EXHIBIT 3 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 1 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

1 8/28/18 Expert Report of Justine Hastings

2 All exhibits, tables and appendices to 8/28/18 Hastings Report 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

3 Amazon - Trade-In 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

4 Apple - Apple Launches iPhone 4S, iOS 5 & iCloud 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

5 Apple - Apple Presents iPhone 4 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

6 Apple - Apple Reports Fourth Quarter Results 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

7 Apple - Trade in with Apple GiveBack 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

8 Apple Community - Does iOS 7 Slow Down an iPhone 4 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

9 Apple Insider - Apple says working on fix for random iOS 7 

crashing issue

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

10 Apple Insider - iOS 7 update brings more Wi-Fi issues for some 

iPhone 4S owners

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

11 Assurant Inc - Mobile Device Protection and Support 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

12 AT&T - Trade-in FAQ 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

13 Best Buy - Trade In Program FAQs 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

14 Best Buy - Trade-In 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

15 Clover - 2014 - iOS 7.1 Causing Issues With Personal Hotspots - 

Mac Rumors

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

16 CNBC - Chinese smartphone thats ramping up in the US 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

17 CNET - The best ways to sell or trade in your iPhone - CNET 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

18 comScore, Inc - comScore Reports July 2014 U.S. Smartphone 

Subscriber Market Share

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

19 Costello, S. - Lifewire - Should You Upgrade Your iPhone 4 to iOS 

7

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

20 Cunningham, A. - ars Technica - iOS 7.1 on the iPhone 4 - As good 

as its going to get

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

21 Ebay - Marketplace Research by Terapeak 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

22 ecoATM - Devices 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

23 ecoATM - How to Sell Your Broken Phone & Other FAQs 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

24 FRED St. Louis Fed - Real gross domestic product per capita 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

25 Gazelle - How is the Gazelle Value offer calculated 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

26 Glyde - Sell 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

27 Google Trends - Interest Over Time 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

28 Hill - 2014 - 48 Problems Users Have and How to Fix Them (iOS 

7.1 Bugs Added) - Digital Trends

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

29 IDC - Worldwide Market for Used Smartphones Forecast to Grow 

to 222.6 Million Units in 2020, According to IDC

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

30 iMore - FaceTime-The ultimate guide 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

31 iMore - How to sell your iPhone _ iMore 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

32 iOS 7 With Completely Redesigned User Interface & Great New 

Features Available September 18 - Apple

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

33 iQmetrix - HYLA Mobile 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

34 Levin, M. - HuffPost - Used Phone Market Growing, Slowly 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

35 Mac Rumors - Apple Handles 'Several Billion' iMessages and 15 to 

20 Million FaceTime Calls Daily

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 2 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

36 Mac Rumors - Apple Introduces New Apple Watch Recycling 

Program Offering Gift Cards Up To $175

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

37 Mac Rumors - iOS 6 Users on Devices Able to Run iOS 7 Must 

Upgrade to Fix FaceTime

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

38 Mohammad, Z. (2017) - Oracle - 8 Best Practices in Data Science 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

39 Movaluate - About Movaluate 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

40 Movaluate - Movaluate 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

41 NextWorth - NextWorth 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

42 Official Apple Support Communities - Iphone 4s ios 7 battery issues 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

43 Osborne - 2014 - Apple iOS 7.1 flaws, problems and fixes _ ZDNet 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

44 PCMag - FaceTime (for iPhone) Review & Rating 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

45 PR Newswire - Best Buy Taps Brightstar To Streamline Reverse 

Supply Chain For Mobile Devices

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

46 PR Newswire - Brightstar Named as Exclusive Handset Provider to 

Key Verizon Wireless Dealers

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

47 PR Newswire - VirnetX Receives Court’s Final Judgment Affirming 

Jury’s Verdict of $1

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

48 Rampell, C. - New York Times - Cracking the Apple Trap 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

49 Sprint - Business BuyBack 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

50 Swappa - Data Services 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

51 Swappa - Swappa Price App 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

52 The Biggest Complaints About iOS 7 and How to Fix Them - The 

Atlantic

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

53 Thurston - 2012 - Formulating Second-Hand Market Value as a 

Function of Product Specifications, Age, and Conditions

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

54 Time - How to Get the Most Money for Your Old iPhone 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

55 T-Mobile - Get an estimate 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

56 Turner, C. - SAS - 5 data management best practices to help you do 

data right

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

57 USA Today - Apple loses some of its magic touch with iOS 7 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

58 Verizon Wireless - Trading in your device is easier than ever 8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

59 Whitney, L. - CNET - iPhone 6 resale value higher than previous 

models, analyst says

8/28/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

60 5/4/18 Expert Report of Justine Hastings Damages Justine Hastings

61 All exhibits, tables and appendices to 5/4/18 Hastings Report 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

62 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2010/06/07Apple-Presents-iPhone-4/ 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

63 https://www.imore.com/facetime 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

64 https://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2385669,00.asp 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

65 https://www.macrumors.com/2014/02/28/apple-40-billion-imessages/ 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

66 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2010/10/18Apple-Reports-FourthQuarter-Results/

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

67 APL-GRACE_00043021-159 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

68 APL-GRACE_00010295 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

69 APL-GRACE_00050788 - 50791 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 3 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

70 VirnetX Inc. v. Apple, Inc., Case No. 6:13-CV-211 at ECF No. 53 

(March 6, 2014) (Redacted February 25, 2014 Order Granting in 

Part VirnetX’s Motion to Set an Ongoing Royalty Rate).

