EXHIBIT 4

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 1 of 39
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

APPLE’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST / CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK 

JOSHUA H. LERNER, SBN 220755 

jlerner@gibsondunn.com 

GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP 

555 Mission Street, Suite 3000 

San Francisco, CA 94105-0921 

Telephone: 415.393.8200 

Facsimile: 415.393.8306 

Attorneys For Defendant APPLE INC. 

EUGENE NOVIKOV, SBN 257849 

enovikov@durietangri.com 

DURIE TANGRI LLP 

217 Leidesdorff Street 

San Francisco, CA 94111 

TELEPHONE: 415.362.6666 

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 

SAN JOSE DIVISION 

CHRISTINA GRACE and KEN POTTER, 

Individually and on Behalf of All Others 

Similarly Situated, 

Plaintiffs, 

v. 

APPLE INC., 

Defendant. 

Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK 

APPLE’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST 

Date: January 16, 2020 

Time: 1:30pm 

Ctrm: Courtroom 4, 5th Floor 

Judge: Honorable Lucy H. Koh 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 2 of 39
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

 2 

APPLE’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST / CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK 

Apple Inc. respectfully submits its trial exhibit list (attached here as Exhibit 6) pursuant to the 

Court’s Guidelines for Final Pretrial Conference in Jury Trials. The exhibit list does not supersede the 

parties’ need to lay the foundation for the admission of documents with a witness with knowledge of the 

document. Apple reserves its right to supplement and revise this list in any respect, including for 

impeachment and rebuttal purposes. Apple reserves the right to rely on any document cited by any of its 

experts, and any table, summary, or work product prepared by its experts. Apple also reserves its right to 

generate and use demonstratives that summarize or highlight particular documents from this exhibit list. 

Dated: December 13, 2019 

 

By: 

GIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP 

/s/ Joshua H. Lerner 

 JOSHUA H. LERNER 

Attorneys for Defendant 

APPLE INC. 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 3 of 39
EXHIBIT 6 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 4 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐001 AKAM‐0016 AKAM‐0017

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 28 [sealed] Akamai David

DTX‐002 AKAM‐0025 AKAM‐0051

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 26 [sealed] Akamai David

DTX‐003 AKAM‐0052 AKAM‐0164

Ex. 202, MSJ Ex. 2 [sealed] Akamai Mark

DTX‐004 APL_GRACE_00175140 APL_GRACE_00175143 Development and maintenance of iOS AvielDTX‐005 APL‐GRACE_00000007 APL‐GRACE_00000008

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 27 [sealed] Akamai David

DTX‐006 APL‐GRACE_00000011 APL‐GRACE_00000014

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 5 [sealed] Akamai David

DTX‐007 APL‐GRACE_00000015 APL‐GRACE_00000016

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 6 [sealed] Akamai David

DTX‐008 APL‐GRACE_00000022 APL‐GRACE_00000030

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 25 [sealed] Akamai David

DTX‐009 APL‐GRACE_00000064 APL‐GRACE_00000064 Ex. 30 Damages ChrisDTX‐010 APL‐GRACE_00000146 APL‐GRACE_00000148 Ex. 25 Damages ChrisDTX‐011 APL‐GRACE_00000152 APL‐GRACE_00000154 Ex. 27 Damages ChrisDTX‐012 APL‐GRACE_00000169 APL‐GRACE_00000171 Ex. 28 Damages ChrisDTX‐013 APL‐GRACE_00000178 APL‐GRACE_00000180 Ex. 29 Damages ChrisDTX‐014 APL‐GRACE_00000988 APL‐GRACE_00000995 Ex. 18, 122, 175 Development and maintenance of iOS

JacquThiru

DTX‐015 APL‐GRACE_00001910 APL‐GRACE_00001913 Development and maintenance of iOS

AvielGoku

DTX‐016 APL‐GRACE_00001956 APL‐GRACE_00001956

Ex. 86, Class Cert Opp. Ex. 4 [sealed] Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐017 APL‐GRACE_00001957 APL‐GRACE_00001957 Ex. 81 Damages Dr. Ju

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 5 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐018 APL‐GRACE_00001958 APL‐GRACE_00001958

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 20 [sealed] Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐019 APL‐GRACE_00002142 APL‐GRACE_00002149 Ex. 190 iOS performance

MarkDeAt

DTX‐020 APL‐GRACE_00002160 APL‐GRACE_00002164 Ex. 191 iOS performance Dalla

DTX‐021 APL‐GRACE_00002323 APL‐GRACE_00002340 Apple customer service and support Deird

DTX‐022 APL‐GRACE_00002786 APL‐GRACE_00002786 Development and maintenance of iOS AvielDTX‐023 APL‐GRACE_00002942 APL‐GRACE_00002958 Ex. 19 and 176 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

DTX‐024 APL‐GRACE_00003160 APL‐GRACE_00003173 Apple customer service and support Deird

DTX‐025 APL‐GRACE_00003420 APL‐GRACE_00003436 Apple customer service and support Deird

DTX‐026 APL‐GRACE_00004739 APL‐GRACE_00004742 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

DTX‐027 APL‐GRACE_00005636 APL‐GRACE_00005648 Ex. 189 Damages

Dr. JuDalla

DTX‐028 APL‐GRACE_00005707 APL‐GRACE_00005715 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

DTX‐029 APL‐GRACE_00005777 APL‐GRACE_00005779 Ex. 137 and Ex. 16 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

DTX‐030 APL‐GRACE_00005783 APL‐GRACE_00005785 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

DTX‐031 APL‐GRACE_00005786 APL‐GRACE_00005788 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

DTX‐032 APL‐GRACE_00005793 APL‐GRACE_00005794 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐033 APL‐GRACE_00005799 APL‐GRACE_00005800 Ex. 137 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

DTX‐034 APL‐GRACE_00005804 APL‐GRACE_00005806 Ex. 139 and 140 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

DTX‐035 APL‐GRACE_00005807 APL‐GRACE_00005812 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 6 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐036 APL‐GRACE_00005813 APL‐GRACE_00005818 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

