mark V. Isola mvi@sbj-law.com 

 J. Eric Ivester Eric.Ivester@skadden.com, Andrea.Bates@skadden.com 

 J. Eric Ivester , Andrea.Bates@skadden.com 

 Ivan C. Jen ivan@icjenlaw.com 

 Monique Jewett-Brewster mjb@hopkinscarley.com, eamaro@hopkinscarley.com 

 James O. Johnston jjohnston@jonesday.com 

 Chris Johnstone chris.johnstone@wilmerhale.com, whdocketing@wilmerhale.com 

 Andrew Jones andrew@ajoneslaw.com 

 Gregory K. Jones GJones@dykema.com, cacossano@dykema.com 

 Robert A. Julian rjulian@bakerlaw.com, hhammonturano@bakerlaw.com 

 George H. Kalikman gkalikman@schnader.com, sdavenport@schnader.com 

 Roberto J. Kampfner rkampfner@whitecase.com, mco@whitecase.com 

 Gary M. Kaplan gkaplan@fbm.com, calendar@fbm.com 

 Robert B. Kaplan rbk@jmbm.com 

 Eve H. Karasik ehk@lnbyb.com 

 Michael G. Kasolas trustee@kasolas.net, CA30@ecfcbis.com,ecf.alert+Kasolas@titlexi.com 

 Elyssa S. Kates ekates@bakerlaw.com 

 Ori Katz okatz@sheppardmullin.com, LSegura@sheppardmullin.com 

 William M. Kaufman wkaufman@smwb.com 

 Jane G. Kearl jkearl@watttieder.com, jbenton@watttieder.com 

 Tobias S. Keller tkeller@kellerbenvenutti.com, pbenvenutti@kellerbenvenutti.com 

 Lynette C. Kelly ustpregion17.oa.ecf@usdoj.gov 

 Matthew K. Kelsey mkelsey@gibsondunn.com 

 Gerald P. Kennedy gerald.kennedy@procopio.com, angela.stevens@procopio.com 

 Erica L. Kerman ekerman@willkie.com 

 Samuel A. Khalil skhalil@milbank.com, jbrewster@milbank.com 

 Samuel M. Kidder skidder@ktbslaw.com 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 8 of

