CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
 

TABLE OF CONTENTS
 

1.1 PURPOSE OF THE DOCUMENT ................................................................................. 1­1
 

1.2 OVERVIEW OF COMMERCIAL EQUIPMENT STANDARDS................................. 1­1
 

1.3 OVERVIEW OF BEVERAGE VENDING MACHINE STANDARDS........................ 1­3
 

1.4 STRUCTURE OF THE DOCUMENT............................................................................ 1­6
 

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1.3.1 Beverage Vending Machine Analyses..................................................................... 1­5
 

1­i

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22
1­ii

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22
    

     

                       

                             

                   

     

   

                             

                            

                           

        

                           

                         

                                   

                       

                          

                       

                       

                       

                         

   

                           

                     

                         

                                     

                            

                               

                             

                       

                               

                         

   

                             

                             

                             

                          

                           

          

CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION
 

1.1 PURPOSE OF THE DOCUMENT
 

This technical support document (TSD) is a stand­alone report that documents the

technical analyses and results in support of the information presented in the Advance Notice of

Proposed Rulemaking (ANOPR) for establishing energy conservation standards for beverage

vending machines (BVM).

1.2 OVERVIEW OF COMMERCIAL EQUIPMENT STANDARDS

Part B of Title III of the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA) sets forth

provisions designed to improve the energy efficiency of various products and equipment. Part B

of Title III provides for the “Energy Conservation Program for Consumer Products Other Than

Automobiles.” (42 U.S.C. 6291–6309)

The National Energy Conservation Policy Act (NECPA) amended EPCA to add Part C of

Title III (42 U.S.C. 6311­6317), which established an energy conservation program for certain

industrial equipment. Part C provides for a program similar to Part B. The Energy Policy Act of

1992 (EPACT 1992), Public Law 102­486, included amendments to EPCA that expanded

Title III to include additional commercial equipment. The Energy Policy Act of 2005

(EPACT 2005), Public Law 109­58, updates several existing standards and test procedures;

prescribes definitions, standards, and test procedures for certain new covered products and

commercial equipment; and mandates that the Secretary of Energy (the Secretary) commence

rulemakings to develop test procedures and standards for certain new covered products and

commercial equipment.

Due to what appears to be an error in legislative drafting, EPACT 2005 includes

provisions dealing with definitions, test procedures, and energy conservation standards relating

to several types of commercial equipment, including beverage vending machines, in a section

that amends sections 321, 323, and 325 of Part B of Title III of EPCA (42 U.S.C. 6291, 6293,

and 6295, respectively) for consumer products. DOE anticipates that this error will be corrected

through legislation, and that the provisions will become amendments to Part C of Title III of

EPCA for “Certain Industrial Equipment.” 70 FR 60407 (October 18, 2005). Consistent with its

previous action to incorporate the EPACT 2005 requirements for commercial equipment into

Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), Part 431, which covers that type of

equipment, DOE intends to place the new requirements for beverage vending machines in

Part 431.

Section 135(c)(4) of EPACT 2005 amends section 325 of EPCA by adding, in part, new

subsections 325(v)(2), (3), and (4) (42 U.S.C. 6295(v)(2), (3) and (4)), which direct the Secretary

to issue by rule, no later than August 8, 2009, energy conservation standards for refrigerated

bottled or canned beverage vending machines. Such standards shall apply to beverage vending

machines manufactured three years after the date of publication of a final rule that establishes

energy conservation standards for that equipment.

1­1

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22
                         

                           

                           

    

                           

                      

                           

        

                                 

        

                             

                        

                

                          

                 

                   

                 

                           

                      

                              

                   

                           

                   

                      

                         

                       

                                 

                         

         

                     

                           

                       

                                    

           

Under EPCA, when the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) studies new or amended

standards, it must consider, the following seven factors to the greatest extent practicable:

(1) the economic impact of the standard on the manufacturers and consumers of the

affected products;

(2) the savings in operating costs throughout the estimated average life of the product

compared to any increases in the initial cost or maintenance expense;

(3) the total projected amount of energy savings likely to result directly from the

imposition of the standard;

(4) any lessening of the utility or the performance of the products likely to result from the

imposition of the standard;

(5) the impact of any lessening of competition, as determined in writing by the Attorney

General, that is likely to result from the imposition of the standard;

(6) the need for national energy conservation; and

(7) other factors the Secretary considers relevant (42 U.S.C. 6295 (o)(2)(B)(i) and 42

U.S.C. 6316(e), added by section 136(h)(3) of EPACT 2005).

