7KH +RQRUDEOH *HUDOG ( 5RVHQ 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW -XGJH IRU WKH(DVWHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 0LFKLJDQ VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,213XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU)LOH 1DPH DS	

			



1,7('7$7(6 2)0(5,&$	

$1'$// (8+$866(5+(,/$(8+$866(5	

 !""#$%&'()#
*(#	((# +* (&*,(-&(%&()#	-()#&+* (&*,(%)*(*,*(*.///.0	&()-&	"*#1#$+* (&*,(2-1#&1-#34#'5#&/6///+#,*#*$#3#5&-&76//8#%
	9:*&,-*(2-1# ;	+* (&*,(2-1#6
 !<)*$*"<*(=#&*,*(*)*$7(>"*#&'*$()*%&""#$$( ?*$$*'-(
+ 		 : *,*(* )* %&""#$$##
<)*$*"<*(=#&*,*(*)*$7(>"*#&'*$()*%&""#$$( ?*$$*'-(

+		:*,*(*)*%&""#$$##	+* (&*,(2-1#+#%#(!""#$$( $$ #-)- #& ""#$  )*#(#,# %& , "*&,7 ( * (&*5-(#  ( " #  @*()*(#((* (&*5-(#,,*#'&*A-*4*$(*%6	BB..+#%#(!""#$$(	)#*$#-)- #&""#$ 5())#&,4*,(*)#& #(#,#%&()* &-1, "*&,7%%# #$ ""#$ )#&,4*,(*-#&.
	BC6%&(&4#$*1**(#& ((#,''#&,#( %-&()#&-$@%-$,(*4*(7()#* (&*5-(*%,,*#$$@*1(&*$()(,''#,#	#"(#'5#&6..()#A-&7&#(--*$(74#&*,( 1* (5()$$	)#*$#-)- #&()# #,)&1# ,(5#&.2-# D& #-)- #& @  #(#,# ( / '()  %*'"&* '#(  / 7#&  % -"#&4* # &#$# # "$-  E6C///%*#	#"(#'5#&D #-)- #&@#(#,#(C7#& %*'"&* '#(C7#& % -"#&4* #&#$# #E6C//%*#8()#%#( (*'#$7""#$# ()# # ""#$  @#&# , $*(# 57 '(* % ()#>4#&'#( !
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	)#*$#-)- #&%*& (,(# ()(()#A-&74#&*,(   )#& ,4*,(*   ()# &-1 , "*&,7 *(#& ((# (&4#$ ,)&1#  &# 1* ( ()# @#*1)( % ()##4*#,#D #-)- #&$ &1-# ()( )#@ #*#()##%%#,(*4# * (,#%,- #$((&*$()&-1))#&,- #$J%*$-&#("&"#&$7,& #F'*#K#7@*(# # 5A#,((()#'* * % )#& 7  "&-,# @*(#  (# (*'7 ()(@-$ ,(&*,( ()# *,&*'*(*1 (# (*'7 % ()#&@*(# #   *$$7 )#  #&(  ()( )# @  #&&#- $7,)&1# ( #(#,*1 @*() ()# #(*&# '-( % &-1*4$4#*()#, "*&,7# "*(#)#&"-&"&(#$7$*'*(#&$#*()* , "*&,7& ()# &#   ((# 5#$@ @# %%*&' $$#-)- #&J  #(#,#	)#*$#-)- #&J ,4*,(* #(#,#()#&-1, "*&,7,)&1#5-(@##& #D #-)- #&J *(#& ((#(&4#$,4*,(* 1* (()#@#*1)(%()##4*#,#




(()#-( #(@#&#,*(#$75&#-($*#%()#%,( #4*#,#"&# #(#((&*$@*()%-&()#&#(*$ (5#"&# #(#
 !$FFRUGLQJ WR 6KHLOD 1HXKDXVVHU¶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
	+* (&*,(-&(%&()#	-()#&+* (&*,(%)*'#+#%#( !""#$$( $$	)#*$#-)- #&$1@*() %-& ()#& **4*-$    ,, "*&(&  *  &-1(&%%*,K*1#(#&"&* #*4$4*1'&*A-,,*#)*, "*&,7$$#1#$7&%&'()&-1)()#(#%()#**,('#(  
 *(* ()# **,('#( ,)&1# 	)#*$#-)- #&,#%#(	,((D#7#& @*()(&4#$*1**(#& ((#,''#&,#*%-&()#&,#%-$@%-$,(*4*(7()# * (&*5-(* %  ,(&$$# -5 (,#  *$$7 ()#**,('#( ,)&1# ()#& ,#%#( 2'# D,&(7@*()-'5#&%()#&&-1&#$(#%%# # $$%-&,#%#(  -$(*'(#$7 #(#&# 1-*$(7 "$#   1&## ((# (*%71* (()##-)- #& (()##-)- #& J(&*$@)*,),''#,#	#"(#'5#&6..()#>4#&'#("&# #(##4*#,#&*1(@&-1(&%%*,K*14#(-&# *& (@*(# # (# (*%*# ((&*"'#($*%&*(5(*'&*A-%& -5 #G-#( $#57$$#-)- #&,#%#(+-18-&1# )*(# (*'7**,(#()(($# ( '#%()#(&*" @#&#'#*&-&- "-&,) #57$$#-)- #&8-&1#   ()( ()# '&*A- @  5&-1)( ( ()##-)- #& J&# *#,#(668#9#5)* $$ @*(# #  (# (*%*# ( ""&F*'(#$7 #*1)( (&*"  ($*%&*(5(*,&$ %'&*A-)##*1)()(&*",,$-#- -,,# %-$$7	#"(#'5#&@)#,#%#( 	,(( D#7#&  @  &&# (# 57 ((# (&"#&  *#5& K )#&#(-&#%&'$*%&*)##5& K ((# !
