1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

1

3467592.1

Isaac M. Pachulski (CA Bar No. 62337)

Debra I. Grassgreen (CA Bar No. 169978)

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL & JONES LLP

150 California Street, 15th Floor

San Francisco, CA 94111

Telephone: (415) 263-7000

Facsimile: (415) 263-7010

Email: dgrassgreen@pszjlaw.com

Eric Seiler (admitted pro hac vice)

FRIEDMAN KAPLAN SEILER AND ADELMAN LLP

7 Times Square

New York, NY 10036-6516

Telephone (212) 833-1103

Facsimile (212) 373-7903

Email: eseiler@fklaw.com

Attorneys for The Baupost Group, L.L.C.,

as the managing general partner and/or investment 

manager of certain entities

UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION

In re:

PG&E CORPORATION,

-andPACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC 

COMPANY,

Debtors.

☐ Affects PG&E Corporation

☐ Affects Pacific Gas and Electric

Company

Affects both Debtors

* All papers shall be filed in the lead case,

No. 19-30088 (DM)

Case No. 19-30088 (DM)

Chapter 11

(Jointly Administered)

JOINDER IN REPLY OF THE AD HOC 

GROUP OF SUBROGATION CLAIM 

HOLDERS TO THE STATUS CONFERENCE 

STATEMENT OF THE OFFICIAL 

COMMITTEE OF TORT CLAIMANTS

Date: September 24, 2019

Time: 9:30 a.m. (Pacific Time)

Place: United States Bankruptcy Court

Courtroom 17, 16th Floor

San Francisco, CA 94102

The Baupost Group, L.L.C., as the general partner and/or investment manager for certain 

entities (“Baupost”) hereby submits this Joinder (the “Joinder”) in the Reply of the Ad Hoc Group of 

Subrogation Claim Holders to the Status Conference Statement of the Official Committee of Tort 

Claimants (the “Subrogation Group Reply”) [Docket No. 3961]. Baupost is a substantial creditor of 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 1 of

13
1

2

3

45

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

2

3467592.1

these estates, is a major holder of insurance subrogation claims and is a member of the Steering 

Committee of the Ad Hoc Group of Subrogation Claim Holders (the “Ad Hoc Subrogation Group”).1 

The Subrogation Group Reply explains why the arguments concerning California’s madewhole rule presented by the Official Committee of Tort Claimants (the “TCC”) in its “Status 

Conference Statement” [Docket No. 3931] (“TCC Statement”) are both speculative and premature. 

See Subrogation Group Reply at 2-5. The objective of these cases, which Baupost fully supports, is 

to make individual wildfire victims whole for their losses. The TCC’s made-whole arguments are 

only relevant to a scenario in which these cases fail to accomplish that important objective. 

Even addressed to such a hypothetical scenario, the TCC’s arguments reflect a fundamental 

misunderstanding of the made-whole rule. Contrary to what the TCC suggests, the made-whole rule 

would never operate to categorically subordinate the claims of all members of the Ad Hoc 

Subrogation Group to the claims of all individual wildfire victims (assuming, arguendo, that the 

made-whole rule would ever support the subordination of even individual subrogation claims within 

the context of a Chapter 11 plan). Where the made-whole rule is concerned, “‘[an] insurer’s 

obligation runs to its insured, and then only to the extent of the policy limits.’” Chandler v. State 

Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 598 F.3d 1115, 1119 (9th Cir. 2010) (quoting Winkelmann v. Excelsior 

Ins. Co., 85 N.Y.2d 577 (1995)). The insured’s right to be made whole does not cross claims, 

insureds, insurers, or fires. As the TCC appears to acknowledge, made-whole refers to an obligation 

of an individual property insurer to its individual insured, and applies only as to the insurer’s 

subrogation claim arising from payments to that insured. See TCC Statement at 4. 

 

1

 As set forth in the Third Amended Verified Statement of the Ad Hoc Group of Subrogation Claim Holders Pursuant to 

Bankruptcy Rule 2019, Baupost also holds 24,500,000 shares of PG&E Corporation Common Stock and $850,000.00 in 

other unsecured wildfire-related claims.

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 2 of

13
1

2

3

45

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

3

3467592.1

Dated: September 23, 2019 PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL & JONES LLP

/s/ Debra I. Grassgreen

Isaac M. Pachulski

Debra I. Grassgreen

- and -

Eric Seiler

FRIEDMAN KAPLAN SEILER 

AND ADELMAN LLP

Attorneys for The Baupost Group, L.L.C., as the 

general partner and investment manager for certain 

entities

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 3 of

13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

1

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

CITY OF SAN FRANCISCO

)

)

)

I, Patricia Jeffries, am employed in the city and county of San Francisco, State of California. 

I am over the age of 18 and not a party to the within action; my business address is 150 California 

Street, 15th Floor, San Francisco, California 94111-4500.

