03-30-37p.m . 07-19-201 0 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 2/6 5

UNITED STATE S DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C . I N TH E MATTERO F PRECISIO N DISPLAY S AN D TOOL S FAA DOCKE T NO . CP09AL000 8 (Civi l Penalty Action ) DM S NO . FAA-2009-073 3 FAA* S MOTIO N FO RDECISIO N O N VIOLATION S I . Introduction . Complainan t

Federal Aviatio n Administratio n ("FAA") , throug hcounsel , hereb y move s th e judg e unde r

1 4 C.F.R . § 13.218(f)(5 ) for adecisio n renderin g partia l summar y judgmen t

in it s favor an dagains t

responden t

Precisio n Display s andTool s ("Precisio n Displays" ) regardin g •'•'- I '('3

th e violation s allege di n thi s matter . Wit hthi s motion , th e FAA seek s partia l summary judgmen t findin g that , i n offerin g undeclare dhazardou s material s fo r transportatio n b y ai r

t o Alask a Airline s i n Ketchikan , Alask ao n Ma y 9 , 2008 , Precisio n Display s committe deac hof th e 1 8 regulatory violation s th e FAA liste di n Sectio n III . 1 of it s complaint . Thi s motio n shoul db e granted'fo r two'reasons . First,'because Precisio n Display s faile d t o provid e full , complete , an dsubstantiv e response s t o eac hof th e FAA' s discovery requests , despit e receivin g specifi c directio n fromth e judg e that it d o so , o r answe r th e complaint , th e judg e should , a s asanction , dee mth e allegation s of th e complain t

admitte dan dfin dth e violation s proven . Second , becaus e n o genuin e issu e of material fac t

remain s regardin g th e

• •r - •..-. - TV ' - . - .. . violations , th e FAA i s entitle dt o adecisio n a s t o thos e violation s a s amatte r o f law . I f granted .

••''::f- : •'.•,'•;. ; itT;,,;: . .•!.':' ! •' .03-30:4 8 p.m . 07-19-201 0 3/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C

thi s motio n wil l narro w th e scop e of issue s t o b e resolve da

t th e upcomin g hearing t o th e appropriat e civi l penalty t o b e imposed . II . Goo dCaus e Exist s t o Conside r Thi s Motion . Under 1 4 C.F.R . § 13.218(c) , al l prehearin g motion s are ordinaril y du e a t leas t 3 0 day s before th e hearin g absen t

goo dcause . Goo dcaus e exist s fo r th e judg e t o entertai n thi s motio n file d2 9 day s before th e hearing . O n Jun e 30 , 2010 , th e FA A filed amotio n base do n Precisio n Displays ' failure to respon dt o th e FAA' s May 12 , 2()1 0 discovery request. ' Prompte db y that motion , th e judg e six day s later directe dPrecisio n Display s t o respon dt o th e reques t b y Jul y 14 , 201 0 o r

fac e sanctions. ^ Becaus e Precisio n Display s di dno t respon dunti l faxin g limite ddiscovery response s t o th e FAA o n th e afternoo n of Jul y 14 , 2010 , jus t

3 4 day s before th e schedule dhearing , th e FA A lacke dsufficient

tim e t o consider , research , compose , an dfil e thi s motio n before th e 3 0 day deadline . Therefore , goo dcaus e exist s for th e judg e t o conside r

thi s motio n an ddecid e i

t o n it s merits . ____ __-. .

:...••• i4t»tFvR<«t|^-3l«M8('t)?aUpfelfF ^ • ^' ^ III . Background . A . Factual Background . O n o r abou t May 9 , 2008 , Precisio n Display s use da n employee , Lewi s Lourenco , t o offe r ashipmen t

t o Alask aAirline s for

transportatio n b y ai r

fromKetchikan , Alask at o San Diego , California.- ' Alask aAirline s memorialize dth e offe r o n Ai r Waybil l 027-7310-6434 , whic hi s date dMa y 9 , 200 8 a

t 11:4 2 a.m..'^ Th e shipment , consistin g of 1 4 piece s weighin g 74 8 pounds , • J • ; ' - i ,.n " mi l ' FAA' s Motio n o n Precisio n Displays ' Failur e t o Respon dt o Discovery . ^ Orde r t o Sho w Cause . • Ex . A , Precisio n Displays'"Respons e t o FA A s Firs t Discovery Request , a

t 3 , 5 . •*Ex . B . • • ^ • • • • ••^ ' • •'•••- • •• " • • - Precisio n Display s an dTool s DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Mo t

io n fo r Decisio n o n Violation s Pag e 2

^5i^.T,»*^!»>slV>S*»?:i ' .V-wV-^-JftH'»"-r4ft!*feTs4{fe*l«r.=-*-.*-,,.- - 5w:*2OnSiiPfCG)sini i DisiMaf s ^ •• : n n r;'npl<ivi"r>, , f•,•.:^'

.. , .ci^AK , cDo r03;31:00p.m . 07-19-201 0 4/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C

wa s destine dfo

r aPrecisio n Display s addres s i n Sa n Diego. ^ I

n completin g th e waybill . Precisio n Display s describe dth e content s o f th e shipmen t

a s "TOOLS , LADDERS , TOTES". ^ In offerin g th e shipment , Mr . Lourenco , o n behal f of Precisio n Displays , certifie dtha t "THI S SHIPMEN T DOE S NO T CONTAI N DANGEROU S GOODS" , thereb y representin g that th e shipmen t di dno t contai n hazardou s materials . Afte r acceptance , Alask aAirline s persorme l physicall y inspecte dth e shipment.* * Thei r inspectio n reveale dthat

tw o of th e piece s containe dhazardou s materials. ^ Alask aAirline s discovered :

• on e 32-oimc e ca n o f

Surmyside lacque r

thinne r ("th e thinner") ; • on e 16-ounc e ca n o f

Minwax Polyshade s stai n ("th e stain") ; • thre e 16-ounc e can s o f 3 M Super

7 7 multipurpos e adhesiv e ("th e adhesive") ; and

• tw o 12-ounc e can s of

Premiu mDeco r

spray pain t

("th e spray paint") . Th e thinner , th e stain , the^adh^sive , ap^,^h?,sjpj;^x,RaJiii t a^g^g^t } cja^^ilfied.a

j a^h^ardou s material under

§ 172.10 1 o f

th e Uiiite dState s Departmen t of Transportatio n Hazardou s Material s Regulation s ("HMRs"):' ° ,„..., . * Th e thinner' s prope r

shippin g nam e i s "Pain t

relate dmaterial. " I

t i s i n hazardclas s 3 (flammabl e liquid ) an dpackin g grou p I I an dha s an assigne didentificatio n number of UN1263. " •['*•** ' Th e stain' s prope r

shippin g nam e i s "Paint. " I t i s i n hazar dclas s 3 (flammabl e liquid ) andpackin g grdii p II I and'ha s a n assigne didentificatio n numbe r of UN1263 . '

^

^Id . 8 Ex.C . ^Id . 1 :ttr-T:!im*njisbM?tju|JCE;: / /*rntrtttpi*rp6sia'^hesi ^ (¥the«Aiihes ive-) ; ;in d

1 0 Ex . A a t 3 , 6 ; 4 9 C.F.R . Chapte r

I , Subchapte r

C (Part s 171-80) . " ' ' "Ex . E . Precisio n Display s an dTool s __,DMSNo . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n dn}!^lations-^^a^ ^ Pa^ e 3 1 •'1ipfifff0"s!Wpj^inli,jiaiir

e is-:"T\iin

t ; ;;;- dtnatf^iial. " i

f is ; ...iii , •• 03-31:1 2 p.m . 07-19-201 0 5/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C

• Bot hth e adhesive' s an dth e spray paint' s prope r shippin g nam e i s "Aerosols , flammable. " The y are i

n hazardclas s 2. 1 (flammabl e gas) , hav e n o packin g group , and hav e a n assigne didentificatio n numbe r of UN1950.' ' Precisio n Display s offere dbu t di dno t declar e thes e hazardou s materials,'' * le t alon e mar

k o r label th e shipmen t

in any manner

tha t woul dindicat e tha

t it containe dhazardou s materials . In fact . Precisio n Display s di dnothin g t o aler t Alask aAirline s to th e presenc e o f th e hazardou s material s containe dwithi n th e shipment . T o th e contrary , i t certifie do n th e waybil l that th e shipment di dno t contai n dangerou s goods.' ^ B . Procedura l Background . Precisio n Displays ' failure t o file ameaningfu l answer an dfailure t o provid e meaningfu l response s t o th e FAA' s discovery request , despit e specifi c directio n fro mth ejudg e tha t i t d o both , ha s prejudice dth e FAA' s ability t o prepar e for th e upcomin g hearin g t o suc hadegre e tha t sanction s establishin g th e violation s are bot hwarrante dan dnecessary . 1 . Precisio n Display s Ha s No t File dMeaningfu l Discovery Responses .

. . . ^ispl3ys*t)i.tgCBa*ut-yid.i*oi'a&te e tha^'^ ha ^ ;ilon O n May 12 , 2010 , th e FA A serve dit s lon e discovery reques t o n Precisio n Displays.' ^

• v : <: . . : ..... . , t ^.. . , V . . . . Th e discovery reques t

consiste dof

te n request s for

admission , five interrogatories , an dareques t fo r production.' ^ Th e FA A serve dthes e item s o n Precisio n Display s b y U.S . certifie dmail , ,

1 8 usin g Ul C KU

l postag e prepaid,' * usin g th e sam e addres s that Precisio n Display s ha s use dthroughou t thi s

1 2 \? > 14 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 Ex . Ex . Ex . Ex . Ex . Id. . Id . F . G, H C . B . I . a t 4 . t . t- i i 1 1 - •

1 „ _ i .'^'-.V - .-•*'» ' ^-'.r"-•r'.ti.^si^*^"^'''*'-'-'^^^'' * • - ^ • '1?°tKc*vi.;:!n''i(»ji ^ ar c V^-!h' ^ si''^' - !

Precisio n Display s an dTool s DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n o n Violation s Pcig e 4 :"itCTTi s o n PrJ c • •on;Di.-vpIay s l^ y L^S . ..•XiU . .... ^ -<w.K.iK:.-.- > I'.i.i i i*\--^c\svoi i [.^isrilnv s h a. use d,-,0 . A.Ack-AMDn r03:31:2 4 p.m . 07-19-201 0 6/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C ' '

proceeding.' ^ Therefore , b y operatio n of 1 4 C.F.R . § 13.211(e ) an d.220(d) , Precisio n Displays ' response s wer e du e o n Jun e 16 . O n Jun e 10 , th e FAA' s packag e o f May 1 2 wa s returne db y th e postal servic e marke d "unclaimed"." " Therefore , th e followin g day , th e FA A wrot e t o Precisio n Display s an dagai n explaine dbot

hPrecisio n Displays ' obligatio n t o respon dt o discovery b y Jun e 1 6 a s wel l a s th e consequence s i t

face dshoul dit

fai l t o d o so." ' Wit

htha t letter , th e FAA include danothe r cop y o f th e discovery request , th e respons e form , andth e FAA' s lette r of May 12." ^ Th e FAA sent th e request , th e letters , an dth e respons e for mt o Precisio n Display s o n Jun e 1 1 b y bot hU.S . mai l 2 1 . 1 • i an dU.S . certifie dmail , bot hpostage-prepaid . Again , Precisio n Display s di dnothing . Therefore , o n Jun e 30 , 2010 , th e FAA move dfor a n orde r compellin g Precisio n Display s t o answe r th e interrogatorie s an drespon dt o th e request s for production.^" * Th e FAA' s motio n als o aske dfor an orde r confirmin g that , b y operatio n of 1 4 : ,. - Oi l JUII C 10 . C.F.R . § 13.220(0(1) , Precisio n Display s b e deeme dt o hav e admitte dth e request s for admission s du e t o it s failure t o respon dt o them.^^

• . . • . . ' . . I';. . ;.:is; . Th e judg e responde dwit

hit s Orde r

t o Sho w Cause.-^ * I

n issuin g tha

t order , th ejudg e di d no t rul e o n th e relie f

requeste di n th e FAA' s motion . Rather , th e judge' s order :

\-• - ' • • • directe dPrecisio n Display s t o respon dt o th e judge' s orde r b y Jul y 14 , 2010 ; •••-•. ' :! • • --ir. , . - . ' J ' ' ',!;.... / ' ^ 155 5 Alu mRoc k

Avenue , Suit e 20 , Sa

n Jose , C A 95116 . - • ' ^^Ex.'j . ^'Ex.K . ^ - I da t 2 . . _:„:. ^ ..~r~' - --sc - \,.';:z'—-. . -~-rr-:-:r:z^::—c i "• . . . "Id-atl . • '•'wt'Msi i riDisp^ay s !( : LIHSV.L:!-t!;- ' .; ; ;TO(?.'-'?():ic.< ; 'in* ^ r;'.' - "• * FAA' s Motio n o n Precisio n Displays ' Failur e t o Respon dt o Discovery .

" ^ Orde r t o Sho w Cause , . Precisio n Display s an dTool s ____ __ _^DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n forJD^f^liamiMi/MQ'iWfW^^t'^ ^ " ! k ' Pag e 5...c-i^iMon r03:31:3 6 p.m . 07-19-201 0 7/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C

• directe dPrecisio n Display s t o "fil e ful l andcomplet e substantiv e answers , o r stat e why i

t canno t furnis haful

l andcomplet e substantiv e answer , t o eac hrequest " b y Jul y 14 , 2010 ; and • warne dPrecisio n Display s that failure t o provid e thes e response s coul dresul t i n sanction s including , bu t

no t limite dto , allegation s in th e Complain t ma y b e deeme d admitted ; any andal l matter s i n th e Complainant' s request s fo r admissio n ma y b e deeme dadmitted ; Responden t ma y b e preclude dfromintroducin g an y evidenc e a

t th e hearin g othe r

than personal testimony ; Respondent' s Reques t for Hearin g ma

y b e dismissed ; and/o r

aDefault Judgmen t

ma y b e entere dagains t

Responden t

i n th e full amoun t

of th e fine requeste db y th e Complainan t

in it s Complaint.'^^ ' O n Jul y 14 , 2010 , Precisio n Display s faxe dit s discovery response s t o th e FAA. " Precisio n Display s stil l di dno t respon dt o any of

th e fiv e interrogatorie s o r th e reques t

for production : i

t lef t th e respons e for

mthat th e FA A prepare dfo

r it blank . B y ignorin g th e interrogatorie s an drelate dreques t for production , Precisio n Display s effeictivel y conceale dfrom th e FAA th e essentia l natur e of it s defense s i n thi s cas e h y failin g to:- - - — - • 'rhish'Ti"tu-!t^yi'oniplct?'1;uKs{:rnti\ ' •\irisivpr . tn^^^ ^ ' ; . ' • addres s th e factual base s supportin g eac hof th e request s for

admissio n i t

denied ; • disclos e th e identitieso f eac hfact andexpert

witnes s Precisio n Display s intend s t o presen t a t th e hearin g an dsummariz e thei r anticipate dtestimony ; • produc e wimes s statement s regardin g th e fact s an dcircumstance s o f th e case ; • explai n an dproduc e evidenc e relate dt o an y inability-to-pay defens e that Precisio n Display s ini^gggj^^i|ffiffi|ai4!|S^ ^ • produc e any other'document s tha t Precisio n Display s intends't o presen t durin g th e hearing . - ^ ^ - i Precisio n Display s admitte drequest s for admissio n 1 , 6 , 9 , an d10,"^ ° thereb y confirmin g tha t Precisio n Display s mad e th e shipment , that th e cite ditem s are al l hazardou s materials , an d that Precisio n Display s neithe r traine dMr . Lourenc o vas^hazmat-employe e no r maintaine d

. -i - . .-•' • -S-v - . • - • ' ^S « ^ ^ Id . a t 2 . ^'^Ex.A . • • •^'••••• ' '• ' •"'•'• • • • • •"••'^ ' . "'Idat7 . •' ° Id , a t 5-6 . Precisio n Di.iPlav s cux

dTools^(^^-;•si^^p\:'n> f

rl^ e flic f "Ac\r<n(\v-.\t\v^P^S:No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n on Violation s Pag e 6 ^Hlu* . . . .:.,i.^ . ;i..lata i iu:ciiiy . ,.s:.bi!ity-to-pi, . . .:..'iiN .. : : '•••: • i>! V " . : •'Uu ' . . --IV , :,•' . •^: -90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:31:5 1 p.m . 07-19-201 0 8/6 5

current record s of

suc htrainin g for

him . However . Precisio n Display s circle d"deny " fo r th e othe r si x request s fo

r admission." " Variousl y assertin g tha t h e ha s n o knowledg e of

th e subject s addresse din thos e request s b y claimin g " I di dno t know" , " I ha dn o knowledge" , " I wa s not present" , an d" I wa s no t

there" , an ddisclosin g n o effort s t o determin e wha t action s Mr . Lourenc o too k

o n behal f of hi s company ; Precisio n Display s owne r Robert Persekian :

• denie dth e waybil l numbe r of th e shipment ; • denie dthat

th e waybil l describe dth e shipmen t a s consistin g of

1 4 piece s wit

hatota l weigh t of 74 8 pound s describe da s "tools , ladder , an dtotes" ; • denie dthat

th e fac e o f

th e waybil l i s marke dt o indicat e tha t th e shipmen t

doe s no t contai n dangerou s goods ; • denie dthat

th e shipmen t

containe dth e thinner , th e stain , th e adhesive , o r th e spray paint ; • denie dtha

t th e shipmen t

wa s no t marke do r

labele dt o reflec t

th e presenc e o f

th e hazardou s material s within ; an d • denie dtha

t th e waybil l di dno t

identif y th e hazardou s material s an dthat shipmen t wa s not accompanie db y ashipper' s declaratio n for dangerou s goods.'"'" ^ A s o f thi s writing . Precisio n Display s ha s provide dnothin g further in respons e t o th e FAA' s discovery request .

2 . Precisio n Display s Failur e t o Responi i t o Discover y I s Consisten t

wit hIt s Earlie r Failur e t o Fil e aMeaningfu l Answer . - • Precisio n Displays ' failure t o provid e substantiv e response s t o th e FAA' s discovery reques t i s consisten t

withitsi^continuing-^failuretQ file an^eaningfulanswerjffth e FAA' s 1 0 pag e " - f t#t^f^!^f!i^fih?d*H^''misrirfc ' '•'T : ari d totes" : complaint . O n Novembe r 6 , 200 9 (whic hwa s nearl y tw o month s after it s deadlin e t o answe r

th e

: • ; l t I . * : . FAA' s complain t

passe dan dweek s afte

r th e FA A move dt o hav e th e allegation s i n th e complain t b e deeme dadmitted) . Precisio n Display s sent aletter t o undersigne dcounsel.''• ' I n tha t 3 1 3 2 .1. ^ J d . IcL . Ex . L . ' W*^i''shiDrcr* s ;iecl; " Tiiior- NM'C' - • .-^n ' •'boil ^ i??^JRd'tlf^ff ^ h i p n i 0 n t

•,'. .

