5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	




(55,&. $0,621

	




	





(55< 2//,16

	




	



#$$%&'()
*(	(

&()	,()*(*+(&

-. /0	#(),	$

#1,2,3

+**%25

6&2677	#
7

,1






	  *%  : ##;
#9
5		&#$$%%();7*%%*1	
%,'?,)*&#$$
4 
  ! "

 : #8 7#9  #;
#9
5		
%<%)*&#$$%%();7*%%*1*%%*'	9@A		
=>
%,'?,)*&#$$%%







677	*+,*(,13%%*$$%()

1( &  $(*(* &  A*( & )? +$, ( *+:'*  )* $* (+ ( ()  '*+%*' ()( () *+*(* ;%*+ $('( B;C $+,(,$$D+,%$(3'(*%,*1)*(*%'* * ( $+,%%3 ? &' <+*1 )*,$$<*++%*'+<*+()()*+%*'*<%*()'*(()&&&*'()1(&()A*(&)?+$,




*+: '* A +<*+( ?3  )* +,( &

11<(',(+(()735*(+)%%A ', #,1,(  -E. ( () (% 6 *A(A*+*(*5*(+)%%A &,%3?3+,('F))+*<?%,(&+(,'(())*<%3%(	<%3A*(AB1< *&&*1 ++,( &C () $$(( (*1 %<*1()?# )$*( &'  ;313' )A&,()($&()?;%*+?%*<()*+*'(?&*('()A(A??*

'* A ( ' () (A '() %( 

+(?4-E.&(??*17%	()*%*(,(#)*,<*%%++'$)(1$))*',*1()??3)*$$%*+&,'3&'7%	()*%*GA%3&'()??31,&'()*??3AA*1;313')
 ! " 


,3-E/$%*+(

%%1++'$%*+*()(%$%*+ ()( )  '* ) '*)((+:()?(

;* ( (*% () $+,(*

*+<3 I,( ?3 **+(*1 A&D+,%$(3<*+();H$+(*+&J)'*+*?A,%1()*+,%$(3'(*%A()((()$+,(FD+%,&'())'*+*?:< ?+' A & D+,%$(*+%*( I,*?3B-"C)*$+(*+)?*

#((*%'*A+<*+(

()('*?(+((()G,3H+''(*'*(),1) () )* +,( A)*+) +(**(()
*(	((	,$

'*()&*%$(+<*+

+,( **1 *&&+(*< *(<*(*3   G,3 *,<*(*3 ,$$* +%*' * $+*1)+''$%++%*'()1,()(()3)$(&'*H*+($$%&'()*+**A*

'*D(&*%$$%*+(*

&)?+$,A)*+)+(*(($(+<*+(*$(*(*'( +,+( *+<3  $( & *+<3 () &'%3 ,$$+'(%*1)('*()&)?$(*(**1()<*

)*(*+(+,($%+(),$

&%%A*1+(1*2
. 
  ! "

BC<*+ %(*1( 3A*( ' 	,11A)$<**(*&*+(**&'(*?,(()$$((&()(%6??3!)'*+*A)((*&*1*($(*(*B4C<*+%(*1()%A%%;(*(*H+&( A) $% 1,*%(3 ( 11<( ??3 *++(*A*()()(%6??3!)'*+*A)((*&*1*($(*(*BC <*+ %(*1(() () 3A*( (()(%6??3!)'*+*A)$<*+*$(*&()(A*%(B.C<*+ %(*1(() ,$+( &()(%6??3!)'*+**(*&*?3();B/C <*+ %(*1 ( () +, & () & 735*(+)%%B"C <*+ %(*1 ( ;(*(*H A*< & )*5**1)(,*1$%*+I,(**1B C <*+ %(*1 ( $(*% (('( &3A*(&()+%%*'*%??*L*+%,*1()((*'3&#<*MA)((*&*(()(%6??3!)'*+*(*%BEC<*+%(*1(()??**<(*1(?3();()(++,*()'11$)*+%&*+*(*,*1()(*';(*(*%%1%3+''*((() +%% *'*% ??*()(A*(,+((*%


