STEVEN L. BESHEAR 

GOVERNOR 

I..JDIIARD K F£IffiS 

SECRETARY 

ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENT CABINET 

OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY 

500 MERO STREET 

12TM FLOOR, CAPITAL PLAZA TOWER 

FRANKFORT, KY 40601 

Ms. Gwendolyn Keyes Fleming 

Regional Administrator 

U.S. EPA, Region 4 

Sam Nunn Atlanta Federal Center 

61 Forsyth Street, SW 

Atlanta, Georgia 30303 

TELEPHONE: 502-564-3350 ~~<v 

FACSIMILE: 502-564-3354 ~(\.)<0 r&-~ 

January 15,2013 ~ ~ "'~ ~~~ t\JR PLANNING &1--.;.~~ '.) ~C;) 

RE: Updated boundary recommendation for the S02 nonattainment area in Jefferson County, 

Kentucky 

Dear Ms. Fleming: 

This letter is written to provide an update to the S02 nonattainment boundary 

recommendation letter dated December 20, 2011. After review of the 2012 quality assured 

monitoring data for S02, Kentucky recommends that the roughly triangular portion of Jefferson 

County that is bounded to the east by Dixie Highway (US60 and US31 W), to the west by the 

Ohio River, to the north by extending Ethan Allen Way to Dixie Highway and the Ohio River, 

and to the south at the adjacent property lines of Louisville Gas and Electric - Mill Creek Electric 

Generating Station and Kosmos Cement, be designated nonattainment for the 1-hour sulfur 

dioxide (S02) standard. Supporting documentation is enclosed. 

Your prompt attention to this letter is appreciated. If you have any questions or 

comments concerning this matter, please contact Andrea Smith at the Division for Air Quality at 

(502) 564-3999. 

Sincerely yours, 

c(~ Leonard K. Peters 

Secretary 

c: Beverly Banister/R. Scott Davis 

KentuckyUnbridledSpirit.com An Equal Opportunity Employer M/F/D 

-
Louisville/Jefferson County, Kentucky 

1-Hour S02 Nonattainment Boundary Recommendation 

Recommendation: 

The Louisville Metro Air Pollution Control District (APCD) recommends that the roughly 

triangular portion of Jefferson County that is bounded to the east by Dixie Highway (US60 and 

US31 W), to the west by the Ohio River, to the north by extending Ethan Allen Way to Dixie 

Highway and the Ohio River, and to the south at the adjacent property lines of Louisville Gas 

and Electric - Mill Creek Electric Generating Station and Kosmos Cement, be designated 

nonattainment for the 1-hour sulfur dioxide (S02) standard. 

Discussion: 

The S02 monitor at Watson Lane Elementary has a three year design value, based on 2010-2012 

data, of 123 parts per billion (ppb). The monitor is located at 7201 Watson Lane, Louisville, 

Kentucky. It was established in 1992 as a population-exposure-based ambient air monitoring site. 

It is generally upwind of a majority of the stationary sources in the county that emit S02. For 

purposes of determining the nonattainment boundary, so2 is presumed to arise from direct 

emissions with concentrations highest relatively close to the source(s) and much lower at greater 

distances due to dispersion. See March 23,2011 Memo from U.S. EPA, "Area Designations for 

the 2010 Revised Primary Sulfur Dioxide National Ambient Air Quality Standards" (Guidance). 

Because of this, and based on the five factor analysis in the Guidance, Kentucky has determined 

that less than the full county should be designated nonattainment. These factors, which are 

discussed below, are: 1) air quality data; 2) emissions-related data; 3) meteorology; 4) 

geography/topography; and 5) jurisdictional boundaries. 

I. Air Quality Data 

Currently, APCD operates three S02 monitors in Jefferson County, Kentucky: Firearms Training 

at Algonquin Parkway (21-111-1 041 ), Cannons Lane (21-111-0067), and Watson Lane (21-111-

051). The Indiana Department ofEnvironmental Management (IDEM) operates one in Floyd 

County, Indiana on Green Valley Road (18-043-1004). 

Attainment of the S02 standard is achieved when the 3-year average of the 99th percentile annual 

distribution of the daily maxima is less than or equal to 75 ppb. Table 1 below provides those 

values and design values based on 2008-2012 data. The data for these monitors can be found in 

the Appendix. 