Other statutory requirements are set forth in 42 U.S.C. 6295 (o)(1)–(2)(A), (2)(B)(ii)–

(iii), and (3)–(4) and 42 U.S.C. 6316(a)(1)­(3), and (e).

DOE considers stakeholder participation to be a very important part of the process for

setting energy conservation standards. DOE actively encourages the participation and interaction

of all stakeholders during the comment period in each stage of the rulemaking. Beginning with

the Framework Document and during subsequent comment periods, interaction among

stakeholders provides a balanced discussion of the information that is required for the standards

rulemaking.

In conducting the energy conservation standards rulemakings, DOE involves stakeholders

through formal public notifications (i.e., Federal Register notices). For this BVM energy

conservation standards rulemaking, DOE will employ the procedures set forth in DOE’s Process

Rule (Procedures for Consideration of New or Revised Energy Conservation Standards for

Consumer Products, 61 FR 36974, July 15, 1996, 10 CFR Part 430, Subpart C, Appendix A) to

the extent they are appropriate for developing energy conservation standards for the BVM

equipment covered under this rulemaking.

Although the Process Rule specifically applies only to the development of energyefficiency standards for consumer products, DOE has decided to apply its procedures to the

development of energy conservation standards for commercial and industrial equipment such as

the BVMs as well. See appendix A to subpart C of Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations,

Part 430 (10 CFR Part 430).

1­2

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22
                       

                              

                       

                      

                        

                                 

                   

                     

                        

                                 

                             

                            

                             

                           

                              

                               

                           

         

                         

                           

                      

                             

          

                           

                         

                         

                       

             

                         

                                 

                             

                   

                       

                     

           

                           

                             

                 

Before DOE determines whether to adopt a proposed energy conservation standard, it

must first solicit comments on the proposed standard. Any new or amended standard must be

designed to achieve significant additional conservation of energy and be technologically feasible

and economically justified. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(3)(B) as directed by 42 U.S.C. 6316(a)(1)

through (3)) To determine whether economic justification exists, DOE must review comments

on the proposal and determine that the benefits of the proposed standard exceed its burdens to the

greatest extent practicable, weighing the seven factors listed above.

Subsequent to the publication of the Framework Document, the standards rulemaking

process involves three additional public notices, which are published in the Federal Register.

The first of the rulemaking notices is an ANOPR, which is designed to publicly vet the models

and tools used in the rulemaking and to facilitate public participation before the proposed rule

stage. The second notice is a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NOPR), which presents a

discussion of comments received in response to the ANOPR; analysis of the impacts of standards

on customers, manufacturers, and the Nation; DOE’s weighing of the impacts; and the proposed

standards. The third notice is the Final Rule, which presents a discussion of comments received

in response to the NOPR; the revised analysis of the impacts of standards; DOE’s weighing of

the impacts; the standards adopted by DOE; and the effective dates of the standards.

1.3 OVERVIEW OF BEVERAGE VENDING MACHINE STANDARDS

As mentioned above, EPACT 2005 amends section 325 of EPCA by adding subsections

that direct the Secretary to issue energy conservation standards for refrigerated bottled or canned

beverage vending machines. Such standards shall apply to beverage vending machines

manufactured three years after the date of publication of a final rule that establishes energy

conservation standards for that equipment.

Additionally, section 135(b) of EPACT 2005 amends section 323 of EPCA by adding, in

part, new subsections 323(b)(15) (42 U.S.C. 6293(b)(15)) and 323(f) (42 U.S.C. 6293(f)), which,

respectively, state that the test procedure for refrigerated bottled or canned beverage vending

machines shall be based on American National Standards Institute (ANSI)/American Society of

Heating, Refrigerating and Air­Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) Standard 32.1­2004,

“Methods of Testing for Rating Vending Machines for Bottled, Canned or Other Sealed

Beverages,” and that the Secretary has until August 8, 2007, to prescribe that new test procedure.

