...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÓÓ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÓÓÚ Ã ̧·­ ° ̧± ̈±  ̧·1 ̧¥·1 ̧ ̈­  ̈ ̧a oa° ̈ ̧ ±o  ̈ ̧a  ̧±¥a ·2 ...Ã›ÍÚ Ã ̧a  ̨­3±μa ̨ ±Æ ° ́¥TMaÆ·¶ao o ́­ ̈ oÆ±3

oaæÆ·­ ø°°aøÆ­  ̈±  ̧øTMa o·3·2·­ ̧ao ·2 1⁄2±3°øÆ·­±2  ̈± ⁄·1 ́Æa ÓðÚ ... ̧·¥a  ̈ ̧aÆa ·­ øæ ́2oø21⁄2a ±o ø¥ ́3·2 ́3

1⁄2¥øoo·21 ±2  ̈ ̧a Æ±±o­ ±o æ ́·¥o·21­ Î ø2o ÍÙ  ̈ ̧aÆa ·­ ¥· ̈ ̈¥a ±Æ 2±2a ·2  ̈ ̧a  ̧±¥a­Ú

⁄·1 ́Æa ÓÌÚ “± ̈·1⁄2a  ̧±© ­ ̈Æø·1 ̧ ̈  ̈ ̧a TMaÆ ̈·1⁄2ø¥  ̧±¥a­ ©aÆa  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 1⁄2 ́ ̈ o±©2  ̈ ̧Æ± ́1 ̧ ...Ã›ÍÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-10 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 1 of 9
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÓÌ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÓÏÚ fl TM·a© ±TMaÆ  ̈ ̧a o±3a ±o ...⁄›Ó ­ ̧±©­  ̈ ̧a oø3ø1a  ̈± ...Ã›Í ·2  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2a2 ̈aÆ ±o  ̈ ̧a ° ̧± ̈±Ú Ã±  ̈ ̧a

¥ao ̈ ·­  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±¥¥ø°­ao ...Ã›ÈÚ × ̈­ oaæÆ·­ ­ ̈ø1⁄2μ ·­ ø ̈ ¥aø­ ̈ o·TMa ­ ̈±Æ·a­  ̧·1 ̧Ú Ã±  ̈ ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈ ±o ...Ã›Í ·­  ̈ ̧a

Æa3ø·2·21 2±Æ ̈ ̧ ©ø¥¥ ±o ...Ã›Ô © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ¥aø2­  ̈±©øÆo ...Ã›ÍÚ ... ̧aÆa o·o  ̈ ̧a ©ø¥¥ 1±· ... ̧aÆa o·o  ̈ ̧a  ̈±° Ôðð

o¥±±Æ­ ±o  ̈ ̧a 2±Æ ̈ ̧ ©ø¥¥ 1±· Ã ̧aß o·o 2± ̈ oø¥¥ ±2 ...Ã›Í ±Æ ...Ã›È æa1⁄2ø ́­a  ̈ ̧aÆa øÆa 2± ­ ̈aa¥ © ̧aø ̈1⁄2 ̧a®  ̈ ̧aÆaÚ

Õ±3a ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±Æa ±o ...Ã›Ô Æa3ø·2­Ù æ ́ ̈ © ̧aÆa ·­  ̈ ̧a Æa­ ̈ ±o  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2±Æa· Ã ̧a ø3± ́2 ̈ ±o ­ ̈aa¥ ±2  ̈ ̧a 1Æ± ́2o

æøÆa¥ß 1⁄2±TMaÆ­  ̈ ̧a 1Æ± ́2oÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-10 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 2 of 9
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÓÏ

fiÚ fl¥3±­ ̈ 1⁄2±3°¥a ̈a ¥ø1⁄2μ ±o Æ ́ææ¥a  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ·­ ¥·μa©·­a ·2o·1⁄2ø ̈·TMa ±o À2 ́­ ́ø¥ ¤2aÆ1ß ×3°ø1⁄2 ̈­

⁄·1 ́Æa ÓÎÚ fl ° ̧± ̈±  ̈øμa2 æß “—flfl ·33ao·ø ̈a¥ß o±¥¥±©·21 ÁÒÔÔÚ  ̄ÁÒÔÌÒðÔ ̃

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-10 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 3 of 9
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÓÎ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÓÍÚ ”±­ ̈ ±o ...Ã›Ì o·­ø°°aøÆao o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o ...Ã›ÔÚ Ã ̧a °aoa­ ̈Æ·ø2 ©ø¥μ©øß

±TMaÆ  ̈ ̧a ...a­ ̈ Õ·oa ÿ·1 ̧©øß ©ø­ 1⁄2±22a1⁄2 ̈ao  ̈± ­±3a ̈ ̧·21  ̈ ̧ø ̈ ·­ 2± ¥±21aÆ  ̈ ̧aÆaÚ Ã ̧a Æa3ø·2­ ±o

...Ã›Ó 1⁄2ø2 æa ­aa2 2aøÆ  ̈ ̧a 1⁄2a2 ̈aÆ ±o  ̈ ̧a ° ̧± ̈± ø2o  ̈ ̧a Æa3ø·2­ ±o ...Ã›Ô øÆa °øÆ ̈¥ß TM·­·æ¥a ·2  ̈ ̧a

¥±©aÆ Æ·1 ̧ ̈ 1⁄2±Æ2aÆÚ

 ̨fi ́·¥o·21 TMø°±Æ ̨ ©øo ̈­  ́° oÆ±3  ̈ ̧a ...Ã›Ô ø2o ...Ã›Ó  ̨°·¥a­Ú ̨ ... ̧aÆa ·­ · ̈ 1⁄2±3·21 oÆ±3· × ̈ Æa­a3æ¥a­