Of the four monitors listed in the table below, only Watson Lane has a design value greater than 

75 ppb for 2010-2012. Firearms Training, Cannons Lane, and Green Valley Road stations do not 

have a violating so2 monitor and are not included in this discussion. 

APCD sent a certification letter to EPA for Cannons Lane, Firearms Training, and Watson Lane 

S02 data on January 8, 2013. IDEM anticipates the Green Valley Road S02 data to be certified 

by January 31, 2013. Once IDEM's data are certified and reviewed, this document will be 

revised to reflect any necessary changes. 

1 
Table 1. S02 Annual 99th Percentiles and Annual Design Values 

Annual 99th Percentiles (ppb) 

Site name 2008 

Watson 113 Lane 

Firearms 122 Training 

Cannons 

Lane1 -

Green 

Valley 138 

Road2 

Samplmg began 05-26-2010 2 2012 data not yet certified 

2009 2010 

116 107 

96 100 

- 45 

125 123 

II. S02 Emissions Data 

2011 2012 

114 147 

35 35 

51 31 

38 34 

Annual Design Values (ppb) 

2008-2010 2009-2011 2010-2012 

112 112 123 

106 77 57 

45 48 42 

128 95 65 

The table below lists the seven Jefferson County, Kentucky stationary sources reporting over ten 

tons per year (tpy) of sulfur dioxide, plus Duke Energy's Gallagher Electric Generating Station 

in New Albany, Indiana. 

Table 2. S02 Emissions Data (2011) 

Pin1 Plant I Facility Site Name EIS Site ID so2 tons per year 

A Louisville Gas & Electric - Mill Creek 7353711 29,944.72 

B Louisville Gas & Electric - Cane Run 5702411 7823.72 

c Louisville Medical Center Steam Plant 9613611 475.90 

D Brown Forman/Early Times 9612011 257.81 

E Kosmos Cement 7353311 187.47 

F American Synthetic Rubber Company 7367811 136.87 

G Rohm and Haas Company 7350211 28.44 

H Duke Energy, Gallagher 7742411 3009.9 

See MapA. 

Map A depicts the locations of Jefferson County, KY and Floyd County, IN S02 monitoring sites 

and stationary sources listed in Tables 1 and 2. A discussion of monitoring and stationary source 

data follows. 

Of the S02 sources listed in Table 2, five (Louisville Gas & Electric- Cane Run, Louisville 

Medical Center Steam Plant, Brown Forman/Early Times, American Synthetic Rubber 

Company, and Rohm and Haas Company) are located in the northern portion of Jefferson 

County and account for 8,722.74 tpy, or 22.4 percent of the 38,871.32 total tpy generated by 

Kentucky sources. These sources are closest to the Firearms Training monitoring site, which is 

not a violating monitor. 

2 
Map A. Location of S02 Emitters and Monitoring Sites 

In May 2009, a federal jury found that Duke 1 had made illegal modifications to Gallagher Units 

1 and 3 without first complying with pre-construction obligations, including obtaining preconstruction permits and installing and operating state-of-the-art pollution control technology, in 

violation of the Clean Air Act (CAA) Nonattainment New Source Review and Prevention of 

Significant Deterioration provisions, 42 U.S.C. §§ 7470-7492, 7501-7515, and the Indiana State 

Implementation Plan. 

The consent decree secured injunctive relief at all four units at the Gallagher Plant even though 

only Units 1 and 3 were found to be in violation of the CAA. The settlement was anticipated to 

reduce S02 emissions at the Gallagher Plant by about 35,000 tons per year, an 86.6 percent 

reduction when compared to 2008 emissions. That goal has been surpassed. In 2008 Gallagher's 

S02 emissions were more than 40,433 tons (slightly less than the 41,644 tons from all source 

sectors in Jefferson County combined); in 2010, 23,000; in 2011, the plant emitted just over 3000 

tons. These dramatic reductions were accomplished by shutting down Units 1 and 3. Additional 

reductions were achieved when Units 2 and 4 were equipped with baghouses and dry sorbent 

1 Suit was initially filed against Cinergy, Gallagher's prior owner. 

3 
pollution-control equipment. Both units continue to operate and are burning low-sulfur coal for 

further emission reductions (768.2 tons were reported for the first three quarters in 2012.) 

