Exhibit 10.1


 


Execution Version


 


	 
	
        LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT

         

        OF

         

        CARBON APPALACHIAN COMPANY, LLC

         

        (A Delaware limited liability company)

         

        Dated as of February 23, 2017

	 
	
         

        THE INTERESTS REPRESENTED BY THIS LIMITED
        LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED UNDER THE UNITED STATES SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED, OR UNDER ANY OTHER
        APPLICABLE FEDERAL OR STATE SECURITIES LAWS. SUCH INTERESTS MAY NOT BE SOLD, ASSIGNED, PLEDGED OR OTHERWISE TRANSFERRED AT ANY
        TIME WITHOUT EFFECTIVE REGISTRATION UNDER SUCH ACT AND LAWS OR EXEMPTION THEREFROM, AND COMPLIANCE WITH THE OTHER RESTRICTIONS
        ON TRANSFER SET FORTH HEREIN.

         





     


     


    

TABLE OF CONTENTS


  




	 	Page
	ARTICLE I GENERAL	1
	Section 1.1   Formation and Organization	1
	Section 1.2   Name	2
	Section 1.3   Principal Office	2
	Section 1.4   Registered Office and Registered Agent	2
	Section 1.5   Term	2
	Section 1.6   Purposes	2
	Section 1.7   Qualification in Other Jurisdictions	3
	Section 1.8   Title to Property	3
	Section 1.9   Payments of Individual Obligations	3
	ARTICLE II MANAGEMENT	3
	Section 2.1   Management of the Company by the Board of Directors	3
	Section 2.2   Election of Directors	5
	Section 2.3   Duties of the Board of Directors	7
	Section 2.4   Approval of the Board of Directors	7
	Section 2.5   Services Agreement	11
	Section 2.6   Performance of Duties; Liability of Manager and Officers	12
	Section 2.7   Payment of Certain General and Administrative Expenses of Carbon	12
	Section 2.8   Budget	13
	Section 2.9   Conflict Activities	14
	Section 2.10   Fair Market Value	15
	ARTICLE III MEMBERS	15
	Section 3.1   Members, Interests and Unit Classes; Voting Rights	15
	Section 3.2   No Liability for Company Obligations	17
	Section 3.3   Meeting of Members	17
	Section 3.4   Duties of Directors and Members	18
	Section 3.5   Other Investments of Member Related Parties; Waiver of Conflicts of Interest
and Negation of Duties and Obligations	20
	Section 3.6   Carbon Non-Compete	22
	Section 3.7   No Resignation or Withdrawal by Members	23
	Section 3.8   Certain Representations and Warranties of the Members	23
	ARTICLE IV CAPITAL	24
	Section 4.1   Capital Contributions	24
	Section 4.2   Key Man Event	27
	Section 4.3   Capital Accounts	27
	Section 4.4   Preemptive Rights	28
	Section 4.5   Unit Certificates	29
	Section 4.6   Defaulting Members	30
	Section 4.7   Optional Contribution	31
	Section 4.8   No Return of Capital Contributions	31



 






    i 


     


    

 


	ARTICLE V ALLOCATIONS; DISTRIBUTIONS	31
	Section 5.1   Allocations of Net Income or Net Loss	31
	Section 5.2   Special Allocations	31
	Section 5.3   Allocations of Taxable Income or Loss	33
	Section 5.4   Distributions	34
	Section 5.5   Tax Distributions	36
	Section 5.6   Liability of Members; Return of Class A Distributions and Class C Distributions.	36
	Section 5.7   Return of Class B Distributions	37
	ARTICLE VI TRANSFER; WITHDRAWAL; SALE RIGHTS; EXIT EVENTS	38
	Section 6.1   Transfers	38
	Section 6.2   Drag-Along Rights	38
	Section 6.3   Tag-Along Rights	41
	Section 6.4   Indirect Transfer	43
	Section 6.5   Liquidity Event	45
	Section 6.6   Buy/Sell Rights	48
	Section 6.7   Assumption of Assignee	51
	Section 6.8   Allocations to Member’s Transferee	51
	Section 6.9   Internal Restructure	51
	Section 6.10   Other Assignment Void	52
	Section 6.11   Allocation and Distribution of Consideration	52
	Section 6.12   Yorktown-Carbon Assignment.	54
	ARTICLE VII DISSOLUTION; WINDING UP	54
	Section 7.1   Dissolution	54
	Section 7.2   Winding Up	55
	Section 7.3   Application and Distribution of Proceeds of Liquidation	55
	Section 7.4   Certificate of Cancellation	56
	ARTICLE VIII LIABILITY AND INDEMNIFICATION	56
	Section 8.1   No Liability for Company Debts	56
	Section 8.2   Indemnification	56
	Section 8.3   Advance Payment and Appearance as a Witness	56
	Section 8.4   Insurance	57
	Section 8.5   Non-exclusivity of Rights; Company as Indemnitor of First Resort	57
	Section 8.6   Savings Clause	58
	ARTICLE IX CERTAIN TAX MATTERS	58
	Section 9.1   Partnership Classification	58
	Section 9.2   Tax Returns and Tax Information	58
	Section 9.3   Tax Elections	58
	Section 9.4   Election by Members	58
	Section 9.5   Tax Matters Representative	59
	Section 9.6   Withholding	59



 






    ii 


     


    

 


	ARTICLE X BOOKS AND RECORDS; REPORTS	59
	Section 10.1   Maintenance of and Access to Books and Records	59
	Section 10.2   Bank Accounts	60
	Section 10.3   Reports	60
	Section 10.4   Fiscal Year	61
	ARTICLE XI DEFINITIONS	61
	Section 11.1   Definitions	61
	Section 11.2   Other Defined Terms	73
	Section 11.3   Construction	75
	ARTICLE XII MISCELLANEOUS	75
	Section 12.1   Notices	75
	Section 12.2   Confidentiality	76
	Section 12.3   Expenses	76
	Section 12.4   Entire Agreement	77
	Section 12.5   Waiver or Consent	77
	Section 12.6   Amendment	77
	Section 12.7   Choice of Law	77
	Section 12.8   Public Announcement	78
	Section 12.9   Availability of Equitable Relief	78
	Section 12.10   Binding Agreement	78
	Section 12.11   Benefit of Agreement	78
	Section 12.12   Further Assurances	78
	Section 12.13   Counterparts	78


 


EXHIBITS


 


Exhibit A – Members


Exhibit B – Board of Directors


Exhibit C – Participation Agreement


Exhibit D – Initial Budget

Exhibit E – Initial Insurance

Exhibit F – AMI




 




    iii 


     


    

 


LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT


 


OF


 


CARBON APPALACHIAN COMPANY, LLC


 


This LIMITED LIABILITY
COMPANY AGREEMENT (this “Agreement”) of Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC (the “Company”),
dated as of February 23, 2017 (the “Effective Date”), is entered into by and among Carbon Natural
Gas Company, a Delaware corporation (“Carbon”), Yorktown Energy Partners XI, L.P., a Delaware
limited partnership (“Yorktown”), Old Ironsides Fund II-A Portfolio Holding Company, LLC, a Delaware
limited liability company (“OIE Fund II-A”) and Old Ironsides Fund II-B Portfolio Holding Company, LLC,
a Delaware limited liability company (“OIE Fund II-B” and, together with OIE Fund II-A, “Old
Ironsides”). Capitalized terms used herein without definition shall have the respective meanings assigned to such
terms in Article XI.


 


W I T N E S S E T H:


 


WHEREAS, as of the
date hereof, Carbon has caused its Subsidiary, Nytis Exploration Company LLC (“Nytis LLC”), to enter
into that certain Participation Agreement, substantially in the form of Exhibit C attached hereto (the “Participation
Agreement”), pursuant to which Nytis LLC is granting the Company (through its Subsidiary, OpCo) the right to participate
in the oil and gas development of Nytis LLC’s Tennessee Mining Tract property described in Exhibits A and B attached thereto
(the “Tennessee Mining Tract”) under the terms and conditions of the Participation Agreement; and


 


WHEREAS, the Members
listed on Exhibit A attached hereto desire to enter into this Agreement in accordance with the provisions of the Delaware
Limited Liability Company Act (the “Act”).


 


NOW, THEREFORE, in
consideration of the foregoing, of the mutual promises of the Members, and of other good and valuable mutual consideration, the
receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the Members agree on the following terms and conditions:


 


ARTICLE
I

GENERAL


 


Section 1.1Formation
and Organization.


 


(a)       The
Company has been formed as a Delaware limited liability company by the filing of the Certificate of Formation of the Company (the
“Certificate of Formation”) in the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware under and
pursuant to the Act. The Company hereby represents and warrants to
each Member that: (i) prior to the Effective Date, the Company has not engaged in any business activities other than in connection
with negotiation of this Agreement, the CNX PSA and the Participation Agreement; and (ii) as of the Effective Date, the Company
is not a party to or bound by any contract or agreement other than the Participation Agreement and does not have any liabilities
or obligations other than as set forth therein.


 






    1


     


    

 


(b)       The
Members hereby agree that during the term of the Company, the rights and obligations of the Members with respect to the Company
will be determined in accordance with the terms and provisions of this Agreement and, except where the Act provides that such rights
and obligations specified in the Act shall apply “unless otherwise provided in a limited liability company agreement”
or words of similar effect and such rights and obligations are set forth in this Agreement, the Act. Notwithstanding anything herein
to the contrary, Section 18-210 of the Act, entitled Contractual Appraisal Rights, shall not apply or be incorporated into this
Agreement.


 


Section 1.2Name.
The name of the Company shall be “Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC.” The business of the Company shall be conducted
under the name “Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC” or such other name or names as the Board may determine from time to
time.


 


Section 1.3Principal
Office. The principal office of the Company shall be located at 1700 Broadway, Suite 1170, Denver, Colorado 80290, or such
other place as the Board shall determine from time to time.


 


Section 1.4Registered
Office and Registered Agent. The registered office of the Company required by law to be maintained in the State of Delaware
shall be the initial registered office named in the Certificate of Formation or such other office (which need not be a place of
business of the Company) as the Board may designate from time to time in the manner provided by law. The registered agent of the
Company in the State of Delaware shall be the initial registered agent named in the Certificate of Formation or such other person
or persons as the Board may designate from time to time.


 


Section 1.5Term.
The existence of the Company commenced as of the date upon which the Certificate of Formation was filed in the office of the Secretary
of State of the State of Delaware, and the Company shall continue in existence until it is dissolved in accordance with the provisions
of this Agreement, and to the extent provided under the Act, until its affairs are wound up and the Company is terminated in accordance
with the provisions of this Agreement and the Act.


 


Section 1.6Purposes.
The purposes of the Company, whether carried out in its own name or through its Subsidiaries, are as follows:


 


(a)       to
engage in the evaluation, acquisition, exploration, drilling, development and production of or for oil, gas and other hydrocarbons
within the AMI;


 


(b)       to
engage in all other necessary and appropriate activities incidental to the foregoing business that may be lawfully conducted by
a limited liability company under the Act; and


 


(c)       to
engage in or perform any and all activities otherwise authorized by the Board in accordance with the terms of this Agreement.


 






    2


     


    

 


Section 1.7Qualification
in Other Jurisdictions. The Company shall execute and cause to be filed original or amended articles and/or certificates and
shall take any and all other actions as may be reasonably necessary to perfect and maintain the status of the Company as a limited
liability company or similar type of entity under the laws of any other jurisdictions in which the Company engages in business.
At the request of the Manager, each Member agrees to execute, acknowledge, swear to, and deliver all certificates and other instruments
conforming with this Agreement that are necessary or appropriate to qualify, continue, and terminate the Company as a foreign limited
liability company in all such jurisdictions in which the Company may conduct business.


 


Section 1.8Title
to Property. All property owned by the Company shall be owned by the Company as an entity or by its Subsidiaries and no Member
shall have any ownership interest in such property in its individual capacity, and each Member’s Interests in the Company
shall be personal property for all purposes. The Company shall hold title to all of its property in the name of the Company or
one or more of its Subsidiaries, not in the name of any Member.


 


Section 1.9Payments
of Individual Obligations. The Company’s credit and assets shall be used solely for the benefit of the Company, and no
asset of the Company shall be Transferred or encumbered for, or in payment of, any individual obligation of any Member.


 


ARTICLE
II

MANAGEMENT


 


Section 2.1Management
of the Company by the Board of Directors.


 


(a)       Management
by the Board of Directors. Subject to the terms hereof and except as the Manager and/or the other officers are permitted hereby,
the business, property and affairs of the Company shall be managed and all powers of the Company shall be exercised by or under
the direction of a board of directors (the “Board of Directors” or the “Board”).
The members of the Board of Directors as of the date hereof shall be those Persons set forth on Exhibit B hereto. Each
member of the Board of Directors is referred to herein as a “Director.”


 


(b)       Place
of Meetings. Meetings of the Board of Directors, regular or special, will be held at such places, either within or without
the State of Delaware, as may be specified by the person calling the meeting. In the absence of specific designation, meetings
of the Board of Directors shall be held at the principal office of the Company.


 


(c)       Regular
Meetings. The Board of Directors shall meet on a quarterly basis at such times and places as may be fixed from time to time
by the Board and communicated to all Directors. Any and all business may be transacted at any regular meeting.


 


(d)       Special
Meetings. Special meetings of the Board of Directors shall be held at any time upon the call of any Director or the Manager.
If the Manager desires to take or have authorized any action that requires approval of the Board, the Manager shall request that
the Board of Directors take action with respect thereto by so notifying the Board of Directors in writing and describing in such
notification (i) the nature of the transaction or business and (ii) the proposed course of action recommended by the Manager. The
Manager shall deliver the notification referred to above, together with any available information that is reasonably necessary
to enable the Board of Directors to consider the advisability of the proposed course of action, to the Board of Directors a reasonable
period of time prior to the dates by which action is to be taken as specified therein. Notice of any such special meeting shall
be in writing and shall be given personally or by facsimile or Electronic Transmission to each member of the Board of Directors
at least three Business Days prior to the date of the meeting.


 






    3


     


    

 


(e)       Attendance
at and Notice of Meetings. Attendance at a meeting of the Board of Directors shall constitute a waiver of notice of such meeting,
except where a Director attends a meeting for the express purpose of objecting to the transaction of any business on the ground
that the meeting is not lawfully called or convened, not authorized by the Agreement or impermissible as a matter of Law.


 


(f)       Quorum.
A quorum shall exist when a number of Directors representing at least a Majority of the Voting Power is present in person or by
proxy. If a quorum shall not be present at any meeting of the Board of Directors, the Directors present thereat may adjourn the
meeting from time to time, without notice other than announcement at the meeting, until a quorum shall be present. At any such
adjourned meeting any business may be transacted that might have been transacted at the meeting as originally convened.


 


(g)       Voting.
For purposes of any vote, approval, consent or other action to be taken by the Board, each Director shall possess one (1) vote.
As used in this Agreement, a “Majority of the Voting Power” means the affirmative votes of those Directors whose
aggregate votes equal or exceed a majority of the number of Directors comprising the full Board. As used in this Agreement, a “Supermajority
of the Voting Power” means the affirmative votes of those Directors whose aggregate votes equal or exceed a majority
of the number of Directors comprising the full Board, provided that at least one (1) such vote is (i) the affirmative vote of a
Carbon Designee for so long as Carbon is entitled to designate Directors and is not a Defaulting Member or (ii) the affirmative
vote of a Yorktown Designee for so long as Yorktown is entitled to designate Directors and is not a Defaulting Member; provided,
however, that for purposes of Section 2.4(b)(vii), Section 2.4(b)(viii), and, to the extent relating to any matter
approved pursuant to Section 2.4(b)(vii) or Section 2.4(b)(viii), Section 2.4(b)(ix), a “Supermajority
of the Voting Power” means the affirmative votes of those Directors whose aggregate votes equal or exceed a majority
of the number of Directors comprising the full Board, provided that at least one (1) such vote is the affirmative vote of a Yorktown
Designee for so long as Yorktown is entitled to designate Directors and is not a Defaulting Member.


 


(h)       Proxy.
Each Director entitled to vote at a meeting of the Board of Directors may authorize another Director to act for such Director by
proxy, but no such proxy shall be voted or acted upon after 11 months from its date, unless the proxy provides for a longer period.
A duly executed proxy shall be irrevocable if it states that it is irrevocable and if, and only as long as, it is coupled with
an interest sufficient in law to support an irrevocable power. A proxy may be made irrevocable regardless of whether the interest
with which it is coupled is an interest in an Interest itself or an interest in the Company generally.


 


(i)       Action
by the Board of Directors Without a Meeting. Action required or permitted to be taken at a meeting of Directors may be taken
without a meeting if the action is evidenced by one or more written consents describing the action taken, signed by at least a
Majority of the Voting Power (if the action requires approval of a Majority of the Voting Power) or signed by at least a Supermajority
of the Voting Power (if the action requires approval of a Supermajority of the Voting Power). Action taken under this Section 2.1(i)
is effective when the requisite number of Directors have signed the consent, unless the consent specifies a different effective
date. The Board of Directors shall promptly provide a copy of such adopted written consent to all Directors.


 






    4


     


    

 


(j)       Telephonic
Meetings. The Board of Directors may hold meetings by means of conference telephone or similar communications equipment by
means of which all of the Directors participating in the meeting can hear each other, and participation in such meeting shall constitute
attendance and presence in person at such meeting.


 


(k)       Minutes.
All decisions and resolutions of the Board of Directors shall be reported in the minutes of its meetings, which shall state the
date, time and place of the meeting (or the date of the written consent in the case of a consent executed in lieu of a meeting),
the persons present at the meeting, the resolutions put to a vote (or the subject of a written consent) and the results of such
voting (or written consent). The minutes of all meetings of the Board of Directors shall be circulated to all Directors as soon
as practical after each meeting and shall be kept at the principal office of the Company.


 


(l)       Additional
Information. Upon request from time to time by any Director, the Manager or other officer shall promptly provide to such Director
any and all documents and information requested by such Director relating to the business, operations, prospects, properties, liabilities,
financial condition or results of operations of the Company, including (i) the Records of the Company, (ii) any contracts or agreements
to which the Company is a party and (iii) documents and information relating to or evidencing any claim or liability to which the
Company or its assets are subject.


 


Section 2.2Election
of Directors.


 


(a)       Qualifications.
Each Director shall be a natural person. A Director need not be a resident of the State of Delaware, a Member or an officer of
the Company.


 


(b)       Number.
The Board of Directors initially shall be comprised of five Directors and the initial Directors shall be the persons whose names
are set forth on Exhibit B attached hereto. Each Director shall hold office until a successor shall have been designated
in accordance with the terms of this Agreement. The number of Directors may be increased or decreased from time to time by a Supermajority
of the Voting Power. Upon the removal of any Director pursuant to Section 2.2(e) or mandatory resignation pursuant to Section
2.2(g), the number of Directors shall be automatically reduced.


 


(c)       Designees.


 


(i)       Old
Ironsides Designees. Old Ironsides shall be entitled to appoint three (3) persons to serve on the Board (each, an “Old
Ironsides Designee”). The current Old Ironsides Designees are identified on Exhibit B attached hereto.


 


(ii)       Yorktown
Designee. Yorktown shall be entitled to appoint one (1) person to serve on the Board (“Yorktown Designee”).
The current Yorktown Designee is identified on Exhibit B attached hereto.


 






    5


     


    

 


(iii)       Carbon
Designee. Carbon shall be entitled to appoint one (1) person to serve on the Board (“Carbon Designee”).
The current Carbon Designee is identified on Exhibit B attached hereto.


 


(iv)       The
right of Old Ironsides and Yorktown to appoint Directors is transferable in whole (and not in part), and may be transferred by
such Member to any transferee of such Member’s Class A Units to the extent such Transfer of Class A Units is permitted pursuant
to Section 6.1, provided such transferee (after giving effect to such Transfer) holds twenty percent (20%) or more of the
outstanding Class A Units. The right of Carbon to appoint Directors is not transferable.


 


(v)       If
Old Ironsides or Yorktown, or any Member to which such Member has transferred rights to appoint Directors, shall at any time own
less than twenty percent (20%) of the outstanding Class A Units, such Member shall no longer be entitled to appoint any Directors,
all of its appointed Directors shall be deemed to have concurrently resigned as a Director of the Company and all references and
provisions in this Agreement requiring the vote of or granting rights to any Directors appointed by such Member shall be inapplicable
and disregarded, in each case with no further action required by any such Director, the Company or any other Member.


 


(d)       Vacancies.
If any member of the Board of Directors appointed by a party (the “Designating Party”) pursuant to Section
2.2(c) (each, a “Board of Directors Designee”) shall cease to serve as a member of the Board of Directors
for any reason, the vacancy resulting thereby shall be filled by another individual to be appointed by the Designating Party.


 


(e)       Removal.
No members of the Board of Directors shall be removed from office without the consent of the applicable Designating Party; provided,
however, that if a party is no longer entitled to appoint a Board of Directors Designee or Designees pursuant to Section 2.2(c),
the members of the Board of Directors other than those appointed by such party shall be entitled to remove the Board of Directors
Designee or Designees appointed by such party with or without cause. Any member of the Board of Directors may be removed from office
at any time, with or without cause, if the Designating Party that appointed such Director delivers to the Board of Directors a
written notice requesting the removal of such member of the Board of Directors.


 


(f)       Resignation.
A Director may resign from the Board of Directors at any time by giving written notice to the Company. Such resignation shall take
effect three Business Days following receipt of that notice or at such later time as shall be specified in the notice. Unless otherwise
specified in the notice, the acceptance of a resignation shall not be necessary to make it effective.


 


(g)       Mandatory
Resignation. Unless otherwise approved by the Designating Party who appointed such Director, if any Director who is an Affiliate
of any Member ceases to be an Affiliate of such Member or such Member ceases to be a Member of the Company for any reason, such
Director shall be deemed to have immediately resigned as a Director and shall not be entitled to be re-appointed as a Director.


 


(h)       Compensation.
No Director is entitled to remuneration for services rendered or goods provided to the Company in his or her capacity as a Director.


 






    6


     


    

 


Section 2.3Duties
of the Board of Directors.


 


(a)       To
the fullest extent permitted by the Act, a person, in performing his duties and obligations as a Director under this Agreement,
shall be entitled to act or omit to act at the direction of the Member, if any, that designated such person to serve on the Board
of Directors, considering only such factors, including the separate interests of the Designating Party, as such Director or Designating
Party chooses to consider, and any action of such Person or failure to act, taken or omitted in good faith reliance on the foregoing
provisions shall not, as between the Company and any other Member, on the one hand, and such Person or Designating Party, on the
other hand, constitute a breach of any duty (including any fiduciary or other similar duty, to the extent such exist under the
Act or any other applicable Law) on the part of such Person or Member to the Company or any other Director or Member of the Company.


 


(b)       The
Members (in their own names and in the name and on behalf of the Company) hereby:


 


(i)       agree
that (A) the terms of this Section 2.3, to the extent that they modify or limit a duty or other obligation, if any, that
a Director may have to the Company or any Member under the Act or other applicable Law, are reasonable in form, scope and content;
and (B) the terms of this Section 2.3 shall control to the fullest extent possible if it is in conflict with a duty, if
any, that a Director may have to the Company or any Member, under the Act or any other applicable Law; and


 


(ii)       waive
to the fullest extent permitted by the Act, any duty (including any fiduciary duty) or other obligation, if any, that a Director
may have to the Company or a Member, pursuant to the Act or any other applicable law.


 


(c)       Each
Member (in its own name and in the name and on behalf of the Company), acknowledges, affirms and agrees that (i) the Member would
not be willing to make an investment in the Company, and no person designated by such Member to serve on the Board of Directors
would be willing to so serve, in the absence of this Section 2.3, and (ii) it has reviewed and understands the provisions
of Section 18-1101(c) of the Act.


 


Section 2.4Approval
of the Board of Directors. Except for those matters requiring approval of a Supermajority of the Voting Power pursuant to Section
2.4(b), approval by a Majority of the Voting Power shall be the act and approval of the Board.


 


(a)       Majority
of the Voting Power. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Agreement, but subject to Section 2.4(b),
the Company shall not take (or, with respect to any Subsidiary of the Company, approve or cause to occur) any of the following
actions without the approval of the Majority of the Voting Power:


 


(i)       establish
and maintain any Budget or amend a Budget in any material respect, which amendment for the purposes of this provision means (A)
the modification or reallocation of (I) the aggregate amount provided in the Budget by more than five percent (5%), or (II) any
particular line item of the Budget by more than ten percent (10%), or (B) making expenditures for any proposed Project not currently
in the Budget requiring capital expenditures in excess of $1,000,000 (any deviation from the Budget not in excess of the thresholds
described in the foregoing clauses (A) or (B), a “Permitted Variance”);


 






    7


     


    

 


(ii)       incur
any expenditure or series of related expenditures not otherwise a part of an approved Budget, except any expenditure or series
of related expenditures (x) as required under Section 2.7, (y) as permitted under Section 2.8 or (z) that
constitute a Permitted Variance;


 


(iii)       sell,
transfer, farm out or otherwise dispose of (directly or indirectly) any property or assets of the Company (including, without limitation,
any of its Subsidiaries) having a value in excess of $1,000,000;


 


(iv)       except
in accordance with a hedge policy or guideline approved by a Majority of the Voting Power, enter into or become obligated under
any swap, collar, floor, cap or other derivative contract or any option, forward sale, exchange-traded contract or other hedging
contract with respect to interest rates or commodity prices or basis differentials;


 


(v)       enter
into any marketing arrangements or commitments for midstream services, other than such agreements or commitments that have a term
of 180 days or less;


 


(vi)       amend
or modify, or compromise or waive any rights under, or exercise any rights of the Company or any Subsidiary of the Company to terminate,
any operating agreement, development agreement, operator agreement or similar agreement to which the Company or any of its Subsidiaries
is a party or their assets are bound;


 


(vii)       except
consistent with the then current Budget, elect or make a determination to consent to or elect to participate with respect to any
new well or any Drilling and Completion Activities or other material operation (including any re-entry, sidetracking or recompletion)
with respect to any well under the Participation Agreement, the Primary JOA, or any other operating, participation or similar agreement
to which the Company or any of its Subsidiaries is a party or their assets are bound;


 


(viii)       elect
to exercise tag-along rights or preferential rights to purchase under any operating agreement, participation agreement or similar
agreement;


 


(ix)       amend,
modify or supplement, or waive any rights under, or exercise any rights of the Company or any Subsidiary of the Company to terminate,
the Participation Agreement, the Primary JOA or the Contract Operating Agreement;


 


(x)       reduce
the coverage or amount of coverage for insurance as reflected on Exhibit F;


 






    8


     


    

 


(xi)       authorize
the issuance of or issue any additional Units or other Interests of the Company (other than pursuant to the terms of this Agreement),
and any amendment to this Agreement to reflect the creation of such Units if of an additional or different classes or series of
Units;


 


(xii)       subject
to Section 3.1(b) and Section 3.1(c), authorize the admission of any new Member to the Company;


 


(xiii)       effect
any change (whether by conversion, recapitalization, Internal Restructure or otherwise) in the legal form of the Company from a
limited liability company to any other type of legal entity;


 


(xiv)       except
as provided for in a Budget, borrow any money or otherwise incur, guarantee or otherwise become liable for any Indebtedness;


 


(xv)       mortgage,
pledge, assign in trust or otherwise encumber any property or assets of the Company or any of its Subsidiaries, or assign any monies
owed or to be owed to the Company or any of its Subsidiaries, except for customary Liens contained in or arising under operating
or similar agreements executed by or binding on the Company or any of its Subsidiaries or to secure Indebtedness;


 


(xvi)       initiate,
compromise or settle any lawsuit, administrative matter or other dispute where the amount the Company or any Subsidiary of the
Company may recover or might be obligated to pay, as applicable, is in excess of $100,000, or to repair or replace property or
assets of the Company or any Subsidiary of the Company damaged or destroyed as a result of an accident or other occurrence when
the Company’s or such Subsidiary’s share of the costs of repair or replacement (either individually or in the aggregate,
but net of insurance proceeds) is in excess of $50,000;


 


(xvii)       subject
to Section 4.2(c), exercise the rights of the Company under the Services Agreement to terminate the Services Agreement or,
at any time after the termination of the Services Agreement, to remove any Manager or designate any Person other than Carbon as
Manager;


 


(xviii)       voluntarily
file a petition in bankruptcy for the Company, make an assignment for the benefit of creditors of the Company, file a petition
or answer seeking, consenting to or acquiescing in any reorganization, arrangement, readjustment, liquidation, dissolution or similar
relief with respect to the Company under any statute, law or regulation or take any action seeking, consenting to or acquiescing
in the appointment of a trustee, receiver or liquidator of the Company or any substantial part of the properties and assets of
the Company;


 


(xix)       liquidate
or dissolve the Company or any of its Subsidiaries;


 


(xx)       change
in the number of Directors comprising the full Board;


 


(xxi)       approve
a Capital Call (or issue a Capital Call Notice);


 






    9


     


    

 


(xxii)       approve
of a Transfer of Interests by Carbon or Yorktown pursuant to Section 6.1(a)(i), other than a Yorktown-Carbon Assignment;


 


(xxiii)       enter
into any contract providing for (or committing to provide for), or delegating authority to any Person (including any subcommittee
of the Board for) decisions on, any of the foregoing transactions or matters, or the delegation of authority to any Person to approve
any of the foregoing transactions or matters;


 


(xxiv)       make
(A) any determination of Available Cash or (B) any distributions to the Members pursuant to Section 5.4 or Section 5.5;


 


(xxv)       select,
engage or dismiss the Company’s independent certified public accountants, which accounting firm initially shall be EKS&H
LLLP;


 


(xxvi)       
authorize or permit the Company to form any Subsidiary (other than OpCo);


 


(xxvii)       approve
or consummate any acquisition of assets by the Company or any of its Subsidiaries or series of such acquisitions which individually
or in the aggregate exceeds $1,000,000 in any six-month period, or approve any investment in or acquisition of any ownership interest
in Restricted Interest offered by Carbon to the Company;


 


(xxviii)       set
or adjust the compensation or benefits of any manager, officer or employee of the Company; or


 


(xxix)       take
any action, authorize or approve, or enter into any binding agreement with respect to or otherwise commit to do any of the foregoing.


 


(b)       Supermajority
of the Voting Power. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Agreement, the Company shall not take (or,
with respect to any Subsidiary of the Company, approve or cause to occur) any of the following actions without the approval of
the Supermajority of the Voting Power:


 


(i)       make
any distributions or other payments to the Members other than in accordance with the terms of this Agreement and the Services Agreement;


 


(ii)       redeem
or repurchase any Units or other Interest;


 


(iii)       engage
in any activities or make any investment other than as permitted under Section 1.6(a) and Section 1.6(b), including
without limitation any activity authorized pursuant to Section 1.6(c), or otherwise take any action outside of the Company’s
purpose as set forth in Section 1.6(a) and Section 1.6(b);


 


(iv)       increase
any Member’s Capital Commitment (subject to the consent of any Member whose Capital Commitment is increased);


 






    10


     


    

 


(v)       engage
in any transactions with any Member, Director, officer, employee or other Affiliate of the Company, or their respective Affiliates,
except (A) pursuant to a written employment agreement with such person, (B) this Agreement, (C) the Participation Agreement; (D)
the Management Services Agreement; (E) the Contract Operating Agreement, (F) for reimbursement of reasonable business
expenses of employees or contractors incurred in the ordinary course of the Company’s business, and (G) for payment of a
portion of Carbon’s general and administrative expenses in accordance with Section 2.7;


 


(vi)      any
amendment to the Company’s organizational documents that adversely affects in any material respect the rights of Carbon with
respect to its Class A Units or Class C Units in a manner disproportionate to the rights of the other Class A Members or Class
C Members or adversely affects the economic rights of the Class B Units to receive distributions relative to the Class A Units
or Class C Units;


 


(vii)      except
in connection with a Liquidity Event approved as provided in Section 6.5 or a Third Party Sale pursuant to Section 6.6,
authorize or effect any Internal Restructure, Liquidity Event or other consolidation of the Company with another Person or any
merger of the Company with or into another Person;


 


(viii)    except
in connection with a Liquidity Event approved as provided in Section 6.5, authorize or effect the sale of all or substantially
all of the Company’s assets in a single or series of related transactions, including in connection with a liquidation of
the Company; or


 


(ix)       take
any action, authorize or approve, or enter into any binding agreement with respect to or otherwise commit to do any of the foregoing.


 


(c)       The
Members acknowledge and agree, notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement or in the Act, that the matters described
in Section 2.4(a) and Section 2.4(b) require only the requisite Director approval contemplated therein
and that no separate or additional Member vote, consent or approval shall be required in order for the Company to undertake such
action. Any consolidation or merger of the Company approved by a Supermajority of the Voting Power in accordance with Section 2.4(b)(vii)
shall not be deemed to cause an assignment or other Transfer of the Interests under this Agreement.


 


Section 2.5Services
Agreement. The Manager’s responsibilities may be performed in whole or in part pursuant to a master services or similar
contract (“Services Agreement”). On and effective as of the Effective Date, the Company has entered into
the Management Services Agreement, which shall constitute the initial Services Agreement.


 






    11


     


    

 


Section 2.6Performance
of Duties; Liability of Manager and Officers. The Manager or any officer shall not be liable to the Company or to any Member
for any loss or damage sustained by the Company or any Member as a result of it carrying out its duties as Manager or officer in
good faith, unless the loss or damage shall have been the result of fraud, deceit, gross negligence, reckless or intentional misconduct,
or a knowing violation of Law by the Manager or officer.


 


Section 2.7Payment
of Certain General and Administrative Expenses of Carbon. Until the Termination Date (as defined in the Management Services
Agreement):


 


(a)       Until
such time as the Company has made Capital Calls in an amount equal to or greater than twenty-five percent (25%) of the aggregate
Capital Commitments, the Company shall pay or reimburse Carbon for a portion of its aggregate general and administrative expenses
in the amount of $300,000 per year payable in four (4) equal quarterly installments of $75,000; and


 


(b)       From
and after the Company having made Capital Calls in an amount equal to or greater than twenty-five percent (25%) of the aggregate
Capital Commitments, the Company shall pay to Carbon for each Fiscal Quarter an amount equal to (x) $1,000,000.00, multiplied by
(y) a fraction, (i) the numerator of which shall be the volume of oil and gas produced by the Company and its Subsidiaries
during such Fiscal Quarter and (ii) the denominator of which will be the sum of (A) the volume of oil and gas produced by the Company
and its Subsidiaries during such Fiscal Quarter plus (B) the volume of oil and gas produced by Carbon and its Subsidiaries (other
than the Company or its Subsidiaries) during such Fiscal Quarter in each of the following States: Ohio, Kentucky, Tennessee, West
Virginia and Virginia. Such volumes of oil and gas shall be calculated using the ratio of one barrel of oil as an equivalent to
six thousand cubic feet of natural gas.


 


(c)       Such
payments or reimbursements described in Section 2.7(a) and Section 2.7(b) shall be paid to Carbon within 30
days of the end of each Fiscal Quarter (or, in the case of the last Fiscal Quarter with respect to which payment or reimbursement
is due, within 30 days of the Termination Date (as defined in the Management Services Agreement). With respect to the first Fiscal
Quarter with respect to which payment or reimbursement is due, such payment or reimbursement shall be pro-rated by multiplying
the gross amount of the payment or reimbursement by a fraction, the numerator of which is the number of days from and after the
Effective Date through the end of the Fiscal Quarter and the denominator of which is the number of days in the Fiscal Quarter.
With respect to the last Fiscal Quarter with respect to which payment or reimbursement is due, such payment or reimbursement shall
be pro-rated by multiplying the gross amount of the payment or reimbursement by a fraction, the numerator of which is the
number of days from and after the first day of the Fiscal Quarter through the Termination Date (as defined in the Management Services
Agreement) and the denominator of which is the number of days in the Fiscal Quarter.


