# Patent

## Title
Protection circuit for electronic system

## Abstract

Damages to the rectifying MOSFET in the secondary side of voltage converters are reduced or eliminated by inserting intermediary steps between detecting a dropping in the converter output voltage VCC and activating the under voltage lock out (UVLO) circuitry. During the intermediary steps, the timing for switching off the MOSFET is advanced to prevent the current flow in the MOSFET from reversing its direction.

## Background
This application is a continuation of application Ser. No. 14/585,266, filed on Dec. 30, 2014, now U.S. Pat. No. 9,450,398.


BACKGROUND
A galvanically isolated voltage converter is an electronic system that has a primary side and a secondary side coupled electrically by a transformer. The primary side of converters comprises a controller circuit and a switching power transistor and the output terminal of the power transistor is coupled to the primary winding of the transformer. The secondary side comprises a rectifying device coupled to an output capacitor and to the secondary winding of the transformer. During normal operation the capacitor maintains an output voltage near a specified value.
The rectifying device may be a p-n junction diode or a Schottky diode, which is an uni-directional device configured to conduct current during the periods when the switching transistor in the primary side is switched off and blocks current flow during the periods when the, switching transistor in turned on. This type of rectification, is referred to as non-synchronous rectification.
An alternative to a diode for rectification is a power MOSFET, which is a bi-directional device and is configured to turn on to conduct current and to turn off to block current flow following a command signal from a controller circuit. The controller on the secondary side of the converter may be a single integrated circuit chip, which may or may not encompass the MOSFET. A well-arranged combination of a secondary side controller and a MOSFET dissipates less power than the rectifying diode it replaces. This type of rectification is referred to as synchronous rectification. At the occurrence of abnormal output voltage drop, the converter shuts down to protect the system from damage by activating under voltage lock out (UVLO) circuitry on both sides of the converter. That is, the primary side stops pumping energy into the secondary side and the secondary side stops charging the output capacitor.
SUMMARY
The Inventors observed that even with UVLO protection, many converters suffer from overheating at the occurrence of this abnormality.
The Inventors recognized that the principal reason for the overheating is that the two sides of the converter do not react to the occurrence of the abnormality in correct sequence. In most voltage converters, the secondary side is connected to the output terminal and receives the output voltage drop directly but the primary side has to detect such event by way of the transformer and this information may reach the primary side with a slight time delay. If the lock-out action in primary side is completed before the secondary side, power ceases to be pumped into the secondary side even while the MOSFET in the secondary side is still switching and the converter will survive the voltage drop and can resume its normal operation after the cause of the unexpected output voltage drop is removed.
However, if the UVLO circuit on the secondary side is triggered and shuts off the MOSFET before the primary side ceases pumping energy onto the secondary, the energy delivered from the primary side in term of electrical current can no longer flow in the low resistive channel of the MOSFET and must flow through its body diode. Since the ohmic loss is higher when current flows through the body diode than when the same current flows through the MOSFET channel, extra heat is generated in the MOSFET.
In voltage converters that embody the invention, this problem is eliminated or greatly reduced by having a buffer period inserted into the secondary side lock out sequence so that the converter shuts down more orderly when experiencing an output voltage drop unexpectedly. During this period, the MOSFET continues switching but with a modified timing.
In one implementation, the secondary side controller is configured to turn on the MOSFET when its drain voltage VD reaches a preset threshold VTHON with respect to its source voltage VS. In one example. VTHON is set at −150 mV. During the turned on period, electrical current flows through the channel to charge the output capacitor to maintain it at 5 V with respect to VS. When the current in the MOSFET drops from the peak value IPEAK towards zero the drain voltage VD also drops with respect to VS. When VD drops to a second preset threshold VTHOFF of about −5 mV the controller turns the MOSFET off.
When output voltage unexpectedly drops from 5 V to below a preset voltage such as the preset UVLO threshold in the primary side of the controller, the secondary controller activates the first step of MOSFET shutting down sequence. In this example, the preset voltage is 4.2 V, which is about 16% below the specified VOUT of 5 V. At this stage, the MOSFET continues to switch on at VTHON. The switching-off threshold of the MOSFET VTHOFF, however, is advanced in order to turn off the MOSFET earlier to prevent the current in the MOSFET from reversing its direction as the VDS changes polarities. In this example, the advanced VTHOFF is set at −20 mV.
If the output voltage recovers during this stage and rises above 4.2 V for this example, the VTHOFF reverts back to −5 mV and the system reverts back to normal operation. If the output voltage drop persists to a second threshold value, in this example, 3 V, under-voltage-lock-out procedure is activated and the secondary side controller and the MOSFET are shut down.
The values mentioned in this example are for reference only. Depending on different designed output voltages, these values will change accordingly. Even in 5 V designs, other values may be substituted when appropriate.



BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING FIGURES
FIG. 1 depicts a block diagram of a partial circuit of a voltage converter according to the invention.
FIG. 2 depicts a block diagram of another partial circuit of voltage converter according to the invention.



