1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

 17-cv-00600-LB

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST 

MIRIAM KIM (State Bar No. 238230) 

miriam.kim@mto.com 

EMILY C. CURRAN-HUBERTY (State Bar No. 293065) 

emily.curran-huberty@mto.com 

SKYLAR D. BROOKS (State Bar No. 310707) 

skylar.brooks@mto.com 

MUNGER, TOLLES & OLSON LLP 

560 Mission Street 

Twenty-Seventh Floor 

San Francisco, California 94105-2907 

Telephone: (415) 512-4000 

Facsimile: (415) 512-4077 

Attorneys for Plaintiff 

RENEE LEPAGE 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA, SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION 

RENEE LEPAGE, an individual, 

Plaintiff, 

vs. 

COUNTY OF NAPA; COUNTY OF NAPA 

SHERIFF’S DEPARTMENT; AND DEPUTY 

TIMOTHY REID, 

Defendants. 

 Case No. 3:17-cv-00600-LB 

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST 

Judge: Hon. Laurel Beeler 

Crtrm.: B – 15th Floor 

Trial Date.: October 15, 2019 

Case 3:17-cv-00600-LB Document 146 Filed 10/14/19 Page 1 of 9
LePage v. County of Napa, Reid, et al.

USDC Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, Case No. 17‐cv‐00600‐LB

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

10/14/2019

TRIAL 

EXHIBIT 

NO.

BEGBATES ENDBATES DATE DESCRIPTION STIPULATION OFFERED INTO 

EVIDENCE

ADMITTED 

INTO 

EVIDENCE

SPONSORING 

WITNESS

LIM

001 CON (LePage) (Supp) 

000014

CON (LePage) (Supp) 000145

0/0/2012 Napa County Sheriff's Department, 

Procedures Manual, Napa County Sheriff's Office, Court Security Division

901; 

002 CON (LePage) (Supp) 

000147

CON (LePage) (Supp) 000164

12/1/2015 Napa County Sheriff's Department Case 

Summary Report, Case Number NSD15‐005270 & Attachments 901;

003 n/a n/a 12/7/2015 Napa County Sheriff's Department Case 

Summary Report, Case Number NSD15‐005372 & attached Supplement Notes & Handwritten Note

901;

004 CON (LePage) (Pltf 

Amended RFP, Set One) 000001

CON (LePage) (Pltf Amended RFP, Set One) 000013

5/24/2016 Claim Against the County of Napa, No. 16‐

955 & Attachments

901;

005 CON (LePage) (Supp) 

000175

CON (LePage) (Supp) 000182

9/22/2017 Policy 300, Use of Force, Napa County 

Sheriff's Office, Napa County SO Policy Manual 901;

006 CON (LePage) (Supp) 

000183

CON (LePage) (Supp) 000185

9/22/2017 Policy 100, Law Enforcement Authority, 

Napa County Sheriff's Office, Napa County SO Policy Manual 901;

007 CON (LePage) (Supp) 

000190

CON (LePage) (Supp) 000199

11/14/2017 Commission on Peace Officer Standards 

and Training Report: Timothy Conrad Reid & Certificate

901;

008 CON (LePage) (Supp) 

000190

CON (LePage) (Supp) 000193

11/14/2017 Excerpt, Commission on Peace Officer 

Standards and Training Report: Timothy Conrad Reid

901;

* Plaintiff's Hearsay objections apply to potential use by Defendants. 1 of 8

Case 3:17-cv-00600-LB Document 146 Filed 10/14/19 Page 2 of 9
LePage v. County of Napa, Reid, et al.

USDC Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, Case No. 17‐cv‐00600‐LB

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

10/14/2019

TRIAL 

EXHIBIT 

NO.

BEGBATES ENDBATES DATE DESCRIPTION STIPULATION OFFERED INTO 

EVIDENCE

ADMITTED 

INTO 

EVIDENCE

SPONSORING 

WITNESS

LIM

009 n/a n/a 2/13/2018 Policy 324, Standards of Conduct, Napa 

County Sheriff's Office, Napa County SO Policy Manual 901;

010 n/a n/a 2/13/2018 Policy 300, Use of Force, Napa County 

Sheriff's Office, Napa County SO Policy Manual 901;

011 n/a n/a 6/12/2018 Notice of Taking Deposition of 30(b)(6) 

Witness (County of Napa and County of Napa Sheriff's Department) 901;

012 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN013 LePage_0000718 LePage_0000718 0/0/2015 Photograph of Plaintiff Renee LePage 901;

014 LePage_0000208 LePage_0000209 Arizona State University Unofficial 

Transcript, Renee Marie LePage 901; 803(6)