On September 23, 2019, I caused to be served the following documents in the manner stated 

below:

Joinder in Reply of the Ad Hoc Group of Subrogation Claim Holders to the Status 

Conference Statement of the Official Committee of Tort Claimants



TO BE SERVED BY THE COURT VIA NOTICE OF ELECTRONIC FILING 

(NEF): Pursuant to controlling General Orders and LBR, the foregoing 

document was served by the court via NEF and hyperlink to the document. On 

September 23, 2019, I checked the CM/ECF docket for this bankruptcy case or 

adversary proceeding and determined that the following persons are on the 

Electronic Mail Notice List to receive NEF transmission at the email addresses 

stated below



(BY MAIL) I am readily familiar with the firm’s practice of collection and 

processing correspondence for mailing. Under that practice it would be 

deposited with the U.S. Postal Service on that same day with postage thereon 

fully prepaid at San Francisco, California, in the ordinary course of business. I 

am aware that on motion of the party served, service is presumed invalid if postal 

cancellation date or postage meter date is more than one day after date of deposit 

for mailing in affidavit.

I caused to be served the above-described document U.S. First class mail 

pursuant to the procedures set forth above.

 (BY EMAIL) I caused to be served the above-described document by email to 

the parties indicated on the attached service list at the indicated email address.

I declare under penalty of perjury, under the laws of the State of California and the United 

States of America that the foregoing is true and correct.

Executed on September 23, 2019 at San Francisco, California.

