< D C l U < o

- J > u . U J 

### 2 e s < h - H I C C Z O LU . U J o Q U I O S

Cs i

D C 3 W« 0 ) Z < C

M 0 < o S ^ 9 • • Q c c < U J 1 3 a : z o o o o Z L L z z • * ^ o Q
. $ z , - < m o 4

5 6 7 8 9 1 0 n 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 UNITE D STATE S DEPARTMEN T O FTRAN S F

FEDERA LAVIATIO N ADMINISTRAITIO W

WASHINGTON , D C 

## C E 1 W DEC 2 4 200 9 TATIQ N mmm m 

### r

\ u \ ^ AIRPORT/ENVlBflflMENTA L LAW , AGC-60 0 RDM , LLC , Complainant , V . TE D STEVEN S ANCHORAG E INTERNATIONA L AIRPORT ,

Respondent . _X 3

— I Docke t No . 16-09-1 4 -- .

c 5 SUPPLEMENTA LCERTIFICATIO N AN D MEMORANDU M

I N SUPPOR T O F MOTIO N T O ACCEP T LATE-FILE D ANSWE R Thi s Supplementa l Certificatio n an dMemorandu mupdate s informatio n no t availabl e a

t th e tim e o f

submissio n o f

th e Certificatio n i n Support o f Motio n t o Accep t Late-File dAnswe r

i n th e abov e matter , a s wel l a s t o not e th e applicability o f FA A preceden t

supportin g acceptanc e o f th e late-file danswer . CERTIFICATIO N

1 , A s state din th e Certificatio n in Support o f Motio n t o Accep t

Late

File dAnswe r

an dsupportin g certification , th e undersigne dcounse l delivere dth e Answe r an dsupportin g materials , bothfor filing an dfor

service , t o th e Unite dState s Pos t Offic e in Anchorage , Alaska , o n Decembe r 8 , 2009 . Tha t

delivery , however , wa s jus t before midnight , a s i s reflecte do n th e Unite dState s Posta l Servic e (USPS ) Expres s Mai l trackin g print-ou t

("Acceptance , Decembe r 08 , 2009 , 11:5 9 pm" ) for th e first o f tw o boxe s t o th e FAA . Se e attache dExhibi t "A. " B y th e tim e I ha dfilled-out th e Supplementa l Certificatio n an dMemorandu m i n Support o f Motio n t o Accep t

Late-File dAnswe r RDM , LLCv.AN C Pag e 1 o f 5 Docke t No . 16-09-1 4< a . U J

U . U J < O S (c Z.ft . m S t 2 S < S t - U J o o c I z p . u . z U J o < °U J u 

### s

- " r , = 2 8 U ) " S

- < i n = s * 2 0 ) u > Z < C M 5 < & ? U i £ E < U J 3 o c Z 

### si* " ^ < 3

4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 24 2 5 2 6 •

secon dExpres s Mai l slip , th e secon dFA A bo x wa s logge daccepte db y th e USP S "Decembe r

09 , 2009 , 12:0 1 am " Se e attache dExhibi t "B. " 1 amno t

sure whethe r

th e packag e for

servic e o n Complainant wa s processe dbefore o r after th e secon dFA A package , bu t

i t may hav e reflecte dDecembe r 9 , 200 9 postmark . 2 . Althoug h4 9 CF R§ 16.1 3 (b ) state s that document s shal l b e deeme dfiledo n th e mailin g dat e show n in th e certificat e o f service , counse l believe s i t prope r t o presen t

th e foregoin g fact s t o clarif y th e Certificafio n o f

Counse l an dth e variou s Certificate s o f

Service . 3 . B y signatur e below , counse l certifie s th e abov e t o b e tru e an d correc t t o qualif y th e statemen t

i n th e Motio n t o Accep t Late-File dAnswe r

that th e Answe r wa s "file don e day late, " t o cur e an y erro r i n m y previously-file dCertificatio n o f Counsel , an dt o cur e any erro r in m y previously-file dCertificate s o f Servic e a s t o th e Answer , Motio n t o Accep t Late-File dAnswer , Certificatio n o f Counse l i n Support

o f Motio n t o Accep t

Late-File dAnswer , (proposed ) Orde r Acceptin g Late-File dAnswer , Motio n t o Dismiss , Memorandu min Support o f Motio n t o Dismiss , an d(proposed ) Orde r o f Dismissa l with Prejudice . Certification : i z «-^ )
FA A PRECEDEN T

3 . FA A preceden t

show s tha t

unles s acomplainan t

establishe s that

i t ha s bee n prejudice db y th e lat e filing, i t i s appropriat e fo

r th e FA A t o accep t

a n answer :

