1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Exhibit D 

FEE SUMMARY DETAIL 

Task: Case Administration (CA) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/9/2019 Kovoor, 

Thomas G. 

Manage access to case resources 

per communications w/ R. 

Artale (0.5). 

0.50 210.00 

TOTAL 0.50 $210.00 

Task: Corporate Governance and Board Matters (CG) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

7/1/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Review and revise charts on 

compensation terms for 

presentation to Board and 

Compensation Committee (0.5). 

0.50 767.50 

7/2/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Emails w/ Company re: Board 

compensation deferral terms 

and practices (0.2) and w/ Weil 

re: same (0.1). 

0.30 460.50 

7/5/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Emails w/ Compensation 

Committee members re: 

compensation deferral terms 

and practices and potential 

modifications (0.3). 

0.30 460.50 

7/5/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Emails w/ Compensation 

Committee members re: 

compensation deferral terms 

and practices and potential 

modifications (0.3). 

0.30 460.50 

7/9/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Emails w/ Compensation 

Committee members re: 

compensation deferral terms 

and practices and potential 

modifications (0.6) and 

research/analysis re: same (0.9). 

1.50 2,302.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 1

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

7/10/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

T/c w/ Compensation 

Committee members re: 

compensation deferral terms 

and practices and potential 

modifications (1.5). 

1.50 2,302.50 

7/11/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Review materials prepared by 

outside consultant re: 

compensation practices (0.5). 

0.50 767.50 

7/18/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Emails w/ Compensation 

Committee member re: 

executive compensation matters 

(0.3). 

0.30 460.50 

7/18/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Review UCC responses and 

requests re: compensation 

matters (0.4) and prepare 

responses/commentary for 

Compensation Committee to 

consider (0.8). 

1.20 1,842.00 

7/18/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Call w/ Compensation 

Committee member re: 

executive compensation 

approval process in bankruptcy 

(0.5). 

0.50 767.50 

7/19/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Call w/ Compensation 

Committee members re: 

compensation approval motion 

and objections (1.5). 

1.50 2,302.50 

7/24/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Emails w/ Compensation 

Committee members re: 

compensation matters (0.7). 

0.70 1,074.50 

7/25/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Analysis and preparation for 

call w/ Compensation 

Committee advisors and 

Company HR re: compensation 

matters (0.5). 

0.50 767.50 

7/26/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Participate via telephone in 

informal Compensation 

Committee meeting re: 

compensation matters (0.5). 

0.50 767.50 

7/29/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Review and revise Board 

materials related to 

compensation (0.9), and related 

1.50 2,302.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 2

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

emails w/ Company HR team 

and outside advisors (0.6). 

7/30/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

Review and revise Board 

materials related to 

compensation (0.3), and related 

emails w/ Company HR team 

and outside advisors (0.2). 

0.50 767.50 

7/31/2019 Grogan, Gregory 

T. 

T/c w/ Company counsel re: 

draft compensation materials 

(1.1). 

1.10 1,688.50 

8/1/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Prepare correspondence (0.3); 

review Board material (0.4); 

conference w/ team re: 

workstreams (0.3). 

1.00 1,480.00 

8/1/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Company and Company 

counsel re: matter (0.7); email 

to Company re: same (0.3); 

review new Board materials 

(0.9); review status report from 

Company (1.0); review CPUC 

protocol (1.1). 

4.00 6,560.00 

8/1/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Call w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

document collection (0.4); draft 

summary of request per N. 

Goldin (0.5); email clients re: 

document collection (0.7); 

email w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

same (0.2); review of 

documents and emails in 

preparation for call w/ Cravath 

re: documents (0.4). 

2.20 1,848.00 

8/1/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Restructuring Committee 

Meeting w/ Lazard. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/1/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails re Restructuring 

Committee and Governance 

(1.0); meetings re Restructuring 

Committee and Governance 

(2.0); teleconfs re Restructuring 

Committee and Governance 

(2.0). 

5.00 8,200.00 

8/1/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Research re public disclosure 

obligations. 

1.30 1,092.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 3

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/1/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Attend meeting at WFG (2.5), 

draft emails to Restructuring 

Committee re same (0.5); attend 

Lazard call re model (1.5). 

4.50 6,907.50 

8/2/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (1.0). 

1.00 455.00 

8/2/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Call w/ M. Ponce et al re: 

CPUC protocol (0.6); attend 

Board meeting call (1.5); attend 

Board restructuring calls (1.4). 

3.50 5,740.00 

8/2/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Revise talking points re: 

Directors (0.5); emails w/ R. 

Sussman and K. Kinsel re: same 

(0.3); email to N. Goldin re: 

same (0.1). 

0.90 985.50 

8/2/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Restructuring Committee 

Meetings. 

3.00 4,920.00 

8/2/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Prep for (0.5) and attend 

internal pre-call meeting in 

advance of Board and 

Restructuring Committee 

meeting (1.0). 

1.50 1,372.50 

8/2/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Board call. 2.00 1,830.00 

8/2/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Prepare draft summary re: dual 

board structure. 

2.20 2,013.00 

8/2/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.5) and meeting with 

M. Ponce, S. Qusba, N. Goldin, 

M. Torkin, P. Curnin, R. 

Purushotham and J. Levine in 

prep for 8/2 Board and 

Restructuring Committee 

meeting (1.0). 

1.50 1,260.00 

8/2/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (1.0) and attend PGE 

Board and Restructuring 

Committee Meeting (2.0). 

3.00 2,520.00 

8/2/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Research re and prep summary 

of fiduciary duties of board 

members. 

1.20 1,008.00 

8/3/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Company re: status 

updated (0.8); review CPUC 

protocol (0.5). 

1.30 2,132.00 

8/4/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review Board material (0.3). 0.30 444.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 4

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/4/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Restructuring Call (1.1); follow 

up call with STB team (0.3); 

correspondence w S. Qusba and 

Restructuring Committee (0.4). 

1.80 2,763.00 

8/5/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review work product re: 

meeting w/ directors (0.3); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.2). 

0.50 740.00 

8/5/2019 Calderon, Justin Review and revised outline re: 

subrogation claimant's claims 

and PG&E's defenses (5.0), 

incl. research on caselaw re: 

same (4.8). 

9.80 6,860.00 

8/5/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Analysis re: Director duties 

(1.2); emails w/ R. Sussman, K. 

Kinsel re: same (0.4); emails w/ 

P. Curnin and N. Goldin re: 

same (0.2). 

1.80 1,971.00 

8/5/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c's w/ company and clients re: 

CPUC protocol (1.4); t/c w/ 

Company re: regulatory 

developments (0.7); review 

Board materials (0.7). 

2.80 4,592.00 

8/5/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Legal research re: Director 

duties (2.8); draft summary re: 

same (0.4); calls w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley and K. Kinsel re: same 

(0.4); correspondence w/ STB 

team re: director meeting 

coordination (0.8); review 

discovery response request 

(0.2). 

4.60 3,864.00 

8/5/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Revisions to governance memo 

for N. Brownell. 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/5/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Preparation for Board meeting 

and revisions to Board 

materialsduring travel to SF for 

meeting. 

4.00 6,560.00 

8/5/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Call with BlueMountain (0.3), 

review and revise materials for 

N. Brownell (1.7). 

2.00 2,650.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 5

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/5/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Coordinate distribution of 

Restructuring Committee 

materials. 

0.30 274.50 

8/5/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Prepare draft issues list. 1.70 1,555.50 

8/5/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Revise dual board structure 

summary. 

0.40 366.00 

8/5/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Further research re and prep of 

summary re Board fiduciary 

duties. 

2.30 1,932.00 

8/6/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ team re: 

workstreams (0.2); review 

Board materials (0.3). 

0.50 740.00 

8/6/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Board call (1.0); review MTO 

slides (0.4); t/cs w/ Company 

re: status (1.6); Board follow up 

calls w/ directors (2.7). 

5.70 9,348.00 

8/6/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review draft Board documents 

(0.5); email to N. Goldin re: 

same (0.1). 

0.60 657.00 

8/6/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Legal research re: expert study 

(1.1); correspondence w/ STB 

team re: same (0.4); review R. 

Sparks Bradley comments to 

interview outline (0.6); 

correspondence w/ K. Kinsel re: 

same (0.3). 

2.40 2,016.00 

8/6/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Board meeting. 2.50 4,100.00 

8/6/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Meeting with B. Johnson, J. 

Simon, J. Loduca pre Board 

Meeting. 

0.50 820.00 

8/6/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Meeting with N. Brownell and 

J. Bleich re various governance 

issues. 

1.00 1,640.00 

8/6/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review various Board issues 

during flight from SF to NY. 

3.00 4,920.00 

8/6/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Revisions to materials for N. 

Brownell (0.9), PGE Board call 

(2.5) 

3.40 4,505.00 

8/6/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend PGE board call. 2.50 2,287.50 

8/6/2019 Levine, Jeff P. T/c with S. Karotkin, S. Qusba, 

M. Torkin, R. Purushotham and 

E. Egenes re protocol. 

0.30 274.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 6

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/6/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Revise draft dual board 

structure summary. 

0.80 732.00 

8/6/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep discussion materials re 

fiduciary duties and board 

member duties/responsibilities. 

1.00 840.00 

8/6/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Attend board call. 2.50 2,100.00 

8/6/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Board call (2.5). 2.50 3,837.50 

8/7/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Attend Board call (1.2); review 

slides (0.8); o/c w/ M. Ponce, et 

al re: Board strategy (1.0). 

3.00 4,920.00 

8/7/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Confer w/ team re: workstreams 

(0.3) and bankruptcy issues 

(0.2). 

0.50 740.00 

8/7/2019 Phillips, Jacob 

M. 

Analysis of director 

compensation proposal (0.1); 

internal discussion re: same 

(0.1). 

0.20 168.00 

8/7/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Review MTO slides (0.4); draft 

interview outline (3.0); emails 

w/ K. Kinsel/R. Sparks Bradley 

re: same (0.2). 

3.60 3,024.00 

8/7/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board meeting. 1.50 2,460.00 

8/7/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Revisions to Governance Memo 

for N. Brownell (1.4); 

discussions with J. Bleich and 

N. Brownell and J. Loduca re 

same, various issues (0.8). 

2.20 3,608.00 

8/7/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Board compensation 

emails/issues. 

0.70 1,148.00 

8/7/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails/issues re BlueMountain 

Settlement Amendment. 

0.70 1,148.00 

8/7/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review of 13D filings (0.6); 

Board meeting (1.3); review 

and follow-up on settlement 

agreement extension (0.7) 

2.60 3,445.00 

8/7/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Revise draft summary of dual 

board structure. 

2.60 2,379.00 

8/7/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Coordinate collection and 

distribution of board materials. 

0.80 732.00 

8/7/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Board meeting. 1.50 1,372.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 7

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/7/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Prepare revised draft protocol 

markup (1.0); prepare cover 

email to Restructuring 

Committee re same (0.3). 

1.30 1,189.50 

8/7/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Review 13D filings. 0.80 732.00 

8/7/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Review settlement agreement 

amendment. 

0.40 366.00 

8/7/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for and attend PGE Board 

meeting. 

0.80 672.00 

8/7/2019 Egenes, Erica M. T/c with J. Loduca, S. Karotkin 

and STB team re earlier board 

meeting. 

0.50 420.00 

8/7/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review shareholder 13-D 

filings and proposal. 

1.30 1,092.00 

8/7/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Call w/ M. Ponce, S. Qusba, P. 

Curnin, R. Purushotham re 

board call discussion and prep. 

1.00 1,535.00 

8/8/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Restructuring Committee Call 

(1.0); review draft 10Q (0.8). 

1.80 2,952.00 

8/8/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Call w/ clients and R. Sparks 

Bradley re: document collection 

(0.2); follow up email w/ N. 

Goldin re: same (0.2); call w/ 

Cravath and client re: document 

collection (0.2); draft interview 

outline (4.1); review and revise 

same per comments from R. 

