7KH +RQRUDEOH 'DQ $DURQ 3ROVWHU 

WKH 1RUWKHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 2KLR VLWWLQJ E\ 



5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	





1,7(' 	7$7(6 2) 0(5,&$

	






26&2(  ($7<

	



 !"#$%
&'$(	$

!"$%,'(( )'$"'*$!

.//010//.1

///.245%&'6

"7+(85&+"9

)*'((&(' (8

!"8:)&(

<:	)'$"'






	<$"5	$"'&
%-'  && !"  		
	 

) 		
. 
 

7KH JUDQG MXU\ LGHQWLILHG ILYH VHSDUDWH LQVWDQFHV LQ ZKLFK WKH

GHIHQGDQWV SRVVHVVHG PRQH\ DQG JDPEOLQJ SDUDSKHUQDOLD LQ IXUWKHUDQFHRI WKH FRQVSLUDF\ DQG LQ YLRODWLRQ RI  86&  

7KH JRYHUQPHQW VXEVHTXHQWO\ ILOHG D VXSHUVHGLQJ LQGLFWPHQW

FKDUJLQJ %HDW\ ZLWK D WKLUG FRXQW VHHNLQJ IRUIHLWXUH RI  DQGD FHOO SKRQH XVHG LQ FRPPLVVLRQ RI WKH IHORQ\ FKDUJHG LQ &RXQW 7ZR7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW GHQLHG %HDW\¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV WKH VXSHUVHGLQJ

&& !"    
  <$" 5 	$"'&
=
>?
 %-'  && !" &$?' '#%&@&	@'&*&$		
	

)		;	%-' &&!" 







<:	 )'$"'*$ 5+(7 )!&(&$*$9

 !"#%'A+"9*&-'*$'&&(&$&*!""$'&7&' 7  7#B '&7 B+'& &( $% ('$"'*$ *+"$C 7"&$ !+##"9A+(7#&$'&!-"!$%7-"&#&$'&!+"" $(*'-'  !"!'$+" *$'&  " $% ! D'&7 "& D	



	


	 


!!"#$#%&("  D &!"*#&$ !!'*" ""$( $9 &

B"+"9.0!$" &7$%9'&-$'7$'&!7#B '&7"'&7 '&- -'&7 $9 &( -"  $%" '&('-'(+   &,"*%.7"&(A+"9"$+"&($D*+&$'&('*$#&$7'&$$9&('6$%"(!&(&$+&$&*%"7($%$ B$D& B"+"9 . &( B"+"9  $%(!&(&$*&'"($*&(+*$&' 7 7#B '&7B+'&'&-' $'&!3
	E+&$D*%"7($%$

(+"'&7 $% # "'( $% (!&(&$ "&  &+#B""$'&'&-' $'&!3
	EE.&(
 

LQGLFWPHQW RQ GRXEOH MHRSDUG\ JURXQGV PRWLRQ WR WKH 6L[WK &LUFXLW ZKLFK DIILUPWKH 86 6XSUHPH &RXUW 7KH GLVWULFW FRXZKLOH %HDW\¶V SHWLWLRQ IRU FHUWLRUDUL ZDV 

$9C*"'#'& *"*(

%$$"' &(('&#'$"' $"*%-"('*$$9C*&(5&+"9 .   $ $"'  &77( '& $% *&(+*$ *%"77-"&#&$ %+ ( B $(B*+'$%( (%'#$B '-7#B '&7$#*%9"&(7"D7"D+ ('##+&'F%'#!!"( $% $$'#&9 !  !"*&!'"#($%$'&$%#'(/$%9 +"*%(  $#$%9 D+ !(" '&-$'7$'&&($%'"7#B+BA*$$!(" "*+$'&