	,$$4". " . B	)*4C

) *(*+( +,( )%  +,  $G,*+ )*1(

('*A)()('*)A*<)*<*+,$$*+%*')+,(&,()('*)+,& ( &*%*1 () +%*'  #&( () +,  $G,*+)*1%%*'<()<()(**+*(*;%*+$('( &*% '*(((() +)*(*+( +,(*()**(*(()+*%%&'*H+%*'D+$( &(),$$<*++%*''*A $$%()*%&)* G+( +%*' %%*

 ! " & %%+(*<%3 () <*+ A

&

'*H+<*+(*($*'

((*'3 &)% A%% ';3)$*(&,()?<* A) $*(*< *(*&	<#%%??3A+*()&()(*%?3'*H(*%((

#$$%3*1()(

 ( '* A,% )< ?,&&+(?3()<*+ +<*+(* A,% )< <(&&*');3)<*+$*+&<*+,+(*+();3)<*+*%+<*+(*%(),1)'*A	( )*%* ??3 A*1 ;*(*+%(()$*(&,(()&('3*'*%$*()%<(11$)*+%

)<*+?<(:(1

+)%%1(()$+,(*H() '* ?? () (%''(  ()( '* :*+:()& &&*' () *(*+( +,(<*+A&<?%('*() $+,(*  ()( $G,,$$*&()'(*% 




()&1*1()*

()($(*(*?%A*(+,(G,1'(,%()	((
" 
  ! "

*,%3,1)()(()3++'$*	,11(<%)()$(*(*&3()(3$&(A)(A)<*+%(*1(#()3*'(*%F%(),1)A()%()(()((',((,<<3%(,$+(+**()+, &  *<(*1(* ,1) &+( +*+* A*()$+((#()3()(*&'(*$(**1()*(A*()()A%%(()<*,$*+&(A)(<*+),%)<?(,< <*H(*'3

);%*(*+%&&$(++*1

#<*<*+(*'&()	<#%%,1(??3)&&$(**+(()(<*+,%(*(*&3)((+:(()(*'&()&&#(()(%6(*%<**(*&*'*?*1()$$((&()	<#%%??3	)()((*&*()('*:*+:) * () &+ ?:*1 ?  )* ((*'3 AD('%3 '1*1 1*< () $+,(*H ()3 ()('*):*+:5*(+)%%*()):*%%*1)*'

) && $( +,% )< ? , ( *'$+)

<*H*(*&*+(*&'*((*%<**':  %( *(*&*+(* & '* (  $%*+ %*,$<*((*&*(()*%*,$*(*&*+(*(?%()*+,(*(*&*+(*&'*
$+D'*(*'*(('$((,'*()%*,$*(*&*+(*?3%*+*(*1((*'3&'<*)A*1()())?,?%($*+:'*,(&$)(3*''*(%3$*( () %*,$  <* A A*() () A*( * ()%*,$'(()'(*'
&'*)??%()A()(<*A,?%(*(*&3 '* (()(*' & () && '*H ()3 ()( () %*,$ A*'$$%3 +,+( %%A*1 <* ( ': )*(*&*+(*?()+(*&()A*(A,%)< +* ' A*1)(  ) &+( ()( <*H*(*&*+(* A ( &&+(*<%3 *'$+) $(,?((*%%3('*H*<(11*<()D('%3'1*1(,&)((*'3

 ! " $$% () 1( & )? +,$$<*++%*'





# J&% )? $(*(* A

$,,((&*%G,1'(&(
*( 	(( (*(,(* * ()?+,(':*(A*$&%+%*'A*(),(?*1?,()'*(&()(+%*' +) !"   . 
	#(*(*'&&+(*<()$$%*+?% ( '* A) $#"$
"/4
	4B# %'(&%*'

'*H&*(+%*'*?


