' ... ' 1 FilED19 .JUN'1711:46USDC·iJRP 

2 

3 

4 

5 TN Tf/f UWIT"f'[) STArfs DISTRICT COURT" 

6 FoR T-HE ms-retc-r ar· ()RfGo!V 

15 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 1 of 25
Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 2 of 25
1 ha:> bef A/ Jeck12e d Qy Couff 6;e Je;< 

: A Ve;rd;;u5 J.1f(J4YJ+, /41/;euf!. f3wrj~ 

4 0 £~6YJ J Ctts.e /l)o I 5 C (;o<; 7. See &J;~/f 

s ~.. ORJfQ_ GJ~bki'n5 (J>/C1/rrhff 

6 . A J ~q/;ods A 1 ~S q rt-fa 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 3 of 25
1 7.. LJA:/e /a Cl!S/;Js P/cr/JJ/;f-P 

2 h a.s f; /-e d flu m eeo u J -£,a 11 <k J £/J f V f;-f--,,,.Jr; vs__, 

:sha{'() -friVD/i)LJS !rtwsu/fs aq/»6{ s~;{ 

s Jy_fen da n fs_J Co~ {Jee /Jrm S -/oft !J W (j{;I'~ ~~-eS_, (!(}) Jflf(}4'N-e-/-- ff Ao Some D-f: 

:-+he . '3s,h11f~ ~ vittth'v_s A/f~q4f P~4-/fFS 9 /1h3a.J:u'fl h1-1foRJ tS O<lfjll-el //! -Jie 

10 -ftffcr0hed f:-rhbri-' ~t/. See Ui/6/J=fi:!/ 

ll \I 1Jec laflc["hl/ (yf sbt:/;//70)1 ~(fef 12 

Umcrhl/~ Cctse #o Ctli<;a g1a 13 me11(ch O</, d 0 /1./ e 

11 

14 J 

1s lf-115 &h1b;+4f1.j. o1lso Slows 1-J~ -fJP6?_, 

16 [QS-e-5 +/;d ~~~ cl-IJ'/JJJSSeJ 1a --f/Jf> U. S, 

17 Ors'-h/d- Cr)UR,f - Or?e.gvn_; -/f;crl- +ivs 

:: c!c1ss1fis6 Plc1111 hff cz-5 Q 3 s--d<1 ~ t:fr:,,J 

20 Qn d ~oJe~ P4111-hfF -:rs /ll&f e.//r1 ~l'e_ 21 ~k'.- °" fR~ fee iJ,1 V'ff<1. ~ Etth1hr~L/: 22 A, CAse Nb. s:o5-ciJ.,0Dq77-fflo I UiS; Oslf;1cf(uu.ef-o,e~/j 

23 (6" CTTS1Cfi/.>o ;): /3 -ci1-ooL/03 -.5.:C / (), S, O/SfatcfCout?T-uR~d 

24 C. Casdt/6 d. : I a -ci! - oo 1 Ji V -sr I tl 5. {}4~f Gd -ueem 

Page 4- of d ~ DtfJCn~nf J!n0 £fac4Rti!fa/J - WeV6J!e fJh;ntf-1' /:e tt6/vt1e 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 4 of 25
1 /I(/ CS) +faeee_ C<1Se5 L 4, 6, C, utJ page, (] 

2 

Lf\/e!2_e d 15m15~ed Pf!;ok! fo -!)is C'ctSe f'oe 

3 ' 

4 bei121 --fki'ilo/o Us <JY! J foJZ Fa:/ufe, fa 

s s-lfe q_ c/q1A . ;J1J 1S Fue-f)P-f 

: f Q<Pf (}Jb1/J-h-ff C'r?l?/Jo) Ace/tre., Cls 1t&sc ~~ uJa1Vff!._ In --f);;~ fctSt:__ ctS 

9 unde12_ at ll S, c·.J /q;5 GJ he_ 

10 )~ 

11 ( <?l:11rJfff) Is /1101 e /j; bJ'<- ~~ ez_ 

12 f ~_, v.l1i'V-ef2_ .. 13 

14 ~o E?lc11~hff Q/} /()/114-}e q+ ::-He /wo Qi VfJ!S (DKRt>c/;OIJ« L Jh>lfu/;vn 

::&--- RC l ) h~ s 4 f?Ro/ fie /1 f-i3 qf;;fl 

19 h1s-loR;:_ In +he s+afe ~ o/2ef/°// J/l . 

