Skip to main content Skip to search


Browse by
                    category
                Browse by
                    bureaus & offices
            About the FCC
          About the FCC
                      About the FCC Overview
                                                      What We Do
                                                      Rulemaking Process
                                                      Leadership
                                                      FCC Initiatives
                                                      Find People
                                                      Organizational Charts
                                                      Advisory Committees
                                                      Jobs and Internships
                                                      Contracting
                                                      Strategic Plans & Budgets
                                                      Contact
                                                                    FY 2025 Congressional Budget Justification
                                                      Privacy Policy
                                                      Accessibility Program
                Proceedings & Actions
          Proceedings & Actions
                      Proceedings and Actions Overview
                                                      Electronic Comment Filing System (ECFS)
                                                      Commission Documents (EDOCS)
                                                      Most Active Proceedings
                                                      Items on Circulation
                                                      Ex-Parte
                                                      Daily Digest
                                                      Mergers & Transactions
                                                      Auctions
                Licensing & Databases
          Licensing & Databases
                      Overview
                                                      About Licensing
                                                      Databases
                                                      Fees
                                                      Forms
                                                      FCC Registration System (CORES)
                                                      System Alerts & Notifications
                                                      ASR
                                                      CDBS
                                                      CEFS
                                                      COALS
                                                      CORES
                                                      CSRS
                                                      DIRS
                                                      EA
                                                      ECFS
                                                      EDOCS
                                                      ELS
                                                      ETFS
                                                      ETRS
                                                      GenMen
                                                      HAM
                                                      KDB
                                                      KIDVID
                                                      LMS
                                                      ICFS
                                                      NORS
                                                      PIF
                                                      PIRATE
                                                      PSIX-ESIX
                                                      RLD
                                                      TCB
                                                      ULS
                                                      URS
                                                      VPD
                Reports & Research
          Reports & Research
                      Reports and Data Overview
                                                      Reports
                                                      Data
                                                      Guides
                                                                    Maps
                                                      Working Papers
                                                      For Developers
                                                                    Fiscal Year 2022-2026 Strategic Plan
                                                      Workload Dashboard
                News & Events
          News & Events
                      News and Events Overview
                                                      Headlines
                                                      Commission Meetings
                                                      Events
                                                      Archived Events
                                                      FCC Podcast
                                                      Notes from the FCC
                                                      FCC Blog
                                                      RSS Feeds & Email Signup
                                                                    April 2024 Open Commission Meeting
                For Consumers
          For Consumers
                      Help Center Overview
                                                                    Consumer Complaint Center
                                                      Disability Rights
                                                      Headlines
                                                      Social Media
                                                                    Robocalls
                                                                    Consumer Complaint Center
              Consumer
                Enforcement
                Media
                Public Safety
                Space
                Wireless
                Wireline
                Offices
    
                  Search
  

  X
  Search Home
              News & Events
              FCC Blog

  FCC Transaction Review: Competition and the Public Interest August 12, 2014 - 12:39 pm
    Jon Sallet | General Counsel

