Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

1 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

1 R307-1-1 – adds the 

definition of “Air Quality Related Values” and “Carcinogen” 

R307-101-2 Definitions 

R307-101-2 Definitions 

R307-101-2 (Definitions). The that the State submitted on Sept18, 2006, were superseded by furevisions that the State submitteApril 17, 2008. As explained in January 2, 2013 notice (78 FR 3“[w]e approved the 2008 versiorule on September 2, 2008) and incorporated it by reference into Code of Federal Regulations. S51222.” Thus, in this proposal not acting on the 2006 version o101-2. 

2 R307-1-3.1.1 

Notice of Intent Required (page E-41 of the Effective Rule) 

R307-401-1 Notice of Intent Required Deleting this rule R307-401-1 and moving it to R307-401-5 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version but is substantially the same) 

R307-401-5 Notice of Intent 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19that approval the State rule wernumbered R307-1-3.1.1 and R31.6. 

3 R307-401-1 

Purpose 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to 

1 This rulemaking covered the following three areas of rules: (1) R307-1-1 (Forward and Definitions); (2) R307-3 (Control of Installati

(Permit Content, which are the State’s operating permit requirements that are not approved into the SIP). 

2This column includes the following information from the SIP submittal package: the rule number and title, an explanation of the 2006 

summary of how the State’s 2006 rule analysis described their action . 
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

2 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

per DAR File No. 28325 (11/3/2005) A purpose statement has been added to clarify that other permitting rules have independent requirements that also must be met. 

show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. It does not appear a provision liR307-401-1 (Purpose) in the 20submittal was ever approved by the past. 

4 R307-1-3.1.6 

“ The following information where applicable, shall be submitted with the notice of intent;” 

R307-401-2 Notice of Intent Requirements Deleting this rule R307-401-2 and moving it to R307-401-5 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version but is substantially the same) 

R307-401-5 Notice of Intent 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19that approval the State rule was numbered R307-1-3-1.6. 

5 R307-1-3.1.2 

“Within 90 days of receipt of a complete application including all the information....” (page E-41 of the Effective Rule) 

R307-401-3 Review Period Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-6 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version but is substantially the same) per DAR File No. 28325 (11/3/2005) Subsection R307-401-6(3) requires approval by the Air Quality Board for any 

R307-401-6 Review Period 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19that approval the State rule was numbered R307-1-3.1.2. We also note that R307-3.1.1 fr1992 rule contained completeneprovisions that now appear at R
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

3 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

major source or modification that consumes more than 50 percent of the available increment under PSD has been deleted because concerns about increment consumption are better addressed through other mechanisms. 

6(1). 

6 R-307-1-3.1.3 

Public Notice (pages E41-42 of the Effective Rule) 

R307-401-4 Public Notice Deleting this rule R307-401-4 and moving it to R407-401-7 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version but is substantially the same) 

R407-401-7 Public Notice 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. As discussed in the notice for thwe have not acted on this rule in actions. Public notice provisiocurrent SIP appear in R307-1-3

7 R307-1-3.1.4 

“Whenever the executive secretary determines that the information submitted under the provisions of ...” (page E42 of the Effective Rule) 

R307-401-5 Approval Order Deleting this rule R307-401-5 and moving it to R307-401-8 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version) 

R307-401-8 Approval Order 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19that approval the State rules wenumbered R307-1-3.1.4 and R3

8 R307-1-3.1.8 R307-401-6 R307-401-8 

Approval Order 

Review of eCFR shows that R33.1.8 has been approved on in 4
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

4 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

Conditions for Issuing Approval Order Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401- 8 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version) 

 52.2320(c)(25). 59 FR 35036 (J

1994). 

9 R307-1-3.1.9 

“The owner or operator of a source previously approved under R307-1-3.1 or in a State Implementation Plan may temporarily relocate....” (page E-44 of Effective Rule) 

R307-401-7 Temporary Relocation Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-17 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version but is substantially the same) 

R307-401-17 Temporary Relocation 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19which in that approval was Statnumber R307-1-3.1.9. 

10 R307-1-3.1.10 

“The owner or operator of a major new source or major modification to be located...” (page E-44 Effective Rule) 

R307-401-8 Nonattainment and Maintenance Areas Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-19 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version but is substantially the same) 

R307-401-19 Analysis of Alternatives 

Review of eCFR shows that R33.1.10 has been acted on in 40 C52.2320(c)(25). We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19which in that approval was Statnumber R307-1-3.1.10. 