6 (##&$*#&@)*$#D #-)- #&@ ,)&1#@*()()# '#&-1G-(*(*#  D&#-)- #&()#+* (&*,(-&(1&(#)#&&#G-# (%&@@&#"&(-&###'#)#&"&(*,*"(* $7*15#(@##H'*&IH'**'$I!! 	#(#,*1 #&*1 ( C 2 ( /6 ,*(*1		>B86#1&*1()#&-1G-(*(*# @#)4#5 #&4#  ()# 	#(#,*1 >-*#$*#  ,%*&' ()( #%#(,4*,(#%, "*&,7'75#,)&1#@*()$$&# 5$7%&# ##5$#,( '* * %,, "*&(&* %-&()#&,# % ()# , "*&,7    (/.,*(*1
		>B8""$*,(*(#6
()*  , # ()#&# @  (# (*'7 ()( D  #-)- #& @"&# #(-'5#&%,, * @)#&-1 @#&-1)(5,K%&'$*%&*(()##-)- #& J&# *#,#*)*@)# &-1 "7'#(  @#&# '#  @)# ()# &-1#(#&"&* #@ * ,- #
*(* (##&$*#& '#(# (*'7**,(#()( )#(K'&#,(*4#&$#%#@,, * ()*  &#,&@#,( 7()(()#+* (&*,(-&( ,''*((# ,$#& #&&& * #(#&'**1 ()# &-1G-(*(*# ,)&1#5$#(	)#*$#-)- #&*,$,-$(*1)#&4#&$$ #(#,#& ()# &#   #( %&() 54# @# %%*&' ()# #(#,#*'" #-"$$#-)- #& %&)* &-1, "*&,7,4*,(*  -&()#& @# %%*&' 	)#*$ #-)- #&J  &-1, "*&,7 ,4*,(* #& # )#& ,4*,(* -#& ()#&4#$,(%%*&'()#+* (&*,(-&(J  #(#,#%	)#*$#-)- #&()#&-1, "*&,7,)&1# #G-#($7(	)#*$#-)- #&@#&#'()* '((#&(()#+* (&*,(-&(%&#(&7%'##A-1'#(*,,&,#@*()()* #,* *6.
 !7R WKH H[WHQW WKDW WKLV ODWWHU SRLQW LPSOLFDWHV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO LVVXHVZH KDYH DGGUHVVHG WKHP DERYH DQGIRXQG QRFRQVWLWXWLRQDO LQILUPLW\ LQ0V 1HXKDXVVHU¶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	)#*$#-)- #& (,& #F'*(* % @*(# #   ()# '* *5*$*(7 %)#& 7 '- ( @*( , *#&(* -#&  '&# %-$$7#4#$"#&#,&  !" !"  # $" %
"&!'*$$7	)#*$#-)- #&&1-# ()()#&C7#& #(#,#*  ( &#,,*$5$# @*() )#& $*'*(# &$# * ()# &-1, "*&,7&#%$#,( &-1G-(*(*# ()(&#("&"#&$7,)&1#5$#()#&?#*#@()#%,(-$%**1 %()#+* (&*,(-&(( #(#,*1%&,$#&#&&&/./.()*&C	6C !
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	)*4#&#,K#&	)#*$#-)- #&@ &#"&# #(#57((<)*$*"<*(=#&,(5#&.()#A-&7&#(-&# 1-*$(7 4#&*,(  1* ( 5() $$  	)#*$#-)- #&  ()# &-1 , "*&,7 ,)&1#   1-*$(74#&*,(1* (D #-)- #&()#*(#& ((#(&4#$,)&1#< ((&*$'(* @#&#%*$#5#)$%%5()#%#( @*()D #-)- #&&#"&# #(#*()* " ((&*$") #( #(#,*1 57 (( )'  D*$$#&  
 ()# "&# #(""#$$$#-)- #&* &#"&# #(#57<)*$*"<*(=#&)#*$J (&*$,- #$@)*$#D #-)- #&* &#"&# #(#57#@ ,- #$ $7( "*#&  ,,&*1 ( D #-)- #&J 5&*#%""#$D&<*(=#&'#(@*()$$#-)- #& #4#&$,, * @)*$#)#@ &#"&# #(*1)#*$#-)- #&D&#-)- #&"*($# ("&(*%<*(=#&J %##%&&#"&# #(*1D #-)- #&((&*$
 !$$#-)- #&@  #(#,#2-#(/'()  % *'"&* '#(  (#7#& "#&* % -"#&4* #&#$# #E6C///%*#( #(#,*1()#+* (&*,(-&(%-()(D&#-)- #&@  &# " *5$# %&4#&6///"- %'&*A-4#&CK*$1&' %,,*#)#-&( $  ""$*#  %-&$#4#$ #),#'#( %& D&#-)- #&J $##& )*"&$#,,&*1$7-"#(#&'**1()(D&#-)- #&J %%# #$#4#$@ /)* ,&*'*$)* (&7 @  ,(#1&7 
M()# +* (&*,(-&( %-()(()#""&"&*(# #(#,*1&1#-#&()#	#(#,*1>-*#$*#@  / '()  ( $*%#  #$#,(# ( #(#,# D&#-)- #&(()#$@#%()* &1#)#*$#-)- #&@  #(#,#	#"(#'5#&(%*4#7#& *"&* %*4#7#& % -"#&4* #&#$# #E6C// %*#)#+* (&*,(-&(*'" #  #(#,#%/'() #,)%()#(@,-( %,4*,(*(5# #&4#,,-&&#($7
*'" *1()*  #(#,#()#-&(%-()()#*$#-)- #&$*K#$$@ ,)&1#5$#@*()4#&CK*$1&' % ,,*# 4#& 6///"- %'&*A-@#4#&()#+* (&*,(-&(1&(#@@&#"&(-&#%&D #-)- #&J '*&&$#*()#&-1, "*&,7 *(*$ #"&(-&# %& )#& ,"#&(* @*() ()#-()&*(*#   )-  D  #-)- #& @   *1#  5 #%%# #$#4#$%6,(#1&7

,&*'*$)* (&7&# -$(*1*  #(#,*1 &1# % C (  '()   )# +* (&*,(-&(J /'() #(#,#%#$$#&()#$@#%()* &1# !
