...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÌË

‹Ú ‹a1Æaa ±o oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥  ̈ ̧ø ̈ Æa­ ́¥ ̈ao ·2  ̨‹ ́­ ̈·o·1⁄2ø ̈·±2 ̨ ±o  ̈ ̧a 3ø­­·TMa Ã©·2 Ã±©aÆ

ø2o ...Ã› 1⁄2±3°¥a® ­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈ ́Æa­  ̄± ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧ø2 ...Ã› È ̃  ̈ ̧ø ̈ øÆaÙ ßa ̈ ø1ø·2Ù ·2o·1⁄2ø ̈·TMa ±o À2 ́­ ́ø¥

¤2aÆ1ß ×3°ø1⁄2 ̈­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ øÆa À2a®°¥ø·2ao æß “×ÕÃÚ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÎÌÚ Ã ̧a oa2­a 1⁄2¥± ́o æ¥±1⁄2μ­ ­ ́2¥·1 ̧ ̈Ú ⁄·1 ́Æa ÎÏÚ ‹øÆμ2a­­ oø¥¥­ ±2 fiø ̈ ̈aÆß –øÆμÚ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÎÎÚ À¥ ̈Æø o·2a o ́­ ̈ oÆ·o ̈­ ­μß©øÆoÚ ⁄·1 ́Æa ÎÍÚ fl oa© ­± ́ ̈ ̧Ù o±©2  ̈ ̧a ©a­ ̈ ­·oaÚ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÎÈÚ Ã ̧·­ ·­ 2± ̈ 1⁄2±2­·­ ̈a2 ̈ ©· ̈ ̧ ø 1⁄2±¥¥ø°­aÚ ⁄·1 ́Æa ÎËÚ fl TM·a© ­± ́ ̈ ̧Ù oÆ±3 o±©2 ⁄‹Œ ‹Æ·TMaÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-12 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 1 of 6
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÌÁ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÎÁÚ ...Ã›Ô ­3±μa ±æ­1⁄2 ́Æa­ ...Ã› Ó

oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2Ú × ̈ ̆­ ¥·μa ø  ̈± ̈ø¥ a1⁄2¥·°­a ±o  ̈ ̧a ­ ́2Ú

⁄·1 ́Æa ÍðÚ ...Ã›Ô oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a 2±Æ ̈ ̧aø­ ̈Ú ‹±a­  ̈ ̧·­ ¥±±μ

3±Æa ¥·μa ø °ø21⁄2øμa 1⁄2±¥¥ø°­aÙ ø TM±¥1⁄2ø2±Ù ±Æ ø o ́­ ̈

o± ́2 ̈ø·2  ̨æ ́ææ¥aÆ ̨·

⁄·1 ́Æa ÍÔÚ oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a 2±Æ ̈ ̧ ⁄·1 ́Æa ÍÓÚ ·a©ao oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a 2±Æ ̈ ̧Û2±Æ ̈ ̧©a­ ̈

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-12 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 2 of 6
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ Ïð

⁄·1 ́Æa ÍÌÚ ...Ã›ÓÙ oa3±2­ ̈Æø ̈·21  ̈ ̧aÆa ·­ ¥· ̈ ̈¥a  ̈± 2± oÆaaÛoø¥¥ oaæÆ·­ ø ̧aøo ±o  ̈ ̧a  ̨1⁄2±¥¥ø°­a ©øTMaÚ ̨

⁄·1 ́Æa ÍÏÚ Ã ̧·­ ·­ 2± ̈ © ̧ø ̈ ø 1⁄2±¥¥ø°­a ¥±±μ­ ¥·μa ⁄·1 ́Æa ÍÎÚ Ã ̧a æ ́·¥o·21 ·­ o·­·2 ̈a1Æø ̈·21Ú

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-12 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 3 of 6
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÏÔ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÍÍÚ Ã ̧·­ ·­ 2± ̈ ø 1⁄2±¥¥ø°­a ø2o · ̈ ·­ oÆø ́o ́¥a2 ̈  ̈±  ̧øTMa ­± ­ ̈ø ̈aoÚ Ã ̧·­ 3øß æa aTM·oa21⁄2a ±o 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥

·2 ̈a2 ̈  ̈± oa1⁄2a·TMa  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2Ú × ̈ ·­ ø¥­± aTM·oa21⁄2a ±o  ̈ ̧a  ́­a ±o ‹¤...Ú “± ± ̈ ̧aÆ a®°¥ø2ø ̈·±2 o· ̈­  ̈ ̧a oa°·1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o

oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ­aa2 øæ±TMa ø­ ©a¥¥ ø­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ±o  ́­a ±o ‹¤...Ú

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-12 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 4 of 6
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÏÓ

Ã ̧·­ Œ⁄›  ̧ø­ ­ ̧±©2  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a TM·­ ́ø¥ aTM·oa21⁄2a ±o  ̈ ̧a 3ø22aÆ ·2 © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ...Ã› ÔÙÓ ©aÆa oa­ ̈Æ±ßao

ø2o  ̈ ̧a ±æ­aÆTMao aooa1⁄2 ̈­ ±o  ̈ ̧ø ̈ oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ·21⁄2¥ ́o·21Ù æß ©øß ±o a®ø3°¥a  ̈ ̧a o±¥¥±©·21

aooa1⁄2 ̈­Ê

ÔÚ Ã ̧a 2aøÆ oÆaaÛoø¥¥  ̈·3aoÆø3a ±o oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2Ú Õaa ⁄·1­Ú Ì õ ËÚ

ÓÚ Ã ̧a oø·¥ ́Æa °Æ±°aÆ¥ß  ̈± ø­­a­­  ̈ ̧a oß2ø3·1⁄2 ±o ì ̈·°°·21í ±o ...Ã› Ó o ́Æ·21 · ̈­ oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2Ú

Õaa ⁄·1­Ú Á õ ÔÏÚ

ÌÚ Ã ̧a ¥ø1⁄2μ ±o oaæÆ·­Ù 1⁄2±2­·­ ̈a2 ̈ ©· ̈ ̧  ́2 ́­ ́ø¥ a2aÆ1ß aooa1⁄2 ̈­Ú Õaa ⁄·1­Ú ÔÎ õ ÓÔÂ ÓÎ õ ÌËÚ

ÏÚ Ã ̧a ì ̧±¥a­í  ̈ ̧ø ̈ øÆa ±2¥ß øoaØ ́ø ̈a¥ß a®°¥ø·2ao æø­ao ±2  ́2 ́­ ́ø¥ a2aÆ1ß aooa1⁄2 ̈­Ù

1⁄2±2­·­ ̈a2 ̈ ©· ̈ ̧  ́­a ±o ‹·Æa1⁄2 ̈ao ¤2aÆ1ß ...aø°±2­  ̄‹¤... ̃Ú Õaa ⁄·1­Ú ÓÓ õ ÓÏ

ÎÚ a ̧·1⁄2¥a­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ øÆa ·2a®°¥·1⁄2øæ¥ß æ ́Æ2ao ø­ ·o  ̈±ø­ ̈ao ø2o o± ́2o ·2  ́2a®°¥ø·2ao °¥ø1⁄2a­ ø2o

ø ̈ TMøÆß·21 o·­ ̈ø21⁄2a­ oÆ±3 ŸÆ± ́2o ÆaÆ±Â ­·3 ́¥ ̈ø2a± ́­ ¥ø1⁄2μ ±o æ ́Æ2·21 ±o °ø°aÆÚ ¤ø1⁄2 ̧ ±o

 ̈ ̧a­a ©·oa­°Æaøo aooa1⁄2 ̈­ øÆa  ́2 ́­ ́ø¥ a2aÆ1ß aooa1⁄2 ̈­Ù 1⁄2±2­·­ ̈a2 ̈ ©· ̈ ̧ ‹¤...Ú Õaa ⁄·1­ ÌÁ õ

ÎÓÚ

ÍÚ Õ ̈aa¥  ̈ ́Æ2ao  ̈± o ́­ ̈ ø­ ¥· ̈aÆø¥¥ß ø­  ̈ ̧a æ ́·¥o·21­ øÆa æa·21 oa­ ̈Æ±ßao æao±Æa ± ́Æ TMaÆß

aßa­Ú Ã ̧a­a aooa1⁄2 ̈­ oaoß a®°¥ø2ø ̈·±2 ± ̈ ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧ø2  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ±o ‹¤...Ú ⁄·1­Ú ÎÌ õ ÍÍÚ

ÈÚ Ã ̧a a®·­ ̈a21⁄2a ±o ‹¤... ·­ 1⁄2±2o·Æ3ao æß ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ·2  ̈ ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 o±3ø·2Ú

“×ÕÃê­ oø·¥ ́Æa  ̈± 1⁄2±2­·oaÆ aTM·oa21⁄2a ø2o ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 Æaøo·¥ß øTMø·¥øæ¥a  ̈± · ̈ ø2o  ̈± · ̈­

1⁄2±2 ̈Æø1⁄2 ̈±Æ­ ø2o ­ ́æ1⁄2±2 ̈Æø1⁄2 ̈±Æ­ ·­ aTM·oa21⁄2a ±o oÆø ́o ø­ ©a¥¥ ø­ ·2o·1⁄2ø ̈·TMa ±o 2±2Û1⁄2±3°¥·ø21⁄2a

©· ̈ ̧ oø ̈ø ø2o ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 Ø ́ø¥· ̈ß ­ ̈ø2oøÆo­Ú