Supplementa l Certificatio n an dMemorandu m i n Support o f Motio n t o Accep t

Late-File dAnswe r RDM , LL C V

. AN C Pag e 2 o f 5 Docke t No . 16-09-1 4< c c U J <« 5

- * > • z u . u i < I - £ * s < g I - U J S c cZ X D . U . Z l U O < °U J u —^

r- , « 5 * °

. < U > 2 (/] < o Z < ( M U J I J £ - 5 < B X uj-2
. KO
. . I T < U J 3 O C Z

r - < n o 3

4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0

2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 . . . Mr . Turne r fileda n Objectio n t o Respondent' s Answe r t o Motion . Mr . Turne r

argue s that

th e Respondent' s answe r t o th e motio n wa s filedafter

th e te n day perio di

n violatio n o f

1 4 CF RPart 16.17(c) , whic h generall y require s that answer s t o motion s mus t b e filedwithi n te n day s after th e motio n ha s bee n serve do n th e party . Althoug h th e answe r

t o th e motio n wa s filedafter th e te n days , th e late documen t

di dnot , in an y manner , prejudic e Mr . Turner' s case . Mr . Turne r

ha s neve r

demonstrate dho w h e wa s prejudice dor harme db y th e lat e filing (abou t eigh t days ) o f th e Respondent' s Motion . [T]h e FA A ha s no t

bee n mad e awar e o f

any harmthat

woul dhav e occurre di n thi s proces s a s aresul t o f som e document s bein g filed late... . Mr . Turner' s appea l doe s no t provid e any basi s fo

r reversin g th e Director' s Determinafion... . Turne r v . Cit y o/Kokomo , FA A Docke t No . 16-98-1 6 a

t 1 0 (Jul y 27 , 1999 ) (Final Decisio n an dOrder) .

4 . Althoug hTurne r

involve da

n answe r t o amotio n rathe r

than t o a complaint , th e requiremen t that an objectin g party sho w prejudic e shoul dappl y witha t leas t equal forc e t o Respondent' s barel y lat e answe r t o th e complain t

in thi s case . Part 1 6 Rule s o f

Practic e d o no t

includ e aprovisio n fo

r default , o r

fo r acomplainant' s allegation s t o b e deeme dadmitted , absen t timel y answer . Unles s th e FA A grant s Respondent' s Motio n t o Dismiss , th e natur e an dscop e o f Complainant' s allegation s i n thi s cas e woul dpreclud e a n initial determinatio n base do n thos e allegation s alone , i n any event . Wer e Respondent' s Answe r t o b e rejecte da s untimely , the n th e FA A woul d nee dt o advanc e t o investigatio n unde r 4 9 CF R§ 16.29 , an dwoul dnee dto gathe r from Supplementa l Certificatio n an dMemorandu m i n Suppor t o f Motio n t o Accep t

Late-File dAnswe r RDM , LL C V

. AN C Pag e 3 o f 5 Docke t No . 16-09-1 4< ( C U J

u . U J S O S c c I - s * 5 2 UI ( - U J o o c I S 0 . u . z UJ O S °U J o C M

11 1 * - I - °

—• " n = 2 S u ) * 2

. < i n ^ 1 ^ < ^ 3 U ) U > Z < C M U I
_ | ^ ? ui S f o . . o c< U I 3 o cZ 2 i S U
. a 3

4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 14 1 5 16 1 7 1 8 19 2 0 21 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 Responden t

essentiall y th e sam e response s t o th e allegation s o f th e Complain t

t o determin e whethe r

th e airport

i s in compliance . Acceptanc e o f Respondent' s Answer , therefore , expedite s rathe r than delay s thi s proceeding . 5 . Complainan t

RDM , LLC , i s a

n investo r i n anothe r

limite dliability compan y that

formerl y hel dleas e fromResponden t t o developmen t

facilitie s fo

r renta l a t th e airport . RD M complain s abou t th e term s o f

that leas e signe di

n 2005 , Respondent' s enforcemen t o f th e term s o f

tha t lease , an dcancellatio n o f that leas e in February , 2009 . Inasmuc h a s th e limite dliability compan y i n whic hRD M investe d neve r develope dth e lease dproperty o r engage di n any airport

services , an dRD M allege s wrong s i n th e relativel y recen t pas t rathe r tha n ongoin g o r

ancien t wrongs , ther e appear s t o b e n o issu e o f

any immediac y whereb y RD M i s prejudice db y Respondent' s Answe r havin g bee n filedon e o r tw o day s late . DATE D thi s 11t

hday o f December , 2009 at

Anchorage , Alaska . DANIE LS . SULLIVA N ATTORNE Y GENERA L By : Johr

f L . Steine r Swiio r Assistan t Attorne y General AB A No . 871110 8

Supplementa l Certificatio n an dMemorandu m i n Support o f Motio n t o Accep t

Late-File dAnswe r RDM . LL C V

. AN C Pag e 4 o f 5 Docke t No . 16-09-1 4< o c U I

- i > u , m O Z J . o c z s H C C U J o o o C M Z . < m < ^ ^ a > O C 3 (A t o C D Z < C

M o s . S < T

- U J £ 5 f « • • O o c< U l z 5 c c z y o o o z u : x x < ^ (J a S z

. - < C O o 3

4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 •

Certificat e O f Servic e I hereb y certif

y tha t o n Decembe r

11 , 2009, 1 hav e thi s da

y serve dth e foregoin g SUPPLEMENTA L CERTIFICATIO N AN D MEMORANDU M I N SUPPOR T O F MOTIO N T O ACCEP T LATE-FILE D ANSWE Ro n th e followin g person s a t th e followin g addresses : Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Offic e o f th e Chie f Counse l Attn. : FA A Part

