Additional SRP Coronado CALPUFF simulations for Bosque del Apache for TSD for Arizona Region

Ran by EPA Region 9 (not UNC) sjb 2012-07-11, updated 07-14

! NOTE: TSD_vis_tables1.xls refers to the copy of the ddv_mult pivot table results !

These results were *not* considered for the NPRM, but are included in one TSD table.

These results are *not* included in any UNC reports or spreadsheets, nor in "AZRHFIP_NPRM_Coronado_visx.xlsx"

Control scenarios

base_q pre-LNB base case ("base_rs" is LNB on unit 1, LNB+SCR 0.08 on unit 2, with H2SO4)

base_rs post-LNB base case: LNB on unit 1, LNB+SCR 0.08 on unit 2, with additional H2SO4

ctrl1_rs SNCR on unit 1; SCR 0.08 lb/MMBtu NOx on unit 2 with additional H2SO4

ctrl2_rs SCR 0.05 lb/MMBtu NOx on unit 1; SCR 0.08 lb/MMBtu NOx on unit 2; both with additional H

ctrl5_rs SCR 0.05 lb/MMBtu NOx on unit 1; SCR 0.05 lb/MMBtu NOx on unit 2; both with additional H

ctrl6_rs SCR on both units 1 and 2: -90% off post-LNB max daily emissions; both with additional H2SO

Pivot Tables

ddv_3yrs 2001-2003 individual year impacts, and average

ddv_mult impacts of merged 2001-2003

Data extracted from CALPOST.LST files

ddv_n22_csv merged 3-year 22nd highs (from ddv_n22_Coronado_bosq.csv)

ddv_n8yrs_csv individual year 8th highs (from ddv_n8yrs_Coronado_bosq.csv)

ddv_table_csv rough table of 8th/22nd highs and number of days over 0.5 and 1.0 dv (from ddv_table_n822
D for Arizona Regional Haze FIP NPRM

ot table results !

do_visx.xlsx"

it 2, with H2SO4)

itional H2SO4

2; both with additional H2SO4

2; both with additional H2SO4

oth with additional H2SO4

dv (from ddv_table_n822_Coronado_bosq.csv)
Additional SRP Coronado CALPUFF simulations for Bosque del Apache

mvis vis8

vbg 20best

Average of deltaDV

Control 

Scenario

base_q base_q Avg base_rs base_rs Avg

Class I Area 2001 2002 2003 2001 2002 2003

Bosque del Apache Wild. 0.91 0.73 0.60 0.75 0.62 0.47 0.43 0.51

sum 0.75 0.51

max 0.75 0.51

area with max Bosque del Apache Wild. Bosque del Apache Wild.
ctrl1_rs ctrl1_rs Avg ctrl2_rs ctrl2_rs Avg ctrl5_rs

2001 2002 2003 2001 2002 2003 2001 2002 2003

0.51 0.38 0.35 0.42 0.35 0.24 0.26 0.28 0.30 0.21 0.23

0.42

0.42

osque del Apache Wild. Bosque del Apache Wild.
ctrl5_rs Avg ctrl6_rs ctrl6_rs Avg

2001 2002 2003

0.25 0.25 0.18 0.21 0.21
Additional SRP Coronado CALPUFF simulations for Bosque del Apache

mvis vis8

vbg 20best

Merged years deltaDV

Control 

Scenario

Class I Area base_q base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs ctrl6_rs

Bosque del Apache Wild. 0.725 0.466 0.382 0.268 0.232 0.212

sum 0.73 0.47 0.38

max 0.73 0.47 0.38

area with max Bosque del Apache W Bosque del Apache W ild. Bosque del Apache W ild. ild.
References to some results, for copying (e.g. pasted to area at right)

Merged 2001-2003 Average of indiv. 2001-2003

area base_q base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs ctrl6_rs base_q base_rs ctrl1_rs

bosq 0.725 0.466 0.382 0.268 0.232 0.212 0.745 0.507 0.416

0.73 0.47 0.38 0.27 0.75 0.51 0.42

0.73 0.47 0.38 0.27 0.75 0.51 0.42
Note: TSD_vis_tables1.xls refers to this copy

Pasted values of some results, for reference by other spreadsheets

vm8b

Merged 2001-2003

ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs ctrl6_rs base_q base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs

0.283 0.247 0.211 0.725 0.466 0.382 0.268 0.232

0.28

0.28
y other spreadsheets

Average of indiv. 2001-2003

ctrl6_rs base_q base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs ctrl6_rs

