1

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

Case No: 5:17-cv-00220-LHK

Case Name: Federal Trade Commission v. Qualcomm Incorporated

JUDGE: PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY: DEFENSE ATTORNEY:

Lucy H. Koh Jennifer Milici Robert Van Nest

TRIAL DATE: REPORTER(S): CLERK:

January 8, 2019 Lee-Anne Shortridge, Irene Rodriguez Elizabeth Garcia

TRIAL SHEET, EXHIBIT and WITNESS LIST

PLF 

NO.

DEF 

NO.

TIME 

OFFERED

ID REC DESCRIPTION

PD 9:06 am** Trial continues. The Court continues with sealed 

testimony by witness John Grubbs by video 

deposition. The courtroom is cleared.

9:26 am** Video deposition concludes. Witness is subject to 

recall. 

PD 9:30 am** The Court moves into sealed testimony by witness 

Scott McGregor by video deposition. The courtroom 

remains cleared. Counsel for plaintiff moves to admit 

trial exhibit and requests the exhibit be sealed. The 

Court granted the request to admit and seal the 

exhibit.

9:44 am Deposition of Scott McGregor concludes. Witness is 

subject to recall. The court concludes sealed testimony 

and reopens the courtroom. 

PD 9:46 am Counsel for Plaintiff calls next witness Andrew Hong 

by video deposition. Counsel for plaintiff moves to 

admit the following exhibits:

CX 9:47 am X X CX 2628

9:47 am X X JX 00122

10:01 am Video deposition of Andrew Hong interrupted. 

Colloquy re: exhibits with counsel. 

10:02 am Continued video deposition of Andrew Hong. 

10:08 am Video deposition of Andrew Hong concludes. Witness 

is subject to recall. 

10:10 am Colloquy re sealing of various exhibits. The Court 

seals exhibits in part: 

CX X X CX 7591

CX X X CX 5551

PD 10:15 am Counsel for plaintiff calls next witness, William Wyatt 

for direct examination.

*Refer to the court transcript for official trial time and exhibits

**Sealed

Case 5:17-cv-00220-LHK Document 1194-1 Filed 01/08/19 Page 1 of 4
2

Case No: 5:17-cv-00220-LHK

Case Name: Federal Trade Commission v. Qualcomm Incorporated

Date: January 8, 2019

Courtroom Deputy: Elizabeth Garcia Court Reporter: Lee-Anne Shortridge, Irene Rodriguez

TRIAL SHEET, EXHIBIT and WITNESS LIST CONTINUED

PLF 

NO.

DEF 

NO.

TIME 

OFFERED

ID REC DESCRIPTION

Counsel for plaintiff moves to admit exhibits into 

evidence. The exhibits were admitted:

CX 10:18 am X X CX 5800

CX 10:20 am X X CX 7591

CX 10:24 am X X CX 5551

CX 10:26 am X X CX 8291

CX 10:31 am X X CX 5809

CX 10:33 am X X CX 5767

CX 10:36 am X X CX 8292

DX 10:39 am Cross examination of William Wyatt

X QX 9312 

10:48 am The court takes the mid morning recess.

11:02 am Proceedings resume with cross examination of 

William Wyatt. 

11:06 am Counsel for Defendant moves to admit exhibits into 

evidence: 

11:06 am X X QX 9250

11:24 am X QX 9312

PRD 11:25 am Redirect examination of William Wyatt. 

11:26 am No re-cross. Witness not subject to recall. Witness is 

excused. The Court holds colloquy on various exhibits 

that may be requested to be sealed by defendant. The 

Court granted the sealing request as to the following:

JX 0086

CX 7644

JX 0096

PD 11:39 am Plaintiff calls Cristiano Amon for direct examination. 

