DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 1 

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS 

SHERMAN DIVISION 

QJ TEAM, LLC AND FIVE POINTS §

HOLDINGS, LLC, individually and on §

behalf of all other persons similarly §

situated, § CIVIL ACTION NO. 

§ 4:23-cv-01013-SDJ

Plaintiffs, §

§

v. § CLASS ACTION

§

TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF §

REALTORS, INC., et al., §

§

§

Defendants. §

____________________________________ ________________________________ 

JULIE MARTIN, MARK ADAMS, AND §

ADELAIDA MATTA, individually and on §

behalf of all other persons similarly §

situated, § CIVIL ACTION NO. 

§ 4:23-cv-01104-SDJ

Plaintiffs, §

§

v. § CLASS ACTION

§

TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF §

REALTORS, INC., et al., §

§

§

Defendants. §

____________________________________ ________________________________ 

DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO 

PLAINTIFFS’ UNOPPOSED MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 2 

The “Responding Defendants,”1 by and through their respective counsel, hereby respond 

to Plaintiffs’ Unopposed Motion to Consolidate [ECF 193 in QJ Team] as follows:2

Defendants are not opposed to, and support, the relief sought in the Motion to Consolidate, 

which requests the Court to enter a proposed Order that would: 

 Consolidate QJ Team, et al. v. Texas Association of Realtors, et al., Case No. Case No. 

4:23-CV-1013-SDJ (E.D. Tex.) and Julie Martin, et al. v. Texas Association of 

Realtors, et al., Case No. 4:23-CV-1104 (E.D. Tex.); 

 Provide that the master docket and master file for the consolidated actions be QJ Team, 

et al. v. Texas Association of Realtors, et al., Case No. 4:23-CV-1013-SDJ (E.D. Tex.); 

and 

 require Plaintiffs to file a consolidated complaint in Case No. 4:23-CV-1013-SDJ on 

or before March 15, 2024. 

Although Defendants are in favor of the relief requested in Motion to Consolidate, they 

disagree with and dispute some of the factual statements and arguments included in the motion, 

including Plaintiffs’ contention that there are “common issues of fact and law posed by the 

1 The Responding Defendants are, in alphabetical order, ABA Management, L.L.C. d/b/a Allie 

Beth Allman and Associates; ATX WIR LLC; Austin Board of Realtors®; Austin/Central Texas 

Realty Information Service; Central Texas Multiple Listing Service, Inc.; CitiQuest Properties, 

Inc.; DMTX, LLC; DSJMM, LLC; Ebby Halliday Real Estate, LLC; Fathom Realty, LLC; Fort 

Hood Area Association of Realtors®, Inc.; Four Rivers Association of Realtors®, Inc.; Greater El 

Paso Association of Realtors®; Greater Fort Worth Association of Realtors®, Inc.; Greenwood 

King Properties II, Inc.; Hexagon Group, LLC; Heyl Group Holdings LLC; HomeServices of 

America, Inc.; Houston Association of Realtors®, Inc.; Houston Realtors® Information Service, 

Inc.; JP Piccinini Real Estate Services, LLC d/b/a JPA; Keller Willis San Antonio, Inc.; Mark 

Anthony Dimas; MetroTex Association of Realtors®, Inc.; MJHM LLC; Moreland Properties, Inc.; 

North Texas Real Estate Information Systems, Inc.; PenFed Realty, LLC; Real Agent LLC; Realty 

Austin, LLC; RFT Enterprises, Inc.; San Antonio Board of Realtors®, Inc.; San Antonio Legacy 

Group, LLC; Side, Inc.; Square MB, LLC; Team Burns, LLC d/b/a Monument Realty; TempleBelton Board of Realtors®, Inc.; Texas Association of Realtors®, Inc.; The Dave Perry-Miller 

Company; The Loken Group, Inc.; Turner Mangum LLC; Victoria Area Association of Realtors®, 

Inc.; and Williamson County Association of Realtors®, Inc.

