Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

Jesse Newmark (SBN 247488) 

Aidin Castillo (SBN 280262) 

CENTRO LEGAL DE LA RAZA 

3022 International Blvd., Suite 410 

Oakland, California 94601 

Telephone: (510) 437-1863 

jnewmark@centrolegal.org 

acastillo@centrolegal.org 

Attorneys for Plaintiffs and the Class 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

JUAN QUINTANILLA VASQUEZ, 

GABRIELA PERDOMO ORTIZ, VICTOR 

HUGO CATALAN MOLINA, and KEVIN 

CALDERON, individually and on behalf of 

all others similarly situated, 

 Plaintiffs, 

 v. 

LIBRE BY NEXUS, INC. and JOHN DOES 

1-50, 

 Defendants. 

Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

DECLARATION OF JESSE NEWMARK 

IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ 

MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND 

SERVICE AWARDS 

Judge: Hon. Claudia Wilken 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 1 of 29
Page 1 of 9

Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

I, Jesse Newmark, declare: 

1. I am an attorney admitted to practice before all Courts of the State of California, 

and counsel of record for Plaintiffs and the Class in this case. I have personal knowledge of all 

of the facts set forth in this Declaration unless otherwise stated, and I am competent to testify to 

these facts if called on to do so. 

ORGANIZATION 

2. Founded in 1969, Centro Legal de la Raza (Centro Legal) is an Oakland-based 

nonprofit organization that has provided legal services to low-income and immigrant clients 

throughout Central and Northern California for more than fifty years. Our work includes direct 

legal services, impact litigation, policy advocacy, and community outreach and education, for the 

rights of immigrants, workers, tenants, and consumers. We have more than forty attorneys and 

advocates who represent thousands of low-income and immigrant clients each year. 

EXPERIENCE 

3. I have practiced law in California for about fifteen years, since graduating from 

Harvard Law School in 2006. I have completed two federal clerkships, for Judge Richard A. 

Paez on the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, and Judge Dean D. Pregerson for the Central 

District of California. I have been the litigation director at Centro Legal since 2013, where I 

manage Centro Legal’s affirmative and impact litigation docket across our program areas. 

4. I have been certified as class counsel in state and federal court, in class actions 

for low-income and immigrant class members like those here. See Gonzalez v. Sessions, 325 

F.R.D. 616, 625 (N.D. Cal. 2018), aff’d, Aleman Gonzalez v. Barr, 955 F.3d 762, No. 18-16465, 

2020 WL 1684034 (9th Cir. 2018) (“The four attorneys at Centro Legal . . . have experience 

litigating complex immigration cases.”); United States ex rel. Terry v. Wasatch, 327 F.R.D. 395, 

(E.D. Cal. 2018), petition to appeal denied, No. 18-80091, 2018 WL 6118456 (9th Cir. 2018) 

(“Counsel’s credentials reflect long-standing advocacy for low-income tenants and sufficient 

familiarity with class action litigation.”); Navarrete v. Burma Superstar Oakland, Inc., No. 

RG16830336 (Alameda County Super. Ct. 2016) (certifying class counsel and granting final 

approval of $1.3 million settlement for low-wage and immigrant restaurant workers). 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 2 of 29
Page 2 of 9

Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

5. I am lead counsel for Centro Legal in several other ongoing class actions for lowincome and immigrant clients. See Brown v. Upside Gading, LP, No. RG18928503 (Alameda 

County Super. Ct. 2018), 42 Cal.App.5th 140 (2019); Cruz v. Las Montañas, No. MSC17-00330 

(Contra Costa County Super. Ct. 2017); Portillo-Cardoza v. Fox, No. RG16843364 (Alameda 

County Super. Ct. 2016). 

6. I have also successfully represented and continue to represent low-income and 

immigrant clients in complex and multi-plaintiff actions in state and federal court. See, e.g., 

Lopez v. Jaber, No. RG15772595 (Alameda County Super. Ct. 2015) ($2 million settlement in a 

complex habitability action); Mancilla v. Abundis, No. RG19030501 (Alameda County Super. 

Ct. 2019); Campana v. Hileman, No. RG19024346 (Alameda County Super. Ct. 2019); Gonzalez 

v. Cam Huong, Inc., No. RG18892554 (Alameda County Super. Ct. 2018); Araiza v. Rockwell 

Drywall, Inc., Nos. 18CV323572, 18CV323583 (Santa Clara County Super. Ct. 2018); City of 

Oakland v. Lee, No. RG1889710 (Alameda County Super. Ct. 2018); Sanchez v. Leong, No. 

RG18916383 (Alameda County Super. Ct. 2018); Cortez v. Choice Hotels Int’l, Inc., No. 

RG17847671 (Alameda County Super. Ct. 2017); Alvarez v. Hernandez, No. RG17883958 

(Alameda County Super. Ct. 2017); Baños v. Polymeric Tech. Inc., No. RG16834861 (Alameda 

County Super. Ct. 2016); Garcia v. Dominguez, No. 3:14-cv-02271 (N.D. Cal. 2014); NavarijoArevalo v. Capital Bldg. Maint., No. RG14747820 (Alameda County Super. Ct. 2014); Pinto v. 

Laundry Express, Inc., No. RG14715334 (Alameda County Super. Ct. 2014). 

7. I previously worked as a Deputy City Attorney for the City of Oakland, where I 

was lead counsel for the City in complex cases on behalf of low-income and immigrant tenants 

and victims of immigration fraud. See City of Oakland v. Am. Legal Servs., No. RG10496098 

(Alameda County Super. Ct. 2013) (civil action for injunctive relief, penalties, and restitution for 

hundreds of low-income immigrants defrauded by an immigration consultant firm, resulting in a 

$15.1 million judgment); People v. Avalon Success, LLC, No. RG09455940, 2010 WL 4919588 

(Alameda County Super. Ct. 2010) (civil action for hundreds of low-income and immigrant 

tenants facing violations of state and local housing laws, with a final judgment providing 

extensive injunctive relief). 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 3 of 29
Page 3 of 9

Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

8. These and other cases have resulted in significant injunctive relief and important 

legal decisions for low-income and immigrant communities like those in this case. 

9. I first worked at Centro Legal as an attorney and Skadden Fellow, representing 

low-income consumers, tenants, and workers, as well as clients in immigration court. 

10. I have published articles discussing litigation and advocacy for low-income and 

immigrant clients and communities. See, e.g., Newmark, Legal Aid Affairs: Collaborating with 

Local Governments on the Side, 21 B.U. Pub. Int. L.J. 195 (2012). I also present at trainings on 

immigrants’ rights law and class action litigation, such as the Impact Fund’s Class Action 

Training Institute and the Public Rights Projects’ panel on affirmative litigation. 

11. Through this decade of specialized legal work, I have particular expertise in the 

complex procedural and substantive areas of law at issue in this case, including the interrelation 

of federal, state, and local laws and contracts on low-income and immigrant communities. 

12. Aidin Castillo is the directing attorney for Centro Legal’s immigrants’ rights 

program. Ms. Castillo graduated from UC Davis School of Law in 2011. 

13. For almost 10 years, Ms. Castillo has devoted her time exclusively to representing 

low-income and immigrant clients. 

14. Ms. Castillo is an expert in all aspects of immigration law, including the legal 

issues surrounding immigration bonds and removal defense at issue in this case. 

15. Through this work, Ms. Castillo is regularly involved in regional and national 

impact litigation and policy advocacy. 

16. Ms. Castillo is also part of an extended network of immigrants’ rights 

practitioners engaged in direct legal services, impact litigation, and policy advocacy. 

17. Ms. Castillo has successfully litigated numerous cases in immigration courts and at 

the Board of Immigration Appeals. 

18. Ms. Castillo regularly conducts immigration law trainings for staff attorneys, pro 

bono attorneys, and law students. As the directing attorney for immigrants’ rights at Centro Legal, 

she also supervises a staff of over 30 people, including attorneys, paralegals, and legal assistants, on 

their legal work. 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 4 of 29
Page 4 of 9

Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

19. Before coming to Centro Legal, Ms. Castillo worked at the Immigrant Legal 

Resource Center, a national organization renowned for expertise in immigration law. During this 

time, Ms. Castillo conducted dozens of statewide, regional, and national trainings for judges, 

attorneys, and other legal advocates, on a variety of immigration law topics, including those at 

issue in this case. She co-authored and edited numerous immigration law training manuals, 

practice advisories, and other secondary sources on a wide range of immigration topics. 

20. Ms. Castillo also previously worked as a policy attorney in Washington D.C., 

writing federal immigration legislative proposals for Congress and policy proposals to the office 

of U.S. Citizenship & Immigration Services, to protect immigrants from increased immigration 

enforcement actions that would result in prolonged immigration detention. 

21. Ms. Castillo makes extensive use of this decade of specialized experience and 

training to provide support to immigrant clients and class members, as she has done in this case. 

ATTORNEYS’ FEES AND COSTS 

22. I have worked extensively on this case, along with Ms. Castillo and other Centro 

Legal staff, since the end of 2016. Centro Legal has been actively involved in all aspects of the 

litigation in the almost four years since then. 

23. Specifically, Centro Legal attorneys took a lead role on critical aspects of the 

case, including: (1) coordinating client meetings, declarations, and other communications and 

support; (2) preparing and defending Plaintiffs and their sponsors at depositions; (3) reviewing 

and correcting deposition transcripts; (4) translating documents and verbal communications as 

needed throughout the litigation; (5) investigating facts by conducting outreach to and 

responding to inquiries from numerous unnamed Class Members and non-parties; (6) negotiating 

the highly complex and multi-faceted injunctive relief in this action; (7) preparing settlement 

term assessments, damage audits, and distribution models to determine the impact of proposed 

terms on the thousands of Class Members nationwide, and revising these audits, assessments, 

and models, based on new data, proposals, and Class Member information provided by 

Defendant over the years of negotiations; (8) reviewing and assessing Defendant’s policy 

changes outside of settlement over the course of the litigation, including new English and 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 5 of 29
Page 5 of 9

Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

Spanish-language contracts and program documents; (9) researching legal and factual issues as 

to the immigration removal, detention, and bond systems in particular; (10) drafting briefs and 

presenting oral argument in successfully opposing Defendant’s motions to dismiss and compel 

arbitration, particularly as to Plaintiffs’ legally complex and fact-intensive state law theories 

opposing arbitration based on fraud and unconscionability; (11) preparing and responding to 

various record requests; (12) conducting written and verbal communications with Defendant, 

opposing counsel, mediators, and the court on various matters; (13) drafting administrative 

motions; (14) researching and drafting memoranda on important legal and factual issues, 

including arbitration agreements, immigration status inquiries in discovery, asylum 

confidentiality laws, Plaintiffs’ state law claims generally, and equitable tolling of Plaintiffs’ 

claims under California Civil Code section 1632; (15) drafting requests for production of 

documents as to arbitration agreements; (16) drafting mediation briefs and researching 

mediators; (17) consulting with various experts on complex legal and policy issues; (18) drafting 

the settlement agreement; (19) researching a potential motion to enforce; (20) drafting Centro 

Legal’s attorney declarations and working with Plaintiffs to draft their declarations in support of 

preliminary approval and this application; (21) researching and drafting the settlement 

assessment and service award sections in particular, in support of preliminary approval and this 

application; and (22) drafting the supplemental brief and revised documents in support of 

preliminary approval. Although we have not billed for this time, our immigration attorneys also 

devoted many hours to representing Plaintiffs in their immigration proceedings. 

24. Centro Legal attorneys also participated in: (1) drafting the initial and amended 

complaints in this action; (2) investigating related cases; (3) reviewing and revising briefs, 

stipulations, and other documents drafted and filed in this matter; (4) preparing for Defendant’s 

30(b)(6) deposition; (5) the many negotiations, mediations, and other meetings with Defendant 

and opposing counsel; (6) the various court hearings; and (7) reviewing the thousands of pages 

of documents produced in discovery and in response to records requests. 

25. We tracked our hours spent on this case using attorney billing software. All staff 

contemporaneously recorded the time they spent working on this case. For each task performed, 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 6 of 29
Page 6 of 9

Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

staff accounted for their time in 1/10th of an hour (6-minute) increments or shorter, and included 

a brief narrative description of the work performed. Staff did not “block bill.” 

26. I generated a report summarizing each staff member’s billable time spent on this 

case through August 31, 2020. 

27. I reviewed the time entries, and believe the hours expended were reasonable and 

necessary to securing the result in this case. I also exercised billing judgment by excluding time 

from non-attorney support staff, law students, and other volunteers. 

28. To avoid unnecessary public disclosures, I redacted certain entries to state only 

“fact investigation” or “consultation” for entries that referenced, for instance, interviews with 

unnamed Class Members or consultations with non-parties. 

29. I have attached a true and correct copy of the time entries as Exhibit A. 

30. Centro Legal calculated its lodestar using the hourly rates established by the LSI 

Laffey Matrix. I am informed and believe that the Laffey Matrix establishes hourly rates for 

attorneys and legal staff based on the prevailing market rates in Washington D.C. Based upon 

recent fee awards to San Francisco Bay Area attorneys in similar class action cases, my 

understanding is that the Laffey Matrix hourly rates are at or below market for the Bay Area. 

31. The following table represents the time spent by the Centro Legal attorneys on 

this case through August 31, 2020, with a total lodestar value of $561,820.36: 

32. I anticipate that Centro Legal will devote substantial additional time to this case after 

August 31, 2020, including: (1) finalizing this application; (2) preparing for and attending the final 

approval hearing; (3) monitoring the claims and distribution process; (4) corresponding with the 

Name Title Years (JD) Hours Rate Lodestar 

Jesse Newmark Litigation Director 15 489.08 $759 $371,214.25 

Aidin Castillo Directing Attorney 10 118.05 $672 $79,329.60 

Alison Pennington Managing Attorney 18 55.85 $759 $42,390.15 

Shira Levine Senior Attorney 9 99.57 $672 $66,910.11 

Ana Henderson-Arjona Staff Attorney 4 4.25 $465 $1,976.25 

Totals 766.80 $561,820.36 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 7 of 29
Page 7 of 9

Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

claims administrator; (5) managing the extended payment plan; (6) ensuring compliance with the 

injunctive relief; and (7) responding to Class Member inquiries. 

