### F r a n c i s c o,

A E P C O app re c i a t e s t h e oppo rtun it y t o c l a r i f y i n f o r m a t i on sub m i tt e d t o E P A on A ugus t23, 3012 b a s e d

o n E P A ’ s d a t a r e qu e s td a t e d A ug u s t6, 2012. P l ea s e do no t h e s i t a t e t o c on t a c t m e i f

you n e e d any f u rt h er c l ar i f

i c a t i ons. Q : We und e r s t and f

r o m t h e r e spons e t o qu e s ti on #4 fr o m E P A th a t A E P C O h a s no

" s c h e du l e d o r

p l ann e d E GU r e ti re m e n td a t e s "

. A l so, A E P C O h a s i nd i c a t e d t h a t t h e

re m a i n i ng l i f

e o f t h e un it s w a s 8 y e ar s. I s th e re a re l a t i onsh i p b e tw e e n th e l e ng th o f th e
e l ec t r i c i t y s a l e s c on t ra c t s ( up t o 2020 ) and th e r e m a i n i ng li f e o f th e un it s ( 8 y ear s ) a s i n c l ud e d i n t

h e an a l ys i s o f f

i n an c i a l i mp a c t s fr o m S C R i ns t a l l a t i on a n d op e r a t i on i n th e

re spons e t o qu e s ti on #1 ? I f so, p l e a s e e l a

bo r a t e and e xp l a i n i f i t i s no t poss i b l e t o

c ons i d e r a re m a i n i ng l i f

e f o r t h e un i t s b e yond 20 2 0. A : A E P C O ’ s S T1 h a s a c u r re n t c on tr a c t l i f e th r ough 2020. A E PC O supp l i e s a ll o r th e

m a j o r i t y po rti on o f t h e po w er n e e ds o f it s s i x Cl a ss A m e mb e rd i s tr i bu ti on c oop e r a ti v e s

u nd e r w ho l e s a l e po w e r c on tr a c t s. A E P C O ’ s op er a t i ons ar e dr i v e n by t h e n ee ds o f

ou r
m e m b e r s. Th e c on t ra c t li f

e o f th e a ss e t i s no t an i nd i ca ti on o f it s us ef u l l i f e

. W i t h

re sp e c t t o t h e t h r ee s t e a m un it s, th e c on tr a c t li fe w a s m od e l e d w ith i n th e f i n an c i a l f o re c a s t , r e g ar d l e ss o f t h e f o r e ca s tp e r i od. Q : A E P C O 's f

i n a n c i a l an a l y s i s i n th e r e sp o ns e t o qu e s t i on #1 r ef l e c t s a t i m e ho r i z on o f

15 y e ar s

. F o r ou rs t a nd ar d a n a l ys i s o f S CR , E P A a ssu m e s a ti m e ho r i z on o f 20 y e ar s f

o r th e

u s e f u l l i f e o f t h e e qu i p m e n t

. W h a t i s A E P C O 's j us ti f i ca ti on f o r a ssu m i ng a

15

- y ear t i m e h o r i z on ? A : Th e an a l y s i s c o mp l e t e d by A E P C O i n r e spon s e t o t h e d a t a r e qu e s t f

r o m E P A w a s b a s e d

o n ou r c u r

r e n t f i n an c i a l f o r e ca s t s. A E P C O m a i n t a i ns a tw e n ty y e a r f o r e c a s t a nd
t h e re f o re t h e y e ar

2031 w a s th e l a s ty e a r

o f our c urr e n t f

o r e ca s t

. Th anks,

M i c h e l l e F r ee a rk D i r e c t o ro f

Env i r on m e n t a l S er

v i c es Ar i z on a E l e c t r i c P o w e r C o op e r a t i v e , I n c

. ( 520 ) 586

- 5122

m f re e ar k@ss w

. c oop

T h is m essag e and an

y a t t a c h e d do c u m e n t

s ar e pr i v il e

g e d and / or c on fi d e n ti a l

. I f y ou ar e no t th e i n t e nd e d r ec i p i e n t , do no t c op

y, di s tr i bu te , or r e ta i n th i

s i n f orm a ti on. I

f y ou ha v e r e c e i v e d t

h i s t rans m iss i on i n e rror, ki nd l y no t if y th e s e nd

e r b yr e p l y e- m a i l

. T

h i s e l ec tron i c s i

gna t u r e i n no w a

y d e no t es an o

f f e r or a cc e p t an c e t o c on tra c t. R E : A dd it i on a l qu e s t i ons f o r Ar i z on a re g i on a l h a ze a n a l ys is M i c h e l l e F r ee a r

