IDEM INDIANA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT

We Protect Hoosiers and Ollr Environment.

Milchell E. Daniels Jr. 100 North Senate Avenue

Governor Indianapolis, Indiana 46204

(317) 232-8603

Thomas W. Easlerly Toll Free (800) 451-6027

Commissioner www.idem.IN.gov

October 20, 2008

Ms. Lynn Buhl

Regional Administrator

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

Region 5

77 West Jackson Boulevard

Chicago, IL 60604-3950

Re: Technical Addendum for the

Request for Redesignation and Maintenance

Plan for Fine Particle Attainment in the

Southwestern Indiana Nonattainment Area

Dear Ms. Buhl:

The Indiana Department of Environmental Management (IDEM) has prepared this

technical addendum to the Request for Redesignation and Maintenance Plan for Fine Particle

Attainment in the Southwestern Indiana Nonattainment Area (Redesignation Request and

Maintenance Plan) to validate the original SIP quality Lake Michigan Air Directors Consortium

(LADCO) - Round 5 annual PM25 modeling results concerning the Clean Air Interstate Rule.

IDEM hereby requests the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) review this

document for approval. The final Request for Redesignation and Maintenance Plan was submitted

to U.S. EPA on April 3,2008. This technical addendum updates the modeling results and

provides the final public participation documents.

On July 11,2008, the U.S. Court of Appeals, for the District ofColumbia Circuit, vacated

the United State Environmental Protection Agency's (U.S. EPA's) Clean Air Interstate Rule

(CAIR) in its entirety. Based on the implications ofthe court's ruling, LADCO in cooperation

with IDEM has recently conducted SIP quality Round 5 annual PM25 modeling to determine the

air quality impacts associated with CAIR controls not being in place on electrical generating units

(EGUs) in the Midwest region. Modeling results show all sites in Dubois, Knox, Spencer and

Vanderburgh counties and nearby in Daviess County, Kentucky have future year modeled design

values in 2009, 2012 and 2018 below the National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for

annual fine particles (15.0 ~g/m3) without CAIR. Table 7.2 and Graph 7.1 (to be considered

updates to Table 7.2 and Graph 7.1 on Pages 33 and 35 ofthe Redesignation Request and

Maintenance Plan show the LADCO - Round 5 non-CAIR annual PM2.5 modeling results.

Recycled Paper*

An Equal Opportunity Employer Please Recycle 0
Ms. Lynn Buhl

Page 2

Updated Table 7.2

LADCO's Round 5 Non-CAIR Modeling Results

Monitor Design Value Base·case Base-case Base·case

Monitor ID Name County 2003-2007 without without without

CAIR- CAIR- CAIR2009 2012 2018

(uvms

) (~g/ms) (~g/m3) (~g/m')

18-163-0006 Civic Center Vanderburgh 14.7 12.5 12.3 11.9

18-163-0012 W. Mill Rd. Vanderburgh 14.8 12.4 12.2 11.8

18-163-0016 Univ.ofEvansville Vanderburgh 15.0 12.8 12.6 12.2

18-147-0009 Dale Soencer 14.3 11.8 11.6 11.3

18-037-2001 Jasoer Post Office Dubois 15.2 12.4 12.2 11.8

18-037-0004 Sports Complex Dubois 13.9 11.3 I 1.1 10.8

18-037-0005 Jasper Golf Course Dubois 14.0 11.5 11.3 10.9

18-083-0004 SW Purdue Ag. Knox 14.0 11.7 11.5 1I. 1

21-059-0005 Owensboro Daviess - KY 14.4 12.2 12.0 11.7

21-059-0014 Wesleyan College Daviess - KY 13.0 11.0 10.9 10.6

Updated Graph 7.1

Modeling Results for Southwest Indiana PM2.5 Monitors for 2009, 2012 and 2018

18

17

16

15 ... '" 14 ::l

13 ~~

12 -n

11

10

2005 2009 2012 2018

--Standard -.- Civic center ---.- W. Mill Rd. Univ. of Evansville

---.- Oak! -.- Jasper Post Office ---.- Sports Corrplex -.- Jasper Golf Course

---.- SW Purdue Ag. Ow ensboro, KY Wesleyan College. KY
Ms. Lynn Buhl

Page 3

These modeling results validate the Redesignation Request and Maintenance Plan because

the SIP quality modeling still shows that future national and local emission control strategies will

ensure that the Southwestern Indiana Area will attain the NAAQS for annual fine pmticles with an

increasing margin ofsafety over time.

Graphs 4.9, 4.10, 4.12 and Table 4.1 (to be considered updates to Graphs 4.9, 4.10, 4.12

and Table 4.1 on Pages 20, 21, 22, and 33 ofthe Redesignation Request and Maintenance Plan

have been revised to back out the 2010 and 2020 projected emissions reductions associated with

CAIR EGU control measures. The revised emissions projections are based on non-CAIR

modeling recently conducted by LADCO utilizing 2007 as the base year. EGU emissions

projections for the year 2020 are based on 2018 emissions estimates. Appendix I ofthe Request

for Redesignation Request and Maintenance Plan has also been revised to reflect these revisions to

the 20 I0 and 2020 projected emissions inventories. Although the revised Graphs 4.9, 4.10,4.12

and Table 4.1 show that regional NO, emissions will remain relatively constant and S02 emissions

will decline between 2005 (base year) and 20 I0 (interim year) and remain relatively constant

between 20 I0 and 2020 (maintenance year), LADCO - Round 5 non-CAIR annual PM25

modeling results show that the future mix ofsources and emissions rates will not cause a violation

ofthe NAAQS. This revised emissions data also reaffirms the adequacy of the transportation

conformity budget outlined in Table 5.2 of Section 5.0 on Page 26 ofthe Redesignation Request

and Maintenance Plan.

Updated Graph 4.9

Comparison of 2005 Estimated and 2010 and 2020 Projected NO, Emissions for the

Southwestern Indiana Area

NOx Trends- All Anthropogenic Sources

Southwestern Indiana Area

120,000

100,000

'"

c

0 80,000

,..

..!. 60,000 '"::I

C

c 40,000 <

20,000 . ._.._~..".

o --

2005 2010 2020
Ms. Lynn Buhl

Page 4

Updated Graph 4.10

Comparison of2005 Estimated and 2010 and 2020 Projected S02 Emissions for the

Southwestern Indiana Area

S02 Trends- All Anthropogenic Sources

Southwestern Indiana Area

400,000 ~----------------------~

350,000 -1--

jg 300,000

F: 250,000 ~--­

§ 200,000 +--- = 150,000 +---

100,000-1--

50,000 -1--

0-1---

2005 2010

l'"l 802 1

2020

Updated Graph 4.12

Comparison of 2005 Estimated and 2010 and 2020 Projected S02, NO" and Direct

PM2.5 Emission Trends for the Southwestern Indiana Area

Trends- All Anthropogenic Sources

Southwestern Indiana Area

400,000

350,000

300,000

250,000 o

f-

.. 200,000 ==

<= 150,000

100,000

50,000

o

2005 20 I0 2020

[0 802 • NOx 0 Direct PM2.51
Ms. Lynn Buhl

Page 5

Updated Table 4.1

Comparison of 2005 Estimated and 2020 Projected Emission Estimates Southwestern

Indiana Area (Annual-Tons)

2005 2020 Change % Change

NO, 100,740.05 101,806.78 1,066.73 1.06% increase

SO, 367,861.51 273,355.32 -94,506.19 25.69% decrease

Direct PM,., 4,566.87 4,688.54 121.67 2.66% increase

IDEM believes that this technical addendum in conjunction with the enclosed

Redesignation Request and Maintenance Plan demonstrates that the Southwestern Indiana Area

has complied with the applicable provisions ofthe 1990 Amendments to the Clean Air Act

regarding redesignation of nonattainment areas for fine particles. It should also be noted a

transcript ofthe public hearing and a summary of, and response to, substantive oral and written

comments has been added to Appendix N ofthe Redesignation Request and Maintenance Plan.

Therefore, IDEM hereby respectively requests that the U.S. EPA proceed with final review

and approval ofthis technical addendum to the Request for Redesignation and Maintenance Plan

for Fine Particle Attainment in the Southwestern Indiana Nonattainment Area. If you have any

questions or need additional information, please contact Mr. Scott Deloney, Chief, Air Programs

Branch, at (317) 233-5694 or sdeloney@idem.IN.gov or Ms. Christine Pedersen, Chief, Air

Planning Section, at (317) 233-5684 or cpedersen@idem.IN.gov.

cr:.Ho'P7I1VlY.~ Daniel Murra , Ass' t t Commissioner

Office of Air Quali

Indiana Departmen 0 nvironmental Management

DM/sad/ghf

Attachments: Request for Redesignation and Maintenance Plan for Fine Particle Attainment in

the Southwestern Indiana Nonattainment Area

LADCO Regional Air Quality Analyses for Ozone, PM25, and Regional Haze:

Final Technical Support Document (Supplement), September 12,2008

cc: Cheryl Newton, U.S. EPA Region 5 (no enclosures)

John Mooney, U.S. EPA Region 5 (no enclosures)

Pat Morris, U.S. EPA Region 5 (w/enclosures)

Scott Deloney, IDEM

Christine Pedersen, IDEM

Gale Ferris, IDEM
/

111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111I
Lake Michigan Air Directors Consortium

Regional Air Quality Analyses for Ozone,

PM2.

s, and Regional Haze: Final Technical

Support Document (Supplement), September

12,2008
j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j

j
Regional Air Quality Analyses for Ozone, PM2.5, and Regional Haze:

Final Technical Support Document (Supplement), September 12,2008

The purpose of this paper is to summarize a new modeling analysis performed by the Lake

Michigan Air Directors Consortium (LADCO) to address the effect of the recent court decision

vacating EPA's Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR). This new modeling is intended to supplement

the LADCO Technical Support Document ("Regional Air Quality Analyses for Ozone, PM2.5,

and Regional Haze: Final Technical Support Document", April 25, 2008), which summarizes the

air quality analyses conducted by LADCO and its contractors to support the development of

State Implementation Plans for ozone, PM2.5, and regional haze in the States of Illinois,

Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin.

Compared to the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1), the new modeling shows similar

results for ozone, but much more nonattainment for PM2.5 and higher visibility levels for

regional haze. Specifically, the new modeling shows:

Ozone: Attainment of the 0.08 ppm standard by 2009 everywhere in the region, except

Holland, MI, and nonattainment of the 0.075 ppm standard through at least 2018.

PM2.5: Widespread nonattainment of annual (15 ug/m') and daily (35 ug/m') standards.

Haze: Higher visibility levels on the 20% worst visibility days in 2018 in Class I areas in

the eastern U.S., resulting in most areas being above the glide path.

Background: On July 11, 2008, the U.S. Court of Appeals for D.C. Circuit vacated EPA's CAIR

rule (cite). The reductions in NOx and S02 emissions associated with this rule were a key part

of the LADCO States' attainment demonstrations for ozone and PM2.5 and the reasonable

progress determinations for regional haze. LADCO's previous modeling (Round 5.1) relied on

EGU emission projections from EPA's IPM3.0 analysis, which assumed implementation of

Phases I and II of CAIR. For this new modeling, alternative EGU emission projections were

developed, which did not rely on CAIR (or IPM).

Model Set·Up: The new modeling was performed consistent with LADCO's previous modeling

(Round 5.1):

Model Version: CAMx v4.50beta_deposition

Future Years: 2009, 2012, 2018

Runs: (a) Ozone: Summer 2005 meteorology with 12 km grids

(b) PM2.5 and haze: Full year 2005 meteorology with 36 km grids

Emission Scenarios: The new modeling assumed the same set of "on the books" controls as

in LADCO's previous modeling (Round 5.1) for all sectors, except EGUs. In light of the CAIR

decision, three new EGU scenarios were prepared:
Scenario A: 2007 CEM-based emissions were projected for all states in the modeling domain

based on EIA growth rates by state (NERC region) and fuel type. The assumed growth rates for

the Midwest States were: MAIN (IL, lA, MO, WI): 8.8% (2007-2018); ECAR (IN, KY, MI, OH):

13.5% (2007-2018); and MAPP (MN): 15.1% (2007-2018). No control was applied. The annual

emissions were temporalized based on profiles derived from 2004-2006 CEM data. (Note, these

are the same temporal profiles used in Round 5.1.)

Scenario B. Scenario A emissions for the LADCO States and select neighboring states (e.g.,

MN, lA, MO, KY, TN, and WII) were adjusted by applying legally enforceable controls (i.e.,

emission reductions required by a Consent Decree, state rule, or permit). Only those legally

enforceable controls identified (and justified) by the States were applied. The States also

supplied the appropriate control factors. A table summarizing the Scenario B controls is provided

in Appendix I.

Scenario C. For the years 2009 and 2012, Scenario A emissions for all states were adjusted by

applying all planned S02 and NOx controls based on the July 10 CAMD list (i.e., 90% reduction

for scrubbers, 95% reduction for SCRs). Because the July 10 CAMD list only includes controls

generally out to 2011, additional S02 and NOx controls for the year 2018 were assumed for all

BART-eligible EGUs in the five LADCO State plus MN, lA, MO, KY, TN, and MO list (i.e., 90%

reduction for scrubbers, 95% reduction for SCRS).' All Scenario B controls were included in

Scenario C. A table summarizing the Scenario C controis is proVided in Appendix II.

Table 1 and Figure 1 provide a summary of the 5-state regional NOx and S02 emissions for

each scenario and future year. (Note, the CAIR emissions included here are based on EPA's

IPM3.0 modeling.) Several comments on the emissions should be noted;

Summer NOx

• There is llittle difference between the three alternative scenarios and CAIR. This

suggests that summer ozone concentrations for the alternative scenarios are

likely to be similar to those predicted with CAIR (i.e., Round 5.1).

Annual NOx;

• There is a significant change in emissions between scenarios, mostly during the

non-summer months.

• Scenario B reflects application of NOx controls in several states (e.g., IL,OH,WI).

• Because there are relatively few SCRs (in the LADCO States) on the CAMD list,

Scenario C results in only a small emissions decrease compared to Scenario B.

• Assumed BART controls result in a significant emissions decrease.

Annual S02

• There is a significant change in emissions between scenarios.

• Scenario B reflects application of S02 controls in several states (e.g., IL,OH,WI).

• Because there are several FGDs (in the LADCO States) on the CAMD list,

Scenario C results in a large emissions decrease compared to Scenario B.

• Assumed BART controls result in a significant emissions decrease (i.e., even

lower emissions than the IPM-estimated CAIR emissions).

1 A subsequent analysis was conducted with the following inventory changes: (a) 95% reduction for

scrubbers, 90% redcuction for SCRs (consistent with EPA's default assumptions for IPM), and (b)

revisions provided for a few plants in Indiana and Minnesota. The changes resulted in a relatively small

difference in the regioinal NOx and S02 emissions (e.g., about a 2% NOx increase and about a 1-2%

decrease in S02). To assess the impact of the changes, PM2.5 modleing was conducted with the new

Scenario B and Scenario C emissions for 2012. The modeling showed little change in the predicted

PM2.5 concentrations.

