7KH +RQRUDEOH 0\URQ + %ULJKW &LUFXLW -XGJH RI WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV&RXUW RI $SSHDOV IRU WKH (LJKWK &LUFXLW VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,213XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU)LOH 1DPH DS	

			



2:$5'7(9(5621	

$8/800(56
	

 !"#$%
&'$(	$$)*')$"'+$,"$!"$%-'(( *')$"'+$!&&))$ ,#.'////01%#)'22'&)*')$"'+$3,(2"2,(43&,"56/7//*+'((&(' (43, 577//8!"4
		
9&(8
'"+,'$3,(2)  3%& 	  5 


 99: ; 99: ,#.' &&)) !"  &$  <'#   "   : 9 
-
93
	
 *
=
	
 )%'  &&)) !"  73HWLWLRQHU¶VWKUHH VWDWH FRQYLFWLRQV VWHPPHG IURP JXLOW\ SOHDV3HWLWLRQHU DUJXHV LQ KLV SHWLWLRQ WKDW KH GLG QRW YROXQWDULO\ DQG NQRZLQJO\HQWHU LQWR WKRVH SOHDV +HIXUWKHUDVVHUWV WKDW KH GLG QRW LQWHQWLRQDOO\UHOLQTXLVK KLV )LIWK $PHQGPHQW ULJKW WR EHIUHH IURP FRPSXOVRU\ VHOILQFULPLQDWLRQ 
  3%& 	  5 