/s/ Patricia Jeffries

Patricia Jeffries

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 4 of

13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

2

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

1. SERVICE VIA NEF

Elliot Adler eadler@theadlerfirm.com, 

bzummer@theadlerfirm.com

Annadel A. Almendras 

annadel.almendras@doj.ca.gov

Monique D. Almy malmy@crowell.com

Dana M. Andreoli 

dandreoli@steyerlaw.com, 

pspencer@steyerlaw.com

Anne Andrews aa@andrewsthornton.com, 

aandrews@andrewsthornton.com

Richard L. Antognini rlalawyer@yahoo.com, 

hallonaegis@gmail.com

Tyson Arbuthnot tarbuthnot@rjo.com, 

jyeung@rjo.com

Lauren T. Attard lattard@bakerlaw.com, 

agrosso@bakerlaw.com

Herb Baer hbaer@primeclerk.com, 

ecf@primeclerk.com

Todd M. Bailey Todd.Bailey@ftb.ca.gov

Kathryn E. Barrett keb@svlg.com, 

amt@svlg.com

Chris Bator cbator@bakerlaw.com, 

jmcguigan@bakerlaw.com

Ronald S. Beacher 

rbeacher@pryorcashman.com

Hagop T. Bedoyan 

hbedoyan@kleinlaw.com, ecf@kleinlaw.com

Andrew David Behlmann 

abehlmann@lowenstein.com, 

elawler@lowenstein.com

James C. Behrens jbehrens@milbank.com, 

mkoch@milbank.com

Jacob Taylor Beiswenger 

jbeiswenger@omm.com, llattin@omm.com

Peter J. Benvenutti 

pbenvenutti@kellerbenvenutti.com

Robert Berens rberens@smtdlaw.com, 

sr@smtdlaw.com

Heinz Binder heinz@bindermalter.com

Neil Jon Bloomfield 

njbloomfield@njblaw.com, 

gklump@njblaw.com

Jason Blumberg 

jason.blumberg@usdoj.gov, 

Tina.L.Spyksma@UST.DOJ.GOV

Ameneh Maria Bordi 

ameneh.bordi@kirkland.com, 

leo.rosenberg@kirkland.com

Peter R. Boutin peter.boutin@kyl.com, 

lara.joel@kyl.com

Erin N. Brady enbrady@jonesday.com

Michael D. Breslauer 

mbreslauer@ecf.courtdrive.com, 

wyones@swsslaw.com

W. Steven Bryant , molly.batistedebose@lockelord.com

Chane Buck cbuck@jonesday.com

Elizabeth J. Cabraser ecabraser@lchb.com, 

awolf@lchb.com

Anthony P. Cali anthony.cali@stinson.com, 

lindsay.petrowski@stinson.com

Peter C. Califano pcalifano@cwclaw.com

Steven M. Campora 

scampora@dbbwc.com, 

nlechuga@dbbwc.com

Leah E. Capritta leah.capritta@hklaw.com, 

lori.labash@hklaw.com

Katherine Rose Catanese 

kcatanese@foley.com

Jennifer Machlin Cecil JCecil@winston.com, 

ECF_SF@winston.com

Karen J. Chedister kchedister@h-jlaw.com

Christina Lin Chen 

christina.chen@morganlewis.com, 

christina.lin.chen@gmail.com

Richard A. Chesley 

richard.chesley@dlapiper.com, 

bill.countryman@dlapiper.com

Shawn M. Christianson 

schristianson@buchalter.com

Robert N.H. Christmas 

rchristmas@nixonpeabody.com, 

nyc.managing.clerk@nixonpeabody.com

Alicia Clough aclough@loeb.com

John B. Coffman john@johncoffman.net

Kevin G. Collins kevin.collins@btlaw.com

Manuel Corrales 

mannycorrales@yahoo.com, 

hcskanchy@hotmail.com

Donald H. Cram dhc@severson.com

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 5 of

13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

3

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

Ashley Vinson Crawford 

avcrawford@akingump.com, dkrasaberstell@akingump.com

John Cumming jcumming@dir.ca.gov

J. Russell Cunningham 

rcunningham@dnlc.net, emehr@dnlc.net

Keith J. Cunningham , 

rkelley@pierceatwood.com

Keith J. Cunningham 

kcunningham@pierceatwood.com, 

rkelley@pierceatwood.com

James D. Curran 

jcurran@wolkincurran.com, 

dstorms@wolkincurran.com

Tambra Curtis tambra.curtis@sonomacounty.org, Kristin.whalley@sonomacounty.org

Jonathan S. Dabbieri 

dabbieri@sullivanhill.com, 

bkstaff@sullivanhill.com

Nicolas De Lancie ndelancie@jmbm.com

Judith A. Descalso , 

jad_9193@ecf.courtdrive.com

Shounak S. Dharap ssd@arnslaw.com, 

mec@arnslaw.com

Kathryn S. Diemer 

kdiemer@diemerwhitman.com, 

ecfnotice@diemerwhitman.com

John P. Dillman 

houston_bankruptcy@publicans.com

Jonathan R. Doolittle 

jdoolittle@reedsmith.com, 

bgonshorowski@reedsmith.com

Jennifer V. Doran jdoran@hinckleyallen.com

Dustin M. Dow ddow@bakerlaw.com, 

mcguigan@bakerlaw.com

Jamie P. Dreher 

jdreher@downeybrand.com

Geoffrey B. Dryvynsyde gbd@cpuc.ca.gov, 

geoffrey.dryvynsyde@cpuc.ca.gov

Cecily Ann Dumas cdumas@bakerlaw.com, 

BHDataServices@ecf.courtdrive.com

Dennis F. Dunne cprice@milbank.com, 

jbrewster@milbank.com

Dennis F. Dunne ddunne@milbank.com, 

jbrewster@milbank.com

Huonganh Annie Duong 

annie.duong@mccormickbarstow.com, 

dawn.houston@mccormickbarstow.com

Kevin M. Eckhardt keckhardt@hunton.com, 

candonian@huntonak.com

Michael Eggenberger 

meggenberger@piercebainbridge.com, 

gchang@piercebainbridge.com

Joseph A. Eisenberg JAE1900@yahoo.com

Michele Ellison mellison@gibbsgiden.com, 

lrochelle@gibbsgiden.com

David Emerzian 

david.emerzian@mccormickbarstow.com, 

Melany.Hertel@mccormickbarstow.com

G. Larry Engel larry@engeladvice.com

Krista M. Enns kenns@beneschlaw.com

Joseph M. Esmont jesmont@bakerlaw.com

Michael P. Esser 

michael.esser@kirkland.com, michael-esser3293@ecf.pacerpro.com.