2
3,000

2,500

2,000

1,500

1,000

500

o

Figure 1. Regional NOx and 502 Emissions

Summer NOx Emissions

r"'

- - I- I1- - - - l- I- - - 1- - - - lI- - l- I- - I- I- 1- - - l- I- I1,000,000

800,000

600,000

400,000

200,000

o

Annual NOx Emissions

r- - - - --- - - --- - -

rI- - I- - - - I- - I- I- I- - lI- l- I- l- I- l- I- I- - I- - - I3,000,000

2,500,000

2,000,000

1,500,000

1,000,000

500,000

o

Annual S02 Emissions

- 1- - --- - I-

- --- I- I- l- I- I- I- r- r-

- I- - - - I- - l- I- - - 1_'-1_

I- I- - - - I- - - - - - l- I3
Table 1. Regional NOx and S02 Emissions

Summer NOx Emissions (TPD)

2010 2012 2018 C- 2018

2005 2007 2009 A 2009 B 2009 C CAIR 2012 A 2012 B 2012 C CAIR 2018 A 2018 B 2018 C BART CAIR

IL 305 305 311 311 311 275 340 236 236 266 333 227 227 219 224

IN 393 393 376 376 374 384 393 393 390 368 410 386 383 292 264

MI 393 393 350 350 350 242 366 366 366 229 377 377 377 260 243

OH 408 408 395 355 335 285 423 351 351 290 431 366 366 230 290

WI 413 413 167 160 160 238 184 170 170 177 183 168 168 168 177

1,912 1,912 1,599 1,552 1,530 1,424 1,706 1,516 1,513 1,330 1,734 1,524 1,521 1,169 1,198

Annual NOx Emissions (TPY)

2010 2012 2018 C- 2018

2005 2007 2009 A 2009 B 2009C CAIR 2012 A 2012 B 2012 C CAIR 2018 A 2018 B 2018 C BART CAIR

IL 126,786 121,006 124,917 124,917 124,917 83,224 137,438 81,989 81,989 82,248 135,983 79,771 79,771 63,590 69,958

IN 214,727 203,493 203,776 203,776 201,947 133,188 212,790 212,790 210,877 125,541 221,950 212,805 210,810 177,027 90,415

MI 120,332 112,484 112,478 112,478 112,478 83,117 117,621 117,621 117,621 77,897 122,447 122,447 122,447 89,444 79,543

OH 255,554 240,351 240,016 173,071 164,911 94,346 251,065 172,514 172,514 97,679 261,644 179,737 179,737 125,762 95,678

WI 71,414 54,582 56,540 54,065 54,065 53,032 62,266 57,759 57,759 56,480 61,812 56,952 56,952 56,952 56,158

788,812 731,917 737,727 668,307 658,317 446,908 781,179 642,673 640,760 439,845 803,837 651,712 649,717 512,774 391,752

Annual S02 Emissions (TPY)

2010 2012 2018 C- 2018

2005 2007 2009 A 2009 B 2009 C CAIR 2012 A 2012 B 2012 C CAIR 2018 A 2018 B 2018 C BART CAIR

IL 326,598 273,467 281,028 281,028 281,028 295,516 309,209 196,238 194,746 267,110 305,364 106,638 105,152 82,351 275,716

IN 866,964 722,301 721,252 721,252 619,486 374,335 754,323 754,323 558,567 379,144 786,551 764,065 559,945 426,695 359,915

MI 350,694 343,487 343,140 343,140 315,326 227,296 358,879 358,879 301,062 233,204 373,964 373,964 313,677 178,680 242,853

OH 1,100,510 960,820 959,466 959,466 693,438 427,145 1,003,633 897,099 572,807 370,532 1,045,945 819,770 481,623 333,740 315,560

WI 181,426 137,562 142,007 142,007 133,738 139,181 156,659 144,818 133,592 139,203 155,818 144,027 132,849 77,214 127,073

2,826,192 2,437,638 2,446,892 2,446,892 2,043,017 1,463,473 2,582,703 2,351,356 1,760,775 1,389,192 2,667,641 2,208,463 1,593,245 1,098,679 1,321,116

4
Modeling Results: Several tables summarizing the modeling results are provided:

Table 2 - future year ozone and PM2.5 concentrations for key monitors in the

LADCO region

Table 3 - number of monitoring sites greater than the National Ambient Air Quality

Standards (NNAQS)

Table 4 - visibility levels for Class I areas in the eastern U.S.

Note, given that Scenario B and BART controls were only applied in an 11-state Midwest

region, the validity of the results for other Class I areas in the eastern U.S. may be

questionable. The Scenario C controls, on the other hand, cover all states and are, thus,

likely valid in other Class I areas.

Spatial plots of the future year ozone and PM2.5 concentrations are provided in Figures 2 - 4.

Based on these results, the following key findings should be noted:

Ozone

• There is little change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1 with CAIR)

• The modeling shows attainment of the 0.08 ppm (85 ppb) standard by 2009,

except Holland. (Note, Holland does meet this standard by 2012.)

• The modeling shows nonattainment of the 0.075 ppm (75 ppb) standard through

2018.

PM2.5 - Annual

• There is a significant change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1

with CAIR)

• The modeling shows extensive nonattainment of the annual standard.

PM2.5 - Daily

• There is a significant change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1

with CAIR)

• The modeling shows extensive nonattainment of the daily standard.

Haze

• There is a significant change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1

with CAIR)

• The modeling shows higher visibility levels in 2018 for the 20% worst visibility

days (average about 0.5 deciviews for the northern Class I areas). The resulting

visibility levels in the northern Class I areas (except Voyageurs) are above the

glide path.

5
Table 2a. Ozone Modeling Results

I 2005 2009 i 2012 2018

Round 5 ! i Round 5 Round 5

Round 5 without CAIR with CAIRI ! Round 5 without CAIR with CAIR Round 5 without CAIR with CAIR

Site Site 10 Base Year Seen. A ! Seen. 8 I Scen.C Seen. A Seen. B i Scen.C Seen. A Seen.S Scen.C Scen.C-BART

Lake Michiga'! A,:ea -~-,,- . .-~--

----

Chiwaukee 550590019 84.7 82.2 82.2 82.0 82,3 81.1 80.8 80.6 80.9 77.2 77.2 77.0 76.0 ! 76.2

Racine ! 551010017 80.3 ! 77.8 77.8 77.5 77.5 76.6 76.2 76.1 76.1 72.9 72.3 72.1 71.1 i 71.2

Milwaukee-Bayside i 550890085 82.7 ! 79.9 79.9 79.7 79.8 78.5 78.0 78.0 78.0 I 74.3 73.6 73.4 72.4 72.7

~~to~~~§l~__ i 550890009 83.3 80.1 I 80.1 79.9 _.~~:~___ .L~ l--- 78.6 78.1 78.0 78.3 _~_ 73.9 73.2 73.1 . ___72·'____1 72.5

t I ._~._--_."..- ._._-_..Manitowoc 550710007 85.0 80.8 80.8 80.7 80.8 i 79.0 78.5 78.4 78.6 73.9 73.2 73.1 72.0 72.5

Sheboygan ! 551170006 88.0 I 84.1 84.0 83.9 84.0 , 82.2 81.7 81.5 81.8 I 76.9 76.0 75.9 74.8 75.4

Kewaunee I

I 550610002 82.7 78.2 78.2 78.0 78.1 76.4 75.9 75.7 75.9 I 71.3 70.7 70.5 69.4 69.9

~~.0~~'-r___ I 550290004 -~~i .....j.~~ 84.1 84.1 83.9 83,9 82.0 ~~:..~~. 81.3 81.5 i 76.5 ~_i 75.5 74.2 74.7 ._.... ........_... ..•_._----- -74~6-r.. ..._---_.~-

Hammond I 180892008 76.2 76.2 76.0 75.4 75.6 75:3 75.2 73.2 72.7 " 72.6 71.7 71.6

Whiting 180890030 79.3 I 77.8 77.8 77.7 77.0 77.2 76.9 76.8 76.2 I 74.8 74.3 74.2 73.2 73.1

Michigan City I 180910005 77.0 74.5 74.5 1 74.3 73.9 73.3 72.9 72.8 72.5 69.7 69.2 69.1 68.1 68.1

22den Dunes I 181270020 78.3 ~-! 76.3 76.2 75.6 75.5 75.1 75.0 74.5 -I~ 72.9 72.3 72.1 71.2 70.8

I - -

'77.5 "'~r~" 7i3 Holland 260050003 90.0 85.7 I , 85.7 85.5 85.3 83.5 83.1 82.9 82.8 78.2 76.0 76.1

Jenison I 261390005 82.0 76.8 76.8 76.7 76.0 75.1 74.6 74.5 74.5 70.2 69.6 I 69.5 67.9 68.7

Muskegon I 261210039 85.0 80.6 80.6 80.5 80.5 78.6 78.2 78.1 78.0 I 73.5 72.8 72.8 71.5 71.9 I

i I

Indianapolis Area I I

I I I I

Noblesville 189571001 82.7 78.3 78.3 78.1 78.1 I 76.1 75.9 I 75.7 75.6 1 70.2 69.9 69.8 68.9 68.7

Fortville 180590003 78.0 74.1 74.1 73.9 73.9 I 71.9 71.8 71.7 71.4 I 66.7 66.5 66.3 65.4 65.1

Fort B. Harrison 180970050 78.7 75.4 75.3 75.2 75.1 ! 73.8 73.6 I 73.6 73.2 ! 70.6 ! 70.3 I 70.2 69.3 69.1

I I

I ! !

Detroit Area I I

New Haven 260990009 86.0 82.4 82.3 82.1 81.4 i 81.4 81.2 I 81.1 80.2 78.1 77.8 77.7 76.5 76.1

Warren 260991003 84.0 82.4 82.3 82.2 81,3 I 82.1 81.8 I 81.7 80.7 79.7 79.4 I 79.3 78.0 77.6

Port Huron 261470005 82.7 78.2 78.2 78.1 77.5 i 76.5 76.3 76.2 75.5 I 72.6 72.5 I 72.3 70.9 70.9

i I

Cleveland Area I I I !

Ashtabula 390071001 89.0 84.2 84.1 I 83.9 83.4 I 82.0 81.8 81.6 81,0 76.8 I 76.5 76.4 I 74.8 75.1

Geauga 390550004 79.3 75.8 75.8 75.6 74.7 I 74.0 73.8 73.7 72.7 69.5 ! 69.2 69.1 i 67.6 67.3

Eastlake 390850003 86.3 83.1 83.1 82.9 81.9 I 81.8 81.6 81.5 80.5 78.2 78.0 77.8 I

I 76.5 76.2

Akron 391530020 83.7 79.1 79.1 79.0 78.1 76.9 ! 76.7 76.6 75,6 70.9 70.6 70.4 ! 68.7 68.7

I I I !

Cincinnati Area I

1 i

Wilmington 390271002 82.3 77.3 , 77.4 77.1 I 77.5 75.3 ! 75.2 I 74.8 74.9 70.1 69.9 69.5 ! 67.1 68.3

Sycamore 390610006 84.7 81.5 81.4 81.1 I 81.9 80.4 80.2 79.8 80.3 76.4 76.0 I 75.7 i 73.5 74.6

Lebanon 391650007 87.7 82.8 I 82.8 82.4 83.0 80.8 80.7 I 80.3 80.7 75.4 75.1 74.8 I 72.6 74.2

I i ! I I I

Columbus Area I

I I ! I I

London 3909700071 79.7 I 75.0 75.0 74.8 II 75.0 73.0 72.8 72.7 72.6 68.1 67.8 67.6 ! 65.9 66.3

New Albany 3904900291 86.3 I 82.1 82.1 81.9 i 81.8 80.2 80.0 79.9 79.6 74.7 74.3 74.2 I 73.3 73.0

Franklin I 290490028i 80.3 I 76.7 76.6 76.5 75.9 75.1 74.9 74.8 ! 74.1 70.5 70.2 i 70.1 i 70.2 69.0

i 1 I

Sf. Louis Area I I

! I

W. Alton (MO) 2918310021 86.3 81.1 81.2 81.1 81,0 80.0 79.9 79.9 78.6 76.9 76.8 76.7 74.2 74.9

Orchard (MO) I 291831004 87.0 82.1 82.1 82.0 82.0 I 80.9 80.8 80.7 80.0 I 77.7 77.6 77.4 75.2 I 76.2

Sunset Hills (MO) 291890004 82.3 79.2 79.2 79.1 78.7 I 78.3 78.1 78.1 77.1 75.3 75.2 75.1 73.0 I 73.9

Arnold (MO) 290990012 82.3 77.8 77.8 77.7 77.2 I 76.7 76.6 76.5 75.6 73.6 I 73.4 73.4 71.3 72.0

Margaretta (MO) 295100086 83.0 79.8 79.8 79.7 I 79.3 78.8 I 78.7 78.6 77.9 75.7 I 75.6 75.5 73.7 74.4

~a""~ Heights {MO 291890014 87.3 85.4- 85.4 85.3 I 84.0 i 84.3 I 84.1 84.0 81.7 I 81.1 I 80.9 80.8 78.4 7~
-

Table 2b. PM2.

5 Modeling Results (Annual)

2005 I 2009 2012 2018

I Round 5

Round 5 without CAIR Iwith CAIR

Site

Illinois

Site 10 Base Year i Seen. A Seen. B I Scen.C

I

Round 5 without CAIR

Seen. A I Seen. 8 I Scen.C

I

Round 5

with CAIR Round 5 without CAIR

Seen. A I Seen. B I Scen.C I Scen.C-BART

Round 5

with CAIR

Chicago - Washington HS

Chicago Mayfair

Chicago - Springfield

Chicago - Lawndale

Blue Island

Summit

Cicero

Granite City

E. St. louis

170310022

1703100521

1703100571

1703100761

170312001

170313301

170316005

171191007

171630010

15.2

15.8

15.0

14.9

14.8

15.2 I

15.5

16.7

15.6

14.9

15.1

14.6

14.5

14.4

14.9

15.1

16.3

15.2

14.8 1 14.5

15.1 I 14.8

14.6 I 14.3

14.5 I 14.2

14.4 I 14.0

14.9 -1 14.6

15.1 I 14.8

16.2 I 15.9

15.2 I 14.8

14.1

14.4

13.9

13.8

13.7

14,2

14.4

15.1

14.1

14.8

15.1

14.6

14.5

14.4

14.9

15.1

15.1

15.0

14.7 i 14.2

14.9 I 14.5

14.4 I 14.0

14.3 1 13.9

14.2 I 13.8

14.7 i 14.3

14.9 1 14.5

16.0 T 15.3

14.9 I 14.3

14.0

14.2

13.8

13.7

13.6

14.0

14.3

14.9

13.9

15.0

15.1

14.8

14.7

14.5

15.0

15.2

15.9

14.9

14.6

14.7

14.4

14.3

14.1

14.6 I

14.9

15.6

14.6

14.2

14.3

14.0

13.9

13.7

14.3

14.4

14.9

14.0

13.7

13.7

13,4

13.3

13.2

13.7

13.9

14.2

13.3

13.9

13.9

13.7

13.6

13.4

13.9

14.2

14.3

13.4

Indiana

Jeffersonville

Jasper

Gary

Indy-Washington Park

Indy-W 18th Street

Indy- Michigan Street

180190005

180372001

180890031

180970078

180970081

180970083

16.4 I

15.2

15.6

15.3

16.0

15.9

15.8

14.3

13.9

14.4

15.1

15.0

15.7 !

14.2 I

13.9

14.4 I

15.1

15.0

14.8

13.4 I

13.5 I

13.6 I

14.3 I

14.2 I

13.8

12.4

13.0

12.8

13.4

15.8 I 15.6 I 14.5

14.2 I 14.0 i 13.0

13.8 I 13.6 I 13.1

14.3 1 14.2 T 13.2

15.0 I 14.9 I 13.9

14.9 1 14.8 I 13.8

13.7

12.2

12.8

12.6

13.1

16.0 I 15.5

14.3 I 13.9

13.7 I 13.4

14.3 I 13.9

15.0 I 14.6

14.9 I 14.5

14.3 !