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

71 APL-GRACE_00148220 - 148222 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report; MSJ 

Exhibits

Damages Justine Hastings

72 APL-GRACE_00000022 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

73 APL-GRACE_00000009 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

74 APL-GRACE_00010198-10199 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

75 APL-GRACE_00051571-51573 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

76 APL-GRACE_00042431-42432 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

77 https://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/03/magazine/why-apple-wants-to-bustyour-iphone.html

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

78 https://www.lifewire.com/upgrade-iphone-4-ios-7-1999204 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

79 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/5326618 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

80 APL-GRACE_00005636-5637 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report; MSJ 

Exhibits 

Damages Justine Hastings

81 APL-GRACE_00002142-2145 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report; Justine 

Hastings Deposition 

Exhibit 190

Damages Justine Hastings

82 APL-GRACE_00005860-5865 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

83 Defendant Apple Inc.’s Answer to Plaintiffs’ First Amended 

Complaint (August 11, 2017),

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

84 APL-GRACE_00056973-56989 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

85 APL-GRACE_00056772-56786 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

86 APL-GRACE_00056875-56889 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

87 APL-GRACE_00005801 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

88 APL-GRACE_00005804-5806 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

89 APL-GRACE_00044231 - 44233 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

90 APL-GRACE_00025224 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

91 APL-GRACE_00008039-8042 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

92 APL-GRACE_00002942-2958 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report; Jones Rpt.; 

MSJ Exhibits;Gokul 

Thirumalai 

Deposition Exhibit 

19

Damages Justine Hastings

93 APL-GRACE_00012205-12209 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

94 APL-GRACE_00003737-3739 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

95 https://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=prUS41929916 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

96 https://www.prnewswire.com/news‐releases/best‐buy‐taps‐brightstar‐to‐

streamline‐reverse‐supply‐chain‐for‐mobile‐devices‐173138811.html

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

97 https://www.macrumors.com/2017/12/04/apple-watch-recycling-programgift-cards/.

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

98 Intentionally Omitted

99 https://www.prnewswire.com/news‐releases/brightstar‐named‐as‐

exclusive‐handset‐provider‐to‐key‐verizon‐wireless‐dealers‐

147900405.html

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 4 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

100 https://www.huffingtonpost.com/michael-r-levin/used-phone-marketgrowing_b_4847583.html5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

101 http://www.movaluate.com/about 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

102 https://swappa.com/data-services 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

103 https://pages.ebay.com/marketplace_research/ 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

104 https://www.cnet.com/uk/news/iphone-6-resale-value-higher-than-previousmodels-analyst-says

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

105 https://appleinsider.com/articles/13/10/10/ios-7-update-brings-more-wi-fiissues-for-some-iphone-4s-owners

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

106 https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/09/biggestcomplaints-about-ios-7-and-how-fixthem/310738/.

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

107 https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2013/10/17/apple-ios-7-

problems/2986189/

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

108 https://appleinsider.com/articles/14/01/22/apple-says-fix-in-the-works-forrandom-ios-7-crashing-issue

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

109 https://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/03/magazine/why-apple-wants-to-bustyour-iphone.html

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

110 https://www.lifewire.com/upgrade-iphone-4-ios-7-1999204 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

111 Hastings, J.S. and Williams, M.A. (2016), “What is a But-For 

World?,” Antitrust, vol. 31, pp. 102-108

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

112 ABA Section of Antitrust Law (2017), Proving Antitrust Damages: 

Legal and Economic Issues, 3rd Ed., American Bar Association, Ch. 

6, Section F

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

113 McCrary, J. and Rubinfeld, D. (2014), “Measuring Benchmark 

Damages in Antitrust Litigation,” Journal of Econometric Methods, 

vol. 3 Antitrust Litigation,” Journal of Econometric Methods, vol. 3, 

pp. 63-74

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

114 ABA Section of Antitrust Law (2014),Econometrics: Legal, 

Practical, and Technical Issues, 2nd ed., American Bar Association, 

Ch. 12.

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

115 Intentionally Omitted

116 https://www.comscore.com/Insights/Rankings/comScore‐Reports‐July‐

2014‐US‐Smartphone‐Subscriber‐Market‐Share?cs_edgescape_cc=US

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

117 https://www.cnbc.com/2014/11/13/chinese‐smartphone‐tracking‐ztes‐

growth‐in‐us‐mobile‐market.html

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

118 6/18/10 email from Frank Sewald to Justin Wood re FaceTime Tech 

Talk 6/17/2010 APL-GRACE_00102595-102602

5/4/18 Hastings 

Report

Damages Justine Hastings

119 7/13/18 Reply Expert Report of Justine Hastings Damages Justine Hastings

120 All exhibits, tables and appendices to 7/13/18 Hastings Report 7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

121 Allen, M., Hall, R., and Lazear, V. (2011), “Reference Guide on 

Estimation of Economic Damages,” in Reference Manual on 

Scientific Evidence, Federal Judicial Center, National Research 

Council of the National Academies, pp. 425-502, at 432

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

122 Intentionally Omitted

123 Intentionally Omitted

124 Intentionally Omitted

125 Intentionally Omitted

126 Intentionally Omitted

127 https://www.macrumors.com/2014/03/19/ios-7-1-personal-hotspot-issues/ 7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

128 https://www.zdnet.com/pictures/apple-ios-7-1-flaws-problems-and-fixes/6/ 7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

129 https://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/ios-7-problems/ 7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

130 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2014/03/ios-7-1-on-the-iphone-4-as-goodas-its-going-to-get/

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

131 Mas-Colell, A., Whinston, M., and Green, J. (1995), Microeconomic 

Theory, New York, NY: Oxford University Press, Chapters 1-3

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

132 Pindyck, R. and Rubinfeld, D. (2013), Microeconomics, Boston, 

MA: Pearson, Chapters 3 and 4

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

133 Bernheim, B. and Whinston, M. (2008), Microeconomics, New 

York, NY: McGraw-Hill Irwin, Chapters 4 and 5.

