P. 1



# OAR Box 1802 Prepped by Charmelle Mathews



### Document

Number: 

# 48 ) IV-E-4 3
Docket Number: 

# A-90-3 7

Printed 11/4/2008 11:57:59 AM

Sheet 48 of 117P. 2 

# T3 7 -E 

# - 4 3 Fo r NS RREFOR

M Rulemakin g Docke

t SUMMAR

Y O F COMPLE

X MANUFACTURER' S MEETIN G WIT H ROBERT PERCIASEP

E O N JANUAR

Y 21,200 0 Th e meetin g wit

h Bo b Perciasep e wa s requeste db y a n industr y grou p wit h representative s fromNE

D A CARP , CMA , API , AFPA , Allianc e o f Automobil e Manufacturers , Flexibl e Packaging Assoc , and th e Nationa l Assoc , of

Manufacturers

. A

n attende e lis t

i s attached

. The grou

p indicate d their

vie w tha t ther e i s broa dagreemen

t tha t th e Ne w Sourc e Revie w (NSR ) progra mi s broken

. The

y indicate dtha

t their goa l i s t o hav e clarity , consistenc y an d predictability

. The

y do no t mind puttin g o n goo dcontrols , howeve r their primar y concer n i s th e dela y and uncertaint

y associate d wit

h th e curren

t system
. The

y kno w th e final NS Rrul e i s imminen t an d wan t aperio d of

intens e furthe

r dialogu e befor

e th e rul e i s cas t

in concrete
. Thei

r goa l fromthi s dialogu e woul d b e to hav e aworkabl e rul e in orde r t o minimiz e actio n (presumabl

y legal) , afte

r th e rul e i s promulgated

. Bo b Perciasep e note dtha

t hi s vie w of

th e NS Rprogra

mi s on e wher e a s industr

y modernize s andmake s change s t o their facilities , tha

t the pollutio n contro l shoul d b e upgrade da t th e sam e time

. He indicate dtha

t alo t of wor k ha s bee n done ove

r th e las t year , an d mentione dplant

wide applicabilit

y limit s (PALs ) an

dth e sector based approach , in additio n to th e bas e program . He indicate dtha t there ma y b e som e roo mfo r furthe r dialogue , an

d tha t h e would ask

staf f to ge t back to Josephin e Coope

r (Allianc e o f Automobile Manufacturers ) o n th e natur e andtimin g o f

an y futur e dialogu e on thi s subject

afte r som e interna l discussions

.P. 3 

# S\G>tJ-^sketU- Complex Mfrnuf&cJun/i^

•Wes t cu J (4C* ) fcb2-53^ 

# 2 ^ l^c*.u~s- s/f*-4>9-£~f.2>t>v"*<j-'V f - wo 

# &u Htouetr

ePfr/awo frt)£W- i9>7f

7S-M Lc(lr\m<i*z. hlLrJa^.l^c 120

. ??3. till!
tfo-fsin/lfart) Mljfcrtfa /\7o.'he^AQobJ// &y

### ,u(UJ+^Z07. 6?7~ I'*? 1 

# flrinrt/nme iOool

EPA/aAA/ofAt. • 20 2 s<,4-'^< W C^**.. &**7

£^A/C7 V m-SUi-m* -~\ »



# zP. 4

MEMORANDU M Januar y 19 , 200 0
VIA FACSIMILE TO : Assistan t

Administrato r

Rober t Perciasep e FROM : Lesli e Ritts , Hoga n & Hartson , LL P

Chuc k Knauss , Swidler , Berlin , Sherif f & Friedman , LL P RE : Industr y Representative s Attendin g Januar y 21 , 200 0 NS R

Meetin g
Do n Clay , Director , Environmenta l Affairs , Koc h Industries ; Vic e Chairman , NED^/CARP , an d fo r

th e Nationa l Petroleu mRefiner s Associatio n Josephin e Cooper , President , Allianc e of Automobil e Manufacturer s | Le e Hughes , Vic e President , Bayer ; an dChairman , Chemica l Manufacturer s Association' s Ai r

Committe e Jef f Lammers , Vic e President , Durala mIndustries ; an dChairman , Flexibl e Packagin g Associatio n Susa n Moore , Vic e President , Environmenta l Healt h & Safely , Georgia-Pacifi c Corporation , an d for

America n Fores t

& Pape r Associatio n Nanc y Newkirk , Vic e President , Environmen t Affairs , America n Petroleu m Institut e Mar k Whittenton , Vic e President , Environmenta l Affairs , Niitiona l Associatio n o f Manufacturer s I f yo u hav e questions , pleas e cal l Lesli e a t 202/637-657 3 o r

Chuc k a t 202/424-7644

. cc : Pau l Babosh , OAR Ro b Brenner , OA

R Denni s Crumpler , OAQP S Willia mHarnett , OAQP S Joh n Seitz , OAQP S Ann aWood , OA R

\\\D C • U4G22/

1 -#101839 2 v l