Exhibit 9



fim sntemationa: insane ior Appuea ¥ystems Analysis (UASA) * hitp://weww.emacad.org/sum.html +

The International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis
(ASA)

Membership: I[ASA is supported by National Member Organizations (NMO's) in 17
countries: the United States, Russia, Japan, Canada, Austria, Bulgaria, the Czech
Republic, Finland, Germany, Hungary, Khazakstan, the Netherlands, Norway,
Poland, Slovakia, Sweden, and Ukraine. NMO's are non-governmental scientific
organizations. The American NMO is the American Academy of Arts and Sciences.
The Russian NMO is the Russian Academy of Sciences.

Location: The Institute is located in Laxenburg, Austria, outside Vienna, in a former
Hapsburg summer palace provided by the Austrian government for a token annual
rent payment.

Staff: Of a total staff of 220 people, IIASA has approximately 100 full-time senior
research scholars. The staff is recruited primarily from NMO countries. There are no
quotas. The Director has full authority for all hiring and, if need be, firing. Scientists
are on fixed-term contracts from a few months to several years. The in-house research
staff is supplemented by an active network of 1,700 alumni and extensive additional
collaboration with individuals and organizations throughout the world. The Institute
also conducts a summer combined work and study program for a select group of sixty
young international scientists. The program's objective is to expose particularly
promising young researchres early in their careers to HASA's international,
interdisciplinary setting and research approaches.

Research Agenda: The Institute conducts policy research centered on the theme of
Global change. Projects address environmental issues (e.g., agricultural impacts of
possible climatic changes), technological issues (e.g., the diffusion of increasingly
efficient energy technologies), and economic issues (¢.g., transitions to market
economies in the former Soviet Union and Eastern Europe). The research agenda
emphasizes connections between regional policies and-global considerations.”

History: In 1966 President Johnson proposed to the Soviets an institution to build a
bridge between East and West through joint research on common problems, After six
years of negotiation HASA was founded in 1972 with 12 original members. For two
decades it maintained a broad research portfolio bringing researchers from East and
West together for joint studies of environmental, management, and policy issues. The
end of the Cold War in 1989 defined a new era for ASA. In 1990, members negotiated
a new Strategic Plan focused on environmental, technological, and economic issues of
global change. In 1994, ministers from NMO-country governments, meeting for the
first time since IASA's founding, reviewed, endorsed, and pledged their support for the
Institute's new direction.

Finance and Governance: NASA's annual budget is about $13 million. 80% of the
budget comes from core contributions by NMO's. Contracts and grants from
government ministries, private foundations, and indusiry make up the balance. NMO's
contribute according to a three-tier schedule, with Americans and Russians
contributing the most. Payments are in Austrian schillings. The CEG of the Institute is
the Director, currently Gordon J. MacDonald of the United States. There is a

OR/08/97 11:0726



a *.
a ne

PNW0-2234 HEDR
UC-000

Environmental Radiological Monitoring
of Air, Rain, and Snow on and near
the Hanford Site, 1945 - 1957.

R. W. Hanf

_ ME Thiede i

~ March 1994

Prepared for the Technical Steering Panel
and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
under Contract 200-92-0503(CDC)/18620(BNW)

= Batlelle

Pacific Northwest Laboratories

uGIH $Ezz-GMNd



1. Data on OHH OP (This meant that according to HEHF records in 1988, the
worker had been employed in operations work prior to 1979.) “A total of
44,407 workers qualified by meeting this criterion.

2. OHH79 data on MST79 (This meant that according to HEHF records in 1979
the worker had been employed in operations work prior to 1979.) An
additional 104 workers, who had not qualified under criterion 1, met
criterion 2. It is noted that there were 3 workers with OHH79 data on
MST79 where data on more recent OHH88 files indicated that initial
employment was after 1978; these 3 workers were not considered to be
eligible for the study population,

3. Current records (other than OHH OP) at HEHF indicating the worker was a
part of the operations worker cohort. To ascertain this, staff at HEHF
searched for records of workers who were on MST79, but not on OHH_OP.
Many of these workers had only dosimetry data, and had not previously
fad data on the OHH79 file. These searches were primarily conducted in

9.

An additional 36 workers, who had not qualified under criteria 1 or 2,
qualified under criterion 3. Thus, a total of 44,547 workers met at
Teast one of the three criteria.

Because it is known that the OHH files sometimes erroneously included
workers who reported for initial physical examinations, but never actually
started work, it was also required that in_addition workers meet at least one
of the three criteria listed below. The first two criteria involve use of
dosimetry records from both ORE and MST79. The use of MST79 was necessary,
because the ORE system no longer includes the records of over 10,000 early
workers, for whom external dosimetry data were available in 1979 when MST79
was created.!

A. Workers had to have at Teast one year.of onsite operations dosimetry on

the ORE file prior te 1979. 26,375 workers qualified by meeting this
criterion. Dosimetry data for these workers were taken from ORE.

8. Workers had to have dosimetry data on MST79. An additional 10,305
workers, who did not meet criterion A, qualified under criterion B. For
these workers, dosimetry data were taken from MST79. In some cases,
workers had dosimetry on MST79, had a Social Security number match with
ORE but no onsite operations dosimetry on ORE (offsite or construction

‘These records belonged to employees who left Hanford with DuPont when
General Electric replaced DuPont as the major contractor. Because DuPont had
taken exposure records of these persons with them, a decision was made that
these dose records were the responsibility df DuPont rather than the Hanford
Radiological Records program.

