1 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Exhibit D 

FEE SUMMARY DETAIL 

Task: Case Administration (CA) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/10/2019 Carney, Michael Prepare case management tool 

per J. Franklin request (0.3). 

0.30 126.00 

TOTAL 0.30 

 

$126.00 

Task: Corporate Governance and Board Matters (CG) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/1/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Company re: matter 

(0.4); t/c w/ K. Orsini re: 

matter (0.4); t/c w/ M. Moore 

re: matter (1.0); review 

opposition to preference 

motion (0.8). 

2.60 4,264.00 

9/1/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Review memo re: legal fees 

(0.4); review correspondence 

re: same (0.1). 

0.50 740.00 

9/1/2019 

Phillips, Jacob M. Telephonic participation in 

informal compensation 

committee meeting (1.0); 

draft action-item summary for 

internal use (1.0). 

2.00 1,680.00 

9/2/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Emails w/ clients re: counsel 

matters (0.4); review Court 

filing re: monitor's report 

(0.5). 

0.90 1,476.00 

9/2/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Review draft Court 

submission (0.3); review 

correspondence re: WSP 

(0.2). 

0.50 740.00 

9/3/2019 

Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance, review 

Latham draft response letter 

to AEGIS re: D&O insurance 

coverage (0.5); review policy 

re: same (0.5); prep markup of 

Latham draft response letter 

to AEGIS (1.0); email w/ N. 

Goldin and P. Curnin re: 

2.30 2,806.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 1

of 44
2 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

mark-up and next steps re: 

response to AEGIS (0.3). 

9/3/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ M. Moore re: matter 

(0.2); edits to CPP report to 

board (0.5); t/c w/ M. Ponce 

and S. Qusba re: preparation 

for restructuring call (0.5); t/c 

w/ K. Orsini re: matter (0.2). 

1.40 2,296.00 

9/3/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ team re: workstreams 

(0.4); prepare for call w/ 

former director (1.0). 

1.40 2,072.00 

9/3/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review draft CPP Committee 

materials (0.3); email to N. 

Goldin re: same (0.2). 

0.50 547.50 

9/3/2019 

Phillips, Jacob M. Research and analysis of 

compensation issues in 

bankruptcy (3.5). 

3.50 2,940.00 

9/3/2019 

Sussman, Rebecca 

A. 

Calls w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

document collection and 

related requests (0.6). 

0.60 504.00 

9/3/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Emails re: upcoming Board 

meeting (0.1). 

0.10 59.00 

9/3/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Restructuring 

Committee Call (3.3). 

3.30 5,412.00 

9/3/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs, emails w/ various 

Directors and Management re 

Governance issues (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/3/2019 

Purushotham, Ravi Call on backstop commitment 

letter with Cravath, Lazard, 

Weil. 

1.40 1,855.00 

9/3/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Restructuring 

Committee meeting. 

4.50 4,117.50 

9/3/2019 

Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.2) and 

Restructuring Committee call 

and executive session (4.5). 

4.70 3,948.00 

9/3/2019 

Rovner, Grace Per E. Egenes, continue to 

prep. back up materials for 

board. 

0.40 106.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 2

of 44
3 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/4/2019 

Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance, email P. 

Curnin, Latham and PG&E 

(R. Reilly) re: revisions to 

draft response letter to AEGIS 

(0.5); follow-up tc/email w/ 

R. Reilly re: draft letter, draft 

plan and D&O insurance 

issues (0.6); email w/ P. 

Curnin and K. Pasich re: draft 

response letter (0.4); further 

email w/ P. Curnin and R. 

Reilly re: draft plan and 

securities claims/D&O 

insurance issues (0.3). 

1.80 2,196.00 

9/4/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Company re: cyber 

issues (0.2); revise 

correspondence to insurance 

carrier (0.3); t/c w/ M. Moore 

re: matter (0.3); review 

contention interrogatory 

responses (0.3). 

1.10 1,804.00 

9/4/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Analysis re: litigation strategy 

(0.7); communications w/ 

team re: CPP report (0.2); 

communication w/ team re: 

media (0.2); prepare for call 

w/ former director (1.0). 

2.10 3,108.00 

9/4/2019 

Phillips, Jacob M. Discussion w/ internal 

company parties re: board 

approval of compensation 

matters (0.4). 

0.40 336.00 

9/4/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Emails re: Board meetings 

(0.2). 

0.20 118.00 

9/4/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Conference call w/ Cravath re 

Jones Day/Equityholder NDA 

concerns (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

9/4/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs w/ various 

Directors re Governance 

issues (1.1). 

1.10 1,804.00 

9/4/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review revised POR (1.2). 1.20 1,968.00 

9/4/2019 Purushotham, Ravi Follow-up w/ Cleary re BM 

settlement agreement. 

0.20 265.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 3

of 44
4 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/4/2019 

Levine, Jeff P. Call with Board members, M. 

Ponce, S. Qusba and CPUC 

advisors. 

1.20 1,098.00 

9/5/2019 

Alcabes, Elisa Re D&O insurance, review K. 

Pasich edits to draft response 

letter to AEGIS (0.3); prepare 

updated revised draft re: same 

(0.5); email P. Curnin, 

Latham and PG&E (R. Reilly) 

re: same (0.3). 

1.10 1,342.00 

9/5/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review media issue (0.5). 0.50 740.00 

9/5/2019 

Phillips, Jacob M. Informal compensation 

committee call re: 

compensation arrangements 

(0.6). 

0.60 504.00 

9/5/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Restructuring Committee 

meeting (2.0). 

2.00 3,280.00 

9/5/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Meetings, teleconference, 

with various directors re 

various Board governance 

issues (2.3). 

2.30 3,772.00 

9/5/2019 Purushotham, Ravi Restructuring Committee call 

(2.5). 

2.50 3,312.50 

9/5/2019 

Levine, Jeff P. Attend call with S. Qusba, 

Jones Day, Knighthead, 

Abrams and representative of 

PGE Restructuring 

Committee. 

1.00 915.00 

9/5/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Coordinate distribution to 

Restructuring Committee. 

0.60 549.00 

9/5/2019 

Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.7) and 

Restructuring Committee 

meeting and executive session 

(2.0). 

2.70 2,268.00 

9/5/2019 

Rovner, Grace Per E. Egenes, continue to 

prep. back up materials for 

board. 

0.30 79.50 

9/6/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Board conference call (1.3); 

review bankruptcy plan re: 

continuing liability (1.0). 

2.30 3,772.00 

9/6/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ team re: 

workstreams (0.4). 

0.40 592.00 

9/6/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Board meeting (1.8). 1.80 2,952.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 4

of 44
5 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/6/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Restructuring Committee 

meeting (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/6/2019 

Levine, Jeff P. Attend Board meeting w/ M. 

Ponce, R. Purushotham, S. 

Qusba and E. Egenes. 

2.00 1,830.00 

9/6/2019 

Levine, Jeff P. Attend Restructuring 

Committee call with M. 

Ponce, R. Purushotham, S. 

Qusba and E. Egenes. 

1.00 915.00 

9/6/2019 

Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.4) and attend 

portion of Board executive 

session (1.0). 

1.40 1,176.00 

9/6/2019 

Rovner, Grace Per E. Egenes, continue to 

prep. back up materials for 

board. 

0.30 79.50 

9/7/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Teleconferences w/ various 

Directors re Governance 

issues and Director 

resignation (1.0). 

1.00 1,640.00 

9/8/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board Meeting 

(2.0). 

2.00 3,280.00 

9/8/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review 8k re Director 

Resignation (0.4); emails, 

teleconfs w/ K. Liang (0.3) 

and Cravath re 8-K (0.3). 

1.00 1,640.00 

9/8/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs w/ N. Brownell, M. 

Moore re various Governance 

issues (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/8/2019 

Purushotham, Ravi Board call (1.4); followup call 

with Cravath, Weil and 

Lazard (0.2). 

1.60 2,120.00 

9/9/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ J. Loduca re: press and 

discovery (0.4); edit 

bankruptcy plan re: directors 

(0.8); review new Caremark 

decision (0.9). 

2.10 3,444.00 

9/9/2019 

Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Participate in Compensation 

Committee meeting via phone 

(0.8); review materials in 

preparation for meeting (1.0). 

1.80 2,763.00 

9/9/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ client re: matter (0.4); 

confer w/ team re: civil 

litigation (0.2); confer w/ 

0.70 1,036.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 5

of 44
6 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

team re: bankruptcy plan 

(0.1). 

9/9/2019 

Phillips, Jacob M. Telephonic participation in 

compensation committee 

meeting (2.0). 

2.00 1,680.00 

9/9/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review materials and prep for 

Board and Committee 

meetings while traveling to 

SF (6.0). 

6.00 9,840.00 

9/9/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Review draft 8-K. 1.30 1,189.50 

9/9/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of 8-Ks. 0.80 672.00 

9/10/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Attend Safety and Nuclear 

Committee meeting in San 

Francisco (2.3); attend Board 

meeting in San Francisco 

(1.8). 

4.10 6,724.00 

9/10/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Attend Board meetings in San 

Francisco (4.0); follow-up 

meeting w/ J. Loduca re: 

matters (1.5). 

5.50 9,020.00 

9/10/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Attend Board meetings (2.7); 

confer w/ team re: strategies 

(0.3). 

3.00 4,440.00 

9/10/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Board and Committee 

meetings (4.0). 

