...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÌÔ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌÈÚ Ã ̧a ...Ã› °¥ø¶ø æao±Æa ÁÒÔÔÚ ...Ã›Ó ·­ ±2  ̈ ̧a ¥ao ̈Ù ...Ã›Ô ·­ ±2  ̈ ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈Ù ø2o ...Ã›Ì ·­ ­ ̈Æø·1 ̧ ̈

ø ̧aøoÚ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌËÚ Õ1⁄2±±°·21  ́°  ̈ ̧a æ ́·¥o·21

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-11 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 1 of 7
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÌÓ

›Ú ¤TM·oa21⁄2a ±o a ̧·1⁄2 ́¥øÆ æ ́Æ2 aooa1⁄2 ̈­Ù oø3ø1a­ aooa1⁄2 ̈­ ø2o ¥· ̈aÆø¥ Ã±ø­ ̈·21 ±o ›øÆ­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ øÆa

·2o·1⁄2ø ̈·TMa ±o À2 ́­ ́ø¥ ø2o À2a®°¥ø·2ao æß “×ÕÃ ¤2aÆ1ß ×3°ø1⁄2 ̈­Ú

ÿaÆa ×  ̧øTMa ÆaoaÆÆao  ̈±  ̨ ́2 ́­ ́ø¥ a2aÆ1ß aooa1⁄2 ̈­Ú ̨ ×  ̧aÆa ©ø2 ̈  ̈± a¥øæ±Æø ̈a  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a aooa1⁄2 ̈­ ­aa3 ù Ã ̧a­a aooa1⁄2 ̈­

øÆa 1⁄2±2­·­ ̈a2 ̈ ©· ̈ ̧  ̈ ̧a  ́­a ±o ‹·Æa1⁄2 ̈ao ¤2aÆ1ß ...aø°±2Æß  ̄‹¤... ̃ ø­ ø 1⁄2ø ́­ø¥ oø1⁄2 ̈±Æ o±Æ  ̈ ̧a aTMa2 ̈­ ±o ÁÒÔÔÚÔ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÌÁÚ –a1⁄2 ́¥·øÆ ©·¥ ̈·21 ±o 1⁄2øÆ o±±Æ­ ø2o oao±Æ3ao ©·2o±© ­ ́ÆÆ± ́2o­ ±2 ⁄‹Œ ‹Æ·TMaÚ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÏðÚ Ã ̧aÆa ·­ a® ̈a2­·TMa oø3ø1a  ̈±  ̈ ̧a oÆ±2 ̈ ±o 1⁄2øÆ ÓÈÓÌÙ ·21⁄2¥ ́o·21 2± o±±Æ  ̧ø2o¥a ±2  ̈ ̧a oÆ·TMaÆ ̆­ o±±ÆÚ

Ã ̧aÆa ·­ ø2  ́2 ́­ ́ø¥Ù  ́2æ ́Æ2ao 1⁄2·Æ1⁄2 ́¥øÆ øÆaø ±2  ̈ ̧a ÆaøÆ o±±ÆÚ

Ô

 Ã ̧a ° ́æ¥·1⁄2 o±3ø·2 1⁄2±2 ̈ø·2­ ø ©aø¥ ̈ ̧ ±o ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ±2  ̈ ̧a oaTMa¥±°3a2 ̈ ø2o 1⁄2 ́ÆÆa2 ̈ ­ ̈ø ̈ ́­ ±2 ‹¤...Ú –¥aø­a ­aa  ̈ ̧a o±¥¥±©·21 ¥·2μo±Æ ø 1⁄2±3°·¥ø ̈·±2 ±o ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ‹¤...Ú