2.2



;
|
i
\
|
i
|
|
i
|
|

PNWD-2226 HEDR
UC-000
. DRAFT

A Guide to Environmental Monitoring Data,
1945-1972

Hanford Environmental Dose Reconstruction Project

M. E. Thiede

D. J. Bates
E. £. Mart
R. W. Hanf

March 1994

Prepared for review and approval by

the Technical Steering Panel and

the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
under Contract 200-92-0503(CDC)/1 8620(BNW)

Battelle,

Pacific Northwest Laboratories
Richland, Washington 99352



Exhibit 10



taf2

rs aes AUVIDULY GruEp

_U.S. HASA Advisory Group

Betsy Ancker-Jobnson, World Environment Center
Kenneth J. Arrow, Stanford University

Jesse H. Ausubel, Rockefeller University

Walter S. Baer, The Rand Corporation

Francis M. Bator, Harvard University

Alfred Blumstein, Carnhegie-Melion University
Chester L. Cooper, Pacific Northwest Laboratories
Floyd L. Culler, Electric Power Research Institute
Edward E. David, Jr., Edward E. David, Inc.

Peter E. de J6nosi, London, U.K.

Richard Getzinger, American Association for the Advancement of Science
Robert Herman, University of Texas at Austin

-Yu-Chi Ho, Harvard University

C. §, Holling, University of Florida at Gainsville

Manuel L. Ib6cez, Texas A&M University, Kingsville
Helen Ingram, University of Arizona, Tucson

Alex Inkeles, Hoover Institution, Stanford University
Dale W. Jorgenson, Harvard University

Richard M. Karp, University of California at Berkeley
Robert W. Kates, Brown University

Carl Kaysen, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Nathan Keyfitz, American Academy of Arts and Sciences
Judith Kildow, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Miriam King, University of Minnesota

Thomas H. Lee, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Harold R. Lenizner, National Center for Health Statistics
Henry R. Linden, Illinois Institute of Technology

Diana M. Liverman, University of Arizona

Franklin A. Long, University of California at Irvine

. Thomas E- Lovejoy; Smithsotifah Institution

Jane Lubchenco, Oregon State University

Michael Maccoby, Maccoby Group, Inc.

Gordon J. MacDonaid (on leave at ILASA)

Charles Maechling, Jr., Washington, DC

Thomas F. Malone, North Carolina State University
Robert S. McNamara, Washington, DC

John R. Meyer, Harvard University

James W. Mitchell, AT&T Bell Laboratories

Harold A. Mooney, Stanford University

John H. Moore, Grove City College

hp: //www.amacad.org/usadvis.html E

Richard D. Morgenstern, Environmental Protection Agency and Resources for the Future

Homer A. Neal, University of Michigan

George L. Nemhauser, Georgia Institute of Technology
Rodney W. Nichols, The-New York Academy of Sciences
William A. Nitze, Environmental Protection Agency
William D. Nordhaus, Yale University

Merton J. Peck, Yale University

AR INB 107 TA AT



i
|
i
|
i
{

DEMO: Software for quntitative study of population survival and demographic growth. Proc, of
IFIP/TC9 Conf. "Information systems, work and organization design", Berlin, Humboldt Univ., GDR,
1989,

34. A.A -Klementiev

Optimal contro! of an infectious disease epidemics. In: Proc. of XI All-Union Congress “Problems of
control". Tashkent, 1989. (RUSSIAN).

35. A.A-Klementiev, E.G.Shekhter

Aggregate estimate of pilots' professional health. In: Proc. of Prague Internat. Symposium "Simulation
of systems in biology and medicine" Prague, CSSR, 1990. (RUSSIAN)

36. A.AKlementiev

Model for analysis of mortality data in follow-up studies. In: Methods of data gathering and their
analysis. M., Institute for Control Sci., 1991. (RUSSIAN).

37. A.A Klementiev

Health Program Effectiveness Measurement: A Case of Degenerative Diseases. Methods of
Information in Medicine. 1992; 31: 298-302.

38. A.A.Klementiev

Modeling the impact of radioactive environment contamination on population health: an applied
semiotic approach, In: Intelligent systems: a semiotic perspective. Proceedings of the 1996
International Multidisciplisary Conference, 20-23 October 1996, Gaithersburg, Maryland.

39, A.A Klementiev

Establishing health intervention priorities for local public health agencies. APHA 126th Annual
Meeting "Public Health and Mamaged Care". November 15-19, 1998, Washington DC.

40. Paddee Buzzard, Rebecca Casey, Alexandre Klementiev, Tery Murray

We knew you could do it! Protective factors for ‘pregnant and parenting teenagers. Washington State
6" Annual Joint Conference on Health. October 4-6, 1999, Spokane, WA.

41. A.A. Klementiey.

Washington State population life tables. Eliminating certain causes of death, 1989 — 1999, Western
Regional Epidemiology Network (WREN 2000). May 18-21, 2000, Ashland, OR.

42. A.A. Klementiev .

Establishing health intervention priorities for local public health agencies. The 7° Intemational
Conference on System Science in Health Care. May 29 - June 2, 2000, Budapest, Hungary.

43. Rebecca Casey, Alex Klementiev, Dorothy Wharton Lo,

Mother and Child Health integrated database: strcture and usage. Washington State 7" Annual Joint
Conference on Health. October 2 — 4, 2000, Tacoma, Washington.

44. Omelyanets N.I., Klementiev A.A.

Analysis of mortality and duration of life of Ukrainian population after the Chemoby) catastrophe.
International Conference Health effects of the Chernobyl accident: Results of 15-years' follow-up
studies, June 4 - 8, 2001, Kyiv, Ukraine.

45. A.A.Klementiev

Measuring health expectancy based on BRFS data. 8° Annual Joint Conference on Health. October
8-10, 2001, Yakima, Washington.