Sparks Bradley (0.9); email w/ 

N. Goldin re: same (0.1). 

5.70 4,788.00 

8/8/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Restructuring Committee call 

(1.3); materials and related 

issues (0.7). 

2.00 3,280.00 

8/8/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re CPUC Protocol and 

Board meetings. 

1.70 2,788.00 

8/8/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails and teleconfs re N. 

Brownell/J. Bleich meeting. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/8/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference call with J. Loduca 

and C. Campbell and D. Mielle 

re Board Meeting (0.5); prepare 

outline re same (0.3). 

0.80 1,312.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 8

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/8/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Restructuring Committee and 

Board meetings (1.8); update 

call w/ certain directors, J. 

Loduca and M. Ponce (0.3); 

review of board materials for 

Friday call (0.6). 

2.70 3,577.50 

8/8/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Restructuring 

Committee call re: term sheet. 

1.30 1,189.50 

8/8/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Debrief meeting re: 

Board/Restructuring Committee 

call. 

0.60 549.00 

8/8/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.9) and Restructuring 

Committee meeting followed 

by PGE Board meeting (1.8). 

2.70 2,268.00 

8/8/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for and Restructuring 

Committee meeting re 

shareholder proposal. 

1.40 1,176.00 

8/8/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Attend restructuring call and 

Board call (2.0); follow-up re: 

same w/ STB (0.5); review 

equity proposal (0.7); review 

Elliot proposal and papers (0.4). 

3.60 5,526.00 

8/9/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (0.5). 

0.50 227.50 

8/9/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Case file management (1.0). 1.00 455.00 

8/9/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Board meeting (0.2); prepare 

for interview (0.4). 

0.60 888.00 

8/9/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Board meeting. 1.50 2,460.00 

8/9/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review/issues re BlueMountain 

Settlement Amendment. 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/9/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails re proposed CPUC 

protocol (0.5); teleconfs, 

various issues re proposed 

CPUC Protocol (0.9). 

1.40 2,296.00 

8/9/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review of board materials 

(0.3); Board call (1.8); call w/ 

M. Ponce and S. Qusba (0.3); 

call w/ Cleary re extension of 

settlement agreement (0.3), 

review and comment on press 

release re Abrams and 

Knighthead (0.4). 

3.10 4,107.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 9

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/9/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Board call. 1.80 1,647.00 

8/9/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Debrief meeting following 

Board call. 

0.50 457.50 

8/9/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for and attend telephonic 

restructuring committee 

meeting. 

1.30 1,092.00 

8/9/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for and attend telephonic 

Board meeting. 

0.50 420.00 

8/9/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Attend afternoon telephonic 

Restructuring Committee 

meeting. 

1.30 1,092.00 

8/9/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Call with M. Ponce, S. Qusba 

and J. Levine re morning 

Restructuring and Board 

Committee meetings. 

0.50 420.00 

8/9/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Review equity commitment 

(0.5); call w/Qusba re: equity 

term sheet (0.5); attend Board 

call (1.8). 

2.80 4,298.00 

8/10/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Call w J. Levine re rights 

offering precedent (0.2); review 

of rights offering precedent 

(0.2); Restructuring Committee 

call (1.3). 

1.70 2,252.50 

8/10/2019 Levine, Jeff P. T/c with M. Ponce, S. Qusba, 

R. Purushotham, M. Torkin and 

certain Restructuring 

Committee members to discuss 

court hearing and next steps. 

1.30 1,189.50 

8/10/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Coordinate (0.2) and conduct 

research (2.2) re: rights 

offerings. 

2.40 2,196.00 

8/10/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Research re rights offering 

precedents. 

2.00 1,680.00 

8/10/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Status update call with S. 

Qusba, S. Karotkin, K. Ziman. 

0.70 588.00 

8/10/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.1) and t/c with M. 

Moore; K. Liang; S. Qusba; M. 

Ponce; P. Curnin; J. Levine; R. 

Purushotham; M.Torkin re 

8/9/19 bankruptcy hearing and 

next steps (1.3). 

1.40 1,176.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 10

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/11/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Email w/ STB team re: Board 

meeting (0.1). 

0.10 84.00 

8/11/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, calls with Board 

members, management and 

advisors (1.4) and review 

materials re same (1.0). 

2.40 3,936.00 

8/12/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Board call (1.1); calls w/ team 

re: developments (0.5); review 

Court order and Monitor 

material (1.0); prepare for 

meeting w/ Company executive 

(3.5) and meeting w/ Company 

executive (2.0). 

8.10 11,988.00 

8/12/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review Court order and 

Monitor letter to Court (0.6); 

emails w/ Company team re: 

same (0.5). 

1.10 1,804.00 

8/12/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Email w/ R. Duran re: interview 

(0.5); email w/ N. Goldin re: 

same (0.6); review document in 

preparation for same (0.9); 

email w/ J. Fell re: claims (0.1); 

email w/ R. Duran and R. 

Sparks Bradley re: interview 

memo (0.2). 

2.30 1,932.00 

8/12/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board meeting. 1.00 1,640.00 

8/12/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Restructuring 

Committee meeting. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/12/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Calls with Cravath, Jones Day 

and Lazard re NDA and Equity 

Backstop Commitments (1.3); 

documents, emails, various 

issues re same (1.0). 

2.30 3,772.00 

8/12/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Restructuring Committee 

meeting (1.2); Board meeting 

(1.0); call w R. Hall, D. Haaren, 

K. Ziman re shareholder 

proposal (0.4); review of 

shareholder proposal (1.1). 

3.70 4,902.50 

8/12/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Board call with M. 

Ponce, R. Purushotham, S. 

Qusba, M. Torkin and E. 

Egenes. 

1.00 915.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 11

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/12/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Restructuring 

Committee call with M. Ponce, 

R. Purushotham, S. Qusba, M. 

Torkin and E. Egenes. 

1.00 915.00 

8/12/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of materials in prep of 

Restructuring Committee and 

Board meetings. 

0.40 336.00 

8/12/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Attend telephonic Restructuring 

and Board Committee meetings.

2.50 2,100.00 

8/12/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Attend Restructuring 

Committee call (1.2); attend 

board call (1.1). 

2.30 3,530.50 

8/13/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Calls w/ Company re: Court 

order (1.5); review Monitor 

reports (1.0); call w/ MTO re: 

same (0.5). 

3.00 4,440.00 

8/13/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review Monitor's Report and 

exhibits (0.9); t/c w/ client re: 

same (0.8); t/c w/ MTO re: 

meeting (1.0). 

2.70 4,428.00 

8/13/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/cs w/ in-house counsel and 

company counsel re: Court 

response (1.4). 

1.40 2,296.00 

8/13/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Review and revise draft 

interview memo (1.8) and 

emails/calls w/ R. Duran re: 

same (0.4); email w/ N. Goldin 

re: CPP question (0.2); call w/ 

R. Sparks Bradley re: 

assignments (0.2); email w/ K. 

Kinsel re: interview outline 

(0.1); review Monitor report 

(1.4). 

4.10 3,444.00 

8/13/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference calls with Jones 

Day, Cravath, Weil and Lazard 

re Equityholders NDA and 

issues. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/13/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Equity Commitment 

Letter (1.0); comments, 

teleconfs re Equity 

Commitment Letter issues 

(0.7). 

1.70 2,788.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 12

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/13/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, issues, teleconfs re 

BlueMountain Settlement 

Agreement and developments 

regarding BlueMountain. 

0.90 1,476.00 

8/13/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Judge Alsop order 

(0.4); Emails, issues, teleconfs 

re Judge Alsop order(0.3). 

0.70 1,148.00 

8/13/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues with Board re Subro 

settlement discussions and 

Columbus Hill letter to Board. 

0.70 1,148.00 

8/13/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re Director 

Compensation issues. 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/13/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Calls re shareholder proposal 

and NDA w/ R. Hall, D. 

Haaren, K. Ziman and others 

(1.7); review of news articles re 

BlueMountain (0.4); review of 

letter to Board from Columbus 

Hill Capital Partners (0.2). 

2.30 3,047.50 

8/13/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Attention to board materials and 

recordkeeping. 

0.70 588.00 

8/13/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Attend call with Lazard 

regarding SH rights offering 

(0.6). 

0.60 921.00 

8/13/2019 Rovner, Grace Per E. Egenes, prep materials 

for Board. 

0.50 132.50 

8/14/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review Court order (0.2); 

review public communications 

re: same (0.6); communications 

w/ team re: same (0.3). 

1.10 1,628.00 

8/14/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Call w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

document collection (0.3); call 

w/ S. Reents re: same (0.2); call 

w/ client, Cravath, and PwC re: 

document collection (0.7) and 

prep for same (0.3); email w. N 

Goldin re: document collection 

(0.1); email w/ J. Fell re: proof 

of claim (0.1); call w/ document 

vendor re: collection (0.4); calls 

w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: same 

3.30 2,772.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 13

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

(0.5); email w/ N. Goldin re: 

director meeting (0.2); review 

of correspondence memos re: 

document collection (0.5). 

8/14/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Work on press issues (0.8). 0.80 1,312.00 

8/14/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re NDA with equity 

holders. 

1.70 2,788.00 

8/14/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs, emails with N. 

Brownell, G. Grogan and J. 

Bleich re Director 

compensation issues. 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/14/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re BlueMountain. 

0.70 1,148.00 

8/14/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Nominating and 

Governance Committee 

meeting minutes (0.5) emails, 

teleconfs re same (0.3). 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/14/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Monitor's report (0.5); 

emails, various issues from 

Directors re same (0.3). 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/14/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review of markup of NDA 

with Knighthead and Abrams 

and call w D. Haaren re same. 

0.80 1,060.00 

8/14/2019 Rovner, Grace Per E. Egenes, continue to 

prepare materials for Board. 

0.90 238.50 

8/15/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Company re: status 

(0.2); t/cs w/ clients re: status 

(0.7); emails w/ team re: press 

(0.4); review Monitor's exhibits 

(1.0). 

2.30 3,772.00 

8/15/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

File management of case 

materials (3.1). 

3.10 1,410.50 

8/15/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Correspondence w/ clients re: 

status (0.4); communications w/ 

team re: workstreams (0.8). 

1.20 1,776.00 

8/15/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Emails w/ Cravath and PwC re: 

search terms (0.3); call w/ R. 

Sparks Bradley re: search terms 

and email from client (0.3); 

review and respond to emails 

from client’s agent (0.3). 

0.90 756.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 14

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/15/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Restructuring Committee 

meeting (2.0); review materials, 

emails, issues re same (1.0). 

3.00 4,920.00 

8/15/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Meeting with AlixPartners and 

Restructuring Committee. 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/15/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re NDA and Equity 

Commitments. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/15/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, issues with F. Chang re 

best practices/Board minutes. 

0.60 984.00 

8/15/2019 Kelley, Karen H. Prep. e-mail to G. Grogan re: 

Form 8-K question. 

0.30 427.50 

8/15/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Call w Blue Heron re reports 

requested (0.3); Restructuring 

Committee meeting (2.0); 

review of markup of NDA from 

Jones Day (0.3). 

2.60 3,445.00 

8/15/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Restructuring 

Committee meeting. 

2.00 1,830.00 

8/15/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Attend portion of Restructuring 

Committee meeting. 

0.60 504.00 

8/15/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Attend advisors meeting with S. 

Qusba, members of 

management, Alix Partners, 

Weil, Lazard and Paul Weiss, 

Ducera (each, on behalf of the 

CPUC), and O’Melveny and 

Guggenheim (each, on behalf of 

the Governor). 

2.50 2,100.00 

8/15/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep communications to 

Restructuring Committee re 

8/15 meetings. 

0.60 504.00 

8/15/2019 Rovner, Grace Per E. Egenes, prepare 

materials for Board. 

2.40 636.00 

8/16/2019 Vallejo, Melissa 

A. 

Call w/ R. Sussman re: Board 

request (0.2). 

0.20 118.00 

8/16/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/cs w/ Company re: status 

(0.5); attend Board call (1.0); 

review draft Board documents 

(1.5). 