k
t o: F r a n c i s c o D on ez 09 / 17 / 2012 05 : 07 PM C c: C o ll ee n M c K a

ugh a n, L ar

r y S o r r e l s, M ar g a re t A l kon, Tho m a s W e bb H i d e D e t a il s F r o m: M i c h e ll e F re e ar

k < m fr e ear k@s s w

. c oop> To : F ran c i s c o D on e z / R 9 /U S E P A /U S @E P A
, C c : C o l l e e n M c K a

ugh an/R 9 /U S E P A /U S @E P A , L arr y S o rre l s /R T P /U S E P A /

U S @E P A
, M a r g ar e t A l kon/ R 9 /U S E P A / U S @E P A , Tho m a s W e bb / R 9 /U S E P A /U S @ E PA P a g e 1 o f 3

9/ 17/ 2012 f i l e : /// C :/U s e r s / f

don ez

. A A / A pp D a t a / Lo c a l/ T e mp /no t e s5524 D 1 /

~ w e b6794.h tmF r o m: F r a n c is c o D o n e z [ ma il t o : D o n e z. F r a n c is c o @ e p ama il. e p a .gov ]

S e n t: Mo n d a y , S e p t e m b e r 1 7 , 20 1 2 3 : 1 2 PM To: Mi c h e ll e F r e ea rk C c: C o ll e e n M c Ka u g h a n ; L a rr y S orr e ls ; M a rg a r e t A l k o n ; T h o ma s W e bb S u b j e c t: R E : A ddi t io n a l q u e s t io n s f or A riz o n a r e gio n a l h a z e a n a l y sis

H i M i c h e l l e:

Y e s , o f c ou rs e n oon on S e p te m be r 1 8 i s f i ne

. T ha n k y o u!

F r a n c is co

F r a n c is c o Dó ñ e z , P h .D. U S E n v i r o nm e nta l P r o te c t i o n A ge n cy O n de t a i l t o A i r P l an n i n g O ff i c e ( A IR

- 2) 600 W i l s h i r e B l v d., S u i te 1 460 Lo s A ng e l e s , C A9 0 017 T e l

. ( 2 13 ) 2 44

- 1 8 34

http : //www

. ep a .go v / r e g i o n 9/a i r / i n de x .h t ml http : //www

. ep a .go v / r e g i o n 9/ s o c a l /ab o ut

- u s .h t ml

F r o m : M i c h e ll e F r ee a r k< m f r eea r k @s s w

. c oop > T o : F r a n c i s c o D o n e z / R 9 / U S E PA / U S @ EP A

, C c : T ho m a s Web b / R 9 / U S E PA / U S @ EP A

, M a r g a r e t A l k on / R 9 / U S EP A / U S @ E PA

, L a rr y So r r e l s / R T P / U S E PA / U S @ EP A

, C o ll e en
M c K aug h an / R 9 / U S EP A / U S @ E PA

D a t e : 0 9 / 1 7 / 201 2 0 8 : 2 9 AM

S ubj e c t: R E : A dd i t i o n a l que s t i on s f o r A ri z on a r e g i o n a l ha z e ana l y s is

Fr a n c i s c o,

I s i t a cc e p ta b l e f o r A E P C O to h a v e a n a n s w e r to E PA by noon o n S e p t e m b e r 18
, 201 2 ? O u r o ff i c e s o u r c l o s e d o n Fri d ay s

w h ic h cr e at e s s o m e p r ob l e m s.

T h a n k s, Mic h e l l e Fr e e a rk

F r o m: F r a n c is c o D o n e z [ ma il t o : D o n e z. F r a n c is c o @ e p ama il. e p a .gov ] S e n t: T h u rsd a y , S e p t em b e r 1 3 , 2 0 1 2 1 0 : 1 2 AM To: Mi c h e ll e F r e ea rk C c: Th o m a s W e bb ; M a rg a r et A l ko n ; L a rr y S o rr e ls ; C o ll e e n M c K a u g h an S u b j e c t: A ddi t io n a l q u e s t io n s f or A riz o n a r e gio n a l h a z e a n a l y sis

Dea r M i c he l l e:

S o rry , I g o t o u r r e qu e s t ed s u b m i s s i o n d ate w r o ng i n m y p r e v i o u s me ss ag e b e l o w