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-12 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 5 of 6
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÏÌ

fiÀŒ‹¤“ —⁄ –Œ——⁄

×2 ø2o ©· ̈ ̧ Æa­°a1⁄2 ̈  ̈± ø¥¥ ŒaØ ́a­ ̈­ o±Æ ›±ÆÆa1⁄2 ̈·±2 ø2o ø¥¥ 1⁄2¥ø·3­ ­a ̈ o±Æ ̈ ̧  ̧aÆa·2 øæ±TMaÙ ×  ̧øTMa o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈ao  ̈ ̧a

3ø2ß ·21⁄2±21Æ ́· ̈·a­ ø2o  ́2a®°¥ø·2ao ° ̧a2±3a2ø  ̈ ̧ø ̈ o·Æa1⁄2 ̈¥ß 1⁄2±2 ̈Æøo·1⁄2 ̈  ̈ ̧a °Æa3·­a  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̨1⁄2±¥¥ø°­a ̨ ©ø­

·2aTM· ̈øæ¥aÚ × ©·¥¥ °Æ±TM·oa ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ± ̈ ̧aÆ ø2o o ́Æ ̈ ̧aÆ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2  ̈± ­ ́æ­ ̈ø2 ̈·ø ̈a aø1⁄2 ̧ ø2o aTMaÆß ÆaØ ́a­ ̈ o±Æ

1⁄2±ÆÆa1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±Æ ± ̈ ̧aÆ 1⁄2¥ø·3 ­a ̈ o±Æ ̈ ̧  ̧aÆa·2 ·2 o ́a 1⁄2± ́Æ­aÙ oa°a2oa2 ̈ ­±¥a¥ß  ́°±2 © ̧a ̈ ̧aÆ ø2o  ̈± © ̧ø ̈ a® ̈a2 ̈ “×ÕÃ

­aaμ­  ̈± ±æ¶a1⁄2 ̈  ̈± ±Æ ± ̈ ̧aÆ©·­a ø­­aÆ ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ±2a ±Æ 3±Æa ±o  ̈ ̧a ÆaØ ́a­ ̈­ o±Æ 1⁄2±ÆÆa1⁄2 ̈·±2 1⁄2±2 ̈ø·2ao  ̧aÆa·2 øÆa 2± ̈

ø1⁄21⁄2a° ̈øæ¥a  ̈± · ̈Ú Ã ̧a æa ̈ ̈aÆ 1⁄2± ́Æ­a ±o ø1⁄2 ̈·±2 ©± ́¥o æa o±Æ “×ÕÃÙ ø1⁄2 ̈·21 æß ø2o  ̈ ̧Æ± ́1 ̧ · ̈­ ±oo·1⁄2·ø¥ oa1⁄2·­·±2

3øμ·21 °Æ±1⁄2a­­Ù ø2oÒ±Æ æø­ao ±2 °aÆ­±2­ ©· ̈ ̧ μ2±©¥ao1a TM±¥ ́2 ̈øÆ·¥ß 1⁄2±3·21 o±Æ©øÆo  ̈± o± ­±Ù  ̈± ·­­ ́a  ̈ ̧a

2a1⁄2a­­øÆß 1⁄2±ÆÆa1⁄2 ̈·±2­ ø2o  ̈øμa ± ̈ ̧aÆ ø°°Æ±°Æ·ø ̈a ø1⁄2 ̈·±2 o±Æ ̈ ̧©· ̈ ̧Ú

×  ̧øTMa ­a ̈ o±Æ ̈ ̧ ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 1⁄2±2o·Æ3·21  ̈ ̧a a®·­ ̈a21⁄2a ±o ­·12·o·1⁄2ø2 ̈ aTM·oa21⁄2a ±o ìÀ2 ́­ ́ø¥ a2aÆ1ß ·3°ø1⁄2 ̈­í  ̈ ̧ø ̈

øÆa 1⁄2±2­·­ ̈a2 ̈ ©· ̈ ̧ ‹·Æa1⁄2 ̈ao ¤2aÆ1ß ...aø°±2­  ̄‹¤... ̃  ̧øTM·21 æaa2  ́­ao ø­ ø 1⁄2ø ́­ø¥ oø1⁄2 ̈±Æ ·2  ̈ ̧a oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o

 ̈ ̧a ...±Æ¥o ÃÆøoa ›a2 ̈aÆ 1⁄2±3°¥a® ±2 ÔÔ Õa° ̈a3æaÆÙ ÓððÔÚ Ã ̧·­ aTM·oa21⁄2a ø°°aøÆ­  ̈±  ̧øTMa æaa2 ·12±Æao  ̈ ̧ ́­ oøÆÙ

æ ́ ̈ 1⁄2ø22± ̈ Æaø­±2øæ¥ß æa ·12±Æao ø2ß ¥±21aÆÚ × ø3 ø©øÆa  ̈ ̧ø ̈ × ø3  ̧aÆa ø­­aÆ ̈·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a aTM·oa21⁄2a °Æa­a2 ̈ao ·­

