# ;nergy Saving and Net Present Values for Ballasts



# 40* Cottvertittgfrom EEM to Electronic Rapid Start For Units Sold from 2,005 to 2030 Discounted at 7% to 1997 (in billion 1997 $)

2F40 I F40 2F96/ES 2F96HOIES All T12 

# LIST INPUTS Total Quad Saved 0.37 0
.02 0.20 0
.02 0.61 

### Total Benefit 0.71 0
.03 0.35 0.02 1.12 Total Equipment Cost 0.19 0
.02 0.13 0.01 0.34 

### Net Present Value 4S2 0
.02 0.23 0
.01 

### 0.78



### Corri'etimg fro;r! EE.-If lo Cathode Cutout For Units Sold from 2005 to 2030 Discounted at No to 1997 (in billion 1997 $)



### 2F40 1F40 2F96/ES 2F96H0/ES All T12 Total Quad Saved 0.26 0.01 0.01 0.26 Total Benefit 0.49 0.01 0.01 0.51 

### Total Equipment Cost 0.18 0
.01 0.00 0.19 Net Present Value 0.31 0.00 0.01 0.32 iN o o C§l



## .. o .-l :1' \ J£f

## ~nergy 

# Saving and Net Present. Values for Ballasts

x

### '~ 

### C<ml'crtiftgf"olll EEM 10 

### Elf/t:{ronj(' Rapid Slal'l 8 8 

### For Units Sold from 2005 to 2030 

## Discounted at 7% 

## to 1997 

## (in billion 1997 $) 

### 2F40 IF40 

## 2F961ES Total Quad 

### Saved 0.37 0.02 0.20 

### Total Benefit 0.71 

### 0.03 

### 0.35 

### Total Equipment Cost 0.l9 

### O,ol 0.13 

### Net 

### Present Value 6.52 0.02 0.23

) W\ '%'



### BeL 

### COfll'e,.1iugjt"ow 

## EEMLo Catllode 

## Cutout For Units Sold from 2005 to 2030 

## Discounted at 7% 

## to 1997 

## (in billion 1997 $) 

## 2F96HO/ES All T12 0.02 0.61 0.02 

### 1.12 0.01 0.34 6.01 0.78



### 2F40 0.26 0.49 

### 0.18 0.11 

### IF40 0.01 0.01 (t01 

### 0.00 

### 2F961ES 2F96HOIES All T12 Total Quad Saved 

### Total Benefit Total Equipment Cost Net Present Value 0.01 6.23 

### 0.01 0.00 0.01 0.51 

### 0.19 0.32. 

# L

LIST INPUTSw

0 "I ) )**~**

o ..-l

### Discounting 7! 77 

### Start Year Shipment 2 ...:l 

### 1990 

### 2000 

### 2010 2020 

### z j:Q .. ...:l ,. p... 5 

### Indusbial Elec Price 

### ...:**~**

# ~
to CI) CI) 2. to to 199{) 2000 2010 2020 00 '<i' 0 .-I IQ 1><\ 

### ...: J:>.. t- .-I 0 .-I



### .....

### ~ 00 CI) "- '<i' N "- 

## "'" 0

# Effective Date of Ballast Standard 0,7 1 421-:

U-M 2005

3, aTEAMMi -RE

-- ------------- 

## e Pr ce s n i ul -_ = = Shipment List lnput^ Il'l o o· I§l0 1 .4

oa 0 

# .. o ,..;Engineering

Default annual lighting hour:
MOTIVES Level Description 0 Baseline I Cathode Cutout 2 Electronic, RS NFW 42.3 38.9 32.4 Price (97$)

$11.70 $17.60 $22.50 kWh/yr

152 140 117 Incr. Cost

$5.90 $10.80 kWh Saving

12 36 2F4OTI2/ES (weighted average) Price (97$) kWh/yr Incr. Cost kWh Saving Level Description NFW per ballast per ballast per ballast per ballast 0 Baseline 111.6 $12.24 265.7 1 Cathode Cutout 100.8 $17.53 240.3 $5.30 25.4 2 Electronic, RS 96.2 $17.80 228.7 $5.57 37.0
2F96TI2/ES Level Description NFW Price (97$) kWh/yr Incr. Cost kWh Saving 0 Baseline 126.1 $19.90 454 I Cathode Cutout 2 Electronic, RS 111.3 $30.50 401 $10.60 53
2F96T12HO/ES Level Description NFW Price (97$) kWh/yr Incr. Cost kWh Saving 0 Baseline 200.0 $32.85 1000 I Cathode Cutout 185.3 $37.76 927 $4.91 73 2 Electronic, RS 176.5 $46.42 883 $13.57 117

Page 1 

### Engineering

Default IIlDDuallighting houn IF40TIlIES Level Description NFW Price (97$) IcWhlyr Iner. Cost 

### kWh Saving

0 Baseline 42.3 $11.70 152 

### 1 Cathode Cutout 

### 38.9 S17.6O 140 

### $5.90 12 2 Electronic, RS 

### 32.4 $22.50 117 

### $10.80 36 2F40TIlIES (weighted avenge) Price (97$) kWhlyr Iner. Cost 

### kWh Saving Level Description NFW per ballast per ballast per ballast per ballast

0 Baseline 111.6 $12.24 265.7 

### 1 Cathode Cutout 100.8 $17.53 240.3 $5.30 25.4 

### 2 Electronic, RS 96.2 $17.80 228.7 $5.57 37.0 2F96TlllES Level Description NFW Price (97$) kWhlyr Incr. Cost 

### kWh Saving

0 Baseline 126.1 $19.90 454 

### 1 Cathode Cutout 

### 2 Electronic, RS 

### 111.3 $30.50 401 

### $10.60 53 2F96T12HOIES Level Description NFW Price (97$) kWhlyr Iner. Cost 

### kWh Saving

0 Baseline 200.0 $32.85 1000 

### 1 Cathode Cutout 

### 185.3 $37.76 927 

### $4.91 73 2 Electronic, RS 

### 176.5 $46.42 883 

### $13.57 117



### Page 131 2 3-- 1995


## 5

01995 

## Co ercial Electricity Price

High Growth ®®AEO 1998 `-GRI 1998 Low Growth 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030



## Industrial Electricity Price

High Growth ®-AEO 1998 Low Growth -GR11998 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 6 

### 5 -High Growth 

### 4 ..... ·-AEO 199& 

### 3**~=GRI199a** 

### 2 -Low Growlh 1995 

### 2000 

### 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025

5 

## Industrial Electricity Price

3 2 

### -High Growtn

-· .... AEO 1998 -Low 

### Growth ;**~GRJ]998** 0--,-,
.



### 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025


### OK