33. As a nonprofit legal services provider, Centro Legal does not charge our clients, 

including Plaintiffs or the Class in this action, any fees for our services. Centro Legal therefore 

relies on awards for attorneys’ fees and costs in order to continue its work on behalf of lowincome and immigrant clients, to enforce their legal rights. Centro Legal invested the substantial 

attorney and staff time described above with no guarantee that any fees would be recovered. All 

attorneys’ fees and costs awarded to Centro Legal will be used to fund the nonprofit 

organization’s ongoing work representing low-income and immigrant clients who would not 

otherwise have access to legal representation. 

SERVICE AWARDS 

34. As Plaintiffs describe in detail in their own declarations, they took on significant 

personal risks and particular hardships in bringing and litigating this action. 

35. Plaintiffs also invested substantial time and effort in this litigation, staying 

actively involved over the past almost four years to obtain critical injunctive and monetary relief 

for the Class. 

36. Plaintiffs provided critical assistance by: (1) helping counsel investigate the facts 

and claims in the case; (2) meeting in-person with counsel on numerous occasions, including to 

draft the initial and amended complaints, respond to discovery requests, and prepare 

declarations; (3) attending depositions, after extensively preparing for them with counsel at inperson meetings and by telephone; (4) reviewing and correcting deposition transcripts; (5) 

discussing issues in the case with their partners and sponsors; (6) responding to discovery 

requests; (7) being available and providing assistance during mediations; (8) reviewing and 

approving settlement terms; and (9) conferring regularly with counsel by telephone. 

37. As low-income and immigrant clients, Plaintiffs also made substantial personal 

sacrifices in devoting significant time and effort to this case. Plaintiffs had to take unpaid time 

away from work and childcare responsibilities on numerous occasions over the course of the 

litigation. 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 8 of 29
Page 8 of 9

Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

38. Plaintiffs also litigated this case on behalf of the Class despite the particularly 

significant risks to themselves and their families. The four Plaintiffs are asylum seekers, or 

family members of asylum seekers, facing immigration removal proceedings and litigating 

claims against the company who secured their conditional release from immigration detention. 

39. As Plaintiffs detail in their declarations, they nonetheless came forward to 

represent the Class, despite their reasonable fears of immigration-related retaliation, potentially 

leading to their re-detention or even deportation. 

40. Plaintiffs also suffered significant personal trauma in highly sensitive client 

meetings and contentious depositions. At the depositions, Plaintiffs had to describe in detail and 

relive the conditions of their removal proceedings and detention, and face questions about their 

own and their families’ personal lives and immigration status. Plaintiffs bravely undertook these 

risks despite being refugees who had already suffered violence in their countries of origin. 

41. For these reasons, immigrant clients and their family members are often 

understandably reluctant to participate in legal actions, particularly high-profile actions like the 

national class action litigation here. This case in particular resulted in substantial media 

coverage and broad dissemination of the Plaintiffs’ names. Plaintiffs nonetheless chose to bring 

and fully participate in this action, and thereby obtained critical relief for tens of thousands of 

Class Members. 

42. In agreeing to serve as Class Representatives, Plaintiffs also agreed to accept the 

responsibilities of representing the interests of all Class Members, and forego their own individual 

claims and potential recovery that may not have been limited by class certification issues or 

solvency concerns. Plaintiffs therefore voluntarily and knowingly gave up individual recovery that 

could have been substantially higher for Plaintiffs individually, but would have provided no relief 

for the tens of thousands of Class Members. 

43. In addition, by agreeing to a complete release of all known and unknown claims, 

Plaintiffs’ release of claims is substantially broader than those of the other Class Members. 

44. For all of these reasons, the requested service awards of $10,000 for each Plaintiff 

are reasonable. 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 9 of 29
Page 9 of 9

Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of California that the foregoing is true 

and correct, and that this declaration was executed in Oakland, California, on September 1, 2020. 

 _____________________________ 

 Jesse Newmark 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 10 of 29
Vasquez v. Libre by Nexus, Inc. Case No. 4:17-cv-00755-CW 

NEWMARK DECL. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR FEES, COSTS, AND SERVICE AWARDS 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

18 

19 

20 

21 

22 

23 

24 

25 

26 

27 

28 

Exhibit A 

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 11 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Review and revise draft complaint Aidin Castillo 02/01/2017 3.00

Call w/client GPO re: civil action Aidin Castillo 02/03/2017 0.30

Call w/client JQV re: civil action Aidin Castillo 02/03/2017 0.30

Confer w/Paul Chavez re: civil action Jesse Newmark 02/03/2017 0.17

Call w/client GPO to schedule mtg and call to review and sign retainer Aidin Castillo 02/06/2017 0.20

Call w/client JQV to schedule mtg and call to review and sign retainer Aidin Castillo 02/06/2017 0.20

Call w/Paul Chavez re: potential co-counsel, case development Jesse Newmark 02/06/2017 0.50

Confer w/Paul Chavez, AC, and SL re: civil action Jesse Newmark 02/06/2017 0.08

Review complaint, outline potential additional claims, and other issues Jesse Newmark 02/06/2017 1.00

Review co-counsel agreement, confer w/Paul Chavez, AC, and SL on edits Jesse Newmark 02/08/2017 0.25

Review client retainers, confer w/Paul Chavez and co-counsel re: filing, additional claim possibilities, etc. Jesse Newmark 02/08/2017 0.42

Co-counsel agreement review, respond re: claim research Jesse Newmark 02/08/2017 0.08

Client mtg. w/GPO and JQV; call with co-counsel to review retainers Aidin Castillo 02/09/2017 0.80

Review and edit draft complaint, summary of clients' experiences Aidin Castillo 02/09/2017 0.50

Final review co-counsel agreement Jesse Newmark 02/09/2017 0.08

Revise complaint, confer w/AC, Paul Chavez, and co-counsel re: substantive changes and EOIR memo Jesse Newmark 02/09/2017 1.67

Confer w/co-counsel re: filing and release timing Jesse Newmark 02/09/2017 0.08

Review ICE documents re: LBN policies and re-detention Jesse Newmark 02/09/2017 0.25

Call with client GPO Aidin Castillo 02/10/2017 0.30

Call with client JQV Aidin Castillo 02/10/2017 0.30

Confer w/DS, AC, Paul Chavez re: FDCA claim Jesse Newmark 02/10/2017 0.25

Confer w/Paul Chavez re: Does option, respond to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/13/2017 0.17

Confer w/AC re: client declaration meetings, respond to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/13/2017 0.25

Corr. w/intake re: client declaration meetings Jesse Newmark 02/13/2017 0.08

Discuss complaint review and claims w/SL Jesse Newmark 02/14/2017 0.08

Meet with client GPO to sign venue declaration, schedule client JQV Jesse Newmark 02/14/2017 0.25

Meet with client JQV, review and sign declaration Jesse Newmark 02/14/2017 0.25

Scan and send declarations to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/14/2017 0.17

Download filed complaint, check EM/ECF Jesse Newmark 02/15/2017 0.08

Download and review initial court order, calendar dates, confer w/co-counsel re: magistrate judge and options Jesse Newmark 02/17/2017 0.33

Review complaint, discuss w/JN Shira Levine 02/20/2017 1.00

Confer w/AC re: additional plaintiff contacts and other investigations Jesse Newmark 02/23/2017 0.17

Meet w/AC and confer w/co-counsel re: protective order, client comm., and potential contacts, follow-up w/AC Jesse Newmark 02/28/2017 0.25

Corr. w/AC re: client calls re: contact Jesse Newmark 03/01/2017 0.08

Call from JQV regarding ankle monitor Aidin Castillo 03/03/2017 0.40

Call with LBN regarding ankle monitor Aidin Castillo 03/03/2017 0.30

Call to LBN regarding ankle monitor Aidin Castillo 03/03/2017 0.10

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: ankle monitor Aidin Castillo 03/03/2017 0.50

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: ankle monitor Aidin Castillo 03/03/2017 0.40

Confer w/AC re: plaintiff outreach Jesse Newmark 03/07/2017 0.08

Call to LBN regarding ankle monitor Aidin Castillo 03/08/2017 0.10

Emails re: new potential plaintiffs, discuss with Lisa Knox Shira Levine 03/21/2017 0.20

Review potential additional plaintiffs, resp. to SL, AC, and Lisa Knox Jesse Newmark 03/23/2017 0.17

Corr. w/staff re: consultant Jesse Newmark 04/10/2017 0.08

Client call Aidin Castillo 04/11/2017 0.20

Edits to second amended complaint Aidin Castillo 04/11/2017 2.80

Discuss strategy w/SL Jesse Newmark 04/11/2017 0.17

Edits to second amended complaint Aidin Castillo 04/13/2017 1.60

Corr. w/consultant Jesse Newmark 04/13/2017 0.08

Review and revise amended complaint, incl. bond revocation issue, FOIA docs Jesse Newmark 04/13/2017 1.00

Preparation for letter to LBN Shira Levine 04/13/2017 0.20

Confer w/staff re: letter to LBN Shira Levine 04/13/2017 0.20

Draft letter to LBN re payments, research agent for service of process Shira Levine 04/13/2017 0.60

Confer w/co-counsel re: judicial assignment Jesse Newmark 04/13/2017 0.08

Discuss letter w/SL, review and revise letter, corr. re: service Jesse Newmark 04/13/2017 0.50

Send payment letter to opposing counsel Shira Levine 04/13/2017 0.20

Confer w/co-counsel re: letter Jesse Newmark 04/14/2017 0.08

Confer w/LK re: letter Shira Levine 04/14/2017 0.20

Confer w/consultant re: case, incl. potential claim Jesse Newmark 04/19/2017 0.17

Research state claims for first amended complaint Jesse Newmark 04/19/2017 1.50

Research state claims for first amended complaint, prepare memo, send to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 04/19/2017 2.25

Discuss forced labor and labor code issue w/Derek Schoonmaker Jesse Newmark 04/19/2017 0.25

Prepare FOIA request Aidin Castillo 04/20/2017 0.50

FOIA request Aidin Castillo 04/20/2017 0.50

Review additional claims Shira Levine 04/21/2017 0.30

Confer w/consultant re: potential claims Jesse Newmark 04/24/2017 0.50

Revise FAC, confer w/CA re: federal FDCPA, other issues Jesse Newmark 04/24/2017 0.50

Research confidentiality issues, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 04/27/2017 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: ADR approval, first amended complaint signatures, mediation options Jesse Newmark 05/01/2017 0.17

Calls to clients re ADR permission, confer w/staff and co-counsel Shira Levine 05/01/2017 0.80

Page 1 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 12 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re ADR and clients Shira Levine 05/01/2017 0.20

Review opposing counsel motion to dismiss email, brief research and response on civil code 1632 Jesse Newmark 05/04/2017 0.25

Research on additional state claims, email about additional state claims Shira Levine 05/05/2017 1.20

Confer w/SL and AC re: related case Jesse Newmark 05/08/2017 0.25

Research on related case Shira Levine 05/08/2017 1.30

Research additional claims Shira Levine 05/08/2017 0.50

Research additional claims Shira Levine 05/12/2017 0.30

Revise case management conference statement Shira Levine 05/15/2017 0.50

Confer w/SL re: additional claims, respond to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 05/16/2017 0.17

Call w/co-counsel and opposing counsel re: case management conference Shira Levine 05/16/2017 0.50

Email to opposing counsel about ankle monitor Aidin Castillo 05/17/2017 0.30

Discuss ankle monitor remove w/AC Shira Levine 05/17/2017 0.20

Confer w/co-counsel re: case management conference coordination Shira Levine 05/18/2017 0.20

Review comments on additional claims, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 05/22/2017 0.25

Case management conference Shira Levine 05/23/2017 2.00

Drafting requests for production of documents re: arbitration agreement Shira Levine 05/24/2017 2.00

Arbitration law research Shira Levine 05/25/2017 1.30

Emails re: claims Shira Levine 05/25/2017 0.50

Call re: arbitration, claims Shira Levine 05/25/2017 0.30

Confer w/SL re: case management conference Jesse Newmark 05/25/2017 0.17

Review deposition scheduling and arbitration issue discussion Jesse Newmark 05/25/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: dismissing claims Jesse Newmark 05/25/2017 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: dismissing claims Jesse Newmark 05/26/2017 0.17

Reviewing complaint, comments Shira Levine 05/26/2017 0.50

Review court order, add case deadlines Jesse Newmark 05/26/2017 0.25

Scans and emails re discovery Shira Levine 06/06/2017 0.30

Research asylum confidentiality laws Aidin Castillo 06/07/2017 1.00

Review corr. re: upcoming deposition and arbitration research, corr. w/SL on arbitration Jesse Newmark 06/07/2017 0.17

Emails re: arbitration research Shira Levine 06/07/2017 0.20

Confer w/AC re: RFP documents Shira Levine 06/08/2017 0.20

Schedule call Shira Levine 06/08/2017 0.10

Revise RFPs Aidin Castillo 06/12/2017 0.60

Discuss client w/SL Aidin Castillo 06/12/2017 0.50

Research and draft memo on arbitration and language Shira Levine 06/12/2017 2.00

Call re: depositions Shira Levine 06/12/2017 0.30

Call w/AC to prepare for depositions Shira Levine 06/12/2017 0.30

Revise and send disclosures Shira Levine 06/12/2017 0.30

Call client re: deposition representation, discuss case, confer w/co-counsel Shira Levine 06/12/2017 0.50