12.8 !

12.9

12.9 i

13.5 [

13.5 I

13.7

12.1

12.3

12.2

12.8

12.8

13.4

11.8

12.4

12.0

12.6

Michigan

Allen Park

Southwest HS

Linwood

Dearborn

Wyandotte

261630001

261630015

261630016

261630033

261630036

14.5

15.9

14.6

17.5

14.7

I 11.0 14.0

15.3 I 15.3

14.1 14.1

17.0 i 17.0

14.2 i 14.1

I

13.5 i 13.0

14.8 ! 14.2

13.6 I 13.1

16.4 I 15.8

13.6 I 13.1

14.0

15.2

14.0

16.9

14.1

13.8

15.0

13.9

16.7

13.9

13.2

14.4

13.3

16.0

13.3 I

12.8

13.9

12.8

15.5

12.8

13.9 I 13.6

15.1 I 14.8

13.9 I 13.6

16.8 I 16.4

14.0 I 13.7

I

13.0 !

14.1 r

13.0

15.7 I

13.0

12.4

13.5

12.5

15.1

12.4

12.4

13.5

12.5

15.1

12.5

Ohio I I I I I I -r I I I I !

Middletown - Bonita 3901700031 16.2 15.3 15.2 I 14.3 I 13.5 15.2 I 15.0 I 13.9 ! 13.2 I 15.2 I 14.8 1 13.7 I 13.0 i 12.8

Fairtield 3901700161 15.8 I I 15.1 15.0 1 14.1 I 13.1 15.1 I 14.9 I 13.7 11"2.9-1 115.2 I 14.7 1~1---------12:8 ! 12.5

~::~::~~~~~.t~j~~:t -~ ~~~~~~~~;!-~~~t"~"l-~+---~-~~~-t-- ~::~ -F ~::~---r=~:~H·~~·+· ...m~ .~'"}~-~- --1----+1~~----r=--~~:r--r .~ ·~U:}~-I -f --- ~::~--[---~::~~-}i:~·-· + w-i~~~- -~ ~~:~._.- Cleveland-Broadway 139035(1045! 16.5 1 15.9 15.8 T--1S:2------j 14.4 15.6 I ~~5---r----1-4.8i 14.0 I I 15.5 I 15.1 i 14.4 1 13.6 i 13.5

Cleveland-GTCraig 1 3903500601 17.1 I 1---i-6j 16.4 I 15.8 1 15.0 16.3 i 16.1 I 15,4 i 14.6 I I 16.1 I 15.7 I 15.0 1 14.2 I 14.1

Newburg Hts ¥ Harvard Av1 3903500651 16.0 -F--------I~..!..~_!~:~.,,~ ..J..__J_~2__F14:0-----nl=J.:3!?~~~1.~ .....!?:Qn--l-m-J-i:.3~~T--i ~~.-1-.-~1 ....1.§_:L J 14.7 I 14.0 I.._.~._.~.~ ~~ Columbus~Fairgrounds , 3904900241 15.3 14.6 i 14.5 I 13.7 12.9 i ' 14.4 I 14.1 13.2 12.6: 14.2 r 13.8 I 12.8 12.2 I 12.0

Columbus-Ann Street I 3904900251 15.1 I I 14.4 14.3 I 13.5 I 12.7 14.21 13.9 I 13.1 I -12:"4 I I 14.1 I 13.6 I 12.6 12.0 I 11.9

Cjncinnati~Seymour I 390610014i 17.3 I I 16.6 i 16.5 I 15.5 1---- 14.5 16.5 ! 16.3 I 15.1 1 14.3 I I 16.6 -nrm-16j--i 14.9 1 14.2 r 13.8

~:~~:~~::: ;~:t~~~-.~-+ ~~~:~~~:~r- ~::: 'l-'""I~+i{-~ +--}~~~-- r~~:-~----F~+f6' ..J....w'"~ ..-n~~-~i---l---n~-~:-:----T~+}~~·····+·---}j-:-~--I-----1 ~::~ +·"tt~~i ..---+}H ~~:~ -~-'-l-~"H+-- Sharonville i 3906100431 15.6 I I 14.9 i 14.8 i 13.9 I 12.9 14-.-9-mn r 14.7 ) 13.5 I 12.7 I 114.9 I 14.5 i 13.3 I 12.6 I 12.3

Norwood I 3906170011 16.2 I 115.5 15,,4 114.4 r----1-i-4 15.4 I 15.2--r-------1-"4.01 13.2 I 115.5 I 15.1113.8 I 13.1 12.8

I~:~~~~~:~~e -1' ~~~:~~~~~I ~;:: -+._~.- ~::~ ~:~__ n_ t- ~~:; t-_·~·i.~" __n_~m .. --;-n:=~:-:~---I~+-t·~-~t~---H1=1~I~- ..~::~-·--+ --i~1-f ~::~--l- ..-...-...~.~~- ----I ~~:~--- Mingo Junction 1 3908110011 16.5 I i 15.2 15.2 1 14.3 I 13.5 ! 15.0 I 14.9 ! 13.8 I 13.2 1 i 15.6 1 15.2 I 14.0 I 13.6 13.4

Ironton 3908700101 15.2 I I 14.8 14.6 --T----1-i-i51 12.8 14.6 1 14.4 13.2 1 --Ti":5 1 I 14.8 1 14.1 I 12.8 I 12.4 12.3

Dayton 1 3911300321 15.5 I I 14.9 14.8 I 14.0 I 13.2 14.8 1 14.6 1 13.6 i 12.9 1 1 14.8 I 14.3 1 13.3 I 12.6 I 12.4

New Boston I 3914500131 14.7 1 I 12.0 14.0 1 13.0 1 12.1 14.1 I 13.8 1 12.5 I 11.9 r -I 14.2 I 13.6 1 12.2 1 11.7 I 11.6

Canton - Dueber I 3915100171 16.3 I I 15.7 ~6-Tn

----14.8 I 14.0 15.5 I 15.3 1 14.4 I 13.6 i 1 15.4 I 14.9 I 14.0 I 13.3 I 13.3

Canton-Market I 3915100201 14.6 I 11.0 14.1 I 13.3 I 12.6 13.9 ) 13.7 I 12.91 12.3 I I 13.9 I 13.5 I 12.6 I 12.0 I 11.9

Akron-Brittain I 3915300171 15.1 14.6 14.5 I 13.8 I 13.0 14.4 [ 14.2 1 13.4 I 12.7 I 1 14.3 I 13.8 I 13.0 I 12.3 I 12.3

Akron - W. Exchange I 3915300231 14.3 1 I 13.7 13.7 I 13.0 I 12.3 13.6 - -I 13.3 ) 12.6 I 12.0 i ) 13.4 1 13.0--r- 12.2 I 11.6 I 11.5
Table 2c. PM2.

5 Modeling Results (Daily)

i RoundS 1with CAIR

Scen.C Seen. C - BART I

Round 5 without CAIR

2018

Seen. A I Seen. B

Round 5

with CAIR

2012

Round Swithout CAIR

II

Scen.C

2009

I

. , Round 5 I

Round S wIthout CAIR :with CAIR I

Seen. AT Seen. B I I Seen. A I Seen. B I Scen.C

2005

Site ID Base Year

I

Key Site County j

Illinois

Chicago - Washington HS

Chicago.~r.,t]:3Yfair

Chicago - Springfield

Chicago - Lawndale

McCook

Blue Island

Schiller Park

Summit

Maywood

Granite City

E. St. Louis

Cook

Cook

ICook

Cook

ICook

Cook

Cook

Cook

Cook

Madison

St. Clair

170310022

170310052

170310057

170310076

170311016

170312001

170313103

170313301

170316005

i171191007

1171630010

36.6

40.3

37.4

38.1

43.0

37.7

41.6

40.2

39.2

39.2

33.7

36

37

34

35

39

35

40

38

38

36

31

36

37

34

35

39

35

40

38

38

36

31

36

37

33

35

39

35

40

39

38

35

30

36

36

32

35

39

34

39

38

38

33

28

36

37

35

36

40

36

40

39

38

3.

31

36

36

34

35

39

35

40

38

38

35

30

37

37

33

36

40

36

40

39

39

34

29

36

36

32

35

39

34

39

38

38

33

28

-+

-+

i

37

38

36

36

40

36

41

39

39

36

31

36

37

34

35

40

35

40

38

38

35

30

37

37

33

36

41

36

40

39

39

35

30

37

37

33

36

40

36

39

39

39

33

29

=t

35

36

31

34

38

33

39

37

37

32

28

Indiana

Jeffersonville

Jasper

Gary -IITRI

Gary - Burr School

Gary

Indy-West Street

Indy·English Avenue

Indy-Washington Park

Indy·W 18th Street

Indy· Michigan Street

Clark

Dubois

Lake

Lake

Lake

Marion

IMarion

Marion

Marion

Marion

180190005

180372001

180890022

180890026

180890031

180970043

180970066

180970078

180970081

180970083

38.4

36.2

39.0

39.0

35.2

38.0

38.0

36.6

38.3

36.0

-t 35

32

35

34

29

34

34

33

33

32

33

32

35

34

28

34

34

33

33

32

31

30

35

34

26

33

32

32

31 ......,.

29

29

28

34

33

24

33

32

31

31

28

I

35

32

35

34

28

35

35

33

33

32

34

32

34

34

28

35

34

33 ,

33 -,

311

32

30

35

35

24 i

34 1

33

32

32

29

31

29

34

34

241

33 I

32

31

31

28

37

33

36

34

29

36

35

34

34

32

35

31

36

34

28

35

34

33

33

31

34

31

36

34

27

34

33

32

32 !

29i

33

30

35

34

27

34

33

32

32

29

31

28

35

32

27

33

32

32

31

29

Michigan

luna Pier 34 32 34 33 32 j 31 31

Oak Park 37 I 37 38 37 37 36 35

Port Huron 35 I 35 35 I 35 34 I 33 33

:~:~a;~irk .~".~!::~~~en~1ii~~~~~~~ -+---1·~:·~···"··-I----t--- ~~ r- ..j~..-·-I~ ~: r~{-~fr-~~~:---------F ..~~ ··~+--1~F~ -.-.+----!-~~ ~t=.~~ -.)---i~+- ...{%.- -----1- - ~~ _.. Southwest HS IWayne 1261630015 I 40.1 I I 3£ I 36 I 36 35 I I 36 I 35 35 35 I I 36 I 35 35 34 I 33

Linwood IWayne 1261630016 I 43.0 I 40 I 40 40 39 I T 40 I 40 I 40 39 I I 40 I 39 39 39 I 38

I~:a~i~~~-_----"~~+~:~~: i~~·~{~~~~--~l :~:%~·~-Ff-~~--f~-~~-~·~F-~~~--------: ·_·~5 m-uTi ~~ I·'-~-* ---1- ~~--+" ... :~ ---~..u~-t---~~ L_%6· ·"~··I ~~ +~m_}i----- Wyandotte Wayne 1261630036 36 - -36 35 I I 35 35 35 34

Newberry Wayne 1261630038 39 I 39 38 I 39 39 38 36

~_._ _.!wayne j261630Q3,- __!_""7__ ++ 351:'4+_34 !_----"- __.__ 1+--'5+ 34_F:'3~_+33__++35_P::'i··3~+ __":ii_+__3_'__ Ohio i i

Middleton ISutier 1390170003 39.3 i i 33 I 32 I 29 28 I I 33 I 33 1 ~-T 28 I I 34 1 32 29 I 28 I 27

IFairfiel~m .. ~_,l~~~::~ 1~~~~i6§+~· :~:: -,·~t··- -)-- ~~ =-~."-~~~+--~._~---.-- +-f ~; -i.m,·-··~j-1=------~~· ·~··'l~· -~~ --=r=F~ ~j.--=F~~---~~Lm~~~~%~~·~l-- ~~- Cleveland-28th Street Cuyahoga 1390350027 36.9 i 34 I 34 i 33 33 32 33 I 31 31

Cleveland-St. Tikhon ICuyahoga 1390350038 44.2 i 40 i 40 i 37 36 i 35 36 I 35 I 34

Cleveland-Broadway Cuyahoga T390350045 35 i 35 ! 33 31 35 34 32 I 30 34 31 29! 29

Cleveland-GT Craig ICuyahoga 1390350060 39 I 39 I 38 37 I 39 I 38 38 37 I 38 37 36 I 35

Newburg Hts - Harvard!yye ICuyahoga I390350065 -,---38.9 I 35 1 35 I 33 31 I I 35 I 34 1- 32 I 30 -T -I 36 ~---35----i 32 I 31 I 30

Columbus - Fairgrounds I 34 : 34 I 33 33 34 I 33 32 34 31

Columbus - Ann Street 34 I 33 I 31 31 I I 33 I 33 31 ! I 34 30

ICinci F ' IHamilton 1390610006 I 40.6 I I 33 r 33 I 30 27 i I 33 1 32 I 29 I 28 -I---r 34 TY- 29 I ?8 i 27
Table 2c. PM2.

5 Mvdeling Results (Daily)

I 2005 2009 2012 2018

I Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 Round 5 without CAIR Round 5

with CAIR I with CAIR with CAIR

Key Site County Site ID I Base Year Seen. A ISeen.SI Scen.C I Seen. A Seen.S Scen.C Seen. A I Seen. B Scen.C Seen. C - BART

Cincinnati Seymour Hamilton 390610014 I 38.4 33 I 33 i 28 26 I 33 I 32 27 25 i I 33 I

, 31 29 25 I 24

Cincinnati - Taft Ave Hamilton 390610040 I 36.7 31 I 30 i 26 24 I 31 30 26 24 32 I 29 26 24 I 23

Cincinnati 8th Ave Hamilton 390610042 37.3 32 i 32 I 30 28 32 31 29 I 28 33 I 31 29 28 i 27

Sharonville Hamilton 390610043 36.0 I 32 i 31 I 30 28 32 31 29 I 28 32 i 31 29 28 27

Norwood Hamilton 390617001 38.8 I

I 34 ! 33 I 32 30 33 33 31 ! 30 34 j 33 31 30 I 29

51. Bernard IHamilton 390618001 40.6 I 35 ! 35 i 32 30 35 34 31 I 30 35 i 33 32 31 , 29

Steubenville Jefferson 390810016 40.7 I 36 ! 35 I 32 29 35 34 30 I 28 37 i 35 31 29 28

Mingo Junction Jefferson 390811001 42.0 37 I 37 I 33 30 37 36 32 30 I , 38 I 36 32 30 30

Dayton Montgomel"\ 391130032 37.8 34 I 33 I 31 30 33 33 31 I 30 I 34 i 33 31 31 30

Canton - Dueber Stark 391510017 38.6 33 I 32 30 28 33 31 30 ,

I 28 I 33 ! 30 29 28 i 27

Akron - Brittain Summit 391530017 38.1 33 33 31 30 i 33 32 31 I 30 33 32 30 29 I 29

i I i

Wisconsin I I

, I I I

Green Bay - Est High Brown 550090005 37.1 35 I 34 i 35 35 I 34 35 35 I 34 33 I 33 33 32 32

Madison Dane 550250047 36.4 33 I 33 i 32 32 33 32 32 I 31 32 ! 31 30 29 29

Milwaukee-Health Center Milwaukee 550790010 38.7 35 35 i 35 35 35 35 35 i 34 35 , 34 34 34 33