Precisio n Display s an dTool s FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n o n Violation s DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 Pag e 7

.. . r.-^ ' ,.i i I-. . >Mii :90 7 276726 1 ALASKANRO C 03:32:04p.m . 07-19-201 0 9/6 5

letter , whic hprimaril y deal t wit hwhy Precisio n Display s di dno t file a n answer , Mr . Persekian adde dth e following : I woul db e mor e tha n happ y t o provid e you wit harespons e in thi s matter . Pursuan t t o th e statute . I hav e no t "knowingl y committ(ed ) a n ac t i n violatio n o f 4 9 U.S.C . chapte r

5 1 . . . . " (Sectio n 13.16(c) ) becaus e I di dno t kno w tha

t th e package s containe dflammabl e and/o r hazardou s material.^"''* ' Precisio n Display s di dnot addres s eac hnumbere dparagrap hi n th e complaint , let alon e specificall y den y any statemen t o r allegatio n i n th e complaint . Nevertheless , th e judg e determine dt o treat

thi s general denial a s an answer."*^ IV . Argument . A . Th e Judg e Shoul dEnte r aDecisio n Establishin g Eac hof th e Violation s a s Allege db y th e FA A a s aSanctio n for Precisio n Displays ' Failur e t o Answer th e Complain t

an dRespon dt o Discovery . Precisio n Displays ' failure t o file bothameaningfu l answer t o th e specifi c allegation s of th e complain t

an dsubstantiv e response s t o th e FAA' s discovery reques t ha s prejudice dth e FAA' s ability t o presen t

it s cas e o n it s merit s a

t th e rapidly-approachin g hearin g t o suc hadegre e tha t th e judg e should^WSfsanction.^eeiSth^iolatlbhs ^ prove dhiriiiJthe'scop e o f th e hearin g t o th e amoun t

of civi l penalty t o b e imposed . 1 . Precisio n Displays ' 'Answe r " I s No t A n Answer . Precisio n Displays ' cursory statement containe di n alette r

t o undersigne dcounse l tha t i t di dno t knowingl y violateth e HMR s becaus e it di dno t kno w tha t it s shipmen t

containe d hazardou s material s i s insufficient a s amatte r

of la w an dwarrant s th e requeste dsanction . Th e Rule s o f

Practic e specif

y bothwha

t an answer

mus t contai n an dwha

t consequence s awai t aresponden t

wh o fail s t o file asubstantiv e answer :

'^ Orde r Grantin g Motio n t o Postpon e Hearin g a t footnote I . Precisio n Display s an dTool s ; . . - n ' < DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n o n Violation s Pag e 8 ^tii^fmf^sMM^m^ti?^*--^^- '907276726 1 ALASKANRO C 03;32:17p.m . 07-19-201 0 10/6 5

(e ) Specifi c denia l of

allegation s required . A perso n filing a n answe r shal l admit , deny , o r stat e that

th e perso n i s withou t

sufficient knowledg e o r

informatio n t o admi t o r deny , eac hnumbere dparagrap hof th e complaint . Any statemen t o r allegatio n containe di n th e complain t that i s no t specificall y denie din th e answer ma y b e deeme da

n admissio n of

th e tnithof

tha t allegation . A general denial o f th e complain t

i s deeme dafailur

e t o file a n answer . (f ) Failur e t o file answer . A person' s failur e t o file a n answe r withou t goo dcaus e shal l b e deeme da

n admissio n of

th e truthof

eac hallegatio n containe din th e complaint.'"^* ^ Althoug hth e judg e decide dt o treat Precisio n Displays ' two-sentenc e paragrap hi n apost complain t lette r t o undersigne dcounse l t o b e a n answer , th e judg e ha s no t foundi t to b e a legally-sufficient

answer . I

t i s not . Rather , i

t i s precisel y th e sort

of cursory respons e tha

t Rul e 209(e ) wa s meant

t o discourage . Settin g asid e th e fac t

that it wa s untimel y b y nearl y tw o months , th e fac t tha t Precisio n Displays ' paragrap hdoe s no t specificall y admi t

o r den y eac hallegatio n enumerate di n th e complain t confirm s tha

t it i s jus t th e sor t of genera l denial that , unde r Rul e 209(e) , constitute s a failure t p fil e af l a^Y(gdf^JJfi^1^<?*&1 ^ allegation s i n th e complain t that on e of it s employee s shippe dflammable s a s undeclared , tha t it s :'iic- . •.,;..• . iJi . ;S(.:; \i;;;!ui- e ; o :•'."••• ' :M - . . ; . : ,1 ' employe e certifie do n th e waybil l tha t th e shipmen t

di dno t contai n dangerou s goods , an dtha t th e dangerou s good s wer e no t properl y package dfor

shipment ? Precisio n Displays',paragrap honl y deal s withMr . Persekian' s knowledg e of th e incident . • .- • -1. . :• : M!rTtrflf«irWliafWI9tt«rfei?eW ^ ' - ^ However , th e FA A ha s no t allege dtha

t Mr . Persekia n knowingl y violate dth e HMRs . Yet tha t

. . Li . .....; • 1 i-Si''iiJ; , . . i S j..;.• . . •.' . l y iii ^ sor' . . . ..<•• . th e answer

t o tha t questio n i s all that

Precisio n Displays ' answer provides . Under

Rul e 209(e) , Precisio n Display s general denia l i s n o answer a t all . Rul e 209(f

) mandate s that

apart y wh o fail s t o file a

n answe r mus t b e deeme dt o hav e admitte dth e trut

ho f eac hallegatio n o f

th e complaint . Th e judg e shoul dgiv e effec t t o th e plai n i ; i : . ili C ^(^i . M ' • >•; ; .. . .;:: ! ; : .. L.:; . ' . ; .:. L. ^ ^ 14C.F.R . § 13.20 9 (emphasisadded) . ; • , i , \ , . ,;„ays - n,, , Precisio n Display s an dTool s DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n o n Violation s Pag e 9

Kl'l H ^ K90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C ^:,;,:. ; ".ir-^.viv^/o,'. . :;=:;;.;;:::;:.;:;:-/-^^v^-.-;.. v ;^ : ;; : . ./^;v::v!?3-j?2:J32p,m , 07-19-201 0 11/6 5

languag e o f

thes e rules , dee meac hallegatio n o f th e complain t

admitted , an dnarro w th e scop e o f th e hearin g t o th e amoun t o f civi l penalt y t o b e imposed . 2 . Precisio n Displays ' Discover y Response s Ar e Insufficien t an dRequir e Sanctions . Precisio n Displays ' discover y response , serve dunde r threa t o f sanction s detaile di n th e judge' s recen t

Orde r t o Sho w Cause , i s largel y unresponsive , work s actua l prejudic e agains t th e FAA , an dmerit s th e requeste dsanction . Th e Practic e Rule s stat e tha t aresponden t

ma y hav e th e substanc e o f th e cas e decide d agains t i t shoul di t

fai l t o adequatel y respon dt o adiscover y reques t o r order : I f apart y fail s t o compl y wit hadiscover y orde r o r a n orde r

t o compel , th e administrativ e la w judge , limite dt o th e exten t o f th e party' s failur e t o compl y wit hth e discover y orde r o r motio n t o compel , may : (1 ) Strik e th^f,port)i9p,(|);^aj) ^ , , ;,,,,;;. ] , , (2 ) Preclud e prehearin g o r discover y motion s b y tha t party ; (3 ) Preclud e admissio n o f tha t portio n o f

aparty' s evidenc e a t

th e hearing ; o r (4 ) Preclud e tha t

portio n o f

th e testimon y o f

tha t party' s witnesse s at

th e hearing.^'*' ' Mor e immediat e sanction s atten dfailure s t o respon dt o request s fo r admissions : . A party' s falluret o respon dt o areques t fo r admission , i n writin g an dsigne d b y th e attorne y o r

th e party , no t

late r tha n 3 0 day s afte r

servic e o f

th e request , i s deeme da n admissio n of.th e trut ho f th e statemen t

o r statement s containe di n th e reques t fo r admission.^"^* ' Thus , fo r request s fo r

admission , th e part y tha t pose dth e discover y nee dno t obtai n a n orde r compellin g responsest o ajequestfo r ad^ssion^th e failitr^tQresponcUiistdeemed" , absen t a n •-!\ - -fMiSsto^conTply " *A-iln' aaisaiv e '>-ic r ar-<'i n <m.lo f l o .: ^ affirmativ e demonstratio n o f goo dcause , t o constitut e a n admission , , ; N'v. ' r v . ; ': l UlOl.iUT' l i dCr.jupL':. . i. l ' M 4 C.F.R . § 13.220(n) . ' * 1 4 C.F.R . § 13.220 m

li-.v-; . Precisio n Display s an dTool s FAA' s Motio n fo r

Deci.sio ho n 'Violation s r y'l'^H ! llflMJ.ilS«tl ( the DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 "^^ i Pag e 1 0.,«e.^AK . cn r03:32:45p.m . 07-19-201 0 12/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C

Althoug hth e judg e wa s quit e clear in directin g Precisio n Display s t o "fil e full an d complet e substantiv e answers" . Precisio n Display s di dno t d o so . I t chos e no t

t o respon dt o eithe r th e interrogatorie s o r

th e reques t

fo r production . ^

^ And , withregardt o th e request s fo r admissions , Precisio n Displays ' denial s are s o cursor y ands o devoi dof

meanin g give n th e substantiv e question s pose dtha t they , too , are , i n effect , unresponsive.^ " Precisio n Displays ' failure t o explai n h s ground s for contestin g th e FAA' s charges , firs t b y failin g t o provid e ameaningfu l answer an dno w b y refusing , in th e fac e o f th e judge' s order , t o suppl y full andcomplet e discovery responses , ha s prejudice dth e FAA' s ability t o presen t it s cas e an ddeman dsanctions . A s Judg e Benki n ha s observed : [D]iscovery request s ar e a n inheren t

par t of th e proces s o f

conductin g an administrativ e hearin g o n th e merits ; o f th e complain t

file dagains t

th e Respondent , ahearin g tha t h e himsel f

requested . Th e Responden t canno t hav e it bothways . H e caimo t

obtai n th e benefi t

of ahearin g under

th e Rule s and , a

t th e same time , flout

th e sam e se t

o f rule s that

provid e for

an orderl y hearin g process.'*""'^' e ansv^.-H" , rt;;i:<i(^:inisr'.A v ' . . ; ... - v - I t •.::, > ^ r What Judg e Benki n describe di s precisel y wha t ishappenin g here . Precisio n Display s i s openl y floutin g th e rule s o f

discovery despit e th e judge' s patienc e wit hit i n givin g it

additional tim e to respon dan ddespit e th e judge' s carefu l wor k i n fully explainin g t o Precisio n Display s th e sanction s it

face dshoUld4Pfait'tW|>fevidg^rbpfcrfesFk)rise^^^ ^ F'

^ ' " ^ ^ ' Despit e th e judge' s lenience , Precisio n Displays'discover y respons e constitute s n o real respons e a

t all . Therefore , th e judg e shoul dabid e b y th e plai n languag e o f Rule s 220(I) ( 1 ) an d -iccmeAtaia)Afgi*aiSi03fteK«w:p3rt.^^^<Slh^fe"l3^ ^ a

n "' ^ Ex A a t 7 ''^--htrnVinp^ : o

n the " Vnerif

s o f ]..:, • ci.mpIaiDl fJ!o

d ldiat5-6 . .;cjn . •;...; , •u.^h.'l-nofu-o t ahe--i'^- - '•-•VIJ , :hc .

R ^ ' Geral dW . Keller . FAA Docke t No . CP06GL0007 . FDM S No . FAA-2006-25869 , Administrativ e Law Judge' s Orde r Imposin g Sanction s for

Failur e t o Compl y Wit

hOrder s Compellin g Discovery , a

t 2 (Mar . 2 , 2007) . Precisio n Display s <mJ.Tw;/J^iif^7^!p^Pp? y FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n o n Violation s " Pag e 1 1 •-cjt u . . :J U u i \Vci k .i t iLiiiy - .'-plainiiigrtM ; rcv.sie. .AiAou-AMon r03:32:59p.m . 07-19-201 0 13/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKANRO C ...r;^.-;;;-^,;^:;vg^v., ; ,;.;-^:-.,.; ^

(n) . deemeachallegatio n of th e complain t

admitted , an dnarro w th e scop e o f th e hearin g t o th e amount of civi l penalty t o b e imposed . B . Becaus e N o Genuin e Issu e o f Material Fac t

Regardin g th e Violation s Remains . th e Judg e Shoul dEnte r

aDecisio n That

Establishe s Th e Violation s A s aMatter of Law . A s a n alternativ e pat

ht o concludin g th e disput e o n th e merit s of thi s matte r

and proceedin g t o ahearin g focuse dsolel y o n th e amoun t o f th e civi l penalty , th e FAA request s partial summar

y judgmen t

establishin g th e violation s du e t o th e lack of an y genuin e issu e of material fact.'* " A s introduce dabove , th e waybill,"* ^ th e irregularity report,'* * th e photo s of th e hazardou s material s recovere dfro mth e shipment,* ^ th e material s safet y dat asheets,"* ^ and Precisio n Displays ' admission s regardin g th e shipment* ^ ampl y demonstrat e that Precisio n Display s knowingl y offere dundeclare dhazardou s matei^al s fo r shipmen t b y ai r i n violatio n of • •- . ' ; .;ll<fgSti5n^

f tHF^mfilaifitTT'dn'-iittJd . m dluTr-nSv ; ihe"scop e n'"'' ' ' hr

eac hof th e regulation s cite di n th e complaint .

. - L Where it s answe r

an ddiscovery response s ar e misdirecte dan dopaque . Precisio n Displays ' Statement s durin g th e investigatio n were rathe r direc t i n acknowledgin g th e ke y fact s i n thi s case . First , i n alette r t o FA A Specia l Agen t

Jeffrey Deitz , Mr . Pereekian pu t th e blam e jaiauviSpayfeKSSGinfeiaUiiTgiheyisputeJoffi ^ an d fo r th e shipment

o n a"back-u p crew " i n Ketchikan tha t "naivel y jus t

mad e sur e t o packag e ever y itemtha t wa s to retiu n t o San Diego , Ca." , ** Mr . Persekian sai dthat hi s compan y "apologize[s ] ^"14CF R5 132 1 Srf^f5 ^ Ex . B . * * Ex . C . Ex . D . •''.. . itiv.\'i:- . xl':. . 'i-( i " , '"

• 'upini; : * ^ Ex . E , F , G , andH . * ^ Ex . A a t 5 . ^^Ex.M . .,.,.......-.. . : . . •.,... ' ^. . . •"%(ifnl^-t'^*ia^-v.-ktif^i'';oiTAvorcrV " • .'ir. " : t i n ;)r'-KfS-\':• > • ' Precisio n Display s an dTool s ^ DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n o n •yi,olatioriSr.,:f-\u..^ffy y ' \.:,:.;..'V r Pag e 1 2

.:t-^ii^»*Vim&H v -<-«tet--.*^».«wSifcv. > ».: >, . . A.Aci^iMon r 03:33:11p.m . 07-19-201 0 14/6 5 00 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C . ' ^

for thi s incident " an dwa s "read y t o take full responsibility for ou r actions."*' ' Second , i n a subsequen t

telephon e intervie w wit

hSpecial Agen t

Deitz , Mr . Persekia n sai dtha t th e Precisio n Display s cre w i n Ketchikan wa s i n ahurry , mad e amistake , andaccidentall y shippe dth e hazardou s materials.' " Third , i n hi s telephon e intervie w withSpecial Agent Deitz , Mr . Lourenco , wh o offere dth e shipmen t i n Ketchikan , echoe dth e story tol db y Mr . Persekian , tha t bein g that som e Ketchikan laborer s hire db y Precisio n Display s place dth e hazardou s material s into tote s an dthat

th e tote s wer e the n include dwithth e shipmen t sent t o Sa n Diego.' ' Thes e admission s b y Mr . Persekia n an dMr . Lourenco , rea dfairly agains t th e backgroun dof

th e waybill , th e irregularity report , th e photos , an dth e discovery admission s abou t th e shipment

an d Mr . Lourenco' s lac k

o f training , demonstrat e tha t n o material questio n of

fact remain s regardin g any of th e allege dviolations . T o th e exten t

that Precisio n Display s ha s mounte dan y defens e a

t all , it consist s of

Mr . Persekian' s assertions , appearin g i n bothPrecisio n Displays ' putativ e ?inswer' ^ an dit s discovery 

## ••:•: • •" . ; nf<5gi^1i?ji?r'si()^[tn"Ti'nv^ ^• itT• response'"^ , tha

t h e personall y di dno t

kno w wha

t th e shipmen t

containe do r

whether thos e content s include dhazardou s materials . However , unde r Scott H . Smalling.' * Mr . Persekian' s personal knowledg e o f

wha t Mr . Lourenc o offere dt o Alask aAirline s o n behal f of Precisio n Display s i s no t

relevan t t o any of th e violation s a

t issu e in thi s proceeding . Thi s i s particularl y : .^ ...v . . . a4asawl3SS*eS33henanelude3S^ithnhB ^ The;. . ^^Id. . .•.-. • . A.uc-,.^a v 5 0 Ex . N . " Ex . O . Not e that

th e waybil l (Ex . B ) describe s th e item s shippe da s "TOOLS , LADDER , TOTES " —- " E x L •'••'•-. • -. y -.; . • . , "Ex . Aat5- 6 ' * FA A Orde r No . 1994-31 , a

t 7.'-' y '"•"- ' • 'it-ivcun , Precisio n Display s an dTool s DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n of

i Violations,. , , . - Pag e 1 3907276726 1 ALASKANRO C 03:33:2 4 p.m . 07-19-201 0 15/6 5

significant give n Precisio n Displays ' admissio n tha t Mr . Lourenc o di di n fact

offe r th e shipment in questio n o n behal f

of Precisio n Displays.' ' Th e judg e shoul dno t

b e distracte db y Mr . Persekian' s claime dlac k o f knowledg e about th e incident . Whil e ake y statut e provide s that , t o b e foun dliable . Precisio n Display s o r a similarl y situate dreasonabl e perso n mus t hav e knowledg e of

th e "fact s givin g rise t o th e violation",' ^ knowledg e o f th e la w itsel f i s no t necessary . Congres s intende dto preven t individual s fromrelyin g o n ignoranc e of th e law a s an excus e i n civi l hazardou s material s cases.' ^ A s aresult , Precisio n Display s ma y b e hel dliabl e eve n i

f it s employee s di dno t consciousl y appreciat e that the y were breakin g th e law,' ^ A s in Smalling . Precisio n Display s ha s admitte dtha

t it s worker s in Ketchikan ha dactual knowledg e of th e fact s givin g ris e t o th e violatio n - tha

t the y place dth e hazardou s material s in th e shipmen t an dofferedth e shipmen t t o Alask aAirline s for

transport b y air . Becaus e Precisio n Display s admitte dactual knowledg e of th e fact s givin g rise t o th e violation , it hadth e requisit e knowledg e t o suppor t eac ho f th e allege d violations . Precisio n Display s knowingl y offere dundeclare dhazardou s material s for transportatio n b y ai r commerc e andthu s violate dth e HMR s a s alleged . Moreover , Precisio n Display s ha s

"Ex.AatS. ' -;-^-^ - ' "^-—.•

—- - - ^'^^^•-'^--^^^• - - • '^49U.S.C . §5123(a)(1) . ^'''- ^ - ^ ' ^' ' ' " ' ' ^ Th e legislativ e history o f th e Hazardou s Materia l Transportatio n Ac t confirm s that

Congres s intende dt o impos e civi l penaltie s o n person s wh o kne w abou t th e ac t constitutin g th e violatio n eve n i f the y di dno t

kno w abou t

th e law . Th e conferenc e substitut e explain s tha t " acivi l penalt

y ma y b e impose donl y upo n proo f tha t th e defendan t

knowingl y committe dth e ac t whic h constitute s th e violatio n (i t i s not necessary t o sho w .that

h e knew th e ac t

constitute daviolation )

.. . (emphasi s supplied)^:^S.:epnfvRep.-No.;13,47;^93 l Cong:;i?2"JSess:?reprinte di n 197 4 U.S . Cod e Cong . & Ad . News?7669l7686 : se e als o TC I Corporation . FA A Orde r .No . 92-77 , a

t 8- 9 n . 13 . ' ^ Riverdal e Mill s Corp.!:'PAA'Oi^erI^o ; IZOOS^O^'tAS : ' " ^ ' ' '^^ - ' ' ;-'P ' Precisio n Display s an dTool s DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n o n Violation s Pag e 1 490 7 276726 1 ALASKANRO C 03:33:3 8 p.m . 07-19-201 0 16/6 5

effectivel y admitte deac hmaterial fac t regardin g thos e violations . Therefore , a s a n alternativ e t o grantin g partial summary judgmen t t o th e FA A du e t o Precisio n Displays ' willfu l refiLsa l to file a n answe r o r produc e requeste ddiscovery , th e judg e shoul dente r partial summary judgmen t in favor of th e FAA du e t o th e absenc e of an y material issue s o f

fact . V . Conclusion . For th e foregoin g reasons , th e judg e shoul dente r adecisio n findin g that , i n offerin g undeclare dhazardou s material s fo r transportatio n by ai r

Precisio n Display s committe deac hof th e 1 8 regulatory violation s th e FAA liste di n Sectio n III . I of it s complain t

an dlimitin g th e scop e of th e upcomin g hearing t o th e amoun t of civi l penalty t o b e imposed . DATED thi s JllSda y of July , 2010 .

HOWARD L . MARTIN , JR . Regional Counse l

p '•':• ' '! - -'e n • *^

! ^-Cral j Wm.^lac r -v,^Starf^Attomey CERTIFICAT E O FSERVIC E Re : Precisio n Display s an dTool s . _ _•

. • • 'FA A Docke t

Not iGPb^A*ir0(X)8;i'<'tc

diri'Scctioi ; 'V.. I o

f il. s i.-oinplain

t ; ' n DM S No . FAA-2009-073 3 I HEREB Y CERTIF Y that o n thi s dat e I hav e serve dacop y o f th e foregoin g b y postage-prepai d mail , facsimile , an demairto : Th e Honorabl e Richar dC . Goodwi n Administrativ e La

w Judg e i i u . . ,._ / ;

_... . ..v.i. . .,.j... ^ Offic e o f U6aigg^M^^2(y^' ' '-^'^^f^^^^^^^ ^ ' U.S . Departmen t

o f Transportatio n 1200 New Jerse y Avenue , S.E . , / . - ...-^ ^ Precisio n Display s an dTool s DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAu\' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n o n Violation s Pag e 1 590 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C __. f l^^:,*^'^' ^ 07-19-201 0 17/6 5

Eas t Buildin g Groun dFloor , Roo mE12-32 0 Washington , D C 2059 0 Fax : (202 ) 366-753 6 Email : Richard.Goodwin@dot.go v I HEREB Y FURTHERCERTIF Y tha t o n thi s dat e I hav e serve d(1 ) th e original andtw o copie s of th e foregoin g b y postage-prepai dmail , an d(2 ) th e original o f th e foregoin g b y facsimil e to : Federal Aviatio n Administratio n ATTN : Docke t

Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbur Wrigh t Buildin g - Suite 2W100 0 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Washington , D C 2059 1 FAX : (202)493-502 0 I HEREB Y FURTHE RCERTIF Y tha t o n dii s dat e I hav e serve don e cop y o f th e foregoin g b y postage-prepai dfirst-class mai l to : Rober t Persekian Precisio n Display s an dTool s 155 5 Alu mRoc k

Avenue.^uit e 2 0 Sa n Jose , GAi951l6'^tl*^'If«r.^R"on».El2".U( ) 

## DATED : >/.//< ? 1^(0/ 0 

# r /

Federal AviaS;ioh^3ministratidn; % Offic e o f Regional Counse l ;

> i ^ 22 2 Wes t 7t hAvenue,'Bo x 14,^AAL- 7 Anchorage , A K

99513-758 7

•T^^TB-jn #iirtfe»j»lfcff-»n.>.'rJ>tc-ft ' -^y •>^i — T r ;*iy;' ' no ; ' I . ^ '

Precisio n Display s an dTool s DM S No . FAA-2009-097 6 FAA' s Motio n fo r

Decisio n o n Violation s Pag e 1 6 y y

. • 1 .90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:33:5 8 p.m . 07-19-201 0 18/6 5 

# 9 U . S . Depanmen t o f Transportatio n Federa l Aviatio n AdmiBiitratio a Alaska n Regio n Onic e ofth e Regiona

l Counsel 22 2 W . 7t h Avenu e * M

Aitchorage , Alask a 99SI3-7S8 7 PH : (907 ) 271-527 1 FAX ; (907 ) 271-280 0 glenn.brown@(aB.go v Cas e No . 2008AL70003 9 MAY1 2 201 0 Mr . Rober t

Persekia n Precisio n Display s an dToot s 155 5 Alu mRoc k

Avenue , Suit e 2 0 Sa n Jose , C A 9511 6 Dea r Mr . Persekian : 

## ,,EC^t^^ ^ 

# mI

A s yo u kno w th e judg e ha s se t ou r matte r fo r ahearin g o n Augus t

17,2010 . I n lookm g throug h ou r file , I se c tha t

yo u hav e neve r

actuall y submitte da n answe r i n whic hyo u admi t

o r den y eac h o f th e paragraph s h i th e complaint . Thus , i n orde r t o mov e thi $ proces s along , I hav e incluide d Request s fbr

Admissio n i n th e enclose ddiscovery , request . AIS Q include di n thi s reques t ar e Interrogatorie s an dRequest s fo r Froduction.wm^!o n ' :; f w 7i hA - ^ J Offi . -: f

<h ' Pleas e not e tha t

i f yo u d o no t

respon dt o eac ho f

th e Request s fo r

Admissio n ^thi n 3 0 days , the n th e Rule s o f

Practic e specif

y tha t the y ar e deeme dadmitted . br- . Fo r you r itiformation , ther e i s n o specifi c forma t yo u mus t

us e i n respondin g t o thi s request . T o assis t yo u i n preparin g you r

response , I hav e prepare dan denclose da4-pag e formtha t yo u ma y us e fo r thi s purpose . A s fo r

eac hreques t

fo r admission , yo u can eithe r circl e you r

choic e o f "Admit " o r

"Deny, " o r

yo u ca n mar k

.throug hth e -•Admit " or"Deny " yoi i ar e not|^9hoosing . Th e "Explanatio n fo r

Denial " afte r

eac hanswe r

t o areques t

fo r admissio n i s ^ referenc e io ^ Interrogator y No . I , wliio hask s yo u t o explai n an y denial . Yo u ar e no t require dt o us e thi s form , bu t yo u mus t

at leas t clearl y conve y you r

response s i n writing . I f yo u hav e an y questions , I ca n b e reache da t th e abov e numbe r

o r emai i address . Sincerely , Olei mH . Brow n Senio r Attorne y -M' . EncJoswe s 

### W^^M^IMW^^^^- ^ •' : I -.t o ai: . . 0 thitprobcL . -.-—-i, -

M*\ .