Review corr. re: deposition issue Jesse Newmark 06/12/2017 0.08

Call w/AC re: client and representation Shira Levine 06/13/2017 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: deposition issue Shira Levine 06/13/2017 0.10

Call to client re: deposition representation Shira Levine 06/13/2017 0.10

Calls to clients re: deposition representation Shira Levine 06/13/2017 0.20

Call to client re: deposition representation Shira Levine 06/14/2017 0.30

Initial research on arbitration challenge, confer w/SL Jesse Newmark 06/15/2017 0.25

Research on arbitration, language, civil code 1632, and unconscionability Shira Levine 06/15/2017 4.00

Discuss arbitration research w/JN Shira Levine 06/16/2017 0.30

Client and partner meeting to assess deposition representation Shira Levine 06/19/2017 1.50

Draft summary re: client meeting Shira Levine 06/19/2017 0.30

Draft memo on arbitration Shira Levine 06/19/2017 4.00

Confer w/SL re: client deposition preparation meeting, and arbitration research Jesse Newmark 06/19/2017 0.25

Met with clients JQV and NPR to prepare documents for disclosure Aidin Castillo 06/20/2017 0.80

Review SL arbitration research memo Jesse Newmark 06/20/2017 0.25

Revise memo Shira Levine 06/20/2017 0.20

Confer w/co-counsel and SL-AC re: plaintiff discovery and deposition preparation scheduling Jesse Newmark 06/20/2017 0.17

Emails re: deposition preparation Shira Levine 06/20/2017 0.10

Emails re: coordinating deposition preparation Shira Levine 06/20/2017 0.10

Corr. w/co-counsel re: deposition dates Jesse Newmark 06/21/2017 0.08

Schedule deposition preparation with clients Shira Levine 06/21/2017 0.60

Met with client VCM to prepare documents for disclosure Aidin Castillo 06/22/2017 0.50

Confer w/SL and AC on deposition preparation scheduling and coverage Jesse Newmark 06/22/2017 0.25

Meet w/AC re: deposition preparation Shira Levine 06/22/2017 0.50

Reschedule deposition preparation Shira Levine 06/22/2017 0.10

Review 30b6 deposition summary, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/22/2017 0.17

Confer w/AC, SL, and co-counsel re: preparation calls and rescheduling Jesse Newmark 06/22/2017 0.17

Client call with JQV about deposition preparation scheduling Aidin Castillo 06/23/2017 0.20

Conf. w/SL re: arbitration research Jesse Newmark 06/23/2017 0.08

Confer w/SL re: cosigner deposition dates Jesse Newmark 06/23/2017 0.17

Schedule depositions and deposition preparation Shira Levine 06/23/2017 0.70

Confer w/AC, SL, and AP re: co-signer deposition dates Jesse Newmark 06/26/2017 0.17

Page 2 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 13 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: plaintiff deposition coverage Jesse Newmark 06/26/2017 0.17

Confer w/AC re: co-signer deposition coverage and partner support Jesse Newmark 06/26/2017 0.17

Confer w/AC re: client deposition preparation call coverage and logisitics Jesse Newmark 06/26/2017 0.25

Confer w/staff re: case status and research tasks Jesse Newmark 06/27/2017 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: co-signer depositions Jesse Newmark 06/27/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: co-signer depositions Jesse Newmark 06/27/2017 0.17

Confer w/AC re: deposition preparation outline and meeting Jesse Newmark 06/27/2017 0.08

Revise outline, meet w/AC for client deposition preparation Jesse Newmark 06/28/2017 1.25

Deposition preparation with AC and co-counsel (JQV) Jesse Newmark 06/28/2017 1.50

Confer w/co-counsel on deposition preparation additions Jesse Newmark 06/28/2017 0.08

Emails with co-counsel re: cosigner depositions Aidin Castillo 06/30/2017 0.30

Prepare deposition preparation and coverage spreadsheet, calendar, and confer w/staff Jesse Newmark 07/05/2017 0.50

Confer w/staff on deposition coverage dates Jesse Newmark 07/06/2017 0.17

Confer w/SL and PC re: immigration status research and Rule 11 Jesse Newmark 07/06/2017 0.25

Research immigration status for depositions Shira Levine 07/06/2017 1.00

Draft statement on immigration status Shira Levine 07/07/2017 0.50

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: deposition preparation coverage issues Jesse Newmark 07/07/2017 0.17

Review law on immigration status discovery, confer w/SL Jesse Newmark 07/07/2017 0.17

Call to interpreter re: scheduling deposition preparation Aidin Castillo 07/10/2017 0.20

Client call re: deposition preparation Aidin Castillo 07/10/2017 0.20

Deposition preparation Aidin Castillo 07/10/2017 1.50

Review Rule 11 motion, confer w/co-counsel on response Jesse Newmark 07/10/2017 0.25

Review and revise discovery deficiency letter Jesse Newmark 07/10/2017 0.17

Deposition preparation organization Shira Levine 07/10/2017 0.30

Corr. re: deposition coverage Jesse Newmark 07/10/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: deposition preparation Jesse Newmark 07/10/2017 0.08

Client JQV deposition preparation Jesse Newmark 07/10/2017 2.75

Confer w/AC re: scheduling client Jesse Newmark 07/10/2017 0.17

Deposition client JQV Aidin Castillo 07/11/2017 7.00

Client GPO deposition preparation Aidin Castillo 07/11/2017 1.50

Corr. w/AP re: deposition meeting, corr. w/AC re: client call Jesse Newmark 07/11/2017 0.17

Client JQV meeting and deposition Jesse Newmark 07/11/2017 10.00

Deposition preparation with client GPO Shira Levine 07/11/2017 3.00

Confer w/SL re: deposition and coverage Jesse Newmark 07/11/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: co-signer deposition preparation coverage Jesse Newmark 07/11/2017 0.17

Review class representative duties on complaint knowledge Jesse Newmark 07/11/2017 0.25

Client GPO deposition Aidin Castillo 07/12/2017 8.00

Client GPO deposition (incl. commute) Shira Levine 07/12/2017 9.50

Confer w/SL and Paul Chavez re: negotiation scheduling Jesse Newmark 07/12/2017 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: co-signer deposition preparation availability and coverage Jesse Newmark 07/12/2017 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: co-signer deposition preparation Jesse Newmark 07/12/2017 0.08

Client VM deposition preparation Shira Levine 07/12/2017 2.00

Confirm settlement meeting w/co-counsel and SL Jesse Newmark 07/13/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/13/2017 0.25

VM deposition and transportation Shira Levine 07/13/2017 10.00

Negotiations, monitor removal, client meeting (incl. commute) Jesse Newmark 07/13/2017 3.92

Settlement meeting, monitor removal Shira Levine 07/13/2017 2.00

KC deposition preparation Aidin Castillo 07/14/2017 0.80

Client deposition preparation call Aidin Castillo 07/14/2017 0.80

Client deposition preparation call Shira Levine 07/14/2017 0.01

Client deposition preparation Aidin Castillo 07/16/2017 1.30

Confer w/staff and co-counsel on deposition preparation and scheduling Jesse Newmark 07/16/2017 0.50

Confer w/staff on meeting re: injunctive possibilities pursuant to settlement Jesse Newmark 07/17/2017 0.08

Research proposed mediator, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/17/2017 0.33

Review Rule 11 response, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/17/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel and staff on deposition defense for co-signers Jesse Newmark 07/17/2017 0.50

Research proposed mediators, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/17/2017 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/17/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: ADR coverage Jesse Newmark 07/17/2017 0.08

Client deposition preparation call Shira Levine 07/17/2017 0.20

Confer w/AC re: client deposition preparation Shira Levine 07/17/2017 0.20

Confer w/staff for depositions and preparation Shira Levine 07/17/2017 0.30

Confer w/AP re: deposition coverage Jesse Newmark 07/17/2017 0.08

Client deposition Aidin Castillo 07/18/2017 4.00

Deposition and preparation (incl. commute) Jesse Newmark 07/18/2017 4.75

Client deposition preparation Shira Levine 07/18/2017 2.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: ADR, call and mediator research Jesse Newmark 07/18/2017 0.58

Client deposition preparation Jesse Newmark 07/18/2017 2.00

Research deposition ethical issue Jesse Newmark 07/18/2017 0.50

Meet w/client and partner about case and representation Aidin Castillo 07/19/2017 1.50

Page 3 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 14 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Deposition (incl. preparation, commute, and follow up w/client) Jesse Newmark 07/19/2017 5.00

Deposition (incl. preparation and commute) Shira Levine 07/19/2017 4.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/21/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement updates and meeting Jesse Newmark 07/22/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff re: settlement issues Jesse Newmark 07/23/2017 0.17

KC deposition Aidin Castillo 07/24/2017 6.00

Confer w/staff re: injunctive settlement meeting and confidentiality Jesse Newmark 07/24/2017 0.17

Confer w/AC re: deposition coverage and OIS objections Jesse Newmark 07/24/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff re: injunctive relief and fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/25/2017 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: manager depositions Jesse Newmark 07/25/2017 0.08

Review deposition summary, confer w/AC Jesse Newmark 07/25/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: initial mediation call, research mediator Jesse Newmark 07/25/2017 0.33

Respond to co-counsel and staff re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/25/2017 0.17

Call re: co-signer depositions, amended complaint drafting, discovery Jesse Newmark 07/26/2017 0.33

Call re: depositions and discovery Shira Levine 07/26/2017 0.50

Confer w/staff re: fact investigation Shira Levine 07/26/2017 0.30

Confer w/staff re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/26/2017 0.17

Schedule co-signer deposition Jesse Newmark 07/26/2017 0.08

Confer w/staff re: fact investigation Aidin Castillo 07/27/2017 1.00

Confer w/staff re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/27/2017 0.08

Meet w/staff re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/27/2017 1.00

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/27/2017 1.25

Fact investigation Shira Levine 07/27/2017 1.00

Fact investigation Shira Levine 07/27/2017 1.00

Confer w/JN re: fact investigation Shira Levine 07/27/2017 0.50

Meet and confer phone call Shira Levine 07/27/2017 0.50

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/27/2017 0.17

Confer w/AP re: custody issue Jesse Newmark 07/28/2017 0.17

Confer w/Paul Chavez re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 07/28/2017 0.08

Legal research on bonds and analysis Jesse Newmark 07/28/2017 0.50

Confer w/staff re: LBN meeting Jesse Newmark 07/28/2017 0.25

Confirm client deposition and preparation coverage Jesse Newmark 07/28/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: fact investigation, additional class representatives Jesse Newmark 07/28/2017 0.17

Research LBN action, draft memo Jesse Newmark 07/30/2017 0.92

Review draft stipulation for mediation, confer w/co-counsel and Paul Chavez Jesse Newmark 07/31/2017 0.25

Email re: client deposition Shira Levine 07/31/2017 0.10

Revise stipulation, add data and policy questions Jesse Newmark 08/05/2017 0.33

Review stipulation, confer w/staff re: policy and strategy Jesse Newmark 08/05/2017 0.25

Confer w/staff and counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/07/2017 0.17

Review stipulated stay Jesse Newmark 08/07/2017 0.08

Confer w/SL re: errata issue Jesse Newmark 08/07/2017 0.08

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/07/2017 0.08

Send additional revisions for informal requests to AP Jesse Newmark 08/08/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/08/2017 0.50

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/09/2017 0.08

Confer re: deposition cancelation Jesse Newmark 08/09/2017 0.08

Initial VDRP call Jesse Newmark 08/10/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: pre-mediation meeting w/LBN Jesse Newmark 08/10/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff re: pre-mediation meeting and fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/10/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff re: pre-mediation meeting and fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/10/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: pre-mediation meeting scheduling Jesse Newmark 08/10/2017 0.08

Review corr. from assigned VDRP Jesse Newmark 08/10/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/14/2017 0.25

Confer w/SL and co-counsel re: deposition transcript review and translation Jesse Newmark 08/14/2017 0.25

Confer w/SL re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/14/2017 0.17

Emails re deposition errata Shira Levine 08/14/2017 0.20

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation brief Jesse Newmark 08/14/2017 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: errata extension and attorney review Jesse Newmark 08/14/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: injunctive relief requests Jesse Newmark 08/14/2017 0.17

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/15/2017 0.17

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/15/2017 1.00

Review deposition transcripts for errata Shira Levine 08/15/2017 1.00

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/15/2017 0.08

Review deposition transcripts for errata Shira Levine 08/16/2017 0.00

Review deposition transcripts for errata Shira Levine 08/16/2017 0.38

Review deposition transcripts for errata Shira Levine 08/16/2017 0.88

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/16/2017 1.30

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/16/2017 0.17

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/18/2017 2.50

Review deposition transcripts for errata Shira Levine 08/18/2017 1.00

Page 4 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 15 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation schedule Jesse Newmark 08/21/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/21/2017 3.00

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/21/2017 0.80

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/22/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/23/2017 0.17

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/23/2017 0.08

Confer w/AC re: deposition transcript review Jesse Newmark 08/23/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/23/2017 0.50

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/24/2017 0.17

Confer w/AC re: deposition transcript review Shira Levine 08/25/2017 0.20

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/25/2017 1.50

Client call Shira Levine 08/25/2017 0.10

Fact investigation, review mediation brief Jesse Newmark 08/28/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Alison Pennington 08/29/2017 1.50

Fact investigation Aidin Castillo 08/29/2017 1.00

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/29/2017 0.08

Review complaint and injunctive relief options, prepare outline Jesse Newmark 08/30/2017 1.50