46. A.AKlementiev

Measuring years of healthy life: Washington State adults 1993-2000. 19th Annual BRFSS Conference
March 11-14, 2002, Atlanta, Georgia.

47. D.Moriarty, M-Zack, R.Kobau, Z.Gizlice, A.Klementiev

Socio-Economic Determinants in Life and Health Expectancies. REVES-2003, Guadalajara, Mexico,
May 5-7, 2003.

48. A.AKlementiev

Altemative measure of years of healthy life. REVES 2003, Brugge, Belgium, May 17-19, 2004.



TEACHING
EXPERIENCE

CONSULTING

COMPUTER
SKILLS

PUBLICATIONS

Engineer, Senior Research Scientist, Leading Research Scientist (1966-1971,
1973-1975, 1978-1992).

Developed mathematical and computer models for the epidemiological studies
(1972 - 1992).

+ Developed software for prevalence estimation for different types of cancer;

- Developed computer programs for public health assessment for the populations
residing in the areas contaminated due to Chernobyl accident;

+ Developed computer programs for evaluating the effectiveness for health
program interventions; :
+ Developed computer models which are used in the Russian Health Ministry ‘
Computing Research Centers for population survival analysis; |
+ Developed mathematical models for the estimation of sexually transmitted
diseases prevalence;

* Developed various computer models for health resources allocation.

International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis / Bio-Medical Project,
Vienna, Austria. Research Scholar (1975 - 1978).

~ Developed a new approach to prevalence estimation for degenerative type
diseases based on the use of mortality data;

* Developed the computer model for estimating health resources tequirements,

Moscow City Council Research Computing Center, Moscow, Russia. Head,
Laboratory for Systems Analysis (1971 - 1973).
* Provided technical support for the Moscow city planning comuuittee.

Courses taught :

+ Business Data Processing, Tacoma Community College (1996 - Present);

+ Programming Visual Basic (Lab assisting), Tacoma Community College (1996 -
Present);

: Computer Modeling in Health Field, Moscow Institute of Physics and
Technology (1984 - 1992);

+ Systems Modeling, Moscow Power Institute, (1981-1982);

+ Automation and Remote Control, Moscow Institute for Automation and . 4
Computer Technology, (1980 - 1981). ‘

+ Biostatistics and Epidemiology, Chelyabinsk-McGill Project in Population Child
Health, Chelyabinsk, Russia, (2000).

Consulted the regional Health Ministry Computer Centers in the former USSR on
applications of mathematical modeling for epidemiological studies (Stavropol,
Moscow, Novosibirsk, Tbilishi), i

Languages: FORTRAN, Pascal, C, Extend, Visual Basic;
Software: Variety of MS DOS and Windows software - MS' Office, GIS (IDRIS),
SPSS, STATA, SAS, Crystal Ball, etc.

2 monographs and over 50 articles and papers in Russian and English on
mathematical modeling in public health related fields



ALEXANDRE A. KLEMENTIEV, Ph.D.

Present
5023 N. Mildred Street . Phone: (253) 798-3528
Tacoma, WA 98407 Fax: (253) 798-2947

OBECTIVE N/A

EDUCATION Mathematical Epidemiology (Ph.D.), Institute of Cybemetics, Kiev, Ukraine, 1991.
Applied Mathematics in Automation and Remote Control (Ph.D.), Moscow
Institute for Physics and Technology, Dolgoproudniy, Russia, 1971.
Electrical Engineering (M.S.), Moscow Institute for Physics and Technology,
Dolgoproudniy, Russia, 1966.

AWARDS Malcolm L. Peterson Award (1994, Washington Physicians for Social

! Responsibility), .

. Best Diploma Research Award (1966, Moscow Institute for Physics and
- Technology, Dolgoproudniy, Russia,).

PROFESSIONAL Tacoma-Pierce County Health Department, Tacoma, WA. Epidemiologist 0 |
EXPERIENCE — (Dec. 1996- Present), Computer modeling for Public Health related projects:
: Establishing Health Intervention Priorities;
Designing databases, such as “Mother and Child Health”, “Domestic Violence”:
Conducting projects on epidemiology.

CDC/WHO, Training Course Evidence-Based Noncommunicable
Diseases Prevention, Moscow, Russia. Instructor, (Apr.2003). Taught

. course “Introduction to the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System”.

> Chelyabinsk-McGill Project in Population Child Health, Chelyabinsk, Russia.
Instructor, (Jan.2000 - Feb.2000), Taught courses Biostatistics and Epidemiology.

Tacoma Community College, Tacoma, WA. Instructor (an. 1996-Dec.1996).
i Teaching course Business Data Processing, Lab assisting for the course
: Programming Visual Basic.

we Tom H. Foulds and Associated Counsel: Hanford Litigation Office, Seattle,
WA. Consultant, Expert witness (1994 - Present).
+ Developed computer model for estimation of radioactive Iodine-131 releases into
the atmosphere from Hanford Site in 1944 - 1948;
+ Estimated of Pu-239 releases into the atmosphere from Hanford Site;
~ Developed computer model for prevalence estimation of degenerative type
diseases.

NeuRobotics, Inc., Puyallup, WA. Senior Research Scientist (1992-1994).