60/T 0 39V d 'h.L "^ f llS.ir i rSs'pdi^mgib^;:..' . .:v5ue . " p

. iOJtC e ...; . : ^ ^ai;^/w5f;iv^Auiuiasicnf;.>o u canjeithlS r cii'c-i e yOL i •.;i;'-.'*«•''• • ' " "^ ^ sa3-BM3 rnvAo a flTSQZ.^Bt' E 22:^ 0 8003/t72/f 0

...i . * •illl>i<,-'««<ail>«<ii.aj<*4ituu-'ai>OVQa r90 7 276726 1 A i A<i;^A N RO r . - • - - -• •-•-- ; : :^:^-- ^ • . -;: \v:- . vv . i;::;fr:..0a:34:11..p.m. , ,,„,07r19-201 0 ALASKA N KU O •.•

. • ...,;v...'_-.'•,'-i'vi~~<.5 : :- J ^-.v'lr'::;.^^^^ ^ " • -•• ; :-.••..-•:•-••••:-"'-." : •-.^•••• : - 19/6 5

UNITE D STATE S DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C . I N TH E MATTE RO F PRECISIO N DISPLAY S AN D TOOL S FAA DOCKE T NO . CP09AL00O 8 (Civi l Penalt

y Proceedhig ) DM S NO . FAA-2009-073 3 COMPLAINANT' S HRS T SE T O FREQUEST S FO RADMISSION , INTERROGATORIES , AN D REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N O FDOCUMENT S

\• • • • • . . To : Rober

t PerseldaQ , Owner . Prcoiaio n Display s an dTool s ' ,: , Pursuan t t o 1 4 Ci^.R . § 13J220 , ih o Complainant ; b y an dthroug hit s Regiona l Counsel , request s that

you , b y Jun e 14,2010 , make ttu> requeste dadmissions , answer th e following interrogatorie s under

oath , aiul identif

y an dproduc e th e requeste ddocument s fo r inspectio n and copyin g a t th e OfiRc e o f th e Regional Counsel , Alaska n Regio n FAA , 22 2 W . 7 * Avenue , Bo x 14 , Anohorage . Alask a99513-7587 . . ^ .^R.^ ^ ,^^.^,. . Thes e request s ar e deeme dcontinuing , an dan y informatio n secure dafter answerin g and/o r stqiplyin g th e requeste danswer s o r dociunenta^tem s i s t o b e supplie db y supplemental productio n pursuan t

t o § 13.220( 0 o f

th e Rule » o f

Practic e i n FA A Ci> ^ Penalt y Actions . B E ADVISE D that

1 4 C.F.R . § 13.220(1)(1 ) states , " A party' s failut e t o respon dt o a reques t fo r adinission , i n writin g andsigne db y th e attorne y o r th e party , no t

late r tha n 3 0 day s afte r servic e o f

th e request , i s deeme dan admissio n o f th e trut ho f th e statemen t

o r statement s containe di n th e reques t

fo r admission. ' 

# PsriNmQN s 1 . "Documents " means , regardles s o f origi n of location , an y handwriting , note , letter , manual , memorandim) , record , report , statement , study , drawing , sketch , photognqih . telegram , telex , o r message , whethe r

repotted , transcribed , pundied , taped , filme do r graphicall y represente di n an

y manner , o r

materia l o f an y kin dIn th e possessio n o f subjec t t o th e contro l of

, o r withi n th e knowledg e oi

^ Responclen

t and/o r Iii s ^ployecs , agents , consultants , o r experts . I f

&

^ 60/2 0 39V d Sa3T3«3 r IVAO a . l7lTS9iZ.0t'E ' Z2:i 0 800Z/fZ/f 0

-'•-'-••••^•^•^"-^'•^^^[flliHflmniifaff i», A= i^AMDr> r03:34:2 4 p.m . 07-19-201 0 20/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C

2 . "Identify " and/o r

"stat e th e identit

y of * withreferenc e t o individual s mean s state th e name , current

o r las t know n address , employer , andijo b descriptio n o r title , an dtelephon e number . 3 . **Identif

y al l documents " mean s stat e th e dat e an dautho r unles s apparen t

fromth e document . 4 . A s liste dherein , singula r pronoimaals o includ e th e plural . 5 . "You, " "your, " an d"Respondent " a s use dherei n refe r toPccdsio n Display s andTools , th e Respondent

i n thi s matter . REQUEST S FO RADMlSS|O K Pleas e admit

th e trutho f

eac ho f th e followin g statements : 1 . On o r abou t Ma y 9,2008 , Precisio n Display s an dTool s use dan employee , Lewi s Lourenco , t o o£fo

r asiupmoat

t o Alask aAirline s fo

r transportatio n b y ai r

ftcm Ketchikan , Alaska , t o Sa

n Diego , California .

- - • - ~ • - . , . . • ' . 2 . Th e above shipmeni ' wa s offcae dt o 'Alask aAirline s o n Ai r WaEybil l No . 02773106434 . 3 . The abov e shipmen t

i s describe do n th e abov e ai r waybil l a * consistin g o f

1 4 piece s wit

h atotal weigh t

o f 74 8 pound s andconsistin g o f tools , ladder , an dtotes . 4 . Th e abov e ai r

waybil l i s marke dt o indicat e tha t th e shipmen t

doe s no t contai n dangerou s goods . 5 . Th e abov e shipmen t

include daone-quar

t ca n o f Sunnyside llacque

r thinner , aone^pin

t ca n o f Minwax PolysbadeStStaiOj-three : 16-ounc e can s o f 3M'Supe r

7 7 multipurpos e adhesive , an dtwo-12-ounc e can s o f Premiu mD6co r

spray padnt . 6 . Sunnyside lacque r

thinner . Minwa

x Polyshade s stain , 3 M Supe r 7 7 multipurpos e adhesive , an dPremiu mD^cor spray pain t

are al l hazardau s material s unde r di e Hazardou s Material s Regulations . 7 . Th e abov e shipmen t

wa s no t marke dor . (abele din^yjnattp r tha t woul dindwat e tha

t i t comainedhazarddu8matOTids.'^5^^s:t^'.-^..;;r: " >.v^.---.-..^ ^ ^ - 8 . Ther e wa s n o shipper' s declaratio n for dangerou s good s that,wa s submitte dt o Alaska Airline s withth e ajjov e ai r waybill ; an dh o dsqgerou s good s nr e identijSedo n tti c abov e ai r waybill . 

# fc

60/e 0 39w

d"•

' saaiBMa

r "WAo a: ' '. , PUQQUQ^ Z ZZ'L Q 800z/i7z/t7 090 7 2767.26 1 ALASKA N ROC . •.; : ^ r: o j.-z;^-^;.:...:;.^:.,.^:^-^^^^^^^^^^^^ ^ ^ '^ ^

9 . A t th e tim e h e offisre

dth e above shipment , Lewi s Lourenc o ha dno t receive dthe trainin g sipecifie di n subpart

H o f par t 17 2 o f th e HM Rwithi n th e precedin g thre e yean , an dh e wa s not workin g unde r

th e direc t supervisio n o f

aproperl y trainedan dknowledgeabl e hazma t employee . 10 . A t th e tim e Lewi s Lourenc o offere dth e abov e shipment . Precisio n Display s an dTool s di dno t hav e arecor do f

curren t trainin g for

Lewi s Lourenc o tha t

containe dth e informatio n specifie dI n Sectio n 172.704(d ) o f th e HMR . INTERROGATORIE S AN D REQUEST S FO RPROD t JCTTn N 1 . Fo r eac ho f th e abov e request s fo

r admissio n tha

t yo u d o not

admit, explai n what

specific &ct 8 o r contention s i n eac hstatemen t yo u believ e ar e no t

tru ^ stat e all fact s Aa t

suppor t you r beliefii i n thi s regard , an dproduc e al l document s tha t si^^ipor t thes e belied . 2 . Identi ^ eac hperso n who myo u inten dt o cal l a s awitnes s at th e hearin g i n thi s matter , andfor eac hsuc hwitness , provid e asummai y o f th e expecte dtestimony . 3 . Fo r eac hperso n identifie di n respons e t o Intenogatot y No . 2 . produc e acop y o f eac hand ever y statement

mad e 1 ^ tha t

perso n i n whic hth e fhots an dcircumstance s o f matter s a t issu e h i thi s cas e ar e reference do r discussed . : - . 4 . D o yo u inten dt o presen t an y expert

witnes s testimon y a t

thalteailn g o f

thi s nutter ? I f so , the n provid e asynopsi s o f eac hexpert

witness ' testimony , stat e th e givund ^ fo r each exper t opinion , an dproduc e acurriculu mvitae fo r eac hexpert

witness . 5 . D o yo u conten dthat

Precisio n Display s an dTool s lack s th e ability t o pay di e propose d civi l penaltx'ZidllaoUthaiistatttleveiy^ctaip.o^ttdu ^ ybu^ten dt o rel y a t th e taearin g i n suppor t o f thi s contention , an dproduc e acop y o f eac han dever y document yo « intendto mttoduc e a t

th e hearin g i n thi s tnatte r i n siQ)poi t o f thi s contention . 6 . T o th e exten t

no t encompasse dmyou r

respons e t o an y of^^regoin g items , identif y an dproduc e ai l document s upo n whic hyo u expec t to rel y at th e hearin g o r

intnnduc e a s evidenc e in suppor

t o f you r positio n a t

th e hearin g I

n thi s matter . Requeste dthi s 12? ! da y o f Ma y 2010 . uv

v .; . ^.., ^ -^^.^_.. . - v §fif?^.jf^Jt'h& n yof

c tttSh^HOWAR

D L . MARTIN . J R :r,pr.v...:c. ; JlegionalCounsel^ . . ;es .

Olenn H . Brow n Sem'o r Attorney 3 . 60/1^ 0 39V d" 5a3T3M3 r TWAO y . . f ITSSZZ0t' E • ZZ:i 0 8002/^2/1^ 0

U1...4.1U M ••...^,^.,,,.^^,...^i,..M^-u...^ ^90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C J C A-.iii.Knt; . 03:34:5 2 p.m . 07-19-201 0 22/6 5

sy/f n -i-.^ H UNITE D STATE S DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D. C / n • r\r^--,~ '

I N THE MATTE

RO F PRECISIO N DISPLAY S AN D TOOL S FAA DOCKE T NO . CP09AL000 8 (Civi l Penalt

y Proceeding ) DM S NO . (>AA-2009^73 3 RESPONDENT' S REPL Y T O COMPLAINANT' S FIRS T SE T O FREQUEST S FO R ADMISSION , INTERROGATORIES , AN D REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N O F DOCUMENT S Respondent

answer s Complainant' s discover y reques t a s follows : REQUEST S FO RADMISSIO N Explanatio n fb

r Denial : ^ I imwt,iit--"'»'^t^»,J. ^ ...tm^^A.-:... . ^-ii>Wli'|rtrlnMiwanml« ^ i -i m,4*»*<^. y - ^ ~.^ - '

! ^ •'V - -

» V -• ^ > s r 2 . Admi t (Den y Explanatio n fo r

Deoiali^ps^ ^ -•X^

^ ^-'^"Je^r'-*:^'' " i«>/-^„^::..; ^ ^ , 

# BU T r DtJwpT ^' ^ '^<:>^J ^ ' ^ "^ „ ^ ' "^ ^ ^" ^ " ^ ' ^ 3 . Admi t (beay j . . -^.. ^ v v 

# ^ 'O^TnU. s O f ut^^ r Explanatio n for

Denial : 

## uy/» $ ^'^'^^^S:^i^'^f ^ i O h *^. : 60/5 0 39V d d.0fc£«,„ZZ:i 0 SOBZ/t-Z/f B90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:35:0 1 p.m . 07-19-201 0 23/6 5

4 . Adnxl t ^Den ^ Explanatio n for

Denial ; _ 5 . Admit (o&a^ ^ Explanatio n fo

r Denial : — > , - » . .*-. ^ / . ^ rtj^iJi^^T -

6 . (Admlj /

Deny Explanatio n fbr

Denial : o a 30. 0 i t j 11 1 . . ( J / I ' J .: '

7 . Admi t ^^Den y Explanatio n fo r

Denial : / . • ) 8 . Admit ny . " i l • • • ' • L .. . ' Explanatio n fb

r Denial : « > ^ 

# T tr)^\t ^ V ^ bBvnit^s . /^ecus r lykf/^i - ^JAS - s^^ ^ f^&i: ^ ^\^^ ^ Den

y Explanatio n fo r

Denial :

. r Admit 

# ^^mW ' ri^^'^'''^ ' -

' *-'*?r-"?'^Tt****--^'*-r-'' / ,-^*V— ; .^'--•-r' ' .•!|;**--'-*-'*^«r-^-i^*-* - Explanatio n for

Denial : K--0 ^ 

# :,.^ V . 60/9 0 3EW

d "afeGjiatta riVAoy, . „ ^ t-ngg^^i.B^ E zz:^ 0 800z/t7Z/f 090 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:35:0 8 p.m . 07-19-201 0 24/6 5

INTERROGATORIE S AND REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N 1 . Explanation s fo r

eac hdenial are provide dabove . Al l supportin g document s at e enclosed . 2 . 3 . 4 . • 'tV---^*^^' - *J*-;S«^^,iai«i»jti' + - I

6 . •« ' .?,T*l|i ^ •^ha^**^-l-fc«J*-»_i.l.,_^i

_,-. -

Submittedthi s ^ day o f

/ ^ 201 0 •:::T - .^^,,^,^^^^,^ . ^PRECISIO N DISPLAY S AN D TOOL S

:.^^?jj*5*JSs^*%*>V; - •?>#^'^*"?«*-?' ' • • •• - "yfe-/-'-4-^-'-'-!^3;'a.^a^i!BW*»^^.-*' - - ' 

# -•^^4 :

50//L 0 39W d sa3-i3M3 r"WAo a i'XX55Liet>E ZZ'-L B BmZ/trZ/P Q90 7 276726 1 ALASKANRO C 03:35:14p.m . 07-19-201 0 25/6 5 

# o U.S . Deputme mAlaska n Regio n o f Tianqxwtmio n OtElo e o f th « Regiona l CounM l (907 ) 271-357 0 vo/c e Federa l Aviatio n 22 2 Wes t Sevent hAvenu e #1 4 (907)271-280 0 fa x Admiaittraao mAjichortSiB , AlftSka99S13-7S8 7 crBig.blael(@foa.go v tmat i Jun e 11 . 201 0 VIA BOTH FIRS T CLAS S MAILAND CERTIFIE

D MAIL , RETUR

N RECEIPT REQUESTED Rober t Persekia n Precisio n Display s andTool s 155 5 AlumRock

Avenue , Suite 2 0 Sa n Jose , C A 9511 6 RE : Cas e 2008AL70003 9 Dea r Mr , Persekian , O n Ma y 12,2010 , thi s offic e sent t o yo u vi acertified , return-receip t requeste dmai l a

t you r addres s abov e our

first discov^ y reques t

i n thi s matter . Yesterday , th e Postal Servic e returne d ou r reques t t o u s unopene dandmarice d'Unclaimed" . Pleas e b e advise ddw t

any failur e by'yo#td^re6eiVe'm£Qll>rQperl y sent t o yot ^ recordinure s t o you , no t

us : put another way , yo u canno t

avoi dth e consequence s o f our servic e b y avoidin g your

mail . (g ) Vali dservice . A document tlia t wa s properly addressed , wa s sent in accordanc e wit

hthi s subpart , andtha

t wa s letumed , tha

t vva s no t claimed , o r

tha t was refused , i s denne dt o hav e bee n serve dmaccordanc e wit hthi s subpart . Ih e servic e shal l b e considere dvali da s of th e dat e andth e time tha

t th e document

wa s deposite dwit

hacontrac t

o r expres s messenger , th e documen t wa s mailed , or , ^ personal delivery o f

th e document

wa s refhsed . ' ' (h ) Presumptio ho f

service . There shal l b e apresumptio n o f servic e \dier c apart

y o r aperson , wdi

o customaril y receive s mail , o r receive s i t

i n th e ordinar

y cours e o f business , a

t eithe r th e person' s residenc e o r th e person' s principa

l plac e o f business , acknovtdedge s receip t o f th e document . 1 4 CF R§ 13.211(g) , (h) . Wha

t thi s mean s i n simpl e term s i s tha t servic e i s complete 'v^e n w e properl y mai l yo u things : an y failur e b y yo u t o clai mthos e thing s come s at your peril , no t ours...._ . .,^^«^^^^^STM-;wj:r^^^^ ^ Unde r 1 4 CFR§ 13.211(c ) an d.220(d),'-yo u mus t serv e your

discover y response s o n u s b y Jun e 16,2010 . I f

yo u fki l t o d o so , you shoul dexpec t apromp t motio n b y u s t o compel discover

y andfor sanctions , a s appropriate . 

# ^ 

# _£.^ r ( -j; - ^ - 5 • ~^ ^ 60/8 0 39V dJ^;iW^,Si^;;3^q,W^-^TV^:\' r ^fr^-yxPUSSlLQPE : ZZ'.L ^ 800Z/t'Z/t' 0

. , \..ji. . ....... . .i ; \^^U i i<j'i> i -...iC'CiciU . .. • ..ji J Lri.i : lini e K. . . ; ' . . t

t; . - :,.W'-;,. . •_, , .J . ,,, , .^.. . ,^i . ^^-^V ; .*^j. . , . , j. ^" . ','.;;.,,•:; • sv ;90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:35:2 8 p.m .

Rober t Persekia n CaseNo.2008AL70003 9 07-19-201 0 Jun e 11,201 0 26/6 5

I hav e assume dresponsibilit y fo r thi s cas e fromm y colleagu e Glen n H . Brown . I f yo u hav e an y question s o r

concerns , yo u ma y contac t m e a s se t

fort habove . Sincerely ,

..... . • I r. • . . 1 I I I I • a I . I I . I . i HOWAR D L . MARTIN , J R Regiona l Counse l

End : Lette r

fro mOlen n H . Brow n t o Rober t Persekian , Ma y 12,201 0 Complainant' s Firs t

Se t o f Request s fo r

Admission , Interrogatories , an dRequest s fo r Productio n o f

Document s Respondent' s Repl y t o Complainant' s Firs t Se t o f Request s fo r

Admission , InteiTOgatories , an dRequest s fo r Productio n o f

Document s (blan k for mfo r respondei^t o complete)_ „ ___

"'vb' - m?:'. - •••oTif^:' ' ff>.-;!-;;! x

ifv;.-.-----«.*r.5i>5i((^t-.,-'..n.- , '. . .»*,.-t;,;- „ . -rff^,-^,i..j.i^..*.-ij .