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/30/2017 1.00

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/30/2017 0.17

Fact investigation Alison Pennington 08/31/2017 2.50

Fact investigation Aidin Castillo 08/31/2017 2.50

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/31/2017 2.50

Fact investigation Shira Levine 08/31/2017 3.00

Confer w/staff re: policy changes Jesse Newmark 08/31/2017 0.25

Confirm LBN meeting and location, confer w/staff Jesse Newmark 08/31/2017 0.17

Confer w/AP re: updated mediation brief draft and compensation section Jesse Newmark 08/31/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff re: mediation brief section drafting, and non-confidentiality Jesse Newmark 08/31/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: LBN meeting and pre-mediation call Jesse Newmark 08/31/2017 0.08

Draft mediation brief Shira Levine 08/31/2017 0.06

Fact investigation Alison Pennington 09/01/2017 0.80

Fact investigation Aidin Castillo 09/01/2017 0.80

Schedule mediation, review documents, confer w/staff Jesse Newmark 09/01/2017 0.25

Confer w/staff re: mediation brief review and drafting Jesse Newmark 09/01/2017 0.17

Revise and draft mediation brief Jesse Newmark 09/01/2017 2.00

Confer w/staff and JT co-counsel re: LBN meeting and pre-meeting Jesse Newmark 09/04/2017 0.25

Revise mediation brief Jesse Newmark 09/04/2017 0.50

Fact investigation Alison Pennington 09/06/2017 0.50

Revise mediation statement Alison Pennington 09/07/2017 2.00

Revise mediation statement Aidin Castillo 09/07/2017 0.80

Mediation planning meeting Aidin Castillo 09/07/2017 1.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation brief Jesse Newmark 09/07/2017 0.25

Schedule meeting w/staff re: mediation brief review and LBN meeting Jesse Newmark 09/07/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: research on bond regs, etc. Jesse Newmark 09/07/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 09/07/2017 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel potential class representatives Jesse Newmark 09/07/2017 0.33

Revise mediation brief, confer w/staff Jesse Newmark 09/07/2017 1.00

Call w/staff re: mediation brief edits and meeting with LBN Jesse Newmark 09/07/2017 0.75

Fact investigation Shira Levine 09/07/2017 1.50

Review and revise mediation brief Shira Levine 09/07/2017 0.80

Confer w/co-counsel and corr. w/opposing counsel re: mediation cont. Jesse Newmark 09/07/2017 0.25

Review mediation brief revisions, send to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 09/07/2017 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation date changes, other mediators Jesse Newmark 09/08/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation date Jesse Newmark 09/08/2017 0.08

Schedule new mediation dates, confer w/staff on attendance Jesse Newmark 09/11/2017 0.17

Review deposition transcript Shira Levine 09/11/2017 2.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation scheduling Jesse Newmark 09/12/2017 0.08

Confirm mediation date w/staff Jesse Newmark 09/14/2017 0.08

Confer w/Paul Chavez re: potential class representative Jesse Newmark 09/14/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 09/19/2017 0.25

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 09/20/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 09/22/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Shira Levine 09/26/2017 0.30

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 09/26/2017 0.50

Confer w/staff re: LBN meeting and mediation attendance and preparation Jesse Newmark 10/03/2017 0.25

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: pre-LBN meeting, etc. Jesse Newmark 10/05/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff re: pre-mediation meeting Jesse Newmark 10/08/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: pre-mediation meeting Jesse Newmark 10/08/2017 0.08

Strategy session with co-counsel Alison Pennington 10/09/2017 2.00

Meeting with LBN Alison Pennington 10/09/2017 1.50

Meeting with LBN Aidin Castillo 10/09/2017 2.00

Page 5 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 16 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Meeting with LBN and preparation Shira Levine 10/09/2017 3.50

Review materials for LBN meeting Jesse Newmark 10/09/2017 0.50

LBN meeting (incl. preparation and follow-up, and pre-meeting w/co-counsel) Jesse Newmark 10/09/2017 4.75

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: meeting and mediation Jesse Newmark 10/09/2017 0.08

Mediation Alison Pennington 10/10/2017 8.00

Mediation Aidin Castillo 10/10/2017 6.00

Mediation (incl. preparation, commute, and follow up) Jesse Newmark 10/10/2017 8.00

Mediation Shira Levine 10/10/2017 0.14

Confer w/consultant re: bond research Jesse Newmark 10/12/2017 0.08

Confer w/AP and co-counsel re: bond research, etc. Jesse Newmark 10/12/2017 0.17

Confer w/consultant re: bond research Jesse Newmark 10/13/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: subpoena response Jesse Newmark 10/16/2017 0.08

Fact investigation, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 10/19/2017 0.17

Fact investigation, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 10/19/2017 0.08

Fact investigation, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 10/23/2017 0.25

Fact investigation, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 10/24/2017 0.17

Fact investigation, confer w/staff Jesse Newmark 10/24/2017 0.08

Fact investigation, confer w/staff Jesse Newmark 10/24/2017 0.08

Review and confer w/co-counsel on mot. for protective order, etc. Jesse Newmark 10/27/2017 0.50

Fact investigation Alison Pennington 10/30/2017 1.50

Fact investigation Aidin Castillo 10/30/2017 3.00

Fact investigation Ana Henderson-Arjo 10/30/2017 1.25

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 10/30/2017 0.08

Fact investigation Ana Henderson-Arjo 10/31/2017 2.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: various Jesse Newmark 11/03/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: various Jesse Newmark 11/06/2017 1.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: various Jesse Newmark 11/07/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: response to opposing counsel re: mediation call Jesse Newmark 11/08/2017 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: call to opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 11/10/2017 0.25

Review notes from settlement call Alison Pennington 11/17/2017 0.40

Confer w/co-counsel on materials; call w/opposing counsel re: proposal Jesse Newmark 11/17/2017 1.08

Draft memo re: LBN proposal and next steps, schedule meeting Jesse Newmark 11/17/2017 1.00

Confer w/AC re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 11/17/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff re: settlement response Jesse Newmark 11/20/2017 0.17

Review settlement discussion notes Alison Pennington 11/21/2017 0.40

Meet re: settlement Alison Pennington 11/21/2017 1.50

Draft memo re: response to settlement offer, confer w/staff Jesse Newmark 11/21/2017 1.50

Meet w/Paul Chavez, AP, and AC re: response to settlement offer Jesse Newmark 11/21/2017 1.25

Memo to co-counsel re: settlement response Jesse Newmark 11/21/2017 0.50

Call w/co-counsel re: response to settlement, etc. Jesse Newmark 11/21/2017 1.50

Prepare notes from call and next steps on settlement response Jesse Newmark 11/21/2017 0.25

Meet w/staff re: settlement strategy Ana Henderson-Arjo 11/21/2017 1.00

Discuss common fund issues w/DS Jesse Newmark 11/21/2017 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: various Jesse Newmark 11/22/2017 1.00

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 11/22/2017 0.25

Consultations re: common fund distribution issues Jesse Newmark 11/27/2017 0.08

Review stip to cont., respond to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 11/27/2017 0.17

Prepare and file notice of appearance; review standing order, local rules Jesse Newmark 11/27/2017 1.00

Confer w/AP re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 11/28/2017 0.08

Review court scheduling order, update dates Jesse Newmark 11/29/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: various Jesse Newmark 12/04/2017 0.17

Confer w/AP, AC, and Paul Chavez re: potential class representative Jesse Newmark 12/06/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: various Jesse Newmark 12/06/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff re: review of new LBN contract Jesse Newmark 12/06/2017 0.17

Confer w/AP and AC re: contract review, prepare memo on issues Jesse Newmark 12/07/2017 0.17

Confer w/staff re: opposing counsel contact request Jesse Newmark 12/07/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: requesting opposing counsel contact, etc. Jesse Newmark 12/08/2017 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: contract review Jesse Newmark 12/08/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: contact request Jesse Newmark 12/11/2017 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: contract review and mediation Jesse Newmark 12/12/2017 0.08

Confer w/AP and AC re: contract review Jesse Newmark 12/13/2017 0.08

Review LBN's new contracts Alison Pennington 12/14/2017 2.00

Prepare analysis of LBN's new contracts Alison Pennington 12/14/2017 3.00

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: proposed mediation dates Jesse Newmark 12/19/2017 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation date Jesse Newmark 12/19/2017 0.17

Corr. w/opposing counsel re: contact person; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 12/29/2017 0.25

Review AP memo on contract changes, responses; review contracts; prepare calculations and chart for changes Jesse Newmark 01/02/2018 2.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 01/03/2018 0.08

Confer w/staff re: contract changes and response Jesse Newmark 01/04/2018 0.08

Page 6 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 17 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 01/04/2018 0.08

Confer w/AC and AP re: additional calculations and response to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/05/2018 0.25

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 01/08/2018 0.08

Draft memo re: LBN response and new contract; revise calculations and spreadsheet Jesse Newmark 01/11/2018 2.42

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: mediation dates and contract analysis Jesse Newmark 01/12/2018 0.17

Finalize memos re: LBN contract and response and send to co-counsel, confer re: next steps Jesse Newmark 01/12/2018 0.33

Confer w/staff re: potential class representative call Jesse Newmark 01/19/2018 0.08

Confirm mediation date Jesse Newmark 01/22/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: potential class representative Jesse Newmark 01/22/2018 0.08

Review proposed stipulation and order; confer w/co-counsel re: issues and analysis Jesse Newmark 01/24/2018 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: meeting on policy change issues Jesse Newmark 02/02/2018 0.08

Confer w/staff re: call scheduling Jesse Newmark 02/05/2018 0.08

Review and calendar new deadlines per court order Jesse Newmark 02/05/2018 0.17

Strategy call with co-counsel Alison Pennington 02/08/2018 0.50

Review policy change notes; conf. call w/co-counsel re: strategy for mediation, changes; viability of claims and 

remedies, incl. rescission Jesse Newmark 02/08/2018 0.75

Confer w/AP and AC re: payment plans, meeting Jesse Newmark 02/12/2018 0.25

Confer w/AC re: policy demands Jesse Newmark 02/13/2018 0.08

Confer w/AP and AC re: payment plans, meeting Jesse Newmark 02/14/2018 0.08

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: payment plan meeting Jesse Newmark 02/14/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: meeting and fact investigation Jesse Newmark 02/15/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: rescheduled meeting; calendar Jesse Newmark 02/15/2018 0.08

LBN new fee structure assessment Aidin Castillo 02/19/2018 1.50

Confer w/AP re: fee structure and potential proposals, data needed; confer w/co-counsel re: conclusions and 

need for data Jesse Newmark 02/20/2018 0.83

Confer w/AP re: appearance, draft notice Jesse Newmark 02/21/2018 0.17

Call w/co-counsel re: mediation strategy and demands, discovery needs for settlement, arbitration strategy, 

rescission, etc. Jesse Newmark 02/21/2018 0.67

Review prior requests and prepare updated request of items needed for mediation, draft email to opposing 

counsel, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/28/2018 0.83

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: LBN offer re: bonds Jesse Newmark 03/01/2018 0.17

Draft response to LBN; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/02/2018 0.17

Corr. w/opposing counsel re: info needed for mediation Jesse Newmark 03/02/2018 0.25

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 03/02/2018 0.17

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 03/05/2018 0.08

Review opposing counsel corr.; confer w/co-counsel re: response Jesse Newmark 03/07/2018 0.17

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 03/07/2018 0.08

Confer w/staff re: response to inquiries and LBN contact Jesse Newmark 03/07/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: informal discovery call Jesse Newmark 03/07/2018 0.08

Corr. w/opposing counsel re: informal discovery call Jesse Newmark 03/08/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: scheduling opposing counsel call Jesse Newmark 03/14/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: scheduling opposing counsel call Jesse Newmark 03/15/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel and corr. w/opposing counsel re: informal discovery call Jesse Newmark 03/16/2018 0.08

Corr. w/opposing counsel re: pre-mediation call Jesse Newmark 03/19/2018 0.08

Pre-settlement call re: data Aidin Castillo 03/20/2018 0.80

Preparation and call w/opposing counsel re: informal discovery / mediation, follow-up call w/staff and co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/20/2018 1.25

Draft memo to opposing counsel clarifying requests for info and responding to issues raised; confer w/co-counsel 

and staff Jesse Newmark 03/21/2018 0.92

Revise and send memo to opposing counsel; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/21/2018 0.33

Revise and send memo to opposing counsel; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/21/2018 0.17

Review mediation statement Aidin Castillo 03/26/2018 2.00

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: meeting pre-mediation Jesse Newmark 03/26/2018 0.17

Revise mediation statement, confer w/AC and AP Jesse Newmark 03/26/2018 1.17

Review and revise mediation statement Alison Pennington 03/27/2018 0.50

Strategy call with co-counsel Alison Pennington 03/27/2018 1.25

Review corr. re: data questions, respond as to issues and strategy Jesse Newmark 03/27/2018 0.17

Discuss mediation brief revisions w/AP and AC; revise and confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/27/2018 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: mediation and brief Jesse Newmark 03/27/2018 0.08

Review revised brief; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/27/2018 0.08

Call w/co-counsel, preparation for mediation, etc. Jesse Newmark 03/27/2018 1.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: call from opposing counsel and mediation Jesse Newmark 03/28/2018 0.08

Mediation Alison Pennington 03/29/2018 8.00

Mediation (incl. commute and preparation) Jesse Newmark 03/29/2018 10.25

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 03/30/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: potential class representative and strategy Jesse Newmark 03/30/2018 0.17

Review mediator letter Alison Pennington 04/03/2018 0.20

Review mediator letter; confer w/co-counsel and staff Jesse Newmark 04/03/2018 0.33

Confer w/AP and AC re: mediation statement, strategy Jesse Newmark 04/03/2018 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: claim research, licensing laws, LBN news, etc. Jesse Newmark 04/03/2018 1.42

Page 7 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 18 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Review UCL law; confer w/co-counsel re: strategy Jesse Newmark 04/06/2018 0.08

