# The Attorney General of Texas

July 8, 1982 MARK WHITE Attorney General

Supreme Court Building P. 0. BOY 12546 Austin, TX. 7671% 2546 512/475-2501 Telex 9101674-1367 Telecopier 5121475-0266

1607 Main St., Suite 1400 Dallas, TX. 75201.4709 2141742.6944

4624 Alberta Ave., Suite 160 El Paso, TX. 79005-2793 9151533.3464

1220 Dallas Ave., Suite 202 Houston, TX. 770026966 7131650-0666

606 Broadway, Suite 312 Lubbock, TX. 79401.3479 6061747-5236

4309 N. Tenth. Suite B McAllen, TX. 76501-1665 5121662.4547

200 Main Plaza, Suite 400 San Antonio, TX. 76205.2797 5121225-4191

An Equal Opportunity/ Affirmative Action Employer Honorable Jerry Bhackelford Chairman opinionNo.MW-491

Texas Juvenile ProbationCommission Re: Whether Deaf SmithCounty 309 PotterCounty Courthouse =Y continue to employ a Amarillo,Texas 79101 juvenilepeace officer

Dear Judge Shackelford:

You recently requestedan interpretationof House Bill No. 1704. which became effective on September 1, 1981 and is codified as Human ResourcesCode sections 75.001, et seq.
You ask:
1. Does section- 75.042(f) repeal the authority of the Deaf Smith County Juvenile Board to employ a juvenile peace officer under articles 5139DDD and 5142, V.T.C.S.?
2. If such authority does remain in effect, is the Deaf Smith County Juvenile Board in compliancewith House Bill No. 1704,by combining both of the titles as equal positions, under the same office, including the sharing of files, budget, etc.? If not, do the statutes require separate and distinct offices under the juvenile board?

In order to answeryour questions, it is necessary to analyze the statutes to determinewhat each authorized. We will also discuss the customand practicewith respect to allocatingdutiesbetween juvenile officerswhich countieshave followed.
Article 5142, V.T.C.S., was enacted in 1919, and originally provided for the appointment of "probation officers." It was amended in 1927 to apply to "juvenileofficers." The duties, of these officers were enumerated in article 5142:

Such officers shallhave authorityand it shall be their duty to make investigationsof all cases referred to them as such by such Board; to be

p. 1745HonorableJerry Shackelford- Page 2 (MW-491)

present in court and to represent the interest of the juvenile when the case is heard, and to furnish to the court and such Board any information and assistance as such Board may require, and to take charge of any child before and after the trial and to perform such other services for the child as may be requiredby the court or said Board, and such juvenile officers shall be vested with all the power and authority of police officers or sheriffs incident to their offices. (Emphasisadded).
Article 5142 has not been expresslyrepealed. A juvenile officerwith the powers enumerated in this provision has the authority of a peace officer. Attorney GeneralOpinionH-1157 (1978).
The duties of the juvenile officer alongwith his title indicate that juvenileofficerswould have the responsibilitiesof both a peace officer and of a child's advocate. See, e.g., In re S.E.B., 514 S.W.2d 948 (Tex. Civ. App. - El Paso 1974, no writ) (a juvenile officer may make arrest without a warrant for any offense committed within his presence or view); Attorney General Opinion O-7332 (1946) (a juvenile officer has the legal right to carry a gun in the dischargeof officialduty). Both responsibilitieswere to lie in one person, as shown by the provision in article 5142 for one juvenile officer in counties under 80,000 persons. Attorney General Opinion o-2997 (1941).
Article 5139DDD,enacted in 1971,authorized the establishmentof a juvenile board in the county of Deaf Smith, and permitted the appointment of a juvenile officer or officers. Section 3 of that article gave the county board the final determination of the qualifications for the position of juvenile officer. All the powers and duties described in article 5142 were expressly given to Deaf Smith juvenile officers. The legislaturehas not expressly repealed this statute.

You have forwarded to us information indicating that a juvenile officer was hired subsequent to the passage of article 5139DDD. and that in 1979, the juvenile board divided that office into two positions: juvenile peace officer and juvenile probation officer. The juvenile peace officer is commissioned through the sheriff's department. It appears, however, from our examination of articles 5139DDD and 5142, V.T.C.S., that juvenile officers in both positions would have the powers of peace officers, even though the board assigned them differentresponsibilitiesfor administrativereasons.

p. 1746HonorableJerry Shackelford- Page 3 (m-491)

You also sent us excerpts from the 1978 Texas Juvenile Probation Manual,which highlight the dichotomywhich has arisen due to the use of the title "juvenileofficer." It states in pertinentpart:

The usage of the term 'juvenile officer' is misleading. It is often used in reference to a police officer or deputy sheriff who works primarily with cases involving juveniles. Many Texas counties use the term to denote the officer who performs probation services for the Juvenile Court. The Texas statutes use the terms 'probation officer' and 'juvenile officer' interchangeably. Juvenile 'police' officers -- derive their authority from their commissions as peace officers. Their responsibilitiesand power are exactly the sameas for any peace officer,and it is only by departmental policy that they are assigned to juvenile cases. Juvenile 'probation' officers -- are juvenile court workers. Their work usuallybegins at the time of referralby the police officer,although inmany communitiestheir work overlaps that of the police officer. The bulk of their work lies in social investigations and social caseworkwith the juvenileoffenderand his family. Their authority stems from a series of 'bracketlaws,' the first of which was enacted in 1919. Prior to 1919, juvenile probation officers were provided for permissively. The Texas Juvenile Court Act of 1907 provided that a delinquentchild couldbe committed to the custody of a probation officer or any proper person. Probation officers were required to be 'discreet persons of goodmoral character,'and theywere to servewithout compensation. (Footnoteomitted).
The manual also states that there is little uniformity among the provisions for juvenile boards, and that many countieshave designed programs based upon social need rather than upon legislative authority.