 ̧ ̈ ̈°ÊÒÒ¶ø2ao±aðÁÔÔÚ ̈Æ·°±oÚ1⁄2±3ÒÕ ̈øÆ...øÆ­fiaø3ÈÚ ̧ ̈3¥ ̋3·1⁄2Æ±©øTM·21Ù

 ̧ ̈ ̈°ÊÒÒ©©©ÚÁÔÔ­1⁄2 ̧±¥øÆ­Ú±Æ1Ò”ao·øÒ‹¤...Ò”ßaÆ­Œ ́3­oa¥o‹·Æa1⁄2 ̈ao¤2aÆ1ßÚ©3TM

 ̧ ̈ ̈°ÊÒÒ©©©ÚÁÔÔ­1⁄2 ̧±¥øÆ­Ú±Æ1Ò”ao·øÒ‹¤...Ò”ßaÆ­ÛŒ ́3­oa¥oÚ”— 

 ̧ ̈ ̈°ÊÒÒ¶ø2ao±aðÁÔÔÚ ̈Æ·°±oÚ1⁄2±3ÒÕ ̈øÆ...øÆ­fl°°a2o·®ÔÚ ̧ ̈3¥

 ̧ ̈ ̈°ÊÒÒ¶ø2ao±aðÁÔÔÚ ̈Æ·°±oÚ1⁄2±3ÒÕ ̈øÆ...øÆ­fl°°a2o·®ÓÚ ̧ ̈3¥

 ̧ ̈ ̈°ÊÒÒ¶ø2ao±aðÁÔÔÚ ̈Æ·°±oÚ1⁄2±3ÒÕ ̈øÆ...øÆ­fl°°a2o·®ÌÚ ̧ ̈3¥

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-11 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 2 of 7
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÌÌ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÏÔÚ a ̧·1⁄2¥a­ ©aÆa  ̈±ø­ ̈ao ø¥±21 ⁄‹Œ oÆ·TMaÚ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÏÓÚ Ã ̧a oÆ±2 ̈  ̧ø¥o ±o 1⁄2øÆ ÓÈÓÌ ·­  ̈±ø­ ̈aoÙ æ ́ ̈

1⁄2 ̧a1⁄2μ ± ́ ̈  ̈ ̧a 2a© ©ø® ¶±æ ±2  ̈ ̧a æø1⁄2μÚ “± ̈·1⁄2a  ̈ ̧a

3·­­·21 oÆ±2 ̈ o±±Æ  ̧ø2o¥a ø2o  ̈ ̧a  ́2 ̈± ́1⁄2 ̧ao æø1⁄2μ

o±±Æ  ̧ø2o¥aÚ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÏÌÚ fi ́Æ2ao “«–‹ 1⁄2øÆ

–±¥·1⁄2a 1⁄2øÆ × ̆TMa 2± ̈ ­aa2 æao±ÆaÚ

... ̧ß  ̈ ̧a æø1⁄2μ a2o ø2o 2± ̈  ̈ ̧a oÆ±2 ̈·

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-11 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 3 of 7
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÌÏ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÏÏÚ Ã±ø­ ̈ao 1⁄2øÆ­ ·2 ø ¥± ̈ 2aøÆ  ̈ ̧a ...Ã›Ù ±2  ̈ ̧a 2±Æ ̈ ̧©a­ ̈ 1⁄2±Æ2aÆ ±o a­aß ø2o ...a­ ̈ ­ ̈Æaa ̈­Ú

⁄·1 ́Æa ÏÎÚ æ¥±1⁄2μ ©· ̈ ̧ o·Æa ø ̈ a2o

×  ̈ ̧·2μ  ̈ ̧·­ ·­ ¶ ́­ ̈ æao±Æa  ̈ ̧aß o·o ...Ã›ÈÚ “± ̈·1⁄2a  ̧±© a3° ̈ß  ̈ ̧a ­ ̈Æaa ̈­ øÆaÙ © ̧·¥a  ̈ ̧aß øÆa o¥±±oao ©· ̈ ̧

©ø ̈aÆ ø2o ¥± ̈­ ±o o·Æa  ̧±­a­Ú —æTM·± ́­¥ß  ̈ ̧a ©ø ̈aÆ ¥·2a­ ©aÆa2 ̆ ̈ æ ́­ ̈aoˇ Ã ̧a  ̈Æøoo·1⁄2 ¥·1 ̧ ̈ ·2  ̈ ̧a o·­ ̈ø21⁄2a

ø°°aøÆ­  ̈± ­ ̈·¥¥  ̧øTMa °±©aÆÚ  ̄ÁÒÔÔÒðÔ ̃

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-11 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 4 of 7
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÌÎ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÏÍÚ fi ́Æ2ao ÕÀ ø2o 3ø·¥  ̈Æ ́1⁄2μÚ Ú  ̄ÁÒÔÔÒðÔ ̃

⁄·1 ́Æa ÏÈÚ ›øÆ­ æ ́Æ2 © ̧·¥a °ø°aÆ o±a­ 2± ̈Ú ⁄·1 ́Æa ÏËÚ ‘±±μ·21 ©a­ ̈ ±2 a­aß Õ ̈Æaa ̈ øo ̈aÆ æ± ̈ ̧

...Ã›Ó ø2o...Ã›Ô  ̧øTMa æaa2 oa­ ̈Æ±ßaoÚ Ã ̧a øæ­a21⁄2a

±o ­·12·o·1⁄2ø2 ̈ oaæÆ·­ ·­ Æa3øÆμøæ¥aÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-11 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 5 of 7
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÌÍ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÏÁÚ Õø2­ ©·2o±©­Ú  ̄fi ́ ̈ 2·1⁄2a  ̈·Æaˇ ̃ Ã ̧a øæ±TMa ·¥¥ ́­ ̈Æø ̈a­  ́2 ́­ ́ø¥ a2aÆ1ß aooa1⁄2 ̈­ ·2  ̈ ̧ø ̈  ̈ ̧a