••,mi { * j i .M ^ for

Pi'cductiorLC t

Uocument s

-l:¥^^t*?*fe>* ^ "«f»:«agfra^*^. " i.-i**,.*_ J , -'T*' ' 

# _H

60/6 0 3W d 

### sy3i3M3 r ivAo y MigQiiiLOf E ZZ;/ 0 8002/^2/^ 090 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:35:3 5 p.m . 07-19-201 0 27/6 5

02 7 KT N 731 0 643 4 027-731 0 643 4 &hipp«f' » ^4sm « ant ) Addru s PRECISIO N JEWELR Y T 101 1 KNO W AV E SA N JOSE . C A9512 2 US A Tel : Shlppar ^ Accoun t Numba r Cusionwr* ! I D Numbv r 1522 4

Coniign*«' t Accoun t ^umb w Ai rWaybil l B y ALASK A AIRLIHC i KH0R120 H A I R ^ ^ P.O . 'BO X 6t»0 0 SEATTLE , W A *11& I »00-Z2S-Z7S 2 ALASKACARC0.CO M PRECISIO N DISPLAYS/ T 125 9 L AMEDI AR D SA N DIEGO , C A X US A A l u notif y

Tel : 61 9 708-244 1 Tel : Issuin g Ca'Tler' s Agen t ftnd Cit y

Agent' , lAT ACod * Accoun t No " Alipor t o l Departu n (Addr . o ( Rn t Cwriat ) in d Requatla d Routin g Ketchika n Accountin g InlomwUo n PRECISIO N JEWELRY TOO L AN D SUPPL Y 101 1 KNO

W AV E SA N JOSE , C

A9512 2 US A Genera J Carg o 1522 4

1 5 B yFirs t Cante r SE AAlask a Airline s To/B y SA N To/B y Currenc y US D WT/VA L ledare d Velu e Fo rCarrleg e NV D Declare d VaX w Fo rCuttom e

NC V \ S 

## x l othe r Airpor t o f Destinatio n Sa n Dieg o FUgM/DU a A S 064/1 0 :|flhVDll *

A S 480/1 1 Amoun t o t lnsLjr«n »

XX X " T Handlln g Infomiatia n HFP U NO

A -t^tr-^'-.^u : op- -

Noo ( Pleca s Gros e

Wslgti l Corranodn y He m Mo . Ctwrgeatal a Weig m net* / Charg e Natur e ari d Quantit y• ( Good e (Ind . Olmanelort a o rVokjme ) 1 4 748. 0 748. 0 A S AGREE D TOOLS . LADDER , TOTE S



### p: :

1 4 748. 0 A S AGREE D Dims : 2 6 X 19x16x 5 :. - 29x10x8x 1 31x15x8x 1 30x17x14x 1 GE N 18x10x13x 1

Prapat d Welgli t Charg e • Cellae l "" ^ "'AS'AGREED ' I -mm-'y^^i^ ^ Valuttto n Ch«ro « f^V|Y(^134:6|!t7i! ^ I .O^i . ; .J: , 24x15x16x 1 J:^::f^2 x20x5x1 -

4 4 X 3 1 x2 3 X 1

Tota l othe rCharge * Du e Agen t Shippe rceitina a tha t H WpattkMlar a o n th e tac a hereo l u a come t an d tha t Inaota ra * an ypar t a f th e canalgrman t eonlal M dangaiwi a 9aa«a , aud i par t l a praparl ydaeerlbe d l>i rnam a »n t l a I n prope re«ndKla n fa rcarriag e b yai raecordlii g t o th « appMcaW a DangerBu a Oooti a nagutadona . I conaair t t o th e InapecHa n o f tlil e cargo . Tola ) Othe rCharga a Du e OvM t For : PRECISIO N JEWELR Y TOO L AN D Slorutur a o t Shiooe ro rhi s Aaen t T lANGEnou e GOOD S Av^ i idir- u Ketchika n TH

Tota l Prepai d A S AGREE D Tota l Collac I ' 0 9 Ma y200 8 11:4 2 E«aculad6 n lOale ) « 1 (Place ) Alask a Ajrilne s Signatur e o t Iss'uirig'CarTierV rH i Agent ,

..Bt.iiiii>.:«rj'-^i) ^ Wi^ta;<i)e«e«»K . o r 027-731 0 643 4



# , .._i, - -i-! 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C nHY-i.i-c;i<:)e) b l.i:k M t-KUn : 03:35:4 9 p.m . 07-19-201 0 28/6 5



## K y



# o ^:P'^0k^Ai^^f'^^S^jV ^ Ai r Carg o Dangerou s Good s Irregularit y Repor t INSTRUCTIONS : Phon e o r fa x thi s complete drepor t t o th e FAA . Photograph s ma y h e take n t o suppor t th e incident . (T o repor t

spill s o r leak s Involvin g dangerou s goods , us e DO T For m5800.1 , whic h ma y b e foun di n Firs t

Class . C o to : AS A Conferences/A S Environmentai/Sit E Forms . Q Quantit y exceed s allowe dlimit s Q Imprope r

insid e container s Q Insid e container s no t

oriente da s show n o n tli e packagin g ^<IZndeclarsdiHidde n Typ e o f incident : Q Erroneousl y declare d

Q Insufficient/imprope r absorptio n material s INITIA LINCIDEN T INFORMATION : Date/Tim e discovered : *S/<y^g> ^ 7 V 3C 7 Wher e an dho w discovere d(e.g . X-ray^gfiysica l tnspeotidft>spill , etc) : // ^ T^^ O Name/phon o numbe r

o f perso n reporting ; RitUi Lpf ^ A < ^-f ^ - Cf°l, } -^^^-SJ^ X Wher e ar e th e dangerou s good s now ? ^ t4/\ 7 tA/TT n t f^os^^y . la ^ >ci

O CARG O INFORMATION : Ai r Waybil l numbe r

o f item(s ) containin g Dangerou s Goods : /^/ c (r*Y^< f Typ e o f carg o involve d(e.g . Ooldstreak , Ooldrush , Cargo , etc) : / ^ ^/^ ^ ^ C^jii^ . ^ Prope r Shippin g Name ; U N Number ; Ar e ther e an y D Gl3)« s oi f O^^utsulS^ f

fiw^Jpment?^ \^*'«ir ^ t f yes.'^ha t

kind ? S:«Fiii.>nL ' o r

ta x IK H co^:^;iielt-iJ r , no. - : . ' : ; .-i.i . j ./u/<j^/J/'J'I. S ; ' Tota l numbe r

o f piece s offarc db y shipper . "^'^• ' ^ ' .•n./.'/.u'/Sc' : Tota l numberofpiece acontainin g Dangerou s Goods : a ^ ^ ' SHIPPE RINFORMATION : Name : /^fZ^^,^jxv, y Qjrf^^gz^f ^ y^: ^ ^^z ? AOP^^^/ ' Address;.. . foi\iCAJt>\ y f^(y^ . , 

### City : ^ ^••ii^d^^^>:^^T^^^;^i}r ^ ^ < ; ,^ ^ Telephon e numbe r

Y^/^iyT^y-Jg^i^^ / . , j ^ INCIDEN T DESCRIPTION ; Describ e th e dangerou s good s tha t wa s found , includin g type , amount , bran dnam e o r manufacturer , etc : ' (PAtS ^ "Sa . oz - CA ^ a P ^ViiA/ r 7»/Mii!t r

^/* f ^cM-t ^ H&i/i ^

--• - •tftUvfe d(e^.Golt}stx^lfttQblirtish;.C r ^-6 , etcV

J -V^. - >= #

T — 

# O ZK-a i (06X)3 ) A5A«0<mO-2-301 2 |^[MiiaB8»aai<pi|tMll4,IJI | |.„,i7 - TS . 

# £i ^

''^ftifXKXtty

m ,T'-'TV1t^/--'M!<i«rt- ^ 

# .i. . -j-'—.•< ; - • .j..-.JLic..**=jae(t- -

• < !90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:36:0 4 p.m . 07-19-201 0 29/6 5

U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N FEDERA LAVIATIO N ADMINISTRATIO N SECURIT- y t

HAZARDOU S MATERIAL S 

### 3 - 1

Photograp hshow s the unde^e dha^a t qffered:a^carg o by PRECISION|)ISPLAY S AN D TOOLS . Photographtaken on Ma

y 13^*2008, JsynASA

A Gustome

r Servic e A^ent , Richar

dChray , a t the ASA A carg o facilit

y a t the KetchikanyyrpOTt. * nv^f V Th e Hazma t wa s kep t and1 ^ Th e picture s wer

e recei v mad e t o the photographsjp

j

_Intervtewsd/Reviewe dO n 

### ^ Mi^SpeciafeVgenff

l FA AFor m 1600^2- 1 (g-M ) FO R OFFICIA L US E ONL Y (Publi ctvoum ^

lob * dttmnnhM d und f 5 US. C SSi }90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:36:1 6 p.m . 07-19-201 0 30/6 5

U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N FEDERA L AVIATIO N ADMINISTRATIO N SECURTT

Y & HAZARDOU S MATERIAL S 3 - 2

Photograp hshow s clos e up j Th e Hazmat

wa s kep t an dlater dispose do f

b y ASA A statio n pei^oqnely K KTN. =^. - -. . Th e picture s wer e receive dthroug hLotu s Note s an dtransferre dt o thi s cas e file . N o alteration s were mad e t o th e photograph s ptheiahanxopvin g the mfromXotu s Note s tQ-Microsoft-OfKceJVord . 

### '^^^^si^^m>^

-i^ r ^^fc ' V ir*-3»-Tftw

v '. ' '*i r-ywr . Interviewed/Reviewe d O n . g y Special Agen t

Jeffre y D^Uz', ' '':*^*;' v -^ ^ ^;^- ' % - ^ FA AFor m 1600-32- 1 (»«« ) *#•• . Fil e No . 2008AL70003 9 FO R OFFICIA L US E ONL Y (Publi cmrmllmbiniyt o b » dfmiUlm d undm r5 U.S.C . S5 y...ci^AMon r03:36:2 8 p.m . 07-19-201 0 31/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C Pag e 1 of 6 

## SUNNYSID E COR P - SUNNYSID E LACQUE RTHINNE R- - -

==================== = Produc t Identificatio n ============ = produc t ID:SUNNYSID E LACQUE R THINNE R MSD S Date:12/03/199 6 FS C : NUN : Submitte r : D D G Statu s Code: A MSD S Number : CKSX T == = Responsibl e Part y== = Compan yName:SUNNYSID E COR P Address:22 5 CARPENTE R AV E City:WHEELIN G State:I L ZIP : 60090-600 9 u.^o.^p. , Country:U S Inf o Phon e Num:708-541-570 0 Emergenc yPhon e Num:708-541-570 0 Chemtre c Ind/Phon e : (800 ) 424-930 0 r ^ v, , CAGE:9J57 0 == = Contracto r Identificatio n == = Compan yName:GRAVES-HUMPHREY S C O 

## • Address : 53;^0s^mmmmiEmm^?^:^' ^ Box : 13 4 0 7 '''^' " / i " - 5 City : ROANOK E , ^. ^ _. C State:V A ZIP:2403 3 Country:U S Phone:(800-336-5998 ) CAGE:1B236,;,. , ^«iti:tiasisEdiiii^A^/^.i,n^:-:^^^^^ ^ wv^;:: . -\^

- ..:.•. - •

• . 

### Compan yNamerNASC O INT L INC. , NASC O DI V Address:90 1 JANESVIL L AV E Box:City:FOR T ATKINSO N State:W I ZIP:53538-090 1 • Country:U S Phon e : 920-563-^4i_i^^^^^^^_,^4,^^^^^ . , • ••CAGE^:33089n - .-^^^^^t^^T ^ ••^-*^-^^^----'-''^^ ^ Compan yName:SUNNYSIDEiCOR P ?- n Addres s : 22 5 CAR£BNTER > iAVE4r;P;Y, 9 -C O Box:City:WHEELING . State:I L U 

### ZIP : 60090-600 9 ^^ - J z http://www2.siri.org/msds/f2/cks/cksxt.htm l 5/14/200 8I 907276726 1 ALASKA N ROCy^^P^Bsl'^^^^'^f^^^^^^ ^ -X)7-19-201 0 32/6 5 

### I Pag e 2 o f 6 ; | Country : U S I Phone:847-541-570 0 j Contrac t

Num:MDA414-99-A-0001-062 8 1 CAGE:9J57 0

============ = Composition/Informatio n o n Ingredient s Ingre d Name:ACETON E (SAR A313 ) (CERCLA ) CAS:67-64- l RTEC S #:AL315000 0 Othe r RE C Limits:NON E RECOMMENDE D OSH APEL;100 0 PP M ACGI H TLV:750PPM/1000STEL;959 6 EP ARp t Qty:50 0 0 LB S DO T Rp t Qty: 5 00 0 LB S Ingre d Name:ETHY L ACETAT E (CERCLA ) CAS:141-78- 6 RTEC S #:AH542500 0 Othe r RE C Limits:NON E RECOMMENDE D OSH APEL;40 0 PP M ACGI H TLV:40 0 PPM ; 959 6 EP ARp t Qty:500 0 LB S DO T Rp t Qty:500 0 LB S Ingre d Name : ISOPRp,PXL,.ALCQH9i^;(S^^S^,^A;3 ) . ^ , CAS:67-63-0 : r • : RTEC S #:NT805000 0 Othe r RE C Limits;:NON E • RECOMMENDE D OSH APEL: 4 0 0 PP M ACGI H TLV:40 0 PPM/5OOSTEL7959 6 Ingre d Name:V M & P , NAPHTH A • CA S :64742-89 - Qj^..-^--^^?::^^:,^^^ ^ ..: ^ «;:^^:-.S?^^;^. ^ T'^r^:"'- - •r:p-;-~r^^^A . > • -. . 

### Othe r RE C Limit' s cNONEgR^COMMENDE D Ingre d Name:TOLUEN E (SAR A313 ) (CERCLA ) CAS:108-88- 3 RTEC S #:XS525000 0 Othe r RE C Limits:NON E RECOMMENDE D OSHA PE L: 2 0 p . PPMv/T^ag ^ .^:57;s,.;^;^ . ' zT^^^iTT^rvwm^^-^-- . ACGI H TLV : S , 5WPPM|^959 6 

### ' EP A Rp t

Qty:100 0 LB S ; 

## ^ 6 http://www2.siri.org/msds/f2/cks/cksxt.html 5/14/200 8

•'/^' " '" ^ • '^ ^ • " • " ' •90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:36:4 8 p.m . 07-19-201 0 33/6 5 

### Pag e 3 o f 6 

### DO T Rp t Qty:100 0 LB S Ingre d Name;2-BUTOXYETHANO L CAS:lll-76- 2 RTEC S #:KJ857500 0 Othe r RE C Limits;NON E RECOMMENDE D OSH APEL:S , 5 0 PP M ACGI H TLV:S,.2 5 PPM ; 959 6

==================== = Hazard s Identificatio n ============ = Route s o f Entry : Inhalation:YE S Skin:YE S IngestionYE S Report s o f Carcinogenicity:NTP:N O IARC:N O OSHA:N O Healt h Hazard s Acut e an d Chronic:TARGE T ORGANS : THER E I S AP HAZAR D (FROM TOLUENE ) T O TH E CENTRA L ^IJ^^y^qp S ;X'STEM , KID N SENS E OF'^HEARING . 

### EY E CONTACT : SEVEREL Y IRRITATING . MA Y TISSU E PERMANENTLY . SKI NCON T ACT : SKI NIRRITANT . PROL O REPEATE D SKI NCONTAC T CA NCAUS E DERMATITIS . INHALATION : HIG H VAPO R CONCENTRATION S MA Y RESUL T I NRESPIRATOR Y TRA C IRRITATION , CENTRA L NERVOU S SYSTE M DEPRES S ION , LIVE R & DAMAGE . BRAI NCEL L DAMAG E MA Y RESUL T FRO M LONGTER M VAP O INHALATION . INGESTION : SMAL L AMOUNT S O F THI S PRODUC T AS P

- TH E RESP!^5^AW0RY-:'SYSTE M DURIN G 'INGESTIONOR ' VOMITIN G MAY T O SEVER E PULMONARYKINJURY , 

### Explanatio n ofjCarcinogenicity:THER E I S INADEQUAT E DAT AAVA I EVALUAT E TH E RIS K O F DEVELOPIN G CANCE R FRO M EXPOSUR E T O PRESEN T I NTHI S PRODUCT . HOWEVER , NON E O F TH E SOLVENT S I PRODUC T AR E CARCINOGEN S O R POTENTI AL CARCINOGEN S B Y TH E O R OSHA . E.f,fgp,t. g of^.OiV-eJSf3CRp5«^ed'SK5Jfe^^©J^TAg]?iPJlA55^GEi ^ S CA NCAUS E DERMATITIS / DRYING , CRACKTNG ; OF - SKIN . INHALAT I CAUS E HEADACH E & DIZZINESS ; A:UNgONS.CIOUSNES S . Medica l Con d Aggravate d b yExposur e :CONpiT'i;pN S AGGRAVATE D B Y MA Y INCLUD E SKI NDISORDERS , RESPIRATOR Y (ASTHMALIKE ) C O KIDNE Y DISORDERS , LIVE R DISORDERS . Firs t Aid ; EYES-MOV E _VI.eT3;M^.AWAY..FR0W_EXf?0SaRE: & INT O FRES H A EYE S WIT H WATER - FDRTI.SIMJNSLWHIL E 

### iHOLDIN G EYELID S OPEN . ATTENTION . SKIN-REMOV E ;CONTAMINATED>SH0E S & CLOTHING . F O

SOA P & WATER . I F IRRITATIO NPERSIST , GE T MED I INHALAT I ON-USING PROPE R RESPIRATOR Y PROTECTI O WAS H WI T H ATTENTION .

• ] T 

### http://www2.siri.org/msds/f2/cks/cksxt.htni l 5/14/200 8

r. T 

### .ROLaN(.:> .90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:37:0 5 p.m . 07-19-201 0 34/6 5 Pag e 4 of 6 

### IMMEDIATEL Y REMOV E VICTI M INT O FRES H AIR . I F RESPIRATOR Y PERSIST S SEE K MEDICA L AT T ENTION . I F NO T BREATHING , IMM E BEGI NARTIFICIA L RESPIRATION . I F BREATHIN G I S HARD , OXY G B E GIVE NB Y QUALIFIE D PERSON . INGESTIO ND O NO T INDUC E V O OCCURS , KEE P HEA D BELO W HIPS . GE T MEDICA L ATTENTIO NIMM

==================== = Fir e Fightin g Measure s ============ = Flas h Poin t Method:TC C Flas h Point:=-17.60 , O. F Autoignitio n Temp:=237.8C , 460. F Autoignitio n Temp Text:MINIM U Lowe r Limits:2. 6 % Extinguishin g Media:EITHE R ALLO W FIR E T O BUR NUNDE R CONTROL L CONDITION S O R EXTINGUIS H WIT H ALCOHO L TYP E FOA M & DRY C H T O COVE R LIQUI D SPILL S WIT H FOAM . Fir e Fightin g Procedures:US E WATE R SPRAY T O COO L FIR E EXPOS E & T O PROTEC T PERSONNEL . SHU T OF F "FUEL " T O FIRE . I F AL E HA S NOT-^IGNJTED^^USE'TWATE R ISPRAY"TOI;DISPERS E 

### TH E VAPOR S . Unusua l Fire/Explosio n Hazard:EXTREMEL Y FLAMMABLE . VAPOR S M A FLAS H FIR E O R IGNIT E EXPLOSIVELY . VAPOR S MA Y TRAVE L CON S DISTANC E T O ASOURC E O F IGNITIO N&V;,FLAS H BACK . PREVEN T B VAPO R O R GASE S T O EXPLOSIV E C ONCENTRATIONS .

Accidenta l Releas e Measure s ==========: = Spil l Releas e Procedures:REMOV E IGNITIO NSOURCES , EVACUAT E A BREATHING VAPORS ^ OR , CONTAC T WIT H LIQUID . US E NONSPARKI N EXPLOSIO NPROOF-EQUIPMENT. , RECOVE R FRE E LIQUI D O R STO P L POSSIBLE . DIK E LARG E S P ILL S & US E ABSORBEN T MATERIA L F O SPILLS . KEE P SPILLE D MATERIA L OU T O F SEWERS , DITCHE S & B WATER . WAR NOCCUPANT S & SHIPPIN G I NSURROUNDIN G & DOWNW I FIR E & A^PJjQS$P^jti?^;?AJy2,diEWI.THStAT^OH0i ^ & D.^^ Y n ^III^UID-'JSPIT-.";'': ? WTT M •A'?' "

. : 1 •.:..' . i . i.,. : •.••,.'..• • • r ' j i: . _ j 

### Handlin g an d Storag e Precautions:KEEP-AWAY'^FRO M HEAT , SPARK S KEE P CONTAINER S CLOSE D WHE NNO T I NUSE . AVOI D EY E CONTA C PROLONGE D CONTAC T WIT H SKIN . GROUN D CONTAINER S WHE NTRA N 

# LIQUI D T O FR3y^miu.sjj^3:xQ.JiCCJMux^ ^ _ othe r ^ Precauti'oRslI^WBTYi^tJHTKTJtJERSj^E^X'lN^ ^ DU E AN D CA N DANGEROUS . D

O NOT'PRESSURIZE , CUT , WELD , BRAZE , SOLDER , GRIN D OREXPOSE-SUCHiCONTAINER S TO.HEAT7;rFLAME , SPARK S O http://www2.siri.org/msds/f2/cks/cksxt.html 

# e 5/14/200 8 iT'J.'C. * •'|!^"'T^''T'p' '90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:37:2 3 p.m . 07-19-201 0 35/6 5 Pag e 5 o f 6 O F IGNITION . THE Y MAY'EXP L OD E & CAUS E INJUR Y O R DEATH , ATTEMP T T O CLEA NSINC E RESIDU E I S DIFFICUL T T O EMOVE .