015

LePage_0000702 LePage_0000703

8/11/2016 Arizona State University ‐ Medical 

Withdrawal Request Approval for Spring 2016 901; 803(6)

016 LePage_0000704 LePage_0000704 8/25/2017 Arizona State University ‐ Medical 

Withdrawal Request Approval for Spring 2017 901; 803(6)

017

LePage_0000701 LePage_0000701

2/2/2018 Arizona State University ‐ Request for 

Documented Medical/Compassionate Withdrawal 901; 803(6)

018 LePage_0000705 LePage_0000705 3/29/2018

Arizona State University ‐ Medical Withdrawal Request Approval for Fall 2017 901; 803(6)

019 LePage_0000714 LePage_0000715 5/22/2019 Arizona State University ‐ Medical 

Withdrawal Request Approval for Spring 2019 901;

020 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Errata: Expert Report of Eric A. Madsen

901;

021 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 1 to Expert Report of Eric A. 

Madsen ‐ Estimate of Ms. LePage's Annual Wages After Graduation 901;

022 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 2 to Expert Report of Eric A. 

Madsen ‐ Estimate of Ms. LePage's Employment Benefits as a Percentage of Wages 901;

023 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 3 to Expert Report of Eric A. 

Madsen ‐ Employment Rates (White Women by Age, US) 901;

* Plaintiff's Hearsay objections apply to potential use by Defendants. 2 of 8

Case 3:17-cv-00600-LB Document 146 Filed 10/14/19 Page 3 of 9
LePage v. County of Napa, Reid, et al.

USDC Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, Case No. 17‐cv‐00600‐LB

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

10/14/2019

TRIAL 

EXHIBIT 

NO.

BEGBATES ENDBATES DATE DESCRIPTION STIPULATION OFFERED INTO 

EVIDENCE

ADMITTED 

INTO 

EVIDENCE

SPONSORING 

WITNESS

LIM

024 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 4 to Expert Report of Eric A. 

Madsen ‐ Historical Wage Growth vs. Historical Inflation 901;

025 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 5 to Expert Report of Eric A. 

Madsen ‐ Discount Rate Based on Income‐Oriented Portfolio 901;

026 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 6 to Expert Report of Eric A. 

Madsen ‐ Present Value of Ms. LePage's Lost Wages and Benefits as of December 31, 2018  901;

027 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 7 to Expert Report of Eric A. 

Madsen ‐ Present Value of Ms. LePage's Cost to Hire A Personal Care Aide as of December 31, 2018 901;

028 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 8 to Expert Report of Eric A. 

Madsen ‐ Medical Costs Resulting from Ms. LePage's Injuries 901;

029 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 9 to Expert Report of Eric Madsen ‐ 

Historical Inflation of Medical Care Costs to Consumers 901;

030 n/a n/a 7/16/2018 Exhibit 10 to Expert Report of Eric A. 

Madsen ‐ Present Value of Ms. LePage's Future Medical Costs 901;

031 OLE Health Napa 

000001

OLE Health Napa 000002

6/27/2017 OLE Health Clinic Affidavit

901;

032 OLE Health Napa 

000166

OLE Health Napa 000171

4/25/2016 OLE Health Account Statement (through 

4/25/2016) 

901;

033 Fairfield 000001 Fairfield 000002 4/27/2018 Fairfield Post Acute Rehab Affidavit  901;034 Fairfield 000113 Fairfield 000113 4/24/2018 Fairfield Post Acute Rehab Billing 

Statement

901;

035 UCSF MCB 000001 UCSF MCB 000002 6/27/2017 UCSF Medical Center Affidavit  901;036 UCSF MCB 000003 UCSF MCB 000003 6/20/2017 UCSF Medical Center Detail Bill (October 

18, 2016)

901;

037 UCSF MGBS 000001 UCSF MGBS 000002 6/27/2017 UCSF Medical Center Affidavit ‐ Regarding 

MGBS documents 901;

038 UCSF MGBS 000006 UCSF MGBS 000006 6/20/2017 UCSF Medical Center Detail Bill (May 9, 

2016)

901;

* Plaintiff's Hearsay objections apply to potential use by Defendants. 3 of 8

Case 3:17-cv-00600-LB Document 146 Filed 10/14/19 Page 4 of 9
LePage v. County of Napa, Reid, et al.

USDC Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, Case No. 17‐cv‐00600‐LB

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

10/14/2019

TRIAL 

EXHIBIT 

NO.

