Statistical evaluation of the May 15 - September 30, 2002 BaseB1 CMAQ simulation across the OTR

 (including all of VA)

Daily average CO (97 sites), NO (75 sites), NO2 (97 sites), and SO2 (134 sites)

Daily averages computed from hourly data, require at least 12 valid hours per day

Only those hours where the observed and predicted concentrations agreed to within a

 factor of 25 are considered in this analysis

July 6-9 data were excluded because of the influence of the Quebec forest fires

Only those predictions from hours with valid observed concentrations were included here

A majority of the sites are SLAMS/NAMS, but special sites are included as well

 (e.g. AIRMAP sites in NH, Pinnacle State Park in NY, and Harvard Forest in MA)

Site names: first 9 characters = AQS code or descriptive name for special sites, last character =

 parameter occurrence code

Statistics:

observed average

predicted average

coefficient of determination, R2

normalized mean error

root mean square error

fractional gross error

mean absolute gross error

mean normalized gross error

mean bias

mean normalized bias

mean fractionalized bias

normalized mean bias

Statistics are organized two ways - "by date" (consider all valid observed/predicted data pairs at all

 sites on a given day) and "by site" (consider all valid days at a given site)
obs avg, ppb CMAQ avg, ppb R^2 NME, % RMSE, ppb FE, % MAGE, ppb MNGE, % MB, ppb MNB, % MFB, % NMB, % N

20020515 381.27 270.51 0.078 46.73 253.31 51.82 178.17 66.7 -110.77 16.2 -16.76 -29.05 89

20020516 449.48 342.24 0.147 45.21 277.58 52.88 203.23 92.16 -107.24 40.13 -15.92 -23.86 90

20020517 431.74 315.96 0.176 45.02 282.82 49.02 194.36 82.69 -115.77 32.09 -18.46 -26.82 86

20020518 334.62 275.34 0.203 42.32 186.38 45.01 141.62 60.65 -59.28 21.11 -6.26 -17.72 83

20020519 288.02 271.02 0.092 47.7 183.4 51.72 137.39 133.74 -17 101.81 10.12 -5.9 87

20020520 360.79 356.3 0.1 48.19 240.64 50.11 173.87 112.51 -4.49 83.67 11.97 -1.24 86

20020521 362.15 334.56 0.075 48.13 246.59 51.04 174.29 111.25 -27.59 77.6 6.62 -7.62 89

20020522 414.11 366.86 0.148 42.39 242.98 46.48 175.54 75.35 -47.25 38.07 -1.36 -11.41 90

20020523 466.99 386.48 0.214 43.18 276.57 51.24 201.64 118.19 -80.51 76.07 -4 -17.24 93

20020524 498.52 355.93 0.124 45.57 310.1 51.05 227.17 53.52 -142.58 -2.09 -22.65 -28.6 87

20020525 344.57 243.42 0.114 49.58 232.03 57.82 170.85 104.76 -101.15 49.64 -15.8 -29.36 84

20020526 432.35 297.07 0.208 46 284.96 55.36 198.89 96.74 -135.28 38.46 -22.96 -31.29 83

20020527 482.06 312.74 0.186 48.41 311.26 57.64 233.35 78.22 -169.32 13.33 -30.29 -35.13 84

20020528 517.68 337.02 0.157 47.18 359.14 54.85 244.25 71.82 -180.66 11.21 -27.42 -34.9 87

20020529 504.24 328.08 0.183 44.63 343.68 50.86 225.02 58.19 -176.17 -0.27 -28.78 -34.94 89

20020530 471.11 327.41 0.245 44.62 287.54 52.01 210.2 101.68 -143.7 47.06 -22.02 -30.5 87

20020531 460.82 290.47 0.175 51.4 334.51 62.89 236.86 111.13 -170.35 47.66 -25.71 -36.97 87

20020601 419.29 261.08 0.087 56.32 306.77 70.84 236.13 122.99 -158.21 51.62 -28.52 -37.73 86

20020602 331.11 239.46 0.163 49.02 221.16 58.11 162.31 104.05 -91.64 50.15 -13.6 -27.68 86

20020603 350.27 334.48 0.146 48.89 232.04 51.9 171.26 145.3 -15.79 111.53 8.76 -4.51 87

20020604 405.06 347.58 0.106 46.29 271.14 49.77 187.5 85.84 -57.48 46.82 -2.05 -14.19 89

20020605 479.54 309.34 0.179 48.75 342.02 58.56 233.79 124.44 -170.2 63.9 -25.12 -35.49 88

20020606 462.56 330.9 0.212 48.6 303.16 57.74 224.81 119.94 -131.66 63.11 -19.01 -28.46 90

20020607 417.32 289.59 0.211 46.94 302.71 50.79 195.87 78.7 -127.73 26.73 -19.52 -30.61 88

20020608 424.91 299.26 0.221 44.57 268.87 49.83 189.38 56.75 -125.65 1.75 -24.07 -29.57 88

20020609 442.47 284.1 0.167 47.64 276.56 57.36 210.81 78.43 -158.37 13.5 -31.14 -35.79 90

20020610 509.49 340.01 0.186 46.75 347.81 54.74 238.19 74.49 -169.48 16.45 -24.94 -33.27 90

20020611 524.19 351.04 0.189 46.46 333.02 55.87 243.55 80.99 -173.15 20.83 -26.68 -33.03 92

20020612 493.57 348.54 0.18 48.06 318.08 55.9 237.23 75.11 -145.03 18.26 -21.84 -29.38 87

20020613 480.67 393.86 0.259 42.37 280.48 46.47 203.66 57.37 -86.81 13.01 -11.69 -18.06 86

20020614 463.87 403.06 0.306 39.6 246.66 43.22 183.68 53.54 -60.82 16.17 -5.6 -13.11 86

20020615 394.73 332.21 0.336 50.69 248.5 62.45 200.08 147.91 -62.53 102.17 2.43 -15.84 90

20020616 388.15 279.37 0.218 49.28 247.07 56.78 191.29 88.13 -108.78 33.29 -16.74 -28.02 89

20020617 462.41 335.94 0.181 48.61 297.21 56.92 224.79 96.26 -126.48 41.69 -17.09 -27.35 91

20020618 480.03 349.08 0.153 48.23 302.45 56.01 231.53 92.33 -130.95 37.52 -17.76 -27.28 90

20020619 517.1 363.71 0.245 45.47 321.96 52.31 235.11 71.09 -153.38 15.34 -22.43 -29.66 91
20020620 539.42 376.88 0.316 44.49 341.61 51.05 239.99 63.12 -162.53 9.16 -21.8 -30.13 93

20020621 499 356.96 0.165 47.55 332.63 55.49 237.27 89.76 -142.04 36.11 -17.27 -28.47 92

20020622 480.51 334.23 0.102 50.05 309.17 58.71 240.49 85.68 -146.29 26.5 -22.1 -30.44 90

20020623 438.39 312.68 0.094 49.04 279.83 58.42 215 81.1 -125.7 24.33 -19.22 -28.67 88

20020624 479.69 344.47 0.169 49.57 311.47 60.72 237.79 119.35 -135.22 63.04 -16.65 -28.19 89

20020625 497.19 405.74 0.229 45.12 306.23 52.28 224.33 82.45 -91.46 37.25 -7.5 -18.39 92

20020626 529.72 355.69 0.251 49.52 377.98 58.3 262.29 77.16 -174.03 20.01 -20.29 -32.85 89

20020627 452.28 288.11 0.149 53.56 350.8 65.86 242.23 141.76 -164.17 80.54 -19.88 -36.3 86

20020628 479.17 306.79 0.066 55.51 364.08 66.11 265.97 86.63 -172.38 18.32 -29.94 -35.97 85

20020629 463.75 298.18 0.104 52.27 329.69 62.41 242.42 91.97 -165.56 27.84 -27.04 -35.7 89

20020630 497.92 320.15 0.162 48.37 322.12 61.01 240.83 87.53 -177.78 21.22 -29.85 -35.7 89

20020701 524.16 353.6 0.091 46.59 330.21 54.57 244.19 55.3 -170.56 -6.1 -29.55 -32.54 90

20020702 584.72 391.26 0.092 50.15 395.36 58.46 293.24 57.22 -193.47 -8.78 -34.03 -33.09 93

20020703 546.55 353.86 0.058 51.74 408 58.8 282.77 63.01 -192.68 -0.34 -30.91 -35.25 93

20020704 416.27 270.62 0.013 56.55 314.61 64.1 235.39 79.35 -145.65 14.29 -28.42 -34.99 90

20020705 350.26 250.72 0.027 53.56 266.28 58.36 187.61 74.37 -99.54 20.02 -18.43 -28.42 84

20020706

20020707

20020708

20020709

20020710 395.45 272.45 0.189 46.04 270.69 52.4 182.06 74.95 -123 20.16 -23.08 -31.1 80

20020711 341.49 283.81 0.117 54.66 270.52 57.15 186.68 78.45 -57.68 39.99 3.61 -16.89 88

20020712 430.34 358.4 0.209 44.62 287.98 47 192 74.65 -71.94 38.34 -2.15 -16.72 89

20020713 423.97 326.61 0.138 45.09 270.04 48.49 191.17 54.01 -97.36 7.14 -13.09 -22.96 84

20020714 415.16 310.35 0.127 47.4 262.65 55.4 196.77 89.78 -104.8 36.68 -15.55 -25.24 84

20020715 467.38 347.28 0.145 45.71 300.72 53.56 213.64 81.02 -120.1 28.7 -16.41 -25.7 87

20020716 426.17 302.71 0.171 45.31 273.06 52.53 193.12 83.97 -123.46 30.34 -20.26 -28.97 84

20020717 503.91 381.89 0.23 44.4 329.18 52.49 223.74 93.28 -122.02 43.08 -15.61 -24.21 89

20020718 525.96 367.15 0.145 44.61 327.46 52.89 234.63 61.25 -158.81 3.02 -27.04 -30.19 88

20020719 519.64 359.9 0.286 46.03 324.21 56.4 239.19 66.06 -159.74 6.47 -24.98 -30.74 90

20020720 429.74 278.45 0.128 53.7 316.08 65.93 230.78 111.31 -151.28 47.22 -23.54 -35.2 91

20020721 412.17 258.84 0.081 50.63 287.6 61.87 208.7 82.99 -153.32 17.5 -28.74 -37.2 87

20020722 458.48 313.07 0.109 46.92 319.2 54.71 215.12 75.98 -145.41 18.2 -23.77 -31.72 88

20020723 465.35 323.13 0.194 47.65 317.47 54.99 221.72 78.45 -142.23 20.67 -23.44 -30.56 86

20020724 394.51 298.21 0.302 43.89 247.94 50.19 173.15 91.1 -96.31 43.98 -12.79 -24.41 82

20020725 371.43 291.01 0.11 49.78 276.69 54.15 184.91 102.81 -80.41 59.04 -5.12 -21.65 84

20020726 399.09 323.7 0.111 52.57 310.54 57.98 209.82 134.79 -75.38 91.63 -1 -18.89 87
20020727 463.23 318.23 0.151 46.6 322.01 53.43 215.87 64.28 -145 9.69 -21.77 -31.3 86

20020728 498.19 309.6 0.211 49.99 340.43 61.66 249.06 115.39 -188.6 48.05 -31.6 -37.86 88

20020729 491.9 329.2 0.074 51.67 354.83 60.07 254.17 79.12 -162.69 16.97 -26.71 -33.07 86

20020730 420.82 292.16 0.056 50.69 303.36 58.09 213.31 83.43 -128.67 26.76 -20.32 -30.57 87

20020731 426.51 331.43 0.083 49.54 298.3 55.89 211.29 85.31 -95.09 35.17 -13.32 -22.29 88

20020801 506.05 372.96 0.195 44.9 336.13 52.29 227.24 70.3 -133.09 18 -18.04 -26.3 88

20020802 490.64 401.68 0.266 42.22 292.55 49.71 207.14 70.96 -88.95 25.27 -10.57 -18.13 87

20020803 478.73 340.32 0.186 43.06 305.67 46.57 206.12 44.42 -138.41 -9.01 -24.81 -28.91 82

20020804 471.54 321.4 0.222 44.68 290.13 54.26 210.68 81.41 -150.15 22.65 -24.09 -31.84 85

20020805 447.07 381.92 0.11 47.99 305.7 53.25 214.55 79.7 -65.14 34.1 -7.56 -14.57 83

20020806 292.59 249.52 0.121 46.92 187.09 53.23 137.29 117.08 -43.07 77.22 -0.12 -14.72 77

20020807 348.03 320.55 0.218 46.69 218.05 53.27 162.49 112 -27.48 78.93 9.38 -7.9 78

20020808 379.76 363.11 0.25 45.81 231.9 53.05 173.97 124.63 -16.64 93.09 11.69 -4.38 83

20020809 402.21 386.59 0.224 45.33 249.99 50.12 182.33 116.14 -15.62 85.1 10.13 -3.88 87

20020810 386.2 313.93 0.212 42.66 237.56 47.93 164.75 94.73 -72.27 54.67 -4.77 -18.71 86

20020811 385.48 324.56 0.131 43 227.52 48.24 165.77 85.95 -60.92 44.91 -5.47 -15.8 83

20020812 501.18 423.63 0.27 39.21 279.96 46.91 196.53 86.46 -77.55 44.2 -7.52 -15.47 87

20020813 529.26 430.18 0.256 41.98 311.7 50.83 222.18 83.6 -99.07 37.63 -9.08 -18.72 90

20020814 483.54 361.11 0.258 42.36 291.87 52.4 204.82 96.92 -122.43 45.97 -14.15 -25.32 88

20020815 412 328.72 0.09 45.89 284.52 54.5 189.07 98.54 -83.29 51.76 -7.73 -20.21 83

20020816 457.38 354.92 0.239 48.77 339.78 60.55 223.06 151.85 -102.46 103.22 -5.06 -22.4 87

20020817 440.05 328.42 0.226 46.87 290.42 58.25 206.25 105.9 -111.63 51.32 -15.34 -25.37 82

20020818 422.73 329.65 0.205 50.57 277.92 62.08 213.75 135.07 -93.08 79.8 -11.69 -22.02 83

20020819 426.92 391.97 0.197 46.57 259.58 54.89 198.81 111.12 -34.95 68.57 -0.43 -8.19 85

20020820 436.76 353.5 0.269 46.69 264.16 57.31 203.94 104.37 -83.27 53.76 -9.88 -19.06 87

20020821 423.81 340.21 0.202 43.74 267.27 51.55 185.39 88.94 -83.6 43.71 -7.61 -19.73 85

20020822 453.04 359.22 0.134 45.53 316.51 51.42 206.29 119.06 -93.81 73.79 -7.81 -20.71 86

20020823 470.84 363.94 0.242 47.09 306.06 56 221.7 109.91 -106.9 59.88 -10.74 -22.71 85

20020824 450.34 357.72 0.345 45.98 301.29 53.37 207.05 98.2 -92.62 52.01 -7.37 -20.57 84

20020825 388.47 295.71 0.165 52.11 267.09 61.51 202.43 90.54 -92.76 36.35 -12.1 -23.88 81

20020826 507.52 421.28 0.23 42.97 307.3 49.69 218.08 79.43 -86.24 33.52 -11.73 -16.99 87

20020827 491.22 400.73 0.387 41.1 281.72 49.5 201.91 91.92 -90.49 47.13 -9 -18.42 87

20020828 390.5 341.12 0.194 45.04 245.77 49.97 175.89 93.1 -49.38 55.09 0.55 -12.64 84

20020829 415.55 404.37 0.316 43.32 232.05 49.07 180.04 109.5 -11.18 79.23 10.46 -2.69 83

20020830 508.59 423.09 0.268 46.41 328.33 53.59 236.06 85.85 -85.5 43.17 -3.36 -16.81 87

20020831 441.63 326.56 0.247 47.09 284.63 55.36 207.97 85.1 -115.07 34.24 -12.8 -26.05 85

20020901 385.15 283.11 0.123 44.92 232.99 50.14 173.01 68.48 -102.03 16.2 -19.48 -26.49 75
20020902 398.45 283.17 0.146 46.58 252.63 53.63 185.59 113.8 -115.28 60.15 -18.44 -28.93 82

20020903 550.25 369.45 0.249 43.93 351.8 50.59 241.71 69.62 -180.81 10.42 -29.26 -32.86 86

20020904 495.82 365.48 0.221 44.48 308.95 52.73 220.54 73.23 -130.35 21.54 -16.54 -26.29 85

20020905 415.92 313.86 0.134 46.66 269.16 52.27 194.06 55.1 -102.05 4.19 -17.56 -24.54 82