============ = Exposur e Controls/Persona l Protectio n Respirator yProtection:APPROPRIAT E VAPO R CANISTER , SILF-CON T BREATHIN G APPARATU S O R SUPPLIED-AI R HOS E MASK , I F NEEDE D Ventilation:EXHAUS T VENTILATIO NSUFFICIEN T T O KEE P SRBORN E CONCENTRATION S BELO W RESPECTIV E TLV'S , Protectiv e Gloves:WEA R RESISTAN T GLOVE S SUC H A S NITRIL E RUB B Ey e Protection:CHEMICA L SAFET Y GOGGLES . Othe r Protectiv e Equipment:IMPERVIOU S CLOTHIN G O R BOOTS , I F Wor k Hygieni c Practices:D O NO T REUS E CLOTHIN G UNTI L CLEANED . Supplementa l Safet yan d Healt h VENTILATION-I T I S NO T RECOMMENDE D THA T Tf^| ^ ^pi^pDUf;;.T „ BE , USE D , SPACE S O R I NAMANNE R THA T WIL L ALLOW ' ACCUMULATIO NO F H I CONCENTRATIONS . HOWEVER , FO R CONTROLLE D INDUTRIA L USE S W PRODUC T I S USE D I NCONFINE D SPACE , HEATE D ABOV E AMBIEN T AGITATED , US E EXPLOSIO NPROO F VENTILATION . Physical/Chemica l Propertie s ========= =

l-^N' ] HCC:F 2 Boilin g Pt:=56 . IC , 1_33, F Melt/Freez e P t :,iyi . P/F . Pj^Tex t :NQT , GIVE N Vapo r Pres:NO T GIVE N Vapo r Density: > 1 Spe c Gravity: < 1 Evaporatio n Rat e . & Reference: < 1 (ETHER=1 ) Solubility_,lA,J'^AJ^^;jM.9J;:!fiL5^Tl'M p non^r - - - Appearanc e an d Odor:CLEAR,-COLORLESSi^LIQUID,:'MILD . SOLVEN T O D Percen t Volatil^ s b y,VpJ.umejJ.^p, Q % 

### TH . ================ = Stability,an d React.ivit yDat a ========= = Stabilit yIndicator/Material s t o Avoid:YE S STRON G O X IDI Z INg^^^p^Sa^jtiKSiN^i^UjJje^liMIJaiifi^ ^ D Stabi1it yConditio h 't o Avoid:HEAT , SPARK S AN D FLAME . Hazardou s Decompositio.n/:Prpduct.s,:,THERWAL . DECOMPOSITIO NMA Y Y DIOXID E AN D CARBO NMONOXIDE . Toxicologica l Informatio n

:. . V .-r> i i^M g TM^J^M.-S..^jjgjlSffe-; < http://www2.siri.org/msds/f2/cks/cksxt.htm l L•e ^ • .-..L:L'z:±-:ince:-- : •'-• • -:7:;^^:ri7z^3:><:^0^ . 5/14/200 8 "r.rr. ' I •>90 7 276726 1 ALASKANRO C t 03:37:3 8 p.m . 07-19-201 0 36/6 5 Pag e 6 o f 6 Toxicologica l Information:DEVELOPMENTAL : POTENTIA L HAZAR D T O CHRONI C EFFECTS : ISOPROPY L ALCOHO L HA S BEE NREPORTE D I N LABORATOR Y ANIMA L STUD Y T O B E FETOTOXI C A T LEVEL S O F 2. 5 DRINKIN G WATER . N O TERATOGENI C E F FECT S WERE , O R HAV E B E REPORTED . THER E AR E N O REPORT S O F ADVERS E REPRODUCTIV E E HUMAN S EXPOSE D T O ISOPROPY L ALCOHOL . Disposa l Consideration s Wast e Disposa l Methods:SEN D T O ALICENSE D RECLAIME R O R INCI N DISPOS E O F I NACCORDANC E WIT H LOCAL , STAT E AN D FEDERA L R MSD S Transpor t Informatio n ========== = Transpor t Information:TRANSPORTATIO N(U.S.D.O.T . LAN D TRANS P PACKAGE S O F 11 9 GALLON S O R LESS) : PROPE R SHIPPIN G NAME : RELATE D MATERIAL . HAZAR D CLASS : 3 . PACKIN G GROU P II . IDENTIFICATIO NNUMBER : UN1263 . "R E FE R T O 4 9 CF R FO R AD D INFORMATION;.h'f:XGE.RT:IpNS-:'iOR-EXEMP,TION S .MAY - EXIS T FO R SMA L QUANTITIES. "

==================== = Regulator yInformatio n ============ = SAR ATitl e II I Information:TOLUENE , CAS # 108-88-3 , 20.29% . G (ETHYLEN E GLYCO L MONOBUTY L ETHER) , CAS # llt76-l , 2.25% . III - HAZARD«dGAaJEGDRIi:^-pti;^|:nSA^,Prc(<A^GiJf f , - DELAY E D HEALTH , FIRE. ' Stat e Regulatory 4 Inform.^tion:P.ALIFRONI:A. - PORPpiSTIO N65 : THI S CONTAIN S TOLUENE, ; ACHEMICA L KNOWN-.T O JH E STAT E O F CALI F CAUS E BIRT H DEFECT S O R OTHE R REPRODUCTIV E HAR M AN D TRAC E BENZENE , ACHEMICA L KNOW NT 0 TH E STAT E O F CALIFORNI AT O CANCER . Disclaime r (provideq i • with ; this " .informatio n b yth e compilin g Thi s informatio n i s formulate d fo r usevb y-element s o f th e D o f Defense . Th e Unite d State s o f Americ a i n n o manne r wha t expressl yo r implied , warrant s thi s informatio n t o b e accu r disclaim s al l li^ility,Xor.JL£.5^.;iS^.«.^.i^ay^^p.ej ^ documen t shouldTsee k competen t professional , advic e t o veri f assum e responsibility.cifo r .the . suitabilit yo f thi s informat i pa:rticula r situation.MoiS-O B iTYiifrEiP'^R ' , . c/- # : fvi-T^ V

. ..,_^ . : ^ http://www2.siri.org/msds/f2/cks/cksxt.html 5/14/200 8

:. : , O.J : K ^ •f'TTI^!^ " • • .^!^ N n T^i^^ '

' %^ ^ -" % % ^

1 ?'•>• ' ^

iJ i '- t90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:37:5 5 p.m . 07-19-201 0 37/6 5

^90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N ROC . 03:38:15.p.m . 07-19-201 0 38/6 5



## S B



# " I

• s u •

OiM O

* s a q

« o 

# I

3 

# shl h

••p f 

# f i 

# 1

O • 9 S 

# 1 ! 5 

# 1 1 ! - 2 s 8 - IT S

a j • > « 

# I

a i 

# i : V a u u ^ 3 ,. ^ e i i S . • § S v 4 4 f « •- 4 A > 

# 1 ?i ?

• ». o ^ n u O 9 . & u 

# i l ^ 4

> ' H 

### s s C '- ' o o U M * * • 4 C

; • ••*• ? 

## . F

. .JL - ^• - ff » ** -90 7 276726 1 ALASKANRO C 03:38:3 5 p.m . 07-19-201 0 39/6 5

I 3 M MATERIALSAFETY DAT A SHEE T 3IV1(TM

> Supe r 77(TM ) Multlpurpot e AJhtslv e (Aerosol ) 04/16/200 7 

### ai. | Materia l Safety Dat aShee t Copyright , 2007,3 M Company . A H rights reserved. Copyin g and/oT downloadin g o f thi s infonnatio n fo r

th e purpos e o f

propyerl y utilizin g 3 M product s i s allowe dprovide dthat : (I ) th e informatio n i s copie di n ful l with n o change s unles s prio r writte n agreemen t

i s obtaine dfrom3M , an d(2 ) neithe r th e cop y no r

th e origina l i s resol do r

otherwis e distribute dwithth e .intentio n o f earnin g aprofi t thereon . 

### I SECTIO N 1 ; PRODUC T AN D COMPAN Y IDENTIFICATIO N PRODUC T NAME : 3M(TM ) Supe r 77(TM ) Multipurpos e Adhesiv e (Aerosol ) MANUFACTURER : 3 M

DIVISION : Constructio n An dHom e Improvemen t Prod s ADDRESS : 3 M Cente r

St . Paul , M N 55144-100 0 I EMERGENC Y PHONE : 1-800-364-357 7 o r (651 ) 737-650 1 (2 4 hours ) \ Issu e Date : 04/16/200 7 Supercede s Date : 04/16/200 7 Documen t

Group : 22-4025- 7 * Produc t Use : Intende dUse : Adhesiv e aeroso l Specifi c Use : , Genera l Purpos e Aeroso l adhesiv e 

### SECTIO N 2 : INGREDIENT S Ingredien t

C.A.S . No . % b v W t NGN-VOLATIL

E COMPONENT S (N

J TRADE SECRE

T #04499600-6433P) v^" " Trade Secret . • - ' v 20-3 0 ACETON E • •-^-'•WWt^.;»f'>ft.?J<MHm',«-—*-,<Wi»"r>m-.--r— - -ixr^^y^. } - -.-- > .iwr-? - -.-:20--3 0 PROPAN E rST^r]! - AND^;O^M'A^-^ ' » ^ ' T74-98-6V'^"^^ ; 15-2 5 2-METHYLPENTAN

E ~ ~ ' 107-83-5 " ~ 10-2 0 CYCLOHHXAN

E u'^ , •.,/.(TNf ) .MMbv.-^-. t Adh.s.v . "v'10-82- 7 3- 7 3-METHYLPENTAN

E ' 96-14- 0 3- 7 2,2-DIMETHYLBUTAN

E 75-83- 2 1- 3 2,3-DIMETHYLBUTAN

E ' 79-29- 8 1- 3 HEXAN E 110-54- 3 < 0. 8 

### SECTIO N 3 ; HAZARD S ^DENTIyICATJOJ^^..,v^,.j..r,..>..^^v ^ . | : 3. 1 EMERGENC

Y OVERVIE

W' Specifi c Physica l Form : Aeroso l Odor , Color , Grade : clear , swee t fruity odo r Genera l Physica l Form : Ga s aeroso l Immediat e health , physical , an deDvironmenta l hazards : Close dcontainer s exposedt o hea t fro mfire may buil dpressur e an d

:-•'-.*:-•w.^AiaaaA'*'!^-^- . Pag e 1 o f 

### "": " . -^-^ ^

-- ; ^ ~ "- " • ~ (. • i r907276726 1 ALASKANRO C . 03:38:47p.m . 07-19-201 0 40/6 5

f3 M MATERIALSAFETY DAT A SHEE T 3M(TM ) Supe r 77(T.'Vt > Multipurpoi e Adhesiv e (Aerosol ) 04/16/200 7 ' " ~ ) explode . Extremel y flammable liqui dan dvapor . Vapor s may trave l lon g distance s alon g th e groun do r floo r t o a n ignitio n sourc e an d flas hback . Aeroso l containe r contain s flammabl e materia l unde r pressure . Ma y caus e targe t orga n effects . Contain s a chemica l o r

chemical s whic h ca n caus e birthdefect s o r othe r reproductiv e harm . 3. 2 POTENTIA LHEALT H EFFECT S Ely e Contact : Moderat e Ey e Irritation : Signs/symptom s ma y includ e redness , swelling , pain , tearing , an dblurre do r haz y vision . Ski n Contact : Prolonge do r

repeate dexposur e may cause : Mil dSki n Irritation : Signs/symptom s ma y includ e localize dredness , swelling , an ditching .

Inhalation : Intentiona l concentratio n an dinhalatio n ma y b e harmfu l o r fatal . Respirator y Trac t

Irritation : Signs/symptom s ma y includ e cough , sneezing , nasa l discharge , headache , hoarseness , an dnos e an d throa t pain . Ma y D e absorbe dfollowin g inhalatio n an dcaus e targe t orga n effectsl'i v ' ^ ' ' • • : ' Ingestion : Gastrointestina l Irritation : Signs/symptom s ma y includ e abdomina l pain , stomac hupset , nausea , vomitin g an ddiarrhea . Ma y b e absorbe dfollowin g ingestio n an dcaus e targe t organ effeas . Targf t Orga n Effects : Centra l Nervou s Syste m(CNS ) Depression : Signs/symptom s ma y includ e headache , dizziness , drowsiness , incoordination , nausea , slowe dreactio n time , slurre dspeech!'giddmess , an diinconsciousness."" - '^ ^ ' ' " '! ' ^i i iv Prolonge do r

repeate dexposur e ma y cause : Periphera l Neuropathy : Signs/symptom s may include ' tinglin g o r numbnes s o f

th e extremities , incoordination , weaknes s o f th e hand s an dfeet , tremor s an dmuscl e atrophy . Contain s achemica l o r

chemical s whic hcan caus e birth defect s o r othe r reproductiv e harm . 

### SECTIO N 4 : FIRS T AI D MEASURE S 4, 1 FIRS T AI D PROCEDURE S Th e followin g first

ai drecommendation s ar e base do n ajijssumptipn_tha t appcppriat c persona l an dindustria l hygien e practice s ar c followed. .._,i-r:i-:^^^i;;^:::i,.;i^..:^ ^ -. - • followed . -"=^5 ^ Ey e Contact : Flus heye s wit hlarg e amount s o f

water . I f

signs/symptom s persist , ge t medica l attention . Pag e 2 o f 8

^ ^ O



## ,.^o : S iAiAcu-AMRO r 03:38:5 9 p.m . 07-19-201 0 41/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C

I3 M MATERIALSAFETY DAT A SHEE T 3M(TM ) Supe r 77(TM ) Multipurpos e AJhe»tv e (Aerosol ) 04/16/200 7 " )

Ski n Contact : Was haffecte dare awit hsoa p an dwater . I f signs/symptom s develop , ge t medica l attention . Inhalation : Remov e perso n t o fres hair . I f signs/symptom s develop , ge t medica l attention . I f Swallowed : D o not

induc e vomitin g unles s instructe dt o d o s o b y medica l personnel . Giv e victi mtw o glasse s o f water . Neve r giv e anythin g b y moutht o an unconsciou s person . Ge t medica l attention . SECTIO N 5 : FIR E FIGHTIN GMEASURE S 5. 1 FLAMMABL

E PROPERTIE S Autoignitio n temperatur e N o Dat aAvailabl e Flas hPoin t

-42.0 0 T [Tes t Method : Tagliabu e Close dCup ] Flammabl e Limit s - LE LN o Dat aAvailabl e Flammabl e Limit s - DE LN o Dat aAvailabl e OSH A Plammabllit y Classification : Clas s l A Flammabl e Liqui d 5. 2 EXTINGUISHIN GMEDI A Us e fire extinguisher s withclas s B extinguishin g agent s (e.g. , dr y chemical , carbo n dioxide) . 5. 3 PROTECTIO N O FFIR E FIGHTER S Specia l Fir e Fightin g Procedures : Wea r ful l protectiv e equipmen t

(Bunke r Gear ) an daself-containe dbreathin g apparatu s (SCBA) . • ' s - Unusua l Fir e an dExplosio n Hazards : ' Close dcontainer s exptose dt o hea t fromfire ma y buil dpressur e an dexplode . Extremel y flammabl e liqui dan dvapor . Vapor s ma y trave l lon g distance s alon g th e groun do r floor t o an ignitio n sourc e an dflash back . Aeroso l containe r contain s flammabl e materia l underpressure . Tt; ; foTTT^ii . vel . •> , . v • - • ':.:..: : Note : Se e STABILIT Y AN D REACTIVIT Y (SECTIO N 10 ) fo r hazardou s combustio n an dtherma l decompositio n infonnation . SECTIO N 6 : ACCIDENTA LRELEAS E MEASURE S Accidenta l Releas e MeasureSJKcfefl o othe r section s o f

thi s MSD S fo r

informatio n regardin g physica l an dhealthhazards , respirator y protection , ventilation , an dpersona l protectiv e equipment . Cal l 3M-HELP S lin e (1-800-364-3577 ) fo r mor e informatio n o n handlin g an dmanagin g th e spill . Evacuat e unprotecte dan duntraine dpersonne l fro mhazar darea . Th e spil l shoul db e cleane dup b y qualifie dpersonnel . Remov e al l ignitio n source s suc ha s flarnes , smokin g materials , an delectrica l spark sources . Us e onl y non sparkin g tools . Ventilat e th e are awithfres hair . Workin g fro maroun dth e edge s o f th e spil l inward , cove r

withbentonite , vcrmiculite , o r

commerciall y availabl e inorgani c absorben t material . Mi x in sufficien t absorben t

unti l it appear s dry . Collec t

a s muc h o f th e spille dmateria l a s possibl e usin g non-sparkin g tools . Clea n u p residu e withan appropriat e organi c solvent . Rea dan dfollo w safet y precaution s o n th e solven t labe l an dMSDS . Plac e in ameta l containe r approve dfor

transportatio n b y appropriat e authorities . Sea l th e container . Dispos e o f collecte dmateria l a s soo n a s possible . • 1 " '•/ . I n th e even t

o f areleas e iftf.thb nut^^jil i th e user;sboul ddetermin e i f th e releas e qualifie s a s reportabl e accordin g t o local , state , an dfedera l regulations . - " ^ .•.'- ' SECTIO N 7 : HANDLIN GAN D STORAG E 7. 1 HANDLIN G

>^:• ^ - <,.KKbr"^s!t)^iP>Asif'^!^' " i*iiuMyi#wniruiiiiiBiiiitt^iigwwB"ag^^^ ^90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:39:1 6 p.m . 07-19-201 0 42/6 5

I 3 M MATERIA LSAFET Y DAT A SHEE T 3M(TM ) Supe r 77(TM ) Multipurpos e Adhesiv e (Aerosol ) 04/16/200 7 _ J D o no t eat , drin k

o r smok e whe n usin g thi s ftroduct . Was hexpose darea s thoroughl y withsoa p an dwater . Kee p awa y fromheat , sparks , ope n flame, pilo t light s an dothe r

source s o f

ignition . D o no t

pierc e o r bu mcontainer , eve n after use . N o smokin g whil e handlin g thi s material . D o no t spra y nea r

flames o r

source s o f

ignition . Avoi dbreathin g o f vapors , mist s o r

spray . Avoi dey e contac t withvapors , mists , o r

spray . Kee p out

o f th e reac ho f

children . Vapor s ma y ignit e explosively . May caus e flash fire. Preven t build-u p o f vapor s - ope n al l window s an ddoors . Maintai n vapo r concentration s belo w recommende dexposur e limits . Us e onl y wit hcross ventilation . Withou t

adequat e ventilation , vapor s may settl e i n low-lyin g areas . Kee p awa y fi^omheat , sparks , an dope n flame. D o no t smok e o r ignit e matches , lighters , etc . 7. 2 STORAG E Stor e awa y fro macids . Stor e awa y fro mheat . Stor e ou t o f direc t sunlight . SECTIO N 8 : EXPOSUR E CONTROLS/PERSONA LPROTECTIO N 8. 1 ENGINEERIN GCONTROL S Us e withappropriat e loca l exhaus t ventilation . Us e in a

n enclose dproces s are ai s recommended . Us e wit hfunctioning spray boot h o r loca l exhaust . Us e i n awell-ventilate darea . I f exhaus t ventilatio n i s no t

available , us e appropriat e respirator y protection . D o no t us e in aconfine dare ao r

area s withlittl e o r

n o ai r movement . Us e genera l dilutio n ventilatio n and/o r loca l exhaus t

ventilatio n t o contro l airborn e exfiosure s t o belo w Occupationa l Exposur e Limit s and/o r contro l mist , vapor , o r

spray . I f

ventilatio n i s not

adequate , us e respirator y protectio n equipment . D o no t us e i n aconfine dare ao r area s withlittl e o r

n o ai r movemen t

I f exhaus t ventilatio n i s no t adequate , us e appropriat e respirator y protection . Provid e ventilatio n adpquat^e t o contro l vapo r concentration s belo w recommende d exposur e limit s and/o r

contro l spray o r

mist . 8. 2 PERSONA LPROTECTIV E EQUIPMEN T (PPE ) - S.2. 1 Eye/Fac e Protectio n Avoi dey e contac t

with vapors , mists , o r

spray . Th e followin g ey e protection(s ) ar e recommended : Safet y Glasse s with sid e shields . ina5SSetttet)TJSSW^-l>auB3t«aS?Kc«;p^W»<«y;fisS«^ ^ upvn ii.iii, c 8.2. 2 Ski n Protectio n Avoi dski n contact . ,',;:i c voiti r Selec t an dus e glove s and/o r

protective , clothin g t o preven t ski n contac t

base do n th e result s o f

a n exposur e assessment . Consul t with you r glov e and/o r

protectiv e clothin g manufacture r for selectio n o f

appropriat e compatibl e materials . Glove s mad e fro mth e followin g matcrial(s ) ar e recommended : Polycthylene/Ethylen e Viny l Alcohol . 8.2. 3 Respirator y Protectio n Avoi dbreathin g o f

vapors , mist s o r

spray . ' Selec t on e o f th e followin g NIOS H approve drespirator s base do n airborn e concentratio n o f contaminant s an di n accordanc e wit h OSH A regulations : Hal f facepiec e o r

fiillfac e air-purifyin g respirato r withorgani c vapo r

cartridges . Consul t

th e curren t

3 M Respirator y Selectio n Guid e fo r additiona l informatio n o r cal l 1-800-243-463 0 for 3 M technica l assistance . 8.2.4 1 Preventio n o f

Syaijqwjagiilllti^kwaiiii t l!!ffigrr g D o no t eat , drin k

o r smok e whe n vsin g (hi s pro(jlfJct.^^as h expose darea s thoroughl y wjt h^ p an dwater . 8. 3 EXPOSirR E GUIDELINE S Ingredien t ACETON E ACETON E ACETON E ACETON E ACETON E •CYCLOHEXAN E CYCLOHEXAN E •...I . i: , .iccjiiiintt ! avca'o r art.i, > v.it h\\\ut ' or n<i... . ;Tn.i\ei

i Authorit y Typ e Limi t ACGI H TW

A 50 0 pp

m ACGI H STE

L75 0 pp

m OSH A TWA , Vacated75 0 pp m OSH A TW

A 100

0 pp m afcivTWA^;t: s wit

h. X shjo o pp

m 3IH g ^'iiffOSHA

^ Additiona l Informatio n Tabi c A 4 Table A 4 Tabi c Z- 1 Tabi c Z- 1 Pag e 4 o f 8 

# a ...J L ?-. . >ivoi-; l i'!rr:-!rnm « '90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:39:3 4 p.m . 07-19-201 0 43/6 5

I 3 M MATERIALSAFETY DAT A SHEE T 3M(TM ) Super 77(TM ) Multipurpos e AJhesiv e (Aerosol ) 04/16/200 7 HEXAN E HEXAN E HEXAN E HEXAN E (ISOMER S OTHE RTHA N N HEXANE ) HEXAN E (ISOMER S OTHE RTHA N N HEXANE ) PROPAN E PROPAN E ACGI H OSH A OSH A ACGI H ACGI H ACGI H OSH A TW A

