10/24/201 1 I B

I D 1 1 l i X'

- 1 6 Z 7 IE ) 2 0 2 2 1 3 2 4 : 5 ?.F ; a " 7 3 2 9 2 0 3 1 2 3 3 J .1 4 3- ^ j $

^ o

• u 4 4

•i ? 4 ? =i D 5 1 B> . 2 5 FA X 202493514 2

FA A OFflC t

O FKl-GIONA

L COWSF L irtO i LiNDAvEKTjtSOUTHWES T R£KTp>j,WAiiHIK0TOr- l 9R05 7 TELEPHONE : (M25)227-ild I FACSJMJLE : (4?.i ) 2:7-100 ? F A P . - QM S



## TJlSflTE D STATE S OF AMERIC A DEPARTMEN

T O FTRANSPORTATION OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGION.D.C . 

# RECEIVE D OC T 

### 2 0 201 1 

# HEARIN G DOCKE T

I n th e Maitc

T of : Coraorglyn e Aviarion , Inc . FA A Ca:^ c No . 20 1 I>ai07002 1 t>M S r^o . K\A-20 J t.048 4 Mollo n forl>eci:*ior

i (Correction ) Judg e Richar dC . GaodM n > T o th e Honorabl e Rich?Tr

l C . Goodwin :

CORRECTIO N T O MOTIO N FO RDEOLSIOI S OR , INTH E ALTERNATIVT E M0110^jlR_Slj>CV1ARODT>CMEN T REfiEAFTK K

LT mT^GBEARTyc ; T O SANCTTO N Coinplfli.nant- s Motio n fo r I>ccisiQix , serve do

n Octobe r 13 , 2011 , conrain s a.scrivener s (^n-o r o n p ^ e 3 . I n Ixn G 10 . th e senionc e "'Hnivcver , Utah Valle y TJniversir\ ' i s aPai+U l school " shoul d rea d"However , Uta

h Va]Ie y Univensit

y iansi aPar

t I^ l school. " A correcte dpag e wit h th e ch'dng e highlvghte dan dunderlint-. di s enclosed . DATED }^ ^ 14t

h da y o f Oftober , 2011 . JcmcyM . Harpe r F A A Attome v pnr.loiure ; Corrcctc dPag e

Corrcciiu n L

O C.jmplainariV i M^bo n Fo r Decisio n Corncr-itoji c . ^ viaiion , ILC . - F/LAOO ) 1 -fli3 4 TEL ; (42:^)''.2''-31 t l i F*LX ; (42.1 ) 127-1CC 7 - 3 - . — I10/24/201 1 16:2 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A - QM S l ^ UUi / vw o

3 1 0

- 1 1. 2 ' . i 1 ^ .'. 7 I R 1 ? £ 0 ^ 1 2 2 2 3 2 « 2 ; 2- ?

=- 9 ? 0 3 1 J 2 :!. :

3 7 5 g A D • i i

•t e • i a s n 5 1 £ 3 

## CERTIFICAT E O F SERVIC E f hfjeb y certifv ' that

th e fnregoin g Motio n for Derisio n (Correction ) hn.' * been ser-'&

dvi afacsimiK'

^ an dCeTtiftr

dMai l - Return Rccc^r

^ Requeste d'iii s dale , t o th e followirjs; : Honorabl e Richar dC

- Gooc^^*^T l Offic e o f Heftring r M-2 0 J 20 0 Ne w Jerse y Avenue . S.F, . Eas i Bujldin g Groiin dFloor . R m£12-32 0 Washingtoa , D.C . 2059 0 FAX : 202.366.75^ 6 Attn : Hearin g Oocke i Clerk . AGC-41 0 Wilbur Wrigh t Buildin e - Suit e 2WI0O O f cdem) AviaTton Adniiniitrotio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenu e S W Washington , D.C . 2059 1 FAX : :0J.-493.502 0 Susa n Horetma

n Chie f Kvrcutiv c Office

r Cornerston e Aviation . Inc . 33 7 Nori i 237 0 West

^13 0 SaitLalceCitv . IJ T 8411 6 FAX ; (801 ) 355-275 4 Date dthi.- i U* , da y o f October . 70 U KtOTFjXlRCiSK^

Offic e o f Rcgion;iI Counse l (>\XN4-7 ) Federa l .Avtaiion Adrnini^rtrTirio n IbU ! LindAvc . :^

W RcniOD . VV

A 9Sy5 7 4'25.227.216 0

C:>rrcaior , c

o Co^nplamani' 5 Mcdor , Fo r Tleciiiou . Cc-rTJenrt£F^cA•^^tlTlo,^ . In c -FAJ\.:r>ll-W8 4 Ps2a2of 2 JEFF7.ni : M . HARPER , FA A Anowci v TF.I. . fill)237-3161 ; "AX:i425>227-ir m10/24/201 1 1B:2 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A - DM S 121003/00 3