BEGBATES ENDBATES DATE DESCRIPTION STIPULATION OFFERED INTO 

EVIDENCE

ADMITTED 

INTO 

EVIDENCE

SPONSORING 

WITNESS

LIM

039 UCSF MGBS 000007 UCSF MGBS 000007 6/20/2017 UCSF Medical Center Detail Bill (October 

18, 2016)

901;

040 UCSF MGBS 000008 UCSF MGBS 000008 6/20/2017 UCSF Medical Center Detail Bill (October 

18, 2016 radiographs) 

901;

041 UCSF MGBS 000009 UCSF MGBS 000009 6/20/2017 UCSF Medical Center Detail Bill (February 

8, 2017)

901;

042 QOV 000001 QOV 000002 4/27/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Affidavit ‐ 

Patient Accounts 901;

043 QOV 000026 QOV 000026 12/5/2015 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 12/1/15 services

901;

044 QOV 000025 QOV 000025 1/15/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 1/12/16 services 

901;

045 QOV 000024 QOV 000024 1/23/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 1/20/16 services 

901;

046 QOV 000003 QOV 000003 3/23/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 3/18/16 services

901;

047 QOV 000023 QOV 000023 3/23/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 3/18/2016 services 

901;

048 QOV 000005 QOV 000005 6/8/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 5/10/16 occupational therapy services 901;

049 QOV 000022 QOV 000022 6/8/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 5/10/16 services 

901;

050 QOV 000019 QOV 000019 10/6/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 9/16/16, 9/19/16 & 9/27/16 services  901;

051 QOV 000007 QOV 000007 10/7/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 9/16/16, 9/19/16 & 9/27/16 physical therapy services 901;

052 QOV 000018 QOV 000018 11/6/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 10/19/16 & 10/26/16 services 

901;

* Plaintiff's Hearsay objections apply to potential use by Defendants. 4 of 8

Case 3:17-cv-00600-LB Document 146 Filed 10/14/19 Page 5 of 9
LePage v. County of Napa, Reid, et al.

USDC Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, Case No. 17‐cv‐00600‐LB

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

10/14/2019

TRIAL 

EXHIBIT 

NO.

BEGBATES ENDBATES DATE DESCRIPTION STIPULATION OFFERED INTO 

EVIDENCE

ADMITTED 

INTO 

EVIDENCE

SPONSORING 

WITNESS

LIM

053 QOV 000008 QOV 000008 11/7/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 10/19/16 & 10/26/16 physical services 901;

054 QOV 000009 QOV 000009 11/11/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 11/4/2016 CT Scan 

901;

055 QOV 000017 QOV 000017 11/11/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 11/4/16 CT Scan

901;

056 QOV 000016 QOV 000016 12/6/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 11/16/16 services 

901;

057 QOV 000010 QOV 000010 12/7/2016 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 11/16/16 physical therapy services  901;

058 QOV 000012 QOV 000012 7/6/2017 Queen of the Valley Hospital Billing 

Statement regarding 7/6/17 X‐ray 

901;

059 QOV 000011 QOV 000011 8/18/2017 Queen of the Valley Hospital Billing 

Statement regarding 8/14/17 CT Scan and services  901;

060 QOV 000013 QOV 000013 4/6/2018 Queen of the Valley Hospital Invoice 

regarding 3/8/18 & 3/22/18 services 

901;

061 LePage_0000024 LePage_0000024 11/16/2015 Dr. Soren Andreas Singel's Progress Notes, 

UCSF Medical Center 901; 803(6)

062 LePage_0000027 LePage_0000027 5/9/2016 Dr. Soren Andreas Singel's Progress Notes, 

UCSF Medical Center

901; 803(6)

063 LePage_0000096 LePage_0000096 10/18/2016 X‐rays of Lumbar Spine Report, UCSF 

Medical Center 901; 803(6)

064 LePage_0000097 LePage_0000097 10/18/2016 X‐rays of Scoliosis Report, UCSF Medical 

Center 901; 803(6)

065 LePage_0000088 LePage_0000088 10/18/2016 X‐rays of Cervical Spine Report, UCSF 

Medical Center 901; 803(6)

066 LePage_0000090 LePage_0000091 10/18/2016 Medical Progress Notes from Dr. Aaron 

John Clark, UCSF Medical Center

901; 803(6)

067 LePage_0000184 LePage_0000185 10/18/2016 MRI Images of Cervical Spine, UCSF 

Medical Center 901; 803(6)

068 LePage_0000186 LePage_0000187 10/18/2016 MRI Images of Lumbar Spine, UCSF 

Medical Center 901; 803(6)

* Plaintiff's Hearsay objections apply to potential use by Defendants. 5 of 8

Case 3:17-cv-00600-LB Document 146 Filed 10/14/19 Page 6 of 9
LePage v. County of Napa, Reid, et al.

USDC Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, Case No. 17‐cv‐00600‐LB

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

10/14/2019

TRIAL 

EXHIBIT 

NO.