20 bu-M :S-11--l Cuue/ c1 n d 'fed e/2a(, Guel. 

21 <?lamHiP has -R!fd DoZt:f25 of' shorm 

:: (ftLVsu:+s a,jf11hs-f () Um-feouS 5/qcJe DJk~Js 

24 CoQ(2ec -f:0 ns s,'-/a+--r:__, faJ,,,;<(ps « 11 d 1b!l7q--/e~ el-r;-J,J 

Page 5 of ~ V- Jfif;>J~YJf ~G Oeckt>?f/;;)J - f?evo6£ Ph1)?/;f[ fee k/q/veR 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 5 of 25
1 o h d w~ I} O V<:-R {_ 3 )+); f2€R__, &-f -!-/; e 

: GJJq1rififfS -Jhqff\_ /awsu1-fs o,e acJ7v~ 

4 uJ·I<JJ'2._, drsm1sseJ on +he, G,{!,ouo J +hey 

5 !;t/_z,ze fQ, ii o/ouS q JJ j 612 Pc,1 /.ed fD 

: s-fdfe a, d:ol{\. 1ie12e_ r'.M7k1e (5J 

s -f-h12~ cczses )sm1>:;~j m ~ c:J£J4 l 

1: Cou12+ ( U, S. DP-h1cf Cxef-O,t1JVl1) Oilt/ 

11 (:J}-+/; f! (!SL c C( S-C' .s j/S /111sSed ! 11 s--4 le 

:: Couef- Cl)7J q// -f6/q2 (}J~iJ;{,pf (S 

:: 4 \\3 dz1 les lJ / l:s1vrl I 17 S~ fe 

t6 Covd C$.eQ_; S:h1brtls 'j qnd cc 

::-KQ950si£1J/~ l-J;(ftrl 1n feJRq0 

:: Cu\j12,} crs vv-el /.. 4 cc oRd;f:J 0JJ +he21 C-ou12+~ oR J12 uJq/1111J (fJ /cmr/;ff S 

22 -F-eeS ('() 1/6+ low bic UiEVD/!e cl. 

: fY1or<e de-h:L cf /ouvf +he /CJWSu1f 

Page la_ of J 0 7)-e-hndad J/r;j JYc4;;qfw -- tid1°/d Ph» Afr !f.e n&/tie~ 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 6 of 25
Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 7 of 25
1 [of] due+ q fl c/ ~ ~ oti/ (/] 41;7 /ff 

: rs /Jvf e/;31h)e., fDl2 ct_ F~ We11vef. 

4 !lccoe_dm~& J as ,s~-Je) -r/;Q (oveh 

: Or2_dzL vJat1J1n3 GJ4m hr& J;'es m(.Jo-1-

, now &, (f]ei/0)/e j Un ~12 a 6" (), S, C,f 

: 1115 (3) Jo; /1ruJ .. 

10 9 Q Pk/rv-Jirfs he ~1 ve~5 !)Ji1&-/--

:: be <Reu0Jled qs q /ro r?~11J/;pp hcts 

13 Yl u--f- q //tjed --+kJ he, IS 111 ClfJ 

:: l1YJm i'Nrcnf dangeQ, o-f Sei?NU5 frs:;c-z,l 

16 '.n u~ 0 {?/c;/17-l:ff ~ -He fl~l)ed. 1

' i~ housed 1n 4 T~c/ -- ~Diec-hue 

:: Cv:s-lsdy Ur)/+.. U11JI! ~ ~ u ~- c.J111sG)_, 

2

o---f-hz_ on~ excep-ft0 fL +o -f-Ae_ f<u/e, D/7 f;e_ 

21 UJ01.VffZS i5 wJriee (( -/-he lrzmcr-fe es·~!;JS)es 

:: Jn 7-k qno/;G /;0 1 

· v2 Wm'vfl2_ o,e /e~RR<rl 

24 --fhif 1be- /nmcr -k_, /s 1IJ 1'mm 1i;e11 Jq1Jel? 

