Appendix L.9 

North Carolina Modeling Summary Report 
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page1 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 1 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State Bart Category description

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC Fossil Fuel-Fired Steam Electric Plants (250

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC Fossil Fuel-Fired Steam Electric Plants (250Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Fossil Fuel-Fired Steam Electric Plants (250

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NC Fossil Fuel-Fired Steam Electric Plants (250Progress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NC Fossil Fuel-Fired Steam Electric Plants (250Progress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC Fossil Fuel-Fired Steam Electric Plants (250Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC Kraft Pulp Mill

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC Kraft Pulp Mill

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC Kraft Pulp MillInternational Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NC Kraft Pulp MillInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC Kraft Pulp Mill

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC Chemical Process Plants

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC Chemical Process Plants

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC Chemical Process Plants

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NC Chemical Process PlantsPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC Phospate Rock Processing Plants/

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC Primary Aluminum Ore Reduction Plants

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page2 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 2 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

 BART category

222222222222

33333

2121

212113

7

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page3 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 3 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

Class I areas impactedJYKM,GSM,SHNR,LINV,COHUJYKM,GSM,SHNR,LINV,COHUCOHU,GSM,JYKM,LINV,SHNRGSM,JAMES,JYKM,LINV,SHNRSWAN,SHEN,JAMES, DOLLY, LINVSWAN,CAPRSHNR,LINV,COHU,JYKM,GSMCAPR, SWANSWAN,SHEN,JAMESSWAN,CAPRSWAN,SHEN,JAMES

SWAN,CAPR

SWAN,CAPR,JAMES,LINV

SWAN,CAPRSWAN,CAPR

SWAN

LIGO, JARI, ROMA, GRSM, SHRO

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page4 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 4 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

OKFE -D OKFE -I COHU -D

184265161

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page5 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 5 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

COHU- I CHAS -D CHAS- I

0.310.05

0.095

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page6 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 6 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

SWAN-D SWAN-I CAPR -D

267.7 0.15

185 0.16 183

65 0.44 30073 0.33

210 0.11 150164 0.3187 0.19 187187 0.09 182170 0.18 200184 0.4 187

32 0.66

266.5

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page7 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 7 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

CAPR -I WOLF-D WOLF -I

0.140.16

0.1

0.160.060.120.32

0.135

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page8 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 8 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

GSM-D GSM-I EVGL-D

50 0.2350 0.26

130 0.09200 0.11

22 0.76

264 0.113

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page9 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 9 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

EVGL-I StMK-D StMK-I

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page10 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 10 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

DOLLY-D DOLLY-I JAMES-D

240

276.1 0.07 123.6

300200291

242.3

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page11 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 11 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

JAMES-I LINV-D LINV-I

68.6 0.1268.6 0.14

60 0.25

0.15 95 0.460.48 258.7 0.21

89 0.2

0.060.230.04 295 0.05

0.175 163.8 0.26

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page12 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 12 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

SIPS-D SIPS-I SHNR-D

26.226.2

105180

11

241.4

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page13 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 13 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

SHNR-I JYKM-D JYKM-I

0.34 125.4 0.40.37 125.4 0.040.13 205 0.050.15 280 0.072.88 99 0.13

0.109

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page14 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 14 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

MMCA-D MMCA-I SHEN-D

173.9

300204

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page15 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 15 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

SHEN-I MNGO-D MNGO-I

0.3

0.060.21

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page16 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 16 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

BRET-D BRET-I BRAD-D

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page17 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 17 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

BRAD-I IMPROVE Eqn used

old

newnewnewnew

oldold

new

oldoldoldoldoldoldold

new

old

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page18 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 18 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

old v new @Max impact

0.31 vs 0.260.29 vs 0.250.52 vs 0.46

0.58 vs 0.483

0.722 vs 0.44 [0.6 vs 0.447]1.32 vs 0.66 [1.33 vs 0.976]

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page19 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 19 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

% diff in IMPRO

161412173950

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page20 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 20 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

BART Determination

nononononono

YES

nononononononono

YES

no

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page21 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 21 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

