8C-i

APPENDIX 8C. LIFE-CYCLE COST SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS 

TABLE OF CONTENTS 

8C.1 POLYPHASE MOTORS.........................................................................................8C-1 

8C.2 CAPACITOR-START INDUCTION RUN MOTORS.........................................8C-11 

8C.3 CAPACITOR-START CAPACITOR RUN MOTORS ........................................8C-21 

TABLE OF TABLES 

Table 8C.1.1 Polyphase Motors: Reference Scenario ......................................................8C-2 

Table 8C.1.2 Polyphase Motors: High Energy Price Trend Scenario ..............................8C-2 

Table 8C.1.3 Polyphase Motors: Low Energy Price Trend Scenario...............................8C-3 

Table 8C.1.4 Polyphase Motors: High Electricity Cost Scenario ....................................8C-3 

Table 8C.1.5 Polyphase Motors: Low Electricity Cost Scenario .....................................8C-4 

Table 8C.1.6 Polyphase Motors: High Markups Scenario ...............................................8C-4 

Table 8C.1.7 Polyphase Motors: Low Markups Scenario................................................8C-5 

Table 8C.1.8 Polyphase Motors: High Loading Scenario ................................................8C-5 

Table 8C.1.9 Polyphase Motors: Low Loading Scenario.................................................8C-6 

Table 8C.1.10 Polyphase Motors: High Operation Hours Scenario...................................8C-6 

Table 8C.1.11 Polyphase Motors: Low Operation Hours Scenario ...................................8C-7 

Table 8C.1.12 Polyphase Motors: Space Constrained Consumer Scenario .......................8C-7 

Table 8C.1.13 Polyphase Motors: Consumers with No Reactive Power Cost Scenario....8C-8 

Table 8C.1.14 Polyphase Motors: Consumers with 100 Reactive Power Cost 

Scenario........................................................................................................8C-8 

Table 8C.1.15 Polyphase Motors: Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario ...................................8C-9 

Table 8C.1.16 Polyphase Motors: Median Social Cost of Carbon Dioxide Emissions 

Scenario........................................................................................................8C-9 

Table 8C.1.17 Polyphase Motors: Small Business Scenario.............................................8C-10 

Table 8C.1.18 Polyphase Motors: National Distribution Scenario ...................................8C-10 

Table 8C.2.1 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Reference Scenario ....................8C-12 

Table 8C.2.2 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Energy Price Trend 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-12 

Table 8C.2.3 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Energy Price Trend 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-13 

Table 8C.2.4 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Electricity Cost Scenario ..8C-13 

Table 8C.2.5 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Electricity Cost Scenario ...8C-14 

Table 8C.2.6 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Markups Scenario .............8C-14 

Table 8C.2.7 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Markups Scenario..............8C-15 

Table 8C.2.8 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Loading Scenario ..............8C-15 

Table 8C.2.9 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Loading Scenario...............8C-16 

Table 8C.2.10 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Operation Hours 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-16 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-ii

Table 8C.2.11 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Operation Hours 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-17 

Table 8C.2.12 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Space Constrained Consumer 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-17 

Table 8C.2.13 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Consumers with No Reactive 

Power Cost Scenario..................................................................................8C-18 

Table 8C.2.14 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Consumers with 100 Reactive 

Power Cost Scenario..................................................................................8C-18 

Table 8C.2.15 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Carbon Cap and Trade 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-19 

Table 8C.2.16 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Median Social Cost of Carbon 

Dioxide Emissions Scenario ......................................................................8C-19 

Table 8C.2.17 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Small Business Scenario.............8C-20 

Table 8C.2.18 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: National Distribution ..................8C-20 

Table 8C.3.1 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Reference Scenario....................8C-22 

Table 8C.3.2 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Energy Price Trend 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-22 

Table 8C.3.3 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Energy Price Trend 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-23 

Table 8C.3.4 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Electricity Cost Scenario ..8C-23 

Table 8C.3.5 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Electricity Cost Scenario...8C-24 

Table 8C.3.6 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Markups Scenario.............8C-24 

Table 8C.3.7 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Markups Scenario..............8C-25 

Table 8C.3.8 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Loading Scenario..............8C-25 

Table 8C.3.9 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Loading Scenario...............8C-26 

Table 8C.3.10 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Operation Hours 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-26 

Table 8C.3.11 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Operation Hours 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-27 

Table 8C.3.12 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Space Constrained Consumer 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-27 

Table 8C.3.13 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Consumers with No Reactive 

Power Cost Scenario..................................................................................8C-28 

Table 8C.3.14 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Consumers with 100 Reactive 

Power Cost Scenario..................................................................................8C-28 

Table 8C.3.15 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: CSIR to CSCR Switching 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-29 

Table 8C.3.16 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Carbon Cap and Trade 

Scenario......................................................................................................8C-29 

Table 8C.3.17 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Median Social Cost of Carbon 

Dioxide Emissions Scenario ......................................................................8C-30 

Table 8C.3.18 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Small Business Scenario.............8C-30 

Table 8C.3.19 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: National Distribution ..................8C-31 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-iii

TABLE OF FIGURES 

Figure 8C.1.1 Polyphase Motors: Life-Cycle Cost Savings versus Motor Efficiency .......8C-1 

Figure 8C.1.2 Polyphase Motors: Consumers with Net Benefit versus Motor 

Efficiency.....................................................................................................8C-1 

Figure 8C.1.3 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Life-Cycle Cost Savings versus 

Motor Efficiency........................................................................................8C-11 

Figure 8C.1.4 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Consumers with Net Benefit 

versus Motor Efficiency.............................................................................8C-11 

Figure 8C.1.5 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Life-Cycle Cost Savings versus 

Motor Efficiency........................................................................................8C-21 

Figure 8C.1.6 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Consumers with Net Benefit 

versus Motor Efficiency.............................................................................8C-21 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-1

APPENDIX 8C. LIFE-CYCLE COST SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS 

8C.1 POLYPHASE MOTORS 

-$150

-$125

-$100

-$75

-$50

-$25

$0

$25

$50

78% 81% 83% 86% 88%

Motor Efficiency (%)

Life-Cycle Cost Savings ($2008)

High Energy Price Trend Scenario

Low Energy Price Trend Scenario

High Electricity Cost Scenario

Low Electricity Cost Scenario

High M arkups Scenario

Low M arkups Scenario

High Loading Scenario

Low Loading Scenario

High Operating Hours Scenario

Low Operating Hours Scenario

Space Constrained Consumer Scenario

Consumers with No Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Consumers with 100% Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario

M edian Social Cost of Carbon Dioxide

Emissions Scenario

Small Business Scenario

Reference

-$3,000

-$2,500

-$2,000

-$1,500

-$1,000

-$500

$0

87% 88% 89%

Figure 8C.1.1 Polyphase Motors: Life-Cycle Cost Savings versus Motor 

Efficiency 

0%

25%

50%

75%

78% 79% 80% 81% 82% 83% 84% 85% 86% 87% 88% 89%

Motor Efficiency (%)

