### SERVE D AUGUS T 3 , 20 1 OLRARTMENTO F 

### • RAN!:PCRWIO N :0K ^ i 0FFRAT!0N 3 'M m' 3 P 2

- Li O

U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O P HEARFNG S WASHINGTON , D C I N TH E MATTE R O F M & RHELICOPTERS , LL C FA A DOCKE T No . CPlOSOOO l 1 {Civi l Penall y Action ) FDMSNo . FAA-2010-12! 1 CONSOLIDATE D ORDE RO N MOTION S Ther e ar e numerou s motion s i n thi s case . The y wil l b e addresse dherein . Additiona l observation s wil l b e reiterated . Respondent , b y it s representative , ha s show n considerabl e passio n an dzealotr y i n advocatin g it s position . Bu t i n it s fervor , th e representativ e - wh o i s no t apractitione r

- appear s t o insufficientl y appreciat e th e solemnit y an ddecoru mo f th e lega l process . Thi s bod y i s adul y constitute dCour t o f La w unde r

th e Administrativ e Procedur e Act . 5 U.S.C . §55 2 e t seq . Th e proces s an dit s participant s mus t

b e treate dwit happropriat e dignity . It i s no t consisten t

wit hprope r decoru mt o demea n Complainant' s attorney s and/o r thi s process . Suc h languag e lack s th e dignit y expecte do f participant s i

n thi s o r an y othe r

lega l proceedings . Al l partie s shoul dus e languag e an dmak e argument s whic huphol dth e dignit y o f th e proceedin g o f whic hthe y ar e apart. ' Violatio n o f

thes e principle s wil l b e deal t wit happropriately . Additionally , Respondenl' s captio n namin g certai n individual s i

n addition t

o th e FA A a s Complainants is no t correct . Ther

e is onl y on e Complainani , an

dtha t i s th e Federa l Aviatio n Administration . Responden i i n th e futur e shoul drefe r t o th e Complainan

t a s such .WHEREFORE , th e rnotion s an dpleading s havin g been rea dan dconsidere di

t b e andi s hereb y ORDERE D a s follows : 1 . Respondent' s "Motio n t o Strike Allegation , Mr . Baker wa s no t o n a drug/alcoho l program " date d11-30-1 0 i s DENIED ; 2 . Respondent' s "Preliminary Objections''date d11-27-1 0 i s DENIED ; 3 . Respondent' s "Motio n to Quash , Strike o r Dismis s Complaint " date dI I -30

- 1 0 i s DENIED ; 4 . Respondent' s "Motio n to Compe l Discovery " date d12-2-1 0 i s DENIED ; 5 . Complainant' s "Motio n Requestin g a n Orde r to Impos e aProcedur e schedul e fo r filing dispositiv e Motion s andDiscover} ' date dDecember 10 , 201 0 i s MOOT ; 6 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Judgmen t

to Dismis s 4 , Failure to Respon do r meet filin g deadline s o n 8 pleadings " date d12-14-1 0 i s DENIED ; 7 . Respondent' s "Motio n to hav e depositio n o f Latony aWilliam s i

n th e Allemown , P

A location " date d12-21-1 0 i s DENIED ; 8 . Respondent' s "Motion s to Disinissan dStrike Allegation " date d12-10-1 0 i s DENIED ; 9 . Respondent' s ''Motion fo r Judg e to Dismiss , Failure l o Respon do r meet filing deadlines " date d12-8-1 0 i s DENIED ; 10 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Judgmen t

t o Dismis s 4 , Failure to Respon dor mee t filing deadline s o n 8 pleadings " date d12-14-1 0 i s DENIED ; 11 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Pre-trial Conference , a

t Gallaghe r

reporting , Allenlown , PA " date dl- l l-l l i s DENIED ; 12 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r More Definite Statement " date dl-ll-l l i s DENIED ; 13 . Respondent' s "Motio n t o Dismis s Complainant s |sic ] Propose dProcedural Schedule " date dl-ll- M i s DENIED ; 14 . Respondenl' s "Motio n fo r Judgmen t

