7KH +RQRUDEOH -RKQ ' +ROVFKXK 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW -XGJH IRU

WKH 6RXWKHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 2KLR VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ



5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU

)LOH 1DPH DS

	

		

	







26$

$5.6

	








$

$&(

(&25'6

	















 !"#$
%&'	()&("&*+"

!"$("%)&("&*!,&*$&-%%%"."

/0/12"."3*4)&("&*5+'-

"-+'6,700

)*&''%'&'6,7008

2!"6
	%'&"*+&5+'-(9

	
)&("&*5+'-







	5$%%&*$"%5"	:;
<	=	,
(%-(&!"%&!" %5( $,2*43

3	3%

 


;"-&!" (5"  	: ;
%-(&!"%&;"-"75=		
	)"&,&*$&-,2*4$"&( $"53%"3
%;"-&!" 







5)	
)&("&*

>"$%#!(%-("4!&"(-&%' "#&%%*'+"&%-$.+(.7*&%	$."&%-((+"*"' "'+*"%'+3(@'+(?((>"$"%#%#($&!$&"(%-$)!%'%(D+(!$"%#*+%'"E8BC!$%$#*&%"+'( % $" *##% ? ,&*$&-%(?)!%'%("(+##"7 F+'-#% .*+( "4>&&% ! $ %$# * )!%'%(!+"$""-+$>>&&% $&" &"( #%'#G "((&%($+'.'!%(($(*&#("4((*%%'("%'"($#&.+%'",&*$&-"&+(&%"!"%*?&$.+(&%($>('%&'&.&&7?&$"( 

"4( ."+-$ $&( *&% &% 

)!%'%( (+.(H+%7 "#>+"!"$("%)&("&*!,#&%( !" (+##"7 F+'-#% "4(D#&%!"(+##"7F+'-#F+'-#% !")!%'%("4((+##"7F+'-#%!")!%'%
 
 8

"$ "(%($"!"( !"$?.&>$?&$

"( *  ( "4(D *&#( +%'" $ %$# * %'+%'"$*##%? "&-$! +.&*&7 @$>&'%*&((+*$ $  "(%. F+"7 *+' "+"%  >"'&* !" $%%#>&%- "7A	
II
	

JBJ/CK$"!"*%*+'$$'&("&**+"""'&%-"%&%-)!%'%(D#&%!"(+##"7F+'-#%% $( *&#( K *%*+' $?>" $ $ '&("&**+" " "7 -"%' (+##"7 F+'-#% &% !>" !)!%'%(%("4(D(?*&#(!'!#&%%'"&+(&%"!"%*?&$.+(&%(("&%($& 

	


	


( "4( &( % $&("&* !&-+" ?$ !&"( -&%'

 "#&%%*((7#.!$*&>&"&-$(#>#%&%$
%&'	('+"&%-$0D(%'/0D(
%?$&"&'&%- &% $ !"% !  (-"-' .+( &% ,%-#"7.#($"!+('7&'$"(?$& ((%-"%'#>$.*4!$.+((.*4(?""H+&"''.7$$%G&(&%-?("H+&"&%-(-"-&%!$"*(8J'7.+(.7*&%,%-#"7!?'!"#$%>% ?$&*$ >%+7 .*#  *7( !" "-%&L'.7*((&&%(%''#%("&%(*"(($	+$"(&%- * ! '!&%* $( -"%"' $" %+#"+( +.&***'(%'?"'(%'($$(+('$*."&7(+( "#>"&+(*&>&%'$+#%"&-$(*+(((?(>&(&% "-"#(%'.4(&%( &"'.7$"&!("7	$$(( ">'**&%!-( "*"'&%-(.7>"&+("&(( %&'	  !

B$@ A.+#C"('&%

)!%'%( " +3( *# "&(' ! "*"'&%- "&((

%'"M@)"MA2%F#&%%'%?%@2&-2&A%9$&""*"' "'+*"( * !+%'' .7 %' %#' !"

 


3DUNV GLG QRW HIIHFW VHUYLFH RI SUR

(GPRQGV DQG WKH\ DUH QRW GHIHQGDQWV DOWKRXJK WKH\ DUH OLVWHG DV GHIHQGDQWV LQ WKGRFNHW%%&@A&'%'3%%7@*D( "*"' '&("&.+"( %"&%#% B**&>7 @)!J)!%'%("('$.+

!&"((&%-"(?((%-&'@$&(&%-A.7(&*4"%$$*%&%'$%#'>&("7?"%&%-!@G &*&*%( " '&(*+((' $ *"&&* '"#&%&%!$"&(&*">% $ *%% ! $ (%- $ *%(&'"'&%$&"%&"7$7

B4C$$$+($$!+((>"7.'7#>$.*4!)7+?%%.+# %'(+# K$7 !  #4$<"(6B2&-2&C,%7'7$( (('$%&-$2+(&
!&%'$&# +$*$(!"$( 7($K4&%%$""+" "(&4;")7#%'#7%&--?7K(..&%->"7*&7$%?;"-&?$?'!"2+'--&%$(&4$#;277+(+%'&%-(&7$%4# "7)&%- '+-$%+( "+%' 7+ ("+%'&&()#%?$*##&-%.2++(-%.+(7+&%$#+
 




B4C<"(6B%'"MC
#-7 (7%'($$& '#(#&!-#(&#+$%*&>$!%'"&-$."&%	&'..7.77+%7!+%47(7+"(*+:+!*+(%$ (7+"((D.$(?$$(%&>.7"&$"$%'&
"7F+($"?&7+'"#&%7+"?%'>%+"%'"-$"(&%$"D(#7'(&%&%	$-!!$.+($*%>"(&%&%-"'&%#7$'!"$+"(4($?"4&%'(+"*+(#7!>"&-"+ &%D*#&%?&$&2+
D#?&*$7+*+(7+ "..7-&%$"+-$&%7?72+%7$??$%&%'+.?%%+%'.+-$&+(
$+-$&?+'.F##&%.+G#&%$!?(47??(47?!+7&D(('%'&D(*(7.+$D(($?"%'
$ 
%>"$>!&%$.
 ($&*"4&D(?4&($(H+$
?%$"?$%
D#-&%'?%?$%D((&'%''%%'?-%?F&%?%K$%$"*"' 7"-(4& &%%'(?&%'?%7?*%(7&($#%&--("%'$*"?%.++%&$%B4CB"#%&*	CB4&!'C

5

 !"

"4((+')!%'%(&%$K7%+%7&"*+&+"

! ,&*$&-% -&%-   $ )!%'%(D

+%+$"&L' +( ! $" %# &%!"&%-( % $" "&-$ 

/ 


3DUNV DOOHJHG DW RUDO DUJXPHQW WKDW E

WKH 6WLSXODWHG )DFWV +RZHYHU 3DUNV GL6WLSXODWHG )DFWV LQ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW ,QGHVXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW DQG LQVLVWHG WKDW WKHEHLQJ GLVSXWHG KHUH ́ -$ DW  36WLSXOSDUWLHV DUH ELQGLQJ ERWK RQ WKH GLVWULFW FRX)HG 'HSRVLW ,QV &RUS Y 6W 3DXO )LUH   WK &LU  3DUNV KDV JLYROXQWDULQHVV RI WKH 6WLSXODWHG )DFWV WKHFKDOOHQJH 6HH (ONLQV Y 5LFKDUGVRQ0HUU&LU  GHFOLQLQJ WR DGGUHVV LVVXHV UDDEVHQW 3H[FHSWLRQDO FLUFXPVWDQFHV ́ +.&*&7 '!#( $" *$"*"%-&%-.+(&%(("&%($& )!$ )&("&*+" !"$ ("4($"!"!&'%#%''*(?*&#(%'''' !(E8BC!$%$#*

$ "&( %"' &%  (

B@	& +' *(AC %' !&' *"F+'-#% 7&%-$
%

&" JC $ '&("&* *+" *#%'#% (  #" ! ?%$# * %' "&-$ ! +.&*I/	+ 'C  	 *&!&*7 $ *+" !"&%($& A .?%$ *%% "%'"($ "&-$! #"!?IJ09BC?&$"$" ?( % G &*& " "(%%'"('.7"4(IJ89B8C!+3(D(%#%$&".+#*%(+#" *%!+(&% .?% .+#((#"!??"(#&4&$'!*%(+#+?&-$' .7 $ &"( #%)!%'%(IJ82*+(&%*+""4($'!&'"&(%7!*>"*#)!%'%(D&"
 


I

$"?&((+ "$"*&#(+%'"$%$#*%'$""&-$! +.&*&7$'&("&**+"'%&'"4(D#&%!"(+##"7 F+'-#% %' -"%' (+##"7 F+'-#% !")!%'%(IJJJ$'&("&**+"(-"%'(+##"7F+'-#%&% !>"!)!%'%(%("4(D*&#(!'!#&%%'"&+(&%"!"%*?&$.+(&%(("&%($& $&( !?'