Consumers with Net Benefit (%)

High Energy Price Trend Scenario

Low Energy Price Trend Scenario

High Electricity Cost Scenario

Low Electricity Cost Scenario

High M arkups Scenario

Low M arkups Scenario

High Loading Scenario

Low Loading Scenario

High Operating Hours Scenario

Low Operating Hours Scenario

Space Constrained Consumer Scenario

Consumers with No Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Consumers with 100% Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario

M edian Social Cost of Carbon Dioxide

Emissions Scenario

Small Business Scenario

Reference

Figure 8C.1.2 Polyphase Motors: Consumers with Net Benefit versus 

Motor Efficiency 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-2

Table 8C.1.1 Polyphase Motors: Reference Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1763 132.69 1,282 

1 78.7 524 1734 130.50 1,282 0 61.9 38.1 33.6 10.6 

2 80.0 531 1698 127.79 1,273 9 48.7 51.3 23.0 7.3 

3 81.6 542 1645 123.77 1,260 22 43.9 56.1 20.2 6.3 

4 82.5 550 1629 122.57 1,262 21 47.5 52.5 22.6 7.1 

5 85.2 642 1549 116.56 1,319 -37 69.6 30.4 47.7 14.0 

6 86.7 697 1529 115.08 1,365 -83 81.1 19.0 61.9 19.3 

7 88.3 1,443 1494 112.42 2,096 -814 98.2 1.9 260.3 55.3 

Table 8C.1.2 Polyphase Motors: High Energy Price Trend Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1763 146.42 1,354 

1 78.7 524 1734 144.01 1,352 2 58.6 41.4 30.4 9.6 

2 80.0 531 1698 141.01 1,342 12 46.0 54.0 20.8 6.6 

3 81.6 542 1645 136.58 1,327 27 41.6 58.4 18.3 5.7 

4 82.5 550 1629 135.25 1,328 26 44.9 55.1 20.4 6.4 

5 85.2 642 1549 128.62 1,382 -28 66.8 33.2 43.1 12.6 

6 86.7 697 1529 126.98 1,427 -73 78.4 21.7 55.9 17.4 

7 88.3 1,443 1494 124.05 2,156 -803 97.3 2.7 235.2 49.8 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-3

Table 8C.1.3 Polyphase Motors: Low Energy Price Trend Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1743 131.36 1,255 

1 78.7 524 1714 129.19 1,255 0 63.3 36.7 33.7 10.6 

2 80.0 531 1678 126.50 1,246 8 49.6 50.4 23.0 7.3 

3 81.6 542 1626 122.53 1,234 20 45.0 55.0 20.2 6.3 

4 82.5 550 1610 121.34 1,236 18 48.7 51.3 22.6 7.1 

5 85.2 642 1531 115.39 1,295 -40 71.2 28.8 47.6 14.2 

6 86.7 697 1512 113.93 1,341 -86 83.1 17.0 61.8 19.3 

7 88.3 1,444 1477 111.28 2,074 -819 98.1 1.9 259.9 55.5 

Table 8C.1.4 Polyphase Motors: High Electricity Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1743 144.28 1,353 

1 78.7 524 1714 141.89 1,351 2 58.7 41.3 30.6 9.7 

2 80.0 531 1678 138.94 1,341 12 45.9 54.1 20.9 6.6 

3 81.6 542 1626 134.58 1,326 27 41.3 58.7 18.4 5.8 

4 82.5 550 1610 133.27 1,327 26 44.6 55.5 20.5 6.5 

5 85.2 642 1531 126.74 1,381 -28 67.0 33.0 43.4 12.9 

6 86.7 697 1512 125.13 1,426 -73 78.8 21.2 56.3 17.5 

7 88.3 1,444 1477 122.23 2,157 -804 97.4 2.6 236.4 50.5 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-4

Table 8C.1.5 Polyphase Motors: Low Electricity Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 512 1732 117.75 1,196 

1 78.7 524 1703 115.81 1,197 -1 66.2 33.8 38.7 12.2 

2 80.0 531 1668 113.39 1,190 6 52.4 47.6 26.3 8.3 

3 81.6 543 1615 109.81 1,180 16 47.7 52.3 23.1 7.2 

4 82.5 551 1599 108.74 1,182 14 51.2 48.8 25.8 8.1 

5 85.2 644 1521 103.38 1,244 -48 73.4 26.7 55.3 15.7 

6 86.7 698 1501 102.07 1,291 -95 85.1 14.9 71.2 21.6 

7 88.3 1,459 1467 99.71 2,038 -841 98.7 1.3 309.5 61.9 

Table 8C.1.6 Polyphase Motors: High Markups Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 537 1737 131.74 1,312 

1 78.7 550 1708 129.57 1,313 -1 64.8 35.2 36.6 11.7 

2 80.0 558 1672 126.87 1,304 8 51.6 48.4 24.9 8.0 

3 81.6 570 1620 122.86 1,292 19 46.8 53.2 21.9 6.9 

4 82.5 579 1604 121.67 1,294 17 50.2 49.8 24.4 7.8 

5 85.2 683 1525 115.67 1,363 -51 73.2 26.8 53.2 15.7 

6 86.7 742 1506 114.20 1,413 -102 84.5 15.5 68.0 21.2 

7 88.3 1,606 1471 111.54 2,262 -950 98.5 1.5 303.8 63.6 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-5

Table 8C.1.7 Polyphase Motors: Low Markups Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 487 1704 128.83 1,242 

1 78.7 498 1676 126.70 1,240 1 59.1 40.9 31.9 10.1 

2 80.0 504 1641 124.07 1,231 10 47.3 52.7 21.9 6.9 

3 81.6 515 1589 120.17 1,218 24 42.7 57.3 19.3 6.0 

4 82.5 522 1574 119.00 1,219 23 46.0 54.0 21.5 6.8 

5 85.2 607 1497 113.17 1,269 -28 67.6 32.4 46.0 13.5 

6 86.7 655 1478 111.73 1,309 -68 78.6 21.4 59.1 18.4 

7 88.3 1,353 1443 109.13 1,992 -750 97.3 2.7 256.7 53.8 

Table 8C.1.8 Polyphase Motors: High Loading Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 512 1871 139.36 1,332 

1 78.7 524 1838 136.94 1,331 2 58.4 41.6 31.3 9.7 

2 80.0 531 1803 134.27 1,322 11 47.0 53.0 22.2 6.9 

3 81.6 543 1751 130.40 1,309 23 42.8 57.2 20.0 6.2 

4 82.5 551 1734 129.12 1,310 22 46.6 53.4 22.2 6.9 

5 85.2 646 1656 123.36 1,371 -39 70.2 29.8 48.2 14.1 

6 86.7 700 1635 121.74 1,415 -83 81.4 18.6 61.7 19.0 

7 88.3 1,489 1597 118.92 2,188 -856 98.1 1.9 265.7 55.0 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-6

Table 8C.1.9 Polyphase Motors: Low Loading Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1611 121.26 1,217 