DTX‐037 APL‐GRACE_00005825 APL‐GRACE_00005830 Ex. 141 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐038 APL‐GRACE_00005835 APL‐GRACE_00005838 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐039 APL‐GRACE_00005842 APL‐GRACE_00005844 Ex. 140 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐040 APL‐GRACE_00005860 APL‐GRACE_00005869 Ex. 192 iOS performance MarkDTX‐041 APL‐GRACE_00006050 APL‐GRACE_00006051

History and development of Apple, its iPhone products, and iOS operating systems Deird

DTX‐042 APL‐GRACE_00006808 APL‐GRACE_00006810 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐043 APL‐GRACE_00007274 APL‐GRACE_00007277 Ex. 177 and 196 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

DTX‐044 APL‐GRACE_00007354 APL‐GRACE_00007359 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐045 APL‐GRACE_00007412 APL‐GRACE_00007414 Ex. 162 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐046 APL‐GRACE_00007448 APL‐GRACE_00007449 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐047 APL‐GRACE_00007555 APL‐GRACE_00007558 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐048 APL‐GRACE_00007711 APL‐GRACE_00007711 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐049 APL‐GRACE_00007831 APL‐GRACE_00007833 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐050 APL‐GRACE_00007864 APL‐GRACE_00007865 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐051 APL‐GRACE_00007868 APL‐GRACE_00007871 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐052 APL‐GRACE_00007894 APL‐GRACE_00007897 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 7 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐053 APL‐GRACE_00007914 APL‐GRACE_00007916 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐054 APL‐GRACE_00007920 APL‐GRACE_00007920 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐055 APL‐GRACE_00007947 APL‐GRACE_00007950 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐056 APL‐GRACE_00008032 APL‐GRACE_00008035 Development and maintenance of iOS AvielDTX‐057 APL‐GRACE_00008039 APL‐GRACE_00008042

Ex. 120, 144 and 166 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

DTX‐058 APL‐GRACE_00008045 APL‐GRACE_00008048 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐059 APL‐GRACE_00008220 APL‐GRACE_00008220 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐060 APL‐GRACE_00008228 APL‐GRACE_00008229 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐061 APL‐GRACE_00008274 APL‐GRACE_00008275 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐062 APL‐GRACE_00008450 APL‐GRACE_00008451 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐063 APL‐GRACE_00008889 APL‐GRACE_00008892 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐064 APL‐GRACE_00008961 APL‐GRACE_00008963 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐065 APL‐GRACE_00009292 APL‐GRACE_00009301 Development and maintenance of iOS

JacquDeAt

DTX‐066 APL‐GRACE_00009562 APL‐GRACE_00009567 Apple customer service and support DallaDTX‐067 APL‐GRACE_00010204 APL‐GRACE_00010204 Akamai DavidDTX‐068 APL‐GRACE_00011318 APL‐GRACE_00011323 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐069 APL‐GRACE_00011446 APL‐GRACE_00011449 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐070 APL‐GRACE_00012240 APL‐GRACE_00012244 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 8 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐071 APL‐GRACE_00012700 APL‐GRACE_00012702 Akamai DallaDTX‐072 APL‐GRACE_00012707 APL‐GRACE_00012709 Development and maintenance of iOS DavidDTX‐073 APL‐GRACE_00012997 APL‐GRACE_00012999 Akamai DavidDTX‐074 APL‐GRACE_00013728 APL-GRACE_00013737 Product information Deird

DTX‐075 APL‐GRACE_00013995 APL‐GRACE_00013998 Development and maintenance of iOS AvielDTX‐076 APL‐GRACE_00014005 APL‐GRACE_00014010 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐077 APL‐GRACE_00014021 APL‐GRACE_00014022 Development and maintenance of iOS DeirdDTX‐078 APL‐GRACE_00014907 APL‐GRACE_00014915 Product information DeirdDTX‐079 APL‐GRACE_00014916 APL‐GRACE_00014919 Product information DeirdDTX‐080 APL‐GRACE_00014936 APL‐GRACE_00014938 Development and maintenance of iOS DeirdDTX‐081 APL‐GRACE_00015079 APL‐GRACE_00015088 Product information DeirdDTX‐082 APL‐GRACE_00015104 APL‐GRACE_00015108 Product information DeirdDTX‐083 APL‐GRACE_00015517 APL‐GRACE_00015519 Ex. 20 Development and maintenance of iOS DeirdDTX‐084 APL‐GRACE_00016575 APL‐GRACE_00016584 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐085 APL‐GRACE_00016892 APL‐GRACE_00016896 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

DTX‐086 APL‐GRACE_00017393 APL‐GRACE_00017396 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐087 APL‐GRACE_00017411 APL‐GRACE_00017413 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐088 APL‐GRACE_00017422 APL‐GRACE_00017423 Development and maintenance of iOS Goku

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 9 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐089 APL‐GRACE_00017443 APL‐GRACE_00017445 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐090 APL‐GRACE_00017480 APL‐GRACE_00017481 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐091 APL‐GRACE_00017484 APL‐GRACE_00017485 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐092 APL‐GRACE_00017488 APL‐GRACE_00017489 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐093 APL‐GRACE_00017491 APL‐GRACE_00017491 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐094 APL‐GRACE_00020912 APL‐GRACE_00020918 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐095 APL‐GRACE_00021013 APL‐GRACE_00021014 Akamai GokuDTX‐096 APL‐GRACE_00021797 APL‐GRACE_00021799 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐097 APL‐GRACE_00021882 APL‐GRACE_00021885 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐098 APL‐GRACE_00021931 APL‐GRACE_00021931 Akamai GokuDTX‐099 APL‐GRACE_00022090 APL‐GRACE_00022095 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐100 APL‐GRACE_00022165 APL‐GRACE_00022168 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐101 APL‐GRACE_00022187 APL‐GRACE_00022194 Ex. 17, 181 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐102 APL‐GRACE_00022370 APL‐GRACE_00022399 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐103 APL‐GRACE_00022457 APL‐GRACE_00022464 Ex. 181 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐104 APL‐GRACE_00022552 APL‐GRACE_00022554 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐105 APL‐GRACE_00022913 APL‐GRACE_00022915 Development and maintenance of iOS