	#$%!&

K">&?$'&("&**+"D(-"%!(+##"7F+'-#%


&&

!'$
()I8'

J80B/$&"00C	+##"7F+'-#%&( " "?$"%-%+&%&((+!#"&!*G&((%'$#>&%- "7&(%&'F+'-#%(#"!?&'&>

/B*C-%+&%&((+!#"&!*G&((@&!$>&'%*&((+*$$"(%.F+"7*+'"+"%>"'&*!"$%%#>&%- "7A	
II
	J BJ/C 
% *%(&'"&%- (+*$ #&%$ *+"#+(>&?$>&'%*%''"?"(%.&%!"%*(&%!>"!$%%#>&%- "7&! '* )
+')
I
	IJIBJ/C$*%"&((+&(@?$$"$>&'%* "(%((+!!&*&%'&(-"#%"H+&"(+.#&((&%F+"7"?$$"&&((%(&''$% "7#+( ">&(#"!?A	II
	

$ !* $ $ "&( $> !&' *"((#&%( !"

(+##"7F+'-#%'(%#%!*+"($(+##"7F+'-#%!"%(&'"$$"&(%*(("&7 " "&@K$% "&(!&*"((#&%(!"(+##"7F+'-#%N$#4&%- ! (+*$ &%$"%7 *%"'&*"7 *&#( '( %*%(&+ % -"#%$&!%&( "F*'$$"&(%*(("&7F+(&!&'"$$(&%- "7?&>(F+'&*&*%(&'"&%%''"#&%&%?$$"-%+&%&((+(!#"& !* G&(DA  , %' ) 
 - &

)
8'JI8B/$&"00CB$0

$"(%K"&-$"$+",&"%',"7373% EI0B8''JCC

J 


'#'

	*&%8BC!$%$#

*&%-&%(%7 "(%?$&'%(+*$?7(&47*+(*%!+ *+( *%(+#"(  #4 *%(+#"((((*&&%!$?&$%$" "(%""-"'&%-$( %("($& " ">!$ $%-+-!E8BC&(."'

BC%7 "(%?$%"&%*%"(">&*("%7*%&%"!"-%7 ?"' "# %# (7#.*#.&%&%$"!"%7!(!( " #&('&%- '(*"& &#&('&%-" "(%&%!!*BC&(&47*+(*%!+(&%'*&>($!!&&&%*!(+*$ "(%?&$%$" "( %("($& " ">!$&(*##"*&*&>&&(.7%$($ . &. &%  *&>& *&.&>($$"($&("&((+*$*


	EBC

&%&!!( !% &%>4 E 8B

 " "7 "&-$( &% @#"4(A " .#"*$%'&((+*$( "
(&&&"000CB(+&.7#%+!*+""-&%(#%+!*+""!@$,&"(">&*((+*$(#"--*# !$$)

 #%IBI$&"JCB(+&.?%#+(&%-$@&%+#A%#C
 




?>"$ (* !E8BC G%'(.7%' '&( +(

.?% "'+*"( ! *##"*& "'+*( %' $&"*# &"(
( "#&(*."&&(>&%'&* " "7"&-$( &% $&" &'%&&( -&%( -'7 #&('&%-*##"*&+(.7$"(&1
IJ

'080B$&"CB*."&7(+&-&%((%*4#%+!*+""!"+%+$"&L'+(!$&('&(&%*&>>&*&%*##"*&C9	
2(/0	+ //B	):JCB*."&7(+&-&%(>&'"&"!" +( !  *."&7 4&4 &% &( '>"&(#%(C9'#
0%I8'///B/$&" 000C B*" (+'7 *# %7 !" *"&%- % *&%!&-+" %#' !" % ! $&( #>& *$"*"(C9 	 3 
 % ! )
 J 8' 0I 0 B$ &"/CB "!((&%.(4. 7"(+'*"#%+!*+""!" +(&%- $&( .&"$ %#  ( *"(C  ."&&( $>(%'&%-  (+ +%'" E 8BC .*+( $7 (((( %*%#&* &%"( &% $&" &'%&&( 4&%  $ ! "'&&%"'#"4$'"&1IJ'0&5$#(,*"$7!)'#-)#
EJ6 B$'00CB'&(*+((&%-*((C.


% "'"  ">& %  !( '>"&(&%- *&# +%'"

E8BC*."&7#+(($?$+(!$&("$"%#&(&47  *+( *%!+(&% #%- *%(+#"( (  $@!!&&&%*%%*&%"((*&&%A.?%$*."&7%'$'!%'%D(-'("(">&*("($*."&7D( "&*& &%&%$@"&-&%( %("($& " ">A!$'!%'%D( -'( " (">&*(  &  
	

EBCBCBC9'#I8'//91
/

(8'J0/JB$&"IC9))


!4$ ,	(8'//B0$&"/C91'
&# $*	#I'8 8 B$ &" C  %(+#" *%!+(&% **+"(?$%@*%(+#"(.&>$$ "'+*("(">&*(!!"' .7 $ "&( " !!&&' &% (# ?7A/#0% 

/#!$&
8'000IB/$&"C"@?$%*%(+#"(#4% &%*""* #% ((*&&% .?% $ &%>>'

0 
*##"*& "'+*("$&" "'+//B" $ &	&5#
)##J8
	5'&((%&%-CC@&4&$'A#$%@ ((&.&&7A!*%!+(&%
)
8'JJ8)
'#J8'J8 @*" &4&$' ! *%!+(&% "..A $  +"*$(" ?+!!&&'?&$%$"#%+!*+"!)'#-'00CB*&&%-*((C, 
,$(#! B/$&" IC B%&%-$  (+!!&*&%
!*%!+(&%%

"4(*%%'($)!%'%(

*.*+($&.&>&%-$$(%-&(.+$?&$$)!%'%("$(( %((%-%'$	" #.+#! *%!+(&% &( %$%*' .7 $ .+#&(&%$#"4 .+# !+"&%- $  

>&'%* !" $" *&# "4(*%*((&% $ $7 $> +(' 

'>"&(%' "#.$$(%	$ ( (+ &( ?%7% !!!&"#&%- $ $7 &$" .&>.+"4("?(*%%*'$.7$"

)!%'%("( %'$"4(D

!"?"(%(&"($7*&#"'#"4"&-$&%$"%#%'"'#"4+(!$"%#(!*&%+%'"$%$#*>% &! +( ! $ & (' *%!+(&% $ "&(4 &( +?&-$#%'#%"&-$!"G "((&
 
 

$ FHOHEULW\ LV GHILQHG DV 3D FHOHEUDWHG RU ZLGHO\ NQRZQ SHUVRQ RQH

SRSXODUO\ KRQRUHG IRU VRPH VLJQDO DFKLHYHPHQW ́ :HEVWHU¶V 7KLUG 1HZ,QWHUQDWLRQDO 'LFWLRQDU\  3KLOOLS %DEFRFN *RYH HG 

)	





&&%-./#.!  #
%

 88'II/B/$&"JC)!%'%(*%%'$"4(DE8BC*&##+(!&.*+($7$>#'%"'#"4+(!$"%#?>")!%'%(#&(*%*&>$-.(&(!%$#**&#
&(%%*(("7!"$##4@"'#"4A+(!("4(D%# &% "'" !" $"  $>  *+( ! *&% !" !('>"&(&%-+%'"E8BC!$%$#*

("4(*"7$( " "7&%"(&%$"%#4&%

$! "(%$'&%-"'#"4
&(.7%'H+(&%$"4(&(*."&7$ "&($>(& +'$"&%"%&%!#%'$" "&"+$"&L&%!>&(&% "-"#(%'.4(K$>"'7(.&($' 


$*+"("+&%7"*-%&L " "7 "&-$&%*."&7&'%&74&%$!"'#"4$'"+%'"E8BC&$'#I 8' //91IJ ' 09

	 /0  	+   /  K !&%' "4(D "&"*##"*& *&>&&( %' &%"%&% "*-%&&% ( (7#. ! $ *&>& "&-$( #>#% %'? $" ?&$ "'#"4 &%"( &% $" %# $ (# ( &! ($ ?" !#+(*""#+(&*&%

$"!" >%$+-$( "4(D%##&-$%.