 






    12


     


    

 


Section 2.8Budget.


 


(a)       The
Budget for the period from the date of this Agreement through December 31, 2017, as approved as of the date of this Agreement,
is attached hereto as Exhibit E (the “Initial Budget”), which is hereby approved for all
purposes of this Agreement without the need for further approval by the Board.


 


(b)       The
Board shall review each Budget, including the Initial Budget, from time to time as requested by the Manager during the capital
year to which such Budget relates and the Budget shall be amended or modified to reflect any amendments or modifications thereto
approved by the Board and as so modified or amended shall thereafter constitute the Budget for the remainder of the calendar year
to which such Budget relates. Each Budget, including the Initial Budget, shall be divided into at least two sections as follows:
(i) a section setting forth expenditures which are fundamental to the operation of the Company and its Subsidiaries and continuing
and ongoing operation of their producing assets (the “Baseline Budget”) and (ii) a section setting forth
expenditures related to the development of and growth or development capital expenditures related to the assets of the Company
and its Subsidiaries (the “Development Budget”).


 


(c)       The
officers of the Company shall prepare or cause to be prepared and presented to the Board not later than December 1 of each
calendar year (beginning December 1, 2017 (for calendar year 2018)) a draft Budget for the next succeeding calendar year (the
“Proposed Budget”) setting forth the anticipated revenues and expenses of the Company for such calendar
year in a format consistent with the Initial Budget, which shall include such information requested by the Board.


 


(d)       Expenditures
in a Budget may extend over more than one calendar year because such expenditures represent activities or operations that require
commitments in excess of one calendar year. Once such expenditures have been approved by the Board as part of a Budget, unless
the Board determines otherwise in accordance with its review of a Budget pursuant to Section 2.8(b), such expenditures shall
not be required to be resubmitted for approval on an annual or other periodic basis, but instead all such items, until completed,
automatically shall be included in future Budgets (subject to limits and amounts as previously approved) as items which have already
been approved.


 


(e)       If
the Board does not approve a Proposed Budget for a calendar year on or prior to the December 20 preceding January 1 of
the calendar year to which such Proposed Budget relates, the officers shall use good faith efforts to prepare or to cause to be
prepared a revised Proposed Budget for approval by the Board. Each Proposed Budget approved hereunder by the Board in accordance
with Section 2.4(a)(i) shall be deemed a “Budget.”


 


(f)       To
the extent that any Proposed Budget is not approved by the Board in accordance with Section 2.4(a)(i) by the first
day of the calendar year to which such Proposed Budget relates, then, until a Proposed Budget for such calendar year is approved
by the Board in accordance with Section 2.4(a)(i), the Baseline Budget for such calendar year shall be equal to the
Baseline Budget for the immediately preceding calendar year (excluding non-recurring items but including recurring maintenance
capital expenditures).


 


(g)       The
Company shall not incur expenses or capital expenditures in excess of amounts set forth in the Budget without prior approval of
the Board in accordance with Section 2.4(a)(ii), except (i) Permitted Variances and (ii) as set forth in Section 2.8(h).


 






    13


     


    

 


(h)       Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary in this Agreement, the Company is expressly authorized to make Emergency Expenditures without prior authorization
or approval of the Board when necessary or advisable, in the judgment of the officers of the Company or the Manager, pursuant to
Prudent Industry Practices, to deal with emergencies, including explosions, fires, spills, or any other similar event, which may
endanger property, lives, or the environment. The officers of the Company or the Manager shall as soon as practicable report to
the Board the nature of any such emergency which arises, the measures he intends to take in respect of such emergency and the estimated
related expenditures.


 


Section 2.9Conflict
Activities.


 


(a)       Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary in this Agreement, any Conflict Activity shall be conducted by and under the direction of, and subject
to the sole approval by, the Directors that have been appointed by a Non-Conflicted Member and neither the Conflicted Member nor
the Directors appointed by the Conflicted Member shall have the right to vote or participate in any meeting of the Board regarding
such Conflict Activity or any approval in connection with any action by the Board in respect of such Conflict Activity and the
presence of any Directors appointed by the Conflicted Member shall not be required for purposes of determining the presence of
a quorum in connection with any such action.


 


(b)       No
officer of the Company that is also an officer, director, member, manager, stockholder, partner or employee of a Conflicted Member
(or one of its Affiliates) shall have any obligation to take or refrain from taking any action on behalf of the Company with respect
to such Conflict Activity except to provide information, documents and other related items reasonably requested by the Company
or the Board in connection with such Conflict Activity (provided that such Person shall not be required to provide such information,
documents or other items if doing so would require such Person to violate any applicable confidentiality restrictions (following
a request of the waiver thereof) or waive or violate any legal professional privilege or similar duty of confidentiality). Except
with respect to such Person’s failure to provide information, documents or other related items requested by the Company in
connection with such Conflict Activity in violation of the foregoing or to provide testimony, give evidence or otherwise participate
in any suit, litigation, arbitration or other dispute resolution proceeding involving the Conflicted Member, any such Person’s
failure or refusal to take or refrain from taking any such action shall not constitute (i) a breach of any duty, fiduciary or otherwise,
if any, owed by such Person to the Company or (ii) gross negligence or willful misconduct on the part of such Person.


 


(c)       Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary in this Agreement, at any time that a Member is a Defaulting Member, this Section 2.9 shall not
apply for the benefit of such Member, the Directors that have been appointed by such Defaulting Member shall have no rights under
this Section 2.9 with respect to any Conflict Activity, and the Directors appointed by the Non-Defaulting Member shall have
authority to act on behalf of the Company with respect to such Conflict Activity.


 






    14


     


    

 


Section 2.10Fair
Market Value. All determinations of Fair Market Value and Company Sale Value required by this Agreement, other than pursuant
to Section 6.6, shall be made by a Supermajority of the Voting Power; provided, however, that if the approval of
a Supermajority of the Voting Power cannot be obtained in connection with any such determination, such disputed determination shall
be submitted to, and resolved by, Ernst & Young LLP or, if such Person is unable or unwilling to serve in such capacity, by
any replacement approved by a Supermajority of the Voting Power (the “Independent Appraiser”); provided,
however, that in the event a Supermajority of the Voting Power cannot agree on a replacement Independent Appraiser within five
(5) Business Days after any Director has proposed a replacement for approval, within seven (7) days after the end of such five
(5) Business Day period, each of the applicable Parties unable to agree on a replacement Independent Appraiser shall submit the
names of three (3) Qualified Appraisers, and each such Party shall be entitled to strike one (1) name from the other party’s
list of firms, and the Qualified Appraiser shall be selected by lot from the remaining firms. The Independent Appraiser shall submit
to the Board a written report within 30 days of its engagement setting forth such determination. The expenses of the Independent
Appraiser shall be borne by the Company. The determination of the Independent Appraiser as to Fair Market Value or Company Sale
Value shall be final and binding upon the Company, the Board and all Members. The matter dependent on such determination of Fair
Market Value or Company Sale Value with respect to which such determination is to be made by an Independent Appraiser pursuant
to this Section 2.10 shall be deferred until the determination pursuant to this Section 2.10.


 


ARTICLE
III

MEMBERS


 


Section 3.1Members,
Interests and Unit Classes; Voting Rights.


 


(a)       The
Company shall have one or more Members with Interests designated as Units. Initially there shall be three classes of Units, designated
“Class A Units”, “Class B Units” and “Class C Units”.
The names, addresses and number and class of Units of each of the initial Members are set forth in Exhibit A attached
hereto. To the extent of their holdings of Class A Units, Members holding Class A Units shall be referred to as “Class
A Members” and to the extent of their holdings of Class B Units, Members holding Class B Units shall be referred
to as “Class B Members” and to the extent of their holdings of Class C Units, Members holding Class C
Units shall be referred to as “Class C Members.”


 


(b)       Subject
to Section 2.4(a)(xi), Section 2.4(a)(xii) and Article VI, any Person to which Units are issued
by the Company after the date hereof shall be admitted to the Company as a Member on the date of issuance of such Units.


 


(c)       Any
Person to which Units are Transferred as permitted by Article VI shall be admitted to the Company as a Member with
respect to the Units acquired on the date upon which such Transfer has been effected and the requirements set forth in Section
6.1 and Section 6.7 have been satisfied.


 


(d)       Class
A Units shall be issued from time to time as provided in this Article III and be the only Interests entitled to vote
and each Class A Member shall have a number of votes equal to the number of Class A Units it holds.


 






    15


     


    

 


(e)       Class
B Units.


 


(i)       The
class of Units designated as Class B Units shall consist solely of one thousand (1,000) Class B Units, all of which currently are
issued and held by Carbon as the Class B Member.


 


(ii)       The
Class B Member shall have no obligation to make any capital contributions to the Company in exchange for or on account of the Class
B Units.


 


(iii)       Subject
to Section 12.6, the Class B Units shall have no voting rights on any matter, including amendments to this Agreement.


 


(iv)       The
Company and each Member agree to treat each Class B Unit as a separate “profits interest” within the meaning of Rev.
Proc. 93-27, 1993-2 C.B. 343. Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary, distributions to each Class B Member pursuant to
Section 5.4 hereof (solely with respect to such Class B Units) shall be limited to the extent necessary so that each Class
B Unit qualifies as a “profits interest” under Rev. Proc. 93-27, and this Agreement shall be interpreted accordingly.
In the event that distributions to a Class B Member pursuant to Section 5.4 hereof are limited as a result of the preceding
sentence of this Section 3.1(e)(iv), the Manager is authorized to adjust future distributions to the Members in whatever
manner it deems appropriate so that, after such adjustments are made, each Member receives, to the maximum extent possible, an
amount of distributions equal to the amount of distributions such Member would have received were such sentence not part of this
Agreement; provided, that any such adjustment to distributions shall be consistent with the treatment of the Class B Units as “profits
interests.” Additionally, in accordance with Rev. Proc. 2001-43, 2001-2 C.B. 191, the Company shall treat each Class B Member
as the owner of a Class B Unit from the date it is granted, and shall file its IRS Form 1065, and issue appropriate Schedule K-1s
to such Class B Members, allocating to such Class B Members their distributive shares of all items of income, gain, loss, deduction
and credit associated with such Class B Units. Each Class B Member agrees to take into account such distributive share in computing
its U.S. federal income tax liability for the entire period during which it holds the Class B Unit. The Company and each Member
agree not to claim a deduction (as wages, compensation or otherwise) for the Fair Market Value of such Class B Units issued to
Class B Members at any time. The undertakings contained in this Section 3.1(e)(iv) shall be construed in accordance with
Section 4 of Rev. Proc. 2001-43. The provisions of this Section 3.1(e)(iv) shall apply regardless of whether or not a Class
B Member files an election pursuant to Section 83(b) of the Code.


 






    16


     


    

 


(f)       Class
C Units.


 


(i)       The
class of Units designated as Class C Units shall consist solely of 121.21212 Class C Units, all of which currently are issued and
held by Carbon as the sole Class C Member.


 


(ii)       Other
than the Class C Non-Cash Capital Contribution, the Class C Member shall have no right or obligation to make any capital contributions
to the Company in exchange for or on account of the Class C Units.


 


(iii)       Subject
to Section 12.6, the Class C Units shall have no voting rights on any matter, including amendments to this Agreement.


 


(g)       Old
Ironsides as Class A Member. Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary, with respect to OIE Fund II-A and/or OIE
Fund II-B in its or their capacity as Class A Member, any right, approval, consent, vote or similar action of Old Ironsides
contemplated under this Agreement may be exercised by either OIE Fund II-A or OIE Fund II-B acting unilaterally or by OIE Fund
II-A and OIE Fund II-B acting jointly.


 


Section 3.2No
Liability for Company Obligations. Without limiting the generality of Article VIII, a Member is not liable for
the debts, obligations and liabilities of the Company, including under a judgment, decree or order of a court.


 


Section 3.3Meeting
of Members.


 


(a)       Place
of Meetings. Meetings of Members may be held at any such place within or without the State of Delaware as may be designated
by the Board of Directors.


 


(b)       Meetings.
Meetings of the Members may be called from time to time by the Board of Directors or by the Manager. Only business within the purpose
or purposes described in the notice of meeting referred to in paragraph (c) below may be conducted at a meeting of Members.


 


(c)       Notice
of Meeting. Written or printed notice of all meetings of the Members stating the place, date and time of the meeting and, in
the case of a special meeting, the purpose or purposes for which the meeting is called, shall be delivered personally or by facsimile
or Electronic Transmission not less than five (5) Business Days before the date of the meeting by or at the direction of the Manager
to each Member entitled to vote at such meeting.


 


(d)       Quorum.
A quorum shall exist if Members are present holding at least a majority of the then outstanding Class A Units.


 


(e)       Required
Vote. Unless otherwise expressly required by this Agreement, including Section 2.4, any matter brought before any meeting
of the Members shall be decided by a Majority Vote.


 


(f)       Conduct
of Meetings of Members. At each meeting of the Members, the Person designated by the Manager or, in such Person’s absence,
a chairman chosen by a Majority Vote of the Members present in person or represented by proxy and entitled to vote thereat, shall
preside and act as chairman of the meeting. A Person appointed by the Manager, shall act as secretary of such meeting and keep
the minutes thereof. The Board of Directors may adopt such rules and regulations as it determines are reasonably necessary or appropriate
in connection with the organization and conduct of any meeting of the Members.


 






    17


     


    

 


(g)       Proxies.
Each Member entitled to vote at a meeting of the Members may authorize another person or persons to act for such Member by proxy,
but no such proxy shall be voted or acted upon after 11 months from its date, unless the proxy provides for a longer period. A
duly executed proxy shall be irrevocable if it states that it is irrevocable and if, and only as long as, it is coupled with an
interest sufficient in law to support an irrevocable power. A proxy may be made irrevocable regardless of whether the interest
with which it is coupled is an interest in an Interest itself or an interest in the Company generally.


 


(h)       Written
Consent. Any action required or permitted to be taken at any meeting of Members may be taken without a meeting, without prior
notice, and without a vote, if a consent or consents in writing, setting forth the action so taken, shall have been delivered to
each Member at least twenty-four hours prior to being executed and shall be signed by Members holding the minimum number of Class
A Units to take such action at a meeting of Members. Every written consent shall bear the date of signature of each Member that
signs the consent. Notice of any such action taken shall be provided to those Members who have not consented in writing promptly
following the taking of such action. Delivery shall be by hand or certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, to the
Company’s principal office and shall be addressed to the Board of Directors.


 


(i)       Telephonic
Meetings. Members may participate in and hold a meeting by means of conference telephone or similar communications equipment
by means of which all Members participating in the meeting can hear each other, and participation in such meeting shall constitute
attendance and presence in person at such meeting.


 


(j)       Minutes.
All decisions and resolutions of the Members shall be reported in the minutes of the meetings, which shall state the date, time
and place of the meeting (or the date of the written consent in the case of a written consent in lieu of a meeting), the persons
present at the meeting, the resolutions put to a vote (or the subject of a written consent) and the results of such voting (or
written consent). The minutes of all meetings of the Members shall be circulated to all Members as soon as practical after each
meeting and shall be kept at the principal office of the Company.


 


Section 3.4Duties
of Directors and Members.


 


(a)       Except
as otherwise provided in Section 3.4(b), Section 3.4(c) and Section 3.6:


 


(i)       no
Member or any of its present or future Affiliates or any of their respective stockholders, partners, members, directors, managers,
officers or employees (each a “Member Related Party”) shall be expressly or impliedly restricted or prohibited
by virtue of this Agreement or the relationships created hereby from engaging in other activities or business ventures of any kind
or character whatsoever;


 


(ii)       each
Member and any Member Related Party shall have the right to conduct, or to possess a direct or indirect ownership interest in,
activities and business ventures of every type and description;


 






    18


     


    

 


(iii)       no
Member or any Member Related Party shall be obligated by virtue of this Agreement to present any particular business opportunity
to the Company;


 


(iv)       each
Member and Member Related Party shall have the right to take or pursue any such opportunity for its own account (individually or
as a partner, member, stockholder, fiduciary or otherwise) or to present or recommend it to any third party; and


 


(v)       neither
the Company nor any Member shall have any rights or claims by virtue of this Agreement or the relationships created hereby in any
activities or business ventures of (i) in the instance of the Company, a Member or any Member Related Party, or (ii) in the instance
of a Member, another Member or such other Member’s Member Related Party (it being expressly understood and agreed that any
and all such rights and claims are hereby irrevocably waived by each Member on its behalf and on behalf of the Company).


 


(b)       The
Members (in their own names and in the name and on behalf of the Company), subject to and except as provided in Section 3.6:


 


(i)       agree
that (A) the terms of this Section 3.4, to the extent that they modify or limit a duty or other obligation, if any, that
a Member Related Party may have to the Company or any other Member under the Act or other applicable law are reasonable in form,
scope and content; (B) the terms of this Section 3.4 are expressly intended to restrict the duties, including any fiduciary
or similar duties, of a Member Related Party to the Company and the Members, as permitted by the Act and applicable law; and (C)
the terms of this Section 3.4 shall control to the fullest extent possible if it is in conflict with a duty, if any, that
a Member Related Party may have to the Company or another Member, under the Act or any other applicable law;


 


(ii)       waive
to the fullest extent permitted by the Act and other applicable law, any duty or other obligation, if any, that a Member Related
Party may have to the Company or another Member, pursuant to the Act or any other applicable law; and


 


(iii)       agree
that (A) the legal doctrines of “corporate opportunity,” “business opportunity”
and similar doctrines will not be applied to any ventures or activities of the Member Related Party (including those serving as
Director or an officer of the Company), (B) none of the Member Related Party (including those serving as Director) will have any
obligation to the Company or its other Members with respect to any opportunity to expand the Company’s business, whether
geographically, or otherwise, (C) the Company and each Member hereby renounces any interest or expectancy in any business opportunity,
transaction or other matter in which any Member Related Party (including those serving as Director or an officer of the Company)
participates or desires or seeks to participate (each, a “Business Opportunity”), (D) no Member Related
Party (including those serving as Director or an officer of the Company) shall have any obligation to communicate or offer any
Business Opportunity to the Company or any other Member, and each may pursue for itself or direct, sell, assign or transfer to
any other Person any such Business Opportunity and (E) each Member Related Party (including those serving as Director or an officer
of the Company) shall be entitled to and may have business interests and activities that are in direct competition with the Company
or a Member or that are enhanced by the activities of the Company, and neither the Company nor any Member shall have any rights
by virtue of this Agreement in any business venture of the Company or any Member.


 






    19


     


    

 


(c)       The
Members (in their own names and in the name and on behalf of the Company), acknowledge, affirm and agree that (i) no Member would
be willing to make an investment in the Company, and (ii) no Director appointed to serve on the Board or a Member Related Party
appointed as an officer of the Company or any Subsidiary of the Company would be willing to so serve, in the absence of this Section
3.4.


 


Section 3.5Other
Investments of Member Related Parties; Waiver of Conflicts of Interest and Negation of Duties and Obligations.


 


(a)       Each
Member acknowledges and affirms that the Member Related Parties:


 


(i)       (A)
have participated (directly or indirectly) and will continue to participate (directly or indirectly) in venture capital, private
equity and other direct investments in corporations, joint ventures, limited liability companies and other entities (the “Other
Investments”), including Other Investments engaged in various aspects of the United States “upstream,”
“downstream” and “midstream” oil and gas business that may, are or will be
competitive with the Company’s business or that could be suitable for the Company, (B) have interests in, participate with,
aid and maintain seats on the board of directors or similar governing bodies of, Other Investments, and (C) may develop or become
aware of business opportunities for Other Investments: and


 


(ii)       may
or will, as a result of or arising from the matters referenced in clause (i) above, the nature of the Member Related Parties’
businesses and other factors, have conflicts of interest or potential conflicts of interest with the Company and/or other Members.


 


(b)       The
Members (individually and on behalf of the Company), subject to and except as provided in Section 3.6, expressly (i) waive
any such conflicts of interest or potential conflicts of interest and agree that no Member Related Party or its respective representatives
shall have any liability to any Member or any Affiliate thereof, or the Company with respect to such conflicts of interest or potential
conflicts of interest and (ii) acknowledge and agree that the Member Related Parties and their respective representatives will
not have any duty to disclose to the Company, any other Member or the Board or any Directors any such business opportunities, whether
or not competitive with the Company’s business and whether or not the Company might be interested in such business opportunity
for itself. The Members (for themselves and on behalf of the Company) also acknowledge that the Member Related Parties and their
representatives have duties not to disclose confidential information of or related to the Other Investments. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, each Member agrees that it will disclose to the other Members if such Member or an Affiliate has an interest in another
entity that proposes to engage in a transaction with the Company, which disclosure shall be made as promptly as reasonably possible
after such Member becomes aware of the proposed transaction.


 






    20


     


    

 


(c)       The
Members (individually and on behalf of the Company) hereby:


 


(i)       agree
that (A) the terms of this Section 3.5, to the extent that they modify or limit any duty of loyalty or other similar obligation,
if any, that a Member Related Party may have to the Company or another Member under the Act or other applicable law, are reasonable
in form, scope and content; and (B) the terms of this Section 3.5 shall control to the fullest extent possible if it is
in conflict with any duty of loyalty or similar obligation, if any, that a Member Related Party or its representatives may have
to the Company or another Member, under the Act or any other applicable law; and


 


(ii)       subject
to and except as provided in Section 3.6, waive any duty of loyalty or other fiduciary duty or similar obligation, if any,
that a Member Related Party or its representatives may have to the Company, any Director or another Member, pursuant to the Act
or any other applicable law.


 


(d)       Whenever
in this Agreement a Member or any representative thereof (which shall include for purposes of this Agreement a Director appointed
by such Member or instructed to act by such Member) is permitted or required to make a decision (i) in its “sole discretion”
or “discretion” or under a grant of similar authority or latitude, the Member or the representative thereof, as the
case may be, shall be entitled to consider only such interests and factors as such Member or representative desires, including
such Member’s own interests, and shall have no duty or obligation to give any consideration to any interests of or factors
affecting the Company or any other Member, or (ii) in its “good faith” or under another expressed standard, a Member
or the representative thereof, as the case may be, shall act under such express standard and shall not be subject to any other
or different standard imposed by this Agreement or any other agreement contemplated herein or by relevant provisions of law or
in equity or otherwise; provided, however, that no Member or its appointed Director may disapprove of any proposed
asset acquisition or expenditure relating to any proposed asset acquisitions solely on the grounds that an Affiliate of such Member
(x) has made, or intends to make, a competing offering for the purchase of the assets which are the target of such proposed asset
acquisitions (the “Subject Assets”) or (y) is participating or intends to participate in any auction
or other sales process relating to the Subject Assets.


 


(e)       The
Members (individually and on behalf of the Company) acknowledge, affirm and agree that (i) the execution and delivery of this Agreement
by the Members is of material benefit to the Company and the Members, and that the Members would not be willing to (x) execute
and deliver this Agreement, and (y) make their agreed Capital Contributions to the Company, without the benefit of this Section
3.5 and the agreement of the parties, including the Members, thereto.


 






    21


     


    

 


Section 3.6Carbon
Non-Compete. Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary:


 


(a)       Prior
to Carbon or any of its Affiliates (excluding, for the avoidance of doubt, Yorktown and any of its Affiliates), or any of its or
their respective officers or directors (in their capacities as such), making any investment in, acquiring any ownership interest
in, or participating in the development of any oil and gas properties (e.g., working interests or royalty interests), operations
or prospects or any rights and interests therein or relating thereto (e.g., carried interests, profits interests or participations)
that are located in the AMI (including acquiring any interest in (i) any new oil and gas lease covering any unleased mineral
interest within the AMI, (ii) any interest in an existing oil and gas lease covering any lands within the AMI, (iii) the
right to acquire any oil and gas lease covering any lands within the AMI or (iv) any mineral interest, fee interest, royalty
interest, overriding royalty interest or other right or interest covering any lands or interests within the AMI), in each case
other than Existing Assets (any such investment, acquisition or participation, a “Restricted Interest”),
Carbon shall offer such proposed Restricted Interest to the Company by giving written notice to the Board of such Restricted Interest
and furnishing to the Board a reasonably detailed description of such Restricted Interest containing all material terms thereof,
including, to the extent applicable, a schedule of the oil and gas leases, lands and/or interests proposed to be acquired, copies
of any leases, agreements or other instruments proposed to be acquired or entered into in connection therewith, the price of the
interests to be acquired and/or any other relevant pricing information relating thereto, all diligence materials prepared by or
on behalf of Carbon relating thereto and any other documents necessary for the Board’s evaluation of the proposed Restricted
Interest. If an oil and gas lease or interest covers lands or interests both inside and outside of the AMI, only the portion inside
the AMI will be deemed a Restricted Interest. The Board shall have fifteen (15) days after receipt of such notice, together with
the supporting information and documentation required by the first sentence of this Section 3.6(a), within which to elect,
by written notice delivered by the Company to Carbon within such fifteen (15) day period, to cause the Company to undertake any
investment in or acquisition of any ownership interest in such Restricted Interest. If the Board elects to cause the Company to
undertake any investment in or acquisition of any ownership interest in a Restricted Interest, the Company and Carbon shall each
use their commercially reasonable efforts, including cooperating with one another vis-à-vis the applicable counterparties
involved in the Restricted Interest, to complete the investment in or acquisition of any ownership interest in such Restricted
Interest for the Company’s account on terms acceptable to the Company.


 


(b)       If
(i) the Board elects not to cause the Company to undertake an investment in or acquisition of any ownership interest in a Restricted
Interest or the Board fails to reply to Carbon within the applicable fifteen (15) day period for its response with respect to a
Restricted Interest offered by Carbon to the Company pursuant to Section 3.6(a) and (ii) the Board approves Carbon and its
Affiliates, or its or their respective officers or directors (in their capacities as such), as applicable, to undertake any investment
in or acquisition of any ownership interest in such Restricted Interest, such investment in or acquisition of any ownership
interest in such Restricted Interest (subject to any terms or conditions regarding such investment or acquisition imposed
by the Board) will be deemed a “Permitted Investment”.


 


(c)       Carbon
agrees that neither it nor any of its Affiliates, nor any of its or their respective officers or directors (in their capacities
as such), shall make any investment in, acquire any ownership interest in, or participate in the development of any Restricted
Investment other than (i) Carbon’s investment in the Company, (ii) the Existing Assets and (iii) any Permitted Investments.


 






    22


     


    

 


(d)       Carbon
hereby represents and warrants to the Company and each other Member that, except for the Existing Assets, neither it nor any of
its Affiliates hold or have an investment or ownership interest in any oil and gas properties, operations or prospects or
any rights and interests therein or relating thereto in the AMI. 


 


Section 3.7No
Resignation or Withdrawal by Members. Except in connection with a Transfer of all of its Interest as permitted under Article VI,
no Member shall be entitled to resign or withdraw from the Company.


 


Section 3.8Certain
Representations and Warranties of the Members. Each Member hereby represents and warrants to the Company and each other Member
as of the Effective Date and as of each date after the Effective Date such Member makes an additional Capital Contribution in exchange
for additional Units or other Interests that:


 


(a)       such
Member has full power and authority to enter into this Agreement and to perform its obligations hereunder;


 


(b)       the
execution, delivery and performance of this Agreement do not conflict with any other agreement or arrangement to which such Member
is a party or by which it is or its assets are bound;


 


(c)       all
property contributed to the Company by such Member, and any property thereafter to be contributed to the Company by such Member,
has been or will be duly and lawfully acquired and will be contributed to the Company without any liens or encumbrances (other
than statutory liens for taxes not yet due or owing);


 


(d)       such
Member is and will be acquiring its interest in the Company for investment purposes only for his or its own account and not with
a view to the distribution, reoffer, resale, or other disposition not in compliance with the Securities Act and applicable state
securities laws;


 


(e)       such
Member alone or together with his or its representatives, possesses such expertise, knowledge, and sophistication in financial
and business matters generally, and in the type of transactions in which the Company proposes to engage in particular, that such
Member is capable of evaluating the merits and economic risks of acquiring and holding an Interest, and that such Member is able
to bear all such economic risks now and in the future;


 


(f)       such
Member has had access to all of the information with respect to his or its Interest that such Member deems necessary to make a
complete evaluation thereof;


 


(g)       such
Member’s decision to acquire an Interest for investment has been based solely upon the evaluation made by such Member;


 






    23


     


    

 


(h)       such
Member is aware that he, she or it may have to bear the economic risk of such Member’s investment in the Company for an indefinite
period of time because Interests have not been registered under the Securities Act or under the securities laws of any state, and,
therefore, such Interests cannot be sold unless they are subsequently registered under the Securities Act and any applicable state
securities laws or an exemption from registration is available;


 


(i)       such
Member is aware that only the Company can take action to register Interests in the Company and that the Company is under no such
obligation and does not propose or intend to attempt to do so other than pursuant to the terms of this Agreement;


 


(j)       such
Member is aware that this Agreement provides restrictions on the ability of a Member to Transfer its Interests, and such Member
will not seek to effect any Transfer of his, her or its Interests other than in accordance with such restrictions;


 


(k)       such
Member is an “accredited investor” within the meaning ascribed to such term under Regulation D of the Securities Act;
and


 


(l)       such
Member is not a registered investment company under the Investment Company Act and is not required to register as an investment
company under the Investment Company Act.


 


ARTICLE
IV

CAPITAL


 


Section 4.1Capital
Contributions.


 


(a)       As
of the Effective Date, pursuant to and subject to the terms of the Participation Agreement, Nytis LLC assigned to OpCo 75% of Nytis
LLC’s undivided interest in the Tennessee Mining Tract properties. For purposes of this Agreement, a portion of such assignment
shall be deemed a Capital Contribution to the Company by Carbon of non-cash property (such Capital Contribution, the “Class
C Non-Cash Capital Contribution”) and the agreed Book Basis of such Class C Non-Cash Capital Contribution is $121,212.
In exchange for the Class C Non-Cash Capital Contribution, Carbon shall receive the Class C Units reflected on Exhibit A.


 


(b)       At
or before the closing of the CNX Acquisition, Carbon, Yorktown, OIE Fund II-A and OIE Fund II-B shall have each made Capital Contributions
of cash to the Company in the amounts set forth opposite their respective names on Exhibit A (the “Initial
Contributions”), and in exchange therefor shall receive the number of Class A Units set forth opposite their respective
names on Exhibit A; all amounts contributed by Carbon, Yorktown, OIE Fund II-A and OIE Fund II-B pursuant to this Section
4.1(b) at or before the closing of the CNX Acquisition as the Initial Contributions will be deemed contributed to the Company (regardless
of the date actually contributed), including for purposes of calculating the IRR and Priority Amounts of each holder of Class A
Units, as of the date the first of such Initial Contributions are made to the Company.


 






    24


     


    

 


(c)       Capital
Contributions in excess of each Class A Member’s Initial Class A Funding Percentage of the Initial Contribution shall be
made only upon delivery to the Class A Members of a written notice (each a “Capital Call Notice”) requesting
such Class A Members to make additional Capital Contributions (each a “Capital Call”); provided no Capital
Call Notice shall be issued (and no Capital Contributions shall be made) other than (i) to fund an approved Budget (and Permitted
Variances thereto), (ii) to fund a Capital Call for a matter approved by the Board of Directors or (iii) to pay Company Expenses.
Each Capital Call Notice shall state the purpose of the capital requested.


 


(d)       Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary contained herein, no Capital Call Notice shall require (or permit) any Class A Member to contribute Capital
Contributions, in the aggregate together with all prior Capital Contributions of such Class A Member, in excess of the amount set
forth opposite the name of such Class A Member under the column headed “Capital Commitment” on Exhibit A
(the “Capital Commitment”).


 


(e)       Subject
to Section 4.1(d), each Class A Member’s share of any Capital Call shall be equal to (i) its Initial Class A Funding
Percentage of the aggregate amount called pursuant to a Capital Call Notice until the Commitment Release Point and (ii) after the
Commitment Release Point, each Class A Member’s then current Class A Sharing Percentage of the aggregate amount called pursuant
to a Capital Call Notice.


 


(f)       Capital
Calls shall be due and payable within fifteen (15) Business Days of the date of receipt by a Class A Member of the Capital Call
Notice pertaining to such Capital Call. Upon the receipt of any Capital Contribution and in consideration of such additional Capital
Contribution made by any Member pursuant to this Section 4.1, there shall be issued to such Class A Member a number of Class
A Units equal to the quotient of (x) the amount of such Capital Contribution, divided by (y) the Class A Unit Price.


 


(g)       In
the event that the Company has not received Capital Contributions from the Class A Members which in the aggregate are equal to
the Capital Commitments of the Class A Members on or before the earlier of the fifth anniversary of the Effective Date and a Public
Offering (the “Commitment Reduction Date”), each Class A Member’s Capital Commitment may be permanently
reduced to an amount not less than such Class A Member’s Initial Percentage Interest of the Capital Calls for which a Capital
Call Notice shall have been delivered pursuant to Section 4.1(c) prior to the Commitment Reduction Date.


 


(h)       Each
Class A Member shall be required to contribute to the Company its Initial Class A Funding Percentage of each Capital Call amount
until the earlier of (i) the Commitment Reduction Date or (ii) an aggregate amount equal to $100,000,000 in cash has been
funded to the Company as Capital Contributions (including the Initial Contributions), subject to Section 4.6 (the earlier
of (i) and (ii), the “Commitment Release Point”).


 






    25


     


    

 


(i)       From
and after the Commitment Release Point, each Class A Member shall be entitled (but not required) to contribute its Class A Sharing
Percentage of each Capital Call amount (as provided in Section 4.1(c)). If any Class A Member (a “Shortfall
Member”) fails to timely contribute its full Class A Sharing Percentage of a Capital Call amount after the Commitment
Release Point and one or more other Class A Members timely contributes its full Class A Sharing Percentage of such Capital Call
amount (the “Non-Shortfall Member”), then the Company or the Non-Shortfall Member shall deliver a written
notice (a “Shortfall Notice”) to the Shortfall Member setting forth the amount such Shortfall Member
failed to timely fund. If the Shortfall Member’s full Class A Sharing Percentage of such Capital Call Amount is not received
by the Company from such Shortfall Member within ten (10) Business Days after delivery of the Shortfall Notice (the “Shortfall
Cure Period”), then the Non-Shortfall Member may, in its discretion, (x) fund all or a portion of the Shortfall Member’s
Unfunded Amount as a Capital Contribution or (y) by delivery of written notice to the Company and the Shortfall Member within twenty
(20) Business Days after the date the Shortfall Notice is delivered to the Shortfall Member, require the Company to return to the
Non-Shortfall Member up to 100% of the amount contributed by the Non-Shortfall Member to the Company in connection with such Capital
Call. A Shortfall Member’s failure to timely fund its Class A Sharing Percentage of any Capital Call after the Commitment
Release Point will result in proportionate dilution of the Class A Sharing Percentage of such Shortfall Member and adjustment of
the Class A Sharing Percentage of each Class A Member to equal an amount, expressed as a percentage, equal to the number of Class
A Units held by such Class A Member divided by the total number of Class A Units held by all Class A Members after giving effect
to such Capital Contribution and the issuance of additional Class A Units in respect of such Capital Contribution. Notwithstanding
anything in this Agreement to the contrary, the proportionate dilution provided for in this Section 4.1(i) and the
option of the Non-Shortfall Member to (x) fund all or a portion of the Shortfall Member’s Unfunded Amount as a Capital Contribution
or (y) receive the return of its funded portion of the applicable Capital Call shall be the sole remedies for the failure of any
Shortfall Member to timely contribute its full Class A Sharing Percentage of any Capital Call after the Commitment Release Point,
and neither the Company nor any Class A Member shall have any other rights or remedies against a Shortfall Member with respect
thereto.