	 E B-"C  )* +  $+*<*%(A)()$+&<?%(()++,*+*''(*%(1,*%(((+*1%( *&'(* * () $*1+3*<(*1(*1()&&

.-. EB--/C

#<*%(*+*(&()

&()?3'/4 
',((?%*)BC()(()<*+()(*(A,$$BA)()*1<'( BC()($G,*+

)$G,*+B'(*%*(3C%'(?%*)*&()*?%,(+'&()(*%)()

%(

'*1,()()*(

()$+,(*),%)<1*<( () -E/ (*%  ) +,'D+,%$(3<*+B!*(*&*
" 
  ! "

()()'**++(*A*()()(%6??3!',C*&'(*,&,%&()*'$+)'(&()$+,(*H:3A*(

'*1,()(()(*%$$(*$+(*+&()

;()$+,(H&&*++,<*+'(*%(()&(?,$$6+,&()$+(*+()$+,(A(A&*&'(*(*())'*+*?:()&*((,()(*&'(*<(()&  A I,* ?3   ) $+,( 5;*$'*((*&*()())%*())'*+*?:()()A,%)<(,D+,%$(3'(*%<(()&)):A&*(

# () *(*+( +,( ( *1*&*+( $(* & ()

,$$'(*%A&<?%('*)<*+<% () $((*% ,$+( & () +*' $<**'$+)'( <*+ *+(%3 $$%*+?% ( () '('1*1((*'3B()(&&?3#<*)% A%%C *'$+) () 3A*( () ()A%%B,+)	,11CA))$%+'*(()+&()+*'&&%((*<D$%(*&)A5*(+)%% * B'(% $*$ () () (,' ?3 $(:*+:*1C()(*+(%3$$A%%H((*'3()A5*(+)%%*);)'*+*?:$+(*+%<,?(()(()'(*%A*1*%%3,$$)%3%'( &  +%*'()( '* 1,?%*()( &'(*%*(3A)*+)**+,?%A6 ;+,%&,%(

%%* +%*' ()( '*H  +%*' ),% (

+*<'*(<*A)$+,%%3&,%(()(+%*'?3(&*($(*1*((((+,('**(*()**,*+($$%(($(+<*+(*<*A)&*(*(+&()*+%*'A*()')? $(*(*  '* ) &,%( ,% ) + ?D+, &' $$%*+(* & () +(* & $+,%&,%(

 ! " 

75(*A)A*()

',+*?(A?%+:'(%%J"N<K()5(* (% $%*+ ()( () (AB+(*+(*1A%%H((*'3+*(?()$%+()$,*+)BA)%*<+()+*?$$((?*1)(*()'*,'/N1*)A?%+:'%&'/N O(/&%&'()(%6(()(*'

'* +*() )*1)( 

?+,)(&%%()$$((B'**"NOC?,(?<3)*)*1)((+*?3 5$$ %% 5(*  *$$((  6+, () *&'3A*(*1*&*+(%3,'A 1 A*() () *(*+( +,&<?%'(*% <*+1*1();

'* % +'$%* ()( )

$*+&*&'(*1(),(% 6 ', 1*1 ?(;+3*('#()3A)A(+3*()A(A??*+,A(*+%(()&

#()3A%:A(A

**+(*1()(#()3A,%%%%*&'()$%*+())?<(*1()?*''AJ,'')(K71*+)()(%%&()'AA*1$%*+(%(3$(,(#,1,(()(%%'AA*1J%1+*(*K  ) ; (: ()
. 
  ! "

6XJJV¶V GHVFULSWLRQ LV XVHG KHUH PHUHO\ WR OHQG FUHGHQFH WR +DOO¶V

VLQFH LW ZDV UXOHG E\ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW WKDW 6XJJV¶V GHVFULSWLRQ KDG EHHQNQRZQ WR WKH GHIHQVH DW WULDO DQG WKHUHIRUH ZDV QRW D YDOLG EDVLV IRU D%UDG\ FODLP

+ *1)(*1)(3A*(
(*&*+(*

'* % * ( +*<  ,'? & +,'(

+(**1+*$(*?33A*(BA)*(((*&3((*%C+*?*1())*1)(A*1)(:*(()$)3*+% +)+(*(*+ & () $$((  #%(),1) ()(('(  ( ?3 3 ' %*'*( '*  ()',()3+(*+(A%%H((*'3()()'* +''*(( () +*' (1() ,'* ()$+,(*H()3&)A5*(+)%%***+(()$*?% ,$+( & () (% 6 ',  '*H&((13A(1,()()A(A*()A%%()(3  ()( () ,$+( A <%: ?3 ()*<(*1(*F()**&'(**+%%+(*<%3'(*%()*&