3.00 4,920.00 

8/16/2019 Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Communications w/ team re: 

Tubbs ruling (0.5). 

0.50 767.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 15

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/16/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ Company re: 

workstreams (0.5); 

communications w/ team re: 

same (0.6); call w/ client re: 

Board reports (0.5); 

correspondence w/ client re: 

same (0.2); Board call (1.8); 

review Board material (0.3); 

review confidentiality 

provisions (0.1). 

4.00 5,920.00 

8/16/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Email w/ PwC and STB 

paralegal re: client documents 

(0.5); review of committee 

wildfire briefing (2.0); 

emails/call w/ M. Vallejo, R. 

Sparks Bradley, and N. Goldin 

re: same (0.4); email w/ Cravath 

re: CDS (0.2); call w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley re: client documents 

(0.3); email w. document 

vendor re: same (0.4). 

3.80 3,192.00 

8/16/2019 Phillips, Jacob 

M. 

Research Company filings re: 

change in control provisions 

(0.7); correspondence w/ 

Company re: same (0.3). 

1.00 840.00 

8/16/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Telephonic Board Meeting 

(1.7); review related materials 

(0.3). 

2.00 3,280.00 

8/16/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs, emails with B. 

Johnson re governance issues. 

0.50 820.00 

8/16/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Prepare comments on Equity 

Commitment Letter (1.0); 

emails and teleconfs re Equity 

Commitment Letter (0.7). 

1.70 2,788.00 

8/16/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs, emails, issues re 

Board annotations to materials 

on BoardVantage. 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/16/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Telephonic Board meeting. 1.70 2,252.50 

8/16/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.5) and attend PG&E 

Board call (1.7). 

2.20 1,848.00 

8/17/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review outline of response to 

Court order (0.5); 

0.70 1,036.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 16

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

correspondence w/ team re: 

workstreams (0.2). 

8/17/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re Exclusivity ruling 

(0.9); emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re Equity Commitment 

Letter (0.8). 

1.70 2,788.00 

8/17/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of materials regarding 

proposed response to backstop 

proposal and related matters. 

0.40 336.00 

8/18/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Comment on Court response 

outline (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/18/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review outline re: Court 

response (0.6); communications 

w/ team re: same (0.5). 

1.10 1,628.00 

8/18/2019 Ponce, Mario A. T/c w/ STB team re: Board 

matters (0.7). 

0.70 1,148.00 

8/18/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Respond to numerous 

questions/issues posed by 

Directors. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/18/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Call w/ M. Ponce, S. Qusba, M. 

Torkin re Board matters. 

0.70 927.50 

8/19/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Conference call re: draft Board 

report w/ client (0.3); t/c w/ 

Company re: matter (0.3); t/c w/ 

Cravath re: status (0.3). 

0.90 1,476.00 

8/19/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Conference call w/ Company 

management re: response to 

Court (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

8/19/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Review litigation matters chart 

(0.4) and email w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley and J. Calderon re: 

same (0.1). 

0.50 420.00 

8/19/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Emails w/ STB team re: 

upcoming Board meetings 

(1.1); calls w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley re: same and related 

assignments (0.6); review of 

engagement letters and key 

documents/correspondence re: 

request from N. Goldin and M. 

Torkin (1.5). 

3.20 2,688.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 17

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/19/2019 Phillips, Jacob 

M. 

Research (0.3) and analysis of 

AB 1054 (0.2). 

0.50 420.00 

8/19/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Restructuring Committee 

telephonic meeting. 

1.70 2,788.00 

8/19/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs with 

Management and various 

Directors re Governance issues. 

1.30 2,132.00 

8/19/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review and comment on 

Nominating Committee 

minutes. 

0.70 1,148.00 

8/19/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, research, issues related 

to Director questions regarding 

SB 901, AB 235 and AB 1054. 

1.50 2,460.00 

8/19/2019 Rovner, Grace Per E. Egenes, continue to 

prepare materials for Board. 

0.50 132.50 

8/20/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Team meeting re: strategy (0.4); 

t/c w/ Company re: same (0.3); 

t/c w/ Restructuring Committee 

(1.5); t/conf client re: 

committee (0.3). 

2.50 4,100.00 

8/20/2019 Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Call w/ Board, Cravath re: 

Tubbs status, strategy (1.0). 

1.00 1,535.00 

8/20/2019 Calderon, Justin Revise litigation chart (0.9). 0.90 630.00 

8/20/2019 Phillips, Jacob 

M. 

Research (0.8) and analysis of 

AB 1054 (0.7); call w/ 

compensation committee re: 

same (1.0). 

2.50 2,100.00 

8/20/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Calls/emails w/ Kinsel re: 

outline for interview (0.6); 

emails/calls w/ N. Goldin and 

R. Sparks Bradley re: same 

(0.3); email w/ N. Goldin re: 

CDS database (0.3). 

1.20 1,008.00 

8/20/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Restructuring Committee 

telephonic meeting re Business 

Plan/Projections (1.8); review 

materials re same (0.2). 

2.00 3,280.00 

8/20/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Compensation Committee call 

re AB 1054 compliance (0.5); 

emails re same(0.3). 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/20/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various 

issues re preparation for 

meeting with Equity Holders. 

1.80 2,952.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 18

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/20/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review and comment on issues 

list re: backstop commitment 

(0.5); attend Restructuring 

Committee call on settlement 

(1.2); review of settlement term 

sheet (0.4); call w/ Blue Heron 

re reports requested by N. 

Brownell (0.3). 

2.40 3,180.00 

8/20/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.9) and attendance at 

joint finance and Restructuring 

Committee call (1.8). 

2.70 2,268.00 

8/20/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of potential settlement 

terms and related matters. 

0.60 504.00 

8/20/2019 Rovner, Grace Per E. Egenes, continue to 

prepare Board materials. 

0.10 26.50 

8/21/2019 Vallejo, Melissa 

A. 

Review Board documents (1.0). 1.00 590.00 

8/21/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Call w/ Company re: matter 

(0.3); call w/ Cravath re: same 

(0.3); review legislation update 

memo (0.3). 

0.90 1,476.00 

8/21/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review new bankruptcy orders 

(0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

8/21/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Call w/ N. Goldin, R. Sparks 

Bradley, and Cravath re: CDS 

database (0.3); follow up call w/ 

R. Sparks Bradley and N. 

Goldin re: same (0.2); 

correspondence w/ Cravath and 

Company re: review of 

documents (2.4); review and 

revise K. Kinsel interview 

outline (2.1); prepare key 

documents for N. Goldin re: 

same (0.6); draft summary 

outline for interview (0.2). 

5.80 4,872.00 

8/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review Subro Settlement term 

sheet (0.8); emails, teleconfs, 

issues re same (0.5). 

1.30 2,132.00 

8/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Attend meeting w/ Ad hoc 

Equity Group. 

2.50 4,100.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 19

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs, emails w/ N. 

Brownell re various 

Governance issues. 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs, emails, issues re 

Bankruptcy Court rulings. 

0.70 1,148.00 

8/21/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails with Board members re 

various Governance and Subro 

settlement issues. 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/21/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for and attend portion of 

t/c with members of 

management and Board, Alix 

Partners, Abrams, Knighthead, 

PJT, Jones Day, Lazard, 

Cravath, Weil and STB. 

1.60 1,344.00 

8/21/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of issues lists in prep of 

meeting with equityholders. 

0.70 588.00 

8/22/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Confer w/ team re: media 

strategy (0.5); review media 

statements (0.5); call w/ 

Company re: Board matters 

(0.5); call w/ team re: same 

(0.3). 

1.80 2,664.00 

8/22/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Company re: Boardvantage (0.3). 0.30 492.00 

8/22/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Finance Committee telephonic 

meeting and review related 

materials. 

1.50 2,460.00 

8/22/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference call with L. Cheng, 

B. Wong, N. Goldin re Board 

governance issues. 

0.50 820.00 

8/22/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review of Financing 

Committee meeting minutes. 

0.70 1,148.00 

8/22/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conference calls with N. 

Brownell, S. Qusba, Weil, 

Lazard re process and 

preparation for Board meeting. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/22/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Advisors meeting at Cravath re 

equity commitment letter (3.0); 

correspondence w N. Brownell 

re Blue Heron reports (0.3); 

coordination w/ Blue Heron re 

reports (0.4); t/c w/ STB re 

open issues and review of slides 

4.20 5,565.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 20

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

re responses to backstop 

proposal (0.5). 

8/23/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Board and Committee calls 

(3.5); call w/ team re: 

workstreams (0.3); review 

Monitor report (0.4); review 

estimated fees (0.2). 

4.40 6,512.00 

8/23/2019 Isaacman, 

Jennifer 

Meeting w/ Cravath re: 

documents and databases (3.2). 

3.20 1,888.00 

8/23/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review draft estimation 

documents from Company 

(0.2); revise same (0.2); t/c w/ 

N. Goldin re: same (0.1); email 

to Company re: same (0.1). 

0.60 657.00 

8/23/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Board call (1.0); CPP 

Committee call w/ Monitor 

(1.7); emails w/ team re: media 

strategy (0.3). 

3.00 4,920.00 

8/23/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Board telephonic meeting (1.3); 

Restructuring Committee 

telephonic meeting (1.6); 

review and revise equity 

commitment letter (1.6); emails, 

telecoms re various issues and 

review of materials (0.5). 

5.00 8,200.00 

8/23/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Restructuring Committee 

meeting (1.6); Board meeting 

(1.3); review of settlement 

agreement in response to 

director questions (0.2). 

3.10 4,107.50 

8/23/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.2) and Restructuring 

Committee meeting (1.6). 

1.80 1,512.00 

8/23/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Attend special telephonic Board 

meeting. 

1.30 1,092.00 

8/24/2019 Scott, Eric Dean Proofread Court filing draft per 

R. Sparks Bradley (4.0). 

4.00 1,060.00 

8/24/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review draft Court response 

(2.2); communications w/ team 

re: same (0.2). 

2.40 3,552.00 

8/24/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Attend call with M. Moore, N. 

Brownell, S. Qusba, M. Ponce, 

B. Bennett. 

0.80 672.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 21

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/25/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review Court draft response 

(1.0); call w/ Company re: same 

(0.4); correspondence re: same 

(0.3). 

1.70 2,516.00 

8/25/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Revise draft Court response re: 

wildfires (0.8). 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/26/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review Court order (0.4) 

correspondence w/ Company 

and team re: same (0.1). 

0.50 740.00 

8/26/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Conference call w/ PGE re: 

Court response (0.7); review & 

edit draft to Court (0.8); CPUC 

process call w/ MTO and 

restructuring committee (1.7); 

t/c w/ Company re: same (0.3); 

t/c w/ Cravath re: same (0.3); 

review memo and appeal re: 

CPUC decisions (0.3). 

4.10 6,724.00 

8/26/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of filed pleadings. 0.70 588.00 

8/26/2019 Rovner, Grace Per E. Egenes, continue to 

prepare Board materials. 

0.50 132.50 

8/27/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ Cravath re: status (0.2); 

t/cs w/ Company re: status 

(0.6); review Board materials 

(1.5). 

2.30 3,772.00 

8/27/2019 Vallejo, Melissa 

A. 

Review draft Board report 

(1.0); correspondence w/ R. 

Sussman re: same (0.2). 

1.20 708.00 

8/27/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Correspondence w/ team and 

Company re: Board issues 

(0.3); review report on wildfire 

safety (0.7); review draft Court 

submission re: same (0.4); 

communications w/ team re: 

workstreams (0.2). 

1.60 2,368.00 

8/27/2019 Koslowe, Jamin 

R. 

Call w/ G. Grogan re: 409A 

issues (0.3). 

0.30 366.00 

8/27/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Review key documents per 

question from N. Goldin (2.7); 

review and revise CPP draft 

report (1.2); emails w/ N. 

Goldin and R. Sparks Bradley 

4.70 3,948.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 22

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

re: same (0.5); emails and calls 

w/ M. Vallejo re: same (0.3). 