to Dismiss , Failure to properl y respon d o r meetin g filing deadlines " date d12-24-1 0 i s DENIED ; 15 . Respondent' s "Motio n forbearin g locatio n i n Allentown , PA. " filedJanuary 18 , 101 1 i s DENIE D a s Moot ; 16 . Respondent' s "Motio n to hav e pre-trial depositio n o f Latony aWilliams , a

t Gallaghe r Reporting , Allentown , PA. " i s date d1-7-1 1 i s DENIED ; 17 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Judgtnen t

t o Dismiss , Truth s o f

Admissions " date d 1-7-1 1 i s DENIED ; 18 . Respondent' s "Motio n to Strike Allegation , Mr . Baker wa s no t o n a drug/alcoho l Prograins " date d1-7-1 1 i s DENIED ; l9r'Respondent' s "Motio n t o Compe l Discover y andNe w Matter , failure t o provid e requeste dreference devidence " date d1-8-1 1 i s DENIED ; 20 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Judgmen t

t o Dismiss , Judicial Estoppels , Lega l Inconsistency " date d1-8-1 1 i s DENIED ; 21 . Respondent' s "Motio n to Dismis s Complainant' s Propose dProcedural Order " date dl-ll-l l i s DENIED ;22 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Pre-Trial Conferenc e a

t Gallaghe r

Reportin g , Allentown , PA. " filed1-11- I I i s DENIED ; 23 . Respondent' s "Repl y b y wa y o f Objectio n t o Complainant s fsic ] Motio n fo r Procedural Schedul e Impositions " date d12-16-1 0 i s DENIED ; 24 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Judgmen t

t o Quash , Additional Substantiatin g Evidence " date d12-4-1

- i s DENIED ; 25 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Mor e Definite Statement , 'Insufficien t Evidence ' als o fo r Mr . Baker " date d2-1-1 1 i s DENIED ; 26 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Depositio n o f

Cynthi aDominik , A

t Gallaghe r Reporting , Allentown , PA. " date d1-21-I I i s DENIED ; 27 . Complainant' s "Motio n l o Dismis s Counter-Cotiiplaint " date dMarc h21 , 2011 , i s GRANTED ; 28 . Respondent' s "Motio n to Compe l Discover y andNe w Matter , Failure t o Provid e Requeste dReference dEvidence " date di-8- l 1 i s DENIED ; 29 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Definite Statement , Failin g to Meet Filin g Deadlines " filedJanuar

y 28,2011 , i s DENIED ; 30 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Mor e Definite Statement , Holdin g Responden i t o a higher standardthan I'A

A officials " filedJanuar

y 28 , 201 1 i s DENIED ; 31 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r More Definite Statement , 119.6 9 Shutdow n an d Human Factors " filedJanuary 28 , 201 1 i s DENIED ; 32 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r More Definite Statement , changin g th e fundainental caus e o f

action " filedJanuary 28 , 201 1 i s DENIED ; 33 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Definite Requeste dDiscovery " date d2-7-1 1 i s DENIED ; 34 . Respondent' s "Motio n to Dismiss , recurren t failin g to meet

filing deadlines

4 more " date d1-6-1 1 i s DENIED ; 35 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Protectiv e Order , changin g th e fundamental caus e o f action " date d2-6-1 1 i s DENIED ; 36 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Mor e Definite Statement , Depositio n o f Cynthi a Dominik " date d1-6-1 1 i s DENIED ; 37 . Respondenl' s "Motio n fo r Specifi c Discovery , trave l lo g fo r Latony a Williams " date d1-24-1 1 i s DENIED ; 38 . Respondenl' s "Notic e o f Filings , NAS A for

man dPetitio n fo

r Rulemaking , Propose dChanges " filedFebruar y 7 , 201 1 i s DENIED ; 39 . Respondent' s "Mofio n l o Defin e andEnter 4 Truth s o f

Admissions " undate d i s DENIED ; 40 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Rul e t o Sho w Cause , 'insufficien t evidence ' als o — fo r Mr . Baker

