Other RP Sources: CALPUFF simulations for Arizona Regional Haze FIP NPRM, January 2014

Cholla unit 1; Springerville units 1,2; Sundt units 1,2,3 sjb 2014-01-23

Tables for FRN; tables and bar charts for TSD Appendix B

These use copies of results from UNC Task 9 "FAC_dollarperdv_analysis_final.xls" spreadsheets
APS Cholla unit 1, Arizona RH FIP NPR, January 2014

Visibility Impact, method vm8b, 22nd high

Class I Area

ctrl-0/ctrl2_r2: 

Base (SCR on 

u.2,3,4)

ctrl2-1: SNCR ctrl2-2: SCR

Capitol Reef NP 0.71 0.67 0.62

Galiuro Wild. 0.30 0.29 0.29

Gila Wild. 0.48 0.48 0.48

Grand Canyon NP 1.14 1.09 1.02

Mazatzal Wild. 0.79 0.78 0.75

Mesa Verde NP 0.65 0.62 0.60

Mount Baldy Wild. 0.71 0.70 0.69

Petrified Forest NP 3.38 3.28 3.18

Pine Mountain Wild. 0.55 0.55 0.52

Saguaro NP 0.23 0.23 0.23

Sierra Ancha Wild. 0.87 0.85 0.81

Superstition Wild. 0.81 0.78 0.75

Sycamore Canyon Wild. 0.76 0.74 0.69

Cumulative (sum) 11.39 11.06 10.64

Maximum 3.38 3.28 3.18

# CIAs >= 0.5 dv 10 10 10

APS Cholla unit 1, Arizona RH FIP NPR, January 2014

Visibility Benefit, method vm8b, 22nd high

Class I Area

ctrl-0/ctrl2_r2: 

Base (SCR on 

u.2,3,4)

ctrl2-1: SNCR ctrl2-2: SCR

Capitol Reef NP 0.04 0.09

Galiuro Wild. 0.01 0.01

Gila Wild. 0.01 0.01

Grand Canyon NP 0.05 0.12

Mazatzal Wild. 0.02 0.04

Mesa Verde NP 0.03 0.06

Mount Baldy Wild. 0.01 0.02

Petrified Forest NP 0.10 0.20

Pine Mountain Wild. 0.01 0.03

Saguaro NP 0.00 0.00

Sierra Ancha Wild. 0.02 0.06

Superstition Wild. 0.03 0.06

Sycamore Canyon Wild. 0.03 0.07

Cumulative (sum) 0.33 0.75

Maximum 0.10 0.20

# CIAs improvement >= 0.3 

dv 0 0

AZ RH FIP3 TSD App. B, p.23 (from 09000064815434d4)
TEP Springerville units 1 & 2, Arizona RH FIP NPR, January 2014

