32716 Federal Register / Vol. 79, No. 109 / Friday, June 6, 2014 / Notices 

14Big Data Report at 45. 

15PCAST Report at 39. 

16 Id. at 21. 

17 Id. at 38. 

18 Id. at 39. 

19Big Data Report at 51, 53. 

20 Id. at 49. 

21PCAST Report at 40–41. 

22 Id. at 41. 

23See National Institute of Standards and 

Technology, Privacy Engineering Workshop (Apr. 

9–10, 2014), available at: http://www.nist.gov/itl/

csd/privacy-engineering-workshop.cfm. 

individuals.’’ 14 How significant are 

such risks? How could they be 

addressed in the context of the 

Consumer Privacy Bill of Rights? 

Should they be? Should potential 

privacy legislation impose similar 

obligations with respect to uses of data 

that are not currently regulated? 

9. How significant are the privacy 

risks posed by unindexed data backups 

and other ‘‘latent information about 

individuals?’’ 15 Do standard methods 

exist for determining whether data is 

sufficiently obfuscated and/or 

unavailable as to be irretrievable as a 

practical matter? 

10. The PCAST Report notes that 

‘‘data fusion occurs when data from 

different sources are brought into 

contact and new, often unexpected, 

phenomena emerge;’’ this process 

‘‘frequently results in the identification 

of individual people,’’ even when the 

underlying data sources were not linked 

to individuals’ identities.16 How 

significant are the privacy risks 

associated with this? How should 

entities performing big data analysis 

implement individuals’ requests to 

delete personal data when previously 

unassociated information becomes 

associated with an individual at a 

subsequent date? Do existing systems 

enable entities to log and act on deletion 

requests on an ongoing basis? 

11. As the PCAST Report explains, ‘‘it 

is increasingly easy to defeat [deidentification of personal data] by the 

very techniques that are being 

developed for many legitimate 

applications of big data.’’ 17 However, 

de-identification may remain useful as 

an added safeguard in some contexts, 

particularly when employed in 

combination with policy safeguards.18

How significant are the privacy risks 

posed by re-identification of deidentified data? How can deidentification be used to mitigate 

privacy risks in light of the analytical 

capabilities of big data? Can particular 

policy safeguards bolster the 

effectiveness of de-identification? Does 

the relative efficacy of de-identification 

depend on whether it is applied to 

public or private data sets? Can 

differential privacy mitigate risks in 

some cases? What steps could the 

government or private sector take to 

expand the capabilities and practical 

application of these techniques? 

12. The Big Data Report concludes 

that ‘‘big data technologies can cause 

societal harms beyond damages to 

privacy, such as discrimination against 

individuals and groups’’ and warns ‘‘big 

data could enable new forms of 

discrimination and predatory 

practices.’’ 19 The Report states that ‘‘it 

is the responsibility of government to 

ensure that transformative technologies 

are used fairly’’ and urges agencies to 

determine ‘‘how to protect citizens from 

new forms of discrimination that may be 

enabled by big data technologies.’’ 20

Should the Consumer Privacy Bill of 

Rights address the risk of discriminatory 

effects resulting from automated 

decision processes using personal data, 

and if so, how? How could consumer 

privacy legislation (either alone or in 

combination with anti-discrimination 

laws) make a useful contribution to 

addressing this concern? Should big 

data analytics be accompanied by 

assessments of the potential 

discriminatory impacts on protected 

classes? 

Possible Approaches to Big Data 

Suggested by the Reports and the Big 

Data Workshops 

13. Can accountability mechanisms 

play a useful role in promoting socially 

beneficial uses of big data while 

safeguarding privacy? Should ethics 

boards, privacy advisory committees, 

consumer advisory boards, or 

Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) be 

consulted when practical limits frustrate 

transparency and individuals’ control 

over their personal information? How 

could such entities be structured? How 

might they be useful in the commercial 

context? Can privacy impact 

assessments and third-party audits 

complement the work of such entities? 

What kinds of parameters would be 

valuable for different kinds of big data 

analysts to consider, and what kinds of 

incentives might be most effective in 

promoting their consideration? 

14. Would a system using ‘‘privacy 

preference profiles,’’ as discussed in 

Section 4.5.1 of the PCAST Report, 

mitigate privacy risks regarding big data 

analysis? 21

15. Related to the concept of ‘‘privacy 

preference profiles,’’ some have urged 

that privacy preferences could be 

attached to and travel with personal 

data (in the form of metadata), thereby 

enabling recipients of data to know how 

to handle the data.22 Could such an 

approach mitigate privacy risks 

regarding big data analysis? 

