1

Sutton, Tia

From: Whiteman, Chad <Chad_S_Whiteman@omb.eop.gov>

Sent: Thursday, June 04, 2015 9:05 AM

To: Sutton, Tia; Hengst, Benjamin

Subject: RE: EO 12866 Comments on EPA Aircraft Endangerment Finding NOPR/GHG Standards 

ANPR (2060-AS31)

Attachments: EO 12866 Summary Comments on EPA Aircraft EF NPRM and GHG ANPRM 2060-AS31 - 

6_4_2015.docx

Follow Up Flag: Follow up

Flag Status: Flagged

Tia & Ben, Attached are the comments that I’ve received so far. I wanted to get these over to you now although I’m still 

waiting on one more reviewer to respond. Will provide any additional comments as soon as I hear from them. Chad 

From: Sutton, Tia [mailto:sutton.tia@epa.gov] 

Sent: Wednesday, June 3, 2015 3:32 PM 

To: Whiteman, Chad; Hengst, Benjamin 

Subject: RE: EO 12866 Comments on EPA Aircraft Endangerment Finding NOPR/GHG Standards ANPR (2060-AS31) 

Importance: High 

Hi Chad, 

Per your question about which pages have the “blue comment bubble” edits, a list is below. I added “6-3-15:” at the 

beginning of each comment so they’re easier to find. I also noticed that the formatting wasn’t quite right on a few 

tables, so I fixed those, but it repaginated the document a bit. The list below denotes which pages have the comments 

and the tables that I fixed. 

Blue comment bubbles are on the following pages: 

- 16-17 

- 90-93 

- 140 

- 156 

- 159 

I also reformatted the TofC, and the tables on pp.131 and 133-134 to be single-spaced. 

Thanks, 

 Tia 

From: Sutton, Tia 

Sent: Wednesday, June 03, 2015 12:28 PM 

To: 'Whiteman, Chad'; Hengst, Benjamin 

Subject: RE: EO 12866 Comments on EPA Aircraft Endangerment Finding NOPR/GHG Standards ANPR (2060-AS31) 

Hi Chad, 

Please see attached file for EPA’s edits in response to the discussion from yesterday’s call -- our edits made in response 

to the comments are highlighted in blue comment bubbles. We also made an additional edit on the signature page only 

to add a heading that is now required on signature pages for EPA rules. 

Thanks, 
2

 Tia 

From: Whiteman, Chad [mailto:Chad_S_Whiteman@omb.eop.gov] 

Sent: Monday, May 25, 2015 11:10 PM 

To: Hengst, Benjamin 

Cc: Sutton, Tia 

Subject: RE: EO 12866 Comments on EPA Aircraft Endangerment Finding NOPR/GHG Standards ANPR (2060-AS31) 

Ben, 

 Attached are the latest round of EO 12866 interagency comments. The comments can be identified by searching for 

EO13563 in the comment bubbles. We accepted the redline from your most recent passback so that only redline 

changes would be due to suggested edits. We left the previous comment bubbles though. Let me know if you would 

like to discuss. 

Chad 

From: Hengst, Benjamin [mailto:Hengst.Benjamin@epa.gov] 

Sent: Thursday, May 14, 2015 12:16 PM 

To: Whiteman, Chad 

Cc: Sutton, Tia 

Subject: RE: EO 12866 Comments on EPA Aircraft Endangerment Finding NOPR/GHG Standards ANPR (2060-AS31) 

Hi Chad, 

I’m attaching the next iteration of the aircraft package. A few notes: 

• This version responds to the 5/8 comments, and incorporates the new Section G edits as well. 

• We are attaching three supporting documents that you requested. 

• In addition to responding to specific interagency comments in this 2nd round, we have updated sections I, II, and 

V (most updates are in section V) with 2013 GHG inventory numbers, which are from the 2015 EPA GHG & Sinks 

report just published on April 15, 2015. Note, in the first round of OMB review, OMB asked, “has EPA released 

the inventory for 2013 and 2014 yet – if so, consider including in this discussion.” We responded that since the 

2013 inventory numbers were just released, we need time to update the inventory numbers throughout the

preamble (particularly section V), and OMB was okay with this response. Subsequently, we have now finished 

updating these inventory numbers. 

Please let me know if you have questions. 

Thanks, 

Ben 

From: Whiteman, Chad [mailto:Chad_S_Whiteman@omb.eop.gov] 

Sent: Friday, May 08, 2015 5:29 PM 

To: Sutton, Tia 

Cc: Hengst, Benjamin 

Subject: RE: EO 12866 Comments on EPA Aircraft Endangerment Finding NOPR/GHG Standards ANPR (2060-AS31) 

Tia, 

 Attached are the suggested EO 12866 interagency comments pertaining to just Section G of the draft rule. The 

attached document does not contain the comments that I sent over on 5/8 in the email below. When EPA responds, 
3

please use the document from 5/8 and substitute Section G from the document attached to this email. The suggested 

changes in Section G can be identified by green highlighted text in the body of the email. 

 Please let me know if you have any questions. 

Thanks, 

Chad 

From: Whiteman, Chad 

Sent: Friday, May 08, 2015 12:18 AM 

To: 'Sutton, Tia' 

Cc: Hengst, Benjamin 

Subject: EO 12866 Comments on EPA Aircraft Endangerment Finding NOPR/GHG Standards ANPR (2060-AS31) 

Tia, 

 Attached are additional comments on the aircraft emissions rule and endangerment finding. We’re still working 

through language Section G and how to have something early next week. In the meantime, would you please respond 

to the attached comments. The new comments can be identified by searching for EO12866 in the comment bubbles. 

Thanks, 

Chad