III. Meteorology 

We reviewed 1-hour S02 2010-2012 exceedances for the Watson Lane monitoring site. For each 

exceedance, wind data for the corresponding 24-hour period was obtained and mapped. (Source: 

2008-2012 processed meteorological data for Louisville using Wilmington, OH upper air and 1-

minute ASOS data.) 

Map B illustrates the daily average wind rose plot for the Watson Lane S02 monitor's 

exceedances. This plot indicates two sources (Louisville Gas & Electric, Mill Creek and Kosmos 

Cement) upwind of the monitor that could contribute to the exceedances of the S02 standard. 

After further analysis of those emissions sources and a comparison to a similar emissions source 

(Brown Forman/Early Times) near the Firearms Training monitoring site, we determined that 

Kosmos Cement contributes a negligible amount, <1 percent, of Jefferson County's S02 

emissions. Firearms Training had no S02 exceedances in 2011 or 2012. Similarly, we believe 

that Kosmos Cement is not a significant contributor to the Watson Lane monitor exceedances 

and violation. 

Map B. Location of Watson Lane Monitoring Site with Nearby 802 Emitters 

4 
The recommended nonattainment area in Map C includes the largest sulfur dioxide source in 

Jefferson County, Louisville Gas and Electric Company's Mill Creek Electric Generating 

Station. This one source produces slightly over 77 percent of all stationary source S02 emissions 

in Jefferson County, Kentucky, and is less than one mile upwind of the Watson Lane monitoring 

site. The wind rose plot clearly indicates that the Watson Lane exceedances of the S02 standard 

result from emissions from this stationary source. 

Map C. Location of Proposed S02 Nonattainment Boundary 

IV. Geographyffopography 

As shown on Maps B and C, neither topography nor geography plays a role in the violations at 

the Watson Lane monitoring site. 

The boundary of the recommended nonattainment area is influenced by the Louisville Gas and 

Electric, Mill Creek Electric Generating Station, which produces 77.04 percent of all stationary 

source S02 emissions in Jefferson County, Kentucky. 

V. Jurisdictional Boundary 

The USEP A guidance requested clearly defined legal boundaries for carrying out air quality 

planning and enforcement functions for the nonattainment area. Where boundaries are not 

adequate to describe the nonattainment area, other clearly defined and permanent landmarks or 

5 
geographic coordinates may be used. In this case we are using jurisdictional, legal, and 

permanent landmarks which create a nonattainment area roughly triangular in shape. Two roads 

will be used as boundaries: Dixie Highway (US60 and US31 W) to the east and Ethan Allen Way 

which runs at a northwesterly angle from Dixie Highway. One jurisdictional boundary will be 

used: to the west, the Ohio River. The last boundary will be the adjacent property lines of 

Louisville Gas and Electric - Mill Creek Electric Generating Station and Kosmos Cement to the 

south. The shaded area in Map C illustrates the proposed nonattainment boundary. 

Conclusion: 

After analyzing the five factors outlined in the Guidance, we recommend that the roughly 

triangular portion of Jefferson County that is bounded to the east by Dixie Highway (US60 and 

US31 W), to the west by the Ohio River, to the north by extending Ethan Allen Way to Dixie 

Highway and the Ohio River, and to the south at the adjacent property lines of Louisville Gas 

and Electric - Mill Creek Electric Generating Station and Kosmos Cement, be designated 

nonattainment for the 1-hour sulfur dioxide (S02) standard. 

6 
GREG FISCHER 

MAYOR 

Mr. Todd Rinck 

AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT 

LOUISVIiLE, KENTUCKY 

January 8, 2013 

Air, Pesticides and Toxics Management Division 

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region 4 

Atlanta Federal Center 

61 Forsyth Street SW 

Atlanta, GA 30303-8909 

Dear Mr. Rinck: 

LAUREN ANDERSON, DIRECTOR 

The Louisville Metro Air Pollution Control District is informing you that ambient air 

monitoring data for sulfur dioxide acquired during 2012 is ready for certification. The 

ambient concentration data and the quality assurance data have been reviewed and 

completely submitted to AQS. Taking into consideration the quality assurance findings, 

the ambient data are accurate to the best of my knowledge. Enclosed is AQS report 

AMP450 that list the data to be certified. Also enclosed is an AMP255 report that 

contains the quality assurance data used during the data review. 