TWA , Vacate d TW A TW A STE L TW A TW A 5 0 pp m

S O pp m 50 0 pp m 50 0 pp m 100 0 pp m 100 0 pp m 100 0 pp m Ski n Notatio n

Tabl e Z- 1 A Tabl e Z- 1 A

Tabl e Z- 1 * Substance(s ) refe r

t o th e potentia l contributio n t o th e overal l exposur e b y th e cutaneou s rout e includin g mucou s membran e an deye , eithe r b y airborn e or , mor e particularly , b y direc t contac t with th e substance . Vehicle s ca n alte r ski n absorption , VA C Vacate dPEL:Vacate dPermissibl e Exposur e Limit s [PEL ] ar e enforce da s th e OSH A PE Li n som e states . Chec k wit h you r loca l regulator y agency . SOURC E O FEXPOSUR E LIMI T DATA : ACGIH : America n Conferenc e o f Governmenta l Industria l Hygienist s CMRG : Chemica l Manufacture r Recommende dGuidelin e OSHA : Occupationa l Safety an dHeah hAdministratio n AIHA : America n Industria l Hygien e Assodatio n Workplac e Environmenta l Exposur e Leve l (WEEL ) 

### SECTIO N 9 : PHYSICA LAN D CHEMICA LPROPERTIE S Specifi c Physica l Form : Odor , Color , Grade : Genera l Physica l Form : Autoignitio n temperatur e Flas hPoin t Flammabl e Limit s - LE L Flammabl e Limit s - UE L

, Boilin g poin t Vapo r Densit y .AUOii, — AC' ' H •.)SH. - Aeroso l

clear , swee t

fi-uit y odo r Ga s aeroso l N o Dat aA vailabl e -42.0 0 ° F[Tes t

Method : Tagliabu e Close dCup ] N o Dat aAvailabl e ,^fis^at aAvailable i «n>tppifR^..; ; * ; No t Applicabl e TV.- \••'••" • -.rv. i , 2,9 7 [RefStd : AIR=7l] . ; , Specifi c Gravit y p H Meltin g poin t Solubilit y I n Wate r 0.72 6 I/fc/5'/</.WATER=l ] N o Dat aA vailabl e N o Dat aAvailabl e iltO V

Ni l Evaporatio n rat e .....Mmmmmmmf&millSmt^^ ^ Hazardou s Ai r

Pollutant s Hazardou s Ai r

Pollutant s Hazardou s Ai r

Pollutant s Volatil e Organi c Compound s fc—.• > jWffr " Rt \MTTi'il^iH: J.rmi'.! - lin e e/,i/</>-ETHER=l ] V 4""weigh t [Tes t Method : Calculated ] y.gn . Percen t volatil e • '• • • VO C Les s H2 0 & Exemp t Solvent s Viscosit y 0,01 6 l b HAPS/l b solid s ^;| ' ^^^ ^ ^ 1 q.p 2 l b HAPS/g^l.[7>jt.Afe/Aof/. - (Calculated ] o r ,j i '*'-^ppj^J^jn,atgiy 5i'o/,'|3Toj/A'/e/W'calculate dSCAQM D rul e 443,1 ]

- <=7 5 % weigh t • 468g/ l No t Applicabl e

i i I ,-},i . 

### SECTIO N 1 O

f STABILITY*AN D REACTIVITY'S'* ^ iai » ~«K!,-5' ' .•iS'-ssKtaS.i TTT - •ko.i . ' ' Ni> . Uu! u Avaiblu't ' Pag e 5 o f 8 ^ 

## " ?

iWS«»sir.V-*'.» * "'^Nnnas. t ...'.lb/ , ^itft^K-t , V • -90 7 276726 1 ALASKANRO C 03:39:4 7 p.m . 07-19-201 0 44/6 5

I 3 M MATERIA LSAFET Y DAT A SHEE T 3M(TM ) Supe r 77(TM ) Multipurpos e Adhesiv e (Aeroiol ) 04/lfr200 7 Stability : Stable . Material s an dCondition s t o Avoid : Hea t Hazardou s Polymerization : Hazardou s polymerizatio n wil l no t occur . Hazardou s Decompositio n o r By-Product s Substanc e Conditio n Aldehyde s Durin g Combustio n Carbo n monoxid e Durin g Combustio n Carbo n dioxid e Durin g Combustio n 

### I SECTIO N 11 : TOXICOLOGICA LINFORMATIO N rT^!rTMff?-4^"TrTT' ' Pleas e contac t

th e addres s liste do n th e first pag e o f th e MSD S fo r

Toxicologica l Informatio n o n thi s materia l and/o r it s components . 

### I SECTIO N 12 ; ECOLOGICA LINFORMATIO N ECOTOXICOLOGICA L INFORMATIO N No t determined .

. . . „•:.. , :n^ufAyohia>fa5:-rtL(<ja-.4.'.;.. . ..i'~^i ^ 7... . ,,u.^;:r:;.; . . . ":• \..~--^ ^ .7.:...^.i'iskC;,4,.i . CHEMICA LFAT E INFORMATIO N No t determined . .i.-.u . ..,./,.,.i,, , i . J ..V... . 

### SECTIO N 13 : DISPOSA LCONSIDERATION S Wast e Disposa l Method : Incinerat e uncure dproduc t i n apermitte dhazardou s wast e incinerator . Incinerat e i n apermitte dhazardou s wast e incinerator . A s adisposa l ^Itcrngive , dispose ^ o f wast e produc t

i n apermitte dhazardou s wast e facility . '•" - ^ :.::^".:,':~'r5;..^.^,-^.'i.-.. ; . ;"j,:^7^.j; . uUrtnfc;cembtiki6JTri;"~." ; ,>,.„.j:',v*.>.rj i \. Th e facilit y shoul db e equippe dt o handl e gaseou s waste . Facilit y mus t

b e capabl e o f

handlin g aeroso l cans ^ Djspos e o f empt y produc t

container s i n asanitar y landfill . RECYCL E EMPT Y AEROS01<CpNTAlNERS,^jiEjlE/^^;L^^L^:{O N EP A Hazardou s Wast e Numbe r (RCRA):D0O I (Ignitable ) !iv((>:rr,it^ ! I Sinc e regulation s vary , consul t applicabl e regulation s o r authoritie s befor e disposal . 

### SECTIO N 14:TRANSPOR T INFORMATIO N

" ' ••"••s*1p;' - • • • • : • • • • 1 0 Number(5) : :r'JrT , ,:.»% • . ,,* . LN-A100-0323-8 , LN-A100-0323-9,'LN-A100-0324-0 , 62-4977-4030-8 , 62-4977-4920-0 , 62-4977-4926-7 . 62-4977^977-0 , 70 - 0714-1653-4 , 70-0714-1654-2 , 70-0714-1656-7 , 70-0714-7444-2 , 70-0714-7572-0 , 70-0714-7930-0 , 70-0714-8259-3 , 70-0714 - 8947- 3 ^^Pag e 6 o f 8 ••MgaaMKaBMiMBiwiiiffniriiii ' /c , ; i f {^^.-mn.. . < '• - rjT < ; . .'MC ! ^r . : i ri,"..iillc j ii.;-.i:dou- ; u jsfeyri.;. . .:,./...r . .90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N ROi:: ] :x:.'-^zy--'^^<^^'Z-^;.'-t^~':.i^-.\'y.-j:^-*.'.if ' -^'•^'•'•••''''^^^''(JsMiSQp.^ ^ 45/6 5

I 3 M MATERIALSAFET Y DAT A SHEE T 3M(TM ) Supe r 77aM ) Multipurpos e Adhesiv e (Aerosol ) 04/16/200? "

Pleas e contac t

th e emergenc y number s liste do n th e first pag e o f th e MSD S fo r

Transportatio n Informatio n fo r thi s material . 

### SECTIO N 15 : REGULATOR Y INFORMATIO N U S FEDERA LREGULATION S Contac t 3 M fo r mor e information . 311/31 2 Hazar dCategories : Fir e Hazar d- Ye s Pressur e Hazar d- Ye s Reactivit y Hazar d- N o Immediat e Hazar d- Ye s Delaye dHazar d- Ye s Sectio n 31 3 Toxi c Chemical s subjec t t o th e reportin g requirement s o f tha t sectio n an d4 0 CF Rpar t 37 2 (EPCRA) : Ingredien t CYCLOHEXAN

E C.A.S . N o 110-82- 7 % b vW t

3 - 7

- - - -fv r .x. — Thi s materia l contain s achemluJ^'wiiJcti^eqiiTre s ekpor f botlflcatlo'n^undelrTSC X ^ectlo'nlijb ] i)j'i(,':oft 7 Ingredien t

(Categor y I f

applicable' ) HEXAN E CYCLOHEXAN

E ACETON E C.A.S . N o Regulatio n Statu s 110-54- 3 Toxi c Substance s Control Act (TSCA) 4 Test

Applicable Rul e Chemical s 110-82- 7 Toxic Substance s Control Act (TSCA) 4 Tes t

Applicable Rul e Chemical s 67-64- 1 Toxk ; Substance s Control Ac t (TSCA) 4 Test

Applicable Rule Chemical s STAT E REGULATIONS r Contac t 3 M for mor e information .

CHEMICA LINVENTORIE S Th e component s o f

thi s produc t

ar c i n complianc e wit

h th e chemica l notificatio n requirement s o f TSCA . Al l applicabl e chemica l ingredient s i n thi s matma l y e liste do n fceiEuropean InyCTtpiy;pf.Exi5tingX^emica l Substance s (EINECS) , bf^^arc=exemptpblymere'whi5s2StJoSomS^ ^ ' Contac t 3 M fo r mor e information . j ^ \^, . _ ^ _, . ^, >_v

» s



### INTERNATIONA L REGULATION S Thi s materia l contain s on e o r moreingrcdient^^atjjp^yJ^^ul^t^-b>;.thgjpt ( ilnJf'nwfiiciiU. ' 

### ^S?§sfeSiga^i,W^,.'» " Pag e 7 o f

8



### r^% m90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:40:1 0 p.m . 07-19-201 0 46/6 5

r3 M MATERIALSAFETY DAT A SHEE T 3M(TM ) Supe r 77(TM ) Multipurpos e Adhetiv e (Aerosol ) 04/16/200 7 | expor t contro l o f

U S militar y technolog y an dchemicals . Prio r t o export o f thi s materia l o r

an y produc t

containin g thi s material , determin e whethe r

aprope r licens e fro mth e Departmen t o f Stat e mus t

b e obtained . Se e 22CF R120-13 0 for an y specifi c requirements . Contac t 3 M fo r mor e information .

Thi s MSD S ha s bee n prepare dt o mee t th e U.S . OSH A Hazar dCommunicatio n Standard , 2 9 CF R1910.1200 . 

### SECTIO N 16 : OTHE RINFORMATIO N NFP A Hazar dCiasslficatio n Health : 2 FlamraabUity : 4 Reactivity ! 0 Specia l Hazards : Non

e Aeroso l Storag e Code : 3 ijj:.iu:li. i p Nationa l Fir e Protection Association (NFPA) hazar dratings ar

e designedfo

r us e by emergency respons e personnel t o addres s the hazard s tha

t ar e presente dby short-term , acute exposur e t o amateria

l unde r condition s o f

fire , spill , o r

simila r emei;gencies . Hazar

drating s ar

e primaril y base don ih e inherent physica l an dtoxi c propertie s o f

the niateria

l bu t ab o includ

e the toxi c propertie s of

combustio n o r

decompositio n product s tha t ar e known to b e generate di

n significan

t quantities . HMI S Hazar dClassificatio n Health : 2 FlammabUity : 4 ReactMty : 0 Protection : X - See PP E sectbn . Hazardou s Materia

l Identification Syste

m(HMIS(r) ) hazar

drating s ar

e designe dt

o infor memployee s of

chemica l hazard s i n the workplace . Thes e rating s ar e basedon th

e inherent propertie s ofth e materia

l unde r expecte dccndition s o f

norma l us e andar

e no t intende dfo

r us e i n emergenc

y situations . HMlS(r

) rating s ar

e l o b e usedwit

h i full y implementedHMIS(r

) program . HMIS(r

) i s aregistere dmar

k o f th e Nationa

l Pain t an d Coating s Association (NPCA) . :c:|'jjji|^'*f,-' . ' ' Revisio n Changes : Sectio n 14 : I D Number(s ) wa s modified . DISCLAIMER : Th e informatio n i n thi s Materia l Safety Dat aShee t (MSDS ) i s believe dt o b e correc t a s ofth e dat e issued . 3 M MAKE S N O WARRANTIES , EXPRESSE D O RIMPLIED , INCLUDING , BU T NO T LIMITE D TO , AN Y IMPLIE D WARRANT Y O FMERCHANTABILIT Y O RFITNES S FO RA PARTICULA RPURPOS E O RCOURS E O FPERFORMANC E O RUSAG E O F TRADE . Use r

i s responsiblgifcE.detgiiimiiit^^t|j^'p^t^ ^ 3MpT0<tocLiS.fiUig. apa ^ fo r user' s metho do f us e o r application . Give n th e variet y o f factor s tha t

can affec t

th e us e an dapplicatio n o f a3 M product , som e o f

whic har e uniquel y withi n th e user' s knowledg e an dcontrol , it i s essentia l tha t

th e use r evaluat e th e 3 M produc t t o determin e whethe r

i t i s fi t for a particula r purpose an dsuitabl e fo

r user' s metho do f

us e p r application. ; MIL

i . oitt' : 3 M provide s informatio n i n electroni c for ma s aservic e t o it s customers . Du e t o th e remot e possibilit y tha t electroni c transfe r

ma y hav e resulte din errors , omission s o r alteration s i n thi s information , 3 M make s n o representation s a s t o it s completenes s o r accuracy . In addition , informatio n obtaine diro madatabas e ma y not b e a s curren t

a s th e informatio n i n th e MSD S availabl e directl y from3M . 3 M MSDS s ar e availabl e at-wyw.3M.co m-~^r^ ^ »»;a>*'ii^aai.-"X-,.i.i- , • - . -,. • .tlOI l .-v^^rrr.T' . ' f

i-"':':on:i i i:.i-'^ ; . . r'-v: : : i -,vi r :; ; .n : . . . .;rc. r

'lM0':^il0}d-'!''^;9l>^f:'^^ Pag e 8 of; 8

, . .\i/>i . ... . i ) O Ri;vU'(!i:1) : 1 .,L,U.i.JiN^i . H- U i NO t Ll. : 1 ! :-: D h'90 7 276726 1 ALASKANRO C , y-'Vi-i^tf^' ' ,,,....^93 ; 4Q:26p.m . 07-19-201 0 47/6 5

MATERLV LSAFET Y DAT A SHEE T / FICH E SIGN^VLfeTIQU E SECTIO N I - MATERL\ LIDENTIFICATIO N AN D US E / IDENTIFICATIO N D E L A M.ATIER E E T USAG E \LVTERL1 LNAM E / IDENTIFIE R- NO M / IDENTIFICATIO N D E L A MATI£R E PRODUC T NM'IE : Premiu mDeco r Spra y Ename l PRODUC T CODE(S) : PDS - 1-6,15,21,22,25,30-31,33,35,40,44,50 , 56,60,70,8 0 PRODUC T USE : Spra y Pain t DATE : Apri l 17 . 200 3 SUPERCEDES : Jul y 16 , 200 2 WHMIS : A,B54)2 B HEALTH/SANT E FLAMMABILITY

/ INTLAMMABILrr

^ REACTIVIT

Y RfeACTIVlTli . PERSONA

LPROTECTION

/ PROTECTIO

N P E 

## I D 

# m [ 1 Mamifactursr' s name/no mdu fabrican t Genera l Pain t

& Manufacturin g Compan y Supplier' s nam e / na mdu foumisseu r TruSer v Canad aCooperative , Inc . Stree t addres s / ' adress e 20 1 Jandu s Roa d Stree t addres s / adtess e 153 0 Gambl e Plac e P.O . Bo x 680 0 Cit y / ViU e posta l Cary . I L6001 3 State/Provinc e US A Posta l code/cod e Cit y / Vill e Provinc e Winnipeg , Manitob aR3C3A 9 Posta l code/cod e postj J Emergenc y phon e na'n o d e telephon e d'urgenc e 1/800-228-563 5 ex t

01 7 Emergenc y phon e no/n o d e telephon e d'urgenc e 1/800-228-S63 S post * 01 7 Chemica l mme/dinomiMtio n chimique Mixture/melang e Chemica l famity/hmill c chimique Mixture/melang e Chemica l formuli/formule chimic^e Mixture/melang e Trade nsm c Appellation cotnniercial e Se e above/voi r

ci-dessu s Molecula r wt/^id s moltoilair i Unknown/Inconn u Materia l use/Utilisatio n de l amitiir e Se e above/voi r

ci-dessu s SECTIO N n - HAZARDOU S MATERIALS/DSTGRJSDIENT S DANGEREU X D B L A MATIER E Hazardou s Ingredients/Ingr^cnlEdangereu x 5M>i?:?idinaleTr:J : ccncenmuon/ 1 .A cancentration —' — ippfOximaUv«(% ) rAS,:NiCoru>r* -

"niimben' " ' VI C Numiro CAS , NA I Fs;Tf; N

TLV" ~ LUs

t aptcu y tpKltriiiidToiit

l LDsoFriciser r esp^c e et l i voie d'administntio n Aceton e Prof)ane/Isobutan e Blen d Toluen e Petroleu mNaphtha(l ) Soap s tone(2 ) Carbo n Blac k

(3 ) Crystallin e Silic a(4 ) Xylen e • • . •. ^r.'iM' ^ Ethy l Benzen e -J ^ Ligroin e (5 ) Naphth a(6 ) C.I . Pigmen t

Yello w 4 2 (7 ) i t'l ; 25-3 2 26-2 9 9-2 1 3- 5 3- 8 .1-. 7 ..6-. 8 . .3- 4 -wl-. S - . 3-1 0 -1-9 — 1- 2 iMC',•!•' • - , : 1

67-64- 1 Mixtur e 108-88- 3 64742-89- 8 14807-96- 6 1333-86- 4 .14464-46- 1 . , ^,« TM *^l?3Q-20-^<?JMn»O O ppi n

-~ ^ 100-41- 4 lOOpp m '8032-32- 4 ^ " ;.00ppn i

75 0 pp mJ lOOOppni: . 5 0 pp m 20 0 pp m 2ntg/m ' 3. 5 mg/m '

1 8030-30- 6 "••IH.' ! "300 pp m 51274-00- 1 Smg/mta ' 5.5g/k g ora l (rat ) N A 63 6 mg/k g ora l (rat ) 5. 5 mg/k g ora l (rat ) N A N A 4. 3 g/k g ora l (rat ) -80 0 mg/k g ora l (rat ) '^ 5 g/k g ora l (rat ) - ' 5 g/k g ora l (rat ) N A { .\ l

t.iUi t

< > (1 ) I n PDS- 6 onl y (2 ) I n PDS-3 , 4 , 5 , 6 onl y (3 ) I n PDS-2 , 4 , 6 , 30 . 6 0 only . (4 ) I n PDS-5 , 6 only . (5 ) I n PDS-1-6,21.22,25,30-31,33,35.40,44.50 . 56 , 60 , 70 , 8 0 only . (6 ) I n PDS-2 , 5 , 6 , 1 5 only . (7 ) I n PDS-50 , 6 0 only . SECTIO N m: PHYSICAiqV\lAy6R^RfATERIAL^ARACTERISTIQlJE S PHYSIQJ^ ^ Physica l Slate/l^a l physique ' QOiis.'gaz E l Liquid/liquld e Osoli<l/$9lide [y.nr.'.ri.']!.' . y. ; • • ^ - "•'•h.Cr-. - Odou

r an dappearanc e /

Odeur^e l apparcDce^.i.^ . .Odo r (ik e petroleu msolven t ~.~~~~r ' Odou r tireshol d(ppm

) Scul l d e i'odeu r (ppm ) Unknown/Inconn u Specifi c gravit y | - Deiuiti relative ' 0.72-0.8 4 Vapou r pressur e (mm ) - Tension d e vapeu r (mm ) 2.6@20° C -Vapou r densit y (aii^'I ) Densit e d c vapeu r (aii=l ) < 1 Evaporation rate Tau x d'cvaporation Slowe r tlia n petroleu methe r Boiling poiidCC ) Poin t d'ctmlljtlon i'C ) 149-193' C Freezing poin t C O Poin t d e congelation (°C } NA/S O Solubilit y i n wate r (20°C) Solubiiit e dan s I'ea

u (20'C ) 0 % % Volatile (b

y volume) % Volatilit

i (pa i CocffxMfi* . o r Wate r v« l didnbubci ;

TF'-i '90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:40:4 5 p.m . 07-19-201 0 48/6 5

Pag e 2 PDS-Ltn e Premiu mDecu r Spra y Ename l SECTIO N I V - FIR E AN D RXPLOSIO N HAZAR D / RISQUE S D'INCENDI E E T D'EXPLOSIO N D U MATERIE L Fl(ishpointC'C)(nitfthod)/Poin t d'iclaii<;methode) <-7* C Uppe r explosion limit

( % b y volume) Seui l ma^NJina l d'inflammabiIite(V » pa

r volume ) 9.5 % Lowe r explosion s limit

(% b y volume) Seui J minima l d'inflairmiabilit

^ (*4pa r volume ) 1.9 % Mean s of extinctioiv'moyen s d'tsctinctio n H Foam/mouss e ( 3 CO ; Q Dr y chemical/poudr

e chimique E

G Wate r fog/ea u pulverisee Specia l Proceduies/Klarch

e & suivr e speciole Thi s materia l i s extremel y ilammabl e an dma y b e Ignite db y heat , spark s flame o r othe r source s o f

ignition . Respirator y equipmen t

shoul db e wor n t o avoi dInhalatio n o f vapors . Wate r

ma y b e use dt o coo l containers . Hazardou s combustion products/ Produit s de combustion dangeieux CO , CO 2 SECTIO N V - REACTIVIT Y DAT A / DONNEE S SU RLAREACTIVIT E Chemica l stabilit y / Stabilit e E

D Yes/ou i tl J No/non Incompadbilit

y t o othe r substances/ Incompatibilit

y ave c d'autre s substanc e Stron g acids , oxidizin g agent s an dextremel y alkalin e materials . Hazardou s decomposition products/ Produit s d e decomposition dangereux C O & CO 2 SECTIO N V I - TOXICOLOGICA LPROPERTIE S O FMATERL4L L/ PROPRIETfe S TOXICOLOGIQUE S D E L A MATIER E Route o f entr y / Voi e d'administTation Skin contact/contact

ave c lapea u B Inhalation acute/inhalation aigu ^ ' B Skin absorption/absorption pa r lapea u Q Inhalation chronic/inhalation chroniqu e [ g Eye contact/contac t oculaii e EE

I Irigestion D Effect s of acut e exposur e to materia

l / eOets de I'expusitio n aigue & l amatier e SKI N - Sligh t

irritan t LNGESTIO N - Unknow n . EYES - Sever e Irritan t INHALATIO N - Headache , dizziness , nausea .