Milwaukee-SER Hdqs Milwaukee 550790026 37.4 34 34 i 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 I 34 34 34 33

Milwaukee-Virginia FS Milwaukee 550790043 ! 39.9 37 37 I 37 36 37 38 37 38 36 38 37 36 36

Milwaukee- Fire Dept Hdqs Milwaukee 550790099 i 37.8 34 34 I

I 33 33 34 33 33 32 34 33 33 33 32

Waukesha Waukesha 551330027 i 35.5 32 32 I 32 31 32 32 32 31 32 31 31 30 29
Table 3. Modeling Results: Number of Sites> NAAQS

Ozone (85 ppb) Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 wi CAIR

2009 Basevear Seen. A Seen.B Seen.C Seen. C-BART

IL 0 0 0 0 ---- 0

IN 0 0 0 0 ---- 0

MI 3 1 1 1 ---- 1

OH 4 0 0 0 ---- 0

WI 2 0 0 0 ---- 0

Total 9 1 1 1 1

2012

IL 0 0 0 0 ---- 0

IN 0 0 0 0 ---- 0

MI 3 0 0 0 ---- 0

OH 4 0 0 0 ---- 0

WI 2 0 0 0 ---- 0

Total 9 0 0 0 0

2018

IL 0 0 0 0 0 0

IN 0 0 0 0 0 0

MI 3 0 0 0 0 0

OH 4 0 0 0 0 0

WI 2 0 0 0 0 0

Total 9 0 0 0 0 0

Ozone (75 ppb) Round 5 without CAIR RoundS wi CAIR

2009 Baseyear Seen. A Seen. B Seen.C Seen. C-BART

IL 12 6 6 6 ---- 4

IN 26 10 9 8 ---- 5

MI 21 12 12 12 ---- 12

OH 45 27 25 24 ---- 21

WI 12 10 10 10 ---- 10

Total 116 65 62 60 ---- 52

2012

IL 12 3 3 3 ---- 1

IN 26 5 4 4 ---- 3

MI 21 9 8 8 ---- 6

OH 45 18 14 12 ---- 11

WI 12 10 9 9 ---- 9

Total 116 45 38 36 30

2018

IL 12 0 0 0 0 0

IN 26 0 0 0 0 0

MI 21 3 3 3 3 3

OH 45 3 3 2 1 1

WI 12 3 2 1 1 1

Total 116 9 8 6 5 5

10
PM2.5 - Annual Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 wi CAIR

2009 Basevear Seen. A Scen.B Scen.C Seen. C-BART

IL 7 4 4 1 ~~~- 1

IN 6 2 2 0 ---- 0

MI 2 2 2 1 ---- 1

OH 26 13 12 5 ---- 1

WI 0 0 0 0 ---- 0

Total 41 21 20 7 3

2012

IL 7 3 1 1 ---- 0

IN 6 1 1 0 ---- 0

MI 2 2 1 1 ---- 1

OH 26 12 9 4 ---- 0

WI 0 0 0 0 ---- 0

Total 41 18 12 6 1

2018

IL 7 3 1 0 0 0

IN 6 1 1 0 0 0

MI 2 2 1 1 1 1

OH 26 13 8 2 0 0

WI 0 0 0 0 0 0

Total 41 19 11 3 1 1

PM2.5 - Dailv

Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 wi CAIR

2009 Baseyear Seen. A Scen.B Scen.C Seen. C-BART

IL 16 7 7 6 ---- 6

IN 13 0 0 0 ---- 0

MI 14 10 9 9 ---- 5

OH 31 4 3 2 ---- 2

WI 8 1 1 1 ---- 1

Total 82 22 20 18 ---- 14

2012

IL 16 9 6 8 ---- 6

IN 13 0 0 0 ---- 0

MI 14 8 6 6 ---- 5

OH 31 3 3 2 ---- 1

WI 8 1 1 1 ---- 1

Total 82 21 16 17 13

2018

IL 16 10 6 8 8 5

IN 13 4 1 1 0 0

MI 14 8 6 6 5 4

OH 31 5 3 2 1 0

WI 8 1 1 1 1 1

Total 82 28 17 18 15 10

11
Table 4. Modeling Results: Future Year Visibility Levels

Worst 20% 2018

Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 wI CAIR

Baseline Scen. CSite 12000-2004) 2018 URP Scen. A Scen.B Scen.C BART

BOWA1 19.86 17.94 19.09 18.87 18.54 18.02 17.94

VOYA2 19.48 17.75 18.60 18.44 18.17 17.77 17.63

SENEl 24.38 21.64 24.02 23.58 23.03 22.38 22.59

ISLEl 21.59 19.43 21.05 20.86 20.62 20.22 20.09

ISLE9 21.59 19.43 20.83 20.58 20.38 19.84 19.84

HEGL1 26.75 23.13 26.24 25.83 24.87 24.23 24.22

MINGl 28.15 24.27 27.51 26.98 25.81 24.93 24.74

CACRl 26.36 22.91 25.32 24.80 23.57 22.97 22.44

UPBUl 26.27 22.82 25.31 24.79 23.50 22.79 22.59

MACA1 31.37 26.64 30.11 29.08 27.06 26.24 26.10

DOS01 29.05 24.69 27.88 26.96 24.36 23.74 23.00

SHEN1 29.31 25.12 28.38 27.65 25.24 24.69 23.92

JARI1 29.12 24.91 28.06 27.21 25.00 24.48 24.06

BRIGl 29.01 25.05 28.10 28.07 26.57 26.25 25.21

LYBR1 24.45 21.48 24.06 23.86 22.58 22.30 21.14

ACAD1 22.89 20.45 22.88 22.76 22.31 22.16 21.49

Best 20% 2018

Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 wi CAIR

Baseline Scen. CSite (2000·2004) 2018 Max Seen. A Scen.B Scen.C BART

BOWA1 6.42 6.42 6.20 6.17 6.16 6.12 6.14

VOYA2 7.09 7.09 6.87 6.83 6.81 6.78 6.75

SENEl 7.14 7.14 7.80 7.78 7.81 7.77 7.71

ISLEl 6.75 6.75 6.77 6.76 6.72 6.67 6.60

ISLE9 6.75 6.75 6.63 6.61 6.58 6.53 6.52

HEGL1 12.84 12.84 12.17 12.20 12.07 11.63 11.66

MINGl 14.46 14.46 13.78 13.77 13.70 13.37 13.28

CACRl 11.24 11.24 10.94 10.99 10.97 10.78 10.52

UPBUl 11.71 11.71 11.18 11.23 11.18 10.96 10.73

MACA1 16.51 16.51 16.32 16.21 15.76 15.34 15.25

DOS01 12.28 12.28 12.02 11.84 11.27 11.03 11.00

SHEN1 10.93 10.93 10.98 10.91 10.25 10.16 9.91

JARll 14.21 14.21 14.19 13.98 13.42 13.21 13.14

BRIG1 14.33 14.33 14.32 14.46 14.22 14.17 13.92

LYBR1 6.37 6.37 6.39 6.38 6.31 6.28 6.14

ACAD1 8.78 8.78 8.97 8.96 8.90 8.89 8.82

12
;:0 ;:0 i;:o 0 0 00 " e: ~c: :::l :::l l:::l a. a. sa.

'" '" =: ~'"

I

0

0 'sO

»

»

i ;Q ;Q !;:o

I\) I\) I\) 0 0 00 CXl '" U>

;:0 i;:o i;:o 0 eO gO e: .. " Ie: ::I ~::I s:::l a. lia. .a.

'" ~'" .'" I ,~ I 's I

CIl 'CIl jCll 0 i 0 .0 l\l ! l\l • l\l ? ? ? » » »

;:0 ;:0 i;:o

e: 0

0 eO e: .. e:

::I ::I ~::I a. a. ia. '" '" ::. U'l

"

I

I .;I _.

CIl CIl 'CIllO 0 0 I 0 l: l\l l\l c; ? ? 'I\)

[I] [I] [1]'0N0

::I

l\l

w

0

a.

l\l

;:0 ;:0

i 5- s::tJ(Q

0

0 ··0

"

::I

"

::I I"::I ;;0l\l a. a. • a. l/l

'" '" U'l I: I I ': I ;:::;

CIl CIl iClll/l n 0 ! n l\l l\l l\l ? ? ? 0 0 0
Round 5 - CAIR

Round 5 - CAIR

Round 5 - Seen. C Round 5 - CAIR

Round 5 - Seen. C

14

Figure 3. PM2.5 Annual Modeling Results

Round 5 - Seen. B Round 5 - Seen. C

? j';;

Round 5 - Seen. B

Round 5 - Seen. B

Round 5 - Seen. A

Round 5 - Seen. A

Round 5 - Seen. A

2009:ll.u 10

'9n

I7n

16.0

15.0

14.0

13.0

11.0

9.0

3.0

nn 'H

2012ll.U 10

'9n

I7n

16n

ISn

14n

13n

lin

9.0

3.0

nn ~7

2018ll.U 10

19.0

17.0

16.0

15.0

14.0

13.0

11.0

9.0

3.0

nn ';17
•

'.

Figure 4. PM2.5 Daily Modeling Results

2009 Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C CAIR ~.O 70 I /" L7 II? Ii? li-'

so.o

<IS.o

40.0

35.0

30.0

25.0

20.0

15.0

:: 3711" =V" - ---L:ijU• =V' - J-i:jII" -\{-:- ---L:ijU" \! J.r1

•

•

0.0 37L1". V '~U" V' ~U" \! ~U' \!

10.0

so.o

45.0

40.0

35.0

30.0

25.0

20.0

15.0

10.0

30~

25~

35~

2O~

15~

0.0 37L1" \[' - .-L-:i:111" =V' - ---L:ijLl" -\!- .-L-:i:111" \! ---!:r1

2018 Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C CAIR

"'~

so.o

45.0

40~

2012 Scenario A Scenario B Scenario C CAIR ~.U lUi....... Ii 7 II? II/'_ i

15
Appendix I

Scenario B (Legally Enforceable) Controls

16
NOx-2009

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for NOX r6s1b_2009

Base Year = 2002

Future Year =2009

STID=17 CYID=57 fcid=057801AM name=AES DUCK CREEK

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrltype etrldes

17 57 057801AM 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 0.8147 0.8416 0.8416 0.00 0.00 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=143 feid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 3.0515 3.1522 3.1522 0.00 0.00 Inb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.9419 7.1708 7.1708 0.00 0.00 Inb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 NOX 2.1310 2.2013 2.2013 0.00 0.00 Inb LNB added by LADCO

--- -- --

fcid 12.1244 12.5243 12.5243

eyid 12.1244 12.5243 12.5243

stid 12.9392 13.3659 13.3659

STID=39 CYID=1 feid=0701000007 name="DP&L, J.M. STUART GENERATING STATION"

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day TonslDay Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrltype ctrldes

39 1 0701000007 R1 B001 B001P1 10100202 NOX 6.9860 6.9756 2.3252 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R2 B002 B002P1 10100202 NOX 3.6327 3.6273 1.2091 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R3 B003 B003P1 10100202 NOX 5.0133 5.0058 1.6686 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R4 B004 B004P1 10100202 NOX 7.8493 7.8376 2.6125 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO --- --

feid 23.4814 23.4464 7.8155

eyid 23.4814 23.4464 7.8155

STID=39 CYID=167 feid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day TonslDay Control EF Control EF ctrltype etrldes

39 167 0684000000 R1 B001 B001P1 10200501 NOX 0.0017 0.0017 0.0001 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 NOX 5.8167 5.8080 0.2904 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 NOX 7.9017 7.8899 0.3945 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17
39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 NOX 7.8775 7.8657 0.3933 0.00 095 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 NOX 3.8586 3.8528 0.1926 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

-- -- fcid 25.4561 25.4182 1.2709

cyid 25.4561 25.4182 1.2709

stid 48.9375 48.8646 9.0864

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007800 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER VALLEY STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007800 S11 B21 01 10100202 NOX 2.7972 2.8895 1.6470 0.00 0.43 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S11 B22 01 10100202 NOX 2.9073 3.0032 1.7118 0.00 0.43 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B23 01 10100202 NOX 2.3270 2.4038 1.2740 0.00 0.47 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B24 01 10100202 NOX 2.3427 2.4199 1.2826 0.00 0.47 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -- ---

fcid 10.3742 10.7164 5.9154

cyid 10.3742 10.7164 5.9154

STID=55 CYID=117 fcid=460033090 name=WP & LAlliant Energy - Edgewater Gen Station

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 117 460033090 S11 B23 01 10100203 NOX 1.6197 1.6731 1.0038 0.00

55 117 460033090 S11 B24 01 10100203 NOX 4.1072 4.2426 3.4789 0.00

55 117 460033090 S12 B25 01 10100221 NOX 5.6804 5.8677 4.9876 0.00

-- ---- fcid 11.4072 11.7834 9.4703

cyid 11.4072 11.7834 9.4703

stid 21.7814 22.4997 15.3857

======== ======== ==========

83.6581 84.7302 37.8380

0.40 SCR SCR added by LADCO

0.18 SCR SCR added by LADCO

0.15 SCR SCR added by LADCO

18
NOx·2012

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for NOX r6s1 b_2012

Base Year = 2002

Future Year =2012

STID=17 CYID=33 fcid=033801AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrttype etrtdes

17 33 033801AAA 0005 0005 01

17 33 033801AAA 0006 0006 01

feid

eyid

10100202 NOX 1.642 1.871 0.9357 0.00

10100202 NOX 2.116 2.413 1.2063 0.00

3.758 4.284 2.1420

3.758 4.284 2.1420

0.500 SCR

0.500 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=57 feid=057801AAA name=AES DUCK CREEK

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrttype etrtdes

17 57 057801AAA 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 0.815 0.929 0.9288 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=79 feid=079808AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID feid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrttype etrtdes

17 79 079808AAA 0003 0003 01

17 79 079808AAA 0012 0013 01

fcid

eyid

10100202 NOX 6.735 7.678 7.6780 0.00

10100501 NOX 5.936 5.378 5.3781 0.00

12.671 13.056 13.0561

12.671 13.056 13.0561

0.000 SCR

0.000 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=97 feid=097190MC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrttype etrtdes

17 97 097190MC 0016 0031 02 10100401 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=137 feid=137805AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID feid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day TonslDay Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrttype etrtdes

17 137 137805AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 NOX 5.356 6.106 6.1058 0.00

19

0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO
STID=17 CYID=143 feid=143805MG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrltype etrldes

17 143 143805MG 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 3.052 3.479 3.4789 0.00

17 143 143805MG 0001 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.942 7.914 7.9141 0.00

17 143 143805MG 0002 0004 01 10100202 NOX 2.131 2.429 2.4294 0.00

-- -- ---

fcid 12.124 13.822 13.8224

eyid 12.124 13.822 13.8224

0.000 Inb

0.000 Inb

0.000 Inb

LNB added by LADCO

LNB added by LADCO

LNB added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=167 feid=167120MO name=CITY WATER LIGHT &POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrltype etrldes

17 167 167120MO 0010 0012 01

17 167 167120MO 0010 0013 01

fcid

eyid

10100203 NOX 6.527 7.441 0.0074 0.00

10100203 NOX 2.646 3.017 0.0030 0.00

9.173 10.458 0.0105

9.173 10.458 0.0105

0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=179 feid=179801AM name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype etrldes

17 179 179801AM 0018 0029 01

17 179 179801AM 0018 0031 01

fcid

eyid

10100203 NOX 22.429 25.570 1.2785 0.00

10100203 NOX 38.993 44.454 2.2227 0.00

61.422 70.024 3.5012

61.422 70.024 3.5012

0.950 SCR

0.950 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197809MO name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrltype etrldes