&-&. !" "-&("&% (  "'#"4 %' >% $+-$)!%'%(?"%(&%-("4(."%')D(>&.*+(!*&%(G&((+%'"E8BC&!*%(+#"(!(7.&>'$("4($'( %("'" ">'$(%-"?((#$?!!&&'?&$$(%-"$.+#K+"%$%)!%'%(D(*%'"-+#%$>%&!"4(*+' (.&($ (# &4&$' ! *%!+(&% $ &"(#%'#% "*()!%'%(D*$&*!&

 


*




)!%'%(-$>%&!

(#&4&$'!*%(+#"*%!%'.+#$&"&"(#%'#%"+# ($*%*"%)!%'%("#%*&%&#(#+(&*$(.G "((&'(((+*$#+(&*&(!& "*&%( !$ &"( #%'#

	#% .,6 


	I/BCB(&%-$ " @+%H+(&%.7 ($&''A .1 
  	$ # B@,+(&* (  !"# ! G "((& "*'+%'"$&"(#%'##%'#%*%% "#&%7%'?$%&*#(%#$"?"4("$+-$.(.(">'@OP$ +"*$("!.*%! ($("&-$%.#%'"(#%P!$ "'+*A

 ) 2  
 ,#

% 
JJ/'08B "*&%&(%((&# 7.*++( &( &% *%%*&% ?&$  ?"B*&&%#&'CC+"($>'.%*&"(#%'#%&%"((%$#*6BC$@&4&$'@"%&>>%+(A(9%'B*CK?&G#&%*$%&%+"% ') 

#)

%  "*$ &(  "7 (

*%!+(&%A !*"(  &' &% "'#"4*(($&(?% &%&!!D( #"49 C $ "'%(&#&"&7!$#"4(9C>&'%*#"4&%-*$%%(+('9/C$
 
 8

*"9 IC $ '!%'%D( &%% &% (*&%- $ #"49 %'JC $ &4&$' ! G %(&% &% $ "'+* &%( ! $ "&(  & '(   
 *( ,$ , & 
  /I0 ' / /J B/$ &" JCB' &%-$( !"#	! 
&,'88JB$&"ICC9 )

 * )
 JI '   B' &" /CB*"&%->"&%!$(C2('+ %$>&'%*?$% '*&' &! $ &%&!! $( "&('  -%+&% &((+ !#"& !* (  $ &4&$' ! *%(+#" *%!+(&%
%'"$&( "*$?'% 7( *&(&*&+'%(("'&"(#%'#%'!%(

$&(  "*$ $( .%&%!""' !"#$ &%$&"*+&

*(& *

$ ,-&	08'8B$&"IC&#
	$#	+ '0/J0IJB)JCB@O
P "($&%$&"*+&?&%' OP(.%*&%-"'#"4 "*&%(-&%($"&(&*&%"(&% "*&%-&""7&(&  ("%-7(+--(( $ $&( N.%*&%-D $( "'7 .% 'H+7**# &($' .7 $ (+"7 !"#?"4 O! $ %$#*PAC, !
!)	/8'J0B$&"00C8	8B008CB'&(&%-+&($&%-& C$%$&"*+&$(.&H+7

%'"('$&( "*$(?&)8'

I0B(+--(&%-$@&4&$'!*%!+(&%A(@(">O(P>&'&"(#%'#%*%*"%(A&%"'#"4*((C	
	
 

(*%' "*$&($@"%&>>%+(A($&(

&($(+"-'+ %+(.7"4(%'%'"('.7 %!$&-$$&"*+&
%'"$@"%&>>%+(A(&!%G "((&>?"4?&%. "*'!"#!('>"&(&%-*&#&!$""(+!!&*&%"%&>#%(!"%"&(*%>7$&("$"&'&!  5#')
2
J8/'8I0BJ$&"JIC B*""!

 "'7($&"(% "*'.7&"(#%'#%.*+($*+'(& "'+* "'7'&"&(&%.4(#-L&%(

 
"!&#C9	#7 )

	+ 'III8B),&%% "*&% !"%&%!"&%-&%-#>&$"&($ "'+*"(*+'+(
,  (J8'I/#%'#% "*&%%>&.*%!+(&%-"'#"4 +( ?( @? "'&(D((' +" (C$
%#

&%7  $&"'  "*$ &( $

	*%' &"*+& &%$ 
 %#'&("&* *+" &% $&( *(  
%' "*' +%(( & $( @% "+%'"7&%- ?"4 " &! $" &( @G &*&7 #&('( ($ (+?"4A$JI'

' '.7$ &!$&"*+&&%1-&	/$8'/J%'.7 %!$&%$&"*+&
?((' '.7'&("&**& 
 %#   %%/C	

K*%*+'$%&$"$!&"(

**"'('H+?&-$$&"$&(*($!&"( "*$+%#&4&$'!*%!+(&%!*"(&%?&-$&"(#%'#%*%*%#!%"&(&*?"4(&!&?%# ! % "'&%"7 *##"*& "*$&-%"($!*$$

*##"*& "'+*.+&((& / 
) 

B	):IJCB@O,P"($% " (# $" (+*$ N#"*$%'&(>$&*($"+-$?$&*$&'(%'%'((+*$$>%F7'*"&%
 
 

%-%"7**"''N#"*$%'&(DAC9 )

8'I0B@$!*$G "((&>#"&("('%&$""%'"($( *$+% "*'%""($>! "*&%+%'"$&"(#%'#%ACB*&&%(#&'C$%#("&((.(?%$&""*%. "%' "*!$"&(&*#((-&$JI'J B@&##4"(%'+$"(!"H+%7"7%?"' 7#.&-+&7&"%7 %' +(&%&%&&%-$&" ?"4(AC  $ !*$)!%'%(+($&&%'>"&(&%-'(%+#&*7"($G "((&> !+%*&%!$&%'"%'"&#"*##"*&G &&%9&!(%-&(('%'$ & &( "*' .7 $ &"( #%'#% $ &%+"7?&.@&%G"&*.7&%"?&%'A?&$$(%-D(*##"*& "#&%&9 
2((

', JI 
	IJI/ BJJC B$'&%-$?$% "*' ( *$ &( &%G"&*. !"# +% "*'( *$$*+"?&"$%&"#((-( "*'C9)8'I0

$ +.&*$(((#+*$&%"(&%$!"G*$%-

! &'( ( & '( &% >&'&%- #&('&%- '>"&(&%-  
!"4( ((((("&-$ &*$+(!$"%#>%?$%$"&-$*%.G"*&('%7 ">%*%(+#"*%!+(&%($$($#%("("&*$ +.&*'&(*+"( (# G%  ( 5+'- 3L&%(4& $( &%' +@
%*+ " "7"&-$("%D!"6$7D"&# ('$ G %( ! !++" *""( %' !$ +.&* "-A1'
&# $*	#J'/B$&"8CB3L&%(4&5'&((%&%-!"#'%&!"$"&%-% .%*C  @
%*+ " "7    &%*+'( $ ?"'(&#-( %' (+%'($ ?+( *##+%&* %' N?*%%&%'+-&%$!*&((+# &%$%*%!".&' "&*+"?"'( ?&$+ ( "+%%&%-  (+.(%& "&(4!(+ "((&%-&'(&%$ "*((DA)8'I B" $ )'
)08
	/BICC
%(+#?'%!&%'$+%#'&!&'&4&$'!*%!+(&%( &'*##"*& "'+*('H+'&!!"%&.?%$( "&(( ?$ *$(&( !"$ +" (!-&&# "&(&* ">%*7 %' $( "&(( ?$ *$(#&('&%-&( !"$ +" (! *##"*&-&%&

/ 
! /8'00B@OKP$%

"&-$*%"$??G "(("'&&%O&4&$'!*%!+(&$!+?&-$!$ +.&*D(&%$"!"?"F*$!&"( "

$ (*%'  "*$ $ @

(&#&"7 ".#&*  $ @"&*+'&%)0)')#  /0 ' 00 0

'"&>'!"#" " "7?%&% $ F+( (  " " "( 4"!"#($ &%-#(!" $ ( 4"  '&>" $&( # "$&.&+(!$&("$"%#(G&(!"$"&(*##+%&*B$)

0I !    5#'  )

)0/0'0/C8	+ 'I8

," $% % *+" $( %

%-&L&%- " "7"&-$(&%%'"&'(&1'!