0.212 0.745 0.507 0.416 0.282667 0.247333 0.211333
Class I Area fac scen year area mvis vbg filegroup Rank Pctile

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2001 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2002 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2003 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2001 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2002 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2003 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2001 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2002 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2003 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2001 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2002 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2003 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2001 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2002 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2003 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2001 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2002 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2003 bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2001 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2002 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2003 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2001 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2002 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2003 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2001 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2002 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2003 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2001 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2002 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2003 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2001 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2002 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2003 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2001 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2002 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2003 bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2001 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2002 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2003 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2001 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2002 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2003 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2001 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2002 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2003 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2001 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1
Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2002 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo

8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2003 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2001 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2002 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2003 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2001 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2002 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2003 bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2001 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2002 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q 2003 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2001 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2002 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs 2003 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2001 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2002 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs 2003 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2001 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2002 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs 2003 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2001 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2002 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs 2003 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2001 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2002 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2002_calpost_bo8 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs 2003 bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2003_calpost_bo8 98.1
Date YearDay Year Day Hr Rec Xkm Ykm TypeDVtot DVbkg deltaDV

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.831 1.842 0.99

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.651 1.861 0.79

3/10/2003 2003069 2003 69 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.478 1.802 0.676

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.522 1.842 0.68

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.379 1.861 0.517

12/11/2003 2003345 2003 345 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.404 1.921 0.483

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.409 1.842 0.567

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.284 1.861 0.422

8/31/2003 2003243 2003 243 23 157 -914.282 -629.363 D 2.268 1.862 0.406

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.28 1.901 0.379

1/2/2002 2002002 2002 2 23 1 -911.81 -649.181 D 2.168 1.901 0.267

3/5/2003 2003064 2003 64 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.089 1.802 0.288

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.229 1.901 0.328

7/20/2002 2002201 2002 201 23 72 -917.383 -636.469 D 2.081 1.842 0.239

9/5/2003 2003248 2003 248 23 18 -909.113 -645.752 D 2.12 1.861 0.258

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.17 1.901 0.269

7/20/2002 2002201 2002 201 23 72 -917.383 -636.469 D 2.074 1.842 0.233

7/5/2003 2003186 2003 186 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.092 1.842 0.25

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 5.199 4.426 0.773

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 5.083 4.469 0.614

3/10/2003 2003069 2003 69 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.87 4.341 0.528

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.956 4.426 0.529

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.87 4.469 0.401

12/11/2003 2003345 2003 345 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.966 4.594 0.372

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.867 4.426 0.441

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.796 4.469 0.327

8/31/2003 2003243 2003 243 23 157 -914.282 -629.363 D 4.784 4.47 0.314

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.844 4.553 0.292

2/3/2002 2002034 2002 34 23 72 -917.383 -636.469 D 4.674 4.469 0.206

3/5/2003 2003064 2003 64 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.565 4.341 0.224

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.805 4.553 0.252

7/20/2002 2002201 2002 201 23 72 -917.383 -636.469 D 4.612 4.426 0.185

2/8/2003 2003039 2003 39 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.668 4.469 0.199

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.76 4.553 0.207

7/20/2002 2002201 2002 201 23 72 -917.383 -636.469 D 4.607 4.426 0.18

7/5/2003 2003186 2003 186 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.62 4.426 0.194

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 3.085 2.179 0.906

2/3/2002 2002034 2002 34 23 72 -917.383 -636.469 D 2.945 2.219 0.725

3/10/2003 2003069 2003 69 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.707 2.103 0.604

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.797 2.179 0.618

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.691 2.219 0.471

12/11/2003 2003345 2003 345 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.735 2.304 0.431

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.693 2.179 0.514

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.603 2.219 0.384

12/11/2003 2003345 2003 345 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.654 2.304 0.35

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.527 2.179 0.348
1/2/2002 2002002 2002

2 231 -911.81 -649.181D 2.556 2.313 0.243

3/5/2003 2003064 2003 64 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 2.36 2.103 0.257

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 2.614 2.313 0.301

1/2/2002 2002002 20022 231 -911.81 -649.181D 2.525 2.313 0.212

3/5/2003 2003064 2003 64 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 2.332 2.103 0.229

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 2.559 2.313 0.246

7/20/2002 2002201 2002 201 23 72 -917.383 -636.469D 2.308 2.124 0.183

7/5/2003 2003186 2003 186 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 2.329 2.124 0.205