16. Would the development of a 

framework for privacy risk management 

be an effective mechanism for 

addressing challenges with big data? 23

17. Can emerging privacy enhancing 

technologies mitigate privacy risks to 

individuals while preserving the 

benefits of robust aggregate data sets? 

18. How can the approaches and 

issues addressed in Questions 14–17 be 

accommodated within the Consumer 

Privacy Bill of Rights? 

19. What other approaches to big data 

could be considered to promote 

privacy? 

20. What other questions should we 

be asking about big data and consumer 

privacy? 

Dated: June 3, 2014. 

Angela M. Simpson, 

Deputy Assistant Secretary for 

Communications and Information. 

[FR Doc. 2014–13195 Filed 6–5–14; 8:45 am] 

BILLING CODE 3510–60–P 

COMMITTEE FOR PURCHASE FROM 

PEOPLE WHO ARE BLIND OR 

SEVERELY DISABLED 

Procurement List Proposed Additions 

and Deletions 

AGENCY: Committee for Purchase from 

People Who are Blind or Severely 

Disabled. 

ACTION: Proposed Additions to and 

Deletions from the Procurement List. 

SUMMARY: The Committee is proposing 

to add products and services to the 

Procurement List that will be furnished 

by nonprofit agencies employing 

persons who are blind or have other 

severe disabilities, and deletes products 

and a service previously furnished by 

such agencies. 

DATES: Comments must be received on 

or before: 7/7/2014. 

ADDRESSES: Committee for Purchase 

From People Who Are Blind or Severely 

Disabled, 1401 S. Clark Street, Suite 

10800, Arlington, Virginia, 22202–4149. 

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: 

Barry S. Lineback, Telephone: (703) 

603–7740, Fax: (703) 603–0655, or email 

CMTEFedReg@AbilityOne.gov. 

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: This 

notice is published pursuant to 41 

U.S.C. 8503(a)(2) and 41 CFR 51–2.3. Its 

purpose is to provide interested persons 

an opportunity to submit comments on 

the proposed actions. 


wreier-aviles on DSK5TPTVN1PROD with NOTICES
Federal Register / Vol. 79, No. 109 / Friday, June 6, 2014 / Notices 32717 

Additions 

If the Committee approves the 

proposed additions, the entities of the 

Federal Government identified in this 

notice will be required to procure the 

products and services listed below from 

nonprofit agencies employing persons 

who are blind or have other severe 

disabilities. 

The following products and services 

are proposed for addition to the 

Procurement List for production by the 

nonprofit agencies listed: 

Products 

NSN: 8540–00–NIB–0093—Tissue, Toilet, 1- 

Ply, White, 96 rolls 

NSN: 8540–00–NIB–0094—Tissue, Toilet, 2- 

Ply, White, 96 rolls 

NPA: Outlook-Nebraska, Inc., Omaha, NE 

Contracting Activity: General Services 

Administration, New York, NY 

Coverage: A-List for the Total Government 

Requirement as aggregated by the 

General Services Administration, New 

York, NY. 

NSN: 7490–00–NIB–0044—Paper Shredder, 

High Security, Level 6, Cabinet Style 

NSN: 7490–00–NIB–0045—Paper Shredder, 

Desk-Side, Personal, Level 3, Cross-Cut 

NPA: L.C. Industries, Inc., Durham, NC 

Contracting Activity: General Services 

Administration, New York, NY 

Coverage: A-List for the Total Government 

Requirement as aggregated by the 

General Services Administration, New 

York, NY. 

Individual Lockout Devices 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0160—Safety Padlock, 

Red, 1.5′′ Shackle 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0162—Hasp, Steel with 

Tabs, 1′′ 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0163—Large Plug 

Lockout with Label 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0164—Small Plug 

Lockout with Label 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0166—Gate Valve 

Lockout, 1′′ to 2–1⁄ fxsp0;2′′ 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0169—Gate Valve 

Lockout, 2–1/2′′ to 5′′ 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0183—Wall Switch 

Lockout 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0204—Universal Single 

Circuit Breaker Lockout 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0205—Universal Multipole Circuit Breaker Lockout 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0208—Hasp, 1.5′′ Steel 

with Tabs 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0213—Cable/Valve/

Hasp Lockout Device 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0220—6 Lockout 