4.00 6,560.00 

9/10/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconference 

various Board members re 

various Board governance 

issues (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/10/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review NDA for 

equityholders and emails re 

same (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

9/11/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Attend Board meetings in San 

Francisco and individual 

discussions w/ Directors (5.0); 

discussion re: matters w/ J. 

Loduca (0.2); review 

additional Board materials 

(0.8). 

6.00 9,840.00 

9/11/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Attend Board meetings (4.8); 

communications w/ team re: 

workstreams, strategy (0.5). 

5.30 7,844.00 

9/11/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Board meeting (6.0). 6.00 9,840.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 6

of 44
7 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/11/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs with Brownell and 

Moore re various governance 

issues (1.0). 

1.00 1,640.00 

9/11/2019 Qusba, Sandy Attend Board Meeting (6.5). 6.50 9,977.50 

9/12/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review 8K (0.3). 0.30 492.00 

9/12/2019 

Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

T/c’s and emails w/ M. Moore 

and Weil re: scheduled 

compensation committee 

meeting topics (1.0). 

1.00 1,535.00 

9/12/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review of Subro RSA and 

Equity Commitment Letters 

while traveling from SF to 

NY (3.0); emails, various 

issues re same and 

Governance matters while 

traveling from SF to NY 

(2.0). 

5.00 8,200.00 

9/12/2019 Purushotham, Ravi Review of draft Board 

minutes. 

0.70 927.50 

9/13/2019 

Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Participate in Compensation 

Committee meeting via phone 

(1.4). 

1.40 2,149.00 

9/13/2019 

Phillips, Jacob M. Telephonic participation in 

informal compensation 

committee meeting (2.0). 

2.00 1,680.00 

9/13/2019 Calderon, Justin Communications w/ team re: 

Board documents (1.0). 

1.00 700.00 

9/13/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review and comment on 

Board and Committee 

Meeting Minutes (2.2). 

2.20 3,608.00 

9/13/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

directors re compensation and 

governance issues (0.7). 

0.70 1,148.00 

9/13/2019 

Purushotham, Ravi Review of Board minute 

guidelines to ensure draft 

minutes are consistent. 

0.60 795.00 

9/15/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Review Board minutes (0.4); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.1). 

0.50 740.00 

9/16/2019 

Kreissman, James 

G. 

Review background materials 

to prepare for Court hearing 

on vegetation management 

(1.3). 

1.30 2,132.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 7

of 44
8 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/16/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Review draft statement for 

hearing (0.2); t/c w/ Jenner & 

Block re: hearing (0.6); t/c w/ 

M. Moore re: matter (0.3). 

1.10 1,804.00 

9/16/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ Company re: minutes 

(0.3). 

0.30 444.00 

9/16/2019 

Vallejo, Melissa 

A. 

Review Board materials per J. 

Calderon (0.1); correspond w/ 

J. Isaacman re: same (0.2). 

0.30 177.00 

9/16/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Weekly call w/ J. Loduca and 

J. Kane re various Board 

issues (0.4). 

0.40 656.00 

9/16/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Call w/ F. Chang re Board 

and Committee Minutes (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

9/16/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review, teleconfs, 

emailsvarious directors re 

issues re Subro Support 

Agreement (1.3). 

1.30 2,132.00 

9/16/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review 

Legal/Regulatory/Legislative 

Update (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/16/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails various directors 

regarding issues re Tubbs 

hearing (0.6). 

0.60 984.00 

9/16/2019 Purushotham, Ravi Review of RSA. 0.30 397.50 

9/17/2019 

Kreissman, James 

G. 

Attend court hearing on 

vegetation management (1.7); 

t/c w/ N. Goldin re: same 

(0.2); t/c w/ client re: same 

(0.3). 

2.20 3,608.00 

9/17/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review report from Court 

(0.2). 

0.20 328.00 

9/17/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs, emails, various 

issues re Governance (0.6), 

and re Legal Hold protocol re 

Directors (0.5) and re Subro 

Support Agreement (0.5). 

1.60 2,624.00 

9/18/2019 

Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Communications w/ team re: 

Tubbs discovery, monitoring 

(0.5). 

0.50 767.50 

9/18/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review cyber issue (0.2). 0.20 296.00 

9/18/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review new Equity 

Commitment Letters (0.5); 

0.80 1,312.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 8

of 44
9 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

teleconfs, emails, various 

issues re same (0.3). 

9/18/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs re Board 

Governance issues (0.8) and 

re Board document retention 

matters (0.4). 

1.20 1,968.00 

9/19/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Review CPP talking points 

(0.2); review wildfire claim 

form (0.3); t/c w/ client re: 

status (0.3). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/19/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Review cyber issue (0.1); 

review document retention 

issue (0.1); call w/ team re: 

plan (0.4). 

0.60 888.00 

9/19/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Calls, emails, various issues 

re Backstop Equity 

Commitment Letters (1.7). 

1.70 2,788.00 

9/19/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs w/ Directors 

re Legal Holds (0.4). 

0.40 656.00 

9/19/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review, emails, various 

issues re TCC/Bondholder 

Motion to terminate 

exclusivity (1.0). 

1.00 1,640.00 

9/20/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Attend Board call (1.1); 

attend CPP Committee call 

(1.2); review draft MTO 

slides (0.4); t/c w/ client re: 

restructuring issues (0.5). 

3.20 5,248.00 

9/20/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Attend Board meeting (1.2); 

attend CPP meeting (0.8); 

correspondence w/ team re: 

Board issues (0.2); review 

cyber issues (0.3). 

2.50 3,700.00 

9/20/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board Meeting, 

review materials (1.7). 

1.70 2,788.00 

9/20/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Conference call w/ 

Chairperson of Board and 

other advisors re Governance 

issues (0.8) and emails re 

same (0.2). 

1.00 1,640.00 

9/20/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review draft press release re 

Subros and Equity 

Commitment (0.3). 

0.30 492.00 

9/20/2019 Purushotham, Ravi Board meeting (1.2). 1.20 1,590.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 9

of 44
10 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/21/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re Subro settlement and 

Board Governance. 

1.20 1,968.00 

9/23/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ Company re: cyber 

issues (0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

9/23/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Meeting w/ representatives of 

Abrams Capital and 

Knighthead re various issues 

(1.2). 

1.20 1,968.00 

9/23/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Weekly Call w/ J. Loduca/J. 

Kane re various issues (0.7). 

0.70 1,148.00 

9/23/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, re various 

Governance issues (0.5); 

review and prepare 

Guidelines for Board 

Committees and significant 

Chapter 11 action items (0.8). 

1.30 2,132.00 

9/24/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Revise media background 

statement (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

9/24/2019 

Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Review Board action for 

compensation filings (0.5); 

t/c’s w/ M. Moore and other 

Board members re: 

compensation filings (0.4). 

0.90 1,381.50 

9/24/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ Company re: monitor 

(0.1); communications w/ 

clients re: privilege issues 

(0.1); advice re: news media 

(1.3); review matter update 

(0.2). 

1.70 2,516.00 

9/24/2019 

Phillips, Jacob M. Draft compensation 

committee proposed actions 

incorporating feedback from 

compensation committee 

(0.5). 

0.50 420.00 

9/24/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, calls w/ K. Liang, 

former director, P. Curnin and 

PGE legal re Director Legal 

Hold policy and document 

retention issues (0.6), review 

documents re same (0.5). 

1.10 1,804.00 

9/24/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Revised Process Guidelines 

for Board Committees (0.8); 

1.20 1,968.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 10

of 44
11 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

emails, teleconfs re same 

(0.4). 

9/24/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs w/ Board 

Chair re various Governance 

issues (0.7). 

0.70 1,148.00 

9/25/2019 

Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Communications w/ team re: 

CMC statement, trial structure 

issues (0.3); t/c w/ M. Moore 

re: same (0.2). 

0.50 767.50 

9/25/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Cravath re: trial 

strategy (0.3); emails w/ 

clients re: same (0.4); emails 

w/ Cravath re: bifurcation 

(0.4); t/c w/ Company and 

Cravath re: bifurcation (0.1); 

review locate and mark 

settlement (0.2). 

1.40 2,296.00 

9/25/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

T/c’s w/ Board members re: 

compensation filings (0.3). 

0.30 460.50 

9/25/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ Company, team re: 

monitor (0.5); review OII 

submission (0.5); review 

correspondence re: cyber 

issue (0.3). 

1.30 1,924.00 

9/25/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

Governance issues (1.0). 

1.00 1,640.00 

9/26/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Review submission to trial 

court on bifurcation (0.4); 

attend Board meeting call 

(1.0); t/c w/ client re: monitor 

(0.2); review monitor deck 

(0.5). 

2.10 3,444.00 

9/26/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Review draft OII submission 

(0.4); review draft Court 

response (0.5); review 

monitor issues (0.3). 

1.20 1,776.00 

9/26/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Attend infrastructure call w/ 

Company et al. (2.5); emails 

w/ P. Curnin and N. Goldin 

re: same (0.4); t/c w/ S. Qusba 

re: subrogation settlement 

discovery (0.2); emails w/ 

Cravath and Weil re: same 

(0.2). 

3.30 3,613.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 11

of 44
12 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/26/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board Meeting 

(1.5); review Board materials 

(0.8). 