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 5.089 4.351 0.737

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.992 4.404 0.588

3/10/2003 2003069 2003 69 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.743 4.252 0.491

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.853 4.351 0.501

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.786 4.404 0.382

12/11/2003 2003345 2003 345 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.861 4.513 0.348

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.768 4.351 0.417

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.714 4.404 0.31

12/11/2003 2003345 2003 345 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.795 4.513 0.282

11/6/2001 2001310 2001 310 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.633 4.351 0.282

1/2/2002 2002002 20022 231 -911.81 -649.181D 4.721 4.525 0.196

3/5/2003 2003064 2003 64 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.46 4.252 0.208

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.768 4.525 0.243

1/2/2002 2002002 20022 231 -911.81 -649.181D 4.696 4.525 0.171

3/5/2003 2003064 2003 64 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.437 4.252 0.185

1/13/2001 2001013 2001 13 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.723 4.525 0.198

7/20/2002 2002201 2002 201 23 72 -917.383 -636.469D 4.428 4.28 0.148

7/5/2003 2003186 2003 186 23 137 -915.248 -631.119D 4.446 4.28 0.166
dvpSO4 dvpNO3 dvpOC dvpEC dvpPMC dvpPMF dvpNO2 fRHsml fRHlrg

7.74 75.1 0 1.35 2.88 3.53 9.4 1.8 0

6.67 83.46 0 0.88 1.87 2.29 4.83 1.9 0

18.92 71.23 0 1.38 2.94 3.6 1.93 1.6 0

15.47 65.02 0 2 4.25 5.21 8.05 1.8 0

13.24 74.63 0 1.36 2.9 3.55 4.31 1.9 0

10.74 79.2 0 1.03 2.19 2.68 4.17 2.2 0

18.64 60.14 0 2.41 5.12 6.28 7.4 1.8 0

16.3 70.04 0 1.68 3.57 4.37 4.04 1.9 0

80.66 7.46 0 2.06 4.38 5.37 0.06 1.904 0

28.88 56.95 0 2.05 4.35 5.33 2.44 2.1 0

42.62 49.4 0 1.31 2.78 3.41 0.49 2.1 0

30.56 43.28 0 3.74 7.93 9.72 4.76 1.6 0

33.48 50.75 0 2.37 5.04 6.18 2.18 2.1 0

81.88 7.76 0 1.79 3.8 4.66 0.11 1.8 0

69.35 4.68 0 4.29 9.1 11.15 1.42 1.9 0

40.91 40.73 0 2.9 6.16 7.55 1.74 2.1 0

84.19 5.19 0 1.84 3.91 4.79 0.08 1.8 0

70.69 1.61 0 4.56 9.68 11.86 1.6 1.8 0

7.74 75.1 0 1.35 2.88 3.53 9.4 1.8 0

6.67 83.46 0 0.88 1.87 2.29 4.83 1.9 0

18.92 71.23 0 1.38 2.94 3.6 1.93 1.6 0

15.47 65.02 0 2 4.25 5.21 8.05 1.8 0

13.24 74.63 0 1.36 2.9 3.55 4.31 1.9 0

10.74 79.2 0 1.03 2.19 2.68 4.17 2.2 0

18.64 60.14 0 2.41 5.12 6.28 7.4 1.8 0

16.3 70.04 0 1.68 3.57 4.37 4.04 1.9 0

80.66 7.46 0 2.06 4.38 5.37 0.06 1.904 0

28.88 56.95 0 2.05 4.35 5.33 2.44 2.1 0

42.35 50.06 0 1.28 2.72 3.34 0.26 1.9 0

30.56 43.28 0 3.74 7.93 9.72 4.76 1.6 0

33.48 50.75 0 2.37 5.04 6.18 2.18 2.1 0

81.87 7.76 0 1.79 3.8 4.66 0.11 1.8 0

32.51 46.95 0 2.98 6.33 7.75 3.49 1.9 0

40.92 40.73 0 2.9 6.16 7.55 1.74 2.1 0

84.18 5.19 0 1.84 3.91 4.79 0.08 1.8 0

70.68 1.61 0 4.56 9.68 11.86 1.6 1.8 0

7.03 74.78 0 1.44 3.05 3.74 9.97 2.09 1.73

11.01 85.97 0 0.44 0.94 1.15 0.48 2.23 1.82

17.45 71.79 0 1.51 3.21 3.93 2.11 1.83 1.55

14.16 65.01 0 2.14 4.54 5.56 8.59 2.09 1.73

12.18 74.95 0 1.45 3.08 3.77 4.58 2.23 1.82

9.85 79.28 0 1.11 2.36 2.9 4.5 2.53 2

17.11 60.2 0 2.58 5.48 6.72 7.91 2.09 1.73

15.03 70.44 0 1.79 3.8 4.65 4.3 2.23 1.82

12.19 75.66 0 1.38 2.93 3.58 4.26 2.53 2

32.21 40.52 0 3.84 8.16 10 5.26 2.09 1.73
40.48 51.1

0 1.38 2.93 3.59 0.52 2.56 2.03

28.13 43.390 4.07 8.64 10.59 5.19 1.83 1.55

31.5 52.010 2.48 5.27 6.46 2.27 2.56 2.03

46.42 44.060 1.58 3.36 4.12 0.45 2.56 2.03

31.66 37.630 4.58 9.72 11.92 4.5 1.83 1.55

38.72 41.980 3.05 6.48 7.94 1.83 2.56 2.03

81.39 5.460 2.28 4.84 5.94 0.09 1.9 1.61

65.5 1.620 5.41 11.49 14.08 1.9 1.9 1.61