8/28/2019 Franklin, Janie 

Marie 

Communications w/ team re: 

case updates (0.1). 

0.10 45.50 

8/28/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review/revise draft CPP 

Committee materials (1.6); 

emails w/ R. Sussman and M. 

Vallejo re: same (0.4); emails 

w/ N. Goldin re: same (0.3); 

revise same per P. Curnin (0.7); 

further internal emails re: same 

(0.3); email to client re: same 

(0.1). 

3.40 3,723.00 

8/28/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review CPP draft report (0.8); 

t/c w/ Company re: status (0.2); 

t/c w/ Munger Tolles re: Butte 

DA (0.5); t/c w/ Company re: 

Court response (0.9); review 

bankruptcy court order (0.2). 

2.60 4,264.00 

8/28/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Calls w/ Company re: Court 

response (0.8); correspondence 

w/ Company and directors re: 

same (0.2); calls w/ director re: 

same (0.5); call w/ team re: 

same (0.3); revise CPP draft 

report (1.2); correspondence w/ 

team re: same (0.2). 

3.20 4,736.00 

8/28/2019 Phillips, Jacob 

M. 

Review (1.0) and comment on 

AB 1054 memorandum (1.0). 

2.00 1,680.00 

8/28/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Revise CPP draft report (2.9); 

emails w/ client, R. Sparks 

Bradley, M. Vallejo, P. Curnin, 

and N. Goldin re: same (0.8). 

3.70 3,108.00 

8/28/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Board Restructuring Committee 

telephonic meeting (1.4); 

review materials; emails, 

telecoms re various issues (1.1). 

2.50 4,100.00 

8/28/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Restructuring Committee 

meeting (1.4); review of subro 

term sheet (0.3); follow-up re 

BlueMountain settlement 

agreement (0.6). 

2.30 3,047.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 23

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/29/2019 Phillips, Jacob 

M. 

Review (0.6) and comment on 

AB 1054 memorandum (0.9). 

1.50 1,260.00 

8/29/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review Monitor feedback (0.2); 

review correspondence w/ 

Company re: compliance, 

Monitor (0.2); communications 

w/ team re: same (0.1). 

0.50 740.00 

8/30/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Special Board meeting call 

(0.9) and follow-up 

correspondence w/ directors 

(0.4). 

1.30 2,132.00 

8/30/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Email w/ K. Kinsel re: 

scheduling Board calls (0.2). 

0.20 168.00 

8/30/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review correspondence w/ 

clients and Company re: 

Monitor, media (0.4); review 

media report (0.2). 

0.60 888.00 

8/30/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Board telephonic meeting (1.5) 

and preparation (1.0). 

2.50 4,100.00 

8/30/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Board meeting (1.5), review of 

backstop commitment letter 

(0.5), call on tax matters in 

BCL (0.6), coordination with 

Blue Heron re director reports 

(0.4); review of subro term 

sheet (0.4). 

3.40 4,505.00 

TOTAL 444.00 $557,458.50 

Task Code: Court Hearings (CH)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/9/2019 Qusba, Sandy Participate in court hearing re 

plan status conference (2.5). 

2.50 3,837.50 

8/9/2019 Fell, Jamie Attend hearing re: plan process 

update. 

2.00 1,990.00 

8/9/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Attend hearing/status 

conference (1.5). 

1.50 2,302.50 

8/13/2019 Fell, Jamie Attend court hearing re 

exclusivity. 

1.00 995.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 24

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/13/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Attend exclusivity hearing (2.5) 2.50 3,837.50 

8/14/2019 Qusba, Sandy Attend estimation and lift stay 

hearing (7.5). 

7.50 11,512.50 

8/14/2019 Fell, Jamie Dial in/attend court hearing re 

exclusivity/estimation. 

1.50 1,492.50 

8/14/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Attend estimation and lift stay 

hearing. 

4.80 7,368.00 

8/27/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Attend 8-27 omnibus hearing 

and estimation status 

conference (by telephone) (3.8). 

3.80 4,636.00 

TOTAL 27.10 $37,971.50

Task Code: Claims Administration and Objections (CM)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/8/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Emails w/ team re: proofs of 

claim (0.3). 

0.30 444.00 

8/8/2019 Fell, Jamie Review proof of claim issues 

and correspondence w/ WGM 

re: same (0.5). 

0.50 497.50 

8/9/2019 Fell, Jamie Research re: subrogation 

claims. 

1.60 1,592.00 

8/14/2019 Fell, Jamie Review bar order (0.4); begin 

managing/prepare proofs of 

claim for directors (0.8). 

1.20 1,194.00 

8/21/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review proof of claims (0.1). 0.10 148.00 

8/21/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Correspondence w/ Bankruptcy 

team re: proof of claim (0.3). 

0.30 252.00 

8/23/2019 Fell, Jamie Further prepare draft proofs of 

claims for directors (0.5). 

0.50 497.50 

8/23/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ J. Fell re: proofs of claim 

(0.3). 

0.30 328.50 

8/26/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ K. McLendon re: proof 

of claims (0.2); review 

documents re: same (0.2). 

0.40 438.00 

8/26/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

T/c w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

prep of proofs of claim for 

directors and timetable (0.2); 

0.30 366.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 25

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

email to R. Sparks Bradley re: 

proof of claim precedents (0.1). 

8/28/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review bar date order (0.2); 

emails w/ K. McLendon re: 

same, proofs of claim (0.5); 

review proofs of claim (0.4). 

1.10 1,204.50 

8/28/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Review bar date notice (0.2); 

emails w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

bar date requirements and POCs 

for pre-filing directors (0.2). 

0.40 488.00 

TOTAL 7.00 $7,450.00

Task Code: Fee/Employment Applications (FA) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/1/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Prepare fee application 

materials (1.7). 

1.70 1,861.50 

8/2/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Prepare fee application 

materials (1.1). 

1.10 1,204.50 

8/2/2019 Fell, Jamie Review of billing for privilege. 1.00 995.00 

8/4/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Prepare fee application 

materials (2.2). 

2.20 2,409.00 

8/5/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Emails w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

comments on June monthly 

statement (0.2). 

0.20 244.00 

8/5/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Prepare fee application 

materials (0.9); emails w/ 

billing team re: same (0.3). 

1.20 1,314.00 

8/5/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Review and comment on draft 

statement for June (1.0); emails 

w/ J. Fell re: review of revisions 

to June statement (0.1). 

1.10 1,342.00 

8/6/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee application 

materials (0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

8/6/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Prepare fee application 

materials (1.0); emails w/ N. 

Goldin re: same (0.2). 

1.20 1,314.00 

8/7/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Prepare fee application 

materials (0.2); emails w/ K. 

McLendon re: same (0.2). 

0.40 438.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 26

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/7/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Review draft June monthly 

statement for outside director 

matters (0.7); email to R. 

Sparks Bradley and accounting 

team re: finalizing same (0.1). 

0.80 976.00 

8/7/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Email J. Fell and accounting 

team re finalizing June monthly 

statement. 

0.10 122.00 

8/7/2019 Fell, Jamie Review billing for privilege 

issues. 

0.60 597.00 

8/13/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Review fee protocol (0.3) and 

attend meeting with M. Ponce, 

P. Curnin and N. Goldin to 

discuss Fee Examiner protocol 

and response (0.7). 

1.00 1,535.00 

8/14/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fee application 

materials (0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

8/14/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ N. Goldin and M. Torkin 

re: fee application materials 

(0.2). 

0.20 219.00 

8/15/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ team re: fee examiner 

(0.3). 

0.30 444.00 

8/20/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ team re: fee examiner 

(0.2); prepare material for fee 

examiner (0.5). 

0.70 1,036.00 

8/21/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Prep for fee examiner call (0.4); 

call re: same (0.4). 

0.80 1,184.00 

8/21/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Call w/ fee examiner. 0.60 921.00 

8/22/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Correspondence w/ team re: fee 

application (0.3). 

0.30 252.00 

8/23/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ J. Fell and J. 

Calderon re: fee application 

materials (0.2). 

0.20 219.00 

8/23/2019 Fell, Jamie Prep June fee statement and 

monthly invoices (0.6) and corr. 

w/ M. Sofroniou and R. Sparks 

Bradley re: same (0.2). 

0.80 796.00 

8/24/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Fee examiner data review. 0.40 614.00 

8/25/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft June application of fee 

statement (2.4). 

2.40 1,680.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 27

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/26/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft June application of fee 

statement (0.7). 

0.70 490.00 

8/26/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Review fee examiner report on 

STB 1st interim fee application 

(0.2). 

0.20 244.00 

8/27/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft June application of fee 

statement (0.4). 

0.40 280.00 

8/27/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Prepare CNO for May 

statement (0.4) and email MCO 

and J. Sanders re: filing thereof 

(0.1); emails w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley, J. Fell and J. Calderon 

re: prep of monthly statement 

for June (0.1); emails w/ R. 

Lapisa re: first interim fee 

application data for response to 

fee auditor inquiries (0.5); t/cs 

w/ R. Lapisa re: followups on 

data for response to fee auditor 

(0.2). 

1.30 1,586.00 

8/28/2019 Calderon, Justin Draft May Fee Application in 

Bankruptcy Case (3.1). 

3.10 2,170.00 

8/28/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Emails w/ J. Trentacosta re: 

notification to Company re: 

associate class step increases 

(0.2); review draft monthly 

statement for June (0.5); email 

to J. Calderon re: comments 

thereon (0.1); email to J. 

Calderon re: service of June 

statement and LEDES files 

(0.1); further emails w/ J. Fell 

and J. Calderon re: June 

monthly statement and UST and 

fee examiner submissions (0.1); 

email MCO re: filing of 

monthly statement for June 

(0.1). 

1.10 1,342.00 

8/28/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Begin review and comment on 

draft monthly statement for 

July. 

0.80 976.00 

8/29/2019 Calderon, Justin Revise May fee application 

(2.1), including 

2.50 1,750.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 28

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

communications w/ MCO re: 

deadlines (0.4). 

8/29/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Continue review and comment 

on draft statement for July 

(0.8); emails accounting team re 

follow up questions (0.2). 

1.00 1,220.00 

8/30/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Emails w/ J. Calderon and 

MCO re: filing of July 

statement (0.2); emails w/ 

accounting re: July submissions 

(0.1). 

0.30 366.00 

8/30/2019 Laspisa, 

Rosemarie 

Review and analyze retention 

fee monthly statements. 

3.00 1,200.00 

8/30/2019 Terricone, 

Cyrena 

Review and analyze retention 

fee monthly statements per R. 

Artale-LaSpisa and K. 

McLendon. 

6.50 2,600.00 

TOTAL 40.60 $36,533.00 

Task Code: Litigation – Contested Matters and Adversary Proceedings (LI) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/1/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review PERA reply brief (0.3). 0.30 492.00 

TOTAL 0.30 $492.00 

Task Code: Plan/Disclosure Statement (PL) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/1/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review update to Board and 

comment on same (0.5); review 

draft plan protocol and 

correspondence with STB team 

regarding same (1.5). 

2.00 3,070.00 

8/1/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of competing plan 

proposal protocol. 

0.50 420.00 

8/1/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Call with M. Ponce re protocol 

(0.2); review emails from 

0.50 767.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 29

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

Restructuring Committee re: 

same (0.3). 

8/2/2019 Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Communications w/ P. Curnin 

et al re: restructuring, 

subrogation issues (0.5); 

communications w/ J. Calderon 

re: same (0.5); review filings re: 

estimation (0.5); Board 

presentation re: subrogation 

strategy (0.5); Willkie response 

to settlement proposal (0.5). 

2.50 3,837.50 

8/2/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

Review and comment on J. Fell 

report re call with Weil re 

estimation and plan matters 

(0.2); review and comment on J. 

Fell report on call with Milbank 

re estimation and plan matters 

(0.2). 

0.40 488.00 

8/2/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review/analyze Proposed Plan 

Protocol for Auction Process 

(2.5), meetings, teleconfs, 

emails re same (2.5). 

