p.1 

OAR Box 1877 

Prepped by Keeia / ichards 

Document Num )er: 

6) ll-B-3 

Docket Number. 

A-b-19 

Printed 12/2/200810:36:4< AM Sheet 6 of 46 
___L2 

* RAHMAN 

C O R PO R A T I O N 

A-90-19 

ll-B-3 

TO: HON Project File 

FROM: Chuck Zukor 

DATE: August 23, 1991 

GUI O 

EPA AIR DOCKET 

SUBJECT: Documentation of Cost Factors used by the HON Project 

This memorandum documents utility and labor cost factors used by 

the HON project. These cost factors were originally gathered 

from a variety of sources for the Industrial Wastewater (IWW) CTG 

project. The HON Wastewater team adopted these cost factors to 

remain consistent with the IWW-CTG costing methodology because 

both projects were developing costs for similar pollution control 

techniques. The rest of the HON teams decided to use these cost 

factors so that there would be consistent cost assumptions 

throughout the HON analysis. 

HON utility and labor cost factors and their reference source 

numbers are presented in Table 1. These cost factors have bean 

adjusted to July 1989 dollars using a ratio of plant cost indices 

from Chemical Engineering magazine. Calculations for all of the 

HON cost factor adjustments are presented in Table 2. Table 3 

lists the reference sources used to develop the HON cost factors. 

Photocopies of these cited references are included as an 

attachment to this memorandum. 

It should be understood that utility and labor cost factors can 

vary aiross the nation due to regional economic impacts. This 

results in a number of reference sources for utility and labor 

cost factors. The reference sources used by ths HON project team 

are considered representative of national utility and labor cost 

factori. 

Progress Center/3200 E. Chapel Hill Rd./Nelson Hwy.. P.O. Box 13000/Research Triangle Park. N.C. 27709/(919)541-9100 
P.3 

RADIAN 

CORPORATIO N 

SIGNATURE £L 

CALCULATION SHEET 

OATE 

CALC. NO 

ftHPrtrcn DATE 

JOBTM 239-Q(3-^-3Z_. 

SUBJECT. TAC^g *H SHEET. OF. .SHEETS 

L&tpy. 

— \ 

_—1_ 

i I I 

nsk\__ 

a*M^jf- _l^>y^/^w 

MKlg^^t-Lt-iy j^ip^/|^ *£_. 

^fc ^ 

^ 2few£f 

U^cterr i SESZW^^ 

.J_k^W^l^*t T&tej/] itoo|4f^ 

X 

i 

dpWfo3I_j3eft cke^ I ; i \a%~n7ipl-atj-
P.4 

Ft_ADIAIN CALCULATION SHEET 

I O N 

SIGNATURE 

PROJECT __ 7^ DATE 

TVW--B(t> 

SUBJECT. TAfeug ±7^ 

CALC. NO. 

CHECKED 

JOB NO. 

-2.-y?-a(?--*r3-rz_ 

DATE. 

SHEET. OF. .SHEETS 

-1_. 

i j » A. l * «• 

q^^^gj-^fwef*^^Xor : -Hcja y^^-p-H- H -j—33——f 

liecrt-Atc^Uy > 

4 ioj d^iJatlLLg -L..^-y ' ju____t. k T^yfea . - • , ^r",• -j—-p S — 

kw-ki xZESKlOvrL' _L_ 

(\yJ4..L <^a4- k<v*-fr***-/vfg^

 a * [X4*i35V^_|.-J 

»rifei 3to/r! ill ' ;/f 1< 

: , , : ! I I ! . t j I _ 

UkA*. x-Wir**. r j 

T&^Q. 

10QMA\L m '^fiC&A i ^m^^^r^K 

Ar^v^ S /i"^^ ^ pAtctrl r^t-U^W j^* 4 f*j»4g"^g^ 
P.5 

RADIAN 

SIGNATURE. 

PROJECT 

I O N 

CALCULATION SHEET 

DATE CHECKED 

SUBJECT. •rmuE ±2~ /CMI/CTO) 

CALC. NO., 

DATE. 

9^01^-53-I Z, 

.SHEETS 

A^U^C^,\ Ci.A*L ' 

1 i • i i i r ; i 

i-t-

^^^t-^^^k 

\t\% r&zk*M 

[ 'lA- j 1 1 1 --•-"- f , ; , 1 f 

uvK^r^ufrcfc i L__^4jbeLp__l^ ; [ x____._I_L. 1 ' . 4 -

-r-h-4-i ^-U-M- 1- ! . i ! 1 ' i-HB

___________j _ ___. 

-4Mi4*ia5 

__n_4__r 

• i I i ! I I • i : ; ; ; ; ; 

k/WccU. i^o>i ^*_'4.\c*4* ¥*^fea6*@ <>•&• 4uv^ re.-C^e»A££\. 

- T — +" 

I 9 
P.6 

RADIAN 

CORPORATIO N 

SIGNATURE. 

PROJECT 

CALCULATION SHEET 

• > 

Qk _, DATE J/HJ31_ . CHECKED 

CALC. NO. 

DATE 

SUBJECT. TA-BLg- »r% SHEET. OF. .SHEETS 

T 

_ L^44 jeLLi.bad:JjSri^fi__iute|2L. _ j^ ^ _^ ^ —' ^^iaL^^^L-j j 

—:—I—|—j—j—i—i—i—^—j—!—^—i—j—!—j—i—i—j—I—r -

CqS^H 

-_/^_p_>C!y _j__X&___4S^ --- y^o^n | 

^iucUITly r KTO#i__ja|bterq[ J I i 1 ! : T +1 

i _ i _ L _ i i 1 _ J _j_

 !

 _L ' J_ ' I i I ; i *__ 

4>*a 

^rWWT T^wST^ U/UU6.^ utWi/t - i>.^e> 

E l I I I ! I ! ! j I' ' 

U.4- -?PA _g^_(l_ 

i | I : j 1 [ 1 ' 1 j i 

J 6 u 

^ ^A41i_2k33d 

-J— g^a^-ifigloj ~t*He.' 4AH^T^- -

1

 ! ; | M ! i 11 ; | 1 T . | if | 

_L. _ J^fe**!' <U^d^s*kk LJ^*lj4.TO.« oiM6^J-Uv_fiL^cc-isXu^V i&»»^ h^shl *Q'&rte^o/H%c ha 

\^*]Kf.t^-«±?d\ \ K •gfcCertvvf-ei'^-g)