* Provided professional analysis for airbome radionuclide releases including
estimates for population health impacts;

- Constructed and supplemented GIS representations of radionuclide
contamination for Easter Washington;

+ Served as scientific and technical translator for Russian scientific articles,
research papers, and texts;

+ Established NewRobotics support groups in Moscow, Kiev, and Vladivostok and
facilitated communication with these groups via E-mail.

i
i
i
i
|
|
|
|
i

Institute of Control Sciences (Russian Academy of Sciences), Moscow, Russia. °



roe

poe vey

Russell W. Peterson, Wilmington, DE

Kenneth Prewitt, Social Science Research Council
Robert H. Pry, Great Falls, VA

James Brian Quirin, Dartmouth College

Mary Martha Rabinowitch, Chicago, IL

Howard Ravi arvard University

Walter A. Rosenblith, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
F. Sherwood Rowland, University of California at Irvine
Jack P. Ruina, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Alan Schriesheim, Argonne National Labs

James K. Sebenius, Harvard Business School
Harrison Shull, Naval Postgraduate School

William J. Spencer, Sematech, Inc.

Chauncey Starr, Electric Power Research Institute
Francis X. Suiton, Dobbs Ferry, NY

Alvin M. Weinberg, Oak Ridge Associated Universities
Roger J. B. Wets, University of California at Davis

H. Peyton Young, Johns Hopkins University

Last update: 12/27/96

Return to Academy Home Page

Summary Information

TASA Home Page
US Committee for ASA

Contact Information

up: / [weve amacad.org/usadvis html

R108 107 ETA



|
i
i
}
|

}
i
i

Modelling of the health resources allocation: Case of multidimentional health resource. Ibid.
(RUSSIAN).

18. A.M-Petrovsky, A.A Klementicv, O.N-Pyatigorskaya

On the contro! of epidemics in venerology. In: Mathematical modelling in inmunology and medicine.
Proc. IFIP Working conf.- Amsterdam, North-Holland, 1983.

19. A.A Klementiev, AB.Stupin

On investigation of prevalence fo a certain disease. Ibid.

20. A.A.Klementiev

Resources allocation modelling in the health system. M.,Inst. for Control Sci., 1983. (RUSSIAN)

21. AA Klementiev, A.B.Stupin

Properties of the model of an epidemic for a certain infectious disease, N.Y., Consultunts Bureau,
Automation and remote control, 11, 1984. .

22. A.A.Klementiev

Modelling of some veneral disease prevalence. Proc. of 3-rd Internat. Conference "Systems science in
health care". Munchen, FRG, 1984. .

23. A.A.Klementiev, L.V.German

The model of health resources reallocation. In: Data analysis and expert systems. M., Institute for
Control Sci., 1985. (RUSSIAN).

24, A.A.Klementiev

Quantitative models development for solving of the health control problems. M., Nauka, 1985. 209p.
(RUSSIAN).

25. A.A Klementiev

On the control of infectious disease prevalence. 5-th World Congress on medical informatics
MEDINFO. Washington, DC, 1986.

26. A.A.Kiementiev, A.B.Stupin

Analysis of the deterministic and simulation models of an infectious disease prevalence. Proc. of 5-th
Prague Internat. Simposium "Simulation of systems in biology and medicine", Praha, CSSR, 1986.
27. L.M.Manoukyan, A.M.Petrovsky, V.KOlshansky, A.A Klementiev, R.R Moshashvili
Dispencerization: management and control. Proc. of All-Union Conf. "Informatics and computer
technology in health care", M., 1986. (RUSSIAN)

28. A.A -Klementiev, A.B.Stupin

Simulation of epidemics with the use of deterministic and Monte-Carlo approaches, In: Prac, of 1-st.
World Congr. of the BernouHi Society, M.,vol.1, 1986. _

29. A.A.Klementicv, G.L.Strongin, 1.8.Tomarchenko

On the use of demographic modelling for the estimation of the pilots professional lifespan. In:
Quantitative models in medicine and health care. M., Institute for Control Sci., 1987. (RUSSIAN).
30. A.A.Klementiev, A.M Petrovsky

On the optimal control of migration. In: Quantitative models in medicine and health care. M., Institute
for Control Sci., 1987. (RUSSIAN).

31. AAKlementiev  *

Modelling in medicine and biology for population health estimation. In: Proc. of | Prague Internat.
Symposium "Simulation of systems in biology and medicine" Praha, CSSR, 1988.
32. A.A.Klementiev
An epidemiological model of degenerative-type disease: tool for morbidity estimation. Proc. of 4th
Internat. Conference "Systems Sci. in Health Care", Lyon, France, 1988.

33. A.A.Klementiev



|
iT

Introduction

To support the Hanford Environmental Dose Reconstruction (HEDR) Project's
objective of estimating the radiation dose that individuals could have
received as a result of emissions from the Hanford Site, HEDR Project staff
developed a database of historical environmental measurements. The data from
these measurements are made available to the applicable HEDR tasks and the
public. .

Environmental sampling for radiological contaminants has been conducted at and
around the Hanford Site since operations began in the mid-1940s. This report

. provides information on the measurement of ambient environmental radiation
" Tevels in the air and on the collection of air, rain, and snow samples for

radiological analysis from 1945 through 1957. The information in this docu-
ment was compiled to assess the type and amount of data collected during these
years. No databases of historical air, rain, and snow concentration and/or —
measurement data have been created. During the 1940s and early 1950s, the
equipment and techniques used for collecting radiological samples and °
monitoring radiation levels were often inaccurate. This was due to the
newness of the nuclear industry and the haste with which the industry
(including the facilities and monitoring equipment at the Hanford Site) was
developed. The result was that the air monitoring data are insufficient for
use in the HEDR Project. Because access to these data may be of interest to
the public, however, an overview of the available air monitoring data for
1945-1957 is being published.