 99: ; 99: ,#.' &&)) !"  &$  <'#   "   : 9 
-
93
	
*
=
	
)%' &&))!" 9  
	 '"+,'$ 3,(2  $'$'&" >"($")& )$%(')#')) !%')$'$'&)?'&2%.)+",)" '!!"#$%"@'"()$$+&'+$'&)$%$>",)($&%&+%')+,""&$!(" )&$&+,&("$%"#("""'#'& +$A
	B7CD
&'>!$% 	,"#,"$E) "+&$ '&'&)'&  
	7	$0AC7//D&(	
	7	$0C7//D>!!'"#$%(')$"'+$+,"$E)(')#')) !$'$'&"E)%.)+$'&!" +?!F,"')('+$'&)>@ '&. >$'$'&" () &$ #$ $% G'& +,)$(5H "I,'"#&$ !%.) $'$'&) )'&+ $% )&$&+) ! $% +&'+$'&) %)?)$+% &2%@'"(&3,&A$'$'&">)+%"2(>'$%$%"+,&$)!.'&2! &'&))))'&!!'""#'&' $'&!A	B77C2DF,"5!,&($'$'&"2,' $5!+%+,&$& 3&,"5    %" >?) $" $'$'&" !' ( $'$'& !" >"'$!%.) +",),"),&$$7A
	B 77  
& %') $'$'& $'$'&" $$+?( $%" )$$+&'+$'&)!"#A!"".."5>'$%(( 5>& $%,2% % %( +# $( $% )&$&+) !" $% )$$63XUVXDQW WR  86&  H D SHUVRQ ZKR LV JXLOW\ RIYLRODWLQJ  86&  J DQG KDV 3WKUHH SUHYLRXV FRQYLFWLRQV   IRUD YLROHQW IHORQ\VKDOO EHLPSULVRQHG QRW OHVV WKDQ ILIWHHQ \HDUV ́+&'+$'&)&+$."6/$'$'&"+ '#($%$%>)&"$% )) )$' '&+,)$(5 !","))!.$'&'&2" '! ,&(" B 77 .+,)$% 
&'$( 	$$)'&$&(($% %') )&$&+ &%&+( .)( & $% "#( """'#'& +$A
	B7CDCGHD
&((!$"$'$'&" !' ( %') $'$'& $% (')$"'+$ +,"$ )&$&+($'$'&"$!'!$&5")E'#"')&#&$,"),&$$B7CD$'$'&"$%&),++))!, 5#($#&(%')$'$'&$"! +$ $%$ % >) & &2" )'# 5 & .&( &('&2)&$&+'&2&($%$)!-5$%($$%$%>)$""$$$%8,",!"')&)%>, ( '$" 5.'&+,)$(5  %,) $'$'&" ),2%$ $ +% &2 %') A".."5+&'+$'&)),&+&)$'$,$'& +% &2>%'+%'!),++))!, >, ("I,'"$%$%')+,""&$&%&+()&$&+.+$(&)&(&$E)#$'&$%(')$"'+$+,"$(')#'))($%$'$'& !" +? ! F,"')('+$'&  	'&+ $% )&$&+) !$'$'&"E)A+&'+$'&)%(@'"($%(')$"'+$+,"$% ($%$$'$'&"('(&$#$$%G'&+,)$(5H"I,'"#&$!7A
	B77J 5(& "'>$I,)$'&)!),.F+$#$$"F,"')('+$'& !"66(/06/00C$%'"D#$&($%G
&,)$(5HI,'"#&$"!(" +,"$$%F,"')('+$'&$2"&$$'$'&!">"'$!%.)+",),&("B77$'$'&"#,)$.G'&+,)$(5,"),&$$$%F,(2#&$!	$$+,"$H7A	B77CDK7A
	B77C+DC6DCG%>"'$!%.)+",))% &$@$&($"')&",& ))L%M') '& +,)$(5 '& ' $'& ! $% &)$'$,$'& " >) "7KH SHWLWLRQHU KDG DOVR DOOHJHG WKDW WKH  FRQYLFWLRQ KDG EHHQXVHG WRHQKDQFH WKHIHGHUDO VHQWHQFH WKDW KH ZDV VHUYLQJ DW WKH WLPH KHILOHG +RZHYHU VLQFH WKH WULDO FRXUW KDG QRW DGGUHVVHG WKH FRQWHQWLRQ DQGWKH SHWLWLRQHU GLG QRW SUHVV WKH DUJXPHQW EHIRUH WKH &RXUW WKH &RXUW GLGQRW FRQVLGHU LW,GDW  Q
$"$')!$%
&'$(	$$)HD
&#$/
