Pursuant to 5 T H C IR . R. 47.5, the court has determined that thi s opinion should not * be publishe d and is not precedent except under the limited circu mstance s set forth in 5 T H C IR . R. 47.5 .4. 

### INTHE UNI TED S TATESCOU RT OFAPPEALS

FORTHEFIFTH CIRCU IT

N o. 08- 60951 Su m m ar y Cal endar

K E V IN T H O M A S , P l a i n tiff - A p p ell a n t v. C O N S T A N C E R E E S E , i n her Indivi du alC ap aci t y as a F ederalO f f i cer; JU L IE D

. SO U T H E R LA N D , i n her Indivi du alC ap aci t y as a F ederalO f f i cer; Z . P L E A S A N T , inh e rIn d iv id u a l C a p a c itya s aF e d e r a l O ffic e r , D efen da n t s - A pp el l ees

Appe alf

r o m t he U ni t e d St at e s D i s t r i c tCour tf o rt he So ut he r n Di s t r i c to f

M i s s i s s i ppia tJ ac ks o n 5: 07- C V

- 160

B ef ore D AV IS, SM ITH , an d O W E N , C i rcui tJu dg es. P E R C U R IA M: * P l ai n tiff, K e v inT h o m a s, i s a F e d e ra l i n m a te se rv in ga1 8 0 m o n th sentence
a t F e d e ra l C o rr e ctio n a l C o m p lexinY a z o o C it y , M iss iss ip p i(F C C Y a z o o C ity). H i s proj ect ed rel ease date i s i n Sep t em ber 201 3. Th om as f i l ed thi s Bi v e nsact i on a g a in s t p r is o n o ffic ia ls , C o n s ta n c e R e e s e , W a r d e n ; J u lie D

. S o u th e r la n d , U n it M ana ge r ; a nd Z ane t a Pl e as ant , Couns e l or . H i s c o r e c o m pl ai nti s t hatt he United States Court of App eals

Fifth Circuit 

### F I L E D Aug ust28, 2009 Cha rl es R. F ulb ru g e II I ClerkN o. 08- 60951

2 de fe nda nt s de pr ive d hi m o f l e ga lm at e r i al s ne c e s s ar y t o f i l e ac o m pl ai nta bo ut i n ad equ ate m edi calcare i n th e p ri son. Th om as assert s t h at defen da n t s, S ou t h erl a n d an d P l easan t , searc h ed h i s c el lan d rem ovedf rom hi s l ocker t y p e wr i t e rr ib b o n s , t y p e wr i t e re r a s e rr ib b o n s a n dac iv i lj u r yt r i a lma n u a l

. H e a l l eg edtha t bytak i n g th i s p rop ertythe pr i son off i ci a l s “crea tedan i m p ed i m en t” t o hi s as se r t i ng hi s c l ai m of i nadequat e m edi c al c ar e. H e f urt heras se r t ed that
a com pl et e breakd ow n i n t h e i n st i t u t i on ’ s el ect roni c l egal researc h com pu t er syst em dep rivedhi m of acces s t o t h e court s. The m ag i s t r at e j udg e w r o t e ade t ail e d r e po r ta nd r e c o m m e nda t i o n t o t he di s t r i c tc o ur tr e c o m m e ndi ng t hatt he def e nda nt s ’m o t i o n f

o rs um m ar y j udg m e nt be gr ant ed o n gr ounds thatTh om as had notdem ons t r at ed a c ons t i t uti onal vi o l at i o n. The di s t r i c tc o ur ta c cepted t he r e c o m m e nda t i o n a nd d i s m i s s e d the
c as e . W e a f

f i r m t he di s t r i c tcour t ’ s o r de rg r ant i ng s um m ar y j udg m e ntf o rt he f ol l ow i n g reasons. 1) Pl a i n ti f

f pr oduc ed no sum m ar y j udgm entev i denc e i ndi c at i ng t hat C o n s ta n c e R e e s e th e W a r d e n o f F C C Y a z o o C ity , M is s is s ip p i w a s p e r s o n a lly i nvolved orhad know l edge of t he all ege d c onf