14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

 Marc Kieselstein , carrie.oppenheim@kirkland.com 

 Jane Kim jkim@kellerbenvenutti.com 

 Kody D. L. Kleber kkleber@bakerlaw.com, dmartinez@bakerlaw.com 

 Matthew Ryan Klinger mklinger@sheppardmullin.com, DGatmen@sheppardmullin.com 

 Bradley C. Knapp bknapp@lockelord.com, Yamille.Harrison@lockelord.com 

 Kelly V. Knight kelly.knight@srz.com 

 Lydia Vanessa Ko Lvko@stonelawoffice.com 

 Thomas F. Koegel tkoegel@crowell.com 

 Katherine Kohn kkohn@groom.com, ashahinllari@groom.com 

 Andy S. Kong kong.andy@arentfox.com, Yvonne.Li@arentfox.com 

 Anna Kordas akordas@jonesday.com, mmelvin@jonesday.com 

 Alan W. Kornberg , akornberg@paulweiss.com 

 Bernard Kornberg bjk@severson.com 

 David I. Kornbluh dik@millermorton.com, mhr@millermorton.com 

 Lauren Kramer lkramer@rjo.com 

 Jeffrey C. Krause jkrause@gibsondunn.com 

 Thomas R. Kreller tkreller@milbank.com 

 Lindsey E. Kress lkress@lockelord.com, autodocket@lockelord.com 

 Hannah C. Kreuser hkreuser@porterlaw.com, ooberg@porterlaw.com 

 Michael Thomas Krueger michael.krueger@ndlf.com, Havilyn.lee@ndlf.com 

 Robert T. Kugler robert.kugler@stinson.com 

 Boris Kukso boris.kukso@usdoj.gov, western.taxcivil@usdoj.gov 

 Alisa C. Lacey alisa.lacey@stinson.com, karen.graves@stinson.com 

 Timothy S. Laffredi timothy.s.laffredi@usdoj.gov, patti.vargas@usdoj.gov 

 Richard A. Lapping rich@trodellalapping.com 

 Omeed Latifi olatifi@theadlerfirm.com, kdeubler@theadlerfirm.com 

 John E. Lattin jlattin@ostergar.com, cslovenec@ostergar.com 

 Michael Lauter mlauter@sheppardmullin.com 

 Kenneth T. Law klaw@bbslaw.com 

 Francis J. Lawall lawallf@pepperlaw.com, henrys@pepperlaw.com 

 Andrew Michael Leblanc ALeblanc@milbank.com 

 Erica Lee Erica.Lee@doj.ca.gov 

 Scott Lee scott.lee@lewisbrisbois.com, monique.talamante@lewisbrisbois.com 

 Edward J. Leen eleen@mkbllp.com 

 Lisa Lenherr llenherr@wendel.com, bankruptcy@wendel.com 

 Matthew A. Lesnick matt@lesnickprince.com, jmack@lesnickprince.com 

 Bryn G. Letsch bletsch@braytonlaw.com 

 David B. Levant david.levant@stoel.com, rene.alvin@stoel.com 

 Andrew H. Levin alevin@wcghlaw.com 

 David Levine dnl@groom.com 

 Marc A. Levinson Malevinson@orrick.com, casestream@ecf.courtdrive.com 

 Dara Levinson Silveira dsilveira@kellerbenvenutti.com 

 Alexander James Demitro Lewicki kdiemer@diemerwei.com, alewicki@diemerwei.com 

 William S. Lisa , jcaruso@nixonpeabody.com 

 William S. Lisa wlisa@nixonpeabody.com, jcaruso@nixonpeabody.com 

 Jonathan A. Loeb jon.loeb@bingham.com 

 John William Lucas jlucas@pszjlaw.com, ocarpio@pszjlaw.com 

 Jane Luciano jane-luciano@comcast.net 

 Kerri Lyman klyman@irell.com 

 Carissa A. Lynch Carissa.Lynch@ftb.ca.gov, Martha.Gehrig@ftb.ca.gov 

 John H. MacConaghy macclaw@macbarlaw.com, smansour@macbarlaw.com;kmuller@macbarlaw.com 

 Iain A. Macdonald iain@macfern.com, ecf@macfern.com 

 Tracy L. Mainguy tmainguy@unioncounsel.net, bankruptcycourtnotices@unioncounsel.net 

 Samuel R. Maizel samuel.maizel@dentons.com, alicia.aguilar@dentons.com 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 9 of

14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

 Adam Malatesta adam.malatesta@lw.com, adam--malatesta-8393@ecf.pacerpro.com 

 Katharine Malone malonek@gtlaw.com 

 Liam K. Malone malone@oles.com, shahin@oles.com 

 Michael W. Malter michael@bindermalter.com 

 Craig Margulies cmargulies@margulies-law.com, lsalazar@margulies-law.com 

 Geoffrey E. Marr gemarr59@hotmail.com 

 Richard A. Marshack rmarshack@marshackhays.com, lbuchanan@marshackhays.com 

 Catherine Martin cmartin@simon.com, rtucker@simon.com;bankruptcy@simon.com 

 Laila Masud lmasud@marshackhays.com, 8649808420@filings.docketbird.com 

 David P. Matthews jrhoades@thematthewslawfirm.com, aharrison@thematthewslawfirm.com 