1⁄2±2­·­ ̈a2 ̈ ©· ̈ ̧ °±­­·æ¥a 1⁄2Æ·3·2ø¥· ̈ß ø2o oÆø ́o ±o ø2  ́2°Æa1⁄2aoa2 ̈ao ­1⁄2ø¥aÚ ”±Æa±TMaÆÙ ± ̈ ̧aÆ ø2o o ́Æ ̈ ̧aÆ ­aÆ·± ́­

©Æ±21o±·21 ·­ Æaøo·¥ß ø°°øÆa2 ̈ ·2  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a øæ ́2oø2 ̈ aTM·oa21⁄2a ·2 ­ ́°°±Æ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a­a 1⁄2±2 ̈a2 ̈·±2­ ­ ̧± ́¥o  ̧øTMa æaa2

±æTM·± ́­  ̈± 1⁄2±3°a ̈a2 ̈ ·2TMa­ ̈·1ø ̈±Æ­Ù æa  ̈ ̧aß 1±TMaÆ23a2 ̈ø¥ ±oo·1⁄2·ø¥­ ±Æ 1⁄2±2 ̈Æø1⁄2 ̈±Æ­Ú Õ±3a aTM·oa21⁄2a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 3·1 ̧ ̈

 ̧øTMa °Æ±3° ̈¥ß ø2o aooa1⁄2 ̈·TMa¥ß ÆaTMaø¥ao  ̈ ̧a °Æa­a21⁄2a ±o  ́2 ́­ ́ø¥ a2aÆ1ß aooa1⁄2 ̈­ ©ø­ a· ̈ ̧aÆ ·12±Æao ±Æ oaø¥ ̈ ©· ̈ ̧

·2 ø oa1⁄2a° ̈·TMa ±Æ 3·­¥aøo·21 3ø22aÆÙ ·21⁄2¥ ́o·21Ù æß ©øß ±o a®ø3°¥aÙ oa¥·æaÆø ̈a ø¥ ̈aÆø ̈·±2 ±o aTM·oa21⁄2a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ©ø­

1⁄2±2­·­ ̈a2 ̈ ©· ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a  ́­a ±o o·Æa1⁄2 ̈ao a2aÆ1ß ©aø°±2­Ú

fiø­ao  ́°±2 ø¥¥ ±o  ̈ ̧a o±Æa1±·21Ù “›ÕÃflŒ Ô 3 ́­ ̈ æa Æa ̈Æø1⁄2 ̈ao ·2 · ̈­ a2 ̈·Æa ̈ß ø2o “×ÕÃ 3 ́­ ̈ ø1⁄2μ2±©¥ao1a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ · ̈

·­ o±·21 ­± æa1⁄2ø ́­a  ̈ ̧a o±1⁄2 ́3a2 ̈ ·­ oÆø ́o ́¥a2 ̈Ù 3·­¥aøo·21 ±Æ oa1⁄2a° ̈·TMaÙ ±Æ ø¥¥ ±o  ̈ ̧a­aÚ

fiß 1⁄2±°ß ±o  ̈ ̧·­ ›±ÆÆa1⁄2 ̈·±2 ŒaØ ́a­ ̈  ̈± 3ß 1⁄2± ́2­a¥Ù ÷aÆÆß Ú ‘aø° ̧øÆ ̈ ø2o fl­­±1⁄2·ø ̈a­Ù –Ú›ÚÙ ×  ̧aÆaæß ÆaØ ́a­ ̈  ̈ ̧ø ̈

 ̧a o·¥a ­ ́1⁄2 ̧ ± ̈ ̧aÆ ø2o o ́Æ ̈ ̧aÆ ÆaØ ́a­ ̈­ o±Æ Æa¥·ao ø­ 3øß æa ­ ́· ̈øæ¥a æø­ao ±2  ̈ ̧a ±Æ·1·2ø¥ ­± ́Æ1⁄2a ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2

­ ́æ3· ̈ ̈ao  ̧aÆa·2Ú

Œa­°a1⁄2 ̈o ́¥¥ß ­ ́æ3· ̈ ̈aoÙ

‹ÆÚ ÷ ́oß ...±±o

›1⁄2

÷aÆÆß Ú ‘aø° ̧øÆ ̈

Ë ...a­ ̈ Õ ̈Æaa ̈

Õ ́· ̈a ÓðÌ

‹ø2æ ́ÆßÙ ›Ã ðÍËÔð

°ÛÓðÌÛËÓÎÛÍÓÍÎ

oÛÓðÌÛËÓÎÛÍÓÎÍ

÷­¥aø° ̧øÆ ̈‡1⁄2­Ú1⁄2±3

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-12 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 6 of 6