JacquThiru

DTX‐106 APL‐GRACE_00022932 APL‐GRACE_00022934 Development and maintenance of iOS Goku

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 10 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐107 APL‐GRACE_00022976 APL‐GRACE_00022977 Akamai GokuDTX‐108 APL‐GRACE_00023219 APL‐GRACE_00023223 Apple customer service and support

DeirdThiru

DTX‐109 APL‐GRACE_00023257 APL‐GRACE_00023279 Akamai DavidDTX‐110 APL‐GRACE_00023306 APL‐GRACE_00023309 Apple customer service and support GokuDTX‐111 APL‐GRACE_00023459 APL‐GRACE_00023465 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐112 APL‐GRACE_00023466 APL‐GRACE_00023472 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐113 APL‐GRACE_00024173 APL‐GRACE_00024174 Akamai DallaDTX‐114 APL‐GRACE_00024484 APL‐GRACE_00024510 Akamai GokuDTX‐115 APL‐GRACE_00024564 APL‐GRACE_00024577 Akamai DavidDTX‐116 APL‐GRACE_00024645 APL‐GRACE_00024646 Akamai GokuDTX‐117 APL‐GRACE_00024804 APL‐GRACE_00024808 Akamai DavidDTX‐118 APL‐GRACE_00024933 APL‐GRACE_00024938

Ex. 174, 121 and 201 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

DTX‐119 APL‐GRACE_00024939 APL‐GRACE_00024939 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐120 APL‐GRACE_00024977 APL‐GRACE_00024981 Development and maintenance of iOS AvielDTX‐121 APL‐GRACE_00025022 APL‐GRACE_00025022 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐122 APL‐GRACE_00025082 APL‐GRACE_00025083 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐123 APL‐GRACE_00025224 APL‐GRACE_00025224

Ex. 127, 142 and 165 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

DTX‐124 APL‐GRACE_00025226 APL‐GRACE_00025227 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 11 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐125 APL‐GRACE_00025227 APL‐GRACE_00025227 Ex. 163 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐126 APL‐GRACE_00025234 APL‐GRACE_00025234 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐127 APL‐GRACE_00025390 APL‐GRACE_00025392 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐128 APL‐GRACE_00025422 APL‐GRACE_00025423 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐129 APL‐GRACE_00025656 APL‐GRACE_00025664 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐130 APL‐GRACE_00025677 APL‐GRACE_00025684 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐131 APL‐GRACE_00025714 APL‐GRACE_00025714 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐132 APL‐GRACE_00025735 APL‐GRACE_00025740 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐133 APL‐GRACE_00025769 APL‐GRACE_00025772 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐134 APL‐GRACE_00025847 APL‐GRACE_00025850 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐135 APL‐GRACE_00025857 APL‐GRACE_00025859 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐136 APL‐GRACE_00025884 APL‐GRACE_00025885 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐137 APL‐GRACE_00026031 APL‐GRACE_00026033 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐138 APL‐GRACE_00026163 APL‐GRACE_00026170 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐139 APL‐GRACE_00026346 APL‐GRACE_00026346 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐140 APL‐GRACE_00026432 APL‐GRACE_00026438 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐141 APL‐GRACE_00026503 APL‐GRACE_00026507 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐142 APL‐GRACE_00026630 APL‐GRACE_00026631 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 12 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐143 APL‐GRACE_00027323 APL‐GRACE_00027323 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐144 APL‐GRACE_00029600 APL‐GRACE_00029607 Akamai DallaDTX‐145 APL‐GRACE_00029648 APL‐GRACE_00029653 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐146 APL‐GRACE_00030672 APL‐GRACE_00030675 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐147 APL‐GRACE_00031769 APL‐GRACE_00031777 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐148 APL‐GRACE_00032144 APL‐GRACE_00032146 iOS performance MarkDTX‐149 APL‐GRACE_00032224 APL‐GRACE_00032232 iOS performance MarkDTX‐150 APL‐GRACE_00033262 APL‐GRACE_00033295 iOS performance MarkDTX‐151 APL‐GRACE_00033377 APL‐GRACE_00033379 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐152 APL‐GRACE_00033434 APL‐GRACE_00033438 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐153 APL‐GRACE_00033450 APL‐GRACE_00033450 Product information DeirdDTX‐154 APL‐GRACE_00033456 APL‐GRACE_00033459 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐155 APL‐GRACE_00033549 APL‐GRACE_00033550 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐156 APL‐GRACE_00033665 APL‐GRACE_00033669 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐157 APL‐GRACE_00033812 APL‐GRACE_00033812 Akamai JacquDTX‐158 APL‐GRACE_00033822 APL‐GRACE_00033823 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐159 APL‐GRACE_00034010 APL‐GRACE_00034011 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐160 APL‐GRACE_00034168 APL‐GRACE_00034173 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 13 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐161 APL‐GRACE_00034244 APL‐GRACE_00034248 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐162 APL‐GRACE_00034378 APL‐GRACE_00034381 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐163 APL‐GRACE_00034585 APL‐GRACE_00034586 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐164 APL‐GRACE_00034821 APL‐GRACE_00034824 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐165 APL‐GRACE_00034896 APL‐GRACE_00034896 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐166 APL‐GRACE_00034915 APL‐GRACE_00034916 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐167 APL‐GRACE_00034922 APL‐GRACE_00034922 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐168 APL‐GRACE_00034955 APL‐GRACE_00034957 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐169 APL‐GRACE_00035294 APL‐GRACE_00035295 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐170 APL‐GRACE_00035697 APL‐GRACE_00035704 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐171 APL‐GRACE_00035904 APL‐GRACE_00035906 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐172 APL‐GRACE_00036433 APL‐GRACE_00036434 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐173 APL‐GRACE_00036459 APL‐GRACE_00036460 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐174 APL‐GRACE_00037058 APL-GRACE_00037059 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