Section 135(a)(3) of EPACT 2005 amends section 321 of EPCA by adding, in part, new

subsection 321(40) (42 U.S.C. 6291(40)), which establishes the following definition:

The term “refrigerated bottled or canned beverage vending machine” means a

commercial refrigerator that cools bottled or canned beverages and dispenses the

bottled or canned beverages on payment.

In addition, section 136(a)(3) of EPACT 2005 amends section 340 of EPCA by replacing

subsection 340(9) (42 U.S.C 6311(9)) with, in part, definitions for the following terms relating to

commercial refrigeration equipment that are relevant to beverage vending machines:

1­3

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22
                

     

                       

                         

                         

                   

     

                           

                 

                     

   

                           

                       

                   

       

              

                   

                           

                         

             

                       

                   

                         

                 

       

                      

                 

                         

                   

       

“(9)(A) The term ‘commercial refrigerator, freezer, and refrigerator­freezer’

means refrigeration equipment that—

“(i) is not a consumer product (as defined in section 321);

“(ii) is not designed and marketed exclusively for medical, scientific, or research

purposes;

“(iii) operates at a chilled, frozen, combination chilled and frozen, or variable
 

temperature;
 

“(iv) displays or stores merchandise and other perishable materials horizontally,

semivertically, or vertically;

“(v) has transparent or solid doors, sliding or hinged doors, a combination of
 

hinged, sliding, transparent, or solid doors, or no doors;
 

“(vi) is designed for pull­down temperature applications or holding temperature

applications; and

“(vii) is connected to a self­contained condensing unit or to a remote condensing

unit.

“(B) The term ‘holding temperature application’ means a use of commercial

refrigeration equipment other than a pull­down temperature application, except a

blast chiller or freezer.

* * *

“(D) The term ‘pull­down temperature application’ means a commercial

refrigerator with doors that, when fully loaded with 12 ounce beverage cans at 90

degrees F, can cool those beverages to an average stable temperature of 38

degrees F in 12 hours or less.

“(E) The term ‘remote condensing unit’ means a factory­made assembly of

refrigerating components designed to compress and liquefy a specific refrigerant

that is remotely located from the refrigerated equipment and consists of one or

more refrigerant compressors, refrigerant condensers, condenser fans and motors,

and factory supplied accessories.

“(F) The term ‘self­contained condensing unit’ means a factory­made assembly

of refrigerating components designed to compress and liquefy a specific

refrigerant that is an integral part of the refrigerated equipment and consists of

one or more refrigerant compressors, refrigerant condensers, condenser fans and

motors, and factory supplied accessories.”

1­4

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22
                       

                   

                        

   

                           

                       

                        

                           

                         

                                  

             

            

   

                   

             

           

         

                  

                  

           

     

       

                                           

                                      

                       

                    

                              

               

                         

                           

                   

                         

                         

                   

                       

                          

                           

     

                     

                          

                             

In June 2006, DOE published a Rulemaking Framework for Refrigerated Bottled or

Canned Beverage Vending Machines describing the procedural and analytical approaches DOE

anticipated using to evaluate the establishment of energy conservation standards for BVMs. This

document is available at http://www.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/

commercial/pdfs/vending_machines_framework.pdf.

DOE held a public meeting on July 11, 2006, to discuss procedural and analytical

approaches to the rulemaking and to facilitate stakeholder involvement in the rulemaking

process. The analytical framework presented at the public meeting described different analyses,

such as the engineering analysis and the life­cycle cost (LCC) and payback period (PBP)

analyses, the methods proposed for conducting them, and the relationships among the various

analyses. See Table 1.3.1 for all the analyses discussed at the public meeting to be undertaken in

each of the formal public rulemaking documents.