1 78.7 524 1585 119.33 1,218 -1 65.7 34.3 37.8 12.0 

2 80.0 531 1550 116.67 1,209 7 50.8 49.2 24.6 7.8 

3 81.6 542 1497 112.66 1,197 20 44.9 55.1 21.0 6.6 

4 82.5 550 1482 111.55 1,198 18 48.8 51.3 23.6 7.4 

5 85.2 642 1402 105.52 1,256 -39 70.4 29.6 49.0 14.3 

6 86.7 697 1384 104.18 1,303 -86 82.1 17.9 64.0 19.8 

7 88.3 1,443 1352 101.74 2,035 -818 98.4 1.6 269.4 57.3 

Table 8C.1.10 Polyphase Motors: High Operation Hours Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 2091 157.39 1,355 

1 78.7 524 2057 154.79 1,354 2 56.9 43.1 28.1 8.8 

2 80.0 531 2014 151.57 1,343 12 43.8 56.2 19.2 6.1 

3 81.6 542 1951 146.81 1,328 27 39.3 60.7 16.9 5.3 

4 82.5 550 1932 145.39 1,329 26 42.5 57.5 18.8 5.9 

5 85.2 642 1837 138.26 1,383 -28 65.9 34.2 39.7 11.8 

6 86.7 697 1814 136.51 1,428 -73 78.9 21.1 51.6 16.1 

7 88.3 1,444 1772 133.34 2,159 -804 97.7 2.3 216.7 46.3 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-7

Table 8C.1.11 Polyphase Motors: Low Operation Hours Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1394 104.93 1,182 

1 78.7 524 1371 103.19 1,183 -1 68.0 32.0 42.1 13.3 

2 80.0 531 1343 101.05 1,176 6 55.0 45.0 28.8 9.1 

3 81.6 542 1301 97.88 1,167 15 50.1 49.9 25.3 7.9 

4 82.5 550 1288 96.92 1,169 13 53.6 46.4 28.2 8.9 

5 85.2 642 1225 92.18 1,231 -49 75.0 25.0 59.6 17.7 

6 86.7 697 1209 91.00 1,278 -96 85.2 14.8 77.4 24.1 

7 88.3 1,444 1181 88.89 2,012 -830 98.4 1.6 325.1 69.5 

Table 8C.1.12 Polyphase Motors: Space Constrained Consumer Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 512 1732 130.83 1,272 

1 78.7 524 1703 128.68 1,272 0 62.7 37.3 34.8 11.0 

2 80.0 531 1668 125.99 1,263 9 49.3 50.7 23.7 7.5 

3 81.6 543 1615 122.01 1,251 21 44.6 55.4 20.8 6.5 

4 82.5 551 1599 120.83 1,253 20 48.0 52.0 23.2 7.3 

5 85.2 757 1515 114.41 1,422 -150 92.2 7.8 90.1 27.8 

6 86.7 769 1491 112.60 1,424 -151 90.9 9.2 84.7 26.4 

7 88.3 3,578 1448 109.41 4,213 -2,941 100.0 0.0 860.5 266.8 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-8

Table 8C.1.13 Polyphase Motors: Consumers with No Reactive Power Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 512 1737 131.74 1,279 

1 78.7 525 1708 129.57 1,279 0 61.9 38.2 33.6 10.7 

2 80.0 532 1672 126.87 1,270 9 49.5 50.5 22.9 7.3 

3 81.6 543 1620 122.86 1,258 21 45.6 54.4 20.1 6.4 

4 82.5 551 1604 121.67 1,259 20 48.8 51.2 22.4 7.1 

5 85.2 646 1525 115.67 1,319 -40 71.0 29.1 48.6 14.3 

6 86.7 700 1506 114.20 1,364 -85 82.1 17.9 62.1 19.4 

7 88.3 1,485 1471 111.54 2,134 -856 98.0 2.0 276.4 58.0 

Table 8C.1.14 Polyphase Motors: Consumers with 100 Reactive Power Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1704 128.83 1,292 

1 78.7 523 1676 126.70 1,291 0 61.8 38.2 35.1 11.2 

2 80.0 530 1641 124.07 1,282 10 48.3 51.7 24.1 7.6 

3 81.6 542 1589 120.17 1,267 25 41.5 58.5 21.2 6.6 

4 82.5 550 1574 119.00 1,268 23 45.7 54.3 23.6 7.4 

5 85.2 644 1497 113.17 1,327 -36 69.3 30.8 50.9 14.9 

6 86.7 697 1478 111.73 1,373 -81 81.2 18.8 65.3 20.3 

7 88.3 1,472 1443 109.13 2,133 -841 98.1 1.9 284.9 59.7 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-9

Table 8C.1.15 Polyphase Motors: Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1763 142.05 1,357 

1 78.7 524 1734 139.71 1,355 2 58.3 41.7 31.2 9.9 

2 80.0 531 1698 136.80 1,345 12 45.7 54.3 21.4 6.8 

3 81.6 542 1645 132.50 1,330 27 41.4 58.6 18.8 5.9 

4 82.5 550 1629 131.21 1,331 26 44.6 55.4 21.0 6.6 

5 85.2 642 1549 124.78 1,384 -28 66.6 33.4 44.3 13.0 

6 86.7 697 1529 123.19 1,430 -73 78.2 21.8 57.5 17.9 

7 88.3 1,443 1494 120.34 2,159 -802 97.4 2.7 242.0 51.3 

Table 8C.1.16 Polyphase Motors: Median Social Cost of Carbon Dioxide Emissions 

Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1743 167.03 1,494 

1 78.7 524 1714 164.27 1,490 4 51.9 48.1 25.0 8.2 

2 80.0 531 1678 160.85 1,477 17 40.3 59.8 17.1 5.5 

3 81.6 542 1626 155.80 1,458 36 36.3 63.7 15.0 4.8 

4 82.5 550 1610 154.28 1,457 37 39.4 60.6 16.8 5.4 

5 85.2 642 1531 146.73 1,505 -11 60.8 39.3 35.4 10.7 

6 86.7 697 1512 144.86 1,549 -55 72.0 28.0 45.9 14.6 

7 88.3 1,444 1477 141.50 2,277 -782 96.4 3.7 192.6 42.1 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-10

Table 8C.1.17 Polyphase Motors: Small Business Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 77.2 511 1743 131.16 1,164 

1 78.7 524 1714 128.99 1,166 -2 68.3 31.7 33.7 10.6 

2 80.0 531 1678 126.31 1,159 5 54.3 45.7 23.0 7.3 

3 81.6 542 1626 122.34 1,150 14 49.5 50.5 20.2 6.3 

4 82.5 550 1610 121.15 1,153 11 53.1 47.0 22.6 7.1 

5 85.2 642 1531 115.22 1,215 -51 75.6 24.4 47.7 14.2 

6 86.7 697 1512 113.75 1,263 -99 86.7 13.3 61.9 19.3 

7 88.3 1,444 1477 111.12 1,997 -833 98.8 1.2 260.1 55.6 

Table 8C.1.18 Polyphase Motors: National Distribution Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

