IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS 

TYLER DIVISION

THE DAILY WIRE, LLC; 

FDRLST MEDIA, LLC; and

THE STATE OF TEXAS, by and through its 

Attorney General, Ken Paxton, 

Plaintiffs, 

v. 

DEPARTMENT OF STATE;

GLOBAL ENGAGEMENT CENTER;

ANTONY BLINKEN, in his official capacity as 

Secretary of State;

LEAH BRAY, in her official capacity as Deputy 

Coordinator of the State Department’s Global 

Engagement Center;

JAMES P. RUBIN, in his official capacity as 

Coordinator for the Global Engagement Center of the 

State Department;

DANIEL KIMMAGE, in his official capacity as the 

Principal Deputy Coordinator for the Global 

Engagement Center at the State Department;

ALEXIS FRISBIE, in her official capacity as Senior 

Technical Advisor of the Technology Engagement 

Team for the Global Engagement Center at the State 

Department;

PATRICIA WATTS, in her official capacity as the 

Director of the Technology Engagement Team at the 

Global Engagement Center at the State Department,

Defendants. 

Civil Action No.: 6:23-cv-00609 

 

EXHIBIT 1

Case 6:23-cv-00609-JDK Document 25-1 Filed 03/14/24 Page 1 of 5 PageID #: 720
1/4

‘The Decision Was Made’: Texas Bishop Fired By Pope

Says He Declined To Resign, Wasn’t Given Reason

For Dismissal

available at: dailywire.com/news/the-decision-was-made-texas-bishop-fired-by-pope-says-he-declined-to-resignwasnt-given-reason-for-dismissal

— News —

By Bree Dail

Nov 14, 2023 DailyWire.com

Alberto Pizzoli/AFP via Getty Images

VATICAN CITY — On Saturday, news broke that Pope Francis had removed Bishop Joseph

Strickland from his position as Bishop of Tyler, Texas, effective immediately and without

appeal, according to the announcement from Holy See Press Office.

Considered an outspoken “conservative” in the American church, Strickland has been under

fire for recent controversial criticisms of Pope Francis, both on social media and the press,

and as a featured guest at several recent controversial conferences. Yet, Bishops in

Case 6:23-cv-00609-JDK Document 25-1 Filed 03/14/24 Page 2 of 5 PageID #: 721
2/4

Germany have been equally outspoken in the press, even defiant in opposition to Pope

Francis — not solely on political differences, but Catholic Social and Doctrinal teachings —

and seemingly with no response by the Holy See.

Could the disparity be due to a focus of Pope Francis and his advisors on what they consider

conservative America’s “backward” and “reactionary attitude”?

Less than a month ago, at the opening of his “Synod on Synodality,” the Pope decried what

he views as the ambitious political machinations and clerical secrecy that has plagued the

Catholic Hierarchy, and which he believes has led to distrust of it by the faithful: “When the

ministers exceed their service and mistreat the people of God, they disfigure the face of the

church with machismo and dictatorial attitudes.”

Yet, Saturday’s announcement came with no details to the cause for Strickland’s forced

removal, despite the Pope’s repeated promises of a transparent pontificate and words of

condemnation of clericalism.

According to media reports, the removal of a Bishop from his diocese has been a rare

occurrence, with a total of nine removals over the last three decades — the majority of which

have been occurred by order of Pope Francis. Canon Lawyers, who practice the law of the

Catholic Church, state that until recently, a forced removal of a Bishop would only take place

as a result of serious allegations — “penal privation or deposition of a bishop for a canonical

delict or crime.”

In the case of Bishop Joseph Strickland, however, very little is known other than claims of an

“administrative” removal as the cause for investigation, and conclusions have remained

shrouded, leaving the door wide open to reactions and speculation.

In June, it was reported that Pope Francis had issued an Apostolic Visitation (or investigation

by representatives of the Holy See) of Strickland and his Diocese. A month prior to this

investigation, the now-former Bishop of Tyler had published a post on social media, stating

that although he disagreed with those who rejected the authenticity of the pontificate of Pope

Francis, he did reject “his program of undermining the Deposit of Faith.”

Case 6:23-cv-00609-JDK Document 25-1 Filed 03/14/24 Page 3 of 5 PageID #: 722
3/4

After a “series of days” of “confidential” investigation concluded, in late June, a report was

sent back to the Vatican by way of Cardinal Christophe Pierre, the Vatican’s Nuncio to the

United States.