%7-"&#&$*+&$"($%'$

$#'$ !*&$'&($%! D'&

< &$$%$$%''*' 9#&$!(" $6%'($B7'&"*&$'&+$"("B+' *  D 9#&$!$%0!$%
&$"& -&+(!"#& $'"+&'%#&$ !	$$" *  D*&*"&'&7D

% 7-"&#&$   !!"( $7#B "D%(#'$$($%$$%9G'##+&'F $%# !"# !("  "D'$&$$'!'($%$(+"'&7$%&7&$'&!"#(%'#$%$$%$!"#!(" "*+$'&!"D7"* '#($%$%%(" $(%'*&$9!$"&!$%"'(&$%
2 
 

6HFWLRQ ( VWDWHV WKDW D GHIHQGDQW PD\ UHFHLYH D WZROHYHO

GHFUHDVH LQ KLV RIIHQVH OHYHO LI KH 3FOHDUO\ GHPRQVWUDWHV DFFHSWDQFH RI

UHVSRQVLELOLW\ IRU KLV RIIHQVH ́ 86 6HQWHQFLQJ *XLGHOLQHV 0DQXDO (  7KH $SSOLFDWLRQ 1RWHV VWDWH 3,Q UDUH VLWXDWLRQV DGHIHQGDQW PD\ FOHDUO\ GHPRQVWUDWH DQ DFFHSWDQFH RI UHVSRQVLELOLW\ IRU KLVFULPLQDO FRQGXFW HYHQ WKRXJK KH H[HUFLVHV KLV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ULJKW WR DWULDO 7KLV PD\ RFFXU IRU H[DPSOH ZKHUH D GHIHQGDQW JRHV WR WULDO WR

DVVHUW RU SUHVHUYH LVVXHV WKDW GR QRW UHODWH WR IDFWXDO JXLOW     ́ ,G DW FPW

)+"'&7$%$"' $%('$"'*$*+"$'&$"+*$($%A+"9&$%

(!&!&$"#&$B9$ -"(!&*+& CBA*$'&$%*+"$ "-'(($%A+"9D'$%$%! D'&7'&$"+*$'&&( 'B"$'7&"&*8

 & *& -'( "&'B' '$9 !"  *"'# B9( 'B"$ 9'7&"'&7$%B-'+
!9+C"*&-'&*($%$$%(!&(&$( 'B"$ 9'7&"(%'7%"BB' '$9$%$% D'&- -('& &' 7 7#B '&7"$'&+&("$%!("  D$%&9+#9!'&($%$%G&DD%$%D('&7+$ $ !'&( $%' 9+ #+$ B *&-'&*( B9&( "&B (+B$$%$$%(!&(&$DD"!%'7%"BB' '$9$%$%D'&- -('&&' 7 7#B '&7"$'&  +&(" $% !("  D &( $% (!&(&$( 'B"$ 9* (%'9$D%$DB-'+" &"&7 '7&*"! '%&&%'"$'&$$%#G&D (7&('&$&+7%$*&-'*$

% *+"$ ($( $%' '&$"+*$'& -"B$'# !"# <$$"&"'#'& 5+"9
&$"+*$'&!"$%	'6$%'"*+'$E./H?$I

!$"( 'B"$'&7!" $%&$D%+"$%A+"9"$+"&(

7+' $9-"('*$&B$%+&$&&(+&$D<"'"$$%	&$&*'&7"'&7
	<"B$'&!!'*""-'(($%('$"'*$*+"$D'$%<"&$&*
&-$'7$'&"$D%'*%"*##&(($%$$9B7"&$($D - "(+*$'&'&%'!!& - !"**$&*!"&'B' '$9+"+&$$
&'$(	$$	&$&*'&7J+'( '&HK
		JLIE0

 

'XULQJ RUDO DUJXPHQW %HDW\¶V FRX

VHL]HG IURP %HDW\ ZDV QRW SURFHHGV DQG VKRXOG DSSO\ %HDW\ GLG QRW UDLVH WKHVH DLQ KLV DSSHOODWH EULHI &RQVHTXHQWO\ WKZDLYHG 6HH HJ %DXHU Y 9DULW\ 'D\WRQ WK &LU (!&%D$(!"#&$ "" '& 7"&$'&7 $% 7-"&#A+(7#&$




"$%"&$$(B-D

!$%('$"'*$*+"$'&B$%$%*"'I&($%*'-' !"!'$+""*
. 
 