Baseline 509 1810 136.38 1,306 

1 521 1780 134.15 1,305 1 61.5 38.5 33.0 10.7 

2 528 1743 131.35 1,296 10 48.7 51.3 22.5 7.3 

3 540 1688 127.19 1,282 24 44.1 55.9 19.8 6.3 

4 548 1672 125.96 1,283 23 47.5 52.5 22.1 7.1 

5 640 1589 119.74 1,339 -33 69.5 30.5 46.6 14.2 

6 694 1569 118.23 1,384 -78 80.7 19.3 60.6 19.4 

7 1,452 1533 115.49 2,126 -820 97.4 2.6 253.1 56.8 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C.2 CAPACITOR-START INDUCTION RUN MOTORS 

8C-11

-$100

-$75

-$50

-$25

$0

$25

$50

$75

$100

56% 58% 60% 62% 64% 66% 68% 70% 72% 74%

Motor Efficiency (%)

Life-Cycle Cost Savings ($2008)

High Energy Price Trend Scenario

Low Energy Price Trend Scenario

High Electricity Cost Scenario

Low Electricity Cost Scenario

High M arkups Scenario

Low M arkups Scenario

High Loading Scenario

Low Loading Scenario

High Operating Hours Scenario

Low Operating Hours Scenario

Space Constrained Consumer Scenario

Consumers with No Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Consumers with 100% Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario

M edian Social Cost of Carbon Dioxide

Emissions Scenario

Small Business Scenario

Reference

-$2,000

-$1,500

-$1,000

-$500

$0

73% 76% 78%

Figure 8C.1.3 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Life-Cycle Cost 

Savings versus Motor Efficiency 

0%

25%

50%

75%

100%

58% 63% 68% 73% 78%

Motor Efficiency (%)

Consumers with Net Benefit (%)

High Energy Price Trend Scenario

Low Energy Price Trend Scenario

High Electricity Cost Scenario

Low Electricity Cost Scenario

High M arkups Scenario

Low M arkups Scenario

High Loading Scenario

Low Loading Scenario

High Operating Hours Scenario

Low Operating Hours Scenario

Space Constrained Consumer Scenario

Consumers with No Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Consumers with 100% Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario

M edian Social Cost of Carbon Dioxide

Emissions Scenario

Small Business Scenario

Reference

Figure 8C.1.4 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Consumers with 

Net Benefit versus Motor Efficiency 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-12

Table 8C.2.1 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Reference Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1061 79.96 881 

Baseline 57.7 490 1277 96.21 948 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1226 92.33 938 9 39.2 60.8 13.6 4.3 

2 62.0 505 1164 87.69 922 26 31.7 68.3 10.2 3.2 

3 64.2 507 1110 83.60 905 43 26.3 73.7 8.2 2.5 

4 68.5 525 1020 76.86 890 58 32.1 67.9 10.8 3.3 

5 71.2 543 971 73.17 891 56 39.0 61.0 13.6 4.3 

6 73.0 587 942 70.94 924 23 52.1 47.9 22.7 6.8 

7 77.0 975 877 66.05 1,288 -341 62.4 37.6 96.1 10.9 

Table 8C.2.2 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Energy Price Trend 

Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1061 88.21 917 

Baseline 57.7 490 1277 106.14 991 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1226 101.86 980 11 36.5 63.5 12.3 3.8 

2 62.0 505 1164 96.75 961 30 29.8 70.2 9.2 2.9 

3 64.2 507 1110 92.23 942 49 24.6 75.4 7.4 2.3 

4 68.5 525 1020 84.79 924 66 30.1 69.9 9.7 3.0 

5 71.2 543 971 80.72 924 67 36.4 63.6 12.3 3.8 

6 73.0 587 942 78.26 956 35 49.7 50.3 20.5 6.1 

7 77.0 975 877 72.87 1,318 -327 60.3 39.7 86.9 9.8 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-13

Table 8C.2.3 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Energy Price Trend 

Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1073 81.28 874 

Baseline 57.7 490 1291 97.79 939 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1239 93.85 930 9 39.9 60.2 13.7 4.2 

2 62.0 505 1177 89.14 914 25 32.5 67.5 10.3 3.2 

3 64.2 507 1122 84.98 897 42 26.5 73.5 8.2 2.5 

4 68.5 525 1031 78.12 883 56 32.9 67.1 10.7 3.3 

5 71.2 543 982 74.37 884 54 39.7 60.3 13.6 4.2 

6 73.0 587 952 72.11 918 21 52.7 47.3 22.5 6.7 

7 77.0 976 886 67.13 1,283 -344 63.3 36.7 91.8 11.0 

Table 8C.2.4 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Electricity Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1073 89.27 920 

Baseline 57.7 490 1291 107.41 995 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1239 103.08 984 11 36.6 63.4 12.4 3.9 

2 62.0 505 1177 97.90 965 30 29.5 70.5 9.3 2.9 

3 64.2 507 1122 93.34 946 49 24.0 76.0 7.5 2.3 

4 68.5 525 1031 85.80 928 67 29.7 70.3 9.8 3.0 

5 71.2 543 982 81.69 927 68 36.6 63.5 12.4 3.9 

6 73.0 587 952 79.20 959 36 49.0 51.0 20.5 6.1 

7 77.0 976 886 73.73 1,322 -327 60.0 40.0 83.5 10.0 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-14

Table 8C.2.5 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Electricity Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1075 72.45 839 

Baseline 57.7 491 1294 87.16 897 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1242 83.65 889 7 42.2 57.8 15.1 4.8 

2 62.0 505 1179 79.45 876 21 34.4 65.6 11.4 3.6 

3 64.2 508 1124 75.75 861 36 28.3 71.7 9.1 2.9 

4 68.5 526 1034 69.63 850 47 34.8 65.2 11.9 3.7 

5 71.2 544 984 66.30 853 44 42.2 57.8 15.1 4.8 

6 73.0 588 954 64.27 887 9 56.0 44.0 25.0 7.6 

7 77.0 986 888 59.83 1,264 -367 65.7 34.3 102.1 12.6 

Table 8C.2.6 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Markups Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 526 1063 80.72 903 

Baseline 57.7 514 1277 96.98 967 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 523 1226 93.10 959 8 41.7 58.3 15.2 4.8 

2 62.0 530 1165 88.45 943 24 34.1 65.9 11.4 3.6 

3 64.2 533 1111 84.35 927 40 27.9 72.2 9.1 2.9 

4 68.5 552 1022 77.56 914 53 34.5 65.5 12.0 3.8 

5 71.2 572 973 73.87 917 50 41.8 58.3 15.2 4.8 

6 73.0 622 944 71.62 956 11 56.4 43.7 25.6 7.7 

7 77.0 1,079 879 66.70 1,390 -423 66.7 33.3 111.5 12.7 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-15

Table 8C.2.7 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Markups Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 478 1066 79.96 852 

Baseline 57.7 467 1283 96.13 919 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 475 1231 92.27 909 10 37.3 62.7 12.7 3.9 