: ..;a.ajgi'>rBi^aagB»?a,MJ?5 ; sai^iWitmall^gfaMttWI^ ^ tolfim f 1.9 " Effect s ofchroni c exposur

e t o material/Efretsdel'expositio n chronique & lamatiir e / " , Contain s carbo n black , crystallin e silic aan dethy l benzene . Ciystaliin e silic aha s bee n classifle db y lAR C a s acarcinoge n fo r human s (Grou p 1 ) fro mla b anima l studies . Carbo n blac k an dethy l benzen e hav e bee n classifle db y lAR C (no t NT P o r OSHA ) a s possibl e carcinogen s fo r human s (2B ) iro mla b anima l studies . '':ir: : o r cii:. . INHALATION : Report s hav e associate drepeate dan dprolonge doverexposur e t o solvent s wit hpermanen t brai n an d nervou s syste mdamage . Carcinogenictty , reproductiv e eflbcti , teratogenicity , matageiiicity/caiic^ogeiuciti , effect s nocif i n n l aleproductioii , t^ratog^citi , mutag^cit ^ Se e Sectio n V I - Chroni c ove r expQMire,£arclnogenici1y(aN o tenitogenicityriDutageni^ty-pr'reproductive effect s known. - 'AibK'-.^ : Sin-n e •' SECTIO N V H - PREVENTIV E MEASURE S / MESURE S PREVENTIVE S PERSONA LPROTECTIV E EQUIPMEN T / MATERIE L PERSONNE L D E PROTECTIO N Glov«(Specify)/Gan

b (Priciser) Solven t resistan t Ey e (Specify ) / Yeu x (Priciser ) Goggle s o r

protectiv e glasse s Respirator y (Specify) /

Appareil Respirator

e fPreciser ) Dus t & vapo r mas k recommended . Dus t

mas k l^iri f dfli mi s sanded . .ut-h. ' ^^1-—-*«— . • 1—(- -

"SS ^ Othe r (Specify) /

Autre s (Pricif^ J v M NA/S O Engineering Control s (e.g . Ventilation , enclosedprocess , specify) / Mecanisme s Technique s (ex . Ventilation , operation e n milie u ferm e preciser ) Goo dventilatiiH i ' * ' •

. li j ;o ( ; . .'.tii.i.- . fnt'bpftl n itn d)

.il»iMi. . i .i,.' , i^iiltSf . ••Qi;!:- . .CHJl4*r^»tn!..i;c . Ci'. ^ .. " S .nr . .!•:';:•.• , !; i ;;:i..K«!llc r • ' - if?,'. , nfli

v ; 'fy ; . i

- !T;^^;.lfet!:ici :90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:41:03p.m . 07-19-201 0 49/6 5

Pag e 3 PDS-Lin e Premiu mDeco r Spra y Ename l SECTIO N V U - PREVENTIV E MEASURE S / MESURE S PRE\'ENTIVE S Lea k an dspil l procedur

e / Mesure s e n ca s de fuit

e o u de deversemen

t Eliminate nil ignitio n sources . Dik e o r contai n spil l wit habsorben t material . Transfe r

liqui dt o disposa l containe r Kee p spi n ou t

o f sewer s an dope n wate r \Vast « Disposa l / Elimiruitio

n de s residu s Chec k wit hloca l authoritie s Handlin g procedure s andequipment. ' Methode s e t equipemen

t pou r l amonutention Avoi dprolonge do r

repeate dinhalatio n o f

vapor s o r

spra y mists . Avoi dprolonge do r

repeate dski n contact . Storage requirements /

Exigence s d'entreposag e Kee p awa y fro mope n flame an dspark . Specia l shipping information /

Renseignement s speciau

x pou r I'exp^tio n ORM-D Consume

r commodit y SECTIO N VII I - FIRS T AI D MEASURE

S / PREMIER

S SOINS Ey e contact : Flus h wit hwater . Cal l aphysician . Ski n contact : Was hwit hsoa p an dwate r -*.'-'*"*~'^^'-' ' - " Inhalation : Remov e victi mfr6m'areal > Appl y artiflcia l respiratio n i f necessary . Cal l n physician .

. • . " :i.K ' . ; . • • .: • . Ingestion : D o no t

induc e vomiting , kee p perso n war man dquiet-Ge t medica l attention; -

. ou . ,l:iifi . • > i;i i i rafts ; SECTION I

X - PREPARATIO

N DAT E OFMSDS /

FICH E SIGNALETIQU

E Prepare db y / Prepar e pa r Regulator y Complianc e Departmen t Telephone number/N ° d e telephone 1/800/345-921 8 Dat e printed Jun e 2,200 3 I * _flftifi • r r ,,n. i e;f}Ul5*fem*iVtMS5MS«r-i?pp?ffl»TT!mnJ%5 ^ >rs!f*fi''c;ife<

J inliuiatidr i o f

\iifwr s o r

spr.i' , :Oi r l- l .'( - 1 •-.?!.: ( i -

-^^^Sfii ^ M ^ 'SiffT.L,.. . \-.!t'i;.r .

t .SKf-TTON^TX^PttEl " •*^5'S!&L^.%-:dilsJS£fcSf^Mil**^ ^ 

# W 

# H

t ' . o/ T (, r

* ^ itSMCft.:-- ,90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C :.: . 03:41:1 3 p.m . 07-19-201 0 50/6 5 

# o U . S . Department of Transportatio n Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Cas e No . 2008AL70003 9 Alaskan Regio n Offic e ofth e Regional Counse l

:;.:: ; 1 2 Mr . Robert

Persekia n Precisio n Display s an dTool s 155 5 Alu mRoc k

Avenue , Suit e 2 0 Sa n Jose , C A 9511 6 Dea r Mr . Persekian : 22 2 W . 7t h Avenu e #1 4 Anchorage , Aliiska99513-758 7 PH : (907 ) 271-527 1 FAX : (907 ) 271-280 0 glenn.brown'(^'faa.go v

A s yo u kno w th e judg e ha s se t ou r matte r for ahearing o n Augus t

17,2010 . I n lookin g throug h ou r file , I se e tha t

yo u hav e neve r

actuall y submitte da

n answe r i n whic hyo u admi t

o r den y eac h ofth e paragraph s i n th e complaint . Thus , i n orde r t o mov e thi s proces s along , I hav e include d Request s fo

r Admissio n i n th e enclose ddiscpvery request . Als o include di n thi s reques t are Interrogatorie s an dRequest s for Production . Pleas e not e that

i f yo u d o not

respon dto eac hofth e Request s for Adipissio n withi n 3 0 days , the n th e Rule s o f

Practic e specif

y that the y are deeme dadmitted . Fo r you r information , ther e i s n o specifi c forma t yo u mus t

us e i n respondin g t o thi s request . T o assis t yo u i n preparin g you r

response , I hav e prepare dan denclose da4-pag e for mtha t yo u may us e fo r thi s purpose . A s fo r

eac hreques t

for admission , yo u ca n eithe r circl e you r

choic e o f "Admit " or

"Deny, " o r

yo u can mar

k throug hth e "Admit " o r

"Deny " yo u ar e no t

choosing . Th e "Explanatio n for

Denial " after

eac hanswe r

t o areques t

fo r admissio n i s areferenc e to Interrogatory No . 1 , whic hask s yo u t o explai n an y denial . Yo u ar e no t require dt o us e thi s form , but yo u mus t at leas t clearl y conve y you r

response s i n writing . I f yo u hav e any questions , I can b e reache da t th e abov e numbe r

o r emai l address . Sincerely , =jiiri?ft^j^pt?"wv - » * ; :-^*7; 4 :'v-X. - Kfc^i , -., . Glen n H . Brow n Senio r Attome y Enclosure s in e Kute s >>

i Hract :;ii .

'O.n c ..i:-c7 : niHrniUc aa n : 'T^^' . i- f i! > . int h

iitei'. ' :: > 1. " .s;.!eciricioiiaa

t yoi > mus t u5e'inr.-':-r.:nd!;.' ^ :"yT " < - •..p<,:a::'..v l \\:^ : • p:,':'-.' k \a ; " , . ::;o,ve d; . -}-;• • . • 

# 7 . 1- ^ ^

fij.t'l.ftiiH(ilH|B';^.fef%r-;- .A.^oi^AKion r 03:41:25p.m . 07-19-201 0 51/6 5 90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C

• .:-?;*^>??S*'^^t^i?S^-:'-V^S^ ^ ;,> . j";:^:P;Cj;^jg.i^^'j;:^j^st^Sj^s ^ - • • UNITE D STATE S DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C .

IN TH E MATTE RO F PRECISIO N DISPLAY S AN D TOOL S FA A DOCKE T NO . CP09AL000 8 (Civi l Penalty Proceeding ) DM S NO . FAA-2009-073 3 COMPLAINANT' S FIRS T SE T O FREQUEST S FO RADMISSION , INTERROGATORIES , AN D REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N O FDOCUMENT S To : Robert

Persekian , Owne r Precisio n Display s an dTxwl s ';^^^^^i:^^" " Pursuan t t o 1 4 C.F.R . § 13.220 , th e Complainant , b y an dthroug hit s Regional Counsel , request s that

you , b y Jun e 14,2010 , make th e requeste dadmissions , answe r th e follov^n g interrogatorie s unde r

oath , an didentif

y an dproduc e th e requeste ddocument s for inspectio n an d copyin g at

th e Offic e ofth e Regiona l Counsel , Alaskan Regio n FAA , 22 2 W . 7*' Avenue , Bo x 14 , Anchorage , Alask a99513-7587 . Thes e request s ar e deemedjcontimiing,:Mid.anyJnfQniiatio n secure dafte r answerin g and/o r supplyin g th e requeste dans\V9raOTidp<f^upe^^s/item s i s t o be^supijlie db y supplementa l productio n pursuan t

t o § 13.220(iyo f

th e Rifle s o f

Practic e i n FAX^tivi l Penalt y Actions . {(.•\\. . i':- : :-iIi , ; ...c;cd...g ; B E ADVISE D that

1 4 C.F.R . § 13.22Q(I)(1 ) states , " A party' s failure t o respon dt o a reques t fo r admission , i n writin g an dsigne db y th e attome y o r th e party , not

later than 3 0 day s afte r servic e ofth e request , i s deeme dan admissio n ofth e trutho f th e statemen t

o r statement s containe di n th e reques t

for admission. " i#aifaMt<^DEEINmQNSaBllliVr«ifflTOBMISii&l!i<QN . 1 . "Documents " means , regardles s o f origi n o r location , an y handwriting , note , letter , manual , memorandum , record , report , statement , study , drawing , sketch , photograph , telegram , telex , o r message , whethe r

reported^ transcribed , piinched , taped , filme do r graphicall y represente di n any manner , o r material o f

an y kin di n th e possessio n o f subjec t t o th e contro l of

, o r withi n th e knowledg e of

. Responden t

and/o r hi s employees , agents , consultants , o r experts .

i,t;|iviilt;';i ' 

### I^^'V'I^SV-^^ ^ • * = •' " • J2^ : Q90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 'V--i;i3A«*:^S.#-- ; ,,._..,, . .Q3;41.:52p.m . 07-19-201 0 53/6 5

9 . At th e tim e h e offere dth e abov e shipment , Lewi s Lourenc o ha dno t receive dth e trainin g specifie di n subpart

H o f part 17 2 ofth e HM Rwithi n th e precedin g thre e years , andhe wa s no t workin g unde r

th e direc t

supervisio n o f

aproperl y traine dan dknowledgeabl e hazmat employee . 10 . A t th e tim e Lewi s Lourenc o offere dth e abov e shipment , Precisio n Display s an dTool s di dno t hav e arecor do f

curren t trainin g fo

r Lewi s Lourenc o that

containe dth e informatio n specifie di n Sectio n 172.704(d ) ofth e HMR . INTERROGATORIE S AN D REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N 1 . Fo r eac hofth e abov e request s for admissio n that

yo u d o not

admit, explai n wha

t specifi c fact s o r contention s i n eac hstatemen t yo u believ e are no t

true , stat e al l fact s that

suppor t you r belief s i n thi s regard , an dproduc e al l document s that support thes e beliefs . 2 . Identif y eac hperso n who myo u inten dt o cal l a s awitnes s at th e hearin g i n thi s matter , andfor eac hsuc hwitness , provid e asummary ofth e expecte dtestimony . 3 . For eac hperso n identifie di n respons e t o Interrogatory No . 2 , produc e acop y o f eac han d ever y statemen t

inaad e bj' . tha t perso n }n: whic hth e fact s an dcircumstance s o f matter s a t issu e i n thi s cas e are reference do r discussed . . ' . . . ,.^1' . l i nc ; D o yo u inten dt o presen t

an y expert

witnes s testimon y at

th e hearin g o f

thi s matter ? I

f so , the n provid e asynopsi s o f eac hexpert

witness ' testimony , stat e th e ground s fo r eac h expert opinion , an dproduc e acurriculu mvita e fo r eac hexpert

witness . D o yo u conten dthatPrecisio n Display s an dTool s lack s th e ability t o pay th e propose d civi l penalty7fJ f

sp.vtheni^tat

e every fac t

upo n whic hyo u inten dt o rel y at th e hearin g i n support o f thi s contention , an dproduc e acop y o f eac han devery documen t yo u inten dto introduc e a

t th e hearin g i n thi s matte r i n suppor t o f thi s contention . T o th e exten t

not encompasse di n you r

respons e t o any ofth e foregoin g items , identif y an dproduc e al l document s upo n whic hyo u expec t to rel y at th e hearin g o r

introduc e a s evidenc e i n support

o f you r positio n at

th e hearin g i n thi s matter . Requeste dthi s 12lday.^£Mayr2010. - .HOWAR D L . MARTIN , J R Regional Counse l ,'e;i): ' By :

i\J . '..iiSAM^J ^ Glenn H . Brow n -Senio r Attome j t^lti'^'I'lf)> ' *bfMch%5<p^TfwTtji- : is-tor"eac h

..^...^...n'liif

e ^l^fe^(^^il...i,liwu,lf^^^s^.^bi. . ,.a.tu.At^>iiUiaxic.j4<">jisittfc»UMttrttct^ ,90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:42:0 7 p.m . 07-19-201 0 54/6 5

CERTIFICAT E O FSERVIC E Re : Precisio n Display s an dTool s FA A Docke t No . CP09AL000 8 DM S No . FAA-2009-073 3 I hereb y certif

y that o n thi s dat e I hav e serve dacop y ofth e COMPLAINANT' S FIRS T SE T O FREQUEST S FO RADMISSION , INTERROGATORIES , AN D REQUEST S FO R PRODUCTIO N O FDOCUMENT S b y postage-prepaid , certifie dmail , return receip t requested an dfacsimil e t o th e following : Th e Honorabl e Richar dC . Goodwi n Offic e o f Hearings , M-20 ; U.S . Departmen t

o f Transportatio n 1200 Ne w Jerse y Avenue , S.E . Eas t Buildin g Groun dFloor , Roo mEl2-32 0 Washington , D C 2059 0 FAX : (202 ) 366-753 6 Rober t Persekian , Owne r Precisio n Display s an dTool s 155 5 Alu mRoc k

Avenue , Suit e 2 0 Sa n Jose , C A 9511 6 FAX : (408)251-799 0

• i . M^ . V \ . I fVirthe r certifythatCbrilhii^fSlPhav e serve dth e original an dtwocopie s o f th e COMPLAINANT' S FIRS T SE T O FREQUEST S FO RADMISSION , INTERROGATORIES, ! AN D REQUEST S I^O RJPRODUCTIONiO E DOCUMENT S b y postage-prepaid , certifie dmail , Jetum^receiptrequeste dan dfacsiinile^-addresse da s follows : •'\f\f A Federal Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S.W . Washington , D C 2059 1 Attentio n iHeariftg^aocfce^Clerk , AGCT43 0 i " ^ WilburJWrightpuilding—Suit e 2W100 0 FAX : (202)493-502 0 .,S!: .

..rrot i DATED : y . 12-33 0

Federa l VVviatrnTjlSBTSSSSoi r Office o f Regiona l Coimse l 22 2 Wes t 7t hAvenue , Bo x 14 , AAL- 7 Anchorage , Alask a99513-758 7 ' .a-i . > ' r - • .jf- ' • ! • •KVo'co^ir s > \ 

# r90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:42:1 9 p.m . 07-19-201 0 55/6 5

UNITE D STATE S DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C .

I N TH E MATTE RO F PRECISIO N DISPLAY S AN D TOOL S FA A DOCKE T NO . CP09AL000 8 (Civi l Penalty Proceeding ) DM S NO . FAA-2009-073 3 RESPONDENT' S REPL Y T O COMPLAINANT' S FIRS T SE T O FREQUEST S FO R ADMISSION , INTERROGATORIES , AN D REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N O F DOCUMENT S Responden t

answer s Complainant' s discovery reques t a s follows : REQUEST S FO RADMISSIO N LAdmi t Den y s?F..i5.^ r ',r , V .V Explanatio n fo r

Denial : I

N nii^MA l iLRO l

.•i.>i'~ ' I . 

### 'no ' ." ^ 2 , Admi t Den y Explanatio n for

Denial :

# - I - MA^--' V - ..• ' -.^r^f-f-- ^ i.i, .

- DM' ^ NO . I-AA-20 . -071 3 

### ..EV:.\:"rovc>Mr:.A-i> : 3 . Admi t Den y • Explanatio n for

Denial : :iE"r:-i'K....i^ ; yo : 

# ;...j<^--- 9 r.t-,4» ~B0 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:42:2 6 p.m . 07-19-201 0 56/6 5

4 . Admi t Den y Explanatio n fo r

Denial :

5 . Admi t Deny Explanatio n for

Denial :

6 , Admi t Den y Explanatio n for

Denial :

7 . Admi t Deny Explanatio n for

Denial :

8 . Admi t Deny v Explanatio n for

Denial :

9 . Admi t DeEy y Explanatio n for

Denial ; :^^^,,...._,., >, V

10 . Admi t Deny . . . ^ ^ Explanatio n for

Denial:- • * 

# iz/i-i .

r Tt * IRTL/ C tHili t V t^,^#ii^-'-'-?-»"^-- - 'i?*"---'• - > . rV -90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:42:3 0 p.m . 07-19-201 0 57/6 5

INTERROGATORIE S AN D REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N 1 . Explanation s fo

r eac hdenia l ar e provide dabove . Al l supportin g document s are enclosed .

3 .

. OHtE;-:. . ,;•>: • K / k" - j''Ur . uijljOftii'i ^

Submitte dthi s day o f _ 201 0

PRECISIO N DISPLAY S AN D TOOL S |t-i**-t.-^i:-Vf$^i5aiKlr^:>'--F-.--

- -"••.-SV>-:|i-"'r^ - •:•".•• • l-iV^i.-fj - ^ •• : * • • - _ By : Rober

t Persekian , Owne r 

# S^' i 'S%i-,*jsii^i^--..?»s|»fc' f • • ,-.r,;.'•• -'-.j'fc- ? •>'?,*'---^-'i***^"?'»^*-^'.:'^' -9 0 7 276726 1 ALASKA N ROCi^ V v.;;i<:V:iJs-;-'VK^ff>':^« ^ --^^ii•^;r::^-^-j::--^fi'?y:--:i:--l:i^-::^^y:v-.=??ffpi'p3;4^2:3 5 pVm.-: - ' ; 07-19-201 0 58/6 5

CERTIFICAT E O FSERVIC E Re : Precisio n Display s an dTool s FAA Docke t

No . CP09AL000 8 DM S No . FAA-2009-073 3 I hereb y certif

y that o n thi s dat e I hav e serve dacop y o f RESPONDENT' S REPL Y T O COMPLAINANT' S FIRS T SE T O FREQUESTS . FO RADMISSION , INTERROGATORIES , AN D REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N O FDOCUMENT S b y postage-prepaid , certifie dmail , return receip t requeste dan dfacsimil e t o th e following : Th e Honorabl e Richar dC . Goodwi n Offic e o f Hearings , M-20 ; U.S . Departmen t

o f transportatio n 120 0 Ne w Jerse y Avenue , S.E . Eas t Buildin g Groun dFloor , Roo mE12-32 0 * Washington , D C 2059 0 FAX : (202)366-753 6 Glen n H . Brow n Senio r Attome y 22 2 W7 * Avenu e Bo x 1 4 ^ iAnchorage , A K

9951 3 FAX : (907)271-280 0 i > I furthe r certif y tha t o n thi s dat e I hav e serve dth e origina l an dtw o copie s ofth e RESPONDENT' S REPL Y T O COMPLAINANT' S FIRS T SE T O FREQUEST S FO R ADMISSION , INTERROGATORIES , ANDJIEQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N O F I)OCXIMENTS.byTposfag6Jprepa';te1tiffed ^ addresse da s fbllows'^¥:^,AX^RrQL'r^T S F(^ RVD ? CT^O^ ' '^ F^

. ..l.^s. - :C!:.L

U icvvi;- , .c.,iui . •.;...

u Uiii., lacsi-;.. : .