1 6 Airport

Proceeding s Docket , AGC-61 0 Roo m92 5 80 0 Independenc e Ave. , S.W . Washington , D.C . 2059 1 Shau n Debenha m Managin g Member s o f

RDM , LL C 296 0 C Street , Suit e 20 2 Anchorage , A K

9950 3 via : n han ddelivery n faxe d H maile d 

### '^fi^^
. xy>(^ ^ Joh n LySteine r Senicf f Assistan t

Attorne y Genera l Attorne y General' s Offic e Attorney s for

Te dSteven s Anchorag e Internationa l Airport

Supplementa l Certificatio n an dMemorandu m i n Support o f Motio n t o Accep t

Late-File dAnswe r RDM , LL C V

. AN C Pag e 5 o f 5 Docke t No . 16-09-1 4USP S - Trac k & Confir m Pag e 1 o f 1
UNITE D STATE S POSTMSERVfCE* , Hom e I Hel p | Sig n I n
Trac k & Confir m FAQ

s

Trac k & Confir m Ente rLabel/Receip

t Number
. 

### Trac k & Confir m Searc h Result s Label/Receipt Number : EG1 4 743 7 689 U S Class ; Expres s Mail® Status ; Delivere d You rite m wa s delivere d a t 11:3 0 A M o n Decembe r11 , 200 9 i n ' WASHINGTON , DC 2059 1 t o FA A2059 1 R

9
. Th e ite m wa s signe d fo rb y«. , C WASHINGTON
. Detaile d Results ; > Delivered , Decembe r11 , 2009,11:3 0 am , WASHINGTON , D C 2059 1 • Arriva l a t Pos t Office , Decembe r11 , 2009 , 5:5 4 am , WASHINGTON , D C 2002 2 • Processe d throug h Sor t Facility , Decembe r10 , 2009,10:2 9 pm , DULLES , VA2010 1 • Processe d throug h Sor t Facility , Decembe r09 , 2009,12:2 0 am , ANCHORAGE , A K9953 0 • Acceptance , Decembe r08 , 2009,11:5 9 pm , ANCHORAGE , A K9951 9 Notificatio n Option s Trac k & Confir m b yemai l Ge t curren t even t informatio n o rupdate s fo ryou rite m sen t t o yo u o rother s b yemail
. Oa

> < Proo f o f Delivery Verif ywh o signe d fo ryou rIte m b yemail , fax , o rmail
. . fl«> )

Sit e Ma p Cuslome f Servic e Form s Gov' t Service s Career s Privac yPolic yTerm s o f Us e Busines s Custome rGatewa y Copyright ©

200 9 USPS
. Al l Right s Reserved
. N o FEA R Ac t EE O Dat a FOI A1 0 S f



# A

http : //trkcnfrm1 . smi . usps . com/PTSInteme t Web/InterLabellnquiry . d o 12/11/200 9USP S - Trac k & Confirm Pag e 1 o f 1
UNITE D STATE S POSTA L SERVICE * Hom e I Hs! a I SignJ n
Trac k 8 , Confir m FAQ i 

### Trac k & Confir m

Trac k & Confii m Ente rLabel/Receip

t Number
. Searc h Result s Label/Receip t Number ; EG1 4 743 7 675 U S Class ; Expres s Mail* ' Status ; Delivere d You rite m wa s delivere d a t 1 1 ;3 0 A M o n Decembe r11 , 200 9 i n I WASHINGTON , DC 2059 1 t o FA A2059 1 R

9
. Th e ite m was signe d fo rb yC„ , C WASHINGTON
. Detaile d Results ; • Delivered , Decembe r11,2009,11:3 0 am , WASHINGTON , D C 2059 1 • Arriva l a t Pos t Office , Decembe r11,2009 , 5:5 4 am , WASHINGTON , DC 2002 2 • Processe d throug h Sor t Facility , Decembe r10 , 2009,10:2 9 pm , DULLES , V A2010 1 • Processe d throug h Sor t Facility , Decembe r09 , 2009,12:2 0 am , ANCHORAGE , A K9953 0 • Acceptance , Decembe r09 , 2009,12:0 1 am , ANCHORAGE , A K9951 9 Notilicutia n Option s Trac k & Confir m b yemai l Ge t curren t even t informatio n o rupdate s fo ryou rite m sen t to yo u o rother s b yemail
. O

a > > Proo f o f Delivery Verif ywh o signe d fo ryou rite m b yemail , fax , o rmail
. Go > '

S't e tjla p Custome i Servic e Form s Gov' t Service s Career s Privac yPotic vTerm s o t Us e Busines s Custome rGatev^a v Copyriylit R 200 9 USPS
. Al l Right s Reserved
. N o FEA R Ac t EE O Dat a FOI A( 0 ^

Exhttiit
. 

# B

http://trkcnfrml.smi.usps.com/PTSInternetWeb/InterLabelInquiry.d o 12/11/200 9