CALMET ver/date

5.75.7

Mode

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page22 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 22 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

ls used in BART mo

CALPOST ver/date

d

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page23 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 23 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

CALPUFF ver/date

5.7545.754

deling

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page24 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 24 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

POSTUTIL ver/date

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page25 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 25 

December 17, 2007
NC BART Eligible Source Modeling Summary

Class I Area Impacts

Mill/Plant/Facility City County State

Progress Energy Asheville Arden Buncombe NC

Duke Power Belews Belews Creek Stokes NC

Duke Power Cliffside

Cliffside

Cleveland/Rutherford 

NC

Duke Power Marshall Catawba NCProgress Energy Roxboro Semora Person NCProgress Energy Sutton Wilmington New Hanover NC

Blue Ridge Paper Products Inc. Canton Canton Buncombe NC

Weyerhaeuser Co New Bern New Bern Craven NC

Weyerhauser Co (now Domtar) Plymouth Plymouth Martin NC

International Paper Co Riegelwood Riegelwood Columbus NCInternational Paper Co (now Kap Stone KRoanoke Rapids Roanoke Rapids Nash NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cape Fear Leland Brunswick NC

DAK Americas, LLC Cedar Creek Fayetteville Cumberland NC

Elementis Chromium Castle Hayne New Hanover NC

Invista S.a r.l. Wilmington New Hanover NCPCS Phosphate company, Inc Aurora Beaufort NC

ALCOA Badin Badin Stanly NC

DRAFT

Modeler: VISTAS/Consultant/company

URS

ENSRENSRENSR

URSURSURSURSURSURSURS

Trinity

Trinity

URS

RTP

URS

VISTAS

For the Class I impacts: D is distance to the Class I area. I is the delta visibility impact in deciviews. Page26 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 26 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 27 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-31 263.0 428.8 179.2

one 3-chamber, 6-field electrostatic precipitator (115,236 square feet) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-32 263.0 428.8 179.2

one 3-chamber, 4-field electrostatic precipitator (115,236 square feet) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-34 No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-35 8.4 88.2

one Chevron mist eliminator (33.5 square feet of collection surface) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-36 8.4 88.2

one Chevron mist eliminator (33.2 square feet of collection surface) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1005 31.21 138.28 60.59

Two duplex cyclones exhausting to one venturi type wet scrubber to a wet electrostatic precipitator No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1001 31.21 138.28 60.59

two duplex cyclones (CAL 2) , Scrubber (CAL 2: wet fixed throat venturi) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1002 31.21 138.28 60.59

two duplex cyclones (CAL 3) , Scrubber (CAL 3: fixed throat venturi) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1003 31.21 138.28 60.59

two duplex cyclones (CAL 4) , Scrubber (CAL 4: fixed throat venturi) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1006 31.21 138.28 60.59

Duplex cyclone (CAL 5) , Duplex cyclone (CAL 5) , Scrubber (CAL 5: fixed throat venturi); wet electrostatic precipator No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1004 31.21 138.28 60.59

Two duplex cyclones exhausting to one venturi type wet scrubber to a wet electrostatic precipitator No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1000 13.69 149.36 235.43

One duplex cyclone and one venturi type wet scrubber No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1032 1387 40.52 25.32

Vertical tube mist eliminator system installed on final absorbing tower No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1033 1283.34 40.52 25.32

Vertical tube mist eliminator system installed on final absorbing tower No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1037 166.6 78.8 3.94 No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1041 0 0 0.7 bagfilter (124 sq. ft of filter area) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-937 0 0 0 No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-591 175.2 0 0

one spray cross-flow packed-bed type scrubber (800 GPM minimum liquid injection rate) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-592 102.6 0 0

one spray cross-flow packed-bed type scrubber (800 GPM minimum liquid injection rate) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-602 0 0 1.2 one bagfilter No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-590 88.7 0 0

one spray cross-flow packed-bed type scrubber (800 GPM min. liquid injection rate) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1045 5.48 0 0

eductor venturi type wet scrubber (135 gal/min minimum permitted liquid injection rate each) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1046 9.13 0 0

eductor venturi type wet scrubber (135 gal/min minimum permitted liquid injection rate each) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1049 18.25 0 0

eductor venturi type wet scrubber (135 gal/min minimum permitted liquid injection rate each) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-589 88.7 0 0

one spray cross-flow packed-bed type scrubber (800 GPM min. liquid injection rate) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