) <*+ (*%%3 +*( &  * &

*+$+*?(A()$)3*+%+)+(*(*+&'*A%%()+*$(*&()$$((&()(% 6 ', 1*< ( $%*+ *<(*1( ?33A*()3A*(*<%<A715$$%%%%75(*71*+))AA3&'*(:A&()*(('(($%*+&()&,((*&*((*%

%%%%()+:(()(%6+*?(A?%+:

' A) ( () ? G,( $* ( () ??3  	)+*?()(%%&()(A(+:3$$D*'(%3"N4OA*1,'')()()A/N"OA*1)./$,%%B+?(?3	,11C(%$%*+()( () (%% ,$+( )  %*1)( +'$%D*  )

+*$(*&()(%%'*(&*('*'**(%%()A%%?,():+'$%D*

 ! " 


()	*D()*+,*(&,$(

((1,()(&%)?$(*(*H&*%,(?<((" E/4/EB"()',(+(*A)()()*,%  	+ () +,( ',( +,(+(,%%3&+(),%A)() () (( $+,% &&*$( (( 1,  A)&+% <*A&  &% +B () %3 $*( +(( ?3+*'*% &( * ( +'&(',('((()&%%A()$+,%,%()(?3 () %%1 +(*(,(*% $G,*+K%3**()+(&'*


()A+,'*

&()&,%(()(*D($G,*+ * () $+,% &,',()A()(()%%1(*%$*?*%*(3&$G,*+?,(()( ,?((*%*<(1*&&+(*(,(*%*'*./"
	/4 B-E4C;%%*()I,(*(A)(),$$	(*&3*1()'(*%*(3I,*'?%$??*%*(3K()(()? *&&( ) () *&'(*&/4 
	(4EE

?3('**1A)()(G?()<*+(&&+%( ,

'*1,))*?

())*($()*((3A(1*<()*&
E 
  ! "

2KLR DOVR DVVHUWV WKDW -DPLVRQ¶V FRXQVHO FRSLHG WKH HQWLUH SROLFH ILOH

LQ  DV SDUW RI WKH IHGHUDO KDEHDV SURFHHGLQJV +RZHYHU -DPLVRQ

SURSHUO\ DPHQGHG KLV KDEHDV SHWLWLRQ WR DGG WKH %UDG\ YLRODWLRQV LW LV KLV

IDLOXUH WR UDLVH WKH %UDG\ LVVXH EHIRUH WKH VWDWH FRXUWV WKDW FRQFHUQV XV

+,&(+'$%3*1A*()()(($+,%,%*&(,)*(*+(+,(,%()(()+%*'A(**+($$%*$(+<*+(*$+*1*())*+,(F)A<()*(*+(+,(('*()('*))A+,&&*%*1(?*1()+%*'*)*

(( $$%  $(+<*+(* $+*1 ?+, ()J&+(,%  %1% ?* & L()M +%*' A ( ?%3<*%?%(+,%K	,$$4(" .!

$  
 .  
	 . E .EE B-E"C  ) +,($*( ,( ()( () A*())%*1 & <*+ 1%%3+(*(,(+,	+.E"
	4.444B-EEC


*('(*(()*(*+(+,((D$()+B&(

()&%)?<*(*3)*1C)*1,()(()(*$%*+&*%A*$+(?3())*$,?%*+&B()++,%**1'*H+,%C*--,*1

() (( $(+<*+(* $+*1  '*H $(+<*+(*+%*'A&*%*,--$(+<*+(*%*&A**	$('?--)*(((()$+*(()(*(+%*'())*$,?%*+&*$+(()$%*+&*%


(,'*(()(+,)?(?%*)

*()(()(()*1*%&*%,(1*<()D+,%$(3<*+(()&A)I,((()(((*%A+%%3<*%(*
$('*H*+<3I,(?&(*%()	((&)*H*+<3(('(%*(J<*+<?%2:AK5;*$'*B & () (( $+,(C '*(( ( &% )?)*1 ()( ) A,% )< 1*< () D+,%$(3*&'(*(()&*&)):A?,(*(

# & )*H +%*' ()( () (* $%*+ + A

*$+( ?3 () )* $,?%*+ & * -- '*A ()( () &*%  3 *&'(* ++*1

 ! " 

 	,11H
(*&*+(*

	,11  3A*( ( () 