% (*$"'& ! * $"  $  "$ D%& $%"

"M+'"#&$"#$8HI$%'+'&$%*+""&$*$'&&($% "'" *$'& " '(&$'* 1 H.I $% '+ D *$+ 9 '$'7$(1&(H0I$%'+D&*"9&(&$' $$%A+(7#&$ &$% #"'$     
 

  
   
   ! !2.(.3./H$%'"0I"+ ! D"* +("'"*"'#'& *&-'*$'&!"#%-'&7"* +'-!!*$ '&  +BM+&$ *'-'  "*('&7 B$D& $%7-"&#&$ &( $% (!&(&$  "# $ 
 
%$
02/
	33HIHK
$'D $B '%( $%$  "'" *"'#'&  *&-'*$'& #9 D"G &$  '& !-" ! $% 7-"&#&$ '&  +BM+&$ *'-' "*('&7LI  ,"-" KN'O& $% * !  *"'#'& *&-'*$'&B(&A+"9-"('*$!7+' $9'+D%'*%D"&$'  $ $% -"('*$ #+$ B "7"((  %-'&7 B&($"#'&(B9$%A+(7#&$L&$

%&$"#&$B9$ (!&$9G$"''&

$% !"!'$+" "*('&7 ' '(&$'*  $ $% (!& %"&$($%'*"'#'& $"' 
&B$%$%*"'#'& &($%*'-' *&$6$$9CB+"(&!"!!"$B '%'&7$%(!&'$%#4"&("&*!$%-'(&*


'30(..2H0('"I.3
	/0 HI$$"' $9* (D'$& &( '&$"(+*( -'(&* '& +"$ ! %'&$"#&$ B9 $  (!&  %"!" $%" ' '$$ M+$'&$%$%*$+ 9 '$'7$($%'+"'$%"&9(+B$$%$$%A+"9C($"#'&$'&&$%'+D&*"9&(&$' $A+(7#&$&$%#"'$$$"' $%A+(7*'!'* 9'&$"+*$($%A+"9$!'&($9&$7+' $9'!%$B '%( $% &$"#&$ B9 $  (!& B9 "&("&*!$%-'(&*
&"("$*&-'*$$9$%A+"9%($*&* +($%$$%"&("&*!$%-'(&*('( &$ +"$ $% &$"#&$ B9 $  (!&**"('&7 9$%('$"'*$ *+"$ *""*$ 9 *&* +(($%$  $%""M+'"#&$!"* $" $ %(B&$'!'(

*+$9C BA*$'&$$%('$"'*$*+"$C7"&$

!+##"9A+(7#&$(&(+&$%-' B' '$9!$%

 Q%7-"&#&$BA*$($$%"*$9 D &$ &$'$ ( $ & **"(+*$'&B*+%%(*&$$($$%	&$&*'&7"'&7$%('$D -  "(+*$'& !" **$&'#(&$&*!$D&$9	"!+"-'(" &(

& $9"7+$%$$%

7'-'&7( 'B"$'7&"&*'&$"+!' '&7 $ "(+* %' !!& "&'B' '$9+"+&$$
		J


'
 ()*
!!"	+"-' &*!$9C7#B '&

. D%&  *&*"&( *'$'F&%-' < '*)"$#&$HK&+#B""$'&'&%-' . $% %-'  < '* 6-"'+ *$'&'&* +('&7$9< '* 'F( &+#B" $'*G$ $9CB("#)+$$% "7$%%-' < '**&$*$($%HK
	LI&($%$D7&*'B$9C &+#B" "$'&  &7-"&#&$ !' (  *# '&$P22/ 'F( '& $% "'( "' .30$%('$"'*$*+"$7&('&7" +$'&!&9" $(*

!$" *&$'&+( +"-' &* 

!("  D&!"*#&$!!'*"$9C%#&(-"'+$%" %!!'*"'F(&+#B"$'*G$9C %#  & 5+ 9 .3 0!"!'$+"*# '&$G'&7$%!(+"'&7$%"*%
 
 