 Patrick C. Maxcy patrick.maxcy@snrdenton.com 

 Benjamin P. McCallen bmccallen@willkie.com 

 Thomas E. McCurnin tmccurnin@bkolaw.com, kescano@bkolaw.com 

 Hugh M. McDonald hugh.mcdonald@troutman.com, john.murphy@troutman.com 

 Hugh M. McDonald , john.murphy@troutman.com 

 C. Luckey McDowell Luckey.McDowell@Shearman.com 

 Matthew D. McGill MMcGill@gibsondunn.com 

 Scott H. McNutt SMcNutt@ml-sf.com, csnell@ml-sf.com 

 Thomas Melone Thomas.Melone@gmail.com, Thomas.Melone@AllcoUS.com 

 Peter Meringolo peter@pmrklaw.com 

 Frank A. Merola lacalendar@stroock.com, mmagzamen@stroock.com 

 Jennifer L. Mersing jennifer.mersing@stoel.com, lisa.petras@stoel.com 

 Joshua M. Mester jmester@jonesday.com 

 Matthew D. Metzger belvederelegalecf@gmail.com 

 Randy Michelson randy.michelson@michelsonlawgroup.com 

 Joseph G. Minias jminias@willkie.com 

 M. David Minnick dminnick@pillsburylaw.com, docket@pillsburylaw.com 

 Nancy Mitchell nmitchell@omm.com 

 Thomas C. Mitchell tcmitchell@orrick.com, Dcmanagingattorneysoffice@ecf.courtdrive.com 

 John A. Moe john.moe@dentons.com, glenda.spratt@dentons.com 

 Aaron J. Mohamed ajm@brereton.law, aaronmohamedlaw@gmail.com 

 Kevin Montee kmontee@monteeassociates.com 

 David W. Moon lacalendar@stroock.com, mmagzamen@stroock.com 

 Diane Marger Moore dmargermoore@baumhedlundlaw.com 

 Erika L. Morabito emorabito@foley.com, hsiagiandraughn@foley.com 

 Candace J. Morey cjm@cpuc.ca.gov 

 Courtney L. Morgan morgan.courtney@pbgc.gov 

 Joshua D. Morse Joshua.Morse@dlapiper.com, joshua-morse-0092@ecf.pacerpro.com 

 Andrew H. Morton andrew.morton@stoel.com, lisa.petras@stoel.com 

 Thomas G. Mouzes tmouzes@boutinjones.com, cdomingo@boutininc.com 

 Peter S. Munoz pmunoz@reedsmith.com, gsandoval@reedsmith.com 

 Bennett J. Murphy bmurphy@bennettmurphylaw.com 

 Michael S. Myers myersms@ballardspahr.com, hartt@ballardspahr.com 

 Alan I. Nahmias anahmias@mbnlawyers.com, jdale@mbnlawyers.com 

 David L. Neale dln@lnbrb.com 

 David L. Neale dln@lnbyb.com 

 David Neier dneier@winston.com 

 Brittany J. Nelson bnelson@foley.com, hsiagiandraughn@foley.com 

 Michael S. Neumeister MNeumeister@gibsondunn.com 

 Howard S. Nevins hnevins@hsmlaw.com 

 Melissa T. Ngo ngo.melissa@pbgc.gov, efile@pbgc.gov 

 Mario R. Nicholas mario.nicholas@stoel.com, cherie.clark@stoel.com 

 Sean Nolan snolan@akingump.com, NYMCO@akingump.com 

 Gregory C. Nuti gnuti@nutihart.com, nwhite@nutihart.com 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 10