2.30 3,772.00 

9/26/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs w/ Board 

Chair re Governance issues 

and Committee Guidelines 

(0.5), revisions to Guidelines 

(0.3). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/27/2019 

Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Communications w/ team and 

Company re: CMC, trial 

strategy (0.4). 

0.40 614.00 

9/27/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Comments on Wildfire OII 

(0.8); attend CPP Committee 

Call (1.0). 

1.80 2,952.00 

9/27/2019 

Kovoor, Thomas 

G. 

Call w/ PG&E firms re: data 

collection & steps for review 

(0.5); coordinate collection & 

transfer of data to vendor re: 

communications w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley (1.0). 

1.50 630.00 

9/27/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

T/c’s w/ Board members re: 

compensation filings (0.4). 

0.40 614.00 

9/27/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Attend CPP Meeting (1.7); 

call client re: Court (0.2); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.1); review OII 

strategy (0.2). 

2.20 3,256.00 

9/27/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ Cravath and Weil re: 

subrogation settlement 

discovery (0.6); emails w/ T. 

Kovoor re: collecting emails 

for same (0.3); emails w/ CDS 

re: same (0.3). 

1.20 1,314.00 

9/27/2019 Phillips, Jacob M. Review on motion to approve 

compensation (1.5). 

1.50 1,260.00 

9/27/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review case calendar and 

coordinate with Committee 

Guidelines (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/27/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review draft OII response re 

CPUC (0.7). 

0.70 1,148.00 

9/29/2019 

Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Review and provide 

comments on motions re: 

compensation filings (0.6). 

0.60 921.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 12

of 44
13 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/30/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Review draft submission to 

Court (0.4); review 

bankruptcy OII draft to CPUC 

(0.5). 

0.90 1,476.00 

9/30/2019 

Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Review and provide 

comments on motions re: 

compensation filings (0.9); 

t/c’s w/ M. Moore and Weil 

re: motions re: compensation 

filings (0.4). 

1.30 1,995.50 

9/30/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ CDS, Cravath and 

Weil re: subrogation 

settlement discovery (0.7); 

emails w/ J. Isaacman re: 

same (0.2). 

0.90 985.50 

9/30/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review/comments re Board 

Compensation Motion (0.8), 

emails, teleconfs re same 

(0.4). 

1.20 1,968.00 

9/30/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs re (0.2) and 

review of Guidelines for 

Committees and Gantt chart 

re action items upcoming 

(0.5). 

0.70 1,148.00 

9/30/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Legal/Regulatory 

Update (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

9/30/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, issues re Bank 

financing commitments (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

TOTAL 214.50 

 

$306,704.00 

Task Code: Court Hearings (CH)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/24/2019 Fell, Jamie Attend status conference by 

telephone. 1.50 1,492.50 

TOTAL 

1.50 

 

$1,492.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 13

of 44
14 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Task Code: Claims Administration and Objections (CM)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/10/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ J. Calderon re: proofs 

of claim (0.8). 

0.80 876.00 

9/10/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft proofs of claim for 

directors (5.5). 

5.50 3,850.00 

9/11/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft proofs of claim for 

directors (2.0). 

2.00 1,400.00 

9/12/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ team re: 

proof of claims (0.1); call w/ 

team re: strategy for same (0.1); 

review bankruptcy plan (0.1). 

0.30 444.00 

9/12/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ P. Curnin, N. Goldin, 

J. Calderon re: proofs of claim 

(0.6). 

0.60 657.00 

9/16/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Emails w/ R. Sparks Bradley 

and J. Fell re: status of draft 

proof of claim for directors 

(0.2); further email w/ R. 

Sparks Bradley re: timetable for 

completion of director proofs of 

claim (0.1); emails w/ N. 

Goldin and R. Sparks Bradley 

re: director indemnification 

claims (0.1); emails w/ J. Fell 

and J. Calderon re: information 

needed to complete director 

claims (0.2). 

0.60 732.00 

9/16/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review proof of claim drafts 

(0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

9/16/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ P. Curnin, N. Goldin, 

J. Calderon, J. Fell re: proofs of 

claim (0.7). 

0.70 766.50 

9/16/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare proofs of claim for 

directors (1.0). 

1.00 995.00 

9/16/2019 

Calderon, Justin Draft proofs of claim for 

directors (3.3); communications 

w/ K. Kinsel re: same (0.2). 

3.50 2,450.00 

9/18/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Internal emails re: completion 

of proofs of claim for directors 

(0.1); further emails w/ N. 

Goldin re: provisions of director 

POCs and information needed 

(0.2). 

0.30 366.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 14

of 44
15 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/18/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review proofs of claim (0.2). 0.20 296.00 

9/18/2019 

Fell, Jamie Prepare proofs of claim for 

directors (1.0); correspondence 

w/ J. Calderon and N. Goldin 

re: same (0.3). 

1.30 1,293.50 

9/18/2019 

Calderon, Justin Draft proofs of claim for 

directors (0.5); emails to R. 

Sparks Bradley re: same (0.1). 

0.60 420.00 

9/20/2019 

Calderon, Justin Draft proofs of claims for 

directors (1.5), including 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.8). 

2.30 1,610.00 

9/23/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

O/c w/ J. Fell re: status on 

proofs of claim for directors, 

open issues, timetable for drafts 

to be circulated (0.3); email w/ 

J. Fell re: and review emails to 

be sent to directors re: 

confirming information for 

POC and comments thereon 

(0.2). 

0.50 610.00 

9/23/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ N. Goldin, J. 

Calderon, J. Fell re: proofs of 

claim (0.8). 

0.80 876.00 

9/23/2019 

Fell, Jamie Prepare proofs of claim (1.0) 

and emails to directors re: same 

(0.5). 

1.50 1,492.50 

9/23/2019 

Calderon, Justin Review and revise proofs of 

claim for directors (0.5), 

including emails to team re: 

same (0.3). 

0.80 560.00 

9/24/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Review and respond to N. 

Goldin email re: information 

from Directors for proofs of 

claim (0.1). 

0.10 122.00 

9/24/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ team re: 

proofs of claims (0.4). 

0.40 592.00 

9/24/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ N. Goldin, J. 

Calderon, J. Fell re: proofs of 

claim (0.9); review draft of 

same (0.8). 

1.70 1,861.50 

9/24/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare director proofs of claim 

(1.1). 

1.10 1,094.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 15

of 44
16 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/24/2019 

Calderon, Justin Review and revise proofs of 

claim for directors (2.2), 

including emails to directors re: 

same (0.8). 

3.00 2,100.00 

9/25/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review proofs of claim (0.2). 0.20 296.00 

9/26/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Emails w/ J. Fell re: draft POC 

for directors (0.1); begin review 

and comment on draft POC for 

directors (0.5); further emails 

w/ J. Fell re: comments on form 

410 and rider to director POC 

(0.2); review emails from 

certain directors re: 

confirmatory diligence matters 

(0.2); further emails w/ J. Fell 

and J. Calderon re: revisions to 

form POC for directors (0.2). 

1.20 1,464.00 

9/26/2019 Fell, Jamie Prepare proofs of claim (1.3). 1.30 1,293.50 

9/26/2019 

Calderon, Justin Review and revise proofs of 

claim for directors (0.7), 

including emails to team re: 

same (0.3). 

1.00 700.00 

9/27/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Emails w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: additional 

revisions to director POC (0.2); 

additional internal emails re: 

form of director POC and filing 

deadline (0.2). 

0.40 488.00 

9/27/2019 

Calderon, Justin Draft proofs of claim for 

directors (0.4), including emails 

to R. Sparks Bradley re: same 

(0.2). 

0.60 420.00 

TOTAL 34.50 $30,422.00 

Task Code: Fee/Employment Applications (FA) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/1/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review memo re: attorneys’ 

fees (0.9). 

0.90 1,476.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 16

of 44
17 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/3/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Email w/ M. Torkin and N. 

Goldin re: fee examiner 

deliverables (0.1); review and 

respond to M. Torkin emails re: 

fee application and statement 

deadlines, timetable and 

processes (0.5); email w/ R. 

Sparks Bradley and J. Fell re: 

fee application schedule (0.2); 

further email w/ M. Torkin and 

N. Goldin re: deliverables for 

fee examiner report (0.1). 

0.90 1,098.00 

9/3/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Reviewing memos on attorneys 

fees (0.7). 

0.70 1,148.00 

9/3/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Prepare fee application 

materials (4.7); emails w/ K. 

McLendon and accounting re: 

same (0.8). 

5.50 6,022.50 

9/3/2019 

Terricone, 

Cyrena 

Assist R. Artale-LaSpisa w/ 

review of retention-related 

matters per K. McLendon. 

1.00 400.00 

9/4/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Internal emails re: proposed 

response to fee auditor protocol 

(0.2); review Cravath draft 

response (0.1) and comments to 

protocol (0.1); review proposed 

revisions to outside directors 

billings (0.1). 

0.50 610.00 

9/4/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ team re: fee application 

(0.1). 

0.10 148.00 

9/4/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Further preparation of fee 

application materials (2.4); 

emails w/ K. McLendon and 

accounting re: same (0.6); email 

to N. Goldin re: same (0.1); 

emails w/ M. Torkin re: fee 

application (0.2). 

3.30 3,613.50 

9/5/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Meeting w/ M. Torkin, N. 