Page ~ of J ~ Dtfe11Jd ~1 Oc£eet/tv!J - f?evoi{f/c,;114r ~e Mt/Ye£ 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 8 of 25
1 of Sft:1ou h S/C<?L111 LIR 11;;dY-4e 

2 utc-/;on ;?eeckJ ~ ~ 14/e-{ -/Rum 

: d«Y/fj-f:R. )~~gU, ';CJ/'/IS"'{j)o 7f/1S 1.:S ()of 

5 S: uch a CQSe. ?/!l-1JJ/;fP /!'! +/;1J lttJe 

6/5 Y<-ef/IJ (!}0»5 ckmcrg:w., 4:Jq10 --/-)e, 

7 <9 JcfJrlhfF /Jqs 11of c;//f?:S e J -/-)~ Ac 

: 15 I 'rJ C{ n!j J lrJfJ11/Je)1--f /a/J(fl<. of' 

:: SeR1ous P A3s-1<<1l 1h1t11 • 

:: I 0 ° ?/111J+F htt_s Q hs~!}Y 14 or ft !nj -Eaui1J/'fJ1+ Of! -fcrls~ 15 r1+0v'-*Jf\_ c/q;IYJS e :(ll Gh16/l Ifs.:_,; 

:: ms I rbe~Ylj<L Coujhenno!AW!lJ 4 ~B:e /tlq(_ 

:: +o~ ~<:_ s~~ of Ue:tr~ _, Derd/l};n+ 

20 af 0 usf ou l0al Olfl15!ofL u/J?o-k, f6 

J 

2

t-fiie ~261 d1()3 JUJ~ wtf/i -+he /)m((l:l/rv 

:: Co"n+\J, o~~/] Ctecu1+ Cove-/; siri:!J 

24 In he.e "-4-~cfutr. L ch R_0/70 !010 :_) O/J t.e1Ujf-401,;;.) 

Page 9 of _li Dden~t!I J(/;,G oedr12c.t/;6J7 - 'Peva!d Ph1n)~ ~e /l'~~f~ 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 9 of 25
Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 10 of 25
Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 11 of 25
1 r?l,nh-P-F o!/6812J /fJ /J;S (tJmf'/ct1~ 

:f\0£ af p/;ct')foti fol?_ :f~ WC11V'2~ -ftfcr--J--

4 he 1-5 /f't q!J~ 1mm1nel1-/: Jql1[ref2 of J'eR;oi!S 

:(?h;s1(tAL 1>11u~"l • !he ~v)e 1s m-tllchlof)Y 

, undx12 ~t Us.c. J 1115 C8J ct11J /yhlJ 

s r;<,~1f 1«~ M cm !flm4k ~ u};r; V'e/!. 

9 QR f-eQ_, de{;{Jf4l ~ f115 be <flfllv!/ed 

10 w he/8, ~ 112m.c ~ !J 11.s Atf/ d -fi/d2e, w _) 

:: oi<'. vnoe~sh, JlfS l1/ifi1fi --the f?vk qS 

13 -tlr~ rJk1n-h-r+ ~qs p1?1~>< le> --1-)d qcj:,YL 

:: beJ~ fr /-ed • !le1:0R~1J !J_) 1Jq1~ ;L o/qfc 

~ ~1s Ct1121s 6eit£ u/c?iV):!}fJ/ct11//;f{;) 

:: fu rY7 vs-}- ~uJ !JL ;A1u,/e J. 

:: I I. ;tr; & ); 6rl- ii ~ -IJ1s 

21 Coud w1/I ~ fuf!f};eK rflcoo+ wJ:J 

:;+-h~ coue-15 012ckt. u/c,1V;1J <P)Mlrf:J24 'P-ee--5 Y11JU6~ !f/oul b~ f?elltJ;/ecl" 

Page I a of J v Vfflljrrl J/nb D~c4rctl:oJ1 - h?u1u1d f/~;tlf'f- he n~1V~i? 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 12 of 25
1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

[xh1b1} # fo lS : 

J 

( ( 5--k f6 ~€-knci11-/s1 /f/uf;;11 

--fo rf?evo/!e {J/r,,;!7//fPS W&/Wk1 

of 1-e{!s. C-1tsfl/Jo~ CV/~(Jg/~ 

LJ f'f'4 h //A- (o,,r; lq 0 Rcu r-J Co uf2l--

'11 ! e d (f/c:1Rd o~ c;u;s- /:J S111~ f/551.:s-krd li-;lof21Je:J 6e)Jf/2q lS l;c; JJ!JO!l 