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 5 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

134 Intentionally Omitted

135 Mas-Colell, A., Whinston, M., and Green, J. (1995), Microeconomic 

Theory, New York, NY: Oxford University Press, Chapters 1-3

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

136 Intentionally Omitted

137 Intentionally Omitted

138 https://www.sas.com/en_us/insights/articles/data-management/5-datamanagement-best-practices.html

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

139 https://www.datascience.com/blog/eight-data-science-best-practices 7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

140 https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/attachments/economics-bestpractices/ftcperspectivesoneconometrics.pdf

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

141 Koomey, J. (2001), Turing Numbers into Knowledge: Mastering the 

Art of Problem Solving, Oakland, CA: Analytics Press, pp. 123-124

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

142 https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/attachments/economics‐best‐

practices/ftcperspectivesoneconometrics.pdf

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

143 Intentionally Omitted

144 https://us.ecoatm.com/frequently‐asked‐questions/ 7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

145 https://www.bestbuy.com/site/best-buy-trade-in/trade-infaqs/pcmcat257100050022.c?id=pcmcat257100050022

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

146 https://www.gazelle.com/help/faq/sell/question_30 7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

147 http://esol.ise.illinois.edu/static2/pdf/JMD_Kwak_Kim_Thurston_Value_2

012.pdf

7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

148 https://swappa.com/app/price 7/13/18 Hastings 

Reply Report

Damages Justine Hastings

149 http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2010/06/07Apple-Presents-iPhone-4.html Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

150 http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2010/06/28iPhone-4-Sales-Top-1-7-

Million.html

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

151 http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2011/10/17iPhone-4S-First-WeekendSales-Top-Four-Million.html 

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

152 http://www.apple.com/newsroom/2016/07/apple-celebrates-one-billioniphones.html

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

153 http://www.cnn.com/2013/09/18/tech/mobile/ios-7-upgrade-faq Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

154 http://www.apple.com/iphone-7/ios/ Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

155 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204380 Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

156 http://www.macrumors.com/2014/02/28/apple-40-billion-imessages/ Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

157 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKoLp_lGo14 Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

158

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrXc92TLbl0

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

159 ttps://www.forbes.com/sites/marshallphelps/2016/05/09/an‐innovation‐

jason‐bourne‐would‐love/#7f908941289d

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

160 https://www.virnetx.com/virnetx‐awarded‐302‐4‐million‐verdict‐apple/ Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

161 https://support.apple.com/kb/dl1682?locale=en_US Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 6 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

162 http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2013/06/10Apple-Unveils-iOS-7.html Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

163 http://www.techradar.com/news/phone-and-communications/mobilephones/ios-7-vs-ios-6-what-s-different-1179663

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

164 http://readwrite.com/2013/10/15/ios-7-fixes-iphone-4-4S/ Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

165 https://www.lifewire.com/upgrade-iphone-4-ios-7-1999204 Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

166 http://arstechnica.com/apple/2013/09/new-lease-on-life-or-death-sentenceios-7-on-theiphone-4/

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

167 http://smallbusiness.chron.com/advantages-using-wifi-smartphone71651.html

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

168 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201222 Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

169 https://support.apple.com/kb/PH2608?locale=en_US Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

170 http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-19512_7-20116316-233/bluetooth-4.0-whatis-it-and-doesit-matter/

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

171 https://9to5mac.com/2014/04/24/apples‐fix‐for‐facetime‐woes‐in‐ios‐6‐

upgrade‐to‐ios‐7/

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

172 http://www.ibtimes.com.au/solution-facetime-problem-observed-ios-6-ios7-os-x-1339329

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

173 http://www.iphonehacks.com/2014/04/apple-offers-fix-ios-6-facetimecalling-woes.html

Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

174 https://www.macrumors.com/2014/04/24/ios-6-facetime-fix/ Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

175 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Apple_codenames Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

176 https://support.apple.com/kb/dl1722?locale=en_US Complaint Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

177 Dallas DeAtley Deposition Exhibit 1 Dallas DeAtley

178 Dallas DeAtley Deposition Exhibit 2 Dallas DeAtley

179 APL-GRACE 00056770 Dallas DeAtley

180 APL‐GRACE 00056772 Dallas DeAtley

181 APL-GRACE 00056973 Dallas DeAtley

182 APL‐GRACE 00005801 Dallas DeAtley

183 APL‐GRACE 00044254 Dallas DeAtley

184

APL-GRACE 00015699

Deirdre 

Caldbeck

185 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 36 David Hale

186 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 37 David Hale

187 APL-GRACE_00000022-30 MSJ Exhibits David Hale

188 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 39 David Hale

189 AKAM-0025 David Hale

190 AKAM-0132 David Hale

191 AKAM-0136 David Hale

192 APL-GRACE_00000011 David Hale

193 AKAM-0165 David Hale

194 APL-GRACE_00000007 David Hale

195 AKAM-0016 David Hale

196 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 48 David Hale

197 APL-GRACE_00000018-19 MSJ Exhibits David Hale

198 APL-GRACE_00000015-16 MSJ Exhibits David Hale

199 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 52 David Hale

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 7 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