20020906 505.34 387.8 0.215 43.87 323.79 48.35 221.7 68.97 -117.54 23.15 -13.33 -23.26 84

20020907 586.11 371.99 0.416 44.61 352.6 54.23 261.46 65.79 -214.12 0.41 -34.24 -36.53 85

20020908 532.2 342.64 0.285 45.62 320.62 54.36 242.77 57.32 -189.56 -6.62 -31.16 -35.62 85

20020909 668.93 455.11 0.354 43.06 430.53 53.15 288.05 82.57 -213.81 25.06 -23.83 -31.96 89

20020910 637.8 422.37 0.323 41.79 409.79 49.42 266.53 46.4 -215.43 -12.32 -29.29 -33.78 87

20020911 376.5 282.4 0.176 44.6 225.7 51.71 167.93 84.95 -94.1 33.52 -17.31 -24.99 82

20020912 413.06 339.51 0.188 45.23 269.11 51.26 186.83 95.69 -73.56 54.94 -5.02 -17.81 84

20020913 537.24 396.25 0.285 39.61 332.65 43.58 212.8 57.33 -140.99 9.66 -19.98 -26.24 88

20020914 494.39 301.42 0.209 49.38 351.42 60.96 244.13 104.58 -192.96 38.34 -29.46 -39.03 87

20020915 423.78 245.4 0.162 53.33 317.36 64.3 226.02 104.47 -178.38 34.73 -33.06 -42.09 82

20020916 489.47 334.41 0.201 45.73 327.85 54.26 223.83 63.05 -155.06 6.27 -23.88 -31.68 85

20020917 544.25 371.44 0.248 42.7 336.75 51.61 232.38 76.31 -172.81 17.18 -28.94 -31.75 88

20020918 568.41 405.75 0.242 41.58 350.83 47.4 236.35 64.27 -162.66 9.95 -24.78 -28.62 89

20020919 542.88 397.42 0.178 43.27 353.96 48.9 234.9 82.87 -145.46 32.09 -18.94 -26.79 89

20020920 513.86 337.7 0.107 47.37 360.6 52.86 243.43 59.62 -176.16 -1.24 -30.14 -34.28 87

20020921 471.76 291.12 0.108 49.04 340.69 55.23 231.37 51.91 -180.64 -12.53 -33.65 -38.29 84

20020922 399.16 255.61 0.079 51.21 279.86 60.79 204.4 112.23 -143.56 49.79 -25.34 -35.96 85

20020923 427.41 334.39 0.249 41.26 235.93 47.86 176.34 54.96 -93.02 7.7 -15.32 -21.76 83

20020924 522.19 399.84 0.289 38.5 284.81 44.96 201.02 51.68 -122.35 3.8 -18.81 -23.43 87

20020925 507.36 406.36 0.27 40.13 282.41 47.82 203.61 94.3 -101 48.85 -11.76 -19.91 87

20020926 480.6 440.82 0.317 39.84 248.75 45.15 191.45 92.45 -39.78 58.11 1.26 -8.28 83

20020927 525.01 385.5 0.237 45.35 345.8 50.92 238.07 97.85 -139.5 48.08 -16.2 -26.57 83

20020928 426.6 251.18 0.211 50.63 292.47 58.06 215.98 62.57 -175.43 -4.79 -35.72 -41.12 82

20020929 472.63 327.16 0.244 43.61 282.03 48.81 206.1 60.43 -145.47 4.24 -26.21 -30.78 84

20020930 567.8 425.24 0.185 43.32 374.07 46.59 245.95 48.57 -142.56 -1.79 -20.46 -25.11 86
obs avg, ppb CMAQ avg, ppb R^2 NME, % RMSE, ppb FE, % MAGE, ppb MNGE, % MB, ppb MNB, % MFB, % NMB, %

0900100041 663.65 333.55 0.308 49.75 352.93 65.23 330.14 48.1 -330.1 -48.09 -65.22 -49.74

0900100201 852.54 333.7 0.292 60.86 550.34 86.35 518.84 59.63 -518.84 -59.63 -86.35 -60.86

0900300131 408.78 302.63 0.21 27.26 136.49 30.63 111.44 25.41 -106.16 -23.4 -28.78 -25.97

0900300171 1513.87 319.03 0.393 78.93 1255.41 128.41 1194.85 77.95 -1194.85 -77.95 -128.41 -78.93

0900310031 459 339.72 0.347 27.24 146.82 30.89 125.03 25.75 -119.28 -24 -29.23 -25.99

0900900251 571.88 288.8 0.33 49.5 305.56 64.96 283.08 48.06 -283.08 -48.06 -64.96 -49.5

1000310081 398.04 192.74 0.036 58.26 292.66 70.61 231.9 65.87 -205.3 -20.18 -54.24 -51.58

1000320041 295.84 328.21 0.251 31.85 110.74 34.24 94.24 46.04 32.38 31.4 17.5 10.94

1100100231 855.64 452.96 0.105 48.09 473.9 58.89 411.47 44.26 -402.68 -41.72 -56.8 -47.06

1100100411 1055.16 476.69 0.025 55.96 643.09 74.76 590.43 53.6 -578.48 -50.13 -71.99 -54.82

2300520031 464.8 212.34 0.078 54.7 291.1 70.57 254.26 50.64 -252.46 -49.72 -69.76 -54.32

2300901021 276.05 151.51 0.073 47.84 145.44 60.74 132.07 50.46 -124.53 -36.1 -54.61 -45.11

2400530011 378.16 326.01 0.084 41.26 197.95 42.93 156.02 45.21 -52.15 8.79 -4.24 -13.79

2451000401 420.58 408.73 0.155 29.17 148.64 32.82 122.68 45.64 -11.85 21.44 4.15 -2.82

2501300161 601.81 258.4 0.11 58.02 394.83 75.49 349.19 53.17 -343.41 -49.45 -72.63 -57.06

2501320071 764.27 254.25 0.075 66.76 567.4 94.78 510.24 62.85 -510.02 -62.77 -94.69 -66.73

2501700071 304.01 286.02 0.167 37 137.66 43.74 112.5 87.8 -17.99 57.8 7.56 -5.92

2502500021 303.35 397.97 0.168 44.23 167.79 47.31 134.17 114.74 94.62 106.15 37.66 31.19

2502500211 261.8 352.29 0.031 82.75 256.78 78.87 216.64 234.63 90.49 217.64 56.08 34.57

2502500381 665.88 377.54 0.11 46.52 369.05 54.61 309.8 42.33 -288.34 -34.33 -48.33 -43.3

2502500421 223.98 394.17 0.002 92.09 261.34 74.08 206.27 274.7 170.19 270.29 68.39 75.99

2502700201 516.19 228.93 0.053 56.1 330.16 73.23 289.6 53.1 -287.27 -48.84 -71.28 -55.65

2502700221 441.69 228.86 0.01 50.5 268.7 61.23 223.04 45.75 -212.83 -39.25 -56.36 -48.19

3301100201 295.51 241.33 0.257 33.37 118 37.76 98.61 53.14 -54.19 12.92 -11.05 -18.34

3301110091 245.66 219.82 0.175 46.58 150.02 52.26 114.42 108.98 -25.83 76.61 10.45 -10.52

3400300041 994.27 536.36 0.085 46.87 519.15 60.24 465.99 44.76 -457.92 -43.35 -58.95 -46.06

3400350011 540.06 536.73 0.449 19.85 133.76 21.78 107.21 22.94 -3.33 4.84 0.7 -0.62

3400510011 590.49 341.81 0.181 43.13 309.58 50.31 254.67 38.33 -248.68 -36.08 -48.27 -42.11

3400700031 443 349.15 0.083 33.95 173.54 38.52 150.42 37.2 -93.85 -8.95 -18.91 -21.18

3400710011 237.86 205.88 0.01 32.68 100.68 33.77 77.74 33.64 -31.98 -1.29 -9.94 -13.44

3401300161 551.54 576.9 0.238 20.01 141.62 19.86 110.34 21.55 25.36 7.89 4.23 4.6

3401710021 1117.67 567.31 0.014 51.57 665.06 65.8 576.39 51.75 -550.36 -37.73 -58.96 -49.24

3401750021 659.71 600.08 0.374 19.28 147.52 20.09 127.19 19.22 -59.63 -6.73 -9.26 -9.04

3402320031 539.05 455.7 0.168 24.88 163.61 27.55 134.14 25.79 -83.34 -10.27 -15.58 -15.46

3402520011 639.4 257.73 0.349 59.69 403.55 84.18 381.67 58.66 -381.67 -58.66 -84.18 -59.69

3402700031 721.44 310.1 0.046 57.05 469.77 76.88 411.55 53.48 -411.34 -53.4 -76.81 -57.02
3403900031 929.41 457.3 0.226 51.31 559.46 64.19 476.85 47.15 -472.11 -45.3 -62.72 -50.8

3600100121 267.53 310.55 0.049 46.1 149.1 49.35 123.35 104.86 43.01 87.33 27.86 16.08

3600500831 690.71 761.81 0.275 22.43 200.32 21.7 154.93 24.93 71.1 13.79 9.07 10.29

3602900051 437.68 284.48 0.046 36.53 194.37 43.28 159.87 34.6 -153.2 -32 -41.22 -35

3604700711 1058.78 657.45 0.266 37.94 450.14 46.46 401.66 36.53 -401.32 -36.48 -46.4 -37.9

3605510041 375.51 258.68 0.113 32.43 149.25 37.48 121.78 30.07 -116.83 -28.03 -35.68 -31.11

3605560011 472.85 301.07 0.306 37.12 195.66 44.9 175.51 35.69 -171.78 -34.18 -43.53 -36.33

3606100561 719.46 870.26 0.136 29.68 267.14 28.5 213.57 38.28 150.8 31 20.45 20.96

3606100921 925.5 873.24 0.293 21.21 261.9 21.91 196.26 22.71 -52.25 1.68 -2.7 -5.65

3606320081 366.75 241.68 0.025 39.15 165.8 45.57 143.56 38.38 -125.07 -26.16 -37.01 -34.1

3606700171 455.56 320.63 0.207 30.7 160.18 36.04 139.85 29.85 -134.93 -27.66 -34.35 -29.62

3608101241 469.17 622.73 0.138 45.03 255.15 41.27 211.29 65.99 153.56 58.21 32.3 32.73

3609300031 470.11 246.74 0.146 49.67 270.89 61.61 233.49 46.66 -223.37 -39.78 -56.3 -47.51

3610300092 112.17 340.95 0.163 206.26 247.4 112.47 231.36 481.17 228.77 480.5 111.74 203.95

4200100011 172.55 161.81 0.112 40.63 89.53 47.96 70.11 110.96 -10.75 80.44 9.61 -6.23

4200300101 452.28 370.96 0.102 47.97 267.02 59.73 216.97 164.16 -81.32 119.29 2.49 -17.98

4200300381 249.46 382.22 0.168 85.1 242.45 80.85 212.28 292.74 132.76 280.76 65.96 53.22

4200700141 146.63 178.22 0.005 66.06 111.95 69.39 96.87 245.06 31.59 221.57 40.17 21.55

4201100091 434.82 283.9 0 37.4 188.09 44.38 162.63 35.45 -150.92 -31.07 -40.68 -34.71

4201308011 31 178.1 0.013 474.48 150.09 143.65 147.1 842.33 147.1 842.33 143.65 474.48

4201700121 73.27 369.93 0.097 404.87 304.75 138.08 296.66 712.68 296.66 712.68 138.08 404.87

4202100111 463.83 159.9 0.058 65.67 331.61 92.83 304.6 62.2 -303.93 -61.77 -92.42 -65.53

4204301021 362.07 313.94 0.115 28.02 133.23 30.22 101.45 33.21 -48.13 0.39 -9.63 -13.29

4204901011 464.45 197.61 0.193 57.54 343.54 72.95 267.24 52.19 -266.84 -51.88 -72.67 -57.45

4205900021 21.24 112.94 0.075 431.78 93.93 142.5 91.7 818.83 91.7 818.83 142.5 431.78

4206920061 47.55 242.01 0.042 408.91 200.72 139.53 194.45 763.74 194.45 763.74 139.53 408.91

4207100071 339.07 275.5 0.126 52.36 216.95 61.43 177.55 138.15 -63.57 95.25 4.48 -18.75

4207300151 308.75 181.44 0.27 43.11 158.31 50.29 133.11 40.21 -127.3 -33.47 -45.89 -41.23

4207701001 577.7 335.95 0.106 44.01 293.41 52.74 254.28 41.11 -241.75 -36.6 -49.13 -41.85

4207921001 307.01 245.14 0.007 54.33 207.44 65.24 166.81 164.48 -61.87 115.99 2.06 -20.15

4209100131 177.01 360.61 0.066 123.09 253.69 106.35 217.87 695.48 183.6 687.18 96.93 103.73

4209500251 294.63 267.66 0.017 32.47 123.77 34.45 95.66 41.19 -26.97 11.14 -2.44 -9.15

4210100041 370.48 402.5 0.152 23.68 111.74 23.58 87.73 28.22 32.02 16.39 10.29 8.64

4210100271 587.35 428.08 0.139 35.26 255.5 39.36 207.07 40.52 -159.27 -10.16 -24.63 -27.12

4210100291 414.69 428.24 0.143 26.93 150 27.95 111.69 34.59 13.55 18.11 8.42 3.27

4210100471 441.46 358.75 0.128 29.65 157.46 33.48 130.88 32.54 -82.71 -8.77 -17.03 -18.73

4210700031 173.47 145.73 0.005 54.65 153.25 59.39 94.8 106.77 -27.74 68.6 9.05 -15.99
4212500051 200.99 179.83 0.001 56.5 135.18 64.09 113.55 145.58 -21.15 106.09 11.24 -10.53

4212900081 358.3 195.39 0.001 55.53 220.3 72.57 198.95 100.82 -162.91 15.13 -44.95 -45.47

4213300081 216.24 269.36 0.165 35.58 100.01 37.42 76.94 83.19 53.13 75.76 29.19 24.57

4400710091 684.09 361.09 0.141 47.5 377.56 58.95 324.94 43.8 -323 -43.13 -58.34 -47.22

4400710101 547.25 370.98 0.147 32.94 213.19 38.65 180.27 30.87 -176.27 -29.75 -37.62 -32.21

5002100021 571.67 140.27 0.014 75.46 455.9 118.01 431.39 73.75 -431.39 -73.75 -118.01 -75.46

5101300201 353.77 452.97 0.079 40.06 182.08 40.01 141.73 96.9 99.2 89.83 32 28.04

5105900051 452.3 423.45 0.186 30.03 175.34 32.71 135.83 52.29 -28.85 26.76 1.21 -6.38

5105900301 364.52 446.59 0.037 30.42 145.3 28.58 110.89 39.12 82.07 32.88 21.8 22.52

5105910051 496.11 446.02 0.017 27.02 172.96 28.25 134.06 28.73 -50.1 -0.53 -7.33 -10.1

5105950011 410.26 454.05 0.232 22.17 112.09 21.15 90.94 23.89 43.78 15.36 11.49 10.67

5151000091 396.99 355.43 0.209 32.35 169.64 37.3 128.42 63.59 -41.56 32.37 -1.69 -10.47

5165000042 289.32 492.54 0.048 80.34 268.25 60.75 232.45 112.82 203.22 105.79 52.19 70.24

5171000191 295.72 305.55 0.094 53.27 189.78 60.03 157.53 175.37 9.84 148.16 25.51 3.33

5171000231 193.16 306.08 0.032 84.77 186.69 77.26 163.75 224.99 112.91 214.07 63.8 58.46

5176000221 352.92 341.29 0.018 54.35 231.69 61.01 191.82 124.53 -11.63 91.95 18.63 -3.3

5176000241 279.29 338.350 52.37 174.95 53.41 146.25 131.2 59.06 113.02 31.1 21.15

5177000131 616.85 279.73 0.014 54.65 374.9 71.61 337.12 51.48 -337.12 -51.48 -71.61 -54.65

airmap_cs1 157.36 125.5 0.071 24.56 46.22 27.02 38.65 23.43 -31.87 -17.92 -22.08 -20.25

airmap_is1 199.67 183.12 0.525 18.05 46.49 18.52 36.04 17.64 -16.55 -5.73 -8.07 -8.29

airmap_mw1 148.84 109.17 0.002 28.22 49.22 32.04 42 26.71 -39.67 -24.81 -30.29 -26.65

airmap_tf1 184.15 176.04 0.244 18.2 43.67 18.32 33.52 18.34 -8.11 -1.35 -4.02 -4.4

harvard_f1 158.98 153.93 0.147 19.19 41.62 18.74 30.5 19.3 -5.05 0.74 -2.38 -3.17

pinnacle01 187.67 111.62 0.046 40.61 83.15 49.75 76.21 38.97 -76.05 -38.84 -49.63 -40.53
N