2 By filing this Response, Defendants do not waive, in this or any other action, any Defendant’s 

counterclaims, defenses, affirmative defenses, rights (including arbitration), or arguments, whether 

stemming from common law, statute, or otherwise.
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 3 

Actions.” Motion to Consolidate pp. 4-5. While it is true that the QJ Team case and Martin case 

include numerous overlapping parties, issues, and facts that satisfy Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 

42(a) and justify consolidation, these issues of fact and law are not “common” with respect to the 

alleged class members in either case for purposes of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23. 

DATED: February 15, 2024.

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Bradley C. Weber 

Bradley C. Weber 

Texas Bar No. 21042470 

bweber@lockelord.com

LOCKE LORD LLP 

2200 Ross Avenue, Suite 2800 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (214) 740-8497 

Fax: (214) 756-8497 

Grant P. Harpold 

Texas Bar No. 09034300 

gharpold@buckkeenan.com

BUCK KEENAN LLP 

2229 San Felipe Street, Suite 1000 

Houston, Texas 77019 

Tel: 713-225-4500 

Fax: 713-225-3719 

Attorneys for Defendants Houston 

Association of Realtors®, Inc. and Houston 

Realtors® Information Service, Inc. 

/s/ George W. Morrison 

George W. Morrison (a/k/a Bill Morrison) 

Texas Bar No. 24007710 

bill.morrison@haynesboone.com

Neil Issar 

Texas Bar No. 24102704 

neil.issar@haynesboone.com

Greta Gieseke 

Texas Bar No. 24132925 

greta.gieseke@haynesboone.com
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 4 

HAYNES AND BOONE, LLP 

2801 N. Harwood Street, Suite 2300 

Dallas, Texas 75201-2747 

Tel: (214) 651-5000 

Fax: (214) 651-5940 

Attorneys for Defendants MetroTex 

Association of Realtors®, Inc. and North 

Texas Real Estate Information Systems, 

Inc. 

/s/ Richard A. Illmer 

Richard A. Illmer 

Texas Bar No. 10388350 

rick.illmer@huschblackwell.com

Chalon Clark 

Texas Bar No. 24050045 

chalon.clark@huschblackwell.com

HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP 

1900 N. Pearl St., Suite 1800 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (214) 999-6100 

Fax: (214) 999-6170 

Christopher A. Smith (Pro Hac Vice) 