	+"-' &* ! $9C &+#B" "$'& B7& 7'&

! D'&7$%6*+$'&!$% 5+&0 "*%D""&$B"-$'&!7#B '&7" $(*$'-'$'-"$%&6$9" ($$%6*+$'&!&$%"$!"*%D""&$'&" 95+&2&*7'&$%7-"&#&$'F(#&9&(7#B '&7 "%"& ' !"# $9C %# &( $%" *$'&&5+ 92$%7-"&#&$!' (&$%"!"!'$+" *# '&$ G'&7 $% #&9 'F( (+"'&7 $%"'"#&$%C"*%

&$'&+( +"-' &* ! $9C &+#B" "$'&

*+(!(" +$%"'$'$6*+$!+"$%&(!'& $!"*%D""&$&B"+"9.0%$"*%"+ $('&$%'F+"!*%&+#B"$'*G$&(B$$'&7(&( ( $ $% ""$ &( -&$+  *&-'*$'& ! $9  &,"*%$%7-"&#&$!' (!"!'$+"*# '&$G'&7#&9'F('&$%"'(&B"+"9.0

&B"+"92$%('$"'*$*+"$"'&$$($%!'"$

!"!'$+"*# '&$$$%*$'-(*G$&(-*$($%$9%('$"'*$*+"$*& '($($%!+"!"!'$+""*('&7'&$&*&	$#B"0/3
&*$B"3$%7-"&#&$#-(!"+##"9A+(7#&$$9($%#$'&!"+##"9A+(7#&$B9"7+'&7$%$$%"D 7&+'& '+ ! #$"'  !*$ "7"('&7 %'  7(&$"#&$B9$%!(" 7-"&#&$

& 5+ 9 .  $% ('$"'*$ *+"$ 7"&$( $%

7-"&#&$C #$'& &( &$"(  (*" ! !"!'$+"$9!' ($'# 9$'*! !$"D%'*%$%('$"'*$*+"$'+(&"("6 '&'&7'$"&!"7"&$'&7$%#$'&  
& $% "(" $% ('$"'*$ *+"$ '&('*$( $%$ '$7"&$($%#$'&!"+##"9A+(7#&$!$"*&* +('&7$%$ $9 %( '$'7$( $% &$"#&$ B9 $  '+(+"'&7$%" $(*"'#'& "*('&7&($%$"+ $$%(!&DB""(B9$%(*$"'&!* $" $ & $9"7+$%$$%('$"'*$*+"$""(B97"&$'&7$%7-"&#&$C#$'&!"+##"9A+(7#&$B*+%'(!&!&$"#&$B9$ "'(!*$+ '+$%$%+ (%-"* +((&D"(!+##"9A+(7#&$

 *&(&D%'*%$%$"$9D' B$"' L(

2


&!"!'$+"*$'&$%7-"&

!%D'&7"BB *+$+


		)2023H$%'".///I<"BB 'K"&B 7"+&(!"B '!$%& "'# !*' "! B+$ #
''!
,-.../01!2 H$% '" 30I HM+$'&7 
 &#
2.(30(('$'&$$B '%'&7"BB 7-"&#&$#+$$B '%"BB &6+B$D&$%""$9 'F7'-'&7 "' $ '$ !"!'$+"   '5!#67.42 . 0( 2 23 H$%7-"&#&$$B '%"BB *$'!' $% &6+ "M+'"#&$ * '#&$D%#+$"-B9"$%$$%""$9'&$ +BA*$$) # "*!
 .3 $$ ( $%$ $% 7-"&#&$ ' !"!'$+"+&&+&"B+$$(%DHM+$'&7
899+/H$%'"0II

$9 *&$&( $%$ $% ('$"'*

+##"9 A+(7#&$ B*+ %' (!& "'  7&+'& '+ 6'$&*!"BB *+%7('$"'*$ *+"$C D"( ! +##B*+$%(*$"'&!* $" !"#"''&7$%&$"#&$B9$(("'&7 $%  '*B' '$9 ! $$ $9'&$(!*++!$%&$"#&$B9$ (!
/ 
 