If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at 502-574-6009. Please direct 

technical questions to Ms. Cynthia Lee at 502-574-7217. 

8?62-

Lauren Anderson 

Executive Director 

cc: John Lyons, Kentucky DAQ 

Darren Palmer, USEP A, Region IV 

www.louisvilleky. gov 

WWW.LOUISVILLEKY.GOV/APCD 850 BARRET AVENUE, ROOM 20S LOUISVILLE, KENTUCKY 40204-1745 502.574.6000 FAX, 50:2.574.5306 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT 

Notes: 1. Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time the report was run (may not be all data for year). 

2. Some PM2.5 24-hour DVs for incomplete data that are marked invalid here may be marked valid in the Official report 

3. Annual Values not meeting completeness criteria are marked with an asterisk ('*'). 

Page 1 of 7 
User ID: DWU 

Report Request ID: 1048859 

Tribal 

Code State County Site 

21 

18 

111 

043 

Parameter 

42401 42401 

SELECTED OPTIONS 

Option Type 

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

DESIGN VALUE REPORT 

Report Code: 

POC City AQCR 

Option Value 

STREET ADDRESS 

YES 

NO 

UAR 

AMP480 

GEOGRAPHIC SELECTIONS 

CBSA CSA 

EPA 

Region Method Duration Begin 

USER SITE METADATA 

MERGE PDF FILES 

QUARTERLY DATA IN WORKFILE 

WORKFILE DELIMITER 

SINGLE EVENT PROCESSING EXCLUDE REGIONALLY CONCURRED EVENTS 

GLOBAL DATES APPLICABLE STANDA

Start Date End Date Standard Descript

2010 2012 S02 1-hour 2010 

Selection Criteria Page 1 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT 

Design Value Year: 20 1 0 

Pollutant: Sulfur dioxide( 4 24 01) 

Standard Units: Parts per bill ion(0 08) 

NAAQS Standard: 802 1-hou r 20 1 0 REPORT EXCLUDES MEASUREMENTS WITH REGIONALLY CON

Statistic: Annual 99t h Percentile Level: 75 State Name: Indi a na 

2010 

I 2009 I 2008 

I Comp. 99th Cart . I Comp. 99th Cart 1 Comp . 99th Cart. I 

Site ID STREET ADDRESS I Qrtrs Percentile Ind. 1 Qrtrs Percentile Ind. 1 Qrtrs Percentile Ind. I 

18-043-0004 0.2 MILE N OF BALD KNOB RD 4 72 4 87 4 117 18-043-0007 FALLING RUN 4 75 4 68 4 192 

18-043-1004 2230 GREEN VALLEY ROAD/GREE 4 123 4 125 4 138 

Notes: 1. Compu t ed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time t h e report was run (may not be all data for year). 

2 . Some PM2.5 24-hour DVs for incompl ete data that are marked inval id here ma y be marked valid in the Official repor t 

3. Annual Va l ues not meeting completeness criteria are marked wi th an asterisk ( ' *'). 

Page 2 of 7 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT 

Design Value Year: 20 1 0 

Pollutant: Sulfur dioxide( 4 2 4 01) 

Standard Units: Parts per billi on(OOB) NAAQS Standard: 802 1-hou r 2010 

REPORT EXCLUDES MEASUREMENTS WITH REGIONALLY CON

Statistic: Annual 99th Percentile 

Site ID 

21-lll-0051 

21-lll-0067 21-lll-1041 

STREET ADDRESS 

7201 WATSON LN , WATSON LN E 

2730 CANNONS LANE, BOWMAN F 

4201 ALGONQUIN PKWY 

Level: 75 

2010 

Comp. 99th Cert. 

Qrtrs Percenti le Ind. 

4 107 

2 45 * 

4 100 

State Name: Kentucky 

I 2009 I 2008 I Comp. 99th Cert 1 Comp . 99th Cert . I Qrtrs Percentile Ind. 1 Qrtrs Percentile Ind . 

4 ll6 y 4 ll3 y 

4 96 y 4 122 y 

Notes: 1. Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time the report was run (may not be all data for year). 