Plaintiff moves exhibits into evidence: 

CX 11:42 am X X CX 8257

CX 11:45 am X X CX 5393

*Refer to the court transcript for official trial time and exhibits

**Sealed

Case 5:17-cv-00220-LHK Document 1194-1 Filed 01/08/19 Page 2 of 4
3

Case No: 5:17-cv-00220-LHK

Case Name: Federal Trade Commission v. Qualcomm Incorporated

Date: January 8, 2019

Courtroom Deputy: Elizabeth Garcia Court Reporter: Lee-Anne Shortridge, Irene Rodriguez

TRIAL SHEET, EXHIBIT and WITNESS LIST CONTINUED

PLF 

NO.

DEF 

NO.

TIME 

OFFERED

ID REC DESCRIPTION

CX 11:47 am X X CX 5294

CX 11:48 am CX 5279

CX 11:48 am CX 6839

CX 11:55 am CX 6840

CX 11:57 am CX 8276

CX 11:58 am CX 7606

CX 12:00 pm CX 7607

12:00 pm The court takes the lunch recess. 

1:01 pm Colloquy regarding follow up on sealing of specific 

exhibits. The Court grants in part, denies in part 

sealing for the following exhibit:

CX 8256

1:10 pm Continued direct examination of Cristiano Amon. 

Counsel for plaintiff moves the following exhibits into 

evidence. The exhibits were admitted:

CX 1:12 pm X X CX 7644

JX 1:14 pm X X JX 0096

CX 1:16 pm X X CX 8256

CX 1:18 pm X X CX 5321

CX 1:23 pm X X CX 5053

CX 1:24 pm X X CX 7024

DX 1:26 pm Cross examination of Cristiano Amon. 

Counsel for defendant moves to admit the following 

exhibit. The Court granted it admitted for limited 

purpose:

QX 2:05 pm X X QX 9225

PRD 2:20 pm Redirect examination of Cristiano Amon. 

2:28 pm No further re-cross. Witness is subject to recall. 

2:29 pm The court takes the mid afternoon recess.

PD 2:41 pm Proceedings resume. Plaintiff calls next witness, 

Aichatou Evans for direct examination. 

*Refer to the court transcript for official trial time and exhibits

**Sealed

Case 5:17-cv-00220-LHK Document 1194-1 Filed 01/08/19 Page 3 of 4
4

Case No: 5:17-cv-00220-LHK

Case Name: Federal Trade Commission v. Qualcomm Incorporated

Date: January 8, 2019

Courtroom Deputy: Elizabeth Garcia Court Reporter: Lee-Anne Shortridge, Irene Rodriguez

TRIAL SHEET, EXHIBIT and WITNESS LIST CONTINUED

PLF 

NO.

DEF 

NO.

TIME 

OFFERED

ID REC DESCRIPTION

3:21 pm Plaintiff moves to admit exhibits into evidence. Exhibits 

were admitted:

3:21 pm X X CX 1599

3:27 pm X X CX 1598

3:34 pm The court takes the mid afternoon recess.

3:45 pm Proceedings resume. Continued direct examination of 

Aichatou Evans. 

DX 3:46 pm Direct examination concludes. Cross examination of 

Aichatou Evans. 

Counsel for defendant moves the following exhibit into 

evidence. No objections. Exhibit admitted:

QX 3:53 pm X X QX 76

3:58 pm Colloquy re admission of exhibit QX 92. Exhibit

admitted:

4:00 pm QX 92

4:07 pm Counsel for defendant moved the following exhibit into 

evidence. Exhibit admitted:

4:07 pm QX 89

4:17 pm QX 94

4:19 pm Colloquy with counsel.

4:20 pm Cross examination of Aichatou Evans continues. 

4:36 pm The court asks the witness Aichatou Evans to return on 

Friday, January 11, 2018 at 9:00 am for continuance of 

her testimony. The court holds colloquy with counsel on 

housekeeping matters.

4:44 pm Proceedings conclude. Further Bench Trial set for 

January 11, 2019 at 9:00 am. 

*Refer to the court transcript for official trial time and exhibits

** Sealed

Case 5:17-cv-00220-LHK Document 1194-1 Filed 01/08/19 Page 4 of 4