5.00 8,200.00 

8/2/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review of plan protocol (0.5); 

participate in internal meeting 

with M. Ponce, S. Qusba, M. 

Torkin re protocol (0.6), Board 

meeting (2.0); Restructuring 

Committee call (1.5); call w 

Restructuring Committee (0.5). 

5.10 6,757.50 

8/2/2019 Qusba, Sandy Meeting with R. Purushotham, 

M. Ponce, M. Torkin, E. Egenes 

and J. Levine regarding 

protocol (1.0); review and 

revise draft plan protocol (2.6); 

participate on Board call (2.0); 

participate on Restructuring 

Committee call (1.5). 

7.10 10,898.50 

8/2/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend call with Restructuring 

Committee re: plan protocol. 

1.50 1,372.50 

8/2/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.5) and attend 

meeting with members of 

Restructuring Committee re 

2.00 1,680.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 30

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

proposed plan protocol 

comments (1.5). 

8/2/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Review plan protocol and 

comment on same (0.6); attend 

internal meeting re same (1.0); 

attend board meeting (1.5); 

attend Restructuring Committee 

call (1.7); attend plan protocol 

call with professionals (1.0); 

revise plan protocol (1.1); call 

w Restructuring Committee on 

protocol (1.5). 

8.40 12,894.00 

8/3/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review material re: bankruptcy 

plan (0.5). 

0.50 740.00 

8/3/2019 Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Communications w/ J. Calderon 

re: subrogation follow up issues 

(0.5). 

0.50 767.50 

8/3/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails re plan protocol (2.0); 

numerous teleconfs re various 

issues re plan protocol. 

4.60 7,544.00 

8/3/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review and revisions to plan 

protocol (1.8) and discussions 

with STB team re same (0.3). 

2.10 2,782.50 

8/3/2019 Qusba, Sandy Prep for and t/c with B. Bennet 

regarding perspective on 

protocol (0.8); review and 

revise draft protocol (1.0); t/c 

with M. Torkin, M. Ponce, E. 

Egenes, J. Levine and R. 

Purushotham regarding prep for 

Restructuring Committee call 

(0.3); t/c with STB team and 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding protocol (1.5); t/c 

with A. Kornberg regarding 

protocol (0.5); correspondence 

with Restructuring Committee 

regarding same (0.8). 

4.90 7,521.50 

8/3/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend t/c with M. Ponce, R. 

Purushotham, M. Torkin, S. 

Qusba, E. Egenes and 

Restructuring Committee re: 

plan proposal protocol. 

1.00 915.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 31

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/3/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend t/c with M. Ponce, R. 

Purushotham, M. Torkin, S. 

Qusba and E. Egenes re: plan 

proposal protocol. 

0.40 366.00 

8/3/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Review and revise draft plan 

proposal protocol. 

1.30 1,189.50 

8/3/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep revision of plan protocol. 0.60 504.00 

8/3/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.6) and calls with 

members of Restructuring 

Committee and STB re plan 

protocol (1.4). 

2.00 1,680.00 

8/3/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Emails re plan protocol w team 

(0.2); call w S. Karotkin re 

same (0.2); call w M. Ponce re 

same (0.2); Restructuring 

Committee call re protocol 

(1.4); call w S. Qusba, E. 

Egenes, M. Ponce and R. 

Purushotham re same (0.3). 

2.30 3,530.50 

8/4/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails re plan protocol (1.5); 

teleconfs re various issues re 

plan protocol (1.9). 

3.40 5,576.00 

8/4/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review and revisions to plan 

protocol. 

0.30 397.50 

8/4/2019 Qusba, Sandy Prep for (0.3) and participate in 

t/c with S. Karotkin, M. Ponce, 

CEO, GC, M. Torkin, R. 

Purushotham, K. Ziman, E. 

Egenes and J. Levine regarding 

markup to draft plan protocol 

and next steps (1.2); t/c with 

STB team regarding next steps 

(1.5); t/c with STB team 

regarding next steps (0.4); t/cs 

(numerous) with S. Karotkin 

regarding protocol (0.8); review 

and revise draft protocol (0.6); 

correspondence with 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding same (0.5). 

5.30 8,135.50 

8/4/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend t/c with M. Ponce, R. 

Purushotham, M. Torkin, S. 

Qusba, E. Egenes, Company 

1.00 915.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 32

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

management team, Weil and 

Lazard re: plan proposal 

protocol. 

8/4/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend t/c with M. Ponce, R. 

Purushotham, M. Torkin, S. 

Qusba and E. Egenes re: plan 

proposal protocol. 

0.20 183.00 

8/4/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Revise draft plan proposal 

protocol. 

1.90 1,738.50 

8/4/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep revision of plan protocol. 1.30 1,092.00 

8/4/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.1) and call with 

management, Alix Partners, 

Weil and Lazard re protocol 

(1.2). 

1.30 1,092.00 

8/4/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Call with M. Ponce, S. Qusba, 

M. Torkin, R. Purushotham and 

J. Levine re plan protocol next 

steps coming out of 

management meeting. 

0.30 252.00 

8/5/2019 Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Communications w/ M. Tokin, 

N. Goldin, S. Qusba re: 

subrogation issues (0.8); review 

research re: same (2.0); 

communications w/ J. Calderon 

re: same (0.4) and follow up re: 

subro claims and potential 

defenses (0.6). 

3.80 5,833.00 

8/5/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review revisions to Protocol 

proposed by CPUC (1.0); 

emails, teleconfs, various issues 

re same (1.2). 

2.20 3,608.00 

8/5/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Comparison of management vs. 

Restructuring Committee 

comments to protocol. 

1.40 2,296.00 

8/5/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Prepare protocol issues list 

(2.4), review CPUC memo 

(0.4). 

2.80 3,710.00 

8/5/2019 Qusba, Sandy Participate in call with S. 

Karotkin, N. Mitchell and M. 

Torkin and follow-up with M. 

Torkin (0.8); correspondence 

with Restructuring Committee 

regarding same; (0.8); t/c 

4.80 7,368.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 33

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

(numerous) with S. Karotkin 

regarding protocol and next 

steps (0.8); review and 

comment on draft objection to 

Subro Motion to Terminate 

Exclusivity (1.1); t/c with 

Restructuring Committee 

members regarding protocol 

(0.7); review and comment on 

protocol chart (0.6). 

8/5/2019 Fell, Jamie Review motions to terminate 

exclusivity (0.8) and corr. w/ 

M. Torkin and S. Qusba re: 

same (0.1). 

0.90 895.50 

8/5/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep summary of Restructuring 

Committee plan protocol 

revision. 

2.80 2,352.00 

8/5/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Call with S. Qusba, N. Mitchell 

and S. Karotkin re plan protocol 

(0.4); meet with S. Qusba re 

same (0.4); call re next step - 

internal (0.6); call with S. 

Qusba and S. Karotkin (0.8) re 

same; call with A. Frankel re 

subrogation claims (0.4); 

review and comment on debtor 

objection (1.6); review protocol 

chart (0.3); catch-up with S. 

Qusba re next steps (0.5); 

review WGM protocol and 

discuss w S. Qusba (0.4). 

5.40 8,289.00 

8/6/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ A. Frankel re: 

subrogation issues (0.3). 

0.30 492.00 

8/6/2019 Calderon, Justin Revised outline re: subrogation 

claimant's claims and PG&E's 

defenses (4.9), including 

research re: same (3.0). 

7.90 5,530.00 

8/6/2019 Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Communications re: 

subrogation issues (0.3); review 

expert report (0.3); 

communications re: same (0.6); 

communications w/ J. Calderon 

re: same (0.1); draft outline re: 

2.30 3,530.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 34

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

potential defenses, strategy 

(1.0). 

8/6/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Post Board meeting emails, 

teleconfs, and meetings with S. 

Qusba, S. Karotkin, N. 

Brownell, J. Loduca re plan 

protocol. 

0.80 1,312.00 

8/6/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

T/c with S. Karotkin, S. Qusba, 

M. Torkin, R. Purushotham, J. 

Levine and E. Egenes re 

protocol (0.3) T/c with S. 

Karotkin, N. Brownell, M. 

Ponce, S. Qusba, M. Torkin, R. 

Purushotham, J. Levine and E. 

Egenes re protocol (0.3). 

0.60 795.00 

8/6/2019 Qusba, Sandy Prep for Board call (0.7); t/c 

with Board (2.5); t/c 

(numerous) with S. Karotkin 

and M. Torkin regarding 

protocol and next steps (0.8); t/c 

with S. Karotkin, N. Brownell, 

M. Ponce, M. Torkin, R. 

Purushotham, J. Levine and E. 

Egenes regarding plan protocol 

and next steps (0.3); review and 

revise objection to Subro 

Motion (0.7). 

5.00 7,675.00 

8/6/2019 Fell, Jamie Review of comparable plan 

processes and prepare summary 

and comparison chart in 

advance of Board meetings. 

2.80 2,786.00 

8/6/2019 Levine, Jeff P. T/c with S. Karotkin, N. 

Brownell, M. Ponce, S. Qusba, 

M. Torkin, R. Purushotham, J. 

Levine and E. Egenes re 

protocol. 

0.30 274.50 

8/6/2019 Egenes, Erica M. T/c with S. Karotkin, S. Qusba, 

M. Torkin, R. Purushotham, 

and J. Levine re protocol. 

0.30 252.00 

8/6/2019 Egenes, Erica M. T/c with S. Karotkin, N. 

Brownell, M. Ponce, S. Qusba, 

M. Torkin, R. Purushotham, 

and J. Levine re protocol. 

0.30 252.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 35

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/6/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Call with S. Qusba re plan 

protocol and board meeting 

(0.2); call w S. Karotkin re 

objection to Subro Motion and 

emails re same (0.5); t/c with S. 

Karotkin, S. Qusba, R. 

Purushotham, J. Levine and E. 

Egenes re protocol (0.3); T/c 

with S. Karotkin, N. Brownell, 

M. Ponce, S. Qusba, R. 

Purushotham (0.3); J. Levine 

and E. Egenes re protocol (0.3) 

call w A. Frankel re subro 

claims (0.3); call w S. Qusba re 

protocol issues (0.5). 

2.40 3,684.00 

8/7/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review debtor motion on 

estimation (1.1); review 

exponent report (0.7); review 

public advocates data report 

(0.5). 

2.30 3,772.00 

8/7/2019 Calderon, Justin Revise draft outline of 

subrogation claimant's claims & 

PG&E's defenses (0.5). 

0.50 350.00 

8/7/2019 Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

T/c w/ K. Orsini re: subrogation 

strategy issues (0.5); 

communications w/ J. Calderon 

re: same (0.5), draft/revise 

outline (0.5) and prep for 

restructuring call (0.5); Board 

committee call re: subrogation 

issues (1.8); communications w/ 

M. Torkin, S. Qusba re: same 

(0.4). 

4.20 6,447.00 

8/7/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, revisions and 

various issues to CPUC 

Protocol. 

1.40 2,296.00 

8/7/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Meeting re Subro estimation 

claims. 

0.50 820.00 

8/7/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Revisions to protocol (1.9). 1.90 2,517.50 

8/7/2019 Qusba, Sandy Correspondence with M. Ponce, 

M. Torkin and S. Karotkin 

regarding protocol and board 

5.90 9,056.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 36

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

discussion (0.6); meeting M. 

Ponce, M. Torkin, P. Curnin 

and R. Purushotham regarding 

next steps and prep for Board 

call (1.0); t/c with M. Torkin, 

A. Frankel and Restructuring 

Committee regarding 

subrogation claims (1.8); prep 

for Board meeting (1.5); t/c 

with M. Ponce, R. 

Purushotham, J. Levine and E. 

Egenes and Board regarding 

protocol (1.0). 

8/7/2019 Fell, Jamie Plan process research and 

summary and comparison chart 

for Board meetings. 

1.70 1,691.50 

8/7/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep revised draft of plan 

protocol. 

1.60 1,344.00 

8/7/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Call w S. Qusba re protocol 

issues. 

0.40 614.00 

8/7/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Call re subros w A. Frankel, S. 