 


(j)       No
Capital Contribution to the Company may be required or permitted from any Person other than in accordance with this Section
4.1 or Section 4.7, and no Person shall be issued or granted any Class A Units or any other Interest by the Company
other than as provided in this Section 4.1 or Section 4.7, in each case without prior approval of the Board pursuant
to Section 2.4(a)(xi).


 


(k)       Exhibit A
shall be amended upon the occurrence of any additional Capital Contributions to reflect such additional Capital Contributions,
the issuance of Class A Units in exchange therefor and the Class A Sharing Percentage of each Class A Member after giving effect
to such additional Capital Contributions.


 


(l)       If
a Capital Call relates to amounts above and below the Commitment Release Point (as determined under clause (ii) of Section 4.1(h)),
such Capital Call shall be treated as two separate Capital Calls, one for the remaining amount required to be funded to achieve
the Commitment Release Point and one for the balance of the amount of such Capital Call.


 






    26


     


    

 


Section 4.2Key
Man Event. Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary, in the event Patrick R. McDonald no longer serves as Chief Executive
Officer of the Company and/or Mark Pierce no longer serves as President of the Company for any reason (in each case, whether due
to resignation, termination, death, disability or otherwise) (the “Key Man Event”), then:


 


(a)       the
Company shall, as soon as reasonably practicable but in any event within three (3) Business Days following the Key Man Event, deliver
a written notice to the Members informing the Members of the Key Man Event;


 


(b)       if
the Key Man Event involves the loss of the Chief Executive Officer, from and after the Key Man Event, no Class A Member shall be
required to make any additional Capital Contributions to the Company and no Class A Member shall be a Defaulting Member as a result
of failing to fund any additional Capital Contribution due on or after the Key Man Event, provided that any Defaulting Member as
of the Key Man Event shall continue to be a Defaulting Member from and after the Key Man Event; and


 


(c)       if
the Key Man Event involves the loss of the Chief Executive Officer and the President, from and after the Key Man Event, in addition
to the consequences provided in clause (b) above, Old Ironsides may replace Carbon (or cause Carbon to be replaced) as the Manager
and/or cause the Company to effect a Liquidity Event pursuant to Section 6.5.


 


Section 4.3Capital
Accounts.


 


(a)       A
separate Capital Account for each Member shall be established and maintained on the books of the Company in accordance with Treasury
Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv) and, to the extent not in conflict with such Treasury Regulations, the provisions of this
Agreement. Each Member shall have a single Capital Account that reflects all of its Interests, regardless of class or the time
or manner in which acquired. Upon a Transfer of all or part of any Units, the Capital Account, Capital Contributions, and Priority
Amount, if any, of the transferor attributable to the Transferred Units shall carryover to the transferee.


 


(b)       There
will be credited to the Capital Account of each Member (i) the amount of cash and the initial Book Basis of any property contributed
by such Member to the Company, (ii) such Member’s share of Net Income (as determined in accordance with Section 5.1)
and any items of income or gain allocated to such Member pursuant to Section 5.2, and (iii) the amount of any liabilities
of the Company assumed by such Member or that are secured by any property distributed to such Member.


 


(c)       There
will be debited to the Capital Account of each Member (i) the amount of any cash and the Book Basis of any property distributed
by the Company to such Member, (ii) such Member’s share of Net Loss (as determined in accordance with Section 5.1,
and any items of loss or deduction allocated to such Member pursuant to Section 5.2, and (iii) the amount of any liabilities
of such Member assumed by the Company or that are secured by any property contributed by such Member to the Company.


 


(d)       Simulated
Basis shall be allocated among the Members in accordance with each Member’s Capital Interest Percentage as of the time such
Oil and Gas Property is contributed to or acquired by the Company (and any additions to such Simulated Basis resulting from expenditures
required to be capitalized in such Simulated Basis shall be allocated among the Members in a manner designed to cause the Members’
proportionate shares of such Simulated Basis to be in accordance with their Capital Interest Percentages as determined at the time
of any such additions), and shall be reallocated among the Members in accordance with the Members’ Capital Interest Percentages
as determined immediately following the occurrence of an event giving rise to an adjustment to the Book Basis of the Company’s
Oil and Gas Properties pursuant to clause (ii) of the definition of Book Basis.


 






    27


     


    

 


Section 4.4Preemptive
Rights. At any time that the Company proposes to sell Interests to any Person other than Class A Units issued in accordance
with Section 4.1 or Section 4.7, each Member other than a Defaulting Member (each, a “Preemptive
Rights Member”) shall have the preemptive right to purchase its Class A Sharing Percentage share of the Interests.
Any participation pursuant to this Section 4.4 shall be on the same terms and conditions as applied to all offerees in the
respective offering. In the event of a proposed transaction or transactions giving rise to preemptive rights of Preemptive Rights
Members, the Company shall provide notice (“Preemptive Right Notice”) to the Preemptive Rights Members,
which Preemptive Rights Notice shall contain the price at which the Interests will be offered and the other material terms of the
offering and such Interests, no later than ten (10) Business Days prior to the expected consummation of such transaction or transactions.
Each Preemptive Rights Member shall provide notice of its election to exercise its preemptive rights within five (5) Business Days
after delivery of the Preemptive Right Notice from the Company (each Preemptive Rights Member electing to exercise its preemptive
right in such instances is referred to as an “Electing Party”). The failure of a Preemptive Rights Member
to respond to the Preemptive Right Notice and affirmatively exercise its preemptive right in accordance with the terms of this
Agreement shall be deemed as an election of the Preemptive Rights Member not to exercise its preemptive right in connection with
the proposed transaction. If a Preemptive Rights Member shall elect not to exercise its respective preemptive right or fails to
timely exercise, the Electing Parties who timely exercise shall have the right to purchase the Interests (a “Subsequent
Purchase”) as to which no such right was exercised (based on the ratio that the Class A Sharing Percentage of each
Electing Party desiring to purchase the additional Interests bears to the sum of the Class A Sharing Percentages of all Electing
Parties desiring to purchase the additional Interests) insofar as more than one such Electing Party desires to so purchase additional
Interests. In the event of a situation described in the preceding sentence in which a Preemptive Rights Member does not exercise
its preemptive right, the Company shall provide notice (the “Subsequent Notice”) of such fact within
three (3) Business Days following expiration of the deadline for submission of notices concerning such elections from the parties
possessing preemptive rights. Each Electing Party that desires to purchase the additional Interests shall respond to the Subsequent
Notice by sending a response notice with respect thereto within three (3) Business Days after delivery of the Subsequent Notice.
The failure of an Electing Party to respond to a Subsequent Notice and affirmatively exercise its preemptive right in accordance
with the terms of this Agreement shall be deemed an election not to exercise its preemptive right in connection with the Subsequent
Purchase. If the number of Interests proposed to be offered as described in the Preemptive Rights Notice exceeds the sum of the
Interests for which the Preemptive Rights Members timely elected to exercise their preemptive rights (including with respect to
any Subsequent Notice), the Company may offer and issue such excess Interests or any portion thereof (at a price and on other terms
and conditions not more favorable to any proposed offeree or purchaser of such Interests than those set forth in the Preemptive
Rights Notice) to any purchaser of such Interests within one-hundred-twenty (120) days after the date the Preemptive Rights Notice
(or, if applicable, the Subsequent Notice) was delivered. If such issuance is not made within such one-hundred twenty (120) day
period, the Company shall not thereafter issue or sell any of such Interests without first re-offering such securities in the manner
provided above; provided, that if such issuance or sale is subject to regulatory approval, such one-hundred-twenty (120) day period
shall be extended until the expiration of ten (10) Business Days after all such approvals have been received, but in no event later
than one-hundred-eighty (180) days from the date the Preemptive Rights Notice (or, if applicable, the Subsequent Notice) was delivered.


 






    28


     


    

 


Section 4.5Unit
Certificates.


 


(a)       The
Units initially shall be uncertificated, provided that the Board may, in its sole discretion, elect to cause the Company to evidence
ownership of Units by issuing a certificate (each, a “Unit Certificate”) executed by appropriate officers
of the Company certifying the number of Units owned by each Member.


 


(b)       Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary contained in this Agreement, in order to effect a valid Transfer of Units for which a Unit Certificate
has been issued, prior to the effectiveness of such Transfer, the transferring Member, as applicable, shall surrender the subject
Unit Certificate to the Company together with a transfer power duly executed by the transferring Member, as applicable, with the
transferring Member’s signature thereon guaranteed by a medallion stamp upon the Board’s request. Upon such compliance,
surrender and delivery, the Company shall execute and deliver a new Unit Certificate in the name of the assignee(s) and in the
denominations specified in the Transfer documentation, and shall issue to the transferring Member, as applicable, a new Unit Certificate
evidencing the portion of the surrendered Unit Certificate, if any, not so Transferred, and the surrendered Unit Certificate shall
promptly be cancelled.


 


(c)       The
Company shall issue a new Unit Certificate in place of any Unit Certificate theretofore issued by it that is alleged to have been
lost, stolen or destroyed, provided that as a condition precedent thereto the Board may in its discretion require the Member that
is the record owner of any allegedly lost, stolen or destroyed Unit Certificate to deliver to the Company a duly executed affidavit
of loss and an agreement and/or a bond sufficient to indemnify the Company against any adverse claim in connection with the issue
of a new Unit Certificate.


 


(d)       Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary contained in this Agreement, the Board and the Company shall be entitled to rely exclusively on record
ownership of Units for which a Unit Certificate has been issued as evidenced by outstanding Unit Certificates and the Company’s
records thereof. The Company shall treat the record owner of a Unit Certificate as the holder of the Units evidenced thereby unless
and until such Units have been Transferred in accordance with this Agreement.


 






    29


     


    

 


Section 4.6Defaulting
Members. If any Class A Member fails to timely contribute its full Initial Class A Funding Percentage of a Capital Call that
such Class A Member is required to contribute pursuant to Section 4.1(e)(i) and at least one other Class A Member timely
contributes its full Class A Sharing Percentage of such Capital Call amount (the “Non-Defaulting Member”),
then the Company or a Non-Defaulting Member shall deliver a written notice of default (a “Default Notice”)
to the Defaulting Member setting forth the amount such Defaulting Member failed to timely fund. If the Defaulting Member’s
full Initial Class A Funding Percentage of such Capital Call amount is not received by the Company from such Class A Member within
ten (10) Business Days after delivery of the Default Notice (the “Default Cure Period”), then:


 


(i)       such
Class A Member shall be deemed a “Defaulting Member” and


 


if the Defaulting Member
is Carbon, then Supermajority of the Voting Power shall not require the affirmative vote of a Carbon Designee;


 


if the Defaulting Member
is Yorktown, then Supermajority of the Voting Power shall not require the affirmative vote of a Yorktown Designee; and


 


if the Defaulting Member
is Old Ironsides, then a Majority of the Voting Power shall not require the affirmative vote of an Old Ironsides Designee;


 


(ii)       the
Defaulting Member shall not be entitled to participate in any future Capital Calls pursuant to Section 4.1 or as a Preemptive
Rights Member pursuant to Section 4.4;


 


(iii)       each
Non-Defaulting Member shall have the option, exercisable in its sole and absolute discretion to either (A) fund all or a portion
of the Defaulting Member’s Unfunded Amount and to treat such funding of the Unfunded Amount as either an additional Capital
Contribution, subject to Section 4.8 (an “Optional Contribution”), or (B) by delivery of written
notice to the Company and the Defaulting Member within twenty (20) Business Days after the date the Default Notice is delivered
to the Defaulting Member, require the Company to return to the Non-Defaulting Member up to 100% of the amount contributed by the
Non-Defaulting Member to the Company in connection with such Capital Call;


 


(iv)       the
Non-Defaulting Member(s) may fund the Defaulting Member’s Initial Class A Funding Percentage of all subsequent Capital Call
amounts as Optional Contributions until the Defaulting Member’s Capital Commitment has been fully funded; and “Class
A Sharing Percentage” for purposes of Section 4.1(i) and Section 4.4 shall be calculated without giving effect
to Units held by the Defaulting Member; and


 


(v)       if
more than one Non-Defaulting Member elects to fund the Unfunded Amount or the Defaulting Member’s Class A Sharing Percentage
of all subsequent Capital Call amounts, then each Non-Defaulting Member so electing shall be entitled to fund its portion of such
Unfunded Amount or the Defaulting Member’s Class A Sharing Percentage of all subsequent Capital Call amounts based on the
relative Class A Sharing Percentage of each such Non-Defaulting Member, unless otherwise agreed to among such Non-Defaulting Members.


 






    30


     


    

 


Section 4.7Optional
Contribution. If a contribution with respect to an Unfunded Amount is treated as an Optional Contribution pursuant to Section
4.6, upon the receipt of any such Optional Contribution and in consideration of such additional Optional Contribution made
by any Member pursuant to Section 4.1, there shall be issued to such Member a number of Class A Units equal to the quotient
of (x) the amount of such Optional Contribution, divided by (y) the Class A Unit Price, and the Class A Sharing Percentage of each
Class A Member will be adjusted to equal an amount, expressed as a percentage, equal to the number of Class A Units held by such
Class A Member divided by the total number of Units held by all Class A Members after giving effect to such Optional Contribution
and the issuance of additional Class A Units in respect of such Optional Contribution.


 


Section 4.8No
Return of Capital Contributions. Except as expressly provided in this Agreement, a Member shall not be entitled to the return
of any part of its Capital Contributions or to be paid any interest, salary or draw in respect of its Capital Contributions. A
Capital Contribution that has not been repaid is not a liability of the Company or any Member.


 


ARTICLE
V

ALLOCATIONS; DISTRIBUTIONS


 


Section 5.1Allocations
of Net Income or Net Loss. After giving effect to the allocation in Section 5.2 for purposes of maintaining the
Capital Accounts the Company’s items of Net Income and Net Loss shall be allocated among the Members in a manner such that
the Capital Account of each Member, immediately after making such allocations is, as nearly as possible, equal (proportionately)
to the distributions that would be made to such Member pursuant to Section 5.4 if the Company and each of its Subsidiaries
were dissolved, their respective affairs wound up and their respective assets sold for cash equal to their Book Basis, all of the
liabilities of the Company and its Subsidiaries were satisfied (limited with respect to each nonrecourse liability to the Book
Basis of the asset securing such liability), and the net assets of the Company were distributed in accordance with Section 5.4
less (ii) the Member’s share of Company Minimum Gain, share of Member Nonrecourse Debt Minimum Gain, and the amount, if any,
which such Member is obligated to contribute to the capital of the Company.


 


Section 5.2Special
Allocations. Notwithstanding Section 5.1, for each taxable year or other relevant period, the following special
allocations will be made in the following order and priority:


 


(a)       Minimum
Gain Chargeback. If there is a net decrease in Company Minimum Gain for the taxable year or other relevant period, then, to
the extent required by the Treasury Regulations, items of income (determined in accordance with the provisions of Treasury Regulations
Section 1.704-2(f)(6)) shall be specially allocated to the Members in an amount equal to each Member’s share of the net decrease
in Company Minimum Gain (determined in accordance with the provisions of Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-2(g)). This Section 5.2(a)
shall be interpreted consistently with, and subject to the exceptions contained in, Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-2(f).


 


(b)       Member
Minimum Gain Chargeback. If there is a net decrease in Member Nonrecourse Debt Minimum Gain for the taxable year or other relevant
period, then, to the extent required by Treasury Regulations, items of income (determined in accordance with the provisions of
the Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-2(i)(4)) shall be specially allocated to the Members in an amount equal to each Member’s
share of the net decrease in Member Nonrecourse Debt Minimum Gain (determined in accordance with the provisions of Treasury Regulations
Section 1.704-2(i)(5)). This Section 5.2(b) shall be interpreted consistently with, and subject to the exceptions contained
in, Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-2(i)(4).


 






    31


     


    

 


(c)       Qualified
Income Offset. If any Member unexpectedly receives any adjustment, allocation or distribution described in Treasury Regulations
Sections 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), (5) or (6), which causes or increases such Member’s Adjusted Capital Account Deficit, such
Member will be allocated items of income (including gross income), gain and Simulated Gain in an amount and manner sufficient to
eliminate, to the extent required by the Treasury Regulations, the Member’s Adjusted Capital Account Deficit as quickly as
possible; provided that an allocation pursuant to this Section 5.2(c) shall be made only to the extent that the Member
has an Adjusted Capital Account Deficit after all other allocations provided for in Section 5.1 and this Section 5.2
have been tentatively made as if this Section 5.2(c) was not in this Agreement.


 


(d)       Deficit
Capital Accounts Generally. If any Member has an Adjusted Capital Account Deficit at the end of any Fiscal Year, such member
will be allocated items of income (including gross income), gain and Simulated Gain in an amount and manner sufficient to eliminate
the Member’s Adjusted Capital Account Deficit as quickly as possible; provided that an allocation pursuant to this
Section 5.2(d) shall be made only to the extent that the Member has an Adjusted Capital Account Deficit after all other
allocations provided for in Section 5.1 and this Section 5.2 have been tentatively made as if Section 5.2(c)
and this Section 5.2(d) were not in this Agreement.


 


(e)       Nonrecourse
Deductions. Nonrecourse Deductions shall be allocated among the Members pro rata in accordance with their A/C Sharing
Percentage.


 


(f)       Member
Nonrecourse Deductions. Member Nonrecourse Deductions shall be specially allocated to the Members who bear the economic risk
of loss for the liability to which the deductions are attributable, determined in accordance with the principles of Treasury Regulations
Section 1.704-2(i).


 


(g)       Section
754 Adjustment. To the extent an adjustment to the adjusted tax basis of any Company asset pursuant to Code Sections 734(b)
or 743(b) is required to be taken into account in determining Capital Accounts under Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(m),
the amount of the adjustment shall be included as an item of gain (if positive) or loss (if negative) and shall be specially allocated
to the Members consistent with the manner in which their Capital Accounts are required to be adjusted by such Treasury Regulation.


 


(h)       The
Company’s “excess nonrecourse liabilities” (as defined in Treasury Regulations Section 1.752-3(a)(3)) for a particular
Fiscal Year shall be allocated among the Members pro rata in accordance with their A/C Sharing Percentage


 


(i)       Simulated
Depletion Deductions and Simulated Loss with respect to each Oil and Gas Property shall be allocated in proportion to the manner
in which the Simulated Basis of such property is allocated between the Members pursuant to Section 4.3(d), provided,
however, if the percentage depletion method is used, any excess percentage depletion shall be allocated in accordance with
Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(4)(iii). Simulated Gain shall be included in Net Income or Net Loss and allocated pursuant
to Section 5.1.


 






    32


     


    

 


(j)       For
purposes of Treasury Regulations Sections 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(k)(2) and 1.704-1(b)(4)(v), the amount realized on the disposition
of any Oil and Gas Property shall be allocated (i) first to the Members in an amount equal to the remaining Simulated Basis of
such property in the same proportions as the Simulated Basis of such property was allocated to the Members pursuant to Section 4.3(d),
and (ii) any remaining amount realized shall be allocated to the Members in the same ratio as the Simulated Gain.


 


Section 5.3Allocations
of Taxable Income or Loss.


 


(a)       Except
as provided in Section 5.3(b), (c), or (d) or as otherwise required by the Code or Treasury Regulations,
solely for U.S. federal income tax purposes, items of Company taxable income, gain, loss and deduction for each Fiscal Year shall
be allocated among the Members in the same manner as each correlative item of income, gain, loss and deduction, as determined for
Capital Account purposes, is allocated pursuant to Section 5.1 and Section 5.2.


 


(b)       If
property contributed to the Company by a Member has an adjusted U.S. federal income tax basis that differs from its initial Book
Basis on the date of contribution or if the Book Basis of property is adjusted upon the occurrence of a Revaluation Event, income,
gain, loss and deductions with respect to such property will, solely for tax purposes, be allocated among the Members so as to
take account of such difference. Such allocations will be made among the Members in the manner provided in Section 704(c) of the
Code, pursuant to the remedial allocation method described in Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-3(d), or such other reasonable
method determined by the Board of Directors.


 


(c)       Depreciation,
depletion, intangible drilling cost, and amortization recapture amounts under Sections 1245, 1250 or 1254 of the Code and the Treasury
Regulations thereunder, if any, resulting from any sale or disposition of tangible or intangible depreciable, depletable or amortizable
property shall be allocated to the Members in the same proportions that the depreciation, depletion, intangible drilling cost or
amortization being recaptured was allocated.


 






    33


     


    

 


(d)       Pursuant
to Section 613A(c)(7)(D) of the Code and the Treasury Regulations promulgated thereunder, cost and percentage depletion deductions
with respect to any Oil and Gas Property shall be computed separately by the Members rather than the Company. For purposes of such
computations, the U.S. federal income tax basis of each Oil and Gas Property shall be allocated to each Member in accordance with
such Member’s Capital Interest Percentage as of the time such Oil and Gas Property is contributed to or acquired by the Company
(and any additions to such U.S. federal income tax basis resulting from expenditures required to be capitalized in such basis shall
be allocated among the Members in a manner designed to cause the Members’ proportionate shares of such adjusted U.S. federal
income tax basis to be in accordance with their respective Capital Interest Percentages as determined at the time of any such additions),
and shall be reallocated among the Members in accordance with the Members’ respective Capital Interest Percentages as determined
immediately following the occurrence of an event giving rise to an adjustment to the Book Basis of the Company’s Oil and
Gas Properties pursuant to clause (ii) of the definition of Book Basis. The Company shall include in the information provided to
each Member pursuant to this Agreement such Member’s allocable share of the U.S. federal income tax basis of each Oil and
Gas Property, any adjustment resulting from expenditures required to be capitalized in such basis, and any reallocation of such
basis as provided in the previous sentence. The allocations described in this Section 5.3 are intended to be applied in
accordance with the Members’ “interests in partnership capital” under Section 613A(c)(7)(D) of the Code; provided
that the Members may, in good faith, authorize special allocations of U.S. federal income tax basis, income, gain, deduction or
loss, as computed for U.S. federal income tax purposes, in order to eliminate differences between Simulated Basis and adjusted
U.S. federal income tax basis with respect to Oil and Gas Properties, in such manner as determined consistent with the principles
outlined in Section 5.3(b). The provisions of this Section 5.3 and the other provisions of this Agreement relating
to allocations under Section 613A(c)(7)(D) of the Code are intended to comply with Treasury Regulations Section 1.704–1(b)(4)(v)
and shall be interpreted and applied in a manner consistent with such Treasury Regulations. Each Member, with the assistance of
the Company, shall separately keep records of its share of the adjusted tax basis in each Oil and Gas Property, adjust such share
of the adjusted tax basis for any cost or percentage depletion allowable with respect to such property and use such adjusted tax
basis in the computation of its cost depletion or in the computation of its gain or loss on the disposition of such property by
the Company. Upon the request of the Company, each Member shall advise the Company of its adjusted tax basis in each Oil and Gas
Property and any depletion computed with respect thereto, both as computed in accordance with the provisions of this subsection.
The Company may rely on such information and, if it is not provided by the Member, may make such reasonable assumptions as it shall
determine with respect thereto. The Company shall provide each Member with information reasonably requested by such Member to comply
with this Section 5.3 and other tax reporting obligations.


 


Section 5.4Distributions.
Distributions from the Company will be made from Available Cash or pursuant to Section 5.4(d), as provided in this
Section 5.4:


 


(a)       Distributions
of Available Cash and pursuant to Section 5.4(d) shall be made upon the occurrence of any of a Liquidity Event or as
otherwise determined by the Board from time to time, and all such distributions shall be allocated and distributed as follows:


 


(i)       first,
until the Priority Amount of each Class A Unit has been reduced to zero, (A) an amount equal to the A/C Sharing Percentage of the
holder of Class C Units shall be allocated and distributed to the holder of Class C Units and (B) the remaining amount shall be
allocated to the holders of Class A Units and distributed to each such holder of Class A Units in proportion to the respective
aggregate Priority Amount of the Class A Units held by such holders of Class A Units;


 


(ii)       thereafter
(subject to the following paragraph), (A) eighty percent (80%) shall be allocated among the holders of Class A Units and the holder
of Class C Units in proportion to their respective A/C Sharing Percentages at such time and (x) such amount allocated to the holders
of Class A Units shall be distributed to the holders of Class A Units in proportion to their respective Class A Sharing Percentage
at such time and (y) such amount allocated to the holder of Class C Units shall be distributed to such holder of Class C Units
and (B) twenty percent (20%) shall be allocated and distributed to the holder of Class B Units.


 






    34


     


    

 


If, after any distributions
are made pursuant to this Section 5.4, additional Capital Contributions are made on account of or in exchange for Class
A Units, then (x) subsequent distributions under this Section 5.4 shall be made giving effect to such additional Capital
Contributions and the effect of such additional Capital Contributions on the distributions to be made pursuant to Section 5.4
to each holder of Class A Units and the amount required to be distributed to each holder of Class A Units pursuant to each of Section
5.4(a)(i) and (ii), and (y) any amount that otherwise would be distributable to the holders of Class B Units on account
of their Class B Units shall instead be paid to the holders of Class A Units on account of their Class A Units until the holders
of Class A Units shall have received on account of their Class A Units the amount that they would have received on account of their
Class A Units pursuant to this Agreement based on the total amount that has been distributed by the Company.


 


(b)       All
distributions, including tax distributions treated as advances of such distributions pursuant to Section 5.4, shall
be credited towards or applied against the return calculations in clause (a) above. For the avoidance of doubt, no distributions
will be made under this Agreement other than distributions made pursuant to this Section 5.4 and Section 5.5.
In the event that a reassignment to Nytis LLC occurs pursuant to Section 2.4 of the Participation Agreement, such reassignment
amounts shall not be treated as a distribution under this Agreement.


 


(c)       Prior
to the dissolution of the Company in accordance with Article VII, distributions pursuant to Section 5.4
may only be made of cash and Marketable Securities without the approval of a Supermajority of the Voting Power. In connection with
a dissolution of the Company in accordance with Article VII, the Company may distribute property other than cash and
Marketable Securities with the approval of a Majority of the Voting Power.


 


(d)       Cash
and Non-Cash Distributions.


 


(i)       Subject
to Section 5.4(d)(ii), if any distribution consists of both cash and non–cash property, then unless otherwise
determined by a Supermajority of Voting Power the cash and non–cash property shall be distributed on a pro rata basis such
that the total amount of property distributed on account of each Unit shall contain the same percentage of cash and the same percentage
of non–cash property (based on the Fair Market Value of such non–cash property), and, to the extent the non–cash
distributable property shall consist of more than one item of non–cash property, the Board shall, to the extent practicable,
allocate to each Unit receiving a distribution the same percentage (as a percentage of the total value of cash and non–cash
property distributed) of each item or type of non–cash property.


 






    35


     


    

 


(ii)       If
any distribution consists of both cash and non–cash property and such distribution is allocated among more than one class
of Units, then the cash and non–cash property shall be distributed on a pro rata basis such that the total amount of property
distributed to each class of Units receiving a distribution shall contain the same percentage of cash and the same percentage of
non–cash property (based on the Fair Market Value of such non–cash property), and, to the extent the non–cash
distributable property shall consist of more than one item of non–cash property, the Board shall, to the extent practicable,
allocate to each class of Units receiving a distribution the same percentage (as a percentage of the total value of cash and non–cash
property distributed) of each item or type of non–cash property.


 


(iii)       The
amount of any non-cash property to be distributed in accordance with Section 5.4 shall be its Fair Market Value.


 


(e)       Any
distributions pursuant to this Section 5.4 made in error or in violation of Section 18-607(a) of the Act, will, upon
demand by the Board, be returned to the Company.


 


Section 5.5Tax
Distributions. Subject to the Act, the Company may, to the extent of Available Cash and in proportion to their respective allocations
of taxable income of the Company for the taxable year, distribute to the Members an amount up to the aggregate amount equal to
the Tax Liability Deficiency. The distributions pursuant to this Section 5.5 shall be made in quarterly installments on
an estimated basis on or before the 10th day of each March, June, September and December. The amount to be distributed to a Member
pursuant to this Section 5.5 in respect of any taxable year shall be computed as if any distributions made to such Member
pursuant to Section 5.4 during such taxable year were a distribution under this Section 5.5 in respect of such taxable
year.


 


(a)       All
distributions made to a Member pursuant to this Section 5.5 on account of the taxable income allocated to such Member shall
be treated as advance distributions under Section 5.4 and shall be taken into account in determining the amount of
future distributions to such Member, and for purposes of determining the amount of distributions to be made to the Members pursuant
to Section 5.4, distributions made pursuant to this Section 5.5 shall be taken into account at such time as
they are being made pursuant to this Section 5.4.


 


Section 5.6Liability
of Members; Return of Class A Distributions and Class C Distributions.


 


(a)       Except
as explicitly provided in the Act, no Member shall be liable for any debts, liabilities, contracts or obligations of the Company
whatsoever.


 


(b)       (i)
Except as required by the Act, other applicable law or as otherwise expressly set forth herein, no Member shall be required to
repay to the Company, any Member or any creditor of the Company all or any part of the distributions made to such Member pursuant
hereto; provided, however, that, subject to the limitations set forth in Section 5.6(c) hereof, the Board may
require a Class A Member and a Class C Member to return distributions made to such Class A Member on account of their Class A Units
and Class C Member on account of its Class C Units for the purpose of meeting such Member’s pro rata share of any Company
Expenses (as determined by the Board based on distributions received from the Company by each Class A Member on account of its
Class A Units and Class C Member on account of its Class C Units relative to all distributions received from the Company by all
Class A Members on account of their Class A Units and Class C Member on account of its Class C Units); provided, however,
that in no event shall the Board require any Class A Member or Class C Member to return any distributions unless the Board requires
each Class A Member and the Class C Member to return a proportionate share (as determined on the same basis as above) of distributions.


 






    36


     


    

 


(ii)       If,
notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained herein, it is determined under applicable law that any Class A Member or Class
C Member has received a distribution which is required to be returned to or for the account of the Company or Company creditors,
then the obligation under applicable law of any Class A Member or Class C Member to return all or any part of a distribution made
to such Class A Member or Class C Member shall be the obligation of such Class A Member or Class C Member and not of any other
Class A Member or Class C Member.


 


(iii)       Any
amount returned by a Class A Member or Class C Member pursuant to this Section 5.6(b) shall be treated as a Capital Contribution
to the Company.


 


(c)       The
obligation of a Class A Member and a Class C Member to return distributions pursuant to this Section 5.6 shall survive the
termination of the Company and this Agreement and be subject to the following limitations:


 


(i)       no
Class A Member or Class C Member shall be required to return a distribution after the earlier to occur of (x) the third anniversary
of the date of termination of the Company, and (y) the third anniversary of the date of the applicable distribution; provided,
however, that if at such applicable anniversary, there are any legal proceedings then pending or any other liability (whether
contingent or otherwise) or claim then outstanding, then, the obligation of such Class A Member or Class C Member to return such
distribution for the purpose of meeting such Member’s pro rata share of any Company Expenses shall survive with respect to
each such legal proceeding, liability and claim set forth in such notice (or any related legal proceeding, liability or claim based
upon the same or a similar claim) until the date that such legal proceeding, liability or claim is ultimately resolved and satisfied;


 


(ii)       the
aggregate amount of distributions which a Class A Member or Class C Member may be required to return hereunder shall not exceed
an amount equal to the aggregate amount of distributions made to them on account of their Class A Units or Class C Units, as applicable
(net of taxes actually paid on account of such distributions by any such holder of Class A Units or Class C Units, its Affiliates
or direct or indirect members or equity owners).


 


Section 5.7Return
of Class B Distributions. If, upon the dissolution by the Company pursuant to Article VII and the final distribution
of all assets of the Company pursuant to Section 5.4, the amount distributed on account of the Class B Units exceeds
the aggregate amount distributable on account of the Class B Units pursuant to Section 5.4 after giving effect to all distributions
pursuant to Section 5.4 and Section 5.5 (the amount of such excess, the “Excess Class B Distribution
Amount”) then the Class B Member shall return to the Company an amount equal to the Excess Class B Distribution Amount,
and the amount returned to the Company shall be allocated among and distributed to the holders of Class A Units and Class C Units
in accordance with Section 5.4 and Section 5.5, as applicable.


 






    37


     


    

 


ARTICLE
VI

TRANSFER; WITHDRAWAL; SALE RIGHTS; EXIT EVENTS


 


Section 6.1Transfers.


 


(a)       No
Transfer of all or part of a Member’s Interest may be made except (i) in the case of Yorktown or Carbon, with the approval
of a Majority of the Voting Power (provided that approval of a Majority of the Voting Power is not required for a Yorktown-Carbon
Assignment), (ii) to a Permitted Transferee of such Member, (iii) in accordance with Section 6.2, Section 6.3,
Section 6.5, Section 6.6 or Section 6.9, or (iv) Transfers to or from a Subject Company pursuant
to Section 6.4, and then only if a counterpart of the instrument of Transfer, executed and acknowledged by or on behalf
of the parties thereto (provided if a holder of Units fails to execute any such instrument in breach of its obligations under this
Agreement, the signature of such Person shall not be required) is delivered to the Company. Notwithstanding the foregoing, no Indirect
Parent Transfer may be made without first obtaining approval of a Supermajority of the Voting Power. A permitted Transfer will
be effective as of the date specified in the instruments of assignment or conveyance, subject to applicable law, provided that
an assignee will not be admitted as a Member except in accordance with Section 6.7. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Class
B Units and Class C Units shall not be Transferable except as expressly provided in this Article VI.


 


(b)       In
no event shall a Transfer be permitted if (i) such Transfer would cause interests in the Company to be traded on an established
securities market, secondary market or substantial equivalent thereof within the meaning of Treasury Regulations Sections 1.7704-1
or (ii) such Transfer would cause the Company to become subject to regulation under either the Investment Company Act or the Investment
Advisers Act.


 


Section 6.2Drag-Along
Rights.


 


(a)       In
the event Old Ironsides or its Permitted Transferees propose to Transfer all or any portion of its Interests other than to a Permitted
Transferee of such Member and such Interests constitute more than 50% of the outstanding Class A Units (a “Drag-Along
Sale”), Old Ironsides and its Permitted Transferees effecting such Transfer (collectively, the “Dragging
Member”) shall have the right to require each other Member (each, a “Drag-Along Member”)
to sell their Interests in such Drag-Along Sale by Transferring up to a proportion (based on the percentage of the Class A Units
being Transferred by the Dragging Member relative to the number of Class A Units owned by the Dragging Member) of the Class A Units
held by each Drag-Along Member at the purchase price and upon the other terms and subject to the conditions of the Drag-Along Sale
(all of which shall be set forth in the Drag-Along Notice).


 


(b)       The
Dragging Member shall provide each Drag-Along Member written notice of the terms and conditions of such proposed Transfer (the
“Drag-Along Notice”) not later than 15 Business Days prior to the closing of the proposed Drag-Along
Sale. The Drag-Along Notice shall contain a true and complete copy of any and all available documents constituting the agreement
to transfer and, to the extent not set forth in the accompanying documents, the price offered for the Interests, all information
reasonably available to the Dragging Member regarding the acquirer, all other material terms and conditions of the proposed Drag-Along
Sale and, in the case of a proposed Drag-Along Sale in which the consideration payable for the Interests consists in whole or in
part of consideration other than cash, such information relating to such other consideration as is reasonably available to the
Dragging Member. Each Drag-Along Member shall be required to participate in the Drag-Along Sale on the terms and conditions set
forth in the Drag-Along Notice and this Section 6.2. No Member shall have any dissenters’ or appraisal rights in connection
with the Drag-Along Sale, and each Member hereby releases, and will execute such further instrument as the Company reasonably requests
to further evidence the waiver of, such rights.


