<PAGE>

                                                                     EXHIBIT 4.9

                          SUBSIDIARY PLEDGE AGREEMENT
                             (LOCAL FIBER, L.L.C.)

     This SUBSIDIARY PLEDGE AGREEMENT (as amended, supplemented, amended and
restated or otherwise modified from time to time, this "Pledge Agreement"), is
entered into as of April 11, 2000, by FIBERNET TELECOM, INC., a Delaware
corporation (the "Pledgor"), in favor of DEUTSCHE BANK AG NEW YORK BRANCH, as
administrative agent (together with any successor(s) thereto in such capacity,
the "Administrative Agent") for each of the Secured Parties.


                                   RECITALS
                                   --------

     A.   Pursuant to the Credit Agreement, dated as of April 11, 2000 (as
amended, supplemented, amended and restated or otherwise modified from time to
time, the "Credit Agreement"), among FiberNet Telecom Group, Inc., a Delaware
corporation (the "Borrower"), the financial institutions from time to time
parties thereto as lenders (collectively, the "Lenders"), the Administrative
Agent, Deutsche Bank Securities Inc., as co-syndications agent, and Toronto
Dominion (Texas), Inc., as co-syndications agent, the Lenders have extended
commitments to make Loans and to issue Letters of Credit (each as defined in the
Credit Agreement) to, and for the benefit of, the Borrower;

     B.   It is a condition precedent to the making of the Loans and issuance of
the Letters of Credit under the Credit Agreement that the Pledgor execute and
deliver this Pledge Agreement;

     C.   The Pledgor has duly authorized the execution, delivery and
performance of this Pledge Agreement; and

     D.   It is in the best interest of the Pledgor to execute this Pledge
Agreement as the Pledgor will derive substantial direct and indirect benefits
from the Loans made to the Borrower, and the Letters of Credit issued for the
benefit of the Borrower, from time to time pursuant to the Credit Agreement.

                                   AGREEMENT
                                   ---------

     NOW, THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and
sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, and in order to induce the Lenders
to make the Loans and issue the Letters of Credit to or for the benefit of the
Borrower pursuant to the Credit Agreement and to induce the Secured Parties to
enter into any Interest Rate Agreements, the Pledgor agrees, for the benefit of
each Secured Party, as follows:
<PAGE>

                                  ARTICLE I.
                                 DEFINITIONS

     Section 1.1  Defined Terms.
                  -------------

     The following terms when used in this Pledge Agreement shall have the
following meanings:

     "Administrative Agent" shall have the meaning assigned to such term in the
Preamble.
--------

     "Capital Stock" means any and all shares, interests, participations or
other equivalents (however designated) of capital stock of a corporation, any
and all equivalent ownership interests in a Person other than a corporation
(including partnership interests in a partnership, member interests in a limited
liability company and beneficial interests in a trust), and any and all
warrants, options and other rights to purchase any of the foregoing.

     "Credit Agreement" shall have the meaning assigned to such term in the
Recitals.
--------

     "Distributions" means all stock dividends, liquidating dividends, shares of
stock resulting from (or in connection with the exercise of) stock splits,
reclassifications, warrants, options, non-cash dividends, mergers,
consolidations, and all other distributions (whether similar or dissimilar to
the foregoing) on or with respect to any Pledged Shares or other shares of
Capital Stock constituting Pledged Collateral, but shall not include Dividends
or repurchases of redeemable shares.

     "Dividends" means cash dividends and cash distributions with respect to any
Pledged Shares or other Pledged Property which is not a liquidating dividend.

     "Lender" shall have the meaning assigned to such term in the Recitals.
                                                                  --------

     "Pledge Agreement" shall have the meaning assigned to such term in the
Preamble.
--------

     "Pledged Collateral" shall have the meaning assigned to such term in
Section 2.1.
-----------

     "Pledged Note Issuer" means each Person identified in Item A of Attachment
                                                           ------    ----------
1 hereto as the issuer of the Pledged Note identified opposite the name of such
-
Person.

     "Pledged Notes" means all notes (including, without limitation, promissory
notes and notes evidencing indebtedness of (i) a Subsidiary of the Pledgor to
the Pledgor or any other Subsidiary of the Pledgor, or (ii) the Pledgor to any
of its Subsidiaries) of any Pledged Note Issuer which are required to be
delivered by the Pledgor to the Administrative Agent as Pledged Property
hereunder.

                                       2
<PAGE>

     "Pledged Property" means all Pledged Shares, all Pledged Notes, and all
other pledged shares of Capital Stock or promissory notes, all other securities,
all assignments of any amounts due or to become due, all other instruments which
are now being delivered by the Pledgor to the Administrative Agent or may from
time to time hereafter be delivered by the Pledgor to the Administrative Agent
for the purpose of pledge under this Pledge Agreement or any other Loan
Document, and all proceeds of any of the foregoing.

     "Pledged Share Issuer" means each Person identified in Item B of Attachment
                                                            ------    ----------
1 hereto as the issuer of the Pledged Shares identified opposite the name of
-
such Person.

     "Pledged Shares" means all shares or interest of Capital Stock of any
Pledged Share Issuer which are required to be delivered by the Pledgor to the
Administrative Agent as Pledged Property hereunder.

     "Pledged Subsidiary" means Local Fiber, L.L.C.