121

135

73

134

61

131

135

135

131

135

135

135

135

134

135

126

133

134

98

74

125

134

133

135

129

47

135

134

132

132

130

135

49

131

135

135
126

135

135

135

134

135

135

135

135

135

135

130

129

111

108

127

109

117

135

40

75

135

135

135

13

84

128

135

92

130

44

135

134

131

124

134

129
116

82

133

127

129

135

135

135

135

132

135

131

135

126

124

115

131

135

131

80

123

129

47

114
obs avg, ppb CMAQ avg, ppb R^2 NME, % RMSE, ppb FE, % MAGE, ppb MNGE, % MB, ppb MNB, % MFB, % NMB, % N

20020515 6.03 3.48 0.241 72.83 6.82 88.14 4.39 106.89 -2.55 21.89 -44.28 -42.28 67

20020516 12.16 5.58 0.147 73.91 14.38 88.51 8.99 84.56 -6.59 -3.64 -51.61 -54.14 66

20020517 3.98 3.69 0.179 83.1 6.16 72.47 3.31 80.88 -0.29 14.34 -30.3 -7.28 65

20020518 3.03 2.33 0.056 88.97 5.06 94.38 2.7 126.11 -0.7 41.04 -40.51 -23.22 63

20020519 2.77 3.03 0.051 101.25 6.18 77.93 2.8 117.85 0.26 58.41 -9.59 9.29 64

20020520 4.95 4.63 0.144 80.03 7.71 75.84 3.96 98.15 -0.32 34.76 -18.32 -6.55 71

20020521 6.54 5.18 0.155 77.18 8.47 76.17 5.05 84.28 -1.37 23.82 -18.9 -20.87 68

20020522 9.33 5.67 0.18 71.85 10.22 81.7 6.7 81.86 -3.66 0.26 -47.98 -39.27 68

20020523 11.43 5.81 0.216 65.52 12.71 77.06 7.49 66.22 -5.62 -14.56 -49.39 -49.2 69

20020524 6.62 4.28 0.301 64.1 6.7 68.68 4.24 53.29 -2.33 -23.48 -48.09 -35.26 65

20020525 2.54 1.8 0.057 81.44 3.54 82.7 2.07 82.23 -0.74 4.22 -41.11 -29.09 63

20020526 2.75 2.61 0.248 96.27 4.96 87.17 2.65 84.43 -0.15 -1.05 -49.86 -5.32 59

20020527 3.91 2.8 0.21 78.17 5.21 84.31 3.06 97.52 -1.11 12.04 -51.79 -28.43 65

20020528 8.3 4.86 0.581 55.35 7.87 88.56 4.6 71.7 -3.45 -24.43 -65.02 -41.53 63

20020529 7.83 4.77 0.166 78.91 11.06 88.23 6.18 75.43 -3.07 -18.8 -64.43 -39.16 65

20020530 8.69 5.3 0.49 63.18 8.46 84.7 5.49 92.7 -3.39 5.76 -50.36 -39.03 68

20020531 6.8 3.93 0.567 56.27 6.24 81.44 3.83 73.58 -2.87 -12.31 -50.85 -42.2 70

20020601 3.32 2.4 0.179 81.71 4.94 80.05 2.71 83.84 -0.92 5.85 -40.51 -27.76 68

20020602 2.2 2.28 0.035 114.82 5.25 92.04 2.53 148.63 0.08 72.32 -28.95 3.5 65

20020603 4.43 5.68 0.416 98.93 9.47 77.21 4.39 130.17 1.24 75.04 -5.72 28.03 70

20020604 5.3 3.75 0.188 73.15 6.27 83.46 3.88 83.8 -1.55 9.89 -33.37 -29.32 68

20020605 3.96 1.97 0.328 66.36 4.22 86.89 2.63 102.09 -1.99 17.02 -50.44 -50.31 65

20020606 5.51 3.36 0.267 68.94 6.46 89.5 3.8 71.6 -2.16 -24.22 -64.51 -39.1 66

20020607 5.18 2.6 0.083 78.12 7.47 93.18 4.05 104.6 -2.59 14.51 -54.22 -49.89 68

20020608 5.56 3.34 0.085 83.69 7.91 95.91 4.65 98.68 -2.22 10.55 -47.42 -40 71

20020609 2.8 2.44 0.065 98.1 5.11 85.37 2.74 109.86 -0.35 34.1 -32.13 -12.68 68

20020610 4.61 3.14 0.132 78.87 5.95 88.14 3.63 103.96 -1.46 24.27 -37.39 -31.74 73

20020611 4.57 2.6 0.245 72.38 5.34 88.1 3.31 107.5 -1.97 28.4 -37.89 -43.11 70

20020612 4.06 3.58 0.328 79.65 5.54 88.15 3.24 128.09 -0.48 48.73 -37.97 -11.84 62

20020613 5.31 3.07 0.185 67.84 6.39 85.18 3.61 90.45 -2.24 3.02 -54.93 -42.15 65

20020614 6.53 2.85 0.143 74.22 9.05 89.65 4.85 75.28 -3.68 -16.62 -57.16 -56.37 65

20020615 3.18 4.15 0.377 113.39 7.95 93.44 3.61 137.69 0.97 63.39 -24.56 30.47 59

20020616 4.04 3.32 0.165 87.06 6.34 93.18 3.52 121.17 -0.72 40.54 -33.34 -17.85 63

20020617 8.06 5.64 0.12 80.21 10.44 85.57 6.46 112.84 -2.41 30.89 -41.67 -29.94 68

20020618 9.22 4.42 0.222 70.48 9.91 90.84 6.5 81.04 -4.81 -12.98 -57.25 -52.11 67

20020619 8.08 3.74 0.178 74.59 9.37 96.43 6.02 65.83 -4.34 -47.64 -84.29 -53.69 65
20020620 9.36 3.88 0.239 73.98 10.46 103.04 6.92 73.98 -5.48 -38.91 -82.24 -58.57 67

20020621 8.22 3.94 0.229 77.36 9.81 101.67 6.36 83.67 -4.28 -25.85 -76.45 -52.03 67

20020622 3.58 2.48 0.202 80.64 4.76 90.87 2.88 81.13 -1.1 -10.6 -55.07 -30.81 65

20020623 2.3 1.97 0.01 104.48 4.42 95.56 2.41 179.54 -0.33 102.95 -25.08 -14.52 62

20020624 4.56 3.35 0.023 94.99 7.46 93.29 4.33 122.85 -1.2 34.86 -46.01 -26.4 64

20020625 6.66 4.03 0.051 86.77 8.94 88.4 5.77 82.99 -2.63 1.2 -43.34 -39.45 65

20020626 5.04 3.06 0.654 52.98 4.16 79.31 2.67 67.11 -1.98 -17.1 -52.49 -39.25 60

20020627 3.33 2.21 0.23 76.44 3.91 90.3 2.55 82.69 -1.12 -7.89 -53.04 -33.77 61

20020628 3.93 4.28 0.336 98.47 8.15 84.33 3.87 120.39 0.35 45.85 -31.25 8.96 65

20020629 4.37 3.49 0.029 107.88 8.99 101.74 4.72 110.1 -0.88 18.29 -47.8 -20.16 62

20020630 5.42 3.48 0.066 95.01 10.03 99.81 5.15 104.34 -1.94 9.75 -54.44 -35.86 63

20020701 3.52 3.49 0.204 90.56 5.74 84.78 3.18 155.85 -0.03 95.28 -8.74 -0.74 66

20020702 4.19 4.15 0.16 101.48 8.4 87.45 4.25 138.14 -0.04 68.82 -22.22 -0.91 67

20020703 3.02 3.04 0.181 108.06 6.39 94.26 3.27 128.47 0.02 47.67 -34.29 0.56 66

20020704 1.67 1.22 0.004 101.79 3.16 100.99 1.7 174.7 -0.45 92.18 -32.1 -27.04 67

20020705 2.36 2.53 0.124 99.38 4.53 82.7 2.34 103.09 0.18 37.81 -19.27 7.46 60

20020706

20020707

20020708

20020709

20020710 2.79 2.42 0.072 94.01 5.13 82.19 2.62 99.95 -0.37 23.83 -36.51 -13.19 65

20020711 5.09 3.69 0.053 84.73 7.73 84.9 4.31 99.37 -1.39 24.5 -32.58 -27.38 69

20020712 8.04 4.92 0.093 73.95 10.09 83.3 5.95 94.53 -3.12 18.33 -35 -38.8 69

20020713 2.96 2.49 0.038 97.48 5.52 81.71 2.88 127.79 -0.47 60.29 -25.12 -15.89 68

20020714 2.24 2.11 0.002 105.99 5.01 80.85 2.37 127.7 -0.13 56.73 -28.02 -5.77 66

20020715 5.09 3.71 0.223 72.29 6.42 76.31 3.68 91.61 -1.38 17.49 -37.82 -27.11 64

20020716 4.71 3.24 0.084 80.83 6.66 87.65 3.81 99.38 -1.47 19.66 -39.18 -31.29 67

20020717 7.33 5.33 0.274 73.4 9.1 86.25 5.38 107.57 -2.01 30.28 -33.1 -27.37 67

20020718 3.79 2.28 0.349 58.89 4.1 73.85 2.23 88.26 -1.51 22.29 -28.17 -39.74 66

20020719 3.86 2.56 0.062 85.03 6.13 87.8 3.28 110.67 -1.31 25.66 -47.35 -33.82 63

20020720 2.54 1.89 0.004 104.54 5.4 99.7 2.65 135.43 -0.64 46.81 -42.98 -25.34 66

20020721 2.18 1.13 0.055 76.72 2.74 84.51 1.67 99.94 -1.05 21.66 -41.08 -48.3 65

20020722 3.5 2.93 0.184 89.14 5.61 79.99 3.12 94.66 -0.58 25.63 -28.38 -16.43 66

20020723 2.84 3.11 0.094 117.12 7.7 85.67 3.32 144.99 0.27 77.74 -18.72 9.61 63

20020724 4.52 2.22 0.187 68.3 5.36 90.22 3.09 88.09 -2.3 -4.81 -55.81 -50.83 66

20020725 5.51 3.58 0.166 74.82 7.25 84.19 4.12 82.45 -1.93 2.16 -42.84 -34.97 67

20020726 5.47 4.27 0.106 88.04 8.99 87.95 4.82 89.36 -1.2 4.55 -48.57 -21.99 68
20020727 4.44

4 0.407 83.82 7.1 86.31 3.73 111.67 -0.44 37.03 -30.99 -9.99 65

20020728 3.37 1.91 0.313 72.69 3.86 94.84 2.45 87.74 -1.46 -12.59 -64.5 -43.34 63

20020729 4.41 2.93 0.319 65.75 4.84 83.31 2.9 106.71 -1.48 28.8 -38.07 -33.64 66

20020730 4.97 2.59 0.124 75.34 6.09 90.83 3.75 109.59 -2.38 23.93 -44.93 -47.87 66

20020731 4.47 3.74 0.125 95.96 8.67 93.67 4.29 136.58 -0.73 56.49 -32.07 -16.39 66

20020801 5.3 3.79 0.111 79.84 7.03 88.43 4.23 121.39 -1.51 45.86 -28.23 -28.46 66

20020802 5.05 4.38 0.174 94.05 9.05 87.27 4.75 98.09 -0.67 20.82 -38.22 -13.3 63

20020803 3.27 1.67 0.116 79.74 4.26 90.87 2.61 83.43 -1.6 -16.03 -67.51 -48.95 64

20020804 4.52 1.79 0.198 75.33 5.58 105.62 3.4 125.17 -2.73 16.87 -72.55 -60.34 63

20020805 3.5 3.99 0.201 108.77 8.03 89.45 3.81 173.63 0.5 106.56 -16.16 14.16 62

20020806 3.27 3.31 0.147 95.56 6.1 87.51 3.13 111.6 0.04 39.8 -25.34 1.17 65

20020807 5.22 6.23 0.183 93.46 9.17 84.65 4.88 135.39 1.01 77.14 -4.26 19.38 69

20020808 7.32 6.38 0.096 83.06 10.93 84.14 6.08 108.89 -0.94 43.56 -17.51 -12.86 71

20020809 7.01 5.47 0.083 80.75 9.14 85.28 5.66 125.92 -1.54 57.39 -21.16 -21.96 71

20020810 3.79 2.8 0.029 91.02 5.66 85.6 3.45 117 -0.99 47.83 -22.56 -26.22 65

20020811 1.97 2.1 0.029 113.67 4.81 87.16 2.24 153.1 0.13 86.01 -18.46 6.53 60

20020812 4.86 3.59 0.268 74.61 6.59 80.65 3.63 131.9 -1.27 64.14 -24.9 -26.08 65

20020813 5.4 3.28 0.129 75.79 6.75 89.52 4.09 106.71 -2.12 24.73 -41.71 -39.25 68

20020814 3.88 2.37 0.208 74.17 5.19 87.6 2.88 135.98 -1.51 63.18 -26.89 -38.8 64

20020815 3.26 2.93 0.205 87.33 5.25 85.44 2.85 135.51 -0.33 75.02 -10.18 -10.22 67

20020816 4.71 3.24 0.743 53.84 3.83 82.17 2.54 124.06 -1.47 47.42 -38.57 -31.19 66

20020817 2.66 2.71 0.141 100.87 5.33 84.71 2.69 102.01 0.05 27.61 -32.4 1.82 64

20020818 2.47 2.68 0.482 94.53 4.48 91.58 2.33 128.46 0.21 58.88 -20.13 8.67 64

20020819 3.67 3.52 0.11 99.92 7.55 86.53 3.67 140.72 -0.15 71.99 -20.7 -4.06 68

20020820 4.17 2.91 0.114 88.97 6.6 97.27 3.71 158.46 -1.26 73.98 -39.53 -30.27 69

20020821 5.26 3.55 0.113 78.98 7.07 85.22 4.16 91.98 -1.71 14.32 -38.6 -32.55 66

20020822 5.4 3.72 0.042 90.28 8.95 85.66 4.87 98.2 -1.67 24.13 -32.31 -30.99 69

20020823 3.69 2.75 0.067 97.91 6.95 94.71 3.61 117.43 -0.93 37.16 -36.66 -25.33 68

20020824 4.38 4.22 0.378 82.93 7.14 85.85 3.63 124.83 -0.15 47.97 -33.69 -3.5 65

20020825 3.23 2.65 0.253 90.67 6.03 94.51 2.93 103 -0.58 11.1 -51.66 -17.89 65

20020826 10.47 6.22 0.305 65.96 10.42 85.37 6.91 74.2 -4.25 -15.48 -55.11 -40.56 68

20020827 9.68 5.26 0.297 68.57 10.21 91.1 6.64 75.36 -4.42 -22.46 -63.97 -45.65 70

20020828 4.83 3.68 0.206 74.78 6.3 82.33 3.61 130.95 -1.15 71.21 -11.82 -23.89 68

20020829 6.7 7.18 0.13 93.37 10.18 82.57 6.25 143.74 0.48 89.2 -3.66 7.21 69

20020830 10.73 6.85 0.29 68.88 11.08 90.2 7.39 78.13 -3.88 -18.26 -62.69 -36.19 70

20020831 9.13 3.96 0.212 71.53 10.31 101.08 6.53 84.91 -5.17 -19.85 -70.82 -56.61 67

20020901 3.09 3.41 0.069 98.81 5.87 86.35 3.06 135.21 0.32 77.61 -4.66 10.44 67
20020902 3.8 2.3 0.04 87.36 6.13 92.62 3.32 138.03 -1.5 60.47 -30.09 -39.53 65

20020903 10.27 5.76 0.222 73.56 12.63 93.7 7.56 87.18 -4.51 -10.95 -64.06 -43.94 62

20020904 7.23 4.09 0.398 67.24 7.81 90.37 4.86 72.87 -3.14 -27.61 -69.08 -43.47 67

20020905 6.13 4.48 0.113 91.09 9.53 93.18 5.58 90.98 -1.64 4.19 -49.06 -26.8 67

20020906 10 6.72 0.237 76.98 12.4 89.09 7.7 82.93 -3.28 -6.67 -54.07 -32.76 66

20020907 15.04 5.98 0.446 66.79 15.62 106.86 10.05 80.28 -9.06 -35.97 -87.89 -60.22 65