17 197 197809MO 0032 0033 02 10100604 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=197 feid=197810MK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrltype etrldes

17 197 197810MK 0011 0016 02

17 197 197810MK 0011 0016 03

17 197 197810MK 0013 0010 02

10100222 NOX

10100501 NOX

10100223 NOX

5.731 6.534 3.9203

0.000 0.000 0.0000

8.598 9.802 0.0098

20

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO
17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 NOX 10.974 12.511 0.0125 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

---- -- -- fcid 25.303 28.847 3.9426

cyid 25.303 28.847 3.9426

stid 130.622 147.527 43.5096

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=27061 00004 name=Minnesota Power Inc - Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctntype ctndes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 NOX 13.661 14.142 2.8284 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 002 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

fcid

cyid

13.661 14.142 2.8284

13.661 14.142 2.8284

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=271 0900011 name=Rochester Public Utilities - Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctndes

27 109 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 NOX 2.079 2.152 1.2911 0.00 0.400 SNCR SCR added by LADCO

stid 15.739 16.294 4.1195

STID=39 CYID=1 fcid=0701000007 name="DP&L, J.M. STUART GENERATING STATION"

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF

39 1 0701000007 R1 B001 B001P1 10100202 NOX 6.986 7.296 2.4319 0.85

39 1 0701000007 R2 B002 B002P1 10100202 NOX 3.633 3.794 1.2646 0.85

39 1 0701000007 R3 B003 B003P1 10100202 NOX 5.013 5.235 1.7452 0.85

39 1 0701000007 R4 B004 B004P1 10100202 NOX 7.849 8.197 2.7324 0.85

-- -- fcid 23.481 24.522 8.1740

cyid 23.481 24.522 8.1740

Control EF ctntype ctndes

0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctntype ctndes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 NOX 20.852 21.776 1.0888 0.00

21

0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO
STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 167 0684000000 R1 B001 B001P1 10200501 NOX 0.002 0.002 0.0001 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 NOX 5.817 6.074 0.3037 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 NOX 7.902 8.252 0.4126 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 NOX 7.877 8.227 0.4113 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 NOX 3.859 4.030 0.2015 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

-- -- fcid 25.456 26.584 1.3292

cyid 25.456 26.584 1.3292

stid 69.789 72.882 10.5920

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid TonslDay Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 NOX 4.755 5.421 3.0898 0.00 0.430 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 NOX 3.277 3.736 2.2045 0.00 0.410 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 NOX 3.333 3.800 2.8499 0.00 0.250 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 NOX 3.384 3.857 2.9316 0.00 0.240 SCR SCR added by LADCO

-- --- ---

fcid 14.749 16.814 11.0757

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007800 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER VALLEY STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007800 S11 B21 01 10100202 NOX 2.797 3.189 1.8177 0.00

55 79 241007800 S11 B22 01 10100202 NOX 2.907 3.314 1.8893 0.00

55 79 241007800 S12 B23 01 10100202 NOX 2.327 2.653 1.4061 0.00

55 79 241007800 S12 B24 01 10100202 NOX 2.343 2.671 1.4155 0.00

--- -- -- fcid 10.374 11.827 6.5285

cyid 25.123 28.641 17.6042

22

0.430 SCR

0.430 SCR

0.470 SCR

0.470 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

Scrubber added by LADCO
STID=55 CYID=117 fcid=460033090 name=WP & LAlliant Energy - Edgewater Gen Station

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid see polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrltype etrldes

55 117 460033090 S11 B23 01 10100203 NOX 1.620 1.846 1.1079 0.00

55 117 460033090 S11 B24 01 10100203 NOX 4.107 4.682 3.8395 0.00

55 117 460033090 S12 B25 01 10100221 NOX 5.680 6.476 5.5045 0.00

-- ---- feid 11.407 13.005 10.4519

eyid 11.407 13.005 10.4519

stid 36.530 41.646 28.0562

======== ======== ==========

252.681 278.349 86.2773

23

0.400 SCR

0.180 SCR

0.150 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO
NOx 2018

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for NOX r6s1b_2018

Base Year =2002

Future Year = 2018

STIO=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AIN name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrides

17 31 031600AIN 0010 0013 01 10100226 NOX 2.283 2.592 1.5550 0.00

17 31 031600AIN 0010 0013 02 10100601 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00

17 31 031600AIN 0012 0016 01 10100226 NOX 3.991 4.531 2.7184 0.00

17 31 031600AIN 0012 0016 02 10100601 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00

---- -- --- fcid 6.274 7.122 4.2734

cyid 6.274 7.122 4.2734

0.400 SCR

0.400 SCR

0.400 SCR

0.400 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=33 fcid=033801AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrldes

17 33 033801AAA 0005 0005 01

17 33 033801AAA 0006 0006 01

fcid

cyid

10100202 NOX 1.642 1.863 0.9317 0.00

10100202 NOX 2.116 2.402 1.2012 0.00

3.758 4.266 2.1329

3.758 4.266 2.1329

0.500 SCR

0.500 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=57 fcid=057801AAA name=AES DUCK CREEK

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrldes

17 57 057801AAA 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 0.815 0.925 0.9249 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=79 fcid=079808AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid TonslDay Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

17 79 079808AAA 0003 0003 01

17 79 079808AAA 0012 0013 01

fcid

cyid

10100202 NOX 6.735 7.645 7.6453 0.00

10100501 NOX 5.936 3.984 3.9838 0.00

12.671 11.629 11.6291

12.671 11.629 11.6291

24

0.000 SCR

0.000 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO
STID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID teid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctdtype ctddes

17 97 097190AAC 0016 0031 02 10100401 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=137 feid=137805AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID teid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctdtype ctddes

17 137 137805AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 NOX 5.356 6.080 6.0798 0.00 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID teid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctdtype ctddes

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 3.052 3.464 3.4641 0.00

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.942 7.880 7.8804 0.00

17 143 143805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 NOX 2.131 2.419 2.4191 0.00

-- -- ------

teid 12.124 13.764 13.7636

cyid 12.124 13.764 13.7636

0.000 Inb

. 0.000 Inb

0.000 Inb

LNB added by LADCO

LNB added by LADCO

LNB added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=167 teid=167120AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID teid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctdtype ctddes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01

fcid

cyid

10100203 NOX 6.527 7.410 0.0074 0.00

10100203 NOX 2.646 3.004 0.0030 0.00

9.173 10.414 0.0104

9.173 10.414 0.0104

0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID teid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctdtype etddes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0031 01

teid

cyid

10100203 NOX 22.429 25.462 1.2731 0.00

10100203 NOX 38.993 44.265 2.2132 0.00

61.422 69.726 3.4863

61.422 69.726 3.4863

25

0.950 SCR

0.950 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO
STID=17 CYID=197 feid=197809AAO name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid see polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etritype etrides

17 197 197809AAO 0032 0033 02 10100604 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=197 feid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID feid stkid dvid prid see polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrltype etrides

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 02 10100222 NOX 5.731 6.506 3.9036 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 02 10100223 NOX 8.598 9.760 0.0098 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 NOX 10.974 12.458 0.0125 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

-- -~~- ---

fcid 25.303 28.724 3.9258

eyid 25.303 28.724 3.9258

stid 136.896 152.649 46.2263

STID=18 CYID=147 fcid=00020 name=INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER-ROCKPORT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid see polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype etrides

18 147 00020 1 001 01 10100222 NOX 23.226 25.291 1.2646 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

18 147 00020 1 001 02 10100501 NOX 0.000 0,000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

-- -- fcid 23.226 25.291 1.2646

eyid 23.226 25.291 1.2646

stid 23.226 25.291 1.2646

STID=27 CYID=61 feid=2706100004 name=Minnesota Power Ine - Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid see polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrltype etrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 NOX 13.661 15.733 3.1466 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 002 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

fcid

eyid

13.661 15.733 3.1466

13.661 15.733 3.1466

26
STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=2710900011 name=Roehester Public Utilities - Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID feid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrttype ctrtdes

27 109 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 NOX 2.079 2.394 1A363 0.00 OAOO SNCR SCR added by LADCO

-- --- --

stid 15.739 18.127 4.5830

STID=39 CYID=1 fcid=0701000007 name="DP&L, J,M. STUART GENERATING STATION"

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrttype etrtdes

39 1 0701000007 R1 B001 B001P1 10100202 NOX 6.986 7.607 2.5358 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R2 B002 B002P1 10100202 NOX 3.633 3.956 1.3186 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R3 B003 B003P1 10100202 NOX 5.013 5A59 1.8197 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R4 B004 B004P1 10100202 NOX 7.849 8.547 2.8491 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -- fcid 23A81 25.570 8.5232

eyid 23A81 25.570 8.5232

STID=39 CYID=31 feid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrttype etrtdes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 NOX 20.852 22.706 1.1353 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF etrttype etrtdes

39 167 0684000000 R1 B001 B001P1 10200501 NOX 0.002 0.002 0.0001 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 NOX 5.817 6.334 0.3167 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201' NOX 7.902 8.604 OA302 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 NOX 7.877 8.578 OA289 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 NOX 3.859 4.202 0.2101 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

-- -- fcid 25A56 27.720 1.3860

eyid 25A56 27.720 1.3860

stid 69.789 75.996 11.0445

27
STID=54 CYID=39 fcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER - KANAWHA RIVER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrHype ctrldes

54 39 0006 012 001 99 10100202 NOX 4.829 5.258 2.6291 0.00 0.500 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

54 39 0006 012 002 99 10100202 NOX 4.921 5.359 2.6794 0.00 0.500 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

--- ---

fcid 9.750 10.617 5.3085

cyid 9.750 10.617 5.3085

stid 9.750 10.617 5.3085

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 NOX 4.755 5.398 3.0766 0.00

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 NOX 3.277 3.720 2.1951 0.00

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 NOX 3.333 3.784 2.8378 0.00

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 NOX 3.384 3.841 2.9191 0.00

-- --- -----

fcid 14.749 16.743 11.0285

0.430 SCR

0.410 SCR

0.250 SCR

0.240 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241 007800 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER VALLEY STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007800 S11 B21 01 10100202 NOX 2.797 3.175 1.4289 0.00

55 79 241007800 S11 B22 01 10100202 NOX 2.907 3.300 1.4852 0.00

55 79 241007800 S12 B23 01 10100202 NOX 2.327 2.642 1.1887 0.00

55 79 241007800 S12 B24 01 10100202 NOX 2.343 2.659 1.1967 0.00

-- -- ---

fcid 10.374 11.777 5.2995

cyid 25.123 28.519 16.3281

0.550 SCR

0.550 SCR

0.550 SCR

0.550 SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

STID=55 CYID=117 fcid=460033090 name=WP &L Alliant Energy - Edgewater Gen Station

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 117 460033090 S11

55 117 460033090 S11

55 117 460033090 S12

B23 01

B24 01

B25 01

10100203 NOX

10100203 NOX

10100221 NOX

1.620

4.107

5.680

1.839

4.662

6.448

1.1032

3.8232

5.4811

28

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.400

0.180

0.150

SCR

SCR

SCR

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO

SCR added by LADCO
======== ======== ==========

fcid

cyid

slid

11.407

11.407

36.530

12.949

12.949

41.469

10.4074

10.4074

26.7355

291.931 324.149 95.1624

29
502-2009

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for S02 r6s1b_2009

Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2009

STID=19 CYID=115 fcid=58-07-001 name=MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO. - LOUISA STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctntype ctndes

19 115 58-07-001 117487 147281 99 10100222 S02 33.664 34.774 3.4774 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=161 fcid=2116100009 name=EAST KY POWER COOP

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctntype ctrldes

21 161 2116100009 1 001 99 10100202 S02 42.166 42.103 4.2103 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

21 161 2116100009 2 002 99 10100212 S02 55.385 55.303 5.5303 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- -- --- fcid 97.551 97.406 9.7406

cyid 97.551 97.406 9.7406

stid 97.551 97.406 9.7406

STID=27 CYID=141 fcid=2714100004 name=NSP - Sherburne Generating Plant

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU001 001 10100222 S02 16.765 16.987 3.6401 0.3 0.85 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU002 001 10100222 S02 22.549 22.848 4.8959 0.3 0.85 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- --

fcid 39.314 39.834 8.5360

cyid 39.314 39.834 8.5360

stid 39.314 39.834 8.5360

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0005 name=OHIO POWER - MITCHELL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctntype ctrldes

54 51 0005 012 001 99 10100202 S02 17.775 17.748 1.7748 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0005 012 002 99 10100202 S02 5.689 5.680 0.5680 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

- -- ---

fcid 23.463 23.428 2.3428

cyid 23.463 23.428 2.3428

30
STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0009 name=APPALACHIAN POWER - MOUNTAINEER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0009 001 001 99 10100202 S02 11.196 11.179 1.1179 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=54 CYID=79 fcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER - JOHN EAMOS PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 79 0006

54 79 0006

012 001 99 10100202 S02 79.635 79.516 7.9516 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

003 003 99 10100202 S02 139.377 139.169 13.9169 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

======== ======== ==========

fcid

cyid

stid

219.012 218.685

219.012 218.685

253.671 253.293

21.8685

21.8685

25.3293

424.200 425.307 47.0832

31
502- 2012

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by tadlity tor S02 r6s1b_2012

Base Year =2002

Future Year = 2012

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AMI name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AMI 0007 0010 01 10100226 S02 16.13 18.39 1.839 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 97 097190AAC 0018 0033 01 10100226 S02 24.14 27.52 2.752 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190AAC 0021 0036 01 10100226 S02 19.23 21.92 2.192 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190AAC 0016 0031 01 10100203 S02 4.59 5.24 0.005 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

-- --- --

fcid 47.96 54.68 4.950

cyid 47.96 54.68 4.950

STID=17 CYID=125 fcid=125804AAB name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 125 125804AAB 0019 0023 01 10100202 S02 22.34 25.47 3.821 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=127 fcid=127855AAC name=ELECTRIC ENERGY INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0001 01 10100222 S02 11.83 13.48 13.482 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0002 01 10100222 S02 11.48 13.09 13.085 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0003 01 10100222 S02 . 10.25 11.68 11.680 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0004 01 10100222 S02 12.04 13.73 13.731 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0003 0006 01 10100222 S02 12.68 14.46 14.456 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

--- -- -- fcid 58.27 66.43 66.435

cyid 58.27 66.43 66.435

32
STID=17 CYID=135 fcid=135803AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctdtype ctddes

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0001 01

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0003 01

fcid

cyid

10100203 S02 32.99 37.61 3.761

10100203 S02 72.92 83.13 8.313

105.91 120.74 12.074

105.91 120.74 12.074

0.0

0.0

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=157 fcid=157851AAA name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 157 157851AAA 0001 0001 01 10100203 S02 25.14 28.66 4.299 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0002 0002 01 10100203 S02 25.79 29.41 4.411 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0013 0013 01 10100202 S02 27.79 31.68 4.752 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- ---- fcid 78.72 89.75 13.462

cyid 78.72 89.75 13.462

STID=17 CYID=167 fcid=167120AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT &POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prld sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctdtype ctrldes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01

fcid

cyid

10100203 S02 44.20 50.39 0.050

10100203 S02 16.40 18.70 0.019

60.61 69.10 0.069

60.61 69.10 0.069

0.0

0.0

0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctddes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0031 01

fcid

cyid

10100203 S02 25.35 28.90 2.890

10100203 S02 41.57 47.39 4.739

66.91 76.29 7.629

66.91 76.29 7.629

0.0

0.0

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prld sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctdtype ctddes