7.04 74.820 1.43 3.04 3.73 9.94 2.09 1.73

6.1 83.510 0.93 1.97 2.41 5.08 2.23 1.82

17.46 71.820 1.51 3.2 3.92 2.1 1.83 1.55

14.17 65.050 2.13 4.53 5.55 8.57 2.09 1.73

12.19 74.970 1.44 3.07 3.76 4.57 2.23 1.82

9.85 79.30 1.11 2.36 2.89 4.49 2.532

17.12 60.240 2.57 5.47 6.7 7.89 2.09 1.73

15.04 70.470 1.78 3.79 4.64 4.29 2.23 1.82

12.2 75.690 1.37 2.92 3.58 4.25 2.532

32.24 40.550 3.84 8.15 9.98 5.25 2.09 1.73

40.49 51.10 1.38 2.93 3.58 0.52 2.56 2.03

28.16 43.420 4.06 8.62 10.56 5.17 1.83 1.55

31.52 52.030 2.48 5.26 6.44 2.27 2.56 2.03

46.44 44.070 1.58 3.35 4.11 0.45 2.56 2.03

31.69 37.670 4.57 9.7 11.89 4.49 1.83 1.55

38.75 420 3.04 6.46 7.92 1.83 2.56 2.03

81.43 5.460 2.27 4.83 5.92 0.09 1.9 1.61

65.57 1.620 5.4 11.47 14.05 1.89 1.9 1.61
fRHss

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

2.27

2.43

1.95

2.27

2.43

2.71

2.27

2.43

2.71

2.27
2.77

1.95

2.77

2.77

1.95

2.77

2.06

2.06

2.27

2.43

1.95

2.27

2.43

2.71

2.27

2.43

2.71

2.27

2.77

1.95

2.77

2.77

1.95

2.77

2.06

2.06
Class I Area fac scen year area mvis vbg filegroup Rank Pctile

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q mult bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs mult bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs mult bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs mult bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs mult bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs mult bosq vis6 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q mult bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs mult bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs mult bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs mult bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs mult bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs mult bosq vis6 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q mult bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs mult bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs mult bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs mult bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs mult bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs mult bosq vis8 20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q mult bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs mult bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs mult bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs mult bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs mult bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1

Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs mult bosq vis8 annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_b22 98.1
Date YearDay Year Day Hr Rec Xkm Ykm TypeDVtot DVbkg deltaDV

1/18/2003 2003018 2003 18 23 2 -911.045 -649.265 D 2.685 1.901 0.783

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.379 1.861 0.517

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.284 1.861 0.422

2/8/2003 2003039 2003 39 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.159 1.861 0.297

2/8/2003 2003039 2003 39 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.119 1.861 0.258

9/5/2003 2003248 2003 248 23 18 -909.113 -645.752 D 2.114 1.861 0.253

1/18/2003 2003018 2003 18 23 2 -911.045 -649.265 D 5.159 4.553 0.606

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.87 4.469 0.401

2/26/2002 2002057 2002 57 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.796 4.469 0.327

2/8/2003 2003039 2003 39 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.698 4.469 0.23

3/5/2003 2003064 2003 64 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.541 4.341 0.2