Confer w/AC and AP re: settlement decisions Jesse Newmark 04/09/2018 0.33

Review co-counsel corr.; confer w/AP re: settlement issues Jesse Newmark 04/09/2018 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: potential class rep Jesse Newmark 04/10/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: merits of UCL claim, injunctive relief, and strategy Jesse Newmark 04/10/2018 0.33

Call w/co-counsel re: legal strategy and mediation efforts Jesse Newmark 04/10/2018 1.33

Confer w/AP and AC re: legal strategy and continued mediation efforts Jesse Newmark 04/10/2018 0.17

Corr. w/mediator re: extension request; respond to opposing counsel re: next steps Jesse Newmark 04/10/2018 0.17

Confer w/AP, AC, and co-counsel re: settlement strategy, risk Jesse Newmark 04/12/2018 0.17

Review settlement emails and notes from JN Aidin Castillo 04/13/2018 1.50

Staff meeting on strategy Alison Pennington 04/16/2018 1.00

Confer w/JN and AP re: settlement strategy Aidin Castillo 04/16/2018 1.00

Draft memo on settlement and legal strategy Jesse Newmark 04/16/2018 0.25

Confer w/AP and AC re: legal strategy and continued mediation decision Jesse Newmark 04/16/2018 1.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: litigation/mediation decision, response to mediator and opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 04/16/2018 0.58

Staff call on strategy Alison Pennington 04/17/2018 0.50

Call with co-counsel about settlement response to mediator Aidin Castillo 04/17/2018 0.50

Call w/co-counsel re: legal strategy and mediation efforts; draft response to mediator/opposing counsel, revise 

w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 04/17/2018 0.50

Finalize corr. to mediator and opposing counsel re: settlement Jesse Newmark 04/17/2018 0.25

Staff email on strategy Alison Pennington 04/23/2018 0.20

Review documents from related lawsuits; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 04/23/2018 1.50

Review documents from related lawsuits; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 04/23/2018 0.25

Review transcript from LBN article, confer w/co-counsel on subpoenas Jesse Newmark 05/04/2018 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: potential class representative outreach and response Jesse Newmark 05/11/2018 0.08

Confer w/AP and AC re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/22/2018 0.08

Confer w/AP and AC re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/23/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: meeting re: various motions; schedule motions, review proposed briefing schedule and 

respond Jesse Newmark 05/30/2018 0.33

Emails to schedule call and coordinate briefing Aidin Castillo 06/04/2018 0.50

Staff call to coordinate briefing Alison Pennington 06/05/2018 0.50

Staff call to coordinate briefing Aidin Castillo 06/05/2018 1.00

Staff call to coordinate briefing Jesse Newmark 06/05/2018 0.08

Review motions and confer w/co-counsel re: response and discovery Jesse Newmark 06/05/2018 0.92

Brief research on translation legal issue, consultation Jesse Newmark 06/06/2018 0.50

Consultations re: arbitration briefing Jesse Newmark 06/07/2018 0.17

Research arbitration opp. args under state law; review contract, agreement, depositions; confer w/co-counsel re: 

arguments and steps (declarations, deposition review) Jesse Newmark 06/08/2018 4.00

Research and drafting opp. to arbitration, consultation; confer w/staff and co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/11/2018 3.67

Research on procedural unconscionability Alison Pennington 06/12/2018 2.00

Revise Rule 11 opposition, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/12/2018 0.50

Consultation re: briefing Jesse Newmark 06/12/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: deadline and review Jesse Newmark 06/12/2018 0.17

Confer w/staff re: deposition review Jesse Newmark 06/12/2018 0.17

Research and outlining/drafting opposition to arbitration Jesse Newmark 06/12/2018 5.08

Confer w/AP re: deposition summary, review Jesse Newmark 06/13/2018 0.50

Additional research on substantive unconscionability factors Jesse Newmark 06/13/2018 2.00

Finish drafting all sections, organizing unconscionability Jesse Newmark 06/13/2018 4.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: unconscionability issues and strategy Jesse Newmark 06/13/2018 0.50

Confer w/SL re: substantive unconscionability, application to entire contract Jesse Newmark 06/13/2018 0.33

Client call Aidin Castillo 06/15/2018 0.30

Confer w/AC re: client call Jesse Newmark 06/15/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel call Jesse Newmark 06/15/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: edits and restructuring of arbitration brief; review McGill section Jesse Newmark 06/15/2018 0.33

Review and revisions to arbitration opposition, remove unconscionability arg., review declaration and add cites to 

translation and coverage arguments Jesse Newmark 06/15/2018 1.00

Review declaration, AP memo, and client deposition, add cites to fraud section Jesse Newmark 06/15/2018 2.33

Review deposition transcripts, re-draft fraud section, add cites; review and revise brief; confer w/co-counsel re: 

declarations, etc. Jesse Newmark 06/16/2018 4.08

Review brief, add transcript citations Aidin Castillo 06/18/2018 5.50

Confer w/AC re: cites and review edits Jesse Newmark 06/18/2018 0.50

Review and revise opposition to arbitration, confer w/co-counsel re: brief and confidentiality Jesse Newmark 06/18/2018 1.83

Revise cites to depositions Jesse Newmark 06/18/2018 0.25

Final revisions and additions to deposition cites; confer re: signatures and filing Jesse Newmark 06/18/2018 0.58

Revise brief, add transcript citations Aidin Castillo 06/19/2018 1.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: review and filing Jesse Newmark 06/19/2018 0.08

Confer w/AC re: client call Jesse Newmark 06/19/2018 0.08

Respond to opposing counsel re: request Jesse Newmark 06/19/2018 0.08

Confer w/SL re: bond alternatives, case impact Jesse Newmark 06/20/2018 0.08

Review final opposition Jesse Newmark 06/20/2018 0.08

Page 8 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 19 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Confer w/co-counsel re: client issue Jesse Newmark 06/20/2018 0.08

Confer w/AC re: client call Jesse Newmark 06/21/2018 0.08

Review opposing counsel corr., etc. Jesse Newmark 06/21/2018 0.25

Confer w/AC re: client issues Jesse Newmark 06/22/2018 0.08

Respond to opposing counsel re: request; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/22/2018 0.17

Review opposing counsel corr., confer w/co-counsel and staff Jesse Newmark 06/25/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: response Jesse Newmark 06/27/2018 0.08

Corr. w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 07/09/2018 0.17

Review of reply brief Jesse Newmark 07/09/2018 0.17

Draft response to mediator, confer w/co-counsel re: response and oral argument coverage Jesse Newmark 07/12/2018 0.25

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: class representative, witness calls and scheduling discovery Jesse Newmark 08/03/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel and schedule call and agenda Jesse Newmark 08/06/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: witnesses Jesse Newmark 08/07/2018 0.08

Confer w/AC and AP re: witnesses Jesse Newmark 08/08/2018 0.33

Response to email about client bond cancellation Aidin Castillo 08/09/2018 0.50

Oral argument preparation call Aidin Castillo 08/09/2018 0.50

Conf. call re: discovery, class member calls, and hearing preparation; follow-up w/staff Jesse Newmark 08/09/2018 0.58

Confer w/staff re: strategy Jesse Newmark 08/09/2018 0.08

Confer w/AC and AP re: hearing Jesse Newmark 08/09/2018 0.08

Review motions for oral argument Aidin Castillo 08/11/2018 1.50

Review co-counsel memo on motion to dismiss briefing, confer w/co-counsel re: briefs Jesse Newmark 08/13/2018 0.58

Consultation re: tolling and discovery delay Jesse Newmark 08/13/2018 0.67

Oral argument preparation: initial research on tolling and delayed discovery, brief memo to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/13/2018 1.92

Oral argument preparation: initial research on FDCPA claim, incl. research on bond companies Jesse Newmark 08/13/2018 1.92

Oral argument preparation: review all briefing and declarations Jesse Newmark 08/13/2018 2.00

Oral argument preparation: confer w/co-counsel re: documents and review, research civil code 1632 Jesse Newmark 08/13/2018 1.08

Draft oral argument outline for motion to dismiss Jesse Newmark 08/13/2018 1.83

Oral argument Aidin Castillo 08/14/2018 2.50

Research McGill argument, confer w/co-counsel re: Blair Jesse Newmark 08/14/2018 0.50

Draft oral argument outline for arbitration; final revisions and practice oral arg on both motions Jesse Newmark 08/14/2018 2.67

Oral argument (incl. preparation and commute) Jesse Newmark 08/14/2018 3.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: motion hearing Jesse Newmark 08/14/2018 0.42

Client call Aidin Castillo 08/15/2018 0.30

Confer w/co-counsel re: appeal and discovery, stay Jesse Newmark 08/15/2018 0.17

Review court order on motion to dismiss, sanctions, arbitration; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/20/2018 0.33

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: deposition transcripts and client interviews Jesse Newmark 08/28/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: deadline to file amended tolling claim, strategy and argument Jesse Newmark 08/31/2018 0.17

Calculate deadline, review court order and research law, prepare summary of amendments and questions for 

plaintiffs, confer w/co-counsel and staff Jesse Newmark 09/04/2018 1.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: strategy on amending civil code 1632 Jesse Newmark 09/04/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: civil code 1632 strategy and client responses, initial review Jesse Newmark 09/06/2018 0.33

Detailed review of client responses, confer w/co-counsel and staff re: additional questions and application of law 

to answers, alternative arguments and strategy Jesse Newmark 09/07/2018 0.58

Confer w/co-counsel re: tolling, class certification, discovery; research and draft amended tolling filing Jesse Newmark 09/10/2018 3.00

Confer w/AC re: additional facts Jesse Newmark 09/10/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: filing logistics Jesse Newmark 09/10/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: decision on amendment Jesse Newmark 09/10/2018 0.25

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 09/13/2018 0.08

Review notices of appeal, confer w/co-counsel re: stay of proceedings, ongoing discovery; brief research on 

FAA/interlocutory Jesse Newmark 09/18/2018 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 09/18/2018 0.17

Review appeal filing, briefing order; schedule and confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 09/19/2018 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 09/20/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: discovery review, damages models and experts Jesse Newmark 09/20/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: discovery requests, etc. Jesse Newmark 09/26/2018 0.08

Confer w/AC and AP re: strategy Jesse Newmark 09/26/2018 0.08

Review mediation form, confer w/co-counsel re: relating cases, etc. Jesse Newmark 09/26/2018 0.17

Review mediation form, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 09/26/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 09/27/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: call scheduling Jesse Newmark 10/01/2018 0.08

Confer w/AP re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 10/01/2018 0.08

Review motion to stay / permission to appeal, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 10/09/2018 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: motions and call scheduling Jesse Newmark 10/11/2018 0.08

Call scheduling Jesse Newmark 10/16/2018 0.08

Review discovery, respond to damages model Jesse Newmark 10/17/2018 0.33

Call w/co-counsel re: motions, extension, discovery; confer w/AP Jesse Newmark 10/17/2018 0.50

Find and share sample motion to amend Jesse Newmark 10/17/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: hearing transcript Jesse Newmark 10/18/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel, review templates and local rules, start drafting motions to extend and shorten Jesse Newmark 10/19/2018 1.25

Page 9 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 20 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Revise amended complaint; review third-party subpoenas; review emails and docket for timeline on motion to 

extend; confer w/co-counsel re: issues, next steps Jesse Newmark 10/21/2018 2.75

Draft motion to extend, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 10/22/2018 1.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: revisions and schedule to complete Jesse Newmark 10/22/2018 0.08

Revise opposition to stay, confer w/co-counsel re: monitor removal, draft motion to extend Jesse Newmark 10/23/2018 0.67

Draft motion to extend, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 10/23/2018 0.83

Confer w/co-counsel re: strategy, meet and confer efforts Jesse Newmark 10/24/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: motions to extend and shorten Jesse Newmark 10/24/2018 0.08

Review co-counsel edits to motion to extend, confer re: defendant response, timing, etc. Jesse Newmark 10/25/2018 0.50

Research timing on L.R. 7-2 motion deadline, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 10/25/2018 0.17

Revise motion to extend, amended complaint, and motion to amend Jesse Newmark 10/25/2018 1.00

Confer w/co-counsel re: discovery responses Jesse Newmark 10/26/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel refusal to stipulate Jesse Newmark 10/26/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: UCL amendments Jesse Newmark 10/26/2018 0.08

Revise motion for administrative relief, declaration, proposed order Jesse Newmark 10/29/2018 0.25

Revise motion to amend Jesse Newmark 10/29/2018 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel settlement outreach Jesse Newmark 10/29/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation call, review reply in support of stay Jesse Newmark 10/30/2018 0.25

Fact investigation Aidin Castillo 10/31/2018 2.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: motion for administrative relief, mediation assessment call Jesse Newmark 11/05/2018 0.08

Review mediation statement for new opposing counsel, and confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel settlement 

conversation, etc. Jesse Newmark 11/05/2018 0.25

9th Cir. mediation call Jesse Newmark 11/07/2018 0.50

Confer re: opposing counsel extension requests Jesse Newmark 11/08/2018 0.08

Review of opposition to amend Jesse Newmark 11/13/2018 0.08

Review order granting administrative relief, update deadlines, confer w/co-counsel, etc. Jesse Newmark 11/14/2018 0.25

Review correspondence and confer w/co-counsel re: claims and strategy Jesse Newmark 11/15/2018 0.08

Review correspondence and confer w/co-counsel re: claims and strategy Jesse Newmark 11/15/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 11/19/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: call to discuss settlement terms Jesse Newmark 11/20/2018 0.08

Review reply brief Jesse Newmark 11/20/2018 0.08

Call w/co-counsel re: settlement terms, case strategy, claims, etc. Jesse Newmark 11/20/2018 0.50

Review court order denying stay, etc., confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 11/20/2018 0.17

Revise proposed settlement terms, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 11/20/2018 0.33

Confer w/AP re: case status, settlement terms and review Jesse Newmark 11/20/2018 0.50

