UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF INDIANA

SOUTH BEND DIVISION

RONALD THRASH, )

)

Petitioner, )

) 

v. ) No. 3:13 CV 775

)

SUPERINTENDENT, )

)

Respondent. )

OPINION and ORDER

Ronald Thrash, a pro se prisoner, filed a habeas corpus petition challenging two

prison disciplinary charges that were heard at the Indiana State Prison on May 3, 2013.

Under case number ISP 13-04-332, the Disciplinary Hearing Body (DHB) found him

guilty of Sexual Conduct in violation of B-216 and sanctioned him with the loss of 60

days earned credit time and demoted him from Credit Class 1 to Credit Class 2. Under

case number ISP 13-04-333 the DHB found him guilty of Trafficking in violation of

A-113, sanctioned him the loss of 120 days earned credit time, and demoted him from

Credit Class 2 to Credit Class 3. Thrash raises three grounds, one which challenges the

Sexual Conduct charge, the other two challenging the Trafficking charge.

As to the Sexual Conduct charge, Thrash argues that a female officer violated

policy by entering his cell alone for the purpose of having sex with him. However, the

violation of a prison policy is irrelevant because “[i]n conducting habeas review, a

federal court is limited to deciding whether a conviction violated the Constitution, laws,

or treaties of the United States.” Estelle v. McGuire, 502 U.S. 62, 67-68 (1991). He also

case 3:13-cv-00775-JTM document 5 filed 09/16/13 page 1 of 3
argues that there was no evidence that he engaged in sexual conduct. However, there

was. The female guard stated that when she entered the cell, Thrash was exposed for

the purpose of having sex with her. Finally, he argues that there was no corroborating

evidence to support the female guard’s statement. However, corroborating evidence is

unnecessary because “the relevant question is whether there is any evidence in the

record that could support the conclusion reached by the disciplinary board.”

Superintendent v. Hill, 472 U.S. 445, 455-56 (1985). See also McPherson v. McBride, 188 F.3d

784, 786 (7th Cir. 1999) (Even a conduct report alone can provide evidence sufficient to

support the finding of guilt.)

As to the Trafficking charge, Thrash argues that it was a violation of due process

that he was found guilty of Trafficking even though no marijuana or tobacco was

presented at his hearing after he had requested it on the screening report. However, no

marijuana or tobacco was confiscated and so none existed to present at his hearing.

Thrash knows this. He also knows that he was found guilty based on the statement of a

staff member who confessed to trafficking with him. Moreover, if there had been

marijuana or tobacco to present at the hearing, it would not have been exculpatory

evidence. See Wolff v. McDonnell, 418 U.S. 539, 566 (1974) (accused inmates have the

right to present relevant, exculpatory evidence). Thus, it was not a due process error to

have denied Thrash non-existent, inculpatory evidence.

Thrash also argues that it was a violation of due process for the hearing officer to

have found him guilty of Trafficking in food stuffs. The Disciplinary Hearing Report

2

case 3:13-cv-00775-JTM document 5 filed 09/16/13 page 2 of 3
(DE # 2-1 at 3) makes no mention of food stuffs. The Conduct Report (DE # 2-1 at 2)

makes no mention of food stuffs. Both mention tobacco and marijuana. Thrash was

found guilty of Trafficking in tobacco and marijuana. The Incident Report (DE # 2-1 at

1) does mention food stuffs, but that is irrelevant. It also mentions tobacco and

marijuana. The mere mention of food stuffs in the Incident Report is not a basis for

habeas corpus relief overturning the finding that Thrash trafficked in tobacco and

marijuana. 

For the foregoing reasons, the court DENIES the habeas corpus petition

pursuant to 2254 Habeas Corpus Rule 4, and dismisses this action. Clerk to enter final

judgment. 

SO ORDERED.

Date: September 16, 2013

s/James T. Moody 

JUDGE JAMES T. MOODY

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

case 3:13-cv-00775-JTM document 5 filed 09/16/13 page 3 of 3