"(%. "%&> >%+(  "&%*##+%&*&>%' " "'#"4(AC9,


' /  B( &" JIC B@$&%>>'&%$&(*(*%%.'&"&-$(!"'#"4?%"?&$$ " "7AC+"$"#"$	*&()0'*&(&%&%% B@K ' % "'  )

-%"7 "*+'&%-*%(&'"*%*"%( ?$%>" % -'N"%&>>%+(!*##+%&*

(+--($$"?"'(*%

%+$"D("*# ("D(#((?&-$&%-&"(#%'#%"&-$(
 
 I

@$'&!!"%*.?%$#("&-$?"'%'$"&-$?"'&("7"-#"&D($'&!!"%*.?%$N&-$%&%-.+-D %' $ N&-$%&%-DA  5 2"#7 I B/$ 'C9 ( 208'

,
20	# ($I'8080/B$&"C B@OKP%'%.."$ &%$(#?"'( $"(( " (7#.( ." *%>7$&"&%%'' #%&%-($%$"(AC&%7' &%-$@"%&>>%+(A(?+' %'((7 %%- *+"( &% $ "*(( ! &&%-?"4(! "9 *+"( ?+'. (4' '"#&%%F+(?$$"&&("(%.7@"&(&*A.+?$$"&&(@%*(("7A*##+%&*$&'K$"!""F*$"%&>>%+((

$$&"' "*$$$(?(' '.7$

'&("&**+"&%$&(*(%'$(.%%'"('.7 %(&%$	*%'&!$%'&%$&"*+&($+-$$$

( $( .% *"&&*&L' $

 5 $#(,*"$7

!)'#-)#
E068B$ ' 00C ? !&%'&$ #(  " "& #$'.%*$ +.&*&%"(&%>&'&%-*%(+#"*%!+(&%?&$$ +.&*&%"(&%!"G "((&%


%$$ &%&!!?('%*"%' !&# (";&%-"

-"(
&%#>"'"&*&%&#'!&*&%#>& &' %$   .+ $ "+%&% ! ?"(?$&*."'%*"(?$.*#4%?%$&"!%(("' %' ;&%-" .*+( $7 &#&' "' (&" %';&%-" -"( &% $&" *  $ JI '  /I

-"(D *# &% -' $$& #&('

>&?"(&%$&%4&%-$$#>&?(.+$"!#+(*."&%?&$"'(&"&%>&&%!$%$#* %' $ $ +( ! $" %# &%!"&%-' $" "&-$ ! +.&*&7  &  I  $$ *+" !&%'&%-$>"G%(&%!%$#*"("&*&%(&%$"!&(#&-$ &%"+' % &"( #%'#% >+( %' $ $@"%&>>%+(A(&(&%(+!!&*&%**##'$ +.&*D(&%"(&%!"G "((&%' '? "%-'(6

J 


$PRQJ WKH OLQHV LQ WKH VRQJ ZHUH WK

LQ P\ %DUELH ZRUOG /LIH LQ SODVWLF LW¶V IDXQGUHVV PH HYHU\ZKHUH     ́ DQG LQ WKH FKLQ D IDQWDV\ ZRUOG 'UHVV PH XS PDNH LW WLKHUH WRXFK PH WKHUH KDQN\SDQN\     ́ 


% $ *%G ! -'7 #*."&7D( %# $ .%*%(+#"*%!+(&%%' "*%"#7%(+ " &*&%& $( % "&(&* ">%* ?$(>""&!&$((#OP$&G &*&7#&('(*%%!$?"4



+"(&% $ 	*%'&"*+& $

$ (  $" %$# *


 ((&" 8C9 ) 2 JJ/ 

)#     B):C9%& -  ($ % 
  J0J B	):C$&!$&"*+1'!8'//


%''&&% %!$&%$

$ $ ( &% !  
!$#%+!*+""!$?(+')%&($.%'H+!"$&

#%-$"$&%-(*%&%'&%%-&>&-$,-'$

@2".&A&%$&$'*%!+('$,?(!!&&'?&$$

J,"-+'$$(%-?$%**+'%. "*'.7$'&("&* *+" ( (+ ", H+.%'##."(&%&%">&?($'KD"#4&%-!+%!$
 
 

 
!)	J	+ '08JB)JC,((+ &'>&'%*$ +" "'($?$&%'&>&'+(?"#&('&%.&>&%-,%'$(%-?"!!&&'&%(#?7#%-$>&'%*?((+">7!/ "(%(!>"&+(-(&%(&G((IR!?$#.&>'$,"@2".&A?($(+"*!*%%*'?&$"-> "#&((&%!"$,%(%-888

%   !"#  (+##"7 F+'-#% &% !>" ! $

'!%'%$&%$&"*+& 7&%-$*%*+''$$ &"( #%'#% +?&-$' %7 "&(4 ! *%!+(&%.?%,%'$(%-&	 *&!&*7&!+%'6


%'"$!&"( "%-!$$+(!2".&&%$

(%- & *"7 &( ">%  $ +%'"7&%- ?"4%#7$(%-&(!OP$(%-&(.+2".&%'$>+(H+*&#(($" "(%($(%-&'(%G &*&7#&('($(+"*!$?"49&'(%G &*&7"$"?&((+--($&?( "'+*' .7 , $  &%'&*&% $ ,#&-$.((*&'?&$$(%-&($+(!2".&&%$&9&!$&(?"%+-$(&(!7$&( "%-!$$(&?+'"%'"$%+&7

!/8'0

$ &*&%!$&%!(?(&%*((

'*&''&%$"*&"*+&( "(+'(+($$&($.((!".%*&%-)!%'%(D%'$ +.&*D(&%"(&%!"G "((&%+%'"$&"(#%'#%-&%("4(D%'$ +.&*D(&%"(&%%!"*#%!$%$#*K$+( 7$$($!*(.!"+(

+



,


	
$

$ !&"( "%- ! $ "H+&"(  '"#&%&% !

?$$"$"&(%7"&(&*"&%($& .?%$&%'$ +%'"7&%- ?"4  $ JI '    "4(

0 


*%%'($*+"("7">&?!$7"&*( '#%("( $ $" &.?% $#  "4( ( (+.###."(!+3(" +" "'(%-?(%.+$"( !+"$@"%(&%A!$7"&*(!$ !"#>"&+(*"%&*@'&*&%"& '#%(" $ $ (%- "+"4( $"(!  $ @"%(&%A!?(6

@2H+&%'( $*##.*4 + O?&$ %? #+(&*P (*$*4"(" "(,("!"7+?%"&'%'$%-+?7 !-"+ #4$*+.(

2"

)!%'%( "( %' $ $&"

@# $"&*A"@(7#.&*A$((*&&%.?%("4(%.*4!$.+(A&(.7%''&( +$$ (%-&(%@.+A$"(&# 7&"">%

$ '&("&* *+" ?( ! $ 

"&%($& .?%$&%'$$#"&(% %"(

	+ 'IJ$*+"(&'

( "4( &( +%&>"(7 4%((*&'?&$$""!+(! $ .+(A  $ (%-  &((+"!"%*  $ (7#.&* *'#&'7$(%-&(%..&-" $&* (%( .+ & %'!%'%(D+(! &%&!!D(%#@#>  $ .*4 ! $ .+((7#.&*
 
 

$FFRUGLQJ WR WKH <=¶V 8QRIILFLDO 5DS 'LFWLRQDU\ 30& ́ LV 30DVWHU

RI &HUHPRQLHV WKH PLF FKHFNHU μ,¶P WKH UHDO HPFHH PDF GDGG\¶ ́ -$DW 

6XJJHVWLQJ WKDW 3%DFN RI WKH %XV ́ ZRXOG KDYH EHHQ DQ DSSURSULDWH

WLWOH LV QRW PHDQW WR EH DQ DSSOLFDWLRQ RI WKH 3DOWHUQDWLYH DYHQXHV ́ WHVWGLVFXVVHG VXSUD ,W VLPSO\ VKRZV WKDW VXFK D WLWOH ZRXOG FOHDUO\ EH

DUWLVWLFDOO\ UHOHYDQW XQGHU WKH ILUVW SURQJ RI 5RJHUV

IJ0

%""7$ &%&%!$'&("&**+"?.&>$

$"&(&*"&%($& .?%$&%'$*%%!$(%- &( *"&%7 % .>&+( %' &%'' &( @ % "(%.'.A!"$!?&%-"(%(


&("+$$ $"(@#>$.*4!$.+(A&(

" '7+('&%$@$4A"*$"+(!$(%-K$%$ $"(&(*%(&'"''6'$?>"

