II 

116TH CONGRESS 

1ST SESSION S. 2343 

To amend the Endangered Species Act of 1973 to permit Governors of 

States to regulate intrastate endangered species and intrastate threatened 

species, to amend the Migratory Bird Treaty Act to permit the taking 

of certain black vultures and ravens, and for other purposes. 

IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES 

JULY 30, 2019 

Mr. PAUL (for himself and Mr. CRUZ) introduced the following bill; which was 

read twice and referred to the Committee on Environment and Public Works 

A BILL 

To amend the Endangered Species Act of 1973 to permit 

Governors of States to regulate intrastate endangered 

species and intrastate threatened species, to amend the 

Migratory Bird Treaty Act to permit the taking of certain black vultures and ravens, and for other purposes. 

1 Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representa2 tives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, 

3 SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE. 

4 This Act may be cited as the ‘‘Endangered Species 

5 Management Self-Determination Act’’. 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
2 

•S 2343 IS

1 SEC. 2. DEFINITION OF ESA. 

2 In this Act, the term ‘‘ESA’’ means the Endangered 

3 Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). 

4 SEC. 3. FINDINGS. 

5 Congress finds that— 

6 (1) the ESA was passed in 1973 as a means of 

7 protecting and recovering species and has not been 

8 substantially revised in over 25 years; 

9 (2) the ESA has not achieved its stated goal of 

10 recovering threatened species or endangered species; 

11 (3) of the species listed in accordance with the 

12 ESA, less than 1 percent of the total number of spe13 cies in the United States have been recovered and 

14 removed from the list, largely due to data errors or 

15 other factors; 

16 (4) there is— 

17 (A) no comprehensive independent study of 

18 the costs or benefits of the ESA; 

19 (B) no full accounting of how much the 

20 Federal Government and State and local gov21 ernments spend to implement, enforce, and 

22 comply with the ESA; and 

23 (C) no meaningful effort to account for the 

24 costs the ESA imposes on the private sector; 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
3 

•S 2343 IS

1 (5) the ESA effectively penalizes landowners for 

2 owning endangered species habitat by forcing them 

3 to bear the cost of conservation; 

4 (6) the regulatory listing process under the 

5 ESA has become a tool for environmentalists to un6 dermine, slow down, or halt construction of infra7 structure projects, hampering economic growth and 

8 employment; and 

9 (7) litigation stemming from the ESA and some 

10 resulting settlements between the litigants and the 

11 Federal Government have made the ESA even more 

12 unworkable, to the detriment of species. 

13 SEC. 4. AMENDMENTS TO THE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT 

14 OF 1973. 

15 (a) DETERMINATIONS OF ENDANGERED SPECIES

16 AND THREATENED SPECIES.—Section 4 of the Endan17 gered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1533) is amended— 

18 (1) in subsection (a)— 

19 (A) in paragraph (1), by inserting ‘‘, with 

20 the consent of the Governor of each State in 

21 which the endangered species or threatened spe22 cies is present,’’ after ‘‘The Secretary’’; and 

23 (B) in paragraph (2)(A)(ii), by inserting ‘‘, 

24 with the consent of the Governor of each State 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
4 

•S 2343 IS

1 in which the endangered species or threatened 

2 species is present,’’ after ‘‘, who’’; 

3 (2) in subsection (b)— 

4 (A) by striking paragraph (3); 

5 (B) by redesignating paragraphs (4) 

6 through (8) as paragraphs (3) through (7), re7 spectively; 

8 (C) in paragraph (3) (as so redesignated), 

9 by striking ‘‘paragraphs (5) and (6) of this sub10 section’’ and inserting ‘‘paragraphs (4) and 

11 (5)’’; 

12 (D) in paragraph (5)(A) (as so redesig13 nated), by striking ‘‘paragraph (5)(A)(i)’’ and 

14 inserting ‘‘paragraph (4)(A)(i)’’; 

15 (E) in paragraph (6) (as so redesignated), 

16 by striking ‘‘paragraph (4), (5), or (6) of this 

17 subsection’’ and inserting ‘‘paragraph (3), (4), 

18 or (5)’’; and 

19 (F) by adding at the end the following: 