Table 1.3.1 Beverage Vending Machine Analyses

ANOPR NOPR Final Rule*

Market and technology assessment Revised ANOPR analyses Revised NOPR analyses

Screening analysis Life­cycle cost sub­group analysis

Engineering analysis Manufacturer impact analysis

Energy use characterization Utility impact analysis

Markups to determine equipment price Employment impact analysis

Life­cycle cost and payback period analyses Environmental assessment

Shipments analysis Regulatory impact analysis

National impact analysis

Preliminary manufacturer impact analysis

* During the Final Rule phase, DOE considers the comments submitted by the U.S. Department of Justice in the NOPR phase concerning the

impact of any lessening of competition that is likely to result from the imposition of the standard. (42 U.S.C. 6295(o)(2)(B)(v))

During the July 11, 2006, public meeting, stakeholders discussed their concerns regarding

the BVM rulemaking. Stakeholder comments submitted during the Framework Document

comment period elaborated upon the issues raised at the public meeting. DOE worked with its

contractors to address these issues in the analyses.

As part of the information gathering and sharing process, DOE organized and held

interviews with BVM manufacturers. DOE had four objectives for these interviews: (1) solicit

feedback on the draft engineering analysis (including methodology, production costs,

manufacturing processes, and findings); (2) solicit feedback on topics related to the preliminary

manufacturer impact analysis; (3) provide an early opportunity to express specific concerns to

DOE; and (4) foster cooperation between the manufacturers and DOE.

Six topics related to the preliminary manufacturer impact analysis were discussed during

the interviews: (1) general key issues, (2) BVM shipment projections, (3) capital conversion

costs, (4) product mix and profitability, (5) market shares and industry consolidation, and (6)

cumulative regulatory burden.

DOE incorporated the information gathered at the meetings into its engineering analysis

(see Chapter 5) and the preliminary manufacturer impact analysis (see Chapter 12). Following

the publication of the ANOPR and the ANOPR public meeting, DOE intends to hold additional

1­5

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22
                         

           

                           

                            

                         

                     

                           

                            

                         

                        

                          

                         

         

                       

                       

                           

                                 

                                 

                         

                       

                          

                                  

                            

         

     

                          

                       

                       

                     

               

                       

                                                

                             

                             

                           

                        

                   

meetings with manufacturers as part of the consultative process for the manufacturer impact

analysis conducted during the NOPR phase.

DOE conducted the LCC and PBP analyses based on an approach that establishes an

annual energy expense using electric utility tariffs. Under this approach, LCC results are based

on the assumption that manufacturing plants and commercial building customers in the future

will face electricity rates similar to those in today’s electricity markets.

DOE developed spreadsheets for the LCC, PBP, and national impact analyses to meet the

objectives of the Process Rule. A spreadsheet tool that demonstrates the calculation of annual

energy expenses based on commercial and industrial electric utility tariffs accompanies the LCC

spreadsheet. DOE developed a national impact analysis spreadsheet that calculates the national

energy savings (NES) and national net present values (NPVs) at various energy­efficiency levels.

This spreadsheet includes a model that forecasts the impacts of energy­efficiency standards at

various levels of BVM shipments.

DOE reviewed the recommendations made on April 21, 1998, by the Advisory

Committee on Appliance Energy Efficiency Standards. (Advisory Committee, No. 96)a These

recommendations related to (1) using the full range of consumer marginal energy rates (CMERs)

in the LCC analysis (replacing the use of national average energy prices), (2) defining a range of

energy price futures for each fuel used in the economic analyses, and (3) defining a range of

primary energy conversion factors and associated emission reductions based on the generation of

energy and emissions that would be displaced by energy­efficiency standards for each

rulemaking. As discussed above, DOE conducted the LCC analysis with electricity prices based

on electric utility tariffs to capture the full range of CMERs. Thus, DOE incorporated the use of

consumer marginal energy rates into the analysis. Also, DOE incorporated a range of future

energy prices in the analysis.

1.4 STRUCTURE OF THE DOCUMENT

This ANOPR TSD outlines the analytical approaches used in this rulemaking. The TSD

consists of 14 chapters, an environmental assessment, a regulatory impact analysis, and

appendices.

Chapter 1 Introduction: provides an overview of the appliance and equipment

standards program and how it applies to the beverage vending machine

rulemaking, and outlines the structure of the document.