$ $"( $( .(+7 %$&%-  ' ?&$ ( "4($"*+'.%("%-"%#"*# &%->&'%*!$&(!*$%$'#&((&%!@)"MAB%'"M@)"MA2%F#&%C$@KB+3(C%>"&%%''!"$(%-..+( "4( " $ *&>& "&-$( #>#%  
 ?( F+((7#.&*#%&%-$?*#&%D.*4+(7+$",( #>  $ .*4 ! $ .+(A  5  888  $

*# ("('&'&%%'&..+("4(%'$7"&*(".+("4($7"&*(D(#((-&(

$+3(D(*# &"("!(("H+&7%'$"!"#+(@#>$.*4!$.+(A"&%$"?"'(@4 .*4 (A  K .&> $ "(%. "(%( *+'*%*+'$$"&(% "&%($& !%74&%'.?%("4(D%#%'$*%%!$(%-Q(%-$&(%$&%-#"%'%$&%-(($% %%%+%*&%-$"&+# $!(+ "&"  &%$%"&%#%.+(&%((>"&%!"&"  &%$.+(&%((,', !"G# ?+'.&$&(.>&+(7">%$*%%!$(%-.+&(?+'%$>$#"4&%- ?"!%&*%!$*&>&"&-$(#>#%$(&%-("4(D

 


%# ($&$ (%-+%H(%-D( %&($*%(+#

$$*+"#'%&# 

 &(&%$&(*($*+"(?&$+&#&($ +"*$("!*%! ($("&-$%.$ "'+*A$JI'"-"'&%-$ *%%!  (%-&'$("&-$%

*%%!$(%-K$&$G '#&'7 "H+&"( #" "*"'&%"7*##"*& "'+*(@O"&(&* ">%* *%% . (+!!&G "((&%&%"(A%&%$ "(%*(*+'.!+%'$%$#*
%*+'&%-$ $$.+(A&%$7"&*(!$&((%-F+(&!7(#"!?$ %#!"$&$(%-%'" '%&#("!&!7&#('!$">%*7!$&$

$'&("&**+"#'$!

&%&!!("4(&(?4

$( .% "*-%&L' ( % &%!"'# $+#%&7 '&-%&7 %7"(&%&!!D(%"&7"(-&%("*&&%H+&7&%$	&%,%-#"7.#$"(?$& ((%-"%'.+(  $&( % '!&% * "*.7*$%''(-"-&%%'+( "4'$&>&/0U(

I/	+ 'III

K$&)!%'%(D7"&*(*%&%

!@G &*&A%-+-B-$"?&
 
 8

*%&% .(+7 %$&%- $ *+' *%*&>.7 .7 %7("*$ ! $ &#-&%&% . *%(&'"' G &*&7 "&# &*&7  "!"%* *+"- (*"&!&*$ *&>&"&-$( #>#% "  %7 $" H+&7 ?&$ ?$&*$("4(&(&'%&!&'
!$"H+&"#%!@">%*A&($> %7 #%&%-   & ?+' % . +%"(%. *%*+' $ $ &   &(  ">%  $

*%%!$ (%-&%H+(&%$+(!$&(?#%D(%#+%H+(&%.7?(-'#"4&%-Q?(&47(!"#""*"'&%-($%,', Q

.+&(+(*+'.!+%'.7"(%.!&%'"!!*.!-"%'* &%%$ +.&*"-"'&%-$*+*%%!$&((%-%'$*"&%!%&# "((&%$("4(?$$' ">'$+(!$"%#&%*%%*&%?&$$ .+#$'( ">'"( %("'$+(!$"%#%)!%'%(D*# (&&%


 &( *"&%7 % '&( (&&> $ &% "( %(  %

&%">&? !?&%- $ !&&%- ! $&( ?(+& % ! $+3( ##."( (&' $ +(&%- ( "4(D %# ?(@(7#.&*AK$"%"&( "*&#($*."&7D(%#&(+('#"7(@(7#.A!"$7"&*(!(%-%'(+*$+(&($&-$7H+(&%.?$%$7"&*("G#&%'-&&# H+(&% &( "(%' (  ?$$" $ "&(D(*&#&( (&%*""#"7-+&((* &.&&7+"(4&(#(+(&(%** ?&$+H+(&%?$>" +" ()!%'%(#7%?*&#$7$'&%+(&%-("4(D%# 
&(&%('#4'"#&%&%(?$$" 7&%-$?!$$"&(-%+&%&((+!#"&!*"-"'&%-$H+(&%!?$$"$&&("&(&*7 ">%  $ *%% ! $ (%-  ( %'.>*"7&%-@"&(A'(%*%!"'+$"&7

  " "&  *."&7D( %#  +"$"#" *"7&%-@(7#.A '( % *$%- $ " (&&% %' *%!"+$"&7+(*."&7D(%#?$%%%&%!*#7G&(


  "( $$ '&("&* *+"D( "%'&&% ! (+##"7

F+'-#%!"+3(?(.('%$*+"D(*%*+(&%$)!%'%(D+(!&%&!!D(%#($(%-D(&

 
?(@# $"&*%'(7#.&*AH+(&%$?>"&(#$("4(&((7#.($&%"%&% (7#. ! !"'#("%-$A5I$"&(%%7 ! $( H+&&( &% $ (*$'$"%#
%7"&*($"&%@$4A"*$"+($&( +"  *+'!&%'$$&(&((%-$H+&&(&'%&!&'?&$(+(!("4(D%#&%#H+(&%.# $"&(@!&?"'" $"('%&%-%4&%'&% *!%$"(+--(&4$#A1('20B$&& 2.**4;>'I/C$.*4!$.+(A#7.#& "!"(  +3(D( *# &"+3(D("+"%%'.&%-!"*'(%-$?>"&(%&', %' & &( '&!!&*+  H+(+ "&"&7 # $"&*7 " &% H+&&(!"?$&*$("4(&(K.&>$"(%.  ("4(D%#($&$&.&%-# $"&*"(7#.&*"4(&(!#+($*%""7!&%'$$%# ?(  " "&>(7&%*"('#"4&%- ?"%#!%&%$"&%!$*

K'%#%&# 7$

'&( 7'&%!"&%-#%%".&&7 ">%%7$"*$"**."&7%'((+*$($*%% #%%"$#7%. (&%-&%% $#
&
$%$/0BICB2&"'5*%*+""&%'"&>'!"# +.&* "#&%%*'?"'!!*"&*+" "'7%'(
 
 

7\SLFDO RI WKH DIILGDYLWV ILOHG LQ WKLV FDVH LV WKDW RI &XUW 0HUUZHWK

 , SXUFKDVHG WKH 2XWNDVW DOEXP $TXHPLQL ZLWK 5RVD 3DUNV¶VRQJ DGYHUWLVHG RQ WKH RXWVLGH ODEHO , WKRXJKW WKH O\ULFV ZHUH DERXW WKH FLYLO ULJKWV PRYHPHQWDQG 0UV 5RVD 3DUNV¶ KLVWRULF FRQWULEXWLRQV , OHDUQHG DIWHU SXUFKDVLQJ WKH DOEXP DQG OLVWHQLQJ WR WKHFRQWHQW RI WKH VRQJ WKDW 0UV 3DUNV¶ QDPH ZDV XVHG WR JHW P\DWWHQWLRQ VR WKDW , ZRXOG EX\ WKH DOEXP

-$ DW 

G#  $ @O P"'&( ! *."&&( " % ( *&7>+.#%(!G "((&%.*+(!$"*."&&( 7&%#'"%(*&7A)8'I$

 "(% *( $?>" '( % &%>> %7 *&# !*"&*+" "'7"(&"
&%>>(&%('$+(!*."&7D( %# ( $ &   (%- ?$% & "(%.7*+' . !+%' $ $ *."&7D( %# $( % "&(&*">%*$*%%!$(%-
&%>>(&%($""(%.'&( +?$$"$+(!("4(D%#?(#&(" "(%&%%'!('>"&(&%-"?$$"&?(-&&#+(!*."&7D(%#&%(#"*-%&L'!"#!"&(&*G "((&% "*'.7$&"(#%'#%


%$$*+"&%'&(*+((&%-$&$#>&

%$.(">'$@$"&(%'+."&(4$(#  4&%- $& N;&%-" %' "'D#&-$$&%4 $ !&# ?( .+ -"( %' (&" &%  '&"*.&-" $&*(%("$(-&%&%-$&# "((&%$& &( #&('&%-A  JI '  00  &4?&( &% $ "(% *( (#   4&%-  $ & 

#&-$ $&%4 $ (%- &( .+ ( "4( %' !" $(-&%&%-$&# "((&%B(?%7%*%(+#"!!&'>&(!&'&%$&(*(&%'&*$ %'58/C$&&(#&('&%-$&((%'&%-%#7%.(+!!&*&%

($?>&&%!$%$#*$&&(%>"$((

"&(&*7">%$*%%!$+%'"7&%-?"4

$"&(*"'&(&%*&%$?>".?%$!*(&%

$%'$!*(&%$ "(%*(
%$$*+"

$'%'&!!&*+7&%!&%'&%-$$&*$(%!"$#>&

/ 


%$$'"&(&*">

#>& @$ *%" *$"*"(&N;&%-"D %' N"'D %' $( *$(%F+( G &$ +.&*&*+%" "(.+&%('$>-%+("7AJI'00 $+$$&%$&*%%&%"!""&%-$!&#D("4%?%$&"
&%+'&%*


%$"?"'($&&%$?