Data Quality Objectives
The information in this report has been compiled without analysis. The

original, purpose was to provide an overview.of the data-available. Because it- - -

was determined that the air monitoring data would not be used in the HEDR
Project, no data quality objectives were established nor were the data
submitted to a rigorous data quality review. The information presented in
this report should only be used as a guide to the original documents. The
original documents need to be consulted directly prior to use of any of the
data presented in this report.

General Information

For the most part, the data are reported here in the units provided in the
original documents. No attempt was made to quantitatively convert the data to
currently used units. Radiation exposure was reported in units of
williroentgen {mr) and milliroentgen-equivalent-physical (mrep) through the
third quarter of 1953. The roentgen (abbreviated r for old or R for new) is a
unit for defining exposure in the air to x- or gamma radiation (ionizing



93-17-06 Pizza yy

March 15; 2006

Office of Compensation Analysis and Support
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health

SEC Petition
4676 Columbia Parkway, MS-C-47
Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

Supplements to: SEC 00050,

Response to NIOSH letter of March 2°", 2006 Special Exposure
Cohort

Petitioner: Authorized Representative for Claimants
on Record with Original Petition

See Point F.2 below explaining why NIOSH.and ORAUT are incorrect -
in believing that CEDR has stored examples of records of personal
monitoring records of Hanford Dupont workers.

In addition to CEDR’s Data File Set HFC78Ao1 of the Hanford
Cohort Study, 1989 and the Hanford Cohort Study, 1993, Data File Set
HFI89Aa1, where both studies specified that Pacific Northwest
Laboratories (PNL) was the source of their external and internal dosimetry
data, and knowing that PNL has gone on record as not being able to obtain
any DuPont Hanford worker dosimetry, there is yet another study in
CEDR’s database that makes the same point.

See PNL-8449, “Description of Process Used to Create 1992
Hanford Mortality Study Database,” E. S. Gilbert, 1992.

Page1of 3



HOCKOBCKAR OPAEHA TP¥ROGorO KPACHOTO 3RAMEH

OHSAMO-TEXHAYECKMA HHCTATYT
11700, Hoscepyorat, Mocwe, v6. Tex, 108-493-648

oF,

Bumucxa 23 yueGworo mana BurycKHaKa MOTH 1966 :upe >
Knementeesa Anexcaanpa Astexcanaponinia

HaHMMeHopaune Kypcor Racns
Matemarwsecxaii ananus 380
Ananmareckaa reomerpusn 132
Anddepenunancasie ypaavernn 132
Berucauren.nas maremarnsa 9”
Teopua byuxunit kommmexciu Tepemeunttx : 85 |
Ypasncnna Matemurnucckoit gusuxn . 149
Teopermueckan Mexannxa 132
Odwas hisnka 700 |
Teopernueckas hbusuxa 149
O6mnas xuua 102

~ Maocrparmnii x3nx 520
Ocvosst utpkencpuare Hpocxraporatons 34
Ocuoses nporpamuupouanna 66
Baemenue B sxonorrto 32
Besonacnocrs usneqearensnocri 36 4
Ecrectaeuno-nayuie Kypeul no BarGopy . . : 38

— - OGinewrxenepads noxrotoRKa 34
Suexrpayeckne nem 132
Suexrponunie npuGopsr 134
” Pannoresnaxa 326
Hnynecunie 1 nirpponuie upxGapnt 66
axynerercxaa naSoparopis 224
Ochoa oSpaGora carson %
Ocaosst teopun asromarayecxoro yrpasaciuay 66
Teopua ynpapnennn s coi {HAI 1O-IKOHOMHYCCKBA
cucremax 66
Teopas croxacruuccnax cucten 98
Onrumanoice ynpapsenne s annamauccxnx cncremax 99
SBM a ocuonsi uporpammupopanna : ”
Caysaiinere nponeccst & cueremax yupaancuns 4
Asropurmmreckie Mosenn 8 Npoucecas ynpasnenies 31

Oxpana tpyna



‘je : : , . ‘upc. mipta/MIPT erecting iy

q Welcome to MIPT Home Page

Thave great pleasure in presenting Russia's most famous science and technology
educational establishment -- the Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology from which
I graduated in 1952 and of which I am now the rector.

The MIPT is the first Russian University of Physics and Technology and was founded in

1951 from the physics and technology department of Moscow State University by the
winners P.L.Kapitza, N.N.Semenov, L.D.Landan et al. Our 1,000 staff

members are working diligently with 5,000 students and postgraduates to train the best

researchers in solid state physics, chemistry, biology, high energy physics, space -
research, computer science etc.

Z
z

: The majority of the staff work here part-time, being well-imown scientists of the following |
. research centers cooperating with MIPT: .

© P.N.Lebedev Physical Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences
© P.L.Kapitza Institute for Physical Problems of the Russian Academy of Sciences
® General Physics Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences
® L.D.Landau Institute of Theoretical Physics of the Russian Academy of Sciences
© Russian Research Center “Kurchatov Institute”
: © N.N.Semenov Institute of Chemical Physics of the Russian Academy of Sciences
. © Institute of Physics and Technology of the Russian Academy of Sciences
® High Energy Institute
© General Aerohydrodynamic Institute

During the first 3 years students.receive a- fundamental university training in physics
and mathematics after which they continue their education for another 3 years
specialising in research at the Institutes mentioned above and some others. They carry
out their research together with the best scientists, and the best students continue their
research work as postgraduates for their Ph.D.