Page 27 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 27 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 28 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-31

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-32

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-34

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-35

Blue Ridge Paper Products - Canton Mill NC 3 G-36

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1005PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1001PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1002PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1003PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1006PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1004PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1000PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1032PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1033PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1037PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1041PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-937PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-591PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-592PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-602PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-590PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1045PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1046PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1049PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-589

BART Determination Reason

No additional control

PM-Most stringent controls in place for MACT MM; NOx-Not economically feasible; SO2-Not economically feasible

No additional control

PM-Most stringent controls in place for MACT MM; NOx-Not economically feasible; SO2-Not economically feasible

No additional control

PM, NOx, SO2-Greater than MACT MM controls in place via Equivalency by Permit RTO/Scrubber combination. Additional control not feasible.

No additional control

PM-Not economically feasible; SO2-Not economically feasible; NOx-No control technologies available

No additional control

PM-Not economically feasible; SO2-Not economically feasible; NOx-No control technologies available

No additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional control

Page 28 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 28 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 29 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-981 138.3 32.11 152.25

Buell cyclones , Buell cyclones , cyclonic / venturi type wet scrubber (750 gal/min minimum permitted injection rate) , cyclonic / venturi type wet scrubber (900 gal/min minimum permitted injection rate) , cyclonictype gas scrubber (recirculated No >0.5 dv contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-982 160.5 60.71 58.15

one venturi scrubber at the DAP NO.3 (800 GPM minimum permitted injection rate) , one wet cyclonic scrubber at the DAP NO.3 (350 GPM minimum permitted injection rate) , one dryer quad cyclone (60 inch diameter each) , cooler dual cyclone (57" diam) , dust dual cyclone (51" diam); part of 511-MSHE at the DAP NO.3, two-stage dryer wet cyclonic scrubber (550 GPM 1st stage; 350 GPM 2nd Stage), dust cyclonic wet scrubber (150 GPM minimum PIR); part of 511-MSHE at the DAP NO.3, cooler wet cyclonic scrubber (150 GPM minimum PIR), cyclonic tail gas scrubber (1000 GPM minimum PIR) No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 0 0 4.51 one bagfilter No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1044 0 0 3.46 one bagfilter No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1044 0 0 1.31 one bagfilter No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1044 0 0 1.31 No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1044 0 0 3.46 No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1029 0 0 0.11 No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 0 0 0.07 Enclosures No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 0 0 0.07 Enclosures No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 0 0 4.01 Enclosures No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 0 0 4.01 Enclosures No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 0 0 1.13 Bagfilter No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 0 0 4.01 Enclosures No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 0 0 9.7 Enclosures No

>0.5 dv 

contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-108 11.3

dry coke scrubber consisting of a venturi reactor and a bagfilter (9, 989 sq ft of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-133 0.94

fabric filter; 360 square feet of filter area Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-148 3.2

cyclone (60 inches in diameter), one bagfilter (5,000 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-150 0.05 8.02 0.6 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-151 161 35.4 2.19

dry alumina venturi reactor (1.0 to 5.0 tph dry injection rate) , bagfilter (27,500 square feet of filter area)

dry alumina venturi reactor (1.0 to 5.0 tph dry injection rate) , bagfilter (27,500 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-152 4.13

bagfilter (3,519 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-153 2.7

fabric filter; 250 square feet of filter area , fabric filter; 250 square feet of filter area) , fabric filter; 250 square feet of filter area , fabric filter; 250 square feet of filter area Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-154 11.4

bagfilter (1,120 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 29 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 29 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 30 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-981PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-982PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1044PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1044PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1044PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1044PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13 G-1029PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13PCS Phosphate Company Inc. - Aurora NC 13Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-108

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-133

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-148

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-150

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-151

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-152

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-153

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-154

BART Determination Reason

No additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional controlNo additional control