20020908 7.09 4.51 0.065 99.79 12.22 103.19 7.07 107.59 -2.58 6.29 -62.1 -36.34 65

20020909 17.06 6.4 0.498 65.99 17.63 101.49 11.26 75.37 -10.67 -36.32 -81.39 -62.51 64

20020910 15.26 7.23 0.531 59.41 14.58 90.04 9.06 72.38 -8.03 -24.81 -67.5 -52.61 66

20020911 5.02 3.55 0.508 66.68 5.83 84.15 3.35 67.91 -1.47 -22.15 -57.98 -29.25 66

20020912 8.55 5.74 0.241 78.5 10.69 96.49 6.71 88.47 -2.81 -8.02 -58.38 -32.87 63

20020913 14.4 6.87 0.377 68.33 15.32 90.91 9.84 72.2 -7.53 -20.58 -59.48 -52.29 65

20020914 4.12 2.86 0.118 89.62 6.1 93.87 3.7 104.28 -1.26 20.78 -40.09 -30.64 64

200209153 2.91 0.266 101.8 5.75 97.97 3.05 196.37 -0.09 112.68 -36.6 -3.03 59

20020916 5.57 5.86 0.225 92.99 10.33 84.37 5.18 119.16 0.29 53.16 -19.3 5.21 65

20020917 10.17 6.07 0.194 88.61 15.3 105.53 9.01 74.54 -4.1 -40.55 -86.18 -40.3 64

20020918 12.65 6.24 0.039 89.99 17.18 110.34 11.39 116.66 -6.41 0.27 -82.56 -50.68 67

20020919 11.56 5.83 0.223 77.44 15.49 99.13 8.95 88.61 -5.73 -10.2 -63.65 -49.59 66

20020920 6.18 4.84 0.166 90.8 10 87.48 5.61 104.97 -1.34 30.98 -31.03 -21.66 69

20020921 3.44 3.92 0.069 127.2 9.36 91.23 4.37 168.56 0.48 99.5 -18.44 13.85 65

20020922 2.89 2.81 0.035 121.06 6.95 98.45 3.5 160.28 -0.08 81.03 -29.28 -2.68 65

20020923 4.56 3.64 0.112 103.02 9.28 103.6 4.69 101.03 -0.92 -4.43 -68.28 -20.12 64

20020924 10.62 4.43 0.08 88.04 14.21 122.19 9.35 80.72 -6.2 -54.97 -109.02 -58.31 62

20020925 12.32 5.32 0.032 84.9 16.08 110.81 10.46 81.19 -6.99 -41.58 -93.74 -56.77 63

20020926 9.29 5.69 0.183 68.17 11.02 86.66 6.33 67.79 -3.6 -23.57 -60.71 -38.73 61

20020927 11.39 7.36 0.265 71.36 12.29 95.92 8.13 101.79 -4.04 6.33 -56.39 -35.42 60

20020928 3.47 2.28 0.148 90.91 5.38 102.36 3.15 113.25 -1.18 11.84 -61.32 -34.13 62

20020929 6.02 4.38 0.063 95.11 10.42 100.03 5.73 99.33 -1.64 4.19 -57.39 -27.3 66

20020930 16.08 7.38 0.189 81.64 19.79 106.97 13.13 92.25 -8.7 -18.15 -82.01 -54.1 62
obs avg, ppb CMAQ avg, ppb R^2 NME, % RMSE, ppb FE, % MAGE, ppb MNGE, % MB, ppb MNB, % MFB, % NMB, %

0900190031 9.42 1.09 0.364 89.68 13.17 129.44 8.45 93.01 -8.33 -46.51 -114.03 -88.4

0900310031 4.31 1.78 0.32 71.71 5.23 80.96 3.09 116.86 -2.53 46.58 -26.3 -58.69

0900911231 12.35 1.33 0.298 89.19 13.13 154.62 11.01 86.7 -11.01 -86.7 -154.62 -89.19

0900990051 2.27 1.3 0.134 62.71 2.2 72.98 1.43 104.88 -0.97 38.53 -23.78 -42.72

1000310071 0.99 0.83 0.045 73.59 0.89 80.04 0.73 76.99 -0.16 -7.23 -43.49 -16.2

1000320041 7.78 2.74 0.415 65.67 7.06 86.06 5.11 58.32 -5.04 -53.55 -82.72 -64.75

1100100251 6.44 2.64 0.147 62.3 7.78 63.85 4.01 46.23 -3.8 -36.11 -56.22 -59.02

1100100411 15 5.55 0.146 65.43 17.23 68.59 9.81 47.07 -9.45 -41.54 -64.07 -62.98

1100100431 5.79 5.57 0.093 66.39 6.57 59.16 3.85 90.83 -0.22 65.62 23.3 -3.85

2300500271 11.24 0.82 0.572 92.75 12.06 169.28 10.43 91.5 -10.43 -91.5 -169.28 -92.75

2300520032 0.39 0.77 0.192 115 0.53 85.22 0.45 221.71 0.38 216 78.13 95.56

2300901021 0.27 0.13 0.011 54.31 0.19 78.26 0.15 52.86 -0.14 -51.59 -77.08 -53.15

2303130021 2.82 1.17 0.158 80.42 4.04 91.93 2.26 204.75 -1.65 145.86 -1.54 -58.55

2400300193 2.42 1.61 0.146 69.21 2.95 74.81 1.68 137.77 -0.81 91.88 6.04 -33.41

2400530012 5.11 1.4 0.402 74.86 7.03 90.19 3.83 66.21 -3.71 -39.19 -77.05 -72.54

2402590011 1.08 0.78 0.237 44.78 0.77 47.71 0.48 44.1 -0.3 -10.58 -26.24 -27.68

2451000402 14.85 4.07 0.295 73.1 13.76 104.62 10.86 66.78 -10.79 -63.99 -102.61 -72.62

2500100022 0.39 0.53 0.435 57.8 0.32 47.46 0.23 64.05 0.14 42.83 19.39 35.66

2500510021 1.53 0.71 0.094 67.67 1.67 87.33 1.03 127.59 -0.82 52.2 -28.06 -53.4

2500900051 5.12 1.28 0.096 75.06 4.95 110.93 3.84 69.6 -3.84 -69.36 -110.71 -74.92

2500920061 2.46 1.6 0.004 72.88 2.03 94.85 1.79 192.26 -0.86 119.71 -13.89 -35.12

2500940041 1.72 0.47 0.043 72.91 1.37 118.53 1.25 72.19 -1.25 -72.1 -118.44 -72.84

2500940042 0.61 0.45 0.144 50.99 0.43 64.98 0.31 49.59 -0.16 -18.86 -42.56 -26.09

2501300081 5.72 1.15 0.214 79.81 4.94 131.61 4.57 78.56 -4.57 -78.56 -131.61 -79.81

2501300161 10.84 1.1 0.417 89.82 12.28 154.33 9.74 86.58 -9.74 -86.58 -154.33 -89.82

2501540021 0.97 0.47 0.204 53.22 0.56 77.37 0.52 53.47 -0.5 -51.74 -75.94 -51.55

2501540022 0.92 0.48 0.005 60.45 0.77 67.31 0.56 53.19 -0.44 -24.06 -48.61 -47.76

2502130031 1.56 2.07 0.048 82.7 1.78 65.91 1.29 122.68 0.52 91.43 22.63 33.29

2502500021 22.64 5.23 0.148 77.04 20.63 121.73 17.44 74.25 -17.41 -73.97 -121.47 -76.88

2502500211 5.3 2.94 0.147 52 4.19 57.71 2.75 45.53 -2.36 -26.95 -44.85 -44.5

2502500401 6.08 5.3 0.197 43.13 4.25 39.23 2.62 42.9 -0.78 6.7 -7.27 -12.78

2502500411 3.27 2.09 0.138 74.7 3.38 91.9 2.44 131.76 -1.18 65.77 -12.46 -36.03

2502500421 13.53 5.44 0.101 62.32 10.81 83.36 8.43 56.85 -8.09 -51.4 -79.09 -59.78

2502700201 9.05 1.16 0.237 87.23 9.6 147.54 7.89 83.8 -7.89 -83.8 -147.54 -87.23

3301500131 0.96 0.37 0.208 82.81 1.53 93.91 0.79 158.84 -0.59 91.21 -13.75 -61.95

3400300051 10.68 7.09 0.365 51.4 7.72 59.69 5.49 51.07 -3.59 -17.36 -38.15 -33.59
3400700032 5.23 4.02 0.233 56.72 5.18 51.66 2.97 58.27 -1.21 12.35 -9.5 -23.18

3401300161 13.44 10.08 0.299 47.56 10.47 47.49 6.39 49.29 -3.36 5.16 -12.84 -25

3402100051 5.71 1.46 0.274 76.09 7.52 89.26 4.35 58.69 -4.26 -54.56 -86.29 -74.52

3402300111 4.45 2.27 0.166 58.59 5.32 57.72 2.61 44.28 -2.18 -31.37 -50.19 -48.9

3402730011 2.37 0.69 0.075 75.99 2.26 114.89 1.8 72.1 -1.69 -64.2 -109.31 -71.06

3600500831 8.07 18.2 0.331 131.8 13.47 86.37 10.63 256.19 10.13 253.04 82.36 125.57

3600501101 11.85 37.22 0.315 214.28 27.99 113.27 25.38 389.68 25.38 389.67 113.26 214.24

3602900021 4.25 2.52 0.19 73.95 7.39 74.62 3.14 154.59 -1.73 123.81 28.51 -40.81

3602900051 10.37 1.9 0.361 81.97 12.02 119.92 8.5 72.72 -8.47 -70.7 -118.23 -81.67

3605900052 10.4 4.94 0.33 59.6 11.14 68.02 6.2 59.06 -5.46 -20.31 -46.64 -52.51

3606100561 19.3 38.08 0.303 99.94 22.28 73.2 19.29 170.27 18.78 168.74 71.51 97.34

3608100981 14.78 36.27 0.446 147.82 23.98 96.1 21.84 247.02 21.49 246.54 95.58 145.47

3608101241 9.17 10.23 0.156 70.64 9.98 66.46 6.48 119.78 1.06 96.66 34.03 11.55

3610300092 6.76 1.96 0.232 71.73 7.71 94.83 4.85 63.35 -4.8 -57.19 -91.85 -70.97

4200300081 9.42 3.48 0.348 65.91 8.66 84.84 6.21 71.71 -5.95 -30.08 -70.47 -63.13

4200310051 4.99 0.76 0.466 84.81 4.86 145.49 4.23 83.88 -4.23 -83.88 -145.49 -84.81

4210100041 5.57 4.16 0.43 50.14 4.99 47.34 2.79 51.12 -1.41 12.47 -5.1 -25.34

4400300021 0.27 0.34 0.134 75.29 0.3 65.52 0.2 119.95 0.07 94.87 32.02 24.39

4400700121 4.44 1.95 0.145 58.51 3.91 70.89 2.6 49.58 -2.49 -45.68 -67.67 -56.11

4400710101 1.51 2.01 0.166 98.85 2.2 90.67 1.49 277.82 0.5 259.79 65.5 33.14

5000700131 5.55 0.59 0.217 89.38 5.05 162.7 4.96 89.51 -4.96 -89.51 -162.7 -89.38

5002100021 6.19 0.3 0.495 95.21 5.97 181.68 5.89 95.19 -5.89 -95.19 -181.68 -95.21

5101300201 5.8 4.08 0.252 48.74 5.09 45.55 2.82 41.58 -1.72 -4.63 -18.77 -29.66

5103300011 0.44 0.75 0.135 115.1 0.82 88 0.5 237.65 0.31 227.13 73.81 71.78

5103600021 4.19 0.58 0.282 86.27 4.8 147.47 3.62 86.2 -3.61 -80.8 -145.37 -86.16

5105900051 1.16 3.41 0.348 203.45 2.8 119.23 2.37 556.46 2.25 553.43 115.69 192.9

5105910051 3.14 2.98 0.295 55.63 2.77 63.18 1.75 120.47 -0.16 91.67 24.1 -5

5105950011 5.98 2.31 0.269 63.4 5.69 74.25 3.79 51.98 -3.67 -40.67 -65.27 -61.4

5110710051 2.91 0.51 0.249 82.6 2.7 143.39 2.4 82.71 -2.4 -82.71 -143.39 -82.6

5115300091 2.17 0.21 0.409 90.33 2.38 156 1.96 86.14 -1.96 -86.14 -156 -90.33

5116110041 4.7 1.36 0.094 71.08 4.18 103.83 3.34 66.59 -3.34 -66.59 -103.83 -71.08

5151000091 8.07 2.37 0.298 73.29 9.44 97.32 5.91 96.81 -5.7 -10.4 -71.72 -70.64

5171000231 5.45 1.81 0.146 69.98 5.8 90.48 3.82 70.2 -3.64 -34.55 -72.5 -66.81

5176000241 4.54 1.73 0.245 70.02 4.58 97.32 3.18 183.18 -2.81 87.34 -49.16 -61.89

airmap_cs1 0.1 0.08 0.008 58.15 0.09 59.21 0.06 88.18 -0.02 43.66 -2.6 -19.46

airmap_mw1 0.11 0.04 0.041 75.58 0.15 82.16 0.08 95.41 -0.08 15.53 -46.4 -67.16

airmap_tf1 0.25 0.35 0.265 73.04 0.26 71.27 0.18 153.29 0.1 142.69 56.16 38.48
harvard_f1 0.13 0.34 0.315 160.25 0.25 96.23 0.21 273 0.21 272.65 95.86 159.35

pinnacle01 0.13 0.1 0.187 40.03 0.09 38.91 0.05 34.24 -0.03 -10.83 -20.77 -20.45
N

110

131

129

133

40

135

135

135

135

107

135

130

102

126

133

134

135

127

117

135

112

106

88

135

131

135

117

133

135

109

135

130

96

134

85

132
134

130

135

135

129

124

98

121

134

134

126

130

135

130

120

133

134

49

135

76

132

18

135

115

117

107

132

35

132

61

133

126

126

104

130

101

116
82

133
obs avg, ppb CMAQ avg, ppb R^2 NME, % RMSE, ppb FE, % MAGE, ppb MNGE, % MB, ppb MNB, % MFB, % NMB, % N

20020515 14.03 11.81 0.498 35.19 6.5 43.27 4.94 52.23 -2.22 10.9 -11.08 -15.82 94

20020516 20.8 18.1 0.516 32.06 8.78 40.04 6.67 42.42 -2.7 4.43 -9.71 -12.97 93

20020517 14.93 16.69 0.589 34.51 7.15 36.58 5.15 46.9 1.76 27.61 11.86 11.79 94

20020518 8.49 10.7 0.487 47.74 5.35 49.85 4.05 105.47 2.21 90.37 30.97 26.09 93

20020519 8.98 10.9 0.43 45.85 5.57 49.4 4.12 102.31 1.92 83.11 24.88 21.37 93

20020520 13.88 14.74 0.444 36.63 6.82 40.91 5.08 62.3 0.86 36.23 7.26 6.22 92

20020521 14.08 13.29 0.473 33.64 6.04 40 4.74 54.67 -0.78 21.38 -2.74 -5.56 91

20020522 17.11 15.88 0.585 27.7 6.09 36.48 4.74 50.97 -1.23 18.39 -5.31 -7.17 92

20020523 21.99 18.26 0.558 29.62 8.71 37.69 6.51 35.76 -3.73 -7.6 -18.83 -16.98 92

20020524 19.98 17.51 0.522 31.54 8.36 37.81 6.3 36.32 -2.47 -2.38 -13.07 -12.37 93

20020525 9.08 10.84 0.351 50.89 6.41 49.11 4.62 76.38 1.75 51.9 17.2 19.31 93

20020526 10.65 14.27 0.582 49.2 8.65 43.52 5.24 93.93 3.62 77.72 22.64 34.03 93

20020527 13.7 15.48 0.56 37.1 7.52 37.25 5.08 45.44 1.78 21.55 5.81 12.98 91

20020528 17.19 16.65 0.509 33.4 7.55 39.11 5.74 55.28 -0.54 21.88 -3.76 -3.12 91

20020529 15.37 15.39 0.469 34.64 7.23 37.36 5.32 41.92 0.02 12.08 -0.54 0.13 91

20020530 14.32 14.83 0.446 33.58 6.71 36.03 4.81 47.01 0.51 22.71 4.73 3.55 91

20020531 13.72 14.39 0.383 39.87 7.63 43.03 5.47 54.2 0.66 27.84 7.47 4.84 92

20020601 13.94 13.39 0.527 37.96 7.22 42.31 5.29 55.84 -0.55 20.65 -3.77 -3.94 91