Review AP edits to terms, confer re: updates Jesse Newmark 11/20/2018 0.17

Mediation call Jesse Newmark 11/21/2018 0.25

Incorporate AP edits to settlement terms, confer w/co-counsel; review final version Jesse Newmark 11/21/2018 0.17

Corr. w/mediator re: follow-up call Jesse Newmark 11/21/2018 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 11/27/2018 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 11/27/2018 0.08

Revise proposed terms, calculate impact for clients, confer w/AP; mediation call with 9th Cir. Jesse Newmark 11/29/2018 2.00

Confer w/AP re: settlement terms review Jesse Newmark 11/30/2018 0.08

Discuss term revisions and issues w/AP Jesse Newmark 11/30/2018 0.50

Final review and comment revisions, confer w/co-counsel on terms Jesse Newmark 11/30/2018 0.25

Review order on motion to amend, confer w/co-counsel re: call on settlement terms Jesse Newmark 12/03/2018 0.17

Call w/AP and co-counsel re: settlement terms; revise terms Jesse Newmark 12/04/2018 1.58

Confer w/co-counsel re: potential revision to pro rata distribution, calculate examples Jesse Newmark 12/04/2018 0.17

Confer w/AC and AP re: review of defendant's response and meeting Jesse Newmark 12/06/2018 0.08

Confer w/AP re: mediation call Jesse Newmark 12/07/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: meeting Jesse Newmark 12/07/2018 0.08

Call w/co-counsel and staff Alison Pennington 12/10/2018 1.00

Review proposed settlement terms, initial response draft Jesse Newmark 12/10/2018 0.83

Confer w/AP re: settlement terms Jesse Newmark 12/10/2018 0.33

Conf. call w/co-counsel re: settlement terms Jesse Newmark 12/10/2018 1.00

Revise proposed settlement terms, confer w/co-counsel and AP, further revisions Jesse Newmark 12/11/2018 1.00

Discuss proposed terms w/AP Jesse Newmark 12/11/2018 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: total cap strategy Jesse Newmark 12/11/2018 0.17

Confer w/AP re: potential class member follow-up Jesse Newmark 12/11/2018 0.08

Negotiations (incl. preparation, commute, follow-up) Jesse Newmark 12/12/2018 10.75

Research and review financial documents, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 12/14/2018 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: accountant review Jesse Newmark 12/17/2018 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: common fund, fee issues, policy change details and concerns, next steps Jesse Newmark 12/17/2018 0.33

Discuss response to settlement term strategy with AP Jesse Newmark 12/18/2018 0.08

Corr. w/opposing counsel re: concerns Jesse Newmark 12/18/2018 0.50

Prepare settlement term response Jesse Newmark 12/20/2018 0.75

Drafting revised terms, confer w/AP re: review Jesse Newmark 12/22/2018 0.92

Confer w/AP re: proposed terms review; review and finalize draft, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/03/2019 0.75

Confer w/co-counsel and AP re: reviewing terms Jesse Newmark 01/04/2019 0.17

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 01/04/2019 0.08

Page 10 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 21 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Revise proposed terms, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/05/2019 1.25

Conf. call re: LBN term sheet Alison Pennington 01/07/2019 0.50

Call re: proposed terms, strategy Jesse Newmark 01/07/2019 0.67

Corr. w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 01/07/2019 0.08

Fact investigation, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/08/2019 0.17

Fact investigation, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/08/2019 0.08

Revise proposed terms, confer w/co-counsel re: issues (sponsor class, etc.) Jesse Newmark 01/08/2019 0.58

Confer w/co-counsel re: refund subclass issue; class representatives, etc. Jesse Newmark 01/08/2019 0.17

Review co-counsel corr. w/opposing counsel; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/08/2019 0.08

Review contracts for sponsor liability, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/09/2019 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: sponsor liability Jesse Newmark 01/09/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: rescheduling; AP re: preparation Jesse Newmark 01/10/2019 0.17

LBN negotiation call, revise term sheet outline, etc. Jesse Newmark 01/11/2019 1.67

Confer w/AP re: I-391 drafting, etc. Jesse Newmark 01/11/2019 0.08

Confer w/AP re: I-391 drafting, etc. Jesse Newmark 01/14/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation call, rescheduling Jesse Newmark 01/18/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 01/22/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 01/24/2019 0.17

Call w/9th Cir. mediator Jesse Newmark 01/24/2019 0.50

Review scheduling order, calendar new dates Jesse Newmark 01/24/2019 0.08

Draft I-391 alternative and other language, confer w/AP on remaining issues Jesse Newmark 01/28/2019 0.42

Schedule call w/AP re: I-391 / non-disparagement Jesse Newmark 01/28/2019 0.08

Confer w/AP re: I-391 alternatives, revise; discuss non-disparagement issue Jesse Newmark 01/29/2019 0.42

Confer w/AC and co-counsel re: fact investigation; client calls Jesse Newmark 01/31/2019 0.25

Confer w/AP and co-counsel re: fact investigation; client calls Jesse Newmark 01/31/2019 0.08

Fact investigation; client calls; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/31/2019 0.25

Fact investigation; client calls; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/01/2019 0.08

Fact investigation; client calls; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/04/2019 1.00

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 02/04/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation, settlement strategy Jesse Newmark 02/06/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 02/11/2019 0.08

Brief review of defendant's response to terms, confer w/co-counsel re: strategy Jesse Newmark 02/14/2019 0.25

Review and compare settlement terms, outline response Jesse Newmark 02/15/2019 1.00

Call w/co-counsel re: new terms, etc., response, mediation, update chart Jesse Newmark 02/15/2019 0.67

Confer w/co-counsel re: potential mediators Jesse Newmark 02/18/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel response and mediation date Jesse Newmark 02/19/2019 0.08

Revise terms, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/19/2019 0.67

Review stiplation Jesse Newmark 02/21/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement term review Jesse Newmark 02/21/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: subpoena response, and AP re: mediation Jesse Newmark 02/25/2019 0.17

Review AP edits to terms, respond to LBN inquiry, review subpoena Jesse Newmark 02/26/2019 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: subpoena and response Jesse Newmark 02/27/2019 0.08

Review subpoena docs, confer w/co-counsel on release issues Jesse Newmark 02/27/2019 0.17

Review I-391 language, revise terms, confer w/AP and co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/28/2019 0.92

Review term edits and prepare clean and redline versions Jesse Newmark 03/01/2019 0.50

Call w/co-counsel re: term edits, other settlement issues Jesse Newmark 03/01/2019 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: common fund Jesse Newmark 03/01/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation call coverage Jesse Newmark 03/05/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: preparation for mediation Jesse Newmark 03/07/2019 0.08

Revise mediation brief, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/11/2019 0.83

Review final mediation brief, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/12/2019 0.08

Review article, confer w/co-counsel and staff Jesse Newmark 03/13/2019 0.25

Confer w/staff and co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 03/14/2019 0.25

Mediation Alison Pennington 03/15/2019 7.00

Mediation Jesse Newmark 03/15/2019 9.00

Confer w/AP and co-counsel re: update on settlement discussions Jesse Newmark 03/18/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel and AP re: settlement response Jesse Newmark 03/26/2019 0.17

Review LBN proposed settlement terms Alison Pennington 03/27/2019 0.30

Confer w/co-counsel re: response to proposed terms; review defendant's response; prepare outline of changes 

and potential responses Jesse Newmark 03/27/2019 0.83

Confer w/co-counsel and AP re: settlement response, next litigation steps (discovery, subpoenas, etc.) Jesse Newmark 03/29/2019 0.92

Chart outstanding term disagreements and responses; draft counter-proposal term sheet; review opposing 

counsel corr. and confer w/co-counsel on next steps Jesse Newmark 04/04/2019 2.83

Confer w/AC re: scheduling meeting Jesse Newmark 04/05/2019 0.08

Team call Alison Pennington 04/09/2019 1.00

Confer w/AP and AC re: settlement steps Jesse Newmark 04/09/2019 0.17

Review subpoena response records, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 04/09/2019 0.92

Confer w/co-counsel and staff re: next steps on discovery, subpoena response, settlement terms, etc. Jesse Newmark 04/09/2019 1.17

Confer w/AP & AC re: settlement meeting Jesse Newmark 04/10/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: discovery correspondence Jesse Newmark 04/10/2019 0.08

Page 11 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 22 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Meet to discuss term sheet Alison Pennington 04/11/2019 2.00

Meet to discuss term sheet Aidin Castillo 04/11/2019 1.00

Meet w/AC and AP re: settlement response, etc. Jesse Newmark 04/11/2019 2.50

Review term sheet, compare versions, confer w/AP and AC Jesse Newmark 04/11/2019 1.08

Review and revise proposed term sheet Alison Pennington 04/12/2019 0.50

Review and confer w/AP and AC re: revised term sheet Jesse Newmark 04/12/2019 0.17

Review co-counsel responses to terms; confer w/AP and AC re: edits Jesse Newmark 04/15/2019 0.25

Review opposing counsel corr.; confer w/AP re: term sheet and remaining issues; fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/16/2019 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/16/2019 0.08

Confer w/AP and co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/17/2019 0.50

Call w/AP re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/17/2019 0.08

Fact investigation, confer w/staff and co-counsel on next steps; review docs Jesse Newmark 04/17/2019 1.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/17/2019 0.17

Confer w/AC re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/18/2019 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/18/2019 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/18/2019 0.25

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/22/2019 1.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: MTC Jesse Newmark 04/22/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: response to 9th Cir. mediator Jesse Newmark 04/22/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: 9th Cir. call Jesse Newmark 04/23/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC & AP re: 9th Cir. mediation call Jesse Newmark 04/24/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 04/24/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: new mediator strategy and dates Jesse Newmark 04/25/2019 0.17

Discuss opposing counsel response w/AP, next steps for trial Jesse Newmark 04/29/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel and AP re: call w/opposing counsel on settlement terms, discovery letter Jesse Newmark 05/01/2019 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/02/2019 0.42

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/02/2019 0.08

Review deposition decisions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 05/02/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/03/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation strategy; corr. w/opposing counsel on settlement response Jesse Newmark 05/03/2019 0.17

Review opposing counsel response to discovery letter; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 05/07/2019 0.17

Fact investigation Alison Pennington 05/09/2019 1.00

Review M&C letter re: discovery; confer w/co-counsel re: settlement follow-up Jesse Newmark 05/21/2019 0.17

Review opposing counsel correspondence, discovery meet and confer; confer w/co-counsel re: capacity, 

strategy, next steps Jesse Newmark 05/24/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: stay and settlement strategy; bond reseach; confer w/AP and AC Jesse Newmark 05/24/2019 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: bond research, etc, Jesse Newmark 05/29/2019 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel call on terms Jesse Newmark 05/30/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/30/2019 0.17

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/30/2019 0.17

Review scheduling order, update dates and calendar Jesse Newmark 05/30/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: various Jesse Newmark 05/30/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: call w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 05/30/2019 0.08

Review settlement term correspondence / terms, in preparation for call w/opposing counsel; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 05/31/2019 0.25

Review settlement terms, chart, pre-call Jesse Newmark 05/31/2019 0.08

Call w/opposing counsel re: terms, mediation, next steps; confer w/co-counsel re: call and fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/31/2019 1.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation, subpoena Jesse Newmark 05/31/2019 0.08

Confer w/AP re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 06/04/2019 0.08

Confer w/AP and co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 06/11/2019 0.17

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 06/13/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation dates Jesse Newmark 06/13/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation dates Jesse Newmark 06/19/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation dates Jesse Newmark 06/21/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation call coverage Jesse Newmark 07/11/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation correspondence Jesse Newmark 07/20/2019 0.08

Libre premediation call Aidin Castillo 07/30/2019 0.30

Confer w/co-counsel re: post-settlement call w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 08/01/2019 0.08

Schedule meeting, review terms, confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel response, mediation preparation Jesse Newmark 08/05/2019 0.58

Revise mediation brief, confer w/co-counsel and AC re: terms, etc. Jesse Newmark 08/07/2019 0.92

Revise term sheet, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/09/2019 0.17

Review correspondence, confer w/co-counsel re: LBN call Jesse Newmark 08/11/2019 0.42

Confer w/AC re: response to participant inquiries, contacts Jesse Newmark 08/11/2019 0.25

Correspond w/opposing counsel re: other litigation Jesse Newmark 08/11/2019 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/12/2019 0.17

Review terms, prepare comparison chart Jesse Newmark 08/12/2019 0.67

Finalize comparison chart, confer w/co-counsel and AC re: issues for mediation Jesse Newmark 08/12/2019 0.67

Meet w/JN to discuss settlement terms Aidin Castillo 08/13/2019 0.30

Page 12 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 23 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Meet w/AC re: settlement terms, strategy Jesse Newmark 08/13/2019 0.67

Confer w/co-counsel re: estimates, sharing mediation statement, monitoring Jesse Newmark 08/13/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: monitoring and mediation strategy Jesse Newmark 08/13/2019 0.08

Correction to comparison chart, confer w/co-counsel and AC Jesse Newmark 08/14/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation Jesse Newmark 08/15/2019 0.08

Mediation Aidin Castillo 08/16/2019 5.00

Mediation (including preparation and follow-up) Jesse Newmark 08/16/2019 9.75

Discuss strategy and next steps w/AC Jesse Newmark 08/19/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: class representatives / sponsors Jesse Newmark 08/19/2019 0.08

Lien research Jesse Newmark 08/19/2019 0.08

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/22/2019 0.33

Confer w/AC re: mediation strategy Jesse Newmark 08/22/2019 0.17

Review case strategy Jesse Newmark 08/22/2019 0.75

Review draft settlement terms, pleadings, new contracts; assess terms, including monthly payment calculations Jesse Newmark 08/27/2019 2.00

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: settlement strategy, detailed assessment Jesse Newmark 08/27/2019 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: settlement strategy, other issues Jesse Newmark 08/27/2019 0.58

