U.S. flagAn official website of the United States government
                    Here's how you know **Official websites use .gov**
                            
                            A **.gov** website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
 **Secure .gov websites use HTTPS**
                            
                            A **lock** (                            
                              A locked padlock                                                      
                            
                            ) or **https://** means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Menu Agricultural Research Service
						
                    U.S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
 close



Research
                Research Home
                            National Programs
                            Research Projects
                            Scientific Manuscripts
                            International Engagement
                            Scientific Software/Models
                            Databases and Datasets
                            Office of Scientific Quality Review
            Media
                News & Features
                            Multimedia
                            Briefing Room
                            Down on the Farm
                            Press Room
                            Science in Your Shopping Cart
                            Scientific Discoveries
                            Tellus
                            Under the Microscope
            About ARS
                About ARS Home
                            Staff Directory
                            Labs and Research Centers (Map)
                            Headquarter Offices
                            Organizational Chart
                            Employee Services (REE Employees Only)
                            Office of Outreach, Diversity, and Equal Opportunity
            Work With Us
                Work With Us Home
                            ARS Vacancies at USAJOBS
                            Careers at ARS Information
                            Scientific Collaborations
                            Extramural Agreements
                            1890 Faculty Research Sabbatical ProgramSearch small
                    Search
            
            ARS Home
                                About ARS
                                Contact Us




ARS Home Office of Scientific Quality Review





- About RPES
- RPES Axon Page
- PPPR Project Plan Template
- PPPR Handbook
- About PPPR
- Panel Outcome Reports
- Reviewer Information
- Be A Peer Reviewer
- PPPR Orientations
- PPPR Axon Page
- About NPRA
- Home

Reviewer Informationheadline bar **yellow star oyster mushroom**  **Reviewer Information**  **Peer Review -**The critical evaluation of ARS research project plans for scientific merit and technical quality.  Written recommendations, emphasizing on the quality and credibility of expert peer reviewer’s insights and suggestions, which are fully considered to strengthen the Agency's overall scientific programming. This includes differentiation of this ARS review from competitive reviews, its similarity to manuscript review, the nature and origin of plan objectives, and the role of stakeholders, Congress, and others in setting research directions. **Peer Reviewers -**Researchers or technical experts, deemed by ARS as possessing relevant knowledge and experience in a particular discipline. Peer reviewers are free from conflicts of interest as related to the lead SY researcher and their research team And also agree by virtue of a Confidentiality Agreement to not copy, quote, discuss, or otherwise use material from the proposal outside the peer panel review process. Peer reviewers are academicians, customers or stakeholders of USDA science or selected USDA researchers. **Peer Panel Review -**The peer reviewer deliberation that assesses the scientific and technical quality of individual research project plans, its approaches, methods, and procedures. Peer reviewers provide their expertise and experience to ARS by participating in a credible, objective and thorough reviews of ARS research project plans.. **Panel Chairs -**Selected chairs can be recommended by National Program Leaders (NPLs) and/or previous OSQR service or sought based on their nationally recognized expertise by the OSQR Director. Selected individuals are examined for suitability to lead a panel review, screened for conflicts of interest (COI) and finally concurred upon by the current Scientific Quality Review Officer (SQRO). **Scientific Quality Review Officer (SQRO) -**A senior USDA-ARS research scientist selected for a two year appointment to serve as part of the Office of Scientific Quality Review and provide additional scientific expertise in the peer review process, including approving panel chairs and other members, ensuring reviewers comments are adequately addressed in project plan revisions, and certifying post plans. **Project Plan -**USDA-ARS sponsored research concept, considered both proprietary and/or confidential **Honorarium -**Modest fee offered to Peer Reviewers for time spent reviewing assigned project plans **Orientation -**Training preparation of Peer Reviewers (Panel and Chair) via written and web-based modules. **Information Forms -**Submissions from Peer reviewers, which serve as supplemental information to account for the identity of each external reviewer assigned to review a plan. **Ad Hoc Review -** A Peer Review without a virtual panel review. All correspondence is sent electronically. **Action Class Rating -**Available scoring selections which a Peer reviewer may assign to a project plan. i.e., No revision; Minor revision; Moderate revision, Major revision, and Not Feasible **General Information** All reviewers must complete a Confidentiality Agreement, an Information Form, and provide a current curriculum vitae (CV) very early in the panel review process. About four-six weeks prior to your panel meeting, you'll receive an email containing: Project plans - It is expected that you will read all plans unless you have a conflict of interest.
Panel review forms
Panel agenda with a list of all of the projects your panel has been assigned to review and your individual assignments as primary and secondary reviewer.
Guidelines for peer reviewers.
Supplemental information specific to your panel.
National Program Action Plan ***Ad Hoc* Reviewers:** At least four weeks are allowed to review a project plan and return reviews electronically. **Other Useful Information:** Sample Peer Review Form (This form contains the peer review criteria and action classes.)  USDA-ARS Research Page Find a USDA-ARS Research Location


Return to top


Research
                            Media
                            About ARS
                            Work With Us


Connect with ARS Sign up


ARS Home
                            USDA.gov
                            Plain Writing
                            Policies & Links
                            Civil Rights Statements
                            FOIA
                            Accessibility Statement
                            Privacy Policy
                            Non-Discrimination Statement
                            Quality of Information
                            USA.gov
                            WhiteHouse.gov