V/nc~ )) oRecr"n OoT. · 

14 fxkL+ tf (g u)(/s sv{t:dsCLJ ~/-won !J 

:: and o5 ~ f?eju/--f of &k61:J 116 ,yavsee 

:: 1~ t)(hi~i"+ #3 +he <Pk111HG J:'~ 

:: Wo:Wt~ W-e~€, Qet!od J /11 -d/22L (V 

21 (QS:\>S c f!S'2 !Uo. Ci/Jl/08?d J CqSf> //Jo, ctl!lfrf!I~ 22 A) 

23 on) G1~-z_, 111 o CV JI/ I & /) _) tl! I/ 1/J Jm4 J; //av 

24 Ctn·n~ C1Ra;J (u"e"Z SecExJ16J ff?. 

Page / 3 of _J__!/_ .De-h11Jrd J-/JJ& Orc4~1;b)1 - f?evo/i P/c?l?J/f[ fep %;;P~ , 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 13 of 25
1 iheee-£PQ_ --fJ;;.S Couef hC!J' {koo~ 2 

b~f>f2e 1~ -fhcrJ-- (jJ lctm );fF /Jct 5 her: n 

: fz)LJ}1d -fs b~ °'-' 11 3 s--41 ~5 };f<J qnf~ 

s and ha-S lk1d ~JS -P-e e_ WC71 v-e17s 

6 

o:{fvoN~J bef~e Ill sh* Luve-f 7 

s ~ &h1 b,+ 11 3 _) ~ t;r:A;J):-t II l/ . 

1: rhe 1tbvll(, /1:SfeJ and 4-ffac)ed 

11 

he~{?_+-o txh:b"i+ fl 3 rJnJ &J1~/f !ff 12 __) -· ---

13 q/50 (?IZ<SVe --f);e_ UJit;/l );ff j4.5 --/~ee (3) 

:: <?£/oR_ sfp_J'/(o )~ +Je J, S, oJ,,s-IK1c,& 

16 Cow2_J o J1 cJ 4CC0/(_/15 ~ _) +k Cou12fs 

::aiecktZ uJc11V;!JJ 6°/r:11/;/,ffl fees mus+ 

19 novJ he, {-]etJr)/eJ. ~ 8 {J. s. c.1' /115 (SJ~ 20 

21 ' a '" t n f x !11 ·lo /f If 7 • If +knyy 

22 

J:ef(~r11y H );1 dm&Yl o~~on 3-f.-,fe BAQ Jf 133 rtfit.4 

23 s-+ot.ed ; YL h I~ d ec~ lei~ ft fio11 ,J t n + Ae IYJa I h-e U/2 ) 

24 (Gt~ f\lt:, 15CV /0 fl J +hcrf h~ ( Jfndmrm J J 1d a__ 

Page J 4 of lJ__ :Dec~rcq/:ua of De#n~f) j;j;" - fieYoJd Ph;J;jPf' P:,e hfct1lf'Y( 

v 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 14 of 25
1 C or~ f.R eli '€n s 1'vt SE'<412'ch u f, Yh<- . Ok>tjo 11 

2 ~ vd 1 c i a L 'lY--(?fWti"f>~ n+· J:rfO e 1r/Ja.i7 on fi/efi.1Jc ;~ J! 

3 (oJI'f) wh:ch CfeV-e4/«d_9~ of/t~P,f 4 031 3-0/JJ )::<-+k Vex-aio1J~ J.1/;J<rd- ~h vifP s h45 }:, le . 0 g Sef1€4 fe, A ct 11/,,,,,.15 15 q m sf 