	AACADC"+,"'#D$%	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¶VVXSSOHPHQWDO ILOLQJ DV ZHOO DV LQ KLV RULJLQDO EULHI KH GRHVQRW FKDOOHQJH KLV  FRQYLFWLRQV IRUUREEHU\ RQ WKHJURXQG WKDW WKHUHZDV D IDLOXUH WR DSSRLQW FRXQVHO 1RU GRHV KH SRLQW WR DQ\ QHZIRXQGFRPSHOOLQJ HYLGHQFH WKDW KH ZDV LQQRFHQW RI WKH FULPHV 3HWLWLRQHU¶V RQO\UHVSRQVH WR'DQLHOVLV WR UHO\ JHQHUDOO\ RQ WKH WKLUG IRXUWK DQG ILIWKSDUDJUDSKV RI VHFWLRQ ,,% RI WKH PDMRULW\ RSLQLRQ WKH WKLUG SDUDJUDSK RI-XVWLFH 6FDOLD¶V FRQFXUUHQFH DQG IRRWQRWH  WR -XVWLFH 6RXWHU¶V GLVVHQWLQJRSLQLRQ :H ILQG QRWKLQJ LQ WKH UHFRUG RU WKH EULHIV LQGLFDWLQJ WKDW WKHVLWXDWLRQV GHVFULEHG LQ WKHVH SDUDJUDSKV DUH DSSRVLWH WR 3HWLWLRQHU¶V FDVH $"&$' 5!$"$%$'#!"('"+$"+ $" "'>%)@'"((!&(&$#5.$'&+# '&2'(&+$%$%')+$, 5'&&+&$!$%+"'#!">%'+%%>)+&'+$(&(>%'+%%+, (&$%,&+"('&$'# 5#&&"7	$$0C+'$$'&)#'$$(D'$%"@+$'& ')$$%+'"+,#)$&+)!$%')+)& '2%$!&(>!!'"#$%(')$"'+$+,"$E)(')#')) ! $'$'&"E)B77$'$'& &'$) !+$%$'$'& +% &2) $% A +&'+$'&) +&'+$'&) !">%'+%$'$'&"')&$G'&+,)$(5H)'&+$%'")&$&+)%(@'"(.5$%$'#% !' (%')$'$'&++"('&2 5>+?),.F+$#$$"F,"')('+$'&$+&)'("%')$'$'&#$/
	$/-""&'!>>"$+&)$",%')$'$'&)B77$'$'&$$+?'&2%')+,""&$!(" )&$&+$%$+%'&2!&(')+ "4$'$'&" +&&$ " 5 & BB 77 " 77 ) %'+ ) $+% &2%')"'"+&'+$'&),)($&%&+%')+,""&$!(" )&$&+9'?$%$'$'&"'&$'$'&"G')>'$%,$"+,")H.+,)%')G"'"+&'+$'&L)M,)($&%&+L%')M!(" )&$&+L"M& &2"&$('"+$"+ $" $$+?'&L$%'"M>&"'2%$.+,)$%(!&(&$!' ($,"),$%)"#(')>%' $%5>"' . H7	$$A67LWOH 86&  LV HVVHQWLDOO\ HTXLYDOHQW WR   WKHIRUPHU EHLQJ D SRVWFRQYLFWLRQ UHPHG\ IRU IHGHUDO SULVRQHUV DQG WKH ODWWHUDYDLODEOH WR 3D SHUVRQ LQ FXVWRG\ SXUVXDQW WR WKH MXGJPHQW RI D 6WDWHFRXUW ́  86&  8 $'$'&"E) I,)$ !"  9'."  &)$",+$'& ! %')$'$'&)$')!5$%G'&+,)$(5H"I,'"#&$$'$'&"$%",2%$%)#+,&) >%""(%')%.)$'$'&+&$&()$%$>)%, (! >),.)I,&$+))$%$%"(#$)"#'$$'&2"')&"$+% &2&,&(" 5'&2+&'+$'&>%))&$&+%)@'"(.5('"+$ 5$$+?'&2+,""&$)&$&+ $%$ $% $'$'&" ') )"'&2 &( >%'+% >)&%&+(.5$%@'"()&$&+
&$%">"()$'$'&"))"$)$%$>)%, (+&)$",%')$'$'&)&$$+?&$%!("  )&$&+ $%$ % ') +,""&$ 5 )"'&2 ) $%$ % ')(#( G'& +,)$(5H !" ,")) ! ),.F+$ #$$"F,"')('+$'&&'!>>"$+&)$",$'$'&"E)B77%.) $'$'& ) & $$+? & %') +,""&$ )&$&+ $%,)!!+$' 5 +&"$'&2 '$ $  B 77 $'$'&$% 
&'$($$)	,"#,"$E)(+')'&)'&&(),"')),(!$"" "2,#&$'&$%'&)$&$+)!"+ )$%'.' '$5!%')"2,#&$$'$'&" +""+$ 5 &$) $%$ $% ,"$ '&#$@")) 5(+ '&($(("))$%')),!>%$%"%.)$'$'&" #5 +% &2 $% +&)$'$,$'& '$5 !  )$$+&'+$'&>%))&$&+%)@'"(.5!+' 5$$+?'&2 +,""&$ )&$&+ $%$ >) &%&+( .5 $% "'" )$$+&'+$'&%$