11 R307-1-3.1.11 R307-401-9 R307-401-20 

Relaxation of limitations 

R307-401-9 as submitted on 9/2was approved in 71 FR 7679. 
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

5 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

“At the time that a source or modification becomes a major source...” (page E-44 Effective Rule) 

Relaxation of limitations Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-20 (language is the same) 

12 R307-1-3.1.12 

Low Oxides of Nitrogen Burner Technology (page E-44-45 of Effective Rule) 

R307-401-10 Low Oxides of Nitrogen Burner Technology Deleting R307-401-10 (1) and (2) have been moved to R307-325. 

R307-325 Davis and Salt Lake Counties and Ozone Nonattainment Areas: Ozone Provisions. Revisions to R307-325 were not requested in 9/15/06 SIP submittal. 

R307-401-10 (1) as submitted o9/20/1999 was approved in 71FR307-401-10 (2) was moved to 325 and review of eCFR indicawe have never approved this pa

13 R307-1-3.1.5 

“Approval orders issued by the Executive Secretary in accordance with the provisions of ...” (page E-42 of 

R307-401-11 Eighteen Month Review Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-18 (language is the same) 

R307-401-18 Eighteen Month Review 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

6 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

Effective Rule) that approval the State rule num

numbered R307-1-3.1.5. 

14 R307-1-3.1.7.G, H 

(page E-44 of Effective Rule) 

R307-413-1 Definitions and General Requirements Deleting this rule R307-413 (1) Definition of boiler and used oil were moved to R307-401-14 

R307-413 (1) Definition of boiler and used oil were moved to R307-401-14 

R307-401-14 (Used Oil Fuel BuEnergy Recovery) was previousproposed for approval (see 77 F(June 25, 2012)), and the final wsigned on October 19, 2012 (FeRegister notice pending). 

15 R307-1-3.7 

“The following are exempt from the notice of intent requirement: Exemptions and Special Provisions” (pages E-42-44 of Effective Rules) 

R307-413-2 Small Source Exemptions – De minimus Emissions Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-9 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version) per DAR File No. 28325 (11/3/2005) the registry for de minimis sources in nonattainement areas in Subsection R307-401-9 (formerly in R307-413-2(2)) has been changed to a voluntary registry that will apply statewide. 

R307-401-9 Small Source Exemptions 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. Additithis was not part of our approva1994 action, 59 FR 35036 (July 1994). 

16 R307-1-3.1.7. B 

(page E-43 of Effective Rule) 

R307-413-3 Flexibility Changes per DAR File No. 28325 

Deleted Review of eCFR on GPO webs

historical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/1
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

7 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

(11/3/2005) the flexibility provisions that were located in Section R307-413-3 have been deleted because the rule has provided little benefit and is routinely misinterpreted. The underlying goals of this exemption are being met through other mechanisms such as flexibility permit 

9/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. The State rule R307-413-3 (FleChanges) is a State-only rule annever been approved into the SI

17 R307-1-3.1.7.C 

(page E-43 of Effective Rule) 

R307-413-4 Other Exemptions per DAR File No. 28325 (11/3/2005) R307-413-4(5) and (6) have been deleted because they are no longer meeting the intended purpose. Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-10 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version but is substantially the same) 

R307-401-10 Source Category Exemptions 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19that approval the State rule was numbered R307-1-3.1.7. 

18 R307-1-3.1.7.D 

(page E-43-44 of Effective Rule) 

R307-413-5 Replacement-in-Kind Equipment Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-11 (language was modified from the 1999 version to the 2006 version but 

R307-401-11 Replacement-in-Kind Equipment 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. This is the first time we are proaction on this rule. 
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

8 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

is substantially the same) 

19 R307-1-3.1.7.E 

(page E-44 of Effective Rule) 

R307-413-6 Reduction of Air Contaminants Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-12 

R307-401-12 Reduction of Air Contaminants 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. 

20 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

R307-413-7 Exemption from Notice of Intent Requirements for Used Oil Fuel Burned for Energy Recovery Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-401-14 

R307-401-14 Used Oil Fuel Burned for Energy Recovery 

R307-401-14 (Used Oil Fuel BuEnergy Recovery) was previousproposed for approval (see 77 F(June 25, 2012)); and the final wsigned on October 19, 2012 (FeRegister notice pending). 