Page 30 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 30 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 31 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-156 1513 71.8 426

eight alumina fluid bed scrubbers in parallel, each in series with: , fabric filter (seven at 36,000 square feet of filter area each and one at 10,750 square feet of fil , 2A four alumina fluid bed scrubbers in parallel, each in series with , 2A a fabric filter (5,800 square feet of filter area each) , 2B four alumina fluid bed scrubbers in parallel, each in series with , 2B fabric filter (5,800 square feet of filter area each) , 2C four alumina fluid bed scrubbers in parallel, each in series with , 2C fabric filter (5,800 square feet of filter area each) , 2D four alumina fluid bed scrubbers in parallel, each in series with , 2D fabric filter (5,800 square feet of filter area each) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-158 3.75

bagfilter (8,608 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-160 0.05 7.73 0.59 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-162 0.026 0.33 4.29 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-165 0.05 7.9 0.6 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-163 0.05 7.8 0.6 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-164 0.05 7.8 0.6 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-166 0.05 7.9 0.6 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-26 0.05 7.73 0.59 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-46 0.676

bagfilter (250 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-47 0.676

bagfilter (250 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-49 0.94

bagfilter (360 square feet of filter area) , bagfilter (360 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-51 0.94

bagfilter (1,120 square feet of filter area), bagfilter (750 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-76 8.82

bagfilter (11,520 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-84 2.6

bagfilter (2,352 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-87 1.5

bagfilter (5,184 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC G-29 11085 6627 3464.58

Unit 1 Control System - Updated 4/1/2002

Unit 1 Control System - Updated 4/1/2002

Unit 1 Control System - Updated 4/1/2002 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-30 19636 7150 3302.5

Unit 2 Control System - Updated 4/1/2002

Unit 2 Control System - Updated 4/1/2002

Unit 2 Control System - Updated 4/1/2002 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-35 18186 10228 2501

Unit 3 Control System - Updated 4/1/2002

Unit 3 Control System - Updated 4/1/2002

Unit 3 Control System - Updated 4/1/2002 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-37 0 0 27.6 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-38 0 0 7.7

Flyash Storage and Transfer Control System Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-38 0 0 195

Flyash Storage and Transfer Control System Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-38 0 0 7.7

Flyash Storage and Transfer Control System Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-38 0 0 7.7

Flyash Storage and Transfer Control System Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Sutton Plant NC 1 G-189 8296 5483 1441

Two electrostatic precip. installed in parallel (Research-Cottrell cold side type) equipped with SO3

Two electrostatic precip. installed in parallel (Research-Cottrell cold side type) equipped with SO3

Two electrostatic precip. installed in parallel (Research-Cottrell cold side type) equipped with SO3 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Sutton Plant NC 1 G-25 0 0 1.73 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

CP&L - Sutton Plant NC 1 G-67 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-177 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 31 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 31 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 32 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-156

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-158

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-160

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-162

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-165

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-163

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-164

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-166

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-26

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-46

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-47

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-49

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-51

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-76

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-84

Alcoa, Inc.-Badin Works NC 7 G-87

NC

CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC G-29CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-30CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-35CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-37CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-38CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-38CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-38CP&L - Roxboro Steam Electric Plant NC 1 G-38CP&L - Sutton Plant NC 1 G-189

CP&L - Sutton Plant NC 1 G-25

CP&L - Sutton Plant NC 1 G-67

NC

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-177

BART Determination Reason

Page 32 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 32 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 33 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-236 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-271 0.375 43.8 17.52

electrostatic precipitator (31,100 square feet of collection plate; ID No. CD-P-11) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-328 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR88 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-346 727.82 121.41 49.71 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-346 727.82 121.41 49.71 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-346 727.82 121.41 49.71 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-348 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR49 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR50 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR51 770.13 128.47 52.6 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR52 770.13 128.47 52.6 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-351 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR53 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR58 1135.92 189.49 138.28 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR59 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR60 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR14 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR15 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR16 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-1 426.3 130.3 10.9 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-10 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-11 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-16 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv 

contribution

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-17

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lb/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system (121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate), one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area)

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lb/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system (121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate), one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area)