chris.smith@huschblackwell.com

HUSCH BLACKWELL, LLP 

8001 Forsyth Blvd., Suite 1500 

St. Louis, Missouri 63105 

Tel: (314) 480-1500 

Fax: (314) 480-1505 

A. James Spung (Pro Hac Vice) 

james.spung@huschblackwell.com

1801 Wewatta St., Suite 1000 

Denver, Colorado 80202 

Tel: (303) 749-7200 

Fax: (303) 749-7272 

Attorneys for Defendant Texas Association 

of Realtors®, Inc. 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 5 

/s/ A. Boone Almanza 

A. Boone Almanza 

Texas Bar No. 01579001 

balmanza@abdmlaw.com

Rachel L. McKenna 

Texas Bar No. 24102183 

rmckenna@abdmlaw.com

Ethan Ranis 

Texas Bar No. 24098303 

eranis@abdmlaw.com

ALMANZA, BLACKBURN, DICKIE &

MITCHELL, LLP 

2301 S. Capital of Texas Highway, Bldg. H 

Austin, Texas 78746 

Tel: (512) 474-9486 

Fax: (512) 478-7151 

Attorneys for Defendant ATX WIR LLC 

/s/ Jay Dewald 

Jay Dewald 

Texas Bar No. 24001990 

jay.dewald@nortonrosefulbright.com

NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP 

111 W. Houston Street, Suite 1800 

San Antonio, Texas 78205 

Tel: (210) 224-5575 

Fax: (210) 270-7205 

Ellen Sessions 

Texas Bar No. 00796282 

ellen.sessions@nortonrosefulbright.com

NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP 

2200 Ross Avenue, Suite 3600 

Dallas, Texas 75201-7932 

Tel: (214) 855-8180 

Fax: (214) 855-8200 

Layne E. Kruse 

Texas Bar No. 11742550 

layne.kruse@nortonrosefulbright.com

NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP 

1301 McKinney Street, Suite 5100 

Houston, Texas 77010-3095 

Tel: (713) 651-5100 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 6 

Fax: (713) 651-5246 

Attorneys for Defendants Austin Board of 

Realtors® and Austin/Central Texas Realty 

Information Service 

/s/ Joseph S. Babb 

Joseph S. Babb 

Texas Bar No. 01478700 

jbabb@brltexaslaw.com

BABB, REED & LEAK, PLLC 

4131 Spicewood Springs Rd., Bldg. G-2 

Austin, Texas 78759 

Tel: (512) 580-5010 

Attorney for Defendants Central Texas 

Multiple Listing Service, Inc., Fort Hood 

Area Association of Realtors®, Inc., Four 

Rivers Association of Realtors®, Inc., 

Greater Fort Worth Association of 

Realtors®, Inc., Temple-Belton Board of 

Realtors®, Inc., Victoria Area Association 

of Realtors®, Inc., and Williamson County 

Association of Realtors®, Inc. 

/s/ Nicole L. Williams 

Nicole L. Williams 

Texas Bar No. 24041784 

nwilliams@thompsoncoburn.com

Mackenzie S. Wallace 

Texas Bar No. 24079535 

mwallace@thompsoncoburn.com

THOMPSON COBURN LLP 

2100 Ross Avenue, Suite 3200 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (972) 629-7100 

Fax: (972) 629-7171 

Attorneys for Defendants DMTX, LLC, 

DSJMM, LLC, Hexagon Group, LLC, 

Keller Willis San Antonio, Inc., and San 

Antonio Legacy Group, LLC 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 7 

/s/ Emilee L. Hargis 

James D. Lawrence (admitted pro hac vice) 

jim.lawrence@bclplaw.com

BRYAN CAVE LEIGHTON PAISNER LLP 

1200 Main St., Suite 3800 

Kansas City, Missouri 64105 

Tel: (816) 374-3200 

Timothy R. Beyer (admitted pro hac vice) 

tim.beyer@bclplaw.com

BRYAN CAVE LEIGHTON PAISNER LLP 

1700 Lincoln Street, #4100 

Denver, Colorado 80203 

Tel: (303) 866-7000 

Elaine Drodge Koch 

Texas Bar No. 06133300 

elaine.koch@bclplaw.com

BRYAN CAVE LEIGHTON PAISNER LLP 

JP Morgan Chase Tower 

2200 Ross Avenue, Suite 4200W 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (214) 721-8000 

Lindsay Sklar Johnson (admitted pro hac 

vice) 

lindsay.johnson@bclplaw.com

BRYAN CAVE LEIGHTON PAISNER LLP 

1201 W. Peachtree St., N.W., 14th Floor 

Atlanta, Georgia 30309-3471 

Tel: (404) 572-6600 

Emilee L. Hargis (admitted pro hac vice) 

emilee.hargis@bclplaw.com

BRYAN CAVE LEIGHTON PAISNER LLP 

211 N. Broadway, Suite 3600 

St. Louis, Missouri 63102 

Tel: (314) 259-2028 

Attorneys for Defendant Fathom Realty, 

LLC 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 8 

/s/ Jason M. Powers 

Jason M. Powers 

Texas Bar No. 24007867 

jpowers@velaw.com

VINSON & ELKINS L.L.P. 

1001 Fannin St., Suite 2300 

Houston, Texas 77002-6760 

Tel: (713) 758-2522 

Fax: (713) 615-5809 

Megan Cloud 

Texas Bar No. 24116207 

mcloud@velaw.com

VINSON & ELKINS L.L.P. 