of 14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

 Abigail O'Brient aobrient@mintz.com, docketing@mintz.com 

 Julie E. Oelsner joelsner@weintraub.com, bjennings@weintraub.com 

 Office of the U.S. Trustee / SF USTPRegion17.SF.ECF@usdoj.gov 

 Matthew Jon Olson matt@macfern.com, stell.laura@dorsey.com 

 Steven M. Olson smo@smolsonlaw.com 

 Aram Ordubegian Ordubegian.Aram@ArentFox.com 

 Gabriel Ozel , gabeozel@gmail.com 

 Margarita Padilla Margarita.Padilla@doj.ca.gov 

 Amy S. Park amy.park@skadden.com, alissa.turnipseed@skadden.com 

 Donna Taylor Parkinson donna@parkinsonphinney.com 

 Peter S. Partee , candonian@huntonak.com 

 Paul J. Pascuzzi ppascuzzi@ffwplaw.com, kwidder@ffwplaw.com 

 Kenneth Pasquale , mlaskowski@stroock.com 

 Charles Scott Penner penner@carneylaw.com, caragol@carneylaw.com 

 Valerie Bantner Peo vbantnerpeo@buchalter.com 

 Yosef Peretz yperetz@peretzlaw.com, skim@peretzlaw.com 

 Thomas R. Phinney tom@parkinsonphinney.com 

 R. Alexander Pilmer alexander.pilmer@kirkland.com, keith.catuara@kirkland.com 

 M. Ryan Pinkston rpinkston@seyfarth.com, jmcdermott@seyfarth.com 

 Estela O. Pino epino@epinolaw.com, rmahal@epinolaw.com 

 Gregory Plaskett GREGORY.PLASKETT@GMAIL.COM, HKHAPPYGRL1@GMAIL.COM 

 Mark D. Plevin mplevin@crowell.com 

 Steven G. Polard spolard@eisnerlaw.com 

 Mark D. Poniatowski ponlaw@ponlaw.com 

 William L. Porter bporter@porterlaw.com, Ooberg@porterlaw.com 

 Christopher E. Prince cprince@lesnickprince.com 

 Douglas B. Provencher dbp@provlaw.com 

 Stacey C. Quan squan@steyerlaw.com, pspencer@steyerlaw.com 

 Amy C. Quartarolo amy.quartarolo@lw.com 

 Lary Alan Rappaport lrappaport@proskauer.com, PHays@proskauer.com 

 Justin E. Rawlins jrawlins@winston.com, justin-rawlins-0284@ecf.pacerpro.com 

 Hugh M. Ray hugh.ray@pillsburylaw.com, nancy.jones@pillsburylaw.com 

 Paul F. Ready smeyer@farmerandready.com 

 Caroline A. Reckler caroline.reckler@lw.com 

 David M. Reeder david@reederlaw.com, david.m.reeder@gmail.com;Jessica@reederlaw.com 

 Steven J. Reisman sreisman@katten.com, nyc.bknotices@kattenlaw.com 

 Jeffrey M. Reisner jreisner@irell.com 

 Jack A. Reitman , srichmond@lgbfirm.com 

 Emily P. Rich erich@unioncounsel.net, bankruptcycourtnotices@unioncounsel.net 

 David J. Richardson drichardson@bakerlaw.com, aagonzalez@bakerlaw.com 

 Christopher O. Rivas crivas@reedsmith.com, chris-rivas-8658@ecf.pacerpro.com 

 David B. Rivkin drivkin@bakerlaw.com, jmeeks@bakerlaw.com 

 John R. Rizzardi kcoselman@cairncross.com, tnguyen@cairncross.com 

 Daniel Robertson robertson.daniel@pbgc.gov, efile@pbgc.gov 

 Lacey E. Rochester lrochester@bakerdonelson.com, gmitchell@bakerdonelson.com 

 Michael Rogers mrogers@lambertrogers.com, jan@lambertrogers.com 

 Julie H. Rome-Banks julie@bindermalter.com 

 Jorian L. Rose jrose@bakerlaw.com 

 Paul M. Rosenblatt prosenblatt@kilpatricktownsend.com, mwilliams@kilpatricktownsend.com 

 Allan Robert Rosin arrosin@alr-law.com 

 Jay M. Ross jross@hopkinscarley.com, eamaro@hopkinscarley.com 

 Gregory A. Rougeau grougeau@brlawsf.com 

 Stacy H. Rubin rubins@ballardspahr.com, BKTDocket_West@ballardspahr.com 

 Jason C. Rubinstein jrubinstein@fklaw.com, mclerk@fklaw.com 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 11