6  !"(  ()  " 	((  
* "+ ++! , 	 ! "+""! 	&& )#&#F(* -#""#$D #-)- #&&1-# ()()# @ #*#()##%%#,(*4# * (,#%,- #$((&*$)#,*(# %-&(7"# %*#G-(#"#&%&',#&*'"&"#&,-,(57)#&(&*$,- #$3%*$-&#("&"#&$7,& #F'*# ,#&(* >4#&'#( @*(# # *&#&($7()#%-(*%&*'"#,)*1()# #@*(# # ()&-1)#F(&* *,#4*#,#%()#*&"&*&*, * (#( ((#'#( ;6%*$-&#("&"#&$7 ,& #F'*# @*(# #  ( "#&'*( ()# A-&7 (* (*1-* )D #-)- #&J ,(* ,-$"5*$*(7%&')#&)- 5J ;%*$-&#(5A#,((*'* *5$#)#& 7-&*1()#(# (*'7%D #-)- #&J $$#1#,, "*&(& ;   ,%$*,( % *(#&# ( @)#&# 	)#*$ #-)- #&J,- #$ ""&#($7 '#( @*()  @  5#*1 "* 57 )#&)- 5-&*G-*&7()* * -#*4$4# '*F#G-# (*%$@%,(
//./. ()*&.C6
	/C ;
	.6/C()*&6C/
	.C ()# >4#&'#( ,&&#,($7(#  @#(7"*,$$7(, *#&*#%%#,(*4#  * (,#% ,- #$ ,$*' *&#,(""#$ 5#,- # ()# &#,& - -$$7 *  ( -%%*,*#($7#4#$"#("#&'*("&"#& # '#(% -,),$*' 
	6.6()*&?#)4##F"$*#3)* &-$# (#' %&'()#%,(()(%**1%"&#A-*,#* "&#&#G-* *(#(,$*'%&*#%%#,(*4# * (,#%,- #$""#$$(#,-&( &#(#G-*""#(&# $4#%,(-$ * -#      &# -$( -& ,-&( )  &-(*#$7,,$-# ()( -,) ,$*'  &# 5# ( 5&-1)( 57 #%#( *  " (,4*,(* "&,##*1 -#& 6.	B66CC ()(()#"&(*# ,#4#$"#G-(#&#,&()* * -#6
 !%HFDXVH 0V1HXKDXVVHU¶V VHQWHQFH RQ WKLV FKDUJH ZDV WR EHVHUYHG FRQFXUUHQWO\ ZLWK KHU PRQWK VHQWHQFH RQ WKH GUXJ FRQVSLUDF\FKDUJH RXU UXOLQJ GRHV QRW DIIHFW KHU RYHUDOO VHQWHQFH()(1-# (* (&(*&#,& %&')(#$*&(9-#&$#$&* )@#()( 	)#*$#-)- #&) ,)#,K#*-1- (#"&(#-1- (/2(C/.)# #)(#$&#,& $ &#%$#,(()(D #-)- #&@(&4#$*1*&-&- @*())*$*,# #"$(# (6)#54*- #%*,*#,7*()* #4*#,#* ()(*("&4*# 5 *  %& ,,$-*1 ()( D  #-)- #& (&4#$# ($&**,#,(*@*()-$@%-$&-1#(#&"&* #&()#&()%&$@%-$"-&" #)#>4#&'#( ##K (%&1#()* #,# &7$*K57"*(*1(2'# D,&(7J (# (*'7()()#)5##($57$$#-)- #&()()*  -&,#%,,*#@ *$&*2(,,#"(*1()*(# (*'7 (&-#*( (*$$# ("&4*##G-(# -""&(%&()#*%#&#,#()(D #-)- #&J -1- ((&*"($&*@  '#)@&#$(#()#&)- 5J ,G-* *(*%,,*# %&' ()( '# ((#  
 %,( ()*  *%#&#,# *-#&,-(57()#&(# (*'7()(D&#-)- #&J "*,K-"(&-,K(()#&-&- @ ()#"&*,*"$4#)*,$#- #* ()# ,,*# * (&*5-(* #(#&"&* #  
 *(* ()#(# (*'7((&*$ -11# (#()($$#-)- #&5(*#()#,,*#%&'D*'*$&*(66@)*$#)* @*%#(&4#$#(&(9-#&$# #G-#($7-"*#@*1()#&#,&@#&#-5$#(*#(*%7 -%%*,*#( #4*#,# %&' @)*,)  &# 5$#A-&&,-$%*5#7&# 5$#-5(()(	)#*$#-)- #&4*$(# ()# &4#$ ,( ()&-1) )#& -1- (  (&*" ($&*)#&#%&#@# #( *#D #-)- #&J ,4*,(* #(#,#-(6%()#**,('#( !
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
!"#.6./()*&.  &* 
"  !" (  "%'(()#(*'#D& #-)- #& @ (&*#  #(#,# *.   *( @  @#$$ #(($# -#& 	*F() *&,-*("&#,##( ()(H()##(#&'*(*%()#G-(*(7%&-1*4$4#* (#$#'#(%()#%%# #,)&1#I
$.66()*&; 
 ../// ()*&;
%C6/()*&)- *(* (($$ -&"&* *1()(()#**,('#(* ()*  , # %*$# ( $$#1# 7 "#,*%*, G-(*(*#  %'&*A-&,,*#*4$4#*()#,)&1#, "*&,7()(()#A-&7* (&-,(* *(,$$-"()#A-&7('K#%**1  (&-1G-(*(*# ()#&()##(#&'*(*%.