• . o i . . ^ Federal Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S.W . i Washington , D C 2059 1 Attention : Hearin g Docke t Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wrigh t Building—Suit e 2 W100 0 FAX : (202)493*5020i»t4«e«wtN>wHWri.a>A£0£>.^si5; ^ DATED : % " r Federal Aviatio n Administratio n Offic e o f Regional Counse l 22 2 Wes t 7t hAvenue ^ Bo x 14 . AA;.- 7 , . .. . -_^^,-x-:x — Anchorage , Aladc|^513^i87-^'*^''^*^:*'^^ ^ "-' '

' • "'fWm"ftia1?"liftr>vi^sT^-\'e dth e ori' - .' ! art' ] tw o cr-'pi?' ; "<"• . .,_—

^

slsjt^ v J i ..-.- •90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:42:4 6 p.m . 07-19-201 0 59/6 5

" § § u i- t J « , l- l m< o 1 4 / mW" ^ ! g P . ..•-*^ , pi

S CL . - J w -*,J * P o ' AP >

P S pt i - I w

wil l "I S I S SENDER : COMPiCT E THI k m Coir|iW*ltaim1,Z,and3.AlsocoiiipM * Ite m 4 H Rastricta d Dallvaf yI s daskad . • Prin t you rnam * an d addrec s o n Ih a raswa a • o tha t W

W ca n latu m Ih a car d to you , p ^ 1 Ej^*tacl i Ihi a car d t o th * boc k o ( til * rnallplacair : -^irofonth»fn)nllfs~~'—"I f "•« • Robrr l Pmtkiti , 0»(« r Prtctlc n DFspliy i in d Too' , ISS 5 AlBr a Roc k

Xvtnic . Sait t V

> SIBJBK.C A *SII ( DAgwi t D B . Itooaind.b y C . OptaofCMlMf y 0 . l>cMiwyaildH><jli;>i«llftanllani1 7 • Y n lfVES,«ntwd*llv«yiddrHatMlow : OH o

3 . S«fvlcaiyp « ^OfRHadlta a OEKpraMMi a • ftogWva d D Rttu m Racalpt (a rManhandl w • kiKira d Ma i D C.O.O . 4 . neiti1cttdOalMry7(EktniAt f a Yt e v*;^^r^.^SPE'oo5,ie25aiPDnjs^s^DflDx:;^i^H«;pr«i*^^^ ^ P S Fbr m 3811 , Fabniai y200 4 Oomaitl cflatiK n Racalpt X 

### ' V 

# V ,90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:42:5 7 p.m . 07-19-201 0 60/6 5 

# o U.S . Dqiartmen t o f Transportatio n Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Alasica n Regio n Oflic e ofth e Regional Counse l 22 2 Wes t Sevent h Avenu e #1 4 Anchorage , Alaslc a99513-758 7 (907 ) 271-357 0 vo/c e (907)271-280 0 fa x craig.black@faB.go v emai l Jun e 11,201 0 VIA BOT H FIRS T CLAS S MAI LAN D CERTIFIE D MAIL , RETURN RECEIP T REQUESTE D Rober t Persekia n Precisio n Display s an dTool s 155 5 Alu mRoc k

Avenue , Suit e 2 0 Sa n Jose , CA 9511 6 RE : Cas e 2008AL70003 9 Dea r Mr . Persekian , O n Ma y 12,2010 , thi s offic e sen t t o yo u vi acertified , return-receip t requeste dmai l a

t your addres s abov e ou r

first discovery reques t

i n thi s matter . Yesterday , th e Posta l Servic e returne d our reques t t o u s unopene dan dmarke d"Unclaimed" . Pleas e b e advise dtha t

an y failur e b y yo u t o receiv e mai l properl y sen t t o you r addres s o f recor dinure s t o yoii , not

us : pu t anothe r way,.yo u cannotjayoid_the..consequence s o f ou r servic e b y avoidm g you r

raaiir^ 7!«« . .-,1 1 -^(WO . (g ) Vali dservice . A documen t that wa s properl y addressed , wa s sen t in accordanc e vwt

hthi s subpart, , an dthat

wa s returned , that

was no t claimed , o r

tha t was refused , i s .deeme dt o hav e bee n serve di n accordanc e withthi s subpart . Th e servic e shal l b e considere dvali da s ofth e dat e an dth e tim e tha t th e documen t

wa s deposite dwithacontrac t o r expres s messenger , th e documen t wa s mailed , o r personal delivery ofth e document wa s refused . (h ) Presumptioniofisewicel<Thgixi.shal l b e apresumption.o f servic e wher e aparty ' o r apersori^fwh

o customaril y receive s mail , or receive s it

i n th e ordinary cours e o f business , at

eithe r th e person's residenc e o r th e person' s principal plac e o f business , acknowledge s receip t ofth e document . 1 4 CF R§ 13.211(g) , (h) . What

thi s mean s in simpl e term s i s tha t servic e i s complet e when w e properl y mai l yo u things : any failure b y you t o clai mthos e thing s come s a t you r peril , no t ours . Under ^ 1 4 CF R§^^^S!^t^^®8^^(B5!S^'ffiM?^eyour^ ^ response s o n u s rOCdWc»ti^U^^1 : b y Jun e 16,2010 . I f

yo u fai l t o d o so , yo u shoul dexpec t apromp t motio n b y u s t o compel discovery an dfor

sanctions,'a s appropriate'.- ' •'^^^' ^ pioperl y c., : t

o . .. . 

## "m . •pxi(-?:-^*th . ;h c v.drr ' 

# :.. : R .

.•..•p.'(ce''S ' docunfen •iVT*-..(-.*t-': r

.- .90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C 03:43:1 1 p.m . 07-19-201 0 6 1 /6 5

Rober t Persekian Cas e No . 2008A I Jun e 11,201 0 fe^itfr-^-^-i-.... I hav e assume dresponsibility fo r thi s c?ise fromm

y colleagu e Glen n H . Brown . I f yo u hav e any question s o r

concerns , yo u may Qontaq t m e a s se t fort habove . Sincerely , ••

• HOWARD L . MARTIN , JR Regional Counse l • ; *

End : Letter

fromGlen n H . Brov mt o Robert Persekian , Ma

y 12 , 201 0 ,.:*I». I ..>.•.. „ .^*VK*.-(ii.*^r w • Complainant* s Firs t

Se t o f Request s for

Admission , Interrogatories , an dRequest s fo r Productio n o f

Document s Respondent' s Repl y t o Complainant' s Firs t Se t o f Request s for

Admission , Interrogatories , an dRequest s fo r Productio n o f

Document s (blank for mfo r responden t

t o complete )

^•^'^"At f ||(P'^if^^#^^-"-"=^'^^*?5=^S?#^'^^-'''- ^ .ilClli . .j.\ixij < Rober

t !'eri>^kian,Mav'I . )iO

^^ZlXi ) •:* * '•i^':-'--x.-e:-i- -

"V:f^# -90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO.C_ : r:ipa:43.:4 8 p.ni. . ,^,:^;07-19^201 0 6 2 /6 5 HowardL . Martin , Jr. , Regiona l Counse l Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Offic e ofth e Regional Counsel , AAL- 7 22 2 Wes t 7t hAvenue , Bo x 1 4 Anchorage , AL99513-758 7 Re : I n th e Matter

o f Precisio n Display s an dTool s Cas e No . 2008AL70003 9 Dea r Sir : r-r\ \ 

# /aecewe o ^

%Avia^^9^ ' )

Pursuan t t o th e requiremen t

o f Respondent' s Answer

o n pag e 1 1 ofth e Complaint , I admittedl y hav e faile dt o file a n answer withi n 3 0 day s a s require dby th e Rule s o f Practic e i n FA A Civi l Penalt

y Proceedings . However , thi s failure t o file a n answer i s no t withou t goo dcause . Pe

r Sectio n 13.209(f

) ofth e Rule s o f

Practice , " A person' s failure t o file a n answe r withou t goo dcaus e shal l b e deeme da

n admissio n ofth e trutho f eac hallegatio n containe di n th e complaint. " M y failure t o file a n answe r wa s du e t o amedical emergenc y i n m y family . O n September 29 , 2009 , w e discovere dtha t my daughte r

ha s abrai n tumo r

an dmus t underg o emergenc y surger y o n Novembe r

30 , 2009. 1 hav e bee n constantl y tie du p withthi s situation , whic hinclude s many MRls , CTs , bloo dtests , spina l taps , an dappointment s wit hm y daughter' s neurosurgeon . Becaus e m y primar y plac e o f residenc e i s i n Mexico , I hav e been continuousl y comin g i n andou t o f Sa n Jose , C A i n order

to^beiwith'ihefifo

r he r medical test s an dappointments .

''' . - ' ^ • ' • ^ Althoug hI di dno t

submi t atimel y answer

to th e complaint , thi s oversigh t i s no t du e t o carelessness ; rathe r

it i s becaus e o f

my daughter' s dir e situation . I t woul db e greatl y appreciate dif you woul dallo w m e anothe r opportunity t o file m

y answe r i n respons e t o th e complaint . Furthermore , m

y daughte r

wil l stil l b e tryin g t o recover durin g th e montho f

January , an di

t woul d b e greatl y aippreciate di f

yo u woul dpostpon e th e trial dat e set fo r January 5-8,201 0 in th e U.S . Ta x Cour t t o alater date . I woul db e more tha n happ y t o provid e yo u wit harespons e in thi s matter . Pursuant t o th e statute , I hav e no t

"knowingl y committ[ed ] a n ac t in violatio n of,4 9 U.S.C . chapte r 5 1 . . . . " (Sectio n 13.16(c) ) because ! di dno t kno w thatth e package s containe dflammable and/o r hazardou s material . •..•'" • v^^., . :h i ' , . ius: . .>

• i, : .. . .'c . i s not. . Any extensio n i n submittin g thi s respons e woul db e greatl y appreciated , a s woul da postponemen t

ofth e trai l date . Thank

yo u ver y muc hfo r your tim e an dfo

r considerin g thi s request . iMaiBMinMtiiittM"irtiffiii«ii'i'iiiltnr>»iMiipi'iiw*i'^"wr^f«i V • • - i ^^llW|UJUffllilIi5^dJu|illll''IiMlI i Hiffifrra ^ ^,.-c . r- — ..andappuiattiicnti

j wit hmy'dau^.!.:^;'s. h. . . Rober t Persekian Precisio n Display s an dShowcase s 155 5 Alu mRock

Avenue.-Sjiite 2 0 .SanJose;'CAi9511t.^^,.,,^^j£,3^g,;^ ^ .„_ _.,..„.. . . _... . , . ;:[•_,••. . ......uiiiposii^...!:; : ^h c .li-i . -Jt e . : : lor

J::...:..: y : •ite.- ' • • . (408)504-241 5 " / /90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO C rrecii s io n 03:43:3 4 p.m . 07-19-201 0 63/6 5 p . 2

June , 04 ; 200 8 Anchorag e Avi a 22 2 Wes t /* " Anchorage , PH : 907-271 - FX : 907-271-4 9 RE : Fil e NO : ISS S ALU M ROC K AVE . SVrTEIia O SA N JOSE . C A 9511 6 TE L: <4I» ) 2S1-799 0 /

(800 ) 786-295 4 FA X : (40S ) 251-230 2 /

<8S8 ) 377-924 3 Io n Securit yan d Hazardou s Material s #1 4 99513-758 7 A \ »nu e Ala - ^ 5 C 3 3 \ 3 2)08AL70003 9 To : Mr . Jeffre y

dec ! ir e W e wer e unaw i Installatio n cre

v chec k an d mad e sur e t o indden t an d w

e sinc e thi s lette r t o tak e ful l res | circumstance s Beatric e Valen c 2515 . l l

jui i tO , vj-.' , ^UU C

• ;rT''- ' . r.-^V® ; f re r . 1 •: . 1 r . r i 0 3 '( 3 3- 1 p 11 1 I ' ^ ilij'c'.'r i : Deit z r e o f thi s unfortunat e situation . I n ou rdefense ^ w e hav e a ne winexperience d V an d i n thi s particula rslijpn^t , ti^ e prope rper^nne l wa s no t availabl e t o th e hazardou s matef1^l^w,,have:,J|st?d . Ou rback-u p cre wnaivel yjus t packag e ever yIte m tha t wasJolitxinjJba^Sa h Diego , Ca . W e apologiz e fb rthi s ar e thankfu l tha t

it vv ^ broughf

t t o ou r a|ptentIon . W e hav e take n prope r actio n wa s receh/ed . I understand.^a t w e ar e unde rinvestigatio n an d w e ar e read y onsibilit yfo rbu ractions . Again , than k yo u fo rth e opportunit yt o explai n ou r regard s t o thi s matter . I f yo u hav e an yconcern s o rquestions , yo u ma yreac h a t ou roffic e I n Sa n Jos e a t 408-251-799 0 o rI ma yb e reache d a t 408-504 - ^^-^'. ^

i<iwuiLUiicii.i.i<*situation». * I n ou rdefe^iic , '/«e hi-i.' . <.' rid-in*'L::is^ps;liculci ' :;hipri,tir!;. . t'- . ; roper-,person.:;: !

. : •.....*i!::.,.;»('Jcju.: , fitate i -' s V : : : _ !: • ^'li,' ^ Of' f ' c 

# H

OLT': - .J. - /_.J U L- r90 7 276726 1 ALASKA N RO.C-^"J^*V^; ? i^':!^--^-.0^'f(yi{45<JiS-f^[n(y^-- ^ 64/6 5 U.S , DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N FEDERA LAVrATlO NADMINISTRATIO N SECURIT

Y & HAZARDOU S MATERIAL S

RECOR D O FINTERVIEW : Robert Persekian , Ovmer/l»resident , Precisio n Display s & Tools, 155 5 Alu mRoc k

Avenue , Sa

n Jose , C A 95116 , (408 ) 251-7990 , O n Jun e 11 , 2008 , 090 0 hours , th e undersigne dinterviewe dRobert Persekian regardin g th e circumstance s surroundin g th e undeclare dofferin g o f hazardou s material s o n Ma y 9 , 2008 . Prio r t o th e intervie w Robert Persekia n was informe dthat th e purpos e o f

th e intervie w was fo

r th e investigatio n o f

aregulatory violation . Mr . Robert

Persekia n agree dt o b e interviewe dan drelate dth e following : Mr . Robert

Persekia n explaine dthat th e compan y plan s , designs , build s an dinstall s custo mcabinetry an d display s worl dwide . The y hav e thei r corporat e office s i n San Jos e andamanufacturin g plan t i n Sa n Diego . Standardprocedure s are for Precisio n Display s & Tool s t o containeriz e an dshi p thei r custo m buil t display s t o alocatio n fo

r installation . Onc e th e displays/fixture s arrive , acre w i s dispatche dan d thei r installatio n tool s ar e shipped . It i s compan y polic y t o neve r shi p hazardou s materials . Item s suc ha s pain t an dthinne r

etc , ar e purchase dlocall y an dan y leftover s are eithe r returne do r

give n to th e stor e fo

r touc h up . ~' ^ _--•-: • MXVMA Y Si-^IA2l\Z<U\n'-:<r'SX^TET(T\L-S-.7.,: . . . .^. : , . Mr . Robert

Persekia n say s h e understand s th e danger s presente db y hazardou s material s an dbecaus e h e ride s o n thes e very aircraft , hi s polic y i s t o no t shi p hazardou s materials . Accordin g t o Mr . Persekian , i n thi s instanc e Precisio n Display s & Tool s was buildin g aJewelry Stor e i n Ketchika n an dupo n completion , an dbein g i n ahurry th e cre w mad e amistak e an daccidentall y shippe d th e hazardou s materials . Mr . Persekia n wen t o n t o say that

i n th e man y year s that

th e hav e bee n i n busines s thi s i s th e first

inciden t o f thi s sort t o occur . Mr . Robert

Persekia n stat'e dthat

nowoevery^job'sit

e manage r

i s persohally'responsibl e t o chec k al l shipmen t prio r t o thei r bein g packaged'ain dshipped.-•-'• - '^•' ^ -la y > . _J '.,;. • : •':)-•.: ! i

M b' - . /<-T.-.^-".v . t' . icdthc.tbi ;

; Jeffrey L . I3eitz ; Specwlf9^e'Sl^'|"^ ^ Hazardou s Material s SpeciaUs t r:c,cu: : :,! , p . ;. , ,.., \u; oi.ij ; i . ^

Intervlevred/ReviQwe d O n B y Specia l Agen t

Jeffrey Deit z if^^ewtelr yStore i n n ' TM J.-

, K . ^ 2008AL70003 9 FA AFor m 1600-32- 1 (s-ae ) ;ci(f?n . .'rihi!ys(?ftfbv^c^ : •; . FO R OFFICIA L US E ONL Y (Publl e tYMllMllt yto b a dHtmlif d unda rS U.S.C . U2 ;

• sp9t3fifit^S^fi^ ^ iN^'sis^SS^-a-ie*** ^ "*****'».•-*-• «90 7 276726 1 ALASKANRO C 03:44:0 0 p.m . 07-19-201 0 65/6 5 U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N FEDERA L AVIATIO N ADMINISTRATIO N SECURIT Y & HAZARDOU S MATERIAL S

RECOR D O FINTERVIEW ; Lewi s Lourenco , Sit e Manager , Precisio n Display s & Tools, 155 5 Alu m Roc k Avenue , Sa

n Jose , C A 95116 , (619 ) 708-2441 . O n Jun e 18 , 2008 , 094 5 hours , th e undersigne dinterviewe dLewi s Lourenc o regardin g th e circumstance s surroundin g th e undeclare dofferin g o f hazardou s material s o n May 9 , 2008 . Prio r t o th e intervie w Lewi s Lourenc o wa s informe dthat th e purpos e ofth e intervie w was fo r th e investigatio n o f

aregulatory violation . Mr . Lewi s Lourenc o agree dt o b e interviewe dandrelate dth e following : Mr , Lewi s Lourenc o explaine dthat i t wa s hi s responsibilit y a s sit e manage r t o ensur e compan y policie s wer e followed . I n attemptin g t o follo w company guideline s h e separate dth e remainin g hazmat/flammable s fromth e tool s an dplace dth e hazma t i n abo x for

later disposition . Mr . Lewi s Lourenc o ha dhire dsom e loca l laborer s t o hel p withth e installation . On e o f thes e laborer s place dth e hazma t into th e tote s that

th e tool s wer e packe dint o for shipmen t bac k t o th e manufacturin g plant i n San Diego . Mr . Lourenc o state dthat he^^i(J,p^j^j^^i^^J^)j];]i,^l^|:)|^^t9if^ ^ shippe dan ddi dno t kno w that th e hazma t

was included . ^r . Mr , Lewi s Lourenc o say s h e understand s th e danger s presente db y hazardou s materials , andth e compan y polic y i s to no t

shi p hazardou s materials . Mr . Persekian tha

t thi s inciden t

ha s increase dhi s awarenes s an dalerte dth e compan y that more care need s t o b e take n i n preparin g an dpackagin g retur n shipments . H e personall y wil l spen dtim e trainin g an y ftiture local hire s o n exactl y what to.pac k an dwha t no t t o pack , prior.t o anythin g bein g readie dfo r return shipment . 

# '/-y ^ • .;Our ; , •; ;

. . •.!.•.•,., . :.:•!; ' ;itj , ; > ,:.;rs;: '

r^'iv. . 'n^: ;

ii'. . i.,icr' .

';>•..; .

. } , . • . .Ii-' .

I ^S . , c di.,c \ tl:- > . . VI S L : : u y V , •''C- i ...:_;.J O i ' ^wDK . \\\'iyr.S' . . ^Jeffrey L . Deitz , Special Agen t r ^-Hazardou s Materialsgpeaalisti^^^i*<cgg^ ^

! ^ •'^fTOff'tDCils^aftdplaeed^h e IVazma i ; ! abo. v fo r later dlsp V . :! . \ LJ : . . .: . .jtcr s t o h-.p v :'! ; .:: - ,..^i.:^il;::iOU . < " ... : oi" . •: i l\0u , .-h-wi^rt " jTOckc dirvft f fo r shipi'-ien t

^xi': hl o th e r;..;;•. . , ' ;; . ' • c JH I {••J' . -y\'.}\k::.h:j'. . ' n - .. . bcing^Jsiii j .

y . •w.Tj.l4U)iiiiji.iU^iiUi^ . I • , nI . .1 1 . . • -, . I.,. . • . —•„-,—.-tr-^ r "•. • 1 — •.•.i^<!ii»<i.-»i<|*«yij:»»ir-'itfy----<ri'*ii*^.^iVtlBit.'.'-.-'i^v ^

' ^f:, a'>''• #.-^^ ' ':• > - •.-• - :--> - ' -^ i ,>

• --.-:-.-. - .-lu'^i i ... . 1 n C 1 V Jl . - : ii: i ,.\ . . , w . . i..iit . ..iwlI^ U i v „i . .. . Interviawed/Reviewe dO n . a. : .u':.:..t-u..iiL^ . ! ! L.^^.jag^ > ..::! • ' 3^ Special Agent

Jeffrey Deitz, ^ • ^a-rj^^^^^^j^^ y :,,..,, . ^,^,P„ ^ ^,,2008AL70003 9 FA A For m1600-32- 1 (9-86 ) FO ROFFICIA LUS E ONL Y (Publi c tnllmblllt y t o b * tf«(inn/iMdundtr S U.S.C . M2 ) 

# I 7 ';:-*^^S^|Sp!r ^ ^rm^..f-'i'K^,-*^-i-i '