For over 40 years about 17,000 researchers and 7,000 Ph.D's. have graduated from the
MIPT and some of them are now very well known, such as:

© prof. A.F. Andreev (P.L.Kapitza Institute for Physical Problems, Moscow)
® prof. S.T.Belyaev (Russian Research Center “Kurchatov Institute", Moscow)
® prof. O.M.Belotserlcousky (Institute of Computer Aided Design, Moscow)
© prof. L.M.Barkou (Institute of Nuclear Research, Moscow)
i © prof. V_E.Fortov (N.N.Semenov Institute of Chemical Physics, Moscow)
: ® prof. L.P.Gor'kou {L.D.Landau Institute of Theoretical Physics, Moscow)
© prof. Yu. V.Gulyaeu (Institute of Radiot ics and Electronics, Moscow)
© prof. Yu.A.Ryzhov (Russian Ambassdor, Paris)
® prof. V.LRyzhit (Institute of Physics and Technology, Moscow}

|
i
i



|
|
i
i
i

Klementiev A.A. |
A.A.Klementiey: List of main publications

1. AA Klemeatiev

Optimal process with random termination. N.Y. Consultants Bureau. Automation and remote control.
6, 1970,

2. AA.Klementiev, A. Yashin

On the problems of estimation and control in health system. In: Control problems in technology,
economy and biology. M., Nauka, 1974, (RUSSIAN).

3. A.M.Petrovsky, A.A.Klementiev, ALYashin

On the use of the method of control with incomplete data in certain public health management
problems. Proc, Vith Congr. IFAC. Boston, Cambridge. 1975.

4. A.A.Klementiev

Mathematical approach to developing a simulation model of health care system. Laxenburg, Austria,
1976, 28p. ASA; RM-76-65.

5. A.AKlementiev

A computer method for projecting a population age-sex structure. Laxenburg, Austria, 1976, 26p.
TIASA; RM-76-36.

6. AM -Petrovsky, A.A Klementiev, A.LYashin

Use of the control theory methods for the solving of the health management problems. In: Biologic
aspects of the contro! theory. M. Institute for Control Sci., 1976, (Russian)

7. A.A.Klementiey :

On the estimation of morbidity. Laxenburg, Austria, 1977, 19p. ASA; RM-77-43.

8. P.Fleissner, A.A.Klementiev

Health care system models: a review. Laxenburg, Austria, 1977, 76p. HASA; RM-77-49, :
9, K.Atsumi, A.Pujimasa, S.Kaihara, A Klementiev
An approach to building a universal health care model: morbidity model for degenerative diseases,
Laxenburg, Austria, 1978, 28p. ASA; RM-77-06.

10. A.A.Klementiev
Health care modelling: morbidity estimation for degenerative diseases, Proc. of Intern. Symp.
"“Simulation-77". Zurich, Acta press, 1977,

i]. A.A.Klementiev, E.N.Shigan

. Aggregate mode} for estimating hhealili care system resources requrements. Laxenburg, Austria, 1978,

28p. IIASA; RM-78-21,

12, L.1.Borodkin, A.A-Klementiev, A.M.Petrovsky, A.IYashin

Problems in public health. N.Y., Consultunts Bureau, Automation and remote control, 6, 1979.

13. A.A-Kiementiey

Modelling of health resources allocation. N.Y., Consultants Bureau, Automation and Remote Control,
10, 1980

14. A.A.Klementiey >

Aggregate model of health resourses allocation. Proc. of All-Union Conf "Systems analysis and
modelling in health field", Novokuznetsk, 1980. (RUSSIAN)

15.. A.A.Klementiev

Modelling of the restricted health resources: The RASPR model. Proc. of All-Union Conf. "System
modelling of socio-economic processes". Voronezh, 1980. (RUSSIAN)

16. A.A.Klementiev

Degenerative-type diseases prevalence estimation. In: Applied system analysis methods in health
management. M., Institute for Control Sci., 1981. (RUSSIAN).

17. A.A-Klementiev



4.0 Overview of Previously Published Data

Radioactive emissions from the Hanford activities were released to three general pathways: the
ait pathway, the’ Columibia River pathway; and tite ground-water pathway. Historical data for the air
pathway are described in previously published HEDR docuntents listed in Sections 4.1 and 4.2.
Previously reported information concerning the Columbia River pathway is in Section 4.3. Environ-
mental data on the ground-water pathway are addressed in Section 4.4. .

4.1 Air Measurements

Historical documents concerning air monitoring data for 1945 through 1957 were searched for.
inventoried (Huesties 1992, 1993), and reviewed (Hanf and Thiede 1994). Historical sampling
devices are described in anf and Thiede (1994), along with a brief statement about the problems
associated with using historical air monitoting data collected with each device.

In general, historical measuremetits of air contamination cannot be used because the historical air
sampling devices did not provide accurate measuceniénts. The air sampling devices were difficult to
maintain and calibrate, did not exchisively monitor the radionuclide found to be the major contributor
of dose, iodine-131 (Napier 1992), and were used in only a few offsite locations, Therefore, the
historical air monitoring data were not used by the HEDR Project because the data were not
satisfactory in quality or number for dose calculations or validation of models.

4.2 Vegetation Measurements

Historical data (1945-1947) of iodine-131 (as total beta activity in 1-gram pellets) in vegetation
are summarized in Deuham et al, (1993a). Reconstructed conversion and correction factors for these
pellets to correct the 1945-1947 vegetation data to today's best, estimates of iodine-121 activity are
described in Mart et al. (1993). Uncertainty and sensitivity of the conversion and correction factors
for the 1945-1947 vegetation data are discussed in Gilbert et al. (1994). Historical vegetation data
(1948-1951) are summarized ia Hanf et al. (1993), and the conversion and correction factors for best
estimates of activity for the 1948-1951 vegetation data are described in Denham et al. (1993b). A
year-by-year overview (1952-1983) of historical documents available concerning vegetation and foods
sampled near Hanford is in Duncan (1994). Databases of historical vegetation data have not been
compiled bevond 1951 for the HEDR Project. Hanford’s Surface Environmental Surveillauce Project
has compiied environmental media (including vegetation and foods) after 1971.