Goldin, R. Sparks Bradley re: 

fee examiner protocol and 

response to fee auditor report on 

first interim fee application 

(0.5); draft email to company 

re: authority to proceed w/ 

0.70 854.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 17

of 44
18 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

payment of second monthly 

statement (0.2). 

9/5/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee application issues 

(0.5). 

0.50 740.00 

9/5/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

O/c w/ M. Torkin, N. Goldin, 

and K. McLendon re: fee 

application (0.5). 

0.50 547.50 

9/7/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Further review and comment on 

draft statement for July. 

0.70 854.00 

9/9/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee application (0.8). 0.80 1,184.00 

9/9/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Further review July statement re 

final revisions and email S. 

Bancone re same. 

0.30 366.00 

9/16/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Email w/ B. Benedict (Cravath) 

re: status of proposed objection 

to fee examiner protocol and 

timetable (0.1). 

0.10 122.00 

9/16/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Further email w/ B. Benedict re: 

fee examiner's request for status 

conference on interim fee 

applications and issues (0.1). 

0.10 122.00 

9/16/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ team re: fee examiner 

(0.1). 

0.10 148.00 

9/17/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee application (0.1). 0.10 148.00 

9/18/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Email w/ J. Fell re: prep of 

CNO for third monthly fee 

statement and timetable (0.2); 

further emails w/ J. Fell re: 

service of June statement and 

CNO (0.1); further call w/ J. 

Fell re: Prime Clerk status on 

service of third monthly 

statement and addressing 

service in CNO (0.3). 

0.60 732.00 

9/20/2019 

Fell, Jamie Prep CNO for STB third 

monthly fee statement (0.5) and 

research re: service and corr. w/ 

Prime Clerk re: same (0.5). 

1.00 995.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 18

of 44
19 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/23/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Review J. Fell updates re: status 

of service of STB statement for 

June (0.2); confer w/ J. Fell re: 

service of STB statement for 

June (0.2); review and comment 

on draft statement for July 

(0.5); further emails w/ J. Fell 

re: service of July statement 

(0.1); further emails w/ M. 

Torkin and J. Fell re: CNO on 

June statement (0.2); review 

draft CNO for June statement 

(0.1) and email w/ J. Fell re: 

same and follow up w/ Weil 

and J. Loduca (0.1); further 

internal emails w/ M. Torkin, 

N. Goldin and J. Fell re: CNO 

for June statement (0.1). 

1.50 1,830.00 

9/23/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee application issues 

(0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

9/23/2019 

Fell, Jamie Prep Fourth Monthly Fee 

Statement (1.6); prep CNO and 

corr. w/ STB and others re: 

CNO and Third Monthly Fee 

Statement (0.7). 

2.30 2,288.50 

9/24/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ team re: 

fee application (0.1). 

0.10 148.00 

9/25/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Email w/ J. Fell re: June CNO 

completion (0.1); further emails 

w/ J. Fell re: update to company 

for payment of June statement 

(0.1). 

0.20 244.00 

9/25/2019 

Fell, Jamie Preparing and filing Certificate 

of No Objection (0.4); 

preparing Fourth Monthly Fee 

Statement and corr. w/ billing 

personnel re: same (0.7). 

1.10 1,094.50 

9/26/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee application (0.2). 0.20 296.00 

9/27/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Emails w/ accounting team re: 

August statement to the 

company and timing thereof 

(0.2); emails w/ J. Fell and 

accounting team re: filing of 

July statement (0.2). 

0.40 488.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 19

of 44
20 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/30/2019 

McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Finalize STB statement for July 

for filing and service (0.3); 

emails w/ MCO and R. Sparks 

Bradley and J. Fell re: objection 

deadline for July statement 

(0.1); email I. Nikelsberg re: 

service of STB July statement 

(0.1); internal emails w/ J. Fell 

and accounting team re: service 

on UST and fee examiner (0.1). 

0.60 732.00 

TOTAL 25.00 28,745.50 

Task Code: Plan/Disclosure Statement (PL) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/1/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Restructuring Committee call 

(1.2). 

1.20 1,590.00 

9/1/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Prep for and call with D. Dunne 

and S. Karotkin (0.4); t/c with 

same regarding update and 

board comp (0.4); review Jones 

Day's comments to ch. 11 plan 

(1.0); prep for Restructuring 

Committee call regarding subro 

settlement term sheet (0.7); t/c 

with restructuring regarding 

subro settlement (1.7); t/c with 

R. Barrera regarding catch-up 

(0.4). 

4.60 7,061.00 

9/1/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of potential settlement 

term sheet. 

1.10 924.00 

9/1/2019 

Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.8) and call with 

Restructuring Committee 

members re potential settlement 

(1.2). 

2.00 1,680.00 

9/2/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Prep for and participate in t/c 

with S. Karotkin, K. Orsini and 

E. Egenes regarding subro 

settlement term sheet (0.5); t/c 

with R. Barrera regarding 

update (0.5); t/c with K. Orsini, 

S. Karotkin and M. Feldman 

regarding subro term sheet 

2.30 3,530.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 20

of 44
21 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

(0.6); t/c with K. Orsini, S. 

Karotkin and R. Barrera 

regarding update (0.7). 

9/2/2019 

Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.3) and call with S. 

Qusba, S. Karotkin and K. 

Orsini re potential settlement 

(0.3). 

0.60 504.00 

9/3/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Negotiations, review, various 

issues re Equity Commitments 

(1.2); emails, teleconfs with 

various directors re Equity 

Commitments (1.0). 

2.20 3,608.00 

9/3/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review revised Subro 

settlement terms (.8), emails, 

teleconfs, with various directors 

re issues re same (0.4). 

1.20 1,968.00 

9/3/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Review subro term sheet and 

prep for call with S. Karotkin, 

K. Orsini and R. Barrera (0.8); 

correspondence with STB team 

regarding update (0.3); t/c with 

M. Ponce, P. Curnin and N. 

Goldin regarding update (0.3); 

prep for call with M. Feldman 

(0.8); t/c with K. Orsini, S. 

Karotkin, M. Feldman 

regarding subro term sheet 

(0.7); t/c with Restructuring 

Committee regarding same and 

additional issues (1.0); t/c with 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding subro settlement term 

sheet (1.0); t/c with S. Karotkin, 

K. Orsini and R. Barrera 

regarding update (0.4) revise 

term sheet (1.5); t/c with 

Cravath, Weil, Lazard and STB 

regarding equity commitment 

issues list (1.0). 

7.80 11,973.00 

9/3/2019 

Levine, Jeff P. Call w/ E. Egenes re: status of 

potential settlement and related 

tasks. 

0.30 274.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 21

of 44
22 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/3/2019 

Egenes, Erica M. Review of backstop 

commitment letter and potential 

settlement term sheet. 

1.50 1,260.00 

9/4/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Conference call w/ Subset of 

Restructuring Committee re 

Subro settlement and Equity 

Commitment issues (1.2). 

1.20 1,968.00 

9/4/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Negotiations, conference calls, 

with various directors regarding 

revised drafts of Equity 

Commitment letter (1.0); 

review revised drafts of Equity 

Commitment letter (1.0). 

2.00 3,280.00 

9/4/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Review revised plan (1.0); t/c 

with R. Barrera regarding subro 

term sheet (0.5); t/c with Jones 

Day, Weil, Cravath, PJT and 

Lazard regarding equity 

commitment (1.5); review 

equity commitment (0.8); revise 

subro term sheet (1.4); t/c with 

R. Barrera regarding same and 

next steps (1.0); t/c with A. 

Kornberg, M. Kramer, K. 

Liang, M. Moore, M. Ponce 

regarding CPUC process update 

(0.6). 

6.80 10,438.00 

9/4/2019 

Levine, Jeff P. Call with Cravath, Weil, 

Lazard, PJT and Jones Day re: 

backstop commitment term 

sheet. 

1.60 1,464.00 

9/5/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Negotiations, review and 

comments re subro settlement 

and equity commitment letter 

(2.0). 

2.00 3,280.00 

9/5/2019 

Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review of backstop 

commitment letter (1.0); call re 

backstop commitment letter 

with Lazard and Cravath; (0.7); 

review of summary of backstop 

commitment letter (0.2). 

1.90 2,517.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 22

of 44
23 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/5/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with R. Barrera regarding 

subro term sheet (0.4); t/c with 

R. Barrera and S. Karotkin 

regarding same (0.4); review K. 

Orsini's comments to term sheet 

(0.5); revise subro term sheet 

(1.0); t/c with R. Barrera, T. 

Wagner, D. Abrams and B. 

Bennett regarding subros, 

equity commitment and bond 

holder discussions (0.7); t/c 

with R. Barrera regarding next 

steps (0.5); t/c with R. Barrera 

and N. Brownell (0.4); t/c with 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding subro term sheet, 

equity commitment letter and 

plan (1.5). 

5.40 8,289.00 

9/5/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Review backstop commitment 

term sheet. 

3.30 3,019.50 

9/6/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review materials and prep for 

meetings with Restructuring 

Committee and Board (1.5). 

1.50 2,460.00 

9/6/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Negotiations, review and 

revisions to equity commitment 

letter and subro settlement 

(2.2). 

2.20 3,608.00 

9/6/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconference with 

various directors re various 

issues re subro settlement and 

equity commitment letter (0.7). 

0.70 1,148.00 

9/6/2019 

Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Board meeting (1.7); 

Restructuring Committee call 

(1.4); review and comment on 

issues list for backstop 

commitment letter (1.5), review 

of board materials (0.8). 