"+$!+($!&#D(*%%.$#&%*$"*"(4%?%&%$!*%"(&*%%.(&'$$&(*"7"+$!+(?$&*$(+3('#&(&(%?(%>"&%%''..+%"!"("4("$4%?%

+"$"#"$*%"(.?

%' $ !&*&% ;&%-" %' "'&"*"D( +" (!(&"&L&%-*%&%$(%($&?(@%&%-$!&##4"D("&(&*G "((&G %&%!"$+(!($&" (%- $?>" &( $ $(7#.A
&(&%''(7#..&( $? $ (7#. ! ( "4$+#%&7'&-%&7%'("%-$A&*%%!(%-$ "(.$( H+&&(  $ (%- &( %  "'7"(#$"!"#!"&. "*' +%'" $ ."' #%'#%$#"!*$$!$.+(A&(% '(*"& &%!%"&%"($7"-"'((("$>&?F+(&!&*&%(#"!%#!("4(
 
 I

!
!)	 /8'JB$&"

00C&%>>'!*($""#"4.7'&!!"%!"#$!*(!$&(*(
% 7&%-$!&"( "%-!$$&%$&"*+&&%!('6

KG *&'(*"&.$+%'"7&%-?"4%

&'%&!7$ "'+*"%'2".&;&"'(F+($

$2".&;&"& "(-((%-.+2".&"

(-&"&42".&$&*%>7(#((-*%(+#"(.+?$$7*%G *'&(*>"&%$(%-&(!9&D(H+&*4-&# (!H+D(4%$&"?%(%-$7"&*(*%!&"#$&(6$!#(&%-"?$*($"(!2".&&(@2".&-&"&%O$"P2".&?"'A 	$($"# *+%" " B%#' 3%C@&!&% (&*&D(!%(&*:+*%."+($#7$&"+%'"(( # >"7?$"T
#-&%&% &! &( 7+"*"&%A%'!!$7-@ "7A$(%- 4(!+%  2".& %' $ >+( $ H+ *%%'( ($" "(%(



-'
$-"(' ,

'$
' $0# ' $   	  ' $   ,'
	" #'


00B# $(&('''C


%($" *%"(!&&($&-$7H+(&%.$$

!*(&%$ "(% *( (&(!7 $ !&"( "%- !$K$"($&,%?(*"7">%$7"&*(!$(%-B@$(%-&(.+2".&%'$>+(H+*&#(($" "(%(AC&*%%.(&'$$&&(*"7">%$7"&*(!$(%-&%$&(*(K$&$7"&*(!,%"*"&%7%!"&%-$?$(#&#- "!""'.7$*""!2".&B@$(%- 4(!+%2".&%'$>+($H+*%%'(($ " "(%(AC "'7 &( % "&(&* !"# ! G "((&% "*'.7$&"(#%'#%
%*%"($"$(.%

J 
% #   '!%'  *%(&+( "'7!("4((#$"!"#!"&(&*G "($"(!

$ ! *( $"!" &%

'&(&%-+&($.!"#$!*(!$?.&>&(  &*&%!$ &*&%$&%'7"&*(!

*%*+(&%$$&

$7"&*(!)!%'%(D(%-)!%'%(*%%(&(!7>%$

"'"F+(&!7$&" " "&&%

*($&(#"(&#&"$

&(&
%# /C
%&'!%'%( "'+*%&'@%$"A?$&*$?(*$&("&*!*&%>>&%-2..7	"7!+%''.7	%'+7?% %' %$" '" ! '"&'->"?" ""7	&#&"  $ (& +&% &% $+%'&( +'$$ &%&!!?($&("&*!&-+"A%'$@OP$&% $ 2*4 %$" "7 #7 .4('&(*+((&%-$&>&&-$(88


% ''&&%$#>&>"&

 "'+*'6BC.4&''' , '  ' &>&' !$#>&9%'B8C**&%!$ (%-( !"#$*>" !"$ $# >&' "(	D( %# %' $'  $- ""7'	?%%'>!$#+(&*)T*((*%&$?(%$$#>&'-$!(*%!"#$#>&	
 
 

$+(!$&(%#!"$#>&$.4$>&' "$)T*((."+-$(+&-&%->&&%(!E8BC!$%$#*%'$&(*##%?"&-$! +.&*&7$'!%'%(#>'!"(+##"7F+'-#%%*&#(

$ & *+" !+%' $ '!%'%( ?" %&' 

(+##"7 F+'-#% % &%&!!D( *##%? "&-$ ! +.&*&7*&#(&*%*"%'$#>&$ &*"&$&("7.4%'$>&' $*+"$'%"+.!&%'&%-$$*"&%!#>&%'$&("7.4$&%-"'!&*&&+(  %'>%(?&$$&("&*  %'>%((+""+%'&%-$#"-%*!$2*4%$""7&%$/0U(?( "*'.7$&"(#%'#%$*+"(!+%'$$@+(!$&%&!!D(%#%'&4%((%$*>"!$ &*"&$&("7.4%'%$*>"!"$$#>&'"'''#$(+.F*#"!?$&*$'(?&$$2*4%$" "7 %'$ &%&!!D( " ( *!+%'"!$"7A88IB# $(&('''C

$+(!$ &%&!!D(%#%'&4%((%$*>"!

$#+(&*)T*(($?>"?(%%&"7'&!!"%#"$#+(&**%&%'%$)T*((*%(&('!>"&+((%-(*# ('.7'&!!"%#+(&*&%($*+" &%'+6

"7$+(!$&%&!!U(%#%'&4%((%$*>"!$#+(&*)T*(('(%"$*%%&%$)T*((&%$(##%%"($+(!$&%&!!U(%#%'&4%((%$*>"!$$#>&'%' &*"&$&("7.4"($*%%!$!&#%' &*"&$&("7.4$(+.F*#"!?$&*$*%*"%($2*4%$""7%'$&%&!!U("(*!+%'"!$"7$!&#%' &*"&$&("7.4$("7!$2*4%$""7 %' $ &%&!!U( " &% $ "7 &% $ /0D(9'# )9#

$
## 0''$'
'''','$"&(-%+&%

80 


,Q DGGLWLRQ WR 5RJHUV WKH 6HDOH FRX

WKH 5HVWDWHPHQW 7KLUG RI 8QIDLU &RPSH

VHFWLRQ LV WLWOHG 3$SSURSULDWLRQ RI WKH &

,GHQWLW\ 7KH 5LJKW RI 3XEOLFLW\ ́ ,W SURYFRPPHUFLDO YDOXH RI D SHUVRQ¶V LGHQWLW\ 

SHUVRQ¶V QDPH OLNHQHVV RU RWKHU LQGLFLD WUDGH LV VXEMHFW WR OLDELOLW\    ́

7KH FRXUW IXUWKHU QRWHG WKDW DOWKRXJ

7KLUG RI 8QIDLU &RPSHWLWLRQ VWDWHV WKDW XQRW RUGLQDULO\ LQFOXGH 3WKH XVH RI D SHUVRFRPPHQWDU\ HQWHUWDLQPHQW ZRUNV RI DGYHUWLVLQJ WKDW LV LQFLGHQWDO WR VXFK XVVWDWHV WKDW 3LI WKH QDPH RU OLNHQHVV LV XVHZRUN WKDW LV QRW UHODWHG WR WKH LGHQWLILHG SWR OLDELOLW\ IRU D XVH RI WKH RWKHU¶V LGHQWLW\ ) 6XSS DW 