*(<*A?3();	,11D();%(((*&*&(),?% ( ':  $*(*< *(*&)* (, ,( ( ? *++( *(*&*+(*(()(A,$+)A  $)(+$3 & () 3 ((*(()$)(1$)()()$)(1$)A(& ,$$*&$*(*<*(*&*+?3  3A*( ( () +*''**+,+(*1)*&? 
'$+)'(&A%%

A%%((*&3*1'*H

??3 A () +(% A*( +,'(A<%($%*+A)*+)*(*+%,AB1*< ((*%C+*?*1 '*) ',%(*$% (*' A)*% 5*('*+,%(*'$+)()*(()$*(('()*<*+

,()3A*(715$$

()(?%+:'&'/N O(/N-O()(%6A)*%+3*1?A,% )< )  (A&% *'$((*'3 *(*& A%% BA)1,11(?35$$CA+()?*(A,%''%*:%3	+*&A$)?,*'$+)A%%H((*'3,()3()('*):*+:5
4 
  ! "

7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW DOVR IRXQG WKDW VRPH SLHFHV RI HYLGHQFH XSRQ

ZKLFK -DPLVRQ EDVHG KLV %UDG\ FODLP ZHUH QRW PDWHULDO DQG WKHUHIRUH GLG

QRW VXSSRUW KLV FODLP )RU H[DPSOH WKH FRXUW KHOG WKDW D IRUP ZDLYHUGRFXPHQW WKDW -DPLVRQ DOOHJHV VKRZV WKDW KH GLG QRW ZDLYH KLV 0LUDQGDULJKWV IROORZLQJ KLV DUUHVW IRU WKH *ROG 6WDU &KLOL UREEHU\ ZDV QRWPDWHULDO EHFDXVH LW GLG QRW UHIXWH HYLGHQFH WKDW -DPLVRQ¶V ZDLYHU RI ULJKWVZDV RUDOO\ JLYHQ 7KH FRXUW DOVR KHOG WKDW D QXPEHU RI GRFXPHQWV KDGEHHQ NQRZQ WR WKH GHIHQVH DQG WKHUHIRUH FDXVH KDG QRW EHHQ HVWDEOLVKHG$Q LQYHVWLJDWLYH VXPPDU\ RIIHUHG E\ -DPHV 6XJJV GHVFULELQJ WKH WZR

SHUSHWUDWRUV ZDV KHOG EDUUHG IRU ODFN RI FDXVH H[FHSW IRU WKH IDLOXUH WRPHQWLRQ WKDW 6XJJV KDG GHVFULEHG RQH RI WKH SHUSHWUDWRUV DV ZHDULQJ DVWUDZ KDW :H DJUHH ZLWK WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW¶V GLVSRVLWLRQ RI WKHVH LVVXHV

$+*&*+ (*%  +,% ) *(*&3 () ,$+( )*++'$%*+  () <*+(*' % ( 4  "  5() %(	(%(@&, +&*(%3 *(*&* () &(  &&()((*'31*1()?,+(*%(4 

)+,(++%,()(	(*+:%)&*%(

(?%*) () $G,*+ I,* ( <+' $+,%&,%(',(,++&,%+%*')+,()%

()( () %<% & $G,*+ I,* A () J?%$??*%*(3 ()( () ,%( & () (*% A,% )< ?*&&(*&(),$$+,'()?*+%(()&K/4 
	(4E-)I,(*A(A)()*(A%*:%3()(	(*+:%H+<*+(*A,%?<(,*%*1)(&A%3*+<<*+
($G,*+ $  A)() J* L() ,$$<*+HM?+)+*<&*(*%,((*%,%(*1*<*+(A()3&+&*+K%(4E--! &/.
	(..