Richard W. Esterkin 

richard.esterkin@morganlewis.com, 

melissa.boey@morganlewis.com

Michael S. Etkin metkin@lowenstein.com

Jacob M. Faircloth 

jacob.faircloth@smolsonlaw.com

Michael C. Fallon mcfallon@fallonlaw.net, 

manders@fallonlaw.net

Joseph Kyle Feist jfeistesq@gmail.com, 

info@norcallawgroup.net

Matthew A. Feldman mfeldman@willkie.com

Mark E. Felger mfelger@cozen.com

James J. Ficenec 

James.Ficenec@ndlf.com, 

caroline.pfahl@ndlf.com

John D. Fiero jfiero@pszjlaw.com, 

ocarpio@pszjlaw.com

Kimberly S. Fineman 

kfineman@nutihart.com, nwhite@nutihart.com

Stephen D. Finestone 

sfinestone@fhlawllp.com

Timothy M. Flaherty tflaherty@mpplaw.com

Daniel I. Forman dforman@willkie.com

Jonathan Forstot 

jonathan.forstot@troutman.com, 

john.murphy@troutman.com

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 6 of

13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

4

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

Jonathan Forstot , 

john.murphy@troutman.com

Matthew Hampton Foushee 

hampton.foushee@hoganlovells.com, 

hfoushee@gmail.com

Carolyn Frederick cfrederick@prklaw.com

Peter Friedman pfriedman@omm.com

Roger F. Friedman rfriedman@rutan.com, 

csolorzano@rutan.com

Xiyi Fu jackie.fu@lockelord.com, 

taylor.warren@lockelord.com

Lars H. Fuller lfuller@bakerlaw.com

Larry W. Gabriel lgabriel@bg.law, 

nfields@bg.law

Gregg M. Galardi 

gregg.galardi@ropesgray.com

Richard L. Gallagher 

richard.gallagher@ropesgray.com

Craig Solomon Ganz 

ganzc@ballardspahr.com, 

hartt@ballardspahr.com

Oscar Garza ogarza@gibsondunn.com

Paul R. Gaus 

paul.gaus@mccormickbarstow.com

Duane M. Geck dmg@severson.com

Evelina Gentry 

evelina.gentry@akerman.com, 

rob.diwa@akerman.com

Janet D. Gertz jgertz@btlaw.com, 

amattingly@btlaw.com

Barry S. Glaser bglaser@swesq.com

Paul R. Glassman glassmanp@gtlaw.com

Gabriel I. Glazer gglazer@pszjlaw.com

Gabrielle Glemann 

gabrielle.glemann@stoel.com, 

rene.alvin@stoel.com

Matthew A. Gold courts@argopartners.net

Eric D. Goldberg 

eric.goldberg@dlapiper.com, eric-goldberg1103@ecf.pacerpro.com

Amy L. Goldman goldman@lbbslaw.com

Eric S. Goldstein egoldstein@goodwin.com

Rhonda Stewart Goldstein 

Rhonda.Goldstein@ucop.edu, 

Lissa.Ly@ucop.edu

Richard H. Golubow 

rgolubow@wcghlaw.com, 

jmartinez@WCGHLaw.com

Michael J. Gomez mgomez@frandzel.com, 

dmoore@frandzel.com

Michael W. Goodin mgoodin@clausen.com, 

mgenova@clausen.com

Eric R. Goodman 

egoodman@bakerlaw.com

Mark A. Gorton mgorton@boutinjones.com, 

cdomingo@boutininc.com

Mark A. Gorton mgorton@boutininc.com, 

cdomingo@boutininc.com

Michael I. Gottfried mgottfried@lgbfirm.com, 

srichmond@lgbfirm.com

Louis Gottlieb Lgottlieb@labaton.com, 

mpenrhyn@labaton.com

Eric A. Grasberger 

eric.grasberger@stoel.com, 

docketclerk@stoel.com

Debra I. Grassgreen 

dgrassgreen@pszjlaw.com, 

hphan@pszjlaw.com

Eric A. Gravink eric@rhrc.net

Elizabeth A. Green egreen@bakerlaw.com, 

orlbankruptcy@bakerlaw.com

Stuart G. Gross sgross@grosskleinlaw.com, 

iatkinsonyoung@grosskleinlaw.com

Elizabeth M. Guffy eguffy@lockelord.com, 

autodocket@lockelord.com

Cameron Gulden 

cameron.m.gulden@usdoj.gov

Laurie Hager lhager@sussmanshank.com

Oren Buchanan Haker 

oren.haker@stoel.com, rene.alvin@stoel.com

Kristopher M. Hansen 

dmohamed@stroock.com,

mmagzamen@stroock.com

Robert G. Harris rob@bindermalter.com

Christopher H. Hart chart@nutihart.com, 

nwhite@nutihart.com

Bryan L. Hawkins 

bryan.hawkins@stoel.com, 

Sharon.witkin@stoel.com

Christopher V. Hawkins 

hawkins@sullivanhill.com, 

Hawkins@ecf.inforuptcy.com

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 7 of

13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

5

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

Jan M Hayden 

jhayden@bakerdonelson.com, 

gmitchell@bakerdonelson.com

Jennifer C. Hayes jhayes@fhlawllp.com

Alaina R. Heine alaina.heine@dechert.com, 

brett.stone@dechert.com

Cristina A. Henriquez 

chenriquez@mayerbrown.com

Stephen E. Hessler, P.C. , 

jozette.chong@kirkland.com

Sean T. Higgins 

