;nergy Saving and Net Present Values for Ballasts

40* Cottvertittg from EEM to Electronic Rapid Start

For Units Sold from 2,005 to 2030

Discounted at 7% to 1997 (in billion 1997 $)

2F40 I F40 2F96/ES 2F96HOIES All T12 LIST INPUTS

Total Quad Saved 0.37 0.02 0.20 0.02 0.61

Total Benefit 0.71 0.03 0.35 0.02 1.12

Total Equipment Cost 0.19 0.02 0.13 0.01 0.34

Net Present Value 4S2 0.02 0.23 0.01 0.78

Corri'etimg fro;r! EE.-If lo Cathode Cutout

For Units Sold from 2005 to 2030

Discounted at No to 1997 (in billion 1997 $)

2F40 1F40 2F96/ES 2F96H0/ES All T12

Total Quad Saved 0.26 0.01 0.01 0.26

Total Benefit 0.49 0.01 0.01 0.51

Total Equipment Cost 0.18 0.01 0.00 0.19

Net Present Value 0.31 0.00 0.01 0.32

EE-RM-97-500 COMMENT 20L

iN 

o 

o 

C§l 

.. 

o 

.-l 

:1' \ J£f 

~nergy Saving and Net Present. Values for Ballasts 

x '~ C<ml'crtiftgf"olll EEM 10 Elf/t:{ronj(' Rapid Slal'l 8 8 

For Units Sold from 2005 to 2030 

Discounted at 7% to 1997 (in billion 1997 $) 

2F40 IF40 2F961ES 

Total Quad Saved 0.37 0.02 0.20 

Total Benefit 0.71 0.03 0.35 

Total Equipment Cost 0.l9 O,ol 0.13 

Net Present Value 6.52 0.02 0.23 

) W\ '%' 

BeL COfll'e,.1iugjt"ow EEMLo Catllode Cutout 

For Units Sold from 2005 to 2030 

Discounted at 7% to 1997 (in billion 1997 $) 

2F96HO/ES All T12 

0.02 0.61 

0.02 1.12 

0.01 0.34 

6.01 0.78 

2F40 

0.26 

0.49 

0.18 

0.11 

IF40 

0.01 

0.01 

(t01 

0.00 

2F961ES 2F96HOIES All T12 

Total Quad Saved 

Total Benefit 

Total Equipment Cost 

Net Present Value 

0.01 6.23 

0.01 

0.00 

0.01 

0.51 

0.19 

0.32. 

L 

LIST INPUTS 
w

0

EE-RM-97-500 COMMENT 20L

" 

I 

) 

) 

~ 

o 

..-l 
Discounting

7! 77

Start Year Shipment

EE-RM-97-500 COMMENT 20L

2 

...:l 1990 2000 2010 2020 

z 

j:Q .. 

...:l ,. 

p... 5 Indusbial Elec Price ...: 

~ 

to 

CI) 

~ CI) 2. to 

to 199{) 2000 2010 2020 

00 

'<i' 

0 

.-I 

IQ 

1><\ 

...: 

J:>.. 

t-

.-I 

0 

.-I 

..... 

~ 

00 

CI) 

"-

'<i' 

N 

"-

"'" 0 
Effective Date of Ballast Standard

0,7 1421-:

U-M

2005

3, -RE aTEAMMi

-- ------------- ule Pr ce s n i

-_ = = Shipment List lnput^

EE-RM-97-500 COMMENT 20L

Il'l 

o 

o· 

I§l 
0

1 .4

oa0

EE-RM-97-500 COMMENT 20L

.. 

o 

,..; 
Engineering

Default annual lighting hour:

MOTIVES

Level Description

0 Baseline

I Cathode Cutout

2 Electronic, RS

NFW

42.3

38.9

32.4

Price (97$)

$11.70

$17.60

$22.50

kWh/yr

152

140

117

Incr. Cost

$5.90

$10.80

kWh Saving

12

36

2F4OTI2/ES (weighted average) Price (97$) kWh/yr Incr. Cost kWh Saving

Level Description NFW per ballast per ballast per ballast per ballast

0 Baseline 111.6 $12.24 265.7

1 Cathode Cutout 100.8 $17.53 240.3 $5.30 25.4

2 Electronic, RS 96.2 $17.80 228.7 $5.57 37.0

2F96TI2/ES

Level Description NFW Price (97$) kWh/yr Incr. Cost kWh Saving

0 Baseline 126.1 $19.90 454

I Cathode Cutout

2 Electronic, RS 111.3 $30.50 401 $10.60 53

2F96T12HO/ES

Level Description NFW Price (97$) kWh/yr Incr. Cost kWh Saving

0 Baseline 200.0 $32.85 1000

I Cathode Cutout 185.3 $37.76 927 $4.91 73

2 Electronic, RS 176.5 $46.42 883 $13.57 117

Page 1

EE-RM-97-500 COMMENT 20L

Engineering 

Default IIlDDuallighting houn 

IF40TIlIES 

Level Description NFW Price (97$) IcWhlyr Iner. Cost kWh Saving 

0 Baseline 42.3 $11.70 152 

1 Cathode Cutout 38.9 S17.6O 140 $5.90 12 

2 Electronic, RS 32.4 $22.50 117 $10.80 36 

2F40TIlIES (weighted avenge) Price (97$) kWhlyr Iner. Cost kWh Saving 

Level Description NFW per ballast per ballast per ballast per ballast 

0 Baseline 111.6 $12.24 265.7 

1 Cathode Cutout 100.8 $17.53 240.3 $5.30 25.4 

2 Electronic, RS 96.2 $17.80 228.7 $5.57 37.0 

2F96TlllES 

Level Description NFW Price (97$) kWhlyr Incr. Cost kWh Saving 

0 Baseline 126.1 $19.90 454 

1 Cathode Cutout 

2 Electronic, RS 111.3 $30.50 401 $10.60 53 

2F96T12HOIES 

Level Description NFW Price (97$) kWhlyr Iner. Cost kWh Saving 

0 Baseline 200.0 $32.85 1000 

1 Cathode Cutout 185.3 $37.76 927 $4.91 73 

2 Electronic, RS 176.5 $46.42 883 $13.57 117 

Page 1 
EE-RM-97-500 COMMENT 20L
31

2 3--

1995

5

0

1995

Co ercial Electricity Price

High Growth

®®AEO 1998

`-GRI 1998

Low Growth

2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030

Industrial Electricity Price

High Growth

®-AEO 1998

Low Growth

-GR11998

2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030

EE-RM-97-500 COMMENT 20L

6 

5 -High Growth 

4 ..... ·-AEO 199& 

3 ~=GRI199a 

2 

-Low Growlh 

1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 

5 

Industrial Electricity Price 

3 

2 

-High Growtn 

-· .... AEO 1998 

-Low Growth 

; ~GRJ]998 0--,-, . 

1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 

OK