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lb/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system (121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate), one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-17

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lb/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system (121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate), one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area)

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lb/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system (121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate), one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area)

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lb/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system (121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate), one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 33 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 33 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 34 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-236

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-271

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-328

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR88

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-346

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-346

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-346DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-348

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR49

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR50

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR51

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR52

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 G-351

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR53

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR58

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR59

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR60

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR14

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR15

DAK Monomers LLC NC 21 GR16

NC

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-1

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-10Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-11Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-16Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-17Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-17

BART Determination Reason

Page 34 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 34 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 35 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-18

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lbs/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system 121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate, one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area)

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lbs/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system 121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate, one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area)

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lbs/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system 121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate, one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-18

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lbs/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system 121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate, one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area)

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lbs/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system 121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate, one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area)

one (1) low NOx burner system employing overfire air, flue gas conditioning - an integral SO3 generator (450 lbs/hr of S input), flue gas conditioning - an anhydrous NH3 injection system 121.5 lb/hr maximum NH3 injection rate, one (1) Selected Catalytic Reduction (SCR), one (1) cold-side electrostatic precipitator (974,600 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-2 426.3 130.3 10.9 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-3 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corporation - Cliffside Steam Station NC 1 G-86

cold-side electrostatic precipitator (Research Cottrell model G. O. 3023) with NH4 & SO3 systems

cold-side electrostatic precipitator (Research Cottrell model G. O. 3023) with NH4 & SO3 systems

cold-side electrostatic precipitator (Research Cottrell model G. O. 3023) with NH4 & SO3 systems Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Energy Corporation - Cliffside Steam Station NC 1 G-86

cold-side electrostatic precipitator (Research Cottrell model G. O. 3023) with NH4 & SO3 systems

cold-side electrostatic precipitator (Research Cottrell model G. O. 3023) with NH4 & SO3 systems

cold-side electrostatic precipitator (Research Cottrell model G. O. 3023) with NH4 & SO3 systems Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-1

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur tioxide ash conditioner, cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area),cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-1

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur tioxide ash conditioner, cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area),cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur tioxide ash conditioner, coldside parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area),cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur tioxide ash conditioner, cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area),cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-2

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur tioxide ash conditioner, cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area),cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur tioxide ash conditioner, coldside parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area),cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur tioxide ash conditioner, cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area),cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 35 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 35 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 36 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-18Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-18Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-2Duke Energy Corp - Belews Creek Steam Station NC 1 G-3

NC

Duke Energy Corporation - Cliffside Steam Station NC 1 G-86

Duke Energy Corporation - Cliffside Steam Station NC 1 G-86

NC

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-1

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-1Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-2

BART Determination Reason

Page 36 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 36 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 37 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-2

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low-NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area), cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low-NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, coldside parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area), cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low-NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area), cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-4

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low-NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area), cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low-NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, coldside parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area), cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low-NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area), cold-side parallel electrostatic precipitator (288,000 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-4

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-5

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-5

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, coldside electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC 1

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, coldside electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area)

modified fuel burner system (low NOx concentric firing system), Separated Overfire Air/Lowered Fire low NOx control technologies (SOFA/LOFIR), flue gas conditioning system consisting of an integral sulfur trioxide ash conditioner, cold-side electrostatic precipitator (267,720 square feet of plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-24 0 0 0.24

one mist eliminator (9.62 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-25 0 0 0.22

one mist eliminator (3.14 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-26 0 0 0.34

one impingement type wet scrubber (100 gallons per minute liquid injection rate) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-27 0 0 4.61

one bagfilter (65 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-28 0 0 0.18

one mist eliminator (7.06 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-29 0 0 0.47

one mist eliminator (15.9 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-30 0 0 0.73

one mist eliminator (15.9 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-31 0 0 0.27

one mist eliminator (7.06 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-32 0 0 3.76

one bagfilter (500 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 37 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 37 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 38 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-2Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-4Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-4Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-5Duke Power Marshall Plt NC 1 G-5