33
17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 S02 15.33 17.48 0.017 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

-- -- -- kid 15.33 17.48 0.017

cyid 15.33 17.48 0.017

stid 472.19 538.32 110.295

STID=19 CYID=115 fcid=58-07-001 name=MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO. - LOUISA STATION

Base Yr Grown Conlrolled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID kid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

19 115 58-07-001 117487 147281 99 10100222 S02 33.66 38.38 3.838 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=161 fcid=2116100009 name=EAST KY POWER COOP

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID kid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

21 161 2116100009 1 001 99 10100202 802 42.17 44.03 4.403 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

21 161 2116100009 2 002 99 10100212 S02 55.39 57.84 5.784 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- -- --- kid 97.55 101.87 10.187

cyid 97.55 101.87 10.187

stid 97.55 101.87 10.187

8TID=27 CYID=61 fcid=27061 00004 name=Minnesota Power Inc - Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID kid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

27 61 2706100004 8V003 EU003 001 10100226 802 33.99 35.19 15.081 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 8V003 EU003 002 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

kid

cyid

33.99 35.19 15.081

33.99 35.19 15.081

STID=27 CYI D=1 09 kid=2710900011 name=Rochester Public Utilities - Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown. Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID kid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

27 109 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 S02 7.86 8.13 1.220

34

0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO
STID=27 CYID=141 fcid=2714100004 name=NSP - Sherburne Generating Planf

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU001 001 10100222 S02 16.76 17.36 3.719 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU002 001 10100222 S02 22.55 23.34 5.002 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- ---- fcid 39.31 40.70 8.721

cyid 39.31 40.70 8.721

stid 81.16 84.02 25.023

STID=39 CYID=13 fcid=0607130015 name=R. E. BURGER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYtD fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 13 0607130015 R6 B011 B011P1 10100202 S02 29.83 31.15 3.115

39 13 0607130015 R7 B012 B012P1 10100202 S02 34.77 36.31 3.631

0.0

0.0

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

fcid

cyid

64.60 67.46 6.746

64.60 67.46 6.746

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day TonslDay Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 S02 316.00 330.00 33.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

stid 380.60 397.46 39.746

STID=47 CYID=1 fcid=0009 name=TVA BULL RUN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 1 0009 8-1 001 99 10100212 S02 130.81 133.01 13.301 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=47 CYID=73 fcid=0007 name=TVA JOHN SEVIER FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 73 0007 S-1A 001 99 10100212 S02 20.15 20.49 2.049 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S-1B 002 99 10100212 S02 20.25 20.59 2.059 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S-2A 003 99 10100212 S02 19.62 19.95 1.995 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S-2B 004 99 10100212 S02 18.93 19.25 1.925 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

--~- ---

35
fcid 78.95 80.28 8.028

cyid 78.95 80.28 8.028

STID=47 CYID=85 fcid=0011 name=TVA JOHNSONVILLE FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

47 85 0011 S1-01 001 99 10100212 S02 17.06 17.35 1.735 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1-04 004 99 10100212 S02 19.85 20.18 2.018 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1-05 005 99 10100212 S02 24.11 24.52 2.452 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- -- fcid 61.02 62.04 6.204

cyid 61.02 62.04 6.204

STID=47 CYID=145 fcid=0013 name=TVA KINGSTON FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrides

47 145 0013 S-1 001 99 10100202 S02 12.68 12.89 1.289 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-1 002 99 10100202 S02 14.00 14.24 1.424 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-1 003 99 10100202 S02 13.80 14.04 1.404 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-1 004 99 10100202 S02 12.24 12.44 1.244 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-1 005 99 10100202 S02 19.57 19.90 1.990 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-2 006 99 10100202 S02 18.92 19.24 1.924 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-2 007 99 10100202 S02 21.30 21.66 2.166 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-2 008 99 10100202 S02 18.54 18.85 1.885 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-2 009 99 10100202 S02 20.72 21.07 2.107 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

- --- -- -- fcid 151.77 154.33 15.433

cyid 151.77 154.33 15.433

STID=47 CYID=165 fcid=0025 name=TVA GALLATIN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrides

47 165 0025 S-01 001 99 10100212 S02 13.91 14.14 1.414 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S-01 002 99 10100212 S02 14.87 15.12 1.512 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S-02 003 99 10100212 S02 16.33 16.60 1.660 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S-02 004 99 10100212 S02 20.39 20.73 2.073 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

--- ~---

fcid 65.49 66.59 6.659

cyid 65.49 66.59 6.659

stid 488.04 496.25 49.625

36
STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0005 name=OHIO POWER - MITCHELL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID feid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0005

54 51 0005

fcid

cyid

012 001 99 10100202 S02 17.77 18.56 1.856 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

012 002 99 10100202 S02 5.69 5.94 0.594 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

23.46 24.50 2.450

23.46 24.50 2.450

STID=54 CYID=53 feid=0009 name=APPALACHIAN POWER - MOUNTAINEER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID feid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0009 001 001 99 10100202 S02 11.20 11.69 1.169 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=54 CYID=79 fcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER - JOHN EAMOS PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 79 0006 012 001 99 10100202 S02 79.63 83.16 8.316 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 012 002 99 10100202 S02 100.33 104.78 10.478 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 003 003 99 10100202 S02 139.38 145.55 14.555 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- ---

fcid 319.35 333.50 33.350

cyid 319.35 333.50 33.350

stid 354.00 369.69 36.969

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 S02 12.75 14.54 3.490 0.0 0.760 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 S02 8.68 9.89 2.473 0.0 0.750 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 S02 10.97 12.51 2.876 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 S02 11.28 12.86 2.958 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- --- ---

fcid 43.68 49.80 11.797

cyid 43.68 49.80 11.797

stid 43.68 49.80 11.797

======== ======== ==========

1950.90 2075.80 287.480

37
502 - 2018

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility lor S02 r6s1b_2018

Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2018

STID=17 CYID=31 Icid=031600AIN name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AIN 0010 0013 01

17 31 031600AIN 0012 0016 01

fcid

10100226 S02 10.92 12.39 1.239

10100226 S02 17.69 20.08 2.008

28.61 32.48 3.248

0.0

0.0

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AMI name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AMI 0007 0010 01

cyid

10100226 S02 16.13 18.31

44.74 50.79 5.079

1.831 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=79 Icid=079808AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 79 079808AAA 0003 0003 01

17 79 079808AAA 0012 0013 01

fcid

cyid

10100202 S02 36.35 41.27 4.127

10100501 S02 28.99 19.46 1.946

65.34 60.72 6.072

65.34 60.72 6.072

0.0

0.0

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=97 Icid=097190MC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 97 097190MC 0018 0033 01 10100226 S02 24.14 27.40 2.740 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190MC 0021 0036 01 10100226 S02 19.23 21.83 2.183 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190MC 0016 0031 01 10100203 S02 4.59 5.22 0.005 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

~--- -- --- fcid 47.96 54.45 4.928

cyid 47.96 54.45 4.928

38
STID=17 CYID=125 fcid=125804AAB name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 125 125804AAB 0019 0023 01 10100202 S02 22.34 25.36 3.805 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=127 fcid=127855AAC name=ELECTRIC ENERGY INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0003 01 10100222 S02 10.25 11.63 11.630 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0004 01 10100222 S02 12.04 13.67 13.673 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0001 01 10100222 S02 11.83 13.42 1.342 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0002 01 10100222 S02 11.48 13.03 1.303 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0003 0005 01 10100222 S02 11.72 13.31 1.331 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0003 0006 01 10100222 S02 12.68 14.39 1.439 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- ---- fcid 70.00 79.46 30.719

cyid 70.00 79.46 30.719

STID=17 CYID=135 fcid=135803AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype clrldes

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0001 01

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0003 01

fcid

cyid

10100203 S02 32.99 37.45 3.745

10100203 S02 72.92 82.77 8.277

105.91 120.22 12.022

105.91 120.22 12.022

0.0

0.0

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF clrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 S02 15.28 17.34 1.734 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=157 fcid=157851AAA name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 157 157851AAA 0001 0001 01

17 157 157851AAA 0002 0002 01

17 157 157851AAA 0013 0013 01

10100203 S02

10100203 S02

10100202 S02

25.14 28.54 4.281

25.79 29.28 4.392

27.79 31.54 4.732

39

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO
fcid

cyid

78.72 89.36 13.404

78.72 89.36 13.404

STID=17 CYID=167 fcid=167120MO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 167 167120MO 0010 0012 01

17 167 167120MO 0010 0013 01

fcid

cyid

10100203 S02 44.20 50.18 0.050

10100203 S02 16.40 18.62 0.019

60.61 68.80 0.069

60.61 68.80 0.069

0.0

0.0

0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AM name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 179 179801AM 0018 0029 01

17 179 179801AM 0018 0031 01

fcid

cyid

10100203 S02 25.35 28.77 2.877

10100203 S02 41.57 47.19 4.719

66.B1 75.96 7.596

66.91 75.96 7.596

0.0

0.0

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197809MO name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Conlrolled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197809MO 0006 0009 01

17 197 197809MO 0016 0031 01

17 197 197809MO 0017 0033 01

10100203 S02

10100202 S02

10100202 S02

15.89 18.04

27.43 31.13

23.13 26.26

1.804

3.113

2.626

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

fcid 66.45 75.44 7.544

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810MK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197810MK 0009 0014 02 10100222 S02 11.64 13.21 1.321 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810MK 0011 0016 02 10100222 S02 25.67 29.14 2.914 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810MK 0013 0010 03 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810MK 0007 0012 02 10100223 S02 15.33 17.40 0.017 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810MK 0007 0012 03 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

--~ --- -- fcid 52.64 59.75 4.252

40
cyid

stid

119.09 135.19 11.796

696.90 777.66 97.225

STID=18 CYID=147 fcid=00020 name=INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER-ROCKPORT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

18 147 00020 1 001 01 10100222 S02 66.42 72.32 7.232 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

18 147 00020 1 001 02 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- ---

fcid 66.42 72.32 7.232

cyid 66.42 72.32 7.232

stid 66.42 72.32 7.232

STID=19 CYID=115 fcid=58-07-001 name=MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO. - LOUISA STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

19 115 58-07-001 117487 147281 99 10100222 S02 33.66 38.22 3.822 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=127 fcid=2112700003 name=KENTUCKY POWER CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

21 127 2112700003 2 002 99 10100202 S02 104.52 113.82 11.382 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=161 fcid=2116100009 name=EAST KY POWER COOP

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctritype ctrides

21 161 2116100009 1 001 99 10100202 S02 42.17 45.92 4.592 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

21 161 2116100009 2 002 99 10100212 S02 55.39 60.31 6.031 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- --- --

fcid 97.55 106.23 10.623

cyid 97.55 106.23 10.623

stid 202.07 220.04 22.004

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=2706100004 name=Minnesota Power Inc - Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 S02 33.99 39.15 16.778 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 002 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

41
fcid

cyid

33.99 39.15 16.778

33.99 39.15 16.778

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=271 0900011 name=Rochester Public Utilities - Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 109 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 S02 7.86 9.05 1.357 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=27 CYID=141 fcid=2714100004 name=NSP - Sherburne Generating Plant

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU001 001 10100222 S02 16.76 19.31 4.138 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU002 001 10100222 S02 22.55 25.97 5.565 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- --- --- fcid 39.31 45.28 9.703

cyid 39.31 45.28 9.703

stid 81.16 93.48 27.838

STID=39 CYID=13 fcid=0607130015 name=R. E. BURGER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 13 0607130015 R6 B011 B011 P1 10100202 S02 29.83 32.48 3.248

39 13 0607130015 R7 B012 B012P1 10100202 S02 34.77 37.86 3.786

0.0

0.0

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

fcid

cyid

64.60 70.34 7.034

64.60 70.34 7.034

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 S02 316.00 344.11 34.411 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 167 0684000000 R2

39 167 0684000000 R2

39 167 0684000000 R3

39 167 0684000000 R3

B002 B002P1 10100201 S02

B002 B002P2 10100501 S02

B003 B003P1 10100201 S02

B003 B003P2 10100501 S02

65.07 70.85 7.085 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

94.58 103.00 10.300 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

42
39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 S02 81.64 88.90 8.890 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R5 BOOS B005P1 10100203 S02 97.22 105.87 10.587 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R5 BOOS B005P2 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 S02 113.96 124.10 12.410 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 S02 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO ----- --

fcid 452.48 492.72 49.272

cyid 452.48 492.72 49.272

stid 833.08 907.16 90.716

STID=47 CYID=1 fcid=0009 name=TVA BULL RUN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 1 0009 S-1 001 99 10100212 S02 130.81 136.82 13.682 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=47 CYID=73 fcid=0007 name=TVA JOHN SEVIER FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 73 0007 S-1A 001 99 10100212 S02 20.15 21.07 2.107 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 &1B 002 99 10100212 S02 20.25 21.18 2.118 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S-2A 003 99 10100212 S02 19.62 20.52 2.052 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 &2B 004 99 10100212 S02 18.93 19.80 1.980 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- -- fcid 78.95 82.57 8.257

cyid 78.95 82.57 8.257

STID=47 CYID=85 fcid=0011 name=TVA JOHNSONVILLE FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 85 0011 S1-01 001 99 10100212 S02 17.06 17.84 1.784 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 81-04 004 99 10100212 S02 19.85 20.76 2.076 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1-05 005 99 10100212 S02 24.11 25.22 2.522 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- --

fcid 61.02 63.82 6.382

cyid 61.02 63.82 6.382

43
STID=47 CYID=145 tcid=0013 name=TVA KINGSTON FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 145 0013 S-1 001 99 10100202 S02 12.68 13.26 1.326 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-1 002 99 10100202 S02 14.00 14.65 1.465 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-1 003 99 10100202 S02 13.80 14.44 1.444 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-1 004 99 10100202 S02 12.24 12.80 1.280 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 3-1 005 99 10100202 S02 19.57 20.47 2.047 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 3-2 006 99 10100202 S02 18.92 19.79 1.979 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 3-2 007 99 10100202 S02 21.30 22.28 2.228 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 3-2 008 99 10100202 S02 18.54 19.39 1.939 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S-2 009 99 10100202 S02 20.72 21.68 2.168 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

- --

tcid 151.77 158.75 15.875

cyid 151.77 158.75 15.875

STtD=47 CYID=165 tcid=0025 name=TVA GALLATIN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STtD CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 165 0025 S-01 001 99 10100212 S02 13.91 14.54 1.454 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S-01 002 99 10100212 S02 14.87 15.56 1.556 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S-02 003 99 10100212 S02 16.33 17.08 1.708 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S-02 004 99 10100212 S02 20.39 21.32 2.132 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- -- fcid 65.49 68.50 6.850

cyid 65.49 68.50 6.850

stid 488.04 510.46 51.046

STID=54 CYID=39 tcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER - KANAWHA RIVER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day TonslDay Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 39 0006

54 39 0006

fcid

cyid

012 001 99 10100202 S02 19.45 21.18 10.591

012 002 99 10100202 S02 20.94 22.80 11.399

40.39 43.98 21.990

40.39 43.98 21.990

44

0.0

0.0

0.500 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

0.500 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO
STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0005 name=OHIO POWER - MITCHELL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID feid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0005