 !G-(*(*#  @  $#%( %& ()# +* (&*,( -&( ( #(#&'*# (#(#,*1 -#& ()# H"&#"#&,# % ()# #4*#,#I(&(//H$&1#57%"&#,##()$ ()(&-1G-(*(7* * -#@*()&# "#,((#(#,*1$7* (5##(#&'*#%(#&,4*,(*57()#* (&*,(A-1#-(*$*=*1()#"&#"#&,#%()##4*#,#(&I2- (@##K 5#%&#D&#-)- #&@  #(#,#)@#4#&()#	-"&#'#-&( *1$#()(()* "*- $7 #(($#$@'*1)(5#"#(G-# (* 
$
C6	 66 6.  	 ( 6C 66  ()# -&(#F"&# # ,,#& ()( ()# H*'** )'#( % ()# A-&7J*1*%*,,# 57 &#'4*1 ,(&$ 4#& %,(  #(#&'**1 ((-(&7 #(#,*1 &1#I '*1)( *'"$*,(# ()# 	*F()'#'#(1-&(##%()# &*1)(((&*$57A-&7 
-5 #G-#( #,* * )# @ #&$*#& ()*  7#& ()#-"&#'#-&(,%*&'#@)($)'#&#$7 -11# (#0()(HNO()#&()()#%,(%"&*&,4*,(*7%,(()(*,&# # ()#"#$(7%&,&*'#5#7()#"&# ,&*5#((-(&7'F*'-''- (5# -5'*((#(A-&7"&4#5#7&# 5$#-5(I
$&C/	6/	(6.666/// (@ &#,#( #,* *  @# )4# , *#&# ()#*'"$*,(* %(,4*,(*  #(#,# -#&%##&$&-1 ((-(# *& (*
'()66C6()*&6///@#&# #, #*@)*,)()##%#(,72#5'"$#1-*$(7(* (&*5-(*%)#&**4*$(*%6
	B.@*()'F*'-'"&* (#&'%6/7#& ( #(#,*1)@#4#&()#+* (&*,(-&(%-57"&#"#&,#%()##4*#,#()(#())&# -$(#%&'#5'J * (&*5-(*%)#&*)* $#(* # #(#,*1&1#%6/7#& ($*%#6
	B.5#5'()#@  #(#,#((#&'%66'() &67#& '() ""#$#5'&1-# ()( ()# +* (&*,( -&(J  %,(-$ #(#&'*(* (#(#,*1 ()(  #() ) &# -$(# %&' )#& &-1* (&*5-(*@ ('#&#$7H #(#,*1%,(&I5-(@  !
6C7KHUH LV VRPH TXHVWLRQ DV WR WKH FRQWLQXLQJ YLDELOLW\ DQGSUHFLVHQDWXUH RI WKLV ODVW HOHPHQW RIVSHFLILF LQWHQW SDUWLFXODUO\ LQ FDVHV ZKHUHD 7UDYHO $FWFKDUJH EURXJKW DJDLQVW RQH FRQVSLUDWRU UHVWV XSRQ WKHLQWHUVWDWH WUDYHO RI D FRFRQVSLUDWRU6HH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y %HWDQFRXUW )G   WK &LUFHUW GHQLHG  86   +RZHYHUZH QHHG QRW UHDFK WKLV TXHVWLRQ XQGHU WKH IDFWV DQG DOOHJDWLRQV RI WKLVFDVH*( &# (#   ,$*' % * -%%*,*#( #4*#,#  ()# &-1, "*&,74#&*,( -'(! "   , 
% !/ ++!  &&"   !"()#*$#-)- #&$ ,)$$#1# ()# -%%*,*#,7%()##4*#,# -#&$7*1 )#& ,4*,(*  -( 6 % ()#**,('#( @)*,) ,)&1# )#& @*() (&4#$*1 * *(#& ((#,''#&,# ( %-&()#& ()# -$@%-$ ,(*4*(7 % ,,*#* (&*5-(** 4*$(* % . 
	 B C6 ()# H&4#$,(I
&#&(,4*,(()* ,)&1#()#>4#&'#('- ("&4#()(D #-)- #&(&4#$#*&- #()#%,*$*(*# %*(#& ((#,''#&,#;6()( )#((#'"(#(&**%,("&'(#'1## (5$* ),&&7&%,*$*((#()#"&'(*'1#'#(# (5$* )'#(&,&&7*1% -$@%-$ ,(*4*(7 * ()*  , # ,,*# * (&*5-(* *4*$(* % 6 
	 B .;   ()( )# %&'# "#,*%*,*(#(( 
C66/.6()*&6
	..
*( &# " #5&*#%""#$()#>4#&'#(*(&#()* ,)$$#1#(()# -%%*,*#,7%()##4*#,#()#&4#$,(,4*,(*)# **,('#( ,*(#   "&(*,-$& * (,# * @)*,)D #-)- #&$$#1#$74*$(#()#&4#$,(	"#,*%*,$$7*($$#1# ()( )#(&4#$#( &(9-#&$# $&*&&--1- (*%-&()#&,#%,,*#* (&*5-(*#(#&"&* #  
 -""&( % ()*  $$#1(* ()# >4#&'#("&# #(#()#(# (*'7%+1#()&$# 	(*#1#$'#7#&6
 !"&(*,*"(#*)#&)- 5J 4#(-(@,, * *@)#&#$$#-)- #&@ (()'#(,,#"('#7 %&'8-&1# @)#&#D #-)- #&,,#"(#()# # "7'#(   )#& )- 5J  5#)$%  ( CC;6()#&,, * @)#&#D&#-)- #&@ (()'#(,,#"(&-1"7'#( %&'2'# D,&(7@)#&#D #-)- #& 1* ,,#"(# ()*  '#7 @&""# * 5&@""#&  ( 6;     & C *,*#(*4$4*1H (&*" #&,)I%8-&1# (C66#1&*1()* $((#&*,*#(8-&1# (# (*%*#()(*(& #%(#&#%)* %&*# @ &&# (#$#*1()##-)- #&( %#& ()( 8-&1#  '*1)( 5#  *%&'(   ( 6,,&*1$75()%()##-)- #& ,-,(# (&*" #&,)%8-&1# (()#"$)- #()#*&8#"&"#&(7(#(#&'*#@)#()#&)#@ @#&*1@*&#(C668-&1# (# (*%*#()(-&*1()*  #&,)	)#*$#-)- #&"*(#1-()*'(C66C)# >4#&'#( ,K@$#1#  ()( D  #-)- #&J'#&#"&# #,# &-1&#$(#(& ,(* ,,-&&#@-$( (*1 $# -%%*,#( - (* )#& ,4*,(*  ,)&1#%, "*&,7@#4#&()#>4#&'#(&1-# @# 1&## ()( ()# #4*#,# % D  #-)- #&J  ,(*4#"&(*,*"(*$5#*(*$*'*(#,",*(7$7%#@,, * @-$"#&'*(&# 5$#A-&&(,,$-#()()#@ '&#()'#&#$7"&# #( &-15- *# @ 5#*1,-,(# @#)4#"*- $7#F"$*#HN O##'*1$7*,#(,( (K#**4*-$$7'7**,(#,'"$*,*(7*, "*&,7@)#4*#@#,$$#,(*4#$7@*()&#%#&#,#(,*&,-' (,# *1##&$I
	.66/6C()*&..*(#&$G-((* ,*((*'*((#  D#& @)*$# '-,) % ()# #4*#,# (# (*'7 &*1 D  #-)- #&J  "&(*,*"(* *,*&,-' ((*$ -,)#4*#,#) 5##)#$(5# -%%*,*#((- (*,4*,(*
.66()*&.,,&*1$7@#%*5 *%&4#&(-&*1()#A-&74#&*,(()#&-1, "*&,7,-( @# %%*&' ()# +* (&*,( -&(J  #*$ % 	)#*$#-)- #&J " ((&*$'(*%&,G-*(($(()##F(#(()( !