NC 1NC

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-24

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-25

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-26

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-27

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-28

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-29

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-30

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-31

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-32

BART Determination Reason

Page 38 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 38 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 39 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-33 237.2 53.2 23.45 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-34 237.2 53.2 23.45 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-35 0 0 7.05

four process multicyclones, four bagfilters (3,366 square feet of filter area total) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-36 0 0 0.32

one mist eliminator (15.9 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-37 171.62 515.84 62.44

three electrostatic precipitators (two 48,775 square feet each and one 52,992 square feet)

three electrostatic precipitators (two 48,775 square feet each and one 52,992 square feet)

three electrostatic precipitators (two 48,775 square feet each and one 52,992 square feet) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-38 10.5 24.94 3.21

two dual (Ducon) cyclones (5.53 feet diameter for each cyclone) installed one each, three electrostatic precipitators (two 48,775 square feet each and one 52,992 square feet)

two dual (Ducon) cyclones (5.53 feet diameter for each cyclone) installed one each, three electrostatic precipitators (two 48,775 square feet each and one 52,992 square feet)

two dual (Ducon) cyclones (5.53 feet diameter for each cyclone) installed one each, three electrostatic precipitators (two 48,775 square feet each and one 52,992 square feet) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-39 2.94 6.91 0.79

one dual (Ducon) cyclone (4.63 feet in diameter), three electrostatic precipitators (two 48,775 square feet each and one 52,992 square feet)

one dual (Ducon) cyclone (4.63 feet in diameter), three electrostatic precipitators (two 48,775 square feet each and one 52,992 square feet)

one dual (Ducon) cyclone (4.63 feet in diameter), three electrostatic precipitators (two 48,775 square feet each and one 52,992 square feet) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-40 20.5 7.5 7

four simple cyclones installed in parallel, one impingement type wet scrubber (120 gallons per minute liquid injection rate)

four simple cyclones installed in parallel, one impingement type wet scrubber (120 gallons per minute liquid injection rate)

four simple cyclones installed in parallel, one impingement type wet scrubber (120 gallons per minute liquid injection rate) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-41 0 0 0.07

a brownian diffusion-type mist eliminator (ID No. 04-F-708) , a packed tower type wet scrubber (200 gallons per minute liquid injection rate) w / mist eliminator , one mist eliminator (4.5 square feet of filter area) , one impingement plate type wet scrub Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-43 0 0 0.38 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-1 0 0 0.36

one mist eliminator (12.57 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-10 0 0 1.02

five cyclonic wet scrubbers (140 gallons per minute liquid injection rate each), 3 wet electrostatic precipitators(225 g.p.m. liquid injection rate, 8692 sq.ft. of plate area each) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-11 0 0 4.61

one bagfilter (642 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-12 0 0 0.09

one mist eliminator (15.9 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-13 0 0 0.13

one mist eliminator (15.9 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-14 0 0 0.49

one mist eliminator (15.9 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-15 0 0 0.02

one mist eliminator (2.18 square feet of filter area) (Group 19) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-16 0 0 0

one mist eliminator (2.18 square feet of filter area) (Group 20) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-2 0 0 0.52

one mist eliminator (19.2 square feet of filter area, ID No. 01-S2828) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-12 6100 4300 60

No.1 Power Boiler Venturi Scrubber , No.1 Power Boiler Venturi Scrubber

No.1 Power Boiler Venturi Scrubber , No.1 Power Boiler Venturi Scrubber

No.1 Power Boiler Venturi Scrubber , No.1 Power Boiler Venturi Scrubber Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-33 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-36 8.5 281 18

Dry Bottom Electrostatic Precipitator (140,000 square feet of collecting area)

Dry Bottom Electrostatic Precipitator (140,000 square feet of collecting area)

Dry Bottom Electrostatic Precipitator (140,000 square feet of collecting area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-37 23 No.7 Dissolver Venturi Scrubber Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-38 10

Bark Cyclone (96 inches in diameter) , Sawdust Silo Cyclone (126 inches in diameter) , Sawdust Cyclone (84 inches in diameter) , ERJO Rechipper Cyclone (72 inches in diameter) , Murray Rechipper Cyclone (72 inches in diameter) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 39 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 39 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 40 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-33