     "Pledgor" shall have the meaning assigned to such term in the Preamble.
                                                                   --------

     "Securities Act" shall have the meaning assigned to such term in Section
                                                                      -------
6.2.
---

     "UCC" shall have the meaning assigned to such term in Section 1.3.
                                                           -----------

     Section 1.2  Credit Agreement Definitions.
                  ----------------------------

     Unless otherwise defined herein or unless the context otherwise requires,
terms used in this Pledge Agreement, including, without limitation, its preamble
and recitals, have the meanings provided in the Credit Agreement.  Nothing in
this Pledge Agreement shall be construed as limiting any of the rights and
remedies under the Credit Agreement, unless expressly set forth herein.

     Section 1.3  UCC Definitions.
                  ---------------

     Unless otherwise defined herein or in the Credit Agreement or unless the
context otherwise requires, terms for which meanings are provided in the Uniform
Commercial Code of the applicable jurisdiction ("UCC") are used in this Pledge
Agreement, including, without limitation, its preamble and recitals, with such
meanings.

                                  ARTICLE II.
                                    PLEDGE

     Section 2.1  Grant of Security Interest.
                  --------------------------

     As security for the due and punctual payments in full in cash and
performance in full of all Obligations, the Pledgor hereby pledges,
hypothecates, assigns, charges, mortgages, delivers, and transfers to the
Administrative Agent for its benefit and the ratable benefit of each of the

                                       3
<PAGE>

Secured Parties, and hereby grants to the Administrative Agent for its benefit
and the ratable benefit of each of the Secured Parties, a continuing security
interest in all of the following property (the "Pledged Collateral"):

                  (a) all promissory notes of each Pledged Note Issuer
          identified in Item A of Attachment I hereto;
                        ------    ------------

                  (b) all issued and outstanding shares of Capital Stock of each
          Pledged Share Issuer identified in Item B of Attachment 1 hereto;
                                             ------    ------------

                  (c) all securities, notes, certificates and instruments
          representing or evidencing the Pledged Property or the ownership
          thereof and any interest of the Pledgor reflected in the books of any
          financial intermediary pertaining to the Pledged Property or of any
          Pledged Share Issuer thereof and all non-cash dividends, cash,
          options, warrants, stock splits, reclassifications, rights,
          instruments or other investment property and other property or
          proceeds from time to time received, receivable or otherwise
          distributed in respect of or in exchange for any or all of the Pledged
          Property;

                  (d) all additional Capital Stock of any Pledged Share Issuer
          from time to time held or acquired by the Pledgor in any manner (which
          shares shall be deemed to be part of the Pledged Property), and all
          securities, certificates and instruments representing or evidencing
          such additional Capital Stock or the ownership thereof and any
          interest of the Pledgor reflected in the books of any financial
          intermediary pertaining to such additional Capital Stock or of the
          Pledged Share Issuer thereof, and all non-cash dividends, cash,
          options, warrants, rights, instruments and other property or proceeds
          from time to time received, receivable or otherwise distributed in
          respect of or in exchange for any or all of such Capital Stock;

                  (e) all other Pledged Property, whether now or hereafter
          delivered to the Administrative Agent in connection with this Pledge
          Agreement;

                  (f) all Dividends, Distributions, interest and other payments;

                  (g) all other options, warrants and rights to subscribe for or
          purchase voting or nonvoting Capital Stock of any Pledged Share Issuer
          and any present or future notes, bonds, debentures or other evidences
          of indebtedness owned by the Pledgor that (i) are at any time
          convertible into Capital Stock of any Pledged Share Issuer, or (ii)
          have or at any time would have voting rights with respect to any
          Pledged Share Issuer;

                  (h) all voting rights in respect of the Pledged Property; and

                                       4
<PAGE>

                  (i)  all proceeds of any of the foregoing.

     Section 2.2  Delivery of Pledged Property.
                  ----------------------------

     All certificates or instruments representing or evidencing any Pledged
Collateral, including, without limitation, all Pledged Shares and all Pledged
Notes, shall be delivered to and held by or on behalf of and, in the case of the
Pledged Notes, endorsed to the order of the Administrative Agent or its designee
pursuant hereto, shall be in suitable form for transfer by delivery, and shall
be accompanied by all necessary instruments of transfer or assignment, duly
executed in blank.

     Section 2.3  Continuing Security Interest; Transfer of Note.
                  -----------------------------------------------

     This Pledge Agreement shall create a continuing security interest in the
Pledged Collateral and shall

                  (a)  remain in full force and effect until payment in full in
          cash of all Obligations,

                  (b)  be binding upon the Pledgor and its successors,
          transferees and assigns, and

                  (c) inure, together with the rights and remedies of the
          Administrative Agent hereunder, to the benefit of the Administrative
          Agent.

Without limiting the foregoing clause (c), any Lender may assign or otherwise
                               ----------
transfer (in whole or in part) any Note, Loan or Commitment held by it to any
other Person or entity as permitted by, and in accordance with the terms of, the
Credit Agreement, and such other Person or entity shall thereupon become vested
with all the rights and benefits in respect thereof granted to such Lender under
any Loan Document (including, without limitation, this Pledge Agreement) or
otherwise.