20 ‘‘(8) DEFINITION OF BEST SCIENTIFIC AND

21 COMMERCIAL DATA.—In this subsection, the term 

22 ‘best scientific and commercial data’ includes any 

23 scientific evidence made available to the Secretary by 

24 any State agency.’’; 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
5 

•S 2343 IS

1 (3) by striking subsection (c) and inserting the 

2 following: 

3 ‘‘(c) LISTS.— 

4 ‘‘(1) DEFINITION OF JOINT RESOLUTION.—In 

5 this subsection, the term ‘joint resolution’ means 

6 only a joint resolution the matter after the resolving 

7 clause of which is as follows: ‘That Congress ap8 proves the lists relating to endangered species and 

9 threatened species submitted by the Secretary of the 

10 Interior on llllll.’ (the blank space being 

11 appropriately filled in). 

12 ‘‘(2) LISTS SUBMITTED TO CONGRESS.—The 

13 Secretary of the Interior shall submit to Congress— 

14 ‘‘(A) a list of all species determined by the 

15 Secretary of the Interior or the Secretary of 

16 Commerce to be endangered species; and 

17 ‘‘(B) a list of all species determined by the 

18 Secretary of the Interior or the Secretary of 

19 Commerce to be threatened species. 

20 ‘‘(3) CONGRESSIONAL APPROVAL.—The lists de21 scribed in paragraph (2) shall not take effect until 

22 a joint resolution described in paragraph (1) is en23 acted. 

24 ‘‘(4) CONTENTS OF LISTS.—Each list described 

25 in paragraph (2) shall— 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
6 

•S 2343 IS

1 ‘‘(A) refer to the species included on the 

2 list by any scientific and common name; and 

3 ‘‘(B) specify— 

4 ‘‘(i) with respect to the species over 

5 what portion of the range of the species 

6 that the species is endangered or threat7 ened; and 

8 ‘‘(ii) any critical habitat within the 

9 range. 

10 ‘‘(5) PUBLICATION.—The Secretary of the Inte11 rior shall publish in the Federal Register each list 

12 approved in accordance with paragraph (3). 

13 ‘‘(6) AUTOMATIC REMOVAL.— 

14 ‘‘(A) IN GENERAL.—On the date that is 5 

15 years after the date on which a joint resolution 

16 is enacted in accordance with this subsection, 

17 each species listed on a list approved by the 

18 joint resolution shall be removed from the list. 

19 ‘‘(B) PETITION FOR RELISTING.— 

20 ‘‘(i) IN GENERAL.—The Secretary of 

21 the Interior, in consultation with the Gov22 ernor of each State in which the endan23 gered species or threatened species is 

24 present, may submit to Congress a list 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
7 

•S 2343 IS

1 that includes any species that was removed 

2 under subparagraph (A). 

3 ‘‘(ii) CONGRESSIONAL APPROVAL.— 

4 The list described in clause (i) shall not 

5 take effect until a joint resolution de6 scribed in paragraph (1) is enacted.’’; 

7 (4) in subsection (d)— 

8 (A) in the first sentence, by striking 

9 ‘‘Whenever any species’’ and inserting ‘‘Except 

10 as provided in subsection (j), whenever any spe11 cies’’; and 

12 (B) in the second sentence, by striking 

13 ‘‘The Secretary may’’ and inserting ‘‘Except as 

14 provided in subsection (j), the Secretary may’’; 

15 (5) in subsection (f)(1), by striking ‘‘The Sec16 retary shall’’ and inserting ‘‘Except as provided in 

17 subsection (j), the Secretary shall’’; 

18 (6) in subsection (g)— 

19 (A) in paragraph (1), by striking ‘‘The 

20 Secretary shall’’ and inserting ‘‘Except as pro21 vided in subsection (j), the Secretary shall’’; 

22 and 

23 (B) in paragraph (2), by striking ‘‘para24 graph 7 of subsection (b) of this section’’ and 

25 inserting ‘‘subsection (b)(6)’’; 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
8 

•S 2343 IS

1 (7) in subsection (h)— 

2 (A) in the matter preceding paragraph (1), 

3 by striking ‘‘The Secretary shall’’ and inserting 

4 ‘‘Except as provided in subsection (j), the Sec5 retary shall’’; 

6 (B) by striking paragraphs (1) and (2); 

7 and 

8 (C) by redesignating paragraphs (3) and 

9 (4) as paragraphs (1) and (2), respectively; 