2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 3900 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (214) 220-7949 

Fax: (214) 220-7716 

Attorneys for Defendant Greater El Paso 

Association of Realtors®

/s/ Edwin Buffmire 

Edwin Buffmire 

Texas Bar No. 24078283 

ebuffmire@jw.com

JACKSON WALKER LLP 

2323 Ross Avenue, Suite 600 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (214) 953-6000 

Attorney for Defendant Greenwood King 

Properties II, Inc. 

/s/ James C. Bookhout 

James C. Bookhout 

Texas Bar No. 24087187 

James.bookhout@us.dlapiper.com

DLA PIPER LLP (US) 

1900 N. Pearl Street, Suite 2200 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (214) 743-4500 

Fax: (214) 743-4545 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 9 

Brett Ingerman (pro hac vice) 

Brett.ingerman@us.dlapiper.com

David B. Hamilton (pro hac vice) 

David.hamilton@us.dlapiper.com

Wes Reichart (pro hac vice) 

West.reichart@us.dlapiper.com

DLA PIPER LLP (US) 

650 S. Exeter Street, Suite 1100 

Baltimore, Maryland 2202 

Tel: (410) 580-4177 

Fax: (410) 580-3000 

Attorneys for Defendant Heyl Group 

Holdings LLC 

/s/ Craig B. Florence 

Craig B. Florence 

cflorence@foley.com

Texas Bar No. 07158010 

FOLEY & LARDNER LLP 

2021 McKinney Avenue, Suite 1600 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (214) 999-4796 

Fax: (214) 999-4667 

Edward D. (“Ed”) Burbach 

eburbach@foley.com

Texas Bar No. 03355250 

FOLEY & LARDNER LLP 

600 Congress Avenue, Suite 3000 

Austin, Texas 78701 

Tel: (512) 542-7000 

Fax: (512) 542-7100 

Jay N. Varon (pro hac vice) 

jvaron@foley.com

Jennifer M. Keas (pro hac vice) 

jkeas@foley.com

FOLEY & LARDNER LLP 

Washington Harbour 

3000 K Street, NW, Suite 600 

Washington, D.C. 20007 

Tel: (202) 672-5380 

Fax: (202) 672-5399 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 10 

Robert D. MacGill (pro hac vice) 

Robert.macgill@macgilllaw.com

Matthew T. Ciulla (pro hac vice) 

Matthew.ciulla@macgilllaw.com

MACGILL PC 

156 E. Market Street, Suite 1200 

Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 

Tel: (317) 721-1253 

Attorneys For Defendants 

ABA Management, L.L.C., Ebby Halliday 

Real Eestate LLC, The Dave Perry-Miller 

Company, and HomeServices of America, 

Inc.

/s/ Carl S. Burkhalter 

Carl S. Burkhalter (pro hac vice) 

cburkhalter@maynardnexsen.com

MAYNARD NEXSEN PC 

1901 Sixth Avenue North, Suite 1700 

Birmingham, Alabama 35203 

Tel: (205) 254-1000 

Fax: (205) 254-1999 

Marcus A. Manos (pro hac vice) 

mmanos@maynardnexsen.com

MAYNARD NEXSEN PC 

1230 Main Street, Suite 700 

Columbia, South Carolina 29201 

Tel: (803) 771-8900 

Fax: (803) 253-8277 

Carlos Soltero 

Texas Bar No. 00791702 

csoltero@maynardnexsen.com

MAYNARD NEXSEN PC 

Sterling Plaza 

5949 Sherry Lane, Suite 820 

Dallas, Texas 75225 

Tel: (214) 239-2360 

Fax: (214) 239-2377 

Alexandra H. Austin (pro hac vice) 

AAustin@maynardnexsen.com

MAYNARD NEXSEN PC 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 11 

205 King Street, Suite 400 

Charleston, South Carolina 29401 

Tel: (843) 579-7827

Attorneys for Defendant JP Piccinini Real 

Estate Services, LLC 

/s/ K. Annette Disch 

K. Annette Disch 

Texas Bar No. 00785822 

Annette.disch@gkbklaw.com

GAUNTT, KOEN, BINNEY & KIDD, LLP 

25700 I-45 North, Ste. 130 

Spring, Texas 77386 

Tel: (281) 367-6555 

Fax: (281) 367-3705 

Attorney for Defendants Mark Anthony 

Dimas and The Loken Group, Inc. 