%**1   #$#'#( % ()# %%# # % ,4*,(*,,&*1$7 (@*() (*1 )#& "$#()&-1) @)*,) )#@*4#)#&&*1)((A-&7(&*$#5',(##()(()*#$#'#( )-$)4#5###(#&'*#-#&()#H5#7&# 5$# -5(I (&  ( ()# $#  &*1&-H"&#"#&,#I (&?#1&##%(#&%*& (*#@*1$
()#&&#,#(	-"&#'#-&(#,* *
C/	6/6/	(6//6///@#()#(-&#( ,,$-# ()( ()*  $((#& #,* * H'#  &*,$#"&(-&#I%&'()##&$*#&# '()66(C6"&(*,-$&@)#&#"&*&, # )$K#($#1* $(*4#*(#(( * (*1-* ) 5#(@## ()# #$#'#(  %  %%# # #(#,*1%,(& "(#'&# (&*1)(%&@&""&,) , *#&*1 $7 @)#()#&  %,( H*,&# #  ()#'F*'-'"#$(7 %&,&*'#I66(C6 *(#&$G-((* ,*((*'*((#
()#@K#%@#,,$-#3-&-(7*$*1)(%()* ,$#&*,((#%&'()#-&(* (#F'*#@)#()#&()# #(#,*1%,(&*()* , #@   %,(-$ #(#&'*(*  @)#()#& ()(#(#&'*(**,&# #()# 'F*'-' "#$(7 %&()#,&*'#,)&1#*()#**,('#(?#%*()(()# ((-(#*G-# (*)#&#(76
	B."&4*# %&%,(-$#(#&'*(*%@)#()#&()#* (&*5-(*%&-1,- ##()& #&*- 5*$7*A-&7()(()#%,(-$#(#&'*(* *1*%*,($7*'",( ()# #(#,#*'" #57()#,-&(*,&# *1()#'F*'-'"#$(7%&'6/7#& (()(%$*%#*'"&* '#(?# ,,$-#()("-& -(( )#& "$# 1&##'#(#5' @*4# )#&&*1)((A-&7(&*$%()#* -#%@)#()#&)#&* (&*5-(*% )#&* ,- # ()# #()  @#4#& @# %* ()(#5'*(@*4#()#&*1)(()4#,-&(#,*#7 &#'**1 #$#'#(  % ()# %%# # 5#7 &# 5$# -5(   "" # ( 'K*1 () ##(#&'*(* 57'#&#"&#"#&,#%()##4*#,#8#,- #()#"&4* * (* -#&#%,(-$#(#&'*(*/
 !5#,- #()#7*,&# #()#'F*'-'"#$(7(@)*,)#5'@ #F" #@#%*()(()#7&##$#'#( %()#%%# #@)*,)'- (5#"&4#5#7&# 5$#-5('()66(C66C)- @##& ##5'J#(#,#&#'#%&%,(-$#(#&'*(*-#&()#'&##F,(*1 (&%"&%D&#&#,#($7*
66C()*& 6/// @# &# #  *(-(* '#@)( *'*$&()-1) ( *#(*,$ ( ()# # @ 5#%&# -   )##%#(  * ()( , # @#&# ,)&1# @*() , "*&,7 (* (&*5-(#  ( " #  @*() *(#( ( * (&*5-(# ,&,K,,*# '#$ @#&#,)&1#@*() -5 ((*4#,-(% * (&*5-(* % ,,*# 5 #  )# #%#(  @#&#,4*,(#$$,-( (()# -5 #G-#( #(#,*1()#+* (&*,(-&(,$,-$(#()#&-1G-(*(*# %&@)*,)#,)#%#(@ &# " *5$#""#$()##%#( &1-#()(()#*& #(#,# @#&#*4$*-#&?#%*& (%%*&'#()(H()#"&*,*"$#  #(%&()*""$N7O(#%#( J , # I66  (C 
"&(*,-$&@#5 #&4#()(()#HN(O)#&#N@ O'#(*%N&-1O G-(*(7 * ()# **,('#(  ()# A-&7 '# %**1  &*1 G-(*(7I 5-( ()( HN"O-& -( ( ()#"&4* *  % B . ()# G-(*(7 % &-1  *   %,(-$#(#&'*(* ()( *1*%*,($7 *'",(  ()# #(#,#*'" #I66(C?##F"$*#3#,(*.5"&4*# %&'F*'-'"#$(7%6/7#& -$# ()#,&*'#*4$4# G-(*(7%&-1 #(%&()* -5 #,(* &8)# # -5 #,(*"&4*#%&'F*'-'"#$(7%/7#& *%()#,&*'#*4$4# C 1&'  & '&# % ,&,K ,,*#B .58   'F*'-' "#$(7 % $*%#*'"&* '#(*%()#,&*'#*4$4#C/1&' &'&#%,&,K ,,*#B.5)#* (&*,(A-1#%-57"&#"#&,#%()##4*#,#()#G-(*(7 !
6PDULMXDQD DQG D GHIHQGDQW ZLWKRXW SULRU GUXJ FRQYLFWLRQV6HH 86& E' 0V 1HXKDXVVHU¶V PRQWK VHQWHQFH GRHV QRWH[FHHGWKLV VWDWXWRU\ PD[LPXP DQG WKHUHIRUH LV QRW SODLQO\ HUURQHRXV  -' (!  "   %"&!'