aandrews@andrewsthornton.com, 

shiggins@andrewsthornton.com

James P. Hill hill@sullivanhill.com, 

bkstaff@sullivanhill.com

Michael R. Hogue hoguem@gtlaw.com, 

frazierl@gtlaw.com

David Holtzman 

david.holtzman@hklaw.com

Alexandra S. Horwitz 

allie.horwitz@dinsmore.com

Marsha Houston 

mhouston@reedsmith.com, 

hvalencia@reedsmith.com

Shane Huang shane.huang@usdoj.gov

Brian D. Huben hubenb@ballardspahr.com

Jonathan Hughes , 

jane.rustice@aporter.com

Michael A. Isaacs 

Michael.Isaacs@dentons.com, 

Alissa.Worthing@dentons.com

Mark V. Isola mvi@sbj-law.com

J. Eric Ivester Eric.Ivester@skadden.com, 

Andrea.Bates@skadden.com

J. Eric Ivester , 

Andrea.Bates@skadden.com

Ivan C. Jen ivan@icjenlaw.com

Monique Jewett-Brewster 

mjb@hopkinscarley.com, 

eamaro@hopkinscarley.com

James O. Johnston 

jjohnston@jonesday.com

Chris Johnstone 

chris.johnstone@wilmerhale.com, 

whdocketing@wilmerhale.com

Andrew Jones andrew@ajoneslaw.com

Gregory K. Jones GJones@dykema.com, 

cacossano@dykema.com

Robert A. Julian rjulian@bakerlaw.com

George H. Kalikman 

gkalikman@schnader.com, 

sdavenport@schnader.com

Roberto J. Kampfner 

rkampfner@whitecase.com, 

mco@whitecase.com

Gary M. Kaplan gkaplan@fbm.com, 

calendar@fbm.com

Robert B. Kaplan rbk@jmbm.com

Eve H. Karasik ehk@lnbyb.com

Elyssa S. Kates ekates@bakerlaw.com

Ori Katz okatz@sheppardmullin.com, 

LSegura@sheppardmullin.com

William M. Kaufman wkaufman@smwb.com

Jane G. Kearl jkearl@watttieder.com, 

jbenton@watttieder.com

Tobias S. Keller 

tkeller@kellerbenvenutti.com, 

pbenvenutti@kellerbenvenutti.com

Lynette C. Kelly lynette.c.kelly@usdoj.gov, 

ustpregion17.oa.ecf@usdoj.gov

Gerald P. Kennedy 

gerald.kennedy@procopio.com, 

angela.stevens@procopio.com

Erica L. Kerman ekerman@willkie.com

Samuel A. Khalil skhalil@milbank.com, 

jbrewster@milbank.com

Samuel M. Kidder skidder@ktbslaw.com

Marc Kieselstein , 

carrie.oppenheim@kirkland.com

Jane Kim jkim@kellerbenvenutti.com

Kody D. L. Kleber kkleber@bakerlaw.com, 

dmartinez@bakerlaw.com

Bradley C. Knapp bknapp@lockelord.com, 

Yamille.Harrison@lockelord.com

Thomas F. Koegel tkoegel@crowell.com

Andy S. Kong kong.andy@arentfox.com, 

Yvonne.Li@arentfox.com

Alan W. Kornberg , 

akornberg@paulweiss.com

Bernard Kornberg bjk@severson.com

David I. Kornbluh dik@millermorton.com, 

mhr@millermorton.com

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 8 of

13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

6

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

Lauren Kramer lkramer@rjo.com, 

mriney@rjo.com

Jeffrey C. Krause 

jkrause@gibsondunn.com, 

psantos@gibsondunn.com

Thomas R. Kreller tkreller@milbank.com

Lindsey E. Kress lkress@lockelord.com, 

autodocket@lockelord.com

Hannah C. Kreuser 

hkreuser@porterlaw.com, 

ooberg@porterlaw.com

Michael Thomas Krueger 

michael.krueger@ndlf.com, 

Havilyn.lee@ndlf.com

Robert T. Kugler robert.kugler@stinson.com

Boris Kukso boris.kukso@usdoj.gov, 

western.taxcivil@usdoj.gov

Alisa C. Lacey alisa.lacey@stinson.com, 

karen.graves@stinson.com

Timothy S. Laffredi 

timothy.s.laffredi@usdoj.gov, 

patti.vargas@usdoj.gov

Richard A. Lapping 

rich@trodellalapping.com

Omeed Latifi olatifi@theadlerfirm.com, 

kdeubler@theadlerfirm.com

Michael Lauter 

mlauter@sheppardmullin.com

Kenneth T. Law klaw@bbslaw.com

Francis J. Lawall lawallf@pepperlaw.com, 

henrys@pepperlaw.com

Andrew Michael Leblanc 

ALeblanc@milbank.com

Scott Lee scott.lee@lewisbrisbois.com, 

monique.talamante@lewisbrisbois.com

Edward J. Leen eleen@mkbllp.com

Matthew A. Lesnick 

matt@lesnickprince.com, 

jmack@lesnickprince.com

Bryn G. Letsch bletsch@braytonlaw.com

David B. Levant david.levant@stoel.com, 

rene.alvin@stoel.com

Andrew H. Levin alevin@wcghlaw.com

David Levine dnl@groom.com

Marc A. Levinson Malevinson@orrick.com, 

casestream@ecf.courtdrive.com

Dara Levinson Silveira 

dsilveira@kellerbenvenutti.com

Alexander James Demitro Lewicki 

kdiemer@diemerwei.com, 

alewicki@diemerwei.com

William S. Lisa , 

jcaruso@nixonpeabody.com