54 51 0005

fcid

012 001 99 10100202 S02 17.77 19.36 1.936 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

012 002 99 10100202 S02 5.69 6.19 0.619 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

23.46 25.55 2.555

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0006 name=OHIO POWER - KAMMER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0006 013 001 99 10100203 S02 47.06 51.25 5.125 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0006 013 002 99 10100203 S02 47.66 51.90 5.190 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0006 013 003 99 10100203 S02 41.94 45.67 4.567 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

- -- ---- fcid 136.67 148.82 14.882

cyid 160.13 174.37 17.437

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0001 name=APPALACHIAN POWER CO.-PHILIP SPORN PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0001 014 001 99 10100202 S02 18.65 20.31 2.031 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 014 002 99 10100202 S02 15.87 17.28 1.728 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 014 003 99 10100202 S02 21.46 23.36 2.336 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 014 004 99 10100202 S02 20.53 22.36 2.236 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 005 005 99 10100202 S02 46.82 50.98 5.098 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- -- ---

fcid 123.33 134.30 13.430

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0009 name=APPALACHIAN POWER - MOUNTAINEER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0009

cyid

001 001 99 10100202 S02 11.20 12.19 1.219

134.53 146.49 14.649

0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=54 CYID=79 feid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER - JOHN EAMOS PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

45
54 79 0006 012 001 99 10100202 S02 79.63 86.72 8.672 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 012 002 99 10100202 S02 100.33 109.26 10.926 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 003 003 99 10100202 S02 139.38 151.77 15.177 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- -- -- --- fcid 319.35 347.75 34.775

cyid 319.35 347.75 34.775

stid 654.39 712.59 88.851

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid pod sec polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctntype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 S02 12.75 14.48 3.475 0.0 0.760 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 S02 8.68 9.85 2.462 0.0 0.750 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 S02 10.97 12.45 2.864 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 S02 11.28 12.81 2.945 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

-- -- --- fcid 43.68 49.59 11.746

cyid 43.68 49.59 11.746

stid 43.68 49.59 11.746

======== ======== ==========

3099.41 3381.52 400.481

46
Appendix II

Scenario C Controls (CAMD List)

47
NOx Controls (SCRs, 2007 - 2013))

SCR I

Capacity On Line Online

Plant Name UniauelD Final State Name County MW Year Year

Chesterfield 3797 B 4 Virainia Chesterfield 166 1960 2013

Chesterfield 3797 B 5 Virqinia Chesterfield 310 1964 2012

Scherer 6257 B 3 Georoia Monroe 875 1987 2011

Chesterfield 3797 B 6 Virainia Chesterfield 658 1969 2011

Sandow No 4 6648 B 4 Texas Milam 545 1981 2011

Beech Hollow Power Proiect 82704 B 1 Pennsvlvania WashinQton 272 2011 2011

Lonqview Power 82702 B 1 West Virqinia Mononqalia 695 2011 2011

Cliffside 2721 B 6 North Carolina Cleveland 800 2011 2011

AES Westover 2526 B 11 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526 B 12 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526 B 13 New York Broome 84 1951 2010

latan 2 6065 B 2 Missouri Platte 850 2010 2010

Southwest 6195 B 2 Missouri Greene 300 2010 2010

Trimble Station ILGE) 6071 B 2 Kentucky Trimble 732 2010 2010

Elm Road Generatina Station 56068 B 2 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2010 2010

Clav Boswell 1893 B 3 Minnesota Itasca 350 1973 2009

Asheville 2706 B 2 North Carolina Buncombe 184 1971 2009

Conesville 2840 B 4 Ohio Coshocton 780 1973 2009

Marshall 2727 B 3 North Carolina Catawba 657 1969 2009

St Johns River Power Park 207 B 1 Florida Duval 626 1987 2009

Ghent 1356 B 2 Kentuckv Carroll 469 1977 2009

Chalk Point LLC 1571 B 1 Marvland Prince Georae's 341 1964 2009

Chalk Point LLC 1571 B 2 Marvland Prince Georae's 342 1965 2009

San Juan 2451 B 2 New Mexico San Juan 320 1973 2009

Biq Bend 645 B BB01 Florida Hillsborouqh 411 1970 2009

Biq Bend 645 B BB02 Florida Hillsborouqh 391 1973 2009

Bia Bend 645 B BB03 Florida Hillsborouoh 414 1976 2009

Nebraska Citv Unit 2 6096 B 2 Nebraska Otoe 663 2009 2009

Cross 130 B 4 South Carolina Berkelev 652 2009 2009

SprinQerville 8223 B 4 Arizona Apache 400 2009 2009

Sandow 5 82010 B 5 Texas Milam 600 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011 B 1 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011 B 2 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

TS Power Plant 82013 B 1 Nevada Eureka 200 2009 2009

Plum Point Enemv 82014 B 1 Arkansas Mississlooi 665 2009 2009

Comanche 470 B 3 Colorado Pueblo 750 2009 2009

Elm Road Generatinq Station 56068 B 1 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2009 2009

Two Elk Generatinq Station 55360 B 1 Wyominq Campbell 300 2009 2009

J K Soruce 7097 B BLR2 Texas Bexar 750 2009 2009

Dallman 963 B 34 Illinois Sanaamon 200 2009 2009

AES GreenidQe LLC 2527 B 4 New York Yates 27 1950 2008

AES GreenidQe LLC 2527 B 5 New York Yates 27 1950 2008

AES GreenidQe LLC 2527 B 6 New York Yates 106 1953 2008

Charles R Lowman 56 B 2 Alabama Washinqton 238 1979 2008

Charles R Lowman 56 B 3 Alabama Washinqton 238 1980 2008

Barrv 3 B 5 Alabama Mobile 750 1971 2008

St Johns River Power Park 207 B 2 Florida Duval 626 1988 2008

Moraantown Generatina Plant 1573 B 2 Marvland Charles 620 1971 2008

48
Baillv 995 B 7 Indiana Porter 160 1962 2008

San Juan 2451 B 1 New Mexico San Juan 322 1976 2008

San Juan 2451 B 3 New Mexico San Juan 495 1979 2008

Weston 4078 B 4 Wisconsin Marathon 519 2008 2008

AES Deepwater 10670 B AAB001 Texas Harris 140 1986 2007

La Cvane 1241 B 1 Kansas Linn 724 1973 2007

Moraantown Generatina Plant 1573 B 1 Marvland Charles 624 1970 2007

PSEG Hudson Generatina Station 2403 B 2 New Jersev Hudson 583 1967 2007

San Juan 2451 B 4 New Mexico San Juan 506 1982 2007

Bia Bend 645 B BB04 Florida Hillsborouqh 457 1985 2007

Cross 130 B 3 South Carolina Berkelev 620 2007 2007

Wyqen II 55479 B 4 Wvomina Camobell 90 2007 2007

Council Bluffs 1082 B 4 Iowa Pottawattamie 790 2007 2007

502 Controls (FGDs, 2007 - 2012)

Scrubber

Capacity On Line Online

Plant Name UniauelD Final State Name County MW Year Year

James H Miller Jr 6002 B 1 Alabama Jefferson 684 1978 2011

James H Miller Jr 6002 B 2 Alabama Jefferson 687 1985 2011

James H Miller Jr 6002 B 3 Alabama Jefferson 687 1989 2011

James H Miller Jr 6002 B 4 Alabama Jefferson 688 1991 2011

Caoe Fear 2708 B 5 North Carolina Chatham 143 1956 2011

Baldwin Enerav Comolex 889 B 1 Illinois Randoloh 624 1970 2011

Baldwin Enerav Comolex 889 B 2 Illinois Randolph 629 1973 2011

Baldwin Enerav Complex 889 B 3 Illinois Randolph 629 1975 2011

Scherer 6257 B 3 Georaia Monroe 875 1987 2011

Milton R Younq 2823 B B1 North Dakota Oliver 250 1970 2011

WH Sammis 2866 B 6 Ohio Jefferson 630 1969 2011

WH Sammis 2866 B 7 Ohio Jefferson 630 1971 2011

PSEG Hudson Generatina Station 2403 B 2 New Jersev Hudson 583 1967 2011

John Sevier 3405 B 1 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1955 2011

John Sevier 3405 B 2 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1955 2011

John Sevier 3405 B 3 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1956 2011

John Sevier 3405 B 4 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1957 2011

Beech Hollow Power Project 82704 B 1 Pennsvlvania Washinaton 272 2011 2011

Loneview Power 82702 B 1 West Virainia Mononaalia 695 2011 2011

Cliffside 2721 B 6 North Carolina Cleveland 800 2011 2011

AES Greenidae LLC 2527 B 4 New York Yates 27 1950 2010

AES Greenidae LLC 2527 B 5 New York Yates 27 1950 2010

Barrv 3 B 5 Alabama Mobile 750 1971 2010

E C Gaston 26 B 5 Alabama Shelbv 861 1974 2010

Warrick 6705 B 4 Indiana Warrick 300 1970 2010

Coffeen 861 B 01 Illinois Montaomerv 340 1965 2010

Coffeen 861 B 02 Illinois Montaomerv 560 1972 2010

Cardinal 2828 B 3 Ohio Jefferson 630 1977 2010

Brandon Shores 602 B 1 Marvland Anne Arundel 643 1984 2010

Brandon Shores 602 B 2 Marvland Anne Arundel 643 1991 2010

Monroe 1733 B 4 Michiqan Monroe 775 1974 2010

Cliffside 2721 B 5 North Carolina Cleveland 550 1972 2010

Crvstal River 628 B 4 Florida Citrus 720 1982 2010

Bowen 703 B 1BLR Georaia Bartow 713 1971 2010

49
Crist 641 B 6 Florida Escambia 302 1970 2010

Crist 641 B 7 Florida Escambia 477 1973 2010

Cliftv Creek 983 B 1 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Cliftv Creek 983 B 2 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Cliftv Creek 983 B 3 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983 B 4 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Cliftv Creek 983 B 5 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983 B 6 Indiana Jefferson 217 1956 2010

Chalk Point LLC 1571 B 1 Maryland Prince Georae's 341 1964 2010

Chalk Point LLC 1571 B 2 Maryland Prince Georae's 342 1965 2010

Dickerson 1572 B 1 Maryland Montaomery 182 1959 2010

Dickerson 1572 B 2 Marvland Montaomery 182 1960 2010

Dickerson 1572 B 3 Maryland Montaomery 182 1962 2010

R E Buraer 2864 B 7 Ohio Belmont 156 1955 2010

R E Buraer 2864 B 8 Ohio Belmont 156 1955 2010

Kvaer Creek 2876 B 1 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kvaer Creek 2876 B 2 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kvaer Creek 2876 B 3 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kvaer Creek 2876 B 4 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kvaer Creek 2876 B 5 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Cheswick 8226 B 1 Pennsvlvania Alleahenv 580 1970 2010

PSEG Mercer Generatina Station 2408 B 1 New Jersey Mercer 315 1960 2010

PSEG Mercer Generatino Station 2408 B 2 New Jersev Mercer 310 1961 2010

Silver Lake 2008 B 4 Minnesota Olmsted 61 1969 2010

Kinaston 3407 B 1 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kinaston 3407 B 2 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kinaston 3407 B 3 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kinaston 3407 B 4 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kinaston 3407 B 5 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kinaston 3407 B 6 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kinaston 3407 B 7 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kinaston 3407 B 8 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kinaston 3407 B 9 Tennessee Roane 178 1955 2010

Sioux 2107 B 1 Missouri St Charles 497 1967 2010

Sioux 2107 B 2 Missouri St Charles 497 1968 2010

Chesterfield 3797 B 5 Virainia Chesterfield 310 1964 2010

Yorktown 3809 B 1 Virainia York 159 1957 2010

AES Westover 2526 B 11 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526 B 12 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526 B 13 New York Broome 84 1951 2010

latan 2 6065 B 2 Missouri Platte 850 2010 2010

Southwest 6195 B 2 Missouri Greene 300 2010 2010

Trimble Station ILGE) 6071 B 2 Kentuckv Trimble 732 2010 2010

Elm Road Generatina Station 56068 B 2 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2010 2010

Cholla 113 B 3 Arizona Nava;o 271 1980 2009

Mavo 6250 B 1A North Carolina Person 362 1963 2009

Mavo 6250 B 1B North Carolina Person 362 1983 2009

Conesville 2840 B 4 Ohio Coshocton 780 1973 2009

G GAlien 2718 B 1 North Carolina Gaston 162 1957 2009

G GAlien 2718 B 2 North Carolina Gaston 162 1957 2009

G GAlien 2718 B 3 North Carolina Gaston 260 1959 2009

50
G GAlien 2718 B 4 North Carolina Gaston 275 1960 2009

G GAlien 2718 B 5 North Carolina Gaston 265 1961 2009

H L Sourlock 6041 B 1 Kentuckv Mason 315 1977 2009

Crvstal River 628 B 5 Florida Citrus 717 1984 2009

Deerhaven Generatino Station 663 B B2 Florida Alachua 228 1981 2009

Bowen. 703 B 2BLR Georoia Bartow 718 1972 2009

Wanslev 6052 B 2 Georoia Heard 892 1978 2009

E WBrown 1355 B 1 Kentuckv Mercer 94 1957 2009

E WBrown 1355 B 2 Kentuckv Mercer 160 1963 2009

EWBrown 1355 B 3 Kentuckv Mercer 422 1971 2009

Ghent 1356 B 2 Kentuckv Carroll 469 1977 2009

Favette Power Proiect 6179 B 1 Texas Favette 598 1979 2009

Favette Power Proiect 6179 B 2 Texas Favette 598 1980 2009

Moroantown Generatina Plant 1573 B 1 Maryland Charles 624 1970 2009

Moraantown Generatina Plant 1573 B 2 Marvland Charles 620 1971 2009

PPL Brunner Island 3140 B 1 Pennsvlvania York 321 1961 2009

PPL Brunner Island 3140 B 2 Pennsvlvania York 378 1965 2009

Kevstone 3136 B 1 Pennsvlvania Armstrona 850 1967 2009

Kevstone 3136 B 2 Pennsvlvania Armstrona 850 1968 2009

Bull Run 3396 B 1 Tennessee Anderson 881 1967 2009

Bav Shore 2878 B 4 Ohio Lucas 215 1968 2009

Hatfields Ferrv Power Station 3179 B 1 Pennsylvania Greene 530 1969 2009

Hatfields Ferrv Power Station 3179 B 2 Pennsvlvania Greene 530 1970 2009

Hatfields Ferry Power Station 3179 B 3 Pennsylvania Greene 530 1971 2009

Nebraska City Unit 2 6096 B 2 Nebraska Otoe 663 2009 2009

Cross 130 B 4 South Carolina Berkelev 652 2009 2009

Sprinoerville 8223 B 4 Arizona Apache 400 2009 2009

Sandow 5 82010 B 5 Texas Milam 600 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011 B 1 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011 B 2 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

TS Power Plant 82013 B 1 Nevada Eureka 200 2009 2009

Plum Point Enerav 82014 B 1 Arkansas Mississiooi 665 2009 2009

Comanche 470 B 3 Colorado Pueblo 750 2009 2009

Elm Road Generatino Station 56068 B 1 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2009 2009