Chapter 2 Analytical Framework: describes the rulemaking process step by step.

a Advisory Committee, No. 96 refers to the recommendations of the Advisory Committee on Energy

Efficiency Standards and is available for inspection at the U.S. Department of Energy, Forrestal Building,

Room 1J­018 (Resource Room of the Building Technologies Program) in the file under “Energy Conservation

Program for Consumer Products: Procedures for Consideration of New or Revised Energy Conservation

Standards for Consumer Products,” RIN [1904–AA83], as document number 96.

1­6

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22
                     

                 

                     

             

                       

             

                         

               

   

                       

                     

             

                         

                   

                     

   

                     

                 

               

     

                       

                 

               

                   

                       

                     

                     

     

                         

         

                           

         

                       

Chapter 3 Market and Technology Assessment: characterizes the beverage vending

machine market and the technologies available for increasing equipment

efficiency.

Chapter 4 Screening Analysis: determines which technology design options are

viable for consideration in the engineering analysis.

Chapter 5 Engineering Analysis: discusses the methods used for developing the

relationship between increased manufacturer price and increased

efficiency.

Chapter 6 Markups to Determine Equipment Price: discusses the methods used for

establishing markups for converting manufacturer prices to customer

equipment prices.

Chapter 7 Energy Use Characterization: discusses the process used for generating

energy use estimates of beverage vending machines for a variety of

equipment classes, climate locations, and standard levels.

Chapter 8 Life­Cycle Cost and Payback Period Analyses: discusses the effects of

standards on individual customers and users of the equipment and

compares the LCC and PBP of equipment with and without higher

efficiency standards.

Chapter 9 Shipments Analysis: discusses the methods used for forecasting

shipments with and without higher efficiency standards, including how

equipment purchase decisions are economically influenced and modeled

with econometric equations.

Chapter 10 National Impact Analysis: discusses the methods used for forecasting

national energy consumption and national economic impacts based on

estimates of future equipment efficiency distributions and annual

equipment shipments in the absence and presence of higher efficiency

standards.

Chapter 11 Life­Cycle Cost Sub­Group Analysis: discusses the effects of standards

on a subgroup of beverage vending machine customers and compares the

LCC and PBP of equipment with and without higher efficiency standards

for these customers.

Chapter 12 Manufacturer Impact Analysis: discusses the effects of standards on the

finances and profitability of equipment manufacturers.

Chapter 13 Utility Impact Analysis: discusses the effects of standards on the installed

generation capacity of electric utilities.

Chapter 14 Employment Impact Analysis: discusses the effects of standards on

national employment.

1­7

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22
                    

             

                        

                 

   

                   

         

                   

                      

          

                     

               

                    

                

                    

          

                       

               

                        

           

Environmental Assessment for Beverage Vending Machines: discusses the effects of

standards on airborne emissions of electric utilities.

Regulatory Impact Analysis for Beverage Vending Machines: discusses the impact of the

present regulatory actions and of non­regulatory alternatives to setting

energy­efficiency standards.

Appendix A Instructions for Using the Engineering Analysis Spreadsheet:

accompanies Chapter 5, Engineering Analysis.

Appendix B Engineering Data: accompanies Chapter 5, Engineering Analysis.

Appendix C Detailed Data for Equipment Price Markups: accompanies Chapter 6,

Markups for Equipment Price Determination.

Appendix D Methodology for developing the weighting factors for Beverage Vending

Machines: accompanies Chapter 7, Energy Use Characterization.

Appendix E User Instructions for Life­Cycle Cost Spreadsheet: accompanies Chapter

8, Life­Cycle Cost and Payback Period Analyses.

Appendix F Detailed Life­Cycle Cost Output: accompanies Chapter 8, Life­Cycle

Cost and Payback Period Analyses.

Appendix G User Instructions for National Energy Savings and Net Present Value

Spreadsheet: accompanies Chapter 10, National Impact Analysis.

Appendix H Detailed National Energy Savings and National Net Present Value Output:

accompanies Chapter 10, National Impact Analysis.

1­8

EERE-2006-STD-0125 COMMENT 22