4.3 River Measurements

(®) Unpublished report iproject nc. SESP-PDMS-001), Project aud Dota Management Sysiem (PDMS) Users Gade
Surface Envirormertal Surveillance Project, by L. E. Bisping, 1990, Unpublished report {project no. SESP-PDMS-
202), Project end Data Menagement System (PDMS} Database Steward's Handbook, by L. E. Bisping. 1990.

41°



Description of the Process
Used to Create 1992 Hanford
Mortality Study Database

E, S. Gilbert
J. A. Buchanan
N. A. Holter

enna

December 1992

Prepared for the U.S. Department of Energy
under Contract DE-AC06-76RLO 1830

Pacific Northwest Laboratory
Operated for the U.S. Department of Energy
by Battelle Memorial Institute

#3 Battelle

AAR. Tesuce

PNE-8449

UC-605

6rt8-INd



f nasa ~ HUD denior Kesearch Schotar http://www.iiasa.ac.at/Admin/PE/Jobs/ecssensci,html

International Institute for Applied Systems Epaun pe’
Analysis (IIASA) Usn

Schlossplatz 1, A-2361 Laxenburg, Austria + Phone: +43-2236-807 Pea uirdd

| Skulls |
| POSITION ANNOUNCEMENT
| on a

Senior Research Scholar
, Environmentally Compatible Energy Strategies Project
oo (ECS)

Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (ILASA) is one of the leading research groups
worldwide in the analysis of long-term interactions between energy, development, and
the environment. IIASA is an interdisciplinary, non-governmental, independent

;
| The Environmentally Compatible Energy Strategies (ECS) Project at the International Y
}
|
i international research organization, located in Laxenburg, Austria.

Current ECS research focuses on: : \ /

1. Contributions to the Third Assessment Report (TAR) of the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) on long-term emissions scenarios (ECS project
members served as convening and lead authors in the Second Assessment Report
of the IPCC and will continue this function during the preparation of the Third
wt > Assessmeiit Report).
2. Integrated assessment modeling of energy and environmentat interactions with
focus on climate change and regional acidification (research activities in this y

domain are mostly externally sponsored).
j 3. Methodological and model development for endogenizing technological change.

All research activities involve the development and use of formal modelin ig techniques of
different mathematical (simulation, optimization) as well as disciplinary .
(macroeconomic, engineering, ecological) orientation. Research activities are supported
through extensive networking activities (coordination of international research networks,
organization of workshops, participation in international research consortia for
contracted research) and documented in an extensive publication record both in V
peer-reviewed academic journals and reports to external sponsors.

i In order to enhance the project's human resources, we are seeking candidates for the
: position oft

Senior Research Scholar

ios

NANA 87 WIR



j

LE U2. 4ADA AaMsory Uroup- . . bitp: / /wwor.amacad.org/usadvis. him}

U.S. HASA Advisory Group

Betsy Ancker-Johnson, World Environment Center
Kenneth J. Arrow, Stanford University
Jesse H. Ausubel, Rockefeller University
Walter S. Baer, The Rand Corporation
Francis M. Bator, Harvard University
Alfred Blumstein, Carnegie-Mellon University
Chester L. Cooper, Pacific Northwest Laboratories
Floyd L. Culler, Electric Power Research Institute
Edward E. David, Jr., Edward E. David, Inc.
Peter E. de J6nosi, London, U.K.
Richard Getzinger, American Association for the Advancement of Science
Robert Herman, University of Texas at Austin
-Yu-Chi Ho, Harvard University
C. S. Holling, University of Florida at Gainsville
Manuel L. Ib6cez, Texas A&M University, Kingsville
Helen Ingram, University of Arizona, Tucson
! Alex Inkeles, Hoover Institution, Stanford University
Dale W. Jorgenson, Harvard University
Richard M. Karp, University of California at Berkeley
Robert W. Kates, Brown University
Carl Kaysen, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
a Nathan Keyfitz, American Academy of Arts and Sciences
- Judith Kildow, Massachusetis Institute of Technology
+ Mirram King, University of Minnesota
Thomas H. Lee, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Harold R. Lentzner, National Center for Health Statistics
Henry R. Linden, Illinois Institute of Technology
Diana M. Liverman, University of Arizona
Franklin A. Long, University of California at Irvine
- Themas E. Lovejoy, Srnithsonian Institution
Jane Lubchenco, Oregon State University
Michael Maccoby, Maccoby Group, Inc.
Gordon J. MacDonald (on leave at HASA)
Charles Maechling, Jr., Washington, DC
‘Thomas F. Malone, North Carolina State University
Robert S. McNamara, Washington; DC
John R. Meyer, Harvard University
James W. Mitchell, AT&T Belt Laboratories
Harojd A. Mooney, Stanford University
John H. Moore, Grove City College
Richard D. Morgenstern, Environmental Protection Agency and Resources for the Future
Homer A. Neal, University of Michigan :
George L. Nemhauser, Georgia Institute of Technology
Rodney W. Nichols, The New York Academy of Sciences
William A. Nitze, Environmental Protection Agency
William D. Nordhaus, Yale University
Merton J. Peck, Yale University



data for validation of his use of: questionable stack release data despite three
separate previous studies finding such data to be unreliable and inadequate
for any use. .