of 14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

 Nathan Q. Rugg nathan.rugg@bfkn.com, jean.montgomery@bfkn.com 

 Thomas B. Rupp trupp@kellerbenvenutti.com 

 Eric E. Sagerman esagerman@bakerlaw.com 

 Robert Sahyan rsahyan@sheppardmullin.com, JNakaso@sheppardmullin.com 

 Jonathan C. Sanders jsanders@stblaw.com 

 Nanette D. Sanders nanette@ringstadlaw.com, becky@ringstadlaw.com 

 Lovee Sarenas Lovee.sarenas@lewisbrisbois.com 

 Sunny S. Sarkis sunny.sarkis@stoel.com, dawn.forgeur@stoel.com 

 Patricia Savage psavesq@gmail.com, jodi.savage@gmail.com 

 Sblend A. Sblendorio sas@hogefenton.com 

 Francis O. Scarpulla fos@scarpullalaw.com, cpc@scarpullalaw.com 

 Daren M Schlecter daren@schlecterlaw.com, info@schlecterlaw.com 

 Bradley R. Schneider bradley.schneider@mto.com 

 Harvey S. Schochet Harveyschochet@dwt.com 

 Lisa Schweitzer lschweitzer@cgsh.com 

 Eric J. Seiler eseiler@fklaw.com, mclerk@fklaw.com 

 David B. Shemano dshemano@pwkllp.com 

 James A. Shepherd jim@jsheplaw.com, shepIGN@gmail.com 

 Leonard M. Shulman lshulman@shbllp.com 

 Andrew I. Silfen andrew.silfen@arentfox.com 

 Wayne A. Silver w_silver@sbcglobal.net, ws@waynesilverlaw.com 

 Craig S. Simon csimon@bergerkahn.com, aketcher@bergerkahn.com 

 Gerald Singleton gerald@slffirm.com, BKECFCANB@SLFfirm.com 

 Jeremy C. Sink jsink@kmclaw.com 

 Michael K. Slattery mslattery@lkfirm.com, rramirez@lkfirm.com 

 Dania Slim dania.slim@pillsburylaw.com, melinda.hernandez@pillsburylaw.com 

 Jennifer N. Slocum jennifer.slocum@stoel.com, docketclerk@stoel.com 

 Aaron C. Smith asmith@lockelord.com, autodocket@lockelord.com 

 Alan D. Smith adsmith@perkinscoie.com, al-smith-9439@ecf.pacerpro.com 

 Jan D. Sokol jdsokol@lawssl.com, dwright@lawssl.com 

 Randye B. Soref rsoref@polsinelli.com 

 Joseph Sorkin jsorkin@akingump.com, NYMCO@akingump.com 

 Bennett L. Spiegel blspiegel@jonesday.com 

 Michael St. James ecf@stjames-law.com 

 Howard J. Steinberg steinbergh@gtlaw.com, pearsallt@gtlaw.com 

 Harriet A. Steiner harriet.steiner@bbklaw.com, claudia.peach@bbklaw.com 

 Lillian G. Stenfeldt lillian.stenfeldt@rimonlaw.com, jon.arneson@sedgwicklaw.com 

 Lillian G. Stenfeldt lillian.stenfeldt@sdma.com, jon.arneson@sedgwicklaw.com 

 Cheryl L. Stengel clstengel@outlook.com, stengelcheryl40@gmail.com 

 David M. Stern dstern@ktbslaw.com 

 Geoffrey S. Stewart gstewart@jonesday.com, mmelvin@jonesday.com 

 Alan J. Stone AStone@milbank.com, DMcCracken@Milbank.com 

 Michael H. Strub mstrub@irell.com, mhstrub1@gmail.com 

 Rebecca Suarez rsuarez@crowell.com 

 Brad T. Summers summerst@lanepowell.com, docketing-pdx@lanepowell.com 

 Kristine Theodesia Takvoryan ktakvoryan@ckrlaw.com 

 Derrick Talerico dtalerico@ztlegal.com, sfritz@ztlegal.com 

 Kesha Tanabe kesha@tanabelaw.com 

 Elizabeth Lee Thompson ethompson@stites.com, docketclerk@stites.com 

 John C. Thornton jct@andrewsthornton.com, aandrews@andrewsthornton.com 

 Elisa Tolentino cao.main@sanjoseca.gov 

 Meagan S. Tom Meagan.tom@lockelord.com, autodocket@lockelord.com 

 Edward J. Tredinnick etredinnick@greeneradovsky.com 

 Matthew Jordan Troy matthew.troy@usdoj.gov 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 12