2 62.0 480 1169 87.65 893 27 30.1 69.9 9.6 3.0 

3 64.2 483 1115 83.58 875 44 24.8 75.2 7.6 2.4 

4 68.5 499 1025 76.83 860 59 30.5 69.5 10.1 3.1 

5 71.2 515 976 73.17 859 60 37.2 62.8 12.6 3.9 

6 73.0 556 946 70.93 889 30 50.2 49.8 21.4 6.3 

7 77.0 924 881 66.04 1,233 -314 61.4 38.6 94.3 10.8 

Table 8C.2.8 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Loading Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1143 85.93 903 

Baseline 57.7 491 1355 101.94 967 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 500 1304 98.08 958 9 39.3 60.7 13.6 4.3 

2 62.0 505 1242 93.39 942 25 32.1 67.9 10.1 3.2 

3 64.2 508 1188 89.35 925 42 26.6 73.4 8.1 2.6 

4 68.5 526 1097 82.50 911 56 32.7 67.3 10.6 3.4 

5 71.2 544 1046 78.68 912 56 38.9 61.1 13.3 4.2 

6 73.0 589 1017 76.43 946 21 52.9 47.1 22.4 6.8 

7 77.0 1,008 950 71.45 1,341 -374 63.7 36.3 95.8 11.7 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-16

Table 8C.2.9 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Loading Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 983 74.02 853 

Baseline 57.7 490 1200 90.43 920 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1149 86.55 911 10 39.1 60.9 13.6 4.3 

2 62.0 505 1088 81.96 895 25 31.8 68.2 10.3 3.2 

3 64.2 507 1033 77.84 878 43 26.3 73.7 8.2 2.6 

4 68.5 525 945 71.18 863 57 32.2 67.9 10.8 3.4 

5 71.2 543 898 67.66 865 55 39.3 60.7 13.7 4.3 

6 73.0 587 868 65.42 898 22 52.4 47.6 23.0 6.8 

7 77.0 975 804 60.59 1,263 -342 62.7 37.3 96.7 11.1 

Table 8C.2.10 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: High Operation Hours Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1288 97.38 919 

Baseline 57.7 490 1549 117.17 993 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1487 112.45 982 11 34.6 65.4 11.4 3.5 

2 62.0 505 1412 106.80 964 30 27.6 72.4 8.5 2.7 

3 64.2 507 1346 101.82 944 49 22.3 77.7 6.8 2.1 

4 68.5 525 1238 93.60 926 67 27.8 72.2 9.0 2.7 

5 71.2 543 1178 89.11 926 67 34.5 65.5 11.3 3.5 

6 73.0 587 1142 86.40 958 35 47.3 52.7 18.8 5.6 

7 77.0 976 1064 80.44 1,321 -327 58.4 41.7 76.5 9.2 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-17

Table 8C.2.11 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Low Operation Hours Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 858 64.92 838 

Baseline 57.7 490 1033 78.12 896 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 991 74.97 889 7 44.6 55.4 17.1 5.3 

2 62.0 505 941 71.20 875 21 37.2 62.8 12.8 4.0 

3 64.2 507 897 67.88 860 36 30.8 69.2 10.3 3.2 

4 68.5 525 825 62.40 849 47 37.3 62.7 13.4 4.1 

5 71.2 543 785 59.41 852 44 44.5 55.5 17.0 5.3 

6 73.0 587 762 57.60 886 10 57.9 42.1 28.2 8.3 

7 77.0 976 709 53.62 1,254 -358 67.8 32.2 114.8 13.8 

Table 8C.2.12 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Space Constrained Consumer 

Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1075 80.50 876 

Baseline 57.7 491 1294 96.85 942 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1242 92.95 933 9 39.4 60.6 13.6 4.3 

2 62.0 505 1179 88.28 917 25 31.8 68.2 10.2 3.2 

3 64.2 508 1124 84.16 900 42 26.1 73.9 8.2 2.6 

4 68.5 535 1024 76.61 892 50 38.3 61.7 13.2 4.1 

5 71.2 544 984 73.66 887 55 39.3 60.7 13.6 4.3 

6 73.0 660 945 70.71 989 -47 73.0 27.0 38.4 12.1 

7 77.0 2,530 871 65.21 2,834 -1,892 100.0 0.0 384.0 120.8 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-18

Table 8C.2.13 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Consumers with No Reactive 

Power Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 503 1063 80.72 874 

Baseline 57.7 491 1277 96.98 938 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 500 1226 93.10 929 9 39.8 60.2 13.9 4.4 

2 62.0 506 1165 88.45 913 25 32.6 67.4 10.4 3.3 

3 64.2 508 1111 84.35 897 41 27.4 72.6 8.3 2.6 

4 68.5 526 1022 77.56 883 54 33.8 66.3 11.0 3.5 

5 71.2 544 973 73.87 884 53 39.9 60.1 13.8 4.4 

6 73.0 589 944 71.62 919 19 54.2 45.8 23.4 7.0 

7 77.0 1,005 879 66.70 1,312 -375 65.1 34.9 101.4 11.6 

Table 8C.2.14 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Consumers with 100 Reactive 

Power Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 501 1066 79.96 890 

Baseline 57.7 490 1283 96.13 962 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1231 92.27 952 10 37.7 62.3 14.1 4.3 

2 62.0 504 1169 87.65 935 27 29.8 70.2 10.5 3.3 

3 64.2 507 1115 83.58 916 46 22.1 77.9 8.4 2.6 

4 68.5 525 1025 76.83 899 63 28.2 71.8 11.1 3.4 

5 71.2 543 976 73.17 903 59 37.3 62.7 14.0 4.3 

6 73.0 587 946 70.93 935 27 51.1 48.9 23.7 7.0 

7 77.0 996 881 66.04 1,318 -356 61.9 38.1 104.6 11.9 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-19

Table 8C.2.15 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1061 85.59 916 

Baseline 57.7 490 1277 102.99 989 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1226 98.84 978 11 36.3 63.7 12.7 4.0 

2 62.0 505 1164 93.87 960 29 29.8 70.2 9.5 3.0 

3 64.2 507 1110 89.49 941 48 24.5 75.5 7.6 2.4 

4 68.5 525 1020 82.27 923 66 30.1 69.9 10.0 3.1 

5 71.2 543 971 78.32 923 66 36.3 63.7 12.6 4.0 

6 73.0 587 942 75.94 955 34 49.6 50.4 21.1 6.3 

7 77.0 975 877 70.70 1,317 -328 60.2 39.8 89.4 10.1 

Table 8C.2.16 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Median Social Cost of Carbon 

Dioxide Emissions Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1073 103.23 989 

Baseline 57.7 490 1291 124.21 1,077 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1239 119.21 1,063 15 31.8 68.2 10.2 3.2 

2 62.0 505 1177 113.22 1,040 37 25.2 74.8 7.6 2.4 

3 64.2 507 1122 107.94 1,017 60 20.1 79.9 6.1 1.9 

4 68.5 525 1031 99.23 993 84 25.3 74.7 8.0 2.5 

5 71.2 543 982 94.47 990 88 31.6 68.4 10.1 3.2 

6 73.0 587 952 91.59 1,020 57 43.8 56.2 16.7 5.1 

7 77.0 976 886 85.27 1,378 -301 55.6 44.4 67.7 8.3 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-20