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-34

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-35

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-36

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-37

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-38

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-39

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-40

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-41

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-43

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-1

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-10

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-11

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-12

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-13

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-14

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-15

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-16

Elementis Chromium NC 21 G-2

NC

International Paper NC 3 G-12International Paper NC 3 G-33International Paper NC 3 G-36International Paper NC 3 G-37International Paper NC 3 G-38

BART Determination Reason

Page 40 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 40 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 41 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

International Paper NC 3 G-38 9

Bark Cyclone (96 inches in diameter) , Sawdust Silo Cyclone (126 inches in diameter) , Sawdust Cyclone (84 inches in diameter) , ERJO Rechipper Cyclone (72 inches in diameter) , Murray Rechipper Cyclone (72 inches in diameter) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-38 2.5

Bark Cyclone (96 inches in diameter) , Sawdust Silo Cyclone (126 inches in diameter) , Sawdust Cyclone (84 inches in diameter) , ERJO Rechipper Cyclone (72 inches in diameter) , Murray Rechipper Cyclone (72 inches in diameter) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-39 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-39 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-42 1905 590 192 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper NC 3 G-45 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-95 1.23 15.6 23

one cyclone (8 feet in diameter), one venturi-type wet scrubber (850 gpm minimum liquid injection rate)

one cyclone (8 feet in diameter), one venturi-type wet scrubber (850 gpm minimum liquid injection rate)

one cyclone (8 feet in diameter), one venturi-type wet scrubber (850 gpm minimum liquid injection rate) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-63 5.6 11.6 117.6

Four fan impingement-type wet scrubbers

Four fan impingement-type wet scrubbers

Four fan impingement-type wet scrubbers Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-69 451 164 171

one electrostatic precipitator (43,952 square feet of collecting plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-69 451 164 171

one electrostatic precipitator (43,952 square feet of collecting plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-69 889 313 320

one electrostatic precipitator (92,000 square feet of collecting plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-69 889 313 320

one electrostatic precipitator (92,000 square feet of collecting plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-70 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-70 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-25 3.5

one packed tower-type wet scrubber (50 gpm minimum caustic solution injection rate) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-5 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 22 G-58 250 416 21.7 wet scrubber wet scrubber Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 22 G-58 wet scrubber wet scrubber Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-59 11

one cyclone (95 inches in diameter) , one cyclone (140 inches in diameter) , one cyclone (72 inches in diameter) , one cyclone (132 inches in diameter) , one cyclone (132 inches in diameter) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-6 0.06 1.5 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-60 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-60 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Invista, S.a.r.l. NC 21 G-166 <250 <250 <250 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Invista, S.a.r.l. NC 21 G-165 <250 <250 <250 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Invista, S.a.r.l. NC 21 TO 309 <250 <250 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-188 0 0 14.5 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 41 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 41 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 42 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

International Paper NC 3 G-38International Paper NC 3 G-38International Paper NC 3 G-39International Paper NC 3 G-39International Paper NC 3 G-42International Paper NC 3 G-45

NC

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-95

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-63

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-69

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-69

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-69

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-69

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-70

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-70

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-25

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-5

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 22 G-58

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 22 G-58

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-59

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-6

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-60

International Paper - Riegelwood Mill NC 3 G-60

NC

Invista, S.a.r.l. NC 21 G-166Invista, S.a.r.l. NC 21 G-165

Invista, S.a.r.l. NC 21 TO

NC

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-188

BART Determination Reason

Page 42 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 42 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 43 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-222 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-158 8.2 1019.23 124.13

North electrostatic precipitator (169,194 square feet plate area), South electrostatic precipitator (169,194 square feet plate area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-224 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-225 0 0 0

South smelt tank spray tower-type wet scrubber (377 GPM max rate) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-159 2.16 13.12 8.14

North smelt tank spray tower-type wet scrubber (377 GPM max rate) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-225 4.53 7.26 7.37