5.40 7,155.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 23

of 44
24 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/6/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with R. Hall and M. Ponce 

regarding NDA (0.3); t/c with 

R. Barrera, N. Brownell and M. 

Ponce regarding board call prep 

(0.5); prep for and participate in 

t/c with Board and advisors 

regarding plan, subro 

settlement, equity commitment 

and next steps (2.0); t/c with S. 

Karotkin regarding term sheet 

changes (0.3); t/c with R. 

Barrera regarding same and 

next steps (0.8); t/c with N. 

Brownell and M. Ponce 

regarding restructuring 

committee call (0.3); t/c with A. 

Wolfe regarding update (0.3); 

t/c with M. Moore regarding 

restructuring committee call 

prep (0.3); t/c with 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding subro term sheet and 

next steps (1.3); t/c with B. 

Bennett regarding next steps 

(0.3); correspondence with N. 

Brownell regarding update 

(0.4). 

6.80 10,438.00 

9/6/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of potential settlement 

term sheet. 

0.40 336.00 

9/7/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Negotiations, various issues, 

emails, teleconfs re Equity 

Commitments (1.0); review and 

comment on Summary Memo 

re same (1.2). 

2.20 3,608.00 

9/7/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review revised Subro 

settlement term sheet, emails, 

teleconfs various directors re 

same (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 24

of 44
25 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/7/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Tc/ with S. Karotkin, K. Orsini 

and R. Barrera regarding subro 

settlement and next steps (0.7); 

correspondence with 

Restructuring Committee (0.2); 

t/c with A. Kornberg regarding 

various updates (0.4); t/c with 

K. Orsini regarding subro 

update (0.2); t/c with S. 

Karotkin regarding same (0.3); 

t/c with R. Barrera regarding 

next steps (0.4); correspondence 

with STB team regarding 

update (0.3); t/c with R. Barrera 

and N. Brownell regarding 

status update (0.5); t/c with M. 

Moore regarding update (1.5); 

t/c with M. Ponce regarding 

update (.3); t/c with K. Liang 

resignation with R. Barrera 

(0.5); t/c with N. Brownell 

regarding same (0.5). 

5.80 8,903.00 

9/7/2019 

Levine, Jeff P. Attend call with Cravath and 

Jones Day re: negotiation of 

backstop commitments. 

0.30 274.50 

9/7/2019 

Levine, Jeff P. Prepare report on call between 

Cravath and Jones Day re: 

negotiation of backstop 

commitments. 

0.50 457.50 

9/7/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Distribute revised draft 

backstop commitment letter. 

0.20 183.00 

9/8/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review Subro settlement and 

Equity Commitment status in 

preparation for Board meeting 

(1.2). 

1.20 1,968.00 

9/8/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Conference calls, emails 

various directors re issues re 

Equity Commitment letters 

(0.4); review and comment on 

Equity Commitment letters 

(0.8). 

1.20 1,968.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 25

of 44
26 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/8/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with R. Barrera regarding 

update (0.3); t/c with S. 

Karotkin regarding same (0.4); 

t/c with K. Orsini regarding 

same (.2); t/c with M. Ponce 

regarding update (0.3); t/c with 

R. Barrera regarding Board call 

(0.4); prep for and participate in 

Board call (2.5); follow-up call 

with advisors regarding next 

steps (.2). 

4.30 6,600.50 

9/9/2019 

Purushotham, 

Ravi 

N&G committee meeting (1.0); 

review of materials for N&G 

committee meeting (0.5); 

review of backstop commitment 

letters (0.6); review of 8-K 

(0.7). 

2.80 3,710.00 

9/9/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Correspondence with N. 

Brownell regarding various 

issues and next steps (0.5); 

coordination on K. Liang 8K 

(0.4); review backstop/Plan 8K 

(0.8) review and comment on 

revised plan and equity 

backstop agreements (2.1). 

3.80 5,833.00 

9/10/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Attend District Court Hearing 

regarding estimation process 

(1.4); attend board meetings 

(3.5). 

4.90 7,521.50 

9/11/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review and comment on 

Support Agreement re Subros 

(0.5); meeting with Qusba and 

Karotkin re same (0.5). 

1.00 1,640.00 

9/11/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review and comment on draft 

RSA (1.5). 

1.50 2,302.50 

9/12/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Negotiate RSA, including 

review of documents and calls 

with S. Karotkin regarding 

same (1.5); t/c with G. Grogan 

regarding KEIP (0.3). 

1.80 2,763.00 

9/13/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review revised Equity 

Backstop Commitment (0.8); 

emails, teleconfs various 

directors re same (0.5). 

1.30 2,132.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 26

of 44
27 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/13/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Correspondence with S. 

Karotkin regarding press 

release. 

0.20 307.00 

9/15/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Review Willkie markup to RSA 

(1.0); t/c with S. Karotkin and 

K. Orsini regarding same (0.6); 

review revised, annotated 

comments from Willkie (0.7); 

t/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

same (0.6); t/c with S. Karotkin 

and M. Feldman regarding same 

(0.5). 

3.40 5,219.00 

9/16/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Review latest draft RSA (0.5); 

t/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

next steps (0.3); correspondence 

with Restructuring Committee 

regarding same (0.4); t/c with 

N. Brownell regarding status 

update (0.4). 

1.60 2,456.00 

9/17/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with Willkie and S. 

Karotkin regarding RSA (0.2); 

review and comment on revised 

term sheet (0.7); t/c with M. 

Moore regarding update (0.4); 

t/c with R. Barrera regarding 

update (0.4). 

1.70 2,609.50 

9/18/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review of backstop 

commitment issues. 

0.40 530.00 

9/18/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with M. Ponce regarding 

update (0.3); review and 

comment on draft plan 

regarding incorporation of 

subro settlement (1.6). 

1.90 2,916.50 

9/19/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review and comments on 

backstop comment letters. 

2.50 3,312.50 

9/19/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with N. Goldin regarding 

plan provisions (0.2); review 

comments on plan provisions 

(0.8); correspondence with 

Restructuring Committee 

members regarding various 

questions on subro settlement 

RSA (0.7); review bondholder 

notice plan term sheet (2.0); t/c 

4.30 6,600.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 27

of 44
28 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

with M. Moore regarding same 

(0.3); t/c with R. Barrera 

regarding same (0.3). 

9/20/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, calls, various issues re 

Equity Commitment letters 

(1.0). 

1.00 1,640.00 

9/20/2019 

Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review and comment on 

backstop commitment letters 

(0.2). 

0.20 265.00 

9/20/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with R. Barrera regarding 

bondholder plan (0.4); 

participate in Board call (1.2); 

t/c with M. Ponce regarding 

next steps (0.2); t/c with R. 

Barrera regarding update (0.5); 

t/c with N. Brownell, M. Ponce, 

A. Wolff, K. Orsini and S. 

Karotkin regarding board 

process (0.6); review revised 

RSA and ch. 11 plan (1.5); t/c 

with S. Karotkin and K. Orsini 

regarding same (0.5); t/c with 

D. Forman regarding same 

(0.4). 

5.30 8,135.50 

9/21/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with R. Barrera regarding 

catch-up (0.5); t/c with B. 

Bennett regarding update (0.4); 

review revised motion and 

order regarding subro 

settlement (1.7); t/c with S. 

Karotkin regarding next steps 

(0.3); t/c with M. Moore 

regarding same (0.3); t/c with 

M. Ponce and R. Purushotham 

regarding same (0.3). 

3.50 5,372.50 

9/22/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs, emails, various 

issues re Subro settlement and 

Board Meeting (1.5). 

1.50 2,460.00 

9/22/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c (numerous) with S. 

Karotkin regarding update and 

next steps (0.5); review revised 

drafts of motion/order regarding 

2.60 3,991.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 28

of 44
29 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

subro settlement (0.8); t/c with 

R. Barrera regarding update 

(0.4); t/c with M. Moore 

regarding update (0.3); review 

plan term sheet between Ad 

Hocs and TCC (0.6). 

9/23/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, various issues re Equity 

Commitments (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

9/23/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review and comment on 

backstop commitment letters. 

1.20 1,590.00 

9/23/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Meeting with D. Abrams, I. 

Gartenberg, A. Shannahan and 

M. Ponce regarding update 

(1.0); t/c with P. Curnin 

regarding same (0.2); t/c with 

R. Barrera regarding update 

(0.4). 

1.60 2,456.00 

9/24/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Emails, various issues re Equity 

Commitments and Chapter 11 

Status Hearing (0.9). 

0.90 1,476.00 

9/24/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Participate in status conference 

hearing (3.0); draft summary of 

same for restructuring 

committee (0.8); t/c with R. 

Barrera regarding update of 

hearing (0.5); t/c with M. Ponce 

regarding same (0.4). 

4.70 7,214.50 

9/25/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, review of revised Elliott 

term sheet (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/25/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Correspondence with Board 

members regarding next steps 

(0.3); t/c with R. Barrera 

regarding plan status (0.5); t/c 

with S. Karotkin regarding 

catch-up (0.3). 

1.10 1,688.50 

9/26/2019 

Qusba, Sandy Review TCC/Elliot revised term 

sheet (1.5); t/c with R. Barrera 

regarding same (0.5); review 

draft response to Bankruptcy 

OII (1.0); t/c with K. Orsini 

regarding discovery request 

(0.2); participate on board call 

(1.6). 