 






    38


     


    

 


(c)       Within
10 Business Days following receipt of the Drag-Along Notice (the “Drag-Along Notice Period”), each
Drag-Along Member must deliver to such Dragging Member (i) wire transfer instructions for payment of the purchase price for the
Interests to be sold in such Drag-Along Sale, and (ii) all other documents required to be executed in connection with such Drag-Along
Sale. Each Member makes, constitutes, and appoints the Manager (or its chief executive officer, in his official corporate capacity)
as its true and lawful attorney-in-fact for such person and in its name, place, and stead and for its use and benefit, to sign,
execute, certify, acknowledge, swear to, file, and record any instrument that is now or may hereafter be deemed necessary by the
Company in its reasonable discretion to carry out fully the provisions and the agreement, obligations, and covenants of such Member
in this Section 6.2 in the event that such Member is or becomes a Drag-Along Member pursuant to this Section 6.2.
Each Member hereby gives such attorney-in-fact full power and authority to do and perform each and every act or thing whatsoever
requisite or advisable to be done in connection with such Member’s obligations and agreements as a Drag-Along Member pursuant
to this Section 6.2 as fully as such Member might or could do personally, and hereby ratifies and confirms all that any
such attorney-in-fact shall lawfully do or cause to be done by virtue of the power of attorney granted hereby. The power of attorney
granted pursuant hereto is a special power of attorney, coupled with an interest, and is irrevocable, and shall survive the bankruptcy,
insolvency, dissolution or cessation of existence of the applicable Member.


 


(d)       If,
at the end of the 90-day period after the date on which the Dragging Member gives the Drag-Along Notice (which 90-day period shall
be extended if any of the transactions contemplated by the Drag-Along Sale are subject to regulatory approval until the expiration
of five Business Days after all such approvals have been received, but in no event later than 120 days following the delivery of
the Drag-Along Notice), the Drag-Along Sale has not been completed on substantially the same terms and conditions set forth in
the Drag-Along Notice, the Drag-Along Members shall no longer be obligated to sell their Interests pursuant to such Drag-Along
Notice and the Dragging Member shall return to each Drag-Along Member any documents in the possession of the Dragging Member executed
by or on behalf of such Drag-Along Member in connection with the proposed Drag-Along Sale.


 


(e)       Concurrently
with the consummation of the Drag-Along Sale, Dragging Member shall (i) notify the Drag-Along Members thereof, (ii) remit to the
Drag-Along Members the total consideration for the Interests of the Drag-Along Members Transferred pursuant thereto, and (iii)
promptly after the consummation of the Drag-Along Sale, furnish such other evidence of the completion and the date of completion
of such Transfer and the terms thereof as may be reasonably requested by the Drag-Along Members.


 






    39


     


    

 


(f)       Notwithstanding
anything contained in this Section 6.2, there shall be no liability on the part of the Dragging Member to the Drag-Along
Members if the Transfer of the Interests pursuant to this Section 6.2 is not consummated for whatever reason.


 


(g)       Notwithstanding
anything contained in this Section 6.2, the obligations of the Drag-Along Members to participate in a Drag-Along Sale
are subject to the following conditions:


 


(i)       upon
consummation of such Drag-Along Sale, (A) all of the Members participating therein will receive the same form of consideration,
and (B) the aggregate consideration received by the Members will be paid to the Members subject to the allocation provisions set
forth in Section 5.4;


 


(ii)       no
Drag-Along Member participating therein shall be obligated to pay any expenses incurred in connection with any unconsummated Drag-Along
Sale, and each Drag-Along Member shall be obligated to pay only its pro rata share (based on the amount of the purchase price received)
of expenses incurred in connection with a consummated Drag-Along Sale to the extent such expenses are incurred for the benefit
of all Members and are not otherwise paid by the Company or another person;


 


(iii)       without
the written consent of a Drag-Along Member, such Drag-Along Member shall not be obligated with respect to (A) any representation
or warranty other than (I) a representation and warranty that relates solely to such Drag-Along Member’s title to its
Interest, and its authority and capacity to execute and deliver the subject purchase and sale agreement or (II) a representation
and warranty that relates to the Company and its operations which each Member is severally making to the buyer, or (B) any indemnity
obligation beyond a pro rata portion (based on and limited to the value of consideration received by such Drag-Along Member in
the Drag-Along Sale) of the indemnity obligations which obligate the Dragging Member and all Drag-Along Members and then, such
indemnity obligations shall be several and not joint, or (C) any other continuing obligation on such Drag-Along Member in favor
of any other person following the Disposition of such Drag-Along Member’s Interests (other than obligations relating to representations
and warranties that relate solely to such Drag-Along Member and not to any other Member or the indemnification obligation provided
for in clause (B) above);


 


(iv)       no
Drag-Along Member shall be obligated to consummate such Drag-Along Sale contemplated by the Drag-Along Notice with respect to its
Interests unless the Dragging Member consummates such Drag-Along Sale with respect to all (but not less than all) of their
Interests on the terms and conditions contemplated by the Drag-Along Notice; and


 


(v)       no
Drag-Along Member shall be obligated to participate in a Drag-Along Sale that is an Excluded Affiliate Transfer.


 






    40


     


    

 


(h)       If
a Member whose Class A Units are Transferred pursuant to this Section 6.2 also holds Class B Units or Class C Units
and all of such Member’s Class A Units are Transferred pursuant to this Section 6.2, then all Class B Units and all
Class C Units held by such Member shall be Transferred together with such Member’s Class A Units in the Drag-Along Sale.
If a Member whose Class A Units are Transferred pursuant to this Section 6.2 also holds Class B Units or Class C Units
and less than all of such Member’s Class A Units are Transferred pursuant to this Section 6.2, then all Class B Units
and all Class C Units held by such Member shall be retained by such Member and not included in the Drag-Along Sale.


 


(i)       In
any Drag-Along Sale in which a Drag-Along Member participates pursuant to this Section 6.2, the aggregate consideration
to be paid by the acquiring party shall be allocated among each class of Units included in such Drag-Along Sale and the holders
of Class A Units (with respect to their Class A Units), the holders of Class B Units (with respect to their Class B Units) and
the holder of Class C Units (with respect to the Class C Units) included in the Drag-Along Sale as provided in Section 6.11.


 


Section 6.3Tag-Along
Rights.


 


(a)       In
the event Old Ironsides or its Permitted Transferees propose to Transfer any of its Interests other than to a Permitted Transferee
of such Member and such Interests constitute more than 50% of the outstanding Class A Units, then Old Ironsides and its Permitted
Transferees effecting such Transfer (collectively, the “Tag-Along Transferring Member”) shall permit
Yorktown and Carbon (each, a “Tag-Along Participant”) to participate in such Transfer (a “Tag-Along
Sale”) by Transferring (at each Tag-Along Participant’s election) up to a proportion (based on the percentage
of the Class A Units being Transferred by the Tag-Along Transferring Member relative to the number of Class A Units owned by the
Tag-Along Transferring Member) of the Class A Units held by each Tag-Along Participant at the purchase price and upon the other
terms and subject to the conditions of the Tag-Along Sale (all of which shall be set forth in the Tag-Along Notice).


 


(b)       At
least twenty (20) Business Days prior to the date on which the Tag-Along Transferring Member expects to consummate the Transfer,
the Tag-Along Transferring Member shall deliver a written notice (“Tag-Along Notice”) to the Tag-Along
Participants, which shall set forth all relevant information with respect to the proposed Transfer, including the identity of the
buyer, the proposed purchase price, the Interests that are the subject of the sale, the expected closing date of the Transfer,
and any other terms and conditions of the proposed Transfer (including copies of all available and relevant proposed purchase and
sale documents). Any Tag-Along Participant electing to participate in the Transfer shall provide the Tag-Along Transferring Member
with written notice thereof within ten (10) Business Days prior to the date on which the Tag-Along Transferring Member expects
to consummate the Transfer (or if the Tag-Along Transferring Member delivers an amended Tag-Along Notice, within 10 days after
the delivery of such amended Tag-Along Notice (and the closing of the Transfer shall not occur prior to the expiration of 10 days
after such amended Tag-Along Notice has been delivered to each Tag-Along Participant)). Each Tag-Along Participant electing to
Transfer its Interests shall execute such documents, as are executed by the Tag-Along Transferring Member with respect to the Transfer;
provided, however, that any representations and warranties relating specifically to any Member shall only be made by that
Member and any indemnification provided by the Members shall be made on a several, not joint, basis (provided each Tag-Along Transferring
Member and Tag-Along Participant shall be required to provide proportionate (based on the amount of consideration to be received)
indemnification with respect to any representations and warranties related to the Company and its Subsidiaries); provided further,
however, that each Tag-Along Participant shall be required to represent and warrant with respect to the Required Representations.
In no event shall the amount of any indemnity obligation of any Tag-Along Participant exceed the amount of cash and the Fair Market
Value of any non-cash consideration received by such Tag-Along Participant in such Transfer, except in the case of fraud by such
Tag-Along Participant. Any indemnification or other obligation assumed or incurred in connection with a Transfer shall be allocated
among the Persons Transferring Units in connection with such Transfer in the same proportion as the consideration received by such
Persons in connection with such Transfer, in each case other than with respect to the Required Representations.


 






    41


     


    

 


(c)       After
the consummation of the Transfer pursuant to this Section 6.3, the Tag-Along Transferring Member shall give notice thereof
to the Tag-Along Participants, shall remit to each such Tag-Along Participant any funds due to such Tag-Along Participant and held
by the Tag-Along Transferring Member, and shall furnish such other evidence of the completion of such Transfer and the terms thereof
as may be reasonably requested by such Tag-Along Participant. If within ninety (90) days after the Tag-Along Transferring Member
gives the Tag-Along Notice (or the amended Tag-Along Notice, if applicable), which 90-day period shall be extended if any of the
transactions contemplated by the Tag-Along Sale are subject to regulatory approval until the expiration of five Business Days after
all such approvals have been received, but in no event later than 120 days following the delivery of the Tag-Along Notice (or the
amended Tag-Along Notice, if applicable), the Tag-Along Transferring Member has not completed the Transfer, it shall return to
each Tag-Along Participant any documents in possession of the Tag-Along Transferring Member executed by such Tag-Along Participant
in connection with such proposed Transfer.


 


(d)       Each
Member selling any Units pursuant to any Transfer pursuant to this Section 6.3 in which less than all of the outstanding
Class A Units are sold (a “Tag-Along Partial Sale”) shall, prior to the consummation of such sale, notify
the Board of which Class A Units are being sold by such Member (including any Capital Contributions and distributions previously
made in respect of such Class A Units) pursuant to such Tag-Along Partial Sale. The transferee of such Class A Units shall succeed
to the portion of the Capital Account and characteristics associated with such Class A Units.


 


(e)       If
a Tag-Along Participant also holds Class B Units or Class C Units and such Tag Along Participant is disposing of all of its Class
A Units in such Tag-Along Sale, then all Class B Units and all Class C Units held by such Tag-Along Participant shall be Transferred
in such Tag-Along Sale together with such Tag-Along Participant’s Class A Units. If a Tag-Along Participant also holds Class
B Units or Class C Units and such Tag Along Participant is disposing of less than all of its Class A Units in such Tag-Along Sale,
then all Class B Units and all Class C Units held by such Tag-Along Participant shall be retained by such Member and not included
in such Tag-Along Sale.


 






    42


     


    

 


(f)       In
any Tag-Along Sale in which a Tag-Along Participant participates pursuant to this Section 6.3, the aggregate consideration
to be paid by the acquiring party shall be allocated among each class of Units included in such Tag-Along Sale and among the holders
of Class A Units (with respect to their Class A Units), the holders of Class B Units (with respect to their Class B Units) and
the holder of Class C Units (with respect to the Class C Units) included in such Tag-Along Sale as provided in Section 6.11.


 


(g)       For
purposes of this Section 6.3, “Old Ironsides” shall mean Old Ironsides and each transferee of Class A Units
from Old Ironsides and “Carbon” shall mean Carbon and each transferee of Class A Units from Carbon.


 


Section 6.4Indirect
Transfer.


 


(a)       If
any holder of Class A Units or any Parent of a holder of Class A Units proposes to effect a transaction or series of transactions
that would result in a Change in Control of such holder of Class A Units or any such Parent (such transaction, an “Indirect
Parent Transfer”), then such holder of Class A Units (the “Subject Company”) or its Parent
shall give written notice to the other Class A Members (“IPT Notice”) at least twenty (20) days prior
to the consummation of such Indirect Parent Transfer (or such shorter period as is agreed by the relevant parties), stating the
desire of such holder of Class A Units or such Parent to effect such Indirect Parent Transfer, the identity of the other party
to such transaction (the “Offeror”), the interest to be Transferred, and all other material terms and
conditions of such transaction, including a description of purchase price allocation.


 


(b)       Upon
an Indirect Parent Transfer consummated without the approval of the IPT Eligible Member, (i) each IPT Eligible Member shall have
the right to, each at its own option, purchase all, but not less than all, of the Units held by the Subject Company for an amount
in cash equal to the implied value per Unit allocated to such Units by the Offeror, or if no such allocation is made by the Offeror,
the fair market value of such Units (such implied value or fair market value per Unit the “IPT Transaction Value”)
(provided more than one IPT Eligible Member exercises its right to purchase, each exercising IPT Eligible Member will have the
right to purchase its pro rata portion of the Units being sold in the proportion that the relative Class A Sharing Percentage of
the exercising Members) or (ii) if the IPT Eligible Member does not exercise its rights under clause (i) above, then each IPT Eligible
Member, each at its own option, may sell to the Subject Company, and the Subject Company shall have the obligation to purchase,
all, but not less than all, of the Units held by each exercising IPT Eligible Member for an amount in cash equal to the IPT Transaction
Value of such Units. Such rights may be exercised by written notice to the Subject Company given within twenty (20) days of receipt
of the IPT Notice, or, if an IPT Notice is not delivered to a IPT Eligible Member in violation of this Section 6.4(b)
or an Indirect Parent Transfer otherwise occurs with respect to a IPT Eligible Member, then such right may be exercised by the
applicable IPT Eligible Member(s) providing written notice to the Subject Company within one hundred twenty (120) days after such
IPT Eligible Member obtains actual knowledge of such Indirect Parent Transfer (any such notice, and “IPT Exercise Notice”).
The failure of a recipient of an IPT Notice or any other IPT Eligible Member to notify the Subject Company within such applicable
time period provided above of any election under this Section 6.4(b) shall be deemed an election by such IPT Eligible
Member not to exercise its right to acquire or sell Units pursuant to this Section 6.4 in connection with such Indirect
Parent Transfer.


 






    43


     


    

 


(c)       For
purposes of this Section 6.4, the “fair market value” of any Units shall be the fair market value
of such Units, as agreed to by the Subject Company and the holders of each Class of Units electing to purchase or sell such Units
(such holders electing to purchase or sell Units, collectively as to each class of Units, the “Exercising Member”)
that collectively hold a majority of such class of Units held by all Exercising Members of such class of Units (as to each class
of Units, the “Primary Exercising Members”) or, in the event the Subject Company and the Primary Exercising
Member fail to agree within fifteen (15) days after the Exercising Member has delivered a IPT Exercise Notice to the Subject Company
in accordance with Section 6.4(b), the fair market value of such Units as determined by a Qualified Appraiser which
has not had any material engagement with the Subject Company or the Primary Exercising Members or any of their respective Affiliates
in the preceding two years selected by the Primary Exercising Member. Any such Qualified Appraiser so appointed shall be deemed
the “Initial Appraiser.”


 


(d)       In
the event that the Subject Company objects to the fair market value determination made by the Initial Appraiser, then the Subject
Company may, within thirty (30) days after receipt of the Initial Appraiser’s determination of fair market value, select
a Qualified Appraiser which has not had any material engagement with the Subject Company or the Primary Exercising Member or any
of their respective Affiliates in the preceding two years (the “Second Appraiser”). The Initial Appraiser
and the Second Appraiser shall thereupon select a third Qualified Appraiser (the “Neutral Appraiser”).
The Subject Company and the Exercising Member shall execute such engagement and indemnity agreements as the Neutral Appraiser shall
require as a condition to engagement and each shall be responsible for all fees and expenses of the investment bank selected by
it and for its one–half of all fees and expenses of the Neutral Appraiser. The Subject Company and the Exercising Member
shall, and shall cause their respective Affiliates to, make available to the other and the investment banks such information as
is reasonably necessary to reach a fair market value determination. Each of the Initial Appraiser, Second Appraiser, and Neutral
Appraiser shall independently determine its proposed fair market value of the Units, and “fair market value”
shall thereupon mean the average of the two such proposed fair market values that are nearest to one another. The following principle
shall apply generally to any determination of fair market value under this Section 6.4: fair market value shall mean the
cash price at which the Units would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under any compulsion
and both having a reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts including the application of Section 5.4 and without reduction
based upon any lack of control, minority ownership, marketability or other similar discounts. If the Subject Company fails to select
the Second Appraiser within the 30 day period provided above, such Subject Company shall be deemed to have waived such objection
and the fair market determination by the Initial Appraiser shall be deemed final.


 


(e)       Notwithstanding
anything in this Section 6.4, within fifteen (15) days after receipt of an IPT Exercise Notice by a Subject Company such
Subject Company may deliver written notice (a “Cure Notice”) to the Person who delivered such IPT Exercise
Notice that the Indirect Parent Transfer was inadvertent and such Subject Company may, during the thirty (30) days immediately
following delivery of a Cure Notice (the “Cure Period”), effect such actions to cause the Change in Control
giving rise to the Indirect Parent Transfer to cease to exist such that there shall no longer exist a Change in Control of such
Subject Company, and the time periods for actions to occur after delivery of an IPT Exercise Notice (other than the Cure Period)
shall be tolled during such Cure Period. If the Subject Company successfully takes such action within such Cure Period to cause
the Change in Control giving rise to such Indirect Parent Transfer to cease to exist such that there shall no longer exist a Change
in Control of the Subject Company upon the expiration of such Cure Period, then this Section 6.4 shall no longer apply with
respect to such previous Indirect Parent Transfer.


 






    44


     


    

 


(f)       Notwithstanding
anything in this Section 6.4, a Change in Control of the Ultimate Parent of Old Ironsides shall not constitute a Change
in Control of Old Ironsides or any Permitted Transferee of Old Ironsides, a Change in Control of the Ultimate Parent of Yorktown
shall not constitute a Change in Control of Yorktown or any Permitted Transferee of Yorktown, a Change in Control of the Ultimate
Parent of Carbon shall not constitute a Change in Control of Carbon or any Permitted Transferee of Carbon, and a Change in Control
of the Ultimate Parent of any other Member shall not constitute a Change in Control of such Member or any Permitted Transferee
of such Member for purposes of this Section 6.4.


 


Section 6.5Liquidity
Event.


 


(a)       Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary set forth herein:


 


(i)       So
long as the Company has not effected a Public Offering, at any time following the seventh anniversary of the Effective Date, Yorktown
and Old Ironsides shall each have the right, at each of their express direction and in each of their sole discretion, to direct
the Board to take such actions to effect a Liquidity Event upon delivering a written notice thereof to the Board of such direction
(a “Liquidity Event Notice”).


 


(ii)       (A)
At any time Yorktown or Carbon is a Defaulting Member, (B) following a Key Man Event pursuant to Section 4.2(c) or
(C) if the Services Agreement is terminated, so long as the Company has not effected a Public Offering, Old Ironsides shall
have the right, at its express direction and in its sole discretion, to direct the Board to take such actions to effect a Liquidity
Event upon delivering a Liquidity Event Notice.


 


(b)       Upon
receipt of a Liquidity Event Notice, the Company shall use commercially reasonable efforts to consummate a Liquidity Event as soon
as practicable and shall diligently pursue the consummation of a Liquidity Event in good faith and the Board shall manage the business
and affairs of the Company primarily with a view toward the consummation of such Liquidity Event as soon as reasonably practicable
following the exercise of such right, and the approval of a Liquidity Event by an Old Ironsides Designee or a Yorktown Designee
shall be deemed approval of such Liquidity Event by the Board, subject to any approval required by Section 2.4(b)(v). Each
Member shall, and shall cause its Affiliates to, take all actions, including those set forth in Section 6.5(c), if applicable,
reasonably necessary or appropriate to (i) cooperate with the Company in working toward the consummation of a Liquidity Event
and (ii) cause its Board appointees to act in accordance with this Section 6.5 (including replacing its Board appointees,
if necessary).


 






    45


     


    

 


(c)       If
the Board approves (or is deemed to have approved) a Liquidity Event (an “Approved Exit”), each Member
shall raise no objections against such Approved Exit and, to the extent necessary to effect the consummation of such Approved Exit,
vote for and consent to such Approved Exit; provided, however, that any such vote, consent or approval by a Member shall
not constitute a waiver or otherwise affect any rights or obligations of any Member under this Section 6.5, or Section
6.6 of this Agreement with respect to such Approved Exit or any rights of a Member with respect to or arising as a result of
such Approved Exit under any agreement to which such Member is a party. If the Approved Exit is structured as a (i) merger, consolidation
or sale of assets, each Member shall waive any dissenters’ rights, appraisal rights or similar rights in connection with
such merger, consolidation or sale of assets or (ii) sale of Units, each Member shall agree to sell all of his, her or its Units
or rights to acquire Units on the terms and conditions approved by the Board (subject to Section 6.11). Each Member shall
take all necessary or desirable actions in connection with the consummation of the Approved Exit as reasonably requested by the
Board.


 


(d)       In
any Approved Exit, the consideration received by the Company shall be allocated and distributed to each Member in accordance with
Section 5.4 after all the liabilities of the Company have been satisfied in full or provided for.


 


(e)       Members
shall bear their pro rata share (based upon the allocation set forth in Section 6.5(d)) of the costs of any sale of Interests
pursuant to an Approved Exit to the extent such costs are incurred for the benefit of all Members and are not otherwise paid by
the Company or the acquiring party. For purposes of this Section 6.5, costs incurred by Members in exercising reasonable
efforts to take all actions in connection with the consummation of an Approved Exit in accordance with this Section 6.5
shall be deemed to be for the benefit of all Members. Costs incurred by Members solely on their own behalf will not be considered
costs of the transaction hereunder.


 


(f)       If
the Board determines that the Liquidity Event shall be a Public Offering:


 


(i)       each
Member agrees that it will, and will cause its Affiliates and any Director appointed by such Member to, and the Company shall:


 


(A)       if
the underwriters in any Public Offering request that all Members hold their Interest (or any equity securities of any Entity effecting
such Public Offering) for a period of time following the Public Offering, do so and enter into a customary lock-up agreement;


 


(B)       complete
and execute all consents, questionnaires, powers of attorney, indemnities, underwriting agreements and other documents as may reasonably
be required or advisable in connection with a Public Offering; provided that no such Person shall be required to make any representations
or warranties in connection with a Public Offering other than representations and warranties regarding such Person and, if applicable,
such Person’s intended method of distribution;


 






    46


     


    

 


(C)       if
determined by the Board to be reasonably necessary or appropriate in connection with a Public Offering, do all things reasonably
necessary or advisable to effect any Internal Restructure in accordance with Section 6.9;


 


(D)       consent
to certain additional restrictions on the Transfer of Interests (or any equity securities of any Entity effecting such Public Offering)
which the Board determines may be required in order to permit compliance with the Securities Act or other applicable law;


 


(E)       use
commercially reasonable efforts to accommodate any such other reasonable actions required by the United States Securities and Exchange
Commission or similar governmental authority to effect the Public Offering; and


 


(F)       make
modifications to this Agreement (or any other agreement then governing the rights and obligations of the Members with respect to
the Company or any successor to the Company) as are customary and appropriate for companies that conduct a Public Offering, such
modifications to be in form and substance reasonably satisfactory to Carbon and Old Ironsides.


 


(ii)       The
Company shall be responsible for its own costs, fees and expenses in connection with a Public Offering and shall reimburse the
Members and their Affiliates for the reasonable out-of-pocket costs, fees and expenses (excluding underwriting discounts, selling
commissions and similar fees) incurred by them in connection with a Public Offering, including the reasonable costs, fees and expenses
of one outside counsel for each Member.


 


(iii)       Each
of the Members shall be granted customary demand and piggyback registration rights effective from and after the Public Offering,
as well as the right to include their Interests (or any securities for which such Interests are exchanged or into which such Interests
are converted) in the Public Offering on a pro rata basis (based on the relative percentages of securities of this type to be included
in the Public Offering held by the Members immediately prior to the Public Offering); provided that if the managing underwriter
or the placement agent advises the Company or the Board that the inclusion of securities of the Members in the Company or any Affiliate
of the Company requested to be included for sale in a secondary offering in connection with the Public Offering would materially
and adversely affect the price, distribution or timing of the offering, then the Company shall have the right to exclude all or
any portion of such securities of the Company or any Affiliate of the Company from sale in connection with the Public Offering,
with such exclusions applied to the Members’ pro rata share of such securities (based on the relative percentages of securities
to be included in the Public Offering held by the Members immediately prior to the Public Offering).


 


(g)       Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary contained herein, if a Liquidity Event is not consummated during the period beginning as of the date a
Liquidity Event Notice is delivered to the Board through the first anniversary of such date and a Member thereafter seeks to Transfer
of its Interests, Board approval for such Transfer shall not be required pursuant to Section 6.1.


 






    47


     


    

 


Section 6.6Buy/Sell
Rights.


 


(a)       If
a Liquidity Event is not consummated during the period beginning as of the date of Liquidity Event Notice is delivered to the Board
through the first anniversary of such date, either Yorktown or Old Ironsides (the “Initiating Member”)
may initiate the buy sell procedure set forth in this Section 6.6 by delivering to the other (the “Non-Initiating
Member”) written notice specifying such Member’s determination of the Company Sale Value and the amount that
would be distributable to each holder of Units by applying Section 5.4 based on an amount equal to the Company Sale Value
as determined by such Member (giving effect to all distributions actually made pursuant to this Agreement through the date of the
transaction for purposes of allocations under Section 5.4) (such aggregate amount as would be distributable to each Member,
the “Buy/Sell Unit Price”), and the other terms and conditions pursuant to which the Initiating Member
proposes to purchase all of the Units held by the Non-Initiating Member (the “Offer”). If either Yorktown
or Old Ironsides has transferred all or a portion of its Units then Yorktown or Old Ironsides, as the case may be, and such transferee
(whether or not the transferee has been admitted as a Member or is only an assignee) will collectively be considered as Yorktown
or Old Ironsides, respectively, for purposes of this Section 6.6 and all Units held by Yorktown or Old Ironsides (including
all such transferees), as the case may be, shall be subject to purchase by the Initiating Member under the provisions of this Section
6.6.


 


(b)       No
later than thirty (30) days following receipt of the Offer, the Non-Initiating Member must notify (a “Buy/Sell Election
Notice”) the Initiating Member of its election to either:


 


(i)       sell
all Units held by the Non-Initiating Member and its Affiliates to the Initiating Member for a price equal to the applicable Buy/Sell
Unit Price and on such other terms specified in the Offer; or


 


(ii)       purchase
all Units held by the Initiating Member and its Affiliates for a price equal to the applicable Buy/Sell Unit Price; provided that
if the Initiating Member has transferred all or a portion of its Units, then the Units held by the Initiating Member and such transferees
(whether or not the transferee has been admitted as a Member or is only an assignee) will collectively be considered as held by
the Initiating Member for purposes of this Section 6.6(b)(ii) and Section 6.6(c) and Section 6.6(d) and the
Units held by the Initiating Member (including all such transferees) shall be subject to purchase by the Non-Initiating Member
under this Section 6.6.


 


(c)       If
the Non-Initiating Member fails to deliver a Buy/Sell Election Notice to the Initiating Member within the thirty (30) day period
(or fails to close the purchase in accordance with Section 6.6(d) within the time period set forth therein), then the Non-Initiating
Member will conclusively be deemed for all purposes to have elected to sell all Units held by the Non-Initiating Member as set
forth in Section 6.6(b)(i), and this deemed election will be treated as having occurred on the last day of the thirty (30)
day period (or ninety (90) day period under Section 6.6(d), if applicable).


 






    48


     


    

 


(d)       If
the Non-Initiating Member elects to purchase all Units held by the Initiating Member pursuant to Section 6.6(b)(ii), then
the closing of any sale under Section 6.6(b)(ii) to the Non-Initiating Member will be held at the principal office of the
Company, unless otherwise mutually agreed, on a mutually acceptable date not more than ninety (90) days after receipt by the Initiating
Member of the Non-Initiating Member’s Buy/Sell Election Notice electing to purchase the Units held by the Initiating Member.


 


(e)       If
the Non-Initiating Member elects to sell all of the Units held by the Non-Initiating Member pursuant to Section 6.6(b)(i)
or is deemed to have so elected pursuant to Section 6.6(c), then the Initiating Member may elect:


 


(i)       to
purchase such Units for the applicable Buy/Sell Unit Price with the closing of any sale to be held at the principal office of the
Company unless otherwise mutually agreed, on a mutually acceptable date not more than ninety (90) days after receipt by the Initiating
Member of the Buy/Sell Election Notice; provided that the Initiating Member may elect to assign its rights to purchase such Units
to any one or more other Persons (which assignment shall not relieve the Initiating Member of its obligations under this Section
6.6); or


 


(ii)       The
Initiating Member may seek a third party purchaser for one hundred percent (100%) of the Units whether through an equity sale or
a sale in any other form or a sale of the assets of the Company and/or its Subsidiaries (“Third Party Sale”).


 


(f)       The
Initiating Member must notify the Non-Initiating Member of its election of Section 6.6(e)(i) or Section 6.6(e)(ii)
within thirty (30) days after the Initiating Member’s receipt of the Buy/Sell Election Notice. If the Initiating Member fails
to timely notify the Non-Initiating Member of its election, then the Initiating Member shall be deemed to have made an election
of Section 6.6(e)(i).


 


(g)       If
the Initiating Member pursues a Third Party Sale:


 


(i)       The
Non-Initiating Member and the Company shall cooperate in the Initiating Member’s Third Party Sale process in any manner reasonably
requested by the Initiating Member. The Initiating Member will bear all costs and fees incurred in connection with the Third Party
Sale (including without limitation all reasonable and necessary third party costs and fees, including attorneys’ fees, incurred
by the Non-Initiating Member in cooperating in such Third Party Sale process), except each Member will bear the costs and fees
of its own independent advisors.


 


(ii)       The
Initiating Member will have the requisite authority to negotiate and approve the Third Party Sale (which Third Party Sale will
be conditioned on the consummation of the purchase or redemption of the Units of the Non-Initiating Member at the applicable Buy/Sell
Unit Price); and to this end the Initiating Member will have exclusive authority during this period to approve such a sale and
any related agreements without the necessity of obtaining the consent or approval of the Board or the other Member; provided,
however, that any representations and warranties relating specifically to any Member shall only be made by that Member and
any indemnification provided by the Members shall be made on a several, not joint, basis; provided further, however, that the Non-Initiating
Member shall be required to make only the Required Representations. In no event shall (A) the consideration to be received by any
Transferring Person in connection with a Third Party Sale consist of any form of non-cash consideration other than freely tradable
publicly traded securities (subject to any customary lockup not to exceed 90 days) or (B) the amount of any indemnity obligation
of any Transferring Person exceed the amount of cash and the fair market value of any non-cash consideration received by such Transferring
Person in such Third Party Sale, except in the case of fraud by such Transferring Person. Any indemnification or other obligation
assumed or incurred in connection with a Transfer shall be allocated among the Transferring Persons in the same proportion as the
consideration received by the Transferring Persons, in each case other than with respect to the Required Representations.


 






    49


     


    

 


(iii)       If
the Initiating Member successfully negotiates a Third Party Sale (other than as a sale of assets), then prior to or upon consummation
of the Third Party Sale, the Initiating Member will purchase the Units held by the other Members at the applicable Buy/Sell Unit
Price, or cause the purchaser in such Third Party Sale to purchase such Units at the applicable Buy/Sell Unit Price. The purchase
of such Units will be held at such time and place as will be elected by the Initiating Member but in any event not more than one
hundred twenty (120) days after the Initiating Member’s receipt of the Buy/Sell Election Notice, subject to extension for
such period of time (not to exceed thirty (30) days) as necessary to permit the Initiating Member or the third party purchaser
to obtain any required governmental approvals but in any event will occur no later than upon the consummation of the Third Party
Sale.


 


(iv)       If
the Initiating Member is unsuccessful in completing a Third Party Sale or the redemption or purchase of the Units held by the other
Members is not consummated within the time period specified in Section 6.6(g)(iii), then Initiating Member will purchase
the Units held by the Non-Initiating Member pursuant to Section 6.6(e)(i) within thirty (30) days after the one hundred
twenty (120) day period set forth in Section 6.6(g)(iii).


 


(h)       It
is expressly agreed that the remedy at law for breach of any of the obligations set forth in this Section 6.6 is inadequate
in view of (i) the complexities and uncertainties in measuring the actual damages that would be sustained by reason of the failure
of a Member to comply with each of said obligations, and (ii) the uniqueness of the Company’s business and the Company’s
relationship with the Members. Accordingly, each of the aforesaid obligations will be, and are hereby expressly made, enforceable
by specific performance.


 


(i)       Notwithstanding
anything contained in this Section 6.6, each transferee of a Member’s Units or any interest therein shall be subject
to the terms of this Section 6.6 (whether or not such transferee has been admitted as a Member) but a Member who has transferred
its Units or any interest therein to any Person shall not be liable or responsible for any noncompliance or compliance, respectively,
with this Section 6.6, by any such transferee of such Member who is not an Affiliate of such Member.


 






    50


     


    

 


Section 6.7Assumption
of Assignee. Any Transfer of an Interest in the Company permitted under this Article VI must be in writing, and
the assignee must expressly, in a written joinder executed by the assignee, (a) agree to be bound by the terms of this Agreement,
(b) assume and agree to perform all of the Transferring Member’s agreements and obligations existing or arising with
respect to the assigned Interest after the Transfer and (c) make the representations and warranties set forth in Section 3.8
to the Company and to the other Members effective as of the date of Transfer. Upon such Transfer and joinder, (i) the Transferring
Member will be relieved of its agreements and obligations arising under this Agreement after the date of the Transfer (but not
before) to the extent of the Interest assigned, and if one hundred percent (100%) of that Member’s Interest is Transferred,
such Member will be deemed to have withdrawn from the Company and (ii) the assignee shall be admitted as a Member with respect
to the Interests acquired upon consummation of such Transfer and compliance with this Section 6.7. An executed copy
of each assignment of an Interest in the Company and the assignee’s joinder must be delivered to each Member and to the Company.
Except as otherwise expressly provided herein, no permitted Transfer of any Interests will cause a termination or winding-up of
the Company.


 


Section 6.8Allocations
to Member’s Transferee. Upon the Transfer of all or any part of the Interest of a Member, the profits, distributions,
net losses, net gains and credits attributable to the Interest Transferred will be allocated, at the sole cost and expense of the
transferee and/or transferor, between the transferee and transferor as of the date set forth in the instrument of transfer, based
upon a manner that complies with Section 706 of the Code and the Treasury Regulations thereunder, as determined by the Board of
Directors.


 


Section 6.9Internal
Restructure.


 


(a)       Subject
to the consent of the Board of Directors in accordance with Article II, the Company may effect an Internal Restructure
on such terms as the Board of Directors in the exercise of its reasonable discretion deems advisable. Each Member agrees that it
will consent to and raise no objections to an Internal Restructure; provided that (i) the Internal Restructure is undertaken in
a manner that results in the Members continuing to have substantially the same direct or indirect ownership of the Company’s
assets in place prior to the Internal Restructure, (ii) the Internal Restructure preserves the relative economic interests, preferences,
priorities and designations of the Members in the Company or any entity that succeeds to the Company in such Internal Restructure
transaction, and (iii) such Member does not determine, based on written advice of counsel, that the Internal Restructure has a
reasonable risk of having an adverse legal, regulatory, tax or accounting effect on such Member. Each Member hereby agrees that
it will execute and deliver all agreements, instruments and documents as are required, in the reasonable judgment of the Board
of Directors to be executed by such Member in order to consummate the Internal Restructure while continuing in effect, to the extent
consistent with such Internal Restructure, the terms and provisions of this Agreement, including those provisions granting the
Board authority to manage the affairs of the Company, granting certain persons the right to nominate and cause the election of
Directors, governing Transfers of Interests in the Company or other equity securities and indemnification.