$W WKH 6HQWHQFLQJ +HDULQJ WKH MXGJH VWDWHG 3, DP QRW JRLQJ WR JLYH

0U %HDW\ FUHGLW IRU DFFHSWDQFH RI UHVSRQVLELOLW\ , GRQ¶W WKLQN LW IDOOVZLWKLQ WKH UDUH LQVWDQFH RI JRLQJ WR WULDO DQG EHLQJ JLYHQ FUHGLW IRUDFFHSWDQFH RI UHVSRQVLELOLW\ ́

D &$ D""&$( '& $%' *  %" ' &$%'&7 '& $%

"*"( $ +77$ $%$ $%' ($"#'&$'& D * " 9""&+"$%'"&D!!'"#$%($"#'&$'&!$%*+"$B D


 
 )) ,,?'$%"7"($$%*'-' !"!'$+"*$'&$9"7+$%$

$% ('$"'*$ *+"$ ""( B9 7"&$'&7 +##"9 A+(7#&$ '&!-"!$%7-"&#&$!$"($"#'&'&7$%$%'&$"#&$(!&D"* +((B9$%(*$"'&!* $" $ 

?"-'D('$"'*$*+"$C7"&$!+##"9A+(7#&$(

&-#G'&7 "&B '&!"&*'&!-"!$%&&#-'&7"$9""2

/2.(00002H$%'"/I	+##"9A+(7#&$'""'!K$% ('&7 ('$'& &D" $ '&$""7$"' &((#''&&!' $7$%"D'$%$%!!'(-'$'!&9%D$%$$%"'&7&+'&'+$&9#$"' !*$&($%$$%#-'&7"$9'&$'$ ($A+(7#&$#$$"! DL('  ,9 < H*I  ?%& D "-'D  #$'& !"

+##"9A+(7#&$$%-'(&* !*$&(&9'&!"&*$%$#9B("D&!"#$%!*$#+$B-'D('&$% '7%$#$ !-"B $$%&&#-'&7"$9$!"&!
:)
2
	23H3I"-' $%"$9'&7+##"9A+(7#&$#+$%D+!!'*'&$-'(&*$*"$7&+'&'+!#$"' !*$ 


;	#.(00022.H$%'"/I#"*'&$' !-'(&*''&+!!'*'&$K$%"#+$B-'(&*&D%'*%$%A+"9*+ ("&B 9!'&(!"$%N&&#-&$OL	
666&2
	.2...H3I&$"9!+##"9A+(7#&$'""'$K7'&$ "$9D% !' $#G %D'&7 +!!'*'&$$$B '%$%6'$&*!& #&$&$' $$%$"$9C

 



	 -). /)'$'&7
<

H$%'"/I$9*&$&($%7'-'&7( 'B"$'7&"&*'&$-'(&*%D'&7$%$8HI$%(D"!%'7%"BB' '$9!$%6&(H.I$%(!&(&$+" 9*&$%' 7 *&(+*$$9"7+$%!' ($#G+*%%D'&7$%$%A+"9*&-'*$(%'#B(+&"$%"$%&"!B9&("&

? "-'D  ('$"'*$ *+"$C *

**"('&7$&B+('*"$'&.20(2/H$%.	$2H.//('*"$'&'&("!$'&7A+"9'&$"+*$'('*"$'&+& $%A+"9*%"7K! DL
I.
	/. 
 ! 30 .( 20

,"-" & '&7  "-''& -'D('&' $'&"$%"$%*%D% 
0I?D' "-"A+(7#&A+"9'&$"+*$'&KQ& 9'!$%'&$"+D"*&!+'&7#' ('&7""+30(333.H$%.HIHM+$'&7
5//.(.0H$%'"/