9/5/2003 2003248 2003 248 23 18 -909.113 -645.752 D 4.664 4.469 0.195

3/5/2003 2003064 2003 64 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.828 2.103 0.725

11/26/2001 2001330 2001 330 23 84 -917.282 -635.549 D 2.645 2.179 0.466

1/10/2003 2003010 2003 10 23 157 -914.282 -629.363 D 2.695 2.313 0.382

2/8/2003 2003039 2003 39 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.487 2.219 0.268

2/8/2003 2003039 2003 39 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 2.451 2.219 0.232

9/5/2003 2003248 2003 248 23 18 -909.113 -645.752 D 2.391 2.18 0.212

1/2/2002 2002002 2002 2 23 1 -911.81 -649.181 D 5.113 4.525 0.587

11/26/2001 2001330 2001 330 23 84 -917.282 -635.549 D 4.729 4.351 0.378

1/10/2003 2003010 2003 10 23 157 -914.282 -629.363 D 4.834 4.525 0.308

2/8/2003 2003039 2003 39 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.62 4.404 0.216

2/8/2003 2003039 2003 39 23 137 -915.248 -631.119 D 4.591 4.404 0.187

9/5/2003 2003248 2003 248 23 18 -909.113 -645.752 D 4.523 4.352 0.171
dvpSO4 dvpNO3 dvpOC dvpEC dvpPMC dvpPMF dvpNO2 fRHsml fRHlrg

11.84 78.84 0 1.13 2.41 2.95 2.82 2.1 0

13.24 74.63 0 1.36 2.9 3.55 4.31 1.9 0

16.3 70.04 0 1.68 3.57 4.37 4.04 1.9 0

28.15 53.14 0 2.58 5.48 6.71 3.95 1.9 0

32.51 46.95 0 2.98 6.33 7.75 3.49 1.9 0

70.86 3.11 0 4.38 9.3 11.4 0.95 1.9 0

11.84 78.84 0 1.13 2.41 2.95 2.82 2.1 0

13.24 74.63 0 1.36 2.9 3.55 4.31 1.9 0

16.3 70.04 0 1.68 3.57 4.37 4.04 1.9 0

28.15 53.13 0 2.58 5.48 6.71 3.95 1.9 0

34.34 37.5 0 4.2 8.92 10.93 4.12 1.6 0

70.86 3.11 0 4.38 9.3 11.4 0.95 1.9 0

5.45 77.19 0 1.41 2.99 3.66 9.3 1.83 1.55

13.61 78.51 0 1.1 2.34 2.87 1.57 2.09 1.73

22.94 65.08 0 1.56 3.32 4.07 3.03 2.56 2.03

26.15 53.78 0 2.76 5.87 7.2 4.23 2.23 1.82

30.28 47.64 0 3.2 6.8 8.33 3.75 2.23 1.82

66.69 3.18 0 5.07 10.77 13.19 1.1 2.09 1.73

11.3 85.26 0 0.45 0.95 1.17 0.87 2.56 2.03

13.62 78.53 0 1.1 2.33 2.86 1.56 2.09 1.73

22.95 65.1 0 1.56 3.31 4.06 3.02 2.56 2.03

26.17 53.81 0 2.76 5.86 7.18 4.22 2.23 1.82

30.3 47.66 0 3.19 6.78 8.31 3.74 2.23 1.82

66.75 3.19 0 5.06 10.74 13.16 1.09 2.09 1.73
fRHss

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

1.95

2.27

2.77

2.43

2.43

2.29

2.77

2.27

2.77

2.43

2.43

2.29
fac scen year area mvis

Control Scenario Class I Area fac scen Year area mvis

base_q: LNB only (on both) Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q mult bosq vis6

base_rs: SCR .08 u2 w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs mult bosq vis6

ctrl1_rs: SNCR u1; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs mult bosq vis6

ctrl2_rs: SCR .05 u1; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs mult bosq vis6

ctrl5_rs: SCR .05 w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs mult bosq vis6

ctrl6_rs: SCR -90%; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs mult bosq vis6

base_q: LNB only (on both) Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q mult bosq vis6

base_rs: SCR .08 u2 w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs mult bosq vis6

ctrl1_rs: SNCR u1; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs mult bosq vis6

ctrl2_rs: SCR .05 u1; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs mult bosq vis6

ctrl5_rs: SCR .05 w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs mult bosq vis6