William S. Lisa wlisa@nixonpeabody.com, 

jcaruso@nixonpeabody.com

Jonathan A. Loeb jon.loeb@bingham.com

John William Lucas jlucas@pszjlaw.com, 

ocarpio@pszjlaw.com

Jane Luciano jane-luciano@comcast.net

Kerri Lyman klyman@irell.com, 

lgauthier@irell.com

John H. MacConaghy 

macclaw@macbarlaw.com, 

smansour@macbarlaw.com;kmuller@macbarl

aw.com

Iain A. Macdonald iain@macfern.com, 

ecf@macfern.com

Tracy L. Mainguy 

tmainguy@unioncounsel.net, 

bankruptcycourtnotices@unioncounsel.net

Samuel R. Maizel 

samuel.maizel@dentons.com, 

alicia.aguilar@dentons.com

Adam Malatesta adam.malatesta@lw.com, 

adam--malatesta-8393@ecf.pacerpro.com

Katharine Malone malonek@gtlaw.com, 

knightj@gtlaw.com

Liam K. Malone malone@oles.com, 

shahin@oles.com

Michael W. Malter 

michael@bindermalter.com

Craig Margulies cmargulies@margulieslaw.com, lsalazar@margulies-law.com

Geoffrey E. Marr gemarr59@hotmail.com

Richard A. Marshack 

rmarshack@marshackhays.com, 

lbuchanan@marshackhays.com

Catherine Martin cmartin@simon.com, 

rtucker@simon.com;bankruptcy@simon.com

Laila Masud lmasud@marshackhays.com, 

8649808420@filings.docketbird.com

David P. Matthews 

jrhoades@thematthewslawfirm.com, 

aharrison@thematthewslawfirm.com

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 9 of

13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

7

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

Patrick C. Maxcy 

patrick.maxcy@snrdenton.com

Benjamin P. McCallen 

bmccallen@willkie.com

Thomas E. McCurnin 

tmccurnin@bkolaw.com, 

kescano@bkolaw.com

Hugh M. McDonald 

hugh.mcdonald@troutman.com, 

john.murphy@troutman.com

Hugh M. McDonald , 

john.murphy@troutman.com

C. Luckey McDowell 

Luckey.McDowell@Shearman.com

Scott H. McNutt SMcNutt@ml-sf.com, 

csnell@ml-sf.com

Thomas Melone 

Thomas.Melone@gmail.com, 

Thomas.Melone@AllcoUS.com

Peter Meringolo peter@pmrklaw.com

Frank A. Merola lacalendar@stroock.com, 

mmagzamen@stroock.com

Joshua M. Mester jmester@jonesday.com

Matthew D. Metzger 

belvederelegalecf@gmail.com

Randy Michelson 

randy.michelson@michelsonlawgroup.com

Joseph G. Minias jminias@willkie.com

M. David Minnick 

dminnick@pillsburylaw.com, 

docket@pillsburylaw.com

Nancy Mitchell nmitchell@omm.com

Thomas C. Mitchell tcmitchell@orrick.com, 

Dcmanagingattorneysoffice@ecf.courtdrive.co

m

John A. Moe john.moe@dentons.com, 

glenda.spratt@dentons.com

Aaron J. Mohamed ajm@brereton.law, 

aaronmohamedlaw@gmail.com

Kevin Montee 

kmontee@monteeassociates.com

David W. Moon lacalendar@stroock.com, 

mmagzamen@stroock.com

Diane Marger Moore 

dmargermoore@baumhedlundlaw.com

Erika L. Morabito emorabito@foley.com, 

hsiagiandraughn@foley.com

Candace J. Morey cjm@cpuc.ca.gov

Courtney L. Morgan 

morgan.courtney@pbgc.gov

Joshua D. Morse 

Joshua.Morse@dlapiper.com, joshua-morse0092@ecf.pacerpro.com

Thomas G. Mouzes 

tmouzes@boutinjones.com, 

cdomingo@boutininc.com

Peter S. Munoz pmunoz@reedsmith.com, 

gsandoval@reedsmith.com

Michael S. Myers 

myersms@ballardspahr.com, 

hartt@ballardspahr.com

Alan I. Nahmias 

anahmias@mbnlawyers.com, 

jdale@mbnlawyers.com

David L. Neale dln@lnbrb.com

David L. Neale dln@lnbyb.com

David Neier dneier@winston.com

Brittany J. Nelson bnelson@foley.com, 

hsiagiandraughn@foley.com

Howard S. Nevins hnevins@hsmlaw.com, 

lsamosa@hsmlaw.com

Melissa T. Ngo ngo.melissa@pbgc.gov, 

efile@pbgc.gov

Mario R. Nicholas 

mario.nicholas@stoel.com, 

cherie.clark@stoel.com

Gregory C. Nuti gnuti@nutihart.com, 

nwhite@nutihart.com

Abigail O'Brient aobrient@mintz.com, 

docketing@mintz.com

Julie E. Oelsner joelsner@weintraub.com, 

bjennings@weintraub.com

Office of the U.S. Trustee / SF 

USTPRegion17.SF.ECF@usdoj.gov

Matthew Jon Olson matt@macfern.com, 

ecf@macfern.com

Steven M. Olson smo@smolsonlaw.com

Aram Ordubegian 

Ordubegian.Aram@ArentFox.com

Gabriel Ozel , gabeozel@gmail.com

Gabriel Ozel gozel@nuvasive.com, 

gabeozel@gmail.com

Margarita Padilla 

Margarita.Padilla@doj.ca.gov

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 10