Table 8C.2.17 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: Small Business Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 65.5 502 1073 81.15 835 

Baseline 57.7 490 1291 97.65 892 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 59.5 499 1239 93.71 885 7 43.0 57.0 13.7 4.2 

2 62.0 505 1177 89.00 872 21 35.7 64.3 10.3 3.2 

3 64.2 507 1122 84.85 857 36 29.5 70.5 8.2 2.5 

4 68.5 525 1031 78.00 846 46 36.1 63.9 10.8 3.3 

5 71.2 543 982 74.26 849 43 42.9 57.1 13.6 4.2 

6 73.0 587 952 72.00 883 9 56.7 43.4 22.6 6.7 

7 77.0 976 886 67.03 1,251 -359 66.7 33.3 91.9 11.0 

Table 8C.2.18 Capacitor-Start Induction Run Motors: National Distribution 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSCR 

Baseline 492 1066 80.20 864 

Baseline 494 1284 96.58 943 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 503 1232 92.62 933 9 39.0 61.0 14.3 4.2 

2 508 1169 87.88 917 25 31.9 68.2 10.7 3.2 

3 511 1113 83.71 900 43 26.2 73.8 8.6 2.5 

4 529 1021 76.80 886 57 32.3 67.7 11.3 3.3 

5 547 971 73.04 887 56 39.0 61.0 14.2 4.2 

6 592 941 70.75 921 21 52.4 47.6 23.9 6.8 

7 997 874 65.74 1,302 -359 63.1 36.9 102.3 11.3 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C.3 CAPACITOR-START CAPACITOR RUN MOTORS 

8C-21

-$200

-$150

-$100

-$50

$0

$50

$100

$150

$200

$250

70% 72% 74% 76% 78% 80% 82% 84% 86%

Motor Efficiency (%)

Life-Cycle Cost Savings ($2008)

High Energy Price Trend Scenario

Low Energy Price Trend Scenario

High Electricity Cost Scenario

Low Electricity Cost Scenario

High M arkups Scenario

Low M arkups Scenario

High Loading Scenario

Low Loading Scenario

High Operating Hours Scenario

Low Operating Hours Scenario

Space Constrained Consumer Scenario

Consumers with No Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Consumers with 100% Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

CSIR to CSCR Switching Scenario

Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario

M edian Social Cost of Carbon Dioxide

Emissions Scenario

Small Business Scenario

Reference

-$3,500

-$3,000

-$2,500

-$2,000

-$1,500

-$1,000

-$500

$0

87% 88%

Figure 8C.1.5 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Life-Cycle Cost 

Savings versus Motor Efficiency 

0%

25%

50%

75%

100%

70% 72% 74% 76% 78% 80% 82% 84% 86% 88%

Motor Efficiency (%)

Consumers with Net Benefit (%)

High Energy Price Trend Scenario

Low Energy Price Trend Scenario

High Electricity Cost Scenario

Low Electricity Cost Scenario

High M arkups Scenario

Low M arkups Scenario

High Loading Scenario

Low Loading Scenario

High Operating Hours Scenario

Low Operating Hours Scenario

Space Constrained Consumer Scenario

Consumers with No Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

Consumers with 100% Reactive Power

Cost Scenario

CSIR to CSCR Switching Scenario

Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario

M edian Social Cost of Carbon Dioxide

Emissions Scenario

Small Business Scenario

Reference

Figure 8C.1.6 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Consumers with 

Net Benefit versus Motor Efficiency 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-22

Table 8C.3.1 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Reference Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1713 129.08 1,157 

Baseline 71.0 541 1451 109.32 1,060 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1389 104.66 1,047 13 33.3 66.7 12.8 4.1 

2 78.3 580 1278 96.25 1,034 26 43.8 56.2 17.3 5.4 

3 80.3 590 1233 92.87 1,029 31 44.7 55.3 17.6 5.5 

4 81.6 606 1239 93.32 1,044 15 52.7 47.3 23.3 7.4 

5 82.7 619 1226 92.37 1,053 7 57.6 42.4 26.5 8.5 

6 83.7 667 1219 91.80 1,098 -38 71.3 28.7 42.5 12.3 

7 85.4 686 1175 88.55 1,101 -41 71.4 28.6 41.0 12.1 

8 87.3 1,493 1144 86.18 1,897 -837 98.8 1.3 238.5 50.2 

Table 8C.3.2 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Energy Price Trend 

Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1713 142.40 1,215 

Baseline 71.0 541 1451 120.60 1,109 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1389 115.46 1,093 15 30.9 69.1 11.5 3.7 

2 78.3 580 1278 106.19 1,077 32 40.9 59.1 15.6 4.9 

3 80.3 590 1233 102.46 1,070 39 42.0 58.0 15.9 5.0 

4 81.6 606 1239 102.95 1,086 23 49.6 50.4 21.1 6.7 

5 82.7 619 1226 101.90 1,094 15 54.4 45.6 24.0 7.7 

6 83.7 667 1219 101.28 1,139 -30 67.9 32.1 38.4 11.2 

7 85.4 686 1175 97.69 1,141 -32 68.0 32.0 37.1 10.9 

8 87.3 1,493 1144 95.07 1,936 -827 98.2 1.8 215.6 45.4 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-23

Table 8C.3.3 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Energy Price Trend 

Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1732 131.20 1,145 

Baseline 71.0 541 1467 111.12 1,050 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1404 106.38 1,037 13 34.3 65.7 12.8 4.0 

2 78.3 580 1291 97.83 1,025 25 44.0 56.0 17.2 5.3 

3 80.3 590 1246 94.39 1,020 30 45.3 54.8 17.5 5.4 

4 81.6 606 1252 94.85 1,036 14 53.5 46.5 23.3 7.4 

5 82.7 619 1239 93.89 1,045 5 58.6 41.4 26.5 8.4 

6 83.7 667 1232 93.31 1,090 -40 72.2 27.8 41.9 12.3 

7 85.4 686 1188 90.01 1,093 -43 72.4 27.6 40.6 12.0 

8 87.3 1,494 1156 87.59 1,891 -841 98.7 1.3 231.2 49.9 

Table 8C.3.4 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Electricity Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1732 144.10 1,221 

Baseline 71.0 541 1467 122.04 1,114 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1404 116.84 1,098 16 30.9 69.1 11.6 3.7 

2 78.3 580 1291 107.45 1,081 33 40.4 59.6 15.7 4.9 

3 80.3 590 1246 103.68 1,074 40 41.6 58.4 16.0 4.9 

4 81.6 606 1252 104.17 1,090 24 49.1 50.9 21.2 6.7 

5 82.7 619 1239 103.12 1,098 16 53.9 46.2 24.1 7.6 

6 83.7 667 1232 102.49 1,142 -29 68.0 32.0 38.1 11.2 

7 85.4 686 1188 98.86 1,144 -31 67.9 32.1 36.9 11.0 

8 87.3 1,494 1156 96.20 1,940 -827 98.0 2.0 210.3 45.5 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-24