I I I 

2 . Some PM2.5 24-hour DVs for incomplete data that are marked invalid here may be marked valid in the Official report 

3. Annual Va l u e s not meeting comp l eteness criteria are marked with an asterisk ( ' * ' ). 

Page 3 of 7 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT 

Design Value Year: 20 11 

Pollutant: Sulfur dioxide( 4 2401) 

Standard Units: Parts per billion(OOB) 

NAAQS Standard: 802 1-hou r 20 1 0 

REPORT EXCLUDES MEASUREMENTS WITH REGIONALLY CON

Statistic: Annual 99th Percent i le 

Site ID 

18-043-0004 18-043-0007 

18-043-1004 

STREET ADDRESS 

0.2 MILE N OF BALD KNOB RD 

FALLING RUN 

2230 GREEN VALLEY ROAD/GREE 

Level: 75 

2011 

Comp . 99th Cert. 

Qrtrs Percentile Ind. 

4 36 4 38 

State Name: India na 

I 

2010 I 2009 

I Comp . 99th Cert 1 Comp. 99th Cert. I Qrtrs Percentile Ind . 1 Qrtrs Percentile Ind. 

4 72 4 87 4 75 4 68 4 123 4 125 

1. Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the t ime the report was run (may not be all data for year). 

I 

I I 

2. Some PM2.5 24-hour DVs for incompl ete data that are marked i nvalid here may be marked valid in the Official report 

3. Annual Values not meeting completeness criteria are marked with an asterisk ('*'). 

Page 4 of 7 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT 

Design Value Year: 20 1 1 

Pollutant: Sulfur dioxide(42401) 

Standard Units: Parts per billion(OOB) 

NAAQS Standard: 802 1-hour 2010 

REPORT EXCLUDES MEASUREMENTS WITH REGIONALLY CON

Statistic: Annual 99th Percentile Level: 75 State Name: Kentucky 

2011 

I 

2010 I 2009 

I Comp. 99th Cert. I Comp. 99th Cert 1 Comp . 99th Cert. I 

Site ID STREET ADDRESS I Qrtrs Per centile Ind . 1 Qrtrs Percent ile Ind. 1 Qrtrs Percentile Ind. I 

21-111-0051 7201 WATSON LN, WATSON LN E 4 114 y 4 107 4 116 y 21-111-0067 2730 CANNONS LANE, BOWMAN F 4 51 y 2 45 * 21-111-1041 4201 ALGONQUIN PKWY 4 35 y 4 100 4 96 y 

Notes: 1. Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time the report was run (may not be all data for year). 

2. Some PM2 . 5 24 - hour DVs for incomplete data that are marked invalid here may be marked valid in the Official report 

3. Annual Values not meeting completeness criteria are marked with an asterisk ( ' *'). 

Page 5 of 7 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT 

Design Value Year: 20 12 

Pollutant: Sulfur dioxide( 4 24 01) 

Standard Units: Pa r ts per b illion(OOB) 

NAAQS Standard: 802 1-hour 20 1 0 

REPORT EXCLUDES MEASUREMENTS WITH REGIONALLY CON

Statistic: An nua l 99 t h Percentil e Level: 75 State Name: Indiana 

2012 

I 

2011 I 2010 

I Comp. 99th Cert. I Comp. 99th Cert 1 Comp. 99th Cert. I 

Site ID STREET ADDRESS I Qrtrs Percentile Ind . 1 Qrtrs Percentile Ind. 1 Qrtrs Percentile Ind . I 

18-043-0004 0.2 MILE N OF BALD KNOB RD 2 39 * 4 36 4 72 

18-04 3-0007 FALLING RUN 4 75 

18-043-1004 2230 GREEN VALLEY ROAD/GREE 3 34 * 4 38 4 123 

Notes: 1 . Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time the report wa s run (may not be all d a t a f or year) . 