of 13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

8

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

Amy S. Park amy.park@skadden.com, 

alissa.turnipseed@skadden.com

Donna Taylor Parkinson 

donna@parkinsonphinney.com

Peter S. Partee , candonian@huntonak.com

Paul J. Pascuzzi ppascuzzi@ffwplaw.com,

kwidder@ffwplaw.com

Kenneth Pasquale , 

mlaskowski@stroock.com

Jennifer Pastarnack 

jennifer.pastarnack@cliffordchance.com, 

damien.morris@cliffordchance.com

Charles Scott Penner 

penner@carneylaw.com, 

caragol@carneylaw.com

Valerie Bantner Peo 

vbantnerpeo@buchalter.com

Danielle A. Pham danielle.pham@usdoj.gov

Thomas R. Phinney 

tom@parkinsonphinney.com

R. Alexander Pilmer 

alexander.pilmer@kirkland.com, 

keith.catuara@kirkland.com

M. Ryan Pinkston rpinkston@seyfarth.com, 

jmcdermott@seyfarth.com

Estela O. Pino epino@epinolaw.com, 

rmahal@epinolaw.com

Gregory Plaskett 

GREGORY.PLASKETT@GMAIL.COM, 

HKHAPPYGRL1@GMAIL.COM

Mark D. Plevin mplevin@crowell.com

Steven G. Polard spolard@eisnerlaw.com

Mark D. Poniatowski ponlaw@ponlaw.com

William L. Porter bporter@porterlaw.com, 

Ooberg@porterlaw.com

Christopher E. Prince 

cprince@lesnickprince.com

Douglas B. Provencher dbp@provlaw.com

Stacey C. Quan squan@steyerlaw.com, 

pspencer@steyerlaw.com

Amy C. Quartarolo amy.quartarolo@lw.com

Lary Alan Rappaport 

lrappaport@proskauer.com, 

PHays@proskauer.com

Justin E. Rawlins jrawlins@winston.com, 

justin-rawlins-0284@ecf.pacerpro.com

Hugh M. Ray hugh.ray@pillsburylaw.com, 

nancy.jones@pillsburylaw.com

Paul F. Ready 

smeyer@farmerandready.com

Caroline A. Reckler 

caroline.reckler@lw.com

David M. Reeder david@reederlaw.com, 

david.m.reeder@gmail.com;Jessica@reederla

w.com

Steven J. Reisman sreisman@katten.com, 

nyc.bknotices@kattenlaw.com

Jeffrey M. Reisner jreisner@irell.com

Jack A. Reitman , srichmond@lgbfirm.com

Emily P. Rich erich@unioncounsel.net, 

bankruptcycourtnotices@unioncounsel.net

Christopher O. Rivas 

crivas@reedsmith.com, chris-rivas8658@ecf.pacerpro.com

David B. Rivkin drivkin@bakerlaw.com, 

jmeeks@bakerlaw.com

Daniel Robertson 

robertson.daniel@pbgc.gov, efile@pbgc.gov

Lacey E. Rochester 

lrochester@bakerdonelson.com, 

gmitchell@bakerdonelson.com

Michael Rogers 

mrogers@lambertrogers.com, 

jan@lambertrogers.com

Julie H. Rome-Banks 

julie@bindermalter.com

Jorian L. Rose jrose@bakerlaw.com

Paul M. Rosenblatt 

prosenblatt@kilpatricktownsend.com, 

mwilliams@kilpatricktownsend.com

Allan Robert Rosin arrosin@alr-law.com

Jay M. Ross jross@hopkinscarley.com,

eamaro@hopkinscarley.com

Gregory A. Rougeau 

grougeau@brlawsf.com

Stacy H. Rubin rubins@ballardspahr.com, 

BKTDocket_West@ballardspahr.com

Nathan Q. Rugg nathan.rugg@bfkn.com, 

jean.montgomery@bfkn.com

Thomas B. Rupp 

trupp@kellerbenvenutti.com

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 11

of 13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

9

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

Eric E. Sagerman 

esagerman@bakerlaw.com, 

pgedocket@bakerlaw.com

Robert Sahyan 

rsahyan@sheppardmullin.com, 

JNakaso@sheppardmullin.com

Jonathan C. Sanders jsanders@stblaw.com

Nanette D. Sanders 

nanette@ringstadlaw.com, 

becky@ringstadlaw.com

Lovee Sarenas 

Lovee.sarenas@lewisbrisbois.com

Sunny S. Sarkis sunny.sarkis@stoel.com, 

dawn.forgeur@stoel.com

Patricia Savage psavesq@gmail.com, 

jodi.savage@gmail.com

Sblend A. Sblendorio sas@hogefenton.com

Francis O. Scarpulla fos@scarpullalaw.com, 

cpc@scarpullalaw.com

Daren M Schlecter 

daren@schlecterlaw.com, 

info@schlecterlaw.com

Bradley R. Schneider 

bradley.schneider@mto.com

Harvey S. Schochet 

Harveyschochet@dwt.com

Lisa Schweitzer lschweitzer@cgsh.com

Eric J. Seiler eseiler@fklaw.com, 

mclerk@fklaw.com

David B. Shemano dshemano@pwkllp.com

Leonard M. Shulman lshulman@shbllp.com

Andrew I. Silfen 

andrew.silfen@arentfox.com

Wayne A. Silver w_silver@sbcglobal.net, 

ws@waynesilverlaw.com

Craig S. Simon csimon@bergerkahn.com, 

aketcher@bergerkahn.com

Gerald Singleton gerald@slffirm.com, 