­ ̈aø3 ±oo ±o ø 3ø2 ́Æa °·¥aÚ × ̈ o±a­ 2± ̈ ­aa3  ̈± ±Æ·1·2ø ̈a oÆ±3 ø ­·21¥a °±·2 ̈Ù æ ́ ̈ Æ·­a­ ±TMaÆ ø ©·oa

¶±2aÙ ¥·μa ø  ̧ø¶a ·2 ø oø·Æ¥ß  ́2·o±Æ3 oø­ ̧·±2Ú

⁄·1 ́Æa ÓÈÚ Ã ̧a ...Ã› °¥ø¶ø æao±Æa ÁÒÔÔÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-10 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 4 of 9
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÓÍ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÓËÚ ÿaÆa ·­ ø Æa3·2oaÆ ±o  ̈ ̧a 3ø ̈aÆ·ø¥  ̈ ̧ø ̈ 3 ́­ ̈ æa ø1⁄21⁄2± ́2 ̈ao o±Æ ·2  ̈ ̧a Æ ́ææ¥a °·¥aÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-10 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 5 of 9
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÓÈ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÓÁÚ ...Ã›Í ­ ́°°±Æ ̈­  ̈ ̧a ¥aø2·21 Æa3ø·2­ ±o  ̈ ̧a 2±Æ ̈ ̧ ©ø¥¥ ±o ...Ã›ÔÚ fl2oÙ ø¥ ̈ ̧± ́1 ̧ ...Ã›Í ·­ ø2

a·1 ̧ ̈Û­ ̈±Æß æ ́·¥o·21Ù · ̈ o©øÆo­  ̈ ̧a Æa3ø·2­ ±o ...Ã›ÔÙ © ̧·1⁄2 ̧  ̧øo æaa2 ø ÔÔðÛ­ ̈±Æß  ̈±©aÆÚ “± ­ ́æ­ ̈ø2 ̈·ø¥

Æa3ø·2­ ±o ...Ã›Ô øÆa TM·­·æ¥a ·2 ø2ß ±o  ̈ ̧a ° ̧± ̈±­ oÆ±3  ̈ ̧·­ øÆaøÚ Ã ̧·­ ·­ 2± ̈ © ̧ø ̈ ø 1ÆøTM· ̈ßÛoÆ·TMa2 1⁄2±¥¥ø°­a

¥±±μ­ ¥·μaÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-10 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 6 of 9
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÓË

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌðÚ ‘±±μ·21 ­± ́ ̈ ̧aø­ ̈  ̈±©øÆo ...Ã›ÍÙ

ø1⁄2Æ±­­  ̈ ̧a ...a­ ̈ Õ ̈Æaa ̈ ø2o a­aß Õ ̈Æaa ̈

·2 ̈aÆ­a1⁄2 ̈·±2Ú

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌÔÚ Ã ̧a­a ° ̧± ̈±­ ©aÆa  ̈øμa2 ·2  ̈ ̧a

øo ̈aÆ2±±2 ±o ÁÒÔÔÒðÔÙ æao±Æa ...Ã›È ©ø­ oa­ ̈Æ±ßaoÚ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌÓÚ Ã ̧a 3·2·3ø¥ oaæÆ·­ ¥ao ̈ æß  ̈ ̧a oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o æ± ̈ ̧  ̈±©aÆ­ ·­ Æa3øÆμøæ¥aÚ Ã ̧·­ ©ø­ 2± 1⁄2±¥¥ø°­aÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-10 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 7 of 9
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÓÁ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌÌÚ fl TM·a© ±o  ̈ ̧a Æa3ø·2­ ±o ...Ã›ÔÙ ¥±±μ·21 aø­ ̈ oÆ±3 ...a­ ̈ Õ ̈Æaa ̈Ú

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌÏÚ fl TM·a© ±o  ̈ ̧a Æa3ø·2­ ±o ...Ã›ÔÙ ¥±±μ·21 2±Æ ̈ ̧Û2±Æ ̈ ̧aø­ ̈ oÆ±3 ...a­ ̈ Õ ̈Æaa ̈Ú ...Ã›È ·­ ­ ̈·¥¥

­ ̈ø2o·21Ù © ̧·1⁄2 ̧ ·oa2 ̈·o·a­  ̈ ̧a  ̈·3a ø­  ̈ ̧a øo ̈aÆ2±±2 ±o ÁÒÔÔÒðÔÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-10 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 8 of 9
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ Ìð

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌÎÚ fl ¥±±μ 2±Æ ̈ ̧ ±2 ...a­ ̈ Õ ̈Æaa ̈Ú ...⁄›Ô ·­ ±2  ̈ ̧a ¥ao ̈Ú Ã ̧a °aoa­ ̈Æ·ø2 ©ø¥μ©øß 1⁄2Æ±­­a­ ...a­ ̈

­ ̈Æaa ̈ ¶ ́­ ̈ ­± ́ ̈ ̧ ±o ‘·æaÆ ̈ß Õ ̈Æaa ̈Ú ÿaÆaÙ  ̈ ̧a Æa3ø·2­ ±o  ̈ ̧a æ ́·¥o·21 ø°°aøÆ  ̈± æa 2± 3±Æa  ̈ ̧ø2 o ́­ ̈ ø2o

°ø°aÆÚ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌÍÚ Õ ̈ø2o·21 ø ̈ 1Æ± ́2o ¥aTMa¥Ù  ̈ ̧a ...Ã›Ô Æ ́ææ¥a °·¥a ø°°aøÆ­ 2±  ̧·1 ̧aÆ  ̈ ̧ø2 1Æ± ́2o ¥aTMa¥Ú  ̄ÁÒÔÌÒðÔ ̃

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-10 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 9 of 9