Table 8C.3.5 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Electricity Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 544 1736 116.95 1,089 

Baseline 71.0 542 1470 99.05 1,002 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1408 94.83 992 11 36.5 63.5 14.1 4.6 

2 78.3 580 1295 87.23 984 18 47.4 52.6 19.1 6.1 

3 80.3 591 1250 84.17 980 22 48.4 51.6 19.5 6.2 

4 81.6 607 1255 84.56 996 6 57.0 43.0 25.9 8.4 

5 82.7 620 1243 83.70 1,005 -3 62.4 37.6 29.4 9.5 

6 83.7 669 1235 83.19 1,051 -49 75.4 24.6 46.7 14.1 

7 85.4 687 1191 80.25 1,056 -54 75.4 24.6 45.2 13.8 

8 87.3 1,508 1159 78.07 1,867 -865 99.3 0.8 257.9 57.6 

Table 8C.3.6 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Markups Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 572 1715 130.18 1,181 

Baseline 71.0 570 1454 110.40 1,084 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 581 1392 105.69 1,072 12 36.4 63.6 14.3 4.6 

2 78.3 612 1282 97.31 1,063 21 47.3 52.7 19.4 6.1 

3 80.3 624 1237 93.93 1,059 25 48.5 51.6 19.7 6.2 

4 81.6 641 1242 94.30 1,076 9 57.2 42.8 26.1 8.3 

5 82.7 655 1230 93.35 1,086 -2 61.7 38.3 29.7 9.5 

6 83.7 711 1222 92.78 1,138 -54 75.3 24.8 48.1 14.1 

7 85.4 731 1179 89.53 1,143 -59 75.3 24.7 46.4 13.9 

8 87.3 1,661 1147 87.09 2,062 -978 99.2 0.8 274.0 58.2 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-25

Table 8C.3.7 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Markups Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 515 1721 129.01 1,122 

Baseline 71.0 513 1458 109.34 1,026 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 523 1396 104.68 1,012 14 31.6 68.4 11.9 3.8 

2 78.3 548 1285 96.34 998 28 41.7 58.3 16.3 5.0 

3 80.3 558 1240 93.00 992 34 42.6 57.4 16.5 5.1 

4 81.6 572 1245 93.38 1,006 20 50.1 49.9 21.8 7.0 

5 82.7 584 1233 92.45 1,013 13 54.5 45.5 24.8 7.9 

6 83.7 629 1225 91.88 1,054 -28 67.6 32.4 40.1 11.8 

7 85.4 645 1182 88.65 1,056 -30 67.8 32.2 38.7 11.5 

8 87.3 1,397 1150 86.21 1,797 -771 98.4 1.6 229.6 48.0 

Table 8C.3.8 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Loading Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 544 1827 137.37 1,186 

Baseline 71.0 542 1568 117.87 1,092 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1500 112.76 1,077 15 31.6 68.4 11.7 3.8 

2 78.3 581 1391 104.55 1,066 26 43.5 56.5 16.8 5.4 

3 80.3 591 1346 101.15 1,061 31 44.4 55.6 17.2 5.5 

4 81.6 607 1345 101.08 1,074 18 52.1 47.9 22.1 7.2 

5 82.7 620 1330 100.02 1,082 9 56.4 43.6 25.1 8.2 

6 83.7 671 1322 99.41 1,129 -37 70.4 29.6 40.3 12.2 

7 85.4 689 1279 96.16 1,133 -41 70.6 29.4 39.1 12.1 

8 87.3 1,538 1248 93.83 1,971 -880 98.7 1.3 230.9 51.1 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-26

Table 8C.3.9 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Loading Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1602 120.72 1,118 

Baseline 71.0 541 1338 100.79 1,020 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1281 96.54 1,008 11 35.6 64.4 14.0 4.5 

2 78.3 580 1168 88.01 995 24 44.5 55.6 17.8 5.5 

3 80.3 590 1124 84.67 990 30 45.3 54.8 18.0 5.6 

4 81.6 606 1136 85.55 1,008 12 54.2 45.8 24.6 7.8 

5 82.7 619 1124 84.69 1,017 3 59.6 40.4 28.0 8.9 

6 83.7 667 1118 84.19 1,062 -42 72.9 27.1 45.0 13.0 

7 85.4 686 1074 80.93 1,065 -46 72.8 27.2 43.1 12.7 

8 87.3 1,493 1042 78.50 1,861 -842 98.9 1.1 247.5 52.1 

Table 8C.3.10 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: High Operation Hours Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 2079 157.20 1,219 

Baseline 71.0 541 1760 133.14 1,112 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1685 127.46 1,096 15 29.5 70.5 10.6 3.4 

2 78.3 580 1550 117.22 1,080 32 38.9 61.1 14.4 4.5 

3 80.3 590 1495 113.10 1,073 39 39.9 60.1 14.6 4.5 

4 81.6 606 1502 113.64 1,089 23 47.7 52.3 19.5 6.1 

5 82.7 619 1487 112.49 1,097 15 52.3 47.7 22.1 7.0 

6 83.7 667 1478 111.81 1,142 -30 67.5 32.5 34.9 10.2 

7 85.4 686 1426 107.85 1,143 -32 67.4 32.7 33.8 10.0 

8 87.3 1,494 1388 104.95 1,940 -828 98.4 1.6 192.8 41.7 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-27

Table 8C.3.11 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Low Operation Hours Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1386 104.80 1,088 

Baseline 71.0 541 1174 88.76 1,001 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1123 84.97 991 11 38.4 61.6 16.0 5.0 

2 78.3 580 1033 78.15 982 19 49.1 50.9 21.6 6.7 

3 80.3 590 997 75.40 979 23 50.2 49.8 22.0 6.8 

4 81.6 606 1002 75.76 994 7 58.6 41.4 29.2 9.2 

5 82.7 619 991 74.99 1,004 -2 63.5 36.5 33.2 10.5 

6 83.7 667 985 74.54 1,048 -47 75.6 24.4 52.4 15.4 

7 85.4 686 951 71.90 1,054 -52 75.8 24.2 50.7 15.1 

8 87.3 1,494 925 69.96 1,852 -851 98.9 1.1 289.2 62.5 

Table 8C.3.12 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Space Constrained Consumer 

Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 544 1736 129.94 1,150 

Baseline 71.0 542 1470 110.06 1,053 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1408 105.37 1,041 13 33.6 66.4 12.7 4.1 

2 78.3 590 1310 98.06 1,044 9 54.8 45.2 23.1 7.5 

3 80.3 600 1273 95.29 1,041 12 54.1 45.9 22.8 7.4 

4 81.6 607 1263 94.51 1,043 10 55.7 44.3 24.3 7.9 

5 82.7 622 1254 93.88 1,055 -2 61.8 38.2 28.6 9.4 

6 83.7 776 1246 93.27 1,205 -151 94.4 5.6 80.8 26.3 

7 85.4 791 1208 90.42 1,207 -153 93.0 7.0 73.6 23.9 

8 87.3 3,598 1142 85.46 3,992 -2,938 100.0 0.0 725.5 234.1 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-28