/s/ Samuel Harris Johnson 

Aaron Benjamin Gottlieb 

Texas Bar No. 24069815 

aaron@jfbusinesslaw.com

Samuel Harris Johnson 

Texas Bar No. 24065507 

sam@jfbusinesslaw.com

JOHNSON FRIEDMAN LAW GROUP PLLC 

16803 Dallas Parkway, Ste. 320 

Addison, Texas 75001 

Tel: (214) 382-0300 

Fax: (214) 466-2481 

Attorneys for Defendant MJHM LLC 

/s/ Gary Neal Schumann 

Gary Neal Schumann 

Texas Bar No. 17851930 

gary@ssjmlaw.com

SAVRICK SCHUMANN JOHNSON MCGARR 

KAMINSKI & SHIRLEY, LLP 

The Overlook at Gaines Ranch 

4330 Gains Ranch Loop, Suite 150 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 12 

Austin, Texas 78735 

Tel: (512) 347-1604 

Fax: (512) 347-1676 

Attorney for Defendant Moreland 

Properties, Inc. 

/s/ Stephanie C. Sparks 

Stephanie C. Sparks 

Texas Bar No. 24042900 

ssparks@vedderprice.com

VEDDER PRICE P.C. 

300 Crescent Court, Suite 400 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (469) 895-4800 

Tel: (469) 895-4802 

Mitchell D. Cohen (pro hac vice) 

mcohen@vedderprice.com

VEDDER PRICE P.C. 

1633 Broadway 31st Floor 

New York, New York 10019 

Tel: (212) 407-7700 

Fax: (212) 407 7799 

Thomas P. Cimino 

tcimino@vedderprice.com

Gregory G. Wrobel (pro hac vice) 

gwrobel@vedderprice.com

VEDDER PRICE P.C. 

222 North LaSalle Street 

Chicago, Illinois 60601 

Tel: (312) 609-7500 

Fax: (312) 609-5005 

Attorneys for Defendant PenFed Realty, 

LLC 

/s/ David E. Dunham 

David E. Dunham 

Texas Bar No. 06227700 

david@dunhamllp.com

DUNHAM LLP 

919 Congress Avenue, Suite 910 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 13 

Austin, Texas 78701 

Tel: (512) 615-1255 

Fax: (512) 615-1256 

Attorneys for Defendant Real Agent LLC 

/s/ Chahira Solh 

Chahira Solh (Lead attorney; pro hac vice) 

csolh@crowell.com

Daniel A. Sasse (pro hac vice) 

dsasse@crowell.com

Eric Fanchiang (pro hac vice) 

efanchiang@crowell.com

CROWELL & MORING LLP 

3 Park Plaza, 20th Floor 

Irvine, California 92614 

Tel: (949) 263-8400 

Fax: (949) 263-8414 

Attorneys for Defendant Realty Austin, 

LLC 

/s/ Brenda T. Cubbage 

Brenda T. Cubbage 

Texas Bar No. 05201300 

bcubbage@cbsattorneys.com

Mary Madden Melle 

Texas Bar No. 24051789 

mmelle@cbsattorneys.com

CALHOUN, BHELLA & SECHREST, LLP 

325 N. Saint Paul Street, Suite 2300 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (214) 981-9200 

Fax: (214) 981-9203 

Attorneys for Defendant RFT Enterprises, 

Inc. 

/s/ Brian D. Schneider 

Brian D. Schneider 

brian.schneider@afslaw.com

ARENTFOX SCHIFF LLP 

1717 K Street NW 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 14 

Washington, DC 20006 

Tel: (202) 857-6000 

Fax: (202) 857-6395 

Jessica Sprovtsoff 

jessica.sprovtsoff@afslaw.com

ARENTFOX SCHIFF LLP 

350 South Main Street, Suite 210 

Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104 

Tel: (734) 222-1500 

 Fax: (734) 222-1501 

Michael E. Jones 

Texas Bar No. 10929400 

mikejones@potterminton.com

POTTER MINTON, PC 

102 North College, Suite 900 

Tyler, Texas 75702 

Tel: (903) 597-8311 

Fax: (903) 593-0846 

Attorneys for Defendant San Antonio 

Board of Realtors®, Inc. 