DTX‐175 APL‐GRACE_00037068 APL‐GRACE_00037069 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐176 APL‐GRACE_00037116 APL‐GRACE_00037117 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐177 APL‐GRACE_00037346 APL‐GRACE_00037347 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐178 APL‐GRACE_00037348 APL‐GRACE_00037349 Development and maintenance of iOS Jacqu

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 14 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐179 APL‐GRACE_00037350 APL‐GRACE_00037351 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐180 APL‐GRACE_00037354 APL‐GRACE_00037355 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐181 APL‐GRACE_00039441 APL‐GRACE_00039442 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐182 APL‐GRACE_00039443 APL‐GRACE_00039444 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐183 APL‐GRACE_00042383 APL‐GRACE_00042385 Ex. 146 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐184 APL‐GRACE_00042397 APL‐GRACE_00042399 Ex. 148 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐185 APL‐GRACE_00043021 APL‐GRACE_00043159 Ex. 184 Damages

Neil Caldb

DTX‐186 APL‐GRACE_00044237 APL‐GRACE_00044239 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐187 APL‐GRACE_00044242 APL‐GRACE_00044243 Development and maintenance of iOS

JacquJacqu

DTX‐188 APL‐GRACE_00044295 APL‐GRACE_00044295 Development and maintenance of iOS DeirdDTX‐189 APL‐GRACE_00044349 APL‐GRACE_00044350

History and development of Apple, its iPhone products, and iOS operating systems Deird

DTX‐190 APL‐GRACE_00044451 APL-GRACE_00044474 Development and maintenance of iOS Deird

DTX‐191 APL‐GRACE_00044770 APL‐GRACE_00044772 Development and maintenance of iOS

AvielDeAt

DTX‐192 APL‐GRACE_00044787 APL‐GRACE_00044789 Development and maintenance of iOS DeirdDTX‐193 APL‐GRACE_00044821 APL‐GRACE_00044829 Apple customer service and support DeirdDTX‐194 APL‐GRACE_00045103 APL‐GRACE_00045120 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐195 APL‐GRACE_00045938 APL‐GRACE_00045976 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 15 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐196 APL‐GRACE_00050444 APL‐GRACE_00050447 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐197 APL‐GRACE_00050684 APL‐GRACE_00050698 Akamai DavidDTX‐198 APL‐GRACE_00050699 APL‐GRACE_00050715 Akamai DavidDTX‐199 APL‐GRACE_00050990 APL‐GRACE_00051000 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐200 APL‐GRACE_00051322 APL‐GRACE_00051332 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐201 APL‐GRACE_00051343 APL‐GRACE_00051353 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐202 APL‐GRACE_00051354 APL‐GRACE_00051365 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐203 APL‐GRACE_00051497 APL‐GRACE_00051503 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐204 APL‐GRACE_00051566 APL‐GRACE_00051573 Akamai DavidDTX‐205 APL‐GRACE_00051586 APL‐GRACE_00051588 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐206 APL‐GRACE_00052534 APL‐GRACE_00052541 Akamai DavidDTX‐207 APL‐GRACE_00052542 APL‐GRACE_00052551 Akamai DavidDTX‐208 APL‐GRACE_00052572 APL‐GRACE_00052580 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐209 APL‐GRACE_00052811 APL‐GRACE_00052813 Akamai DallaDTX‐210 APL‐GRACE_00052832 APL‐GRACE_00052878 Apple customer service and support DeirdDTX‐211 APL‐GRACE_00055423 APL‐GRACE_00055469 Apple customer service and support AvielDTX‐212 APL‐GRACE_00055515 APL‐GRACE_00055516 Product information DeirdDTX‐213 APL‐GRACE_00056772 APL‐GRACE_00056786 Ex. 197 Development and maintenance of iOS Aviel

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 16 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐214 APL‐GRACE_00056875 APL‐GRACE_00056889 MSJ Ex. 3 [sealed]  Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐215 APL‐GRACE_00057676 APL‐GRACE_00057684 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐216 APL‐GRACE_00060542 APL‐GRACE_00060547 Akamai GokuDTX‐217 APL‐GRACE_00060643 APL‐GRACE_00060644 Akamai GokuDTX‐218 APL‐GRACE_00060683 APL‐GRACE_00060683 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐219 APL‐GRACE_00099238 APL‐GRACE_00099240 Development and maintenance of iOS GokuDTX‐220 APL‐GRACE_00099453 APL‐GRACE_00099457 Apple customer service and support GokuDTX‐221 Apl‐GRACE_00099620 APL‐GRACE_00099624 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐222 APL‐GRACE_00099692 APL‐GRACE_00099695 Apple customer service and support AvielDTX‐223 APL‐GRACE_00100191 APL‐GRACE_00100202 Akamai GokuDTX‐224 APL‐GRACE_00100204 APL‐GRACE_00100216 Akamai GokuDTX‐225 APL‐GRACE_00100241 APL‐GRACE_00100250 Akamai DavidDTX‐226 APL‐GRACE_00100253 APL‐GRACE_00100254 Akamai GokuDTX‐227 APL‐GRACE_00100392 APL‐GRACE_00100393 Akamai GokuDTX‐228 APL‐GRACE_00101262 APL‐GRACE_00101264 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐229 APL‐GRACE_00101709 APL‐GRACE_00101713 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐230 APL‐GRACE_00101714 APL‐GRACE_00101728 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐231 APL‐GRACE_00101743 APL‐GRACE_00101744 Development and maintenance of iOS Dalla