200 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 53 David Hale

201 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 54 David Hale

202 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 55 David Hale

203 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 56 David Hale

204 David Hale Deposition Exhibit 57 David Hale

205

Christopher Hall Deposition Exhibit 111

Christopher 

Hall

206

Christopher Hall Deposition Exhibit 112

Christopher 

Hall

207

Christopher Hall Deposition Exhibit 113

Christopher 

Hall

208

Christopher Hall Deposition Exhibit 114

Christopher 

Hall

209

Christopher Hall Deposition Exhibit 115

Christopher 

Hall

210

Christopher Hall Deposition Exhibit 116

Christopher 

Hall

211 Beth Kellerman Deposition Exhibit 1 Beth Kellerman

212 Beth Kellerman Deposition Exhibit 2 Beth Kellerman

213 APL-GRACE_00018063-18605 Beth Kellerman

214 APL-GRACE_00001958 Beth Kellerman

215 APL-GRACE_00001993 Beth Kellerman

216 Neil Malhotra Deposition Exhibit 185 Neil Malhotra

217 Neil Malhotra Deposition Exhibit 186 Neil Malhotra

218 Brian Plott Deposition Exhibit 92 Brian Plott

219 Brian Plott Deposition Exhibit 93 Brian Plott

220 Brian Plott Deposition Exhibit 94 Brian Plott

221 Brian Plott Deposition Exhibit 95 Brian Plott

222 Brian Plott Deposition Exhibit 96 Brian Plott

223 Aviel Rubin Deposition Exhibit 123 - 7/3/2018 Aviel Rubin

224 Aviel Rubin Deposition Exhibit 124 - 7/3/2018 Aviel Rubin

225 APL-GRACE_00003930-3947; APLGRACE_00099793-99795Aviel Rubin

226 Aviel Rubin Deposition Exhibit 128 - 7/3/2018 Aviel Rubin

227 Aviel Rubin Deposition Exhibit 129 - 7/3/2018 Aviel Rubin

228 Aviel Rubin Deposition Exhibit 130 - 7/3/2018 Aviel Rubin

229 Aviel Rubin Deposition Exhibit 131 - 7/3/2018 Aviel Rubin

230 Aviel Rubin Deposition Exhibit 250 - 9/26/2018 Aviel Rubin

231 Aviel Rubin Deposition Exhibit 251 - 9/26/2018 Aviel Rubin

232 Aviel Rubin Deposition Exhibit 252 - 9/26/2018 Aviel Rubin

233 Gokul Thirumalai Deposition Exhibit 9 Gokul 

Thirumalai

234 Gokul Thirumalai Deposition Exhibit 10 Gokul 

Thirumalai

235 APL-GRACE_000060653-60654 Gokul 

Thirumalai

236 APL-GRACE_00056770-56771 Gokul 

Thirumalai

237 APL-GRACE_00005777-5779 Gigi Wang 

Deposition Exhibit 

138

Gokul 

Thirumalai

238 Gokul Thirumalai Deposition Exhibit 23 Gokul 

Thirumalai

239 Dana Trexler Deposition Exhibit 132 Dana Trexler

240 APL_GRACE_00000957-960 Jacques Vidrine

241 APL-GRACE_00007412-7414 Jacques Vidrine

242 APL-GRACE_00169792-169799 Jacques Vidrine

243 APL-GRACE_00172018-172022 Jacques Vidrine

244 APL-GRACE_00172023-172026 Jacques Vidrine

245 APL-GRACE_00172027-172030 Jacques Vidrine

246 APL-GRACE _00044254-44269 Jacques Vidrine

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 8 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

247 APL-GRACE_00175144-175147 Jacques Vidrine

248 APL-GRACE _00002942-2958 Jacques Vidrine

249 APL-GRACE_00008446-8447 Jacques Vidrine

250 APL-GRACE _00022457-22464 Jacques Vidrine

251 APL-GRACE _00044770-44772 Jacques Vidrine

252 Gigi Wang Deposition Exhibit 133 Gigi Wang

253 APL‐GRACE_00005799-5800 Gigi Wang

254 APL-GRACE_00005842-5844 Gigi Wang

255 APL-GRACE_00005825-5830 Gigi Wang

256 APL-GRACE_00025421 Gigi Wang

257 APL-GRACE_00025420 Gigi Wang

258 APL‐GRACE_00042383-42385 Gigi Wang

259 APL‐GRACE_00044252-44253 Gigi Wang

260 APL‐GRACE_00042397-42399 Gigi Wang

261 APL-GRACE_00060653-60654 Justin Wood

262 Brightstar000045-55 Andy Zeinfeld

263 Brightstar000001-30 Andy Zeinfeld

264 Brightstar000031-44 Andy Zeinfeld

265 APL·GRACE_00001957 Andy Zeinfeld

266 Andy Zeinfeld Deposition Exhibit 82 Andy Zeinfeld

267 Andy Zeinfeld Deposition Exhibit 83 Andy Zeinfeld

268 Expert Report of Dr. Mark T. Jones Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

269 Exhibits to the Report of Dr. Mark T. Jones Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

270 https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/6/28/15885636/ipho

ne-10th-anniversary-hardwarespecificationscomparison-apple-ios

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

271 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT1263 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

272 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT4218 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

273 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT5165 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

274 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204611 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

275 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205759 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

276 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205762 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

277 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201222 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

278 https://support.apple.com/kb/DL1621?viewlocale=en_US&locale=e

n_US

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

279 https://support.apple.com/kb/DL1631?viewlocale=en_US&locale=e

n_US

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

280 https://support.apple.com/kb/DL1639?viewlocale=en_US&locale=e

n_US

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

281 https://support.apple.com/kb/DL1652?viewlocale=en_US&locale=e

n_US

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 9 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

282 https://support.apple.com/kb/DL1722?viewlocale=en_US&locale=e

n_US.

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

283 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204204 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

284 APL-GRACE_00004973-5090 Jones Rpt.;MSJ 

Exhibits 

Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

285 https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Security/

Conceptual/CertKeyTrustProgGuide/Encryption.html#//apple_ref/do

c/uid/TP40001358-CH211-SW1

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

286 https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Security/

Conceptual/cryptoservices/Introduction/Introduction.html#//apple_re

f/doc/uid/TP40011172

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

287 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certificate_key_

and_trust_services/certificates?language=objc

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

288 APL-GRACE_00004170 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

289 https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Security/

Conceptual/cryptoservices/CryptographyConcepts/CryptographyCon

cepts.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/TP40011172-CH8-SW1

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

290 https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Security/

Conceptual/CertKeyTrustProgGuide/CertGet.html#//apple_ref/doc/u

id/TP40001358-CH224-SW1

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

291 https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Security/

Conceptual/cryptoservices/CryptographyConcepts/CryptographyCon

cepts.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/TP40011172-CH8-SW1

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

292 https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Security/

Conceptual/cryptoservices/Introduction/Introduction.html#//apple_re

f/doc/uid/TP40011172

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

293 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certificate_key_

and_trust_services/certificates?language=objc

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

294 APL-GRACE_00008708 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

295 https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Security/

Conceptual/CertKeyTrustProgGuide/index.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/

TP40001358-CH218-SW1

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

296 APL-GRACE_00173241 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

297 APL-GRACE_00173236 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

298 APL-GRACE_00173238 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

299 Intentionally Omitted

300 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certificate_key_

and_trust_services/certificates

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

301 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certificate_key_

and_trust_services/policies

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

302 APL-GRACE_00001023 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

303 APL-GRACE_00053108 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

304 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2010/06/07Apple-PresentsiPhone-4/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 10 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

305 APL-GRACE_00036293 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

306 AKAM-001-0024 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

307 APL-GRACE_00171473 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

308 APL-GRACE_00031237 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

309 APL-GRACE_00170582 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

310 APL-GRACE_00035164-35166 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

311 A Dictionary of Computer Science (Oxford Quick Reference) 7th 

Edition - Bug: An error in a program or system. The word is usually 

used to mean a localized implementation error rather than, say, an 

error introduced at the requirements or system-design stage

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

312 Webster's New World Computer Dictionary, 10th Edition - Bug: A 

programming error that causes a program or a computer system to 

perform erratically, produce incorrect results, or crash

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

313 Microsoft Computer Dictionary, Fifth Edition (Cpg-Other) 5th 

Edition - Bug: An error in coding or logic that causes a program to 

malfunction or to produce incorrect results

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

314 AKAM-0001 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

315 AKAM-0010 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

316 AKAM-0014 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

317 APL-GRACE_00001004; APL-GRACE_00010314; 

APLGRACE_

00010324; APL-GRACE_00010335; APLGRACE_00010343; APL-GRACE_00010351;