     Section 2.4  Security Interest Absolute.
                  ---------------------------

     All rights of the Administrative Agent and the security interests granted
to the Administrative Agent hereunder, and all obligations of the Pledgor
hereunder, shall be absolute and unconditional irrespective of :

                  (a) any lack of validity, legality or enforceability of the
          Credit Agreement, any Note, or any other Loan Document or any Interest
          Rate Agreement;

                  (b) the failure of any Secured Party or any holder of any Note

                                       5
<PAGE>

                    (i)  to assert any claim or demand or to enforce any right
               or remedy against the Borrower, any other Loan Party or any other
               Person (including any other pledgor) under the provisions of the
               Credit Agreement, any Note, any other Loan Document, any Interest
               Rate Agreement or otherwise, or

                    (ii) to exercise any right or remedy against any other
               pledgor of, or collateral securing, any of the Obligations;

               (c)  any change in the time, manner or place of payment of, or in
          any other term of, all or any of the Obligations, or any other
          extension or renewal of any Obligation of the Borrower or any other
          Loan Party;

               (d)  any reduction, limitation, impairment or termination of any
          of the Obligations for any reason other than the written agreement of
          the Secured Parties to terminate the Obligations in full, including
          any claim of waiver, release, surrender, alteration or compromise, and
          shall not be subject to, and the Pledgor hereby waives any right to or
          claim of, any defense or setoff, counterclaim, recoupment or
          termination whatsoever by reason of the invalidity, illegality,
          nongenuineness, irregularity, compromise, unenforceability of, or any
          other event or occurrence affecting, any Obligations of the Borrower,
          any other Loan Party or otherwise;

               (e)  any amendment to, rescission, waiver, or other modification
          of, or any consent to departure from, any of the terms of the Credit
          Agreement, any Note, any other Loan Document or any Interest Rate
          Agreement;

               (f)  any addition, exchange, release, surrender or non-perfection
          of any collateral, or any amendment to or waiver or release or
          addition of, or consent to departure from, any other pledgor held by
          any Secured Party or any holder of any Note securing any of the
          Obligations; or

               (g)  any other circumstance which might otherwise constitute a
          defense available to, or a legal or equitable discharge of, the
          Borrower, any other Loan Party, any surety or any pledgor.

     Section 2.5  Postponement of Subrogation.
                  ---------------------------

     The Pledgor agrees that it will not exercise any rights which it may
acquire by way of rights of subrogation under this Pledge, by any payment made
hereunder or otherwise, until the prior payment in full in cash of all of the
Obligations, the termination of all Interest Rate Agreements to which any
Secured Party is a party and the termination of all Commitments.  Any amount
paid to the Pledgor on account of any such subrogation rights prior to the
payment in full in cash of all of the Obligations shall be held in trust for the
benefit of the Secured Parties and each holder of a Note and shall immediately
be paid to the Administrative Agent for the benefit of the Secured Parties and

                                       6
<PAGE>

each holder of a Note and credited and applied against the Obligations of the
Borrower and each other Loan Party, whether matured or unmatured, such order as
the Administrative Agent shall elect; provided, however, that if
                                      --------  -------

               (a) the Pledgor has made payment to the Secured Parties and each
          holder of a Note of all or any part of the Obligations, and

               (b) all Obligations have been paid in full in cash, all Interest
          Rate Agreements to which any Secured Party is a party have been
          terminated and all Commitments have been permanently terminated,

then, at the Pledgor's request, the Administrative Agent, on behalf of the
Secured Parties and the holders of the Notes, will execute and deliver to the
Pledgor appropriate documents (without recourse and without representation or
warranty) necessary to evidence the transfer by subrogation to the Pledgor of an
interest in the Obligations resulting from such payment by the Pledgor.  In
furtherance of the foregoing, for so long as any Obligations or Commitments
remain outstanding, the Pledgor shall refrain from taking any action or
commencing any proceeding against the Borrower or any other Loan Party (or any
of its or their successors or assigns, whether in connection with a bankruptcy
proceeding or otherwise) to recover any amounts in respect of payments made
under this Pledge to any Secured Party or any holder of a Note, except that the
Pledgor may file a proof of claim in a bankruptcy proceeding with respect to the
Borrower or any other Loan Party in connection with any obligations owed by such
Loan Party to the Pledgor in the event that the Administrative Agent has failed
to file a proof of claim on the Pledgor's behalf by the second business day
before the due date for such filing.

                                 ARTICLE III.
                        REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES

     The Pledgor represents and warrants to the Administrative Agent for the
benefit of the Administrative Agent as set forth in this Article.

     Section 3.1  Ownership, No Liens, Etc.
                  -------------------------

     The Pledgor is the legal and beneficial owner of, and has good and
marketable title to (and has full right and authority to pledge and assign), the
Pledged Collateral, free and clear of all Liens except Permitted Liens.

                                       7
<PAGE>

     Section 3.2  Valid Security Interest.
                  -----------------------

     The execution and delivery of this Pledge Agreement, together with the
delivery of all Pledged Shares and all Pledged Notes to the Administrative
Agent, is effective to create a valid, perfected, first priority security
interest in such Pledged Collateral, securing payment of the Obligations.
Possession by the Administrative Agent of the Pledged Shares and the proceeds
thereof is the only action necessary to perfect or protect such security
interest in the Pledged Shares and the proceeds thereof under the UCC, subject
to Section 9-306 of the UCC.

     Section 3.3  As to Pledged Shares.
                  --------------------

     The Pledged Shares are duly authorized and validly issued, fully paid, and
non-assessable, and constitute all of the issued and outstanding shares of
Capital Stock of each Pledged Share Issuer, except as otherwise described on
Schedule 4.1.D to the Credit Agreement.
--------------

     Section 3.4  As to Pledged Notes.
                  -------------------

     Each Pledged Note has been duly authorized, executed, endorsed, issued and
delivered, and is the legal, valid and binding obligation of the issuer thereof,
and such issuer is not in default thereunder.