6 A PGJ k'O'l'1~1d1+e.~ d '8 a s E'fJ4:4J { d .rf,n do11 Is> -de 

7 

O::S/f\) Srcaed ,n [~/;;~/Jd-7, s,!/vws 

: -:P/cliiif;« vJ[J)dkf ~ +; JeJ o/je- /qw; u1+ /~ 

10 

--Jk i.J. S, O;.:S7.t21d (Oe.e_f- m ft}ea-,/. Cou,e..,L 

11 tn uJh1cJ h~ S, Wr;od12ofre) SUf j S ;;cl!J (&~J 

12 d"<fq()clrifs, ):/1 -Me fl-f/c-zcJ,j EA')//;///1 

ll 1 I 1 /<?i . } C 0 . • J 

13 ttrtt:>RfJ~ J/1fJdr!ia11 J Con:r;J</».51 ot1 <Pc1 ~ 3 ,SfG/ib-1 

14 ~, --t-hct+-- h'Wilj of (?Im 1J f ff !Al ou d:z o TFs r:e15'-e s 

15 [ (11ok.e. --tfian 3 J We12e d1s/-JJ!sseJ becquSe 

16 -Hie Sha fl\, )<4 i<Jsti,fs vJe.ee. -fi<lllo /ouS 1

M j 

:: oe_ -fcvA~d -fb s/dk A c la1ff,. fll seve~L 

19 c crS!(S ~ / q ;17 J,tt 14ou J mff0 _, e lN n S u-ed p.rr/rir 

20 vJ h" br J a W vv~J:."' i mm u 1112, • -rJ, /5 txkb;;*J 

21 -f uefi·K12_ s Uf~h --fhd --f'h~ f?/q;,;-/-:/FF ; s q \\3 

:: :s,--k, t/e:, f ,--J;:3qi?f-'1 C?n d. IS JJ{}j e /3,b)"' ~ f)a;~ 

24 °'" -fa '6u -91:.Q, vJ a 1 l/e R. i°h +/; )j Cf/ JJl?M f C c{'S;e. .. 

Page JS of J!L _Deknript ffn& Oc/;!ai/;o11 - Mio/d PkJ'//f-(' kp ;'J41tlf( 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 15 of 25
Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 16 of 25
1 --1); ((f'4 h rJC{in of ~#n~ !lf ;f;-6 . 

2 

13.. £n &),/kt11

3 S dick) 

: '' rf/o-!1~n fa Dt:k12e P/cr1~Af! 6 (! \/u-616 i/f(:rqyJI I/ 

: /n fn~1btf ii~ o!J (/J:JM S crf?d d 

9 +he Courcf w/// ~ P-easf fk Pk;/;tp 

10 had +he-ee (3) rPt?1ok! rAsf'S /;S-/Jl/SStJJ 11 .; ' 

12 c6 --re,·volou:s and oi] -/;,;'/e) -/6 s4h 

13 a, C /01°rtl &~e- he_ ( f ~r,rifFJ /;YeJ---M1~ 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 17 of 25
: ~zce1~-e OR_ J/e.:ep 0 fi.ee ~e, vi)q,i~~ 

3 

1 n -+hi~, cc:i 5-e.,. l!c-co12d/)zJ b; No~ by_ J 

4 La W 1 +k C ou12 fl o.eJe12 lllla1 t111y f /<?1'7//ffs 

s f-I<.e5 Jn (rr5-e il/o J:/~~cll-·Od-39D--S8_/ 

6 -+his GtS-e mud J1/6W h-e_ rflet1°ff6d 011) 

: Sef2l/1CQ., Vf 6n de-#J1J(rf/-/- J!"!J f?etl&J/ej cmj 

9 -f1ii2._ O:C')~ q_jtlJrJ6f J~Y/~11-f ~ <t)S!l11sJed., 

10 I lf-_,. fie P'71!?-A~ hcr5 q 41llee11 11 (/ -

12 of ha v11?j f!/u/;~1!5 f;,e f;e v/a.1~ /efl1~) 

:: and ~ pcr+fe1<_11 ~,(>_ hq J111Jg Oa zens q nJ 

1s aJoZfYJ5 o-F (fJ/}J o/J Cc:tSPS c/ ;/J11s:B-) q3· 

16 -fe1Vo/ou5. and .f:-e f;//11JJ0 Jo 0~/e, q c ;;;m_ 

17 J ) ' 4F 9 0 

18 1"'AJ &h1/J1+ ({ j ., 1/ . , / 

19 ORdnz Ony1cr <P!cpdrPJ 

20 fl1oftJf/ fo,e ~rlt'f,Q 61? 

21 ,Oe-kJ212cr L of Fees onj 

22 C6Sfs Fo12 ~/;Jmls. J) 

23 ) 

24 --r n #;;s -exh; br~f --!-he [Ui/i(r (A//I /See.., 

Page 18 of d ~ -l&fndn-J ~6 Oc~12cr/io1 - ~fo!lf P4Jll/irree M1l'fR 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 18 of 25
1 hct Jrfi!J f-€ e 1.Nc?1 //'fl!:> dfwed 012 <fle1r>;Jj 

: IS fl ofhlrJj !J e VJ -fo (? /tm h ff. :Ir; 

4 Sh1bJ 4f 3 p/cr;11 /,ffi -fl.ere ulct1WK-5 

: W.f.K~ HetJoJeJ 1n -!lee<:- ( 3) SEp7Rqfe . 

