UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

---------------------------------------------------------------------------x

ERNEST CHAMBLEE,

PLAINTIFF, PLAINTIFF’S FIRST

AMENDED

-AGAINST- COMPLAINT

THE CITY OF NEW YORK, POLICE OFFICERS 07-CV-3551(RWS)

JOHN DOE 1 THROUGH 7 AND POLICE

OFFICERS WARREN GALLOP, NAYLINDEN JONES,

AND MICHAEL GRANSHAW,

DEFENDANTS.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------x

Plaintiff, Ernest Chamblee, by his attorney, Robin C. Smith Esq. to this verified 

complaint alleges as follows:

PRELIMINARY STATEMENT

1. This is a civil rights action in which Plaintiff seeks damages to redress the

deprivation, under color of state law, of rights secured to him under the Fourth, Sixth and 

Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution and 42 U.S.C. § 1983.

2. On June 16, 2006, Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers

Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw unlawfully broke into Plaintiff’s

home, causing damage to his home and property, arrested Plaintiff without probable

cause and held Plaintiff for an excessive period of time.

JURISDICTION

3. Jurisdiction is conferred upon this court by 28 U.S.C. § 1343 (3) and (4), which 

provides for original jurisdiction in this Court of all suits brought pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 

1983, which provides jurisdiction over all cases brought pursuant to the Constitution of

the United States.

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 1 of 10
PARTIES

4. During all times relevant to this action, Plaintiff was and is a resident of the

County of Queens, City and State of New York, residing at 121-34 133rd Street, South

Ozone Park, New York 11420.

5. During all times relevant to this action, Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and

Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw were duly

appointed and acting officers of the Police Department of the City of New York, acting

under color of law, to wit, under color of the statutes, ordinances, regulations, policies,

customs and usages of the State of New York and/or the City of New York.

6. During all times relevant to this action, Defendant City of New York (hereinafter

"City”), is a municipal corporation incorporated pursuant to the laws of the City and State

of New York and the public employer of Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police

Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw.

7. At all times relevant to this action, Defendant City operates the New York City

Police Department.

FACTS

8. On June 16, 2006, at approximately 8:00 p.m. at Plaintiff’s home at 121-34 133rd

Street, South Ozone Park, New York, Plaintiff was acting peacefully in the quiet

enjoyment of his home when Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers

Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw forcibly entered Plaintiff’s

home, which was in a locked and secure position, damaged his home and his property 

and while acting within the scope of their authority, intentionally, wrongfully, unlawfully

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 2 of 10
and maliciously arrested Plaintiff, removing him from his home in handcuffs in the

presence of the members of Plaintiff’s community.

9. Without probable cause and without any legal right, Police Officers John Doe 1

through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw,

while acting within the scope of their authority, intentionally, wrongfully, unlawfully and 

maliciously held Plaintiff against his will while he was aware of the confinement for

approximately 26 hours.

10. At the 106th Precinct, Plaintiff’s fingerprints and photographs of Plaintiff were

taken.

11. Upon information and belief, Plaintiff was charged with possessing a half of a

marijuana cigarette, which was recovered from his tenant’s apartment.

12. Plaintiff’s tenant’s apartment is a separate living space from Plaintiff’s apartment.

13. Plaintiff was released from Queens Central Booking on June 17, 2006, at 10 p.m.

14. On October 17, 2006, Plaintiff received an adjournment in contemplation of

dismissal, which was dismissed on November 9, 2006.

15. As a result of the violation of his Constitutional Rights, Plaintiff suffers from

physical, economic and emotional injuries.

FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION FOR FALSE ARREST AND UNLAWFUL

IMPRISONMENT PURSUANT TO 42 U.S.C. § 1983 AGAINST DEFENDANT

CITY, POLICE OFFICERS JOHN DOE 1 THROUGH 7 AND POLICE

OFFICERS WARREN GALLOP, NAYLINDEN JONES AND MICHAEL

GRANSHAW

16. Plaintiff repeats, realleges and incorporates in full paragraphs the contents of

Paragraphs 1 through 15.

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 3 of 10
17. Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop,

Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw had no probable cause, nor reasonable belief that

probable cause existed to arrest Plaintiff and seize Plaintiff’s person.

18. Plaintiff was at all times acting peacefully and had committed no crime.

19. Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop,

Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw intentionally confined plaintiff for a period of

approximately 26 hours without Plaintiff’s consent, while Plaintiff was conscious of the

confinement, without the privilege, right or just cause.

20. Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop,

Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw, in arresting and detaining Plaintiff without

probable cause, nor reasonable belief that probable cause existed, abused their power and 

authority as employees of the New York City Police Department and under the color of

state and/or local law.

21. Upon information and belief, it was the deliberate choice, policy and custom of

Defendant City to fail to adequately supervise and train its police officers, including

Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden 

Jones and Michael Granshaw in a manner to discourage unlawful arrests, causing Police

Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw to arrest Plaintiff with 

neither probable cause nor reasonable belief that probable cause existed.

22. Upon information and belief, it was the deliberate choice, policy and custom of

Defendant City to fail to adequately supervise and train its police officers, including

Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden 

Jones and Michael Granshaw in a manner to discourage false arrest and unlawful

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 4 of 10
imprisonment, causing Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael

Granshaw to unlawfully detain Plaintiff for approximately 26 hours.

23. As a result of the above-described deliberate choices, policies and customs, police

officers employed by Defendant City, including Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7

and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw, believed

that their actions would not be properly monitored by supervisory officers and that

misconduct would not be investigated or sanctioned, but would be tolerated.

24. The above-described deliberate choices, policies and customs demonstrated a

deliberate indifference on the part of the policy makers of the Defendant City to the

constitutional rights of persons residing within the City of New York, and were the cause

of violations of Plaintiff's rights alleged herein.

25. By reason of their acts and omissions, Defendant Police Officers John Doe 1

through 7 and Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw, acting under

color of state law and within the scope of their authority, in gross and wanton disregard

of Plaintiff’s rights, subjected Plaintiff to an unreasonable seizure in violation of the

Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments of United States Constitution.

26. As a result of the Defendants’ conduct, Plaintiff suffered deprivation of liberty

and privacy, has been adversely affected in employment and in ordinary life’s pursuits

and, in addition, was emotionally traumatized and was caused, permitted and allowed to

fear for his physical safety, suffer humiliation, embarrassment, anxiety and ridicule and

suffer all the disabling mental and emotional symptoms of such injuries, all of which may 

be permanent and have caused diminution in the quality of Plaintiff’s life.

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 5 of 10
27. In addition, the acts of the Defendant Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and

Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw were so

egregious and reprehensible and were performed in a manner which so the violates law

and which were so outrageous that it constitutes conduct that no civilized society should

be required to tolerate and, in addition to all the damages inflicted to the Plaintiff and, in

addition to all of the measures of relief to which Plaintiff may properly be entitled herein,

Defendant Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop,

Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw and City should also be required to pay punitive

damages to punish them for their reprehensible conduct and to deter them from such

conduct in the future, and as an example to others similarly situated.

28. Plaintiff, therefore, pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983, seeks compensatory damages in

this cause of action for pain and suffering for the emotional harm inflicted to Plaintiff in

the sum of Five Hundred Thousand ($500,000.00) Dollars and the additional and further

sum of Five Hundred Thousand ($500,000.00) Dollars for punitive damages making a

total of One Million ($1,000,000.00) Dollars, as well as attorney’s fees and all other

damages available under the statute upon which this cause of action is predicated.

SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION FOR FALSE ARREST IN VIOLATION OF NEW 

YORK STATE LAW AND THE NEW YORK STATE CONSTITUTION

AGAINST DEFENDANT CITY AND POLICE OFFICERS JOHN DOE 1

THROUGH 7 AND POLICE OFFICERS WARREN GALLOP, NAYLINDEN

JONES AND MICHAEL GRANSHAW

29. Plaintiff repeats, realleges and incorporates in full paragraphs the contents of

Paragraphs 1 through 28.

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 6 of 10
30. Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop,

Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw had no probable cause, nor reasonable belief that

probable cause existed to arrest Plaintiff and seize Plaintiff’s person.

31. Plaintiff was at all times acting peacefully and had committed no crime.

32. Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop,

Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw intentionally confined plaintiff for a period of

approximately 26 hours without Plaintiff’s consent, while Plaintiff was conscious of the

confinement, without the privilege, right or just cause.

33. Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop,

Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw in arresting and detaining Plaintiff without

probable cause, nor reasonable belief that probable cause existed, abused their power and 

authority as employees of the New York City Police Department and under the color of

state and/or local law.

34. Upon information and belief, it was the deliberate choice, policy and custom of

Defendant City to fail to adequately supervise and train its police officers, including

Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden 

Jones and Michael Granshaw in a manner to discourage unlawful arrests, causing Police

Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and 

Michael Granshaw to arrest Plaintiff with neither probable cause nor reasonable belief

that probable cause existed.