Two Elk Generatina Station 55360 B 1 Wvomina Campbell 300 2009 2009

J K Soruce 7097 B BLR2 Texas Bexar 750 2009 2009

Dallman 963 B 34 Illinois Sanoamon 200 2009 2009

Charles R Lowman 56 B 1 Alabama Washinoton 86 1969 2008

John E Amos 3935 B 1 West Viroinia Putnam 800 1971 2008

John E Amos 3935 B 2 West Virainia Putnam 800 1972 2008

Cholla 113 B 4 Arizona Navaio 380 1981 2008

Roxboro 2712 B 1 North Carolina Person 369 1966 2008

Roxboro 2712 B 3A North Carolina Person 341 1973 2008

Roxboro 2712 B 3B North Carolina Person 341 1973 2008

Miami Fort 2832 B 7 Ohio Hamilton 500 1975 2008

Miami Fort 2832 B 8 Ohio Hamilton 500 1978 2008

Coaentrix Virainia Leasina COrD 10071 B 2A Virainia Portsmouth 19 1988 2008

Coaentrix Viroinia Leasino COrD 10071 B 2B Viroinia Portsmouth 19 1988 2008

Coaentrix Virainia Leasina Corp 10071 B 2C Virainia Portsmouth 19 1988 2008

J M Stuart 2850 B 1 Ohio Adams 585 1971 2008

J M Stuart 2850 B 2 Ohio Adams 597 1970 2008

51
J M Stuart 2850 B 3 Ohio Adams 597 1972 2008

J M Stuart 2850 B 4 Ohio Adams 597 1974 2008

Monroe 1733 B 3 Michiaan Monroe 795 1973 2008

Belews Creek 8042 B 1 North Caroiina Stokes 1,115 1974 2008

Belews Creek 8042 B 2 North Carolina Stokes 1,115 1975 2008

Bowen 703 B 3BLR Georoia Bartow 902 1974 2008

Bowen 703 B 4BLR Georoia Bartow 929 1975 2008

Hammond 708 B 1 Georoia Flovd 112 1954 2008

Hammond 708 B 2 Georaia Flovd 112 1954 2008

Hammond 708 B 3 Georaia Flovd 112 1955 2008

Hammond 708 B 4 Georgia Flovd 510 1970 2008

Wansley 6052 B 1 Georaia Heard 891 1976 2008

Hardina Street 990 B 70 Indiana Marion 435 1973 2008

Coaentrix Hopewell 10377 B 1A Virainia Hopewell (citv) 18 1987 2008

Coaentrix Hopewell 10377 B 1B Virainia Hopewell (citv) 18 1987 2008

Cogentrix Hopeweil 10377 B 1C Virginia Hopewell (citv) 18 1987 2008

Ghent 1356 B 4 Kentuckv Carroll 478 1984 2008

Council Bluffs 1082 B 3 Iowa Pottawattamie 690 1978 2008

PPL Brunner Island 3140 B 3 PennsYlvania York 749 1969 2008

PPL Montour 3149 B 1 Pennsylvania Montour 774 1972 2008

PPL Montour 3149 B 2 Pennsylvania Montour 766 1973 2008

Comanche 470 B 1 Colorado Pueblo 366 1973 2008

Comanche 470 B 2 Colorado Pueblo 370 1975 2008

Cavuaa 1001 B 2 Indiana Vermilion 473 1972 2008

Winvah 6249 B 1 South Carolina Georaetown 295 1975 2008

Winvah 6249 B 2 South Carolina Georaetown 295 1977 2008

Winvah 6249 B 3 South Carolina Georgetown 295 1980 2008

Chesterfield 3797 B 6 Virginia Chesterfield 658 1969 2008

Bravton Point 1619 B 1 Massachusetts Bristo 243 1963 2008

Bravton Point 1619 B 2 Massachusetts Bristo 244 1964 2008

Weston 4078 B 4 Wisconsin Marathon 519 2008 2008

Goraas 8 B 10 Alabama Walker 690 1972 2007

Goraas 8 B 8 Aiabama Walker 165 1956 2007

Gorgas 8 B 9 Alabama Walker 175 1958 2007

John E Amos 3935 B 3 West Virginia Putnam 1,300 1973 2007

Mountaineer 6264 B 1 West Viroinia Mason 1,300 1980 2007

Cardinal 2828 B 1 Ohio Jefferson 600 1967 2007

Cardinal 2828 B 2 Ohio Jefferson 600 1967 2007

Roxboro 2712 B 2 North Carolina Person 639 1968 2007

Roxboro 2712 B 4A North Carolina Person 343 1980 2007

Roxboro 2712 B 4B North Carolina Person 343 1980 2007

Cooentrix Viroinia Leasina Cora 10071 B 1A Virainia Portsmouth 19 1988 2007

Cooentrix Viroinia Leasino Coro 10071 B 1B Virainia Portsmouth 19 1988 2007

Cooentrix Virainia Leasino Cora 10071 B 1C Virainia Portsmouth 19 1988 2007

Killen Station 6031 B 2 Ohio Adams 615 1982 2007

Marshall 2727 B 2 North Carolina CataWba 378 1966 2007

Marshall 2727 B 3 North Carolina CataWba 657 1969 2007

Cooentrix Hopewell 10377 B 2A Viroinia Hopewell icitv) 18 1987 2007

Cooentrix Hopewell 10377 B 2B Virainia Hopewell icitv) 18 1987 2007

Coaentrix Hopewell 10377 B 2C Virainia Hopewell (citv) 18 1987 2007

Ghent 1356 B 3 Kentuckv Carroll 478 1981 2007

52
Louisa 6664 B 101 Iowa Louisa 700 1983 2007

Allen S Kina 1915 B 1 Minnesota Washinaton 571 1968 2007

Mitchell 3948 B 1 West Virainia Marshall 800 1971 2007

Gibson 6113 B 1 Indiana Gibson 630 1975 2007

Gibson 6113 B 2 Indiana Gibson 628 1975 2007

Winyah 6249 B 4 South Carolina Georqetown 270 1981 2007

Pleasant Prairie 6170 B 2 Wisconsin Kenosha 617 1985 2007

Cross 130 B 3 South Carolina Berkelev 620 2007 2007

Wvaen II 55479 B 4 Wvamina Camabell 90 2007 2007

Cauncil Bluffs 1082 B 4 Iowa Pottawattamie 790 2007 2007

Assumed BART Facilities and Units

State County Fac 10 Facility Name Unit 10

MI Bay B2840 CE - KARNIWEADOCK EUOO036

MI Bay B2840 CE - KARNIWEADOCK EUOO037

MI Eaton 84001 LAN. BW&L ERICKSON EUOOO07

MI Houghton B6553 UP POWER CO / PORTAGE EUOOO08

MI Huron B2815 DTE - HARBOR BEACH EUOOO09

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Eckert RGOO023

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Eckert RGOO023

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Eckert RGOO023

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Moores Park RGOO021

MI Marquette B4261 WE-ENERGIES EUOO029

MI Marquette B4261 WE-ENERGIES EUOO030

MI Marquette B4261 WE-ENERGIES EUOO031

MI Marquette B4261 WE-ENERGIES EUOO032

MI Marquette B4261 WE-ENERGIES EUOO033

MI Monroe B2816 DTE - MONROE EUOO062

MI Monroe B2816 DTE - MONROE EUOO068

MI Monroe B2816 DTE-MONROE EUOO063

MI Monroe B2816 DTE - MONROE EUOO064

MI Ottawa B2835 CE - CAMPBELL EUOO062

MI Ottawa B2835 CE - CAMPBELL EUOO061

MI Saint Clair B2796 DTE - ST. CLAIR / BELLE RIVER EU00111

MI Saint Clair B6145 DTE - GREENWOOD EUOOO09

MI Wayne B2132 WYANDOTIE EUOO036

MI Wayne B2185 DETROIT PLD, MISTERSKY EUOO014

MI Wayne B2811 DTE - TRENTON EUOO035

OH Lake 0243160009 CEI., EASTLAKE PLANT B005

OH 0247030013 Orion Power Midwest B012

OH 0285010188 Dept of Public Utilities, City of Orrville B001

OH 0285010188 Dept of Public Utilities, City of Orrville B004

OH 0448020006 Toledo Edison Co., Bay Shore B003

OH 0448020006 Toledo Edison Co., Bay Shore B004

OH 0616000000 Conesville Power Plant B003

OH 0616000000 Conesville Power Plant B004

OH 0616000000 Conesville Power Plant B007

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B001

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B002

53
OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B003

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B004

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B008

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B009

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B009

OH Jefferson 0641160017 W H. SAMMIS PLANT B011

OH Jefferson 0641160017 W H. SAMMIS PLANT B012

OH Jefferson 0641160017 W H. SAMMIS PLANT B013

OH 0684000000 Muskinaum River Power Plant B006

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generatina Station B001

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generatina Station B002

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generatina Station B003

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generatina Station B004

OH 0701000060 DP&L, Killen Station B001

OH 1409040243 City of Hamilton Dept of Public Utilities B002

OH 1409040243 City of Hamilton Dept of Public Utilities B008

OH 1409040243 City of Hamilton Dept of Public Utilities B009

OH 1413100008 CG&E W C. BECKJORD B005

OH 1413100008 CG&E W C. BECKJORD B006

OH 1431350093 CG&E MIAMI FORT STATION B015

IL Peoria 856 Ameren - Edwards 2

IL Sanqamon 963 CWLP - Dallman 31

IL Sanqamon 963 CWLP - Dallman 32

IL Christian 876 Dominion - Kincaid 1

IL Christian 876 Dominion - Kincaid 2

WI COLUMBIA 111003090 Alliant Enerav-Columbia Generatinq B20

WI COLUMBIA 111003090 Alliant Enerav-Columbia Generatinq B21

WI COLUMBIA 111003090 Alliant Enerav-Columbia Generatina B22

WI GRANT 122014530 Alliant Enerav, Nelson Dewev B22 (unit 2\

WI MILWAUKEE 241007690 We Eneraies-Oak Creek Station B26 (Unit 6\

WI MILWAUKEE 241007690 We Eneraies-Oak Creek Station B27 (Unit 7\

WI MILWAUKEE 241007690 We Eneraies-Oak Creek Station B28

WI MILWAUKEE 241007800 We Eneraies-Vallev Station B21

WI MILWAUKEE 241007800 We Eneraies-Vallev Station B23

WI MILWAUKEE 241007800 We Eneraies-Vallev Station B24

WI BROWN 405031990 WI Public Service Com - JP Pulliam B27 lunit 8)

WI SHEBOYGAN 460033090 WP & L Alliant Enerav - Edaewater B24

Dairyland Power Coop Alma Station

WI BUFFALO 606034110 IJ.P. Madaett boilers) B25 (+B26)

WI BUFFALO 606034110 Dairvland Power Cooo Alma Station B27

WI VERNON 663020930 Dairvland Power Cooo Genoa Station B20

WI VERNON 663020930 Dairvland Power Cooo Genoa Station 825

IN Porter 995 Baillv 7

IN Porter 995 Baillv 8

IN Vermillion 1001 Cavuaa 1

IN Vermillion 1001 Cavuaa 2

IN Montaomerv 1024 Crawfordsville 6

IN Warrick 1012 Cullev 2

54
IN Warrick 1012 Cullev 3

IN Gibson 6113 Gibson 1

IN Gibson 6113 Gibson 2

IN Cass 1032 Loaansport 6

IN Sullivan 6213 Merom 1

IN Sullivan 6213 Merom 2

IN LaPorte 997 Michiqan Citv 12

IN Lake 996 Mitchell 11

IN Pike 994 Petersbura 1

IN Pike 994 Petersburq 2

IN Pike 994 Petersbura 3

IN Pike 1043 Ratts 1

IN Pike 1043 Ratts 2

IN Wayne 7335 RPL 2

IN JasDer 6085 Schahfer 14

IN JasDer 6085 Schahfer 15

IN Lake 981 Stateline 4

IN Marion 990 Stout 70

IN Dearborn 988 Tanners Creek 4

IN Viao 1010 Wabash River 6

IN Warrick 6705 Warrick 4

IA 07-02-005 Cedar Falls Utilities Unit #7 (EU10.1A)

Central Iowa Power Cooperative CombTurbines (EU

IA 88-01-004 (CIPCO) - Summit Lake Station 1/1 G, EU2/2G)

Central Iowa Power Cooperative Unit#2 (EU 2 &

IA 70-08-003 (CIPCO) - Fair Station EU 2G)

IA 85-01-006 Citv of Ames - Steam Electric Plant Boiler #7 (EU 2\

IA 29-01-013 Interstate Power & Liaht - Burlinaton Main Plant Boiler.

Boiler #4. Sixteen

IA 03-03-001 Interstate Power & Liqht - Lansina units in total.

Boiler #2. Six units

IA 23-01-014 Interstate Power & Liqht - ML Kapp in total.

Boiler #4. Fourteen

IA 57-01-042 Interstate Power & Liaht - Prairie Creek units in total.

IA 78-01-026 MidAmerican Enerav Co - Council Bluffs Boiler #3 (EU003)

Boilers #1-3

IA 97-04-010 MidAmerican Ener"v Co - Neal North (EU001 - EU003\

IA 97-04-011 MidAmerican Enerav Co - Neal South Boiler #4 (EU003)

IA 70-01-011 Muscatine Power and Water Boiler#8

IA 63-02-005 Pella Municipal Power Plant Boilers #6-8

MN 2709900001 Austin Utilities NE Power Station EU001

MN 2713700027 Hibbina Public Utilities EU003

MN 2703100001 MN Power, Taconite Harbor EU003

MN 2706100004 MN Power, Boswell Enerav Center EU003

MN 2701500010 New Ulm Public Utilities EU003 - Boiler 4

MN 2711100002 Otter Tail Power Hoot Lake EU003

MN 2710900011 Rochester Public Utilities, Silver Lake EU003

MN 2710900011 Rochester Public Utilities, Silver Lake EU004

MN 2713700028 Virainia Public Utilities EU003 - Boiler 9

MN 2714100004 Xcel Enemv, Sherco EU001, EU002

MN 2716300005 Xcel Enemv, Allen S Kina EU001 - Boiler 1

55
MN 2705300015 Xcel Enemv, Riverside EU003 - 80iler 8

MO 290710003 Ameren -Labadie 81, 82, 83, 84

MO 291830001 Ameren - Sioux 81,82

MO 290990016 Ameren - Rush Island 81,82

MO 290950031 Auila - Siblev 83 - 5C

81(EP-01),82

MO 291430004 Assoc. Electric - New Madrid (EP-02i

MO 290770039 Citv Utilities Sorinafield - Southwest 81 (E09i

MO 290770005 Citv Utilities Sorinafield - James River E07, E08

MO 290970001 Emoire Distric Electric - Asburv 87

MO 290830001 KC Power and Liqht - Montrose EP08

MO 290210004 Anula - Lake Road EP06

MO 291750001 Assoc. Electric - Thomas Hill EP01, EP02

MO 290950021 Trioen - Kansas Citv 81A

MO 290190002 Citv of Columbia Municioal Power Plant EP02

MO 291950010 Marshall Munioal Utilities EP05

MO 290950050 Indeoendence Power & Linht-8lue Vallev 83 (EP05i

WV 3943 Fort Martin

WV 6004 Pleasants

WV 3948 Mitchell

WV 3935 Amos

WV 6264 Mountaineer

WV 3944 Harrison

TN 3396 TVA Bull Run

TN 3399 TVA Cumberland

KY 1363 Cane Run

KY 1364 Mill Creek

KY 6041 SDurlock

KY 1384 John Sherman Coooer

KY 1353 Biq Sandv

KY 1356 Ghent

KY 1355 Brown

KY 1374 Owensboro Municinal

KY 1372 Henderson Municioal

KY 1378 Paradise

KY 1361 Coleman

KY 1382 Reid/Henderson 2

KY 6639 Green

56