7KH FRXUW LQ WKH 6HDOH FDVH IROORZ

IRXQG WKDW WKH SODLQWLII KDG IDLOHG WR SUHVHQKLV FODLPV DQG HQWHUHG MXGJPHQW LQ IDYR*UDPHUF\ 3LFWXUHV  ) 6XSS  (

&((+!#"&!*$"!"&%&!!U(%#%'&4%((%)T*((&(*"7"'@%$"A%'(">((%'>"?$$"$)!%'%(D+(!&4%((%$*>"!$)'>"&(#%!"$(!$
%#JI'00

88I8JB# $(&('''C

$ *+"#'$ (# !&%'&

%-+-"-"'&%-	D(*&#%$#*-&% 7&%-$

"(+$-%+&%&((+!#80$*+"$"!"'!"(+##"7F+'-#%%.$$"&-$! +.&*&7*&#%'%$#"'$'!%'%(D+( !&4%((%$)T*((
 
 8

 G &LU  7KH VLJQLILFDQFH RI 6HDOH LQ WKH FRQWH[W RI WKH

SUHVHQW FDVH KRZHYHU LV WKDW WKH TXHVWLRQ RI OLDELOLW\ ZDV QRW GHWHUPLQHGRQ D PRWLRQ IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW EXW ZDV OHIW IRU D WULDO RQ WKH PHULWV

K"*$$(#*%*+(&%&%$ "(%*($"&(

 -%+&% &((+ ! #"& !* ?$$" $ +( ! ("4(D%#( &$ (%-%'%$*>"!$.+# &( "&(&*7 "'  $ *%% ! $ (%- "?$$"$+(!$%#("4(&(%$&%-#"$%#&('&%-'>"&(#%!"$(!$(%-!$$


%$$ *+" $'$&!$& !$ ?"4&(

"&(&*7">%&(*%%$"&(%>&&%!$%$# * $ @& G &*&7 #&('( ($

(+"*"$*%%!$?"4AJI'$*+"%'?&$ "!"%*$ !&"( "%-!$$%7(&(6

#&('&%-&?&$%"&(&*">%**%%.(+!!&*&%7F+(&!&'.7  !" G "((&%&%"( "G# &!  !&##4" *'$& @;&%-" %'"'A%!&#?$&*$&$'%"&(&*">%*$"-+.7#&('&%-(+--(&%(((+"*"*%%&# &*&7*%>7'.7$&*+'.!+%'>&$%$#*((+*$!&#




%'&(*+((&%-$(*%' "%-!&(%7(&(&%$*%G

!+(&%-*."&7D(%#&%$&!(#"&(&*?"4$*+"G &%'6

OP&( ?&$ ( #&%&# "&(&* ">%*$?"4#7&%*+'G &*&(#%(.+$*%%!$?"4$"("&+(7#&('&%-"G# &!$*$"*"(&%$ !&#&%$&(*($' +.&($'$&"##&"(+%'"$& @$"+&! 	"7 !;&%-"%'"'A%'&!$!&##4"$'$%+('

8 


$ !&*&&+( .4 & ( $%$#* *+'.  &*.#&('&%-'(*"& &%!*%%*."&7D( %# #4 % G ?"4 &( .+ $ "(% &%">%*!$..*"%7!">&?&%-""'&&($*%(+#"&%"(&%(&-$  ?""%  &*&% !K$"&?&$((#?"4&(%G &*&7#&('&%-?"4&&(%!('>"&(&%-

000B!%#&'C

K*%(&'"'$!*( "(

$?&$"!"%*$!&"( "$&((+!"&(&*">%*!7"&*( ! $ (%- &( $&-$7 H+"(>'(#"!??!!*!"!+>&'%&"7$"+('&%(#(7#.&*"# !$$%7(&(+%'"$ 

?+' ".*# 
%@#4O(P%G &*&.+ $ "(% &% %7 '&"* )!%'%('&'%%#$(%-

&"


% ($" ?$$" $ & 

">%*$*%%!$(%"(>'.7!&%'"!!*!?%'%.7F+'-(#"!(+.#&'&%(+ "!#&%!%"#%'$!&%'"!!*'"$&  %  (%-">%*$%$&(?+'*%$# * %' F+'-#% ($+&%&!!?>"&!$!&%'"& &( "&(&*7 ">%  $
 
 88

&%H+&"7 &(  % %' .*+( $ & @&( % G &*&7#&('&%- (  $ *%% ! $ ?"4A  
% $ >%F+'-#%($+'.%"'&%!>"!)!%'%(


!,'$-!!"

)
 

$ "&-$! +.&*&7 "*($&'%&7!*."&7

!"# G &&> *##"*& +(  & ) 
 /(

3' /J'J8J8 B/$&"J8C@$$"7!$"&-$&($*."&7D(&'%&7*% . >+. &% $ "#&% ! "'+*( %' $*."&7 $( % &%"( $ #7 . "*' !"# $+%+$"&L'*##"*&G &&%!$&'%&7A((+*$$*##%?"&-$! +.&*&7!"#(( *&(! " "7"&-$&+'
&

/0,)88
	/I8BIIC9/#!
::#
.*6
I08'J8B/$&"00C9)8'/I

$ "&-$ ! +.&*&7 &( ->"%' .7 ( ?  &

'#I8'/,&*$&-%$(&%'&*'$&?+'"*-%&L"&-$! +.&*&7(
)0!.)88K' B,&*$JC%'$ "&( $> % H+(&%' $ &%&!! $(  "&-$ ! +.&*&7$'&( +&(>"&( &*&%$!*(!$&(*(

"4(D"&-$! +.&*&7"-+#%"*4($!$"%$#

**&#	$-($)!%'%($> "!&'!"#$"!#.7+(&%-$"%#(7!"*##"*& +" (	$(+ &(#+*$$(#>&'%*&%(+ "!$""&-$! +.&*&7*&#(($'&'!"$"%$#**$7"&*(!$@"%(&%A%'$ "((*& &%-(H+&%-+3(##."()!%'%('%'%7$$7$>+('$&*##"*&7.+"-+$"4( $( "'+*' % >&'%* $ $&" +( ?(*##"*&  
%(' $7 "-+ $ $ *$&* ?( ("&(&*%'$$7$"!"$>*# '!%(&%$&"(#%'#%

8 


$ '&("&* *+" -"' ?&$ 

*+"  &' $ ?$&*$ &'>"&(&%- *&#+%'"E8BC  +.&*&7 *&% "&(&%- +%'" $?&$"( *"&-$! +((  *."&7D( %# ?& .#%'#% +%(( $ & &( @*%%!$?"4"?(@(&# '>"&(#%!"$(!-'('00$'&("&**+"!+$"?( % "&(&* "&%($& *%%!$(%-%'$"!"@(&# 7'&(-+&('*##"*&'

	+ 'IJ)!%'%(D+(.+#'&'%*$%-$&("(+

*!

"&-$! +.&*&7*&#&((&#

*&# &% $ & -"%(  *."&*%#&*&%"(&%$&("$"%#J8B@$"&-$! +.&*&7$*##"*& &%"( ! *."&&?>""&-$! +.&*&7*&#'>"&(&%-*&#&%%*"+*&"*&#'(%"H+&"%7>&'%* . *%!+('  & /# !B$ #;'<-*BCC9$JI'00)	+ '08080B &%&!!#+( ">&%"&-$! $( *+%&"7&%"(&%$"&'$( .% *##"*&7 G &'#I8'/9)

$ "&($>(& +'$

($$(+('$"%# "#	$ $( $"!" (.&($' % %#  & '# I 8)!%'%( '#& $ $7 $> 
 
 8

%#!$&"(%-%'$>+('$%#($(%-%' $&" .+#  $7 "-+ $?>" $ ( ?&$ $%$#**&#$&"&"(#%'#% "&-$!"&(&*G "((&%($+' ">&>""4(D*&#)$:	##

2*+( &%&!!."("'+*'.+"'%! "(+(&%

(+**' &%  "&-$ ! +.&*&7 *&% *+"( %'*##%"($>"*-%&L'$ +.&*&7"&-$(*""7-""'%-"!&# &%-&%-%&"(#%'#%"&-$($%' "&-$( ((*&' ?&$ !( '>"&(&%- *&#(  &$JI'009)8'/IB%&%- $ +.&*&7 "&-$( !!" @(+.(%&7 ."'" "*&%A $% ?( ">%&%- !( %'"(#%C9 ."(%$3?'$' 
'	##	
 	I0
%'5IBC