APL-GRACE_00010358; APL-GRACE_00010366; 

APL-GRACE_00010373; APL-GRACE_00010381;

APL-GRACE_00010390; APL-GRACE_00010397; 

APL-GRACE_00010403; APL-GRACE_00010408;

APL-GRACE_00017093; APL-GRACE_00017104; 

APL-GRACE_00017111; APL-GRACE_00017121;

APL-GRACE_00017128; APL-GRACE_00017136; 

APL-GRACE_00017144; APL-GRACE_00017152;

APL-GRACE_00029528; APL-GRACE_00029538; 

APL-GRACE_00029548; APL-GRACE_00029555;

APL-GRACE_00029562; APL-GRACE_00029570; 

APL-GRACE_00029578; APL-GRACE_00029585;

APL-GRACE_00029593; APL-GRACE_00029600; 

APL-GRACE_00029608; APL-GRACE_00029617;

APL-GRACE_00029626; APL-GRACE_00029632; 

APL-GRACE_00029638; APL-GRACE_00029643;

APL-GRACE_00029648; APL-GRACE_00029654; 

APL-GRACE_00171924

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

318 APL-GRACE_00060656 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Justine Hastings

319 APL-GRACE_00051792 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

320 APL-GRACE_00021931 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 11 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

321 APL-GRACE_00024933-24938 Jones Rpt.; Jacques 

Vidrine Deposition 

Exhibit 174; Justin 

Wood Deposition 

Exhibit 121

Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

322 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/5163024 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

323 APL-GRACE_00169559 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

324 APL-GRACE_00025001 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

325 APL-GRACE_00013938-13943 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

326 APL-GRACE_00013995 - 13998 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

327 APL-GRACE_00034276 - 34279 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

328 APL-GRACE_00025227 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

329 APL-GRACE_00007274-7277 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

330 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2010/10/20Apple-BringsFaceTime-to-the-Mac/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

331 APL-GRACE_00014073 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

332 APL-GRACE_00000953 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

333 APL-GRACE_00000957 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

334 APL-GRACE_00035672 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

335 APL-GRACE_00015390 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

336 APL-GRACE_00008298-8303 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

337 APL-GRACE_00008039-8042 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

338 APL-GRACE_00015390 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

339 APL-GRACE_00026586 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

340 APL-GRACE_00008999 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

341 APL-GRACE_00000996 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

342 APL-GRACE_00099793-99795 Jones Rpt.; 5/4/18 

Hastings Report

Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones; 

Justin Hastings

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 12 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

343 APL-GRACE_00099304 - 99306 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

344 APL-GRACE_00052567 - 52569 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

345 APL-GRACE_00012728 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

346 APL-GRACE_00164446 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

347 AKAM-0052-0110 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

348 AKAM-0282 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

349 AKAM-0480-0483 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

350 AKAM-0895-0902 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

351 APL-GRACE-CODE0000001 - APL-GRACECODE0000300Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

352 APL-GRACE_00015728 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

353 APL-GRACE_00015732 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

354 APL-GRACE_00002818 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

355 APL-GRACE_00001893 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

356 APL-GRACE_00101577 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

357 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/1396098-

sectrustsetanchorcertificates?language=occ

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

358 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/1397202-

secpolicycreatebasicx509

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

359 https://opensource.apple.com/source/Security/Security55471/sec/Security/SecPolicy.c

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

360 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/1394363-

sectrustevaluate?language=occ

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

361 https://opensource.apple.com/source/Security/Security57336.1.9/OSX/libsecurity_keychain/lib/SecTrust.cpp.auto.html

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

362 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/secpadding/ksec

paddingoaep?language=objc

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

363 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/secpadding/ksec

paddingpkcs1sha224?language=objc

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

364 APL-GRACE_00046382 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

365 APL-GRACE_00046936 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 13 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

366 APL-GRACE_00029195 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

367 APL-GRACE_00029201 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

368 APL-GRACE_00029376 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

369 APL-GRACE_00002807 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

370 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security?language=objc Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

371 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certificate_key_

and_trust_services?language=objc

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

372 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certificate_key_

and_trust_services/certificates?language=objc

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

373 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certificate_key_

and_trust_services/trust/creating_a_trust_object?language=objc

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

374 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/certificate_key_

and_trust_services/trust/creating_a_tr

ust_object?language=objc.

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

375 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2013/09/10Apple-AnnouncesiPhone-5s-The-Most-Forward-Thinking-Smartphone-in-the-World/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

376 https://support.apple.com/kb/sp587?locale=en_US Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

377 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2010/06/07Apple-PresentsiPhone-4/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

378 https://support.apple.com/kb/sp643?locale=en_US Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

379 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2011/10/04Apple-LaunchesiPhone-4S-iOS-5-iCloud/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

380 https://support.apple.com/kb/sp684?locale=en_US Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

381 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2013/09/10Apple-IntroducesiPhone-5c-The-Most-Colorful-iPhone-Yet/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

382 https://support.apple.com/kb/sp685?locale=en_US Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

383 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2013/09/10Apple-AnnouncesiPhone-5s-The-Most-Forward-Thinking-Smartphone-in-the-World/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

384 https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/6/28/15885636/ipho

ne-10th-anniversary-hardware-specifications-comparison-apple-ios

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

385 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201296 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

386 https://everymac.com/systems/apple/iphone/iphone-faq/iphoneprocessor-types.html

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

387 https://www.gsmarena.com/apple_iphone_4-3275.php Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

388 https://www.gsmarena.com/apple_iphone_4s-4212.php Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 14 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

389 https://everymac.com/systems/apple/iphone/iphone-faq/iphoneprocessor-types.htmlJones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

390 https://www.engadget.com/2013/12/10/ios-6-vs-ios-7-icons-a-visualcomparison/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