10 (8) in subsection (i)— 

11 (A) by striking ‘‘subsection (b)(5)(A)(ii) of 

12 this section’’ and inserting ‘‘subsection 

13 (b)(4)(A)(ii)’’; 

14 (B) by striking ‘‘or if the Secretary fails to 

15 adopt a regulation pursuant to an action peti16 tioned by a State agency under subsection 

17 (b)(3),’’; and 

18 (C) by striking ‘‘or petition’’; and 

19 (9) by adding at the end the following: 

20 ‘‘(j) INTRASTATE ENDANGERED SPECIES OR

21 THREATENED SPECIES.— 

22 ‘‘(1) DEFINITIONS.—In this subsection: 

23 ‘‘(A) GOVERNOR OF A STATE.—The term 

24 ‘Governor of a State’ means the Governor of a 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
9 

•S 2343 IS

1 State in which an intrastate endangered species 

2 or intrastate threatened species is present. 

3 ‘‘(B) INTRASTATE ENDANGERED SPE4 CIES.—The term ‘intrastate endangered species’ 

5 means an endangered species that the Governor 

6 of a State determines is present only within the 

7 State. 

8 ‘‘(C) INTRASTATE THREATENED SPE9 CIES.—The term ‘intrastate threatened species’ 

10 means a threatened species that the Governor 

11 of a State determines is present only within the 

12 State. 

13 ‘‘(2) CURRENTLY LISTED SPECIES.— 

14 ‘‘(A) IN GENERAL.—The Governor of a 

15 State may regulate any intrastate endangered 

16 species or any intrastate threatened species list17 ed under this section that is listed before the 

18 date of enactment of this subsection. 

19 ‘‘(B) AUTHORITY OF GOVERNOR.—If the 

20 Governor of a State elects to regulate an intra21 state endangered species or an intrastate 

22 threatened species under subparagraph (A), the 

23 Governor of the State shall, with respect to the 

24 management of the intrastate endangered spe25 cies or intrastate threatened species on any 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
10 

•S 2343 IS

1 land within the State, have the exclusive au2 thority to, in accordance with the purposes and 

3 policy of this Act— 

4 ‘‘(i) promulgate or enforce any regula5 tion or guidance; 

6 ‘‘(ii) designate a critical habitat; 

7 ‘‘(iii) issue a permit or license; 

8 ‘‘(iv) develop or implement a recovery 

9 plan; and 

10 ‘‘(v) establish any goal with respect to 

11 the recovery plan. 

12 ‘‘(C) APPLICABLE LAW.—The management 

13 described in subparagraph (B) shall be subject 

14 to the law of the State in which the land, in15 cluding public lands (as defined in section 103 

16 of the Federal Land Policy and Management 

17 Act of 1976 (43 U.S.C. 1702)), is located. 

18 ‘‘(3) NEWLY LISTED SPECIES.— 

19 ‘‘(A) IN GENERAL.—The Governor of a 

20 State may, before the Secretary or any other 

21 person, regulate any intrastate endangered spe22 cies or any intrastate threatened species listed 

23 under this section that is listed on or after the 

24 date of enactment of this subsection. 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
11 

•S 2343 IS

1 ‘‘(B) APPLICABILITY.—If the Governor of 

2 a State elects to regulate an intrastate endan3 gered species or an intrastate threatened spe4 cies under subparagraph (A), subparagraphs 

5 (B) and (C) of paragraph (2) shall apply. 

6 ‘‘(C) JUDICIAL REVIEW.—Any action by 

7 the Governor of a State under this subsection 

8 shall not be subject to judicial review in any 

9 court of the United States or in any State 

10 court.’’. 

11 (b) COST ACCOUNTING.—The Endangered Species 

12 Act of 1973 is amended by inserting after section 12 (16 

13 U.S.C. 1541) the following: 

14 ‘‘SEC. 12A. COST ACCOUNTING REPORT. 

15 ‘‘(a) DEFINITIONS.—In this section: 

16 ‘‘(1) DIRECT COSTS.—The term ‘direct costs’ 

17 includes— 

18 ‘‘(A) Federal agency obligations related to 

19 the cost of any study; 

20 ‘‘(B) capital, operation, maintenance, and 

21 replacement costs; and 

22 ‘‘(C) staffing costs. 

23 ‘‘(2) INDIRECT COSTS.—The term ‘indirect 

24 costs’ includes foregone power generation costs and 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
12 

•S 2343 IS

1 replacement power costs, including the net costs of 

2 any transmission of power. 

