# Patent

## Title
Method for testing variable cooling geometries in a turbine vane

## Abstract

A method for designing an air cooled turbine airfoil includes selecting a number of different internal cooling air circuits, forming a ceramic core for each of the different cooling air circuits, forming a metal airfoil over each of the ceramic cores, leaching away the ceramic cores, mounting the airfoils in a stage of a turbine, passing a hot gas stream through the turbine, passing cooling air through each of the airfoils, and measuring a pressure and temperature differential across each of the airfoils to determine which cooling air circuit has the best performance.

## Background
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
None.
GOVERNMENT LICENSE RIGHTS
None.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
The present invention relates generally to a gas turbine engine, and more specifically to a method for testing different internal cooling air passages within an air cooled airfoil such as a rotor blade or a stator vane.
2. Description of the Related Art Including Information Disclosed Under 37 CFR 1.97 and 1.98
In a gas turbine engine, such as a large frame heavy-duty industrial gas turbine (IGT) engine, a hot gas stream generated in a combustor is passed through a turbine to produce mechanical work. The turbine includes one or more rows or stages of stator vanes and rotor blades that react with the hot gas stream in a progressively decreasing temperature. The efficiency of the turbine—and therefore the engine—can be increased by passing a higher temperature gas stream into the turbine. However, the turbine inlet temperature is limited to the material properties of the turbine, especially the first stage vanes and blades, and an amount of cooling capability for these first stage airfoils.
The first stage rotor blade and stator vanes are exposed to the highest gas stream temperatures, with the temperature gradually decreasing as the gas stream passes through the turbine stages. The upper stage airfoils (blades and vanes) must be cooled by passing cooling air through internal cooling passages and discharging the cooling air through film cooling holes to provide a blanket layer of cooling air to protect the hot metal surface from the hot gas stream.
A turbine stator vane can be tested for cooling effectiveness by passing a hot gas stream through the vane while monitoring the pressure differential and the temperature change of the cooling air. Measuring for the inlet pressure and the outlet pressure will provide for the pressure drop through the cooling circuit. Measuring the cooling air temperature entering the cooling circuit and then exiting the cooling circuit will determine the cooling effectiveness of the cooling circuit. This method of testing vane cooling circuits is very expensive if each vane must be cast separately using the standard investment casting technique. For example, an industrial gas turbine engine can have 20 vanes in one stage. If each vane in the stage were designed with a different cooling circuit, the casting tooling for each circuit could cost around $100,000 to produce for testing. The total cost for 20 vanes would be $2 million for the set of vanes.
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
A method and an apparatus for testing different airfoil cooling circuit designs and picking the best design, where a number of cooling circuits are designed and a ceramic core is produced for each of the designs. Then, a metal additive process is used to form the metal airfoil over each of the different ceramic cores to form an air cooled turbine airfoil of one type for use in a stage of a turbine. The airfoils are then mounted in an engine or a test rig and a hot gas stream is passed through the airfoils. Cooling air is supplied to each of the airfoils and measured for a pressure differential and a temperature differential. Based on the pressure and temperature differentials, the most effective cooling design can be determined.
Using a metal additive manufacturing process to form the airfoils each having a different internal cooling air circuit is much less than using the conventional investment casting process and therefore the cost to design an airfoil cooling circuit is much cheaper using the present invention. Building up the metal over the ceramic cores and then leaching away the ceramic material results in a smooth surface for the cooling air passages.



BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 shows a representation of a row of stator vanes in a gas turbine engine according to the present invention.
FIG. 2 shows a flow chart of the method for testing variable cooling geometries in a turbine vane according to the present invention.



DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
The present invention is a method of testing different cooling circuits in a stator vane used in a turbine of a gas turbine engine, where the vanes with the different internal cooling circuits are produced using a ceramic core with the vane formed over the ceramic core using an additive manufacturing process such as electron beam melting (EBM), electron beam welding (EBW), Digital Direct Manufacture (DDM), or a metal printing process such as that developed by Mikro Systems, Inc. of Charlottesville, Va.
As an example, a stage of a turbine can have 20 stator vanes. To test cooling circuits, 20 stator vanes would be formed each having a different internal cooling circuit. Each of the 20 cooling circuits would have formed a ceramic core used to form the internal cooling circuit in the vane. Each stator vane would then be formed over the ceramic core using one of the metal additive manufacturing processes such as wire fed digital direct manufacturing to form the metal vane over the ceramic core. This process reduces the cost for manufacturing the vane from $100,000 to $15,000 per vane. FIG. 1 represents an industrial gas turbine engine that has 20 stator vanes in the first stage of the engine. In FIG. 1, N identical stator vanes 11 are represented, each having a different internal cooling circuit.
When the vane outer surfaces that include the airfoil and the inner and outer endwalls are formed, the ceramic core is leached away to leave the internal cooling air circuit. Building up the metal vane over the ceramic core and then leaching away the ceramic material leaves a very smooth cooling air surface formed within the metal vane. A process to form the metal vane without a ceramic core would leave a very rough surface on the cooling passages, and the rough surfaces could not be smoothed because of the extreme difficulty in reaching the surfaces within the vane. Then, the outer surfaces of the vane are machined to produce a smooth and accurate outer surface for the vane. With this machining step, accurate aero results can also be tested for. Any film cooling holes can be drilled into the vanes after machining of the outer surfaces. Each of the 20 vanes is formed this way in which each vane would have a different internal cooling circuit.
The vanes with the different internal cooling circuits are then placed in a test rig or an actual engine in the stage arranged in an annular array and a hot gas stream of a temperature to simulate the actual conditions that the vanes will be exposed to if the vanes are mounted in a test rig. The cooling air pressure and temperature for each vane is measured at both the inlets and the outlets for each vane. Thus, each vane will have a cooling air pressure drop and a cooling air temperature increase. The differential pressure and temperature for each vane can then be used to determine which of the internal cooling circuits provides the best results.
FIG. 2 shows the method of determining which vane cooling circuit design produces the best cooling effectiveness. In step 11, a designer comes up with N different cooling circuits with one cooling circuit for each of the vanes in a certain stage of the turbine. However, for a turbine stage having N vanes, less than N cooling circuit designs could be used. Step 12 is to form a ceramic core for each of the different cooling circuit designs N. step 13 is to form a stator vane for each of the different cooling circuits N where each vane is an identical vane for use in the same stage of the engine or test rig. Step 14 is to place the N vanes with the different cooling circuits in a test rig or engine. Step 15 is to pass a hot gas stream through the vanes to simulate a real condition that the vanes would be exposed to in real operation. Step 16 is to measure each of the N vanes for differential pressure and differential temperature. Differential pressure is a difference between the inlet pressure to the cooling circuit and the outlet pressure. Differential temperature a difference between the inlet temperature of the cooling air into the cooling circuit and the outlet temperature. Step 17 is to determine from the differential pressures and temperatures which vane cooling circuit design produces the best results. Once the best cooling circuit design is determined, the entire stage of stator vanes can then be cast or produced with each having the same internal cooling circuit.

## Claims

1. A method for designing an air cooled turbine airfoil used in a gas turbine engine comprising the steps of:
selecting a number of different internal cooling air circuits for an airfoil;
forming a ceramic core for each of the number of internal cooling air circuits;
forming an airfoil surface over each of the ceramic cores using a metal additive manufacture process;
removing each of the ceramic cores from the airfoils;
placing the airfoils in an engine or a test rig all in one stage;
passing a hot gas stream through the stage of airfoils under similar conditions to a real engine operation;
passing cooling air through each of the internal cooling air circuits of the airfoils;
measuring a pressure and temperature difference for each of the different cooling air circuits; and,
from the measurements, determining which internal cooling air circuit has the best performance.

2. The method for designing an air cooled turbine airfoil of claim 1, and further comprising the step of:
the metal additive manufacture process includes an electron beam melting, or an electron beam welding, or a digital direct manufacture, or a metal printing process.

3. The method for designing an air cooled turbine airfoil of claim 1, and further comprising the step of:
the number of different internal cooling air circuits is equal to a number of airfoils in a stage of the turbine.