    
    The Federal Communications Commission has long played a unique and pivotal role in reviewing communications transactions. Our review is prescribed by the Communications Act and is separate from (though complementary to) the analysis conducted by our sister, antitrust agencies under Section 7 of the Clayton Act.
Three points about the Commission's review of transactions are important to understand: First, the nature of the substantive review that Congress has instructed the Commission to apply. Second, the process that the Commission has instituted, consistent with that statutory standard, to provide an open and fair means of reviewing transactions. Third, the manner in which the complementary approaches of the Commission and the antitrust agencies work harmoniously to serve the public interest in a sector that has traditionally been the subject of careful governmental scrutiny.
The starting point of our mission—and therefore, our substantive review—is the language of the Communications Act itself.
Congress has directed the Commission to review transactions involving licenses and authorizations under the Communications Act and to determine whether the proposed transaction would serve "the public interest, convenience, and necessity."1 The breadth and importance of the public-interest standard to the review of transactions involving our nation's communications networks logically flows from the Commission's statutory mission, since the conduct of buying other licensees can be as important to the public as the way a licensed company conducts itself in the absence of a transaction. This standard complements, but is different from the antitrust agencies' standard set forth Section 7 of the Clayton Act, which instructs them to challenge transactions that would "substantially lessen competition".
I believe, as the Commission has consistently recognized,2 that the FCC's actions should be informed by competition principles. These principles look to the impact of practices on consumers and the public interest, not just on competitors. They are designed to be fact-based and data-driven. They reflect a common-law belief that the experiences of the present are, to paraphrase Justice Holmes, as important as the logic of the past. They should be applied in a rigorous manner.
But, the "public interest" standard is not limited to purely economic outcomes. It necessarily encompasses the "broad aims of the Communications Act,"3 which include, among other things, a deeply rooted preference for preserving and enhancing competition in relevant markets, accelerating private-sector deployment of advanced services, ensuring a diversity of information sources and services to the public,4 and generally managing spectrum in the public interest. Our public interest analysis may also entail assessing whether the transaction will affect the quality of communications services or will result in the provision of new or additional services to consumers. The leading examples may come from broadcast transactions, where the Commission has long applied the congressional admonition to promote localism in programming, and especially news programming, available to communities.5 Consider also Justice Breyer's concurring opinion in *Turner Broadcasting v. FCC*.6 That case concerned a challenge to the "must carry" rules that require cable systems to carry local broadcast signals. In agreeing that the statute should be upheld, Justice Breyer expressly relied on Congress' goal of "promoting the widespread dissemination of information from a multiplicity of sources."7
The second important principle of the Commission's transaction-review is the process by which it carries out its congressionally-mandated functions. Fundamental is the fact that applicants have the burden of demonstrating on the public record that their proposed transaction is in the public interest. Oftentimes, the popular understanding seems to be that the Commission is called upon in the first instance to give a thumbs up or thumbs down. That is wrong.
As the Transactions Team Webpage explains in detail, the Commission can approve a transaction or it can approve a transaction with conditions designed to ensure the public interest is served. But, if after a thorough review the FCC is unable to find that the proposed transaction serves the public interest or if the record presents a substantial and material question of fact, it must designate that transaction for an administrative hearing. Such an administrative hearing examines the facts of the transaction in the traditional adversary process that is the hallmark of our common-law jurisprudence. Following that hearing, the Commission would render a decision on the merits after which, of course, judicial review is available. Although such hearings have been rare, the Commission has been ready to use them as the statute requires. For example, at the time that the applicants in the AT&T/T-Mobile merger withdrew their applications, the Commission's staff had prepared a report recommending that the transaction be designated for hearing.
Understanding the process also illuminates the role of conditions. Conditions can be very important because, appropriately constructed and effectively applied, they can remedy public-interest harms that would otherwise occur. This relationship to the remedy of harm is fundamental and it means that not all conditions can serve that role. As I have said before, I am aware of the reputation that some attribute to the FCC — that the answer is always "yes," and the path to "yes" is by bargaining with the agency. It is hard to imagine that such a view can be squared with the manner in which the Commission assiduously applied the law to the facts of the proposed AT&T/T-Mobile transaction, among others.
The third principle concerns the manner in which we work with the antitrust agencies.
The ability of both the Commission and antitrust agencies to apply their specialized, and complementary, skills is working well. The Commission and the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice cooperated closely to harmonize their approaches (always consistent with their respective statutory commands) in the Comcast-NBCU and AT&T/T-Mobile transactions and that continues to be the way we work together today.
Fidelity to Congressional intent, rigor in the application of facts to law through an open and fair process, and strong working relationships with the sister antitrust agencies — those are the principles that have worked well for the Commission in the past and, as theTransactions Team Webpage and its materials help explain, will continue to serve the public interest, convenience and necessity.

1. 47 U.S.C. §§ 214(a) & 310(d).
2. *See, e.g., Applications of Comcast Corp., Gen. Elec. Co., and NBC Universal, Inc. for Consent to Assign Licenses and Transfer Control of Licenses*, Memorandum Opinion and Order, 26 FCC Rcd. 4238, 4248, ¶23 (2011) ("Comcast/NBCU Order").
3. *Applications for Consent to the Transfer of Control of Licenses, XM Satellite Radio Holdings Inc., Transferor, to Sirius Satellite Radio Inc., Transferee*, Memorandum Opinion and Order and Report and Order, 23 FCC Rcd 12348,12364, ¶31 (2008); *News Corp. and DIRECTV Group, Inc. and Liberty Media Corp. for Authority to Transfer Control, Memorandum Opinion and Order*, 23 FCC Rcd 3265, 3277-78, ¶23 (2008); *Applications of AT&T Wireless Services, Inc. and Cingular Wireless Corp. for Consent to Transfer Control of Licenses and Authorizations*, Memorandum Opinion and Order, 19 FCC Rcd 21522, 21544, ¶41 (2004).
4. 47 U.S.C. § 521(4); *see also* 47 U.S.C. § 532(a).
5. *Comcast/NBCU Order*, 26 FCC Rcd. at 4249-50, ¶26-27.
6. 520 U.S. 180 (1997).
7. *Id*. at 226.
 Text
                  Federal Communications Commission
45 L Street NE
Washington, DC 20554

  Link
        Phone: 1-888-225-5322
              ASL Video Call: 1-844-432-2275
              Fax: 1-866-418-0232
              Contact Us
              Visiting FCC Facilities

          
          Link
        Website Policies & Notices
              Privacy Policy
              FOIA
              No Fear Act Data
              Digital Strategy
              Open Government Directive
              Plain Writing Act
              RSS Feeds & Email Updates
              Accessibility
              Vulnerability Disclosure Policy
              USA.gov

          
          Text
                  CATEGORIES

  Link
        About the FCC
              Proceedings & Actions
              Licensing & Databases
              Reports & Research
              News & Events
              For Consumers

          
          Text
                  BUREAUS & OFFICES

  Link
        Consumer
              Enforcement
              Inspector General
              Media
              Public Safety
              Space
              Wireless
              Wireline
              Offices


          Twitter
        Facebook
        Youtube
        Instagram

          Federal Communications Commission