     Section 3.5  Authorization, Approval, etc.
                  ----------------------------

     No authorization, approval, or other action by, and no notice to or filing
with, any governmental authority, regulatory body or any other Person is
required either

                  (a)  for the pledge by the Pledgor of any Pledged Collateral
          pursuant to this Pledge Agreement or for the execution, delivery, and
          performance of this Pledge Agreement by the Pledgor, or

                  (b)  except as set forth in Schedule 3.5 hereto, for the
                                              ------------
          exercise by the Administrative Agent of the voting or other rights
          provided for in this Pledge Agreement.

     Section 3.6  Application of Representations and Warranties.
                  ---------------------------------------------

     It is understood and agreed that the foregoing representations and
warranties shall apply only to the Pledged Collateral delivered on the date
hereof and that, with respect to Pledged Collateral delivered thereafter, the
Pledgor shall be required to make representations and warranties in form and
substance substantially similar to the foregoing in supplements hereto and that
such representations and warranties contained in such supplements hereto shall
be applicable to such Pledged Collateral hereafter delivered.

                                       8
<PAGE>

                                  ARTICLE IV.
                                   COVENANTS

     Section 4.1  Protect Pledged Collateral.
                  --------------------------

     The Pledgor will not sell, assign, transfer, pledge, or encumber in any
other manner the Pledged Collateral except in accordance with the Credit
Agreement.  The Pledgor will warrant and defend the right and title herein
granted unto the Administrative Agent in and to the Pledged Collateral (and all
right, title, and interest represented by the Pledged Collateral) against the
claims and demands of all Persons whomsoever.

     Section 4.2  Stock Powers, Etc.
                  -----------------

     The Pledgor agrees that all Pledged Shares (and all other shares of Capital
Stock constituting Pledged Collateral) delivered by the Pledgor pursuant to this
Pledge Agreement will be accompanied by duly executed undated blank stock
powers, or other equivalent instruments of transfer acceptable to the
Administrative Agent.  The Pledgor shall, from time to time upon the request of
the Administrative Agent, promptly deliver to the Administrative Agent such
stock powers, instruments, and similar documents, in form and substance
reasonably satisfactory to the Administrative Agent, with respect to the Pledged
Collateral as the Administrative Agent may reasonably request and shall, from
time to time upon the request of the Administrative Agent after the occurrence,
and during the continuance, of any Event of Default, promptly transfer any
Pledged Shares or other shares of common stock constituting Pledged Collateral
into the name of any nominee designated by the Administrative Agent.

     Section 4.3  Continuous Pledge.
                  -----------------

     The Pledgor shall, at all times, keep pledged to the Administrative Agent
pursuant hereto all Pledged Shares and all other shares of Capital Stock
constituting Pledged Collateral, all Dividends and Distributions with respect
thereto, all Pledged Notes, all interest, principal and other proceeds received
by the Administrative Agent with respect to the Pledged Notes, and all other
Pledged Collateral and other securities, instruments, proceeds, and rights from
time to time received by or distributable to the Pledgor in respect of any
Pledged Collateral and will not permit any Pledged Share Issuer to issue any
Capital Stock which shall not have been immediately duly pledged hereunder on a
first priority perfected basis.

     Section 4.4  Voting Rights, Dividends, Etc.
                  -----------------------------

                  (a)  If any Event of Default shall have occurred and be
          continuing, promptly upon receipt of notice thereof by the Pledgor,
          the Pledgor shall deliver (properly endorsed where required hereby or
          requested by the Administrative Agent) to the Administrative Agent,
          without any request therefor by the Administrative Agent, all
          Dividends, all Distributions, all interest, all principal, all other
          cash payments, and all proceeds of the Pledged Collateral, all of
          which shall

                                       9
<PAGE>

     be held by the Administrative Agent as additional Pledged Collateral for
     use in accordance with Section 6.4.
                            -----------

               (b)  If any Event of Default shall have occurred and be
          continuing, and the Administrative Agent shall have notified the
          Pledgor of the Administrative Agent's intention to exercise its right
          under this Section 4.4(b) to exercise (to the exclusion of the
          Pledgor) the voting power and all other incidental rights of ownership
          with respect to any Pledged Shares or other shares of Capital Stock
          constituting Pledged Collateral, the Pledgor shall grant the
          Administrative Agent an irrevocable proxy, exercisable under such
          circumstances, to vote the Pledged Shares and such other Pledged
          Collateral and shall promptly deliver to the Administrative Agent such
          additional proxies and other documents as may be necessary to allow
          the Administrative Agent to effectively exercise such voting power.

               (c)  All Dividends, Distributions, interest, principal, cash
          payments, and proceeds which may at any time and from time to time be
          held by the Pledgor but which the Pledgor is then obligated to deliver
          to the Administrative Agent, shall, until delivery to the
          Administrative Agent, be held by the Pledgor separate and apart from
          its other property in trust for the Administrative Agent. The
          Administrative Agent agrees that unless any Event of Default shall
          have occurred and be continuing and the Administrative Agent shall
          have given the notice referred to in Section 4.4(b), the Pledgor shall
                                               --------------
          have the exclusive voting power with respect to any shares of Capital
          Stock (including, without limitation, any of the Pledged Shares)
          constituting Pledged Collateral and the Administrative Agent shall,
          upon the written request of the Pledgor, promptly deliver such proxies
          and other documents, if any, as shall be reasonably requested by the
          Pledgor which are necessary to allow the Pledgor to exercise voting
          power with respect to any such share of Capital Stock (including,
          without limitation, any of the Pledged Shares) constituting Pledged
          Collateral; provided, however, that no vote shall be cast, or consent,
                      --------  -------
          waiver, or ratification given, or action taken by the Pledgor that
          would be inconsistent with or violate any provision of any Loan
          Document.