 






    51


     


    

 


(b)       The
Members acknowledge that an Internal Restructure may be undertaken in connection with other events, such as a public offering of
the Company or an acquisition of another business or entity and, if so determined by the Board of Directors, such Internal Restructure
shall be deemed completed immediately before any such event.


 


(c)       The
Members acknowledge that, to engage in an initial public offering, it may be necessary or advisable for the Company to merge or
convert into a Delaware corporation (a “Conversion”). Accordingly, if the Board of Directors determines
it to be in the best interests of the Company to engage in an initial public offering and to effect a Conversion, the Members agree
that the Company’s capital structure shall be restructured in the manner described in this Section 6.9 and the Members
shall vote and take all other action necessary in order to effect such Conversion. In connection with a Conversion, all Interests
in the Company (the “Old Interests”) will be exchanged for common stock of the surviving corporation
(the “Conversion Consideration”). In determining the portion of the Conversion Consideration to be exchanged
for the Old Interests, the Company shall determine what portion of the Conversion Consideration would have been distributed among
all of the holders of the Old Interests if the Company’s sole asset consisted of the Conversion Consideration and the Company
distributed the Conversion Consideration in the same manner distributions would have been made in a complete liquidation of the
Company taking into account the various rights, preferences and designations governing the Old Interests (which rights, preferences
and designations are set forth in this Agreement, each as they may exist before the Conversion). Once the Company determines the
portion of the Conversion Consideration that would have been distributed to each class or series of Old Interests if the Company
had been liquidated immediately before the Conversion, the Board of Directors will then determine the exchange ratio of the Old
Interest into common shares of the surviving corporation.


 


(d)       Upon
the consummation of an Internal Restructure, the surviving entity or entities shall assume or succeed to all of the outstanding
debt and other liabilities and obligations of the Company. To the extent practicable, the governing instruments of the surviving
entity shall incorporate the governance provisions of this Agreement. All Members shall take such actions as may be reasonably
required and otherwise cooperate in good faith with the Company in connection with consummating an Internal Restructure including
a Conversion including voting for or consenting thereto.


 


Section 6.10Other
Assignment Void. Any purported Transfer of an Interest in the Company not permitted by this Article VI is null
and void ab initio and of no effect whatsoever.


 


Section 6.11Allocation
and Distribution of Consideration. Upon any Transfer of Units in which two or more holders of Units Transfer Units pursuant
to a Liquidity Event, Internal Restructure or pursuant to Section 6.2 or Section 6.3:


 


(a)       The
Fair Market Value of any non-cash property included in the consideration for such Transfer shall be added to the aggregate cash
proceeds included in the consideration for such Transfer to determine the aggregate proceeds of such Transfer (the “Disposition
Proceeds”). Each holder of Units included in such Transfer shall receive such holder’s (i) proportionate share
of the aggregate non-cash consideration comprising the Disposition Proceeds and (ii) proportionate share of the aggregate cash
consideration comprising the Disposition Proceeds, in each case determined in accordance with Section 6.11(b) below.


 






    52


     


    

 


(b)       For
purposes of determining the proportionate share of the Disposition Proceeds to be delivered to each holder whose Units are included
in such Transfer, the following provisions shall apply:


 


(i)       with
respect to a Transfer in which all outstanding Units are Transferred (A) the Company shall be deemed to have distributed pursuant
to Section 5.4 an amount equal to the Disposition Proceeds (giving effect to all prior distributions under Section 5.4
and Section 5.5) and (B) the amount that would be distributable to each holder of Units pursuant to the hypothetical distribution
in accordance with Section 6.11(b)(i)(A) on account of such holder’s Units shall be the amount of such Disposition
Proceeds to be paid to such holder;


 


(ii)       with
respect to any Drag-Along Sale or Tag-Along Sale that includes less than all outstanding Class A Units and in which Class B Units
are included pursuant to Section 6.2(h) or Section 6.3(e), (A) the Board shall determine a Company Sale Value
based on the purchase price offered for the Class A Units as set forth in the Tag-Along Notice, (B) the Board shall assume that
an amount of cash equal to such Company Sale Value was distributed pursuant to Section 5.4 (giving effect to all prior distributions
under Section 5.4 and Section 5.5 through the date of the Tag-Along Sale for purposes of determining the appropriate
distributions under Section 5.4), (C) each holder of Class B Units whose Class B Units are included in such Tag-Along Sale
shall be allocated a portion of the Disposition Proceeds with respect to such holder’s Class B Units equal to the amount
that would be distributable on account of such holders’ Class B Units by applying Section 5.4 to a distribution amount
equal to such Company Sale Value in accordance with Section 6.11(b)(ii)(B), and (D) each holder of Class A Units and each
holder of Class C Units participating in such Tag-Along Sale shall be allocated, with respect to such holder’s Class A Units
and Class C Units included in such Tag-Along Sale, a portion of the balance of the Disposition Proceeds remaining after giving
effect to clause (C) above (the “Remaining Tag Balance”), equal to the Remaining Tag Balance multiplied
by a fraction, (x) the numerator of which is the amount that would be distributable to such holder in the hypothetical distribution
in accordance with Section 6.11(b)(ii)(B) on account of such holder’s Class A Units and/or Class C Units being
included in such Tag-Along Sale and (y) the denominator of which is the amount that would be distributable to all holders of Class
A Units and Class C Units participating in such Tag-Along Sale on account of such holders’ Class A Units and Class C Units
being included in such Tag-Along Sale by applying Section 5.4 to a distribution amount equal to such Company Sale Value
in accordance with Section 6.11(b)(ii)(B) (subject to any adjustment as necessary to give effect to any different economic
attributes of the Class A Units being Transferred if such Class A Units being Transferred by a holder of Class A Units have different
economic attributes relative to Class A Units being Transferred by other holders of Class A Units).


 


(iii)       with
respect to any Drag-Along Sale or Tag-Along Sale that includes less than all outstanding Class A Units and in which Class B Units
are not included pursuant to Section 6.2(h) or Section 6.3(e), (A) the Company shall be deemed to have distributed
pursuant to Section 5.4 an amount equal to the Disposition Proceeds on account of the Class A Units and Class C Units
being Transferred in such Tag-Along Sale (giving effect to all prior distributions under Section 5.4 and Section 5.5
but assuming that no proceeds are distributable on account of the Class B Units) and (B) the amount that would be distributable
to each holder pursuant to the hypothetical distribution in accordance with Section 6.11(b)(iii)(A) on account of such holder’s
Class A Units and Class C Units being Transferred in such Tag-Along Sale shall be the amount of such Disposition Proceeds to be
paid to such holder (subject to any adjustment as necessary to give effect to any different economic attributes of the Class A
Units being Transferred if such Class A Units being Transferred by a holder of Class A Units have different economic attributes
relative to Class A Units being Transferred by other holders of Class A Units); and


 






    53


     


    

 


(iv)       for
purposes of determining the amount of the Disposition Proceeds to be allocated among and/or delivered for the Class A Units, Class
B Units and Class C Units pursuant to an Internal Restructure or Transferred in a Liquidity Event, other than as described in Section
6.11(b)(i), the methodology set forth in Section 6.11(b)(ii) and Section 6.11(b)(iii) shall apply, mutatis
mutandis.


 


Section 6.12Yorktown-Carbon
Assignment.


 


(a)       Yorktown
may assign all or any portion of its Interests to Carbon in exchange for shares of common stock of Carbon, subject to Section
6.1(b) and Section 6.7 (such assignment, the “Yorktown-Carbon Assignment“). Effective
upon any Yorktown-Carbon Transfer, Carbon shall succeed to the rights of Yorktown with respect to the Interests assigned by Yorktown
to Carbon. In the event that Yorktown assigns all of its Interests to Carbon pursuant to a Yorktown-Carbon Transfer, Yorktown shall
be deemed withdrawn as a Member of the Company and Carbon shall succeed to the rights and obligations of Yorktown under this Agreement
with respect to the Interests assigned by Yorktown to Carbon (including the right to appoint Board designees and the obligation
to make Capital Contributions under Article IV).


 


(b)       If
the Yorktown-Carbon Assignment occurs, the terms agreed to by Yorktown and Carbon with respect to the Yorktown-Carbon Assignment
shall not be taken into account for purposes of Company Sale Value or otherwise with respect to the value of the Company or its
assets.


 


(c)       If
the Yorktown-Carbon Assignment occurs, the Members will act in good faith to amend and restate the Agreement to give effect to
the Yorktown-Carbon Assignment and the purpose and intent of this Section 6.12.


 


ARTICLE
VII

DISSOLUTION; WINDING UP


 


Section 7.1Dissolution.
The Company shall be dissolved only upon the first to occur of any of the following events (“Dissolution Events”):


 


(a)       the
election by the Supermajority of the Voting Power to dissolve the Company;


 






    54


     


    

 


(b)       the
tenth anniversary of the date hereof, unless extended upon Majority of the Voting Power for up to two successive one year terms;
or


 


(c)       the
entry of a decree of judicial dissolution under Section 18-802 of the Act.


 


Section 7.2Winding
Up. Upon the occurrence of a Dissolution Event, the business of the Company shall be wound up and shall, except to the extent
consistent with such winding up, cease. The Board of Directors shall act as liquidator unless it elects to appoint one or more
other Persons, who may or may not be Members, to act as liquidator. The liquidator shall proceed diligently to wind up the business
and affairs of the Company and may determine all matters in connection with the winding up of the Company, including any arrangements
to be made with creditors, the amount or necessity of reserves to cover contingent or unforeseen liabilities, and whether, to what
extent, for what consideration, and on what terms any or all of the assets of the Company are to be sold. The liquidator may in
its discretion retain any obligations due to the Company and distribute (or apply in satisfaction of Company obligations) the proceeds
thereof as collected. The costs and expenses of the winding up and liquidation of the Company shall be borne by the Company. Until
final distribution, the liquidator shall continue to manage the Company’s affairs and, if the liquidator is a Person other
than the Board of Directors, shall, to the extent consistent with the liquidator’s obligations, have all of the power and
authority of the Board of Directors and be entitled to indemnification and advance payment of expenses in accordance with the provisions
of this Agreement as if the liquidator were the Board of Directors. The liquidator shall give or cause to be given all notices
to creditors required by applicable Law and, in addition to any reports otherwise required by this Agreement to be given to the
Members, shall cause a proper accounting of the Company’s assets, liabilities and operations to be made and furnished to
the Members as of the date all assets of the Company are finally distributed to the Members or applied in payment of Company liabilities.


 


Section 7.3Application
and Distribution of Proceeds of Liquidation. During or upon completion of the winding up of the Company, the assets of the
Company shall be applied and distributed by the liquidator, in one or more installments, in the following order and priority:


 


(a)       to
the payment, or provision for payment, of the costs and expenses of the winding up;


 


(b)       to
the payment, or provision for payment, of creditors of the Company (including Members, other than in respect of Distributions)
in the order of priority provided by Law;


 


(c)       to
the establishment of any reserves deemed necessary or appropriate by the liquidator to provide for contingent or unforeseen liabilities
of the Company; and


 


(d)       the
balance shall be distributed to the Members in accordance with Section 5.4.


 


All Distributions to
the Members pursuant to Section 7.3(d) above shall be in the form of cash, unless the Board of Directors otherwise
determines.


 






    55


     


    

 


Section 7.4Certificate
of Cancellation. On completion of the distribution of Company assets as provided herein, the liquidator (or such other Person
or Persons as the Act may require or permit) shall file a Certificate of Cancellation with the Secretary of State of the State
of Delaware, cancel any other filings as necessary and take such other actions as may be necessary to terminate the existence of
the Company.


 


ARTICLE
VIII

LIABILITY AND INDEMNIFICATION


 


Section 8.1No
Liability for Company Debts. The debts, obligations and liabilities of the Company, whether arising in contract, tort or otherwise,
shall be solely the debts, obligations and liabilities of the Company, and no Covered Person shall be liable for any such debts,
obligations or liabilities. Additionally, except as otherwise expressly required by Law, no Member, in its capacity as a Member,
shall have any liability in excess of (a) the amount of its Capital Contributions, (b) its share of any assets and undistributed
profits of the Company, (c) its obligation to make other payments expressly provided for in this Agreement and (d) the amount of
any Distributions wrongfully distributed to it.


 


Section 8.2Indemnification.
To the fullest extent permitted by Law, the Company shall indemnify each Covered Person from and against any and all Covered Losses
arising from any and all claims, demands, causes of action, actions, suits or proceedings, whether civil, criminal, administrative
or investigative, in which such Covered Person may be involved, or is threatened to be involved, as a party or otherwise, by reason
of its status as such, regardless of whether any of the foregoing arise from the sole, partial or concurrent negligence of such
Covered Person; provided, however, that the Company shall not indemnify a Covered Person for Covered Losses arising directly
from fraud, intentional or willful misconduct, gross negligence or a knowing violation of the Law or a breach of the terms of any
Transaction Agreement that is materially related to the claim giving rise to the Covered Losses, for which the Covered Person is
seeking indemnification. The termination of any action, suit or proceeding by judgment, order, settlement or upon a plea of nolo
contendere, or its equivalent shall not, of itself, create a presumption that the Covered Person failed to meet the standards for
indemnification set forth in the immediately preceding sentence. Any indemnification hereunder shall be satisfied solely out of
the assets of the Company (subject to Section 5.6(b)). In no event may a Covered Person subject the Members to personal
liability by reason of these indemnification provisions. The indemnification provided by this Section 8.2 shall be
in addition to, but not duplicative of, any other rights to which a Covered Person or any other Person may be entitled under any
agreement to which the Company is a party, pursuant to any vote of the Members, as a matter of Law or otherwise, and shall continue
as to a Covered Person who has ceased to serve in such capacity and shall inure to the benefit of the heirs, successors, assigns
and administrators of the Covered Person.


 


Section 8.3Advance
Payment and Appearance as a Witness. To the fullest extent permitted by applicable Law, expenses (including legal fees) incurred
by a Covered Person in defending any claim, demand, cause of action, action, suit or proceeding shall, from time to time, be advanced
by the Company prior to the final disposition of such claim, demand, cause of action, action, suit or proceeding upon receipt by
the Company of an undertaking by or on behalf of the Covered Person to repay such amount if it shall be determined that the Covered
Person is not entitled to be indemnified as authorized in Section 8.2. The Company shall pay or reimburse expenses
incurred by a Person who is or was a Member, Manager, officer or employee of the Company in connection with their appearance as
a witness or other participant in a proceeding at a time when they are not a named defendant or respondent in the proceeding.


 






    56


     


    

 


Section 8.4Insurance.
The Company shall procure and maintain insurance, to the extent and in such amounts as approved by the Board of Directors, in its
sole discretion, on behalf of Covered Persons and such other Persons as the Board of Directors shall determine, against any liability
that may be asserted against or expenses that may be incurred by any such Person in connection with the activities of the Company
or such indemnities, regardless of whether the Company would have the power to indemnify such Person against such liability under
the provisions of this Agreement. The Company may enter into indemnity contracts with Covered Persons and adopt written procedures
pursuant to which arrangements are made for the advancement of expenses and the funding of obligations under Section 8.3
and containing such other procedures regarding indemnification as are appropriate. The insurance as in effect for the Company as
of the Effective Date is set forth on Exhibit F, and any reduction in the amount of insurance coverage from as set forth
on Exhibit F shall require approval of a Supermajority of the Voting Power.


 


Section 8.5Non-exclusivity
of Rights; Company as Indemnitor of First Resort. The indemnification and advancement of expenses provided by, or granted pursuant
to, this Article VIII shall not be deemed exclusive of, and shall not limit, any other rights or remedies to which
any Covered Person may be entitled or which may otherwise be available to any Covered Person at Law or in equity. The Company hereby
acknowledges that the Covered Persons may have certain rights to indemnification, advancement of expenses and/or insurance provided
by the Members and certain of their Affiliates (collectively, the “Member Indemnitors”). The Company
hereby agrees that (a) the Company is the indemnitor of first resort for matters covered by this Article VIII (i.e., its
obligations to the Covered Persons under Article VIII are primary and any obligation of the Member Indemnitors to advance
expenses or to provide indemnification for the same expenses or liabilities incurred by the Covered Persons are secondary), (b)
the Company shall be required to advance the full amount of expenses incurred by the Covered Persons and shall be liable for all
expenses, liabilities, judgments, penalties, fines and amounts paid in settlement to the extent legally permitted and as required
by the terms of Article VIII (or any other agreement between the Company and the Covered Persons), without regard to any
rights the Covered Persons may have against the Member Indemnitors, and (c) the Company irrevocably waives, relinquishes and releases
the Member Indemnitors from any and all claims against the Member Indemnitors for contribution, subrogation or any other recovery
of any kind in respect thereof. The Company further agrees that no advancement or payment by the Member Indemnitors on behalf of
a Covered Person with respect to any claim for which the Covered Person has sought indemnification from the Company pursuant to
Article VIII shall affect the foregoing and the Member Indemnitors shall have a right of contribution and/or be subrogated
to the extent of such advancement or payment to all of the rights of recovery of the Covered Persons against the Company. The Company
agrees that the Member Indemnitors who are not Members are express third party beneficiaries of the terms of this Section 8.5.


 






    57


     


    

 


Section 8.6Savings
Clause. If all or any part of this Article VIII shall be invalidated for any reason by any court of competent jurisdiction,
the Company shall nevertheless indemnify and hold harmless each Covered Person, and may indemnify and hold harmless any other Person,
for costs, charges, expenses (including attorneys’ fees), judgments, fines and amounts paid in settlement, in connection
with any claim, to the fullest extent permitted by any portion of this Article VIII not invalidated and to the fullest
extent otherwise permitted by applicable Law.


 


ARTICLE
IX

CERTAIN TAX MATTERS


 


Section 9.1Partnership
Classification. The Company will be treated as a partnership for U.S. federal (and applicable state and local) income tax purposes
and, except with the prior written consent of all Members shall not (i) convert or reorganize into any other legal form or take
any action that would result in the Company no longer being taxed as a partnership for U.S. federal income tax purposes, (ii) elect
under Treasury Regulations Section 301.7701-3 or otherwise to be taxed other than as a partnership, or (iii) elect to exclude the
Company from the application of the provisions of subchapter K of chapter 1 of subtitle A of the Code or any similar provisions
of applicable state law and no Member shall take any action inconsistent with such limitations.


 


Section 9.2Tax
Returns and Tax Information. The Manager shall cause all required federal, state, local and foreign tax returns of the Company
to be prepared and timely filed. Each Member shall furnish to the Company all pertinent information in its possession relating
to the Company, its assets and operations necessary to enable the Company’s tax returns to be prepared and timely filed.


 


Section 9.3Tax
Elections. Except as provided otherwise in this Agreement, the Board of Directors shall have the authority to make all tax
elections required or permitted to be made by the Company; provided, however, that no election shall be made to classify
the Company as an association taxable as a corporation without the consent of all the Members. The Board of Directors shall, at
the request of any Member, cause the Company to make an election under Section 754 of the Code.


 


Section 9.4Election
by Members. In the event any Member makes any tax election that requires the Company to furnish information to such Member
to enable such Member to compute its own tax liability, or requires the Company to file any tax return or report with any tax authority,
in either case that would not be required in the absence of such election made by such Member, the Manager may, as a condition
to furnishing such information or filing such return or report, require such Member to pay to the Company any incremental expenses
incurred in connection therewith.


 






    58


     


    

 


Section 9.5Tax
Matters Representative.


 


(a)       Designation
of Tax Matters Representative. The Manager is hereby designated as the “tax matters partner”, “partnership
representative” or any similar role, as applicable within the meaning of the Code and applicable state, local or foreign
tax law, and shall have all of the rights, authority and power and shall be subject to all of the obligations associated therewith
to the extent provided in the Code, the Treasury Regulations and applicable state, local or foreign tax law (the “Tax
Matters Representative”). The Tax Matters Representative shall carry out the duties and responsibilities of such
status in good faith and to the extent that any such duties or responsibilities are not routine, ministerial functions, the Tax
Matters Representative shall obtain the consent of the Board of Directors before taking (or refraining from taking) any actions
or making any decisions in respect of such duties or responsibilities.


 


(b)       Expenses
of the Tax Matters Representative. Expenses incurred by the Tax Matters Representative or in a similar capacity as set forth
in this Section 9.5, shall be borne by the Company. Such expenses shall include, without limitation fees of attorneys and
other tax professionals, accountants, appraisers and experts, filing fees and reasonable out-of-pocket costs.


 


Section 9.6Withholding.
The Company may withhold and shall timely remit to any applicable tax authority all amounts required by any Law to be withheld
by the Company from or with respect to Distributions to a Member or from or with respect to a Member’s distributive share
of Company taxable income or loss (or item thereof). Each Member shall timely provide to the Company upon request all information,
forms and certifications reasonably necessary or appropriate to enable the Company to comply with any such withholding obligation,
or to establish the Company’s legal entitlement to an exemption from, or reduction of, withholding or other taxes or similar
payments, including U.S. federal withholding tax under Sections 1471 and 1472 of the Code or the Treasury Regulations thereunder.
Further, each Member covenants to the Company that the information, forms and certifications furnished by it shall be true and
accurate in all respects. Each Member shall, upon demand by the Company, indemnify the Company for the indemnifying Member’s
share of any such withholding and all related costs and expenses of the Company. Any amounts so withheld in respect of a Member
shall be treated as a distribution to such Member for all purposes of this Agreement.


 


ARTICLE
X

BOOKS AND RECORDS; REPORTS


 


Section 10.1Maintenance
of and Access to Books and Records. At all times until the dissolution and termination of the Company, the Company shall maintain
separate books of account that show a true and accurate record of all costs and expenses incurred, all charges made, all credits
made and received and all income derived in connection with the conduct of the business of the Company in accordance with this
Agreement. In addition, the Company shall keep and maintain at its principal office all Records and information required to be
kept and maintained in accordance with the Act and shall make such information available to any Member or representative requesting
the same within five (5) days after receipt of a written request by the Company. The Board of Directors shall permit each of the
Members, from time to time and at reasonable intervals, (i) to examine, audit and make copies of the Records of the Company as
well as all such other data and information in the possession or control of the Board of Directors concerning the Company, Company
properties and the ownership and operation thereof, which Records shall be available to the Members or their representatives at
all reasonable times at the principal office of the Company, or at such other office where such information is maintained, upon
the written request of any Member, and (ii) to discuss the business, financial condition and results of operations of the Company
with officers, accountants, and other representatives of the Company.


 






    59


     


    

 


Section 10.2Bank
Accounts. The Board of Directors shall cause to be established and maintained for and in the name of the Company one or more
bank or investment accounts or arrangements. All Company funds shall be deposited in such account(s) and shall not be commingled
with funds of any other Person. All deposits to and disbursements from such account(s) shall be made only for proper Company purposes
and shall be signed by one or more authorized signatories designated by the Board of Directors.


 


Section 10.3Reports.
The Company shall furnish the following to the Members:


 


(a)       Within
45 days after the end of each calendar month: (i) a written report by the Company’s management describing the results of
operations of the Company, including any applicable qualitative analysis comparing the Company’s performance with prior periods,
for such calendar month; and (ii) a report of the Manager with respect to the operational status of the Company and each of its
Subsidiaries for such monthly period, including progress on capital projects included in the Budget for such calendar month, and
a Budget to actual variance analysis;


 


(b)       Within
60 days after the end of each Fiscal Quarter: (i) an unaudited consolidated balance sheet as of the end of such Fiscal Quarter
and unaudited related statement of operations and statement of cash flows for such Fiscal Quarter including any footnotes thereto
(if any) prepared in accordance with GAAP, consistently applied; (ii) a written report by the Company’s management describing
the results of operations of the Company, including any applicable qualitative analysis comparing the Company’s performance
with prior periods, for such Fiscal Quarter; and (iii) a report of the Manager with respect to the operational status of the Company
and each of its Subsidiaries for such quarterly period, including progress on capital projects included in the Budget for such
calendar quarter, and a Budget to actual variance analysis;


 


(c)       (i) Within
60 days after the end of each Fiscal Year, an estimated Schedule K-1, and (ii) within 90 days after the end of each Fiscal Year,
a final Schedule K-1;


 


(d)       Within
90 days after the end of each Fiscal Year (beginning with the 2017 Fiscal Year) (i) an audited consolidated balance sheet as of
the end of such Fiscal Year and the related consolidated statement of operations, statement of members’ equity and statement
of cash flows for such Fiscal Year prepared in accordance with GAAP; (ii) a written report by the Company’s management describing
the results of operations of the Company, including any applicable qualitative analysis comparing the Company’s performance
with prior periods, for such Fiscal Year; and (iii) a report of the Manager with respect to the operational status of the Company
and each of its subsidiaries for such yearly period and a Budget to actual variance analysis;


 


(e)       Upon
the written request of a Member and at such Member’s expense and provided it can be furnished upon exercise of reasonable
commercial efforts, such additional information necessary for the preparation of any state, local and foreign income tax return
that must be filed by such Member;


 






    60


     


    

 


(f)       Promptly
after the occurrence of any event that has, or could reasonably be expected to have, individually or in the aggregate, a material
adverse effect on the business, results of operations, condition, assets, liabilities, employees, prospects, financial condition
or capitalization of the Company, notice of such event together with a summary describing the nature of the event and its impact
on the Company;


 


(g)       Within
90 days after the end of each Fiscal Year, the Company shall furnish to the Members an engineering report prepared by the independent
petroleum engineers of the Company, which report will set forth estimates of the proved, probable and possible oil and gas reserves
of the Company as of the preceding January 1 of such Fiscal Year and net revenues expected to be derived therefrom;


 


(h)       Within
five (5) days after delivery pursuant to a Credit Facility, copies of all reports, notices, certifications and other information
delivered to the agent, lenders or other counterparties to any Credit Facility; and


 


(i)       With
reasonable promptness, the Board of Directors shall cause the Company to furnish to each of the Members such other information
and financial data concerning the Company and its business, operations, assets, liabilities, financial condition and results of
operations as any such Member may reasonably request.


 


Section 10.4Fiscal
Year. The fiscal year of the Company shall be the calendar year (“Fiscal Year”). The Company shall
have the same Fiscal Year for U.S. federal income tax purposes and for accounting purposes.


 


ARTICLE
XI

DEFINITIONS


 


Section 11.1Definitions.
Except as otherwise required by the context, the following terms shall have the following meanings:


 


“A/C Sharing
Percentage” means, (i) until an aggregate of $100,000,000 has been distributed by the Company pursuant to Section
5.4 and Section 5.5 (x) 99% to the holders of Class A Units, as a class, and (y) 1% to the holder of Class C Units and
(ii) thereafter, (x) as to the holders of Class A Units, as a class, a fraction (expressed as a percentage), the numerator of which
is the total number of Class A Units outstanding and the denominator of which is the total number of Class A Units and Class C
Units outstanding and (y) as to the holder of Class C Units, a fraction (expressed as a percentage), the numerator of which is
the total number of Class C Units outstanding and the denominator of which is the total number of Class A Units and Class C Units
outstanding.


 


“Act”
means the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act, as amended from time to time, or any successor statute thereto.


 






    61


     


    

 


“Adjusted
Capital Account” means, as of the end of each Fiscal Year, the balance in a Member’s Capital Account (i) increased
by (A) any additional Capital Contributions the Member makes or is obligated to make, or is treated as obligated to make pursuant
to the provisions of Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(c), (B) the amount of the Member’s share of any Company
Minimum Gain, and (C) the amount of the Member’s share of any Member Nonrecourse Debt Minimum Gain, and (ii) decreased by
any adjustments, allocations or distributions described in Treasury Regulations Sections 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), (5) and (6).
This definition shall be interpreted and applied consistently with the provisions of Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d).


 


“Adjusted
Capital Account Deficit” means, with respect to any Member, the deficit balance, if any in such Member’s Adjusted
Capital Account as of the end of the Fiscal Year, after giving effect to the following adjustments:


 


(i)       Credit
to such Adjusted Capital Account any amounts which such Member is obligated to restore pursuant to any provision of this Agreement
or is deemed obligated to restore pursuant to the penultimate sentences of Treasury Regulations Sections 1.704-2(g)(1) and 1.704-2(i)(5);
and


 


(ii)       Debit
to such Adjusted Capital Account the items described in Treasury Regulations Sections 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(5)
and 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(6).


 


The foregoing definition
of “Adjusted Capital Account Deficit” is intended to comply with the provisions of Treasury Regulations
Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d) and shall be interpreted consistently therewith.


 


“Administrative
Expenses” means Company Expenses as described in clause (i) and clause (ii) of the definition of Company Expenses.


 


“Affiliate”
means, with respect to any Person, any other Person that directly, or indirectly through one or more intermediaries, Controls,
is Controlled by, or is under common Control with, such Person.


 


“Available
Cash” means the sum of (i) gross cash proceeds from the operations of the Company or its Subsidiaries, as applicable
(including sales and dispositions of property whether or not in the ordinary course of business), (ii) any net cash proceeds from
any issuance of equity or refinancing of debt or new debt issuance or incurrence, and (iii) other cash on hand less amounts used
to pay or establish reserves for all expenses of the Company or its Subsidiaries, as applicable (including general and administrative
expenses, contract and marketing costs, debt payments, taxes, capital expenditures, replacements, future acquisitions and investments
and contingencies), all as reasonably determined on a periodic basis by the Board.


 


“Affiliate
Contract” means any contract between the Company, on the one hand, and any Member or any of its Affiliates, on the
other hand (excluding this Agreement).


 


“AMI”
means any lands depicted in Exhibit G attached hereto, provided that, if the Board of Directors approves the
Company conducting business outside of these lands, the AMI shall be automatically revised to include the lands underlying the
area or areas reasonably encompassed by the Board’s election.


 






    62


     


    

 


“Book Basis”
means, with respect to each Company asset, the adjusted basis of the asset for U.S. federal income tax purposes, except that (i)
the initial Book Basis of an asset other than money contributed by a Member to the Company shall be the fair market value of the
asset on the date of contribution, as agreed by the contributor and the Board of Directors, (ii) upon the occurrence of a Revaluation
Event, the Book Basis of all Company assets (including intangibles) shall be adjusted to their respective fair market values on
such date, as determined by the Board of Directors, (iii) the Book Basis of any Company asset distributed to any Member will be
adjusted to equal the fair market value of such asset on the date of distribution as agreed by the Board of Directors and the recipient,
(iv) the Book Basis of Company assets shall be increased (or decreased) to reflect any adjustments to the adjusted basis of such
assets pursuant to Code Section 734(b) or Code Section 743(b), but only to the extent that such adjustments are taken into account
in determining Capital Accounts pursuant to Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(m) and Section 5.2(f); provided,
however, that Book Basis shall be adjusted pursuant to clause (ii) above only if the Board of Directors determines such adjustments
are necessary or appropriate, and (v) if the Book Basis of any Company asset has been determined pursuant to the preceding subsections
(i), (ii) or (iv), the Book Basis of the asset shall thereafter be adjusted by Simulated Depletion Deductions or Book Depreciation
in lieu of any depletion, depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deductions otherwise allowable for U.S. federal income
tax purposes.


 


“Book Depreciation”
means, with respect to any depreciable or amortizable Company asset, an amount that bears the same ratio to the Book Basis of such
asset as the amount of depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deductions with respect to such asset, computed for U.S.
federal income tax purposes, bears to the adjusted tax basis of such asset; provided, however, that, if the adjusted tax
basis of the asset is zero, Book Depreciation shall be determined under any reasonable method selected by the Board of Directors,
and; provided, further, if such asset is subject to adjustments under the remedial allocation method of Treasury Regulations Section
1.704-3(d), Book Depreciation shall be determined under Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-3(d)(2).


 


“Budget”
means the annual capital and operating budget of the Company and each of its Subsidiaries as approved by the Board.


 


“Business
Day” means a day, other than Saturday, Sunday or any other day on which commercial banks in Denver, Colorado or New
York, New York are authorized or required by Law to close.


 


“Capital
Account” means the account established for each Member pursuant to Section 4.3.


 


“Capital
Contribution” means the amount of money and the initial Book Basis of any asset other than money (net of liabilities
secured thereby that the Company is treated as having assumed or taken subject to pursuant to Code Section 752) contributed by
a Member or a Member’s predecessors in interest to the capital of the Company, including Optional Contributions.


 






    63


     


    

 


“Capital
Interest Percentage” means, at any time of determination and as to any Member, the percentage of the total distributions
that would be made to such Member if the assets of the Company were sold for their respective Book Basis, all liabilities of the
Company were paid in accordance with their terms (limited in the case of non-recourse liabilities to the Book Basis of the property
securing such liabilities), all items of Company income, gain, loss and deduction were allocated to the Members in accordance with
Section 5.1 and Section 5.2, and the resulting net proceeds were distributed to the Members in accordance with Section
7.3; provided, however, that the Board may determine that the Members’ Capital Interest Percentages should
be determined based upon a hypothetical sale of the assets of the Company for their respective Fair Market Value (instead of Book
Basis) in order to ensure that such percentages correspond to the Members’ “proportionate interests in partnership
capital” as defined in Treasury Regulations Section 1.613A-3(e)(2)(ii). The foregoing definition of Capital Interest Percentage
is intended to result in a percentage for each Member that corresponds with the Member’s “proportionate interest in
partnership capital” as defined in Treasury Regulations Section 1.613A-3(e)(2)(ii), and Capital Interest Percentage shall
be interpreted consistently therewith.


 


“Class
A Member” means a Member holding Class A Units, in its capacity as a holder of Class A Units.


 


“Class
A Sharing Percentage”, with respect to each holder of Class A Units, shall equal the aggregate Class A Units held
by such holder of Class A Units through the date of determination, divided by the aggregate Class A Units held by all holders of
Class A Units of the Company through the date of determination .


 


“Class
A Unit Price” means:


 


(i)       One
Thousand Dollars ($1,000.00) per Class A Unit for each Class A Unit until the Commitment Release Point; and


 


(ii)       thereafter,
an amount equal to the Fair Market Value of a Class A Unit immediately after giving effect to the Capital Contribution with respect
to which such Class A Unit is being issued.


 


“Class
B Member” means a Member holding Class B Units, in its capacity as a holder of Class B Units.


 


“Class
C Member” means a Member holding Class C Units, in its capacity as a holder of Class C Units.


 


“CNX Acquisition”
means the transactions contemplated by the CNX PSA.


 


“CNX PSA”
means that certain Purchase and Sale Agreement, dated February 17, 2017, by and between CNX Gas Company LLC (as seller) and the
Company (as buyer).


 


“Code”
means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (including any corresponding provisions of succeeding law).


 






    64


     


    

 


“Company
Expenses” means all costs, expenses, liabilities and obligations relating to the Company’s activities, investments
and business (to the extent not borne or reimbursed by a Subsidiary of the Company), including (i) all costs, expenses, liabilities
and obligations attributable to the formation and organization of the Company and acquiring, holding and disposing of the Company’s
investments, (ii) legal, auditing, insurance (including directors and officers and errors and omissions liability insurance), and
accounting expenses, including expenses incurred in connection with the maintenance of the Company’s books of account and
other records and the preparation and distribution of audited or unaudited financial statements of the Company, the cost of the
preparation and distribution of tax returns and Schedule K-1s (included fees and expenses of independent auditors, accountants
and counsel) and other routine administrative expenses of the Company or its Subsidiaries, (iii) all expenses incurred in connection
with any indebtedness of the Company or other credit arrangement (including any line of credit, loan commitment or letter of credit)
for the Company or related to the Company’s investments, (iv) litigation and indemnification costs and expenses, judgments
and settlements, including indemnification obligations under Article III, (vi) consulting, financing, appraisal, filing
and other fees and expenses (including expenses associated with the preparation or distribution of the Company’s financial
statements, and (vii) any taxes, fees and other governmental charges levied against the Company.