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 17 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐232 APL‐GRACE_00101746 APL‐GRACE_00101749 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐233 APL‐GRACE_00101780 APL‐GRACE_00101781 Apple customer service and support JacquDTX‐234 APL‐GRACE_00148538 APL‐GRACE_00148541 Akamai GokuDTX‐235 APL‐GRACE_00148552 APL‐GRACE_00148554 Akamai DallaDTX‐236 APL‐GRACE_00148555 APL‐GRACE_00148557 Akamai DallaDTX‐237 APL‐GRACE_00148576 APL‐GRACE_00148581 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐238 APL‐GRACE_00148610 APL‐GRACE_00148614 Apple customer service and support DeirdDTX‐239 APL‐GRACE_00148731 APL‐GRACE_00148732 Apple customer service and support DeirdDTX‐240 APL‐GRACE_00148737 APL‐GRACE_00148738 Apple customer service and support DeirdDTX‐241 APL‐GRACE_00148743 APL‐GRACE_00148747 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐242 APL‐GRACE_00148809 APL‐GRACE_00148812 iOS performance MarkDTX‐243 APL‐GRACE_00148823 APL‐GRACE_00148825 Akamai DallaDTX‐244 APL‐GRACE_00148832 APL‐GRACE_00148837 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐245 APL‐GRACE_00148846 APL‐GRACE_00148847 Apple customer service and support JacquDTX‐246 APL‐GRACE_00148848 APL‐GRACE_00148849 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐247 APL‐GRACE_00148859 APL‐GRACE_00148859 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐248 APL‐GRACE_00149233 APL‐GRACE_00149240 Apple customer service and support JacquDTX‐249 APL‐GRACE_00149660 APL‐GRACE_00149668 Apple customer service and support Jacqu

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 18 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐250 APL‐GRACE_00149701 APL‐GRACE_00149708 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐251 APL‐GRACE_00163936 APL‐GRACE_00163959 iOS performance DallaDTX‐252 APL‐GRACE_00163988 APL‐GRACE_00163991 iOS performance DallaDTX‐253 APL‐GRACE_00164021 APL‐GRACE_00164025 Apple customer service and support DallaDTX‐254 APL‐GRACE_00165085 APL‐GRACE_00165086 Development and maintenance of iOS DeirdDTX‐255 APL‐GRACE_00168543 APL‐GRACE_00168594 iOS performance MarkDTX‐256 APL‐GRACE_00169585 APL‐GRACE_00169587 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐257 APL‐GRACE_00169594 APL‐GRACE_00169597 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐258 APL‐GRACE_00169659 APL‐GRACE_00169660 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐259 APL‐GRACE_00169775 APL‐GRACE_00169779 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐260 APL‐GRACE_00169780 APL‐GRACE_00169785 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐261 APL‐GRACE_00169792 APL‐GRACE_00169799 Ex. 167 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐262 APL‐GRACE_00169800 APL‐GRACE_00169807 Ex. 167 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐263 APL‐GRACE_00169822 APL‐GRACE_00169840 iOS performance AvielDTX‐264 APL‐GRACE_00172031 APL‐GRACE_00172031 Ex. 64 Damages Ken PDTX‐265 APL‐GRACE_00172033 APL‐GRACE_00172034 Ex. 67 Damages Ken PDTX‐266 APL‐GRACE_00172056 APL‐GRACE_00172058 Ex. 66 Product information DeirdDTX‐267 APL‐GRACE_00172113 APL‐GRACE_00172118 Ex. 72 Damages Ken P

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 19 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐268 APL‐GRACE_00172182 APL‐GRACE_00172182 Ex. 71 Damages Ken PDTX‐269 APL‐GRACE_00172195 APL‐GRACE_00172198 Ex. 75 Damages Ken PDTX‐270 APL‐GRACE_00173229 APL‐GRACE_00173232 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐271 APL‐GRACE_00173236 APL‐GRACE_00173237 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐272 APL‐GRACE_00173241 APL‐GRACE_00173242 Development and maintenance of iOS DallaDTX‐273 APL‐GRACE_00175144 APL‐GRACE_00175147 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐274 APL‐GRACE_00175148 APL‐GRACE_00175151 Development and maintenance of iOS

JacquJacqu

DTX‐275 APL‐GRACE_00175152 APL‐GRACE_00175155 Vidrine Ex. 173 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐276 APL‐GRACE_00175156 APL‐GRACE_00175159 Development and maintenance of iOS

JacquJacqu

DTX‐277 APL‐GRACE_00175160 APL‐GRACE_00175163 Development and maintenance of iOS

JacquJacqu

DTX‐278 APL‐GRACE_00175164 APL‐GRACE_00175166 Development and maintenance of iOS

JacquJacqu

DTX‐279 APL‐GRACE_00175514 APL‐GRACE_00175539 Akamai JacquDTX‐280 APL‐GRACE_00175540 APL‐GRACE_00175565 Akamai JacquDTX‐281 APL‐GRACE_00175603 APL‐GRACE_00175639 Development and maintenance of iOS JacquDTX‐282 APL‐GRACE_00175720 APL‐GRACE_00175759 Akamai JacquDTX‐283 APL‐GRACE_00175997 APL‐GRACE_00176034 Akamai JacquDTX‐284 APL‐GRACE‐CODE00000054 Development and maintenance of iOS

JacquJacqu

DTX‐285 Brightstar000001‐000030 Brightstar000030 Ex. 79 Damages

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 20 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐286 Brightstar000031‐000044 Brightstar000044 Ex. 80 DamagesDTX‐287 Brightstar000045‐000055 Brightstar000055 Ex. 78 DamagesDTX‐288

Christina Grace Verification for Interrogatory Responses dated April 17, 2018 Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐289

Christina Grace Verification for Interrogatory Responses dated March 7, 2018 Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐290

Data analyzed by N. Malhotra and produced as " Malhotra data production" Damages Neil 

DTX‐291

Exhibit C to the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of Dr. Aviel Rubin

History and development of Apple, its iPhone products, and iOS operating systems Aviel

DTX‐292 Expert Report of Aviel Rubin Discovery / Pleadings AvielDTX‐293 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Discovery / Pleadings Neil DTX‐294

Figure 1 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐295

Figure 2 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 21 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐296

