# Supreme Court of Florida

____________ No. SC14

- 1852

____________
IN RE: AMENDMENTS TO THE FLORIDA RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE; FLORIDA FAMILY LAW RULES OF PROCEDURE; NEW FLORIDA RULES FOR COURT - APPOINTED ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION NEUTRALS. [October 8, 2015] PER CURIAM. This matter is before the Court for consideration of proposed amendments to the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, the Florida Family Law Rules of Procedure and proposed new Florida Rules for Court

- Appointed Alternative Dispu te Resolution Neutrals Regarding Dispute Resolution Processes for Which No Other Supreme Court Rules or Standards of Professional Conduct Exist. We have jurisdiction. See art. V, § 2(a), Fla. Const. The Supreme Court Committee on Alternative Dispute Reso lution Rules and Policy (ADR Committee) has filed a petition proposing new Family Law Rules of Procedure, new Rules of Civil Procedure, and new Rules for Court

- Appointed Alternative Dispute Resolution Neutrals Regarding Alternative Dispute Resolution- 2

-

Proce sses for Which No Other Supreme Court Rules or Standards of Professional Conduct Exist. Similar proposals were submitted by the ADR Committee in case number SC11

- 1454; however, the Court declined to adopt those proposals and referred them back to the ADR Committee for further study and consideration. See In re Amend s. to F la

. R

. Civ

. P

. , Fla

. Fam

. L

. R

. P

. , New Fl a. R

. for Qualified and Court

- Appointed Parenting Coordinators, New Fla

. R

. for Other Court

Appointed Alternative Dispute Resolution Neutrals , 104 So. 3d 1043, 1045 (Fla. 2012). According to the petition, the ADR Committee received input from the Florida Bar Rules Committees. The petition also states that the proposals were posted on the Dispute Resolution Center website from May 20, 2011, to June 8, 2011, and the Committee received one comment. After submission to the Court, the proposals were published for comment in The Florida Bar News

. Comments were received from several interested parties and groups, including the Family Law Rules Commi ttee, the Civil Procedure Rules Committee, the Executive Council of the ADR Section of the Florida Bar, t he Honorable Thomas McGrady, Chief Judge of the Sixth Judicial Circuit, the Honorable Robert E. Roundtree, Jr., Chief Judge of the Eighth Judicial Circ uit, Attorney Robert J. Merlin, and Gregory Firestone, Ph.D. T he ADR Committee filed a response to the comments, and o ral argument was heard on the Committee’s proposals on June 3, 2015.- 3

-

We commend the ADR Committee’s careful consideration and considera ble effort in presenting these matters to the Court and its continued work in supporting and encouraging the use of alternative dispute resolution in Florida courts. However, u pon consideration of the ADR Committee’s petition, the comments filed and the Committee’s response thereto, and the presentations of the parties at oral argument, we decline to adopt the Committee’s proposals at this time. Given the substantial criticism, alleged deficiencies in the proposals , and other issues raised at oral argume nt in this matter and in the comments received , we conclude that the time is not yet rip e for rules addressing ADR processes other than those already identified and governed by current court rules

. It is so ordered. LABARGA, C.J., and PARIENTE, QUINCE, C ANADY, POLSTON, and PERRY, JJ., concur. LEWIS, J., concurs in result. NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPIRES TO FILE REHEARING MOTION, AND IF FILED, DETERMINED. Original Proceeding

– Florida Rules of Civil Procedure Judge Rodney Smith, Chair, Committee on Alternative Dispute Resolution Rules and Policy, Miami, Florida; Judge William David Palmer, Past Chair, Committee on Alternative Dispute Resolution Rules and Policy, Daytona Beach, Florida; and Susan Carolyn Marvin, Senior Staff Attorney, Dispute Resoluti on Center, Tallahassee, Florida, for Petitioner- 4

-

Robert Joseph Merlin of Robert J. Merlin, P.A., Coral Gables, Florida; Chief Judge James T. McGrady, III, Sixth Judicial Circuit, Clearwater, Florida; Michael L

. Emge , Senior Staff Attorney, Sixth Judicial Circuit, Saint Petersburg, Florida; Gregory Firestone, Ph.D. , Director of Conflict Resolution Collaborative , University of South Florida , Tampa, Florida; Charles Cole Jeffries, Jr., Chair, Family Law Rules Committee, Tampa, Florida; Elizabeth Ann Blackbur n, Past Chair, Family Law Rules Committee, Daytona Beach, Florida; John F. Harkness, Jr., Executive Director , Ellen H. Sloyer , Senior Rules Liaison, and Gregory A. Zhelesnik, Bar Staff Liaison, The Florida Bar, Tallahassee, Florida ; Judge Jacqueline Hogan Scola, Chair, Civil Procedure Rules Committee, Miami, Florida; Kevin Bayly Cook, Past Chair, Civil Procedure Rules Committee, Roger Towers, P.A., Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida; Chief Judge Robert E. Roundtree, Jr. and Bridget Longridge Baker, Family Court Man ager, Eighth Judicial Circuit, Gainesville, Florida; Michael H

. Lax , Chair, Alternative Dispute Resolution Section of The Florida Bar, Michael H. Lax, P.A., Miami , Florida; David Robert Hoyle, Vice

- Chair, Alternative Dispute Resolution Section of The Flori da Bar, D. Robert Hoyle, P.A., Bradenton, Florida; and Gregory Pierce Brown of Hill Ward Henderson, Tampa, Florida, Responding with Comments