20020602 10.28 11.26 0.507 39.69 5.78 42.46 4.08 80.57 0.97 57.04 12.86 9.48 93

20020603 12.57 14.49 0.451 39.6 6.98 38.81 4.98 55.26 1.93 37.16 16.07 15.33 94

20020604 15.12 15.63 0.348 37.51 7.72 39.98 5.67 66.86 0.51 40.77 5.86 3.39 93

20020605 15.42 14.27 0.402 39.75 8.73 43.4 6.13 62.46 -1.15 25.58 -5.8 -7.44 89

20020606 14.86 15.58 0.535 32.79 6.92 36.56 4.87 46.13 0.72 23.05 7.7 4.85 92

20020607 12.09 12.2 0.348 40.46 6.87 44.89 4.89 76.03 0.11 45.3 3.27 0.9 95

20020608 13.08 13.92 0.455 38.66 7.09 41.56 5.06 51 0.83 24.26 5.21 6.37 94

20020609 13.95 14.14 0.49 37.22 7.5 40.22 5.19 47.27 0.19 18.5 2.51 1.38 94

20020610 17.11 16.08 0.466 34.1 8.14 39.51 5.83 46.98 -1.03 13.8 -3.52 -6 95

20020611 18.38 17.05 0.472 38.5 9.91 42.82 7.08 45.9 -1.33 7.08 -8.76 -7.22 96

20020612 15.72 16.26 0.573 38.7 8.47 46.07 6.08 63.75 0.54 31.48 1.97 3.44 91

20020613 14.41 16.16 0.45 42.23 8.27 42.12 6.09 49.92 1.74 21.46 5.37 12.11 90

20020614 13.99 17.2 0.469 44.34 8.43 41.44 6.2 53.64 3.21 33.91 16.62 22.94 93

20020615 10.85 13.2 0.543 46.75 7.31 50.09 5.07 107.49 2.35 84.72 18.11 21.62 91

20020616 11.11 13.03 0.595 41.38 6.38 45.37 4.59 76.9 1.92 55.86 17.25 17.31 92

20020617 15.06 15.32 0.534 33.58 7.15 37.46 5.06 43.37 0.26 15.67 1.45 1.7 95

20020618 16.62 16.21 0.614 26.38 6.52 31.63 4.38 37.4 -0.41 11.08 -1.98 -2.47 94

20020619 19.62 17.28 0.69 26.47 7.68 34.62 5.19 36.18 -2.33 -0.56 -13.66 -11.89 92
20020620 18.6 16.68 0.592 34.33 8.68 40.73 6.39 41.04 -1.93 -0.28 -12.46 -10.36 94

20020621 18.96 16.83 0.598 32.77 8.54 40.21 6.22 40.02 -2.14 -2.78 -16.06 -11.26 95

20020622 15.68 15.37 0.601 34.3 7.58 37.44 5.38 37.42 -0.31 4.88 -6 -1.96 94

20020623 12.47 13.99 0.508 44.09 8.28 46.03 5.5 67.78 1.52 40.86 8.78 12.19 93

20020624 16.26 16.28 0.592 34.79 8.08 38.87 5.66 43.1 0.02 10.41 -4.05 0.11 93

20020625 19.85 19.37 0.574 34.29 9.2 38.68 6.81 40.2 -0.48 5.51 -6.33 -2.41 92

20020626 19.64 16.43 0.6 35.58 9.63 44.73 6.99 43.49 -3.21 -3.12 -17.94 -16.33 92

20020627 13.55 13.56 0.487 40.18 7.86 42.89 5.45 55.2 0.01 21.02 -2.56 0.08 92

20020628 13.29 14.77 0.495 42.85 7.93 44.41 5.7 61.36 1.48 33.31 7.06 11.13 90

20020629 12.44 13.39 0.545 37.75 6.33 43.25 4.7 72.73 0.95 45.54 9.08 7.61 91

20020630 14.19 14.38 0.558 35.51 7.04 41.27 5.04 53.34 0.19 24.35 4.14 1.31 91

20020701 16.4 17.45 0.471 40.03 9.07 42.34 6.57 52.94 1.05 24.95 6.29 6.4 92

20020702 18.43 18.7 0.513 43.86 11.27 47.3 8.08 56.76 0.27 19.05 -3.34 1.49 93

20020703 16.74 17.09 0.545 40.5 9.76 44.84 6.78 54.2 0.35 17.98 -3 2.11 90

20020704 11.01 12.8 0.447 45.64 7.47 43.18 5.02 58.72 1.8 31.85 8.94 16.32 89

20020705 8.41 11.26 0.408 53.48 6.32 50.46 4.5 105.94 2.86 89.41 29.26 33.97 90

20020706

20020707

20020708

20020709

20020710 9.99 11.85 0.481 46.41 6.19 46.22 4.64 69.44 1.86 45.07 14.68 18.64 91

20020711 11.95 11.58 0.479 33.52 5.09 40.514 56.25 -0.37 23.55 -1.03 -3.09 92

20020712 17.2 15.73 0.525 30.32 7.1 36.55 5.22 41.57 -1.47 5.59 -9.16 -8.54 93

20020713 14.48 15.19 0.463 35.31 7.13 39.29 5.11 60.24 0.71 34.22 5.72 4.91 93

20020714 11.87 15.13 0.58 45.37 7.98 41.02 5.38 65.93 3.26 49.7 20.53 27.49 91

20020715 15.26 16.24 0.536 35.78 7.6 38.38 5.46 54.47 0.98 27.54 3.84 6.41 91

20020716 15.21 13.6 0.401 34.94 7.17 38.2 5.31 39.5 -1.6 2.12 -9.91 -10.54 89

20020717 18.01 17.44 0.616 31.6 7.49 36.24 5.69 38.38 -0.57 4.73 -6.73 -3.18 90

20020718 18.41 17.69 0.527 36.86 8.99 43.85 6.79 62.29 -0.72 25.59 -4.65 -3.93 93

20020719 16.68 16.44 0.537 35.56 8.86 42.32 5.93 50.8 -0.25 16.61 -3.26 -1.47 95

20020720 10.4 12.28 0.341 50.15 7.33 49.37 5.21 78.85 1.89 50.15 12.14 18.16 95

20020721 9.12 11.2 0.243 52.68 7.29 46.28 4.81 71.03 2.07 48.04 16.62 22.72 93

20020722 12.94 14.6 0.384 43.43 8.12 44.22 5.62 83.95 1.66 60.64 14.11 12.84 94

20020723 13.65 15.47 0.5 40.03 7.79 39.53 5.47 57.03 1.82 34.57 10.85 13.31 93

20020724 11.4 14.11 0.446 45.85 7.53 42.86 5.23 54.87 2.7 31.19 11.76 23.7 91

20020725 11.7 12.72 0.336 40.21 6.41 42.21 4.7 59.08 1.02 33.23 7.35 8.75 92

20020726 12.07 15.51 0.469 47.71 7.52 46.58 5.76 97.67 3.44 80.24 24.75 28.52 90
20020727 12.33 16.23 0.598 47.25 7.99 45.21 5.83 74.85 3.9 58.6 24.7 31.65 90

20020728 11.87 15.16 0.564 49.51 9.26 45.5 5.88 76.31 3.29 56.3 20.04 27.73 90

20020729 13.72 16.48 0.576 43.07 8.36 42.95 5.91 72.55 2.76 51.56 15.55 20.13 91

20020730 13.76 15.12 0.531 36.14 7.07 38.7 4.97 69.26 1.37 45.78 8.75 9.92 92

20020731 16.56 16.24 0.478 36.17 8.2 40.27 5.99 46.64 -0.31 9.93 -6.76 -1.9 91

20020801 19.3 17.93 0.634 29.19 7.78 37.29 5.63 54.77 -1.37 20.65 -6.26 -7.09 91

20020802 19.18 18.51 0.56 32.96 9.24 38.14 6.32 56.41 -0.67 26.04 -1.46 -3.5 89

20020803 15.25 15.59 0.644 30.72 6.82 34.3 4.68 41.27 0.34 13.31 -1.18 2.25 89

20020804 14.31 14.05 0.661 29.97 5.8 36.74 4.29 52.27 -0.26 21.59 -2.71 -1.79 89

20020805 15.63 17.87 0.554 41.9 8.96 43.13 6.55 56.62 2.24 31.64 10.42 14.35 89

20020806 8.29 9.53 0.439 44.46 4.94 46.41 3.69 86.02 1.24 59.64 12.91 14.94 91

20020807 11.57 11.62 0.493 32.74 4.85 38.8 3.79 53.7 0.05 26.92 4.98 0.42 93

20020808 14.42 14.26 0.461 32.75 5.97 38.54 4.72 51.94 -0.16 21.53 0.08 -1.1 93

20020809 16.51 16.95 0.495 33.57 7.38 36.78 5.54 44.88 0.44 16.05 0.24 2.69 92

20020810 15.24 15.13 0.506 37.17 7.46 40.75 5.67 44.33 -0.12 8.39 -5.88 -0.76 93

20020811 12.81 14.15 0.504 41.37 7.45 42.03 5.3 57.39 1.34 30.68 6.76 10.47 92

20020812 21.28 19.31 0.63 31.26 8.85 39.73 6.65 44.06 -1.97 4.72 -12.35 -9.24 94

20020813 22.61 19.78 0.599 31.33 9.42 39.27 7.08 39.05 -2.82 -2.35 -14.77 -12.5 94

20020814 19.07 16.43 0.506 31.04 8.89 36.14 5.92 35.24 -2.64 -2.45 -14.05 -13.86 93

20020815 13.16 15.43 0.288 47.74 8.39 44.41 6.28 76.3 2.27 53 13.7 17.25 93

20020816 15.78 17.31 0.555 41.35 8.49 42.59 6.52 50.71 1.53 22.29 5.09 9.68 93

20020817 13.68 16.62 0.591 44.56 8.66 43.02 6.09 56.15 2.94 34.35 14.07 21.49 92

20020818 12.34 16.08 0.714 48.46 8.46 42.7 5.98 61.32 3.74 42.07 18.42 30.27 92

20020819 15.73 18.46 0.499 41.48 9.43 39.14 6.53 50.68 2.72 28.75 11.4 17.32 92

20020820 14.66 17.45 0.542 41.78 8.59 39.11 6.12 48.54 2.79 25.42 9.72 19.02 92

20020821 15.8 16.12 0.508 33.86 6.94 37.85 5.35 42.17 0.32 10.72 -2.72 2.05 92

20020822 15.71 17.77 0.457 40.18 8.61 39.85 6.31 48.71 2.05 24.96 8.55 13.07 92

20020823 13.2 17.37 0.551 49.19 8.63 44.28 6.49 62.81 4.17 45.41 22.73 31.56 92

20020824 11.29 16.59 0.598 61.22 10.17 48.8 6.91 71.94 5.3 56.9 28.29 46.89 90

20020825 10.21 14.43 0.638 57.07 8.19 46.98 5.83 78.63 4.22 61.67 25.32 41.36 90

20020826 19.07 21.18 0.684 30.97 7.69 33.51 5.91 37.92 2.11 15.26 5.19 11.07 92

20020827 18.34 19.56 0.524 34.91 8.66 35.11 6.4 41.99 1.22 18.4 6.1 6.65 93

20020828 12.16 15.76 0.392 47.01 8.6 42.43 5.72 62.71 3.6 46.06 21.12 29.57 92

20020829 11.07 15.68 0.454 52.19 7.29 45.83 5.78 69.12 4.61 57.94 30.63 41.61 92

20020830 12.71 17.33 0.443 52.57 8.5 45.44 6.68 72.17 4.62 55.43 23.76 36.35 92

20020831 10.33 14.67 0.52 54.07 7.28 47.65 5.59 80.22 4.34 68.36 32.44 42.02 91

20020901 8.05 13.24 0.348 73.21 7.84 57.09 5.89 104.36 5.2 96.5 46.5 64.58 91
20020902 7.88 14.32 0.401 89.18 9.07 66.19 7.03 140.92 6.44 133.53 55.64 81.77 91

20020903 15.63 18.89 0.649 38.79 8.58 39.86 6.06 54.18 3.26 34.91 13.96 20.84 91

20020904 16.17 18.59 0.623 34.49 8.32 33.56 5.58 41.18 2.42 22.04 8.82 14.95 91

20020905 13.73 15.55 0.446 39.92 7.17 41.13 5.48 54.58 1.83 31.51 11.55 13.3 90

20020906 19.01 19.67 0.539 30.66 7.87 31.88 5.83 33.47 0.66 5.65 -2.99 3.49 91

20020907 20.96 20.8 0.647 34.06 9.58 37.66 7.14 37.8 -0.15 0.22 -10.32 -0.73 90

20020908 18.63 18.04 0.587 34.35 8.64 39.95 6.4 44.54 -0.6 7.35 -8.48 -3.21 90

20020909 28.65 24.18 0.625 30.96 11.98 38.6 8.87 35 -4.47 -12.22 -22.6 -15.6 90

20020910 25.52 21.22 0.534 32.33 10.44 39.82 8.25 39.58 -4.3 -6.44 -19.93 -16.85 90

20020911 11.31 13.67 0.406 45.3 7.36 42.92 5.12 81.02 2.36 58.72 14.44 20.85 88

20020912 14.28 17.19 0.484 43.54 8.39 42.86 6.22 73.61 2.9 50.93 14.2 20.32 87

20020913 21.87 22 0.52 31.89 9.5 36.06 6.97 38.43 0.13 8.31 -2.67 0.58 88

20020914 14.83 16.53 0.437 40.6 9.06 39.45 6.02 48.95 1.7 22.42 4.48 11.47 87

20020915 8.65 13.71 0.407 77.01 8.64 62.48 6.66 114.83 5.05 98.57 41.06 58.38 86

20020916 12.52 17.15 0.448 53.74 8.78 49.47 6.73 86.52 4.63 69.72 27.82 36.97 87

20020917 18.83 20.1 0.52 37.91 9.68 39.81 7.14 45.36 1.27 13.04 -2.41 6.76 90

20020918 20.46 20.74 0.567 28.75 8.46 29.97 5.88 31.26 0.28 3.38 -4.67 1.37 91

20020919 16.67 20.56 0.487 42.86 9.97 39.25 7.15 49.76 3.89 31.69 15.4 23.31 91

20020920 14.38 17.53 0.446 45.03 8.51 42.75 6.47 61.53 3.15 44.04 20.13 21.9 92

20020921 10.78 15.75 0.404 63.87 9.1 52.08 6.89 79.04 4.96 63.97 32.33 46 91

20020922 8.56 13.38 0.385 73.06 8.54 55.98 6.25 93.95 4.82 78.7 36.15 56.36 92

20020923 11.89 17.57 0.434 64.22 10.57 50.29 7.64 78.76 5.68 63.32 30.48 47.72 90

20020924 17.23 20.84 0.52 42.19 10.32 38.92 7.27 48.38 3.61 26.37 10.55 20.94 91

20020925 18.96 21 0.512 34.42 9.64 34.38 6.53 37.39 2.04 11.38 1.06 10.77 89

20020926 16.66 23.64 0.575 51.74 11.26 41.64 8.62 56.81 6.98 45.55 27.45 41.91 88

20020927 12.25 16.45 0.499 44.19 7.33 41.52 5.41 69.6 4.2 57.86 25.69 34.28 91

20020928 9.29 12.43 0.473 51.06 6.36 48.02 4.74 93.78 3.13 78.75 29.15 33.72 88

20020929 13.08 17.18 0.508 45.43 8.32 41.46 5.94 61.72 4.1 47.97 24.89 31.37 89

20020930 17.57 21.38 0.539 39.61 9.31 38.5 6.96 54.93 3.81 37.2 16.45 21.68 89
obs avg, ppb CMAQ avg, ppb R^2 NME, % RMSE, ppb FE, % MAGE, ppb MNGE, % MB, ppb MNB, % MFB, % NMB, %

0900190031 16.8 11.94 0.38 35.35 7.25 41.01 5.94 35.17 -4.86 -20.54 -30.03 -28.93

0900310031 13.68 14.73 0.281 26.4 4.53 26.73 3.61 31.06 1.05 17.43 10.46 7.65

0900911231 23.93 13.63 0.37 43.64 12.21 54.28 10.44 41.11 -10.31 -40.1 -53.35 -43.06