%" 	%  0% "+ ,(! )#& ""#$ 	)#*$ #-)- #& %*& ( ,)$$#1#  ()#-%%*,*#,7 % ()# #4*#,#   ( )#& ,4*,(*   &-1, "*&,7  *(#& ((# (&4#$ ,)&1#   
 *#@*1 ,)$$#1# ( ()# -%%*,*#,7 % ()# #4*#,# @# '- ( (H@#*1) ()# #4*#,# "&# #(# , *#& ()# ,&#*5*$*(7 %@*(# # & -5 (*(-(#-&A-1'#( %&()(%()#A-&7I

CC6CC.()*&H
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
 !WKH WDVN EHIRUH LW DQG WKDW LWV UHVXOWLQJ YHUGLFW LV VXVFHSWLEOH RI RQO\ RQHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ,Q DGGLWLRQ ZH UHFRJQL]H WKDWWKHUH LV GLFWD LQ5DQGROSKVXSUDVXJJHVWLQJ WKDW LW LV WKH *RYHUQPHQW¶V EXUGHQ WR UHTXHVW D VSHFLDO YHUGLFWZKHQHYHU LW 3VHHNV >WKH@ LPSRVLWLRQ RI D VHQWHQFH UHIOHFWLQJ FXOSDELOLW\ IRUDQ REMHFW RI D FRQVSLUDF\ FDUU\LQJ JUHDWHU WKDQ WKH OHDVW JUDYH VHQWHQFLQJFRQVHTXHQFHV ́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́ LQ ZKLFK VKH FDOOHG RXUDWWHQWLRQ WR WKH$SSUHQGLDQG'DOHGHFLVLRQV 1HYHUWKHOHVV EHFDXVH ZHKDYH DGGUHVVHG WKHVH LVVXHV LQ 0U 1HXKDXVVHU¶V FDVH ZH DOVR FRQVLGHUWKHP DV WKH\ UHODWH WR 0V 1HXKDXVVHU¶V VHQWHQFH8SRQ FRQGXFWLQJ WKLV LQTXLU\ ZH ILQG WKDW 0V 1HXKDXVVHU¶VVHQWHQFH GRHV QRW LPSOLFDWH WKH FRQFHUQV UDLVHG E\$SSUHQGL3DJH DQG'DOH $SSO\LQJ WKHVH SUHFHGHQWV LQ WKHLU EURDGHVW IRUP 0V1HXKDXVVHU¶V PD[LPXP VHQWHQFHZRXOG EH  \HDUV RI LPSULVRQPHQWXQGHU WKH VWDWXWRU\ SURYLVLRQ JRYHUQLQJ DQ XQGHWHUPLQHG DPRXQW RI%$$@#()#*&* (&-,(* )4*15##1*4#&# *()#&#,&( - "#,(()(()#7*(@#%*()($$#-)- #&J /7#& #(#,## (#F,##()# ((-(&7'F*'-'%&()#%%# #%,4*,(*0'#$7, "*&,7( * (&*5-(#  ( " #  @*() *(#( ( * (&*5-(#*#(#&'*(#'-( %'&*A-,,*# !
:H QRWH WKDW DOO RWKHU FLUFXLWV WKDW KDYH UHDFKHG WKH TXHVWLRQ KDYHOLNHZLVH FRQFOXGHG WKDW$SSUHQGLDSSOLHV WR WKH GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI GUXJTXDQWLWLHVXQGHU  E6HHHJ8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y 1DQFH BBB )GBBB  :/  DW 
 WK &LU 'HF  8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y+LVKDZ BBB )G BBB  :/  DW 
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
 !,QD IRRWQRWH ZH UHMHFWHG WKH *RYHUQPHQW¶V DSSHDO WR KDUPOHVV HUURUDQDO\VLV H[SODLQLQJ FXUVRULO\ WKDW WKH GHIHQGDQWV KDG FKDOOHQJHG RQO\WKHLU VHQWHQFHV DQG QRW WKHLU FRQYLFWLRQV  )G DW  Q$7%, "*&,7@#%-"$* #(#,*1#&&&@#4,(# )*  #(#,#  &#'# %& &# #(#,*1  66(CC$*1)(%()# #&#,#(#,* * -&"()* $' (5-((G-*(# ,$#&  $$ #-)- #& $*K# &4#7 <1# @,4*,(#$7% , "*&,7-#&6
	B.@*()'F*'-' "#$(*#  #(#&'*# 57 &#%#&#,# ( 6 
	B.5)#**,('#()#&#$*K#()##*%*$#( "#,*%7&-1G-(*(*# ()#A-&7@ (* (&-,(#(#(#&'*# G-(*(*#  5#7  &# 5$# -5(  )#&#'**1G-# (*()#* @)#()#&()# #(#,#*'" #57()#+* (&*,(-&(,5# - (*#()#A-&74#&*,($#@*()-(&# &((*(*$%,(  -,) &-1G-(*(*# ()(@#&# #(#&'*# ( #(#,*1 -#& ()# H"&#"#&,#I(&?#@(-&(()* * -#1 ++! "+!"(@*() (*1*( "&1#7()#>4#&'#( #&( ()($$#-)- #&J  #(#,#* %-$$7 - (*5$#-#&()#%,(-$%**1 *)#&#(*()#A-&74#&*,(($# (@)# ,'5*# @*() D& #-)- #&J  &#,& % "&*&,4*,(*   	"#,*%*,$$7 ()# >4#&'#( "*(  ( 6	B.5@)*,)# (5$* )# /7#&'F*'-'(#&' % *'"&* '#( %& #%#(  @) ,''*( ,#&(*&-1%%# # *,$-*1() #*4$4*1,,*#@))4#H"&*&,4*,(*%&%#$7&-1%%# #I
()*, #$$#-)- #&) -,)"&*&,4*,(*()#>4#&'#(%*$#()#&#G-* *(#(*,#%*( *(#(*( ##K()* #),#'#( #F"&# $7&#,1*=#*()#%,(%"&*&,4*,(*&#'* @*()*()#"&4*,#%()#,-&((#(#&'*###(5# -5'*((#(A-&76/	((66;
* 6/  . 6 () *& 6/// # 5, !