4.80 7,368.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 29

of 44
30 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/27/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs w/ Directors, J. 

Simon, J. Loduca re revised 

Elliott plan and potential 

responses (1.0). 

1.00 1,640.00 

9/27/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with M. Torkin regarding 

various Board issues (0.3); 

begin review of various motions 

(D&O, OII response, District 

court pleading) (1.5). 

1.80 2,763.00 

9/30/2019 

Ponce, Mario A. Review, emails, various issues 

re Debtors' portion of Joint 

Statement (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

9/30/2019 

Qusba, Sandy T/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

director comp motion and 

update (0.2); review and 

comment on director comp 

motion (1.7); correspondence 

with G. Grogan and M. Ponce 

regarding same (0.6); review 

and comment on Cravath 

estimation proceeding protocol 

(2.0); review and comment on 

CPUC Bankruptcy OII response 

(1.8); t/c with N. Goldin 

regarding same (0.2); t/c with 

M. Ponce and G. Grogan 

regarding director comp motion 

(0.2). 

6.70 10,284.50 

TOTAL 155.60 $230,690.00 

Task Code: Non-Working Travel Time (TV) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/10/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Travel from NY to SF for 

Board meetings (5.0). 5.00 3,700.00 

9/12/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Travel from SF to NY returning 

from Board meetings (3.7). 3.70 2,738.00 

TOTAL 8.70 

 

$6,438.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 30

of 44
31 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Task Code: Fact Investigation/Development (L110) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/4/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Attend interview of employee 

(0.6). 

0.60 354.00 

9/4/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ N. Goldin re: 

documents needed from 

company (0.3); email to 

Company re: same (0.2). 

0.50 547.50 

9/5/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review recent media (0.5); t/c 

w/ Company and Federal 

Monitor re: same (0.2); email to 

P. Curnin and N. Goldin re: 

same (0.6). 

1.30 1,423.50 

9/5/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Draft summary of interview w/ 

employee (3.2). 

3.20 1,888.00 

9/6/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Draft interview summary of 

interview w/ employee (1.9). 

1.90 1,121.00 

9/13/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ Company re: locate and 

mark hearing (0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

9/15/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Emails w/ M. Moore re: Tubbs 

docket (0.3). 

0.30 492.00 

9/16/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of summary of 9-16 

oral arguments (Tubbs Fire) 

(0.2). 

0.20 183.00 

9/16/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review Tubbs tentative ruling 

(0.3). 

0.30 492.00 

9/16/2019 

Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Review docket of California 

North Bay Fires case ISO 

preliminary ruling (0.2) and 

email to P. Curnin re: 

preliminary ruling and 

pleadings (0.1); review 

pleadings in same (0.4); email 

N. Goldin and R. Sparks 

Bradley summary of hearing 

(0.3). 

1.00 590.00 

9/16/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review K. Kinsel email re: 

Tubbs hearing (0.3); emails w/ 

N. Goldin re: same (0.3); email 

to Cravath re: tentative ruling 

(0.1). 

0.70 766.50 

9/16/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Attend California North Bay 

Fire Cases hearing (2.3). 

2.30 1,357.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 31

of 44
32 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/16/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ Company re: Tubbs 

hearing (0.5); confer w/ team 

re: same (0.2); review material 

re: same (0.2); communications 

w/ team re: Tubbs (0.3). 

1.20 1,776.00 

9/17/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

matter updates (1.5). 

1.50 682.50 

9/17/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ team re: hearing (0.4); 

confer w/ team re: same (0.3); 

call w/ client re: same (0.4); 

review correspondence re: same 

(0.2). 

1.30 1,924.00 

9/18/2019 Kortright, 

Magallie 

Preparation of court submission 

for attorney review (3.9). 

3.90 1,560.00 

9/18/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ client re: Tubbs status 

(0.4); communications w/ 

clients re: same (0.7). 

1.10 1,628.00 

9/18/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of background 

materials re: Tubbs trial 

preparations (2.4). 

2.40 2,196.00 

9/19/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Distribute recent filings to team 

for review (0.1). 

0.10 45.50 

9/19/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

matter updates (0.4). 

0.40 182.00 

9/19/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

T/c w/ J. Lundqvist re: Tubbs 

trial schedule (0.2). 

0.20 183.00 

9/19/2019 

Lundqvist, Jacob Draft summary of Tubbs 

wildfire factual allegations and 

key legal issues (0.6). 

0.60 354.00 

9/19/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review Tubbs correspondence 

(0.4). 

0.40 592.00 

9/19/2019 

Kortright, 

Magallie 

Continue preparation of court 

submission for attorney review 

(2.3). 

2.30 920.00 

9/20/2019 

Carney, Michael Prepare material for legal team 

review per J. Franklin request 

(0.4). 

0.40 168.00 

9/20/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

File management of case 

documents (1.5). 

1.50 682.50 

9/20/2019 

Kortright, 

Magallie 

Preparation of court 

submissions for attorney review 

(5.1). 

5.10 2,040.00 

9/20/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Outlining defenses to complaint 

(1.5). 

1.50 2,460.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 32

of 44
33 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/22/2019 

Lundqvist, Jacob Review Tubbs trail schedule 

(0.5); email to team re: same 

(0.2). 

0.70 413.00 

9/22/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Review correspondence w/ 

client re: Tubbs (0.2); review 

material re: same (0.1). 

0.30 444.00 

9/23/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

matter updates (0.1). 

0.10 45.50 

9/23/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Review of Tubbs background 

materials (1.4). 

1.40 826.00 

9/23/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review Tubbs filings (0.5) / 

recent communications (0.4); 

email to Cravath re: same (0.1). 

1.00 1,095.00 

9/23/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Attend to media issues (0.6); 

call w/ team re: workstreams 

(0.2); review Tubbs lit (0.2). 

1.00 1,480.00 

9/23/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft chart of Tubbs causes of 

actions, elements (2.9). 

2.90 2,653.50 

9/24/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Drafted Tubbs litigation 

overview chart (0.1). 

0.10 59.00 

9/24/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

matter updates (0.5). 

0.50 227.50 

9/24/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of background material 

re: Tubbs trial (0.5). 

0.50 457.50 

9/25/2019 

Kortright, 

Magallie 

Collection and distribution of 

ECF filing for team review 

(0.1). 

0.10 40.00 

9/25/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft chart of key elements for 

Tubbs fire trial (0.3). 

0.30 274.50 

9/25/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ team re: 

Tubbs (0.5). 

0.50 740.00 

9/25/2019 

Lundqvist, Jacob Draft Tubbs case elements (1.8) 

and key facts summary (1.7); 

research re: same (1.5); emails 

w/ team re: same (0.6). 

5.60 3,304.00 

9/26/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

File management (1.0). 1.00 455.00 

9/27/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

File management (1.5). 1.50 682.50 

9/28/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

File management (3.0). 3.00 1,365.00 

9/30/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (0.2). 

0.20 91.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 33

of 44
34 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

TOTAL 

57.10 

 

$41,557.00 

Task Code: Pre-Trial Pleadings and Motion (L200) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/3/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ defense counsel re: 

motion to discuss in securities 

class action (0.7). 

0.70 1,148.00 

9/3/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Reviewing class action 

complaint (1.9). 

1.90 3,116.00 

9/3/2019 

Blake, Stephen T/cs w/ P. Curnin and N. 

Goldin re: quarterbacking 

PG&E motion to dismiss (0.8); 

communications w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley re: same (0.2). 

1.00 1,325.00 

9/3/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ counsel group re: PERA 

MTD (0.7); call w/ team re: 

same (0.2); review material re: 

PERA litigation (0.3); draft 

correspondence client re: PERA 

(0.4). 

1.60 2,368.00 

9/3/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Draft client communication re: 

securities action (0.5); emails 

w/ N. Goldin re: same (0.2); 

emails w/ P. Curnin, N. Goldin 

re: securities motion to dismiss 

(0.4); t/c w/ other defense 

counsel re: same (0.3); t/cs w/ 

S. Blake re: motion to dismiss 

(0.5); email to S. Blake re: same 

(0.7). 

2.60 2,847.00 

9/3/2019 

Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Research to confirm assignment 

of securities case to Judge 

Massullo (0.1) and research on 

cases decided by Judge 

Massullo (0.4). 

0.50 295.00 

9/4/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Reviewing class action 

complaint (1.5). 

1.50 2,460.00 

9/4/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications re: securities 

case update (0.7). 

0.70 318.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 34

of 44
35 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/4/2019 

Blake, Stephen Review complaint and related 

documents (1.0) and begin 

drafting MTD outline (1.5); 

communications w/ R. SparksBradley re: same (0.5); meeting 

w/ team re: arguments (1.0); 

research on MTD bespoke 

arguments and 430B issue (2.0). 

6.00 7,950.00 

9/4/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ team re: 

PERA (0.8); review 

correspondence re: PERA case 

(0.2). 

1.00 1,480.00 

9/4/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ S. Blake and team re: 

securities MTD (0.5); emails w/ 

defense group re: same (0.6); 

emails w/ J. Calderon re: 

securities analysis work (0.4). 

1.50 1,642.50 

9/4/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of PERA complaint 

(1.3); communications w/ S. 

Blake, R. Sparks Bradley re: 

motion to dismiss (2.2). 