&(("',)+'"+,'$)(("))($%$%&,&&)>"( I,)$'& !#$ &( &)>"('&$%!!'"#$'!76(666C0$%'"DK&07(00A C/$%'"7DK   7 7( AA A C$% '" D>"$%)(+')'&) ! >%'+%'& ("')&")!' '&2B77$'$'&))'&+$%'"+,""&$&%&+()&$&+>) ).)(&)$$+&'+$'&)> )&5(+')'&) >'&2 $$+?) & "'" )$$ +&'+$'&)$%$ % .&,)( $ &%&+  +,""&$ !("  )&$&+ % .&!!+$' 5 "", ( .5&(  @+$ !" &"">@+$'&.$%!$%)(+')'&)!"+ )$%.' '$5!"')&"$+% &2"'"@'"(+&'+$'&>'$%%.)$$+?&+,""&$)&$&+$%$>)&%&+(.5$%"'"+&'+$'&&$%$'$'&">)+&'+$(,&("A
	B77C2D!.'&2! &'&))))'&!!'""#7 	 $ $ A/  8)( & %') "'" )$$ +&'+$'&)'&+ ,('&2$> !" ".."5 $% $'$'&" >) (F,(2( &"#(+""+"'#'& &(%'))&$&+>)&%&+(,&("$%  %  !$" & ,&),++))!,  ('"+$   $%$'$'&"),2%$%.)+",)" '!,&("7A
	B77 2'&2$%$%') ".."5+&'+$'&)>",&+&)$'$,$'&.+,) $% ,&(" 5'&2 2,' $5  ) >" &$ &$"(?&>'&2 5&( ,&$"' 5%$A/A%'&$%'"+,'$,"$ !  ) ,% ( $% (')$"'+$ +,"$E) (&'  ! $%B 77 #$'& .)( & $% 	,"# ,"$E) (+')'& '&
	ACD6(//6C$%'"D
&$%,"# ,"$ % ( $%$  (!&(&$ )&$&+( ,&(" $%+, (&$(,"'&2%')!(" )&$&+'&2"+('&2+ $" 5$$+?"',))$$+&'+$'&),)($&%&+%')!(" )&$&+
	$0&)$$"')&"%(),2%$%.)+",)" '!,&("B77 2'&2$%$%')"'")$$+&'+$'&)>%'+%%('&! ,&+(%')+,""&$)$$)&$&+>""(,+$!'&!!+$'))')$&+!+,&) 7	$$007 $%,2%$%$'$'&"%(!, 5)"(%'))&$&+)!"$%"'")$$+&'+$'&)$%%'"('"+,'$,"$! )+&+ ,(( $%$ % +, ( +% &2 $%) +&'+$'&) '& B77$'$'&'!$%5!!+$(%')")&$)&$&+	7/6(6/C6('"7///D8)( & $% )#  '+5 +&)'("$'&) (("))( '& '&+ ,('&2 +&+"&) .,$ $% &( !" !'& '$5 !+&'+$'&) &( ) ! (#'&')$"$'&$%,"$ ", ('&&($%$%.)+",)" '!,&("BB77&(077 ') 2&" 5 ,&' .  !" "')&") )?'&2 $+% &2"'"+&'+$'&)4-"'#"$&$!",","))%"')$%I,)$'&>@ '+'$ 5 !$ ,&&)>"( '&#$4 G$% @$&$ $>%'+%$%L"'"@'"(M+&'+$'&'$) !#5.),.F+$$+% &2'&$%$$+?,&$%L+,""&$M)&$&L+M>%'+%'$>),)($&%&+H/
	$/	$ 76 J &+,&$"( $%') )# I,)$'& '& $%B77+&$@$'&67
	$7	$0AJ% ($%"$%$GL'M!"'"+&'+$'& ,)( $ &%&+  !("  )&$&+ ') &&2"&$('"+$"+ $" $$+?'&'$)>&"'2%$.+,)$%(!&(&$ !' ($,"),$%) "#(')>%' $%5>"' . C".+,)$%(!&(&$('() ,&),++))!, 5D $%& $%$ (!&(&$    #5 &$+ $" 5$$+?%')"'"+&'+$'&$%",2%#$'&,&("B77H$7	$0AA6J&> @$&( $%') % ('&2 $ +" B 77 $'$'&)('"+$($&%&+()$$)&$&+)7	$$06&.$%+))$%,"$"+2&'O(&@+$'& >'&2$'$'&),&("BB77&(77G$%$+% &2&&%&+()&$&+&$%.)')$%$$%"'"+&'+$'&,)($&%&+$%)&$&+>).$'&(>%"$%">)!' ,"$'&$+,&) '&' $'&!$%	'@$%#&(#&$))$!"$%'&'($!607
	66C6DH%$0K7	$$A6
&(('$'& ," '$')!"#.$%+))),22)$(&$%"@+$'&
&$% ," '$5 )$$($%$ G$%" #5 . "" +))'& >%'+% &+%&& !"'>>)+$, 5' . $(!&(&$>'$%")+$$ "'" +&'+$'&(,$& !, $!%')>&H7	$$A ," '$5'& ."$(4$')&$ >5)$%+)%>"$%$(!&(&$+&. !, $( !" !' '&2 $ .$'& $'# 5 "'> ! +&)$'$,$'&  + '# " @#   )$$ +,"$ #5>'$%,$F,)$'!'+$'& "!,)$ ", & +&)$'$,$'&+ '# $%$ %) .& "" 5 ")&$( $ '$