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: settlement strategy, other issues Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 0.33

Assessment of settlement terms, calculations, etc.; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 1.92

Assessment of settlement terms, calculations, etc.; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 1.92

Confer w/co-counsel and revise data requests to opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 0.25

Review LBN documents produced, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: strategy; prepare list of issues Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 0.17

Review AG settlement, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 0.42

Review other litigation, confer w/co-counsel re: strategy Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 0.42

Confer w/co-counsel re: AG impact Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: defendant financial issues Jesse Newmark 08/28/2019 0.08

Meet w/AC to review settlement terms, discuss remaining issues and strategy Jesse Newmark 08/29/2019 1.75

Draft memo re: settlement terms, confer w/AC Jesse Newmark 08/29/2019 0.67

Confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding terms Jesse Newmark 08/29/2019 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding terms Jesse Newmark 08/29/2019 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: strategy call, remaining terms Jesse Newmark 08/29/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding mediation terms, strategy Jesse Newmark 08/29/2019 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding mediation terms, strategy Jesse Newmark 08/29/2019 0.42

Confer w/co-counsel re: response to opposing counsel correspondence on mediation issues, term sheet, etc. Jesse Newmark 08/29/2019 0.17

Confer w/AC re: call strategy Jesse Newmark 08/29/2019 0.08

Draft memo re: remaining term issues to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/30/2019 0.17

Call w/co-counsel re: remaining settlement terms, brief to mediator; follow-up on class representative and other 

case issues, missing contract and principals Jesse Newmark 08/30/2019 1.00

Draft mediator memo on outstanding terms, clarifications, etc.; confer w/AC and co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/30/2019 1.83

Fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/30/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: revisions to mediation brief Jesse Newmark 08/30/2019 0.17

Revise settlement memo, confer w/AC Jesse Newmark 08/30/2019 0.33

Confer w/staff re: settlement strategy Jesse Newmark 08/30/2019 0.08

Confer w/staff re: settlement strategy, approval Jesse Newmark 08/30/2019 0.08

Confer w/staff re: settlement strategy, approval Jesse Newmark 09/01/2019 0.17

Review defendant's new term sheet and corr. w/mediator; revise spreadsheet, counter; memo to co-counsel re: 

outstanding issues; mediator call scheduling and strategy Jesse Newmark 09/03/2019 2.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement term revisions, strategy Jesse Newmark 09/03/2019 0.33

Revise term sheets, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 09/03/2019 0.75

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: revisions, outstanding issues and strategy, class representatives Jesse Newmark 09/03/2019 0.42

Call w/co-counsel and mediator Jesse Newmark 09/03/2019 0.83

Review latest version of terms, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 09/03/2019 0.17

Confer w/AC re: class representative follow-up; confer w/co-counsel re: remaining terms, response Jesse Newmark 09/03/2019 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel, send final terms and explanation to mediator Jesse Newmark 09/03/2019 0.25

Mediation Aidin Castillo 09/04/2019 4.00

Mediation (incl. commute and preparation) Jesse Newmark 09/04/2019 10.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: 9th Circuit call Jesse Newmark 09/09/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement draft strategy, 9th cir. follow-up, etc. Jesse Newmark 09/09/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC re: adding sponsor class representative Jesse Newmark 09/12/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC re: adding sponsor class representative Jesse Newmark 09/13/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC re: adding sponsor class representative Jesse Newmark 09/16/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: sponsor class representative Jesse Newmark 09/17/2019 0.08

Review and revise retainer for sponsor Jesse Newmark 09/17/2019 0.67

Review retainer revisions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 09/24/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel, revise retainer Jesse Newmark 09/24/2019 0.08

Review and revise joint stipulation / proposed order Jesse Newmark 09/30/2019 0.17

Translate retainer, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 09/30/2019 0.75

Confer w/co-counsel, revise retainer Jesse Newmark 10/01/2019 0.08

Page 13 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 24 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Confer w/co-counsel re: retainer Jesse Newmark 10/01/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: call on notice Jesse Newmark 10/01/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 10/02/2019 0.08

Call w/opposing counsel re: notice, confer w/co-counsel on issues Jesse Newmark 10/02/2019 0.58

Review court order granting stipulation, recalendar Jesse Newmark 10/02/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC re: client confidentiality follow-up Jesse Newmark 10/02/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC and co-counsel re: client contact and sponsor retainer Jesse Newmark 10/03/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC re: class representative calls and adding sponsor Jesse Newmark 10/09/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC, finalize retainer and confer w/co-counsel re: signing and confidentiality calls Jesse Newmark 10/10/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 10/10/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 10/10/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement agreement review Jesse Newmark 11/01/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement agreement review Jesse Newmark 11/05/2019 0.08

Revise settlement agreement Jesse Newmark 11/05/2019 0.92

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement agreement revisions Jesse Newmark 11/05/2019 0.08

Revise settlement agreement Jesse Newmark 11/06/2019 1.42

Finalize settlement agreement revisions, compare to term sheet, confer w/co-counsel re: major substantive 

issues, confer w/AC re: review Jesse Newmark 11/06/2019 1.83

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: 2nd distribution, notice to attorneys Jesse Newmark 11/07/2019 0.17

Revise settlement agreement, confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding issues Jesse Newmark 11/08/2019 1.25

Review settlement agreement, confer w/co-counsel re: changes Jesse Newmark 11/08/2019 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel call scheduling, review extension discussion Jesse Newmark 11/13/2019 0.08

Call w/opposing counsel and co-counsel re: settlement agreement issues, next steps Jesse Newmark 11/14/2019 0.58

Confer w/co-counsel re: publication notice Jesse Newmark 11/14/2019 0.08

Revise mot. to amend and fourth amended complaint, research rules on leave when consent Jesse Newmark 11/18/2019 0.83

Confer w/AC re: complaint review Jesse Newmark 11/19/2019 0.08

Confer w/AC, review client transcripts, revise complaint for consistency, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 11/19/2019 1.08

Confer w/AC re: complaint revisions Jesse Newmark 11/19/2019 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel call Jesse Newmark 11/26/2019 0.08

Call w/opposing counsel re: settlement issues, confer w/co-counsel re: next steps Jesse Newmark 11/26/2019 0.58

Confer w/co-counsel re: postcard notice issues Jesse Newmark 11/26/2019 0.08

Review proposed term sheet Alison Pennington 12/12/2019 0.30

Confer w/co-counsel re: postcard notice, strategy w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 12/12/2019 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: postcard notice, strategy w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 12/13/2019 0.08

Review and revise settlement agreement, outline to co-counsel on changes and outstanding issues Jesse Newmark 12/18/2019 2.08

Confer w/co-counsel on settlement agreement issues Jesse Newmark 12/20/2019 0.17

Review corr. on deadline for court report, confer w/AC and co-counsel re: publication list Jesse Newmark 01/06/2020 0.17

Confer w/AC re: locations for notice Jesse Newmark 01/08/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: notice / order review Jesse Newmark 01/08/2020 0.08

Review joint status report and order Jesse Newmark 01/09/2020 0.17

Revise class notice Jesse Newmark 01/09/2020 1.17

Revise notice, compare w/settlement agreement, outline of edits to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/10/2020 2.08

Revise proposed order, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/16/2020 0.33

Review edits and revise class notice and postcard notice, confer w/co-counsel re: class definition issue Jesse Newmark 01/21/2020 0.75

Confer w/AC and co-counsel re: listservs etc. for notice, strategy for including Jesse Newmark 01/23/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement agreement review Jesse Newmark 01/27/2020 0.08

Review term sheet, confer w/co-counsel re: administrative costs Jesse Newmark 01/28/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement agreement review, motion timing Jesse Newmark 01/29/2020 0.08

Research and confer w/AC re: cy pres recipients Jesse Newmark 01/29/2020 0.25

Revise settlement agreement Jesse Newmark 01/29/2020 0.25

Revise settlement agreement, compare versions, memo to co-counsel, confer w/AC re: outstanding issues Jesse Newmark 01/29/2020 1.42

Confer w/AC and co-counsel re: publication notice, revise settlement agreement Jesse Newmark 01/30/2020 0.42

Confer w/AC re: notice review Jesse Newmark 01/30/2020 0.08

Finish research on cy pres, confer w/AC and co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/30/2020 0.50

Revise settlement agreement, add cy pres; confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 01/30/2020 0.08

Review and revise class notices, confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding issues Jesse Newmark 01/30/2020 0.75

Confer w/co-counsel re: settlement agreement revisions, response to opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 02/03/2020 0.17

Revise preliminary approval motion, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/07/2020 0.50

Revise preliminary approval motion, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/09/2020 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: preliminary approval motion revisions, opposing counsel call Jesse Newmark 02/10/2020 0.08

Revise preliminary approval motion, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/10/2020 2.58

Call w/opposing counsel and co-counsel, follow-up Jesse Newmark 02/10/2020 0.75

Confer w/co-counsel re: preliminary approval motion revisions; immigration listserve issue Jesse Newmark 02/10/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: listserve issue Jesse Newmark 02/11/2020 0.08

Review stipulation, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/14/2020 0.08

Confer w/AC re: publication issue from defendants, suggestions Jesse Newmark 02/17/2020 0.25

Review proposed edits, make revisions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/17/2020 0.50

Confer w/AC re: publication issue, solutions; confer w/co-counsel re: final approval alternative Jesse Newmark 02/18/2020 0.42

Confer w/AC and co-counsel re: class representative calls from LBN re: meeting, response Jesse Newmark 02/18/2020 0.25

Page 14 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 25 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Confer w/co-counsel re: various issues Jesse Newmark 02/18/2020 0.08

Call w/co-counsel re: delay, substantive settlement agreement issues Jesse Newmark 02/19/2020 0.25

Call w/opposing counsel re: delays, substantive issues Jesse Newmark 02/19/2020 0.42

Confer w/co-counsel re: publication issue Jesse Newmark 02/19/2020 0.08

9th Cir. mediator call, confer w/co-counsel; confer w/AC re: publication / I-391 issues Jesse Newmark 02/20/2020 0.33

Review and revise settlement agreement edits, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 02/24/2020 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: delays Jesse Newmark 02/28/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: call w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 03/01/2020 0.08

Review status report Jesse Newmark 03/04/2020 0.08

Review proposed order edits, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/06/2020 0.08

Review court order on mediation, confer w/co-counsel re: mediator follow-up Jesse Newmark 03/09/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediator follow-up Jesse Newmark 03/09/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediator communication Jesse Newmark 03/10/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediator update Jesse Newmark 03/11/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation Jesse Newmark 03/18/2020 0.08

Review LBN correspondence, confer w/AC Jesse Newmark 03/23/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel correspondence on mediation / COVID impact, response; initial review 

of term sheet enforceability Jesse Newmark 03/25/2020 0.17

Review response confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/26/2020 0.08

Revise status report, review opposing counsel edits, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 03/31/2020 0.25

Review court order on mediation / motion to enforce, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 04/03/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation timing and strategy Jesse Newmark 04/03/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation date, length, call Jesse Newmark 04/06/2020 0.17

Call w/co-counsel re: mediation issues, motion to enforce, etc. Jesse Newmark 04/07/2020 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation scheduling Jesse Newmark 04/09/2020 0.08

Review opposing counsel correspondence, status report Jesse Newmark 04/10/2020 0.08

Calendar mediation Jesse Newmark 04/13/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: drafting mediation brief Jesse Newmark 05/05/2020 0.17

Review documents in preparation for mediation brief Jesse Newmark 05/05/2020 0.33

Review status conference statements, prior mediation brief, court orders, and email corr. in preparation for 

mediation brief Jesse Newmark 05/05/2020 1.17

Draft and revise mediation brief Jesse Newmark 05/05/2020 4.58

Confer w/co-counsel re: brief draft, mediation preparation Jesse Newmark 05/05/2020 0.17

Compare final versions of documents Jesse Newmark 05/05/2020 0.08

Review edits, confer w/co-counsel; review final mediation brief Jesse Newmark 05/06/2020 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: mediation, motion to enforce Jesse Newmark 05/12/2020 0.08

Mediation Aidin Castillo 05/13/2020 6.50

Mediation, incl. drafting of orders / settlement agreement, research on motion to enforce, research on assets, 

data and prior contract, etc. Jesse Newmark 05/13/2020 10.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: notice to court Jesse Newmark 05/14/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: preliminary approval motion timing, tasks Jesse Newmark 05/14/2020 0.08

Review fourth amended complaint versions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 05/14/2020 0.17

Review joint status report, confer w/co-counsel, corr. w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 05/15/2020 0.17

Review N.D. guidance on preliminary approval motion; revise class notice based on guidance and updated 

settlement agreement; revise additional notices, motion, order Jesse Newmark 05/18/2020 3.42

Revise proposed final order Jesse Newmark 05/21/2020 0.25

Revise final order, add injunctive relief, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 05/21/2020 0.58

Revise preliminary approval motion Jesse Newmark 05/21/2020 3.08

Revise preliminary approval motion Jesse Newmark 05/21/2020 0.75

Revise preliminary approval motion, review N.D. guidelines, add comments and email memo to co-counsel Jesse Newmark 05/22/2020 1.58

Review court orders on service awards and fees, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 05/22/2020 0.50

Review settlement agreement exhibits, confer w/co-counsel on strategy Jesse Newmark 05/22/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: preliminary approval motion docs to opposing counsel; fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/22/2020 0.08

Call clients re: cy pres recipients Aidin Castillo 05/25/2020 0.50

Confer w/AC re: cy pres issues, revise preliminary approval motion Jesse Newmark 05/25/2020 0.17

Confer w/AC re: cy pres issues, revise preliminary approval motion Jesse Newmark 05/26/2020 0.08