Table 8C.3.13 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Consumers with No Reactive 

Power Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 544 1715 130.18 1,144 

Baseline 71.0 542 1454 110.40 1,051 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 553 1392 105.69 1,039 11 38.7 61.4 13.1 4.2 

2 78.3 581 1282 97.31 1,029 22 46.9 53.1 17.7 5.6 

3 80.3 592 1237 93.93 1,024 27 47.5 52.5 18.0 5.7 

4 81.6 607 1242 94.30 1,041 10 57.0 43.0 23.9 7.6 

5 82.7 620 1230 93.35 1,050 1 61.4 38.6 27.2 8.7 

6 83.7 671 1222 92.78 1,098 -47 74.2 25.8 43.9 12.9 

7 85.4 689 1179 89.53 1,101 -50 73.8 26.2 42.3 12.7 

8 87.3 1,535 1147 87.09 1,936 -885 98.9 1.1 249.3 53.0 

Table 8C.3.14 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Consumers with 100 Reactive 

Power Cost Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1721 129.01 1,177 

Baseline 71.0 541 1458 109.34 1,072 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 551 1396 104.68 1,054 18 18.8 81.2 13.1 4.2 

2 78.3 579 1285 96.34 1,039 33 36.8 63.2 17.9 5.5 

3 80.3 590 1240 93.00 1,034 39 39.1 60.9 18.2 5.7 

4 81.6 605 1245 93.38 1,043 29 44.3 55.7 24.0 7.7 

5 82.7 619 1233 92.45 1,052 21 50.4 49.6 27.3 8.7 

6 83.7 668 1225 91.88 1,095 -22 64.9 35.1 44.4 13.0 

7 85.4 686 1182 88.65 1,100 -27 66.7 33.3 42.8 12.7 

8 87.3 1,522 1150 86.21 1,923 -851 98.6 1.4 254.9 53.2 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-29

Table 8C.3.15 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: CSIR to CSCR Switching 

Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 544 1713 128.84 1,147 

Baseline 71.0 542 1452 109.15 1,051 96 0.0 100.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1390 104.50 1,039 109 6.1 93.9 2.0 0.6 

2 78.3 581 1279 96.15 1,027 120 20.7 79.3 6.6 2.1 

3 80.3 591 1234 92.80 1,022 125 24.1 75.9 7.7 2.4 

4 81.6 607 1240 93.20 1,038 110 29.9 70.1 10.2 3.3 

5 82.7 620 1227 92.26 1,047 101 34.2 65.8 12.1 3.9 

6 83.7 671 1220 91.69 1,093 54 46.8 53.2 19.8 5.9 

7 85.4 689 1177 88.46 1,097 50 49.2 50.8 20.9 6.4 

8 87.3 1,538 1144 86.03 1,935 -788 91.3 8.7 132.1 28.6 

Table 8C.3.16 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Carbon Cap and Trade Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1713 138.17 1,213 

Baseline 71.0 541 1451 117.02 1,107 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1389 112.03 1,092 15 31.0 69.0 11.9 3.8 

2 78.3 580 1278 103.03 1,076 31 41.0 59.1 16.1 5.0 

3 80.3 590 1233 99.41 1,069 38 42.0 58.0 16.4 5.1 

4 81.6 606 1239 99.89 1,085 22 49.7 50.3 21.7 6.9 

5 82.7 619 1226 98.88 1,093 14 54.5 45.5 24.7 7.9 

6 83.7 667 1219 98.27 1,138 -30 68.1 31.9 39.5 11.5 

7 85.4 686 1175 94.79 1,140 -32 68.1 31.9 38.2 11.3 

8 87.3 1,493 1144 92.25 1,935 -827 98.3 1.7 221.8 46.7 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-30

Table 8C.3.17 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Median Social Cost of Carbon 

Dioxide Emissions Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1732 166.65 1,331 

Baseline 71.0 541 1467 141.13 1,207 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1404 135.12 1,187 20 26.9 73.1 9.5 3.1 

2 78.3 580 1291 124.26 1,164 43 35.8 64.2 12.8 4.0 

3 80.3 590 1246 119.89 1,154 53 36.9 63.1 13.0 4.1 

4 81.6 606 1252 120.47 1,170 37 44.1 55.9 17.3 5.6 

5 82.7 619 1239 119.25 1,177 30 48.1 51.9 19.7 6.4 

6 83.7 667 1232 118.52 1,221 -14 61.3 38.8 31.0 9.3 

7 85.4 686 1188 114.32 1,220 -13 61.1 38.9 30.1 9.1 

8 87.3 1,494 1156 111.25 2,014 -807 97.5 2.5 170.8 38.1 

Table 8C.3.18 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: Small Business Scenario 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Efficiency 

(%) Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net 

Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 63.4 543 1732 131.00 1,083 

Baseline 71.0 541 1467 110.95 997 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 74.3 552 1404 106.22 987 10 37.7 62.3 12.8 4.0 

2 78.3 580 1291 97.68 979 18 48.0 52.0 17.3 5.3 

3 80.3 590 1246 94.25 976 22 49.0 51.0 17.6 5.4 

4 81.6 606 1252 94.70 991 6 58.0 42.0 23.3 7.4 

5 82.7 619 1239 93.74 1,001 -3 63.1 36.9 26.5 8.4 

6 83.7 667 1232 93.17 1,046 -49 76.2 23.8 41.9 12.3 

7 85.4 686 1188 89.87 1,051 -54 76.3 23.7 40.6 12.0 

8 87.3 1,494 1156 87.45 1,850 -852 99.1 0.9 231.4 50.0 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19
8C-31

Table 8C.3.19 Capacitor-Start Capacitor Run Motors: National Distribution 

Life-Cycle Cost Life-Cycle Cost Savings 

Consumers with 

Payback Period 

(years) Energy 

Efficiency 

Level 

Average 

Installed 

Price ($) 

Average 

Annual 

Energy 

Use 

(KWh) 

Average 

Annual 

Operating 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Cost ($) 

Average 

Savings 

($) 

Net Cost 

(%) 

Net 

Benefit 

(%) 

Average Median 

CSIR 

Baseline 611 2659 199.43 1,531 

Baseline 577 2303 172.75 1,372 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

1 589 2216 166.21 1,351 21 30.1 69.9 11.6 3.5 

2 620 2059 154.52 1,328 44 39.2 60.8 15.8 4.7 

3 632 1997 149.81 1,318 54 40.3 59.7 16.1 4.7 

4 650 2004 150.38 1,335 37 47.8 52.2 21.3 6.4 

5 664 1987 149.05 1,344 28 52.6 47.4 24.2 7.3 

6 720 1976 148.26 1,394 -22 66.0 34.0 38.9 10.8 

7 740 1916 143.73 1,394 -23 66.1 33.9 37.6 10.5 

8 1,665 1871 140.40 2,304 -932 97.0 3.0 220.1 44.2 

EERE-2007-BT-STD-0007 COMMENT 19