0900990051 13.9 13.64 0.553 20.86 3.8 20.38 2.9 21.6 -0.26 4.28 0.73 -1.87

1000320041 16.87 19.4 0.071 33.39 7.07 34.41 5.63 54.48 2.53 40.77 18.64 15

1100100251 20.88 20.86 0.36 21.08 5.44 21 4.4 21.98 -0.02 4.34 0.97 -0.09

1100100411 23.37 27.52 0.328 25.39 7.17 24.1 5.93 29.22 4.15 23.81 18.14 17.76

1100100431 20.4 27.59 0.147 41.18 9.96 35.97 8.4 49.2 7.19 45.61 31.99 35.24

2300500271 18.24 7.59 0.232 58.42 12.13 78.88 10.66 55.42 -10.66 -55.42 -78.88 -58.42

2303130021 7.27 11.14 0.228 61.7 5.37 55.9 4.48 132.05 3.87 127.31 50.53 53.28

2400300193 8.38 14.29 0.246 75.45 7.25 60.78 6.32 116.09 5.91 113.72 58.1 70.61

2400530012 15.37 13.13 0.275 28.11 5.59 30.51 4.32 29.67 -2.24 -6.37 -13.69 -14.57

2402590011 7.65 9.23 0.212 36.64 3.44 35.7 2.8 49.7 1.58 37.8 22.03 20.66

2451000401 22.77 25.47 0.341 23.26 6.74 23.31 5.3 29.04 2.69 21.04 14.48 11.82

2500510021 3.43 6.49 0.648 89.73 3.41 73.92 3.08 208.44 3.06 208.19 73.65 89.14

2500900051 10.81 12.03 0.454 22.71 3.2 22.45 2.45 27.2 1.22 18.68 12.94 11.34

2500920061 7.89 14.29 0.493 83.02 7.27 65.06 6.55 132.49 6.4 131.2 63.58 81.12

2500940041 6.13 5.37 0.236 41.89 3.32 56.11 2.57 45.29 -0.75 -11.55 -30.66 -12.29

2501300081 13.65 11.47 0.528 20.93 3.65 22.09 2.86 19.66 -2.18 -13.24 -16.33 -15.96

2501300161 18.77 11.17 0.293 41.11 9.15 48.9 7.72 37.7 -7.6 -36.88 -48.14 -40.49

2501540021 4.01 6.52 0.469 63.85 3.22 49.64 2.56 74.31 2.51 73.89 49.2 62.49

2502130031 6.33 14.36 0.258 127.08 8.83 78.06 8.04 157.13 8.04 157.13 78.06 127.08

2502500021 23.28 23.76 0.353 18.56 5.51 18.47 4.32 19.86 0.48 6.32 3.25 2.06

2502500211 24.32 19.12 0.012 34.46 12.89 33.46 8.38 28.28 -5.2 -9.1 -17.27 -21.38

2502500401 16.31 24.29 0.408 50.64 9.34 43.53 8.26 63.98 7.98 62.93 42.37 48.91

2502500411 9.28 14.76 0.424 70.38 7.76 55.23 6.53 80.4 5.48 67.56 37.94 59.03

2502500421 19.69 23.61 0.376 25.61 6.26 24.04 5.04 28.89 3.92 24.53 19.01 19.92

2502700201 14.51 9.58 0.294 36.02 6.62 41.18 5.23 32.64 -4.93 -30.24 -39.07 -34

3301100201 9.57 10.58 0.204 29.32 3.77 28.49 2.81 40.49 1.01 27.24 13.3 10.55

3301500131 3.23 4.96 0.303 64.86 2.56 60.85 2.1 146.2 1.73 140.66 54.46 53.55

3301500151 10.82 11.1 0.302 26.75 3.95 28.46 2.89 42.41 0.29 25.33 8.23 2.65

3400300051 17.65 28.77 0.566 64.22 13.15 51.97 11.34 86.45 11.12 85.44 50.91 62.98

3400700032 17.36 22.26 0.465 30.72 6.75 28.98 5.33 38.39 4.9 36.43 26.92 28.2

3401300161 25.26 31.2 0.39 30.34 9.67 28.88 7.66 38.4 5.94 33.9 23.94 23.51

3401310031 25.64 31.2 0.344 28.95 9.46 27.75 7.42 35.38 5.56 29.81 21.61 21.69

3401700061 19.09 38.07 0.392 99.45 20.14 70.33 18.98 128.3 18.98 128.3 70.33 99.45
3402100051 14.41 14.03 0.434 21.94 3.99 23.72 3.16 23.96 -0.38 1.55 -2.98 -2.64

3402300111 12.55 14.62 0.457 25.33 4.49 23.1 3.18 28.67 2.07 22.01 15.65 16.47

3402730011 8.12 7.43 0.315 35.86 3.88 33.82 2.91 33.61 -0.69 -4.47 -12.63 -8.53

3403900042 40.51 25.79 0.091 39.59 19.6 45.75 16.04 36.17 -14.72 -30.84 -41.28 -36.34

3600500831 25.02 41.74 0.536 66.81 19.04 49.28 16.72 73.74 16.72 73.74 49.28 66.81

3600501101 30.04 49.87 0.678 65.99 20.82 51.95 19.83 73.99 19.83 73.99 51.95 65.99

3602900021 11.56 16.32 0.494 43.56 5.92 38.96 5.03 55.36 4.76 54.01 37.52 41.23

3602900053 19.25 13.46 0.211 33.5 8.08 37.51 6.45 30.84 -5.79 -25.24 -32.74 -30.09

3605900052 20.83 24.07 0.602 24.82 6.43 25.24 5.17 30.87 3.24 22.74 16.16 15.58

3606100561 40.28 50.67 0.597 27.45 12.96 25.7 11.06 31.6 10.39 30.42 24.4 25.79

3608100981 25.84 50.09 0.62 93.86 25.14 66.51 24.25 107.09 24.25 107.09 66.51 93.86

3608101241 26.3 34.12 0.666 31.51 9.9 27.45 8.29 33.47 7.82 31.96 25.84 29.73

3610300092 15.28 14.7 0.436 21.54 4.24 23.25 3.29 23.77 -0.58 1.63 -2.87 -3.77

4200100011 2.23 4.02 0.273 87.61 2.48 74.33 1.95 273.24 1.79 269.16 69.74 80.38

4200300081 17.9 21.6 0.181 34.81 7.78 34.74 6.23 52.09 3.7 41.83 23.35 20.66

4200300101 19.91 21.6 0.462 23.91 5.72 25.22 4.76 30.53 1.69 19.19 12.58 8.48

4200310051 12.82 9.35 0.494 30.61 5.04 32.61 3.92 27.42 -3.47 -21.07 -27.07 -27.04

4200700141 15.38 7.9 0.238 49.57 8.59 64.67 7.63 47.42 -7.48 -45.94 -63.41 -48.62

4201100091 16.74 12.06 0.036 34.47 7.22 38.91 5.77 32.45 -4.67 -21.28 -29.98 -27.93

4201308011 10.74 5.94 0.392 46.01 6.19 53.73 4.94 41.55 -4.8 -37.45 -50.71 -44.68

4201700121 12.82 21.3 0.425 66.21 9.46 51.96 8.49 78.49 8.48 78.42 51.89 66.1

4202100111 9.44 6.52 0.167 35.39 4.06 41.82 3.34 39.15 -2.92 -20.08 -33.18 -30.96

4202701001 6.41 6.04 0.282 25.23 2.2 26.44 1.62 29.17 -0.37 6.9 -0.05 -5.73

4204304011 13.57 13.13 0.252 27.2 4.77 28.73 3.69 39.18 -0.44 17.36 3.11 -3.23

4204500021 15.45 20.16 0.454 36.44 6.58 36.54 5.63 56.82 4.7 52.57 31.95 30.44

4204900031 10.98 7.74 0.483 33.77 4.52 38.01 3.71 36.28 -3.24 -17.16 -27.95 -29.55

4206920061 11.77 9.55 0.208 34.23 5.07 37.46 4.03 40.06 -2.22 -0.49 -12.92 -18.88

4207100071 10.2 10.95 0.277 26.82 3.47 27.72 2.74 35.64 0.76 22.21 12.45 7.42

4207300151 14.69 7.4 0.453 49.72 8.31 63.83 7.3 47.19 -7.29 -47 -63.64 -49.63

4207700041 10.91 15.74 0.383 47.37 6.06 41.78 5.17 61.66 4.83 59.99 39.98 44.31

4207911011 10.97 9.14 0.222 32.53 4.62 34.36 3.57 35.42 -1.84 -1.15 -10.69 -16.72

4209100131 11.23 16.81 0.534 53.05 6.83 49.84 5.96 90.62 5.58 88.78 47.86 49.71

4209500251 10.95 10.53 0.174 28.2 3.79 28.6 3.09 30.4 -0.42 6.76 0.52 -3.84

4209903011 3.12 3.49 0.364 36.39 1.52 35.94 1.13 53.45 0.38 35.01 13.91 12.09

4210100043 20.74 24.32 0.513 23.03 5.72 22.71 4.78 27.61 3.58 23.54 18.31 17.26

4210100292 26.79 22.83 0.125 26.03 8.46 28.44 6.97 26.87 -3.96 -8.97 -14.7 -14.8

4210100471 26.83 23.84 0.361 18.04 6.02 18.63 4.84 17.24 -3 -8.57 -10.83 -11.17
4212500051 12.24 10.66 0.283 26.96 4.19 28.15 3.3 26.43 -1.58 -6.15 -11.29 -12.89

4212502001 10.52 10.99 0.623 23.6 3.2 24.98 2.48 29.53 0.48 17.25 10.89 4.55

4212550011 4.03 6.37 0.16 67.89 3.26 61.79 2.73 163.41 2.34 157.54 55.1 58.08

4212900081 14.77 8.72 0.314 41.66 7.16 49.59 6.15 38.49 -6.05 -36.53 -47.96 -40.96

4213300081 14.59 11.99 0.447 28.74 5.36 30.05 4.19 29.39 -2.61 -6.29 -12.79 -17.86

4400300021 2.31 3.91 0.128 84.36 2.64 70.75 1.95 238.12 1.6 228.93 60.01 69.26

4400700122 14 14.11 0.241 22.76 4.16 22.09 3.19 23.74 0.11 5.75 1.42 0.77

4400710101 9.57 13.66 0.223 45.2 5.18 37.3 4.33 50.98 4.08 48.98 35.1 42.67

5000700131 7.41 5.15 0.27 35.18 3.27 38.45 2.61 31.49 -2.25 -24.18 -32.03 -30.4

5002100021 9.33 2.06 0.28 77.92 7.81 124.97 7.27 76.53 -7.27 -76.53 -124.97 -77.92

5101300201 18.87 24.71 0.458 37.76 8.37 36.13 7.12 49.51 5.84 45.51 31.65 30.96

5103300011 3.78 8.71 0.419 131.43 5.54 87.81 4.97 281 4.92 280.13 86.82 130.11

5103600021 9.7 8.56 0.448 29.26 3.56 34.6 2.84 33.52 -1.14 -7.43 -16.56 -11.74

5105900051 6.48 20.61 0.577 218.84 14.78 107.05 14.17 255.64 14.14 255.22 106.57 218.36

5105910051 15.53 20.15 0.425 37.09 6.89 34.05 5.76 44.68 4.61 40.04 28.76 29.7

5105950011 16.24 18.15 0.356 23.93 5.06 24.18 3.89 30.28 1.91 21.55 14.2 11.76

5110710051 11.49 8.41 0.595 31.86 4.15 41.87 3.66 33.33 -3.09 -28.67 -37.64 -26.87

5115300091 9.38 3.67 0.301 61.35 6.49 90.51 5.76 59.87 -5.71 -59.1 -89.82 -60.86

5116110041 13.53 12.93 0.249 19.62 3.44 20.2 2.65 20.66 -0.59 1.14 -2.4 -4.38

5151000093 23.75 16.2 0.374 35.96 10.05 45.71 8.54 35.67 -7.56 -30.34 -41.04 -31.81

5171000231 16.23 16.27 0.32 21.88 4.52 22.92 3.55 24.55 0.04 6.55 1.77 0.26

5176000241 17.47 15.73 0.375 22.71 5.18 23.45 3.97 22.93 -1.74 -4.52 -8.83 -9.94

harvard_f1 1.76 4.47 0.779 153.61 2.81 96.59 2.71 232.74 2.71 232.74 96.59 153.61

pinnacle01 1.24 1.61 0.267 50.78 0.82 49.26 0.63 85.5 0.37 74.96 36.45 29.63
N

130

128

135

135

135

135

135

135

135

126

135

135

135

135

133

132

128

129

135

135

67

135

135

109

135

134

111

135

135

133

135

132

134

130

135

131
135

135

130

131

124

98

121

135

135

135

130

135

135

122

121

135

134

135

135

133

135

130

126

135

131

135

135

135

135

134

134

130

135

127

134

123

134
132

135

131

129

134

77

135

83

135

125

135

130

126

122

132

35

135

135

133

130

126

118

40

116
obs avg, ppb CMAQ avg, ppb R^2 NME, % RMSE, ppb FE, % MAGE, ppb MNGE, % MB, ppb MNB, % MFB, % NMB, % N

20020515 3.5 3.26 0.09 63.23 3.39 65.35 2.22 111.51 -0.25 67.71 1.14 -7.02 126

20020516 6.09 5.91 0.061 56.26 5.54 52.9 3.43 72.24 -0.18 38.37 4.74 -2.95 131

20020517 3.89 3.86 0.282 52.27 2.82 56.81 2.03 89.51 -0.03 47.69 -1.48 -0.83 132

20020518 2.2 1.86 0.155 64.47 2.21 72.66 1.42 143.88 -0.34 93.7 -1.17 -15.56 122

20020519 2.5 3.34 0.174 75.47 2.55 67.73 1.89 131.86 0.84 108.26 33.9 33.48 126

20020520 2.79 3.92 0.224 70.64 2.64 64.27 1.97 123.9 1.13 103.5 35.21 40.31 126

20020521 3.19 3.78 0.142 75.41 3.47 72.97 2.41 177.65 0.59 144.14 24.34 18.45 128

20020522 4.42 5.43 0.269 67.75 4.34 61.62 2.99 114.92 1.02 87.69 23.68 23.08 128

20020523 6.41 6.7 0.08 59.22 7.25 53.68 3.8 89.26 0.28 63.7 18.89 4.41 130

20020524 5.85 5.8 0.061 52.9 4.39 52.33 3.09 71.13 -0.05 34.15 1.16 -0.91 129

20020525 2.81 2.71 0.088 66.9 2.69 68.51 1.88 122.41 -0.1 77.22 3.8 -3.47 129

20020526 3.19 3.09 0.075 66.39 3.26 65.43 2.12 117.98 -0.09 73.35 0.48 -2.92 126

20020527 4.56 4.16 0.051 75.67 6.65 72.44 3.45 138.4 -0.4 97.22 10.75 -8.69 127

20020528 3.86 4.52 0.13 69.84 4.25 62.87 2.7 95.11 0.65 58.1 10.77 16.88 123

20020529 4.24 3.68 0.258 65.74 4.53 78.34 2.79 180.04 -0.57 128.6 4.67 -13.32 123

20020530 4.36 3.36 0.105 65.79 5.01 70.86 2.87 101.17 -0.99 47.05 -7.72 -22.8 123

20020531 4.48 3.38 0.109 57.59 4.26 60.14 2.58 100 -1.09 50.69 -9.44 -24.4 130

20020601 3.66 3.53 0.149 63.59 3.45 69.09 2.32 130.22 -0.12 88.29 8.61 -3.4 120

20020602 3.64 3.13 0.151 60.49 3.61 67.97 2.2 108.82 -0.51 56.19 -7.76 -13.93 119

20020603 3.2 3.43 0.188 68.68 3.22 68.96 2.2 133.25 0.23 90.4 5.87 7.07 123

20020604 4.49 4.02 0.074 60.48 4.56 58.17 2.72 93.22 -0.47 51.42 -0.92 -10.43 129

20020605 4.2 2.93 0.141 57.3 3.89 65.6 2.4 90.38 -1.27 30.76 -22.26 -30.18 124

20020606 2.73 1.79 0.127 64.41 2.55 81.16 1.76 98.57 -0.94 22.06 -37.75 -34.44 119

20020607 2.65 2.37 0.095 70 3.04 75.68 1.85 157.49 -0.28 105.76 -0.61 -10.51 123

20020608 4.21 3.72 0.221 60.73 4.49 66.08 2.56 124.08 -0.49 81.52 7.04 -11.71 129

20020609 5.5 5.13 0.184 49.08 5.16 50.44 2.7 85.81 -0.37 57.37 12.08 -6.75 129

20020610 4.78 5.15 0.114 63.11 5.73 62.17 3.02 122.51 0.36 87.8 11 7.59 126

20020611 6.6 5.65 0.108 49.66 6.46 52.84 3.28 74.27 -0.95 34.21 -4.65 -14.4 130

20020612 5.28 3.39 0.163 56.28 4.24 71.4 2.97 69.65 -1.89 -5.75 -42.54 -35.74 119