Qusba and Restructuring 

Committee. 

1.80 2,763.00 

8/8/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review draft letter and 

correspondence with Board 

regarding protocol (0.8); 

participate in Board call (0.5); 

participate in Restructuring 

Committee call (1.3); review 

equity commitment and analysis 

of same (1.0). 

3.60 5,526.00 

8/8/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Restructuring 

Committee call re: protocol. 

1.30 1,189.50 

8/8/2019 Levine, Jeff P. Attend Board call re: protocol. 0.50 457.50 

8/9/2019 Frankel, Andrew 

T. 

Review communications re: 

subrogation counter proposal 

(0.5). 

0.50 767.50 

8/9/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with M. Torkin regarding 

equity term sheet (0.5); 

participate in Board call (1.8); 

debrief among M. Ponce, J. 

Levine and E. Egenes (0.5); t/c 

with M. Ponce and R. 

3.70 5,679.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 37

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

Purushotham regarding protocol 

(0.3); draft summary of status 

conference for M. Ponce and R. 

Purushotham (0.6). 

8/10/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Calls and emails with 

Restructuring Committee (1.3) 

and Weil and Lazard (1.1) re 

various issues re POR and 

scheduling. 

2.30 3,772.00 

8/10/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Calls with Board members and 

management re various issues 

re POR and scheduling (1.2). 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/10/2019 Qusba, Sandy Correspondence with STB team 

regarding Restructuring 

Committee questions and 

various issues (0.7); prep, 

including research, for call with 

Restructuring Committee 

members regarding questions 

(2.5); t/c with M. Ponce, M. 

Torkin R. Purushotham, K. 

Liang and M. Moore regarding 

update and next steps (1.3); t/c 

with S. Karotkin, K. Ziman and 

E. Egenes regarding status and 

update (0.7); t/c with S. 

Karotkin regarding timelines 

(0.3). 

5.50 8,442.50 

8/10/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Call w/ Restructuring 

Committee, M. Ponce, R. 

Purushotham and S. Qusba re: 

court hearing and equity 

proposal (1.3); follow-up w/ S. 

Qusba re: same (0.4); review 

related material (0.7); review 

subrogation pleadings (0.4). 

2.80 4,298.00 

8/11/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review estimation briefing 

(1.0). 

1.00 1,480.00 

8/11/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Restructuring Committee call re 

Subro negotiations and POR 

plan term sheet and schedule. 

2.50 4,100.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 38

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/11/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Attend call on plan term sheet 

with company and 

Restructuring Committee. 

1.50 1,987.50 

8/11/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review supplemental pleading 

regarding exclusivity, plan term 

sheet, analysis of equity 

proposal and response to 

estimation motion objections 

(0.2); t/c with M. Torkin 

regarding plan term sheet and 

update (0.3); t/c with S. 

Karotkin, K. Ziman and M. 

Ponce regarding update and 

prep for Restructuring 

Committee call (0.5); t/c with 

M. Moore regarding 

Restructuring Committee call 

(0.5); t/c with Advisors and 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding next steps regarding 

exclusivity and subros and plan 

term sheet (2.5); t/cs with M. 

Moore (numerous) regarding 

open issues and next steps on 

subros (1.0); t/c with M. Moore 

and N. Brownell regarding 

subros open issues and next 

steps (0.5). 

5.50 8,442.50 

8/11/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Call w/ S. Qusba re: Plan term 

sheet and related matters. 

0.30 460.50 

8/12/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Teleconfs with Board members, 

Restructuring Committee 

members and Management re 

various Subro settlement issues. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/12/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review committee's proposed 

schedule (0.4); t/c with K. 

Orsini regarding settlement 

discussions (0.2); t/c with A. 

Kornberg regarding protocol 

(0.4); t/c with S. Karotkin 

regarding update (0.5); t/c with 

N. Brownell and M. Ponce 

regarding same (0.4); t/c with J. 

2.50 3,837.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 39

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

Loduca regarding subro 

settlement proposal (0.3); t/c 

with Cravath, Weil, Lazard and 

STB regarding prep for call 

with JD/PJT (0.3). 

8/12/2019 Fell, Jamie Research and compare plan 

proposals and prepare 

summary/analysis for Board. 

1.30 1,293.50 

8/13/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Review proposal settlement 

contract (0.2). 

0.20 328.00 

8/13/2019 Tripodi, Lou Obtain Rights Offering 

Precedents for E. Egenes. 

0.50 155.00 

8/13/2019 Qusba, Sandy Attend exclusivity termination 

hearing (2.5); meeting with M. 

Moore regarding next steps 

(0.4); participate in call with 

Jones Day, Cravath, Weil and 

Lazard regarding equity 

commitment letter, NDAs and 

next steps (0.6). 

3.50 5,372.50 

8/14/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs re Exclusivity 

Hearing (0.5). 

0.50 820.00 

8/14/2019 Qusba, Sandy Calls and meeting with M. 

Moore regarding next steps 

(0.4); meeting S. Karotkin and 

J. Mesterharm regarding same 

(0.4); t/c with M. Ponce and R. 

Barrea regarding various 

restructuring issues (0.5). 

1.30 1,995.50 

8/14/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Research re rights offering 

precedents. 

1.80 1,512.00 

8/15/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review and comment on draft 

Plan of Reorganization term 

sheet for CPUC/Governor. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/15/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review Restructuring 

Committee materials and prep 

for call (0.7); t/c with J. 

Mesterharm and Restructuring 

Committee regarding business 

plan (0.8); attend portion of t/c 

with Restructuring Committee 

regarding next steps for plan 

filing (1.5); attend portion of t/c 

4.70 7,214.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 40

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

with CPUC, Lazard, Weil, Paul 

Weiss, O’Melveny and Ducera 

regarding update (1.0); t/c with 

M. Moore regarding catch-up 

(0.7). 

8/15/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Research re rights offering 

precedents. 

0.20 168.00 

8/16/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various issues 

re NDA and POR Term Sheet. 

1.20 1,968.00 

8/16/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review subro proposals (0.6); 

meeting with M. Feldman, K. 

Orsini, S. Karotkin regarding 

settlement discussions for subro 

claims (1.5); t/c with Board and 

advisors regarding updates and 

next steps (1.7); t/c with R. 

Barrera and K. Orsini regarding 

pending motions (0.6); review 

lift-stay and exclusivity 

opinions (1.1). 

5.50 8,442.50 

8/17/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

next steps (0.3); t/c with M. 

Moore regarding same (0.4); t/c 

with S. Karotkin regarding 

update (0.3); correspondence 

with Restructuring Committee 

members regarding next steps 

(0.6). 

1.60 2,456.00 

8/17/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Analyze emergence structures 

and related term sheets (0.7); 

review exclusivity and lift stay 

orders and consider potential 

responses (0.5). 

1.20 1,842.00 

8/18/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Emails, teleconfs, various issues 

with Restructuring Committee 

re POR term sheet and 

provisions and NDA (1.7). 

1.70 2,788.00 

8/18/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with M. Ponce, M. Torkin, 

R. Purushotham and E. Egenes 

re. catch-up (0.7); t/c with D. 

Dunne regarding catch-up (0.4); 

t/c with A. Kornberg regarding 

next steps (0.5); t/c with B. 

3.20 4,912.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 41

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

Bennett regarding next steps 

(0.4); correspondence with 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding update and calls with 

various counsel (0.8); t/c with 

M. Moore regarding next steps 

(0.4). 

8/18/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.2) and call with M. 

Ponce, S. Qusba, M. Torkin, R. 

Purushotham re POR term sheet 

and developments (0.7). 

0.90 756.00 

8/18/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Review of materials related to 

POR term sheet and shareholder 

proposals. 

0.40 336.00 

8/18/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Internal call (M. Ponce, S. 

Qusba, R. Purushotham) to 

discuss potential emergence 

issues and response to court 

orders. 

0.70 1,074.50 

8/19/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review and address issues 

relating to POR term sheet 

(1.5); emails, teleconfs re term 

sheet and other issues(0.7). 

2.20 3,608.00 

8/19/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Call w restructuring committee 

(1.5); revise summary of key 

terms of POR for Restructuring 

Committee (1.8). 

3.30 4,372.50 

8/19/2019 Qusba, Sandy Correspondence with STB team 

regarding plan and plan equity 

commitment (0.4); prep for call 

with Restructuring Committee, 

including review of AB1054 

and summary of plan terms and 

annotations of plan term sheet 

(2.8); t/c with S. Karotkin 

regarding next steps (0.3); t/c 

with M. Ponce and E. Egenes 

regarding prep for call with 

Restructuring Committee (0.3); 

t/c with restructuring committee 

regarding marketing term sheet 

(1.5); t/c with S. Karotkin 

regarding next steps (0.3); 

6.20 9,517.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 42

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

review and comment on term 

sheet (0.6). 

8/19/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Research re AB 1054 and other 

CA state law requirements on 

plan of reorganization. 

2.20 1,848.00 

8/19/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.3) and attend portion 

of t/c with Restructuring 

Committee re summary term 

sheet for POR (0.8). 

1.10 924.00 

8/19/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.2) and attend 

meeting with M. Ponce, S. 

Qusba and R. Purushotham in 

prep of meeting with 

Restructuring Committee re 

summary term sheet for POR 

(0.5). 

0.70 588.00 

8/20/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with R. Barrera regarding 

subro counterproposal and prep 

for calls with restructuring 

committee (0.4); t/c with R. 

Barrera and N. Brownell 

regarding same (0.4); t/c with 

R. Barrera and M. Moore 

regarding same (0.4); t/c with S. 

Karotkin regarding update 

(0.2); t/c with K. Orsini 

regarding update (0.2); prep for 

Restructuring Committee call, 

including prep regarding subro 

counter (0.8); t/c with 

Restructuring Committee 

(including executive session) 

regarding business plan, subro 

counterproposal and mediation 

(1.8); review J. Montali's order 

(0.7); t/c with M. Ponce, E. 

Egenes and R. Purushotham 

regarding same and catch-up 

(0.3); t/c with S. Karotkin 

regarding subro counter, 

mediation and business plan 

(0.4); t/c with Restructuring 

Committee regarding Tubbs, 

7.00 10,745.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 43

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

FEMA, estimation process and 

next steps (1.0); t/c with K. 

Orsini regarding catch-up (0.2); 

t/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

same (0.2). 

8/20/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for and call with R. 

Barrera, M. Moore and S. 

Qusba re settlement matters. 

1.20 1,008.00 

8/20/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.1) and Restructuring 

Committee meeting re 

bankruptcy and litigation update 

(1.2). 

1.30 1,092.00 

8/21/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Telephonic meeting with 

Abrams/Knighthead, Company, 

Lazard, Cravath, Jones Day on 

backstop proposal (3.0); review 

materials re: same (0.4). 

3.40 4,505.00 

8/21/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

meeting with equity holders 

(0.3); begin review draft ch. 11 

plan (0.8); t/c with D. Dunne 

regarding lift stay order (0.2); 

t/c with M. Ponce regarding 

next steps (0.2); review and 

comment on subro settlement 

term sheet (1.0); participate in 

Lazard meeting (including pre 

and post-meetings ) with 

Knighthead, Abrams and 

advisors regarding equity 

commitment letter (3.0). 

5.50 8,442.50 

8/22/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Review, issues, teleconfs and 

emails re Subro Settlement term 

sheet. 

1.30 2,132.00 

8/22/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

Judge Montali's 

recommendations (0.5); t/c with 

M. Ponce and N. Brownell 

regarding open issues (0.4); t/c 

with J. Loduca regarding subro 

settlement and legislative 

session (0.5); meeting at 

Cravath regarding equity 

6.60 10,131.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 44

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

commitment letter and negotiate 

same with Jones Day (3.0); t/c 

with D. Dunne regarding 

withdrawal of reference (0.4); 

t/c with A. Kornberg regarding 

same (0.3); t/c with M. Moore, 

M. Ponce and R. Purushotham 

regarding open issues and 

comments on same (0.5); t/c 

with K. Ziman regarding next 

steps (0.2); review and 

comment on subro settlement 

(0.8). 