Padlocks, Nylon, Red 

NSN: 5340–00–NIB–0221—3 Lockout 

Padlocks, Nylon, Red 

Lockout/Tagout Kits 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0161—Lockout Tags, 25- 

pack 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0185—Kit, Lockout, 

Electrical/Valve with AC Sensor 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0202—Lockout/Tagout 

Station, 3 Padlocks 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0203—Lockout/Tagout 

Station, 8 Padlocks 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0207—AC Sensor, 50V– 

1000V 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0228—Medium 

Electrical Lockout Kit with Breaker 

Lockouts 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0229—Large Electrical 

Lockout Kit 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0230—Large Electrical/

Valve Lockout Kit 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0231—Small Standard 

Lockout Kit 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0232—Extra Small 

Personal Electrical Lockout Kit 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0233—Small Electrical 

Lockout Kit 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0234—Small Electrical 

Lockout Kit with Plug Lockouts 

NSN: 4240–00–NIB–0236—Small Electrical 

Valve Lockout Kit 

NPA: Association for the Blind and Visually 

Impaired—Goodwill Industries of 

Greater Rochester, Rochester, New York 

Contracting Activity: Defense Logistics 

Agency Troop Support, Philadelphia, PA 

Coverage: B-List for the Broad Government 

requirement as aggregated by the Defense 

Logistics Agency Troop Support, 

Philadelphia, PA. 

Broom, Sweeping 

NSN: 7920–00–NIB–0570—Extra-Rough 

Surface, 24′′ Block with 60′′ Handle 

NSN: 7920–00–NIB–0571—Smooth Surface, 

24′′ Block with 60′′ Handle 

NSN: 7920–00–NIB–0572—Medium Surface, 

24′′ Block with 60′′ Handle 

NPA: Industries for the Blind, Inc., West 

Allis, WI 

Contracting Activity: General Services 

Administration, Fort Worth, TX 

Coverage: B-List for the Broad Government 

Requirement as aggregated by the 

General Services Administration, Fort 

Worth, TX. 

NSN: 5120–00–900–6103—Hammer—3 lb, 

Cross-Peen, 15′′ Fiberglass Handle, 

Cushioned Grip 

NPA: Keystone Vocational Services, Inc., 

Sharon, PA 

Contracting Activity: General Services 

Administration, Tools Acquisition 

Division I, Kansas City, MO 

Coverage: B-List for the Broad Government 

Requirement as aggregated by the 

General Services Administration, Kansas 

City, MO. 

NSN: MR 331—Pitter, Cherry and Olive 

NSN: MR 332—Peeler, Corn 

NSN: MR 335—Squeezer, Citrus, Aluminum 

NSN: MR 896—Turner, Flexible, Thin, 

11.5′′X12′′X4′′ 

NPA: Cincinnati Association for the Blind, 

Cincinnati, OH 

Contracting Activity: Defense Commissary 

Agency, Fort Lee, VA 

Coverage: C-List for the requirements of 

military commissaries and exchanges as 

aggregated by the Defense Commissary 

Agency, Fort Lee, VA. 

NSN: MR 604—Drinking Straws, Flexible, 

Clear, 180ct 

NSN: MR 10663—Pouf Balls, Bath, Toddler 

NSN: MR 10674—Funnel, Collapsible 

NSN: MR 10679—Baster, Bottletop 

NPA: Winston-Salem Industries for the 

Blind, Inc., Winston-Salem, NC 

Contracting Activity: Defense Commissary 

Agency, Fort Lee, VA 

Coverage: C-List for the requirements of 

military commissaries and exchanges as 

aggregated by the Defense Commissary 

Agency, Fort Lee, VA. 

NSN: MR 399—Set, Cookie Cutter, Assorted, 

3PC 

NPA: Industries for the Blind, Inc., West 

Allis, WI 

Contracting Activity: Defense Commissary 

Agency, Fort Lee, VA 

Coverage: C-List for the requirements of 

military commissaries and exchanges as 

aggregated by the Defense Commissary 

Agency, Fort Lee, VA. 

Battery 

NSN: 6135–01–372–5191—NEDA 1811A, 

Non-Rechargeable, 12.0V, AlkalineManganese Dioxide Zinc 

NSN: 6135–01–174–8057—NEDA 1166A, 

Non-Rechargeable, 1.5V, AlkalineManganese Dioxide 

NSN: 6140–01–413–3926—NEDA 1.2H2, 

Rechargeable, 1.2V, Nickel-Metal 

Hydride, PG/4 

NSN: 6140–01–467–3225—NEDA 1.2H2, 

Rechargeable, 1.2V, Nickel-Metal 

Hydride, PG/2. 