     Section 4.5  Additional Undertakings.
                  -----------------------

     The Pledgor shall not, without the prior written consent of the
Administrative Agent:

                  (a)  enter into any agreement amending, supplementing, or
     waiving any provision of any Pledged Note (including, without limitation,
     any underlying instrument pursuant to which such Pledged Note is issued) or
     compromising or releasing or extending the time for payment of any
     obligation of the maker thereof;

                  (b)  take or omit to take any action the taking or the
     omission of which would result in any impairment or alteration of any
     obligation of the maker of any

                                       10
<PAGE>

     Pledged Note or other instrument constituting Pledged Collateral (unless
     permitted by the Credit Agreement);

                  (c) take or omit to take any action which would result in the
                  Pledgor ceasing to own directly all of the Capital Stock of
                  the Pledged Subsidiary(ies); or

                  (d) take or omit to take any action which would result in the
                  creation, incorporation or formation of any direct or indirect
                  Subsidiary of the Borrower which is not validly existing as of
                  the date hereof.


                                  ARTICLE V.
                           THE ADMINISTRATIVE AGENT

     Section 5.1  Administrative Agent Appointed Attorney-in-Fact.
                  -----------------------------------------------

     The Pledgor hereby irrevocably appoints the Administrative Agent the
Pledgor's attorney-in-fact, with full authority in the place and stead of the
Pledgor and in the name of the Pledgor or otherwise, from time to time in the
Administrative Agent's discretion, following the occurrence and during the
continuation of any Event of Default, to take any action and to execute any
instrument which the Administrative Agent may deem necessary or advisable to
accomplish the purposes of this Pledge Agreement, including, without limitation:

                  (a) to ask, demand, collect, sue for, recover, compromise,
          receive and give acquittance and receipts for moneys due and to become
          due under or in respect of any of the Pledged Collateral;

                  (b) to receive, endorse, and collect any drafts or other
          instruments, documents and chattel paper, in connection with clause
                                                                       ------
          (a) above;
          ---

                  (c) to file any claims or take any action or institute any
          proceedings which the Administrative Agent may deem necessary or
          desirable for the collection of any of the Pledged Collateral or
          otherwise to enforce the rights of the Administrative Agent with
          respect to any of the Pledged Collateral; provided that, with respect
                                                    --------
          to this clause (c), such rights shall be exercised in accordance with
                  ----------
          Section 6.1; and
          -----------

                  (d) to perform the affirmative Obligations of the Pledgor
          hereunder or under any other Loan Document.

     The Pledgor hereby acknowledges, consents and agrees that the power of
attorney granted pursuant to this Section is irrevocable and coupled with an
interest.

                                       11
<PAGE>

     Section 5.2  Administrative Agent May Perform.
                  --------------------------------

     The Administrative Agent may from time to time, at its option, perform or
cause to be performed any act which the Pledgor agrees hereunder to perform and
which the Pledgor fails to perform.  In addition, the Administrative Agent may
from time to time take any other action which the Administrative Agent
reasonably deems necessary for the maintenance, preservation or protection of
any of the Pledged Collateral or of its security interest therein.  Expenses
incurred by the Administrative Agent pursuant to this Section 5.2 shall be
                                                      -----------
payable by the Pledgor pursuant to Section 6.5.
                                   -----------

     Section 5.3  Administrative Agent Has No Duty.
                  --------------------------------

     The powers conferred on the Administrative Agent hereunder are solely to
protect its interest in the Pledged Collateral and shall not impose any duty on
it to exercise any such powers. Except for the reasonable care of any Pledged
Collateral (subject to Section 5.4) in its possession and the accounting for
                       -----------
moneys actually received by it hereunder, the Administrative Agent shall have no
duty as to any Pledged Collateral or responsibility for (a) ascertaining or
taking action with respect to calls, conversions, exchanges, maturities, tenders
or other matters relative to any Pledged Property, whether or not the
Administrative Agent has or is deemed to have knowledge of such matters, or (b)
taking any necessary steps to preserve rights against prior parties or any other
rights pertaining to any Pledged Collateral.

     Section 5.4  Reasonable Care.
                  ---------------

     The Administrative Agent is required to exercise reasonable care in the
custody and preservation of any of the Pledged Collateral in its possession;
provided, however, the Administrative Agent shall be deemed to have exercised
--------- -------
reasonable care in the custody and preservation of any of the Pledged Collateral
if it takes such action for that purpose as the Pledgor reasonably requests in
writing at times other than upon the occurrence and during the continuance of
any Event of Default, but failure of the Administrative Agent to comply with any
such request at any time shall not in itself be deemed a failure to exercise
reasonable care.