3.50 3,202.50 

9/4/2019 Duran, Raul G. Review complaint (0.4). 0.40 236.00 

9/4/2019 Duran, Raul G. Meeting w/ S. Blake and team 

re: MTD (0.5). 

0.50 295.00 

9/4/2019 Duran, Raul G. Collect relevant offering 

documents for MTDs (1.7). 

1.70 1,003.00 

9/4/2019 Duran, Raul G. Draft chart of plaintiffs’ 

allegations (2.4). 

2.40 1,416.00 

9/4/2019 

Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

T/c w/ internal team re: 

preparing for briefing on 

motion to dismiss (1.0). 

1.00 590.00 

9/4/2019 

Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Communications w/ J. Franklin 

re: filing notice of appearance 

in securities case (0.1). 

0.10 59.00 

9/4/2019 

Lundqvist, Jacob Call w/ team re: MTD (0.6); 

research re: same (2.6); email to 

team re: same (0.2). 

3.40 2,006.00 

9/5/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Assist team w/ NOA 

preparation (2.0). 

2.00 910.00 

9/5/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

case update (0.5). 

0.50 227.50 

9/5/2019 Webb, Daniel N. Discuss securities law questions 

w/ S. Blake (0.5). 

0.50 740.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 35

of 44
36 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/5/2019 

Blake, Stephen Continue reviewing complaint 

(0.5) and related materials (1.0); 

communications w/ DPW re: 

motion (0.5); prepare outline of 

possible JDG arguments (1.5). 

3.50 4,637.50 

9/5/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ DPW re: brief (0.5); 

review complaint (0.9); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.6). 

2.00 2,960.00 

9/5/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review MTD outline (0.8); 

emails w/ E. Campbell re: same 

(0.3); t/c w/ DPW re: securities 

complaint (0.5); review relevant 

securities case law (0.9); emails 

w/ J. Lundqvist re: facts re: 

MTD (0.5); numerous emails w/ 

S. Blake re: MTD (0.6). 

3.60 3,942.00 

9/5/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft outline re: motion to 

dismiss (5.5); t/cs w/ S. Blake, 

R. Sparks Bradley, DPW re: 

same (1.2). 

6.70 6,130.50 

9/5/2019 

Calderon, Justin Research re: assigned judge 

(1.0), including review of all 

securities cases for statistical 

breakdown (2.0); review S. 

Blake NOA (0.5). 

3.50 2,450.00 

9/5/2019 Duran, Raul G. Draft chart of Plaintiffs’ alleged 

misrepresentations (3.5). 

3.50 2,065.00 

9/5/2019 

Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Communications w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley and J. Franklin re: 

notice of appearance for S. 

Blake (0.3). 

0.30 177.00 

9/5/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Research re: MTD (3.3). 3.30 1,947.00 

9/6/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Assist J. Calderon w/ NOA 

filings (2.0). 

2.00 910.00 

9/6/2019 

Blake, Stephen Communications w/ team re: 

MTD outline and arguments; 

comment on outline prepared 

by team and provide guidance 

on further outlining (0.5). 

0.50 662.50 

9/6/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Review outline for MTD (0.4); 

review correspondence re: same 

(0.1). 

0.50 740.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 36

of 44
37 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/6/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Revise MTD securities outline 

(1.3); emails w/ S. Blake and E. 

Campbell re: same (0.7). 

2.00 2,190.00 

9/6/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft outline for motion to 

dismiss (2.3). 

2.30 2,104.50 

9/6/2019 Duran, Raul G. Draft chart of alleged 

misrepresentations (0.5). 

0.50 295.00 

9/6/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Review offering documents 

referenced in complaint (1.8). 

1.80 1,062.00 

9/7/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft MTD detailed outline 

(2.5). 

2.50 2,287.50 

9/7/2019 

Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Analyze offering documents 

mentioned in complaint (4.3) 

and compile work product re: 

same (5.3). 

9.60 5,664.00 

9/7/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Review alleged 

misrepresentations chart (0.2). 

0.20 118.00 

9/8/2019 Blake, Stephen Comment on MTD outline 

(1.5). 

1.50 1,987.50 

9/8/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft outline for motion to 

dismiss (6.2). 

6.20 5,673.00 

9/8/2019 Duran, Raul G. Assess alleged 

misrepresentation context (3.4). 

3.40 2,006.00 

9/8/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Research re: MTD (3.0). 3.00 1,770.00 

9/9/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Company re: securities 

claims (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

9/9/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications re: case 

update (0.2). 

0.20 91.00 

9/9/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Assist R. Duran w/ PHV prep 

for S. Blake's review (2.0). 

2.00 910.00 

9/9/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

O/c w/ S. Blake re: securities 

MTD (1.0); t/c w/ defense 

group re: MTD (0.4). 

1.40 1,533.00 

9/9/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss outline 

(7.3). 

7.30 6,679.50 

9/9/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Meeting w/ S. Blake, R. Sparks 

Bradley re: motion to dismiss 

(1.5). 

1.50 1,372.50 

9/9/2019 Duran, Raul G. Assess alleged 

misrepresentation context (1.9). 

1.90 1,121.00 

9/9/2019 Duran, Raul G. Draft PHV applications (0.6). 0.60 354.00 

9/9/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Research re: MTD arguments 

(5.2). 

5.20 3,068.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 37

of 44
38 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/9/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Team meeting re: motion to 

dismiss (1.4). 

1.40 826.00 

9/9/2019 

Lundqvist, Jacob Team meeting re: MTD strategy 

(1.0); draft MTD background 

(0.9). 

1.90 1,121.00 

9/10/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (0.9). 

0.90 409.50 

9/10/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss outline 

(1.3). 

1.30 1,189.50 

9/10/2019 Duran, Raul G. Draft clients' CIEs (1.3). 1.30 767.00 

9/10/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Research re: MTD arguments 

(4.5). 

4.50 2,655.00 

9/10/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob MTD legal research (5.5); email 

drafting re: same (0.6). 

6.10 3,599.00 

9/11/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (0.1). 

0.10 45.50 

9/11/2019 Carney, Michael Update case management tool 

per J. Franklin request (0.2). 

0.20 84.00 

9/11/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

O/c w/ S. Blake re: securities 

MTD (1.0); t/c w/ defense 

group re: MTD (0.5); emails w/ 

Latham re: materials for same 

(0.5); prep. MTD outline (1.9); 

emails w/ J. Lundqvist re: same 

(0.3). 

4.20 4,599.00 

9/11/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of case law re: motion 

to dismiss arguments (2.2). 

2.20 2,013.00 

9/11/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Meeting w/ S. Blake, R. Sparks 

Bradley re: motion to dismiss 

(0.7). 

0.70 640.50 

9/11/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Research for motion to dismiss 

(3.7). 

3.70 2,183.00 

9/11/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Team meeting re: strategy for 

motion to dismiss (1.2). 

1.20 708.00 

9/11/2019 

Lundqvist, Jacob Team meeting re: MTD (1.0); 

draft background section for 

MTD brief (1.4); legal research 

re: MTD (1.0). 

3.40 2,006.00 

9/12/2019 Webb, Daniel N. Discuss securities law questions 

w/ S. Blake (0.3). 

0.30 444.00 

9/12/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Research re: legal arguments 

(2.5). 

2.50 2,287.50 

9/12/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Research re: MTD brief (2.1). 2.10 1,239.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 38

of 44
39 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/12/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Draft MTD background (4.5); 

research re: same (2.4). 

6.90 4,071.00 

9/13/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (0.9). 

0.90 409.50 

9/13/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review correspondence re: 

scheduling stipulation (0.3). 

0.30 444.00 

9/13/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of legal research re: 

MTD (0.7). 

0.70 640.50 

9/13/2019 Duran, Raul G. Analysis re: MTD arguments 

(0.4). 

0.40 236.00 

9/13/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Prepare email to client re: 

accessing case filings (0.2). 

0.20 118.00 

9/13/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Research cases re: MTD 

arguments (5.7). 

5.70 3,363.00 

9/13/2019 

Lundqvist, Jacob Draft MTD facts outline (2.0); 

research re: legal arguments 

(2.2). 

4.20 2,478.00 

9/15/2019 

Goldin, Nicholas Review stipulation re: 

scheduling (0.1); 

communication w/ team re: 

same (0.1). 

0.20 296.00 

9/15/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Draft MTD (1.1). 1.10 649.00 

9/16/2019 Blake, Stephen Emails w/ DPW and MWE re: 

motion to dismiss briefs (0.5). 

0.50 662.50 

9/16/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Legal research re: motion to 

dismiss case law (3.4); update 

motion to dismiss outline re: 

same (1.0). 

4.40 4,026.00 

9/16/2019 

Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Research (5.0) and draft section 

of motion to dismiss outline 

(2.2). 

7.20 4,248.00 

9/16/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Draft MTD (1.1). 1.10 649.00 

9/17/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Draft MTD (1.0). 1.00 590.00 

9/18/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Analyze securities complaint 

(2.3). 

2.30 3,772.00 

9/18/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Draft MTD argument sections 

(1.3). 

1.30 767.00 

9/19/2019 

Blake, Stephen Continue to prepare draft 

PG&E motion to dismiss 

(director version) (5.5). 

5.50 7,287.50 

9/19/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ S. Blake, E. 