On September 11, Catholic outlet The Pillar reported that the Pope had met with Cardinals

Pierre and Robert Prevost — the latter being the Prefect for the Dicastery for Bishops — who

recommended that the Pope ask for Strickland’s formal resignation. This report, according to

Strickland’s responses to media inquiries at the time, came as a complete surprise to him.

“As a basic principle I cannot resign the mandate given to me by Pope Benedict XVI,” he

said. “Of course that mandate can be rescinded by Pope Francis, but I cannot voluntarily

abandon the flock that I have been given charge of as a successor of the apostles.”

By Nov 9, according to Bishop Strickland, he was told he was to meet with Cardinal Pierre,

he explained.

“The Nuncio presented about 4 pages of ‘concerns’ at our meeting but the official letter he

provided did not mention any reason to why I was being asked to resign.” Strickland told The

Daily Wire.

The bishop also stated that the list of concerns drawn up against him were not provided in

writing for his own records, nor was the opportunity to address the concerns or appeal to the

Pope. “When I met with the Nuncio on November 9, I told him I couldn’t resign as my own

choice but if the Holy Father chose to remove me I would obey.”

Asked if it seemed to him that the Pope’s representative already had a predetermined

outcome to this meeting, Strickland stated that when he refused to voluntarily resign, “the

Nuncio responded that I would be removed (by the Pope).

“As the Nuncio put it, he was there to deliver a message, but there was no discussion,”

Stickland said “The decision was made.”

When asked if he was under any censure, or restrictions of his faculties—and if not, what his

role would now be, Strickland responded that he was not informed that he was under any

restrictions, and that “Nothing was said explicitly (in the letter) but I presume I am a retired

bishop. I have no diocesan jurisdiction but I am able to function with the approval/permission

of the local ordinary.”

The Daily Wire contacted Cardinal Christophe Pierre, the Vatican’s Nuncio in charge of the

investigation, both by phone and email, with questions regarding the concerns he presented

to the Bishop, but received no reply by the time of publishing.

The 65-year-old Strickland was born and raised in rural Texas, and was consecrated a

bishop on November 28, 2012, under the pontificate of Pope Benedict XVI.

Case 6:23-cv-00609-JDK Document 25-1 Filed 03/14/24 Page 4 of 5 PageID #: 723
4/4

Early on in his priesthood, he was adverse to the conservative circles he now frequents,

telling this reporter in an interview in 2020, “It pains me to say this, but part of my hesitancy I

believe in learning how to say the extraordinary form came from my experience of the

community who attend ... discord, division, sectarianism, elitism, even spiritual pride. These

cannot be from the liturgy — it is fully human, reactionary.”

Yet, throughout the last few years, Strickland appears to have been convinced that an

ideological war is being waged amongst the clergy, even at the highest level of the Church,

centered around tradition and the right to life.

Strickland’s vocal stances with the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, and viral posts to

his nearly 168k followers on X, have made him an immediate lightning rod for critics and

provocateurs alike.

When asked by The Daily Wire if he would continue publishing on social media the Bishop

responded, “Yes, I intend to continue using the media. I have learned a few things and I hope

to use social media more effectively to share the truth of the Gospel.”

Bishop Strickland’s popularity has also led him to attend rallies and conferences over the last

year — a lucrative industry, in particular, for Catholic activists and commentators. One such

conference took place early this month in the Eternal City, in which the Bishop read aloud a

letter from an unnamed friend, stating, in part, that he should not “play nice” while in Rome,

and that cowards had been gathered by the “usurper of Peter’s chair.” The video and

transcript have since been used as an example supporting the removal of the Bishop.

When asked what his message was to those who oppose him, found themselves

scandalized by his removal, or angered by the Pope’s decision, Bishop Joseph Strickland

replied, “I’ve encouraged people to take it all to prayer, my hope is that they commit even

more deeply to Christ and His Church. Ultimately the Pope and I are successors of the

Apostles called to serve Christ’s Church. Christ is the head and we are the body.”

In his announcement on Saturday, Pope Francis assigned Bishop Joe Vàsquez of Austin,

Texas, to oversee the Apostolic Administration of the Diocese of Tyler, until a permanent

replacement is identified.

Case 6:23-cv-00609-JDK Document 25-1 Filed 03/14/24 Page 5 of 5 PageID #: 724