. W h at I me a nt t o r eq u e s t i s t h at 

### P a g e 2 o f 3

9/ 17/ 2012 f i l e : /// C :/U s e r s / f

don ez

. A A / A pp D a t a / Lo c a l/ T e mp /no t e s5524 D 1 /

~ w e b6794.h tmy o u s en d A E P C O ' s r e s p o n s e s to t h e s e c l a r i f i c a t i o n q u e s t i o n s b y C O B th i s M on d a y , S ept e mb e r 17

. If a t a l l po ss i b l e, w e w o u l d l ik e to get th i s i nf o r m at i on i nt o th e d o c k et bef o r e th e c o m m ent pe r i o d c l o s e s on S e p tem b e r 1 8

. A p o l o g i e s f o r

a n y c o n fu s i o n, a nd p l e a s e l e t m e k now i f t h i s r e q ue s te d de a d l i n e i s p r o b l e m a t i c.

B e s t, F r a n c is co

F r a n c is c o Dó ñ e z , P h .D. U S E n v i r o nm e nta l P r o te c t i o n A ge n cy O n de t a i l t o A i r P l an n i n g O ff i c e ( A IR

- 2) 600 W i l s h i r e B l v d., S u i te 1 460 Lo s A ng e l e s , C A9 0 017 T e l

. ( 2 13 ) 2 44

- 1 8 34

http : //www

. ep a .go v / r e g i o n 9/a i r / i n de x .h t ml http : //www

. ep a .go v / r e g i o n 9/ s o c a l /ab o ut

- u s .h t ml

___ _ __ _ __ _ __ _ __ _ __
Dea r M i c he l l e:

S o rry fo r t h e d e l a y i n g ett i ng the s e a dd i t i on a l q ue s t i o n s to y o u. S ee be l ow. I f i t i s p o s s i b l e to s e n d r e s p o n s e s to the s e b y c l o s e o f bu si ne ss on Mo n da y , S ep t em b e r 2 7 , th a t wo u l d be g r eat

.

 W e un d e r s t a nd f r o m t h e r e s p o n s e t o qu e s t i o n # 4 f r om EP A t h at A E P C O h a s no "s c h ed u l e d o r p l a n ne d E G U r et i r em e nt d ate s"

. A l s o, A E P C O h a s i n d i c at e d t h at t h e r e m a i n i n g l i fe of t h e u n i t s w a s 8 y ea rs . I s t h e r e
a r e l at i o n s h i p b e twe e n t h e l en g th o f th e e l e c t r ic i t y s a l e s c o nt r a c t s ( up to 2 0 20 ) a nd t he r e m a i n i ng l i fe of the

u n i t s ( 8 y e a rs ) a s i n cl ud e d i n th e a n a l ys i s o f f i n an c i a l i m p a c t s f r om S CR i n s ta l l a t i o n a n d o pe r at i o n i n th e r e s p on s e t o q u e s t i o n # 1 ? If s o , p l ea s e e l a bo r a t e a n d e x p l a i n i f i t i s n o t p o s si b l e to c o n s i d e r a r em a i n i n g l i fe f o r th e un i t s b e y o nd 2 02 0

.
 AE P C O ' s f i n an ci a l an a l y s is i n the r e s p on s e to q u e s t i o n # 1 r ef l e c t s a t i m e ho r i z o n o f 15 y e a r s

. F o r ou r
s t a nd a r d an a l ys i s of S CR

, E P A a s s u me s a t i m e h o r iz on o f 2 0 y ea rs fo r t h e u s e f u l l i fe o f

th e eq u i p m e n t. W h a t i s A E P C O ' s j u s t i f i c a t i o n fo r a s s u m i n g a 1 5 -y ea r t i me ho r i z o n?

 P l ea s e c o n ta c t m e i f y o u n ee d mo r e i n f o r ma t i o n

. T h a n k y o u!

B e s t, F r a n c is co

F r a n c is c o Dó ñ e z , P h .D. U S E n v i r o nm e nta l P r o te c t i o n A ge n cy O n de t a i l t o A i r P l an n i n g O ff i c e ( A IR

- 2) 600 W i l s h i r e B l v d., S u i te 1 460 Lo s A ng e l e s , C A9 0 017 T e l

. ( 2 13 ) 2 44

- 1 8 34

http : //www

. ep a .go v / r e g i o n 9/a i r / i n de x .h t ml http : //www

. ep a .go v / r e g i o n 9/ s o c a l /ab o ut

- u s .h t ml 

### P a g e 3 o f 3

9/ 17/ 2012 f i l e : /// C :/U s e r s / f

don ez

. A A / A pp D a t a / Lo c a l/ T e mp /no t e s5524 D 1 /

~ w e b6794.h tm