20020613 2.99 2.44 0.041 72.54 3.28 80.28 2.17 111.02 -0.55 39.64 -28.05 -18.32 122

20020614 2.68 2.22 0.253 64.24 2.37 78.56 1.72 121.3 -0.46 56.16 -19.47 -17.28 120

20020615 2.9 2.11 0.084 72.07 3.27 85.31 2.09 142.12 -0.79 69.74 -24.08 -27.14 115

20020616 2.67 2.89 0.13 76.2 2.8 82.39 2.03 184.65 0.23 132.39 2.74 8.47 123

20020617 3.19 3.46 0.178 63.55 3.07 69.35 2.03 137.63 0.27 96.75 9.39 8.55 126

20020618 4.14 4.95 0.187 67.44 4.5 64.48 2.79 114.81 0.81 84.8 22.75 19.44 128

20020619 3.6 5.16 0.067 91.57 5.15 72.32 3.3 158.64 1.56 131.8 32.12 43.21 127
20020620 4.79 4.76 0.059 68.95 7.44 64.38 3.3 133.57 -0.03 99.25 14.53 -0.52 130

20020621 4.97 4.65 0.307 53.59 6.21 50.57 2.66 78.94 -0.31 47.02 8.24 -6.33 126

20020622 5.13 5.18 0.29 54.31 5.1 55.16 2.78 104.72 0.05 72.91 12.18 0.99 129

20020623 5.58 5.49 0.2 51.82 4.88 55.37 2.89 96.34 -0.1 63.86 9.48 -1.72 125

20020624 4.64 4.53 0.281 51.39 3.88 57.2 2.38 82.16 -0.11 38.87 -4.52 -2.31 129

20020625 5.52 5.54 0.158 57.36 5.19 56.6 3.17 87.21 0.02 51.7 6.21 0.3 131

20020626 6.18 5.17 0.183 51.34 5.06 52.73 3.17 75.18 -1.01 34.39 -4.34 -16.31 128

20020627 4.81 2.44 0.089 63.43 5.12 80.21 3.05 72.43 -2.37 -10.37 -48.9 -49.31 127

20020628 3.17 2.43 0.265 55.92 2.59 70.11 1.77 99.75 -0.73 35.99 -24.16 -23.14 122

20020629 3.68 3.7 0.242 64.27 3.85 66.72 2.37 122.27 0.02 80.49 6.62 0.54 123

20020630 5.35 5.09 0.241 60.79 6.15 61.5 3.25 123.33 -0.26 88.52 12.16 -4.82 127

20020701 5.86 5.74 0.147 50.69 5.51 44.39 2.97 64.14 -0.13 38.38 9.83 -2.14 127

20020702 5.2 5.66 0.295 49.92 3.96 52.32 2.6 85.65 0.46 59.44 18.14 8.77 125

20020703 4.01 4.59 0.246 58.33 3.35 59.09 2.34 93.99 0.59 62.77 15.74 14.65 120

200207044 3.81 0.192 54.19 3.46 59.96 2.17 100.08 -0.19 57.67 -0.65 -4.63 121

20020705 2.59 2.55 0.189 61.77 2.38 68.03 1.6 116.99 -0.05 69.07 -1.11 -1.81 120

20020706

20020707

20020708

20020709

20020710 2.62 2.51 0.161 65.33 2.57 71.6 1.71 133.88 -0.11 81.31 -5.01 -4.27 118

20020711 2.74 2.74 0.135 70.74 2.99 71.18 1.94 147.410 102.14 5.41 0.09 118

20020712 3.65 4.32 0.317 61.46 3.69 62.31 2.24 123.96 0.67 95.43 21.67 18.27 127

20020713 4.82 5.47 0.229 58.55 4.94 52.01 2.82 97.53 0.66 73.9 20.07 13.63 128

20020714 3.62 4.28 0.146 75.58 4.71 67.33 2.73 146.55 0.66 123.88 34.89 18.22 123

20020715 4.18 4.6 0.185 55.89 3.51 53.61 2.34 118.11 0.42 89.26 15.05 9.97 130

20020716 3.54 3.73 0.323 55.743 61.22 1.97 117.76 0.19 80.31 8.72 5.51 126

20020717 5.54 5.55 0.091 64.83 6.15 58.9 3.59 95.78 0.01 60.03 8.75 0.2 130

20020718 5.81 5.05 0.165 50.85 4.51 53.22 2.95 52.99 -0.76 6.61 -14.18 -13.06 129

20020719 4.42 3.7 0.245 57.95 3.59 71.89 2.56 86.48 -0.71 27.09 -18.14 -16.17 130

20020720 3.31 2.93 0.17 69.87 4.09 70.53 2.31 158.62 -0.38 112.76 5.08 -11.43 123

20020721 3.92 3.24 0.124 69.36 4.79 72.94 2.72 131.32 -0.68 82.62 2.02 -17.42 124

20020722 5.06 3.92 0.135 55.19 5.05 55.34 2.79 87.09 -1.14 39.27 -9.93 -22.5 129

20020723 4.78 2.99 0.167 55.32 4.59 64.06 2.64 65.68 -1.79 -2.82 -35.52 -37.4 127

200207243 2.46 0.318 59.95 2.59 74.84 1.8 118.36 -0.54 60.97 -9.64 -17.99 124

20020725 2.98 2.63 0.136 64.59 3.56 66.78 1.93 99.67 -0.35 52.36 -2.47 -11.89 127

20020726 3.39 2.64 0.113 64.9 3.38 69.47 2.2 139.5 -0.75 85.83 -8.16 -22.19 124
20020727 3.89 3.1 0.032 74.81 5.52 76.01 2.91 129.74 -0.78 74.22 -8.28 -20.17 123

20020728 3.88 3.24 0.07 72.24 4.74 76.58 2.8 130.54 -0.64 73.12 -8.09 -16.55 120

20020729 4.46 3.57 0.054 69.63 5.05 72.04 3.11 94.9 -0.89 39.14 -10.94 -20.03 117

20020730 3.63 3.28 0.104 63 3.69 69.19 2.29 147.07 -0.35 96.91 -5.42 -9.57 128

20020731 3.96 4.06 0.188 58.31 3.63 56.65 2.31 87.8 0.11 50.97 4.27 2.67 122

20020801 5.24 4.73 0.13 59.01 5.88 57.81 3.09 98.54 -0.51 58.81 3.02 -9.68 127

20020802 5.17 5.59 0.206 61.5 4.61 59.86 3.18 84.78 0.42 43.47 3.74 8.08 124

20020803 3.84 4.25 0.213 61.08 3.6 61.12 2.35 128.02 0.41 96.21 17.6 10.8 120

20020804 4.9 4.72 0.174 56.52 4.95 54.51 2.77 105.85 -0.18 70.47 6.58 -3.69 128

20020805 4.87 4.45 0.436 42.51 3.01 51.2 2.07 71.03 -0.42 27.8 -8.83 -8.68 124

20020806 2.26 2.07 0.165 69.35 2.3 77.43 1.57 121.4 -0.19 61.67 -12.23 -8.48 115

20020807 2.22 2.56 0.208 72.98 2.38 75.93 1.62 182.25 0.35 141.43 15.57 15.62 119

20020808 2.72 3.23 0.199 69.44 2.79 69.14 1.89 144.65 0.51 111 20.52 18.67 119

20020809 3.47 4.16 0.135 76.91 4.11 68.82 2.67 149.16 0.69 114.48 19.16 19.72 127

20020810 5.02 5.12 0.197 49.83 5.54 47.23 2.5 99.98 0.11 77.63 17.59 2.18 127

20020811 6.58 6.06 0.105 54.19 6.93 46.33 3.56 57.88 -0.52 31.02 9.34 -7.88 125

20020812 7.28 6.53 0.063 50.4 7.1 45.87 3.67 70.15 -0.74 36.15 0.11 -10.23 128

20020813 6.95 6.41 0.099 51.76 5.49 54 3.6 81.61 -0.54 41.46 -1.1 -7.79 130

20020814 6.19 4.9 0.242 42.96 4.57 45.62 2.66 70.14 -1.29 26.53 -13.11 -20.87 130

20020815 4.21 3.34 0.063 58.09 3.66 58.53 2.45 73.44 -0.87 19.56 -16.13 -20.66 128

20020816 5.36 3.4 0.077 60.665 73.3 3.25 90.43 -1.96 15.21 -38.18 -36.51 128

20020817 4.97 3.86 0.116 59.02 4.72 65.48 2.93 101.51 -1.1 45.36 -17.15 -22.24 129

20020818 4.73 3.88 0.052 64.56 4.53 68.78 3.06 88.94 -0.86 29.8 -20.4 -18.1 130

20020819 4.43 4.38 0.107 61.86 3.94 60.48 2.74 74.82 -0.05 27.82 -6.24 -1.21 128

20020820 3.06 3.25 0.247 63.53 2.78 65.36 1.95 107.76 0.19 62.24 1.48 6.12 127

20020821 3.53 3.92 0.093 67.27 4.12 64.34 2.37 113.06 0.39 78.96 16.52 11.18 126

20020822 4.87 4.14 0.038 61.89 6.2 57.1 3.01 76.56 -0.73 37.61 2.25 -14.98 129

20020823 2.79 2.86 0.167 65.74 3.1 69.86 1.83 131.07 0.07 88.17 6.09 2.51 129

20020824 2.41 3.04 0.088 90.3 3.1 82.3 2.17 190.45 0.63 146.08 16.29 26.3 127

20020825 2.35 2.74 0.184 71.65 2.56 71.66 1.69 125.25 0.39 83.74 10.65 16.51 115

20020826 3.64 4.64 0.207 73.754 65.95 2.69 121.891 89.73 19.05 27.48 124

20020827 3.7 4.45 0.196 69.35 3.86 69.13 2.56 189.9 0.75 162.07 29.63 20.29 125

20020828 3.37 2.66 0.087 71.38 4.04 74.24 2.4 129.54 -0.71 79.6 0.14 -21.12 125

20020829 3.1 2.65 0.284 62.14 3.02 70.55 1.92 140.71 -0.45 91.09 -0.33 -14.43 118

20020830 3.31 3.81 0.355 59.5 3.09 59.5 1.97 110.39 0.5 77.54 14.33 15.17 116

20020831 2.3 2.66 0.037 74.99 3.52 69.1 1.72 178.5 0.36 147.12 24.94 15.84 123

20020901 2.37 2.01 0.074 72.79 2.9 75.17 1.72 167.4 -0.36 119.59 4.12 -15.05 113
20020902 2.91 3.28 0.224 66.8 3.07 65.64 1.94 150.33 0.37 119.13 23.1 12.83 106

20020903 4.86 5.73 0.164 62.99 4.68 58.24 3.06 122.68 0.87 95.24 20.3 17.97 120

20020904 3.75 5.03 0.183 70.29 3.98 62.37 2.64 128.72 1.28 103.81 27.58 34.07 126

20020905 3.08 3.58 0.108 73.47 3.33 69.05 2.26 128.87 0.5 90.98 15.37 16.17 120

20020906 4.03 5.16 0.168 74.8 4.87 63.78 3.02 134.02 1.13 106.82 25.67 27.94 125

20020907 4.58 5.83 0.042 80.54 6.66 67.56 3.69 153.13 1.25 126.26 29.49 27.35 125

20020908 5.7 5.85 0.111 61.97 6.8 57.56 3.53 101.63 0.14 72.53 16.61 2.51 126

20020909 6.78 7.06 0.156 57.48 7.87 49.65 3.9 64.98 0.28 38.46 14.69 4.14 126

20020910 6.64 6.2 0.142 57.93 6.68 56.57 3.85 99.07 -0.44 63.15 7.54 -6.59 128

20020911 3.18 2.97 0.147 65.06 3.18 69.43 2.07 135.19 -0.21 91.17 6.94 -6.69 129

20020912 3.6 3.87 0.101 77.78 4.38 72.56 2.8 150.33 0.26 111.23 16.22 7.34 118

20020913 6.54 6.78 0.126 61.12 8.32 53.844 79.74 0.25 53.66 17.85 3.76 128

20020914 5.41 5.37 0.006 69.28 6.76 61.11 3.75 98.99 -0.04 66.62 14.74 -0.7 125

20020915 2.99 2.4 0.067 68.83 3.21 75.76 2.06 145.4 -0.59 87.73 -12.57 -19.63 120

20020916 3.17 3.25 0.174 67.85 3.35 70.74 2.15 126.24 0.08 81.95 4.99 2.47 120

20020917 4.03 4.62 0.23 70.6 4.37 67.61 2.85 135.2 0.59 100.12 18.65 14.57 123

20020918 4.38 6.06 0.192 75.26 4.9 62.58 3.3 133.75 1.67 110.1 29.85 38.15 127

20020919 3.87 4.1 0.064 74.88 4.18 71.24 2.9 133.03 0.23 93.81 15.43 5.96 127

20020920 4.16 3.5 0.042 69 4.4 69.03 2.87 105.5 -0.66 54.16 -5.73 -15.9 128

20020921 3.75 3.17 0.014 76.48 4.69 74.69 2.87 124.14 -0.58 68.51 -6.55 -15.36 123

20020922 4.01 2.75 0.045 74.16 4.66 81.42 2.98 137.5 -1.26 69.9 -22.65 -31.53 118

20020923 3.17 3.51 0.077 78.8 3.63 74.58 2.5 161.28 0.34 120.94 16.04 10.77 118

20020924 4.39 4.85 0.25 58.95 4.42 60.18 2.59 141.42 0.46 114.67 24.17 10.47 127

20020925 3.98 4.85 0.051 77.59 4.77 69.7 3.09 155.46 0.87 130.74 35.49 21.94 125

20020926 3.19 3.33 0.062 72.36 3.42 70.61 2.31 122.84 0.14 86.91 18.79 4.26 119

20020927 2.57 1.83 0.053 74.92 2.96 82.17 1.92 126.54 -0.74 58.2 -23.85 -28.64 117

20020928 2.84 2.66 0.054 73.83 3.36 74.85 2.1 169.7 -0.19 125.93 10.85 -6.52 114

20020929 4.19 4.95 0.114 76.46 5.15 70.17 3.2 189.72 0.76 162.54 32.95 18.02 122

20020930 5.46 5.78 0.14 74.92 6.52 68.55 4.09 147.33 0.32 116.25 26.02 5.86 125
obs avg, ppb CMAQ avg, ppb R^2 NME, % RMSE, ppb FE, % MAGE, ppb MNGE, % MB, ppb MNB, % MFB, % NMB, %

0900100121 1.98 3.18 0.482 73.4 1.82 69.21 1.46 181.15 1.19 175.88 62.79 60.22

0900111231 1.17 1.91 0.598 71.31 1.11 69.7 0.83 197.77 0.74 192.37 63.11 63.66

0900121241 2.06 2.51 0.71 33.33 0.98 36.51 0.69 65.13 0.45 53.98 23.5 21.87

0900190031 1.03 2.28 0.578 125.53 1.58 93.73 1.29 347.66 1.25 345.3 90.74 121.5

0900320061 1.81 1.79 0.231 53.77 1.29 63.11 0.97 173.22 -0.02 130.31 7.96 -0.9

0900911232 3.24 2.11 0.541 39.33 1.61 54.01 1.28 40.06 -1.13 -36.04 -50.47 -34.95

0900921231 3.55 1.91 0.176 59.3 2.44 86.45 2.11 101.89 -1.64 9.38 -53.31 -46.21

1000310033 2.61 5.32 0.132 115.11 3.58 87.25 3.01 310.61 2.71 306.61 82.61 103.61

1000310071 2.82 2.72 0.119 62.59 2.63 67.9 1.76 158.73 -0.09 127.65 24.8 -3.31

1000310081 2.14 3.8 0.006 156.32 4.26 119.52 3.34 530.85 1.67 514.17 94.14 78.05

1000320041 2.83 4.74 0.18 88.34 3.03 72.03 2.5 184.76 1.92 175.73 61.12 67.84

1100100411 6.6 5.74 0.101 41.32 3.58 44.29 2.73 48.85 -0.86 10.09 -5.68 -13.01

2300100111 1.28 1.19 0.483 32.84 0.64 35.73 0.42 44.46 -0.09 18.73 2.86 -7.14

2300310181 2.21 0.38 0.054 84.81 2.58 130.74 1.87 120.2 -1.83 -25.37 -114.42 -82.97