 


“Company
Minimum Gain” shall have the same meaning as “partnership minimum gain” set forth in Treasury Regulations
Section 1.704-2(b)(2) and Section 1.704-2(d).


 


“Company
Sale Value” means the amount that the Company would receive in an all cash sale of all of the Company’s assets
and businesses as a going concern (free and clear of all Liens and after use of proceeds for the payment of indebtedness for borrowed
money and other outstanding obligations) in an arm’s length transaction with an unaffiliated third-party consummated immediately
preceding the event giving rise to the determination of the Company Sale Value (assuming that all of the proceeds of such sale
were paid directly to the Company).


 


“Confidential
Information” means any proprietary or confidential information of or relating to the Company or, with respect to
each Member, the other Members, including any business information, intellectual property, trade secrets or other information relating
to the respective businesses, operations, assets or liabilities of the Company or the Members; provided, however, that any
information that is generally available to the public (other than through a breach by the party disclosing the same of its obligations
under this Agreement) shall not be deemed “Confidential Information.”


 


“Conflict
Activity” means (a) the negotiation and execution by the Company of any Affiliate Contract or any amendment to or
termination of any Affiliate Contract, (b) the waiver of any of the Company’s rights, or the granting of any consent or approval
by the Company, under this Agreement (as to any Member) or any Affiliate Contract, (c) the enforcement of any rights of the Company
under this Agreement (as to any Member) or with respect to any Affiliate Contract, including enforcing any rights of the Company
under this Agreement or any Affiliate Contract in connection with any breach or default (or alleged breach or default) thereunder
by the Conflicted Member (or its Affiliates) or for making or enforcing any claims by the Company or for indemnification under
this Agreement or any Affiliate Contract or in connection with any dispute with a Conflicted Member (or any of its Affiliates)
under any Affiliate Contract, (d) the enforcement of any rights of the Company or any Member under this Agreement or any Affiliate
Contract in connection with any bankruptcy, reorganization, liquidation or dissolution of the Conflicted Member or (e) the exercise
of discretionary rights by the Company under this Agreement (as to any Member) or any Affiliate Contract.


 






    65


     


    

 


“Conflicted
Member” means a Member that is (or has an Affiliate that is): (i) the counterparty to the Company under an Affiliate
Contract or (ii) the adversary or counterparty opposite the Company on any other transaction or dispute giving rise to a Conflict
Activity.


 


“Contract
Operating Agreement” means that certain Contract Operating Agreement, dated as of February 23, 2017, by and between
Nytis LLC and the Company.


 


“Control,”
“Controlling” and “Controlled by” mean the ability (directly or indirectly
through one or more intermediaries) to direct or cause the direction of the management or affairs of a Person, whether through
the ownership of voting interests, by contract or otherwise.


 


“Covered
Losses” means any and all losses, assessments, fines, penalties, administrative orders, obligations, judgments, amounts
paid in settlement, costs, expenses, liabilities and damages (whether actual, consequential or punitive), including interest, penalties,
reasonable court costs and attorneys’ fees, disbursements and costs of investigations, deficiencies, levies, duties and imposts.


 


“Covered
Person” means (i) any Member, any Affiliate of a Member or any shareholder, partner, member, manager, director, officer,
employee, representative or agent of a Member or any of its Affiliates, (ii) any officer of the Company, (iii) the Manager, and
(iv) any member of the Board of Directors, in each case to the extent any such Person is acting in such capacity in connection
with the business of the Company.


 


“Credit
Agreement” means that certain Credit Agreement, dated as of [__], 2017, by and among Carbon Tennessee Company,
LLC (as borrower), LegacyTexas Bank (as administrative agent, L/C issuer, sole lead arranger and sole book runner), and the lender
parties thereto, as may be amended, restated, modified or supplemented in accordance with its terms.


 


“Credit
Facility” means the Credit Agreement and any other agreement for indebtedness for borrowed money or commodity or
interests rate swap, collar or other hedging transactions to which the Company or any Subsidiary of the Company is a party.


 


“Current
Market Value” when used with reference to any capital stock or other security on any date means: (i) if the capital
stock or security is then listed or admitted to trading on a national securities exchange, is quoted on the OTC Bulletin Board
or is quoted on any other interdealer quotation system or regularly quoted by member firms of the Financial Industry Regulatory
Authority, the volume weighted average of the trading prices of such security on the date of determination (if a trading day) and
on each of the five (5) trading days immediately preceding, and on each of the five (5) trading days immediately following, the
date of the determination (any such capital stock or security so listed, traded or quoted being referred to as “Publicly
Traded”) or (ii) if the capital stock or security is not Publicly Traded, the Fair Market Value of such capital stock
or security.


 






    66


     


    

 


“Drilling
and Completion Activities” shall have the meaning given such term in the Participation Agreement.


 


“Electronic
Transmission” means a form of communication that (i) does not directly involve the physical transmission of paper,
(ii) creates a record that may be retained, retrieved, and reviewed by the recipient, and (iii) may be directly reproduced in paper
form by the recipient through an automated process.


 


“Emergency
Expenditures” means expenditures which are reasonably necessary to be expended in order to mitigate or remedy the
endangerment of property, the health or safety of any Person or the environment.


 


“Excluded
Affiliate Transfer” means (i) any Transfer of Units by a Member who is an individual to a member of such Member’s
family or to a trust or similar entity for estate planning purposes, but only if the Member retains the right to vote such Interest
following such Transfer; (ii) any Transfer occurring by operation of law upon the death or mental incapacity of a Member who is
an individual; (iii) any Transfer of Units by a Member which is a trust to the principal beneficiary of that trust; or (iv) any
Transfer of Units by a Member which is a partnership, limited partnership, limited liability company, corporation or other entity
organized, formed or incorporated to an Affiliate; provided that, in the case of any Transfer described in clauses (i)-(iv), such
transferee agrees to be bound by the terms of this Agreement and evidences same by executing a copy of this Agreement prior to
receiving the assignment of such Units .


 


“Existing
Assets” means Nytis LLC’s interest in the Tennessee
Mining Tract and any other oil and gas assets in which Carbon or any of its Affiliates have an interest as of the date hereof
that are not included in the Participation Assets.


 


“Fair Market
Value” means the fair market value as determined by the Board pursuant to Section 2.13. In determining the
Fair Market Value of any non-cash property, all factors which the Board determines might reasonably affect such value shall be
taken into account; provided, however, that (i) the Fair Market Value of any non-cash property that consists of Publicly
Traded securities or similar instruments shall be the Current Market Value thereof, determined by reference to a record date which
shall be fixed by the Board as of a date not less than five (5) trading days before and no more than ten (10) trading days before
the proposed action requiring a determination of Fair Market Value of any such non cash property and (ii) in no event shall any
non-cash property be valued at less than the price at which the Company can require a third Person to buy the non-cash property,
taking into account the creditworthiness of the Person with such purchase obligation, the availability of any collateral for the
obligation, and other factors that the Board deems appropriate. The Fair Market Value shall be determined without reduction based
upon any lack of control, minority ownership, marketability or other similar discounts.


 


“Fiscal
Quarter” means any three-month period commencing on January 1, April 1, July 1 and October 1
and ending on the last date before the next such date.


 


“GAAP”
means United States generally accepted accounting principles.


 


“Governmental
Authority” means any nation or government, any state, city, municipality or political subdivision thereof, any federal
or state court and any other agency, body, authority or entity exercising executive, legislative, judicial, regulatory or administrative
functions of or pertaining to government.


 






    67


     


    

 


“Indebtedness”
means (without duplication), with respect to any Person, any indebtedness of such Person in respect of borrowed money or evidenced
by bonds, notes, debentures or similar instruments or letters of credit (or reimbursement agreement in respect thereof) or representing
capital lease obligations or the balance deferred and unpaid of the purchase price of any property (except any such balance that
constitutes an accrued expense or trade payable arising in the ordinary course of business), if and to the extent any of the foregoing
indebtedness would appear as a liability upon a balance sheet of such Person prepared in accordance with GAAP, as well as all indebtedness
of others secured by a Lien on any asset of such Person (whether or not such indebtedness is assumed by such Person) and, to the
extent not otherwise included, the guarantee by such Person of any indebtedness of any other Person.


 


“Initial
Class A Funding Percentage” means (i) as to Carbon, 2.0%, (ii) as to Yorktown, 24.5% and (iii) as to Old Ironsides,
73.5%.


 


“Internal
Rate of Return” means, with respect to each Class A Unit as of any distribution date, the annual percentage rate,
which when utilized to calculate the present value of all distributions (i.e., cash inflows) received by the holder of such Class
A Unit from the Company with respect to such Class A Unit shall cause such present value to equal the present value of all Capital
Contributions (i.e., cash outflows) made with respect to such Class A Unit. In order for a holder of a Class A Unit to receive
a positive Internal Rate of Return, a holder must receive an aggregate amount equal to (a) its aggregate Capital Contributions
made to the Company during the term of this Agreement on account of or in exchange for such Class A Unit, plus (b) a return thereon.
The Internal Rate of Return with respect to a Class A Unit, at any distribution date, shall be computed with annual compounding.
For purposes of computing such Internal Rate of Return, (i) each Capital Contribution made on account of or in exchange for such
Class A Unit shall be treated as a Capital Contribution made on the applicable date specified in a Capital Call Notice and (ii)
each distribution or payment of non-cash property received with respect to such Class A Unit at such distribution date shall be
treated as a distribution on such distribution date; provided, however, that for purposes of calculating the Internal Rate
of Return with respect to a Class A Unit, the holder of such Class A Unit shall be deemed to have received cash in an amount equal
to the Fair Market Value of all non-cash property distributed (or deemed distributed) with respect to such Class A Unit by the
Company.


 


“Internal
Restructure” means any re-formation, Conversion, transfer of assets, transfer of membership interests or other securities,
merger, incorporation, liquidation or other transaction of, or relating to, or affecting the Company, completed in compliance with
Section 6.10.


 


“Interest”
means, with respect to any Member, the entire interest of such Member in the Company, including (i) Units, (ii) the right of such
Member to share in the profits of the Company, (iii) the right of such Member to Distributions and (iv) the right of such Member,
if any, to participate in the management of the affairs of the Company.


 


“Investment
Advisers Act” means the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended.


 






    68


     


    

 


“Investment
Company Act” means the Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended.


 


“IPT Eligible
Member” means for purposes of Section 6.5(b)(i) and (ii), (A) if Old Ironsides is the Subject Company,
Yorktown and its Permitted Transferees holding Class A Units, or (B) if Yorktown or Carbon is the Subject Company, Old Ironsides
and its Permitted Transferees holding Class A Units.


 


“Law”
means any applicable constitutional provision, statute, act, code, law, regulation, rule, ordinance, order, decree, ruling, proclamation,
resolution, judgment, decision, declaration, or interpretative or advisory opinion or letter of a Governmental Authority having
valid jurisdiction.


 


“Lien”
means any mortgage, lien (statutory or other), other security agreement, arrangement or interest, hypothecation, pledge or other
deposit arrangement, assignment, charge, levy, executory seizure, attachment, garnishment, encumbrance (including any easement,
exception, reservation or limitation, right of way, and the like), conditional sale, title retention, voting agreement or other
similar agreement, arrangement, device or restriction, preemptive or similar right, the filing of any financing statement under
the Uniform Commercial Code or comparable law of any jurisdiction, or restriction on sale, transfer, assignment, disposition or
other alienation, provided, however, that the term “Lien” shall not include any of the foregoing to the extent
created by this Agreement.


 


“Liquidity
Event” means any event wherein cash or cash equivalent proceeds to the Members on account of their respective Units
are generated outside the ordinary operation of the Company in conjunction with (i) a sale, in one or a series of transactions,
of all or substantially all of the assets of the Company, (ii) a sale by the Members of all of the equity of the Company (through
a sale, merger or similar transaction), or (iii) a Public Offering.


 


“Majority
Vote” means the affirmative vote of Members whose aggregate Class A Sharing Percentages exceed 50%; provided as long
as Old Ironsides owns any Class A Units the affirmative vote of Old Ironsides shall be required to constitute a Majority Vote.


 


“Management
Services Agreement” means that certain Management Services Agreement, dated as of the Effective Date, by and between
the Company and Carbon.


 


“Manager”
shall be the Person from time to time designated by the Board as “Manager” for purposes of this Agreement; Carbon shall
be the “Manager” unless otherwise determined by the Board pursuant to Section 2.4(a)(xvii).


 


“Marketable
Securities” means Securities (a) that are traded on an established U.S. or non-U.S. securities exchange, (b) that
are reported through an established U.S. or non-U.S. over-the-counter trading system or (c) that the Board reasonably believes
are eligible for immediate sale by any Member to which such Securities are distributed (assuming that such Member is not an Affiliate
of the issuer of such Securities), in each case that are not subject to any material restrictions on transfer (generally applicable
to the distributees thereof) under the Securities Act or other applicable securities laws or as a result of any applicable contractual
provisions.


 


“Member
Nonrecourse Deductions” shall have the same meaning as the term “partner nonrecourse deductions” set
forth in Treasury Regulations Section 1.704 2(i)(2).


 






    69


     


    

 


“Member
Nonrecourse Debt Minimum Gain” shall have the same meaning as the term “partner nonrecourse debt minimum gain”
set forth in Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-2(i)(2).


 


“Members”
means any Person admitted as a member of the Company as of the date hereof or at any time hereafter in accordance with this Agreement
(but such term does not include any Person who has ceased to be a member of the Company).


 


“Net Income”
and “Net Loss” means, the taxable income or loss of the Company, as the case may be, as determined in
accordance with Code Section 703(a) for U.S. federal income tax purposes as of the close of each of the Fiscal Years of the Company,
computed with the following adjustments:


 


(a)       Any
income of the Company that is exempt from U.S. federal income tax and not otherwise taken into account in computing Net Income
or Net Losses pursuant to this definition of Net Income and Net Losses will increase the amount of such income and/or decrease
the amount of such loss;


 


(b)       Expenditures
described in Section 705(a)(2)(B) of the Code or those treated as a Code Section 705(a)(2)(B) expenditure pursuant to Treasury
Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(i), and not otherwise taken into account in computing Net Income or Net Loss pursuant to
this definition will be treated as deductible expenses;


 


(c)       In
lieu of the depreciation, amortization and other cost recovery deductions taken into account in computing such taxable income or
loss, there shall be taken into account Book Depreciation for such Fiscal Year or other period;


 


(d)       Gain
or loss from the disposition of any Company asset that has a Book Basis that differs from the asset’s adjusted tax basis,
will be computed based upon the Book Basis (rather than the adjusted tax basis) of such asset;


 


(e)       Any
increase or decrease to Book Basis resulting from a Revaluation Event or from the distribution of any Company asset to a Member
shall be included in the computation of Net Income or Net Loss;


 


(f)       gain
resulting from any disposition of an Oil and Gas Property shall be treated as being equal to the corresponding Simulated Gain;
and


 


(g)       Any
items of income, gain, loss, or deduction allocated pursuant to any provision of Section 5.2 will be excluded from
the computation of Net Income and Net Loss for purposes of applying Section 5.1.


 


“Non-Conflicted
Member” means, in the context of a Conflict Activity, a Member that is not the Conflicted Member.


 






    70


     


    

 


“Nonrecourse
Deductions” has the meaning set forth in in Treasury Regulations Sections 1.704-2(b)(1) and 1.704-2(c).


 


“Oil and
Gas Property” means each separate oil and gas property (as defined in Section 614 of the Code and the applicable
Treasury Regulations) held by the Company or any of its Subsidiaries.


 


“OpCo”
means Carbon Tennessee Mining Company, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, which is a direct, wholly-owned Subsidiary of
the Company.


 


“Parent”
means, with respect to any legal entity, any other legal entity that Controls such first legal entity.


 


“Participation
Assets” means the right, title and interests of Carbon in all of the existing undeveloped leasehold, undrilled prospects,
rights in joint operating agreements and the like, related to Carbon’s Tennessee Mining Tract properties, that are the subject
of the Participation Agreement.


 


“Permitted
Transferee” means, as to any Member, any Affiliate of such Member or any other transferee of such Member in an Excluded
Affiliate Transfer.


 


“Person”
has the meaning given to such term in the Act.


 


“Primary
JOA” means the “Operating Agreement” as such term is defined in the Participation Agreement.


 


“Priority
Amount” means, at the time of any distribution pursuant to Section 5.4, with respect to each Class A
Unit, the amount that would be required to be distributed to the holder of such Class A Unit at such time to cause the cumulative
amount of distributions made pursuant to Section 5.4 and Section 5.5 (to the extent treated as an advanced
distribution under Section 5.4) on account of such Class A Unit to provide an Internal Rate of Return of ten percent
(10%) on the aggregate amount of all funded Capital Contributions made to the Company on account of or in exchange for such Class
A Unit, including a return of the aggregate amount of all funded Capital Contributions made to the Company on account of or in
exchange for such Class A Unit.


 


“Project”
means such projects as may be selected by the Manager for the acquisition, ownership, management, maintenance and operation of
oil and gas leases, lease options or other interests in oil and gas properties and seismic data and other rights of entitlement
that are acquired by the Company or any of its Subsidiaries.


 


“Prudent
Industry Practices” means, at a particular time, any of the practices, methods, standards of care, skill, safety
and diligence, as the same may change from time to time, but applied in light of the facts known at the time, that are consistent
with the general standards applied or utilized under comparable circumstances by a reasonably prudent operator, in a good and workmanlike
manner, with due diligence and dispatch, in accordance with good upstream industry practice.


 






    71


     


    

 


“Public
Offering” means the sale in a firm underwritten public offering registered under the Securities Act of any class
of equity securities of the Company (or any successor thereto).


 


“Qualified
Appraiser” means an investment bank or appraisal firm with experience in valuing businesses or non–public securities
in the upstream oil and gas industry.


 


“Records”
means all books, records and other documentation, both written and electronic, customarily used to conduct an oil and gas exploration
and development business.


 


“Required
Representations” means, with respect to any Member involved in a Transfer of its Interests, representations and warranties
by such Member with respect to its ownership of such Transferred Interests free and clear of all Liens and its authority to sell
such Transferred Interests.


 


“Revaluation
Event” means, except as otherwise agreed by the Board of Directors, (i) the acquisition of an additional Interest
in the Company by any new or existing Member in exchange for more than a de minimis Capital Contribution, (ii) the Distribution
by the Company to a Member of more than a de minimis amount of money or other property as consideration for an Interest
in the Company, (iii) the liquidation of the Company within the meaning of Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(g), (iv)
the grant of an Interest as consideration for the provision of services to or for the benefit of the Company by an existing Member
acting in a Member capacity or by a new Member acting in a Member capacity in anticipation of becoming a Member and (v) at such
other times as the Board may reasonably determine to be necessary or advisable in order to comply with Treasury Regulations Sections
1.704–1(b) and 1.704–2.


 


“Securities
Act” means the Securities Act of 1933, as amended.


 


“Simulated
Basis” means the Book Basis of any Oil and Gas Property.


 


“Simulated
Depletion Deductions” means the simulated depletion allowance computed by the Company with respect to its Oil and
Gas Properties pursuant to Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(k)(2). For purposes of computing Simulated Depletion
Deductions with respect to any Oil and Gas Property, the Simulated Basis of such property shall be deemed to be the Book Basis
of such property, and in no event shall such allowance, in the aggregate, exceed such Simulated Basis. For purposes of computing
Simulated Depletion Deductions, the Company will apply on a property by property basis the simulated cost depletion method or the
simulated percentage depletion method under Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(k)(2), as reasonably determined by the
Manager.


 


“Simulated
Gain” or “Simulated Loss” means the simulated gain or simulated loss computed by the Company
with respect to its Oil and Gas Properties pursuant to Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(k)(2).


 


“Subsidiary”
means, with respect to any Person, any corporation, limited liability company, partnership or other entity (i) of which equity
securities or other ownership interests having ordinary voting power to elect a majority of the board of directors or other similar
managing body of such corporation, limited liability company, partnership or other entity or having the right to more than 50%
of the distributions to be made by such corporation, limited liability company, partnership or other entity (either generally or
upon liquidation of such corporation, limited liability company, partnership or other entity) are at the time owned by such Person
or (ii) the management of which is otherwise Controlled by such Person.


 






    72


     


    

 


“Tax Liability
Deficiency” means an amount equal to the product of (a) the highest combined U.S. federal, state and local income
tax rates (including for this purpose any tax under Code Section 1411 or similar provisions of law) applicable to an individual
or corporation (whichever is higher) resident in New York, New York, multiplied by (b) the amount of the Company’s U.S. federal
taxable income (net of current year federal taxable losses) for the current taxable year (and as estimated by the Board for any
period for which a federal information return has not been filed) allocated to the Members pursuant to this Agreement (ignoring,
for this purpose, any allocations pursuant to Code Section 704(c) and the Treasury Regulations thereunder).


 


“Transfer”
means to sell, or in any other way directly or indirectly transfer, assign, distribute, convey, gift, abandon, hypothecate, encumber,
pledge, mortgage or otherwise dispose of, either voluntarily or involuntarily or by operation of law; and “Transferring”
means the act of making a Transfer; and “Transferred” means the condition of a Transfer having occurred.


 


“Treasury
Regulations” means temporary and final regulations promulgated under the Code by the United States Department of
the Treasury, as amended (including any corresponding provisions of succeeding regulations).


 


“Ultimate
Parent” means (a) subject to clause (b), (i) with respect to Old Ironsides, Old Ironsides Energy Fund II GP,
LLC, (ii) with respect to Carbon, Carbon Natural Gas Company, (iii) with respect to Yorktown, Yorktown XI Associates LLC, and (iv)
with respect to any other Member, the Person designated by the Board reasonably and in good faith as the Person that ultimately
Controls such Member upon its admission as a Member and (b) upon a Change of Control of the Ultimate Parent of a holder of Units,
the Person that ultimately Controls such holder of Units following such Change in Control.


 


“Unfunded
Amount” means, as the context requires, (a) that portion of a Capital Call that a Defaulting Member was required
to contribute but failed to timely contribute (after giving effect to the Default Cure Period) or (b) that portion of a Capital
Call that a Shortfall Member was entitled to contribute but failed to timely contribute (after giving effect to the Shortfall Cure
Period).


 


“Units”
mean the Class A Units, the Class B Units and the Class C Units.


 


Section 11.2Other
Defined Terms. Each of the terms is defined in the provision of the Agreement identified opposite such term in the following
table:


 


	Term	 	Provision
	Act	 	Recitals
	Agreement	 	Preamble
	Approved Exit	 	Section 6.5(c)
	Baseline Budget	 	Section 2.8(b)
	Board of Directors or Board	 	Section 2.1(a)
	Board of Directors Designee	 	Section 2.2(d)
	Business Opportunity	 	Section 3.4(b)(iii)
	Buy/Sell Election Notice	 	Section 6.6(b)
	Buy/Sell Unit Price	 	Section 6.6(a)
	Capital Call Notice	 	Section 4.1(c)
	Capital Calls	 	Section 4.1(c)
	Capital Commitment	 	Section 4.1(d)
	Carbon	 	Preamble
	Carbon Designee	 	Section 2.2(c)
	Certificate of Formation	 	Section 1.1(a)
	Class A Units	 	Section 3.1(a)
	Class B Units	 	Section 3.1(a)
	Class C Units	 	Section 3.1(a)
	Class C Non-Cash Capital Contribution	 	Section 4.1(a)
	Commitment Reduction Date	 	Section 4.1(g)
	Commitment Release Point	 	Section 4.1(h)
	Company	 	Preamble
	Conversion	 	Section 6.10(c)
	Conversion Consideration	 	Section 6.10(c)
	Cure Notice	 	Section 6.4(d)
	Cure Period	 	Section 6.4(d)
	Default Cure Period	 	Section 4.6
	Default Notice	 	Section 4.6
	Defaulting Member	 	Section 4.6(i)(A)
	Designating Party	 	Section 2.2(d)
	Development Budget	 	Section 2.8(b)
	Director	 	Section 2.1(a)
	Disposition Proceeds	 	Section 6.11(a)
	Dissolution Events	 	Section 7.1
	Drag-Along Member	 	Section 6.2(a)



 






    73


     


    

 


	Term	 	Provision
	Drag-Along Notice	 	Section 6.2(b)
	Drag-Along Notice Period	 	Section 6.2(c)
	Drag-Along Sale	 	Section 6.2(a)
	Dragging Member	 	Section 6.2(a)
	Effective Date	 	Preamble
	Electing Party	 	Section 4.4
	Excess Class B Distribution Amount	 	Section 5.7
	Exercising Member	 	Section 6.4(b)
	Fiscal Year	 	Section 10.4
	Independent Appraiser	 	Section 2.11
	Indirect Parent Transfer	 	Section 6.4(a)
	Initial Appraiser	 	Section 6.4(b)
	Initial Budget	 	Section 2.9(a)
	Initial Contributions	 	Section 4.1(b)
	Initiating Member	 	Section 6.6(a)
	IPT Exercise Notice	 	Section 6.4(a)
	IPT Notice	 	Section 6.4(a)
	IPT Transaction Value	 	Section 6.4(a)
	Key Man Event	 	Section 4.2
	Liquidity Event Notice	 	Section 6.5(a)
	Member Indemnitors	 	Section 8.5
	Member Related Party	 	Section 3.4(a)(i)
	Neutral Appraiser	 	Section 6.4(c)
	Non-Defaulting Member	 	Section 4.6
	Non-Initiating Member	 	Section 6.6(a)
	Non-Shortfall Member	 	Section 4.1(i)
	Nytis LLC	 	Recitals
	Offer	 	Section 6.6(a)
	Offeror	 	Section 6.4(a)
	OIE Fund II-A	 	Preamble
	OIE Fund II-B	 	Preamble
	Old Interests	 	Section 6.10(c)
	Old Ironsides	 	Preamble
	Old Ironsides Designee	 	Section 2.2(c)
	Optional Contribution	 	Section 4.6(iii)
	Other Investments	 	Section 3.5(i)
	Participation Agreement	 	Recitals
	Permitted Investments	 	Section 3.6(a)
	Permitted Variance	 	Section 2.4(a)(i)
	Preemptive Rights Member	 	Section 4.4
	Preemptive Rights Notice	 	Section 4.4
	Primary Exercising Member	 	Section 6.4(b)
	Proposed Budget	 	Section 2.9(c)
	Remaining Tag Balance	 	Section 6.11(b)(ii)
	Restricted Interest	 	Section 3.6(a)
	Second Appraiser	 	Section 6.4(c)
	Services Agreement	 	Section 2.5
	Shortfall Member	 	Section 4.1(i)
	Shortfall Cure Period	 	Section 4.1(i)
	Subject Assets	 	Section 3.5(d)
	Subject Company	 	Section 6.4(a)
	Subsequent Notice	 	Section 4.4
	Subsequent Purchase	 	Section 4.4
	Tag-Along Notice	 	Section 6.3(b)



 






    74


     


    

 





	Term	 	Provision
	Tag-Along Participant	 	Section 6.3(a)
	Tag-Along Partial Sale	 	Section 6.3(d)
	Tag-Along Sale	 	Section 6.3(a)
	Tag-Along Transferring Member	 	Section 6.3(a)
	Tax Matters Representative	 	Section 9.5
	Tennessee Mining Tract	 	Recitals
	Third Party Sale	 	Section 6.6(e)(ii)
	Transferring Persons	 	Section 6.2(b)
	Transaction Expenses	 	Section 12.3(a)
	Unit Certificate	 	Section 4.5(a)
	Yorktown	 	Preamble
	Yorktown-Carbon Assignment	 	Section 6.12(a)
	Yorktown Designee	 	Section 2.2(c)



 


Section 11.3Construction.
When required by the context, the gender of words in this Agreement includes the masculine, feminine and neuter genders, and the
singular includes the plural (and vice versa). Unless otherwise specified, references in this Agreement to (a) Articles and Sections
are to Articles and Sections of this Agreement, (b) Schedules, Exhibits or Annexes are to those attached hereto, each of which
is incorporated herein and made a part hereof for all purposes, (c) Article and Section headings are for convenience only and shall
not affect the interpretation of this Agreement, (d) the terms “herein,” “hereof,” “hereinafter”
or similar derivations are to this Agreement as a whole and not to any particular Article or Section, and (e) the terms “include,”
“including” or similar derivations are without limitation.


 


ARTICLE
XII

MISCELLANEOUS


 


Section 12.1Notices.
All notices and other communications under this Agreement or in connection herewith shall be in writing and shall be given by delivery
in person or by overnight courier, by registered or certified mail (return receipt requested and with postage prepaid thereon)
or by facsimile or Electronic Transmission to the parties at the respective addresses set forth in Exhibit A (or at
such other address as any party shall have furnished to the others in accordance with the terms of this Section 12.1).
All notices and other communications that are addressed as provided in or pursuant to this Section 12.1 shall be deemed
duly and validly given (a) if delivered in person or by overnight courier, upon delivery, (b) if delivered by registered or certified
mail (return receipt requested and with postage paid thereon), 72 hours after being placed in a depository of the United States
mails and (c) if delivered by facsimile or Electronic Transmission, upon transmission thereof and receipt of the appropriate answerback.


 






    75


     


    

 


Section 12.2Confidentiality.
Each party hereto acknowledges the proprietary and confidential nature of the Confidential Information, and agrees that it shall
preserve the confidentiality of the Confidential Information and shall not use, publish, disseminate, distribute or otherwise disclose
all or any portion thereof without the prior written approval of the Board of Directors.


 


(a)       In
the event that a Member receives either a request to disclose any Confidential Information under the terms of a subpoena or order
issued by a court or other Governmental Authority of competent jurisdiction or advice of legal counsel that disclosure is required
under applicable Law, such Member agrees that, prior to disclosing any Confidential Information, it shall (i) immediately notify
the Board of Directors of the existence and terms of, and the circumstances attendant to, such request or advice, (ii) consult
with the Board of Directors as to the advisability of taking legally available steps to resist or narrow any such request or to
otherwise eliminate the need for such disclosure and (iii) if disclosure is required, use commercially reasonable efforts to obtain
a protective order or other reliable assurance that confidential treatment will be accorded to such portion of the Confidential
Information as is required to be disclosed.


 


(b)       Notwithstanding
the above, a Member or a member of the Board of Directors may disclose Confidential Information (i) to the extent the disclosure
is necessary as a result of the due and proper performance of its duties to the Company pursuant to this Agreement, (ii) to the
extent necessary to enforce rights hereunder (provided, however, that the Member seeking to enforce its rights uses commercially
reasonable efforts to preserve the confidential nature of the Confidential Information and to limit the harm to the Company or
the other Members from the disclosure thereof) or (iii) in connection with disclosures of a general nature regarding general financial
information, return on investment and similar information, including in connection with communications to direct and indirect beneficial
owners of interests in the Member. The agreements contained in this Section 12.2 shall survive the withdrawal of any
Member and the termination of the Company.


 


Section 12.3Expenses.


 


(a)       Except
as set forth in Section 12.3(b), unless approved by the Board of Directors as a Company Expense, each Member shall be responsible
for the payment of all reasonable fees and expenses incurred by such Member in connection with the negotiation and preparation
of this Agreement and all agreements and documents ancillary thereto (“Transaction Expenses”). Transaction
Expenses shall include all fees, costs, and expenses of legal counsel, accountants and all other third party consultants and advisors
engaged by such Member to assist with the due diligence reviews conducted by it or the negotiation or preparation of this Agreement
or other agreements and all direct out-of-pocket expenses for travel and similar matters.


 


(b)       Carbon
shall be responsible for the payment of all reasonable fees and expenses incurred by or on behalf of such Member in connection
with (i) due diligence relating to the CNX Acquisition and (ii) negotiation and preparation of the CNX PSA; provided, however,
that the Company shall reimburse Carbon (A) $300,000 for its efforts and expenditures related to its diligence review of the
CNX Acquisition and (B) Carbon’s actual out-of-pocket legal and other third party fees incurred in connection with the
CNX Acquisition and CNX PSA, promptly following request thereof by Carbon. The Company shall be responsible for the payment or
reimbursement of all Transaction Expenses incurred by Old Ironsides and by Yorktown in connection with the negotiation and preparation
of this Agreement and all agreements and documents ancillary thereto.


 






    76


     


    

 


Section 12.4Entire
Agreement. This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement among the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof and
supersedes all prior written or oral agreements and understandings and all contemporaneous oral agreements and understandings among
the parties or any of them with respect to the subject matter hereof. All Exhibits and Schedules hereto are expressly made a part
of this Agreement.


 


Section 12.5Waiver
or Consent. A waiver or consent, express or implied, to or of any breach or default by any Person in the performance of its
obligations with respect to the Company is not a consent or waiver to or of any other breach or default in the performance by that
Person of the same or any other obligations of that Person with respect to the Company. Failure on the part of a Person to complain
of any act or omission of any Person or to declare any Person in breach or default with respect to an obligation, irrespective
of how long that failure continues, shall not be construed as a waiver of the breach or default until the applicable statute of
limitations has run. No waiver of any obligation under this Agreement or the Act shall be effective unless in writing signed by
or on behalf of the Person or Persons to whom the obligation is owed.


 


Section 12.6Amendment.
No amendment of this Agreement shall be effective (by merger, consolidation or otherwise) unless such amendment is executed by
all of the Class A Members; provided, however, that no Member approval shall be required for any amendment made (x) to Exhibit A
in accordance with the last sentence of this Section 12.6, (y) to reflect admission of a new Member approved pursuant to
Section 2.4(a)(xii) or effected pursuant to Section 6.7 or (z) in connection with the creation and issuance
of additional or different classes or series of Units approved pursuant to Section 2.4(a)(xi); and, provided, further,
that (i) the approval of the holder of the Class B Units shall be required for any amendment that adversely affects the right of
the Class B Units under Article V of this Agreement relative to the rights of the Class A Units and Class C Units under
this Agreement in any material respect, (ii) the approval of the holder of the Class C Units shall be required for any amendment
that adversely affects the right of the Class C Units under Article V of this Agreement relative to the rights of the Class
A Units and Class B Units under this Agreement in any material respect and (iii) at any time there is a Defaulting Member, the
approval of the Defaulting Member (in its capacity as a Class A Member) shall not be required for any amendment of this Agreement
provided that such amendment does not materially and adversely affect the rights of the Defaulting Member in its capacity as a
holder of Class A Units in a manner that is disproportionate to the other holders of Class A Units. Neither the waiver by the Company
or a Member of a breach of or a default under any of the provisions of this Agreement, nor the failure of the Company or a Member,
on one or more occasions, to enforce any of the provisions of this Agreement or to exercise any right, remedy or privilege hereunder,
shall thereafter be construed as a waiver of any subsequent breach or default of a similar nature, or as a waiver of any such provisions,
rights, remedies or privileges hereunder. Exhibit A shall be amended from time to time to reflect any changes to the
information contained therein without the necessity of any Board or Member approval.


 


Section 12.7Choice
of Law. This Agreement shall be constructed, interpreted and enforced in accordance with, and the respective rights and obligations
of the parties shall be governed by, the laws of the State of Delaware without regard to principles of conflicts of law.


 






    77


     


    

 


Section 12.8Public
Announcement. Except as otherwise required by applicable Law, no Member or its Affiliates shall make any public announcement
or filing with respect to the Company or its affairs or the transactions provided for herein without the prior written consent
of the other Member(s), which shall not be withheld unreasonably, except as may be required by law.


 


Section 12.9Availability
of Equitable Relief. Each of the parties hereto recognizes that irreparable injury may result from a breach of any provision
of this Agreement and that money damages may be inadequate to fully remedy the injury. In order to prevent such irreparable injury,
a party hereto may seek temporary injunctive relief from any court of competent jurisdiction.