South smelt tank spray tower-type wet scrubber (377 GPM max rate) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-226 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-226 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-226 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-55 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-143 3850 1250 447

one primary west, multicyclone w/ 570 nine-inch cones, one secondary east, multicyclone with 1,224 nine-inch cones, East electrified granular filter bed module, Central electrified granular filter bed module, West electrified granular filter bed module

one primary west, multicyclone w/ 570 nine-inch cones, one secondary east, multicyclone with 1,224 nineinch cones, East electrified granular filter bed module, Central electrified granular filter bed module, West electrified granular filter bed module Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-140 851 4910 499

South chamber electrostatic precipitator (total chambers area of 82,080 square feet), North chamber electrostatic precipitator (total chambers area of 82,080 square feet), open spray tower-type wet scrubber (5,976 gallons per minute maximum caustic inject

South chamber electrostatic precipitator (total chambers area of 82,080 square feet), North chamber electrostatic precipitator (total chambers area of 82,080 square feet), open spray tower-type wet scrubber (5,976 gallons per minute maximum caustic inject Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 0 0 10.51 None None None Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-311 0 0 4.42

air washer on ash transport system --- vacuum is created on system to pull the ash Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-306 0 0 1.27

West bagfilter (84 square feet of filter area), East bagfilter (84 square feet of filter area) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-78 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-79 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-257 0 0 70.4 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-92 0 0 18.36

Simple cyclone for carpentry shop 

vacuum system Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-258 1.86 28.47 1.99 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-258 1.86 28.47 1.99 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-258 1.34 20.45 1.43 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

NC 3 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-104 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-107 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-117 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-117 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-119 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-121 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-122 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 43 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 43 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 44 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-222

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-158

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-224

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-225

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-159

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-225

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-226

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-226

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-226

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-55

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-143

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-140

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-311

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-306

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-78

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-79

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-257

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-92

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-258

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-258

Weyerhaeuser Company - Plymouth NC 3 G-258

NC 3

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-104

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-107

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-117

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-117

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-119

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-121

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-122

BART Determination Reason

Page 44 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 44 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 45 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-124 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-124 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-124 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-127 2.9 5.98 50.81

North and South wire mesh mist eliminators Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-127 2.9 5.98 50.81

North and South wire mesh mist eliminators

North and South wire mesh mist eliminators Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-129 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-132 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-139 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-139 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-139 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-139 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 22 G-140 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-141 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-142 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-143 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-144 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 0 0 144.58 Bag filter Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-153 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-156 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 22 G-42 1440 240 82 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-44 4179.76 1158.57 97.38

one electrostatic precipitator (172,800 square feet of collecting plate area, ID No. 445-073) Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-50 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-62 0 0 0.02 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-64 0 0 0.35 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 0 0 0.35 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-66 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 GR1 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-67 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-68 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-69 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-70 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-71 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-72 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-75 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-90 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-91 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-92 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-93 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 45 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 45 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 46 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-124

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-124

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-124

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-127

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-127

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-129

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-132

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-139

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-139

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-139

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-139

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 22 G-140

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-141

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-142

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-143

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-144

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-153

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-156

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 22 G-42

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-44

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-50

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-62

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-64

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-66

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 GR1

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-67

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-68

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-69

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-70

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-71

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-72

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-75

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-90

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-91

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-92

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-93

BART Determination Reason

Page 46 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 46 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 47 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID SO2 PTE NOx PTE PM PTE

Distance 

(km) Q/d Existing Control SO2 Existing Control Nox Existing Control PM

Proposed 

control SO2

Limit - 

SO2

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control NOx

BART Limit -

NOx

Tons 

Reduced

Proposed 

control PM

BART Limit -

PM

Tons 

Reduced

BARTExempt? Reason

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-94 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-106 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-96 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-99 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-133 0 0 0 Yes

<0.5 dv contribution

Page 47 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 47 

December 17, 2007
NC BART-Eligible Souce Modeling Summary

Controls

Page 48 of 48

BART-eligible Source State

Source 

Category Unit ID

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-94

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-106Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-96

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-99

Weyerhaeuser Company - Vanceboro NC 3 G-133

BART Determination Reason

Page 48 of 48

BART Related Documentation 

Regional Haze SIP for NC Class I Areas 

 Appendix L.9 - 48 

December 17, 2007