2 . Some PM2 . 5 24-hour DVs for incomplete data that are marked invalid here may be marked valid in the Official report 

3. Annual Values not meeting comp l eteness criteria are marked wi th an asterisk ( '*' ) . 

Page 6 of 7 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

PRELIMINARY DESIGN VALUE REPORT 

Design Value Year: 2012 

Pollutant: Sulfur dioxide( 4 2401) 

Standard Units: Parts per billion(OOB) 

NAAQS Standard: 802 1-hou r 2010 

REPORT EXCLUDES MEASUREMENTS WITH REGIONALLY CON

Statistic: Annual 99th Percentile Level: 75 State Name: Kentu cky 

2012 

I 

2011 I 2010 

I Camp . 99th Cert. I Camp. 99th Cert 1 Camp. 99th Cert . I 

Site ID STREET ADDRESS I Qrtrs Percentile Ind . 1 Qrtrs Percentile Ind . 1 Qrtrs Percentile Ind . I 

21-111-0051 7201 WATSON LN, WATSON LN E 4 147 4 114 y 4 107 

21-111-0067 2730 CANNONS LANE, BOWMAN F 4 31 4 51 y 2 45 * 

21-111-1041 4201 ALGONQUIN PKWY 3 35 * 4 35 y 4 100 

Notes: 1. Computed design values are a snapshot of the data at the time the report was run (may not be all data for year). 

2. Some PM2.5 24-hour DVs for incomplete data that are marked invalid here may be marked valid in the Official report 

3. Annual Values not meeting completeness criteria are marked with an asterisk ( ' * ' ). 

Page 7 of 7 
User ID: TJA 

Report Request ID: 1048963 

Tribal 

Code State County Site 

21 111 

Parameter 

PROTOCOL SELECTIONS 

Parameter 

Classification 

APP A PARAMETERS 

Parameter Method 

42401 

SELECTED OPTIONS 

Option Type 

INCLUDE ONLY APPENDIX A 

MONITORS 

RESTRICT TO MONITORING 

SEASONS 

MERGE PDF FILES 

GLOBAL DATES 

Start Date End Date 

2012 01 01 Q1 2012 12 31 Q4 

POC City 

Duration 

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

DATA QUALITY INDICATOR REPORT 

Report Code: 

AQCR UAR 

AMP255 

GEOGRAPHIC SELECTIONS 

CBSA CSA 

EPA 

Region Method Duration 

Option Value 

NO 

YES 

YES 

Selection Criteria Page 1 

Begin 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

DATA QUALITY INDICATOR REPORT 

Notes About this Report 

For information about the fields appearing within this report, please refer to the README. txt file that is included wi

for this report. 

M 

If you see this value for a column in a summarized row, this means that more than one occurence exist in the summary. For example

summary that spans multiple States, you would see this value in the States column. 

Code Listing 

The following codes may be seen in the "MT" column throughout this report. Please be advised that not all o

codes may appear in the report. They are provided for completeness . 

Code Description Code Description 

NR NON-REGULATORY S SLAMS 

p 

SP 

NC 

ID 

NA 

F 

PN 

vs 

X 

su 

TS 

UP 

M 

PAMS 

SPECIAL PURPOSE 

NCORE 

INDUSTRIAL 

NATTS NON-EPA FEDERAL 

PROPOSED NCORE 

VOL SCHOOL AT 

SECURED SUPLMNTL SPECIATION 

TRENDS SPECIATION 

UNOFFICIAL PAMS 

WMO 

T TRIBAL MONITORS 

I IMPROVE 

IX INDEX SITE 

N NAMS 

CN CASTNET 

0 OTHER 

ST SCHOOL AIR TOXICS 

QA QA COLLOCATED 

ss SLAMS SPECIATION 

su SUPPLMNTL SPECIATION 

u UNKNOWN 

w WHO 

Page 1 of 3 
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

DATA QUALITY INDICATOR REPORT 

1-Point Quality Control 

Pollutant: S02 PQAO: 0584 (Kentucky Division For Air Quality) 

Year Region State Site ID POC 

2012 2012 

04 KY 21-111-0051 

04 KY 21-111-0067 1 

2012 04 

2012 04 

SUMMARY 04 ' -til,,,,,_,,_,, 

KY 21-111-1 041 KY SUMMARY 

MT 

s s 

s 

Begin End 

Date Date 

01-JAN-12 31-DEC-12 01-JAN-12 31-DEC-12 

#Reg 

26 26 

01-JAN-12 31-DEC-12 26 

78 

- - - - '---''"-· -- -

Page 2 of 3 

% 

#Obs ComQiete 

30 100 

29 100 

25 96 

84 99 

cv B

2.67 - 

3.56 +/- 

5.92 +/- 

3.80 +/- 

3.80 
Pollutant: S02 

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

DATA QUALITY INDICATOR REPORT 

Annual Performance Evaluations 

PQAO: 0584 (Kentucky Division For Air Quality) 