8/22/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for and call with M. 

Moore, M. Ponce, P. Curnin, R. 

Purushotham, S. Qusba re 

potential settlement and 

bankruptcy matters. 

0.80 672.00 

8/22/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for and call re potential 

subro settlement with N. 

Brownell, R. Barrera, K. Orsini, 

S. Karotkin, K. Ziman, M. 

Ponce, S. Qusba. 

0.80 672.00 

8/23/2019 Qusba, Sandy Prep for Board/Restructuring 

Committee calls (1.5); t/c with 

S. Karotkin regarding 

estimation, settlement proposals 

and next steps (0.5); t/c with M. 

Ponce regarding same (0.3); 

correspondence with R. Hall, K. 

Ziman, K. Orsini, M. Ponce and 

S. Karotkin regarding 

Board/Restructuring Committee 

presentation (0.3); t/c with 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding equity commitment, 

subro settlement and next steps 

(1.6); t/c with board regarding 

same (1.3); correspondence 

with Restructuring Committee 

members regarding next steps 

(0.3); review and comment on 

subro settlement (0.5). 

6.30 9,670.50 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 45

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/24/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Correspondence w/ team re: 

plan release (0.1); review draft 

provisions (0.3). 

0.40 592.00 

8/24/2019 Ponce, Mario A. Conf call w/ N. Brownell, S. 

Qusba and B. Bennett re 

various settlement issues (1.0); 

review emails and 

materials(0.5). 

1.50 2,460.00 

8/24/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review of CPUC timeline for 

distribution to Restructuring 

Committee. 

0.30 397.50 

8/24/2019 Qusba, Sandy Begin review of revised plan 

(1.0); prep for calls with B. 

Bennett, S. Karotkin, K. Orsini 

and calls with M. Moore and N. 

Brownell (1.0) t/c with M. 

Torkin regarding plan changes 

(0.3); t/c with B. Bennett, S. 

Karotkin, K. Orsini regarding 

subro and plan issues (1.0); t/c 

with B. Bennett, M. Ponce, N. 

Brownell and M. Moore 

regarding next steps with equity 

commitments (0.6); t/c with K. 

Orsini and S. Karotkin 

regarding subro settlement 

(0.3); t/c with J. Loduca 

regarding next steps (0.4); t/c 

with R. Barerra regarding next 

steps (0.4). 

5.00 7,675.00 

8/24/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (0.5) and call with S. 

Qusba, K. Orsini, S. Karotkin, 

B. Bennett re potential backstop 

with equityholders (0.6). 

1.10 924.00 

8/24/2019 Torkin, Michael 

H. 

Review revised POR (0.7); 

emails to and call with Qusba re 

draft plan modifications (0.3). 

1.00 1,535.00 

8/25/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with S. Karotkin, K. Orsini, 

D. Dunne, A. LaBlanc and G. 

Braye regarding update (0.8); 

t/c with R. Barerra and N. 

Brownell regarding next steps 

(0.6); t/c with R. Barerra 

4.00 6,140.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 46

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

regarding open issues (0.6); 

correspondence with M. Ponce 

and R. Purushotham regarding 

equity commitment letter and 

other issues (0.7); t/c with S. 

Karotkin, K. Orsini and R. 

Barerra regarding subro 

settlement (0.6); t/c with S. 

Karotkin and M. Feldman re 

plan matters (0.3); t/c with R. 

Barerra regarding catch-up 

(0.4). 

8/26/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review bankruptcy plan 

correspondence (0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

8/26/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

T/c w/ S. Qusba re status 

conference on estimation (0.1); 

review submissions res status 

conference on estimation, 

order/recommendation re 

withdrawal of the reference, 

order re jury trial rights, Tubbs 

lift stay rulings and debtors' 

POR timeline in preparation for 

8-27 hearing (1.3); review order 

re status conference on 

estimation (0.2). 

1.60 1,952.00 

8/26/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review and comment on 

backstop commitment letter 

(1.0); Restructuring Committee 

meeting (1.3). 

2.30 3,047.50 

8/26/2019 Qusba, Sandy Correspondence with M. 

Moore, R. Barrera and K. 

Orsini regarding subro 

settlement (0.2); review and 

comment on ch. 11 plan (2.8); 

t/c with R. Barrera regarding 

subro settlement terms and next 

steps (0.7); t/c with H. 

Weissman, K. Liang, M. 

Moore, K. Schmidt and A. 

Wolff regarding CPUC process 

(1.0) t/c with S. Karotkin, K. 

Orsini and R. Barrera regarding 

6.80 10,438.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 47

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

subro settlement and next steps 

(0.6); t/c with R. Barrera 

regarding same (0.8); t/c with 

R. Barrera and M. Moore 

regarding subro settlement and 

next steps (0.3) t/c with R. 

Barrera, K. Orsini and S. 

Karotkin regarding subro 

settlement (0.4). 

8/26/2019 Egenes, Erica M. Prep for (1.2) and call with 

(1.0) M. Moore, K. Liang, K. 

Schmidt, H. Weissmann, S. 

Qusba, M. Ponce, P. Curnin, 

and R. Purushotham re CPUC 

process. 

2.20 1,848.00 

8/27/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ team re: draft plan (0.3). 0.30 444.00 

8/27/2019 Curnin, Paul C. T/c w/ S. Qusba and others re: 

plan (0.3); t/c w/ team re: 

settlement issues (0.3). 

0.60 984.00 

8/27/2019 McLendon, 

Kathrine 

T/c w/ S. Qusba re estimation 

status conference and next steps 

(0.2); emails w/ S. Qusba re 

upcoming schedule re plan and 

estimation proceedings (0.2). 

0.40 488.00 

8/27/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Review of backstop 

commitment letters and subro 

term sheet. 

1.10 1,457.50 

8/27/2019 Qusba, Sandy T/c with S. Karotkin and K. 

Orsini regarding subro 

settlement (0.5); t/c with P. 

Curnin and N. Brownell 

regarding status and open issues 

(0.4); t/c with R. Barrera 

regarding subro settlement 

analysis (0.5); t/c with P. 

Curnin regarding update (0.2); 

t/c with N. Brownell regarding 

update (0.5); t/c with K. 

McLendon regarding court 

hearing update (0.2); prep for 

and participate in t/c with P. 

Curnin and N. Goldin regarding 

plan provisions (0.5). 

2.80 4,298.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 48

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/28/2019 Qusba, Sandy Review subro settlement 

material (0.5); t/c with M. 

Moore regarding update (0.7); 

t/c with K. Orsini regarding 

subro settlement (0.3); t/c with 

R. Barrera regarding same 

(0.5); t/c with S. Karotkin, K. 

Orsini, R. Barrera regarding 

same (0.6); t/c with 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding update on subros, 

equity commitment letter and 

next steps (1.4); t/c with A. 

Wolff regarding board comp 

(0.3); t/c with S. Karotkin 

regarding plan board comp and 

next steps (0.4); t/c with N. 

Brownell regarding next steps 

(0.5); t/c with S. Karotkin and 

A. Kornberg regarding director 

comp (0.2); t/c with A. Wolff 

regarding director comp (0.3); 

t/c with R. Barrera regarding 

subro settlement (0.6). 

6.30 9,670.50 

8/29/2019 Curnin, Paul C. Calls re: governance and 

settlement issues (0.3); t/cs w/ 

Company, Cravath, others re: 

same (1.5). 

1.80 2,952.00 

8/29/2019 Purushotham, 

Ravi 

Call on backstop letter with 

Cravath and Lazard (2.2); 

review of backstop letter (0.6). 

2.80 3,710.00 

8/29/2019 Qusba, Sandy Correspondence with 

Restructuring Committee 

members regarding subro 

settlement (0.4); research case 

law regarding various issues 

(0.8); t/c with P. Curnin 

regarding update (0.2); review 

subro term sheet markup (0.8); 

begin to revise same (1.5); prep 

for and participate in t/c with S. 

Karotkin, K. Orsini and R. 

Barrera regarding same (1.5); 

6.20 9,517.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 49

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

t/c with R. Barrera regarding 

various issues (1.0). 

8/30/2019 Qusba, Sandy Board call (1.5); review and 

comment on subro term sheet 

(1.8); t/c with N. Brownell, A. 

Wolff, K. Schmidt, M. Ponce 

and P. Curnin regarding followup (0.5); t/c with K. Orsini, S. 

Karotkin and R. Barrera 

regarding subro settlement 

(0.4); t/c with N. Brownell 

regarding subro settlement 

(0.5); t/c with R. Barrera 

regarding same (0.5); t/c with 

K. Orsini regarding update 

(0.3); t/c with M. Moore 

regarding update (0.4); 

correspondence with 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding subro questions (0.5). 

6.40 9,824.00 

8/31/2019 Qusba, Sandy Revise subro term sheet (0.8); 

t/c with S. Karotkin regarding 

same (0.4); t/c with R. Barrera 

regarding update (0.3); prep for 

and t/c T. Wagner, D. Abrams, 

Restructuring Committee, M. 

Ponce and R. Purushotham 

(1.3); t/c with R. Barrera, S. 

Karotkin and K. Orsini 

regarding subro settlement term 

sheet (0.5); revise same (0.5); 

t/c with R. Barrera regarding 

next steps (0.3); t/c with N. 

Brownell regarding update 

(0.5); correspondence with 

Restructuring Committee 

regarding subro term sheet 

(0.3). 

4.90 7,521.50 

TOTAL 316.90 $447,791.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 50

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Task Code: Non-Working Travel Time (TV) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/12/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Travel NY/SF (3.0). 3.00 2,220.00 

8/12/2019 Duran, Raul G. Travel to and from meeting w/ 

former executive (0.5). 

0.50 147.50 

8/13/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Travel SF/NY(6.0). 6.00 4,440.00 

TOTAL 9.50 $6,807.50 

Task Code: Fact Investigation/Development (L110) 

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/1/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Review media material (0.2) 

and revise same (0.6). 

0.80 472.00 

8/1/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Review CPUC OII dockets for 

updates (0.2) and summarize 

filings (0.2). 

0.40 236.00 

8/1/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ Cravath re: 

documents (0.5); t/c w/ R. 

Sussman re: same (0.1). 

0.60 657.00 

8/2/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Confer w/ team re: 

strategy/workstreams (1.3); 

attend Board meeting (1.7); 

review correspondence/filings 

re: matters (0.3); call w/ 

company counsel, team re: 

documents (0.5). 

3.80 5,624.00 

8/2/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Call w/ Cravath and N. Goldin 

re: documents database (0.5); 

follow up call w/ N. Goldin re: 

same (0.2); draft memo to file 

re: same (0.6); call w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley re: same (0.1); review 

legal research from J. Calderon 

(0.4); email w/ N. Goldin, R. 

Sparks Bradley, and J. Calderon 

re: same (0.5). 

2.30 1,932.00 

8/2/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Prepare for meeting w/ former 

executive (0.4). 

0.40 236.00 

8/5/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Research re: Board duties (1.6). 1.60 944.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 51

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/5/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Prepare for meeting w/ former 

executive (0.3). 

0.30 177.00 

8/6/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Revise meeting outline (0.8); 

review documents re: same 

(0.9); emails w/ R. Sussman and 

K. Kinsel re: same (0.2); emails 

w/ N. Goldin re: matter status / 

next steps (0.4). 

2.30 2,518.50 

8/7/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Revise meeting outline (0.7); 

review documents re: same 

(0.5); emails w/ K. Kinsel re: 

same (0.3). 

1.50 1,642.50 

8/7/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Revise outline for meeting w/ 

former executive (1.2) and 

gather documents underlying 

same (1.5). 

2.70 1,593.00 

8/8/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review fact gathering issues 

(0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

8/8/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Revise outlines for meetings w/ 

former executives (1.1); review 

documents re: same (0.7); 

emails w/ R. Sussman re: same 

(0.2). 

