10/24/2011 IB 

ID 

11 

l i 

X'-

16 

Z 7 

IE) 

20 

22 

13 

24 

: 5 

?.F; 

a " 

73 

29 

20 

3 1 

23 

3 J 

.14 

3-^ 

j $ 

^o 

•u 

44 

•i? 

4 ? 

=iD 

5 1 

B>. 

2 5 FAX 202493514 2 

FAA OFflCt OF Kl-GIONAL COWSFL 

irtOi LiNDAvEKTjtSOUTHWEST 

R£KTp>j,WAiiHIK0TOr-l 9R057 

TELEPHONE: (M25)227-ildI 

FACSJMJLE: (4?.i) 2:7-100? 

FA P. 

- QMS 

TJlSflTED STATES OF AMERICA 

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

WASHINGION.D.C. 

RECEIVED 

OCT 20 2011 

HEARING DOCKET 

In the MaitcT of: 

Coraorglyne Aviarion, Inc. 

FAA Ca:^c No. 201 I>ai070021 

t>MS r^o. K\A-20J t.0484 

Mollon forl>eci:*iori (Correction) 

Judge Richard C. GaodMn 

> 

To the Honorable Rich?Trl C. Goodwin: 

CORRECTION TO 

MOTION FOR DEOLSIOIS OR, INTHE ALTERNATIVTE 

M0110^jlR_Slj>CV1ARODT>CMENT 

REfiEAFTKK LTm T^GBEARTyc; TO SANCTTO N 

Coinplfli.nant-s Motion for I>ccisiQix, served on October 13, 2011, conrains a .scriveners (^n-or on 

p ^ e 3. In IxnG 10. the senionce "'Hnivcver, Utah Valley TJniversir\' is aPai+Ul school" should 

read "However, Utah Va]Iey Univensity iansia Part I^l school." A corrected page with the 

ch'dnge highlvghted and underlint-.d is enclosed. 

DATED }^^ 14th day of Oftober, 2011. 

JcmcyM. Harper 

F AA Attomev 

pnr.loiure; Corrcctcd Page 

Corrcciiun LO C.jmplainariVi M^bon For Decision 

Corncr-itojic .^ viaiion, ILC. - F/LAOO) 1 -fli34 TEL; (42:^)''.2''-31t li F*LX; (42.1) 127-1CC7 

- 3 -

. —I 
10/24/2011 16:25 FAX 2024935142 

FAA 

- QMS 

l ^ UUi / vw o 

3 

10 

- 1 

1.2 

' . i 

1^ 

.'.7 

I R 

1? 

£0 

^ 1 

22 

23 

2« 

2 ; 

2-? 

=-9 

?0 

31 

J 2 

:!.: 

37 

5g 

AD 

• i i 

•te 

• i a 

sn 

51 

£3 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

f hfjeby certifv' that the fnregoing Motion for Derision (Correction) hn.'* been ser-'&d via facsimiK'^ 

and CeTtiftrd Mail - Return Rccc^r^ Requested 'iiis dale, to the followirjs;: 

Honorable Richard C- Gooc^^*^Tl 

Office of Heftringr M-20 

J 200 New Jersey Avenue. S.F,. 

Easi Bujlding Groiind Floor. Rm £12-320 

Washingtoa, D.C. 20590 

FAX: 202.366.75^6 

Attn: Hearing Oockei Clerk. AGC-410 

Wilbur Wright Buildine - Suite 2WI0OO 

f cdem) AviaTton Adniiniitrotion 

800 Independence Avenue SW 

Washington, D.C. 20591 

FAX: :0J.-493.5020 

Susan Horetman 

Chief Kvrcutivc Officer 

Cornerstone Aviation. Inc. 

337 Norii 2370 West ^130 

SaitLalceCitv. IJT 84116 

FAX; (801) 355-2754 

Dated thi.-i U*, day of October. 70U 

KtOTFjXlRCiSK^ 

Office of Rcgion;iI Counsel (>\XN4-7) 

Federal .Avtaiion Adrnini^rtrTirion 

IbU! LindAvc. :^W 

RcniOD. VVA 9Sy57 

4'25.227.2160 

C:>rrcaior, co Co^nplamani'5 Mcdor, For Tleciiiou. 