Graphic on p. 15 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of A. Rubin

History and development of Apple, its iPhone products, and iOS operating systems Aviel

DTX‐297

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/20

13/09/new‐lease‐on‐life‐or‐death‐sentence‐ios‐7‐on‐the‐iphone‐4/ iOS performance Aviel

DTX‐298

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/20

14/03/ios‐7‐1‐on‐the‐iphone‐4‐as‐good‐as‐its‐going‐to‐get/ Product information Deird

DTX‐299

https://comodosslstore.com/resour

ces/how‐to‐fix‐net‐err_cert_date_invalid‐error‐on‐google‐chrome/ Development and maintenance of iOS Aviel

DTX‐300

https://developer.apple.com/docu

mentation/security/certificate_key_and_trust_services/trust/creating_a_trust_object?language=objc Development and maintenance of iOS Aviel

DTX‐301

https://eid.eesti.ee/index.php/A_Sh

ort_Introduction_to_eID Development and maintenance of iOS Aviel

DTX‐302

https://opensource.apple.com/sour

ce/Security/Security‐55471/sec/Security/SecPolicy.h.auto.html Development and maintenance of iOS Deird

DTX‐303

https://stackoverflow.com/question

s/8770310/extending‐the‐android‐application‐certificate‐past‐itsexpiration Development and maintenance of iOS Aviel

DTX‐304

https://support.apple.com/en‐

us/HT201222/ Product information Deird

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 22 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐305

https://support.apple.com/en‐us/HT201542

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 15 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐306

https://support.apple.com/en‐us/HT201954

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 14 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐307

https://support.apple.com/en‐us/HT202934

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 8 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐308

https://support.apple.com/en‐us/HT202935

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 10 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐309

https://support.apple.com/en‐us/HT202965

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 7 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐310

https://support.apple.com/en‐us/HT203014

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 12 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐311

https://support.apple.com/en‐us/HT204204 Development and maintenance of iOS Deird

DTX‐312

https://support.apple.com/kb/dl1682?locale=en_US

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 4 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐313

https://support.apple.com/kb/dl1682?locale=en_US. Product information Deird

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 23 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐314

https://support.apple.com/kb/dl1701?locale=en_US

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 5 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐315

https://support.apple.com/kb/dl170

2?locale=en_US Product information Deird

DTX‐316

https://support.apple.com/kb/dl1723?locale=en_US

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 9 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐317

https://support.apple.com/kb/dl1732?locale=en_US

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 11 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐318

https://support.apple.com/kb/dl1750?locale=en_US

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 13 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐319

https://web.archive.org/web/20140425185401/http://support.apple.com/kb/TS5419

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 6 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐320

https://www.apple.com/appleca/Ap

pleIncRootCertificate.cer. Development and maintenance of iOS Aviel

DTX‐321

https://www.apple.com/batteries/maximizing‐performance/

Class Cert Opp Ex. 3 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐322

https://www.apple.com/certificatea

uthority/ Development and maintenance of iOS Aviel

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 24 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐323

https://www.apple.com/newsroom/

2010/06/07Apple‐Presents‐iPhone‐4/ Product information Deird

DTX‐324

p // pp / /

2013/09/10iOS‐7‐With‐Completely‐Redesigned‐User‐Interface‐Great‐New‐Features‐Available‐September‐18/ Product information Deird

DTX‐325

https://www.juniper.net/document

ation/en_US/junos‐space17.2/platform/topics/concept/junos‐spacecertificate‐management‐overview.html#jd0e43 Development and maintenance of iOS Aviel

DTX‐326

Ken Potter Verification for Interrogatory Responses dated March 8, 2018 Discovery / Pleadings Ken P

DTX‐327

Learn how to use FaceTime on your iPhone https://support.apple.com/en‐us/HT204380 Development and maintenance of iOS

AvielCaldb

DTX‐328

Plaintiff Christina Grace's Responses to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐329

Plaintiff Ken Potter's Amended Responses to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Ken P

DTX‐330

Plaintiff Ken Potter's Fourth Amended Responses to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 25 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐331

Plaintiff Ken Potter's Responses to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Ken P

DTX‐332

Plaintiff Ken Potter's Second Amended Responses to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Ken P

DTX‐333

Plaintiffs' Amended Objections and Responses to Defendant's Second Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐334

Plaintiffs' Amended Objections and Responses to Defendant's Third Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐335

Plaintiffs' Amended Response to Defendant's Fifth Set of Interrrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐336

Plaintiffs' Amended Response to Defendant's Fourth Set of Interrrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐337

Plaintiffs' Further Amended Objections and Responses to Defendant's Second Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐338

Plaintiffs' Objections and Responses to Defendant's Fifth Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐339

Plaintiffs' Objections and Responses to Defendant's Fourth Set of Requests for Admission Discovery / Pleadings Chris

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 26 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐340

Plaintiffs' Objections and Responses to Defendant's Second Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐341

Plaintiffs' Objections and Responses to Defendant's Third Set of Requests for Admission Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐342

Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Fourth Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐343

Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Second Set of Request for Admission Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐344

Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Third Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐345

Plaintiffs' Responses to Defendant's First Set of Request for Admission Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐346

Plaintiffs' Second Amended Objections and Responses to Defendant's Second Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐347

Plaintiffs' Third Amended Objections and Responses to Defendant's Second Set of Interrogatories Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐348 PLAINTIFFS00001 PLAINTIFFS00001 Ex. 70 Product information ChrisDTX‐349 PLAINTIFFS00319 PLAINTIFFS00319 Ex. 32 Damages Chris

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 27 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐350 PLAINTIFFS00326 PLAINTIFFS00326 Ex. 33 Damages Chris