/s/ Gregory J. Casas 

Gregory J. Casas, Lead Counsel 

Texas Bar No. 00787213 

casasg@gtlaw.com

GREENBERG TRAURIG, LLP 

300 West 6th Street, Suite 2050 

Austin, Texas 78701 

Tel: (512) 320-7200 

Fax: (512) 320-7210 

Christopher S. Dodrill 

Texas Bar No. 24110696 

dodrillc@gtlaw.com

GREENBERG TRAURIG, LLP 

2200 Ross Avenue, Suite 5200 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (214) 665-3600 

Fax: (214) 665-3601 

Becky Leigh Caruso 

Texas Bar No. 24123942 

Becky.Caruso@gtlaw.com
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 15 

GREENBERG TRAURIG, LLP 

500 Campus Drive, Suite 400 

Florham Park, New Jersey 07932 

Tel: (973) 443-3252 

Fax: (973) 301-8410 

Attorneys for Defendant Square MB, LLC 

/s/ Brian E. Robison 

Brian E. Robison 

Texas Bar No. 00794547 

brian@brownfoxlaw.com

BROWN FOX PLLC 

6303 Cowboys Way, Suite 450 

Frisco, Texas 75034 

Tel: (972) 707-1860 

Fax: (214) 327-5001 

Charlene C. Koonce 

Texas Bar No. 11672850 

charlene@brownfox.com

C. Alan Carrillo 

Texas Bar No. 24109693 

alan@brownfoxlaw.com

BROWN FOX PLLC 

8111 Preston Road, Suite 300 

Dallas, Texas 75225 

Tel: (214) 327-5000 

Fax: (214) 327-5001

Attorneys for Defendant Side, Inc. and 

Citiquest Properties, Inc. 

/s/ Bradley J. Purcell 

Keith M. Aurzada 

Texas Bar No. 24009880 

kaurzada@reedsmith.com

Bradley J. Purcell 

Texas Bar No. 24063965 

bpurcell@reedsmith.com

REED SMITH, LLP 

2850 N. Harwood Street, Suite 1500 

Dallas, Texas 75201 

Tel: (469) 680-4200 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 16 

Fax: (469) 680-4299 

Attorneys for Defendant Team Burns, LLC 

d/b/a Monument Realty 

/s/ Frederick T. Johnson 

Frederick T. Johnson 

Texas Bar No. 00785429 

Fjohnson@SpencerFane.com

SPENCER FANE LLP 

3040 Post Oak Boulevard, Suite 1400 

Houston, Texas 77056 

Tel: (713) 212-2635 

Fax: (713) 963-0859 

Sean Whyte 

Texas Bar No. 24047100 

SWhyte@SpencerFane.com

Shelby Menard 

Texas Bar No. 24106581 

Smenard@SpencerFane.com

Mavish Bana 

Texas Bar No. 24096653 

Mbana@spencerfane.com

SPENCER FANE LLP 

5700 Granite Parkway, Suite 650 

Plano, Texas 75024 

Tel: (972) 324-0300 

Fax: (972) 324-0301 

Thomas W. Hayde 

(pro hac vice pending) 

Thayde@SpencerFane.com

SPENCER FANE LLP 

1 N. Brentwood Blvd., Suite 1000 

St. Louis, Missouri 63105 

Tel: (972) 324-0300 

Fax: (972) 324-0301 

Attorneys for Defendant Turner Mangum 

LLC 
DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE PAGE 17 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

Pursuant to Rule 5(d)(1)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, as amended, no 

certificate of service is necessary because this document is being filed with the court’s electronic 

filing system.