21 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

No comparable rule cite from 9/20/1999 submittal 

R307-401-2 Definitions 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. This is the first time we are proaction on this rule. 

22 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

No comparable rule cite from 9/20/1999 submittal 

R307-401-3 Applicability 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets show no prior has been taken on this rule as suon 10/9/1998, 9/20/1999 or 9/15We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19that approval the State rule was 
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

9 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

numbered R307-1-3.1.1. 

23 No comparable rule 

cite for R307-401-4(1) and (2) from 10/9/1998 submittal 

No comparable rule cite for R307-401-4(1) and (2) from 9/20/1999 submittal 

R307-401-4(1) and (2) 3

General Requirements 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. This is the first time we are proaction on this rule. 

24 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

No comparable rule cite from 9/20/1999 submittal 

R307-401-13 Plantwide Applicability Limits 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. This is the first time we are proaction on this rule. 

25 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

No comparable rule cite from 9/20/1999 submittal 

R307-401-15 Air Strippers and Soil Venting Projects 

R307-401-15 (Air Strippers and Venting Projects) was previousproposed for approval (see 77 F(June 25, 2012)); and the final signed on October 19, 2012 (FeRegister notice pending). 

26 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

No comparable rule cite from 9/20/1999 submittal 

R307-401-16 De minimis Emissions From 

Soil Aeration Projects 

(De minimis Emissions From S

Aeration Projects) was previousproposed for approval (see 77 F(June 25, 2012)); and the final signed on October 19, 2012 (Fe

3 We note that R307-401-4(3) was R307-401-3.1.12 in the SIP we approved in 1994. 
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

10 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

Register notice pending). 

27 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

No comparable rule cite from 9/20/1999 submittal 

R307-410-1 Purpose 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. This is the first time we are proaction on this rule. 

28 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

R307-410-1 Definitions Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-410-2 per DAR File No. 28325 (11/3/2005) The definitions in Rule R307-410 are deleted here and incorporated by reference from 40CFR 51.100 into subsection R307-410-2(2). Two definitions that are presently located in section R307-101-2 are being moved to R307-410-2 because the terms are not use in other rules. 

R307-410-2 Definitions 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. This is the first time we are proaction on this rule. 

29 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

R307-410-2 Use of Dispersion Model 

R307-410-3 Use of Dispersion Model 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/1
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

11 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-410-3 

9/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19that approval the State rule was renumbered R307-1-3.7. We note that the 9/15/2006 subdeleted the sentence “A proposasubstitution or modification of a shall be made a subject of requipublic hearings” from this rule. 

30 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

R307-410-3 Modeling Criteria Pollutant Impacts in Attainment Areas Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-410-4 

R307-410-4 Modeling Criteria Pollutant Impacts in Attainment Areas 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We note that VOCs are not listeTable 1 of this rule; the State inits approval order rule that the ESecretary will not issue an approrder unless the owner or operaprovided a satisfactory demonstthat the source will not contribupotential violation of the NAAQrequired under R307-401-8(1)(bAlso see Utah’s Uintah Basin PGuidance in the docket. 

31 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

R307-410-4 Documentation of Ambient 

R307-410-5 Documentation of Ambient 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been t
Table 1. EPA Cross-walk Analysis: State of Utah October 9, 1998, September 20, 1999, September 15, 2006 an

Submittals (Prepared May 30, 2013) 

12 

Row 

tracking 

number 

Citation from 

10/9/1998 submittal1

R307-1-3 

Number of the Rule and 

Rule Title (or first 

sentence where there is 

no rule title) 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/20/1999 SIP Submittal 

Corresponding Citation from 

the 9/15/06 SIP Submittal2

Discussion if there is a Prio

Action and/or Approval Into 

Air Impacts for Hazardous Air Pollutants Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-410-5 

Air Impacts for Hazardous Air Pollutants 

this rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. This is the first time we are proaction on this rule. 

32 No comparable rule 

cite from 10/9/1998 submittal 

R307-410-5 Stack Heights and Dispersion Techniques Deleting this rule and moving it to R307-410-6 

R307-410-6 Stack Heights and Dispersion Techniques 

Review of eCFR on GPO webshistorical dockets dating back to show no prior action has been tthis rule as submitted on 10/9/19/20/1999 or 9/15/2006. We approved an earlier version rule in 59 FR 35036 (July 8, 19that approval the State rule numR307-1-3.8.