 


Section 12.10Binding
Agreement. This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the parties hereto and their respective successors
and assigns (it being understood and agreed that, except as expressly provided herein and the rights of Covered Persons and Member
Indemnitors under Article VIII, nothing contained in this Agreement is intended to confer any rights, benefits or remedies
of any kind or character on any other Person under or by reason of this Agreement). It is expressly understood and agreed that
any attempted or purported Transfer by any party of this Agreement in violation of the provisions of this Section 12.10
shall be null and void.


 


Section 12.11Benefit
of Agreement. Nothing in this Agreement expressed or implied, shall be construed to give to any creditor of the Company or
of any Member any legal or equitable right, remedy or claim under or in respect of this Agreement.


 


Section 12.12Further
Assurances. In connection with this Agreement and the transactions contemplated hereby, each Member agrees to execute and deliver
any additional documents and instruments and to perform any additional acts necessary or appropriate to effectuate the provisions
of this Agreement and those transactions.


 


Section 12.13Counterparts.
This Agreement may be executed in any number of counterparts or counterpart signature pages, each of which shall constitute an
original and all of which shall constitute one and the same instrument.


 


[Remainder of page intentionally
left blank; Signature page follows]


 




    78


     


    

 


IN WITNESS WHEREOF,
the parties hereto have executed this Agreement as of the date first above written.


 





	 	CLASS
    A MEMBERS:
	 	 	 
	 	CARBON
    NATURAL GAS COMPANY
	 	 
	 	By:	/s/
    Patrick R. McDonald
	 	 	Patrick R.
    McDonald,
	 	 	Chief Executive
    Officer
	 	 	 
	 	YORKTOWN
    ENERGY PARTNERS XI, L.P.
	 	 	 
	 	By:	Yorktown
    XI Company LP, its general partner
	 	 	 
	 	By:	Yorktown
    XI Associates LLC, its general partner
	 	 	 
	 	By:	/s/
    Peter A. Leidel
	 	Name:	Peter
    A. Leidel
	 	Title:	Member
	 	 	 
	 	OLD
    IRONSIDES FUND II-A PORTFOLIO HOLDING COMPANY, LLC
	 	 
	 	By:	/s/
    Christopher L. Stoeckle
	 	Name:	Christopher
    L. Stoeckle
	 	Title:	Director
	 	 	 
	 	OLD
    IRONSIDES FUND II-B PORTFOLIO HOLDING COMPANY, LLC
	 	 	 
	 	By:	/s/
    Christopher L. Stoeckle
	 	Name:	Christopher
    L. Stoeckle
	 	Title:	Director




 


Signature Page
of


LIMITED LIABILITY
COMPANY AGREEMENT


OF


CARBON APPALACHIAN
COMPANY, LLC


 




     


     


    

 





	 	CLASS
    B MEMBER:
	 	 	 
	 	CARBON
    NATURAL GAS COMPANY
	 	 	 
	 	By:	/s/
    Patrick R. McDonald
	 	 	Patrick R.
    McDonald,
	 	 	Chief Executive
    Officer
	 	 	 
	 	CLASS
    C MEMBER:
	 	 	 
	 	CARBON
    NATURAL GAS COMPANY
	 	 	 
	 	By:	/s/
    Patrick R. McDonald
	 	 	Patrick R.
    McDonald,
	 	 	Chief Executive
    Officer




 


Signature Page
of


LIMITED LIABILITY
COMPANY AGREEMENT


OF


CARBONAPPALACHIAN
COMPANY, LLC




     


     


    

 


Exhibit
A



LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT OF

CARBON APPALACHIAN COMPANY, LLC


 


This Exhibit is dated as of February
23, 2017


 


	Members and Addresses	 	Capital Contribution (Cash)	 	 	Capital Commitment (Cash)	 	 	Class A Units	 	 	Class A Sharing Percentage	 	 	Class B Units	 	 	Class C Units	 
	Carbon Natural Gas Company
 1700 Broadway, Suite 1170
 Denver, CO  80290	 	$	240,000.00	 	 	$	2,000,000.00	 	 	 	240	 	 	 	2.00	%	 	 	1,000	 	 	 	121.21212	1
	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 
	Yorktown Energy Partners XI, L.P. 
 410 Park Avenue,
 19th Floor
 New York, NY 10022
	 	$	2,940,000.00	 	 	$	24,500,000.00	 	 	 	2,940	 	 	 	24.50	%	 	 	—	 	 	 	—	 
	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 
	Old Ironsides Fund II-A Portfolio 
 Holding Company, LLC
 10 Saint James Avenue, 19th Floor
 Boston, MA 02116	 	$	7,334,169.57	 	 	$	61,118,079.75	 	 	 	7,334.16957	 	 	 	61.12	%	 	 	—	 	 	 	—	 
	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 
	Old Ironsides Fund II-B Portfolio 
 Holding Company, LLC
 10 Saint James Avenue, 19th Floor
 Boston, MA 02116	 	$	1,485,830.43	 	 	$	12,381,920.25	 	 	 	1,485.83043	 	 	 	12.38	%	 	 	—	 	 	 	—	 
	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 	 
	Total	 	$	12,000,000.00	 	 	$	100,000,000.00	 	 	 	12,000	 	 	 	100.0	%	 	 	1,000	 	 	 	121.21212	 







 





 



 


1
The Class C Units were issued to Carbon in exchange for the Class C Non-Cash Capital Contribution.


 






    A-1


     


    

 


Exhibit
B



Members of the Board of Directors


 


	Old Ironsides Designees:	Scott E. Carson
	 	 
	 	Daniel A. Rioux
	 	 
	 	Christopher L. Stoeckle
	 	 
	Yorktown Designee:	Peter A. Leidel
	 	 
	Carbon Designee:	Patrick R. McDonald



 




    B-1


     


    

 


Exhibit
C



Participation AGREEMENT


 


[See Attached.]


 


 




    C-1


     


    

 


Execution


 


PARTICIPATION
AGREEMENT


 

TENNESSEE MINING TRACT


 


This
Participation Agreement (“Agreement”) is entered into as of February 23, 2017 (the “Effective
Date”), by and among NYTIS EXPLORATION COMPANY LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (“Nytis”)
and CARBON TENNESSEE MINING COMPANY, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (“Carbon TN Mining Co”).
Nytis and Carbon TN Mining Co are each sometimes referred to herein as a “Party” and collectively as
the “Parties.”


 


RECITALS


 


WHEREAS,
Nytis has leased, or obtained leases of, certain oil and gas interests in the Contract Area (as defined below) covering approximately
65,000 net mineral acres (the “Tennessee Mining Tract”);


 


WHEREAS,
Carbon TN Mining Co desires to participate in the development of the Tennessee Mining Tract by paying the costs incurred by Nytis
associated with the drilling, completion and equipping of Horizontal Wells to be located thereon (collectively, the “Wells”)
in exchange for seventy-five percent (75%) of Nytis’ undivided working interest in the leases underlying the oil and gas
interests which constitute the Tennessee Mining Tract (the “Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest”),
which leases are more particularly described on Exhibit A attached hereto and incorporated herein (the “Leases”)
in accordance with this Agreement;


 


WHEREAS,
the parties intend that all of their interests in the Tennessee Mining Tract and the Leases shall be subject to a tax partnership
for U.S. federal income tax purposes, as described herein; and


 


WHEREAS,
Carbon TN Mining Co, as consideration for the right to participate in the development of the Tennessee Mining Tract and other
rights set forth herein, has agreed to carry Nytis’ costs in certain of the Wells as set forth herein.


 


NOW,
THEREFORE, for a good and valuable consideration, it is agreed between the parties as follows:


 


ARTICLE
1

Definitions


 


1.1       In
addition to definitions set forth elsewhere herein, the following definitions shall apply in this Agreement:


 


“AFE”
means an authorization for expenditure representing an estimate of work to be performed for a specific drilling, completion or
other operation.


 


“Aggregate
Carry Cap” means $4,500,000, multiplied by a fraction (x) the numerator of which is equal to four, minus the number
of Partial Reassignments executed and delivered by Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, and (y) the denominator
of which is four.


 




    C-2


     


    

 


“Agreement”
has the meaning set forth in the Introduction.


 


“Approved
First Set Well” means each Well that relates to an Approved First Set Well Notice.


 


“Approved
First Set Well Notices” means each of the four Well Notices and AFEs delivered by Operator to Carbon TN Mining Co
immediately subsequent to the approval of the first Initial Carry Well.


 


“Approved
Fourth Set Well” means each Well that relates to an Approved Fourth Set Well Notice.


 


“Approved
Fourth Set Well Notices” means each of the four Well Notices and AFEs delivered by Operator to Carbon TN Mining
Co immediately subsequent to the approval of the fourth Initial Carry Well.


 


“Approved
Second Set Well” means each Well that relates to an Approved Second Set Well Notice.


 


“Approved
Second Set Well Notices” means each of the four Well Notices and AFEs delivered by Operator to Carbon TN Mining
Co immediately subsequent to the approval of the second Initial Carry Well.


 


“Approved
Set Wells” means the Approved First Set Wells, the Approved Second Set Wells, the Approved Third Set Wells and the
Approved Fourth Set Wells.


 


“Approved
Set Well Notices” means the Approved First Set Well Notices, the Approved Second Set Well Notices, the Approved
Third Set Well Notices and the Approved Fourth Set Well Notices.


 


“Approved
Third Set Well” means each Well that relates to an Approved Third Set Well Notice.


 


“Approved
Third Set Well Notices” means each of the four Well Notices and AFEs delivered by Operator to Carbon TN Mining Co
immediately subsequent to the approval of the third Initial Carry Well.


 


“Approved
Spacing Unit” means an area containing eighty (80) acres, or such larger or smaller area as may be indicated on
the as-built plat that is used for division order purposes, in the form of a rectangle as indicated on such plat.


 


“Assignment”
has the meaning provided in Section 3.2. 


 


“Carbon” has the meaning provided in Section 5.2(b).


 


“Carbon
TN Mining Co” has the meaning set forth in the Introduction.


 


“Carbon
TN Mining Co Proposal” has the meaning provided in Section 2.2(e).


 




    C-3


     


    

 


“Carbon
TN Mining Co Working Interest” has the meaning set forth in the Introduction.


 


“Carry
Costs” means the Drilling and Completion Costs for a Well that would otherwise be allocated to be borne by Nytis
pursuant to the terms of the Operating Agreement, multiplied by (i) if no Partial Reassignments have been executed and delivered
by Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 100%, (ii) if one Partial Reassignment has been executed and delivered
by Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 75%, (iii) if two Partial Reassignments have been executed and delivered
by Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 50%, (iv) if three Partial Reassignments have been executed and delivered
by Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 25%, and (v) if four Partial Reassignments have been executed and delivered
by Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 0%.


 


“Carry
Shortfall” has the meaning provided in Section 3.1(c).


 


“Carry
Shortfall Payment Amount” has the meaning provided in Section 3.1(c). 


 


“Carry Well”
means each Initial Carry Well and each Approved Set Well.



 


“Closing” has the meaning provided in Section
6.1.


 


“Contract
Area” means a portion of Anderson, Campbell and Scott Counties, Tennessee, a general outline of which is attached
for illustrative purposes only on Exhibit B attached hereto.


 


“Direct
Nytis Costs” means the Drilling and Completion Costs for a Well that would be allocated to be borne by Nytis pursuant
to the terms of the Operating Agreement, multiplied by (i) if no Partial Reassignments have been executed and delivered by Carbon
TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 0%, (ii) if one Partial Reassignment has been executed and delivered by Carbon TN
Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 25%, (iii) if two Partial Reassignments have been executed and delivered by Carbon TN
Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 50%, (iv) if three Partial Reassignments have been executed and delivered by Carbon
TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 75%, and (v) if four Partial Reassignments have been executed and delivered by Carbon
TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4, 100%.


 


“Drilling
and Completion Activities” means all activities and operations carried out by or on behalf of the parties related
to the Wells and under the terms and conditions of this Agreement, including, but not limited to, drilling, sidetracking, well
control, acquisition, transportation and installation of tubular goods, materials and equipment; surveying, constructing roads
and surface location Through the Tanks.


 


“Drilling
and Completion Costs” means the costs and expenses associated with (a) the drilling, testing and completing of the
Wells Through the Tanks and (b) the plugging and abandoning of dry holes or wells spudded but not completed.


 


“Effective
Date” has the meaning set forth in the Introduction. 



 


“Excess
Costs” has the meaning provided in Section 3.1(b).


 




    C-4


     


    

 


“Good
Cause” shall be deemed to exist only if (i) Nytis has breached any of its material obligations under this Agreement
or the Operating Agreement and has not cured any such breach within 30 days of receiving written notice of such breach from Carbon
TN Mining Co, (ii) OIE ceases to own 50% or more of the Class A Units of Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC or (iii) Carbon TN Mining
Co disposes of all or substantially all of the Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest.


 


“Horizontal
Well” means a well targeting the Chattanooga Shale formation permitted and spudded with the intent to drill with
at least 1500 feet of horizontal displacement from the surface location.


 


“Initial
Carry Well” has the meaning set forth in Section 2.2(b). 


 


“Leases” has the meaning
set forth in the Recitals.


 


“LegacyTexas”
has the meaning provided in Section 5.2(b). 


 


“Nytis” has the meaning set forth in the Introduction.


 


“Operating
Agreement” means the Operating Agreement in substantially the form of that attached hereto as Exhibit C,
together with the COPAS Accounting Procedure annexed thereto, and together with all Exhibits thereto.


 


“Operator”
means Nytis or any assignee of or successor to Nytis’ obligations as “Operator" in accordance with the Operating
Agreement.


 


“Partial
Reassignment” has the meaning provided in Section 2.4(c). 


 


“Party” has the meaning
set forth in the Introduction.


 


“Proportionately
Reduced” means the pro rata reduction of the amount to be paid by Carbon TN Mining Co and/or Nytis, as the case
may be, with respect to any Well and/or Lease in which Carbon TN Mining Co and Nytis do not collectively own a 100% working interest,
based on the actual working interest owned by Carbon TN Mining Co and Nytis, collectively, in such Well and/or Lease.


 


“Tennessee
Mining Tract” has the meaning set forth in the Recitals.


 


“Term” has the meaning provided
in Section 6.2.


 


“Through
the Tanks” means all operations necessary to drill and complete a well and install related equipment reasonably
necessary for the well to be capable of producing oil or gas to tanks or pipelines, as applicable, including all production, processing,
and flowline facilities necessary to connect into and deliver oil or gas to an appropriate transportation pipeline as determined
in Operator’s sole discretion.


 


“Well”
has the meaning set forth in the Recitals.


 





“Well
Notice and AFE” has the meaning provided in Section 2.2(a). 


 


The following Exhibits are attached to and made
a part of this Agreement:


 


Exhibit
“A” Description of Leases


Exhibit
“B” General Outline of Contract Area


Exhibit
“C” Operating Agreement


Exhibit
“D” Form of Reassignment


Exhibit
“E” Form of Lease Assignment


Exhibit
“F” Allocation of Drilling and Completion Costs



 




    C-5


     


    

 


ARTICLE
2


Drilling
Commitment; Subsequent Activities


 


2.1Carry
Wells.


 


(a)       Carbon
TN Mining Co hereby commits to participate in the drilling, completing and equipping of up to twenty (20) Carry Wells, subject
to the terms hereof, which will be operated by Operator on the lands in the Tennessee Mining Tract.


 


(b)       The
Parties shall bear the costs and expenses associated with the Carry Wells in accordance with Section 3.1(a).


 


2.2Carry
Wells – Process.


 


(a)       Not
less than thirty (30) days prior to the anticipated spud date of each Well proposed by Operator to be drilled in the Tennessee
Mining Tract, in each case prior to Operator making a proposal for such Well under the terms of the Operating Agreement, Operator
shall deliver to Carbon TN Mining Co written notice of Operator’s intent to spud such Well, which shall include a description
of the location of such Well, the proposed depth and target formation of such Well, and an AFE, setting forth drilling, completion
and surface equipment costs for such Well (each a “Well Notice and AFE”). It is understood and agreed
that the AFE applicable to a proposed Well represents an estimate of the costs of drilling and completing the applicable Well,
but final billing will be based on actual costs incurred. In connection with any Well Notice and AFE, Operator agrees promptly
to provide any additional information regarding the Well which is reasonably requested by Carbon TN Mining Co.


 


(b)       Following
delivery to Carbon TN Mining Co of a Well Notice and AFE (excluding Approved Set Well Notices relating to Approved Set
Wells), Carbon TN Mining Co will have fifteen (15) days after its receipt of such Well Notice and AFE to elect, in writing,
to either participate or not participate in the drilling and completion of such proposed Well (and, for the avoidance of
doubt, a decision not to participate in such proposed Well will not be subject to Section 2.4). Carbon TN Mining
Co’s failure to deliver to Operator written notice of its election within such period shall be deemed an election by
Carbon TN Mining Co to not participate in the drilling or completion of such Well. Any Well that Carbon TN Mining Co elects
to participate in pursuant to this Section 2.2(b) will be deemed an “Initial Carry Well”.
Operator shall use its best efforts to spud each Initial Carry Well on or before forty-five (45) days after receiving
confirmation that the Board of Directors of Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC (the parent of Carbon TN Mining Co) has
provided its approval of such Initial Carry Well. The approval of an Initial Carry Well will initiate the Drilling and
Completion Activities with respect to such Initial Carry Well and the four subsequent Approved Set Wells, and Carbon TN
Mining Co shall participate in such four subsequent Approved Set Wells in accordance with this Agreement.


 


(c)       Following
approval by the Board of Directors of Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC of:


 


(ii)       the
first Initial Carry Well, Operator shall drill, complete and equip the first Initial Carry Well and each of the Approved First
Set Wells;


 


(iii)       the
second Initial Carry Well, Operator shall drill, complete and equip the second Initial Carry Well and each of the Approved Second
Set Wells;


 


(iv)       the
third Initial Carry Well, Operator shall drill, complete and equip the third Initial Carry Well and each of the Approved Third
Set Wells; and


 


(v)       the
fourth Initial Carry Well, Operator shall drill, complete and equip the fourth Initial Carry Well and each of the Approved Fourth
Set Wells.


 


Carbon
TN Mining Co will participate in each Carry Well in accordance with Section 3.1(a).


 


(d)       Prior
to the expiration of the Term, Operator shall not drill, and shall not make a proposal under the terms of the
Operating Agreement for, any Wells other than Carry Wells. Operator shall not make a proposal under the terms of this
Agreement or the Operating Agreement for any Initial Carry Well (other than the first Initial Carry Well) until all of the
Carry Wells previously required to be drilled pursuant to Section 2.2(c) have been drilled and completed (or plugged
and abandoned).


 


(e)       Upon
request of Carbon TN Mining Co, Operator shall prepare a Well Notice and AFE for a Well proposed by Carbon TN Mining
Co (a “Carbon TN Mining Co Proposal”), and Carbon TN Mining Co shall have the option to participate
in such Well in accordance with Section 2.2, provided that if Carbon TN Mining Co elects not to participate in such
Well, then Operator will not be obligated to drill such Well. If Carbon TN Mining Co elects to participate in such Well, then
Operator shall drill such Well in accordance with the terms hereof and the Operating Agreement.







 


2.3 Drilling
and Completion.


 


(a)       All
Carry Wells shall be drilled and completed as Horizontal Wells (unless otherwise agreed by Operator and Carbon TN
Mining Co) in accordance with the terms of the Operating Agreement. Billings will be charged pursuant to the Operating
Agreement unless otherwise set forth herein. The location of each Well shall be determined by the Operator in its sole
discretion. Operator shall complete, equip and produce, or plug and abandon each of the Wells, with due diligence and
reasonable dispatch in accordance with applicable laws and the Operating Agreement.


 






    C-6


     


    

 





(b)       With
respect to the Tennessee Mining Tract, Operator will provide to Carbon TN Mining Co (i) copies of daily production
reports with respect to all completed Wells, (ii) at least quarterly with respect to all completed Wells (A) production
charts, records and information, (B) all forms and reports filed with any governmental entity and (C) information concerning
the drilling, testing and completing of the Wells, (iii) upon request of Carbon TN Mining Co, current schedules of the Leases
and the ownership interests of all working interest owners in the Leases and (iv) as requested by Carbon TN Mining Co, other
information relating to the Leases, Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest, Wells or any operations otherwise conducted on the
Tennessee Mining Tract or with respect to any other assets in which Carbon TN Mining Co jointly owns an interest with
Operator or its affiliates that is in the possession of Operator or its Affiliates or is available to, or can be produced by,
Operator or Operator without undue burden.


 


2.4 Reassignment. If
during the Term of this Agreement:


 


(a)       Carbon
TN Mining Co fails to pay the Drilling and Completion Costs of the first Initial Carry Well or one or more Approved First Set
Wells as contemplated by Section 3.1(a) and such well is drilled and completed by Operator, then Carbon TN Mining Co shall,
pursuant to recordable assignment in substantially the form attached hereto as Exhibit D (a “Partial Reassignment”),
promptly reassign to Nytis, without consideration, an undivided twenty five percent (25%) of the Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest
assigned to Carbon TN Mining Co by Nytis pursuant to the Assignment;


 


(b)       Carbon
TN Mining Co fails to pay the Drilling and Completion Costs of the second Initial Carry Well or one or more Approved Second Set
Wells as contemplated by Section 3.1(a) and such well is drilled and completed by Operator, then Carbon TN Mining Co shall,
pursuant to a Partial Reassignment, promptly reassign to Nytis, without consideration, an undivided twenty five percent (25%)
of the Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest assigned to Carbon TN Mining Co by Nytis pursuant to the Assignment;


 


(c)       Carbon
TN Mining Co fails to pay the Drilling and Completion Costs of the third Initial Carry Well or one or more Approved Third Set
Wells as contemplated by Section 3.1(a) and such well is drilled and completed by Operator, then Carbon TN Mining Co shall,
pursuant to a Partial Reassignment, promptly reassign to Nytis, without consideration, an undivided twenty five percent (25%)
of the Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest assigned to Carbon TN Mining Co by Nytis pursuant to the Assignment; and


 


(d)       Carbon
TN Mining Co fails to pay the Drilling and Completion Costs of the fourth Initial Carry Well or one or more Approved Fourth Set
Wells as contemplated by Section 3.1(a) and such well is drilled and completed by Operator, then Carbon TN Mining Co shall,
pursuant to a Partial Reassignment, promptly reassign to Nytis, without consideration, an undivided twenty five percent (25%)
of the Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest assigned to Carbon TN Mining Co by Nytis pursuant to the Assignment;


 






    C-7


     


    

 


notwithstanding
anything in this Section 2.4 to the contrary, (i) if any reassignment by Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to Sections
2.4(a) through (d) is required, such assignment will exclude all of Carbon TN Mining Co’s rights
and interest in any Approved Spacing Unit surrounding each Carry Well in which Carbon TN Mining Co has previously
participated in accordance with terms and conditions of this Agreement and (ii) under no circumstances shall Carbon TN Mining
Co be required to make more than a single reassignment pursuant to each of Sections 2.4(a) through (d) (for
example, if Carbon TN Mining Co fails to pay the Drilling and Completion Costs of two Approved First Set Wells and both such
Wells are drilled and completed by Operator, Carbon TN Mining Co would be required to make a single reassignment upon the
completion of the first such Approved First Set Well pursuant to Section 2.4(a), but would not be required to make a
second reassignment upon the completion of the second such Approved First Set Well). Reassignment pursuant to this Section
2.4 shall be the sole remedy of Nytis (including in its capacity as Operator) for any failure of Carbon TN Mining Co to
comply with its obligations pursuant to Section 3.1(a)(i).


 


Notwithstanding
anything herein to the contrary, Carbon TN Mining Co shall not be required to make any reassignment pursuant to this Section
2.4 from and after such time as Carbon TN Mining Co has paid an aggregate amount of Carry Costs equal to or greater than the
Aggregate Carry Cap or has paid the Shortfall Carry Payment Amount.


 


2.5 Subsequent
Activities. Following the expiration of the Term, the Parties may proceed to drill additional Wells on
the Tennessee Mining Tract in accordance with the terms of the Operating Agreement with all Drilling and Completion
Costs associated with such additional Wells borne in accordance with the terms of the Operating Agreement on a heads up
basis (i.e., borne as provided in the Operating Agreement, without application of Section 3.1(a)(i)).


 


ARTICLE
3


Payment
of Carry Costs; Assignment


 


3.1 Purchase
of Working Interest. In accordance with the payment terms of the applicable Operating Agreement, unless
otherwise set forth herein:


 


(a)       (i)
Carbon TN Mining Co agrees to be responsible for and pay Drilling and Completion Costs as follows: with respect to the
Carry Wells, subject to Section 3.1(b), Carbon TN Mining Co shall bear (A) the Carry Costs for the benefit of Nytis,
plus (B) the Drilling and Completion Costs for such Wells that are allocated to be borne by Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to
the terms of the Operating Agreement (being, as of immediately following the Closing, seventy-five percent (75%) of the
Drilling and Completion Costs, Proportionally Reduced) for the benefit of Carbon TN Mining Co.


 


(ii)       Nytis
agrees to be responsible for and pay Drilling and Completion Costs as follows: with respect to the Carry Wells, the Direct Nytis
Costs, if any, for the benefit of Nytis.


 


(iii)       For
(A) any Excess Costs and (B) any Wells drilled subsequent to the expiration of the Term, the Parties shall bear the Drilling
and Completion Costs for such Wells in accordance with the terms of the Operating Agreement on a heads up basis (i.e.,
borne as provided in the Operating Agreement, without application of Section 3.1(a)(i)).


 


For
the avoidance of doubt, Schedule F reflects the allocation of Drilling and Completion Costs with respect to Carry Wells
as provided in Section 3.1(a)(i) and (ii); provided that the allocations set forth on Schedule F are subject
to Section 3.1(a)(iii) and Section 3.1(b).


 


(b)       Notwithstanding
anything to the contrary in Section 3.1(a)(i), the maximum amount of Carry Costs to be borne by Carbon TN Mining Co will
be (i) for each Carry Well, 110% of the aggregate estimate of the costs of drilling and completing such Carry Well as set forth
in the applicable AFE and (ii) for all Carry Wells in the aggregate, the Aggregate Carry Cap. To the extent that the Carry Costs
with respect to any Carry Well would otherwise exceed the thresholds set forth in the preceding sentence (any such excess, “Excess
Costs”), such Excess Costs will be borne as provided in Section 3.1(a)(iii) and not Section 3.1(a)(i).
The maximum number of Carry Wells to be drilled and completed pursuant to this Agreement is twenty (20).


 


(c)       Carbon
TN Mining Co Disposals. If Carbon TN Mining Co disposes of all or substantially all of the Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest
in an arms-length transaction for fair market value paid in cash prior to the expiration of the Term (the aggregate amount by
which the Carry Costs previously paid by Carbon TN Mining Co is less than the Aggregate Carry Cap as of such time, a “Carry
Shortfall”), then Carbon TN Mining Co shall pay to Nytis, concurrently with the closing of such disposition of the
Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest, an amount, in cash in immediately available funds, equal to the lesser of (i) the Carry
Shortfall and (ii) the proceeds actually received by Carbon TN Mining Co in connection with such disposition, net of any taxes
and expenses payable by Carbon TN Mining Co or its direct or indirect owners as a result of or in connection with such disposition.
The amount of any Carry Shortfall paid to Nytis pursuant to this Section 3.1(c) (the “Carry Shortfall Payment
Amount”) will be deemed to be a payment of Carry Costs by Carbon TN Mining Co for purposes of Section 3.1(b),
and following the payment of the Carry Shortfall Payment Amount, Carbon TN Mining Co will have no further obligation or liability
pursuant to Section 3.1(a)(i).


 


3.2Assignment. Simultaneously
with the Closing hereof, Nytis shall deliver to Carbon TN Mining Co a recordable assignment, in substantially the form
attached hereto as Exhibit E (the “Assignment”), assigning to Carbon TN Mining Co
seventy-five percent (75%) of all of Nytis’ undivided right, title and interest in and to the Leases. The Assignment
shall be made with a warranty of title, by, through and under Nytis, but not otherwise, and such assignment(s) shall be
subject to the terms contained in this Agreement and the applicable operating agreements and/or pooling orders, if any.


 






    C-8


     


    

 


ARTICLE
4

Operator


 


4.1Operating
Agreement. Subject to Section 4.2, Nytis shall be the Operator under the Operating Agreement and in such
capacity shall carry out or cause to be carried out all Drilling and Completion Activities as well as all other operations
covered by the Operating Agreement; provided, however, that Nytis shall be permitted to assign its obligations
as Operator in accordance with the Operating Agreement. Additionally, it is understood that Nytis may engage a legitimate
third party contract operator, which is mutually acceptable to the parties hereto, to consummate the actual Drilling and
Completion Activities to be conducted on each designated prospect.


 


4.2Removal
of Operator.


 


(a)       In
addition to the deemed resignation provisions of the Operating Agreement, Carbon TN Mining Co may remove Nytis, or any assignee
of or successor to Nytis as Operator, as Operator under this Agreement (and as operator under the Operating Agreement) for Good
Cause by written notice of election to remove for Good Cause given to the Operator by Carbon TN Mining Co.


 


(b)       In
addition to the removal provisions of Section 4.2(a), Operator may be removed as operator under the Operating Agreement
in accordance with the provisions of the Operating Agreement.


 


4.3Invoicing. Notwithstanding
the payment terms of any Operating Agreement to the contrary, as to any Well proposed by Nytis under any Operating
Agreement, Nytis shall invoice Carbon TN Mining Co twenty (20) days prior to the estimated spud date for such Well for Carbon
TN Mining Co’s estimated share of Drilling and Completion Costs on each such Well. Such invoices will be due and
payable by Carbon TN Mining Co within twenty (20) days of receipt of such invoice.


 


ARTICLE
5


Representations
and Warranties


 


5.1Mutual
Representations and Warranties. Each party, with respect to itself only, hereby represents and warrants to the
other party the following:


 


(a)       Each
party is duly organized, validly existing and in good standing under the applicable laws of the State of its formation, and is
qualified to do business and is in good standing in every other jurisdiction where the failure to so qualify would have a material
adverse effect on its ability to execute, deliver and perform this Agreement and the other agreements contemplated herein.


 


(b)       Each
party has all requisite power and authority to (i) own, lease or operate its assets and properties and to carry on the business
as now conducted, and (ii) enter into and perform its obligations under this Agreement and to carry out the transactions contemplated
hereby.


 


(c)       Each
party has taken (or caused to be taken) all acts and other proceedings required to be taken by such party to authorize the
execution, delivery and performance by such party of this Agreement and the other agreements contemplated herein. This
Agreement has been duly executed and delivered by each party and constitutes the valid and binding obligation of each party,
enforceable against such party in accordance with its terms, except as enforceability may be limited by applicable
bankruptcy, moratorium, reorganization or similar laws affecting the rights of creditors generally and by principles of
equity, whether considered in a proceeding at law or in equity. The execution, delivery and performance of this Agreement by each
party does not and will not (i) conflict with, or result in any violation of or constitute a breach or default (with notice
or lapse of time, or both) under (A) any provision of the organizational documents of such party, or (B) any applicable
statute, law, rule, regulation, order, agreement, instrument or license applicable to such party, except as would not have a
material adverse effect, or (ii) except as provided on Schedule 5.1(c) attached hereto, require the submission of any
notice, report, consent or other filing with or from any governmental authority or third persons.


 






    C-9


     


    

 


(d)       There
are no actions, suits or proceedings pending or, to such party’s knowledge, threatened against a party which if decided
unfavorably to such party could have a material adverse effect on the ability of such party to execute, deliver or perform this
Agreement.


 


(e)       No
party has incurred any obligation or liability, contingent or otherwise, for any fee payable to a broker or finder with respect
to the matters provided for in this Agreement or the other agreements contemplated herein which could be attributable to or charged
to the other party. Each party shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the other party from any claims, damages, liabilities,
costs and expenses, including reasonable attorneys’ fees in the event the prior sentence should be or become untrue as to
such party.


 


5.2       Nytis
Representations and Warranties. Nytis hereby represents and warrants to Carbon TN Mining Co as follows:


 


(a)       There
are no bankruptcy, reorganization or rearrangement proceedings pending, being contemplated by or to its knowledge threatened against
it.


 


(b)       None
of the lands underlying the Leases which will be assigned to Carbon TN Mining Co will be subject to liens burdening Carbon TN
Mining Co’s interest therein, including but not limited to any liens in favor of LegacyTexas Bank (“LegacyTexas”),
as lender, pursuant to that certain Credit Agreement, dated October 3, 2016, by and between Nytis’ parent corporation (and
member of Carbon TN Mining Co), Carbon Natural Gas Company, a Delaware corporation (“Carbon”) and LegacyTexas.
There are no calls on production or contracts for sale of production encumbering the Leases which provide for the delivery of
hydrocarbons at a price below the prevailing market price.


 


(c)       All
Leases are in full force and effect and are legal, valid and binding obligations of the parties thereto, their respective successors
and assigns. Operations with respect to the Wells are in material compliance with applicable rules, regulations, statutes, and
laws of any applicable governmental authority. To the best of Nytis’ knowledge and belief, after appropriate inquiry, Nytis
is not in breach or default under the terms of any of the Leases which may result in material impairment or loss of title to any
material part of the Leases taken as a whole or the value thereof taken as a whole or which might materially hinder or impede
the operation of the Leases as a whole.


 






    C-10


     


    

 


(d)       Nytis
has delivered to Carbon TN Mining Co all Phase I or Phase II environmental site assessment reports in Nytis’
possession or control on the Leases or the lands covered thereby. To the best of Nytis’ knowledge and belief, after
appropriate inquiry, Nytis has complied in all material respects with all environmental laws with respect to the Leases. To
the best of Nytis’ knowledge and belief, after appropriate inquiry, Nytis possesses all environmental permits
that are required for the operation of the Leases (except for such permits as are expected to be obtained in the ordinary
course of business), and is in compliance with the provisions of all such environmental permits. Nytis has not received any
written notice, report or other information regarding any liabilities relating to its business or any of the Leases arising
under environmental laws, including any written notice of violation from any governmental authority. To the best of
Nytis’ knowledge and belief, after appropriate inquiry, Nytis has not treated, stored, disposed of, arranged for or
permitted the disposal of, transported, handled, or released any substance, including any hazardous materials, or owned or
operated any facility or property, so as to give rise to liabilities for response costs, natural resource damages or
attorneys fees pursuant to federal or state environmental laws. Without limiting the foregoing, no facts, events or
conditions relating to the past or present facilities, properties or operations of Nytis with respect to the Leases will
prevent, hinder or limit continued compliance with environmental laws, give rise to any investigatory, remedial or corrective
obligations on the part of Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to environmental laws, or give rise to any other liabilities on the
part of Carbon TN Mining Co (whether accrued, absolute, contingent, unliquidated or otherwise, whether due or to become due,
and regardless of whether asserted) pursuant to environmental laws, including any relating to onsite or offsite releases or
threatened releases of hazardous materials, substances or wastes, personal injury, property damage or natural resource
damage.


 


(e)       The
information set forth on Schedule 5.2(e) with respect to the working interest and net revenue interest of Nytis in the
Leases is true and correct.


 


(f)       Schedule
5.2(f) sets forth a list of all policies of insurance owned or held by or maintained by Nytis with respect to the Leases.
Such policies are in full force and effect and, coupled with the insurance to be obtained under any applicable Operating Agreement,
will satisfy in all material respects all requirements of applicable, laws and any agreements to which Nytis is a party.


 


(g)       Prior
to the execution of this Agreement, Nytis will have obtained, or cause to be obtained, any consents, approvals, certificates,
licenses, permits, and other authorizations of the necessary governmental authorities, which to (i) the best of Nytis’ knowledge
and belief, after appropriate inquiry, are required for Nytis to own, develop, operate, and maintain the Tennessee Mining Tract
and (ii) are required for Nytis to effect the transfer of the Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest pursuant to the Assignment.