1 2 3

• ^ « 7 e 3 1 0 I L 1 3 1 3 1- 1 I G I Q

2 2 3 3 3 4 3 5 2 6 3 7 2 3 A S Tf i 3 1

i-1 ?: . :< £ 3 7 3 9 3 9 if i 4 1 ^ ^

^ 3 d. ) ^ • i 4 6 4 7 4 9 4 9 5 0 5 1 5; . 5 3 groun d(minin g require db y ih c syllabus . Compla.i m11-7, Answe r 7 . Addinonally . Ms . Wilso n di d no t receiv e an y credi t

fo r previousl y raceive dgroun dtreinins , a s pennitie db y 1 4 C.F.R . § 141.77(c)(4) . Admissio n 10 Reques t for Admissio n No . '1 , Admissio n t o Reques t fo r Admissio n >Jo . 5 . Th e lac k

a f Par t 141 , groun dTrai.nin

£i s corTnhnr;iiedb y Ms . Wilson' s logbook , whic h doe s no t sho w th e completio n o f

an y require dgroun du^ning . Complain t n.6 . .Answe

r 6 . Ms . Wilso n di dreceiv e groun dtrainin g unde r Part 6 1 fro mUta h Valle y Univcrsit)- . Admissio n t u Reques t for Admissio n No . 6 . However , Uu h Valle y Universit> ' i s no t aPart 14 1 school . Admissio n t o Rco.ucs t

fo r Admissio n Ko . 7 . A s arc^ul*. , a i mo!> t 2'i % n f th e require d3 0 hour? ; o f trainin g unde r

Un ; Syllabu s coul dhav e bee n credite dt o MB . Wilso n fo r

nor trainin g a i Utali Vflllo

- University . 1 4 C.F. R§ 141.77(cX4) . Responden t

graduate dMs . Wilso n fro mrespondent' s Insinimen t - Airplan e course , iisuLn c he r i graduatio n ccrtil'.uai c o

n Novembe r

] 7 , 2010 . Complain t

IT.fi . An.-swc

r R . A ?MHu?.tin

n rrrrifirrr r constitute s certif;catio n that astuden t ha s complete dth e require dtraining , l^ i CJ.R

_§ l-ll.PS . Unquestionably , Responden t issue dagraduatio n ccrtilkat c l o fi n individua l who hadno t rnmpleie dth e trainin g specifie dfo r Respondent' s srudtnts . Specifically , Ms . Wilso n di dno t complet e th e groun dtrainin g require dfo r th e Instrument

- Airplan e rating . Scclion s 141.77(a)(1 ) an d141.77(b)prohibitaholde r o f apilo t certificat e fromissuin g afrrQduatio n certificat e t o a• .Ttodrn t tmlci s th e .'.tiiHfn

t b;\<; romplrirr l iji c trrtining/ciirriculu mspecifie di n th e pilot

school' s cours e o f irainini^ . Responden t

ha s don e precisel y th e thin g th e regulatio n prohibit s —graduate d astuden i wh o ha doo

x receive da.1 1 require dtraining . Ther e i s n o genuin e issu e regardin g thes e facts ; th e Administrato r

i s entitle dt o adecisio n a s amatte r o f law . b . Complianc e wit

h Approve dTrainin g Course—1 4 C.F.R . § 141.83(a)(1 ) Tli e Administrato r

allege s Comciston e di dno t uumply wit

h it s approve dtrainin s course . A s discusse di

n subpa.riigraph (i) , Responden t -A-a s require dt

o provid e ^is . Wilso n \v[zi \3 0 hour s o f groun dtrainin g t o complet e th e Instrumen t - Airplan e cours e under

th e approve dSyllabus , Respnnden t

faile dt o provid e Ms . Wilso n th e lequire diiaining , thereb y deviatin g fro mit s apprnvc dtninin g co\mc . c . Maintenanc e ofCurren t an dAccurat e Record s —1 4 C.F.R . § 141.101(a) . Sectio n l41.101(Q)requirc s th e holde r o f apilo t schoo l certificat e l o cslablis h an dmaintai n a curren' . an daccurat e recor do f th e participatio n o f

eac h studen t

enrolle di n a

n approve dcours e o f tTHiniji g thai incUtdcs , a

t aminim'jm , ihi : dal e th e siuden- . enrolled , achronologica l lo g o f th e student' s cours e attendance , an dth e dat e th e studen t eithe r graduated , terminate dtraining , o r transferred . Compliiiiani' s i-ljuo n Fo r Dei:iiiQ n Cornerston e Avimion , I:ic . - F.\j\-20 1 l-O^S ^ lOJlN'.VlOTQCO l Pttfi i 3 c f 6 TEL:(-i:5):27-2ltil : FAX . (*:; ) 227-100 7