Cc-rTJenrt£F^cA•^^tlTlo,^. Inc -FAJ\.:r>ll-W84 

Ps2a2of 2 

JEFF7.ni: M. HARPER, FAA Anowciv 

TF.I.. fill)237-3161; "AX:i425>227-irm 
10/24/2011 1B:25 FAX 2024935142 FAA - DMS 121003/003 

1 

2 

3 

• ^ 

« 

7 

e 

3 

10 

IL 

13 

13 

1-1 

IG 

IQ 

22 

33 

34 

35 

26 

37 

23 

AS 

Tfi 

3 1 

i-1 

?:. 

:<£ 

37 

39 

39 

ifi 

41 

^^ 

^3 

d.) 

^ • i 

46 

47 

49 

49 

50 

51 

5;. 

53 

ground (mining required by ihc syllabus. Compla.im 11-7, Answer 7. Addinonally. Ms. Wilson did 

not receive any credit for previously raceived ground treinins, as pennitied by 14 C.F.R. 

§ 141.77(c)(4). Admission 10 Request for Admission No. '1, Admission to Request for Admission 

>Jo. 5. The lack af Part 141, ground Trai.nin£ is corTnhnr;iied by Ms. Wilson's logbook, which does 

not show the completion of any required ground u^ning. Complaint n.6. .Answer 6. 

Ms. Wilson did receive ground training under Part 61 from Utah Valley Univcrsit)-. Admission tu 

Request for Admission No. 6. However, Uuh Valley Universit>' is not a Part 141 school. 

Admission to Rco.ucst for Admission Ko. 7. As a rc^ul*., ai mo!>t 2'i% nf the required 30 hour?; of 

training under Un; Syllabus could have been credited to MB. Wilson for nor training ai Utali 

Vflllo- University. 14 C.F.R § 141.77(cX4). 

Respondent graduated Ms. Wilson from respondent's Insiniment - Airplane course, iisuLnc her i 

graduation ccrtil'.uaic on November ] 7, 2010. Complaint IT.fi. An.-swcr R. A ?MHu?.tinn rrrrifirrrr 

constitutes certif;cation that a student has completed the required training, l^i CJ.R_ § l-ll.PS. 

Unquestionably, Respondent issued a graduation ccrtilkatc lo fin individual who had not 

rnmpleied the training specified for Respondent's srudtnts. Specifically, Ms. Wilson did not 

complete the ground training required for the Instrument- Airplane rating. Scclions 141.77(a)(1) 

and 141.77(b)prohibitaholder of a pilot certificate from issuing a frrQduation certificate to a • 

.Ttodrnt tmlcis the .'.tiiHfnt b;\<; romplrirrl ijic trrtining/ciirriculum specified in the pilot school's 

course of irainini^. Respondent has done precisely the thing the regulation prohibits — graduated 

a studeni who had oox received a.11 required training. There is no genuine issue regarding these 

facts; the Administrator is entitled to a decision as a matter of law. 

b. Compliance with Approved Training Course—14 C.F.R. § 141.83(a)(1) 

Tlie Administrator alleges Comcistone did not uumply with its approved trainins course. As 

discussed in subpa.riigraph (i), Respondent -A-as required to provide ^is. Wilson \v[zi\ 30 hours of 

ground training to complete the Instrument - Airplane course under the approved Syllabus, 

Respnndent failed to provide Ms. Wilson the lequired iiaining, thereby deviating from its 

apprnvcd tnining co\mc. 

c. Maintenance ofCurrent and Accurate Records — 14 C.F.R. § 141.101(a). 

Section l41.101(Q)requircs the holder of a pilot school certificate lo cslablish and maintain a 

curren'. and accurate record of the participation of each student enrolled in an approved course of 

tTHinijig thai incUtdcs, at a minim'jm, ihi: dale the siuden-. enrolled, a chronological log of the 

student's course attendance, and the date the student either graduated, terminated training, or 

transferred. 

Compliiiiani's i-ljuon For Dei:iiiQn 

Cornerstone Avimion, I:ic. - F.\j\-201 l-O^S^ 

lOJlN'.VlOTQCOl 

Pttfii 3 cf 6 

TEL:(-i:5):27-2ltil: FAX. (*:;) 227-1007