Begin End Avg %0 I Level Obs I Q 

Crit

Year Region State Site ID POC MT Date Date L 1/6 L2/7 L3/8 L4/9 L5/10 Q1 02 Q3 Q4 Me

2012 04 KY 21-111-0051 1 s 01-JAN-12 31-DEC-12 8.13 3 6 3 3 y 

(Levels 6 thru 1 0) -4.00 -2.16 -3.33 

2012 04 KY 21-111-0067 1 s 01-JAN-12 31-DEC-12 -2.33 -1.94 3 3 3 3 y 

(Levels 6 thru 1 0) 3.85 

2012 04 KY 21-111-1 041 1 s 01-JAN-12 31-DEC-12 -5.13 3 3 3 3 y 

(Levels 6 thru 1 0) -5.27 -5.00 

2012 04 KY SUMMARY -2.33 0.35 9 12 9 9 10

(Levels 6 thru 1 0) -0.08 -3.72 -4.17 (Levels 6 thru 1 0) -0.08 -3.72 -4.17 

Page 3 of 3 
User ID : DWU 

Report Request ID: 1048594 

Tribal 

Code State County Site 

21 111 

Parameter 

42401 

SELECTED OPTIONS 

POC City 

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

QUICKLOOK CRITERIA PARAMETERS 

Report Code: 

AQCR UAR 

AMP450 

GEOGRAPHIC SELECTIONS 

CBSA CSA 

EPA 

Region Method Duration Begin 

I SORT ORDER 

1 Option Type Option Value 1 Order Column 

MERGE PDF FILES YES 1 PARAMETER CODE 

WORKFILE DELIMITER 

EVENTS PROCESSING 

GLOBAL DATES 

Start Date End Date 

2012 2012 

EXCLUDE REGIONALLY CONCURRED EVENTS 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

Selection Criteria Page 1 

STATE CODE 

COUNTY CODE 

SITE ID 

POC 

DATES 

EDT ID 

APPLICABLE STANDAR

Standard Descripti

S02 1-hour 2010 

S02 24-hour 197

S02 3-hour 1971 S02 Annual 1971 
E -- DESCRIPTION 

0 NO EVENTS 

1 EVENTS EXCLUDED 

2 EVENTS INCLUDED 

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450) 

EXCEPTIONAL DATA TYPES 

5 EVENTS WITH CONCURRENCE EXCLUDED 

Note: The * indicates that the mean does 

not satisfy summary criteria. Page 1 of 4 
Sulfur dioxide (42401) 

p 

0 

ISITE ID c PQAO CITY COUNTY 

21-lll-0051 1 0584 Louisville Jefferson 

21-ll1-0067 1 0584 Not in a city Jefferson 

21-ll1-1041 1 0584 Louisville Jefferson 

Note: The * indicates that the mean does 

not satisfy summary criteria. 

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450) 

Kentucky 

1ST 2ND 

COMP MAX MAX 

ADDRESS YEAR METH OBS QTRS 1-HR 1-HR 

7201 WATSON 2012 060 8720 4 221.7 163.9 

LN, WATSON LN ELEMENTARY 

SCH 

2730 2012 560 8620 4 47.6 38.2 

CANNONS 

LANE, 

BOWMAN 

FIELD 4201 2012 060 7322 3 52.6 36.3 

ALGONQUIN 

PKWY 

Page 2 of 4 

99TH 1ST 2ND 

PCTL MAX MAX 

1-HR 24-HR 24-HR 

147.1 40.1 27.6 

30.6 10.4 7.7 

34.7 10.1 7.8 
PARAMETER 

42401 42401 

METHOD 

CODE 

060 

560 

Note: The * indicates that the mean does 

not satisfy summary criteria. 

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450) 

METHODS USED IN THIS REPORT 

COLLECTION METHOD 

INSTRUMENTAL 

INSTRUMENTAL 

Page 3 of 4 

ANALYSIS METHOD 

PULSED FLUORESCENT 

Pulsed Fluorescent 43C-TLE/43i-TL
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM 

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450) 

PQAOS USED IN THIS REPORT 

[,QAO AGENCY o"menoN I 

0584 

Note: The * indicates that the mean does 

not satisfy summary criteria. 

Kentucky Division For Air Quality 

Page 4 of 4