BKECFCANB@SLFfirm.com

Michael K. Slattery mslattery@lkfirm.com, 

rramirez@lkfirm.com

Dania Slim dania.slim@pillsburylaw.com, 

melinda.hernandez@pillsburylaw.com

Jennifer N. Slocum 

jennifer.slocum@stoel.com, 

docketclerk@stoel.com

Aaron C. Smith asmith@lockelord.com, 

autodocket@lockelord.com

Alan D. Smith adsmith@perkinscoie.com, 

al-smith-9439@ecf.pacerpro.com

Jan D. Sokol jdsokol@lawssl.com, 

dwright@lawssl.com

Randye B. Soref rsoref@polsinelli.com

Bennett L. Spiegel blspiegel@jonesday.com

Michael St. James ecf@stjames-law.com

Howard J. Steinberg 

steinbergh@gtlaw.com, pearsallt@gtlaw.com

Harriet A. Steiner 

harriet.steiner@bbklaw.com, 

claudia.peach@bbklaw.com

Lillian G. Stenfeldt 

lillian.stenfeldt@rimonlaw.com, 

jon.arneson@sedgwicklaw.com

Lillian G. Stenfeldt 

lillian.stenfeldt@sdma.com, 

jon.arneson@sedgwicklaw.com

Cheryl L. Stengel clstengel@outlook.com, 

stengelcheryl40@gmail.com

David M. Stern dstern@ktbslaw.com

Alan J. Stone AStone@milbank.com, 

DMcCracken@Milbank.com

Rebecca Suarez rsuarez@crowell.com

Brad T. Summers 

summerst@lanepowell.com, docketingpdx@lanepowell.com

Kristine Theodesia Takvoryan 

ktakvoryan@ckrlaw.com

Kesha Tanabe kesha@tanabelaw.com

Elizabeth Lee Thompson 

ethompson@stites.com, 

docketclerk@stites.com

John C. Thornton 

jct@andrewsthornton.com, 

aandrews@andrewsthornton.com

Meagan S. Tom 

Meagan.tom@lockelord.com, 

autodocket@lockelord.com

Edward J. Tredinnick 

etredinnick@greeneradovsky.com

Matthew Jordan Troy 

matthew.troy@usdoj.gov

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 12

of 13
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DOCS_SF:101190.1 08442/030 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

10

PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL 

& JONES LLP

AT TO R NE YS AT LAW

SAN F RA N CI S CO , CAL I F O R NI A

Andrew Van Ornum 

avanornum@vlmglaw.com, 

hchea@vlmglaw.com

Shmuel Vasser 

shmuel.vasser@dechert.com, 

brett.stone@dechert.com

Victor A. Vilaplana vavilaplana@foley.com, 

rhurst@foley.com

Marta Villacorta marta.villacorta@usdoj.gov

John A. Vos 

InvalidEMailECFonly@gmail.com, 

PrivateECFNotice@gmail.com

Jonathan D. Waisnor jwaisnor@willkie.com, 

mao@willkie.com

Riley C. Walter ecf@W2LG.com

Phillip K. Wang phillip.wang@rimonlaw.com

Philip S. Warden 

philip.warden@pillsburylaw.com, 

kathy.stout@pillsburylaw.com

Lindsi M. Weber lweber@polsinelli.com, 

yderac@polsinelli.com

Genevieve G. Weiner 

gweiner@gibsondunn.com

Rebecca Weissman 

rebecca.weissman@dechert.com

Joseph M. Welch jwelch@buchalter.com, 

dcyrankowski@buchalter.com

David Walter Wessel 

DWessel@efronlawfirm.com, 

hporter@chdlawyers.com

Joseph West westjoseph@earthlink.net, 

josephw998@gmail.com

Drew M. Widders 

dwidders@wilcoxenlaw.com, 

nina@wilcoxenlaw.com

Eric R. Wilson 

kdwbankruptcydepartment@kelleydrye.com, 

ewilson@kelleydrye.com

Kimberly S. Winick kwinick@clarktrev.com, 

knielsen@clarktrev.com

Rebecca J. Winthrop 

rebecca.winthrop@nortonrosefulbright.com, 

evette.rodriguez@nortonrosefulbright.com

David Wirt david.wirt@hklaw.com, 

denise.harmon@hklaw.com

Ryan A. Witthans rwitthans@fhlawllp.com, 

rwitthans@fhlawllp.com

Risa Lynn Wolf-Smith 

rwolf@hollandhart.com, 

lmlopezvelasquez@hollandhart.com

Douglas Wolfe dwolfe@asmcapital.com

Catherine E. Woltering 

cwoltering@bakerlaw.com

Andrea Wong wong.andrea@pbgc.gov, 

efile@pbgc.gov

Christopher Kwan Shek Wong 

christopher.wong@arentfox.com

Kirsten A. Worley kw@wlawcorp.com, 

admin@wlawcorp.com

Antonio Yanez ayanez@willkie.com

Cathy Yanni cathy@cathyyanni.com, 

pstrunk@browngreer.com

Andrew Yaphe 

andrew.yaphe@davispolk.com, 

pge.dpw.routing@davispolk.com

Tacie H. Yoon tyoon@crowell.com

Bennett G. Young byoung@jmbm.com, 

jb8@jmbm.com

Paul H. Zumbro mao@cravath.com

Brittany Zummer 

bzummer@theadlerfirm.com, 

nfournier@theadlerfirm.com

Dario de Ghetaldi deg@coreylaw.com, 

lf@coreylaw.com

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 3972 Filed: 09/23/19 Entered: 09/23/19 14:00:23 Page 13

of 13