# CEIVE D JA N 2 8 2^1 ^ Michae l Selig , MD , FACC , CFI- H u cAPINf ^ DOCKE T 281 6 Orefiel d Roa d HcAKIN O L . .f ^ Allentown . PA . 1810 4

U.S . DEPARTMEN TO F TRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O F HEARING S = ''^3 ^ WASHINGTON , D.C . " ^ cyi^iz j n: . U :-- . h O 

# Hi s u o Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n ^ ° Com'^dnints""^' ' ^"""'"^ ' Honorabl e Judg e Ronni e Yode r V . Docket : 2010-121 1 M & R Helicopters , LLC . Responden t .J O

MOTIO N FO R MOR E DEFINITE STATEMEN T CHANGIN G TH E FUNDAMENTA LCAUS E O F ACTIO N AN D NOW , come s respondent , MICHAE LB . SELIG , MD , FACC , principl e fo rM R Helicopters , LLC , (MRH ) (non-operationa l sinc e 2007 ) who m aver s an d file s th e followin g Motio n fo rmor e definit e statemen t i n repl yt o complainant s claimin g th e underlyin g premis e an d caus e o factio n fo rthi s propose d civi l penalt yha s no t change d fro m M s William s lO P 9 record . 1 Th e sol e an d primar ypremis e fo rthi s violation , clearl ydocumente d i n M s William s Inspecto rStatemen t lO P 9 record , wa s M s William' s inabilit yt o validat e FA

Aapprove d dru g an d alcoho l testin g progra m informatio n fo rMr Baker . 1 -

### 2 . Ms William s wa s give n evidenc e tha t M rBake rwa s o n a monitorin g

progra m bu t selecte d no t t o pursu e primarysourc e verificatio n and/o r confirmatio n o fthes e fact s pursuan t t o §13.224 , perhap s fo rth e reaso n tha tsh e wa s i n a rus h t o ge t he rallege d civi l penalt yout , 1 da ybefor e th e statut e o f limitations . 3 . Onc e M s William s confirme d tha tM rBake rwa s alway s o n a monitorin g progra m unde rhi s disclose d ful l tim e employer , sh e the n stiifte d tti e fundamenta l basi s (prinnar yfocus ) t o a caus e o factio n violation , t o M rBake rno t bein g o n MRHs ow n companie s monitorin g program , despit e previousl y releasin g th e othe rMechanic/I Afro m thos e regulation s wh o performe d safet y sensitiv e function s unde rexactl yidentica l circumstances . 4 . O fnote , th e reference d violatio n date s cite d wer e Novembe r2 . 200 7 t o Jul y24 , 2008 , a tim e durin g whic h MR H ha d shu tdow n operation s du e t o Huma n factor s i n accordanc e t o 119.69 . MR H i n goo d judgmen tterminate d operation s i n Jun e 200 7 demonstratin g anothe rprocedura l defec tan d prosecutoria l overreaching . 5 . I t als o becam e obviou s tha tth e revise d regulation s o fth e drug/alcohol s program s ne wdefinitio n o femploye rtha twer e no tevident , disclosed , o reve n know n b ya prio rFA ADrug/Alcoho l auditor , M R Vincen t Roots , durin g hi s audi to fMR H i n Marc h 2004 an d thereb ycoul d no tinfor m responden t o fth e regulatio n change . 6 . No rwer e an yothe rFA Aofficial s wh o performe d frequen tinspection so fMRH s operations , locate d acros s th e stree t fro m th e Allentow n FSD O wer e

informed , checke d th e s o calle d "Publi cRegistry " o rkne wanythin g abou t thes e regulation s an d therefor e confirme d an d approve d operation s o fth e responden t fo r6 years . 7 . Therefore , quit e t o th e contrary , complainant s hav e shifte d thei r movin g targe t primar yfocu s o fthei rcomplain t basi s t o pursu e a violatio n b y whateve rmean s neede d t o warran t thei rfrivolou s violatio n b yusin g inconsisten t colo ro fla warguments . WHEREFORE , th e responden t pray s tha t thi s Honorabl e Cour twil l dismis s thi s cas e i n th e effor t o fjudicia l economy . Respectfull ySubmitted , Michae l B . Selig , MD , FACC . Dat e