2300500271 1.65 1.67 0.543 38.1 0.81 45.82 0.63 83.22 0.02 60.84 18.32 1.28

2301720072 1.47 0.33 0.134 77.94 1.23 131.13 1.15 77.59 -1.15 -77.59 -131.13 -77.94

2400320021 4.44 6.26 0.084 74.22 4.38 62.03 3.29 122.17 1.82 105.88 40.14 41.07

2500510041 2.6 2.95 0.008 74.51 2.46 75.08 1.93 235.92 0.36 205.54 33.95 13.76

2500900051 2.13 2.07 0.156 66.36 1.94 75.78 1.42 205.22 -0.07 172.61 30.68 -3.23

2501300161 2.51 2.31 0.124 49.29 1.58 54.12 1.24 78.76 -0.2 43.31 5.35 -8.16

2501540021 2.27 1.39 0.167 67.44 1.88 93.95 1.53 165.82 -0.87 98.19 -11.54 -38.59

2502500021 3.76 4.33 0.259 36.36 1.78 31.94 1.37 37.18 0.57 20.75 11.96 15.22

2502500191 3.27 3.3 0.029 46.14 2.03 46.62 1.51 46.25 0.03 2.03 -14.47 0.97

2502500201 3.15 4.34 0.06 48.83 2.18 35.82 1.54 48.41 1.2 37.9 23.08 38.06

2502500211 0.58 2.93 0.001 416.47 2.65 141.88 2.4 852.13 2.35 850.36 139.73 407.58

2502500212 3.94 3.7 0.021 41.69 2.1 42.19 1.64 40.84 -0.24 -1.58 -13.98 -6.2

2502500401 4.52 4.36 0.003 40.89 3.01 35.99 1.85 37.26 -0.16 7.88 -2.95 -3.52

2502500421 3.61 4.16 0.115 44.84 2.04 42.28 1.62 55.91 0.56 35.94 16.87 15.4

2502700201 2.68 1.76 0.418 42.99 1.38 58.31 1.15 105.54 -0.91 36.33 -34.23 -34.07

3300500071 1.57 0.82 0.521 48.91 0.99 67.27 0.77 49.24 -0.75 -41.26 -63.07 -47.86

3300700191 0.92 0.4 0.031 74.9 1.3 89.86 0.69 109.29 -0.52 34.47 -33.79 -56.91

3300710071 1.32 0.3 0.464 77.28 1.06 134.68 1.02 78.94 -1.02 -78.94 -134.68 -77.28

3301100201 1.35 1.64 0.259 77.81 1.31 86.66 1.05 326.36 0.3 307.22 60.58 22.08

3301110101 0.91 1.46 0.223 97.75 1.04 91.08 0.89 344.52 0.55 331.64 74.56 60.75

3301300071 0.92 1.16 0.211 83.08 1.26 80.92 0.77 251.08 0.24 237.05 61.41 25.79

3301310031 3.75 1 0.022 83.03 4.68 113.71 3.11 116.63 -2.75 -0.49 -78.37 -73.25
3301500151 3.81 2.77 0.001 61.43 4.01 65.85 2.34 112.44 -1.05 68.34 -0.69 -27.48

3400100051 1.84 1.64 0.478 37.61 0.92 53.22 0.69 44.16 -0.2 -13.2 -32.16 -11

3400350012 2.93 4.42 0.549 55.55 2.32 39.94 1.63 62.71 1.49 57.49 33.85 50.81

3400510012 3.02 6.63 0.504 121 3.98 81.26 3.65 163.83 3.62 163.37 80.7 119.97

3400700032 6.41 5.52 0.531 38.34 3.27 43.91 2.46 48.72 -0.89 9.91 -6.04 -13.85

3400710012 2.44 2.27 0.592 33.32 1.05 44.54 0.81 38.21 -0.17 -11.06 -24.1 -6.79

3401100071 2.69 2.44 0.48 33.11 1.19 39.65 0.89 37.69 -0.25 -5.68 -17.03 -9.18

3401300161 3.044 0.228 56.09 2.46 48.17 1.7 76.83 0.96 67.19 36.24 31.61

3401500021 3.55 7.1 0.459 100.63 4.15 70.57 3.57 136.66 3.56 136.53 70.44 100.28

3401700061 5.45 9.46 0.257 74.36 4.65 56.66 4.05 95.4 4.01 94.94 56.17 73.53

3401710022 4.67 9.47 0.126 104.11 5.7 76.91 4.86 197.63 4.8 197 76.25 102.71

3402320032 3.72 3.19 0.432 28.56 1.32 32.89 1.06 29.52 -0.53 -11.69 -18.72 -14.22

3402730011 3.12 2.12 0.527 42.39 1.92 59.58 1.32 45.31 -1 -30.07 -48.03 -31.95

3403900032 4.12 4.6 0.179 37.46 2.06 36.19 1.54 45.17 0.47 28.93 15.76 11.47

3403900042 8.22 4.63 0.203 45.07 4.83 53.33 3.7 39.74 -3.59 -37.68 -51.53 -43.7

3600100121 2.78 4.03 0.283 57.15 1.97 53.55 1.59 102.89 1.25 96.29 46.04 45.12

3600500831 4.71 7.38 0.518 62.49 3.72 50.27 2.94 82.59 2.68 77.52 44.3 56.86

3600501101 6.54 12.98 0.309 100.46 7.34 69.57 6.57 127.05 6.43 126.07 68.46 98.32

3601300061 7.15 6.13 0.002 71 7.5 68.3 5.07 91.2 -1.02 45.87 0.25 -14.28

3601300111 4.11 2.33 0.309 52.22 2.98 65.58 2.14 54.17 -1.77 -24.76 -48.3 -43.22

36015000313 2.29 0.307 31.44 1.25 38.89 0.94 30.68 -0.72 -22.86 -32.07 -23.83

3602900053 6.01 5.46 0.279 39.98 2.96 45.19 2.4 56.49 -0.55 22.48 2.23 -9.21

3602940022 13.17 7.78 0.129 71.71 13.68 84.31 9.45 146.12 -5.39 89.36 -0.6 -40.91

3603100031 0.79 0.51 0.788 42.18 0.52 56.91 0.34 46.52 -0.29 -25.44 -44.48 -36.05

3604100051 0.71 0.55 0.634 43.86 0.45 69.41 0.31 51.55 -0.16 -30.35 -54.61 -23

3604300051 0.63 0.67 0.636 53.07 0.52 64.56 0.34 59.96 0.03 -6.27 -32.92 5.09

3605300062 1.65 1.11 0.452 46.381 63.13 0.77 46.99 -0.54 -32.32 -51.95 -32.93

3605510043 4.73 6.01 0.239 58.18 3.53 50.42 2.75 70.91 1.28 47.66 20 26.96

3605560012 5.14 12.81 0.077 157.17 9.84 89.64 8.08 233.27 7.67 229.46 85.01 149.22

3605900053 2.09 4.05 0.527 99.68 2.51 75.19 2.08 181.15 1.97 177.64 70.91 94.27

3606100561 7.75 12.92 0.312 69.02 6.25 52.07 5.35 81.22 5.18 79.07 49.62 66.85

3606320081 3.24 4.26 0.322 49.66 2.09 42.02 1.61 57.23 1.02 43.14 24.63 31.43

3606710151 2.09 2.88 0.371 53.02 1.39 48.06 1.11 77.01 0.79 66.26 34.41 37.95

3607900051 1.25 2.45 0.397 103.72 1.63 77.98 1.29 198.09 1.2 195.13 74.67 96.04

3608101241 3.49 5.7 0.592 68.683 54.55 2.4 88.82 2.21 86.63 51.94 63.36

3608300041 1.35 1.1 0.639 37.98 0.8 43.77 0.51 46.5 -0.25 6.41 -10.09 -18.52

3609300033 1.98 2.6 0.232 54.98 1.37 48.84 1.09 74.21 0.62 62.96 34.82 31.43
3610300092 3.3 3.63 0.351 39.17 1.67 41.61 1.29 63.78 0.33 38.27 9.67 9.93

3611110051 0.95 0.86 0.599 41.51 0.59 51.24 0.39 48.94 -0.09 -2.1 -20.06 -9.04

4200300022 6.37 5.4 0.001 68.82 6.02 76.31 4.38 131.73 -0.97 83.97 6.31 -15.17

4200300101 10.28 7.35 0.244 34.39 4.53 42.04 3.53 33.8 -2.93 -24.12 -34.26 -28.52

4200300211 5.4 6.47 0.17 53.63 3.58 52.76 2.9 82.73 1.07 58.6 21.13 19.77

4200300641 10.84 6.26 0.022 55.79 63.5 6.03 64.35 -4.57 -3.67 -34.7 -42.19

4200300671 8.12 4.88 0.318 46.62 4.66 59.45 3.79 53.22 -3.24 -21.19 -43.28 -39.93

4200301161 5.91 5.26 0.265 36.96 2.91 39.68 2.18 39.38 -0.65 0.75 -11.03 -10.98

4200330031 11.96 6.35 0.385 56.14 9.55 67.09 6.71 90 -5.62 17.36 -35.69 -46.95

4200700021 9.95 6.35 0.039 61.92 8.57 71.69 6.16 76.96 -3.6 10.47 -28.02 -36.16

4200700051 14.5 5.18 0.391 70.24 15.6 87.82 10.18 102.12 -9.32 12.46 -51.65 -64.29

4200700141 5.43 4.58 0.152 60.85 4.87 67.49 3.3 125.02 -0.85 79.34 1.2 -15.62

4201100091 6.83 3.3 0.333 53.43 4.78 66.52 3.65 48.27 -3.53 -42.51 -62.56 -51.68

4201308011 4.8 3.36 0.207 49.54 4.16 51.99 2.38 46.35 -1.44 -8.91 -27.54 -29.97

4201700121 7.31 6.69 0.114 41.17 3.8 46.57 3.01 84.36 -0.62 49.96 1.48 -8.48

4202100111 5.69 4.85 0.278 44.66 3.67 50.63 2.54 54.74 -0.84 5.14 -17.84 -14.82

4202701001 2.97 2.92 0.084 72.16 2.91 80.06 2.14 201.14 -0.05 162.36 22.53 -1.74

4204304011 3.92 3.09 0.267 40.44 2.35 44.96 1.58 46.01 -0.83 -0.39 -16.52 -21.07

4204500021 5.03 6.47 0.069 69.06 4.39 68.25 3.47 185.77 1.44 167.23 44.25 28.57

4204900031 9.25 4.06 0.143 56.36 6.31 77.91 5.22 53.6 -5.2 -53.28 -77.61 -56.16

4205900021 8.18 4.11 0.28 53.5 5.17 75.92 4.37 53.05 -4.07 -44.85 -69.69 -49.77

4206920061 3.28 2.39 0.399 48.34 2.14 62.73 1.58 103.47 -0.89 43.06 -20.06 -27.22

4207100071 3.39 3.32 0.301 41.55 1.98 42.99 1.41 52.54 -0.07 22.39 3.3 -2.03

4207300151 4.96 4.57 0.315 57.55 4.65 65.06 2.85 150.12 -0.38 117.83 19.52 -7.74

4207700041 5.82 3.98 0.078 48.62 3.83 57.21 2.83 99.59 -1.83 40.39 -23.7 -31.55

4207911011 6.52 2.78 0.464 58.51 4.29 92.43 3.81 60.53 -3.74 -59.3 -91.45 -57.41

4208101001 2.03 2.27 0.111 82.47 2.27 86.77 1.68 253.82 0.23 224.74 43.84 11.4

4208501001 4.22 3.34 0.143 58.86 3.19 70.07 2.48 115.54 -0.88 62.08 -7.01 -20.75

4209100131 3.41 3.94 0.278 51.58 2.12 62.72 1.76 173.67 0.53 151.01 33.38 15.63

4209500251 5.03 3.11 0.189 48.29 3.05 60.68 2.43 68.84 -1.92 -0.42 -35.56 -38.12

4209580001 3.72 3.76 0.061 57.47 2.9 59.89 2.14 103.54 0.03 71.65 15.7 0.92

4209903011 2.55 1.84 0.14 52.56 1.72 70.1 1.34 98.86 -0.71 30.09 -31.55 -28.01

4210100044 3.43 5.59 0.509 76.77 3.11 74.67 2.64 221.46 2.16 216.73 69.17 62.86

4210100292 4.81 5.78 0.467 50.6 3.2 53.92 2.43 105.15 0.97 92.73 38.65 20.15

4210101361 3.78 9.56 0.468 153.09 6.25 98.7 5.79 286.39 5.78 286.33 98.65 152.95

4210700031 3.84 2.44 0.402 50.16 2.48 70.41 1.93 100.09 -1.4 25.62 -37.63 -36.53

4212300031 5.55 1.98 0.139 68.71 4.79 95.56 3.82 74.69 -3.58 -35.72 -79.61 -64.41
4212300041 18.06 2.14 0.409 88.16 21.8 139.04 15.92 79.99 -15.92 -79.86 -138.91 -88.14

4212500051 4.75 4.21 0.09 46.82 2.91 53.04 2.23 71.49 -0.54 25.67 -10.8 -11.35

4212502001 7.93 4.93 0.019 48.77 5.24 60.95 3.87 49.74 -3.01 -23.16 -44.49 -37.89

4212550011 9.22 4.52 0.105 53.03 6.22 71.41 4.89 49.78 -4.71 -46.11 -68.43 -51.01

4212900081 4.82 5.06 0.049 75.04 4.53 79.29 3.62 199.36 0.24 162.59 27 4.9

4213300081 5.26 4.83 0.126 44.23 3.14 49.54 2.33 80.19 -0.43 41.32 -1.52 -8.26

4400700122 1.77 2.38 0.149 69.11 1.55 68.54 1.22 189.32 0.61 172.75 46.71 34.41

4400710091 3.01 2.32 0.207 40.51 1.65 46.48 1.22 57.23 -0.697 -19.55 -22.79

5002100021 1.74 0.73 0.28 60.27 1.32 91.06 1.05 60.21 -1.02 -57.55 -88.91 -58.26

5103600021 4.15 4.55 0.138 59.71 3.49 63.96 2.48 179.32 0.4 152.79 28.21 9.55

5105900051 3.5 4.06 0.306 31.97 1.5 27.47 1.12 32.43 0.56 18.74 11.4 16.09

5105910051 4.45 5.17 0.195 44.2 2.47 46.67 1.97 75.59 0.72 57.39 24.46 16.22

5105950011 4.74 4.59 0.117 44.28 2.68 49.31 2.1 96.74 -0.16 64.41 7.3 -3.31

5111300031 1.47 1.97 0.532 61.3 1.19 65.5 0.9 151.3 0.51 142.42 54.1 34.47

5116110041 1.27 5.78 0.263 353.74 4.64 132.36 4.5 581.84 4.5 581.84 132.36 353.74

5116500021 1.89 5.25 0.205 179.34 3.7 100.33 3.38 313.74 3.36 313.43 100 178.14

5151000092 5.16 5.88 0.139 48.88 3.38 48.21 2.52 74.13 0.72 55.83 24.63 13.86

5165000041 2.8 12.1 0.18 333.85 10.23 128.3 9.36 575.98 9.29 574.9 126.99 331.48

5171000231 5.73 9.13 0.14 84.5 5.73 70.05 4.84 132.63 3.4 124.87 59.8 59.26

5176000241 3.12 8.38 0.33 177.35 5.99 107.91 5.53 390.92 5.27 389.35 105.99 169.05

airmap_cs1 0.73 0.43 0.444 56.18 0.66 66.46 0.41 88.64 -0.3 33.44 -16.69 -40.74

airmap_mw1 0.46 0.31 0.669 50.77 0.41 62.49 0.23 70.24 -0.14 13.1 -20.37 -31.64

airmap_tf1 0.93 1.41 0.344 72.94 0.87 67.49 0.68 159.24 0.48 146.48 51.11 51.37

pinnacle01 1.49 1.19 0.22 57.61 1.29 65 0.86 99.41 -0.3 48.23 -9.86 -19.95
N

132

127

134

96

127

135

129

103

126

87

134

135

127

40

130

130

135

78

125

134

117

135

134

135

43

135

135

126

128

135

31

113

113

94

99

112
122

132

135

135

132

130

135

127

133

135

135

131

135

127

132

134

134

131

134

135

126

135

134

135

134

135

132

135

135

132

135

135

134

135

135

125

135
135

135

120

135

121

123

133

135

105

134

132

122

135

134

127

135

111

133

120

135

133

132

135

128

128

130

104

125

130

124

128

131

124

121

130

124

127
128

132

131

133

114

131

122

124

135

116

135

129

135

131

111

132

134

109

131

124

114

123

126

131