                                  ARTICLE VI.
                                   REMEDIES

     Section 6.1  Certain Remedies.
                  ----------------
     If any Event of Default shall have occurred and be continuing:

                  (a)  The Administrative Agent may exercise in respect of the
            Pledged Collateral, in addition to other rights and remedies
            provided for herein or otherwise available to it, all the rights and
            remedies of a secured party on default under the UCC (whether or not
            the UCC applies to the affected Pledged Collateral) and also may,
            without notice except as specified below, sell the

                                       12
<PAGE>

            Pledged Collateral or any part thereof in one or more parcels at
            public or private sale, at any of the Administrative Agent's offices
            or elsewhere, for cash, on credit or for future delivery, and upon
            such other terms as the Administrative Agent may deem commercially
            reasonable. The Pledgor agrees that, to the extent notice of sale
            shall be required by law, at least ten days prior notice to the
            Pledgor of the time and place of any public sale or the time after
            which any private sale is to be made shall constitute reasonable
            notification. The Administrative Agent shall not be obligated to
            make any sale of Pledged Collateral regardless of notice of sale
            having been given. The Administrative Agent may adjourn any public
            or private sale from time to time by announcement at the time and
            place fixed therefor, and such sale may, without further notice, be
            made at the time and place to which it was so adjourned.

               (b)  The Administrative Agent may:

                    (i)   transfer all or any part of the Pledged Collateral
               into the name of the Administrative Agent or its nominee, with or
               without disclosing that such Pledged Collateral is subject to the
               lien and security interest granted hereunder,

                    (ii)  notify the parties obligated on any of the Pledged
               Collateral to make payment to the Administrative Agent of any
               amount due or to become due thereunder,

                    (iii) enforce collection of any of the Pledged Collateral by
               suit or otherwise, and surrender, release or exchange all or any
               part thereof, or compromise or extend or renew for any period
               (whether or not longer than the original period) any Obligations
               of any nature of any party with respect thereto,

                    (iv)  endorse any checks, drafts, or other writings in the
               Pledgor's name to allow collection of the Pledged Collateral,

                    (v)   take control of any proceeds of the Pledged
               Collateral, and

                    (vi)  execute (in the name, place and stead of the Pledgor)
               endorsements, assignments, stock powers and other instruments of
               conveyance or transfer with respect to all or any of the Pledged
               Collateral.

All rights and remedies provided for in this Pledge Agreement are cumulative,
and not exclusive of any other rights or remedies.  No failure or delay by the
Administrative Agent in exercising any right or power hereunder shall operate as
a waiver thereof, nor shall any single or partial exercise of any such right or
power, or any abandonment or discontinuance of steps to enforce such a

                                       13
<PAGE>

right or power, preclude any other or further exercise thereof or the exercise
of any other right or power.

     Section 6.2  Securities Laws.
                  ---------------

     If the Administrative Agent shall determine to exercise its right to sell
all or any of the Pledged Collateral pursuant to Section 6.1, the Pledgor shall,
                                                 -----------
upon the request of the Administrative Agent, at the expense of the Pledgor:

                  (a) execute and deliver, and cause each issuer of the Pledged
               Collateral contemplated to be sold and the directors and officers
               thereof to execute and deliver, all such instruments and
               documents, and do or cause to be done all such other acts and
               things, as may be necessary to register such Pledged Collateral
               under the provisions of the Securities Act of 1933, as from time
               to time amended (the "Securities Act"), and to cause the
               registration statement relating thereto to become effective and
               to remain effective for such period as prospectuses are required
               by law to be furnished, and to make all amendments and
               supplements thereto and to the related prospectus which, in the
               reasonable opinion of the Administrative Agent, are necessary or
               advisable, all in conformity with the requirements of the
               Securities Act and the rules and regulations of the Securities
               and Exchange Commission applicable thereto;

                  (b) use its best efforts to qualify the Pledged Collateral
               under the state securities or "Blue Sky" laws, and to obtain all
               necessary governmental approvals for the sale of the Pledged
               Collateral, as reasonably requested by the Administrative Agent;

                  (c) cause each such issuer to make available to its security
               holders, as soon as practicable, an earnings statement that will
               satisfy the provisions of Section 11(a) of the Securities Act;
               and

                  (d) do or cause to be done all such other acts and things as
               may be necessary to make such sale of the Pledged Collateral or
               any part thereof valid and binding and in compliance with
               applicable law.

     Section 6.3  Compliance with Restrictions.
                  ----------------------------

     The Pledgor agrees that in any sale of any of the Pledged Collateral
whenever an Event of Default shall have occurred and be continuing, the
Administrative Agent is hereby authorized to comply with any limitation or
restriction in connection with such sale as it may be advised by counsel is
necessary in order to avoid any violation of applicable law (including, without
limitation, compliance with such procedures as may restrict the number of
prospective bidders and purchasers, require that prospective bidders and
purchasers have certain qualifications, and restrict prospective bidders and
purchasers to persons who will represent and agree that they are

                                       14
<PAGE>

purchasing for their own account for investment and not with a view to the
distribution or resale of such Pledged Collateral), or in order to obtain any
required approval of the sale or of the purchaser by any governmental regulatory
authority or official, and the Pledgor further agrees that such compliance shall
not result in such sale being considered or deemed not to have been made in a
commercially reasonable manner, nor shall the Administrative Agent be liable or
accountable to the Pledgor for any discount allowed by reason of the fact that
such Pledged Collateral is sold in compliance with any such limitation or
restriction.

     Section 6.4  Application of Proceeds.
                  -----------------------

     All cash proceeds received by the Administrative Agent in respect of any
sale of, collection from, or other realization upon, all or any part of the
Pledged Collateral in accordance with Section 6.1 hereof may, in the discretion
                                      -----------
of the Administrative Agent, be held by the Administrative Agent as additional
Pledged Collateral security for, or then or at any time thereafter be applied
(after payment of any amounts payable to the Secured Parties pursuant to the
Loan Documents) in whole or in part by the Administrative Agent against all or
any of the Obligations in such order as the Administrative Agent shall elect.
The Pledgor shall remain liable for any deficiency.  Any surplus of such cash or
cash proceeds held by the Administrative Agent and remaining after payment in
full in cash of all the Obligations, the termination of all Interest Rate
Agreements to which a Secured Party is a party and the termination of all
Commitments shall be paid over to the Pledgor or to whomsoever may be lawfully
entitled to receive such surplus.