In 1981, the legislature created the Texas Juvenile Probation Commissionand stated that:

The purposes of this chapterare tomake probation services available throughout the state for juveniles, to improve the effectiveness of probation services,to providealternativesto the commitmentof juvenilesby providing financialaid to juvenile boards for the establishment and

p. 1747Honorable Jerry Shackelford- Page 4 (Mw-491)

improvement of probation services, to establish uniform probationadministrationstandards,and to improve communications between state and local entities within the juvenile justice system. (Emphasisadded).
Section 75.001,Human ResourcesCode.
Section 75.041 provides that the commission shall establish educational, training, and certification standards for juvenile probation officers. Section 75.042 establishesminimum standards for juvenileprobationofficers. It states inpertinentpart:

Sec. 75.042. Minimum Standards

To be eligible for appointment as a probation officer, a person who is not employed as a juvenile probation officer on September 1. 1981, must:
(1) be of goodmoral character;

(2) have acquired a ,bachelor's degree conferredby a collegeor universityaccredited by an accrediting organization recognized by the Coordinating Board, Texas College and University System;
(3) have either:
(A) one year of graduate study in criminology, corrections, counseling, law, socialwork, psychology,sociology,or other field of instruction approved by the commission;or (B) one year of experience in full-time case work, counseling, community or group work in a social service, community, corrections, or juvenile agency that deals with offenders or disadvantaged persons and that is determined by the commissionto provide the kind of experience needed tomeet this requirement;and
(4) have satisfactorily completed the course of preservice training or instruction, have passed the tests or examinations, and

p. 1748HonorableJerry Shackelford- Page 5 (Mw-491)

of possess the level of certification as the commissionmay prescribe.
Cd) The commissionmay make rules [forwaiver graduate study or employmentexperience].
(e) [Requirements to be eligible for employmentsupervisingprobationofficers].
(f) A peace officer, a prosecuting attorney, and any other person who is employed by or who reports directly to a law enforcement or prosecution official may not act as a probation officer or be made responsible for supervisionof a juvenile on probation. A probation officermay not carry a firearm in the course of his official duties. (Emphasisadded).
Articles 75.041 and 75.042 may be harmonized with article 5139DDD.which gives theDeaf SmithCounty JuvenileBoard the right to final determination of the qualifications of juvenile probation officers. The board's discretion to make final determinations is limited, however, by the standards enumerated in section 75.042 or promulgated by the commission. The board's requirements as to qualificationsmay not fall below those stated in article 72.042 or promulgatedpursuant to article 72.041. There is no impliedrepeal of article 5139DDD since section 75.042 does not deal with the establishment of juvenile boards and does not remove appointment authority from the board. The legislaturehas given a more precise standard for juvenileprobationofficers,however, and the new statute should be read to harmonize with the old. State v. Jackson, 370 S.W.2d 797, 800 (Tex.Civ. App. - Houston 1963), aff'd 376 S.W.2d 341 (Tex. 1964).
Section 75.042(f) supercedes Attorney General Opinion O-7332 (1946)s which held that a juvenile probation officer may carry a firearm. In comparing section 75.042(f) to article 5142, it is important to note that article 5142 provided only that "such juvenile officers shall be vested with all the power and authority of police officers or sheriffs incident to their offices." Section 75.042(f) prohibits the employment of peace officers, but does not revoke the power vested in juvenile probation officers, except the authority to carry a firearm. Thus, article 5142, V.T.C.S., is repealed to the extent that it authorized juvenile probation officers to carry a firearm. Section 75.042(f), in establishing uniform standards as stated in section 75.001, clearly and unambiguously states that peace officersand any otherpersonwho reports to a law enforcementofficer may not serve as juvenile probation officers. A "peace officer" within section 75.042(f)refers to someoneemployedby or reporting to

p. 1749.

HonorableJerry Shackelford- Page 6 (Mw-491)

a law enforcementagency. It does not refer topersons reporting to a juvenile board. A sheriff and his deputies are peace officers, article 2.12 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. However, a juvenile probationofficerwith the authorityof a police officer or sheriff is not a "peace officer" within section 75.042(f) because he does not report to a law enforcementagency.
You have informedus that theDeaf Smith "juvenilepeace officer" is a peace officer who carries a commission through the Deaf Smith County sheriff. Since section 75.042(f)prohibits the employmentof a peace officeras a juvenileprobationofficer,he may not serve in the latter capacity. It is therefore unnecessary to answer your second question.

SUMMARY

Under articles 5139DDD and 5142, V.T.C.S., as modified by sections 72.041 and 72.042(f) of the Human Resources Code, the juvenile probation officers employed by Deaf Smith County have the power and authority of police officers and sheriffs except that they may not carry guns. Since section 75.042(f)prohibits a peace officer from serving as a juvenile probation officer, a deputy sheriffmay not serve in that capacity.



# mg

Attorney General of Texas
JOHNW. FAINTER,JR. FirstAssistantAttorneyGeneral

RICHARD E. GRAY III ExecutiveAssistantAttorneyGeneral Preparedby PatriciaHinojosa AssistantAttorneyGeneral

APPROVED: OPINION COMMITTEE
SusanL. Garrison,Chairman Jon Bible Rick Gilpin Maury Hexamer PatriciaHinojosa Jim Moellinger

p. 1750