1 Cc?'.)-e-5 cd-1 -/ie, Sctme, f mf0. '1'17 &16fi/:9 

: o1<11i1fift hC(J his /tJo!:m £~ f.ee 

10 Wa11JeL <:J!l J~,e£<tl o-f' f'e-e.s rlen1e) q/Jj 

:: in &h1b1+ # ~ J &h~rf 1f 7 and 

13 \~ 

14 5L btf 1f Z , -th<?_ Couef /o cvmf1rh q /I '.c, 

:: (f;)~f -f 6 0t Cas-e JYJ -!-/vs Jv led ~fu 

:: Drsh1cf Col/Rf C11s-e ;1/6 3: ( 3 -nl- ~(J3~s:t 

19 in wl)icfL U. s. Dr:>hwt eo(/et sul~J rhe.. 

20 J-/v!Juf?F:rh)Q ~J~j f!Jicha e L }-/, SI l'rJO/l o 11 

21 () - ' ) 

22 <Jc-fo~f. J 5.J d 0!3 /SD ved an D-€ <IPR:. o-/' 

23~k_, L)1 S. Dd12jif Lo(1,e. f~ f;,12 CJRef!°/?_J 

24 +ha+ vJa:::, +,/Jed as Fo l/01-tJs; 

Page / 9 of li_ 7Je£nJ11i ~6- Dtc~~'l/Jon - 0J1o/d /)};/;)~( /fe W11fli%} 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 19 of 25
1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

lfte Courd-1s-hrkd1n -fhD Cc1Se : . 

: Ctr'i,S(_ N6 3: I 3 -ciJ- </ o 3 -sr 

9 CfrsR_ /IJb J: 13 --c J - oo <103 - s:r· 

10 l~~dtloffu V Jr/lc.h~bf?R ef a /v, _) 

11 _('q/)URf:. -fo S~ fe, ff C/q)frl 

12 

(12 J J 6 ( o U5 

:: i:N ''40/!Ma., f;6vr:fR-1s ~-fvs Mv6dJ 

15 (/.-ppeaL J,€dtrl~ -:/'RtYo)ou.5 

:: (1/pfe<tG. in BnJ ':f1J1fA 

18 '1ee //1l11NJ:! £kn1~J 19 

20 {~ +); 15 CCtSe__ Cd: 13 - c J~ CJ di 310 -·SS J 

21+he- -:Plcvnt+-r h<fl5 no+ q ))eged _j,);c:t:-l' /;e_ J 

:: tS 1 tJ a 1?_Y 1 mrfi 1 rrend Ja n~r< o .P Sf'i1J o uS P/fys/C.,-, L 

24 in~fuP-y, Ph1ahft anJ &-fo/J~o-J Jf/(J Q~'(_ 

, Page ~O of JY, !Jffer;J11f ~6 Otc412qh71 - £y6fe pj?)//;J-r:p f:e ~//Jr~ 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 20 of 25
Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 21 of 25
Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 22 of 25
Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 23 of 25
: f);vd IS _$ vbf"'cf, fo (f fJct lj foR {(f'o//· 

3 -:Di~ f)/5 I lo J>J oF C1Uo'0 :J ,;;017. 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 /// 

19 /// 

20 ;)/ 

21 II I 

22 J// 

23 1/I 

24 /)/ 

Pageqj_of a 0 Dr{'Jljll;idG Dfc4Rq-i/J - /JJ0Jd p);)?l!f r;e ~ivfR 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 24 of 25
[ rL1ccd Lhc: db\Jl.C lll ~l :)c1:Ut«:l;, ·Cll·j·.l)c',_L r·1,1:)i_LI~' p.:f>_t[,_l Cl\."'['['1 .?. 1_ 1 1 

named at the r1lacc:0 addrc3scd bclm1,: 

clcek Ts,· 1-f,cl-- 1 /--· 

Case 2:15-cv-02390-SB Document 58 Filed 06/19/17 Page 25 of 25