Campbell re: securities MTD 

1.10 1,204.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 39

of 44
40 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

(0.8); emails w/ Latham re: 

same (0.3). 

9/19/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of CUSIP information 

(0.4). 

0.40 366.00 

9/19/2019 

Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Coordinate w/ MCO and 

assistants to get N. Goldin and 

P. Curnin admitted pro hac 

(0.5). 

0.50 295.00 

9/19/2019 

Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Coordinate w/ Library and E. 

Campbell re: offerings (1.8); 

emails w/ team re: same (0.5); 

draft email to DPW re: offering 

documents (0.4); review 

disclosures for MTD research 

(0.6). 

3.30 1,947.00 

9/19/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Draft MTD argument sections 

(0.5). 

0.50 295.00 

9/20/2019 

Blake, Stephen Review drafts of PG&E 

directors motion to dismiss 

(3.5); communications w/ team 

re: same (0.8). 

4.30 5,697.50 

9/20/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ S. Blake, E. 

Campbell re: securities MTD 

(0.5); t/c w/ Latham re: same 

(0.1). 

0.60 657.00 

9/20/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss (1.3); 

research re: same (1.2). 

2.50 2,287.50 

9/20/2019 

Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Review disclosures for MTD 

research (2.5); draft MTD 

section (3.6) and calls w/ R. 

Sparks Bradley and E. 

Campbell re: same (0.4) and 

emails w/ S. Blake re: same 

(0.2). 

6.70 3,953.00 

9/21/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Draft securities MTD sections 

(4.8). 

4.80 5,256.00 

9/21/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss (7.8). 7.80 7,137.00 

9/21/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Draft MTD section (4.5). 4.50 2,655.00 

9/21/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Draft MTD section (4.3); 

research re: same (2.5). 

6.80 4,012.00 

9/22/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Work on motion to dismiss 

(2.3). 

2.30 3,772.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 40

of 44
41 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/22/2019 

Kortright, 

Magallie 

Preparation of court 

submissions in connection w/ 

York County litigation for 

attorney review (1.1) & 

electronic data update (1.0). 

2.10 840.00 

9/22/2019 

Blake, Stephen Continue to prepare draft 

PG&E motion to dismiss 

(director version) (5.8); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.5); review of 

disclosures and caselaw re: 

same (3.5). 

9.80 12,985.00 

9/22/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Draft / revise securities MTD 

(5.6); t/c w/ S. Blake and E. 

Campbell re: MTD arguments 

(2.0). 

7.60 8,322.00 

9/22/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss (7.8); 

emails/calls w/ S. Blake, R. 

Sparks Bradley re: same (1.9). 

9.70 8,875.50 

9/22/2019 Duran, Raul G. Research for MTD (4.1). 4.10 2,419.00 

9/22/2019 Duran, Raul G. Meeting w/ S. Blake re: MTD 

research (0.8). 

0.80 472.00 

9/22/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Research re: securities case 

(6.5). 

6.50 3,835.00 

9/22/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Research for MTD (1.5). 1.50 885.00 

9/22/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Draft MTD section (1.4). 1.40 826.00 

9/22/2019 

Lundqvist, Jacob Research re: pleading standard 

(1.8); email to S. Blake re: same 

(0.2); draft MTD (2.0); team 

call re: same (0.6). 

4.60 2,714.00 

9/23/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Work on motion to dismiss 

(3.3); t/c w/ Company re: 

upcoming filings (0.5). 

3.80 6,232.00 

9/23/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Draft / revise securities MTD 

(3.7); emails w/ S. Blake and E. 

Campbell re: same (0.9). 

4.60 5,037.00 

9/23/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss (4.0); 

research re: same (3.1). 

7.10 6,496.50 

9/23/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Research re: MTD (2.5). 2.50 1,475.00 

9/23/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Implement S. Blake's edits to 

motion to dismiss (2.3); call w/ 

4.30 2,537.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 41

of 44
42 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

S. Blake and E. Campbell re: 

same (0.3); research for motion 

to dismiss (1.7). 

9/24/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Work on motion to dismiss 

(3.5). 

3.50 5,740.00 

9/24/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Assist R. Duran w/ pro hac vice 

filings (1.5). 

1.50 682.50 

9/24/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Assist R. Duran w/ certificate of 

interested entities filings (2.5). 

2.50 1,137.50 

9/24/2019 

Blake, Stephen Continue to prepare draft 

motion to dismiss (4.7), 

including review of team's draft 

(3.0), review of key cases and 

disclosures (1.0); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (1.0). 

9.70 12,852.50 

9/24/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Draft / revise securities MTD 

(2.2); revise DPW draft (0.9); 

t/c w/ S. Blake and E. Campbell 

re: same (0.9); t/c w/ J. 

Lundqvist re: research for same 

(0.1). 

4.10 4,489.50 

9/24/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss (2.0) 

and appendices to motion to 

dismiss (2.7). 

4.70 4,300.50 

9/24/2019 Duran, Raul G. File CIEs (2.0). 2.00 1,180.00 

9/24/2019 

Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Research for MTD (3.7); call w/ 

team re: motion to dismiss 

(1.0). 

4.70 2,773.00 

9/24/2019 

Lundqvist, Jacob Review of draft MTD from 

DPW (1.9); review of cases 

cited in same (2.4); team 

meeting re: MTD (1.0). 

5.30 3,127.00 

9/25/2019 

Curnin, Paul C. Emails w/ co-counsel re: 

coordination of arguments 

(0.4); work on motion to 

dismiss (1.2). 

1.60 2,624.00 

9/25/2019 

Blake, Stephen T/c w/ DPW re: motion to 

dismiss brief (1.0); continued 

review and comment on motion 

to dismiss brief (2.4). 

3.40 4,505.00 

9/25/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ S. Blake and DPW re: 

securities MTD (1.0); follow up 

o/c w/ S. Blake re: same (0.2); 

3.40 3,723.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 42

of 44
43 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

t/c w/ E. Campbell re: next 

steps (0.4); review 

research/analysis re: relevant 

cases (1.8). 

9/25/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

T/c w/ DPW re: Section 11 

motion to dismiss draft (1.1). 

1.10 1,006.50 

9/25/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss (2.1). 2.10 1,921.50 

9/26/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Work on motion to dismiss 

(1.8). 

1.80 2,952.00 

9/26/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Revise brief (0.5). 0.50 820.00 

9/26/2019 

Blake, Stephen Continue to review and 

comment on motion to dismiss 

draft (2.5), including calls w/ 

DPW (0.6) and communications 

w/ team re: disclosures and 

caselaw (1.7). 

4.80 6,360.00 

9/26/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Revise securities MTD draft 

(1.2); email to E. Campbell re: 

same (0.1). 

1.30 1,423.50 

9/26/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft MTD (3.1); research re: 

same (1.0). 

4.10 3,751.50 

9/27/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Assist team w/ MTD filing 

preparation (2.0). 

2.00 910.00 

9/27/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Further revise securities MTD 

draft per S. Blake comments 

(2.6); emails w/ E. Campbell re: 

same (0.3); review MWE draft 

MTD (0.6). 

3.50 3,832.50 

9/27/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of Company disclosures 

(2.3). 

2.30 2,104.50 

9/28/2019 

Blake, Stephen Continue to review and 

comment on motion to dismiss 

draft (6.0). 

6.00 7,950.00 

9/28/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss (2.0). 2.00 1,830.00 

9/29/2019 

Blake, Stephen Communications w/ team re: 

continued preparation of MTD 

briefs (0.5). 

0.50 662.50 

9/29/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Research re: securities MTD 

issues (0.9); email to Latham re: 

reports (0.1). 

1.00 1,095.00 

9/29/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of disclosures for MTD 

(1.2). 

1.20 1,098.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 43

of 44
44 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 

425 Lexington Ave 

New York, NY 10017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/30/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Work on motion to dismiss 

(3.8). 

3.80 6,232.00 

9/30/2019 

Blake, Stephen Review DPW edits (0.8) and t/c 

w/ DPW re: motion to dismiss 

drafts (1.0); communications w/ 

MWE re: brief comments (0.5) 

and t/c w/ MWE re: same (0.5); 

continue to review and revise 

joint MTD brief (4.2), including 

review of cases and disclosures 

(2.0). 

9.00 11,925.00 

9/30/2019 

Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ S. Blake, DPW re: 

securities MTD draft (0.7); 

numerous emails w/ S. Blake, 

E. Campbell re: draft of same 

(1.9); t/c w/ E. Campbell re: 

same (0.3); review prior filings 

re: same (0.4); email to J. 

Calderon re: same (0.1). 

3.40 3,723.00 

9/30/2019 

Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Draft motion to dismiss (4.0); 

calls w/ DPW, McDermott re: 

same (0.9). 

4.90 4,483.50 

9/30/2019 

Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Call w/ J. Isaacman re: case 

updates (0.2); call w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley re: MTD (0.3). 

0.50 420.00 

9/30/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Coordinate w/ library re: 

offering documents (0.3). 

0.30 177.00 

TOTAL 418.90 

 

$380,184.50 

Task Code: e-Discovery - Production (L670)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

9/3/2019 Scott, Eric Dean 

Create PDF of track 

changes/comments review per 

N. Goldin (0.3). 

0.30 79.50 

TOTAL 0.30 $79.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4892-4 Filed: 11/27/19 Entered: 11/27/19 13:35:40 Page 44

of 44