391 http://osxdaily.com/2013/06/11/ios-7-vs-ios-6-visual-comparison/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

392 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/09/new-lease-on-life-or-deathsentence-ios-7-on-the-iphone4/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

393 https://readwrite.com/2013/10/15/ios-7-fixes-iphone-4-4S/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

394 https://tidbits.com/2013/10/02/four-problems-with-ios-7-crashingmessages-siri-and-audio/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

395 https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/ios-7-on-iphone-4.1633905/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

396 https://news.softpedia.com/news/iOS-7-on-iPhone-4-Is-UnusableCustomers-Say-385141.shtml

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

397 https://mac.softpedia.com/blog/Developer-iPhone-4-Can-BarelyTake-iOS-7-360227.shtml

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

398 https://www.lifewire.com/upgrade-iphone-4-ios-7-1999204 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

399 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3GNOQHKht0c Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

400 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8FAU-gnN-E Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

401 http://www.iphonehacks.com/2016/03/ios-5-through-ios-9-speedtest-on-iphone-4s-confirms-ios-gets-slower-every-year-on-olderdevices.html

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

402 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zH7FslRYsNg&feature=youtu.b

e

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

403 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2014/03/ios-7-1-on-the-iphone-4-asgood-as-its-going-to-get/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

404 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/09/new-lease-on-life-or-deathsentence-ios-7-on-the-iphone-4/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

405 APL-GRACE_00035270-35287 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

406 APL-GRACE_00035928 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

407 APL-GRACE_00169822-169840 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

408 https://www.lifewire.com/can-you-uninstall-ios-7-1999199 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

409 https://readwrite.com/2013/09/24/apple-ios-7-no-downgrade/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

410 https://appleinsider.com/articles/18/01/11/apple-servers-brieflyenabled-signing-of-older-ios-firmwares-allowing-users-todowngrade-to-earlier-versions

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

411 https://wccftech.com/apple-starts-signing-firmware-way-back-ios-6-

downgrade-now-want-jailbreak/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 15 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

412 https://www.reddit.com/r/jailbreak/comments/7qe81d/question_why

_is_ios_613_for_4s_still_being_signed/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

413 http://www.iclarified.com/64117/apple-is-currently-signing-variousios-6-to-ios-10-firmware-versions-downgrades-possible

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

414 http://wololo.net/2018/01/12/apples-big-signing-screw-allowedusers-downgrade-versions-ios-old-ios-6/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

415 https://9to5mac.com/2018/01/10/users-able-downgrade-from-ios-11/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

416 https://www.macrumors.com/2018/01/11/apple-accidentally-signedold-ios-versions/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

417 https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/ios-6-1-3-still-signed-byapple.2100595/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

418 APL-GRACE_00006769; APL-GRACE_00006779; 

APL-GRACE_00006789; APLGRACE_

00006799; APL-GRACE_00006811; APLGRACE_00006822; APL-GRACE_00006909;

APL-GRACE_00006920; APL-GRACE_00006950; 

APL-GRACE_00007019; APL-GRACE_00007034;

APL-GRACE_00007065; APL-GRACE_00007080; 

APL-GRACE_00007105; APL-GRACE_00007121;

APL-GRACE_00007139; APL-GRACE_00007155; 

APL-GRACE_00007226; APL-GRACE_00007243;

APL-GRACE_00008284; APL-GRACE_00011764; 

APL-GRACE_00011774; APL-GRACE_00011784;

APL-GRACE_00011794; APL-GRACE_00011836; 

APL-GRACE_00011890; APL-GRACE_00011933;

APL-GRACE_00011945; APL-GRACE_00011960; 

APL-GRACE_00012026; APL-GRACE_00012068;

APL-GRACE_00012151; APL-GRACE_00013393; 

APL-GRACE_00165087; APL-GRACE_00165105;

APL-GRACE_00165145

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

419 APL-GRACE_00007105 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

420 APL-GRACE_00044282; APL-GRACE_00044300; 

APL-GRACE_00044310; APLGRACE_

00044320; APL-GRACE_00047274; APLGRACE_00047285; APL-GRACE_00047334;

APL-GRACE_00047344; APL-GRACE_00047356; 

APL-GRACE_00048080; APL-GRACE_00048090;

APL-GRACE_00048102; APL-GRACE_00048112; 

APL-GRACE_00051599; APL-GRACE_00051613;

APL-GRACE_00051623; APL-GRACE_00051634; 

APL-GRACE_00054471; APL-GRACE_00054540;

APL-GRACE_00054550; APL-GRACE_00054560; 

APL-GRACE_00148005; APL-GRACE_00148016;

APL-GRACE_00148075; APL-GRACE_00148085; 

APL-GRACE_00148152; APL-GRACE_00148162;

APL-GRACE_00148190; APL-GRACE_00148200

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

421 APL-GRACE_00048080 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

422 APL-GRACE_00002142; APL-GRACE_00005860; 

APL-GRACE_00005885; APLGRACE_

00005893; APL-GRACE_00005983; APLGRACE_00010805; APL-GRACE_00015463;

APL-GRACE_00032224; APL-GRACE_00032233; 

APL-GRACE_00032679; APL-GRACE_00044361;

APL-GRACE_00048123; APL-GRACE_00048152; 

APL-GRACE_00048166; APL-GRACE_00048827;

APL-GRACE_00048836; APL-GRACE_00051694; 

APL-GRACE_00054702; APL-GRACE_00148397;

APL-GRACE_00148558; APL-GRACE_00148567.