 


(h)       Nytis
has paid its pro-rata share of all ad valorem, property, production, severance, excise, and similar taxes and assessments with
respect to the Leases that have become due and payable, and all tax returns required to be filed by Nytis with respect to the
same have been timely filed. To the best of Nytis’ knowledge and belief, after appropriate inquiry, with respect to the
Leases there are no tax deficiencies assessed against or audits in progress by any governmental authority. There are no tax liens
on or with respect to the Leases.


 


(i)       All
rentals, royalties, shut-in royalties, overriding royalties and other payments due pursuant to or with respect to the Leases have
been properly paid.


 




    C-11


     


    

 


(j)       To
the best of Nytis’ knowledge and belief, after appropriate inquiry, there are no wells located on the Leases that (a) Nytis
is obligated by law or contract to plug and abandon; (b) Nytis would be obligated by law or contract to plug and abandon with
the lapse of time or notice or both because the well is not capable of producing oil, gas or other hydrocarbons in commercial
quantities or otherwise being used in normal operations; (c) are subject to exceptions to a requirement to plug and abandon issued
by a regulatory authority having jurisdiction over the Leases; or (d) have been plugged and abandoned but have not been plugged
in accordance, in all material respects, with all applicable requirements of each regulatory authority having jurisdiction over
the Leases.


 


(k)       The
Leases are not subject to any preferential purchase rights applicable to the transactions contemplated hereby.


 


(l)       There
are no outstanding AFEs with respect to wells located on the lands subject to the Leases or other capital commitments which are
binding on the Leases.


 


5.3Carbon
TN Mining Co Representations and Warranties. Carbon TN Mining Co hereby represents and warrants to Nytis as
follows:


 


(a)       There
is no bankruptcy, reorganization or arrangement proceedings pending, being contemplated by or to its knowledge threatened against
it.


 


(b)       The
working interests being acquired by Carbon TN Mining Co are being acquired for investment purposes only, for Carbon TN Mining
Co’s own account, and not with a current view to, for offer for sale or for sale in connection with, the distribution or
transfer thereof. The working interests being acquired by Carbon TN Mining Co are not being purchased for subdivision or fractionalization
thereof; and Carbon TN Mining Co has no contract, agreement or arrangement with any person or entity to sell or otherwise transfer
(with or without consideration) to any such person or entity any of the working interests being acquired by Carbon TN Mining Co,
nor present plans or intention to enter into any such contract, agreement or arrangement.


 


ARTICLE
6


Closing
Conditions; Term and Termination


 


6.1Closing
Conditions. It is the intent of the parties that a closing of the transactions contemplated by this Agreement (the
“Closing”) shall take place contemporaneously with the execution of this Agreement at such location
as is mutually acceptable to the parties. The parties’ obligations to close the transactions contemplated hereby shall
be subject to the execution and delivery of the following:


 


(a)       The
parties shall execute the Operating Agreement;


 


(b)       Nytis
shall deliver to Carbon TN Mining Co:


 


(ii)       the
Assignment; and


 




    C-12


     


    

 


(iii)
a release of all liens with respect to the Carbon TN Mining Co Working Interest, if any, securing any indebtedness for borrowed
money or any guarantee of any obligation of any third party.


 


6.2Term. The
term of this Agreement (the “Term”) shall begin on the Effective Date and shall
continue until the earlier of (a) the tenth anniversary of the Effective Date or (b) dissolution of Carbon Appalachian
Company, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company and parent of Carbon TN Mining Co; provided, however, that
this Agreement shall earlier terminate (x) upon the mutual consent of the parties hereto or (y) after (i) twenty (20) Carry
Wells have been drilled, whether completed Through the Tanks or plugged and abandoned, (ii) Carbon TN Mining Co has paid (A)
an aggregate amount of Carry Costs equal to the Aggregate Carry Cap or (B) the Shortfall Carry Payment Amount or (iii) if the
fourth Initial Carry Well has been approved pursuant to Section 2.2(b) and Carbon TN Mining Co has become required to
effect a Partial Reassignment pursuant to Section 2.4(d), upon such Partial Reassignment; provided further, however,
that any outstanding assignment obligations of either party pursuant to this Agreement shall survive any such
termination.


 


6.3Termination. Upon
termination of this Agreement, all rights and obligations of the parties with respect to the Tennessee Mining
Tract will be governed solely by the terms of the applicable Operating Agreements and any other agreements entered into by
the parties with respect to such properties, and neither party shall have any further rights or obligations hereunder, except
as otherwise provided herein.


 


ARTICLE
7


Confidential
Data and Information


 


7.1Confidential
Information. Nytis has provided Carbon TN Mining Co with certain information, reports and data used in the
evaluation of the Tennessee Mining Tract as contemplated by this Agreement. Subject to the terms of Section 7.2, any
party hereto may at any time utilize, and show and provide to third parties, copies of such information.


 


7.2Limitations. Except
to the extent that such data may legally become a part of the public domain, all data and information acquired by the
parties pursuant to this Agreement or supplied by one party to the other pursuant to this Agreement will be kept
confidential and will be for the sole and exclusive use and benefit of the parties hereto; provided, however,
the parties may disclose such data and information to their respective consultants and parties providing, or proposing to
provide, financial accommodations to the disclosing party where each such recipient has (a) been advised of the confidential
nature of such data and information and the obligations of the disclosing party with respect thereto hereunder, and (b)
agreed to be bound by the terms of this ARTICLE 7, it being understood and agreed that the disclosing party shall
remain liable for any breach by any such recipient of the obligations of the disclosing party under this ARTICLE 7.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, any party may disclose Confidential Information (i) to other working
interest owners in the Tennessee Mining Tract, if any, (ii) to third parties to the extent such information is required to be
disclosed under applicable law, rule, order or regulation of any governmental entity having jurisdiction over such matters,
(iii) to the extent requested by regulatory or self-regulatory authority, (iv) in connection with the exercise of any
remedies hereunder or any suit, action or proceeding relating to this Agreement or the enforcement of rights hereunder, (v)
to an equity owner, director, officer, employee or agent of such party, including legal counsel, accountants and other
advisors where each such recipient has (y) been advised of the confidential nature of such data and information and the
obligations of the disclosing party with respect thereto hereunder and (z) such recipient is subject to enforceable
obligations to keep such data and information confidential, or (vi) in connection with disclosures of a general nature
regarding general financial information, return on investment and similar information, including in connection with
communications to direct and indirect beneficial owners of interests a party hereto.


 






    C-13


     


    

 


ARTICLE
8

Insurance


 


The
Operator will at all times and in connection with all work performed hereunder carry, for the account of the parties, the insurance
specified on Exhibit “D” to the Operating Agreement and shall otherwise comply with the provisions of such Exhibit
“D”.


 


ARTICLE
9

Indemnification


 


9.1       Application
of Indemnities. Indemnities shall apply as follows:


 


(a)       All
indemnities set forth in this Agreement extend to the affiliates, partners, directors, employees, members, shareholders, subsidiaries,
permitted successors and permitted assigns of the indemnified party. The indemnities set forth in this Agreement do not extend
to any part of an indemnified claim that is the result of the gross negligence, willful misconduct or fraud of the indemnified
party.


 


(b)       Neither
Nytis nor Carbon TN Mining Co shall be entitled to recover from the other party, respectively, and each party releases the other
party from and waives, any liabilities arising under this Agreement by reason of the breach thereof, or in connection with or
with respect to the transactions contemplated in this agreement, any amount in excess of the actual compensatory damages suffered
by such party. Each of Nytis and Carbon TN Mining Co waive, and release each other (and Carbon, as applicable) from any right
to recover punitive or exemplary damages arising in connection with or with respect to any breach hereof or as to the transactions
contemplated in this agreement; provided, however, any such damages recovered by a third party (other than a party’s
affiliates) for which a party owes the other party an indemnity under this agreement shall not be waived. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, the parties expressly agree and acknowledge that any and all cost recoupment mechanisms, liens, security interests
and other remedies provided herein or in the Operating Agreement are not waived or released and shall be available to each of
Nytis and Carbon TN Mining Co with respect to a breach hereof or as to the transactions contemplated in this agreement or the
terms and conditions of the Operating Agreement.


 


(c)       The
indemnities of the indemnifying party in this Agreement do not cover or include any amounts that the indemnified party may
legally recoup from other third party owners under applicable joint operating agreements or other agreements, and for which
the indemnified party is reimbursed by any third party. If it is judicially determined that any provision of this
indemnity is found to be in violation of state or federal law, such that the violation would render the entire Agreement void
and unenforceable, said provision shall be amended automatically to comply with said law. In the event that such provision
cannot be amended to comply with said law, the provision shall be disregarded, and the validity and enforceability of the
remaining provisions shall not be affected.


 


9.2Carbon
TN Mining Co Indemnity. Carbon TN Mining Co shall indemnify, defend and hold Nytis harmless from and against any
and all claims and liabilities caused by, resulting from or incidental to (a) any inaccuracy of any representation or
warranty of Carbon TN Mining Co set forth in this agreement or (b) any breach of, or failure to perform or satisfy, any of
the covenants and obligations of Carbon TN Mining Co hereunder.


 


9.3Nytis
Indemnity. Nytis shall indemnify, defend and hold Carbon TN Mining Co harmless from and against any and all claims
and liabilities caused by, resulting from or incidental to (a) any inaccuracy of any representation or warranty of Nytis set
forth in this agreement, (b) any breach of, or failure to perform or satisfy, any of the covenants and obligations of Nytis
hereunder which are to be performed after the execution of this agreement, and (c) any matter arising or resulting from the
ownership and operation of the Leases prior to the Effective Date.


 


9.4Demand.
Each indemnified party hereunder agrees that promptly upon its discovery of facts giving rise to a claim for indemnity
under the provisions of this Agreement, including receipt by it of notice of any demand, assertion, claim, action or proceeding,
judicial or otherwise, by any third party (such third party actions being collectively referred to herein as the “Indemnity
Claim”), with respect to any matter as to which it claims to be entitled to indemnity under the provisions of this
Agreement, it will give prompt notice thereof in writing to the indemnifying party or parties, together with a statement of such
information respecting any of the foregoing as it shall have. Such notice shall include a formal demand for indemnification under
this Agreement. The indemnifying party or parties shall not be obligated to indemnify the indemnified party with respect to any
Indemnity Claim if the indemnified party knowingly failed to notify the indemnifying party or parties thereof in accordance with
the provisions of this Agreement in sufficient time to permit the indemnifying party or parties or its/their counsel to defend
against such matter and to make a timely response thereto including, without limitation, any responsive motion or answer to a
complaint, petition, notice or other legal, equitable or administrative process relating to the Indemnity Claim, only insofar
as such knowing failure to notify the indemnifying party has actually resulted in prejudice or damage to the indemnifying party
or parties.


 


9.5Reimbursement.
The indemnifying party or parties shall pay to the indemnified party in immediately available funds any amounts to
which the indemnified party may become entitled by reason of the provisions of this Agreement, such payment to be made within
five (5) days after any such amounts are finally determined either by mutual agreement of the parties hereto or pursuant to the
final unappealable judgment of a court of competent jurisdiction. In calculating any amount to be paid by an indemnifying party
or parties by reason of the provisions of this Agreement, the amount shall be reduced by all tax benefits and other reimbursements
credited to or received by the other party related to the damages.


 




    C-14


     


    

 


9.6Survival.
The representations and warranties of the parties set forth in Section 5.1 shall survive the execution of this
Agreement indefinitely. All other representations and warranties of Nytis and Carbon TN Mining Co made on the date of execution
of this Agreement shall survive the execution of this Agreement for a period of two (2) years. All other covenants and agreements
contained in this Agreement shall survive the execution of this Agreement until this Agreement is terminated in accordance with
Section 6.2; provided, however, that the indemnification provisions of this ARTICLE 9 shall survive
the execution of this Agreement indefinitely.


 


9.7Exclusive
Remedy. The terms and provisions of this ARTICLE 9 shall be the sole and exclusive remedy of each of the parties
indemnified hereunder with respect to the representations, warranties, covenants and agreements of the parties set forth in this
Agreement and the other documents executed and delivered hereunder, except with respect to any breach of the special warranty
of title contained in the Assignment,.


 


9.8Assumption
of Liability. Each party that is required to assume any obligation or liability of the other party pursuant to this
Agreement or that is required to defend, indemnify or hold the other party harmless hereunder shall, notwithstanding any other
provision hereof to the contrary, be entitled to the use and benefit of all defenses (legal and equitable) and counterclaims of
such other party in defense of third party claims arising out of any such assumption or indemnification.


 


ARTICLE
10


Relationship
of Parties


 


It
is not the purpose or intention hereof to create any mining partnership, joint venture, general partnership or other partnership
relation and none shall be inferred. The parties understand and agree that their relationship hereunder is not one of partnership,
association, trust, joint venture, mining partnership or entity of any kind. The parties intend, however, that pursuant to the
provisions of Subchapter K of Chapter 1 of Subtitle A of the Internal Revenue Code, the arrangement created under this Agreement
is to be treated as a partnership for U.S. federal and state income tax purposes, and each party agrees not to elect to be excluded
from the applicable provisions of said Subchapter K. Therefore, the parties agree to be governed by the Tax Partnership Agreement
attached as Exhibit G to the Operating Agreement. In the event of a conflict between the terms of the Operating Agreement or this
Agreement and the terms and provisions of the Tax Partnership Agreement, the Tax Partnership Agreement shall prevail over the
terms of both this Agreement and the Operating Agreement. For U.S. federal and state income tax purposes (a) the tax partnership
will be treated as (i) holding Nytis’ and CAC’s interests in the Tennessee Mining Tract and the Leases and (ii) engaging
in all activities of the parties with respect to such interests in the Tennessee Mining Tract and the Leases; (b) Nytis will be
treated as contributing its existing interests in the Tennessee Mining Tract and the Leases to the tax partnership in exchange
for an interest in the tax partnership; (c) CAC will be treated as contributing its interests in the Tennessee Mining Tract and
the Leases received pursuant to this Agreement to the tax partnership in exchange for an interest in the tax partnership, (d)
CAC and Nytis will be treated as making capital contributions to the tax partnership in amounts equal to their shares of the costs
incurred pursuant to this Agreement or the Operating AGreement, as they make payments attributable to such costs, and (e) from
and after its commencement, the tax partnership will be treated as realizing all items of income or gain and incurring all items
of cost or expense attributable to the ownership, operation or disposition of such interests in the Tennessee Mining Tract and
the Leases notwithstanding that such items are realized, paid or incurred by parties individually.


 




    C-15


     


    

 


ARTICLE
11

Force Majeure


 


If
any party is rendered unable, wholly or in part, by force majeure to carry out its obligations under this Agreement, other than
an obligation to make payments of money, such party shall give to the other party prompt written notice of the force majeure with
reasonably full particulars concerning it; thereupon, the obligations of the party giving the notice, so far as they are affected
by the force majeure, shall be suspended during, but no longer than, the continuance of the force majeure. The affected party
shall use all reasonable diligence to remove the force majeure situation as quickly as practicable. The requirement that any force
majeure shall be remedied with all reasonable dispatch shall not require the settlement of strikes, lockouts or other labor difficulties
by the party involved, contrary to its wishes; how any such difficulties shall be handled shall be entirely within the discretion
of the party concerned. The term “force majeure”, as here employed, shall mean an act of God, strike, lockout or other
industrial disturbance, act of the public enemy, war, blockade, public riot, lightning, fire, storm, flood, explosion, governmental
action, governmental delay, restraint or inaction, and any other cause, whether of the kind specifically enumerated above or otherwise,
which is not reasonably within the control of the party claiming suspension.


 


ARTICLE
12

Marketing


 


Operator
shall cause production of oil and gas for Carbon TN Mining Co from the Wells and any other wells drilled and completed by the
parties on the Tennessee Mining Tract to be gathered, processed, treated, transported and marketed by Operator or third parties,
after reasonable consultation with Carbon TN Mining Co, with no “mark-up” costs and/or internal fees from Operator
or its affiliates to Carbon TN Mining Co; provided, however, that Operator may charge Carbon TN Mining Co the typical
overhead fees relating to such activities included within the standard COPAS Accounting Procedure annexed to the Operating Agreement.
Any marketing agreement(s) entered into with third parties with respect to production of oil and gas for Carbon TN Mining Co from
the Wells and any other wells drilled and completed by the parties on the Tennessee Mining Tract will be (i) for term(s) of no
longer than twelve (12) months and (ii) otherwise on current market terms on the same basis that production of oil and gas for
Nytis from the Wells and any other wells drilled and completed by the parties on the Tennessee Mining Tract is marketed.


 






    C-16


     


    

 


ARTICLE
13

Notices


 


All
notices and communication required or permitted under this Agreement shall be in writing, delivered to or sent by U.S. Mail or
any other recognized overnight delivery service, postage or similar charges prepaid, or by facsimile, addressed as follows:


 





Nytis
Exploration Company LLC


Attention:
Mark D. Pierce


2480
Fortune Drive, Suite 300


Lexington,
KY 40509


Phone: 859-299-0771


Fax:859-299-0772


 


Carbon
Appalachian Company, LLC


c/o Carbon Natural Gas Company


1700 Broadway, Suite 1170


Denver, CO 80290


Attn:
Patrick R. McDonald


Telephone No. (720) 407-7032


Facsimile No. (720) 407-7031


 


with
a copy to:


 


Old
Ironsides Fund II-A Portfolio Holding Company, LLC and


Old Ironsides Fund II-B Portfolio Holding Company, LLC


10
Saint James Avenue, 19th Floor


Boston,
MA 02116


	 	Attention:	Christopher L. Stoeckle
	 	Phone:	617-366-2038







Fax:


Email:
CStoeckle@oldironsidesenergy.com


 


ARTICLE
14

Conflicts


 


In
the event of any conflict between the provisions of this Agreement and the Operating Agreement, including the Exhibits attached
thereto, the terms of this Agreement shall control.


 


ARTICLE
15


Successors
and Assigns


 


This
Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the parties hereto and their respective permitted successors and assigns.
Neither party shall assign any of its rights and obligations under this Agreement, without the express written consent of the
other party, such consent to not be unreasonably withheld, delayed or conditioned; provided, however, that no consent
shall be required for an assignment in connection with (i) the sale of all or substantially all of such party’s assets or
(ii) the merger or consolidation of such party in which such party is not the survivor, so long as (A) such assignee agrees to
be bound by the provisions of this Agreement, and (B) such party shall promptly notify the other party prior to the making of
such a permitted assignment. No consent shall be required by a party for any mortgage of the other party’s interest herein.


 




    C-17


     


    

 


ARTICLE
16

Governing Law


 


This
Agreement shall be construed under and in accordance with the laws of the State of Colorado, excluding any conflicts-of-law rule
or principle that might apply the law of another jurisdiction. The parties agree that venue for any dispute hereunder shall be
in a Federal or state court in Colorado.


 


ARTICLE
17


No
Third party Beneficiary


 


Nothing
in this Agreement, express or implied, is intended to confer on any person other than the parties hereto any rights, remedies,
obligations or liabilities in and to the Wells, or the interest in lands included therein or pertaining thereto acquired hereunder,
or otherwise, under or by reason of this Agreement.


 


ARTICLE
18


Public
Announcements


 


Subject
to applicable legal requirements, at all times during the term hereof, each party shall promptly advise and cooperate with the
others before issuing, or permitting any of its affiliates, directors, officers, employees, managers, members or agents to issue
any press release or other public announcement with respect to this Agreement or the transactions contemplated hereby.


 


ARTICLE
19


Further
Assurances


 


Each
party agrees to deliver or cause to be delivered to the other parties at such times as shall be requested any additional instrument
that the other may reasonably request for the purpose of carrying out this Agreement.


 


ARTICLE
20


Counterpart
Execution


 


This
Agreement may be executed in one or more counterparts, no one of which need be executed by all parties but all of which shall
constitute but one and the same instrument.


 


ARTICLE
21


Entire
Agreement


 


This
Agreement constitutes the entire understanding between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof, and supersedes all
other agreements, written or oral, between the parties with respect to such subject matter.


 




    C-18


     


    

 


ARTICLE
22


Captions/Headings


 


Any
captions to or headings of the articles, sections, subsections, paragraphs or subparagraphs of this Agreement are solely for the
convenience of the parties, are not a part of this Agreement and shall not be used for the interpretation or determination of
validity of this Agreement or any provision hereof.


 


[Signatures
Begin On The Following Page]


 




    C-19


     


    

 


IN
WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement effective as of the date first set forth above.


 





	 	NYTIS EXPLORATION COMPANY LLC
	 	 	 
	 	By:	Nytis Exploration (USA) Inc., 
	 	 	its Manager
	 	 	 
	 	By: 	/s/ Patrick R. McDonald
	 	 	Patrick R. McDonald,
	 	 	President
	 	 	 
	 	CARBON TENNESSEE MINING COMPANY, LLC
	 	 	 
	 	By:	Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC, 
	 	 	its sole Member
	 	 	 
	 	By: 	Carbon Natural Gas Company, its Manager
	 	 	 
	 	By: 	/s/ Patrick R. McDonald
	 	 	Patrick R. McDonald,
	 	 	Chief Executive Officer




 


Signature
Page


Participation
Agreement


 




     


     


    

 


EXHIBIT
A


 


Description
of Leases


 


Oil,
Gas and Coal Seam Gas Lease dated December 1, 1998 between Tennessee Mining, Inc., as Lessor, and Addington Exploration, LLC,
as Lessee, of record at Book 1086, Page 408, records of the Anderson County, TN Register of Deeds; in Miscellaneous Book 45, Page
181, records of the Campbell County, TN Register of Deeds; and in Miscellaneous Book 132, Page 431, records of the Scott County,
TN Register of Deeds. This lease contained approximately 70,000 acres, and was partially assigned back to the successor-in-interest
to Tennessee Mining, Inc., Nytis Exploration Company, LLC, by Partial Assignment and Surrender of Oil and Gas Lease dated September
29, 2015 from Knox Energy, LLC, successor-in-interest to Addington Exploration, LLC, which agreement is unrecorded.


 




    Exhibit A – Page 1


     


    

 


EXHIBIT
B


 


General
Outline of Contract Area


 


[See Attached]


 




    Exhibit B – Page 1


     


    

 


 




    Exhibit B – Page 2


     


    

 


EXHIBIT
C


 


Form
of Operating Agreement


 




    Exhibit C – Page 1


     


    

 


EXHIBIT
D


 


FORM
OF REASSIGNMENT


 

[See Attached]


 




    Exhibit D – Page 1


     


    

 


ASSIGNMENT


 


	STATE OF TENNESSEE	)
	 	)ss.
	COUNTY OF___________	)




 


ASSIGNMENT
OF PARTIAL INTEREST IN OIL AND GAS LEASES


 


This
Assignment of Partial Interest in Oil and Gas Leases (“Assignment”) is entered into as of February ___,
2017 (the “Effective Date”), by and between CARBON TENNESSEE MINING COMPANY, LLC, a Delaware limited
liability company (“Assignor”) and NYTIS EXPLORATION COMPANY LLC, a Delaware limited liability
company (“Assignee”).


 


For
good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, subject to the express reservations
and exceptions noted herein, Assignor hereby assigns, sells, and conveys to Assignee twenty-five percent (25%) of the undivided
right, title and interest in the working interest previously assigned to Assignor pursuant to the Prior Assignment (as defined
below) in the following described properties, rights and interests. The “Prior Assignment” means that
certain Assignment of Partial Interest in Oil and Gas Leases by Assignee to Assignor, dated as of February [ ], 2017, and relating
to the Leases and Lands described on Exhibit “A” to this Assignment.


 


(a)       The
oil and gas leases (the “Leases”) on the lands located in [       ]
Counties, Tennessee (the “Lands”), which are more particularly described on Exhibit “A”
to this Assignment;


 


(b)       Without
limitation of the foregoing, all other right, title and interest (of whatever kind or character, whether legal or equitable, and
whether vested or contingent) of Assignor in and to the Lands or described in any of the Leases or other instruments described
on such Exhibit A (including, without limitation, interests in oil, gas and/or mineral leases, production payments, net
profits interests, fee mineral interests, fee royalty interests and other interests insofar as they cover such lands) (the “Other
Rights”);


 


(c)       All
pooled, communitized, or unitized acreage which includes all or part of any Leases, and all tenements, hereditaments, and appurtenances
belonging thereto (the “Units,” and, together with the Leases and the Other Rights, the “Properties”);
and


 


(d)       All
hydrocarbons produced from, or attributable to, the Properties from and after the Effective Date; all hydrocarbon inventories
from or attributable to the Properties that are in storage on the Effective Date; and, to the extent related or attributable to
the Properties, all production, plant, and transportation imbalances as of the Effective Date; and all make-up rights with respect
to take-or-pay payments.


 




    Exhibit D – Page 2


     


    

 


The
properties, rights and interests described in subparagraphs (a) through (d) above are herein referred to as the “Assets”.


 


Assignor
expressly reserves and excepts from this Assignment the following: (a) all of Assignor’s right, title and interest in the
Lands and Leases which are not expressly conveyed to Assignee, (b) the right of ingress and egress over, under and on the Lands
for the use, development, and enjoyment of the interests reserved herein, and (c) the wells and associated Approved Spacing Units
(as defined in the Participation Agreement) described on Exhibit “B” to this Assignment.


 


Assignee
accepts this Assignment and the interests conveyed hereby and assumes and agrees to perform all of Assignor’s obligations
thereunder.


 


The
Assignor, for itself, its successors and assigns does covenant and agree that it shall warrant and forever defend the above assigned
right, title and interest against all and every person or persons claiming the whole or any part thereof, by, through or under
the Assignor, but not otherwise. The interests conveyed herein are hereby conveyed to and accepted by Assignee in an “as
is, where is” condition and without any warranty or representation of any kind as to their marketability, condition and/or
fitness for a particular purpose, all of which are expressly disclaimed.


 


The
interest in the Leases assigned to Assignee herein shall bear and be subject to its proportionate share of all burdens affecting
or against the Leases which are of record as of the Effective Date of this Assignment.


 


This
Agreement shall be binding on and shall inure to the benefit of Assignor and Assignee and their respective heirs, personal representatives,
successors, and/or assigns.


 


This
Assignment is made in accordance with, and subject to, all the terms and provisions of that certain Participation Agreement dated
February __, 2017 between Assignor and Assignee (the “Participation Agreement”), which is incorporated
herein by reference for all purposes.


 


This
Assignment is signed as of the date of acknowledgment of the signatures below, but shall be effective for all purposes as of the
Effective Date stated above.


 


Signatures
appear on the following page.


 




    Exhibit D – Page 3


     


    

 


IN
WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Assignment effective as of the date first set forth above.


 





	 	NYTIS EXPLORATION COMPANY LLC
	 	 	 
	 	By: 	Nytis Exploration (USA) Inc.,
	 	 	its Manager
	 	 	 
	 	By:	 
	 	 	Patrick R. McDonald, 
	 	 	President
	 	 	 
	 	CARBON TENNESSEE MINING COMPANY, LLC
	 	 	 
	 	By: 	Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC, 

its sole Member
	 	 	 
	 	By: 	Carbon Natural Gas Company, its Manager
	 	 	 
	 	By:	 
	 	 	Patrick R. McDonald,
	 	 	Chief Executive Officer




 


Prepared
by:________________________


Michael
J. Potter


2480
Fortune Drive, Suite 300


Lexington, Kentucky 40509


 




    Exhibit D – Page 4


     


    

 


STATE
OF COLORADO


 


CITY
AND COUNTY OF DENVER


 


The
foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ___ day of February, 2017, by Patrick R. McDonald, President of Nytis Exploration
USA Inc., the manager of Nytis Exploration Company LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, on behalf of said limited liability
company.


 





	 	 
	 	Notary
Public in and for the State of Colorado



 


STATE
OF COLORADO


 


CITY
AND COUNTY OF DENVER


 


The
foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ___ day of February, 2017, by Patrick R. McDonald, Chief Executive Officer
of Carbon Natural Gas Company, the manager of Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, the sole
member of Carbon Tennessee Mining Company, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, on behalf of said limited liability company.


 





	 	 
	 	Notary
Public in and for the State of Colorado


 




    Exhibit D – Page 5


     


    

 


EXHIBIT
E


 


FORM
OF LEASE ASSIGNMENT


 


[See Attached]


 




    Exhibit E – Page 1


     


    

 


ASSIGNMENT


 





	STATE OF TENNESSEE	)
	 	)ss.
	COUNTY OF___________	)


 


ASSIGNMENT
OF PARTIAL INTEREST IN OIL AND GAS LEASES


 


This
Assignment of Partial Interest in Oil and Gas Leases (“Assignment”) is entered into as of February ___,
2017 (the “Effective Date”), by and between NYTIS EXPLORATION COMPANY LLC, a Delaware limited
liability company (“Assignor”), and CARBON TENNESSEE MINING COMPANY, LLC, a Delaware limited liability
company (“Assignee”).


 


For
good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, subject to the express reservations
and exceptions noted herein, Assignor hereby assigns, sells, and conveys to Assignee seventy-five percent (75%) of Assignor’s
undivided right, title and interest in the working interest in the following described properties, rights and interests:


 


(d)       The
oil and gas leases (the “Leases”) on the lands located in [       ]
Counties, Tennessee (the “Lands”), which are more particularly described on Exhibit
“A” to this Assignment;


 


(e)       Without
limitation of the foregoing, all other right, title and interest (of whatever kind or character, whether legal or equitable, and
whether vested or contingent) of Assignor in and to the Lands or described in any of the Leases or other instruments described
on such Exhibit A (including, without limitation, interests in oil, gas and/or mineral leases, production payments, net
profits interests, fee mineral interests, fee royalty interests and other interests insofar as they cover such lands) (the “Other
Rights”);


 


(f)       All
pooled, communitized, or unitized acreage which includes all or part of any Leases, and all tenements, hereditaments, and appurtenances
belonging thereto (the “Units,” and, together with the Leases and the Other Rights, the “Properties”);
and


 


(g)       All
hydrocarbons produced from, or attributable to, the Properties from and after the Effective Date; all hydrocarbon inventories
from or attributable to the Properties that are in storage on the Effective Date; and, to the extent related or attributable to
the Properties, all production, plant, and transportation imbalances as of the Effective Date; and all make-up rights with respect
to take-or-pay payments.


 


The
properties, rights and interests described in subparagraphs (a) through (d) above are herein referred to as the “Assets”.


 




    Exhibit E – Page 2


     


    

 


Assignor
expressly reserves and excepts from this Assignment the following: (a) all of Assignor’s right, title and interest in the
Lands and Leases which are not expressly conveyed to Assignee and (b) the right of ingress and egress over, under and on the Lands
for the use, development, and enjoyment of the interests reserved herein.


 


Assignee
accepts this Assignment and the interests conveyed hereby and assumes and agrees to perform all of Assignor’s obligations
thereunder from and after the Effective Date.


 


The
Assignor, for itself, its successors and assigns does covenant and agree that it shall warrant and forever defend the above assigned
right, title and interest against all and every person or persons claiming the whole or any part thereof, by, through or under
the Assignor, but not otherwise. The interests conveyed herein are hereby conveyed to and accepted by Assignee in an “as
is, where is” condition and without any warranty or representation of any kind as to their marketability, condition and/or
fitness for a particular purpose, all of which are expressly disclaimed.


 


The
interest in the Leases assigned to Assignee herein shall bear and be subject to its proportionate share of all burdens affecting
or against the Leases which are of record as of the Effective Date of this Assignment.


 


This
Agreement shall be binding on and shall inure to the benefit of Assignor and Assignee and their respective heirs, personal representatives,
successors, and/or assigns.


 


This
Assignment is made in accordance with, and subject to, all the terms and provisions of that certain Participation Agreement dated
February __, 2017 between Assignor and Assignee (the “Participation Agreement”), which is incorporated
herein by reference for all purposes.


 


This
Assignment is signed as of the date of acknowledgment of the signatures below, but shall be effective for all purposes as of the
Effective Date stated above.


 


Signatures
appear on the following page.


 




    Exhibit E – Page 3


     


    

 


IN
WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Assignment effective as of the date first set forth above.


 





	 	NYTIS EXPLORATION COMPANY LLC
	 	 	 
	 	By: 	Nytis Exploration (USA) Inc.,
	 	 	its Manager
	 	 	 
	 	By:	 
	 	 	Patrick R. McDonald, 
	 	 	President
	 	 	 
	 	CARBON TENNESSEE MINING COMPANY, LLC
	 	 	 
	 	By: 	Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC, 
	 	 	its sole Member
	 	 	 
	 	By: 	Carbon Natural Gas Company, its Manager
	 	 	 
	 	By:	 
	 	 	Patrick R. McDonald,
	 	 	Chief Executive Officer


 


Prepared
by:___________________________


Michael
J. Potter


2480
Fortune Drive, Suite 300


Lexington, Kentucky 40509


 




    Exhibit E – Page 4


     


    

 


STATE
OF COLORADO


 


CITY
AND COUNTY OF DENVER


 


The
foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ___ day of February, 2017, by Patrick R. McDonald, President of Nytis Exploration
USA Inc., the manager of Nytis Exploration Company LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, on behalf of said limited liability
company.


 





	 	 
	 	Notary
Public in and for the State of Colorado


 


STATE
OF COLORADO


 


CITY
AND COUNTY OF DENVER


 


The
foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ___ day of February, 2017, by Patrick R. McDonald, Chief Executive Officer
of Carbon Natural Gas Company, the manager of Carbon Appalachian Company, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, the sole
member of Carbon Tennessee Mining Company, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, on behalf of said limited liability company.


 





	 	 
	 	Notary
Public in and for the State of Colorado


 




    Exhibit E – Page 5


     


    

 


EXHIBIT F


 


ALLOCATION OF DRILLING AND COMPLETION COSTS


 





	Number of Partial Reassignments executed and delivered by Carbon TN Mining Co pursuant to Section 2.4	 	Direct Carbon TN Mining Co costs (i.e., Drilling and Completion Costs borne by Carbon TN Mining Co for Carbon TN Mining Co’s account)	 	Carry Costs (i.e., Drilling and Completion Costs borne by Carbon TN Mining Co for Nytis’ account)	 	Direct Nytis Costs (i.e., Drilling and Completion Costs borne by Nytis for Nytis’ account)
	No Partial Reassignments	 	75%	 	25%	 	0%
	1 Partial Reassignment	 	56.25%	 	18.75%	 	25%
	2 Partial Reassignment	 	37.5%	 	12.5%	 	50%
	3 Partial Reassignment	 	18.75%	 	6.25%	 	75%
	4 Partial Reassignment	 	0%	 	0%	 	100%




 






    Exhibit F – Page 1


     


    

 


SCHEDULE 5.1(c)


 


Required Filings


 


1.
Each of the Assignments will be recorded in the clerk and recorder’s office in the appropriate counties.



 






    Schedule 5.1(c)


     


    

 


SCHEDULE 5.2(e)


 


Working Interests; Net Revenue Interests


 


	Lease Name	 	Acreage	 	County	 	State	 	RI	 	WI	 	NRI
	Tennessee

Mining Tract	 	65,000

(Approx.)	 	Anderson

Scott

Campbell	 	TN	 	12.5%	 	100	 	87.5%



  






    Schedule 5.2(e)


     


    

 


SCHEDULE 5.2(f)


 


Insurance


 


See attached.


 






    Schedule 5.2(f) – Page 1


     


    

 





 



    Schedule 5.2(f) – Page 2


     


    

 


EXHIBIT D


 


INITIAL BUDGET


 


[TO COME.]


 






     D-1


     


    

 


EXHIBIT E


 


INITIAL INSURANCE


 


[See Attached.]


 






     E-1


     


    

 





 






     E-2


     


    

 


EXHIBIT G


 


AMI


 


 


 


G-1