Estoppe l b y inconsisten t

positions " undate di s DENIED ; 41 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r More Definite Statement , 'insufficien t evidence ' als o fo r Mr . Baker " undate di s DENIED ; 42 . Respondenl' s "Motio n to Dismiss , recurren t failin g to mee t

filing deadline s - 4 more " date d1-6-1 1 i s DENIED ; 43 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Definite Requeste dDiscovery " date d2-7-1 1 i s DENIED ; 44 . Respondent' s "Mofio n fo r more Definite Statement , trave l lo g o f Latony a Williams"dated2-]7-l l i s DENIED ;45 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r mor e Definit e Statement , inadequat e inethod s o f complianc e an dnotification " undate di s DENIED ; 46 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Specifi c Relie f

an dSanction s Agains t Complainants' , prosecuLaria l [sic ] indiscretion " undate di s DENIED ; 47 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Specia l Relie f

an dSanction s Agains t Complainants' , Prosccularia l [sic ] indiscretion " undate di s DENIED ; 48 . Respondent' s "Motio n t o Defin e an dEnte r 4 1 ruth s o f

Admissions " date d2

- 13-1 1 i s DENIED ; 49 . Respondenl' s "Petitio n fo r Disclosur e o f

Ms . f*onto s Attorne y I D Number " date d3-2-1 1 i s DENIED . Ms . Pont o i s no t apart y t o thi s case . Th e rule s d o no t requir e providin g an attorne y I D i n thi s o r an y othe r

cas e befor e thi s court . Further , th e baseles s allegation s i n th e Petitio n ar e withou t foundatio n an ddemea n these , proceeding . Th e Petitio n wil l b e seale dan dremove dfro m th e publi c portio n o f

th e docke t

su e spontc . Pleading s wit hsimila r accusafion s wil l no t

b e tolerated ; 50 . Respondent' s "PeUlio n fo r Specia l Relief, jurisdicfio n an dvenue " date d3-6

- I I i s DENIED ; 51 . Respondent' s "Counter-Complaint " date d3-9- 1 1 i s DISMISSED ; 52 . Respondent' s "Petitio n fo r Emergenc y Injunefiv e an dDeclarator y Relie f an d Cas e Dismissal " date d3- 1 l- l 1 i s DENIED ; 53 . Complainant' s "Motio n t o Dismis s Counter-Complaint " date dMarc h21 , 201 1 i s GRANTED ; 54 . Respondent' s "Motio n fo r Contemp t

fo r Disobedienc e o f

th e Orde r

Pertainin g t o Spoilatio n [sic ] o f

th e Enforcemen t

Investigativ e Report " date d4-20- 1 I i s DENIED ; 55 . T o th e exten t

an y othe r

outstandin g motion s hav e no t bee n rule do n a s o f

th e dat e o f th e servic e o f

thi s Orde r

the y b e an dar c hereb y DENIED .

Richar dC . Goodwi n Adininistrativ e La w Judg e Attachmen t

- Servic e Lis tFA A Docke t No . CPlOSOOO l 1 (Civi l Penalt y Action ) REVISE D SERVIC E LIS T ORIGINA L& ON E COP Y Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S.W . Washington , D C 2059 1 Attention : Hearin g Docke t Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wrigh t Building—Suit e 2W1000 '

ON E COP Y Michae l Selig , MD , FACC , CFl-H , Respondent' s Representativ e 281 6 Orefiel dRoa d Allentown , PA 1810 4 TEL : 610-360-395 3 FAX : Charle s Raley , Complainant' s Counse l Attorney , Enforcemen t

Division/AGC-30 0 Offic e o f th e Chie f

Counse l Federa l Aviatio n Administrafio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S.W . Washington , D C 2059 1 TEL : 202-267-335 7 FAX : 202-267-510 6 Th e Honorabl e Richar dC . Goodwin , Administrativ e Law,fudg e Offic e o f Hearings , M-2 0 UiSr'Departmen t

o f Transportatio n 120 0 Ne w Jerse y Avenu e Eas t Buildin g Groun dFloor , Roo mEI2-32 0 Washington , D C 2059 0 TEL : Attorney-Adviso r 202-366-213 9 Lega l Assistan t

202-366-512 1 FAX : 202-366-753 6

' Service wa

s b y U.S . Mail . Fo

r service i n perso n o r b y expeditedcourier , use th

e followin g address : Federa

l Aviatio n Admiii i strat i on , 600 Independence Avenue , S.W. , Wilbu r Wrigh t Building—Suit

e 2WI000 , Washington, D C 20591 . Attention : Hearin g Docke t Clerk, AGC-430 .