2.00 2,190.00 

8/9/2019 Duran, Raul G. Prepare materials for executive 

meeting (0.1). 

0.10 59.00 

8/9/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ client and R. Sussman 

re: documents (0.2); follow up 

t/c w/ R. Sussman re: next steps 

(0.4). 

0.60 657.00 

8/9/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Call w/ Cravath and client re: 

document collection (0.3); 

follow up call w/ Cravath re: 

same (0.3); review and revise 

outline for meeting w/ former 

executive (1.4); email w/ N. 

Goldin, R. Sparks Bradley, and 

R. Duran re: same (0.4); email 

w/ client re: director document 

collection (0.3). 

2.70 2,268.00 

8/10/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review correspondence re: 

matter developments (0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

8/11/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call company counsel re: fact 

gathering (0.6). 

0.60 888.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 52

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/12/2019 Laspisa, 

Rosemarie 

Update document repository re: 

reports (0.5). 

0.50 200.00 

8/12/2019 Duran, Raul G. Draft summary of meeting w/ 

former executive (2.5). 

2.50 1,475.00 

8/12/2019 Duran, Raul G. Prepare materials for meeting 

w/ former executive (0.2). 

0.20 118.00 

8/12/2019 Duran, Raul G. Attend meeting w/ former 

executive (1.5). 

1.50 885.00 

8/13/2019 Duran, Raul G. Draft memo of meeting w/ 

former executive (1.8). 

1.80 1,062.00 

8/14/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/cs w/ clients, R. Sussman, 

Cravath re: documents (0.6); 

follow up t/c w/ R. Sussman re: 

next steps (0.2). 

0.80 876.00 

8/16/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Review Tubbs and other 

bankruptcy orders (0.4). 

0.40 592.00 

8/19/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ team re: Tubbs 

workstream (0.3); call w/ 

Company counsel re: matters 

(0.5); call w/ company re: 

communications (0.3); calls w/ 

team re: strategy/workstreams 

(0.3). 

1.40 2,072.00 

8/19/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ R. Sussman re: next 

steps (0.3); t/c w/ N. Goldin re: 

client requests (0.3). 

0.60 657.00 

8/20/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ N. Goldin re: new Tubbs 

workstreams (0.2); t/cs w/ K. 

Kinsel, J. Isaacman, M. Vallejo, 

R. Sussman re: same (0.6). 

0.80 876.00 

8/21/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Tubbs meeting preparation 

(0.2). 

0.20 118.00 

8/21/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ N. Goldin, R. Sussman, 

Cravath re: documents (0.2); 

follow up t/c w/ N. Goldin and 

R. Sussman re: next steps (0.3); 

review outline for meeting w/ 

former executive (0.4); emails 

w/ K. Kinsel and R. Sussman 

re: same (0.2). 

1.10 1,204.50 

8/22/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Call w/ G. Gough re: factual 

materials (0.5); team meeting 

re: Tubbs (0.9); review of 

2.70 1,593.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 53

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

Tubbs background materials 

(1.3). 

8/22/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Confer w/ team re: Tubbs 

workstreams (0.4). 

0.40 592.00 

8/22/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Meetings w/ N. Goldin, R. 

Sparks Bradley, E. Campbell, 

and J. Lundvqist re: Tubbs fire 

(1.5) and prep for same (0.4); 

review key documents re: 

Tubbs fire (1.0) and send to 

teammates (0.5); call w/ G. 

Gough and STB team re: Tubbs 

fire litigation (0.8); emails w/ 

STB team re: same (0.5); calls 

w. R. Sparks Bradley re: CDS 

database (0.4); review media 

material (0.2) and send to N. 

Goldin (0.1); draft summary of 

key documents (0.4) and send 

to E. Campbell and J. Lundqvist 

(0.1). 

5.90 4,956.00 

8/22/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ G. Gough re: fact 

analysis, documents (0.5); 

emails w/ G. Gough re: same 

(0.4); emails w/ J. Lundqvist re: 

same (0.3). O/c w/ N. Goldin, 

R. Sussman, E. Campbell, J. 

Lundqvist re: new workstreams 

(0.5); follow-up emails w/ team, 

Cravath re: same (0.6); 

numerous emails w/ Cravath 

team re: documents, next steps 

(0.8). 

3.10 3,394.50 

8/22/2019 Vallejo, Melissa 

A. 

Review CPP committee reports 

(0.6). 

0.60 354.00 

8/22/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

T/c w/ G. Gough re: database 

and facts (0.5); o/c w/ team re: 

same (0.5); emails re: same 

(0.2). 

1.20 1,098.00 

8/22/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Meeting w/ N. Goldin, R. 

Sparks Bradley, R. Sussman re: 

Tubbs workstream (1.0). 

1.00 915.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 54

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/22/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of key documents re: 

Tubbs fire issues (1.2). 

1.20 1,098.00 

8/23/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Meeting w/ Cravath re: 

documents/Tubbs database 

(1.9); review of litigation 

materials received from cocounsel (0.8). 

2.70 1,593.00 

8/23/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G. 

Prepare data for review (0.4); 

transmit to vendor re: J. 

Lundqvist (0.1). 

0.50 210.00 

8/23/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Meeting w/ Cravath re: 

document databases (1.9); 

prepare for same (0.9). 

2.80 2,562.00 

8/23/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G. 

Attend meeting at Cravath w/ 

legal team (1.9). 

1.90 798.00 

8/23/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Calls/emails w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley re: meeting at Cravath 

re: CDS database (0.9); meeting 

w/ Cravath re: same (3.2); call 

w/ J. Lundqvist re: Tubbs 

documents (0.2); email w. N. 

Goldin re: WSP (0.2); emails w. 

Cravath and CDS re: access 

(0.1). 

4.60 3,864.00 

8/23/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

O/c w/ Cravath re: document 

collections/productions (1.8); 

prep. for same (0.9); emails w/ 

R. Sussman and team re: new 

Tubbs workstreams (0.4). 

3.10 3,394.50 

8/24/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Review of Tubbs background 

materials (0.3) and news 

reporting (0.2). 

0.50 295.00 

8/24/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review draft court submission 

(0.8); emails w/ N. Goldin re: 

same (0.6). 

1.40 1,533.00 

8/26/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Call w/ Cravath team re: Tubbs 

fire (0.7); call w/ CDS re: 

document database (0.6); 

calls/emails w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley and team re: Tubbs fire 

(0.6). 

1.90 1,596.00 

8/26/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ team re: 

document review (0.2). 

0.20 296.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 55

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/26/2019 Lundqvist, Jacob Research re: Tubbs Fire (0.5) & 

review of news coverage (0.5); 

call w/ Cravath team re: Tubbs 

fire (0.8); call w/ CDS re: 

database use (0.5). 

2.30 1,357.00 

8/26/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

T/c w/ N. Denning, K. Docherty 

re: Tubbs fire (0.7). 

0.70 640.50 

8/26/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

T/c w/ CDS re: database use 

(0.6). 

0.60 549.00 

8/26/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ Cravath Tubbs team re: 

next steps, fact development, 

etc. (0.8); o/c w/ R. Sussman, E. 

Campbell, J. Lundqvist re: same 

(0.3); t/c w/ CDS re: documents 

(0.5); emails w/ N. Goldin re: 

status/next steps (0.3). 

1.90 2,080.50 

8/26/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of key documents re: 

Tubbs fire (1.6). 

1.60 1,464.00 

8/27/2019 Laspisa, 

Rosemarie 

Update document repository 

(1.5) and case index (0.5). 

2.00 800.00 

8/27/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G. 

Create new workspace for case 

materials from client re: 

communications w/ R. Artale 

(0.8). 

0.80 336.00 

8/28/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review Tubbs hearing notice 

(0.1); emails w/ J. Calderon re: 

same (0.3). 

0.40 438.00 

8/28/2019 Vallejo, Melissa 

A. 

Review draft Board report (0.9); 

correspondence w/ R. Sparks 

Bradley and R. Sussman re: 

same (0.2). 

1.10 649.00 

8/29/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/c w/ E. Campbell re: Tubbs 

(0.4); t/c w/ R. Sussman re: 

status, workstreams, documents 

(0.3); emails w/ N. Goldin re: 

workstreams (0.2). 

0.90 985.50 

8/29/2019 Sussman, 

Rebecca A. 

Review outstanding requests re: 

fact analysis (0.8) and draft 

summary re: same (0.4); 

correspondence w/ CDS re: 

access to documents (0.6); calls 

w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: same 

(0.5). 

2.30 1,932.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 56

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/29/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

T/c w/ R. Sparks Bradley re: 

Tubbs fire (0.4). 

0.40 366.00 

8/30/2019 Campbell, 

Eamonn W. 

Review of key materials re: 

Tubbs wildfires (0.6). 

0.60 549.00 

8/30/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Communications w/ R. 

Sussman and R. Sparks Bradley 

re: Monitor (0.4). 

0.40 236.00 

TOTAL 86.60 $75,346.00 

Task Code: Analysis/Strategy (L120)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/6/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Prepare outline for meeting w/ 

former executive (0.6). 

0.60 354.00 

8/8/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

T/cs w/ clients, R. Sussman, 

Cravath re: documents (0.8); 

follow up t/c w/ R. Sussman re: 

same (0.1). 

0.90 985.50 

8/20/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Call w/ company re: monitor 

(0.5); call w/ team re: same 

(0.2); review draft 

correspondence re: Tubbs (0.2); 

Board call (0.8); call w/ team 

re: Tubbs workstream (0.3). 

2.00 2,960.00 

8/20/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Draft material for meeting w/ 

former executive (2.6). 

2.60 1,534.00 

8/21/2019 Goldin, Nicholas Communications w/ Company, 

Company counsel, team re: 

Tubbs documents database 

(1.5); communications w/ team 

re: media (0.3); 

communications w/ team re: 

litigation analysis (0.3); call 

counsel for officers re: same 

(0.2). 

2.30 3,404.00 

8/21/2019 Kinsel, Kourtney 

J. 

Prepare outline for meeting w/ 

former executive (1.2) and 

review documents re: same 

(1.2). 

2.40 1,416.00 

8/27/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Telephonic attendance of 

Bankruptcy Court hearing re: 

0.80 876.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 57

of 58
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Sim

pson

T

h

acher &

B

artlett L

L

P

425 Lexington

A

ve

New

York, N

Y 10

017

securities action injunction 

(0.6); email to N. Goldin re: 

same (0.2). 

8/28/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Review decision on adversary 

proceeding re: securities actions 

(0.2); emails w/ N. Goldin, K. 

McLendon, team re: same (0.9). 

1.10 1,204.50 

8/28/2019 Calderon, Justin Calendar dates triggered by 

denial of preliminary injunction 

in bankruptcy docket (0.5). 

0.50 350.00 

TOTAL 13.20 $13,084.00 

Task Code: Pre-Trial Pleadings and Motion (L200)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/6/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ Latham re: 

stipulation in derivative actions 

re: CMC scheduling (0.2); 

emails w/ N. Goldin and P. 

Curnin re: same (0.2). 

0.40 438.00 

8/30/2019 Sparks Bradley, 

Rachel 

Emails w/ P. Curnin, N. Goldin, 

Latham re: securities action 

MTD (0.6); review securities 

complaint (1.3). 

1.90 2,080.50 

TOTAL 2.30 $2,518.00 

Task Code: e-Discovery - Processing (L630)

Work Date Timekeeper 

Name Narrative Bill Hours Bill Amount 

8/2/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G. 

Research documents for team 

(0.4); communications w/ R. 

Artale re: same (0.1). 

0.50 210.00 

8/14/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G. 

Comms w/ R. Sussman & 

TransPerfect re: new database 

for review (0.5). 

0.50 210.00 

8/30/2019 Kovoor, Thomas 

G. 

Prep add'l data for review 

platform (0.4); communications 

re: same w/ team per E. 

Campbell (0.3). 

0.70 294.00 

TOTAL 1.70 $714.00 

Case: 19-30088 Doc# 4521-4 Filed: 10/30/19 Entered: 10/30/19 11:04:10 Page 58

of 58