NPPTL COVID-19 Response: International Respirator Assessment

Manufacturer: Shandong Minghang Nonwoven Products Co., Ltd.

Model Tested: Dr. Dust 3-Dimensional Protective Mask

Date Tested: May 13, 2020

These findings pertain to the products labeled as Shandong Minghang Nonwoven Products Co., Ltd., 

Dr. Dust 3-Dimensional Protective Mask. The labeling for this product indicates that it meets

EN149:2001+A1:2009 (the European standard for Respiratory Protective Devices – Filtering Half Masks 

to Protect Against Particles – Requirements, Testing, Marking).

Ten respirators were submitted for evaluation. The samples were tested using a modified version of 

NIOSH Standard Test Procedure (STP) TEB-APR-STP-0059. This modified assessment plan can be found 

here.

No certificate of approval was provided with the samples received; therefore, the authenticity of the 

claims cannot be validated.

The maximum and minimum filter efficiency was 99.99% and 99.81%, respectively. All ten respirators 

measured more than 95%.

While the above-listed product classification has similar performance requirements to NIOSH-approved 

devices, NIOSH does not have knowledge about the sustained manufacturer quality system and 

product quality control for these products. NIOSH also does not have knowledge about the product’s 

handling and exposures after leaving its manufacturer’s control.

In addition, this product is an ear loop design. Currently, there are no NIOSH-approved products with 

ear loops; NIOSH-approved N95s have head bands. Furthermore, limited assessment of ear loop 

designs, indicate difficulty achieving a proper fit. While filter efficiency shows how well the filter media 

performs, users must ensure a proper fit is achieved.

This assessment is not a part of the NIOSH respirator approval process and will in no way lead to or 

preclude NIOSH approval through the official approval process. This assessment was developed as an 

assessment of the filter efficiency for those respirator’s represented as certified by an international

certification authority, other than NIOSH, to support the availability of respiratory protection to US 

healthcare workers due to the respirator shortage associated with COVID-19. Only particulate filter 

efficiency was assessed.

The results provided in this letter are specific to the subset of samples that were provided to NPPTL for 

evaluation.

These results will be used to update the CDC guidance for Crisis Capacity Strategies (during known 

shortages).
NPPTL COVID-19 Response: International Respirator Assessment

Evaluation of International Respirators

Test: Modified TEB-APR-STP-0059

Date Tested: May 13, 2020

Report Prepared: May 16, 2020

Manufacturer: Shandong Minghang Nonwoven Products Co., Ltd.

Item Tested: Dr. Dust 3-Dimensional Protective Mask

Country of Certification: China (EN149:2001+A1:2009)

Filter Flow Rate

(LPM)

Initial Filter 

Resistance 

(mmH2O)

Initial Percent 

Leakage

(%)

Maximum 

Percent Leakage

(%)

Filter Efficiency

1 85 9.2 0.00 0.01 99.99

2 85 8.7 0.17 0.19 99.81

3 85 9.0 0.12 0.14 99.86

4 85 8.7 0.01 0.03 99.97

5 85 8.7 0.01 0.03 99.97

6 85 9.5 0.02 0.05 99.95

7 85 8.6 0.02 0.05 99.95

8 85 9.3 0.01 0.05 99.95

9 85 9.4 0.01 0.02 99.98

10 85 8.4 0.11 0.15 99.85

Minimum Filter Efficiency: 99.81 Maximum Filter Efficiency: 99.99

• The test method utilized in this assessment is not the NIOSH standard test procedure that is used for certification of 

respirators. Respirators assessed to this modified test plan do not meet the requirements of STP-0059, and therefore 

cannot be considered equivalent to N95 respirators that were tested to STP-0059.

• Respirators tested may not be representative of all respirators with the same certification mark. NIOSH has no control 

over suppliers and distributors of respirators certified by other national or international parties.

• This assessment is not a confirmation that it conforms with any or all of its specifications in accordance with its 

certification mark. 

• This assessment was not a part of the NIOSH approval program. These results do not imply nor preclude a future 

approval through the NIOSH respirator approval program.

Pictures have been added to the 

end of this report.
NPPTL COVID-19 Response: International Respirator Assessment
NPPTL COVID-19 Response: International Respirator Assessment
NPPTL COVID-19 Response: International Respirator Assessment
NPPTL COVID-19 Response: International Respirator Assessment