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 16 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

423 https://support.apple.com/kb/dl1732?locale=en_US Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

424 APL-GRACE_00054711 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

425 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2014/03/ios-7-1-on-the-iphone-4-asgood-as-its-going-to-get/;

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

426 https://mashable.com/2014/03/11/ios-7-1-iphone4/#yn27Xw2kwiqG

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

427 https://www.macrumors.com/2014/03/10/ios71-makes-iphone4-

snappier/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

428 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2014/03/ios-7-1-on-the-iphone-4-asgood-as-its-going-to-get/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

429 https://forums.imore.com/general-apple-news-discussion/325826-

iphone-4-ios-7-1-2-very-slow-keep-rebooting.html

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

430 https://www.quora.com/Ive-an-iPhone-4-which-runs-on-iOS-7-1-2-

It-lags-while-scrolling-down-in-certain-apps-like-Safari-QuoraFacebook-etc-Is-there-any-way-to-fix-this-lag

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

431 https://forum.unity.com/threads/ios-7-1-2-very-slow.368379/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

432 https://community.spotify.com/t5/iOS-iPhone-iPad/iPhone-4-version7-1-2-PAINFULLY-slow-with-Spotify-APP-Help/td-p/1190050

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

433 https://forum.unity.com/threads/ios-7-1-iphone-4-incredibly-slowstartup-affects-games-in-store-and-development.232914/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

434 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/6464105 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

435 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/7020232 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

436 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/5987697 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

437 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/6073451 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

438 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/6622377 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

439 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/6480063 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

440 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/6368399 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

441 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/6652694 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

442 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2011/105/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

443 https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interfaceguidelines/ios/overview/themes/.

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

444 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2015/230/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

445 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2016/719 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 17 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

446 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2016/406 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

447 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2016/418/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

448 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2018/407 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

449 https://devstreamingcdn.apple.com/videos/wwdc/2018/407akll3nbwls9yn4qt/407/407_p

ractical_approaches_to_great_app_performance.pdf?dl=1

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

450 https://devstreamingcdn.apple.com/videos/wwdc/2018/407akll3nbwls9yn4qt/407/407_p

ractical_approaches_to_great_app_performance.pdf?dl=1

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

451 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2016/406 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

452 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2015/230/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

453 https://devstreamingcdn.apple.com/videos/wwdc/2015/230wt8hs0wt8/230/230_perform

ance_on_ios_and_watchos.pdf?dl=1

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

454 https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

455 https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interfaceguidelines/ios/app-architecture/loading/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

456 https://devstreamingcdn.apple.com/videos/wwdc/2018/407akll3nbwls9yn4qt/407/407_p

ractical_approaches_to_great_app_performance.pdf?dl=1

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

457 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2016/406 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

458 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2018/407 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

459 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2014/03/ios-7-1-on-the-iphone-4-asgood-as-its-going-to-get/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

460 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2015/230/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

461 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2015/230/ Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

462 http://services.google.com/fh/files/blogs/google_delayexp.pdf Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

463 http://glinden.blogspot.com/2006/11/marissa-mayer-at-web-20.html Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

464 https://blog.gigaspaces.com/amazon-found-every-100ms-of-latencycost-them-1-in-sales/.

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

465 http://glinden.blogspot.com/2006/11/marissa-mayer-at-web-20.html Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

466 https://blog.gigaspaces.com/amazon-found-every-100ms-of-latencycost-them-1-in-sales/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

467 https://www.fastcompany.com/1825005/how-one-second-could-costamazon-16-billion-sales.

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

468 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2018/407 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 18 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

469 Plaintiff’s Interrogatory No. 14. Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

470 Intentionally Omitted

471 Apple’s Second Supplemental Response to Plaintiffs’ Second Set of 

Interrogatories as to

Interrogatory No. 14 (dated 05/31/2018).

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

472 APL-GRACE_00169903 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

473 APL-GRACE_00005885 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

474 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2016/406 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

475 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2018/407 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

476 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2014/03/ios-7-1-on-the-iphone-4-asgood-as-its-going-to-get/

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

477 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2018/407 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

478

APL‐GRACE_00056875

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

479

AKAM-0052-53

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

480

AKAM-0119-122

Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

481 APL-GRACE_00000953-956 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

482 APL-GRACE_00000957 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

483 AKAM-0328 Jones Rpt. Technical 

materials re: 

Apple's conduct

Mark Jones

484 APL-GRACE_00000988-993 5/4/18 Hastings 

Report; MSJ 

Exhibits; Jacques 

Vidrine Deposition 

Exhibit 175; Justin 

Wood Deposition 

Exhibit 122

Damages Justin Hastings

485 AKAM-0001-966 David Hale

486 AKAM-0020 - 21 MSJ Exhibits David Hale

487 AKAM-0214 - 215 MSJ Exhibits David Hale

488 AKAM-0216 - 220 MSJ Exhibits David Hale

489 APL-GRACE_00000009 - 10 MSJ Exhibits 

490 APL-GRACE_000000939 MSJ Exhibits 

491 APL-GRACE_000000940 MSJ Exhibits 

492 APL-GRACE_000000941 MSJ Exhibits 

493 APL-GRACE_000000942 MSJ Exhibits 

494 APL-GRACE_000000943 MSJ Exhibits 

495 APL-GRACE_00000994 MSJ Exhibits 

496 APL-GRACE_00001002 - 1003 MSJ Exhibits 

497 APL-GRACE_00001004 - 1011 MSJ Exhibits 

498 APL-GRACE_00002142 - 2145 MSJ Exhibits 

499 APL-GRACE_00002160 - 2164 MSJ Exhibits; 5/4/18 

Hastings Report; 

Justine Hastings 

Deposition Exhibit 

191

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 19 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