©·2o±©­ øÆa ø¥¥ æ¥±©2 ± ́ ̈ ·21⁄2¥ ́o·21  ̈ ̧a 3·ÆÆ±Æ­Ù æ ́ ̈ ©· ̈ ̧± ́ ̈ oø3ø1a  ̈±  ̈ ̧a 3a ̈ø¥ °øÆ ̈­ ±o  ̈ ̧a TMa ̧·1⁄2¥aÚ

“×ÕÃ ̆­ oø·¥ ́Æa  ̈± ø2ø¥ß¶a ·2o±Æ3ø ̈·±2 ¥·μa  ̈ ̧·­ Æa2oaÆ­ “›ÕÃflŒÔ  ́­a¥a­­ ø ̈ æa­ ̈ ø2o ·2o·1⁄2ø ̈·TMa ±o oÆø ́o

ø2o oa1⁄2a° ̈·±2Ú ... ̧ø ̈ ©a ­aa  ̧aÆa ·­ 2± ̈ ø2 ·­±¥ø ̈ao ±1⁄21⁄2 ́ÆÆa21⁄2aÚ Õaa ø¥­± ⁄·1 ́Æa­ ÌÔ ø2o ÌÓ øæ±TMa o±Æ

­·3·¥øÆ aooa1⁄2 ̈­Ú

⁄·1 ́Æa ÎðÚ fl 3·2· TMø2 ·­ 1⁄2±2­ ́3ao æß o¥ø3a­Ú

Ã ̧a o·Æa Æø1a­ ·2­·oa  ̈ ̧a TMa ̧·1⁄2¥aÙ 1⁄2±2 ̈ø·2ao æß  ̈ ̧a

Æa3ø·2·21 ©·2o±©­Ú Ã ̧a o·Æa ø°°aøÆ­ 3±Æa ·2 ̈a2­a

ø ̈  ̈ ̧a oÆ±2 ̈ © ̧aÆa  ̈ ̧a a21·2a ·­Ú

⁄·1 ́Æa ÎÔÚ Ã ̧a  ̈·Æa­ ø2o aTMa2  ̈ ̧a °øTMa3a2 ̈  ́2oaÆ

 ̈ ̧a 1⁄2øÆ øÆa ±2 o·ÆaÚ Ã ̧a ©·2o±©­ ø°°aøÆ  ̈± æa ·2 ̈ø1⁄2 ̈

©· ̈ ̧ 2± TM·­·æ¥a ·2 ̈aÆ·±Æ o·ÆaÚ Ã ̧aÆa ·­ ¥·2a ±o o·Æa

ø¥±21  ̈ ̧a  ̈Æ ́2μ ¥·oÚ Ã ̧a Æ·1 ̧ ̈ oÆ±2 ̈ oa2oaÆ ·­

oao±Æ3ao ø2o  ̧ø­  ̈ ́Æ2ao © ̧· ̈aÚ

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-11 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 6 of 7
...±±oÛŒ⁄›Ù ÔÍ ”øÆ1⁄2 ̧ ÓððÈ ÌÈ

⁄·1 ́Æa ÎÓÚ fl o·Æa Æø1a­Ù ø°°øÆa2 ̈¥ß ±2 a­aß Õ ̈Æaa ̈Ù ­a2o·21  ́°  ̈ ̧·1⁄2μ æ¥ø1⁄2μ ­3±μaÚ Ã ̧a­a 3øß æa  ̈ ̧a

TMa ̧·1⁄2¥a­  ̈ ̧ø ̈ aßa©· ̈2a­­ ¤”Ã Œaæa1⁄21⁄2ø —2oÆ±TM·1⁄2Ú oa­1⁄2Æ·æao ø­ ­ ̧a Æø2 °ø­ ̈ ...Ã›Í o ́Æ·21  ̈ ̧a

oa­ ̈Æ ́1⁄2 ̈·±2 ±o ...Ã›ÓÚ Ã ̧a  ̈a® ̈ ±o  ̧aÆ  ̈a­ ̈·3±2ß 1⁄2ø2 æa o± ́2o  ̧aÆaÊ

Å ̧ ̈ ̈°ÊÒÒ¶ø2ao±aðÁÔÔÚ ̈Æ·°±oÚ1⁄2±3ÒÕ ̈øÆ...øÆ­fiaø3ÍÚ ̧ ̈3¥ ̋aßa©· ̈2a­­Ã

Case 1:07-cv-03314-GBD Document 59-11 Filed 02/29/2008 Page 7 of 7