     Section 6.5  Indemnity and Expenses.
                  ----------------------

     The Pledgor shall upon demand pay to the Administrative Agent the amount of
any and all reasonable expenses, including, without limitation, the reasonable
fees and disbursements of its outside counsel and of any experts and agents,
which the Administrative Agent may incur in connection with:

                  (a) the consideration of legal matters relevant to this Pledge
               Agreement; (b) the custody, preservation, use, or operation of,
               or the sale of, collection from, or other realization upon, any
               of the Pledged Collateral;

                  (c) the exercise or enforcement of any of the rights of the
               Administrative Agent hereunder; or

                  (d) the failure by the Pledgor to perform or observe any of
               the provisions hereof.

The provisions of this Section 6.5 shall survive termination of this Pledge
                       -----------
Agreement.

                                       15
<PAGE>

                                 ARTICLE VII.
                           MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS

     Section 7.1  Additional Actions and Documents.
                  --------------------------------

     The Pledgor agrees that at any time, and from time to time, at the expense
of the Pledgor, the Pledgor will promptly execute and deliver all further
instruments, and take all further action that the Administrative Agent may
reasonably request, in order to perfect and protect any security interest
granted or purported to be granted hereby or to enable the Administrative Agent
to exercise and enforce its rights and remedies hereunder with respect to any
Pledged Collateral.

     Section 7.2  Expenses.
                  --------

     The Pledgor agrees to reimburse and save the Administrative Agent harmless
against liability for the payment of all out-of-pocket expenses arising in
connection with the administration or enforcement of, or the preservation or
exercise of, any rights (including, without limitation, the right to collect and
dispose of the Pledged Collateral) under this Pledge Agreement, including,
without limitation, the reasonable fees and other charges of outside counsel to
the Administrative Agent arising in such connection, and all such fees and other
charges shall be deemed to be a part of the Obligations secured hereby.

     Section 7.3  Notices.
                  -------

     Any communications between the parties hereto or notices provided herein to
be given shall be sent in accordance with the provisions of, and to the
addresses set forth in, Section 9.8 of the Credit Agreement, and if to the
                        -----------
Pledgor, to the following address:

                         FiberNet Telecom, Inc.
                         570 Lexington Avenue
                         3rd Floor
                         New York, New York  10022
                         Attn.: President
                         Telecopy: (212) 421-8920

     Section 7.4  Release and Satisfaction.
                  ------------------------

     Upon the indefeasible payment (whether in cash and/or other consideration
which is satisfactory to the Lenders in their sole discretion) and performance
in full of the Obligations, the termination of all Interest Rate Agreements to
which any Secured Party is a party and the termination of all Commitments (i)
this Pledge Agreement and the security interest created hereby shall terminate,
and (ii) upon written request of the Pledgor, the Administrative Agent shall
execute and deliver to the Pledgor, at the Pledgor's expense and without
representation or warranty by or recourse to the Administrative Agent or the
Secured Parties, all certificates, representations or evidences of the Pledged
Shares and all Pledged Notes, together with all other

                                       16
<PAGE>

Pledged Collateral held by the Administrative Agent hereunder and such documents
as the Pledgor shall reasonably request to evidence such termination, and the
Pledgor shall deliver to the Administrative Agent a general release of all of
the Administrative Agent's liabilities and Obligations under all Loan Documents
and an acknowledgment that the same have been terminated.

     Section 7.5  Benefit.
                  -------

     This Pledge Agreement shall be binding upon, and shall inure to the benefit
of, the parties hereto, the Secured Parties and their respective successors,
legal representatives and permitted assigns.  The Pledgor shall not assign any
of its rights or obligations hereunder without the prior written consent of the
Required Lenders.

     Section 7.6  Amendments and Waivers.
                  ----------------------

     No amendment, modification, termination or waiver of any provision of this
Pledge Agreement, or consent to any departure by the Administrative Agent
therefrom, shall be effective unless the same shall be in writing and signed by
the Administrative Agent and the Pledgor and shall comply with the provisions
set forth in Section 9.6 of the Credit Agreement.  Each amendment, modification,
             -----------
termination or waiver shall be effective only in the specific instance and for
the specific purpose for which it was given.

     Section 7.7  Headings.
                  --------

     Section and subsection headings contained in this Pledge Agreement are
inserted for convenience of reference only, shall not be deemed to be a part of
this Pledge Agreement for any purpose, and shall not in any way define or affect
the meaning, construction or scope of any of the provisions hereof.

     Section 7.8  Applicable Law; Entire Agreement.
                  --------------------------------

     This Pledge Agreement shall be governed by, and shall be construed and
enforced in accordance with, the internal laws of the State of New York, without
regard to conflicts of laws principles (other than Sections 5-1401 and 5-1402 of
the General Obligations Law of the State of New York), except to the extent that
the validity or perfection of the security interest hereunder, or exercise of
remedies hereunder, in respect of any particular Pledged Collateral are governed
by the laws of a jurisdiction other than the State of New York.  This Pledge
Agreement and the other Loan Documents constitute the entire understanding among
the parties hereto with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersede any
prior agreements, written or oral, with respect thereto.