67KLV &RXUW SUHYLRXVO\ KDV HOHFWHG WR IROORZ%DQNVDQG WKH FDVHV RQZKLFK LWUHOLHG DOEHLW LQ DQ XQSXEOLVKHG GHFLVLRQ6HH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y&DUWHU  )G  :/  DW 
 WK &LU -XO\  3:KHUH D PXOWLSOHREMHFW FRQVSLUDF\ FKDUJH XVHV WKH FRQMXQFWLYH LQOLVWLQJ WKH VXEVWDQWLYH RIIHQVHV WKDW ZHUH WKH REMHFWV RI WKH FRQVSLUDF\ LWLV QRUPDOO\ KHOG WKDW D JHQHUDO YHUGLFW RI μJXLOW\¶ UHODWHV WR DOO RI WKHVXEVWDQWLYH RIIHQVHV OLVWHG ́:KLOH ZH KROG WKDW WKHUH ZDV QR DPELJXLW\ LQ WKH LQGLFWPHQWLQVWUXFWLRQV RU JHQHUDO YHUGLFW LQ WKLV FDVH ZH GR QRW ZLVK WR GLVFRXUDJHWKH *RYHUQPHQW RU WKH WULDO FRXUW IURP XVLQJ VHSDUDWH FRXQWV VSHFLDOYHUGLFW IRUPV RU PRUH VSHFLILF LQVWUXFWLRQV LQ IXWXUH FDVHV LQYROYLQJPXOWLSOHREMHFW FRQVSLUDFLHV 3ODLQO\ LW LV DSSURSULDWH WR WDNH DQ\UHDVRQDEOH VWHSV ZKLFK PLJKW HQVXUH WKDW WKH MXU\ SURSHUO\ XQGHUVWDQGV()(H()#**,('#(@ PJ(P&J**,('#(I ()(HN(O)#A-&7*(##(#,*#5#(@##()#*%%#&#(&-1 IC/ 6 (CC; 
!./6/()*&%$$@*1@)#&#()#H**,('#(@ ")& #*()#,A-,(*4#I@)#&#H()#,-&(J * (&-,(* (()#A-&7&#*(#&(#()#,A-,(*4#(-&#%()#**,('#(I)C
	/!)
 . 6 C . /() *& . #,$**1 (,,& -,) *1*%*,,# (  **,('#( @)*,)H,A-,(*4#$7*,$-#N O$$()#"(#(*$*$$#1$5A#,(*4# %()#, "*&,7I)- @)#&#()##4*#,# (&-1(7"#@ H(,(&*,(#&-,$#&I()#*1)()*&,-*(%%*&'#()##%#( J #(#,# %**1()(()#(&*$,-&(H*(#$*,*('5*1-- &-,$#&4#&*,(%&'()#A-&7IC/6(CC?#%*()(()# '#)$ (&-#)#&#
##*,(& ((()##4&7*1&#%#&#,#*()#A-&7* (&-,(* **()#**,('#(* (&-,(* *()#"&# #(, #-*%&'$7, * (#($7*&#,(#()#A-&7(, *#&@)#()#&$$#-)- #&), "*&#(* (&*5-(#5()'&*A-,,*#  ( &#(-&  1-*$(7 4#&*,( $7 *% ()# A-&&-*'- $71&##5#7&# 5$#-5(()()#)#  -'*1 @#'- (()(()#A-&& ,&#%-$$76/
 !./(66)#-&(#F"$*#()(#&$*#&#,* *%**1'5*1-- 4#&*,(

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
$*1)(%$$()* ()#-&(@ H'&#(),%*#(()(()#A-&7@ ,4*,#5#7&# 5$#-5(()(5(),,*#"&#$-# @#&#*4$4#I./(66*'*$&$7*
C/6C/..()*&C/
	6()#*1)()*&,-*(* (*1-* )#"&*&#,* **@)*,)*())#$()(@)#&#()# H#4*#,# ( (&*$ *  ( ,$#&   ( @)*,) % (@$(#&(*4#&-1 @#&#*4$4#*'-$(*&-1, "*&,7I()# (&*$ ,-&( )-$ #*()#& - #  "#,*$ 4#&*,( %&' &#(#,#*,,&,#@*()()#&-1@)*,)H7*#$ ()#' (%4&5$# #(#,*1&# -$(%&()##%#( IC/6(CC, (&-*1
+/6.()*&/
57,(& (()#-&(&# # !
8#,- #D&#-)- #&@  #(#,#(/7#&(#&'%*'"&* '#(()#>4#&'#(,(# ()()*  #(#,#$*#@*()*()# ((-(&75-&*# %B.5()- '75#-")#$#4#@*()-(A-&7#(#&'*(*%&-1G-(*(*#  D&#-)- #&"*( -(()#>4#&'#(J &1-'#(*'"$*,(# -&#,* **
.6() *&  @)*,) '#@)( "&# 1# ()# &-$*1 *
 )#&#()##%#(@ ,)&1#,4*,(# *1$#,-(%, "*&,7(* (&*5-(#5(),,*#*()(, #,,*#5 #'&*A-
$*1)(%()#&-1(7"# G-(*(*# *4$4##%#(2#%%+$#%,# #*()#&  C7#& ((-(&7 'F*'-' "&*  (#&' %&, "*&,7 ( * (&*5-(# '&*A- 6 
	B .5+ &  /7#& 'F*'-' %& , "*&,7 (* (&*5-(#,&,K,,*#6
	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
	B.>*4#()#%,( *()* , #()#'F*'-' #(#,#%&, "*&,7 ( * (&*5-(# '&*A- *  %*4# 7#&  6	B.5+@)*$#, "*&,7(* (&*5-(#,&,K@-$7*#$ %&(77#&'F*'-' #(#,#6	B.58*4#,-&( %""#$ )4#)#$()(@)#()#A-&7&#(-& 1##&$4#&*,((,)&1#()(, "*&(&*$1&##'#(,4#&#'-$(*"$#&-1 ()##%#('- (5##(#,# *%)#* (&*5-(#$7()#&-1,&&7*1()#$@#&"#$(7.(6%((# '*((#?##$#,(#(%$$@()*  @#*1)( % -()&*(7 "&(*,-$&$7 @)#&# ()# 	-"&#'#-&(J  &# *1 &#$(#* -#*,
 C6 
	 C . 	 ( C . (## (-11# (()# '#-(,'#.()- @#,,$-#()(H()# )&(#&'F*'-' #(#,# )-$5#- #*%()#4#&*,(* '#&#$71##&$&()#&() "#,*%*, !