i sc at i on o f p l ai nt i f

f ’ s l egal
m ater i al s. A ccor di n gl y t h e di st ri ctcourtcor rect l y di sm i ssed pl ai n t i f f ’ s Bi v e ns cl ai m s agai n stW arden R eese. 2) Th om as ar gues t hathe s uf fer ed har m be c a u se hi s depr ivat i on o f l egal
m ater i al s del ayed hi m i n f i l i n g sui tbeyon d the t i m e p erm i t t ed byt h e st atute of l i m i t at i o ns . W e a gr e e w i t h t he di s t r i c tc o ur tt hatt hi s a s s e r t i o n i s b e l i e d b y t he fac tt hathe had unt i lO c t obe r27, 200 8 t o f i l e a Bi v e nscla im re g a r d in gh is
m e di c alc ar e , l o ng af t e rhe f i l e d hi s c o m pl ai nti n t he i ns t anta c t i o n. 3 ) In ord er t o estab l i sh th a t p ri son off i ci a l s d en i ed h i m acce ss to th e cou rts Th om as m ustdem on str at e a c t uali nj ury, t hati s, t he pr i so nerm usts how t hat hi s l egalp osi t i on w as pr ej udi c ed o rt hathe w as pr eve nt ed f r om r ai si ng aN o. 08- 60951

3 m e r ito r io u s le g a l is s u e . S e eR ic h a r d s o n v . McD o n n e ll, 8 4 1 F

. 2 d12 0 , 12 2 ( 5 th C ir . 1 9 8 8 ); R u iz v. Un i t ed S t ate s , 1 6 0 F .3d 2 7 3 , 2 7 3 (5t h C ir. 1 9 9 8 ). F or exam pl e, T h om as fai l ed to dem on st rat e how t h e l ack of a si n gl e book he all ege d w as take n, a C ivi lT r i alM anual , prej udi c ed hi s pos i t i on w her e he had
access t o an el ect roni c l aw l ibrary. A l t h ou gh a cces s to th e el ect roni c l aw l ibrary
w as r es t r i c t ed, he di d notdem ons t r at e thath e w as unabl e t o c onductt he l egal
r e s e a r c h th r o u g h th is m e a n s . T h om as di d n otdem on st rat e how t h e m ere c on fisca t i on of t yp ew rit er
r ibbons deni ed hi m acc es s t o t he cour t s. H e f i l ed t he i nst ants ui ton Au gust16, 20 07 , m o r e t han a ye arb e f o r e the s t at ut e o f

l i m i t at i o ns w o ul d ha ver un o n a B i vens c la im re g a r d in gh is m e d ic a l ca r e . H e h a s v ig o r o u s lylitig a te dth is cla im
an d th ere i s no i n di cat i on he could not hav e l i t i gated h i s c l ai m regardi n g l ack of proper m edi calcare. 4 ) T h o ma s ’c l a i m th a th e wa s u n a b l e t o t i me l ya s s e r taF e d e r a lT o r tC l a i ms A c tc as e b ec ause hi s m at eri al s w er e c onf i sc at ed i s al som er i t l es s. Thom as has
n ever sough tt o asser ta F T C Acl ai m . Th ere w a s ce rta i n l y n o st atute of l i m i t at i o ns pr o bl e m , ho w e ve r , f o rhi m t o a s s e r ts uc h ac l ai m . W he n he f i l e d the p r e s e n tc a s e h e s t i l lh a dmo r e t h a n 3 mo n t h s t o f i l e h i s F T C Ac l a i m. 5) W e a l soagr ee w i t h t he di st r i c tc our tt hatt her e i s n o i n d i ca ti on t hat Th om as ’adm i ni st r at ive det ent i on f r om A u gu st6, 2006 t o Au gust28, 2006 den i ed h i m acces s t o t h e court s. F o rth e s e re a s o n s a n dt h e r e a s o n s a s s ig n e db yth e m a g is tr a te ju d g e inh is J u ly3 0 , 2 0 0 8 r e p o r t a n dr e c o m m e n d a tio n , t h e ju d g m e n t o f th e d is tr ic t c o u r t is af f i r m e d. AF F I RMED.