Confer w/AC re: time entries Jesse Newmark 05/26/2020 0.08

Revise preliminary approval motion, add cy pres and minor changes; confer w/co-counsel on outstanding issues 

(representative declarations, lodestar, etc.) Jesse Newmark 05/27/2020 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 05/28/2020 0.08

Corr. w/opposing counsel, and confer w/co-counsel re: 9th Cir. mediation call Jesse Newmark 05/29/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: declaration Jesse Newmark 05/29/2020 0.08

Review and edit declaration in support of preliminary approval Aidin Castillo 06/01/2020 0.70

Revise opposing counsel edits to final order, review settlement agreement, confer w/co-counsel re: review and 

next steps (declaration drafting) Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.25

Confer w/AC re: hours, declaration, service award facts Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.33

Confer w/co-counsel re: declaration division Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.08

Research court fee orders Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: fee info needed for preliminary approval, provide sample language Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: strategy on multiple declarations Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.17

Page 15 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 26 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Time entry review Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.67

Review substantive work for declaration Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.67

Draft declaration Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 1.17

Review AC declaration revisions, confer Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.25

Revise co-counsel declaration in support of preliminary approval motion Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 0.92

Revise final approval order, review settlement agreement for compliance, confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding 

issues Jesse Newmark 06/01/2020 1.00

Review settlement agreement with GPO and KC Aidin Castillo 06/02/2020 0.50

Review settlement agreement with JQV Aidin Castillo 06/02/2020 0.50

Review settlement agreement with VCM Aidin Castillo 06/02/2020 0.50

Review final approval order, confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding issue on debt relief timing, review settlement 

agreement Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.33

Review preliminary approval motion revisions, add paragraph on admin selection, etc., based on opposing 

counsel's email, review guidelines for compliance Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.42

Revise administrator declaration, confer w/co-counsel re: class member estimate numbers Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.42

Revise co-counsel declarations in support of motion to amend and preliminary approval motion, confer re: 

lodestar guidelines Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.33

Review calculation guidelines, confer w/co-counsel re: data needed; review term sheet and settlement 

agreement, confer w/co-counsel on f/u w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.42

Finalize lodestar calculations, update matrix Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.58

Call w/opposing counsel re: preliminary approval motion issues (data, etc.); call w/co-counsel re: response and 

incorporating in preliminary approval motion, etc. Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.83

Initial outline of updated valuation section based on opposing counsel call, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.42

Respond to opposing counsel re: revisions to final approval order Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.17

Finalize declaration (service award section, etc.), confer w/AC re: review, and co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 1.50

Final revisions and sign declaration in support of preliminary approval motion Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.17

Review, confer w/co-counsel, and corr. w/opposing counsel re: additional language for final approval order Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: client signatures, confer w/AC, finalize settlement Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 1.42

Final review and revisions to final approval order Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.33

Review and finalize preliminary approval order, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.33

Final review and revise preliminary approval motion (redraft valuation section, calculate numbers, etc.), confer 

w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 1.75

Finalize proposed order, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.08

Download and review preliminary approval motion and motion to amend filings Jesse Newmark 06/02/2020 0.17

Review LBN article, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 06/03/2020 0.08

Review and confer w/AC re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 06/18/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 06/22/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 06/22/2020 0.08

Update co-counsel on call timing Jesse Newmark 06/24/2020 0.08

Fact investigation, confer w/AC Jesse Newmark 06/24/2020 0.58

Confer w/co-counsel re: various Jesse Newmark 06/25/2020 0.08

Review file for preliminary approval hearing Jesse Newmark 06/26/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: preliminary approval hearing coverage / attendance strategy Jesse Newmark 07/15/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: oral argument, etc. Jesse Newmark 07/15/2020 0.17

Confer w/CC re: preliminary approval hearing Aidin Castillo 07/20/2020 0.80

Call GPO re: LBN payment status Aidin Castillo 07/20/2020 0.30

Call JQV re: LBN payment status Aidin Castillo 07/20/2020 0.25

Call VCM re: LBN payment status Aidin Castillo 07/20/2020 0.20

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: oral argument Jesse Newmark 07/20/2020 0.17

Confer w/AC re: preliminary approval hearing, documents for review; corr. w/court re: attendance Jesse Newmark 07/20/2020 0.33

Review state AG settlements, LBN release on monitor removal, in preparation for preliminary approval Jesse Newmark 07/20/2020 0.25

Review CA DOI settlement, confer w/co-counsel re: strategy; call rescheduling Jesse Newmark 07/20/2020 0.25

Review preliminary approval, declarations, settlement, notices, and motion to amend, in preparation for 

preliminary approval hearing Jesse Newmark 07/20/2020 1.92

Preliminary approval motion hearing Aidin Castillo 07/21/2020 0.80

Review AG settlements, etc., confer w/co-counsel on strategy / comparison, notice issues, residual distribution, 

etc. Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 0.75

Preliminary approval hearing call w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 0.83

Review prior assessments, data, and contracts from defendant; prepare assessment of economic impact of 

injunctive relief / incl. class representatives specifically Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 1.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: preliminary approval hearing coordination, opposing counsel call Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 0.08

Confer w/AC re: class representative settlement impact information for preliminary approval hearing Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 0.17

Call w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 0.33

Preliminary approval hearing Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 1.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: next steps on preliminary approval Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 0.25

Prepare rough transcript of hearing, outline of changes needed and strategy, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 1.58

Revise settlement agreement, ameded complaint, and notices post-preliminary approval hearing, confer w/cocounsel re: changes, outstanding issues, and strategy Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 2.75

Confer w/co-counsel re: data from opposing counsel for comparison Jesse Newmark 07/21/2020 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: final document versions for revisions, revise fourth amended complaint Jesse Newmark 07/22/2020 0.17

Page 16 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 27 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Confer w/co-counsel re: preliminary order revisions, call w/opposing counsel, revise notices, and outline issues 

for opposing counsel call Jesse Newmark 07/22/2020 0.67

Confer w/co-counsel re: debt relief issues, review settlement agreement revisions Jesse Newmark 07/22/2020 0.17

Review proposed preliminary / final approval order revisions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/22/2020 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: call to opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 07/22/2020 0.08

Call w/opposing counsel re: revisions and data needed for supplemental preliminary approval briefing Jesse Newmark 07/22/2020 0.83

Confer w/co-counsel re: opposing counsel call, next steps Jesse Newmark 07/22/2020 0.17

Draft summary of outstanding issues post-opposing counsel call, organize revised documents, confer w/cocounsel Jesse Newmark 07/22/2020 0.42

Review and revise settlement agreement, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/24/2020 0.67

Confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding settlement agreement issues Jesse Newmark 07/24/2020 0.17

Revise settlement agreement, confer w/co-counsel re: outstanding issues, call, filing Jesse Newmark 07/24/2020 0.75

Review settlement agreement revisions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/24/2020 0.17

Revise settlement agreement, confer w/co-counsel re: final issue on related claims Jesse Newmark 07/24/2020 0.42

Draft supplemental brief, further settlement agreement and notice revisions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/24/2020 1.75

Draft supplemental brief, further settlement agreement and notice revisions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/24/2020 1.50

Draft supplemental brief, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/26/2020 3.00

Review and revise supplemental brief, confer w/co-counsel re: notices Jesse Newmark 07/27/2020 0.67

Confer w/co-counsel re: timetable edits, next steps Jesse Newmark 07/27/2020 0.08

Review opposing counsel edits to agreement, notice, order, and brief; briefly research objector status; confer 

w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.58

Confer w/co-counsel and AC re: next steps on submission, dates, edits, class representative execution, etc. Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.25

Revise agreement, confer w/co-counsel, corr. w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.50

Review detailed notice, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.08

Final revisions to agreement, corr. w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.33

Revise class notice Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.50

Revise postcard notice, confer w/AC re: Spanish revisions Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.33

Corr. w/opposing counsel and confer w/co-counsel re: final fairness hearing, review transcript, write and call 

court Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.50

Review valuation addition to status report, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel re: status report, review Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.17

Revise supplemental brief, add monthly refund, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 0.75

Review and finalize clean versions of documents for submission; revise proposed orders and notice dates; revise 

supplemental brief, confer w/co-counsel on next steps Jesse Newmark 07/28/2020 1.75

Confer w/co-counsel re: supplemental brief, declaration, and notice revisions, prepare redline and finalize clean 

versions, corr. w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 1.17

Review and revise clean and redline exhibits, corr. w/opposing counsel, prepare publication notice, revise 

supplemental brief and declaration Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 1.17

Corr. w/opposing counsel re: response deadline Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 0.08

Revise supplemental brief and declaration confer w/co-counsel on additional calculations Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 0.33

Revise supplemental brief and declaration confer w/co-counsel on additional calculations Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 0.67

Review opposing counsel revisions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 0.25

Incorporate opposing counsel revisions, prepare new versions, add exhibit sheets / parentheticals, corr. 

w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 0.58

Finalize agreement signatures, prepare executed combined documents, corr. w/opposing counsel Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 0.42

Revise supplemental brief and declaration, and debt relief addition, etc., revise fourth amended complaint, confer 

w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 1.00

Last review and finalize filing, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 0.58

Prepare proposed order for email to court Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel, download filed versions Jesse Newmark 07/29/2020 0.08

Fact investigation, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/30/2020 0.17

Corr. w/court re: final fairness hearing Jesse Newmark 07/30/2020 0.08

Review preliminary approval / motion to amend order, calendar dates, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 07/31/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: class notice, filing complaint, etc, Jesse Newmark 08/05/2020 0.08

Review publication notice revisions, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/18/2020 0.08

Confer w/AC re: fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/18/2020 0.08

Initial research on affirmative defense waiver; confer w/AC and co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/18/2020 0.50

Confer w/co-counsel re: defense waiver issue, fact investigation Jesse Newmark 08/19/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: defense waiver issue Jesse Newmark 08/19/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: response to alleged settlement agreement violations Jesse Newmark 08/21/2020 0.17

Review opposing counsel corr. on notice issues; confer w/co-counsel re: proposed revisions, revise text notice Jesse Newmark 08/21/2020 0.25

Confer w/co-counsel and corr. w/opposing counsel re: text notice revisions Jesse Newmark 08/21/2020 0.25

Corr. w/opposing counsel re: alleged settlement agreement violations, contact Jesse Newmark 08/21/2020 0.25

Review opposing counsel response on defense waiver issue, confer w/co-counsel on response / strategy Jesse Newmark 08/21/2020 0.25

Review court order, confer w/co-counsel re: fee / service award application; strategy on review Jesse Newmark 08/22/2020 0.25

Initial review publication notice translation, confer w/AC Jesse Newmark 08/24/2020 0.17

Review time entries Jesse Newmark 08/25/2020 4.00

Review time entries Jesse Newmark 08/26/2020 0.67

Page 17 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 28 of 29
Time Entry Attorney Date Hours

Confer w/co-counsel re: response to opposing counsel on affirmative defense issue, strategy Jesse Newmark 08/26/2020 0.58

Confer w/AC re: time entries, service award decl. facts Jesse Newmark 08/26/2020 0.17

Review time entries Jesse Newmark 08/26/2020 0.17

Confer w/co-counsel re: response to opposing counsel on affirmative defense issue, strategy Jesse Newmark 08/26/2020 1.00

Review text notice translation, opposing counsel corr. on weblink Jesse Newmark 08/27/2020 0.08

Review time entries, confer w/co-counsel re: fee motion Jesse Newmark 08/27/2020 0.08

Prepare fee motion summary for declaration Jesse Newmark 08/27/2020 0.67

Corr. w/opposing counsel re: affirmative defense issue Jesse Newmark 08/27/2020 0.92

Prepare outline of client activities and questions for service awards; confer w/AC Jesse Newmark 08/27/2020 0.25

Call client GPO re: declaration Aidin Castillo 08/28/2020 0.20

Confer w/co-counsel re: fee motion review timing, service awards Jesse Newmark 08/28/2020 0.42

Call client VCM re: declaration Aidin Castillo 08/30/2020 0.20

Update AC time entries, confer w/AC Jesse Newmark 08/30/2020 0.08

Revise fee and service award motion, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/30/2020 0.25

Review prior fee and service award motions, preliminary approval declaration and motion Jesse Newmark 08/30/2020 1.67

Draft declaration in support of final approval; confer w/co-counsel and AC re: client declarations, other issues Jesse Newmark 08/30/2020 0.58

Call client JQV to prepare declaration Aidin Castillo 08/31/2020 0.50

Call client GPO to prepare declaration Aidin Castillo 08/31/2020 0.50

Call client VCM to prepare declaration Aidin Castillo 08/31/2020 0.50

Call client KC to prepare declaration Aidin Castillo 08/31/2020 0.50

Call client JQV to review declaration Aidin Castillo 08/31/2020 0.30

Call client GPO to review declaration Aidin Castillo 08/31/2020 0.30

Call client VCM to review declaration Aidin Castillo 08/31/2020 0.30

Call client KC to review declaration Aidin Castillo 08/31/2020 0.30

Review GPO activities Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 1.92

Prepare declaration for client GPO, confer w/co-counsel and AC Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.17

Corr. w/opposing counsel re: contact for issues Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.92

Confer w/co-counsel re: affirmative defense issue, response to inquiry Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.08

Confer w/co-counsel re: response to affirmative defense inquiry Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.08

Prepare declaration for client JQV, confer w/co-counsel and AC Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.08

Revise GPO declaration post-client call Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.75

Review co-counsel revisions to GPO declaration Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.42

Review prior service award orders, confer w/co-counsel Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.08

Review deposition transcripts, confer w/AC re: sponsor and partner depositions Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.17

Prepare declaration for client VCM, confer w/co-counsel and AC Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.33

Confer w/AC re: deposition review, signatures, follow-up re: client KC Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.83

Prepare declaration for client KC, confer w/AC Jesse Newmark 08/31/2020 0.17

766.80

Page 18 of 18

Case 4:17-cv-00755-CW Document 147-3 Filed 09/01/20 Page 29 of 29