500 APL-GRACE_00002786 MSJ Exhibits 

501 APL-GRACE_00003930 - 3947 MSJ Exhibits 

502 APL-GRACE_00005807 - 5812 MSJ Exhibits 

503 APL-GRACE_00008120 - 8121 MSJ Exhibits 

504 APL-GRACE_00010314 - 10323 MSJ Exhibits 

505 APL-GRACE_00012808 - 12828 MSJ Exhibits 

506 APL-GRACE_00014721 - 14722 MSJ Exhibits 

507 APL-GRACE_00015517 - 15519 MSJ Exhibits; Gokul 

Thirumalai 

Deposition Exhibit 

20

508 APL-GRACE_00017136 - 1743 MSJ Exhibits 

509 APL-GRACE_00017420 - 17421 MSJ Exhibits 

510 APL-GRACE_00022187 - 22194 MSJ Exhibits; Gokul 

Thirumalai 

Deposition Exhibit 

17

511 APL-GRACE_00035672 - 35675 MSJ Exhibits 

512 APL-GRACE_00044254 - 44269 MSJ Exhibits 

513 APL-GRACE_00049097 - 49103 MSJ Exhibits 

514 APL-GRACE_00052811 MSJ Exhibits 

515 APL-GRACE_00054991 - 54992 MSJ Exhibits 

516 APL-GRACE_00099488 – 99493 MSJ Exhibits 

517 APL-GRACE_00099786 - 99787 MSJ Exhibits 

518 APL-GRACE_00164166 - 164170 MSJ Exhibits 

519 APL-GRACE_00175152 - 175155 MSJ Exhibits 

520 APL-GRACE_00176067-176077

521 APL-GRACE-CCLOG00015301; APL-GRACECCLOG00016127; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00031969; APLGRACE-CCLOG00041263; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00046426; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00047892; APL-GRACECCLOG00048036; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00531466; APLGRACE-CCLOG00048170; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00048240; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00048277; APL-GRACECCLOG00118995; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00119622; APLGRACE-CCLOG00119720; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00120222; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00120283; APL-GRACECCLOG00121030; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00122512; APLGRACE-CCLOG00136607; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00136875; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00136908; APL-GRACECCLOG00136946; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00137242; APLGRACE-CCLOG00137286; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00137495; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00137652; APL-GRACECCLOG00138011; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00138061; APLGRACE-CCLOG00143109; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00143505; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00143730; APL-GRACECCLOG00144823; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00145790; APLGRACE-CCLOG00258385; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00332761; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00332789; APL-GRACECCLOG00332803; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00333972; APLGRACE-CCLOG00334269; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00484666; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00487068; APL-GRACECCLOG00490001; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00497888; APLGRACE-CCLOG00497969; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00499077; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00531466; APL-GRACECCLOG00534995; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00711128; APLGRACE-CCLOG00711180; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00713566; 

APL-GRACE-CCLOG00714204; APL-GRACECCLOG00716365; APL-GRACE-CCLOG00724049; APL522 APL-GRACE-CCLOG00341391 - 341395 MSJ Exhibits 

523 APL-GRACE-CCLOG00531466 - 531471 MSJ Exhibits 

524 Deposition Transcript of the September 26, 2018 Videotaped 

Deposition of Aviel Rubin

MSJ Exhibits 

525 Expert Report of Aviel Rubin filed on September 18, 2018 MSJ Exhibits 

526 Deposition Transcript of the September 24, 2018 Videotaped 

Deposition of Dr. Mark T. Jones

MSJ Exhibits 

527 Deposition Transcript of the July 18, 2018 Videotaped Deposition of 

Gigi Choy Wang

MSJ Exhibits 

528 Deposition Transcript of the April 18, 2018 Videotaped Deposition 

of Dallas De Atley

MSJ Exhibits 

529 Excerpt from the Deposition Transcript of the September 20, 2018, 

Videotaped Deposition of Justine S. Hastings, Phd.D.

MSJ Exhibits 

530 Spreadsheets reflecting California Class size

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 20 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

531 2017 09 28 Apple Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' 

Interrogatories, Set One

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

532 2017 12 12 Apple Supplemental Responses and Objections to 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

533 2018 01 22 Apple's 2nd Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs' 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

534 2018 01 22 Grace Apple's 2nd Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs' 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

535 2018 02 02 Grace's Apple 3rd Supplemental Responses and 

Objections to Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

536 2018 02 08 Apple's Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' 

Interrogatories, Set Two

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

537 2018 02 09 Grace Apple's Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

538 2018 04 12 Plaintiff Grace's Amended Responses to Apple's 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

539 2018 04 12 Plaintiff Ken Potter's Third Amended Responses to 

Apple's Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

540 2018 04 30 Apple's First Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs 

Second Set of Interrogatories (No. 14)

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

541 2018 04 30 Apple's Responses and Objections to 3rd Set of 

Interrogatories (No. 18)

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

542 2018 05 01 Apple_s First Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs 

Second Set of Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

543 2018 05 01 Apple's Responses and Objections to 3rd Set of 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

544 2018 05 11 Plaintiffs Amended Objections and Responses to 

Apple's 2nd Set of Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

545 2018 05 31 Apple's Responses and Objections to 3rd Set of 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

546 2018 05 31 Apple's Second Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs 

Second Set of Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

547 2018 08 13 Plaintiffs' Interrogatory Responses 10-11 Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

548 2018 08 20 Plaintiffs' Amended Response to Apple's Third Set of 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

549 2018 08 22 Grace -- Combined Second Revised Rog Responses Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

550 2018 08 22 Plaintiff Ken Potter's Fourth Amended Responses to 

Apple's Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

551 2018 09 05 Plaintiffs Responses to Apples Fifth Set of 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

552 2018 09 07 Apple's Response and Objections to Potters 1st Set of 

Interrogatories

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

553 2018 09 07 Apple's Supplemental Responses and Objections to 

Plaintiffs Interrogatory No 13

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 21 of 22
Grace et. al. v. Apple, Inc.

Case No.  5:17‐cv‐551

Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibit List

PX No. Description Bates No. Source Substance or 

Purpose

Sponsoring 

Witness

554 2018 10 04 Plaintiffs' Set 2 - Interrogatory Response Third 

Amended

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

555 2018 10 04 Plaintiffs' Set 4 - Interrogatory Response Amended Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

556 2018 10 04 Plaintiffs' Set 5 - Interrogatory Response Amended Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

557 2017 08 29 Apple's Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' First 

RFPs

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

558 2017 11 21 Apple's Amended Responses to RFPs Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

559 2018 01 19 Apple's Second Amended Responses to RFPs Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

560 2018 03 07 Defendants' Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' 

Second RFPs

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

561 2018 09 07 Apple's Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs 4th RFP Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

562 2018 02 08 Apple R&Os Pltfs' RFAs Set 1 Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

563 2018 04 30 Apple's Responses and Objections to 2nd Set of RFAs Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

564 2018 05 31 Apple's Responses and Objections to 2nd Set of RFAs Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

565 2018 08 13 Plaintiffs' RFA Response 9-10 Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

566 2018 09 05 Plaintiffs Responses to Apple RFAs Set Three Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

567 2018 09 07 Apple's Responses to Grace's Request for Admissions, 

Set 3

Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

568 2018 09 07 Plaintiffs' Response to RFAs Set Four Christina 

Grace; Kenneth 

Potter

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-3 Filed 12/16/19 Page 22 of 22