     Section 7.9  Severability.
                  ------------

     The invalidity, illegality or unenforceability in any jurisdiction of any
provision in or obligation under this Pledge Agreement shall not affect or
impair the validity, legality or

                                       17
<PAGE>

enforceability of the remaining provisions or obligations under this Pledge
Agreement or of such provision or obligation in any other jurisdiction.

     Section 7.10  Consent to Jurisdiction.
                   -----------------------

     The Pledgor hereby irrevocably and unconditionally submits, for itself and
its property, to the nonexclusive jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of the State
of New York sitting in New York County and of the United States District Court
of the Southern District of New York, and any appellate court in respect
thereof, in any action or proceeding arising out of or relating to this Pledge
Agreement, or for recognition or enforcement of any judgment, and hereby
irrevocably and unconditionally agrees that all claims in respect of any such
action or proceeding may be heard and determined in such New York State court
or, to the extent permitted by law, in such federal court.  The Pledgor agrees
that a final judgment in any such action or proceeding shall be conclusive and
may be enforced in other jurisdictions by suit on the judgment or in any other
manner provided by law.  Nothing in this Section 7.10 shall affect any right
                                         ------------
that the Administrative Agent or any Secured Party may otherwise have to bring
any action or proceeding relating to this Pledge Agreement against the Pledgor
or any of its properties in the courts of any jurisdiction.  The Pledgor hereby
irrevocably and unconditionally waives, to the fullest extent it may legally and
effectively do so, any objection which it may now or hereafter have to the
laying of venue of any suit, action or proceeding arising out of or relating to
this Pledge Agreement in any court referred to in this Section 7.10.  The
                                                       ------------
Pledgor irrevocably waives, to the fullest extent permitted by law, the defense
of an inconvenient forum to the maintenance of such action or proceeding in any
such court. The Pledgor irrevocably consents to service of process in the manner
provided for notices in Section 7.3.  Nothing in this Pledge Agreement will
                        -----------
affect the right of any party hereto to serve process in any other manner
permitted by law.

     Section 7.11  Construction.
                   ------------

     The Pledgor and the Administrative Agent each acknowledges that it has had
the benefit of legal counsel of its own choice and has been afforded an
opportunity to review this Pledge Agreement with its legal counsel and that this
Pledge Agreement shall be construed as if jointly drafted by the Pledgor and the
Administrative Agent.

     Section 7.12  Waiver of Jury Trial.
                   --------------------

     THE PLEDGOR HEREBY WAIVES, TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE
LAW, ANY RIGHT IT MAY HAVE TO A TRIAL BY JURY IN ANY LEGAL PROCEEDING DIRECTLY
OR INDIRECTLY ARISING OUT OF OR RELATING TO THIS PLEDGE AGREEMENT OR THE
TRANSACTIONS CONTEMPLATED HEREBY (WHETHER BASED ON CONTRACT, TORT OR ANY OTHER
THEORY).

     Section 7.13  Survival.
                   --------

                                       18
<PAGE>

     All agreements, covenants, representations and warranties made herein shall
survive the execution and delivery of this Pledge Agreement.  Notwithstanding
anything in this Pledge Agreement or implied by law to the contrary, the
agreements set forth in Sections 6.5 and 7.2 shall survive the payment of the
                        ------------     ---
Obligations and the termination of this Pledge Agreement.

     Section 7.14  Counterparts; Effectiveness.
                   ---------------------------

     This Pledge Agreement and any amendments, waivers, consents, or supplements
may be executed in any number of counterparts and by different parties hereto in
separate counterparts, each of which when so executed and delivered shall be
deemed an original, but all of which counterparts together shall constitute but
one and the same instrument.  This Pledge Agreement shall become effective upon
the execution of a counterpart hereof by each of the parties hereto.  Delivery
of an executed counterpart of a signature page to this Pledge Agreement or to
any amendments, waivers, consents or supplements hereof by telecopier shall be
as effective as delivery of a manually executed counterpart thereof.


                  [REMAINDER OF PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]

                                       19
<PAGE>

     IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Pledge Agreement to
be duly executed and delivered by their respective officers thereunto duly
authorized as of the day and year first above written.

                              FIBERNET TELECOM, INC.,
                              as the Pledgor

                              By: /s/ Michael S. Liss
                                 --------------------------------
                                 Name:  Michael S. Liss
                                 Title: President

                              DEUTSCHE BANK AG NEW YORK
                                 BRANCH, as Administrative Agent

                              By: /s/ Jon D. Storck
                                 --------------------------------
                                 Name:  Jon D. Storck
                                 Title: Vice President

                              By: /s/ Alexander Richarz
                                 --------------------------------
                                 Name:  Alexander Richarz
                                 Title: Assistant Vice President

<PAGE>

                                                                    Attachment 1
                                              to the Subsidiary Pledge Agreement

Item A.  Pledged Notes
         -------------
  Pledged Note Issuer                  Description of Pledged Notes
-----------------------    -----------------------------------------------------

None                             Not applicable



Item B.  Pledged Shares
         --------------
 Pledged Share Issuer                  Description of Shares
-----------------------    -----------------------------------------------------

                                                      % of
                                                   Outstanding
                                                     Shares
                                                     Pledged
                           -----------------------------------------------------

LOCAL FIBER, L.L.C.                                     100%


<PAGE>

                                 SCHEDULE 3.5


                             GOVERNMENTAL CONSENTS
                             ---------------------


Any consents, authorizations, filings, notices or approvals required under
Article 5, Section 100 of the New York Public Service Law.