ctrl6_rs: SCR -90%; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs mult bosq vis6

base_q: LNB only (on both) Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q mult bosq vis8

base_rs: SCR .08 u2 w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs mult bosq vis8

ctrl1_rs: SNCR u1; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs mult bosq vis8

ctrl2_rs: SCR .05 u1; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs mult bosq vis8

ctrl5_rs: SCR .05 w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs mult bosq vis8

ctrl6_rs: SCR -90%; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs mult bosq vis8

base_q: LNB only (on both) Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_q mult bosq vis8

base_rs: SCR .08 u2 w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp base_rs mult bosq vis8

ctrl1_rs: SNCR u1; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl1_rs mult bosq vis8

ctrl2_rs: SCR .05 u1; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl2_rs mult bosq vis8

ctrl5_rs: SCR .05 w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl5_rs mult bosq vis8

ctrl6_rs: SCR -90%; w/SO4 Bosque del Apache Wild. srp ctrl6_rs mult bosq vis8
2001 2002 2003 '01-'03 '01-'03 2001 2002 2003

vbg filegroup ddv_p98 ddv_p98 ddv_p98 avg merge n_ddv>0.5 n_ddv>0.5 n_ddv>0.5

vbg filegroup 8th 2001 8th 2002 8th 2003

avg '01-

'03 8th

22nd '01-

'03

2001 

#days>0.5

2002 

#days>0.5

2003 

#days>0.5

20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_20best.lst 0.99 0.79 0.676 0.818667 0.783 14 17 13

20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_20best.lst 0.68 0.517 0.483 0.56 0.517 9 8 5

20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_20best.lst 0.567 0.422 0.406 0.465 0.422 8 6 2

20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_20best.lst 0.379 0.267 0.288 0.311333 0.297 2 2 0

20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_20best.lst 0.328 0.239 0.258 0.275 0.258 2 1 0

20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_20best.lst 0.269 0.233 0.25 0.250667 0.253 1 0 0

annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_annav.lst 0.773 0.614 0.528 0.638333 0.606 9 11 8

annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_annav.lst 0.529 0.401 0.372 0.434 0.401 8 6 1

annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_annav.lst 0.441 0.327 0.314 0.360667 0.327 6 3 1

annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_annav.lst 0.292 0.206 0.224 0.240667 0.23 1 1 0

annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_annav.lst 0.252 0.185 0.199 0.212 0.2 0 0 0

annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis6_annav.lst 0.207 0.18 0.194 0.193667 0.195 0 0 0

20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_20best.lst 0.906 0.725 0.604 0.745 0.725 10 14 11

20best srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_20best.lst 0.618 0.471 0.431 0.506667 0.466 8 6 4

20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_20best.lst 0.514 0.384 0.35 0.416 0.382 8 6 1

20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_20best.lst 0.348 0.243 0.257 0.282667 0.268 2 2 0

20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_20best.lst 0.301 0.212 0.229 0.247333 0.232 1 1 0

20best srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_20best.lst 0.246 0.183 0.205 0.211333 0.212 0 0 0

annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_q_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_annav.lst 0.737 0.588 0.491 0.605333 0.587 9 9 7

annav srp_az_unit1-2_base_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_annav.lst 0.501 0.382 0.348 0.410333 0.378 8 6 1

annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl1_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_annav.lst 0.417 0.31 0.282 0.336333 0.308 5 3 0

annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl2_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_annav.lst 0.282 0.196 0.208 0.228667 0.216 0 0 0

annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl5_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_annav.lst 0.243 0.171 0.185 0.199667 0.187 0 0 0

annav srp_az_unit1-2_ctrl6_rs_pu_2001_calpost_bosq_vis8_annav.lst 0.198 0.148 0.166 0.170667 0.171 0 0 0
'01-'03 2001 2002 2003 '01-'03

sum n_ddv>1 n_ddv>1 n_ddv>1 sum

'01-'03 

#days>0.5

2001 

#days>1

2002 

#days>1

2003 

#days>1

'01-'03 

#days>1

44 7 6 1 14

22 2 2 0 4

16 1 1 0 2

4 0 0 0 0

3 0 0 0 0

1 0 0 0 0

28 5 3 1 9

15 1 0 0 1

10 0 0 0 0

2 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

35 7 5 1 13

18 2 1 0 3

15 1 0 0 1

4 0 0 0 0

2 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

25 5 2 0 7

15 0 0 0 0

8 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0