DETAILED DESCRIPTION
FIG. 1 depicts a portion of a voltage converter, specifically a sub-circuit 100 in the secondary side of a voltage converter. The function of the sub-circuit 100 is to interrogate the VCC voltage and to determine its relative value with respect to it to a reference voltage that is set at preset amount below the expected normal VCC. When VCC drops from its expected normal value by a preset amount, the sub-circuit triggers to change the turn-off voltage threshold of the MOSFET.
The sub-circuit 100 comprises a comparator 3 with two input terminals 1, and 2, Terminal 1 is configured to receive VCC and terminal 2 is configured to receive a reference voltage. In this example, the reference voltage is set at 4.2 V, which is about 16% lower than the normal VCC of 5V. Other value for the reference voltage may be appropriate and may be used. When VCC is above 4.2 V, the system is deemed to be operating normally and the comparator outputs a 1 at its output terminal. When VCC drops below 4.2 V, the output of the comparator switches from a 1 to a 0.
The output of the comparator is coupled to a multiplexor 4, Two input terminals 5 and 6 of the multiplexor 4 are configured to receive two turn-off threshold voltages VTHOFF1 and VTHOFF2. In this example, VTHOFF1 is set at −5 mV and VTHOFF2 is set at −20 mV. Other values for the turn-off threshold may be appropriate and may be used When the terminal 7 of the multiplexor 4 receives a 1 signal, indicating a normal functioning condition, it selects VTHOFF1 (−5 mV) at terminal 6 and passes it to the output terminal 8. When the multiplexor 4 receives a 0 signal from the comparator 3, indicating VCC as below the threshold of 4.2 V, the multiplexor 4 selects VTHOFF2 (−20 mV) at terminal 5 and passes it to the output terminal 8.
The output of the multiplexor 4 is added as a bias voltage to a second comparator 9. The comparator 9 compares the voltage VS at one terminal 10 to VD in conjunction with the bias voltage VTHOFF1 or VTHOFF2 at the other input terminal 8. When the biased VD is less than VS, the comparator 9 switches and sends a signal to turn off the MOSFET.
With this sub-circuit as an example, the two turn-off threshold voltages can be successfully incorporated in the converter so the MOSFET can be switched off under different timing schemes depending on whether the converter VCC is above or below the preset threshold.
FIG. 2 depicts the schematic diagram of a circuit 200, which is a portion of a voltage converter, and a MOSFET 300 that is driven by the circuit 200 The circuit 208 comprises a sub-circuit 400, which is similar to the sub-circuit 100 in drawing figure
The MOSFET 300 in this example is external to the circuit 200, which is built in one integrated circuit chip. In other examples, the MOSFET may be a portion of the same integrated circuit chip.
The MOSFET is driven by a driver element 13, which in turn is driven by a AND gate 14. When the output of the AND gate 14 is in a high state, the driver element 13 applies a voltage near VCC on the gate terminal of the MOSFET and turn it on When the output of the AND gate 14 is in a low state, the driver element 13 applies a voltage near GND on the gate terminal of the MOSFET and turns it off.
The sub-circuit 400 is coupled to a SR flip-flop 15 at its RESET terminal. The output Q of the flip-flop 15 is coupled to the AND gate 14. As illustrated in FIG. 1, when VCC drops below a threshold voltage, the sub-circuit 400 switches from a first threshold voltage VTHOFF1 to a second threshold voltage VTHOFF2. This changes the timing of switching-off of the MOSFET so it goes of when VD is further away from the VS. In this example, the RESET of the RS flip-flop 15 is triggered when VD is within −20 mV of VS. At this point, the MOSFET will have about 100 nano-seconds to complete turning off before VD becomes positive, which is to be avoid.
The circuit 200 also comprises a comparator 16 to interrogate the VD in order to determine the timing of turning on the MOSFET. The comparator 16 is biased by VTHON, which in this example is set at −150 mV. Comparator 16 compared to VD to VS and when VD is within VTHON with respect to VS, the comparator 16 switches and triggers the SR flip-flop 15 and, through the AND gate 14 and the driver element 13, applies a voltage near VCC to the gate terminal of the MOSFET 300 to turn it on.
The circuit 400 also comprises a UVLO circuit 17 coupled to VCC. When VCC drops below a second threshold, which in this example, is set at 3 V—about 40% from the normal 5 V, the UVLO circuit 17 shuts down the controller circuit 200.

## Claims

1. A voltage converter, comprising:
a power MOSFET coupled to a secondary-side controller;
the secondary-side controller, operable to sustain a VCC voltage at a VCC terminal;
the secondary-side controller configured to trigger a first bias voltage when the VCC voltage is above a first preset value and to trigger a second bias voltage different from the first bias voltage when the VCC voltage is below the first preset voltage; and
an under-voltage-lock-out (UVLO) circuitry, which is triggered when the VCC voltage is below a second preset voltage, which is below the first preset voltage.

2. The voltage converter of claim 1, in which the first bias voltage corresponds to a first switching-off threshold voltage of the power MOSFET.

3. The voltage converter of claim 2, in which the second bias voltage corresponds to a second switching-off threshold voltage of the power MOSFET, different from the first switching-off threshold voltage.

4. The voltage converter of claim 1, in which the secondary controller and the power MOSFET are integrated in one chip.

5. A voltage converter having a primary side controller and a secondary-side controller, comprising;
a primary-side UVLO circuitry and a secondary-side UVLO circuitry; and
a primary-side UVLO triggering voltage and a secondary-side UVLO triggering voltage lower than the primary-side UVLO triggering voltage;
the secondary-slide controller is operable to sustain a VCC voltage at a VCC terminal;
the primary-side UVLO triggering voltage and the secondary-side UVLO triggering voltage being related to VCC, and
the secondary-side controller is coupled to a power MOSFET, which is configured to turn off at a second turn-off voltage different from a first turn-off voltage.

6. The voltage converter of claim 5, in which the secondary controller and the power MOSFET are integrated in one chip.