DTX‐351 PLAINTIFFS00364 PLAINTIFFS00364 Ex. 73 Damages Ken P

DTX‐352 PLAINTIFFS00376 PLAINTIFFS00376 Ex. 74 Damages Ken P

DTX‐353 PLAINTIFFS00422 PLAINTIFFS00423 Ex. 69 Damages Ken P

DTX‐354 PLAINTIFFS00450 PLAINTIFFS00450 Ex. 76 Damages Ken P

DTX‐355 PLAINTIFFS00456 PLAINTIFFS00456 Ex. 77 Damages Ken P

DTX‐356 PLAINTIFFS00548 PLAINTIFFS00548 Ex. 68 Damages Ken 

DTX‐357 PLAINTIFFS00592 PLAINTIFFS00592 Ex. 65 Damages Ken 

DTX‐358 PLAINTIFFS00621 PLAINTIFFS00622 Ex. 63 Damages Ken 

DTX‐359 PLAINTIFFS00645 PLAINTIFFS00646 Ex. 78 Damages Ken 

DTX‐360

RFC5280: Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure Certificate and Certificate Revocation List(CRL) Profile, https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5280 Development and maintenance of iOS Aviel

DTX‐361

Table 1 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐362

Table 2 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 28 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐363

Table 3.1 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐364

Table 3.2 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐365

Table 3.3 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐366

Table 3.4 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐367

Table 3.5 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐368

Table 3.6 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐369

Table 3.7 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐370

Table 4.1 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐371

Table 4.2 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 29 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐372

Table 4.3 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐373

Table on p. 12 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐374

Table on p. 17 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐375

Table on p. 9 of the 9/18/2018 Expert Report of N. Malhotra Damages Neil 

DTX‐376 VERIZON0000001 Ex. 89 Damages Dr. JuDTX‐377

Apple Presents iPhone 4 press release 

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 1 [public]

History and development of Apple, its iPhone products, and iOS operating systems Dalla

DTX‐378

Apple Launches iPhone 4S, iOS 5 & iCloud press release

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 2 [public] Product information Deird

DTX‐379 Spreadsheet of AT&T data

Class Cert Opp. Ex. 8 [sealed] Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐380

Subpoena to Testify at a Deposiiton in a Civil Action to AT&T Mobility LLC Ex. 111 Discovery / Pleadings

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 30 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐381

Data file A.1, provided by AT&T, average trade‐in value Ex. 112 Damages Neil 

DTX‐382

Excel export of the first part  of file A.1, average trade‐in value Ex. 113 Damages Neil 

DTX‐383

Excerpt from file A.2, provided  by AT&T, average trade‐in value Ex. 114 Damages Neil 

DTX‐384

Subset of the data from A.2 in Excel format, average trade‐in value Ex. 115 Damages Neil 

DTX‐385

Excerpt from file A.3, produced by AT&T, average trade‐in value Ex. 116 Damages Neil 

DTX‐387

Article by C. Rampell entitled "Cracking the Apple Trap," New York Times, October 29, 2013 Ex. 185 Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐388

Article by S. Costello ∙entitled "Should You Upgrade Your iPhone 4 to iOS7?" Lifewire, updated August 9, 2016 Ex. 186 Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐389

Apple Support / customer discussion re "Does iOS 7 Slow Down an iPhone 4?" Ex. 187 Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐390

Table entitled "Trade‐In Promotions" Ex. 188 Damages Dr. Ju

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 31 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐391 Y2K Bug Encyclopedia Entry Ex. 193 Development and maintenance of iOS MarkDTX‐393

Merriam‐Webster Definition of "Bug" Ex. 195 Development and maintenance of iOS Mark

DTX‐394

"Certificates ‐ Apple Developer Documentation" Ex. 198 Development and maintenance of iOS Mark

DTX‐395

"RFC 5280 ‐ Internet X.509 Public Key Infrastructure Certificate and Certificate Revocation" Ex. 199 Development and maintenance of iOS Mark

DTX‐396

"Policies ‐ Apple Developer Documentation" Ex. 200 Development and maintenance of iOS Mark

DTX‐397

Graph "Overall FaceTime User Traffic (Rolling Max)" Ex. 203 Development and maintenance of iOS Mark

DTX‐398

Plaintiff Christina Grace's First Amended Responses to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories Ex. 26 Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐399

Plaintiffs' Responses and Objections to Defendant's First Request for Production of Documents Ex. 31 Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐400

First Amended Class Action Complaint Ex. 34 Discovery / Pleadings Chris

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 32 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐401

Declaration of Christina Grace in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion to Certify a Nationwide Class Ex. 35 Discovery / Pleadings Chris

DTX‐402

Defendant Apple Inc.'s Notice of Service of Revised Subpoena to Akamai Technologies, Inc. Ex. 36 Discovery / Pleadings David

DTX‐403 LinkedIn profile of David Hale  Ex. 37 Akamai DavidDTX‐404

Akamai IP Application Accelerator  Order Form Ex. 38 Akamai David

DTX‐405

Akamai Web Performance Solutions Product Brief Ex. 39 Akamai David

DTX‐406 Addendum to Akamai Contract Ex. 40 Akamai DavidDTX‐407

Email thread dated 11/7/12 from David Hale Re: Triton firedrill Ex. 41 iOS performance David

DTX‐408

Email thread dated 11/17/12 from David Hale Re: Meeting Minutes on Apple Facetime Upgrade Ex. 42 Akamai David

DTX‐409

Akamai IP Application Accelerator  Order Form Ex. 43 Akamai David

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 33 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐410 Addendum #IPA 02 Ex. 44 Akamai DavidDTX‐411

Akamai IP Application Accelerator  Order Form Ex. 45 Akamai David

DTX‐412 Addendum #IPA 03 Ex. 46 Akamai DavidDTX‐413 Overall FaceTime User Traffic graphs Ex. 47 Akamai DavidDTX‐414 Overall FaceTime User Traffic graphs Ex. 48 Akamai DavidDTX‐415

Email thread dated 6/19/14 from Duke Hong Re: Triton ‐ volume drop in mid April Ex. 49 Akamai David