K$>"*-%&L'$&# "%*!&"(#%'#%

'!%(  "&-$ ! +.&*&7  *&%( &%  "*% *( 
%

 &
!"&%'(%'!#&7##."(!$,?%-"+ $@# &%(A(+'$#4"(!>&('#&%&("&( !"$#%%"&%?$&*$$7%'$!"#" -"+  ##."( ?" ""7'&%$ !&#  J 	+ 'I8I/IB),&*$000C(/I8'IB/$&"00C$ &%&!!(-'$$&"&4%(((?" " "&'%'"( "'+*$!&#?&$+$&" "#&((&%IJ$*+"!+%'&%$*($$ &%&!!( *+' % >"*# $ '!%'%D( &"(#%'#% '!%( >% ?$" $ ""7 ! $ &%&!!( ?( "7 !&*&%&L' %' >% ?$" $&4%((( ! $ &%&!!( ?" +('  "# >&'*((>"(&%!$#&%&("&(I8089

&	+ 88IB$'&%-$$!&#'?$&*$+('$%#%'&4%((!2*4%$"!+%'"2..7	?( "*'.7$&"(#%'#%C

(?&$$%$#*$%?#+(*%'+*%$"

.%*&%-!&%"(("4(D " "7"&-$&%$"?%%#>"(+($!"'#!"&(&*G "((&%&*1)



8/ 


3' ($	+ '000C9
2(/50J8B)"&L000C9I8	

	##


%$$ 	*%'&"*+&

 "*' !"# "&-$! +.&*&7 @?$7+%"'A$*%%'&(-+&('*##"*&'>"&(#(">&*(AJI'00$*%G!$"G "((&>?"4($#;'<-@O+P(!%$"D(&'%&7&%%>&(%"'&%"&7%&%!"&%-#%+%((P$%#"&4%((&(+(?"4$&(%"'$$ !"#+&% &( ( (+ 


%$*+"*&88I !" $ " (&&% $ $ &%&!!D(&'%&7%'$*%%!'!%("&-$! +.&*&7	+ 'I8&&%+"%"

	+ 88I9 $$+( 7$$&%(%*

"$(#"(%(?$>(

" ?.&>$"4(D"&-$ -%+&% &((+ ! #"& !* ?$$"$&$(%-&("&($*%%!$(%-"(% &%&%+ %*%(&'"&%!&.@'&(-+&('*##"*&@(7"*%&%A$?000

'.!'!,#

"4( (  ( $ '&("&* 

(+##"7F+'-#%)!%'%(
 
 8I

'!#&% %' &%%&% &%"!"%* ?&$  .+(&%(("&%($& &%'&%-%#"&&%&$"!$(*&#(?"$#."&!7.?

"#



"4("-+($$(%-'!#($"*$"*"" *(

$"&%  !(&-$ (+**'% '!#&% *&#  +.&*!&-+"#+( ">*+#&*&20=#

)
& 
8I/
	IJ0B/C
%+"%*+#&*"H+&"(($?&%-.7*"%'*%>&%*&%->&'%*$'!%'%#'!((#%?&$4%?'-!$!(&7 " ?&$ "*4(( '&("-"' !" $ "+$  &''20


/

I
	I/III8BJ/C(#%&(*&%.%7&!&((*+!*(.+ &%&!!$"@ ">.%' !(A!
'
3 )I
	/I0B0C$(%-&( &%7%.+"4(&%%7.&-" $&*(%(!$"#%'*"&%7'(%#4%7!*+(#%(.+$"($"&(%!*+(#%.+$""4(*%% ($?>%$ !&"(#%!'!#&%*&#$"!"?!&%'$&("-+#%#"&((

"4(D '!#&%.7&# &*&% "-+#% &( &4?&(

#"&(((?&$"'&&%'!#&%*&# &%&!!&%  '!#&%.7&# &*&% *&# #+( (.&($ #"&!(&7&/0
!/'&
J8K'II88B,&*$ JC"4($(%'% (  $ #" !* $ "4(D %# &( *$' (#$&%- @!!%(&>A &( % %+-$  >"*#)!%'%(D&"(#%'#%"&-$(&/ !$:
0J
	/IBJJCB 7&%-$ +.&*!&-+"'!#&%('%7*."&7D(&%%&%&%!&*&%!#&%'&("((*&#-&%('!%'%D(#-L&%!"&(' &*&%!$&#%--'&%&%*(%'*$.+(CK$"!"-"$)!%'%('(">'(+##"7F+'-#%%$&(*&#

8J 


3:KDW LV IRRG WR RQH LV WR RWKHUV E

%& -RKQ %DUWOHWW )DPLOLDU 4XRWDWLRQV

*



 



"4((*&#($)!%'%

?&$ $" .+(&%(( "&%($&  ?  .+#   #4  (+**&%"!"%*?&$.+(&%(("&#+(($?%@&%%&%'&%-$ &%%&% '&%- !  ?!+%F+(&!&'&%?!"$ +" ("&-$(".+(&%(( "&%($& O(P)' *6
 ) 8 8' IB*&&% %' &%"% H+&% ,&*$&-%?C$&(@?"%-!+*%"* ."*$ " %$" .""&%($& &')#K'IB,&*$ ."4'?% **+""' &% $&( *(&#
3'JI	+ ?$&*$(+--(($,&*$&-%#&'!%'%D(*&%#'$ &%#"G %(&>".+"'%(#
-,&*$&-% $( % *"7 "*-%&-"+%'( "4( $( % ."+-)!%'%(D (%-   #

 "#&% ! $   ..+"'%(#%(H+%7$&(*




K"%*'+ %&%$&(*

)!%'%(D (%- %' ?$$" ?" +(&> "($ "  ?"4 ! -'"#&%&%!$-&((+( 

#(007"(-*""*7'%-"+(+%'"4&%-!" "(%*%(&+$#(>(!&%F+'-(&+("&%( +(&' ! $ %""
 
 8

&I 0LOOHU Y &DOLIRUQLD  86   LQ ZKLFK WKH 6XSUHPH

&RXUW DFNQRZOHGJLQJ 3WKH LQKHUHQW GDQJHUV RI XQGHUWDNLQJ WR UHJXODWH

DQ\ IRUP RI H[SUHVVLRQ ́ QHYHUWKHOHVV DGRSWHG D OHJDO VWDQGDUG UHJDUGLQJREVFHQLW\ DQG WKH )LUVW $PHQGPHQW ZKLFK UHTXLUHG WKH WULHU RI IDFW WRFRQVLGHU LQWHU DOLD ZKHWKHU WKH ZRUN WDNHQ DV D ZKROH ODFNV 3VHULRXVOLWHUDU\ DUWLVWLF SROLWLFDO RU VFLHQWLILF YDOXH ́ ,G DW 

:KR VWHDOV P\ SXUVH VWHDOV WUDVK μWLV VRPHWKLQJ QRWKLQJμ7ZDV PLQH μWLV KLV DQG KDV EHHQ VODYH WR WKRXVDQGV%XW KH WKDW ILOFKHV IURP PH P\ JRRG QDPH5REV PH RI WKDW ZKLFK QRW HQULFKHV KLP$QG PDNHV PH SRRU LQGHHG

:LOOLDP 6KDNHVSHDUH 2WKHOOR DFW  VF 

&#&(A%$,
'$
'$)JJ
	8B08C$(#&(%(("+'7%' &(?&$H+!"*#+(&**# (&&%($ &%$?>" &( $ ?$& ? ( F+'-( ' % "(+# '"#&%$"&(&*H+&7!$(%-&%H+(&%?$>$ "( %(&.&&7 ( F+'-(   7  - (%'"' !@"&(&* ">%*A &% "(>&%- $ "&-$( ! ( "4(*%*"%&%-$+(!$"%# %'$ &"( #%'#%"&-$(!$)!%'%(&%$*"&%%'#"4&%-!#+(&**# (&&% &*&%!$(%'"'&%>>(

 "*-%&&% $ ( "4( $( % "&-$  *%" $"&#-.7*%("&%-'&(-". ""7(
(&%>>("*-%&&%$$&"(#%'#%*%% "#&%7%?$*"&(@"&(A$>'?$%&*#(%#&%-%''>"&(&%-$&(?"4(


%$&(*(!"$"(%((!"$.>$!*$

)!%'%( *"7 @"&(A %' @(7#.A ( "(%( !" " "&&%- ( "4(D %# !"  (%- & '( %.(> $# !"# %& &.&&7 !" &% $ ?"'( !	$4( " !&*$&%- ( "4(D -' %#  $

H+(&%!$&.&&7$?>"($+'.'"#&%'.7$"&"!!*!"!+>&'%&"7$"&%-%'%(#"!?%#&%!"(+##"7F+'-#%

0 


"$"(%(('((

%'$"*##%?"&-$! +.&$ )&("&* +" &( /.	!"!++" "*'

$&(  &%&%  K&$ "( * '!#&% %' "&+( &%"!"&%($&  $ F+'-#% ! 	

.