3 ‘‘(b) COST OF COMPLIANCE.— 

4 ‘‘(1) IN GENERAL.—Except with respect to 

5 intrastate endangered species or intrastate threat6 ened species regulated by a Governor of a State 

7 under section 4(j), the Administrator of the Bonne8 ville Power Administration, the Administrator of the 

9 Southeastern Power Administration, the Adminis10 trator of the Southwestern Power Administration, 

11 and the Administrator of the Western Area Power 

12 Administration shall each include in a monthly bill13 ing statement submitted to each customer of the re14 spective Administration the share of the direct and 

15 indirect costs to the customer incurred by the Ad16 ministration related to complying with this Act. 

17 ‘‘(2) ASSISTANCE IN IDENTIFYING COSTS.—The 

18 Director of the Bureau of Reclamation shall assist 

19 the administrators described in paragraph (1) with 

20 identifying the costs described in that paragraph. 

21 ‘‘(c) REPORT.—Not later than January 30 of each 

22 year, each of the administrators described in subsection 

23 (b)(1), in coordination with the Director of the Bureau 

24 of Reclamation, shall submit to the Committee on Envi25 ronment and Public Works of the Senate and the ComVerDate Sep 11 2014 03:29 Aug 08, 2019 Jkt 089200 PO 00000 Frm 00012 Fmt 6652 Sfmt 6201 E:\BILLS\S2343.IS S2343

kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
13 

•S 2343 IS

1 mittee on Natural Resources of the House of Representa2 tives a report estimating the costs described in subsection 

3 (b)(1)— 

4 ‘‘(1) with respect to the Western Area Power 

5 Administration, on a project-by-project basis; and 

6 ‘‘(2) with respect to each of the Administrations 

7 described in subsection (b)(1) (except the Western 

8 Power Administration), on a systemwide basis. 

9 ‘‘SEC. 12B. PROPERTY RIGHTS. 

10 ‘‘(a) DETERMINATION OF PROPOSED USE OF REAL

11 PROPERTY.— 

12 ‘‘(1) IN GENERAL.—Any owner or lessee of any 

13 real property may submit to the Secretary of the In14 terior an application that includes any proposed use 

15 of the real property. 

16 ‘‘(2) DETERMINATION.— 

17 ‘‘(A) IN GENERAL.—Not later than 90 

18 days after the date on which the application de19 scribed in paragraph (1) is submitted, the Sec20 retary of the Interior shall submit to the owner 

21 or lessee in writing a determination as to 

22 whether the proposed use will violate any provi23 sion of this Act. 

24 ‘‘(B) FAILURE TO RESPOND.—If the Sec25 retary of the Interior fails to respond before the 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
14 

•S 2343 IS

1 expiration of the 90-day period described in 

2 subparagraph (A), the proposed use shall be 

3 considered to not violate any provision of this 

4 Act. 

5 ‘‘(3) EFFECT OF DETERMINATIONS.— 

6 ‘‘(A) AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE.—It is an af7 firmative defense to any civil penalty assessed 

8 under section 11 or to any civil action, civil 

9 suit, or prosecution brought under that section 

10 that the owner or lessee of real property reason11 ably relied on a determination, including a de12 termination that resulted under paragraph 

13 (2)(B), that a proposed use will not violate any 

14 provision of this Act. 

15 ‘‘(B) COMPENSATION FOR UNFAVORABLE

16 DETERMINATIONS.—If the Secretary of the In17 terior determines that a proposed use will vio18 late a provision of this Act, the owner or lessee 

19 of the real property may seek compensation in 

20 accordance with subsection (b). 

21 ‘‘(b) COMPENSATION FOR AGENCY ACTIONS.— 

22 ‘‘(1) DEFINITIONS.—In this subsection: 

23 ‘‘(A) AGENCY ACTION.— 

24 ‘‘(i) IN GENERAL.—The term ‘agency 

25 action’ means any action taken by the DiVerDate Sep 11 2014 21:23 Aug 12, 2019 Jkt 089200 PO 00000 Frm 00014 Fmt 6652 Sfmt 6201 E:\BILLS\S2343.IS S2343

kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
15 

•S 2343 IS

1 rector of the United States Fish and Wild2 life Service in accordance with this Act 

3 that diminishes the fair market value of 

4 any real property by not less than 50 per5 cent with respect to the intended use of the 

6 real property. 