$9C * '# $%$ $% ('$"'*$

( 'B"$'7&"&*'&$"+*$'&'&-'(&*'*&$" (B9

H$%'"I
&$$%'+*+"$7'-( 'B"$'7&"&*#'$$$% DB+$'+&+"$'$#$%"# """&
&
3 
 

"!!'"#(+"$%'&G'&7'&$
$!.30(00/H$%'"3IHKNO-&'!$%"%( B& '&+!!'*'&$ -'(&* $ +"$  ( 'B"$'7&"&*'&$"+*$'&D#+$+#$%$$%A+"9! D($% A+"9 *%"7 &( ('( &$ *&-'*$ & $% 7"+&( !( 'B"$'7&"&*LI

%*+"$B D$"'*$ 9(%"($$%D"('&7!$%	'6$%

'"*+'$<$$"&5+"9 
&$"+*$'&D%'*%**+"$ 9$$$% D!$%''"*+'$
%!0.(

./0 .. H$% '" 30I HKN
&$"+*$'& D%'*% "#'$G&D (7$B'&!""(O(&$+$%"'F*&-'*$'&B(&&7 '7&$B%-'"B+$"$%""-&$*"'#'& (!&(&$ !"#*'&7*&-'*$'&#" 9B9( 'B"$ 9* '&7%' 9$$%B-'+ "'G$%$%' &77'&7'&+& D!+  *&(+*$L I  % $$"& '&$"+*$'& ( &$&*+"7  *&-'*$'& B( +& #" &7 '7&* &('&(( 6" 9 *+$'& 7'&$ +*%  !'&('&7 <$$"&"'#'& 5+"9
&$"+*$'&!"$%	'6$%'"*+'$E./H?$IHK" &"&7 '7&*"! '%&&%'"$'&$$%#G&D (7&('&$&+7%$*&-'*$LI,"-"$-" $%"'&$(+"'&7'$A+"9*%"7$%('$"'*$*+"$"#'&(($%A+"9$%$'$*+ (&$*&-'*$$9+& '$!+&(%'#7+' $9B9&("&B (+B$

*+$%('$"'*$*+"$('(&$#'$$$% D"7"('&7

( 'B"$'7&"&*&($%'&$"+*$'&-'D(D% D"&$*&!+'&7#' ('&7""A+('*' D*&* +($%$$%('$"'*$*+"$('(&$*##'$"-"'B """'&7'-'&7$%( 'B"$'7&"&*'&$"+*$'&

 	//,)/ (, -)0$9 !+"$%" *&$&( $%$ $% ('$"'*$ *+"$ ""( B9

"!+'&7 $ "(+* %' !!& -  !" **$&* !"&'B' '$9?('7"

('$"'*$*+"$C(*''&"7"('&7D%$%"$"(+*

(!&(&$C!!& - !"**$&*!"&'B' '$9'!*$+ ($"#'&$'&$%$' +BA*$$ * " 9""&+

 $&("(!"-'D

.H$%'"/I$%'

*+ $% $"'  *+"$C *&$"'$'&D' (&(%-' 9&$% K* " 9 ""&+L $&(+$'&$%A+(7#&$ !$% ('
&(( $% 7+'( '& *'!'&$&*'&7A+(7''&+&'M+(!&(&$C**$&*!"&$%($"#'&$'&!$%&$&7"$(!"&*&"-'D&(+& '$'D'$%+$!+&($'&L

&HM+$'&7
#

'"3II


&+"$!%'*&$&$'&$%$

'&%'!!& - $9*'$.(2H$%'"/I
&;*+"$('(&$""'&7"&$'&7 ""&'B' '$9D%"(!&(&$D&&$"#&$(!&& $%+"*7&'F$%$'$'D'$%'&('$"'* "(+*$'& !"**$&*! "D%"*($$"' $"'&&$$&(!"$%"'$'&$%$&&$"#&$(!&'&$'$ ($ - !"**$&*!"&'B' '!"$%"'$'&$%$$%(*'"(+*$'&!"**$&*!"&%"*(($$"' $"&$&D'$%$%('*"$'&!$%$"' A+(*6" 9"*7&'F($%$'a"&$(!&(&$D%"***$&*!"&'B' '$9B+$!