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
*./6C()*&C6.
	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
%(66. . / () *& 6///;! 
 +-(
6/.C.66()*&6///;
./...()*&CC
	./
()* , #()#**,('#(,)&1#()##%#( @*(), "*&*1(* (&*5-(#5()'&*A- ,,*# ()#A-&7 @  &#"#(#$7  , * (#($7* (&-,(#*,,&,#@*()()* ,)&1#D&#-)- #&*(&#G-# (7 &(%,$&*%7*1&H#),#-*'*(7I* (&-,(*& "#,*$4#&*,(%&' *1*%*,($7)##(@,(#()()* ,4*,(* )-$5# #( *#" *5$7&# (*1-"$# ()-*'- %**1  (#,(&$$# -5 (,#&()#()#&D#&()#A-&7@"&# #(# @*() '"$# #4*#,# %&' @)*,) *( ,-$ )4#%- ()( ()# , "*&,7 *4$4# 5() '&*A- ,,*# !
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¶V VLWXDWLRQ GLIIHUV IURP 'DOH¶V RI FRXUVH LQ WKDW-RKQVRQ¶V FRXQVHO H[SOLFLWO\ UHTXHVWHG D VSHFLDO YHUGLFW RQ WKHTXHVWLRQ ZKHWKHU -RKQVRQ KDG FRQVSLUHG WR GLVWULEXWH PDULMXDQDFRFDLQH RU ERWK +HUH WKH WULDO MXGJH DQG WKH JRYHUQPHQW ZHUHRQ QRWLFH WKDW -RKQVRQ ZLVKHG WR KDYH WKH RSSRUWXQLW\ WRFRQYLQFH D MXU\ WKDW KLV SDUWLFLSDWLRQ LQ WKH FRQVSLUDF\ UHODWHGRQO\ WR PDULMXDQD %\ GHQ\LQJ -RKQVRQ¶V UHTXHVW WKH WULDO FRXUWHIIHFWLYHO\ GHQLHG -RKQVRQ DFFHVV WR WKH MXU\ ZLWK UHVSHFW WR WKLVLPSRUWDQW TXHVWLRQ RI IDFW5DQGROSK  )G DW  %HFDXVH WKLV GHQLDO UHVXOWHG LQ D VHQWHQFH LQH[FHVV RI WKH VWDWXWRU\ PD[LPXP IRU D PDULMXDQDRQO\ FRQVSLUDF\ ZHIRXQG WKDW'DOHUHTXLUHG WKDW WKLV VHQWHQFH EH YDFDWHG  )G DW ()##&-1$$@ %& #(#,#54#()#'F*'-'%&()#&,)&1#&-1I.(( %*& ( 5$- ) *( ""#&  ()( $$ #-)- #&J#(#,# * ()*  , # "&# #(  ()*  '# *$#''  
% )*, "*&,7%%# #*4$4#,,*#()#G-(*(7@#&###'# *#(#&'*(# )# @-$ 5# -5A#,( (  /7#&((-(&7 'F*'-' "&*  (#&' * $*1)( % )*  "&*& &-1,4*,(* 6 
	 B .5  )*  /7#&#(#,#@-$(&* #(()#$#4#$%"$*#&&&
%()#()#&))* , "*&,7,4*,(*&# (# $#$7-"-K@'-(%'&*A-(,,*#)*  #(#,#
 !6LPLODUO\ LQ5DQGROSKVXSUD WKH WULDO FRXUW¶V IDLOXUH WR XVH WKHVSHFLDO YHUGLFW IRUP UHTXHVWHG E\ GHIHQGDQW-DFNVRQSUHFOXGHG DQ\GHWHUPLQDWLRQ ZKHWKHU WKH MXU\ KDG IRXQG -DFNVRQ JXLOW\ RI FRQVSLULQJ WRGLVWULEXWH PDULMXDQD FRFDLQH RU ERWK@-$5#$*'*(#(/7#&'F*'-'*$*1)(%)* "&*&,4*,(*6
	B.5+>*4#()#1##&$A-&74#&*,()#&# ##' (&#G-*&#()#$((#&&# -$(:#(()#&#* #*'"&((0@#,,$-#* " *(*4#0 * (*,(* 5#(@## ()*  , #   
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	,)#-$# 
  

 (&$$#-5 (,# *4*$(*%6
	B.6	B. !
*($# 6 
	 B . 'K#  *(  ,&*'# %&7#(K@*1$7&*(#(*$$7" # ,(&$$#-5 (,#@*()*(#((* (&*5-(#*(D&*A- ,,*# &# ,(&$$# -5 (,#@*()*()#'#*1%()#$@&7-(%*()##%#( 1-*$(7%4*$(*16	 B . 7- '- ( 5# ,4*,# ()( ()#14#&'#() "&4#5#7&# 5$#-5(3 )(#%#( K@*1$7" # #,(&$$#-5 (,# ;6 )(()# -5 (,# @#&#* %,('&*A-,,*#; )(#%#( " # #()# -5 (,# @*()()#*(#((* (&*5-(#()#'QQQQ "*&*1(+* (&*5-(#D&*A-,*#-(#$ ,)&1# ()(()##%#( 4*$(#*($#6
	B.@)*,)'K# *(,&*'#%&7#(, "*&#@*() '###$ #(,''*(4*$(*%,#&(*,(&$$# -5 (,# $@ %()#
*(#	((# QQQQ&7-(%*()##%#( 1-*$(7%4*$(*16	 B . 7- '- ( 5# ,4*,# ()( ()#14#&'#() "&4#5#7&# 5$#-5(3 )((@&'&#"#&  *&#,($7&**&#,($7&#,)#  1&##'#(( " #  @*()*(#((* (&*5-(#'&*A-,,*#;6 )(#%#( K#@%()#-$@%-$"-&" #%()#1&##'#(;