of 14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

 Michael Tye Michael.Tye@usdoj.gov 

 Andrew Van Ornum avanornum@vlmglaw.com, hchea@vlmglaw.com 

 Shmuel Vasser shmuel.vasser@dechert.com, brett.stone@dechert.com 

 Victor A. Vilaplana vavilaplana@foley.com, rhurst@foley.com 

 Marta Villacorta marta.villacorta@usdoj.gov 

 John A. Vos InvalidEMailECFonly@gmail.com, PrivateECFNotice@gmail.com 

 Bao M. Vu bao.vu@stoel.com, sharon.witkin@stoel.com 

 Jonathan D. Waisnor jwaisnor@willkie.com, mao@willkie.com 

 Riley C. Walter ecf@W2LG.com 

 Phillip K. Wang phillip.wang@rimonlaw.com 

 Philip S. Warden philip.warden@pillsburylaw.com, kathy.stout@pillsburylaw.com 

 Lindsi M. Weber lweber@polsinelli.com, yderac@polsinelli.com 

 Rebecca Weissman rebecca.weissman@dechert.com 

 Joseph M. Welch jwelch@buchalter.com, dcyrankowski@buchalter.com 

 David Walter Wessel DWessel@efronlawfirm.com, hporter@chdlawyers.com 

 Joseph West westjoseph@earthlink.net, josephw998@gmail.com 

 Drew M. Widders dwidders@wilcoxenlaw.com, nina@wilcoxenlaw.com 

 Eric R. Wilson kdwbankruptcydepartment@kelleydrye.com, ewilson@kelleydrye.com 

 Kimberly S. Winick kwinick@clarktrev.com, knielsen@clarktrev.com 

 Rebecca J. Winthrop rebecca.winthrop@nortonrosefulbright.com, evette.rodriguez@nortonrosefulbright.com 

 David Wirt david.wirt@hklaw.com, denise.harmon@hklaw.com 

 Ryan A. Witthans rwitthans@fhlawllp.com 

 Risa Lynn Wolf-Smith rwolf@hollandhart.com, lmlopezvelasquez@hollandhart.com 

 Douglas Wolfe dwolfe@asmcapital.com 

 Catherine E. Woltering cwoltering@bakerlaw.com 

 Andrea Wong wong.andrea@pbgc.gov, efile@pbgc.gov 

 Christopher Kwan Shek Wong christopher.wong@arentfox.com 

 Kirsten A. Worley kw@wlawcorp.com, admin@wlawcorp.com 

 Antonio Yanez ayanez@willkie.com 

 Cathy Yanni cathy@cathyyanni.com, pstrunk@browngreer.com 

 Andrew Yaphe andrew.yaphe@davispolk.com, pge.dpw.routing@davispolk.com 

 Tacie H. Yoon tyoon@crowell.com 

 Bennett G. Young byoung@jmbm.com, jb8@jmbm.com 

 Christopher L. Young cyoung@cairncross.com, nspringstroh@cairncross.com 

 Paul H. Zumbro mao@cravath.com 

 Brittany Zummer bzummer@theadlerfirm.com, nfournier@theadlerfirm.com 

 Dario de Ghetaldi deg@coreylaw.com, lf@coreylaw.com 

 Service information continued on attached page 

2. SERVED BY UNITED STATES MAIL: 

On January 22, 20209, I served the following persons and/or entities at the last known addresses in this bankruptcy case 

or adversary proceeding by placing a true and correct copy thereof in a sealed envelope in the United States mail, first 

class, postage prepaid, and addressed as follows. Listing the judge here constitutes a declaration that mailing to the judge 

will be completed no later than 24 hours after the document is filed. 

 Service information continued on attached page 

3. SERVED BY PERSONAL DELIVERY, OVERNIGHT MAIL, FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION OR EMAIL (state method 

for each person or entity served): Pursuant to F.R.Civ.P. 5 and/or controlling LBR, on January 22, 2020, I served the 

following persons and/or entities by personal delivery, overnight mail service, or (for those who consented in writing to 

such service method), by facsimile transmission and/or email as follows. Listing the judge here constitutes a declaration 

that personal delivery on, or overnight mail to, the judge will be completed no later than 24 hours after the document is 

filed. 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 13

of 14
This form is mandatory. It has been approved for use by the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California. 

June 2012 F 9013-3.1.PROOF.SERVICE 

 Service information continued on attached page 

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the foregoing is true and correct. 

January 22, 2020 Christine Pesis /s/ Christine Pesis 

Date Printed Name Signature

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 5446 Filed: 01/22/20 Entered: 01/22/20 14:10:06 Page 14

of 14