7 ‘‘(ii) EXCLUSION.—The term ‘agency 

8 action’ does not include any action taken 

9 with respect to intrastate endangered spe10 cies or intrastate threatened species regu11 lated by a Governor of a State under sec12 tion 4(j). 

13 ‘‘(B) LESSEE.—The term ‘lessee’ means a 

14 lessee of any real property affected by an agen15 cy action. 

16 ‘‘(C) OWNER.—The term ‘owner’ means an 

17 owner of any real property affected by an agen18 cy action. 

19 ‘‘(2) COMPENSATION.—Except as provided in 

20 paragraph (3)(B), not later than 180 days after the 

21 date on which an agency action takes place, the Sec22 retary shall pay an owner or lessee an amount equal 

23 to 150 percent of the fair market value of the real 

24 property determined in accordance with paragraph 

25 (3). 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
16 

•S 2343 IS

1 ‘‘(3) DETERMINATION OF FAIR MARKET

2 VALUE.— 

3 ‘‘(A) IN GENERAL.—The fair market value 

4 described in paragraph (2) shall be determined 

5 by 2 licensed independent appraisers of whom— 

6 ‘‘(i) one shall be chosen by the Sec7 retary; and 

8 ‘‘(ii) one shall be chosen by the owner 

9 or lessee. 

10 ‘‘(B) FAILURE TO AGREE ON FAIR MARKET

11 VALUE.— 

12 ‘‘(i) IN GENERAL.—If the appraisers 

13 chosen under subparagraph (A) fail to 

14 agree on the same fair market value, the 

15 Secretary and the owner shall jointly select 

16 an additional licensed independent ap17 praiser to determine the fair market value. 

18 ‘‘(ii) EXTENSION OF TIME TO MAKE

19 DETERMINATION.—The licensed indepen20 dent appraiser described in clause (i) shall 

21 determine the fair market value not later 

22 than 270 days after the date on which the 

23 agency action takes place. 

24 ‘‘(C) COSTS.—The Secretary shall be re25 sponsible for all costs relating to the determinaVerDate Sep 11 2014 21:23 Aug 12, 2019 Jkt 089200 PO 00000 Frm 00016 Fmt 6652 Sfmt 6201 E:\BILLS\S2343.IS S2343

kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
17 

•S 2343 IS

1 tion of fair market value made under this para2 graph.’’. 

3 (c) PENALTIES AND ENFORCEMENT.—Section 

4 11(g)(4) of the Endangered Species Act (16 U.S.C. 

5 1540(g)(4)) is amended by striking ‘‘attorney and’’. 

6 (d) CONFORMING AMENDMENT.—Section 6(d)(1) of 

7 the Endangered Species Act (16 U.S.C. 1535(d)(1)) is 

8 amended by striking ‘‘the status of candidate species pur9 suant to subparagraph (C) of section 4(b)(3) and’’. 

10 SEC. 5. AMENDMENT TO THE MIGRATORY BIRD TREATY 

11 ACT. 

12 Section 2 of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (16 

13 U.S.C. 703) is amended by adding at the end the fol14 lowing: 

15 ‘‘(c) EXCEPTION FOR BLACK VULTURES.—Sub16 section (a) shall not apply to any black vulture (Coragyps 

17 atratus) that an individual reasonably believes to be en18 dangering any real or personal property, including— 

19 ‘‘(1) livestock; 

20 ‘‘(2) a vehicle; and 

21 ‘‘(3) a building. 

22 ‘‘(d) EXCEPTION FOR RAVENS.—Subsection (a) shall 

23 not apply to any action relating to the population control 

24 of the raven (Corvus corax) in any area in which predation 

25 by a raven poses a risk, as determined by the applicable 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS
18 

•S 2343 IS

1 State wildlife management agency, to an effort to recover 

2 a member of a species that is— 

3 ‘‘(1) listed by the Secretary of the Interior as 

4 an endangered species or a threatened species under 

5 section 4 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 

6 U.S.C. 1533); or 

7 ‘‘(2) a candidate for listing as an endangered 

8 species or a threatened species under section 4 of 

9 the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 

10 1533).’’. 

Æ 


kjohnson on DSK79L0C42 with BILLS