35. Upon information and belief, it was the deliberate choice, policy and custom of

Defendant City to fail to adequately supervise and train its police officers, including

Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden 

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 7 of 10
Jones and Michael Granshaw in a manner to discourage false arrest and unlawful

imprisonment, causing Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael

Granshaw to unlawfully detain Plaintiff for approximately 26 hours.

36. As a result of the above-described deliberate choices, policies and customs, police

officers employed by Defendant City, including Police Officers John Doe 1 through 7

and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael Granshaw, believed

that their actions would not be properly monitored by supervisory officers and that

misconduct would not be investigated or sanctioned, but would be tolerated.

37. The above-described deliberate choices, policies and customs demonstrated a

deliberate indifference on the part of the policy makers of the Defendant City to the

constitutional rights of persons residing within the City of New York, and were the cause

of violations of Plaintiff's rights alleged herein.

38. By reason of their acts and omissions, Defendants, acting under color of state law

and within the scope of their authority, in gross and wanton disregard of Plaintiff’s rights

subjected Plaintiff to an unreasonable seizure in violation of Article I § 12 of the New

York State Constitution.

39. The conduct of Defendants in this cause of action, heretofore, alleged in this

Complaint, was so egregious as to be regarded as atrocious and intolerable in a civilized

society.

40. As a result of Defendants conduct, Plaintiff suffered emotional injury causing 

plaintiff to experience pain and suffering, future pain and suffering, disabling physical

symptoms and economic injuries. All of said injuries may be permanent and all have

caused diminution in the quality of Plaintiff’s life.

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 8 of 10
41. As a result of Defendants conduct, Plaintiff has been forced to incur past, present

and future medical expenses.

42. As a result of Defendants conduct, Plaintiff has been adversely affected in his

employment and in his ordinary life’s pursuits.

43. As a result of Defendants conduct, Plaintiff was deprived of his privacy and

liberty, and, in addition, was emotionally traumatized and was caused, permitted and

allowed to fear for his physical safety, suffer humiliation, embarrassment, anxiety and 

ridicule and suffer all the disabling mental and emotional symptoms of such injuries, all

of which may be permanent and have caused diminution in the quality of Plaintiff’s life.

44. In addition, the acts of the Defendants were so egregious and reprehensible and 

were performed in a manner which so the violates law and which were so outrageous that

it constitutes conduct that no civilized society should be required to tolerate and, in

addition to all the damages inflicted to the Plaintiff and, in addition to all of the measures

of relief to which Plaintiff may properly be entitled herein, Defendants should also be

required to pay punitive damages to punish them for its reprehensible conduct and to 

deter them from such conduct in the future, and as an example to others similarly

situated.

45. Plaintiff, therefore, seeks compensatory damages in this cause of action for past

and future medical expenses, pain and suffering for the physical and emotional harm

inflicted to Plaintiff in the sum of Five Hundred Thousand ($500,000.00) Dollars and the

additional and further sum of Five Hundred Thousand ($500,000.00) Dollars for punitive

damages making a total of One Million ($1,000,000.00) Dollars, as well as attorney’s

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 9 of 10
fees and all other damages available under the statute upon which this cause of action is

predicated.

WHEREFORE, judgment is demanded:

On Plaintiff’s First Cause Of Action against Defendants City and Police Officers

John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and Michael

Granshaw for damages in the amount of Five Hundred Thousand ($500,000.00) Dollars

and the additional and further sum of Five Hundred Thousand ($500,000.00) for punitive

damages making a total of One Million ($1,000,000.00) Dollars;

On Plaintiff’s Second Cause Of Action against Defendants City and Police

Officers John Doe 1 through 7 and Police Officers Warren Gallop, Naylinden Jones and 

Michael Granshaw for damages in the amount of Five Hundred Thousand ($500,000.00)

Dollars and the additional and further sum of Five Hundred Thousand ($500,000.00) for

punitive damages making a total of One Million ($1,000,000.00) Dollars;

Together with reasonable counsel fees, the costs and disbursements of this action

and such other, further and different relief as this Court may deem just and proper.

Dated: Brooklyn, New York

October 25, 2007 /s/

_______________________

Robin C. Smith

Attorney for Plaintiff

44 Court Street, Suite 917

Brooklyn, New York 11201

(718) 403-9599

Case 1:07-cv-03551-RWS Document 7-2 Filed 10/31/2007 Page 10 of 10