Visibility Impact, method vm8b, 22nd high

Class I Area Base case ctrl-1: SNCR ctrl-2: SCR

Bandelier NM 1.08 1.01 0.95

Chiricahua NM 0.85 0.77 0.71

Chiricahua Wild. 0.88 0.87 0.86

Galiuro Wild. 0.95 0.92 0.87

Gila Wild. 4.39 4.21 3.99

Grand Canyon NP 0.79 0.73 0.72

Mazatzal Wild. 0.86 0.85 0.85

Mount Baldy Wild. 3.63 3.49 3.31

Petrified Forest NP 2.46 2.40 2.37

Pine Mountain Wild. 0.67 0.65 0.61

Saguaro NP 0.57 0.56 0.53

San Pedro Parks Wild. 1.53 1.48 1.31

Sierra Ancha Wild. 1.01 0.99 0.96

Superstition Wild. 0.52 0.49 0.46

Sycamore Canyon Wild. 0.65 0.64 0.61

Cumulative (sum) 20.83 20.05 19.10

Maximum 4.39 4.21 3.99

# CIAs >= 0.5 dv 10 9 9

TEP Springerville units 1 & 2, Arizona RH FIP NPR, January 2014

Visibility Benefit, method vm8b, 22nd high

Class I Area Base case ctrl-1: SNCR ctrl-2: SCR

Bandelier NM 0.07 0.13

Chiricahua NM 0.07 0.14

Chiricahua Wild. 0.00 0.01

Galiuro Wild. 0.03 0.08

Gila Wild. 0.18 0.41

Grand Canyon NP 0.07 0.07

Mazatzal Wild. 0.01 0.01

Mount Baldy Wild. 0.13 0.32

Petrified Forest NP 0.06 0.09

Pine Mountain Wild. 0.02 0.06

Saguaro NP 0.01 0.04

San Pedro Parks Wild. 0.05 0.23

Sierra Ancha Wild. 0.02 0.05

Superstition Wild. 0.03 0.06

Sycamore Canyon Wild. 0.02 0.04

Cumulative (sum) 0.79 1.73

Maximum 0.18 0.41

# CIAs improvement >= 

0.3 dv 0 2

million $/dv (cumul. dv) $6.5 $12.6

million $/dv (max. dv) $28.2 $53.4

AZ RH FIP3 TSD App. B, p.25 (from 09000064815434d4)
TEP Sundt units 1,2,3, Arizona RH FIP NPR, January 2014

Visibility Impact, method vm8b, 22nd high

Class I Area ctrl4: Base case 

(SNCR on unit 4)

ULNB (ctrl2-1 

and ctrl2-2)

Chiricahua NM 0.43 0.51

Chiricahua Wild. 0.51 0.58

Galiuro Wild. 1.10 1.32

Gila Wild. 0.17 0.19

Mazatzal Wild. 0.19 0.21

Mount Baldy Wild. 0.15 0.17

Pine Mountain Wild. 0.15 0.16

Saguaro NP 3.40 3.80

Sierra Ancha Wild. 0.19 0.21

Superstition Wild. 0.32 0.35

Cumulative (sum) 6.60 7.49

Maximum 3.40 3.80

# CIAs >= 0.5 dv 3 4

Interpolated from ULNB results having unit 4 at base (LNB)

 and unit 4 with SCR

TEP Sundt units 1,2,3, Arizona RH FIP NPR, January 2014

Visibility Benefit, method vm8b, 22nd high

Class I Area ctrl4: Base case 

(SNCR on unit 4)

ULNB (ctrl2-1 

and ctrl2-2)

Chiricahua NM 0.08

Chiricahua Wild. 0.07

Galiuro Wild. 0.22

Gila Wild. 0.02

Mazatzal Wild. 0.02

Mount Baldy Wild. 0.02

Pine Mountain Wild. 0.01

Saguaro NP 0.40

Sierra Ancha Wild. 0.02

Superstition Wild. 0.04

Cumulative (sum) 0.89

Maximum 0.40

# CIAs improvement >= 

0.3 dv 1

AZ RH FIP3 TSD App. B, p.27 (from 09000064815434d4)
Row headings for max impact, $/dv, etc.

Enter row headings below, or have those cells refer to alt. headings 1 or other location with 

Row headings

range name used in table alt. headings 1

h_dv_cumul Cumulative (sum) Cumulative (sum)

h_dv_max Maximum Maximum

h_nover5 # CIAs >= 0.5 dv # CIAs >= 0.5 dv

h_n_impr_over5 # CIAs improvement >= 0.5 dv # CIAs improvement >= 0.5 dv

h_dpdv_cumul million $/dv (cumul. dv) million $/dv (cumul. dv)

h_dpdv_max million $/dv (max. dv) million $/dv (max. dv)
dings 1 or other location with headings

alt. headings 2

Cumulative Visb Impr.

Single Largest Class I Improvement

Areas >= 0.5 dv

Areas >= 0.5 dv impr

Cumulative Class I area cost effectiveness

Single Class I area cost effectiveness