NSN: 6135–01–394–8087—NEDA 1168A, 

Non-Rechargeable, 1.5V, AlkalineManganese Dioxide 

NSN: 6135–01–268–2151—NEDA 1414A, 

Non-Rechargeable, 6.0V, AlkalineManganese Dioxide 

NSN: 6135–01–314–8415—NEDA 5000LC, 

Non-Rechargeable, 3.0V, Lithium 

NSN: 6135–01–526–6530—NEDA 5003LC, 

Non-Rechargeable, 3.0V, LithiumManganese Dioxide 

NSN: 6135–01–210–8715—NEDA 5004LC, 

Non-Rechargeable, 3.0V, LithiumManganese Dioxide 

NSN: 6135–01–320–4815—NEDA 5011LC, 

Non-Rechargeable, 3.0V, Lithium 

NSN: 6135–01–263–3611—NEDA 5012LC, 

Non-rechargeable, 3.0V, LithiumManganese Dioxide 

NSN: 6135–01–522–2463—NEDA 5021LC, 

Non-Rechargeable, 3.0V, Lithium 

Manganese Dioxide 

NSN: 6135–01–462–4007—NEDA 5032LC, 

Non-Rechargeable, 6.0V, LithiumManganese Dioxide 

NSN: 6135–01–534–0310—NEDA 5046LC, 

Non-Rechargeable, 3.0V, LithiumManganese Dioxide 

NSN: 6135–01–138–8157—NEDA 7003ZD, 

Non-Rechargeable, 1.4V, Zinc Air 

NSN: 6135–01–586–4220—NEDA 5018LC, 

Non-Rechargeable, 3.0V, Lithium Photo 

NPA: Eastern Carolina Vocational Center, 

Inc., Greenville, NC 

Contracting Activity: Defense Logistics 

Agency Land and Maritime, Columbus, 

OH 

Coverage: C-List for 100% of the requirement 

of the Department of Defense, as 

aggregated by the Defense Logistics 

Agency Land and Maritime, Columbus, 

OH. 

NSN: 6850–01–560–6131—Calcium, Lime, 

and Rust Remover, 5 GL 

NPA: The Lighthouse for the Blind, St. Louis, 


wreier-aviles on DSK5TPTVN1PROD with NOTICES
32718 Federal Register / Vol. 79, No. 109 / Friday, June 6, 2014 / Notices 

MO 

Contracting Activity: Defense Logistics 

Agency Aviation, Richmond, VA 

Coverage: A-List for the Total Government 

Requirement as aggregated by the 

Defense Logistics Agency Aviation, 

Richmond, VA. 

Services 

Service Type/Location: Custodial Service, 

Federal Aviation Administration, Atlanta 

Large TRACON, 784 Highway 74 South, 

Peachtree City, GA 

NPA: New Ventures Enterprises, Inc., 

LaGrange, GA 

Contracting Activity: Dept. of Transportation, 

Federal Aviation Administration, College 

Park, GA 

Service Type/Location: Fleet Maintenance, 

U.S. Department of Energy, National 

Nuclear Security Administration, Agent 

Operations Eastern Command, Office of 

Secure Transportation, Transportation 

Safeguards Training Site, Fort Chaffee, 

AR, 11408 Roberts Blvd., Fort Smith, AR 

NPA: Skookum Educational Programs, 

Bremerton, WA 

Contracting Activity: Department of Energy, 

National Nuclear Security Administion 

Business Services Division, Washington, 

DC 

Deletions 

The following products and service 

are proposed for deletion from the 

Procurement List: 

Products 

Ergo Aluminum Broom Handle & Mophead 

NSN: 7920–01–503–1669 

NSN: 7920–01–503–1670 

NSN: 7920–01–503–1671 

NSN: 7920–01–503–1672 

NSN: 7920–01–503–5365 

NSN: 7920–01–503–5366 

NSN: 7920–01–503–5367 

NPA: Industries for the Blind, Inc., West 

Allis, WI 

Contracting Activities: Department Of 

Veterans Affairs, NAC, Hines, IL; General 

Services Administration, Fort Worth, TX 

Service 

Service Type/Location: Linen Distribution, 

Veterans Affairs Medical Center, 1900 

East Main Street, Danville, IL 

NPA: WorkSource Enterprises, NFP, 

Danville, IL 

Contracting Activity: Department Of Veterans 

Affairs, 251-Network Contract Office 11, 

Indianapolis, IN 

Barry S. Lineback, 

Director, Business Operations. 