In addition to Exh. #8: Memo from Sandra Cannon to Dill
Shipler: Hanford’s Air Monitoring Program from 1945-1955, June 17,
1993, and following Memo: Hanford’s Air Monitoring Program from 1945
To 1955 ~ A Compilation of Notes, E. I. Mart, February 10, 1988, there is
also:

Exh. #9: PNWD-2226, Thiede, 1994.
“Therefore the historical air monitoring data were not used by the HEDR
project because the data were not satisfactory in quality or number
for dose calculation or validation of models.” Pg. 4.1.

Exh. #10: PNWD-2234, R. W. Hanf, 1994.
“The result was that air monitoring data are insufficient for use in the
HEDR project.” Pg. 1.

In other words, not only are Heeb’s release fractions inaccurate, but
Napier’s effort to correct HEDR is also deficient. HEDR cannot be used
with any scientific plausibility as a source for release fractions, or releases,
for any time period.

Yours truly,

eae

Page 3 of 3



;
H
|
j

“These records belonged to employees who left Hanford with
Du Pont when General Electric replaced Du Pont as the major
contractor. Because Du Pont had taken exposure records of
these persons with them, a decision was made that these dose
records were the responsibility of Du Pont rather than the
Hanford Radiological Records program.” See footnote on pg.
2.2.

Po rer

In other words, the Du Pont Hanford worker dose records are
not a part of the Hanford Radiological Records program. This
would appear to be the definitive word on the subject.

Accordingly, in regard to point F.2, The extensive documentary
evidence continues to confirm there are no individual dosimetry or bio-
assay records available for Du Pont workers at Hanford, and Petitioner
would respectfully again suggest that CEDR and ORAUT make that point
clear in their reports.

To understand the impact of the documents and expert reports that
Petitioner is submitting have upon “the limitations of existing DOE or
AWE records in radiation exposures at” Hanford, a review of the
errors or deficiencies in the steps or stages of the underlying basis of
ORAUT’s dose reconstruction demonstrate the limitations of existing
records.

Supplement of Klementiev’s Qualifications -
In regard to these errors, Petitioner had attached the expert report of
A. A. Klementiev in his Response of questions raised in the phone
conference with NIOSH and ORAUT representatives. To supplement his
report please see attached Klementiev’s CV of his enormous academic
training in physics, mathematics and in the mathematical modeling of
complex systems, and publications.

Supplement to Studies demonstrating invalidity of Napier’s
reliance upon atmospheric air monitoring.

HEDR’ chief author, Napier, made a critique of Heeb’s work which
supported some of the same points made by Petitioner’s experts and the
EPRP. But Napier depended also upon the atmospheric air monitoring

Page 2 of 3

ee



j
iH
i

i
|
i

4

Dy

Moscow Order Of The Red Flag institute Of Physics and Technology

141700 Dolgoprudniy, Moscow regian

Phone 408-42-54

Excerpt from the curriculum of Kleméntiev Alexander Alexandrovich,

graduated from M.L.Ph.T. in 1966

Course title

Calculus

Analytical geometry

Differential equations
Computational mathematics
Functions of a complex variable
Equations of mathematical physics
Theoretical mechanics

General physics

Theoretical physics

General chemistry

Foreign language

Basics of draughting

Basics of computer programming
Introduction to ecology

Life safety

_ Natural science course

General engineering

Electrical circuits

Electronic devices

Telecommunications theory and devices
Pulse and digital devices

Lab for telecommunications devices ”
Signal processing

Basics of automatic control theory

Controt theory in social-economic systems
Theory of stochastic systems

Optimal control in dynamic systems
Computers and principles of computer programming
Stochastic processes in control systems
Simulation in control systems
Occupational safety

Master's thesis work

Dean (signature)

Hours
Total

380
132
132
99
85
149
132
760
149
102
520
34
66
32
36
58
34
432 |
134

326
66.
224
66
66



ante

Tasks

http:/, /www.iiasa.ec.at/ Admin /PB/, (Jobs/ecssensci.htin}

Assumes responsibility for the advancement of the ECS set of mathematical analysis

tools. Works independently on all aspects of model development, model application,

result interpretaion, and report preparation for externally funded research contracts.

“tapreat ean tren ects,

“ete

Ph.D. in mathematics, energy-economics, operations research, environmental sciences

or similar discipline. Demonstrated accomplishments in the field of mathematical
modeling. Modeling-related programming and computer skilis (PC and UNIX

environment). Good peer-reviewed publication record. Ability to work independenitly in

an interdisciplinary and international team. At least ten years of experience in the
relevant research areas.

Appointment Terms -
‘The successful candidate will be offered a one-year, fixed-term contract,

as

soon as possible. The salary is competitive and commensurate with experience. It is
exempt from taxation in Ausiria, but subject to the principle of income aggregation. The
appoiniment includes moving and settlement allowances. An exceptionally beautiful
working environment with a true international and interdisciplinary institute are added
rewards for those seeking association with a highly motivated and productive research

team.

Applications

To apply send a cover letter, resume, plus names, addresses, telephone and fax numbers
of three work-related references, as well as copies of two recent publications/papers
{articles, research papers, model documentation, proposals, minutes of meelings, etc.} to:

Walter Foith, Personnel Administrator

International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IASA)
Schlossplatz 1, A-2361 Laxenburg, Austria

Fax:-4-43) 2236-713-13 .

E-mail: foithw@iiasa.ac.at

Review of applications will begin immediately.
For further information about the post, please contact:

Dr. Nebojsa Nakicenovic

Project Leader

Environmentally Compatible Energy Strategies Project
Tel: (+43) 2236-807-411

E-mail: naki@iiasa.ac.at

For general information about our institute, please visit our UASA web sile or go right to

the ECS homepage.

Aa Ina AT Ae