DTX‐416 Addendum #IPA 04 Ex. 50 Akamai DavidDTX‐417

Akamai IP Application Accelerator  Order Form Ex. 51 Akamai David

DTX‐418 Addendum #IPA 05 Ex. 52 Akamai David

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 34 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐419 IPA Relay Service ‐ Total Revenue Ex. 53 Akamai DavidDTX‐420 Triton Contract spreadsheets Ex. 54 Akamai DavidDTX‐421 Triton Capacity spreadsheets Ex. 55 Akamai DavidDTX‐422

Akamai Technologies, Inc. invoices to Apple Inc. Ex. 56 Akamai David

DTX‐423

Email thread dated 6/10/14 from Morris Leeor Re: Triton ‐ volume drop in mid April Ex. 57 Akamai David

DTX‐424 Overall FaceTime User Traffic graphs Ex. 58 Akamai DavidDTX‐425

First Amended Class Action Complaint Ex. 59 Discovery / Pleadings Ken P

DTX‐426

Plaintiff Ken Potter's Third Amended Responses to Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories Ex. 60 Discovery / Pleadings Ken P

DTX‐427

Verification of Interrogatory Answers Ex. 61 Discovery / Pleadings Ken P

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 35 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐428

Declaration of Ken Potter in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion to Certify a Nationwide Class Ex. 62 Discovery / Pleadings Ken P

DTX‐429

Subpoena to Testify at a Deposition in a Civil Action to Brightstar Corp. Ex. 82 Discovery / Pleadings

DTX‐430

Subpoena to Testify at a Deposition in a Civil Action to Brightstar International Corp. Ex. 83 Discovery / Pleadings

DTX‐431

Information sheet for iOS 7.1 update Ex. 85 Product information Deird

DTX‐432

iPhone devices upgrading to iOS 7 (9/2013 through 12/2014) Ex. 87 Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐433

 Spreadsheet of AT&T data, average price / trade‐in values Ex. 88 Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐434  Spreadsheet of AT&T data Ex. 88 Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐435

Best Buy Secondary Markets IT Responses as of 04/19/2018 Ex. 90 Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐436

Memorandum from Competition Economics, LLC re ecoATM Data Questions Ex. 91 Damages Neil 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 36 of 39
CASE NO. 5:17‐CV‐00551‐LHK (NC)// Grace v. Apple, Inc. 

No. Beginning Bates Stamp Ending Bates Stamp Exhibit (if Any) Topic SponDTX‐437

6 Simple Steps to an iPhone Trade‐in Ex. 93 Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐438

Best Buy transaction by customer Records Ex. 94 Damages Dr. Ju

DTX‐439 Best Buy Trade In FAQs Ex. 95 Damages Dr. JuDTX‐440 Brightstar Article Ex. 96 Damages Dr. JuDTX‐441

Apple Inc. iOS Software License Agreement

MTD Ex. 1 and MSJ Ex. 9 Product information Deird

DTX‐442

Unable to make or receive FaceTime calls after April 16, 2014, KB Article, TS5419 MTD Ex. 3 Apple customer service and support Deird

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 37 of 39
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

7

APPLE’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST / CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK (NC) 

Gibson, Dunn & 

Crutcher LLP 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I, Ashley Moser, declare as follows: 

I am employed in the County of San Francisco, State of California, I am over the age of 

eighteen years and am not a party to this action; my business address is 555 Mission Street, Suite 

3000, San Francisco, CA 94105-0921, in said County and State. On the date set forth below, I served 

the following document(s): 

APPLE’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST 

 BY ELECTRONIC TRANSFER TO THE CM/ECF SYSTEM: On this date, I electronically uploaded a true

and correct copy in Adobe “pdf” format the above-listed document(s) to the United States District Court’s Case

Management and Electronic Case Filing (CM/ECF) system. After the electronic filing of a document, service is

deemed complete upon receipt of the Notice of Electronic Filing (“NEF”) by the registered CM/ECF users.

 (FEDERAL) I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.

Executed on December 13, 2019 

/s/ Ashley Moser

Ashley Moser 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 38 of 39
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

8

APPLE’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST / CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK (NC) 

Gibson, Dunn & 

Crutcher LLP 

SERVICE LIST 

Bruce L. Simon 

Daniel L. Warshaw 

Alexander Lee Simon 

PEARSON SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP 

44 Montgomery Street, Suite 2450 

San Francisco, CA 94104 

Telephone: 415-433-9000 

Fax: 415-433-9008 

Email: bsimon@pswlaw.com 

Email: dwarshaw@pswlaw.com 

Email: asimon@pswlaw.com 

Attorneys for Plaintiffs 

Bradley W. Caldwell 

Christopher S. Stewart 

Jason D. Cassady 

John A. Curry 

John Summers 

Daniel R. Pearson 

Warren J. McCarty III 

CALDWELL CASSADY CURRY P.C. 

2101 Cedar Springs Road, Suite 1000 

Dallas, TX 75201 

Telephone: 214-888-4848 

Fax: 214-888-4849 

Email: bcaldwell@caldwellcc.com 

Email: cstewart@caldwellcc.com 

Email: jcassady@caldwellcc.com 

Email: acurry@caldwellcc.com 

Email: jsummers@caldwellcc.com 

Email: dpearson@caldwellcc.com 

Email: wmccarty@caldwellcc.com 

Email: grace@caldwellcc.com 

Attorneys for Plaintiffs 

David F.E. Tejtel 

FRIEDMAN OSTER & TEJTEL PLLC 

240 East 79th Street, Suite A 

New York, NY 10075 

Telephone: 646-661-5881 

Email: dtejtel@fotpllc.com 

Attorneys for Plaintiffs 

Allan Steyer 

Jill M. Manning 

D. Scott Macrae

Suneel Jain

STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ &

SMITH LLP

One California Street, Suite 300

San Francisco, CA 94111

Telephone: 415-421-3400

Fax: 415-421-2234

Email: asteyer@steyerlaw.com

Email: jmanning@steyerlaw.com

Email: smacrae@steyerlaw.com

Email: sjain@steyerlaw.com

Attorneys for Plaintiffs 

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 341-4 Filed 12/16/19 Page 39 of 39