[FR Doc. 2014–13317 Filed 6–5–14; 8:45 am] 

BILLING CODE 6353–01–P 

CONSUMER PRODUCT SAFETY 

COMMISSION 

[Docket No. CPSC–2011–0014] 

Submission for OMB Review; 

Comment Request— Generic 

Clearance for the Collection of 

Qualitative Feedback on Agency 

Service Delivery. 

AGENCY: Consumer Product Safety 

Commission. 

ACTION: Notice. 

SUMMARY: As required by the Paperwork 

Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 

Chapter 35), the Consumer Product 

Safety Commission (CPSC or 

Commission) announces that the CPSC 

has submitted to the Office of 

Management and Budget (OMB) a 

request for extension of approval of a 

collection of information relating to the 

generic clearance for the collection of 

qualitative feedback on agency service 

delivery (OMB No. 3041–0148). In the 

Federal Register of March 13, 2014 (79 

FR 14237), the CPSC published a notice 

announcing the agency’s intent to seek 

an extension of approval of this 

collection of information. CPSC 

received no comments in response to 

that notice. Therefore, by publication of 

this notice, the Commission announces 

that CPSC has submitted to the OMB a 

request for extension of approval of that 

collection of information without 

change. 

DATES: Written comments on this 

request for extension of approval of 

information collection requirements 

should be submitted by July 7, 2014. 

ADDRESSES: Submit comments about 

this request by email: OIRA_

submission@omb.eop.gov or fax: 202– 

395–6881. Comments by mail should be 

sent to the Office of Information and 

Regulatory Affairs, Attn: OMB Desk 

Officer for the CPSC, Office of 

Management and Budget, Room 10235, 

725 17th Street NW., Washington, DC 

20503. In addition, written comments 

that are sent to OMB also should be 

submitted electronically at http://

www.regulations.gov, under Docket No. 

CPSC–2011–0014. 

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For 

further information contact: Robert H. 

Squibb, Consumer Product Safety 

Commission, 4330 East West Highway, 

Bethesda, MD 20814; (301) 504–7815, or 

by email to: rsquibb@cpsc.gov. 

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: CPSC 

seeks to renew the following collection 

of information: 

Title: Generic Clearance for the 

Collection of Qualitative Feedback on 

Agency Service Delivery. 

Abstract: The information collection 

activity will garner qualitative customer 

and stakeholder feedback in an efficient, 

timely manner, to improve service 

delivery. Below we provide CPSC’s 

projected average estimates for activities 

including qualitative surveys, focus 

groups, customer satisfaction surveys, 

and usability tests. 

Current Actions: Renewal of 

collection of information. 

Type of Review: Renewal. 

Affected Public: Individuals and 

Households, Businesses and 

Organizations, State, Local or Tribal 

Government. 

Average Expected Annual Number of 

Activities: Eight activities, including 

qualitative surveys, focus groups, 

customer satisfaction surveys, and 

usability tests. 

Annual Number of Respondents: 

1,600. 

Annual Responses: 1,600. 

Frequency of Response: Once per 

request. 

Average Minutes per Response: 45 

minutes per response. 

Annual Burden Hours: 1,200. 

An agency may not conduct or 

sponsor, and a person is not required to 

respond to, a collection of information 

unless it displays a currently valid OMB 

control number. 

Todd A. Stevenson, 

Secretary, 

Consumer Product Safety Commission. 

[FR Doc. 2014–13170 Filed 6–5–14; 8:45 am] 

BILLING CODE 6355–01–P 

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE 

Office of the Secretary 

[Docket ID DoD–2013–OS–0086] 

Proposed Collection; Comment 

Request 

AGENCY: Office of the Inspector General, 

DoD. 

ACTION: Notice. 

SUMMARY: In compliance with Section 

3506(c)(2)(A) of the Paperwork 

Reduction Act of 1995, the Office of the 

Inspector General announces a proposed 

public information collection and seeks 

public comment on the provisions 

thereof. Comments are invited on: (a) 

Whether the proposed collection of 

information is necessary for the proper 

performance of the functions of the 

agency, including whether the 

information shall have practical utility; 

(b) the accuracy of the agency’s estimate 

of the burden of the proposed 

information collection; (c) ways to 


wreier-aviles on DSK5TPTVN1PROD with NOTICES