#$$%3*1 () ,% &  ( () *(( + ()

*(*+(+,()%()('*))A()(()<*+,$$ A '(*%  ()( ) ) ()& ?$G,*+ ?3 *( ,$$*   A D'* +(*$*+&,$$<*+&'(*%*(3

 ! " 

7KH ILOLQJ GDWH RI 2KLR¶V PRWLRQ WR 

'*(+++(*(*($*(*+(+,(&,)*H%(+  ;* ( () <*(*3 +(**1 A)()  'A*())%C ,%3 ----()$(*(&*%*+%,&A*((())*1)*%*(%3()'*+*(*%)**(%*(()*( +%% () (* $%*+ &*% &'*<(*1(*

),1),( () )*1 )*

<*+%(*1(()J+'$%(,()(*+(3$%*+&*%*&'&()<*(*3)*1()	

+$,,((,% &()44/.*()
*(	((*&()%,%&<*+*(),% ,%"%%A

)$,$&,% J*(

')?$(*(*(*'*()(*'D$I,*&
	P44/.B,% <*3+*'((%*'*(,+3D$*&+3

,%"%%A$(3(*(

&*(?+*+('$+(('(*(,+?J<%*?*&$,%()*11%'(&*%',(?'?+,()3)$$(?$)3*+%)E-E4,(),,%"()$(3*(,+&():&+'$%(A+,'(?*(,+(()
 
  ! "

%%1%3*+'$%(+,'(!)#! E  4.E-/ B()*-E"C '*I,(?(*'**&(*+,'()** ( ?G+(  ) %3 $+*&*+ +,'( ()( )*'(*A'*((

<*A<*(*3,%*1&*(*+(+,(&?,&

*+(*#%(),1),+**'*1)()<?*&&(A+(3()(()*(*+(+,(?,*(*+(**&,*1('*(()$%*+&*%&(()<*(*3)*1

A<A%(()(+(%3&&*'?3

)?*($((*'$&&*'(*<,(3(<%,(<*+$<*D+,%$(3<*+(()&&/.
	(. B1<'(),(3($<*D+,%$(3<*+<*&<I,(?3()&C   () & I,( %% D+,%$(3<*+?3$$$(*%*+<3I,(#()	*D()*+,*( ( JL?M+,   $+(*+% '((*'$%'((* & ()  ,% +('$%( ()( ()

1<'(A*%%G3',&*+(**('**1A)()<*+**($**'(*%*(*?,A*()  +$*1 ,(3 ( <%,( $((*% 

'(*%*'()(A*%%,%(*&*(*%K),-//-/-- 
	#$$9
	 4-Q" B"()*-- CB,$,?%*)C),()<*%(*%*(%3*&*%*1($<*()D+,%$(3<*+?,(*&*%*1(A*1)()<*+&$,$&*+%,)$+,(*)+,%()<$&'()(,(3*+*(A*((*%%3:$(*():1*1()D+,%$(3<*+

,*)AA)() &+(,%?*&()+%*'A

J?%3,:AK(()&(H+,%	.E"
	(444)*&*%(<%,(()+'(*%&I,*  *+%,  )* &,() &&*'(*<%3

$((()&()(&<?%<*+D*()*+(A1,()(*(A,?%&&

 ! " 

1RWH WKDW WKLV VLWXDWLRQ LV HDVLO\ GL

WKDW KROG WKDW QR UHOLHI LV UHTXLUHG GHV

SURVHFXWLRQ LI WKH LQIRUPDWLRQ ZDV DYDLODLQTXLU\ 6HH HJ 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y %KXWD

 :KHUH WKH LQIRUPDWLRQ ZDV LQWHUIHUHQFH LV QRW DW LVVXH D UHDVRQDEOHQGHIHQGDQW¶V FRXQVHO VKRXOG KDYH GLVFRYH+,%(()<+,1)(*(,$$

() &+(,% ?* &() +%*' A&(H+,%A&&*'()(+,4 ;G,*+2;+,%&,%(

;G,*+ & $,$ & $

I,*)A*1()(()&,+($*?*%*(3&$G,*+(A:()*+(,%,?((*)* (* (*% A*()  & +)   * ./" 
	+$+,%&,%($'(*%*(3%3*,)& &%%A*1 () 	,$'$+('(*%*(3

;G,*+B'(*%*(3C*()

(( ( '(2 () 	,$' ,( ()',(?J?%$?)<(,*&&(<*+(KF)<?+<*+(?<*,$$ '(*%() +<*+(*/4 
	(4-"


  () $+,(* 

*+*(#	(%(@&,()$(4  	(%(@&,((*&*+&*%A*((()?,+(*&(),$$ +,'( )A ()&%%A*1 () *+*( +,%