BEGBATES ENDBATES DATE DESCRIPTION STIPULATION OFFERED INTO 

EVIDENCE

ADMITTED 

INTO 

EVIDENCE

SPONSORING 

WITNESS

LIM

069 LePage_0000188 LePage_0000195 10/18/2016 MRI Images of Scoliosis, UCSF Medical 

Center 901; 803(6)

070 LePage_0000216 LePage_0000216 12/22/2017 Surgical Records from Dr. Aaron John 

Clark, UCSF Medical Center 901; 803(6)

071 LePage_0000223 LePage_0000224 12/21/2017 Surgical Records from Dr. Aaron John 

Clark, UCSF Medical Center 901; 803(6)

072 LePage_0000259 LePage_0000259 12/22/2017 X‐rays of Scoliosis Report, UCSF Medical 

Center 901; 803(6)

073 LePage_0000461 LePage_0000468 12/22/2017 MRI Images of Scoliosis, UCSF Medical 

Center 901; 803(6)

074 LePage_0000100 LePage_0000102 2/8/2017 Medical Progress Notes from Dr. Scott 

Collins Berta, UCSF Medical Center 901; 803(6)

075 LePage_0000030 LePage_0000035 1/20/2016 Emergency Department Report, Queen of 

the Valley Medical Center 901; 803(6)

076 LePage_0000041 LePage_0000042 3/18/2016 MRI Imaging Services Report of Cervical 

Spine, Queen of the Valley Medical Center

901; 803(6)

077 LePage_0000151 LePage_0000183 3/18/2016 MRI Images of Lumbar Spine, Queen of the 

Valley Medical Center 901; 803(6)

078 LePage_0000098 LePage_0000099 11/4/2016 CT Imaging Services Report of Cervical 

Spine, Queen of the Valley Medical Center

901; 803(6)

079 LePage_0000210 LePage_0000212 12/20/2017 Medical Progress Notes from Dr. Colleen 

M. Townsend, OLE Health 901; 803(6)

080 n/a n/a 9/11/2019 Affidavit of Custodian of Records of UCSF 

Medical Center, Radiology Department

081 n/a n/a Affidavit of Custodian of Records of Queen 

of the Valley Medical Center

082 n/a n/a 9/10/2019 Affidavit of Custodian of Records of OLE 

Health 

083 n/a n/a Affidavit of Custodian of Records of UCSF 

Medical Center

084 LePage_0000719 LePage_0000719 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

085 LePage_0000720 LePage_0000720 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

* Plaintiff's Hearsay objections apply to potential use by Defendants. 6 of 8

Case 3:17-cv-00600-LB Document 146 Filed 10/14/19 Page 7 of 9
LePage v. County of Napa, Reid, et al.

USDC Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, Case No. 17‐cv‐00600‐LB

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

10/14/2019

TRIAL 

EXHIBIT 

NO.

BEGBATES ENDBATES DATE DESCRIPTION STIPULATION OFFERED INTO 

EVIDENCE

ADMITTED 

INTO 

EVIDENCE

SPONSORING 

WITNESS

LIM

086 LePage_0000721 LePage_0000721 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

087 LePage_0000722 LePage_0000722 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

088 LePage_0000723 LePage_0000723 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

089 LePage_0000724 LePage_0000724 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

090 LePage_0000725 LePage_0000725 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

091 LePage_0000726 LePage_0000726 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

092 LePage_0000727 LePage_0000727 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

093 LePage_0000728 LePage_0000728 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

094 LePage_0000729 LePage_0000729 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

* Plaintiff's Hearsay objections apply to potential use by Defendants. 7 of 8

Case 3:17-cv-00600-LB Document 146 Filed 10/14/19 Page 8 of 9
LePage v. County of Napa, Reid, et al.

USDC Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, Case No. 17‐cv‐00600‐LB

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

10/14/2019

TRIAL 

EXHIBIT 

NO.

BEGBATES ENDBATES DATE DESCRIPTION STIPULATION OFFERED INTO 

EVIDENCE

ADMITTED 

INTO 

EVIDENCE

SPONSORING 

WITNESS

LIM

095 LePage_0000730 LePage_0000730 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

096 LePage_0000731 LePage_0000731 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

097 LePage_0000732 LePage_0000732 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

098 LePage_0000733 LePage_0000733 Superior Court of California, County of 

Napa Courthouse Photo of Location of December 1, 2015 Incident

901;

201 n/a n/a 6/12/2018 IME Report of Thomas Mampalam, M.D. 

and exhibits 901;

* Plaintiff's Hearsay objections apply to potential use by Defendants. 8 of 8

Case 3:17-cv-00600-LB Document 146 Filed 10/14/19 Page 9 of 9